PROCEEDINGS
THIRTEENTH ANNUAL CONVENTION
American Railway Engineering
Association
HELD AT THE
CONGRESS HOTEL, CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
March 19, 20 and 21, 1912
VOLUME 13
PUBLISHED UNDER DIRECTION OF THE COMMITTEE
ON PUBLICATIONS
1912
TABLE OF CONTENTS.
PAGE.
TABLE OF CONTENTS 7-20
CONSTITUTION.
CONSTITUTION 23-31
Name, Object and Location 23
Membership '. . . 23, 24
Admissions and Expulsions 24, 25
Dues 26
Officers 26. 27
Nomination and Election of Officers 27-29
Management 29, 30
Meetings 30, 3 1
Amendments 31
GENERAL INFORMATION.
GENERAL INFORMATION 32-36
Appointment of Committees and Outline of Work 32
Preparation of Committee Reports 32-34
Publication of Committee Reports 34
Consideration of Committee Reports 34. 35
General Rules for the Publication of the Manual 36
BUSINESS SESSION.
BUSINESS SESSION 39-62
Introductory Remarks by the President 39
President's Address 40-48
Association Affairs 40-44
Progress in Engineering Works 44-47
The Complete Engineer of 300 Years Ago 47, 48
7
8 TABLE OF CONTENTS.
BUSINESS SESSION— Continued.
PAGE.
Report of Secretary 49-52
r> Membership 4Q. 50
Geographical Distribution of Membership . ; 50
Classification of Members 50
Publications 51
Financial Statement 5 1., 52
Expenditures in Detail 52
Report of Treasurer . .. , 53
Condensed Report of Convention 54-62
Resolutions Adopted 59-62
Report of Tellers 59, 60
Election and Installation of Officers 61
COMMITTEE REPORTS.
RULES AND ORGANIZATION 65-68
Introductory ;. ...... • 65
Instructions as to Conduct of Work 66-68
Cross-Sections ' 66
Drainage 66
Ballasting 66
TlCS '• ■■■-. 66'67
Rail 67
Surfacing 68
SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING .:...: 69-74
Introductory 69
Conclusions 69, 70
Table of Insulation Resistances 70
Uniform Signaling 7°'74
Essentials of Signaling 70, 71
Minority Report '. .v 75,76
WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES 77-8o
Introductory 77, 78
Sheet Piling — Progress Report 78, 79
1 Pile Formulas — Progress Report '. 79
Guard Rails — Progress Report 79
Fii s Protection — Progress Report 79, 80
TABLE OF CONTENTS. 9
PAGE.
IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES 81-88
Introductory 81, 82
Conclusions 82
Specifications for the Erection of Railroad Bridges . . . . 83-87
Work to Be Done 83
Falsework ' 83
Conduct of Work 83, 84
Engine Service 84
Transportation 84
Masonry 84
Handling and Storing Materials 84
Maintenance of Traffic .' 85
Removal of Old Structure 85
Metal Work 85
Misfits 85, 86
Anchor Bolts ' 86
Bed Plates 86
Decks 86
Painting 86
Clearing the Site 86
Superintendence and Workmen 86, 87
Inspection 87
Responsibility 87
Insurance and Bond 87
Engineer Defined 87
Secondary Stresses 88
YARDS AND TERMINALS 89-93
Introductory 89
Typical Situation Plans of Passenger Stations 90
Handling of Freight by Al'echanical Means 90, 91
Typical Situation Plans for Division Engine Terminal 91,92
Conclusions 93
BALLAST 95-300
Introductory 95
Proper Depth of Ballast to Insure Uniform Distribution of the
Loads on the Roadbed 95-97
10 TABLE OF CONTENTS.
BALLAST — Continued.
pagf.
Physical Tests of Stone for Ballast 97-99
Review of Gravel Ballast and Methods for Grading the Differ-
ent Qualities 99-102
Gravel Washing Plant of the Richmond, Fredericksburg &
Potomac Railroad 10.3- 1 10
Experiment to Determine the Necessary Depth of Stone
Ballast 113-265
Description of Test Track 1 14-121
Methods of Tests 122-127
Conclusions 126, 127
Detail of Tests 128-265
Gravel as Ballast 266-289
Ballast (Monograph by G. W. Vaughan) 290-300
TIES 301-370
Introductory 3°[
Size of Cross-Ties Required for the Stresses to Which They
Are Subjected 301-331
Bearing Strength of Ties Under the Rail Tests 303
Bibliography on Size of Cross-Ties 307-311
Summary of Answers to Circular Regarding Size of
Cross-Ties Required for the Stresses to Which They Are
Subjected 312-329
Arrangement of Ties Under Joints 330
Conclusions Mi
Tie Renewals in Continuous Stretches Versus Single-Tie Re-
newals 332-34-'
Co .elusion 342
Metal, Composite and Concrete Ties 343"370
Conclusions 37c'
TRACK 371-386
Introductory 371
Frogs, Crossings and Switches 37I_374
Tie-Plates and Track Fastenings 374
Designs of Main Line Turnouts 374
Vertical Curves 374
Conclusions 37 4
TABLE OF CONTENTS. 11
TRACK — Continued.
page.
General Specifications for Frogs, Crossings and Switches. .. .375-386
General Instructions 375
Inspection 375) 3?6
Material ^76, 377
Workmanship 377
Fr°gs 377,37*
Switches 381-386
ROADWAY 387-400
Introductory 387
Waterway Formulas 387, 388
Unit Pressures Allowable on Roadbeds of Different Materials. .388-396
Tunnel Construction and Ventilation 306
Agricultural Drainage as It Affects Railways 396, 397
Record of Tunnel Ventilation 398-400
WATER SERVICE 401-428
Introductory 401
Use of Reinforced Concrete for Water Tanks and Supports. .402-417
General Specifications for a Reinforced Concrete Standpipe
Water Tank for Railways 413-417
General Specifications for Ordinary Steel Water and Oil
Tanks 417-419
Conclusion 419
Locomotive Boiler Corrosion and Treated Water 420-428
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES 429-457
Introductory 429
Tree Planting and General Reforestation (United States) ... .430-437
Bibliography of Timber Resources 435-437
Coal and Fuel Oil Resources 437-454
Advantages of Oil as Fuel Compared to Coal 437, 438
Petroleum as a Locomotive Fuel 438, 439
Evaporative Tests — Oil as Fuel 439-441
Inspection and Tests of Fuel Oil 441-443
Government Fuel Oil Specifications 443, 444
Methods of Preventing or Lessening Waste 444-449
12 TABLE OF CONTENTS.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES— Continued.
PAGE.
Coal Fields of the United States 449-452
Duration of Supply : 453. 454
Tree Planting and Reforestation in Canada ....455,456
Annual Fire Loss 456
Coal and Fuel Oil Resources 456, 457
Peat Deposits in Canada 457
Crude Petroleum ■ • 457
Natural Gas in Canada 457
MASONRY 459-504
Introductory 459
Waterproofing of Masonry 459-474
Methods of Patching and Repairing Plain and Reinforced
Concrete 474"4§7
Methods of Depositing Concrete Under Water 487-502
Conclusions 4S8
Report on Work of Joint Committee on Concrete and Rein-
forced Concrete 502
Unification of Portland Cement Specifications 502-504
Conclusions 504
RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS i 505-507
Introductory ■ 505. 506
Reasons for Maintaining a Storehouse 506, 507
Conclusions 5°°. 5°7
ELECTRICITY 509-558
Introductory 5°9
Clearances • 510
. Transmission Lines and Crossings 510, 511
Recommendations ,, 511
Specifications for Overhead Crossings of Electric Light and
Power Lines 512-521
General Requirements 5r2-5i4
Loads 514. 515
Factors of Safety . . . .• ■ 515, 516
TABLE OF CONTENTS. 13
ELECTRICITY— Continued.
PAGE.
Material 516-518
Protective Coatings 518
Foundations ! ' 518
Working Unit Stresses '. 518, 519
Specification for Galvanizing for Iron or Steel 519-521
Data Regarding Third Rail Clearances 524
Diagrams Showing Equipment Lines of Various Railways 526-534
Diagrams Showing Third Rail Structure of Various Railways'. 535-558
RAIL 559-872
Introductory 559-564
Specifications for Carbon Steel Rails . . . . .565-571
Inspection 565
Material 565
Chemical Requirements ■ 565, 566
- Physical Requirements 566-569
Details of Mann f acture ( 569-571
A Study of Seventeen Good Service Rails 1 ^. .573-612
Rail Failure Statistics for Year Ending October 31, 1910 613-633
Thoughts Resulting from the Study . 633
Comparative Wear of Bessemer, Open-hearth and Nickel Steei
Rail on Pennsylvania Railroad .635-654
Segregation and Other Rail Properties as Influenced by Si?e
of Ingot . . . .655-751
Tests of Rail Steel Ingots and Derivative Shapes Made at
Watertown Arsenal , 753
Influence of Rolling Temperature on the Properties of Bes-
semer Rails ,.,-..! 797-839
•Hearing Before Indiana Railroad Commission 841-862
The History and Development and Use of Rails by Rail-
road Companies of the United States from 1830 . to
Date .843-850
Investigations Made by the American Society of Civil En-
gineers on Steel Rails 851,852
The Question of the Improvement of Rail Design and
- Specifications from 1830 to the Present Time ^853-862
14 TABLE OF CONTENTS.
PAGF.
WOOD PRESERVATION 863-872
Grouping of Timbers for Antiseptic Treatment 863, 864, 868-872
Reco. ds from Service Tests 864
Merits of Various Preservatives 864
Revision of the Adopted Specifications for Creosote Oil 865, 866
Forms for Reporting Inspection 866
Specification for Impregnation with Creosote Oil 866
Value of Brush Coating and Dipping 867
Value of Impregnation with Crude Oil 867
Conclusions 867
GRADING OF LUMBER 873-884
Introductory 873
Recommendations 873, 874
Classification and Grading Rules for Cypress Lumber and
Shingles 875-884
General Instructions 875
Standard Defects 875-877
Standard Lengths 878
Standard Finished Sizes of Cypress 878, 879
Tank Stock 879
First and Second Clear 879, 880
Selects 880
Selected Common Tank Stock 880
No. 1 Barn or Dimension S80
No. 2 Barn or Dimension 880, 881
Cull or Peck 881
Finishing 88i, 882
Siding 882
Flooring and Ceiling 882
Partition 882
Pickets 883
Battens 883
Car Roofing and Siding 883
Car Lining 883
Shingles 883, 884
TABLE OF CONTENTS. 15
PAGE.
BUILDINGS 885-890
Introductory 885
Roof Coverings 885-800
Gutters 88&-88o
Flashings 889, 890
Details of Flashing and Counter Flashing for Roofs and
Walls 891-806
American Method of Laying Asbestos Shingles 897, 898
Diagonal Method of Laying Asbestos Shingles 899
SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS 900-904
Intro luctory 900
Quality of Fence Wire to Resist Corrosion and Secure Dura-
bility 900-002
Concrete Fence Posts 902
Track Construction and Flangeways at Street Crossings in
Paved Streets 902, 903
Signs for Railroad Purposes 903, 904
Recommendations 904
ECONOMICS OF RAILWAY LOCATION 905,906
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS 907-916
Introductory 907, 90S
Construction Contract — Agreement 909, 910
Construction Contract — General Conditions 911-916
Bond Oil
Contractor's Understanding 91 1
Intent of Plans and Specifications 911
Permits 91 1
Protection 911
Rights of Various Interests 911
Consent to Transfer 912
Superintendence 912
Timely Demand for Points and Instructions 912
Report Errors and Discrepancies 912
Preservation of Stakes 912
Inspection 912
16 TABLE OF CONTENTS.
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS— Continued.
PAGE.
Defective Work or Material 912
Insurance 912
Indemnity '912
•- Settlement for Wages ■ 913
Liens 913
Work Adjacent to Railroad 913
Risk 913
Order and Discipline 913
Contractor Not to Hire Company's Employes 913
Intoxicating Liquors Prohibited 913
Cleaning Up , 913
Engineer and Chief Engineer Defined 913,914
Power of Engineer 914
Adjustment of Dispute 914
Order of Completion ; Use of Completed Portion . . . 914
Changes '■ ■ '■ 9J4
Extra Work .. ' . .914.915
Property and Right of Entry 915
Unavoidable Delays; Extension of Time on Parts of Work 915
Suspension of Work 915
Monthly Estimate 916
DISCUSSIONS.
RULES AND ORGANIZATION I . . . '9*0-931
SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING 932, 933
IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES 934-945
WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES ...... . 946
YARDS AND TERMINALS 947, 948
BALLAST ....i .049,950
ties .....:..:.. .:. 951-964
TRACK ;■■••••: r 965-980
ROADWAY 981,982
WATER SERVICE !;".'......... '." 983-988
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 989
TABLE OF CONTENTS. 17
DISCUSSIONS— Continued.
PAGE.
MASONRY 990-995
RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS 996, 997
ELECTRICITY 998-1016
RAIL 1017-1038
WOOD PRESERVATION 1039-1051
GRADING OF LUMBER 1052, 1053
BUILDINGS 1054
SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS 1055-105/
ECONOMICS OF RAILWAY LOCATION 105S
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS 1059-1076
AMENDMENTS.
Amendments to Report on Uniform Rules and Organization... 1079
Amendments to Report on Iron and Steel Structures 1080
Amendments to Report on Ballast 1080
Amendments to Report on Track 1080
Amendments to Report on Water Service 1080
Amendments to Report on Electricity 1080, 108 1
Amendments to Report on Rail io8t
Amendments to Report on Wood Preservation 1081, 1082
Amendments to Report on Buildings 1082
Amendments to Report on Uniform General Contract Forms... 1082
MONOGRAPHS.
THE DESIGN OF RAILWAY BRIDGE ABUTMENTS,
by J. H. Prior 1085-1 150
Introductory 1085, 1086
Abutments Built of Stone Masonry 1087-1090
Abutments of Concrete, Plain and Reinforced 1091-H25
Memorandum of Total Cost of Various Types 1125-1141
Conclusion 1 142, 1 143
Discussion and Closure 1 149, 1 150
18 TABLE OF CONTENTS.
p
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING FOR LOCOMOTIVES,
by M. H. Wickhorst 1 151-
Introductory „
Tonnage Rating of Locomotives, C. B. & Q. R. R 1152-
Tractive Force 1 153,
Train Resistance 1 155-
Equated Tonnage Tables 1 158,
Explanation of Method
Table of Tractive Force, Weights and Heating Surface....
Curves of Train Resistance, Frictional and Grade
Curves of Negative Train Resistance
Curves of Tractive Force of Engines
Curve of Engine Resistance
Method of Calculating Equated Train Resistances in Tons of
Train
Sample Tonnage Rates, Aurora Division, C. B. & Q. R. R.. .
Equated Tonnage for 0.3 to 1.5 Per cent Grades 1167-
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE,
by L. C. Fritch 1181-
Introductory
History 1 181-
The Lead-Sulphuric Acid Storage Battery 1183-
Principles of the Storage Battery 1 183,
The Lead Cell
Characteristics of the Lead Cell 1184-
Lead Battery Characteristics 1188,
Types of Plates 1 189-
Contaiuing Vessels 1 I93_
Method of Control and Controlling Apparatus
Definitions of Component Parts. . . . . 1198-
Special Instructions Regarding Lead Storage Batteries. .
The Edison Storage Battery 1206-
Theory of Chemical Reaction
Positive Plate
Negative Plate
Electrolyte
Insulation
180
180
154
158
159
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
180
221
181
183
205
184
iS-i
188
i8q
192
197
198
205
205
2IT
206
207
207
207
208
TABLE OF CONTENTS. 19
THE STORAGE BATTERY— Continued.
PAGE.
Container or Jar 1208
Trays or Boxes 1209
Connectors 1209
Voltage 1209
Efficiency 1209, 1210
Applications in Railway Service 1211-1220
Train Lighting 1211-1214
Signaling 1214, 1215
Drawbridge Operation 1215
Station Lighting 1215
Storage Battery Traction 1218
Storage Battery Charging Apparatus 1218-1220
List of Illustrations 1221
INDEX 1223-1236
CONSTITUTION
CONSTITUTION.
REVISED Al THE FIFTH, EIGHTH AND TWELFTH ANNUAL CONVENTIONS.
ARTICLE I.
NAME, OBJECT AND LOCATION.
i. The name of this Association is the American Railway Engi-
neering Association.
2. Its object is the advancement of knowledge pertaining to the
scientific and economic location, construction, operation and maintenance
of railways.
3. The means to be used for this purpose shall be as follows :
(a) Meetings for the reading and discussion of reports and papers
and for social intercourse.
(b) The investigation of matters pertaining to the objects of this
Association through Standing and Special Committees.
(c) The publication of papers, reports and discussions.
(d) The maintenance of a library.
4. Its action shall be recommendatory, and not binding upon its
members.
5. Its permanent office shall be located in Chicago, 111., and the
annual convention shall be held in that city.
Name.
Object.
Means to
be Used.
Responsibil-
ity.
Location of
Office.
ARTICLE II.
MEMBERSHIP.
i. The membership of this Association shall be divided into three Membership
classes, viz. : Members, Honorary Members and Associates.
(2) A Member shall be:
(a) Either a Civil Engineer, a Mechanical Engineer, an Electrical
Engineer, or an official of a railway corporation, who has had not less than
five (5) years' experience in the location, construction, maintenance or op-
eration of railways, and who, at the time of application for membership, is
engaged in railway service in a responsible position in charge of work con
nected with the Location, Construction, Operation or Maintenance of a
Railway; provided, that all persons who were Active Members prior to
March 20, 1907, shall remain Members except as modified by Article II,
Clause 9.
(b) A Professor of Engineering in a college of recognized standing.
23
Membership
Qualifica-
tions.
24
CONSTITUTION.
Honorary
Membership
Qualifica-
tions.
Associate
Membership
Qualifica-
tions.
Membership
Rights.
Age Require-
ment.
"Railway"
Defined.
Changes in
Classes.
Supply
Men.
Transfers.
3. An Honorary Member shall be a person of acknowledged emi-
nence in railway engineering or management. The number of Honorary
Members shall be limited to ten.
4. An Associate shall be a person not eligible as a Member, but
whose pursuits, scientific acquirements or practical experience qualify
him to co-operate with Members in the advancement of professional
knowledge, such as Consulting, Inspecting, Contracting, Government or
other Engineers, Instructors of Engineering in Colleges of recognized
standing, and Engineers of Industrial Corporations when their duties- are
purely technical.
5. (a) Members shall have all the rights and privileges of the
Association.
(b) Honorary Members shall have all the rights of Members, except
that of holding office, and shall be exempt from the payment of dues.
(c) Associates shall have all the rights of Members,' except those
of voting and holding office.
6. An applicant to be eligible for membership in any class shall not
be less than twenty-five (25) years of age.
7. The word "railway" in this Constitution means one operated
by steam or electricity as a common carrier, dependent upon transpor-
tation for its revenue. Engineers of street railway systems and of rail-
ways which are used primarily to transport the material or product of
an industry or industries to and from a point on a railway which is a
common carrier, or those which are merely adjuncts to such industries,
are eligible only as Associates.
8. A Member, elected after March 20, 1007, who shall leave the
railway service, shall cease to be a Member, but may retain membership
in the Association as an Associate, subject to the provisions of Article II,
Clause 9; provided, however, if he re-enters the railway service, he shall
be restored to the class of Members. .
9. Persons whose principal duties require them to be engaged in
the sale or promotion of railway patents, appliances or supplies, shall
not be eligible for, nor retain membership in any class in this Association,
except that those who were Active Members prior to March 20, 1907,
may retain membership as Associates ; provided, however, that anyone
having held membership in the Association and subsequently having be-
come subject to the operation of this clause, shall, if he again becomes
eligible, be permitted to re-enter the Association, without the payment of
a second entrance fee.
10. The Board of Direction shall transfer members from one class
to another, or • remove a member from the membership list, under the
provisions of this Article.
ARTICLE III.
Charter
Membership.
! ADMISSIONS AND EXPULSIONS. ,.
i'. The Charter Membership consists of all persons who were elected
before March 15, 1900.
CONSTITUTION.
2. The Charter Membership having been completed, any person
desirous of becoming a member shall make application upon the form
prescribed by the Board of Direction, setting forth in a concise statement
his name, age, residence, technical education and practical experience.
He shall refer to at least three members to whom he is personally known,
each of whom shall be requested by the Secretary to certify to a personal
knowledge of the candidate and his fitness for membership,
. 3. Upon receipt of an application properly endorsed, the Board of
Direction, through its Secretary, or a Membership Committee selected
from its own members, shall make such investigation of the candidate's
fitness as may be deemed necessary. The Secretary will furnish copies
of t,he information obtained and of the application to each member of the
Board of Direction. At. any time, not less than thirty days after the
filing of the application, the admission of the applicant shall be. canvassed
by letter-ballot among the members of the Board, and affirmative votes
by two-thirds of its members shall elect the candidate; provided, how-
ever, that should an applicant for membership be personally unknown to
three members of the Association, due to residence in a foreign country,
or in such a portion of the United States as precludes him from a sufficient
acquaintance with its members, he may refer to well-known men engaged
in railway or allied professional work, upon the form above described,
and such application shall be considered by the Board of Direction in the
manner above set forth,' and the applicant may be elected to membership
by a unanimous vote of the Board.
4. All persons, after due notice from the Secretary of their elec-
tion, shall subscribe to the Constitution on the form prescribed by the
Board of Direction. If this provision be not complied with within six
months of said notice, the election shall be considered null and void.
5. Any person having been a member of this Association, and hav-
ing, while in good standing, resigned such membership, may be reinstated
without the payment of a second entrance fee; provided his application
for reinstatement is signed by five members certifying to his fitness for
same, and such application is passed by a tv/o-thirds majority of the
Board of Direction.
6. Proposals for Honorary Membership shall be submitted by ten or
more Members. Each Member of the Board of Direction shall be fur-
nished with a copy cf the proposal, and if, after thirty days, the nominee
shall receive the unanimous vote of said Board, he shall be declared an
Honorary Member.
7. When charges are preferred against a Member in writing by ten
or more Members, the Member complained of shall be served with a copy
of such charges, and he shall be called upon to show cause to the Board
of Direction why he should not be expelled from the Association. Not
less than thirty days thereafter a vote shall be taken on his expulsion,
and he shall be expelled upon a two-thirds vote of the Board of Direction.
8. The Board of Direction shall accept the resignation, tendered in
writing, of any Member whose dues are fully paid up.
Application
for Member-
ship.
Election to
Membership.
Subscription
to Constitu-
tion.
Reinstate-
ment.
Honorary
Membership.
Expulsions.
Resignations.
26
CONSTITUTION.
ARTICLE IV.
i. An entrance fee of $10.00 shall be payable to the Association
through its Secretary with each application for membership; and this
sum shall be returned to the applicant if not elected.
2. The annual dues are $10.00, payable during the first three months
of the calendar year.
3. Any person whose dues are not paid before April 1st of the cur-
rent year shall be notified of same by the Secretary. Should the dues
not be paid prior to July 1st, the delinquent Member shall lose his right
to vote. Should the dues remain unpaid October 1st, he shall be notified
on the form prescribed by the Board of Direction, and he shall no longer
receive the publications of the Association. If the dues are not paid by
December 31st, he shall forfeit his membership without further action
or notice, except as provided for in Clause 4 of this Article.
4. The Board of Direction may extend the time of payment of dues,
and may remit the dues of any Member, who, from ill-health, advanced
age or other good reasons, is unable to pay them.
ARTICLE V.
OFFICERS.
i. The officers of the Association shall be Members and shall con-
sist of:
A President,
A First Vice-President,
A Second Vice-President,
A Treasurer,
A Secretary,
Nine Directors,
who, together with the five latest living Past-Presidents who are Members,
shall constitute tbe Board of Direction in which the government of the
Association shall be vested, and who shall act as Trustees, and have the
custody of all property belonging to the Association.
2. The offices of First and Second Vice-Presidents shall be deter-
mined by the priority of their respective dates of election.
3. The terms of office of the several officers shall be as follows :
President, one year.
Vice-Presidents, two years.
Treasurer, one year.
Secretary, one year.
Directors, three years.
4. (a) There shall be elected at each Annual Convention:
A President,
One Vice-President,
A Treasurer,
A Secretary,
Three Directors.
CONSTITUTION.
27
(b) The candidates for President and for Vice-President shall be
selected from the members of the Board of Direction.
5. The office of President shall not be held twice by the same per- conditions of
son. A person who shall have held the office of Vice-President or R,e"®l.ection
. „, . of Officers.
Director shall not be eligible for re-election to the same office until at
least one full term shall have elapsed after the expiration of his previous
term of office.
6. The term of each officer shall begin with his election and con- Term of
., , . . Officers,
tinue until his successor is elected.
7. (a) A vacancy in the office of President shall be filled by the Vacancies
ir- * ir t> -a I m Offices,
rirst Vice-President.
(b) A vacancy in the office of either of the Vice-Presidents shall
be filled by the Board of Direction by election from the Directors. A
Vice-Presidency shall not be considered vacant when one of the Vice-
Presidents is filling a vacancy in the Presidency.
(c) Any other vacancies for the unexpired term in the membership
of the Board of Direction shall be filled by the Board.
(d) An incumbent in any office for an unexpired term shall be
eligible for re-election to the office he is holding; provided, however,
that anyone appointed to fill a vacancy as Director within six months
after the term commences shall be considered as coming within the pro-
vision of Article V, Clause 5.
8. When an officer ceases to be a Member of the Association, as Vacation of
. Office
provided in Article II, his office shall be vacated, and be filled as provided
in Article V, Clause 7.
9. In case of the disability or neglect in the performance of his duty, ^ Neg/ect
of an officer, the Board of Direction, by a two-thirds majority vote of the
entire Board, shall have power to declare the office vacant, and fill it as
provided in Article V, Clause 7.
ARTICLE VI.
NOMINATION AND ELECTION OF OFFICERS.
1. (a) There shall be a Nominating Committee composed of the Nominating
five latest living Past-Presidents of the Association, who are Members, Committee,
and five Members not officers.
(b) The five Members shall be elected annually when the officers of
the Association are elected.
2. It shall be the dutv of this committee to nominate candidates to £un\ber of
P3.ndlQ3.t6S
fill the offices named in Article V, and vacancies in the Nominating Com-
mittee caused by expiration of term of service, for the ensuing year, as
follows : Number of Candi- Number of Candi-
dates to be named dates to be elected
Office to be Filled. by Nominating at Annual Election
Committee. of Officers.
President 1 1
Vice-President 1 1
Treasurer 1 1
Secretary 1 1
Directors 9 3
Nominating Committee 10 5
28
CONSTITUTION.
Chairman.
Meeting of
Committee.
Announce-
ment of
Names of
Nominees.
Additional
Nominations
by Members.
Vacancies
in List of
Nominees.
Ballots
Issued.
Substitution
of Names.
Ballots.
Invalid
Ballots.
Closure
of Polls.
Requirements
for Election.
Tie Vote.
3. The Senior Past-President shall act as permanent chairman of
the committee, and will issue the call for meetings. In his absence from
meetings, the Past-President next in age of service shall act as Chairman
pro tern, at the meeting.
4.: Prior to December 1st, each year, the Chairman shall call a meet-
ing of the committee at a convenient place and, at this meeting, nominees
for office shall be agreed upon.
5. The names of the nominees shall be announced by the permanent
Chairman to the President and Secretary not later than December 15th of
the same year, and the Secretary shall report them to the Members of the
Association on a printed slip not later than January 1st following.
6. At any time between January 1st and February 1st, any ten or
more Members may send to the Secretary additional nominations for the
ensuing year signed by such Members.
7. If any person so nominated shall be found by the Board of Direc-
tion to be ineligible for the office for which he is nominated, or should
a nominee decline such nomination, his name shall be removed and the
Board may substitute another one therefor ; and may also fill any
vacancies that may occur in this list of nominees up to the time the bal-
lots are sent out.
8. Not less than thirty days prior to each Annual Convention, the
Secretary shall issue ballots to each voting member of record in ,good
standing, with a list of the several candidates to be voted upon, with the
names arranged in alphabetical order when there is more than one name
for any office.
9. Members may erase names from the printed ballot list and may
substitute the name or names of any other person or persons eligible for
any office, but the number of names voted for each office on the ballot
must not exceed the number to be elected at that time to such office.
10. (a) Ballots shall be placed in an envelope, sealed and endorsed
with the name of the voter, and mailed or deposited with the Secretary
at any time previous to the closure of the polls.
(b) A voter may withdraw his ballot, and may substitute another,
at any time before the polls close.
11. Ballots not endorsed or from persons not qualified to vote shall
not be opened; and any others not complying with the above provisions
shall not be counted.
12. The polls shall be closed at twelve o'clock noon on the second
day of the Annual Convention, and the ballots shall be counted by three
tellers appointed by the Presiding Officer. The ballots and envelopes shall
be preserved for not less than ten days after the vote is canvassed.
13. The persons who shall receive the highest number of votes for
the offices for which they are candidates shall be declared elected.
14. In case of a tie between two or more candidates for the same
office, the members present at the Annual Convention shall elect the officer
by ballot from the candidates so tied.
CONSTITUTION. 29
15. The Presiding Officer shall announce at the convention the names Announce-
of the officers elected in accordance with this Article. men "
16. Except as to the Past-Presidents, the first Nominating Com- First
mittee and the three additional Directors provided for shall be appointed committee?
by the Board of Direction, one of the Directors for one year one for
two years, and one for three years.
ARTICLE VII.
MANAGEMENT.
R? (a) The President shall have general supervision of the affairs
of the Association, shall preside at meetings of the Association and of
the Board of Direction, and shall be ex-officio member of all Committees,
except the Nominating Committee.
(b) The Vice-Presidents, in order of seniority, shall preside at meet-
ings in the absence of the President and discharge his duties in case of a
vacancy in his office.
2.' The Treasurer shall receive all moneys and deposit same in the
name of the Association, and shall receipt to the Secretary therefor. He
shall invest all funds not needed for current disbursements as shall be
ordered by the Board of Direction. He shall pay all bills, when properly
certified and audited by the Finance Committee, and make such reports
as may be called for by the Board of Direction.
3. The Secretary shall be, under the direction of the President and
Board of Direction, the Executive Officer of the Association. He shall
attend the meetings of the Association and of the Board of Direction,
prepare the business therefor, and duly record the proceedings thereof.
He shall see that the moneys due the Association are collected and with-
out loss transferred to the custody of the Treasurer. He shall personally
certify to the accuracy of all bills or vouchers on which money is to be
paid. He is to conduct the correspondence of the Association and keep
proper record thereof, and perform such other duties as the Board of
Direction may prescribe.
4. The accounts of the Treasurer and Secretary shall be audited
annually by a public accountant, under the direction of the Finance Com-
mittee of the Board.
5. The Board of Direction shall manage the affairs of the Associa-
tion, and shall have full power to control and regulate all matters not
otherwise provided in the Constitution.
6. The Board of Direction shall meet within thirty days after each
Annual Convention, and at such other times as the President may direct.
Special meetings shall be called on request, in writing, of five members
of the Board.
7. Seven members of the Board shall constitute a quorum.
8. At the first meeting of the Board after the Annual Convention,
the following committees from its members shall be appointed by the
President, and shall report to and: perform their duties under the super-
vision of the Board of Direction :
Duties of
President.
Duties of
Treasurer.
Duties of
Secretary.
Auditing of
Accounts.
Duties of
Board.
Board
Meetings.
Board l
Quorum.
Board
Committees
30
CONSTITUTION.
Duties of
Finance
Committee.
Duties of
Publication
Committee.
Duties of
Library
Committee.
Duties of
Committee or
Outline of
Work of
Standing
Committees.
Standing
Committees.
Special
Committees.
Discussion
by Non-
Memteers.
Sanction of
Acts of
Board.
a. Finance Committee of three members.
b. Publication Committee of three members.
c. Library Committee of three members.
d. Outline of Work of Standing Committees of five members.
9. The Finance Committee shall have immediate supervision of the
accounts and financial affairs of the Association; shall approve all bills
before payment, and shall make recommendations to the Board of Direc-
tion as to the investment of moneys and as to other financial matters. The
Finance Committee shall not have the power to incur debts or other obli-
gations binding the Association, nor authorize the payment of money
other1 than the amounts necessary to meet ordinary current expenses of
the Association, except by previous action and authority of the Board of
Direction.
10. The Publication Committee shall have general supervision of
the publications of the Association.
11. The Library Committee shall have general supervision of the
Library, the property therein, and the quarters occupied by the Secretary;
shall make recommendations to the Board with reference thereto, and
shall direct the expenditure for books and other articles of permanent
value, from such sums as may be appropriated for these purposes.
12. The Committee on Outline of Work of Standing Committees
shall present a list of subjects for committee work during the ensuing
year at the first meeting of the Board of Direction after the Annual Con-
vention.
13. The Board of Direction may appoint such Standing Committees
as it may deem best, to investigate, consider and report upon questions
pertaining to railway location, construction or maintenance.
14. Special Committees to examine into and report upon any subject
connected with the objects of this Association may be appointed from
time to time by the Board of Direction.
15. The Board of Direction may invite discussions of reports from
persons not members of the Association.
16. An act of the Board of Direction which shall have received the
expressed or implied sanction of the membership at the next Annual Con-
vention of the Association shall be deemed to be the act of the Associa-
tion, and shall not afterwards be impeached by any Member.
Annual
Convention.
Special
Meetings.
ARTICLE VIII.
MEETINGS.
1. The Annual Convention shall begin upon the third Tuesday in
March of each year, and shall be held at such place in the City of Chicago
as the Board of Direction may select.
2. Special meetings of the Association may be called by the Board
of Direction, and special meetings shall be so called by the Board upon
request of thirty Members, which request shall state the purpose of such
meeting. The call for such meeting shall be issued not less than ten
days in advance, and shall state the purpose and place thereof, and no
other business shall be taken up at such meeting.
CONSTITUTION.
31
3. The Secretary shall notify all members of the time and place of
the Annual Convention of the Association at least thirty days in advance
thereof.
4. Twenty-five Members shall constitute a quorum at all meetings
of the Association.
5. (a) The order of business at annual conventions of the Associa-
tion shall be as follows :
Reading of minutes of last meeting.
Address of the President.
Reports of the Secretary and Treasurer.
Reports of Standing Committees.
Reports of Special Committees.
Unfinished business.
New business.
Election of officers.
Adjournment.
(b) This order of business, however, may be changed by a majority
vote of members present.
6. The proceedings shall be governed by "Robert's Rules of Order,"
except as otherwise herein provided.
7. Discussion shall be limited to members and to those invited by
the presiding officer to speak.
Notification
of Annual
Convention.
Association
Quorum.
Order of
Business.
Rules of
Order.
Discussion.
ARTICLE IX.
AMENDMENTS.
I. Proposed amendments to this Constitution shall be made in writ- Amendments
ing and signed by not less than ten Members, and shall be acted upon
in the following manner:
The amendments shall be presented to the Secretary, who shall send
a copy of same to each member of the Board of Direction as soon as
received. If at the next meeting of the Board of Direction a majority
of the entire Board are in favor of considering the proposed amend-
ments, the matter shall then be submitted to the Association for letter-
ballot, and the result announced by the Secretary at the next Annual
Convention. In case two-thirds of the votes received are affirmative,
the amendments shall be declared adopted and become immediately
effective.
Standing
Commit-
ters.
Special
Commit-
tees.
Personnel
of Com-
mittees.
Outline of
Work.
General.
GENERAL INFORMATION.
(Subject to change from time to time by Board of Direction.)
GENERAL RULES FOR THE PREPARATION, PUBLICATION
AND CONSIDERATION OF COMMITTEE REPORTS.
(a) appointment of committees and outline of work.
i. The following are standing committees:
I. Roadway.
II. Ballast.
III. Ties.
IV. Rail.
V. Track.
VI. Buildings.
VII. Wooden Bridges and Trestles.
VIII. Masonry.
IX. Signs, Fences and Crossings. ,
X. Signals and Interlocking.
XL Records and Accounts
XII. Rules and Organization.
XIII. Water Service.
XIV. Yards and Terminals.
XV. Iron and Steel Structures.
XVI. Economics of Railway Location.
XVII. Wood Preservation.
XVIII. Electricity. .
XIX. Conservation of Natural Resources. ■•-,-..
2. Special Committees will be appointed from time to time,, as may
be deemed expedient, in the manner prescribed by Article. ;VII, Clause
14, of the Constitution.
3. The personnel of all Committees will continue from year to
year, except when changes are announced by the Board of Direction. . ,
4. As soon as practicable after each annual convention the^Boarql
of Direction will assign to each Committee the important questions
which, in its judgment, should preferably be considered during the cur-
rent year. Committees are privileged to present the results of any spe-
cial study or investigation they may be engaged upon or that may be
considered of sufficient importance to warrant presentation.
(b) preparation of committee reports.
5. The collection and compilation of data and subsequent analysis
in the form of arguments and criticism is a necessary and valuable pre-
liminary element of committee work.
32
GENERAL INFORMATION.
'63
6. Committees are privileged to obtain data or information in any-
proper way. If desired, the Secretary will issue circulars of inquiry,
which should be brief and concise. The questions asked should be specific
and pertinent, and not of such general or involved character as to pre-
clude the possibility of obtaining satisfactory and prompt responses.
They should specify to whom answers are to be sent, and should be in
such form that copies can be retained by persons replying either by
typewriter or blue-print.
7. Committee reports should be prepared as far as practicable to
conform to the following general plan:
(a) It is extremely important that every Committee should ex-
amine its own subject-matter in the "Manual" prior to each annual con-
vention, and revise and supplement it, if deemed desirable, giving the
necessary notice of any recommended changes in accordance with Clause
6 (a) of the General Rules for the Publication of the "Manual." If no
changes are recommended, statement should be made accordingly.
(b) When deemed necessary, the previous report should be reviewed.
(c) Subjects presented in previous reports on which no action
was taken should be resubmitted, stating concisely the action desired. It
may not be necessary to repeat the original text in the report, reference
to former publication being sufficient, unless changes in the previously
published version are extensive. Minor changes can be explained in the
text of the report.
(d) Technical terms used in the report, the meaning of which is
not clearly established, should be defined, but defined only from the
standpoint of railway engineering.
(e) If necessary, a brief history of the subject-matter under dis-
cussion, with an outline of its origin and development, should be given.
(f) An analysis of the most important elements of the subject-matter
should be given.
(g) The advantages and disadvantages of the present and recom-
mended practices should be set forth.
(h) Illustrations accompanying reports should be prepared so that
they can be reproduced on one page. The use of folders should be avoided
as much as possible, on account of the increased expense and inconvenience
in referring to them. Plans showing current practice, or necessary for
illustration, are admissible, but those showing proposed definite design
or practice should be excluded. Recommendatoins should be confined to
governing principles.
Illustrations should be made on tracing cloth with heavy black lines
and figures, so as to stand a two-thirds reduction ; for example : To come
within a type page (4 inches by 7 inches), the illustration should be
made three times the above size.
To insure uniformity, the one-stroke, inclined Gothic lettering is
recommended.
Photographs should be clear and distinct silver prints.
Collection
of Data.
Plan of
Reports
Definitions.
History.
Analysis.
Argument.
Illustrations
34
GENERAL INFORMATION.
Conclusions.
Reports
Required.
Date of
Filing
Reports.
Publication
of Reports.
Written
Discussions.
Verbal
Discussions.
Sequence.
Plans showing current practice, or necessary for illustration, are
admissible, but those showing proposed definite design or practice should
be excluded. Recommendations should be confined to governing principles.
(i) The conclusions of the Committee which are recommended for
publication in the Manual should be stated in concise language, logical
sequence, and grouped together, setting forth the principles, specifications,
definitions, forms, tables and formulas included in the recommendation.
Portions of the text of the report which are essential to a clear interpre-
tation and understanding of the conclusions, should be included as an
integral part thereof.
(C) PUBLICATION OF COMMITTEE REPORTS.
8. (a) Reports will be required from each of the Standing and
Special Committees each year.
(b) Although several subjects may be assigned to each Committee
by the Board of Direction, a full report on only one subject is expected
at each annual convention, but the preliminary work, on some of the
remaining subjects should be in progress, and, when deemed advisable,
partial reports of progress should also be presented. This method allows
time for their proper preparation and consideration.
g. Committee reports to come before the succeeding convention for
discussion should be filed with the Secretary not later than November,
30 of each year.
10. Committees engaged upon subjects involving an extended investi-
gation and study are privileged to present progress reports, giving a
brief statement of the work accomplished, and, if deemed expedient, a
forecast of the final report to be presented.
11. Committee reports will be published in the Bulletin in such
sequence as the Board of Direction may determine, for consideration at
the succeeding convention. Reports will be published in the form pre-
sented by the respective Committees. Alterations ordered by the conven-
tion will be printed as an appendix to the report.
12. Committees should endeavor to secure written discussions of
published reports. Written discussions will be transmitted to the
respective Committees, and if deemed desirable by the Committee, the
discussions will be published prior to the convention and be considered
in connection with the report.
13. Each speaker's remarks will be submitted to him in writing be-
fore publication in the Proceedings, for the correction of diction and
errors of reporting, but not for the elimination of remarks.
(d) consideration of committee reports.
14. The sequence in which Committee reports will be considered by
the convention will be determined by the Board of Direction.
GENERAL INFORMATION.
35
15. The method of consideration of Committee reports will be one Method,
of the following:
(a) Reading by title.
(b) Reading, discussing and acting upon each conclusion sep-
arately.
(c) By majority vote, discussion will be had on each item.
Clauses not objected to when read will be considered
as voted upon and adopted.
16. Action by the convention on Committee reports will be one of Final
the following, after discussion is closed :
(a) Receiving as information.
(b) Receiving as a progress report.
(c) Adoption of a part complete in itself and referring re-
mainder back to Committee.
(d) Adoption as a whole.
(e) Recommittal with or without instructions.
(1) Adoption as a whole.
(g) Recommendation to publish in the Manual.
Action.
Note. — An amendment which affects underlying principles, if adopted,
shall of itself constitute a recommittal of such part of the report as the
Committee considers affected.
The Chair will decline to entertain amendments which in his opinion
lie entirely within the duties of the Editor.
GENERAL RULES FOR THE PUBLICATION OF THE "MANUAL."
i. The title of the volume will be "Manual of the American Railway
Engineering Association."
2. The Board of Direction shall edit the Manual and shall have
authortiy to withhold from publication any matter which it shall consider as
not desirable to publish, or as not being in proper shape, or as not having
received proper study and consideration.
3. Matters adopted by the Association and subsequently published
in the Manual shall be considered in the direction of good practice, but
shall not be binding on the members.
4. The Manual will only include conclusions relating to definitions,
specifications and principles of practice as have been made the subject of a
special study by a Standing or Special Committee and embodied in a com-
mittee report, published not less than thirty days prior to the annual con-
A'ention, and submitted by the Committee to the annual convention, and
which, after due consideration and discussion, shall have been voted
on and formally adopted by the Association. Subjects which, in the opinion
of the Board of Direction, should be reviewed by the American Rail-
way Association, may be referred to that Association before being pub-
lished in the Manual.
5. All conclusions included in the Manual must be in concise and
proper shape for publication, as the Manual will consist only of a summary
record of the definitions, specifications and principles of practice adopted
by the Association, with a brief reference to the published Proceedings
of the Association for the context of the Committee report and subsequent
discussion and the final action of the Association.
6. Any matter published in the Manual may be amended or with-
drawn by vote at any subsequent annual convention, provided such
changes are proposed in time for publication not less than thirty days
prior to the annual convention, and in the following manner : (a) Upon
recommendation of the Committee in charge of the subject; (b) upon
recommendation of the Board of Direction; (c) upon request of five
members, made to the Board of Direction.
7. The Manual will be revised either by publishing a new edition or
a supplemental pamphlet as promptly as possible after each annual con-
vention.
36
BUSINESS SESSION
PROCEEDINGS.
The object of this Association is the advancement of knowledge pertaining to the
scientific and economic location, construction, operation and maintenance
of railways. Its actios is not binding upon its members.
TUESDAY, MARCH 19, 1912.
MORNING SESSION.
The Convention was called to order by Mr. W. C. Cashing. Chief
Engineer Maintenance of Way, Pennsylvania Lines West of Pittsburgh,
at 9:20 o'clock.
The President : — Gentlemen, please come to order.
The Thirteenth Annual Convention of our Association, now known
for its first year under its new name, American Railway Engineering
Association, ought to be an auspicious one, for was not "13" the number
of the original States of our glorious Republic and "13" the number of
letters in the motto of our State coat of arms, ''E Pluribus Unum," while,
in one claw, the eagle holds thirteen sharp-pointed arrows, and in the
other an olive branch with thirteen leaves? Moreover, the words "City
of Chicago," which lends its hospitality for our meeting, contain thirteen
letters.
The Committee on Arrangements has been untiring in its zeal, and
we are certain that our program has been well-prepared, and that we
will have an enjoyable time.
The Railway Age-Gazette and the Railway and Engineering Review
will prepare Daily Editions, thus helping to keep up our interest and in-
form us of the current events during the Convention. They are entitled
to the gratitude and thanks of the members.
The privileges of the floor are extended to railway officials, engineers,
and others not members of the Association, and they are cordially invited
to participate in the discussions.
For the benefit of your fellow-members and the reporters, each
speaker is requested, upon arising for recognition by the Chair, to state
his name and the Company or College with which he is associated.
The first business to be attended to is the reading of the Minutes
of the last Convention, but, as they have already been in print for some
time, the reading will be dispensed with and the approval of the members
considered as given, unless there is some objection.
There being no objection, the Minutes stand approved as printed.
Next in order is the report of the President.
39
40
BUSINESS SESSION.
PRESIDENT'S ADDRESS.
ASSOCIATION AFFAIRS.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
At the last Annual Convention we numbered 967 Members, Honorary
Members and Associates. During the year we have passed the 1,000 mark,
although, naturally, our rate of growth has not been quite so rapid as in
former years. As the date of our fiscal year has been changed from
March to December 31st, it is difficult to make exact comparisons. The
largest number of accretions in any one year was 124, in 1901, while in
1904 we had 104, and in 191 1, 98 new members. From last March to
December 31, 191 1, only part of a year, 37 new members have joined.
During the first few years of the existence of the Association a com-
fortable cash surplus was accumulated, but in the last three years the
amount of printed matter issued has grown to such an extent that our ex-
penditures have been in excess of our receipts, and the surplus has been
drawn upon. The following table gives approximately the number of
printed pages issued in each year since the beginning :
1899
1900
1901
1902|l903
1904
1905
1906
1907
1908 1909
1910 1911
Totals
54
54
172
513
430
1124
794
1028
1074
848
1302 2234
1990
1470
12979
244
825
598
602
1000
9S0
942
768
970 1778
1412
19S2
12101
210
316
522
1048
44
36
36
44
48
48
80
78
62
82
558
24
8
26
34
34
32
158
Totals
54
4161338
1072
1786
1838
2262
2064
1980
2378 4184
3498
4330
27140
You will observe from this that during the last four years 14,330
pages, or more than half the total, have been printed, exceeding the num-
ber issued in the preceding nine years.
It was clear to your Board, therefore, that either the printing bill
must be reduced, or the revenue increased, or both.
So far as increasing the revenues are concerned, your Board has
been unwilling as yet to recommend an increase in annual membership
dues, but is arranging for the present to obtain additional revenue by em-
ploying an advertising agent to secure advertisements for the Bulletins
and Program. It is estimated that this arrangement will net about $4,000
annually. The advertisements, and methods of obtaining them, will be
closely supervised, but, nevertheless, the members of the Board are op-
posed to the principle, and would not resort to it except in a case of
emergency. It is hoped that the plan can be abolished at a future date,
as in the case of the American Society of Civil Engineers.
With reference to reducing the expenditures, the Board has given a
great deal of study to the question during the past year, and has made
BUSINESS SESSION. 41
some changes through the careful and energetic investigation of the
Publication Committee and the Secretary.
First in importance is the Secretary's plan to avoid a reprinting of
the reports for the Proceedings, after the Convention, by having a suffi-
cient number of pages for the Proceedings printed at the same time as
the Bulletins. The only disadvantage is that the discussions will be col-
lected together at the end of the volume, instead of appearing at the end
of the reports to which they refer, as in the past. This objection, how-
ever, was not considered of sufficient importance in comparison with the
saving in printing, which is estimated to be about $1,000.
In addition to the above, but 10 Bulletins a year instead of 12 will
be issued, the May and June numbers being omitted. This is done be-
cause it is usually difficult to obtain articles for them, and the Secre-
tary is very busy during those months in preparing for the publication
of the Proceedings. It is hoped that it will result in their earlier ap-
pearance. Moreover, a reduction in the number of Bulletins to be printed
will be made, so that it will be necessary for members to bring their
copies with them to the Convention. Some extra ones will be provided
for those who prefer to purchase them at cost.
Further economy is expected in postal rates by obtaining the second-
class mail privilege, • application for which has been made to the Post-
master-General. All the prescribed details have been complied with,
among which is the altered appearance of the cover of the Bulletins. In
this connection it was necessary to establish regular subscription rates for
our Bulletins, and we are also now advertising in them the established
prices for all of our publications. The estimated reduction of expense for
postage by this arrangement is about $500. It is of interest to know
that we could not come under the regulations for this privilege till our
Association numbered 1,000 persons.
The question of the use of a thinner and lighter weight paper for
our publications is now before the Board, and its adoption will probably
result in some economy of postage expense. The transactions of the
American Society of Civil Engineers are hereafter to be issued in one
volume printed on India paper, but its use would not be economical for
this Association, because a special paper is required for the illustrations.
For a good while the Board of Direction realized that the number of
subjects reported on by committees was apt to be too many for thorough
discussion on the floor, considering the large number of standing com-
mittees, and introduced Rule 8-b for the preparation of committee reports,
which limited the number to two for action by the Convention. A large
number of subjects has always been assigned each year, so that the com-
mittees could be collecting subject matter for other reports to be presented
a year or more hence. When the increase in expenses became alarm-
ing the Board found it necessary to have the President issue a special
circular to committee chairmen, calling attention to the necessity for en-
forcing the rule strictly this year. The several committees have re-
42 BUSINESS SESSION.
sponded heartily to the request, and the results of their conscientious and
painstaking work is apparent in the valuable reports presented.
The ideal method of increasing our revenues (without resorting either
to the augmentation of the annual dues or to advertising) would be to
secure a larger membership, approximately double the present number,
as the expense involved in issuing the Bulletins and Proceedings is not
much more for a membership of 2,coo than for one of 1,000, while the
revenue would be doubled. While we are pleased with the present num-
ber of members, yet it is evident that many who are eligible and who
would be most desirable confreres have not yet identified themselves with
the Association.
In view of the unauthorized use of extracts from our Proceedings
for advertising purposes by commercial agencies, your Board arranged for
copyrighting all of our publications in the United States. It was not ex-
pedient to do so in Canada.
At the last Convention important changes in our Constitution were
adopted, among which were the shortening of the name, the establish-
ment of a Nominating Committee, in order to place a larger share of the
management in the hands of the members, and the addition of three
members to the Board of Direction. During the past year it has been found
desirable to make some changes in the "General Rules for the Prepara-
tion, Publication and Consideration of Committee Reports," and the
"General Rules for the Publication of the Manual," in order to make the
work of the Association more expeditious and the papers and reports
more valuable.
An invitation to send five delegates to the Third National Conserva-
tion Congress at Kansas City on September 25, 26 and 27, 191 1, was ex-
tended to the Association, and Messrs. W. S. Kinnear, John V. Hanna,
John R. Leighty, H. S. Moore and J. A. L. Waddell were named.
An invitation was issued to your Association through the sub-
department Secretaries of the Department of Commerce and Labor to
participate with them, the Government engineers, and other engineering
societies, in a conference for the purpose of unifying specifications for
Portland Cement, and the invitation was accepted, the matter being put
in the hands of Committee VIII — Masonry. We were advised by the
Special Committee of the Departmental Conference that, on January 8,
1912, all parties had agreed to the preliminary specifications, except there
was a difference of opinion as to whether the Vicat or Gilmore needles
should be used for determining the time of setting. On January 17, the
Committee of the American Society of Civil Engineers presented its final
report, recommending the continued use of the Vicat needle for deter-
mining consistency and time of setting, which was accepted.
The Assistant Purchasing Agent of the Isthmian Canal Commission
has written our Secretary for our rules covering creosote treatment of
lumber and piling.
An invitation was also sent to this Association to send a representa-
tive to the convention of the International Association for Testing Ma-
terials to be held in September, 1912, and we will accept it.
BUSINESS SESSION. 43
The Association has received from Mr. Willard A. Smith, President
of the Railway and Engineering Review, a valuable contribution of photo-
graphic views of the St. Gothard Railway in Switzerland, and another
valuable contribution of a bound volume entitled "Railroad Transportation
at the St. Louis World's Fair" from Mr. W. M. Camp, Editor of the
same journal, both of which are in the Library.
Prof. W. F. M. Goss, Dean and Director of the University of Illi-
nois, has tendered the use of data collected by the University, and the
assistance of its staff, in the work of Committee XVI — Economics of
Railway Location.
In 1910 the amount of money contributed by the American Railway
Association for experiments and other work in connection with the study
of the rail problem was $6,213.57, while the amount authorized by that
Association for 191 1 is $10,000. The results of the study are published in
the Bulletins as fast as completed. In this connection you are informed
that the following letter has been received by your President from Judge
Wm. J. Wood, Chairman, Railroad Commission of Indiana :
"The Railroad Commission of Indiana has about decided to commence
a formal inquiry into the condition of steel now being put into the rail-
road tracks of this State, involving, of course, a comparison of the steel
now being constructed and that formerly used on the railroads of this
State.
"I understand that your Association has had this matter up more than
once, and I wish to have a conference with you about it in order, among
other things, to have a suggestion from you, as to some person who could
address a conference of Railroad Managers and Engineers, and other
persons interested, held at Indianapolis under the direction of this Com-
mission. Will you be in Chicago this week? I will thank you to advise
me in reference to this subject, and whether or not I could meet you if I
shall come there for that purpose.
"Yours very truly,
(Signed) "W. J. Wood, Chairman."
Your President called upon Judge Wood, and explained to him the
work which Committee IV — Rail, has been doing.
At the meeting subsequently held on February 20, 1912, papers con-
cerning the question of improvement of rail design and specifications were
read by Messrs. P. H. Dudley (by representative), Thos. H. Johnson and
W. C. Cushing, and, in addition, addresses were made by Messrs. F. A.
Delano, E. J. Buffington, R. Montfort and Dr. Benjamin.
Your attention is called to the kindly expression of appreciation of
our work in the editorial of the Railway and Engineering Review of
October 28, 191 1, page 940, and the statement on "Railway and Engineer-
ing Literature," page 944. These words should be a stimulus to further
effort.
In the "Regulations adopted on December 28, 191 1, by the Superin-
tendents of Buildings of all Five Boroughs of the City of New York,"
relative to reinforced concrete, clause No. 9, says that "Steel for rein-
forcement of concrete shall meet the requirements of the standard speci-
fications for steel reinforcement of the American Railway Engineering
Association."
44 BUSINESS SESSION.
In addition to the above three authors of new books to be published
have asked the authority of your Board of Direction to embody informa-
tion contained in our Proceedings in their books.
From these instances it will be apparent that your work has attained
such a value that information from it is now sought. The knowledge,
ought to spur us on to constant improvement.
During the past year the third edition of the Manual has been issued.
The comments on this volume by members and others have been quite
complimentary. These compliments are deserved by the committees,
Mr. Edwin F. Wendt, the Reviewer, Prof. Pence, the Editor, and your
Secretary, Mr. E. H. Fritch.
It is our sad task to announce that we have lost several of our
fellow-members by death during the past year :
Benjamin Douglas, late Tunnel Engineer, Detroit River Tunnel Com-
pany, a charter member and an active worker on committees, was acci-
dentally killed while inspecting a bridge in Brazil, South America.
W. D. Taylor, late Chief Engineer, Chicago & Alton Railroad, a brief
sketch of whom was given in Bulletin 138.
Frank E. Simar, late Division Engineer, Canadian Northern Railway,
at Duluth, Minn.
N. P. Curtis, late Instructor, University of Wisconsin, at Madison.
N. J. Gibbs, until recently engaged in construction work on the Pan-
ama Canal. He was accidentally killed at Tomkins Cove, N. Y.
H. Pierce, late Engineer of Construction of the Chesapeake & Ohio
Railway.
Lewis Kingman, late Office Engineer of the National Railways of
Mexico.
John S. Metcalf, President of John S. Metcalf Co., Chicago.
PROGRESS IN ENGINEERING WORKS.
The year 191 1 has witnessed the continued progress, and in some
cases the completion, of vast works of engineers. Governments, whether
Federal, State or Municipal, continue their works in times of depressed
business as well as in prosperous times, and, therefore, the three greatest
government undertakings, the Panama Canal, the Catskill Aqueduct and
the Erie Canal, have been pushed steadily forward.
Of these the Catskill Aqueduct, estimated to cost $162,000,000, is of
high importance, for it is expected to carry ultimately the water supply
for 20,000,000 people. It is a stupendous undertaking, measuring 92 miles
in length, from the Ashokan Reservoir in the Catskill Mountains to New
York City, and, in time, to be extended into Brooklyn and Staten Island.
The daily delivery of water is to reach 500,000,000 gallons. In addition
to the 55 miles of cut and cover, there will be 24 grade tunnels, aggre-
gating 14 miles, 6 miles of steel pipe siphons and 17 miles of pressure
tunnels, 7 in number. The pressure tunnels are circular, about 14 ft.
diameter, and the one of greatest magnitude and difficulty is that under
the Hudson at Storm King Mountain, 1,150 feet below the surface of the
BUSINESS SESSION. 45
ground. It was holed through last month in the presence of the Mayor
of New York City and many others.
Another important government enterprise, which was brought to suc-
cessful completion last March, is the Roosevelt Dam, in the canyon of
the Salt River, about 70 miles east of Phoenix, Ariz., as it is for the
purpose of impounding 418,000,000,000 gallons of water for irrigation. It
is 276 feet high, with a crest length of 1,080 ft. It was begun in Septem-
ber, 1906, and was estimated to cost about $3,850,000. Owing to its iso-
lation, the cement used was manufactured at the site in a mill especially
constructed for the work. The cost per barrel was $1.96, whereas, if
shipped in, it would have been $9 per barrel.
Notwithstanding the depression in business, the year witnessed the
continued progress, and also the completion, of some magnificent engi-
neering works in the railway world.
The erection of the enormous and palatial station of the New York
Central Lines in New York City has been finally started, after carrying
on since 1903 a large amount of preliminary work of excavation, track
laying and office building. This work has embraced about 3,000,000 cu.
yds. of rock excavation, carried on under great difficulties, about 250,000
cu. yds. of concrete and about 60,000 tons of steel.
The tracks are on two levels, the suburban, 20 in number, about 49
ft. below the street level, and the express or through tracks, 22 in number,
20 to 25 feet above them.
On June 4, 191 1, the large new passenger station of the Chicago &
Northwestern Railway in Chicago, costing about $24,000,000, was opened
for service. Its style is Italian Renaissance, and it is built of gray Maine
granite. The train shed has 16 tracks, and belt conveyors are used for
conveying some of the incoming mail.
Identified with the name of one man, Henry M. Flagler, an enterprise
entirely different from any other was brought to successful completion in
the last week of December, 191 1, so far as the placing of the last batch
of concrete was concerned. This is the famous ocean railway from
Miami to Key West in Florida, 154 miles, of which 74 miles are on land,
25 miles on swamps and 55 miles over water or on the long line of
islands that make up the Florida Keys. There are about 500 reinforced
concrete segmental and semi-circular arches from 45 to 60 ft. span. The
longest viaduct is 10,500 ft., between Long Key and Conch Key. It is a
wonderful piece of work and several disasters from storms during the
construction have been experienced. It was opened for public service
January 22, 1912.
Another great railroad enterprise, estimated to cost $9,500,000, is the
line and grade improvement of the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western
Railroad, between Slateford, Pa., and Hopatcong, N. J., which was opened
for traffic Christmas, 191 1. The old line was shortened from 39.57 miles to
28.45 miles, the grade reduced from 1.14 per cent, to .55 per cent., and
the curvature from 6° 54' to 2°, except in the case of one of 3^2°, saving
1,560° of central angle. It was an unusually bold piece of work, and of
46 BUSINESS SESSION.
great magnitude. The grading consisted of 7,890,000 cu. yds. of earth ex-
cavation, 6,502,000 cu. yds. of rock excavation and 16,000,000 cu. yds. of
embankment. The Pequest fill, containing 6,625,650 cu. yds. of material,
is probably the largest railroad embankment ever constructed, being 3
miles long and from 75 ft. to no ft. high. The total quantity of concrete
is 266,900 cu. yds., and two of the bridges are magnificent reinforced con-
crete arch viaducts, one over the Delaware River, and the other over the
Paulins Kill. The first is 1,540 ft. long and 64 ft. high, and consists of
five spans of 150 ft., two of 120, one of 53 and one of 50J/2 ft. The
Paulins Kill viaduct is 1,100 ft. long and 117 ft. high, and has five spans
of 120 ft. and two of 100 ft.
The Southern Pacific Railway also completed a line and grade change
up the western slope of the Sierras from Rocklin, Cal., to Colfax, 30.8
miles on a 1.5 per cent, grade. There are 17 tunnels on the line
The Galveston Causeway, estimated to cost $1,615,000, was be^un in
1909, and is a structure a little more than 2 miles long, connecting Gal-
veston Island, on which the city of that name stands, with the mainland,
its main feature being a reinforced concrete viaduct 2,455 ft. long, consist-
ing of twenty-eight 70 ft. arch spans and a lift span with a clear water-
way of 109 ft. The viaduct portion is 66 ft. wide, and carries 2 railroad
tracks, one electric railway track and a roadway of 19 ft. clear width. On
the causeway embankment approaches there are more tracks, and the
roadway widens to 40 ft. About 9,808 concrete sheet piles, making a con-
tinuous strip 35 miles long, were required.
The work of introducing electric power on steam railroads was con-
tinued, although in this case, the Hoosac Tunnel, it was of but limited
extent. The work was begun October 3, 1910, and finished May 18, 191 1,
at a cost of 1^4 millions. The electric system is the same as used by the
New York, New Haven & Hartford, and the zone extends from a small
tunnel just west of the North Adams Station to a point just east of the
Hoosac Tunnel station, 21 miles of track being electrically operated. The
tunnel is 4.75 miles long, and was opened in 1875. But lately the New
Haven Company has made known its plan to change the main line from
Stamford to New Haven to electric traction at an early date, at an esti-
mated cost of $7,000,000.
Last April it was announced that a beginning had been made on the
last of the $160,000,000 worth of improvements started in 1903 by the
Pennsylvania Railroad Company, viz : the New York Connecting Rail-
road, which will link the Pennsylvania and New Haven roads together.
This link will be 12 miles long, the principal feature of which will be the
four-track bridge from Astoria on Long Island over Hell Gate, Ward's
and Randall's Islands to Mott Haven or Port Morris. The bridge over
Hell Gate and its approaches will be about 3 miles long, and will be of
most massive construction, costing about $20,000,000. The main span is a
steel arch 1,020 ft. long and 140 ft. above mean water level, making an
imposing gateway for the East River entrance to New York Harbor.
Great engineering works are not confined to this country. The Swiss
:'. BUSINESS SESSION. 47
railway engineers have been obliged, by the rugged nature of their coun-
try, to resort to long and ingenious tunnel building, in order to prevent
their land from becoming a barrier to international transportation. The
world's longest tunnels have been built there, the Simplon, 12.4 miles long;
the St. Gothard, 9.5 miles long, and the past year witnessed the piercing
of the third longest, the Loetschberg, 9 miles long. They also have the
first, Mont Cenis, 7.5 miles long, begun in 1857, and the Arlberg, 6.5 milet
long. In the case of many of these tunnels, gain in elevation in short ins-
tances has been obtained by the use of the spiral, making the journey over
the railway most fascinating, interesting and beautiful.
The Loetschberg Tunnel is built to put the capital, Bern, on the main
line from Milan, Italy, to Paris and Calais in France, while at the same
time the distance is shortened by 80 miles to 675 miles. It was originally
planned to be straight, but a disastrous inrush of water from the Kander
River, burying 25 men, compelled the contractors to wall it up and build
a detour with two short curves. The record of tunnel driving has been
made in this work, a start being made November 1, 1906, while the head-
ings met March 31, 191 1.
The increased daily rate of tunnel driving due to improved methods
and machinery is well illustrated in these Swiss tunnels.
The rate at the M'ont Cenis, begun in 1857, was 7.75 ft. per day, two
headings.
The rate at the St. Gothard, begun in 1872, was 18 ft. per day, two
headings.
The rate at the Arlberg, begun in 1880, was 27.25 ft. per day, two
headings.
The rate at the Simplon, begun in 1893, was 36 ft. per day, two head-
ings.
The rate at the Loetschberg, begun in 1906, was 29.5 ft. per day, one
heading, while a maximum for one day with one heading was 36 ft.
The Panama Canal continues to> be the most costly and most stupen-
dous enterprise now in progress, and its engineers are earning a monu-
ment of fame for themselves. The Special Commissioner to "The Engi-
neer" of London, Mr. Percy F. Martin, F.R.G.S., who visited the Canal in
1910, makes this statement in the issue of June 9, 191 1: "When the
Canal shall be pronounced completed, and the huge lock gates swing open
for the first time to receive the earliest vessel, a chorus of acclamation
and congratulation will ascend such as probably no human achievement
has ever yet called forth. And justifiably so."
In Engineering News for February 17, 1910, the following appeared:
THE COMPLETE ENGINEER OF 30O YEARS AGO.
"Wrapped in the stoutest of manila paper and deposited on the shelves
of the library of the American Society of Civil Engineers is a book, the
gift of Mr. W. A. Haven, M. Am. Soc. C. E., which is probably one of
the earliest of printed books in the English language treating of the art
of science of engineering. On a curiously embellished title page is the
following caption :
48 BUSINESS SESSION.
" 'A Practical Abstract of the Arts of Fortification and Assailing
* * * Written for the benefit of such as delight in the Practice of
those Noble Arts. By David Papillon Gent : * * * London Printed
by R : Austin and are to be sould at the south side of the Exchange &
in Popes head Alley 1645.'
"Engineering in that day, and for a century or so after, was entirely
a military accomplishment, and so the science discussed by the author
did not embrace any of the civil arts which were later a part of the en-
gineer's knowledge, but prefacing the more serious work there is a chap-
ter on (The True Character of a Complete Engineer) which will appeal
even to the modern engineer. Especially will the last paragraph of this
chapter touch a tender spot in the heart of every engineer who has had
to argue against all reason with the lawyer, director or business man
who can see in engineering only a superior sort of craftsmanship which, in
its fundamentals, should be knowledge easily deduced by themselves. The
major portion of this first chapter follow:
" 'of the true character of a complete engineer.
" '(1) He is to be religious for the fear of the Lord is the beginning
of wisdom.
"'(2) He is to be a souldier for none can better judge of the suffi-
diency or insufficiency of fortification. * * *
"'(3) He is to be a traveller; for he that hath not seen variety of
works, and the excellency of foreign Fortifications, cannot perceive the
defects of ours, nor give directions to rectify them.
"'(4) He is to be well versed in the Arithmetike for his calcula-
tions; in the Geometry, for the setting out of all superficies; in the
Architecture, for to direct all manner of artificers ; and in the other parts
of the Mathematikes, for the taking of distances, depths and elevations,
and for the inventing and contriving of all manner of Engines and ma-
chines.
" '(5) He is to be wise in all his proceedings, punctual in all his
promises, careful and diligent in his calling, and rather inclined to aus-
terity with lenity, or otherwise he will never be respected, served or
obeyed.
"'(6) He is to be of solid judgment and quick of apprehension to
judge aright of the defects and advantages of places. * * * He is not
to give account of his actions to any,- but to the Generall, or to the lieu-
tenant Generall of the Ordnance if he be in an Army, or in a Garison,
only to the grand Committee, and to the Governour; and as for all other
kinds of men, inhabitants, souldiers or officers; he is not bound to ex-
postulate the case, if they demand of him reasons for any thing he directs
or commands to be done; neither ought he if he regards his reputation,
and makes conscience of his ways, to comply * * * with the humour
of the greatest in authority, or be led to assent to any resolution, that is
against the maxims of his Art, by the Logical and Sophisticall reasons
and arguments of Scholars or Church-men ; for some of them are now
a days overbusie in things that go beyond their element, and endeavor to
over-sway Artists by rhetorike, considering not that their reasons are no
reasons at all to the reasons of Art. And this last quality is the essen-
tiall part of a good Engineer ; for all the other are but to small purpose
without this.' "
Fellow members : Many of the engineers engaged in the huge enter-
prises briefly outlined in the foregoing pages, and in other work, too, not
mentioned, will measure up with "The Complete Engineer of 300 Years
Ago." (Applause.)
BUSINESS SESSION. 49
The President :■ — I desire to read the following extract from a letter
from Mr. Edwin F. Wendt, Chairman of the Publication Committee, as
it gives additional information to that which I have given in the report:
"The work of the Publication Committee for the year may be con-
sidered as finished.
"The Secretary reports that the paper stock for Proceedings has been
imported from Europe and is now in Chicago. The results from the
use of this paper have been very satisfactory and the Secretary reports
that all experience with this paper so far demonstrates the wisdom of its
selection. It is particularly gratifying to know that it will be feasible
and practical to bind the 1,600 pages of our Proceedings into one vol-
ume, winch will be No. 13. The advantages of this practice will be:
"A saving in shelf room in libraries.
"The elimination of one volume of our Proceedings.
"A reduction in costs of binding.
"It is probable that the 1912 Proceedings will be available in paper
binding by May 1. Cloth bound copies will likely be ready June 1. When
our next Proceedings have been issued and all of our printing bills have
been paid, the Board of Direction will have reason to congratulate itself
by reason of the reduction in expenses of printing, binding and mailing.
The Secretary, as usual, has followed this work in detail with the great-
est care and we are fortunate in having as Secretary a man who is
capable, energetic and loyal in the highest degree.
"Another subject needs some comment at this time. Our Advertising
Representative has not been successful in making contracts for advertis-
ing, either for the Bulletins or the Official Program of the Convention.
This is a matter for regret as we had confidently calculated upon a net
return from the Program, especially. After a conference between the
Advertising Representative ana Mr. Fritch, it was decided by the Secretary
and myself that it would be proper, and even satisfactory to the Adver-
tising Representative, for the Secretary to make his usual effort to obtain
advertising for the Program which will be issued this week before the
Convention."
The President: — The next order of business is the Secretary's and
Treasurer's reports.
(Secretary E. H. Fritch then read the following reports:)
50 BUSINESS SESSION.
SECRETARY'S REPORT.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
I have the honor to present the following report for the period ending
December 31, 1911, and from January 1, 1912, to March 15, 1912:
MEMBERSHIP.
Total Membership at last annual convention, March 15, 1911 967
Additions during the year, 95 95
1,062
Deceased Members 7
Withdrawals during the year 13
Dropped for non-payment of dues 12
32 32
Total membership March 15, 1912 1,030
Consisting of:
Members 939
Honorary Members 4
Associates 87
1,030
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION.
The geographical distribution of the membership is indicated in the
following table :
United States 899 Korea 1
Dominion of Canada 83 Panama 1
Mexico 9 Australia 1
Cuba 5 Great Britain 1
China 6 Peru 2
New Zealand 4 Russia 1
Philippine Islands 3 Central America 2
India 2 Porto Rico 1
Bolivia 1
Japan 3 Total 1,030
BUSINESS SESSION.
Si
CLASSIFICATION OF MEMBERS.
Presidents zz
Assistant to President 2
Vice-Presidents z"j
General Managers 20
Dir. Maint. and Operation.... 1
Asst. General Managers 8
General Superintendents 16
Asst. General Superintendent. 1
Division Superintendents 38
Chief Engineers 121
Asst. Chief Engineers 16
Principal Asst. Engineers [4
Chief Eng. Maint. of Way.... 5
Asst. Chief Eng. M. of Way. 5
Engineers of Construction.... 14
Engineers Maint. of Way 86
Bridge Engineers Z/
Engineers Surveys 1
Division Engineers 86
Assistant Engineers 1 1 1
District Engineers 13
Electrical Engineers 2
Inspecting Engineers 14
Supervising Engineers 1
Architects 4
Locating Engineers 3
Engineers Track Economics. . . 1
Engineers Track and Roadway 4
Maintenance of Way Acct. ... 1
Engineers Bridges and Bldgs. 7
Office Engineers 5
Chief Draftsmen 4
General Roadmasters 2
Roadmasters 16
Master Carpenters 2
Rail Expert 1
Supt. Bridges and Buildings.. 9
Supervisors 2
Resident Engineers 36
Signal Engineers 18
Assistant Signal Engineer 1
Managers Timber Dept 6
Chief Timber Inspector 1
Forester 3
Contracting Engineers 13
Supervisor Materials 1
Chemists and Engineers Tests. 4
Metallurgical Engineers 4
Professors in Colleges 19
Associate Professors 16
Civil Engineers 50
Consulting Engineers 89
General Foreman Water Works 1
Engineer Grade Elimination. . 4
Purchasing Agent 1
Receivers 3
Editors 3
Inspector Maintenance 3
Masonry Engineer
Asst. Superintendents
Engineers Valuation
Drainage Engineer
General Agent
Engineer Water Service...
Municipal Engineers 6
Commercial Engineer 1
Miscellaneous 26
Totals 1,030
PUBLICATIONS.
During the year the following publications have been issued by the
Association :
12 Bulletins.
Proceedings for 191 1 (Parts 1 and 2).
1 Edition of the Manual.
2 Editions of Specifications for Plain and Reinforced Concrete and
Steel Reinforcement.
1 Edition of Conventional Signs.
Program for the Thirteenth Annual Convention.
52 BUSINESS SESSION.
The table below indicates the number of pages, illustrations, etc., of
the publications issued :
No. Half- Folding Dia-
Pages. Tones. Plates grams. Tables. Forms.
Bulletins 1740 440 20
Proceedings 135.2 82 8
Manual 525 55 5 264
Steel Specifications. 34
Concrete Specific. 15
Conventional Signs 15 30
Program 56
240
35i
306
219
264
44
3
2
1
1
no
3737 607 33 924 61;
FINANCIAL STATEMENT.
Balance cash on hand March 15, 191 1 $13,216.6^
Consisting of:
Ten Railroad Bonds, as follows : Four St.
Louis Southwestern Railway Company
Bonds, par value $1,000 each, at cost $ 3,319.31
Six Lake Shore & Michigan Southern Rail-
way Company Bonds, par value $1,000 each,
at cost 5,660.25
Cash in bank 4,237.06
$13,216.62
Receipts during the year :
March 16, Jan. 1, 1912, Totals
1911, to to for One
Dec. 31, 1911. Mar. 15, 1912. Year.
From Members, dues, etc $ 5,274.48 $ 8,567.35 $13,841.83
From Others, sales of publications,
advertising, etc 6,853.59 1,394.91 8,248.50
From American Railway Association,
account Rail Committee Expense. 6,495.57
From Interest 295.72
From Loan 1,000.00
From Proceeds of Sale of Bonds.... 3,797-33
508.56
7,004.13
67.62
363-34
1,000.00
3,797-33
Totals $23,716.69 $10,538.44 $34,255.13
Expenditures during the year:
March 16, 191 1, to Dec. 31, 191 1 $26,650.64
January 1, 1912, to March 15, 1912 2,719.02
Total Expenditures $29,369.66
BUSINESS SESSION. 53
Summary.
March 16, Jan. i, 1912,
191 1, to to
Dec. 31, 1911. Mar. 15, 1912.
Receipts $23,716.69 $10,538.44 $34,255.13
Expenditures 26,650.64 2,719.02 29,369.66
Total $ 4,885.47
Less amount of proceeds from sale of bonds 3,797-33
Net Excess of Receipts over Expenditures $ 1,088.14
EXPENDITURES IN DETAIL.
March 16, Jan. 1, 1912, Totals
Items. 1911, to to for One
Dec. 31, 191 1. Mar. 15, 1912, Year.
Stationery and Printing $ 298.20 $ 66.66 $ 364.86
Proceedings 4,842.18 .25 4,842.43
Bulletins 4,i5i-6i 366.54 4,518.15
Manual 2,187.79 2,187.79
Postage 784.20 189.87 974-07
Salaries 3,593-30 746.66 4-339-90
Officers Expenses 19.00 16.50 35-50
Annual Meeting 1,220.93 1,220.93
Telephone and Telegrams 67.41 20.24 87.65
Rents 600.00 120.00 720.00
Expressage 524.46 28.53 552-99
Exchange 23.20 2.40 25.60
Supplies 220.06 36.18 256.24
Light 12.79 6.15 18.94
Miscellaneous 75.91 9.85 85.76
Badges 80.00 80.00
Commission on Advertising 76.25 76.25
Impact 1,048.96 1,048.96
Rail Committee 5,850.70 936.26 6,786.96
Committee Expenses H7-44 16.68 I34-T2
Repayment of Loan 1,000.00 1,000.00
Interest on Loan 12.50 , 12.50
Total $26,650.64 $2,719.02 $29,369.66
Respectfully submitted,
E. H. Fritch, Secretary.
54 BUSINESS SESSION.
TREASURER'S REPORT.
To the Members of the American Raikvay Engineering Association:
I have the honor of presenting the following report :
Balance Cash on hand, March 15, 191 1 $13,216.62
Consisting of:
Ten railroad bonds, as follows : Four St.
Louis Southwestern bonds, par value,
$1,000 each, at cost. $ 3,319.31
Six L. S. & M. S. Ry. bonds, par value,
$1,000 each, at cost 5,660.25
Cash in Bank 4,237.06
Total $13,216.62
Receipts from all sources, March 16, 1911, to Dec. 31, 1911 $23,716.69
Receipts from all sources, Jan. 1, 1912, to March 15, 1912 10,538.44
Total Receipts for the year $34,255.13
Expenditures :
March 16, Jan. 1, 1912,
1911,10 to
Dec. 31, 1911. Mar. 15, 1912.
Paid on audited vouchers $25,602.96 $ 3,766.70 $29,369.66
Balance to credit $ 4,885.47
Less proceeds from sale of four L. S. & M. S. bonds 3,797-33
Net Excess of Receipts over Expenditures $ 1,088.14
Composition of Balance, March 15, 1912:
Cash in bank $ 8,836.43
Cash on hand, checks, etc 286.10
Four St. Louis Southwestern bonds, at cost 3,319-31
Two L. S. & M. S. bonds, at cost 1,886.75
Total Cash Assets, March 15, 1912 $14,328.59
The bonds above listed are registered in the name of the Association
and have been placed in a safety deposit box in the Merchants' Loan and
Trust Company's vaults, Chicago.
Respectfully submitted,
Geo. H. Bremner, Treasurer.
The President : — What is your pleasure in regard to the reports of
the Secretary and the Treasurer?
Mr. W. H. Elliott : — I move the acceptance of the reports.
(The motion was carried.)
The President : — There has been prepared for our benefit by the
National Railway Appliances Association an unparalleled exhibit of rail-
BUSINESS SESSION. 55
way appliances in the Coliseum, on Wabash Avenue, and in order to allow
the members time to visit it, it has been decided to adjourn at 4 p. m.
to-day. The exhibit is more complete and larger than ever, so that it
has been necessary to use the adjacent armory building this year.
There will be no evening session.
The members are requested, as usual, to be early in the purchase of
dinner tickets, which will be on sale this afternoon in the lobby outside
of this room. You all know, from what has been said in previous years,
that we have to give the necessary information to the hotel people in
order that they may make the necessary preparations.
The next order of business is the presentation of the reports of the
Standing and Special Committees. The members of committees will
please take their places on the platform when their names are called by
the Secretary. If all the reports assigned for any one day are finished
before the time of adjournment, the first report assigned for the following
day may be brought before the Association in order to advance the work
of the convention.
We will now take up the report of the Committee on Rules and Or-
ganization. Mr. Jos. O. Osgood, the Chairman of the Committee, at the
last minute was prevented from coming here, so that he has not had an
opportunity to fully instruct the other members of his Committee as to
the preliminary announcement. Mr. F. D. Anthony will be kind enough
to state the general work of the Committee in order that the report of the
Committee may be discussed.
(The report of the Committee on Rules and Organization was pre-
sented by Mr. F. D. Anthony, a member of the Committee. See report,
pp. 65-68; discussion, pp. 919-931.)
The President : The next report is that of the Committee on Signals
and Interlocking, of which Mr. A. H. Rudd is Chairman. In the absence
of the Chairman, Mr. L. R. Clausen, the Vice-Chairman, will present the
report.
(The report of the Committee on Signals and Interlocking was pre-
sented by Mr. L. R. Clausen, the Vice-Chairman. See report, pp. 69-76 ;
discussion, pp. 932, 933.)
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Iron
and Steel Structures, of which Mr. C. H. Cartlidge is Chairman. We
will ask the Chairman of the Committee to make the opening statement.
(The report of the Committee on Iron and Steel Structures was pre-
sented by Mr. C. H. Cartlidge, the Chairman. See report, pp. 81-88;. dis-
cussion, pp. 934-945.)
AFTERNOON SESSION.
The President : — The report of the Committee on Wooden Bridges
and Trestles will next be disposed of. Mr. C. C. Went worth, the Chair-
man, will make the opening statement.
56 BUSINESS SESSION.
(The report of the Committee on Wooden Bridges and Trestles was
presented by Mr. C. C. Wentworth, the Chairman. See report, pp. 71-80 ;
discussion, page 946.)
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Ballast,
of which Mr. H. E. Hale is Chairman. The Chair will ask Mr. Hale to-
make the opening statement.
(The report of the Committee on Ballast was presented by Mr. H. E.
Hale, the Chairman. See report, pp. 95-300; discussion, pp. 949, 950.)
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Ties,
of which Mr. L. A. Downs is Chairman. Mr. Downs will make the
opening statement for the Committee.
(The report of the Committee on Ties was presented by Mr. L. A.
Downs, the Chairman. See report, pp. 301-370; discussion, pp. 951-964.)
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on Track,
of which Mr. J. B. Jenkins is Chairman. Mr. Jenkins will make the pre-
liminary statement for the Committee.
(The report of the Committee on Track was presented by Mr. J. B.
Jenkins, the Chairman. See report, pp. 371-386; discussion, pp. 965-980.)
The President: — We will now adjourn, and the remaining questions
will be taken up in the morning on the length of switches and also the
specifications.
(Adjourned until 9 o'clock a. m., Wednesday.)
WEDNESDAY, MARCH 20, 1912.
MORNING SESSION.
The President: — Before taking up the regular order of business, the
Chair would ask the unanimous consent of the Association to vary
slightly from the program in order to be able to announce the results
of the election of officers at the close of the afternoon session. The
Chair will appoint as Tellers the following members : C. H. Spencer,
C. H. Fisk and W. J. Bergen. The Secretary will turn over the ballots
to the Tellers after the noon adjournment. The Tellers will retire to the
anteroom and prepare their report. The polls will close at twelve o'clock
to-day. This room has been engaged for some banquet this evening, and
as an accommodation to the hotel they would like to have us adjourn
between four-thirty and five o'clock if we can possibly do so, in order
that they may have the room so as to prepare for the banquet.
This evening our annual dinner is to commence promptly at seven
o'clock, and the members are urgently requested to be at the banquet hall
before seven o'clock, so that we can begin promptly at seven.
The further consideration of the report of the Committee on Track
will now be taken up. The consideration of the report was suspended last
evening while we were discussing conclusion 3 on page 374, with reference
to the lengths of switches and number of frogs, and this question is now
BUSINESS SESSION. 57
open for discussion. Mr. Jenkins, the Chairman of the Committee, will
continue the presentation of the report.
The next report is that of the Committee on Yards and Terminals, of
which Mr. C. H. Spencer is Chairman. The Chairman will make the pre-
liminary announcement.
(The report of the Committee on Yards and Terminals was presented
by Mr. C. H. Spencer, the Chairman. See report, pp. 89-92; discussion,
PP. 947, 948.)
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on Rail,
Mr. Chas. S. Churchill, Chairman. The Chairman is requested to make
the preliminary statement.
(The report of the Committee on Rail was presented by Mr. Chas. S.
Churchill, the Chairman. See report, pp. 559-862; discussion, pp.
1017-1038.)
The President :^The next report is that of the Committee on Road-
way. In the absence of the Chairman, Mr. W. M. Dawley, the Vice-Chair-
man, will make the preliminary statement.
(The report of the Committee on Roadway was presented by Mr.
W. M. Dawley, the Vice-Chairman. See report, pp. 387-400; discussion,
pp. 981, 982.)
The President : — The next Committee is that on Water Service, Mr.
Robert Ferriday, Chairman. The Chairman will make the opening re-
marks in regard to the report.
(The report of the Committee on Water Service was presented by Mr.
Robert Ferriday, the Chairman. See report, pp. 421-428; discussion, pp
983-988.)
AFTERNOON SESSION.
The President :— The next report is that of the Committee on Masonry,
of which Mr. Geo. PI. Tinker is Chairman. Mr. Tinker will make the
opening statement.
(The report of the Committee on Masonry was presented by Mr. Geo.
H. Tinker, the Chairman. See report, pp. 459-504; discussion, pp. 990-995O
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on Records
and Accounts, of which Mr. H. J. Pfeifer is Chairman. The Chairman
will make the preliminary statement.
(The report of the Committee on Records and Accounts was pre-
sented by Mr. H. J. Pfeifer, the Chairman. See report, pp. 505-507; dis-
cussion, pp. 946, 947.)
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on Elec-
tricity, of which Mr. George W. Kittredge is Chairman. Mr. Kittredge
will make the preliminary statement for the Committee.
(The report of the Committee on Electricity was presented by Mr.
George W. Kittredge, the Chairman. See report, pp. 509-558 ; discussion,
pp. 998-1016.)
58 BUSINESS SESSION.
The Chair expected to announce the result of the election to-night,
but the Committee is still counting the ballots and he will, therefore,
be unable to do so until to-morrow.
Some members have expressed a desire to visit the cement plants at
Buffington and the steel plants at Gary, Indiana. Arrangements have
been made for a trip of inspection Friday morning.
No more reports will be taken up this evening, and a motion to ad-
journ is in order.
(On motion the meeting was adjourned until 9 a. m., Thursday.)
THURSDAY, MARCH 21, 1912.
.MORNING SESSION.
The President : — The first business this morning will be the report of
the Committee on Conservation of Natural Resources, Mr. E. O. Faulkner,
Chairman. In the absence of Mr. Faulkner, the report will be presented
by Mr. William McNab, the Vice-Chairman.
(The report of the Committee on Conservation of Natural Resources
was presented by Mr. William McNab, the Vice-Chairman. See report, pp.
429-458; discussion, page 989.)
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Signs,
Fences and Crossings, Mr. C. H. Stein, Chairman.
(The report of the Committee on Signs, Fences and Crossings was
presented by Mr. C. H. Stein, the Chairman. See report, pp. 900-904; dis-
cussion, pp. 1055-1057.)
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Build-
ings, of which Mr. Maurice Coburn is Chairman. Mr. Coburn will make
the opening statement.
(The report of the Committee on Buildings was presented by Mr.
Maurice Coburn, the Chairman. See report, pp. 885-889; discussion, page
1054.)
The President : — The Committee on Uniform General Contract Forms
will please come forward. Mr. W. G. Atwood, the Vice-Chairman, will
make the statement of the work of this Committee.
(The report of the Committee on Uniform General Contract Forms
was presented by Mr. W. G. Atwood, the Vice-Chairman. See report, pp.
907-916; discussion, pp. 1 059-1076.)
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on
Economics of Railway Location), of which Mr. A. K. Shurtleff is Chair-
man. Mr. Shurtleff will make the opening statement.
(The report of the Committee on Economics of Railway Location was
presented by Mr. A. K. Shurtleff, the Chairman. See report pp. 905, 906:
discussion, page 958.)
. The President : — The next Committee is the Special Committee on
Grading of Lumber, Dr. Hermann von Schrenk, Chairman. We will hear
from Dr. von Schrenk.
BUSINESS SESSION. 59
(The report of the Special Committee on Grading of Lumber was pre-
sented by Dr. Hermann von Schrenk, the Chairman. See report, pp. 873-
884: discussion, pp. 1052, 1053.)
The President: — The next report is the Committee on Wood Preser-
vation. Mr. Earl Stimson is the Chairman. We will have the opening
statement by Mr. Stimson.
(The report of the Committee on Wood Preservation was presented by
Mr. Earl Stimson, the Chairman. See report, pp. 863-872; discussion, pp.
1030- 105 1.)
The President: — We have finished the business in connection with the
reports of Special and Standing Committees, and under the heading of
"New Business" there are some resolutions to be offered.
Mr. J. B. Berry (Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific) : — I would suggest
action by the members of this Association on the following resolutions :
'"Resolved, by the members of the American Railway Engineering
Association in convention assembled, that we desire to place on record
our hearty appreciation of the efforts made and the admirable results ob-
tained by the Railway Age Gazette in its daily issue during this conven-
tion.
"Resolved, that the cordial thanks of the Association be extended to
its managing officers and editorial staff.
"Resolved, that a copy of these resolutions be spread upon the Minutes
of this convention and a copy transmitted to the Railway Age Gazette."
I submit the foregoing resolutions for adoption by the Association.
(The resolution was unanimously adopted.)
Mr. Berry: — I offer the following resolutions:
"Resolved, by the members of the American Railway Engineering
Association in convention assembled, that we desire to place on record
cur hearty appreciation of the efforts made and the admirable results ob-
tained by the Railway and Engineering Review in its daily issue during
this convention.
"Resolved, that the cordial thanks of the Association be extended to
its managing officers and editorial staff.
"Resolved, that a copy of these resolutions be spread upon the Min-
utes of this convention and a copy transmitted to the Railway and En-
gineering Review."
(The resolution was unanimously adopted.)
Mr. Chas. S. Churchill (Norfolk & Western) : — I offer the following
resolutions :
"Resolved, by the members of the American Railway Engineering
Association, in convention assembled, that we desire to place on record
our appreciation of the efforts made by the National Railway Appliances
Association in making possible the most admirable and instructive exhibit
of devices and materials used in the construction, operation and mainten-
ance of railways, and of the educational value of the exhibition.
"Resolved, that the thanks of the members of this Association be ex-
tended to the officers and members of the National Railway Appliances
Association for courtesies and facilities placed at our disposal during
the convention.
60 BUSINESS SESSION.
"Resolved, that a copy of these resolutions be forwarded to the offi-
cers of the National Railway Appliances Association, and that they be
spread upon the Minutes of this convention."
(The resolutions were unanimously adopted.)
Mr. Edwin F. Wendt (Pittsburgh & Lake Erie) :— I offer the follow-,
ing resolution :
"Resolved, that the hearty thanks of the members of the American
Railway Engineering Association in convention assembled lie tendered
to the Official Reporters, Messrs. T. E. Crossman and G. W. Burgoyne,
for their efficient and accurate report of the Proceedings of this conven-
tion, and that a copy of this resolution be spread upon the Minutes and
a copy transmitted to them."
(The resolution was unanimously adopted.)
Mr. C. H. Stein (Central Railroad of New Jersey) : — I offer the fol-
lowing resolution for adoption :
"Resolved, that the hearty thanks of the members of the American
Railway Engineering Association in convention assembled be tendered the
Tellers, Messrs. C. H. Spencer, C. H. Fisk and W. J. Bergen, for their
arduous labor and for the efficient manner in which the work has been
performed."
(The resolution was unanimously adopted.)
Mr. A. F. Robinson (Santa Fe) : — I offer the following resolution:
"Resolved, that the hearty thanks of the members of the American
Railway Engineering Association in convention assembled be extended
and are hereby tendered the Committee on Arrangements for the efficient
manner in which all details for this convention have been carried out.
"Resolved, that the Committee be 'continued at the same salary.' "
(The resolution was unanimously adopted.)
The President : — I will ask the Secretary to announce the election
of officers for the ensuing year, and I desire to say that we have imposed
on the Tellers this time. They were all afternoon yesterday and long
into the evening counting the votes, and we are, therefore, under obliga-
tions to the Committee at this time for the care and labor used in the
preparation of their report.
The Secretary: — The report of the Tellers is as follows:
REPORT OF TELLERS.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
We, the undersigned, appointed Tellers to canvass the votes cast for
the election of officers, Board of Direction and Nominating Committee
for the year 1912, beg leave to advise that after careful examination and
canvass of each ballot the results are as follows :
Total vote cast 517
Unsigned ballots 12
Associate members not counted 20 32
Total vote counted 485
BUSINESS SESSION. 61
President :
C. S. Churchill 483
A. W. Thompson 1
Blank 1
Vice-President :
W. B. Storey, Jr 482
J. B. Berry 1
A. S. Baldwin 1
Robert Trimble 1
Treasurer :
Geo. H. Bremner 485
Secretary:
E. H. Fritch 485
Directors for 3 Years :
F. A. Delano 238
W. L. Darling 236
W. B. Scott 188
C. H. Cartlidge 182
C. C. Anthony 141
S. B. Fisher 131
W. S. Kinnear 117
C. H. Ewing 109
J. M. R. Fairbairn 88
J. G. Sullivan 1
Nominating Committee :
F. L. Stuart 330
C. F W. Felt 307
J. O. Osgood 267
G. J. Ray 249
F. H. Alfred 241
A. K. Shurtleff 224
C. E. Lindsay 216
W. Beahan 203
A. W. Newton 148
C. L. Ransom 125
A. O. Cunningham'. 1
J. F Coleman 1
J. G. Sullivan 1
Respectfully submitted,
C. H. Spencer,
C. H. Fisk,
W. J. Bergen,
Tellers.
The Secretary — The result of the ballot for officers is as follows :
President — Chas. S. Churchill.
Vice-President — W. B. Storey, Jr.
Treasurer — Geo. H. Bremner.
Secretary— E. H. Fritch.
Three Directors (three years each)— W. L. Darling, F. A. Delano,
W. B. Scott.
Five Members of Nominating Committee — 'Francis Lee Stuart, C. F.
W. Felt, Jos. O. Osgood, G. J. Ray, F. H. Alfred.
62 BUSINESS SESSION.
The President : — Gentlemen, in relinquishing the office of President,
I desire to express my profound appreciation of the honor and favor
you have done me in electing me to that office for the past year. I now
take pleasure in asking Mr. McDonald and Mr. Wendt to escort the
newly-elected President to the platform.
President-Elect Churchill : — Gentlemen, I have always considered a
membership on any Committee of this working association to be a posi-
tion of distinct trust and prestige, and any official position as an honor.
I, therefore, am very grateful for this highest honor that you have con-
ferred upon me in making me the President of this Association, which
now stands so high in the railway matters of the world.
I thank you. I appreciate the fact that in taking this office after
such brilliant stars who have preceded me that I need all the help that
the committees and members can give, and I am sure that I will have it,
and you shall have my best efforts in everything that we are called upon
to carry out.
In my last word I want to call attention to the recommendation of the
outgoing President : — that we try to increase the membership for the
specific object at this time of increasing the revenues of the Association.
There are many matters before this Association that could be looked
into further than we are now able to look into them, and experiments
which could be carried on which we are now unable to make, because of a
lack of sufficient funds. If each member of this Association will leave
this assembly with the idea that he will try to bring into the Association
during this year more new members, we will in the course of a year or
so have the revenue from the membership dues which we require.
This, I believe, is all the business before this convention.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) : — Mr. President. I wish
to offer the following resolution :
"Resolved, by the members of the American Railway Engineering
Association in convention assembled, that we desire to place on record
our hearty appreciation of the well-directed and untiring efforts and
eminently efficient administration of the retiring President, Mr. W. C.
dishing, and that this resolution be spread upon the Minutes of the
meeting and a copy transmitted to Mr. Cushing."
(The question on the adoption of the resolution was put by Mr.
J. B. Berry, and was unanimously adopted.)
Past-President Cushing:— I thank you.
The President : — I wish to announce a meeting of the Board of Di-
rection in Room 1166, at two o'clock.
The convention is adjourned to March, 1913.
E. H. Fritch, Secretary.
COMMITTEE REPORTS
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XII— ON RULES AND
ORGANIZATION.
Jos. O. Osgood, Chairman; G. D. Brooke, Vice-Chairman;
F. D. Anthony. F. P. Gutelius.
J. B. Carothers. Kenneth Hanger.
S. E. Coombs. Jos. Mullen.
J. B. Dickson. F. L. Nicholson.
C. Dougherty. W. C. Smith.
J. A. Gordon. Committee.
To the Members of the American Raihvay Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Rules and Organization respectfully submits here-
with its report, as follows :
Meetings of the Committee, Sub-Committees and Chairmen of the
Sub-Committees were held as follows : A meeting of the Committee was
held in New York, June 9, 191 1; Sub-Committee meetings were held in
New York and Chicago on July 21, and in Montreal on July 31, 191 1 ;
three Chairmen of Sub-Committees held a meeting in New York on Sep-
tember 8, 191 1.
Last year's report of this Committee embodied revisions of the rules
as then published in the Manual and additional rules of the same general
character, all relating to the government of employes of the Maintenance
of Way Department.
For this year's work your Committee was instructed by the Board of
Direction to :
(1) Continue the compilation of rules for the government of Main-
tenance of Way employes.
(2) Formulate rules in the nature of specifications or instructions
regarding the conduct of work, making use of the recommendations of the
various Committees dealing with these subjects and of the best practice
of railway companies, as embodied in their books of rules.
Some progress has been made with rules falling under the first of the
instructions, but this year's report deals only with the work falling under
the second of the instructions.
Your Committee recommends :
(1) That no change be made in the General Rules for the Govern-
ment of Employes of the Maintenance of Way Department heretofore
adopted by the Association.
(2) That to the rules heretofore adopted by the Association be
added instructions, as follows :
65
66 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
♦INSTRUCTIONS.
Cross-Sections.
(i) The roadbed, ballast and track shall conform to the standard
plans. No changes in the sections shown shall be made without proper
authority. ^
(Note: It is understood that cross-sections for wet cuts will be in-
cluded in the standard plans.)
Drainage.
(2) All ditches, including intercepting ditches on the upper side of
cuts, must be kept clean.
(3) Where heaving or wet spots develop, special drainage shall be
provided.
Ballasting.
(4) Before re-ballasting track, line and grade stakes shall be set
by the Engineer. All unsuitable material shall be removed and the road-
bed widened to proper section, the waste material being used to widen
banks, or otherwise, as may be directed.
(5) Track must be kept in good line and surface while ballasting,
open track avoided as far as practicable, and such track carefully watched.
(6) After ballast is distributed it shall be trimmed, and the track
lined and surfaced to conform to the standard plans.
(7) Where track is bonded, ballast must be kept at least one inch
below the base of rail. At road crossings, platforms, etc., where this is
not practicable, only clean gravel or rock ballast shall be used.
Ties.
(8) Ties stored along right-of-way shall be piled to conform to the
standard plan.
(Note: The standard plan should show the minimum distance to the
nearest rail.)
(9) The ties in track must be inspected at stated times each year
and those which will not last until the next inspection marked for renewal.
(10) The renewal of ties shall be started when directed by the
\ .1.t... When ties are being renewed, the line and sur-
face shall be corrected and ballast trimmed.
(11) All defective ties removed from track shall each day be placed
for burning or loading on cars.
(12) The *:.}.... shall frequently inspect ties removed
from track to see if any have been removed which might have remained
in the track with safety until the next inspection.
(13) Ties shall be spaced according to the standard plans. All ties
shall be placed square to the line of rails. The outside ends on double
tracks, and the ends on one side throughout on single track, must be lined
parallel with the rail.
(14) The heart side of ties must be turned down. The largest and
*For amendments to Clauses 6. 7. 10. 12 and 14, see Index.
RULES AND ORGANIZATION. 67
best ties shall be selected for use at joints. Twisted or badly hewn ties
must not be notched, but the bearings must be made true with the adze.
(15) Whenever spikes are drawn from ties, wooden tie plugs must
be driven into all holes except in ties which are to be renewed that season.
In replacing spikes they should be driven into the plugs.
Rail.
(16) In unloading rails from cars they should be skidded or other-
wise carefully lowered to avoid injury. Where it is necessary to drop
them, both ends must be dropped together and the greatest care taken
to avoid their falling on hard and uneven surfaces.
(17) The bottom of the new rail and the bearing surface of the tie
shall be cleaned before the new rail is laid.
(18) When replacing rail with rail of the same section, only two
rows of spikes shall be drawn ; in replacing with rail of a different section,
three rows of spikes shall be drawn.
(19) In laying new rail, standard expansion shims shall be used.
The temperature of the rail shall be taken by placing the thermometer on
the rail. The openings between 33 ft. rails shall be as follows:
Temperature (Fahrenheit). Amount of Opening.
— 200 to o° fe in.
0° to 25° Vi, in.
250 to 50° -h in.
50° to 75° V* in-
750 to ioo0 tV in.
Over ioo° to be laid close.
The rail should be laid without bumping and when practicable, laid
rail by rail.
(20) The rails shall be brought squarely into line and at least two
bolts tightened before spiking. All joint bars shall be securely fastened
with the full number of bolts, tightening those at the center first. At
permanent connections of rails of different sections step chairs and off-set
splices must be used.
(21) All spikes must be driven vertically with the face in contact
with the base of the rail. They should not be straightened while being
driven. The rail must be full spiked and the spikes staggered so that
the outside spikes shall be on the same side of the tie and the inside
spikes on the opposite side.
(22) In making temporary connections in main tracks an old rail
should be cut and fastened to the new rail, using compromise joints when
necessary. Switch points shall be used for this purpose only during the
presence of the Track Foreman.
(23) After new rail is laid the track must be lined and surfaced.
(24) All kinked or crooked rails must be straightened before being
laid ; if bent in service they must either be removed or straightened.
(25) Rails for curves of 2 degrees and over should be curved before
being laid. In curving or straightening rails, the rail bender must be used.
*For amendments to Clauses 17, 18, 20 and 25, see Index.
68 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
Surfacing.
*(26) When surfacing (picking up low points or other low places),
the general level of the track must not be disturbed.
NEXT YEAR'S WORK.
(3) For next year it is recommended that the Committee continue
this year's work.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
*For amendment to Clause 26, see Index.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE X— ON SIGNALS AND
INTERLOCKING.
A. H. Rudd, Chairman; L. R. Clausen, Vice-Chairman;
Azel Ames. A. S. Ingalls.
C. C. Anthony. J. C. Mock.
H. Baker. F. P. Patenall.
H. S. Balliet. J. A. Peabody.
W. B. Causey. Frank Rhea.
C. A. Christofferson. W. B. Scott.
C. E. Denney. A. G. Shaver.
W. J. Eck. T. S. Stevens.
W. H. Elliott. H. H. Temple.
G. E. Ellis. Edwin F. Wendt.
W. J. Harahan. J. C. Young.
M'. H. Hovey. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
During the past year your Committee has met as follows : At Buffalo,
May 25; Buffalo, June 29; Buffalo, July 27.
The Board of Direction assigned four subjects for consideration:
(1) Continue investigation of outline and description of a com-
prehensive and uniform signal system, suitable for general adoption, con-
ferring with proper committee of the American Railway Association.
(2) Revise mechanical interlocking specifications, and include
wrought-iron pipe as well as steel.
(3) Revise electric interlocking specifications and submit statement of
the results from experience.
(4) Report on the effect of treated and metal ties on track circuits.
Last year your Committee presented revised specifications for various
kinds of insulated wire, which the Association adopted. In order to
bring these specifications into conformity with those adopted by the Rail-
way Signal Association, a new insulation resistance table is herewith
submitted with the following:
CONCLUSION.
(1) The following table of insulation resistances in megohms per
mile at sixty (60) degrees Fahrenheit for the various thicknesses of in-
sulation in fractions of an inch and the various sizes of wire is made a
part of the specifications for mineral matter, rubber compound, insulated
signal wire for current of 660 volts or less, appearing in Vol. 12, Part 1,
69
70 SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
pp. 101 to 104, inclusive, and the insulation resistance in megohms per
mile, shown on page 108, is revised to conform with this table.
i i L L L i !L *L L _!
B. & S. G. 64 32 64 32 64 32 32 32 32 32
0 900 1100 1200 1300 1500 1800 2000 2200
1 1000 1200 1400 1500 1800 1900 2200 2400
2 1000 1100 1400 1500 1600 1900 2200 2300 2600
3 1100 1200 1500 1600 1800 2000 2300 2600 2700
4 1200 1400 1600 1800 1900 2200 2400 2700 2800
5 1300 1500 1700 1900 2000 2300 2600 2800 3100
6 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2600 2800 3100 3400
8 1400 1600 1900 2200 2300 2600 2800 3200 3500 3800
9 1500 1800 2000 2300 2600 2700 3100 3400 3600 3900
10 1600 1900 2200 2400 2700 3000 3200 3600 3900 4200
12 1800 2200 2500 2800 3100 3200 3600 4000 4300 4600
14 2200 2600 2800 3200 3500 3600 4200 4400 4800 5100
(2) The above table of insulation resistances in megohms per mile at
sixty (60) degrees Fahrenheit for the various thicknesses of insulation
in fractions of an inch and the various sizes of wire is made a part of
the specifications for mineral matter, rubber compound, insulated aerial
braided cables for current of 660 volts or less, shown on pp. 105 to 109,
inclusive, of the same Volume, and the insulation resistance megohms per
mile, shown on page 108, is revised to conform thereto.
(3) The above table of insulation resistances in megohms per mile at
sixty (60) degrees Fahrenheit for the various thicknesses of insulation in
fractions of an inch and the various sizes of wire is made a part of the
specifications for mineral matter, rubber compound, insulated, lead-covered,
armored submarine cables for 600 or lower voltage service, shown on pp.
no to 114, inclusive, of the same Volume, and the insulation resistance
megohms per mile, shown on page 113, is revised to conform thereto.
Your Committee does not report this year on subjects Nos. 2, 3 or 4,
assigned by the Board of Direction. It reports on Subject No. 1 as follows:
UNIFORM SIGNALING.
This subject was referred to the Committee on Transportation of the
American Railway Association by the 1910 convention. In 191 1, progress
was reported.
The amended report of the Committee on Transportation, accepted
by the American Railway Association, as information, May, 191 1, and
transmitted to your Committee X through Secretary Fritch, is as follows :
MEMORANDUM ON THE ESSENTIALS OF SIGNALING.
Incorporated in the Report of the Committee on Transportation of the
American Railway Association, May, 1911.
The reports of_ various Committees of the Railway Signal Association
and of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way
Association on the subject of signaling have been submitted to this Com-
mittee, with the request that the essentials of signaling be outlined or
defined for the future guidance of their Committees.
The subject has been carefully analyzed and considered. There are
three signals that are essential in operation and therefore fundamental, viz. :
(1) Stop.
(2) Proceed with caution.
(3) Proceed.
SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING. 71
The fundamental, "Proceed with caution," may be used with the
same aspect to govern any cautionary movement, for example, when
(a) Next signal is "stop."
(b) Next signal is "proceed at low speed."
(c) Next signal is "proceed at medium speed."
(d) A train is in the block.
(e) There may be an obstruction ahead.
There are two additional indications which may be used where move-
ments are to be made at a restricted speed, viz. :
(4) Proceed at low speed.
(5) Proceed at medium speed.
Where automatic block system rules are in effect, a special mark of
some distinctive character should be applied at the stop signal.
The Committee therefore recommends :
SIGNAL FUNDAMENTALS.
(1) Stop.
(2) Proceed with caution.
(3) Proceed.
SUPPLEMENTARY INDICATIONS TO BE USED WHERE REQUIRED.
(4) Proceed at low speed.
(5) Proceed at medium speed.
Stop signals operated under automatic block system rules should be
designated by some distinctive mark, to be determined by each road in
accordance with local requirements.
RECOMMENDATIONS OF COMMITTEE X.
The simplest aspects for the three fundamental indications are : [Z3
1. Stop
2. Proceed with caution.
O
J]
3. Proceed
Having in view, and not desiring to depart from, the established
practice of indicating diverging routes and incidentally low and medium
speeds, your Committee recommends that the medium and low speed in-
dications be given by an additional arm or arms. The simplest method
(although incapable of expansion to provide additional aspects or even
combinations of the fundamentals and supplementaries) is to use a
second arm for both of these indications. The Committee on Transporta-
tion rules that the fundamental, "Proceed with caution," may be used to
govern any cautionary movement. Therefore, for those roads which de-
sire to operate under this plan and deem the five indications entirely
sufficient, two additional aspects are necessary:
72
SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
4. Proceed at low speed.
o
p
5. Proceed at medium speed.
D
At interlocking plants which are also block stations it may be desirable,
even on such roads, to give passenger trains caution signals for diverging
movements, but not for entering occupied block sections ; this would,
with the system outlined above, require a separate signal beyond the
interlocked switches. It may frequently also be desirable to display the
fundamental, "Proceed with caution," on the medium-speed route, and to
logically and consistently apply the fundamental aspects for "Proceed with
caution" and "proceed" to those signals indicating medium speed and low
speed, the 45-degree position should be used for caution and the vertical
for proceed.
Again, as the Committee on Transportation merely makes optional the
combination of various indications under caution and as several roads have
found it desirable to differentiate between such indications, the Committee
recommends for such roads a low arm as a low-speed arm and a middle
arm where the indication of medium speed is desired.
The Committee on Transportation states that "stop signals operated
under automatic block system rules should be designated by some dis-
tinctive mark to be determined by each road in accordance with local re-
quirements." The instructions to this Committee are to design a uniform
system, which end is defeated if each road uses a different method of
designating the automatic home signal. Therefore, the Committee recom-
mends as follows :
Conclusion No. 1.
On roads desiring to operate with the three fundamentals and the
two additional indications without expansion or combination of these in-
dications, the following aspects may be used :
Scheme No. 1.
FUNDAMENTALS.
i. Stop.
\0 \0
2. Proceed with caution.
p
3. Proceed .
H U
SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
SUPPLEMENTARY INDICATIONS.
4. Proceed at low speed
73
<?
F
5. Proceed at medium speed.
D
Conclusion No 2.
On those roads desiring combinations of the fundamentals and supple-
mentary indications and different aspects for the various caution indica-
tions permissible under the ruling of the Committee on Transportation,
the following aspects should be used:
Scheme No. 2.
FUNDAMENTALS.
i. Stop.
2. Proceed, prepare to stop at next signal.
3. Proceed.
SUPPLEMENTARY INDICATIONS.
=1
=1
=1
or
or
Z]
3 or p
f
f
f
or
or
=1
D
3
n
a
J]
or
or
=1
I]
■3
4. Proceed at low speed, prepare to stop.
O O
F
5. Proceed at medium speed.
D
Conclusion No. 3.
When it is desired to indicate "Proceed at
medium speed, prepare to stop at next
signal," aspect
o
should be
used.
74
SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
Conclusion No. 4.
When it is desired to indicate, "Proceed at
low speed," aspect
iD
should be
used.
Conclusion No. 5.
When it is desired to indicate, "Proceed,
prepare to pass next signal at medium
speed," aspect
D
should be
used.
Conclusion No. 6.
Where in manual block territory, it is de-
sired to indicate "Proceed with caution,
block occupied," aspect
should be
used.
Conclusion No. 7.
That the arms of automatic signals be pointed and the arms of other
signals giving the stop indication have square ends ; that, on roads using
Scheme No. 1, a number plate be added on the automatic signal and, on
roads using Scheme No. 2, a red marker light below and to the left of
the active light be provided.
Note. — Messrs. Baker, Clausen, Scott, Stevens and Young do not ap-
prove the report on Subject No. 1.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
MINORITY REPORT OF COMMITEE X— AMERICAN
RAILWAY ENGINEERING ASSOCIATION.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
The undersigned believe that the indications provided by the Ameri-
can Railway Association are sufficient for the operation of any railroad
and are all for which this Association should provide aspects.
We, therefore, recommend that the following indications specified by
the Committee on Transportation of the American Railway Association
and the aspects used to represent them be accepted and approved as rec-
ommended practice :
FUNDAMENTAL
SUPPLEMENTAL
i. Stop.
2. Proceed with caution.
3. Proceed.
O
1. Stop.
2. Proceed with caution ^
D
3. Proceed.
4. Proceed at low speed /y
5. Proceed at medium speed
D
(Stop signals operated under automatic block system rules shall be
designated by a number plate.)
The specific objections to the additional indications and aspects pro-
vided by the Majority are the same as previously presented to this Asso-
ciation and are in accordance with the arguments presented before the
Transportation Committee of the American Railway Association at
Niagara Falls in June, 1010.
75
76 SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
They are as follows :
i. It is impracticable to provide a separate signal for each of the
conditions on a railroad requiring cautious running and to maintain the
fine-haired distinctions necessary to their interpretation.
2. It is unnecessary, and, in fact, dangerous, to tell the engineman
by fixed signal how he shall control his train at some point in advance.
3. Advance information so given is misleading and unreliable, as it
is subject to change without notice, and therefore the engineman cannot
safely use it. If he does so use it, it is done at the expense of safety.
4. The conditions of modern railway operation do not require trains
to be run at full speed past Caution signals, and any time gained by this
practice is at the expense of safety.
5. Each signal should indicate Stop or Caution or Proceed, and
have no relation to signals in advance or in the rear.
6. Each signal should be observed in turn as the train comes to it,
and not at some point in advance at the option of the engineman.
7. With signals properly located, it is time a train should be run with
caution if it has reached a point so close to preceding trains or Stop
signals in advance that a Caution signal is received.
8. No Proceed or Caution indication should "imply or assure clear
track to a point in advance." Railway signaling devices and our methods
of communication have not reached the perfection that will admit of
this being done. We cannot know positively if the track is clear, and
further, it may not stay clear. We are under a moral obligation not
to give such misleading information.
9. The giving of information by signal indications about conditions
in advance, whether it be regarding the next signal or the next station,
or any other object or condition, is wrong practice, productive of laxity
and a fruitful source of danger and accident.
10. It wilj be difficult, if not impossible, to maintain discipline and
proper observance of the great variety of Caution indications proposed
by the Majority, because of the fine distinctions involved.
A number of serious and fatal accidents in the past few years,
wherein the engineman failed to properly observe the Caution signal, but
fully intended to stop at the next signal, testify most conclusively to
the correctness of our position in this matter.
Respectfully submitted,
H. S. Baker,
W. B. Scott,
T. S. Stevens,
J. C. Young,
L. R. Clausen.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE VII— ON WOODEN BRIDGES
AND TRESTLES.
C. C. Wentworth, Chairman; W. F. Steffens, V ice -Chairman ;
F. H. Bainbridge. Hans Ibsen.
F. E. Bissell. Henry S. Jacoby.
W. S. Bouton. J. A. Lahmer.
R. D. Coombs. H. Rettinghouse.
E. A. Hadley. I. L. Simmons.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
COMMITTEE MEETINGS.
One meeting of the Committee was held in Chicago at the offices of the
Association on October 2, 191 1. Those in attendance were H. Ibsen, H.
Rettinghouse, I. L. Simmons and C. C. Wentworth.
REVIEW OF THE REPORT OF 19H.
A pile record form was recommended and adopted. See Proceedings,
Vol. 12, Part 1, page 307; also Manual, Edition of 191 1, page 154.
Principles of practice for pile driving were recommended, and, after
some amendment by the convention, adopted. See Proceedings, Vol. 12,
Part 1, pp. 307 to 320, inclusive; also Manual, Edition of 191 1, pp. 150 to
152, inclusive.
The remainder of the report on piles and pile driving was accepted as
information, so also was the conclusion as to a means of protecting piling
against marine borers by surrounding each pile with a vitrified clay pipe
and filling the space between the pile and the pipe with sand. See Pro-
ceedings, Vol. 12, Part 1, page 322.
The work assigned by the Board of Direction for the year 191 1 was as
follows :
(1) Report on the formulas for use in determining the strength of
sheet piling.
(2) Report on equipment required for pile driving.
(3) Collect information on special methods of driving sheet piles
in cofferdams where conditions do not permit the use of ordinary equip-
ment.
(4) Collect information on actual experience on the bearing power
of piles and on the practical results of the use of formulas.
(5) Report on the use of guard rails for wooden bridges and
trestles.
(6) Report on fire protection of wooden bridges and trestles.
77
78 WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES.
In accordance with the general rules as to Committee reports given
on page 14 of Bulletin 134, the following subjects were finally selected
for consideration this year : Nos. 1, 4, 5 and 6 of the foregoing list. The
Committee reports its progress thereon as follows :
(1) Sheet Piling — .Prof. H. S. Jacoby, Chairman; and H. Ibsen, Sub-
Committee :
This subject Committee VII did not think could be reported on this
year, as an experimental investigation, which it was hoped Cornell Uni-
versity would make, could not be completed in time for report if under-
taken; and it was thought that the result of these experiments would
be of much service in making up its final report to the Association. The
Committee has since been advised that Cornell could not undertake these
experiments, but the Committee hopes that some other Institution may
find it desirable that they be carried out by it.
The procedure suggested for these experiments was that a strong
concrete open top box be made, across which at its middle a vertical
plate diaphragm of tempered spring steel could be set; this diaphragm
being held in place against horizontal motion at its top and bottom. On
both sides of this diaphragm the box would be simultaneously filled with
the material to be tested, as sand ; thus, when the box is full, represent-
ing sheet piling driven in sand.
The sand was then to be removed from one side of the diaphragm,
as would occur when a trench is excavated protected by sheet piling. After
the diaphragm had assumed the curve due to the pressure of the sand its
curved shape was to be accurately determined and a closely fitting tem-
plate made to record its curvature.
In order to determine the amount and distribution of the sand pres-
sure, the diaphragm would then be removed from the box and placed
horizontally, supported at its ends at the same points it was supported
by when vertical in the box. A number of metal strips should be
provided, each long enough to reach across the diaphragm, but of vary-
ing thickness to make up any required weight, and of equal width. These
would be piled at equal intervals on the diaphragm until the curve of flex-
ure is again exactly reached by it which was given it by the sand and
recorded by the template; bearing in mind that the tops of the succes-
sive piles of metal strips must be on a curve of some uniformity, which
may be called the curve of load, without such irregular outline as that
of a battlement, and carried over the supports on the line indicated by
the curve approaching them. The total pressure, and the center of pres-
sure, would thus be determined, it is thought, with considerable accur-
acy.
As a check, the flexure curve of the diaphragm already found could
be plotted to a convenient scale, and successive differentials taken thereof
up to and including the fourth. As the equation of this flexure curve is
unknown, the differentiation would be done graphically, remembering
that the first differentiation gives the curve of tangents to the flexure
curve ; the second the curve of moments ; the third the curve of shear,
WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES. 79
and the fourth the curve of load, which should agree with the curve of
load determined by the first method — that of weights superimposed on the
horizontal plate.
Other materials than sand need testing, such as a heavy semi-fluid
mud, and ballast. In each case the angle of repose would be noted of the
unretained material, and its weight per cubic foot.
In order to obtain definite conclusions the concrete box and steel
diaphragm should be of rather large size; and to prevent the friction of
the retained material on the sides of the box from affecting the result ma-
terially, narrower steel plates could be placed on each side of the main
diaphragm, observations being taken on the main plate only.
The investigation could be extended to determine the pressure on
abutments, which are generally filled against gradually on one side only,
though this is not part of the work of this Committee. It seems prob-
able that under such mode of filling, the total pressure would be greater,
and its center lower, than in the case of sheet piling.
(4) Pile Formulas — F. E. Bissell, Chairman; F. H. Bainbridge, R.
D. Coombs and W. F. Steffens, Sub-Committee :
A large number of requests for information were sent out, but the
chief matter to be noted from the replies received was the very small
number of roads keeping record of their pile driving in form for use in
this investigation.
It seems to the Committee that while a pile driving formula should
be based on theoretical considerations, there are so many modifying con-
ditions to be allowed for that the result is a formula more or less em-
pirical in its final make-up.
These modifying conditions can best be noted from actual experience
in pile driving ; and members are urged, for the advancement of the art.
to keep record of the behavior of piles during driving and after loading.
Especially is this record valuable in the case of test piles loaded to failure.
(5) Guard Rails — H. Ibsen, Chairman: Prof. H. S. Jacoby, I. L.
Simmons and H. Rettinghouse, Sub-Committee :
A large amount of work was done on this subject, replies having been
received from members and others representing a mileage of 119,314.
These replies were tabulated and considered, but recommendations were
not reached for presentation to the Association.
It seems that there are two types of guard rail in use ; a guard rail
being a member as defined on page 130 of the Manual, Edition of 191 1. In
one type the two rails are brought together at their ends at the middle of
the track ; in the other, two similar rails are not brought together at their
ends, but remain parallel to the stock rail, and a third rail, also straight,
is put in the middle of the track ; all three rails in the latter case being
deflected at their ends below base of rail.
(6) Fire Protection — I. L. Simmons, Chairman ; F. H. Bainbridge, F.
E. Bissell, H. Isben and J. A. Lahmer, Sub-Committee:
Replies to a circular letter of inquiry were received from members
and others representing 110,214 miles of railway. Of this mileage 62 per
80 WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES.
cent, when using fire protection adopted either full ballast decks, floors
protected by a thin covering of ballast or other like material, or by sheet
metal.
NEXT YEAR'S WORK.
The Committee recommends that the same subjects be assigned it
for the year 1912 as were assigned for the year 191 1, and given in full at
the beginning of this report.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XV— ON IRON AND STEEL
STRUCTURES.
C. H. CartlidgE; Chairman; A. J. Himes, y ice-Chair man;
J. A. Bohland. Albert Reich mann.
Charles Chandler. A. F. Robinson.
C. L. Crandall. C. C. Schneider.
J. E. Crawford. O. E. Selby.
J. E. Greiner. C. E. Smith.
J. M. Johnson. I. F. Stern.
C. N. MONSARRAT. F. E. TURNEAURE.
W. H. Moore. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee held two meetings during the year 191 1 — one at
Niagara Falls on June 27 and the other at Chicago on October 24th.
We have to report as follows :
Subject No. 1 — Investigation on Impact and Secondary Stresses :
Appendix B contains a report from Prof. F. E. Turneaure, Chairman
of Sub-Committee on Impact, giving an outline of the work done by the
Committee during the past year.
Subject No. 2 — Influence of Theory, Experiment and Experience on
Bridge Design : It was unanimously decided by the Committee that it was
unable to report adequately on this subject, and the request is therefore
made that the subject be dropped.
Subject No. 3 — Rules for Instruction and Guidance of Inspectors in
Mills, Shop and Field: The Committee reports progress. The Chairman of
the Sub-Committee has received discussion from two of the members of
his Sub-Committee, and will probably be able to submit a paper giving
the results of their findings during the next few months.
Subject No. 4 — Design of Built-up Columns : The tender of the serv-
ices of this Committee to collaborate with the Joint Committee of the
American Society of Civil Engineers was made and very promptly ac-
cepted. Sufficient time has not yet elapsed to permit the organization
of any actual work on this subject. The program proposed by the
A. S. C. E. Committee is very elaborate and comprehensive and
when carried out will immensely increase our knowledge of the subject.
In order that this Committee do any practical work on this subject, it
will be necessary to have funds. Your Committee understands, of course,
that none of the funds of the Association are available for this purpose.
We feel warranted, however, in recommending that individual roads be
asked to contribute for the purpose of making these tests. This work
81
82 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
and that of the Impact Committee are original research work and it is
hardly necessary for us to point out the ultimate value of the work done
in the manner in which it has been done. It will probably be necessary
in the near future to take cognizance of these experiments in our speci-
fications for design, but the Committee does not recommend that any
change be made at present, nor until further experiments on secondary
stresses have been made, and if possible, considerable work on columns.
The Committee will present later a more definite report of the probable
amount of money needed for the first year's work. It is expected that this
will be very small and that it can easily be raised.
Subject No. 5 — (Specifications for Erection of Steel Bridges: In
Appendix A the Committee presents for the consideration of the Asso-
ciation a set of specifications, revised in accordance with the discussion
at the last convention and with the written discussions from members and
others received since the convention.
CONCLUSIONS.
The recommendations of the Committee are as follows :
(i) That the specifications for Bridge Erection be adopted and
printed in the Manual.
(2) That the report of the Impact Committee be received as in-
formation.
(3) That no change be made at present in the specifications printed
in the Manual.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
Appendix A.
SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE ERECTION OF RAILROAD
BRIDGES.
Work to Be Done.
i. The Contractor shall erect, rivet and adjust all metal work in
place complete, and perform all other work hereinafter specified.
Plant.
2. The Contractor shall provide all tools, machinery and appliances
necessary for the expeditious handling of the work, including drift pins
and fitting up bolts.
Falsework.
3. The method of erection and plans for falsework and erection
equipment shall be subject to approval by the Engineer, but such
approval shall not relieve the Contractor from any responsibility. False-
work will be built by * Falsework material of
every character will be provided by the *
The temporary structure for use during erection and for maintaining
the traffic shall be properly designed and substantially constructed for
the loads which will come upon it. All bents shall be thoroughly secured
against movement, both transversely and longitudinally. The bents shall
be well secured against settling, and piles used wherever firm bottom
cannot be obtained. Upon completion of the erection, the temporary
structure, if the property of the Railway Company, shall be removed
without unnecessary damage, and neatly piled near the site or loaded on
cars, as may be directed. If the property of the Contractor, it shall be re-
moved in a manner subject to the approval of the Engineer.
Falsework placed by the Railway Company under an old structure or
for carrying traffic, may be used as far as practicable by the Contractor
during erection, but it shall not be unnecessarily cut or wasted.
Conduct of Work.
4. The work shall be prosecuted with sufficient force, plant and equip-
ment to expedite its completion to the utmost extent and in such a man-
ner as to be at all times subordinate to the use of the tracks by the
Railway Company, and so as not to interfere with the work of other
contractors or to close or obstruct any thoroughfare by land or water,
except under proper authority.
Reasonable reduction of speed will be allowed upon request of the
Contractor.
*Insert "Railway Company" or "Contractor," as the case may be.
83
84 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
Tracks shall not be cut nor shall trains be subjected to any stoppage
except when specifically authorized by the Engineer.
The Contractor shall protect traffic and his work by flagman furnished
by and at the expense of the Railway Company. The Contractor shall
provide competent watchmen to guard the work and material against
injury.
Engine Service.
5. If under the contract, work train or engine service is furnished
the Contractor free of charge, such service shall consist only in unloading
materials and in transferring the same from a convenient siding to the
bridge site. Other engine service shall be paid for by the Contractor at
the rate of $ per day per engine, the time to include the
time necessary for the engine to come from and return to its terminal.
When engine service is desired the Contractor shall give the proper railway
officials at least 24 hours' advance notice and the Railway Company will
furnish the service as promptly as possible, consistent with railroad
operations.
When derrick cars are used on main tracks, their movements shall
be in charge of a train crew, and the expense of the crew and any engine
service other than as noted above shall be charged to the Contractor.
Transportation.
6. When transportation of equipment, materials and men is fur-
nished free over the Railway Company's line, it shall be subject to such
conditions as may be stated in the contract.
Masonry.
7. The Railway Company will furnish all masonry to correct lines
and elevations, and unless otherwise stated in the contract, will make
all changes in old masonry without unnecessarily impeding the operations
of the Contractor. The Railway Company's engineers will establish lines
and elevations and assume responsibility therefor, but the Contractor shall
compare the elevations, distances, etc., shown on plans, with the masonry
as actually constructed as far as practicable, before he assembles the steel.
In case of discrepancy, he shall immediately notify the Engineer.
Handling and Storing Materials.
8. Cars containing materials or plant shall be promptly unloaded
upon delivery therefor, and in case of failure to do so the Contractor
shall be liable for demurrage charges. Material shall be placed on skids
above the ground, laid so as not to hold water, and stored and handled in
such a manner as not to be injured or to interfere with railroad operations.
The expense of repairing or replacing material damaged by rough handling
shall be charged to the Contractor. The Contractor, while unloading and
storing material, shall compare each piece with the shipping list and
promptly report any shortage or injury discovered.
IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES. 85
Maintenance of Traffic.
9. When traffic is to be maintained it will be carried on in such a
manner as to interfere as little as practicable with the work of the
Contractor.
Changes in the supporting structure or tracks required during erection
shall be at all times under the direct control and supervision of the Rail-
way Company.
Removal of Old Structure.
10. Unless otherwise specified, metal work in the old structure shall
be dismantled without unnecessary damage and loaded on cars or neatly
piled at a site immediately adjacent to the tracks, and at a convenient
grade for future handling, as may be directed. When the structure is
to be used elsewhere all parts will be matchmarked by the Railway Com-
pany; when the old bridge is composed of several spans the parts of each
shall be kept separate.
Metal Work.
11. Material shall be handled without damage. Threads of all
pins shall be protected by pilot and driving nuts while being driven in
place.
Light drifting will be permitted in order to draw the parts together,
but drifting for the purpose of matching unfair holes will not be per-
mitted. Unfair holes shall be reamed or drilled.
Nuts on pins and on bolts remaining in the structure shall be effectively
locked by checking the threads.
All splices and field connections shall be securely bolted prior to
riveting. When the parts are required to carry traffic, important connec-
tions, such as attachments of stringers and floor beams, shall have at least
fifty (50) per cent, of the holes filled with bolts and twenty-five (25) per
cent, with drift pins. All tension splices shall be riveted up complete
before blocking is removed. When not carrying traffic, at least thirty-three
and one-third (33}<3) per cent, of the holes shall have bolts.
Rivets in splices of compression members shall not be driven until the
members shall have been subjected to full dead load stresses. Rivets
shall be driven tight. No recupping or calking will be permitted. The
heads shall be full and uniform in size and free from fins, concentric and
in full contact with the metal. Heads shall be painted immediately after
acceptance.
Rivets shall be uniformly and thoroughly heated and no burnt rivetj
shall be driven. All defective rivets shall be promptly cut out and re-
driven. In removing rivets the surrounding metal shall not be injured ;
if necessary, the rivets shall be drilled out.
Misfits.
12. Correction of minor misfits and a reasonable amount of reaming
shall be considered as a legitimate part of the erection.
Any error in shop work which prevents the proper assembling and
fitting up of parts by the moderate use of drift pins, and a moderate amount
86 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
of reaming and slight chipping or cutting, shall be immediately reported
to the Engineer and the work of correction done in the presence of the
Engineer, who shall check the time expended.
The Contractor shall render an itemized bill for such work of correc-
tion for the approval of the Engineer.
Anchor Bolts.
13. Holes for all anchor bolts, except where bolts are built up with
the masonry, shall be drilled by the Contractor after the metal is in place
and the bolts shall be set in Portland cement grout.
Bed Plates.
14. Bed plates resting on masonry shall be set level and have a
full even bearing over their entire surface ; this shall be attained by either
the use of Portland cement grout or mortar, or by tightly ramming in
rust cement under the bed plates after blocking them accurately in position.
Decks.
15. The * will frame and place the per-
manent timber deck.
Painting.
16. The paint will be furnished by * and
shall be of such color, quality and manufacture as may be specified.
Surfaces inaccessible after erection, such as bottoms of base plates,
tops of stringers, etc., shall receive two coats of paint before assembling
in place. After erection, the entire structure shall receive two coats of
paint, allowing enough time between coats for the first coat to dry
before applying the second. No paint shall be applied in wet or freezing
weather, nor when the surface of the metal is damp. Painting shall be
done in good and workmanlike manner, subject to strict inspection during
progress and after completion, and in accordance with special instructions
which shall be given by the Engineer. All metal shall be thoroughly
cieaned of dirt, rust, loose scale, etc., before the paint is applied.
Clearing the Site.
17. The Contractor, after completion of the work of erection, shall
remove all old material and debris resulting from his operations and place
the premises in a neat condition.
Superintendence and Workmen.
18. During the entire progress of the work the Contractor shall have
a competent superintendent in personal charge and shall employ only
skilled and competent workmen. Instructions given by the Engineer to
the superintendent shall be carried out the same as if given to the Con-
tractor. If any of the Contractor's employes by unseemly or boisterous
conduct, or by incompetency or dishonesty, show unfitness for employment
on the work, they shall, upon instructions from the Engineer, be discharged
♦Insert "Railway Company" or "Contractor," as the case may be.
IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES. 87
from the work, nor thereafter be employed upon it without the Engineer's
consent.
Inspection.
19. The work of erection shall at all times be subject to the inspec-
tion and acceptance of the Engineer.
Responsibility.
20. The Contractor shall assume all responsibility for loss or damage
to his own work, materials or plant, due to any cause; also, for all loss
or damage to the Railway Company's materials or property, and to other
property adjacent to the railroad, due to causes within his reasonable
control.
The Contractor shall assume all responsibility for injury to the work-
men and the public, or to any individual ; and in case of accident or suit
he shall defend the suit in person and relieve the Railway Company
from all costs and expenses, and pay any judgments that may be recovered
thereon.
The Contractor shall comply with the laws and ordinances affecting
the manner of doing work; shall take out all necessary permits and com-
ply with their requirements, and shall take such precaution as may be
necessary to protect life and property.
Insurance and Bond.
21. The Contractor shall carry such liability insurance as is necessary
to protect himself and the Railway Company against loss or damage caused
by injuries to his men, and shall furnish the Railway Company a bond in
form and of a surety acceptable to the Railway Company, providing for
the faithful performance of the work and all matters pertaining thereto,
in such sum as shall be specified in the contract.
Engineer.
22. The term "Engineer," as used herein, shall be understood to mean
the Chief Engineer of the Railway Company, or his accredited repre-
sentative.
Clauses 20 and 21 to be eliminated; Clause 22 to be renumbered. See
Index.
Appendix B.
SECONDARY STRESSES.
We herewith submit a brief report of progress relative to tests of
secondary stresses, which were carried out during the past summer by
your Sub-Committee on Impact and Secondary Stresses.
Through the assistance of the mechanician's shop at the University
of Wisconsin, we were able to develop and manufacture a special form
of extensometer for use in measuring secondary stresses. An important
requirement of such an instrument is freedom from friction of all moving
parts and, in general, a high degree of sensitiveness, combined with sta-
bility and strength of framework, convenience of adjustment and ma-
nipulation. An instrument was developed along the line of the ex-
tensometers used for impact tests, but to secure sensitiveness the principal
bearings were made of knife edges, and instead of using a pencil for se-
curing a continuous record, a ray of light is allowed to pass through a
minute perforation in a disc at the end of the long lever, and a path of
this ray of light is photographed on a moving slip of sensitized paper.
The apparatus proved satisfactory in practical operation, and the
method of obtaining the record was found to be very good indeed. The
sensitized paper was developed in the field so that results could quickly
he obtained.
Four of these extensometers were made by the University of Wiscon-
sin and were used by the Committee on its tests.
About three weeks were spent in the field and tests were made on the
following bridges :
On the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway, a 160-ft. riveted
span and a 176-ft. pin-connected span at Byron, 111., a 104-ft. pony truss
span at Rockton, 111., in which eye-bars were used for the diagonal mem-
bers, and a span of the same length at Brodhead, Wis., in whicfh all
members were riveted.
On the Chicago & North- Western Railway, a 182-ft. riveted truss,
a 75-ft. deck-plate girder, and a through riveted lattice truss, all on the
new Belt Line at Milwaukee.
At the present time preliminary results only are available, which are
not in form for publication. It is expected that before the meeting in
March it will be possible to present all important results, together with
comparative results determined from a theoretical analysis.
In all of these tests the Railroad Company furnished a special train,
and such other facilities in the way of mechanics as were needed ; and
your Sub-Committee desires here to express its great appreciation for the
assistance thereby rendered.
The field work was carried out by Professors C. L. Crandall and F.
E. Turneaure, members of the Sub-Committee, assisted by Messrs. W. L.
Conwell and W. A. Axtell, of Cornell University, and Messrs. W. S.
Kinne, 0. L. Kowalke and J. B. Kommers, of the University of Wisconsin.
Respectfully submitted,
C. L. CRANDALL,
F. E. TURNEAURE,
Sub-Committee on Impact.
88
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XIV— ON YARDS AND
TERMINALS.
C. H. Spencer, Chairman; E. B. Temple, V ice-Chairman;
Hadley Baldwin. L. J. McIntyre.
W. C. Barrett. B. H. Mann.
M. S. Blaiklock. A. Montzheimer.
G. H. Burgess. W. L. Seddon.
A. E. Clift. A. Swartz.
A. L. Davis. J. E. Taussig.
H. T. Douglas, Jr. E. E. R. Tratman.
A. C. Everham. W. L. Webb.
D. B. Johnston. J. G. Wishart.
H. A. Lane. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Yards and Terminals submits herewith its
Twelfth Annual Report.
The Board of Direction has assigned the following subjects to your
Committee :
(i) Report on typical situation plans of passenger stations, of both
through and stub types, with critical analyses of working capacity, and
include a review of the different methods of estimating their capacity.
(2) Report on developments in the handling of freight by mechanical
means.
(3) Report on developments in the design and operation of hump
yards.
(4) Report on typical' situation plans for a division engine terminal.
(5) Report on methods of handling baggage, express and mail, at
passenger terminals.
The Committee was also instructed to consider revision of Manual ;
if no changes were recommended, to make statement accordingly, and
to make concise recommendations for next year's work.
The Committee held two meetings during the year, in addition to
the meetings of the various Sub-Committees, as follows :
St. Louis, Mo., June 26 and 27; Washington, D. C, October 6
and 7.
A large amount of work has been done by all of the Sub-Committees
on topics assigned to them.
REVISION OF MANUAL.
After careful consideration of the present Manual, the Committee
has no recommendation for further changes at the present time.
89
90 YARDS AND TERMINALS.
(i) TYPICAL SITUATION PLANS OF PASSENGER STATIONS.
The Sub-Committee has accumulated a large amount of data with
respect to existing terminals. The subject assigned, however, is so broad
and important that it is desirable to continue work on it through another
year. In view, therefore, of the expressed desire of the Board of Direc-
tion that the reports be limited as far as possible, it was decided to reserve
report on this subject until next year.
(2) HANDLING OF FREIGHT BY MECHANICAL MEANS.
Considerable progress has been made at different points in the de-
velopment of freight handling by mechanical means since the Committee's
last report, and during the past year inspection was made of the new
Missouri, Kansas & Texas Railway freight handling plant at Broadway
Station, St. Louis, Mo., the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad telpher system at
Pier No. 8, Locust Point, Baltimore, Md., the power conveyor system
in one of the new warehouses of the Texas City Transportation Com-
pany, at Galveston, Texas, and of the electric truck system at Dock
No. 6, Jersey City, N. J. As nearly all of these systems are practically
new and sufficient time has not elapsed since installation to enable all
points as to their utility to be definitely determined, both as to economy
of operation and practical utility, full report on these systems is held
over for future publication.
The attention of the Association is called to certain published
articles noted below in relation to this subject:
1. Freight House at St. Louis, with Mechanical Freight-Handling
Equipment ; Engineering News, June 29 ; Railway Age Gazette, June 23 ;
Railway and Engineering Review, November 11.
2. Electric Truck System at Dock No. 6, Jersey City, N. J.; Rail-
way and Engineering Review, July 29.
3. Mechanical Handling of Freight (by S. B. Fowler) ; Proceedings
of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers; Railway and Engi-
neering Review, February 11.
4. Motor Trucks for Freight Transportation ; Engineering News,
June 22.
5. Freight Handling Installations at River Ports ; Engineering News,
May 4.
6. Mechanical Handling of Package Freight; Engineering News,
May 11.
7. A Freight Station for the Use of Storage Battery Trucks ; En-
gineering Record, January 28.
8. Electric Trucks for Handling Freight and Baggage ; Engineer-
ing News, May 11, June 22, December 7.
9. Telfer System for Handling Baggage at an English Passenger
Terminal Station; Engineering News, August 17.
10. Terminals, Yards and Mechanical Handling of Baggpge at Sta-
tions; Bulletin of the International Railway Congress, November, 191 1.
YARDS AND TERMINALS. 91
ii. Cargo Transference at Steamship Terminals (H. McL. Hard-
ing) ; Proceedings of the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engi-
neers, 191 1.
12. Terminals and Freight Piers at Boston; Engineering News,
November 2, 191 1.
13. Freight Piers and Freight Handling Machinery at Boston, Engi-
neering News, November 9, 1911.
(3) DESIGN AND OPERATION OF HUMP YARDS.
Additional data on existing hump yards has been secured by Sub-
Committee, and is held for future report.
(4) TYPICAL SITUATION PLANS FOR DIVISION ENGINE
TERMINAL.
In treating this subject, the Committee understands its work to be
the making of recommendations as to the best arrangement of facilities
for the handling of locomotives at terminals rather than as to specifica-
tions for exact designs of the various structures involved, excepting
as in a general way the characteristics of such structures seem to be
more or less suited to the arrangement recommended.
It is also understood that the scope of the Committee's work does
not include the consideration of shop or repair yard locations.
We submit herewith a typical plan or layout for an engine terminal
whose characteristics permit of application equally well to larger or
smaller demands practically without limit and without respect to whether
the locomotives cared for are all freight or passenger, or in both kinds
of service.
We have examined a number of plans of recently constructed engine
terminals, and think we have adopted in our plan the best ideas of
all, and that we have avoided the manifest errors of some at least of
these plans. It must, of course, be recognized that in any case of actual
construction, physical limitations as to space and shape of the ground
site will impose more or less modification of the plan we recommend, but
we think it will come more generally within the possibility of any given
set of conditions than any other typical plan that could be suggested.
In locating an engine terminal, the facilities should be placed with
reference to the yards and main line in the most advantageous position
possible, that is, so that the distance between the engine terminal and
the points where engines begin and end their service shall be a minimum,
and so that reverse or conflicting movements shall be avoided as much
as practicable.
The idea to be kept in mind is the most direct and convenient, that
is, rapid and economical performance of those things required for an
engine in its terminal in that sequence which answers all requirements
in the order of their urgency. It appears to us that on the arrival of
a locomotive at its terminal, the first imperative demand is likely to be
92 YARDS AND TERMINALS.
for water, and that this demand is likely to be the last when leaving
the terminal for service, and for this reason our typical plan provides
for the location of watering facilities accordingly.
After an incoming engine has been protected by receiving water,
the next step appears logically to clean its fires or remove it entirety,
according to need, and place the engine as quickly as possible in the
engine house where the repairs necessary to prepare it for new service
may be made, engine cleaned, etc. The cinder pit should be located as
close as practicable to the engine house and permit at the same time of en-
gines moving off cinder pit in normal direction, being switched direct to an
outbound track without using or fouling turntable, as may often be
desired.
It appears logical that the process of coaling should be reserved,
if practicable, until just before the engine re-enters service in order that
it may do so with a maximum supply of fuel, and also because the
cleaning or removal of fire on cinder pit, as well as repairs of engine
tank or other repairs, can be accomplished without that interference
that might result from having tender filled with coal, and this reasoning
dictates that the location of the coaling station should be primarily to
serve the outbound tracks. Inasmuch, however, as it may often occur
that incoming engines will require coal, the coaling station should be
located as indicated on our typical plan, so that coal may also be taken
by an engine on an inbound track.
The trestle type of coal dock may be used if desired, if only two
coaling tracks are required, and can be located between the inbound
and outbound tracks in same relative position as shown in typical
plan.
The most convenient and economical arrangement for storing and
drying sand is at the coal station, where it may be handled by the same
attendants. Sand should ordinarily be delivered to engines passing on the
inbound tracks.
It will be observed that the arrangement of facilities permits of
large increase in capacity of cinder pit, coaling station, etc.,- and in this
connection the idea of having the coaling station at a busy terminal
comprising two independent units makes a strong appeal for approval
in view of the possibility of one of the hoisting plants suffering tem-
porary disability from breakdown, or other cause.
The location of storehouse, oil house, enginemen's tool and locker
rooms need not be arbitrarily prescribed, but should be as close as prac-
ticable to the engine house and the cinder pit. However, where any of
these buildings are served by their own tracks, those tracks should be
so located and connected as not to interfere with the uninterrupted free
use of the engine tracks.
A system of ample lighting facilities is important, with lights dis-
tributed so as to avoid, as far as practicable, darkness or shadow where
men are engaged in work upon engines.
TYPICAL PLAN OF RNGINE TERMINAL.
93
sy
se
le
er
TrfitC *L &L **/V QT fA/GtMC 7f
Ptoooosco mv Sum Co***** Tree A/o£
YARDS AND TERMINALS. 93
CONCLUSIONS.
(i) The engine terminal should be so located as to afford easy
access to both Main Line and Yards, with the fewest possible reverse
or conflicting movements.
(2) The facilities provided should be arranged to permit of the
most direct and rapid handling of an engine in its terminal in the order
of its needs.
The Committee recommends for next year's work a continuation
of Subjects Nos. 1, 2 and 3, enumerated above.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON YARDS AND TERMINALS.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE II -ON BALLAST.
H. E. Hale, Chairman;
W. J. Bergen.
A. F. Blaess.
T. C. Burpee.
F. T. Darrow.
J. M. Egan.
T. W. Fatherson.
H. L. Gordon.
G. H. Harris.
J. M. Meade, Vice-Chair man;
C. C. Hill.
S. A. Jordan.
A. S. More.
J. V. Neubert.
S. B. Rice.
E. V. Smith.
F. J. Stimson.
S. N. Williams.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Raihvay Engineering Association:
Two meetings of the Committee were held in Chicago, one on July
27, and one on November 13, 191 1.
Five meetings of Sub-Committees were held during the year, as fol-
lows: June 26, at Washington, D. C. ; June 30, at St. Louis; July 27, at
Chicago ; October 7, at Chicago ; November 1, at Washington, D. C.
REPORT ON THE PROPER DEPTH OF BALLAST TO INSURE
UNIFORM DISTRIBUTION OF THE LOADS ON
THE ROADBED.
REVIEW OF PREVIOUS REPORT.
The report of the Committee on the proper depth of ballast submitted
during the year 1910 was in the form of a progress report, accompanied
by a table showing the approved depth of ballast on various railroads,
as printed in the Proceedings, Vol. 12, Part 1, page 345, but on account
of lack of sufficient information on which to base definite recommenda-
tions, no action was taken on this subject by the Association.
DEFINITIONS.
Depth of Ballast. — The distance from the bottom of the tie to the
top of the subgrade. (For definition of "subgrade," see Manual, 191 1,
page 16.)
historical.
Various experiments and investigations have been made to deter-
mine the proper depth of ballast, and a list of some of the most im-
portant ones follows :
(A) Experiments by Railroad Director Schubert, in Germany, given
95
96 BALLAST.
in Proceedings, American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way
Association, Vol. 7 (1906), page 102.
(B) Report on the "Question of Strengthening the Track and
Bridges, with a View to Increasing the Speed of Trains," made to the
International Railway Congress by the Reporter for America, Mr. M. L.
Byers, and later published in the Engineering News, of February 3, 191a
(C) An article entitled "Gravel as Ballast," by Mr. C. Brauning,
translated from "Zeitschrift fur Bauwesen," Vol. LIV, Berlin, 1904, being
Appendix "C" (Bulletin 136, pp. 157-179).
(D) An article on "Ballast," by Mr. George W. Vaughan, Engineer
Maintenance of Way, New York Central & Hudson River Railroad,
printed in this report at Appendix "D" (Bulletin 136, pp. 180-190).
(E) Report of Pennsylvania Railroad General Manager's Committee
appointed "To Determine by Experiment the Necessary Depth of Stone
Ballast," dated March 5, 191 1, being Appendix "B" (Bulletin 136, pp.
3-155)-
(F) "A Study of the Stresses Existing in Track Superstructure and
Rational Design Based Thereon," by Mr. O. E. Selby, Bridge Engineer,
Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Railway, published in Pro-
ceedings, American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way Asso-
ciation, Vol. 8, 1907, pp. 52-59.
ANALYTICAL.
Your Committee feels that very valuable information was given to
the Association in the report of the Pennsylvania Railroad Committee
on the necessary depth of stone ballast, published in Bulletin 136, through
the kindness of Mr. W. C. Cushing, President of the American Railway
Engineering Association, and Mr. L. R. Zollinger, Chairman of the Com-
mittee, appointed by the General Manager of the Pennsylvania Railroad.
The details of the test, which are very complete, are given in Ap-
pendix "D" of this report, and the conclusions, in so far as the proper
depth of ballast which will insure uniform pressure on the subgrade, are
as follows :
The tests made by the Pennsylvania Railroad at Altoona indicate that
with approximately 320,000 to 440,000-lb. axle loads, or 75,000 lbs. each, pass-
ing over test ties on the test ballast, at five miles per hour, the subgrade
practically reached a permanent settlement, and that where the ballast was
materially less than 24 in., the settlement of the subgrade (loam) und«?
the ballast was not uniform, but showed a greater settlement under tbk.
ties than between the ties.
These experiments further indicated that when stone ballast was
placed 24 in. deep under the ties, the settlement of the subgrade (loam)
under the ballast was practically uniform, and therefore the pressure must
have been approximately uniform.
It was also found that a combination of stone and cinder ballast 24
in. deep under the ties (lower layer of cinders 18 in. to 14 in. deep, upper
layer of stone 6 in. to 10 in. deep) gave nearly as gooil results, although
BALLAST. 97
the deformation of the subgrade was greater than with 24 in. of stone
ballast.
The result of this series of tests, which indicated that approximately
24 in. of stone ballast is required to produce a uniform pressure on the
subgrade, with the ties spaced 24 in. to 25.5 in., center to center, agrees
very closely with the formula given by Mr. Thos. H. Johnson, in the
Proceedings of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of
Way Association, Vol. 7 (1006), which was derived from the experiments
of Director Schubert, namely, that with ties spaced 23 in. apart, center
to center, stone ballast should be 22 2-3 in. deep to produce uniform
pressure on the subgrade.
CONCLUSION.
With the data available, your Committee finds that with the ties
(7 in. by 9 in. by SZA ft.) spaced approximately 24 in. to 25.5 in., center
to center, a depth of 24 in. of stone ballast is necessary to produce uni-
form pressure on the subgrade, and a combination of a lower layer of
cinder ballast (18 in. to 14 in.) and an upper layer of stone ballast
(6 in. to 10 in.), approximately 24 in. deep in the aggregate, with the
same spacing of the ties will produce nearly the same results.
REPORT ON PHYSICAL TESTS OF STONE FOR BALLAST.
REVIEW OF PREVIOUS REPORTS.
The Physical Tests of Stone for Ballast adopted by the Association
and described in Vol. 11 (1910), Part 2, pp. 910-914, were the first tests
of this character adopted by the Association, and the question of re-
vising the tests, if necessary, or adding other tests to those adopted,
was again referred to the Ballast Committee for furher investigation
and consideration.
HISTORICAL.
Your Committee ascertained that the railroads as a rule had no uni-
form practice in making physical tests of stone for ballast. Some of the
roads selected their stone for ballast by simply observing the character
of the stone, and then ascertaining its durability and fitness for ballast by
the actual results obtained in track. Some roads required a compression
test in their specifications, but only one railroad was found to have
used the physical tests made by the United States Government, previous
to their adoption by the Association, as above referred to.
ANALYTICAL.
Your Committee does not recommend any changes in the physical tests
already adopted, but feels that the tests would be more complete if the
compression test were added.
With this in view, the question was taken up with the Department of
Agriculture of the United States Government at Washington, D. C,
*For amendment to Conclusion, see Index.
98 BALLAST.
and they have agreed to add the compression test to those adopted by the
Association, which were described in Vol. n (1910), Part 2, pp. 910-914.
of the Association Proceedings.
The description of the compression test, which the Government will
make, is as follows :
A cylinder two (2) in. in diameter and more than two (2) in. long
is drilled from the specimen of stone to be tested, by means of a diamond
core drill, and sawed to a length of two (2) in. by a band saw fed with
emery. The specimen is finally faced off on each end by means of a
power-driven grinding lap, on which water and emery are continuously fed.
The cylinder then has both ends embedded in plaster of paris, the
bed being made as thin as possible and both ends being made parallel.
The cylinder is next mounted on an Olsen test machine on a special bear-
ing block between blotting papers, three thicknesses being placed at each
end, between the cylinder and the steel-bearing faces of the machine.
The load is then applied at a speed of 0.152 in. per minute, the machine
being kept balanced during the application of the load.
Your Committee believes that with the physical tests of stone for
Ballast, which the Association adopted, and the compression test above
described, sufficient information will be given by which to compare the
character of stone from the various quarries from which it is proposed
to obtain ballast.
As a matter of information your Committee has, during the past year,
requested a number of railroads to send samples of their stone ballast
to the Government for test, and through the assistance and courtesy of
these railroads we are enabled to present a tabulated statement of the re-
sults of these tests, and while this statement is not as complete as was
desired, yet we feel it will be of considerable value in studying this
question.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES.
The advantage of using approved physical tests of stone for ballast
is to determine the character of the stone and its fitness for ballast without
the expense of opening quarries and using the stone, before it is known
whether it will be suitable for ballast or not, and without some method
of determining this by physical tests, railroads will undoubtedly be put
to considerable expense by opening quarries and applying stone ballast,
which in some cases will have to be replaced with better ballast from other
quarries.
CONCLUSIONS.
Your Committee recommends that in addition to the Physical Tests
of Stone for Ballast, which have been adopted by the Association, that
the "Compression Test," above described, be adopted and included in
the Manual.
Your Committee also recommends that the following reference be
made in the Manual to the description of the tests and the action nec-
essary to have tests made:
BALLAST. 99
"For the description of the physical tests of stone for ballast as
recommended by the Association and full instructions as to how the sam-
ples should be obtained and shipped to the Government, see Proceedings
of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way Associa-
tion, Vol. ii, Part 2, pp. 910-914, and report of Ballast Committee of 1912.
If blueprints of the machines used in making the tests are desired, they
can be obtained from the Department of Agriculture, United States Govern-
ment, Washington, D. C."
COMPLETE REVIEW OF GRAVEL BALLAST AND RECOM-
MENDED METHODS FOR GRADING THE
DIFFERENT QUALITIES.
REVIEW OF PREVIOUS REPORT.
In the Proceedings of the American Railway Engineering and Main-
tenance of Way Association, of 1910, Vol. 11, pp. 909-932, a classifi-
cation of gravel ballast was adopted by the Association, which depended
on the amount of sand and dust found in the gravel, the size of the sand,
and the size of the gravel, being determined in accordance with the defini-
tions of "Sand and Gravel" given in the Manual, and this subject was
again referred to the Ballast Committee for a complete review.
ANALYTICAL.
Your Committee, during the year, requested a number of railroads
to test their gravel ballast and determine the percentage of sand, gravel
(following the definitions of sand and gravel, given in the Manual), dust
etc., in the ballast, and we present herewith a statement showing the
percentages as found in ballast now in use, and a brief of the reports
obtained from the railroads in regard to the use of these deposits of
gravel for ballast is as follows :
The Santa Fe Railway reports that it is using the Chillicothe gravel
almost entirely and finds it to be very satisfactory, giving good results
on the roadbed, as it comes from the pit, using 12 in. under the ties.
The Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad reports show gravel
being taken from four different places, and put under the tracks as it is
loaded from the pits, which makes excellent track, binds well and is
easily worked.
The Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway reports gravel taken
from five different places, the best being from Benton, Ark., on their
Southern lines, but not equal to the glacial gravel of Iowa and Illinois.
The gravel was used on the track as it came from the pits, and not washed.
Twelve tests of pits on the Grand Rapids & Indiana Railroad are
shown in the tabulated statement. The ballast is not washed, but is put
in the track as it comes from the pit.
In the case of the Illinois Central Railroad, the tabulated statement
shows tests from four different places, and the ballast from each is used
100
STATEMENT
BALLAST.
SHOWING PERCENTAGES OF SAND, CLAY, ETC., IN GRAVEL
BALLAST
Name of
Location of
Gravel Pit
PERCENTAGES
Railway
Dust
and
Clay
Sand
Grav-
el
Rock Voids
Remarks
C. B. &Q
Atchison, Kansas.. . .
10.0
12.7
77.3
0.0 No
Data
Per cent, by weight.
Main track.
C. B. &Q
O'Neill, Neb
8.5
57.5
34.0
0.0 No
Data
Per cent, by weight .
Branch line.
C. B. &Q
Ballantine, Montana.
7.0
4.9
52.5
35.6 ! No
Data
Per cent, by weight.
Main line.
C.B.&Q
Peetz, Colorado
4.8
51.5
42.5
1.2 1 No
Data
Per cent, by weight.
Main line.
C. R. I. & P
Chillicothe, Illinois..
6.0
60.0
40.0
0.0 No
Data
Per centege arrived
at by volume.
C. R. I. & P
Grattinger, Iowa ....
16.4
41.4
53.7
No No
Data Data
Percentage arrived
at by volume.
C. R. I. & P
Benton, Arkansas
23.3
20.8
79.2
No No
Data Data
C. R. I. & P
On St. Louis Division
5.8
22.0
80.0
No No
Data Data
C. R.I.&P
16.3
11.8
90.9
No No
Data Data
G. R.&I
Big Rapids, Michigan
6.0
32.0
78.0
No No
Data Data
Shown as good qual-
ity of ballast.
G.R.&I
Sand Lake, Michigan
18.0
44.0
63.0
No
Data
No
Date
Shown as fair quality
of ballast.
G. R.&I
5.0
30.0
80.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as poor qual-
ity of ballast.
G. R.&I
Belmont Pit
0.5
15.0
91.0
No
Data
No
Date
ity of ballast.
G.R.&I
M..G R.&I
0.0
40.0
75.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as fair quality
of ballast.
G. R. & I
Paris Pit
15.0
40.0
70.0
No
Date
No
Data
ity of ballast.
G. R. &I
11.0
36.0
72.0
No
Data
No
Data
ity of ballast.
G. R. &I
5.0
40.0
72.0
No
Data
No
Data
ity of ballast.
G. R. & I
Tustin
8.0
42.0
72.0
No
Data
No
Data
ity of ballast.
G.R.&I
K. S. Tower Pit,
Oden
13.0
60.0
48.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as poor qual-
G.R.&I
K. S. Tower Pit,
T. C. Sect. 2
18.0
49.0
55.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as poor qual-
ity of ballast.
G.R.&I
K. S. Tower Pit,
T.C. Sect. 3
15.0
56.0
50.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as poor qual-
ity of ballast.
G. R.&I
K. S. Tower Pit,
T.C. Sect. 4
16.0
55.0
50.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as poor qual-
ity of ballast.
BALLAST.
101
STATEMENT SHOWING PERCENTAGES OF SAND, CLAY, ETC., IN GRAVEL
BALLAST.
Location of
Gravel Pit
PERCENTAGES
Name of
Railway
Dust
and
Clay
Sand
Grav-
el
Rock
Voids
Remarks
G.R.&I
Suttons Bay Pit
15.0
36.0
67.0
No
Data
No
Data
Shown as poor qual-
ity of ballast.
I. C
Forreston, Illinois
4.8
17.2
72.0
6.0
20.0
I. C
Riverton, Indiana. . .
7.9
23.5
68.6
0.0
13.4
I. C
Gravel Switch,
7.0
6.2
85.0
1.8
18.8
I. C
Memphis, Tennessee.
3.3
17.8
77.7
1.2
17.3
Fowler, Colorado
2.0
65.0
33.0
0.0
No
Data
Fair results.
Ft. Gibson,
5.0
4.0
94.0
0.006
No
Data
Clay included in per-
Bethel, Arkansas. . . .
4.0
34.0
76.0
0.0
No
Data
N. Y. C.&H. R.
18.0
55.0
27.0
No
Data
No
Data
Sample No. 16.
N. Y. C. & H. R.
5.0
20.0
75.0
No
Data
No
Data
Sample No. 17, first
quality.
N. Y. C. & H. R.
Glenfield
18.0
57.0
25.0
No
Data
No
Data
Sample No. 19, coarse
sand, very good but
dusty.
N. Y. C. & H. R.
Todds
10.0
35.0
55.0
No
Data
No
Data
Sample No. 18.
N. Y. C. & H. R.
8.0
27.0
65.0
No
Data
No
Data
Sample No. 21.
Note. — The sand and gravel in the ballast given in the above table was
determined in accordance with the definition of sand and gravel in the
Manual, edition of 1911.
102 BALLAST.
in the track as it comes from the pits, except in the case of the Memphis
gravel, which is taken from the bed of the Mississippi River and washed.
The Missouri Pacific Railway reports tests from three different places,
and like the other roads the ballast was used on the track as it came
from the pits.
It will be seen from the reports of the six different roads that no
expense was incurred in washing or screening the gravel, which was used
upon the tracks as it came from the pits, except in the case of the Illinois
Central Railroad, for gravel secured at Memphis.
A report from the Chief Engineer of the Intercolonial Railroad of
Canada states that he is of the impression that if they screened their
gravel they would not get as good results as where they took the sand
with a coarser material combined.
A report from the Engineering Department of the Canadian Pacific
Railway states that they are ballasting with gravel taken direct from
the pit, without any cost of treatment.
Your Committee further endeavored to determine the maximum
amount of clay which would be permissible in good cementing ballast,
and by reference to the data we have on this subject we find that most
of the tests that have been made of gravel ballast give very meager in-
formation as to the amount of clay in cementing ballast, but from the best
information we have at hand we are of the opinion that where the clay
amounts to over 10 per cent, it would be quite objectionable.
Your Committee wishes to give a high endorsement of the report
on "Gravel as Ballast," by Mr. C. Brauning, which Mr. W. M. Dawley
had translated from "Zeitschrift fiir Bauwesen," Vol. LIV, Berlin, 1904.
We also present to the Association, under Appendix "A," a description
and photographs of a gravel washing plant on the Richmond, Fredericks-
burg & Potomac Railroad, at Massaponax, midway between Richmond,
Va., and Washington, D. C, which plant is under the charge of Mr. S. B.
Rice, Engineer Maintenance of Way, to whom we are indebted for that
report. The results obtained from this washed gravel ballast, as can
be seen from this report, are far superior to the results obtained from
the use of gravel for ballast without washing.
CONCLUSIONS.
Your Committee recommends further investigation of the amount of
sand, dust and clay, permissible in good gravel ballast, since reports ob-
tained this year from various railways, and attached hereto in a tabulated
statement, indicate wide variations in the amount of these materials found
in gravel ballast in actual use, yet reported as giving good results.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON BALLAST.
Appendix A.
GRAVEL WASHING PLANT OF THE RICHMOND, FREDERICKS-
BURG & POTOMAC AND WASHINGTON SOUTHERN
RAILWAYS.
By. S. B. Rice, Engineer Maintenance of Way.
The latter part of July, 1907, or about the time the double tracking of
the Richmond, Fredericksburg & Potomac Railroad and Washington
Southern Railway had been completed, the officials were discussing the
matter of using stone ballast to make the line first-class in every respect,
it being a through trunk line between Richmond, Va., and Washington,
D. C, with a traffic that is very heavy. We have an average of 24
through passenger and 10 local trains daily during the heavy season and
an average of 20 through passenger and 10 local trains daily during
the light season, the through trains consisting of from six to twelve
cars and the local trains of from four to five cars. We have
an average of 20 freight trains daily throughout the year. Weight of
heaviest engine, 156,730 lbs. on drivers; total weight, 373,200 lbs.
About this time we had discovered a heavy deposit of very excellent
gravel at Massaponax, Va., 57 miles from Richmond, midway between
that point and Washington, and thought it possible that we could make a
first-class road from this material. The gravel lies in a bed from ten to
twenty feet in depth, about 800 ft. wide and 4,000 ft. in length. The
pit we estimated to contain about 1,000,000 cu. yds. of serviceable mate-
rial. The pit was opened on August 22, 1007.
The pit-run gravel from this pit was used on portions of our track and
made an excellent track, but in long, dry seasons it was found to be very
dusty, and in long wet spells we found that track became sloppy. In the
latter part of 1907 we conceived the idea of washing and screening this
material, as was done by the Lake Shore & Michigan Southern Railway
at Roupel and Pleasant Lake. In July, 1908, W. D. Duke, Assistant to
President; S. B. Rice, Engineer Maintenance of Way, and E. M'. Hastings,
Resident Engineer, made a trip to the Roupel plant with a view of looking
into the advisability of duplicating this plant, also to have the opportunity
of inspecting track that had been ballasted with washed gravel. Mr. Duke
was so much pleased with the condition of the track and plant that he at
once recommended the installation of the washing plant at Massaponax at
the earliest possible time. The authority for this work was given in the
latter part of July, 1908. Work was at once started on this plant and
pushed as rapidly as possible to have it completed before bad weather set
in. The first shipment of washed gravel was on November 20, 1908, start-
ing at the Richmond end.
103
104 BALLAST.
The plant consists of a large concrete hopper into which the pit-run
gravel is dumped, from which it is carried by a pan conveyor having a
speed of 30 ft. per minute, or 120 to 150 cu. yds. per hour, on an incline of
30 degrees, to the top of the trestle some 45 ft. high, where it is discharged
into a steel-lined box, 6x3 ft. in plan and one foot deep in front, or at the
chute. The water, discharged from a flat nozzle, one inch wide and 24
in. long, connected to a 6-in. discharge pipe, strikes the gravel as it falls
into the box, washing it down over a steel-lined chute, six ft. wide and
eight ft. long, with a slope of 3 in. to the foot.
It was found necessary, in order to more completely wash the gravel,
to place a series of rods across the chute, making the gravel tumble over
them, thereby retarding its progress and obtaining a more complete
washing.
At the end of the chute there is a double screen placed at an angle
of about 45 degrees with the chute. The screens are about 9 in. apart, and
are of double-crimped tool steel wire. The first of No. 6 wire, one mesh
to the inch ; the second of No. 10 wire, two meshes to the inch. All gravel
that does not pass these two screens falls into the ballast bin, which is 36
ft. long and 12 ft. wide and about 12 ft. deep. The lower six ft. of this
bin is sloped toward the center, so that the gravel will fall by gravity
through the openings in the bottom. (Fig. 4.)
All of the material which passes these two screens along with the
water falls upon a second steel-lined chute which is eight ft. wide, nine
ft. long, and a slope of two in. to the foot. From this chute the material
is discharged against another screen, of double crimped tool steel wire
No. 12, four meshes to the inch. This screen takes out practically every-
thing larger than y$-in. in diameter. All material which does not pass
this screen falls into the ballast bin also.
The material passing the screen is carried over another steel-lined
chute about ten ft. wide and seven ft. long, where it is discharged as sand
into a settling tank about 12x13 ft. and three ft. deep. On the side of the
tank opposite this chute is the waste flume where the muddy water is car-
ried off and discharged on the bed of gravel where the gravel had been
previously excavated.
The settling tank is water-tight and is fitted at the bottom with two
conical steel hoppers, six ft. in diameter at the top and ten in. in diameter
at the base, five ft. deep. The bottoms of the steel cones are fitted with a
steel cone plug which makes them nearly water-tight. The plugs or cones
are operated from the top. The idea of having two of the conical hoppers
was to grade the sand, the coarse sand settling in the first hopper and the
fine sand in the farther one, there being a distinct difference in the two
grades of sand. For this sand we have found ready sale, as it is of ex-
cellent quality for building purposes and concrete work, the finer sand
making excellent engine sand.
The ballast bin is steel-lined throughout and has three openings at
the bottom, fitted with 20x20 in. rack and pinion valves, spaced so as to
empty into the center and two ends of the ballast car, giving a uniform
BALLAST. 105
loading without necessitating the moving of car. The material is dis-
tributed in the ballast bin about equally over the three openings.
The water is brought from Massaponax Creek through a gravity canal,
900 ft. long (Fig. 1), to a concrete lined well, 7x5 ft. and 11 ft. deep; the
bottom of the well being four ft. lower than the creek at the intake. This
canal is a 20x20-in. open wood flume for 500 ft. where it runs into a
20x20-in. wood box, covered by some eight ft. of earth. This box is about
370 ft. long, where connection is made with an 18-in. terra cotta pipe,
which runs under the engine foundation and pull-out track into the well,
which is located close to the engine ; this flume is always submerged.
The pump is an Emerson pump No. 4 with a 6-in. suction, rated for a 5-in.
discharge. The rated capacity is from 800 to 1,200 gallons per minute.
To overcome friction it was fitted with a 6-in. discharge. The steam is
furnished by a go H.P. return tubular boiler, which is under same roof as
engine and pump. We also have a No. 5 pulling pump, rated at 350 gal-
lons per minute, for the purpose of pumping water into a 25,000 gallon
tank about 1,400 ft. distant, which is used by ballast and spotting engines.
This tank is located on the pull-out track, just north of the coal bin.
At this point we have the office and bunk houses for both white ana
colored help. These bunk houses are separated. The Superintendent of
the plant is on the ground at all times. Steam shovel and spotting engine
crews are provided with both lodging and board.
The concrete hopper (Fig. 4), into which the pit gravel is dumped
preparatory to washing, is 18 ft. above the foundation, 36 ft. long and 12
ft. wide inside, the outside walls are two ft. thick. The inside of the
hopper slopes from the top all ways toward the center opening, which is
18x20 in., and provided with a steel sliding door which governs the feed
on the conveyor. The slant sides of the hopper are six in. thick, rein-
forced with from l/2 to i^-in. iron rods, spaced 18 in. in centers and bent
over into the two ft. outside walls. They are fastened together with y2-'m.
rods spaced about 12 in. apart. The track on the hopper is carried on
12x14 in. wood stringers, one of which is immediately over the outside
wall, the other carried on I2xi4-in. cross stringers, spaced six ft. c. to c,
and imbedded in the outside walls. The track over the hopper is fitted
with a bar screen, bars spaced 4^ in. apart, so as to prevent roots, stumps,
boulders, or large lumps of clay from being carried to the washing plant.
The approach to the hopper (Fig. 1) is on a 2 per cent, grade as-
cending, which terminates at a point 150 ft. from the end of the hopper,
thence by a 1 per cent, descending grade, which continues over the hopper,
where it breaks into a 2.5 per cent, descending, then to a 5 per cent,
descending grade for about 150 ft., then to an 18 per cent, ascending grade.
At the junction of the 5 per cent, and 18 per cent, grades there is located a
spring switch, the track leading away from the switch being on a descend-
ing grade to the pit level, the idea being to do most of the shifting by
gravity. The loaded cars after being pushed up the 2 per cent, approach to
the hopper are unloaded, dropped from the 5 per cent, grade by gravity,
and up on the 18 per cent, grade, which gives them a kick back through
106 BALLAST.
the spring switch and down to the pit level, where they are taken by the
engine to be reloaded.
It is intended to cover the 112 miles of double track with washed
gravel, thereby securing a dustless roadbed. In order to accomplish this
we had new grades given, making a lift in track from 3 to 16 in., taking
out some slight sags that were in tracks. Of course, where the track was
lifted as much as 6 inches the old ballast could be worked under the ties,
but at the other points the old sand and gravel ballast was thrown out to
make roadbed. Ballast was loaded into the Rodgers drop bottom ballast
cars and delivered in track, using a Rodgers plow for levelling down.
This work was carried on by an extra force, renewing all ties that
were not good for two years, regaging track and properly spacing ties
ahead of new ballast. The renewal of ties and regaging was charged to
maintenance ; surfacing track was charged to reballasting. It required
from 3,200 to 3,800 cu. yds. to the double track mile. The force em-
ployed at the pit consists of the following : One general foreman, one
clerk, one shovel engineer, one craneman, one shovel fireman, four men at
shovel, one engineer in charge of plant, one towerman who operates the
machinery at top of plant, also looking after the screens, one foreman on
hopper, one hopper and two helpers, one sand loader, one gravel loader
and two droppers of cars. In addition to this there are three men on
cars closing them up and calking and getting them ready for sand. Shift-
ing track is generally done by section force and is, of course, charged to
pit expense.
Since the starting of the washing plant there have been 371,877 cu.
yds. of washed gravel shipped, of which 354,439 cubic yards were used for
ballast and 17,438 cu. yds. for concrete and other purposes. From this
total amount of gravel we have taken 78,232 cu. yds. of sand, most of
which has been sold for building purposes. Of course, the hauling of this
has been revenue to the Company. Cost per cubic yard of loading rough
gravel, 8.95 cents; cost per cubic yard of washing gravel, 11.34 cents; cost
per cubic yard for hauling, il.ll cents; cost per cubic yard for placing
in track, 26.15 cents; or a total cost of 57.55 cents per cubic yard of fin-
ished track. This cost includes hire of all engines, train crews, coal and
supplies ; rental of shovel, coal, supplies and repairs ; one cent per cubic
yard to cover cost of gravel in pit and 10 per cent, depreciation on plant
and tracks ; but no credit is taken in these figures for sand sold.
We have found by actual test that the washed gravel is nearly self-
draining; it will not retain over nTA per cent, of water, while the pit-run
gravel will retain 55 per cent. It has been demonstrated that the washed
gravel will withstand any amount of continued rain and not slop, while the
pit-run would, causing rough track in continued wet spells. Aside from
the better condition of track we estimate to add at least two years to life
of the ties. It makes a dustless roadbed and reduces the cost of main-
tenance.
BALLAST.
107
O
>
fe
1LS
5ALLAST.
BALLAST
109
K
pq
O
>
[x,
110
BALLAST.
Fig. 4— View Showing Where Gravel is Emptied from Carrier and
Where Water First Strikes It, Also Showing Action the
Ballast and Water Take in Passing Over the Bars
into the First Flume.
RESULTS OF GOVERNMENT TESTS ON STONE FOR
BALLAST, RESULTS IN TRACK, AND RAILWAY
BALLAST SPECIFICATIONS.
• IN TIUOK IND riAII.WAI rill II II Ml..'.!,
.>»...«.
'.l (lOVl IINM1 N i
llhnuai ir,..„i„^
> * lifr.i.1 8ta» Co, Pataoa C». lad.
inhhtlV ID .
Co-3w.:: Co, K>
:=:
Co Otto
■»Go.O»*>
v< W«t Co, Oa,
WlnjiiniKi Co,OMa
WatVo. Uor»aCo,Pa .
* -a- Ma at Blraan. Barb Co. Pa '..
PlaBaT JaAraa Co. T «. .
Bcraw Plana, UMmmm Co . T«a .
■m Float, Jafaaaa Co, T«
oa
en
US
ia
1 M
1M
oa
IB
IS
i a
m
ea
m
OM
in
i a
■ a
1 14
id
> u
ia
o to
IU
i n
IB
i a
in
on
ia
ia
oa
ia
Oil
1M
IH
ia
ian
m
ia
ia
0 10
ia
m
in
0 II
in
on
in
m
.
bota iaa a
1* urn only .)..
In u*n ..nl, .,„
: ■
M-ilmon.
Ib aarvioa only 3 y*a>ra
I* aarrioa only 3 yv»
la mtvIm only 2 y«*n
only Syaara.
Ii MrriM otlr lytan
Ia a-rnoaoaly 3 >«*/*
Ia aai-Tioa oily 2 yrara
Uaad I yarn/*, doaa
Bt/»n* Ui ba bard. darmMa, aad U qaaL
HvaeetpUfa
Hhall ..r-.. in ■«(.
' fnii,»i| aad • r.*ll ba taor>va«hry
I aeraaaad <A all dart, dirt, aad brvca
I InvavM) avtaawd --I-) Em boa dUai
Good aarrioa; wmn roua-1 la 3 or 1 ya*ra. ,
Oood aarrlea, mm roun-J la 3 or I yamra.
-'»; wmr* round ia 3 or 3 yaavra.
Uood aarrioa. waara roaad la 3 or 3 yamra. .
n
Liaaa
Uaad ID yaavra; vary aataafartory r
rtaUriariory: rtnad lampuat wall
I ■■ BtaB MM • -«.-> i ■- . ana c-i
Vary mod
Poor: oramka ia tarn pi a< .
Good: Mill l**l 10 >**ra. rUaui martin
• .|n.liim- r'agarva abo
ia tba ubla aboar tba partawrtaar*
Fraa from doat, aartb mad traab
Fitaaaa radxad by aa* ta track.
Limartona o. approrad a oaLiy . Grads
atad ia «u*. Sunaid of all dirt aad
rubbiab aad rtooa amailar tbaa 1 aatb-
riiaba pBaauac 34-ttch n* awl ka-ter
thaa I vacb. mart ba brokaa by nauad
at plara of loadiac.
Lux* Eart — Craabiaa: Stna«U:
UmeatoM, 10.000 tba. par aq La.
Trap. 13.000 Iba. par aq. aa.
by aratgbt of dart ot drtntaa arora oS apaea-
loar; troot 13 to 19 tnaduim, aad nbora 10 biftb.
Appendix B.
(Bulletin 136.)
EXPERIMENT TO DETERMINE THE NECESSARY DEPTH OF
STONE BALLAST.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
In the Proceedings of the Association, Vol. 7 (1906), page 102, the
writer called attention to the experiments of Railroad Director Schubert
of Germany to determine the depth of ballast necessary to distribute the
superimposed loads arising from the traffic to the best advantage over the
roadbed, and these experiments of Director Schubert have inspired the
Pennsylvania Railroad Company to supplement the data obtained at that
time by a series of experiments, or tests, on a larger scale and more in
accordance with the conditions to be met with in the United States.
Through the kindness of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company and Mr.
L. R. Zollinger, Engineer of Maintenance of Way, the Chairman of the
Committee appointed to conduct the tests, the writer is enabled to pre-
sent the information in full to the members of our Association.
These tests are the most extensive of the kind ever conducted in this
country, and will be found of great interest and value to railway engineers.
It is worthy of note how closely the depth of stone ballast, deter-
mined by these experiments as necessary for the best distribution of the
superimposed loads, 24 in., agrees with the depth for the same material as
given by Mr. Thos. H. Johnson's formula, which he derived from
Director Schubert's experiments, viz., 225-3 in.
W. C. Cushing,
Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way,
June 5, 191T. Pennsylvania Lines West of Pittsburg.
113
THE PENNSYLVANIA RAILROAD COMPANY.
REPORT OF THE GENERAL MANAGER'S COMMITTEE AP-
POINTED TO DETERMINE, BY EXPERIMENT, THE
NECESSARY DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
COMMITTEE.
L. R. Zollinger, Chairman;
E. D. Nelson,
Allen B. Cuthbert,
G. W. Snyder.
Philadelphia, March 5, 191 1.
Mr. S. C. Long,
General Manager.
Dear Sir: — Your Committee, appointed to determine, by experiments,
the proper depth of ballast under track necessary to equally distribute
the pressure, due to moving loads on the surface of the underlying mate-
rial, submits the following report :
During the years 1887 to 1890, inclusive, Railroad Director Schubert
of Germany conducted a series of experiments to demonstrate, "Which
ballast material affords the best distribution of force upon the subgrade
or roadbed." These experiments were conducted by filling boxes with
layers of different kinds of ballast and other material upon which a
section of a tie was laid. This tie was then tamped in the ordinary way
and subjected, by means of an eccentric, to a load which was alternately
imposed upon and lifted from the tie — thus imitating the process of
passing a loaded wheel over the track. After repeated tampings and
applications of the load the ends of the box were removed and the con-
ditions beneath the tie investigated. One of the conclusions drawn from
the experiment was, as the depth of stone ballast under the tie increased,
that the distribution of pressure on the underlying material became more
uniform.
The data obtained by Mr. Schubert were very instructive, yet your
Committee felt that more valuable data could be obtained from a series
of experiments if made in a manner approaching more nearly actual track
conditions.
Accordingly, at South Altoona Foundries, a piece of single track was
constructed, under which were placed three strong boxes open at the top
and having removable ends, each box sufficiently large to contain two
standard ties spaced the standard distance apart; the boxes were filled
with various kinds of ballast and roadbed material.
A heavily loaded truck was designed to run back and forth on the
track so that the effect of its load acting through the ties upon the ballast
and roadbed could be studied by the removal of the ends of the boxes,
when measurements and photographs could be taken. The general
arrangement of the plant is shown by the photographs, Figs. 1, 2, 3. The
track was 109 ft. in length, built of new P. R. R. standard 85-lb. rail,
114
depth of stoke ballast.
115
h
116
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
117
u.
118 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
spiked to standard white oak ties 7 in. by 9 in. by 8J/.2 ft. long, no tieplates
being used. The rail fastenings were standard spikes, and the rail joints
were so arranged as not to fall within the limits of the boxes. Eighty-
five-pound rail was selected in preference to 100-lb. rail in order that
the track might be sufficiently flexible to subject the ties to as much weight
as possible. The ends of the track were elevated to facilitate the stop-
ping and starting of the car, but the part over the boxes was level. The
boxes were built of yellow pine planking 4^2 in. thick by 8 in. wide and
had floors of the same material resting on sand several inches deep,
which, in turn, rested on an undisturbed shale formation. The site was
selected to provide a solid bottom to prevent any appreciable settlement
taking place in the boxes. The joints between the planks were not
tongued and grooved nor sufficiently tight to prevent the passage of water.
The boxes were strengthened by an arrangement of heavy posts and tie
rods, as the photographs show.
The boxes under the track were 12 ft. apart, center to center. They
were alike, and their inside dimensions were as follows : 4 ft. 8J4 in.
wide, 9 ft. long and 3 ft. 4 in. high, being set so that their tops were 2 in.
below the base of the rail.
The testing plant was roofed over to prevent rain from falling on
the boxes so that the amount of water applied to the boxes could be
accurately determined.
The car or truck having two axles (as shown by the photographs)
was designed to run back and forth upon the track at a speed of about
five miles per hour. The car had a wheel base of 9 ft. and was loaded
with pig iron, so that the gross weight amounted to 150,000 lbs., or 75,000
lbs. per axle. There was no spring intervention between the weight and
the axle, the journal boxes being fastened directly to the body of the car.
The car was kept moving by an electric motor geared to one axle,
the current being supplied through an overhead shoe bearing against a
conductor. At the elevated ends of the track a device automatically shut
off the current and reversed the motor ; the car needed very little power or
attention to keep it in motion. A counter on the car registered the num-
ber of trips made.
It being impracticable to run the car faster than about five miles per
hour, at which speed any effect upon the track, due to impact alone, would
be negligible, a weight of 75,000 lbs. per axle was chosen for the experi-
mental truck, so as to obtain about the same effect on the track as an
"H8b" locomotive running at the usual speed. The weight per axle for
this class of locomotive is 58,100 lbs. It was assumed that the effect on
the track of the experimental truck, running at about five miles per hour,
was about as great as that of an "H8b" locomotive running at the usual
rate of speed. Even if the assumption is open to question, the results
obtained with the use of different combinations of material supporting the
tie can be, at least, considered comparative.
In order to conduct the experiments as rapidly as possible, the car,
during the tests, was kept running night and day.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 119
The running back and forth of the loaded truck over the track
resulted in a settlement of the ballast and roadbed materials contained in
the boxes. After a settlement was noticed, aggregating about an inch,
the car was stopped and the track raised to its original elevation and sur-
faced by tamping the stone ballast with tamping picks according to the
usual service methods, the proper elevation and levels of the track being
determined by the use of a "Y" level. The truck was then started and the
above operation repeated from time to time, additional ballast being
added, when necessary, to supply the loss due to tamping and settlement.
In filling the boxes in each test, the loam, clay, engine cinder or
other material, except the stone ballast, was compacted by a rammer,
care being taken to ram each box and each kind of material as nearly alike
as possible.
The truck was kept running and the accumulated results of settle-
ment were noted until the decrease in the daily settlement was so marked
that it was considered time to close the test, when the boxes were opened
and at each end three vertical sections parallel with the rail were cut in
the ballast and roadbed materials ; the first was taken at the end of the
tie ; the second half-way between the tie and the end of the rail ; and the
third beneath the rail. Each section was photographed, also carefully
measured by the use of the "Y" level, to show the curve or line between
the ballast and the various materials with which each box was filled. In
addition, measurements were made in the same manner of vertical cross-
sections at right angles to the track ; first, under the middle of the north
tie; second, under the middle of the south tie; and third, midway between
the two ties. The data thus obtained were plotted for each box, in each
test, and appear in the appendix.
In addition to this, other data were collected showing the amount of
daily settlement of the rail over each box ; also, the amount the track was
raised each time it was tamped. The total number of trips of the car
was recorded, as well as all other data that would influence the results
obtained.
In order to simulate natural conditions as to rainfall, water in known
quantities was sprinkled over each box for the purpose of wetting the
ballast and roadbed materials, to induce settlement and possibly to pro-
duce pumping track, but the latter never developed. A careful record
was kept showing when the water was applied and of the amount in its
equivalent in inches of rainfall.
While the various tests were being conducted the ties adjacent to
and between the boxes were kept slightly loose, as far as tamping was
concerned, in order that the full weight of the car, in passing, would
come upon the two ties in each of the three boxes.
A series of five tests has been completed; the first one beginning on
September 2, 1908, and the last one ending on August 2, 1910.
The attached diagram, Fig. 4, shows the relative position of the
various kinds of material used in each box and for each of the five
tests.
120
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
&H
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
121
'—
122 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
TEST NO. I.
In filling the boxes for the first test it was determined to use 8 in.
of standard trap rock ballast beneath each tie, 8 in. of ballast being
standard for single track. Beneath the ballast in one box were 27 in.
of yellow clay from Neff s Cut on the Middle Division, which had proved
itself a very bad and unstable material for roadbed purposes. In the sec-
ond box, beneath the 8 in. of trap rock ballast, were placed 27 in. of
good sandy loam, and in the third box, beneath the 8 in. of trap rock
ballast, were placed 12 in. of engine cinder, and below that 15 in. of
yellow clay, the same as in the first box. The track was then surfaced
by the use of tamping picks, brought up to grade and the boxes filled with
standard trap rock ballast to the top of the tie. The car was started and
elevations taken from time to time to note the settlement and the track
was raised, by tamping, when required, as before described.
After the car had made about 4,000 round trips, water was applied by
sprinkling it equally over each box, first applying each day an amount
equivalent to one-half inch rainfall.
After a few days this amount was increased to 2 in. each day and
continued daily for quite a period, when the amount was increased to 4 in.
per day for about a week, then 8 in. per day applied for two days, in the
hope of producing pumping track, but this was not accomplished for the
reason that the water found its way out between the cracks of the plank-
ing about as fast as it was put in.
The car having made 81,600 round trips and the track over the boxes
being nearly stationary, that is, settling very slowly, it was decided to
close the test.
The track over box No. 1 had settled a total of 10& in. ; over box
No. 2, a total of 14^5 in., and over box No. 3, a total of io^i in. Water
equivalent to a rainfall of 98^4 m- had been sprinkled over each box dur-
ing the test. After the ends of the boxes were removed, sections and
photographs were taken, which are fully shown in the account of test No. 1
in the appendix.
An inspection of the boxes showed that in every case the depth of
the ballast beneath the bottom of the tie had been materially increased,
due to the compression of the roadbed material and the sinking of the
ballast into the material beneath it.
Further, the line of demarkation between the bottom of the ballast and
the roadbed material was not straight, the ballast having formed a saucer-
like depression in the roadbed material beneath each tie under each rail.
In box No. 3 the original 12 in. of engine cinder, between the bottom
of the ballast and the top of the clay, were very considerably compressed,
the bottom of the ballast immediately under the rail being forced about
half way through the cinder. On the other hand, the clay beneath the
cinder showed very little compression and the line of demarkation between
the bottom of the cinder and the clay was quite straight, while the line
between the bottom of the ballast and the top of the cinder was very much
depressed under each tie.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 123
The test showed conclusively that a depth of 8 in. of standard trap
rock ballast, when laid on the usual roadbed material, was not sufficient
to distribute the weight carried by the ties uniformly over the roadbed.
The results in the third box showed, however, that if 12 in. of per-
meable material, such as soft coal engine cinder, were used beneath the
8 in. of ballast, the distribution of the weight over the roadbed material
was much better, as is shown by the cross-sections and photographs.
The results of the first test led to the conclusion that a second test
should be conducted to determine how a depth of 12 in., 18 in. and 24 in.
of trap rock ballast under the ties would behave.
The experience gained from the first test suggested that better results
would be obtained by using sandy loam beneath the ballast rather than
yellow clay, because the first test showed that the sandy loam was more
compressible than the yellow clay and that the line dividing the ballast and
the loam was easier to study than the line dividing the ballast and the clay.
test no. 2.
The boxes were again filled, No. 1 box having 12 in. of trap rock
ballast beneath the tie, with 26 in. of loam underneath it ; box No. 2 hav-
ing 18 in. of ballast under the tie, with 19 in. of loam beneath it ; and box
No. 3 having 24 in. of ballast under the tie, with 14 in. of loam be-
neath it.
The car was started running on April 18, 1909, and practically the
same method was pursued as in test No. 1, already described. During
the test, water equivalent to nj4 in. of rainfall was applied. After the
car had made 49,932 round trips, it was stopped on June 15, 1909, because
the track over the boxes settled very slowly. The boxes were opened and
photographs and measurements made, as are shown in the report of test
No. 2, in the appendix.
An inspection of the boxes clearly showed that in box No. 1, having
12 in. of ballast beneath the tie, the lower surface of the ballast had been
compressed a considerable distance into the loam, and that the line dividing
the two was far from straight, there being a considerable depression in the
line beneath each tie, especially under the rail.
In box No. 2, where there were 18 in. of ballast originally under the
tie, the ballast had not been driven so far down into the loam and the
dividing line was much straighter.
In box No. 3, having 24 in. of standard trap rock ballast beneath the
tie, the amount of ballast settlement was still less and the line between it
and the loam quite straight.
In test No. 2, measurements were taken to show cross-sections at
right angles to the rail, one through the middle of each tie and one through
the center between the two ties.
An inspection of these sections will confirm the conclusion already
reached, as it will be noticed the deeper the ballast, the straighter the line
between it and the loam.
After a careful consideration of the data presented by the second test,
124 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
the conclusion seems inevitable that with standard stone ballast nothing
less than 24 in. beneath the tie will distribute the weight of the load uni-
formly over the sub-grade or roadbed. On the other hand, test No. 1 had
shown that a depth of 8 in. of stone and 12 in. of cinder gave apparently
fair results in distributing the weight upon the sub-grade.
TEST NO. 3.
It was therefore decided to fill No. 1 box with 24 in. of cinder beneath
the ties and 12 in. of loam below that ; No. 2 box and No. 3 box the same ;
to run a number of trips over each box and then remove from No. 1 box
8 in. of cinder beneath the tie tnd substitute for it 8 in. of standard trap
rock ballast; in No. 2 box to remove 12 in. of cinder and substitute for it
12 in. of ballast and allow No. 3 box to remain without any change in
the materials and then run a number of trips over each box. The object
in running on the engine cinder before putting in the stone ballast was to
compact it in a similar manner to actual service conditions when the
track is first ballasted with engine cinder and later raised out of the cinder
upon standard stone ballast.
No. 3 test was started on June 28, 1909, and when the car had made
45,500 round trips it was stopped and the cinder removed and stone ballast
put in boxes Nos. 1 and 2, as described above.
The car was then started and 40,100 round trips were made, water
being applied at a rate equivalent to about one-half inch of rainfall per
day until a total of 15^4 'n- had been sprinkled over each box.
In the previous tests it had been noted that the water found its way
through the stone ballast to the top of the clay or loam beneath it and
there collected and ran through the cracks between the planks.
In making the third test a new feature was introduced in one of the
boxes by placing therein, on top of the loam, beneath the 24 in. of cinder,
two pieces of iron pipe perforated with many holes. Each piece of pipe
sloped from the center of the box outward to the ends of the box, a slot
being made in each end of the box opposite the end of the pipe, so that it
could be watched.
When the test was started, on June 28, IQC.9, water equivalent to one-
half inch of rainfall was applied daily. This was in progress for nine
rlays, until water equivalent to a total rainfall of 4^4 in. had been sprinkled
on box No. 3 before any moisture appeared at the ends of the iron pipe,
and then only a very small quantity of slime began to ooze out at the ends.
At no time during the test did water run freely from the ends of these
pipes. This was considered a very significant fact, inasmuch as it showed
the ability of engine cinders to absorb and dissipate a large amount of
water falling upon it before the water was able to reach the sub-grade in
sufficient quantities to do much damage by saturating it. During the
experiments the pipes were carefully watched and kept clean from the
inside, so that any water reaching them could be observed.
On August 6, 1909, after 85,600 round trips had been made and water
equivalent to isYa ™. of rainfall had been sprinkled on each of the boxes,
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 125
they were opened, sections measured and photographs taken, as shown in
report of test No. 3, in the appendix.
A study of the sections and photographs as to the line separating the
engine cinder and the loam, showed that in box No. 3, where cinder was
continued through the entire test and no stone ballast substituted, the line
between the cinder and the loam was the straighiest or best, showing the
least amount of cupping, and that the line between the cinder and the loam
in boxes Nos. 1 and 2 left very little to choose between them, with a
difference, we think, slightly in favor of box No. 2. At the same time it
should be clearly noted that the sections taken at right angles to the track
show the ties bent more in box No. 3 than they did in either boxes No. I
or No. 2, due to the fact that engine cinder is more compressible than
broken trap rock.
A study of the lines of demarkation, between the trap rock ballast
and engine cinder in boxes Nos. 1 and 2, develops that there was less
deformation or cupping of the cinder beneath the ties where the depth of
stone ballast had originally been 12 in. in box No. 2 than where 8 in. in
box No. 1.
test no. 4.
It was determined upon the conclusion of test No. 3 that it would be
well to test two other materials available for use as sub-ballast, namely,
granulated slag and gravel, to see how they would compare with engine
cinder under similar conditions. Therefore test No. 4 was started, boxes
Nos. 1 and 2 having 24 in. of granulated slag under the ties and 12 in.
of loam beneath, that ; box No. 3 having 24 in. of a sandy New Jersey
gravel procured along the Bonhampton Branch of the New York Division.
After the boxes were filled practically the same method was pursued as in
test No. 3. It was noted that the compressibility of gravel was about equal
to that of engine cinder, while that of granulated slag was much greater.
After 45.561 round trips had been made by the car, boxes Nos. 1 and 2,
respectively, had 8 in. and 12 in. of trap rock ballast put in beneath the ties
and on top of the granulated slag, while box No. 3 had 12 in. of standard
trap rock ballast put in on top of the gravel. The car was again started
and run for 40.060 round trips.
After a total of 85.621 round trips had been made and water equivalent
to 14 in. of rainfall had been sprinkled over each box. the car was stopped
on December 3, 1909, the boxes opened, sections measured and photographs
taken, as before described.
This test developed the superiority of gravel when used for sub-
ballast, as compared with granulated slag, the granulated slag being much
more compressible and unstable than the gravel. There was little differ-
ence, however, in the line dividing the slag and the loam, and the gravel
and the lo?m. This would seem to indicate that neither material had
much advantage over the other in distributing the pressure upon the loam.
A further study of this line showed that in box No. 2, where, during the
latter half of the test, there were 12 in. of trap rock ballast beneath the tie,
126 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
the line between the slag and the loam was a trifle better than where there
were only 8 in. beneath the tie in box No. i.
An inspection of the line, dividing the trap rock ballast and slag in
boxes Nos. i and 2, and the ballast and the gravel in box No. 3, showed
that there was more cupping or deformation where the ballast was only
8 in. deep beneath the tie on top of the slag than where it was 12 in. deep
beneath the tie on top of the slag or gravel.
Further, the line in box No. 3, between the trap rock ballast and the
gravel, was still better than between the stone ballast and the slag in box
No. 2. This is also confirmed by an inspection of the sections taken at
right angles to the track.
test no. 5.
The data obtained from all of the tests up to this point indicate that
the greater the depth of trap rock ballast, beneath the tie, at least to a
depth of 24 in., the less deformation there is in the line dividing the trap
rock ballast and the material directly beneath it, the best results in this
respect having been shown with a depth of 24 in. of trap rock ballast
beneath the tie in box No. 3 of the second test. This brought forward
the proposition whether it would be possible, by a combination of trap rock
ballast and engine cinder, having a total depth of 24 in., to get as good a
distribution of weight or pressure on the loam as was obtained by a depth
of 24 in. of standard trap rock ballast alone. And, further, would such a
combination of standard trap rock ballast and engine cinder show too much
deformation of the line separating the stone and the engine cinder?
To determine this, if possible, test No. 5 was started with 24 in. of
engine cinder beneath the ties on top of 13 in. of loam in each box. The
car was started running on May 19, 1910, and 19,210 round trips made to
compact the engine cinder until the daily settlement of the cinder amounted
to very little.
On June 24, 1910, the car was stopped and 6 in. of standard trap rock
ballast were placed beneath the ties in box No. 1 ; 8 in. beneath the ties in
box No. 2, and 10 in. beneath the ties in box No. 3. The ballast was
tamped with tamping picks as in all the previous tests. The car was run
until a total of 112,304 round trips had been made and water equivalent
to a rainfall of i&A in. had been sprinkled over each box. On August 2,
1910, the car was stopped, the track having, for several days prior, shown
very little settlement. The boxes were opened, and the usual measure-
ments made and photographs taken.
The fifth test showed that there was less total settlement in box No. 3,
where the depth of the stone ballast was the greatest, namely, 10 in.
beneath the tie. Also, that there was less deformation or cupping between
the line of engine cinder and the loam, and between the line of ballast and
the engine cinder, but the line between the engine cinder and the loam in
box No. 3 was not as good as the line between the ballast and the loam
in box No. 3 of test No. 2, where there were 24 in. of trap rock ballast
beneath the tie and on top of the loam. This indicates that 24 in. of trap
rock ballast beneath the tie will distribute the pressure upon the sub-grade
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 127
more uniformly than a like depth of trap rock ballast and compressed
engine cinder combined, up to the point where the layer of engine cinder
has a thickness of not less than 14 in., and it is our opinion that any layer
of engine cinder, having a less depth than 14 in., would be sufficient to
produce the results desired by the use of engine cinder, viz., a layer of
material beneath the stone ballast which will absorb, lead off and dissipate
water falling upon the track before it can reach the roadbed proper in
sufficient quantities to be injurious.
A depth of 24 in. of standard trap rock ballast, beneath which is an
additional layer or mat, 24 in. thick, of good permeable material, will place
our sub-grade at a depth below the average frost line obtaining in the
latitude in which the greater part of our system is located, thereby elim-
inating the trouble due to the action of the frost upon the roadbed and
track.
Since the amount of wear and tear imposed on the experimental track
and sub-soil during the various tests was very small compared with that
to which our main line tracks are subjected under service conditions, your
Committee recommends the use of 24 in. of stone ballast underneath the
ties to meet satisfactorily the conditions that exist to-day and which will
probably become more severe as time goes on, and that in addition to the
24 in. of trap rock ballast beneath the ties, there should be provided a
layer of engine cinder, gravel or an equivalent, to act as an absorbent mat
to promptly and properly dispose of the water falling on the track in such
a manner as to prevent its softening the roadbed material. Where the
material forming the roadbed is of poor quality, the mat of engine cinder
or gravel will also prove advantageous to prevent its working up into the
ballast, thus shutting off drainage.
APPENDIX.
TEST NO. i.
September 2, 1908, to January 5, 1905.
MATERIAL IN BOXES.
Box No. 1 — 8 in. of trap rock ballast under the ties and 27 in. of bad
yellow clay below.
Box No. 2 — 8 in. of trap rock ballast under t:es and 27 in. of sandy
loam below.
Box No. 3 — 8 in. of trap rock ballast under ties ; 12 in. of engine cinder
under ballast and 15 in. of bad yellow clay below cinder.
The car was started on September 2, 1908, and was run at various
intervals, making approximately 500 round trips to October 2, when a
register was pl?ced on the car for recording the number of trips made.
The total settlement for the 81,600 round trips was as follows:
Box No. 1 — iofs in.
Box No. 2 — I4tW in.
Box No. 3 — io$4, in.
After 4,000 round trips, water in definite quantities v/as sprayed equally
on each box daily. A total amount of water equivalent to 98^ hi. of rain-
fall was used.
On January 5, 1909, freezing weather made it impracticable to obta'.n
any further results, and as the settlement curves showed a tendency to run
horizontally, the first test was closed.
128
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
129
130
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
131
132
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
133
■t ,
134
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
135
136
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
137
138
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
139
—+-$
140
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
I BM
aUV*SS
Ni'iS
t Q
Ji
~~l*
^
X
o
* s
d3
o -^
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
141
142
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
143
144
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
145
f)
o
*
5
■i
\ 5
< 8'
0 0
*
8
(0
ui
U__L
■'*•
146
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
147
m
B
— *,» p»*'»a
i<i p»»!»,3
■it p-»»:»^j.
■".3
.11 p»»ITJ
»»i p»«'<a
•< i»«ria
.» ♦••>»<a
** **«t«ai'
.« po«%a
.i »»»>ia
••* ^wa
'«^!-i P^"»«Q O09IQ
in
TO
5e i<j<
i ? s n i,i 1 1 *•* »,*
Lftr* i
0 :
Hr' 5
SpJI\ ■ u.'*.
11 1 ' •
1
1
r * i
tt5 ItltlSHSt} } I HHtiliH?
148 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
TEST NO. 2.
April 18 to June 15, 1009.
MATERIAL IN BOXES.
Box No. 1 — 12 in. trap rock ballast under ties and 26 in. of loam
below.
Box No. 2 — 18 in. trap rock ballast under ties and 19 in. of loam
below.
Box No. 3 — 24 in. trap rock ballast under ties and 14 in. of loam
below.
The car was started on the 18th of April, 1909, and continued to June
15, making 49,932 trips, running in the daytime only.
Water was put on each box during the test to an amount equivalent
to 11^4 m- rainfall.
The total settlement for box No. 1 was 8^ in. ; for box No. 2, g*/& in.,
and for box No. 3, g% in.
Upon opening the boxes on June 15 it was found that the loam in
each box had been compressed an average of 8 in. in box No. 1, 6 in. in
box No. 2, and 2>Va m- in box No. 3.
Photographs and elevations taken at the time of opening the boxes
show that the loam in box No. 1 received the greatest pressure directly
under the ties, thereby causing unequal settlement of the loam and the
formation of hollows under the ties. This effect was noticeable in box
No. 2, but to a less degree, and in box No. 3, with 24 in. of stone ballast,
the pressure was so evenly distributed over the loam that only a very slight
cupping effect was noticed.
By taking elevations through the boxes at right angles to the track
it was found that the greatest elevation existed along a line parallel to and
equidistant from the rails. From this line the surface of the loam inclined
towards the ends of the ties, with a cupping directly under the rails. Box
No. 3 showed the most uniform surface of sub-grade.
It was found that the water had not penetrated the loam to a greater
depth than three or four inches and at the time of investigation trickled
out over the sub-grade in small streams.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
149
150
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
151
152
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
153
154
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
165
156
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
157
in
OK
A3 o
$1
<0
■ * u *
i If
D *
r o
*>1
158
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
159
160
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
0
p*
J*.
<j
!
P
0
w»
id
0
0
E
0
1
L-
cJ
w+-
d
h
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
161
162
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
163
164
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
165
166
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
ft
It
w
ft
Qtr:
I 0
sl
^<
0 0
<0
F>
0 0*
o * ^
z S - y
15 > »
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
167
168
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
169
170
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
171
172
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
173
174
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
175
176
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
H
A
• w
.«-
" ,f6 -4*?©"
» : i . •-'_, ' ' ''.-.-■ ':■
• ,!l '
w^wjgB-iJfog?. y
.
xiwwniu-j.aC? -iv±oj_ ' j
•£ c
' 1
-
1
I
• ■■■':; . r
i' ';■■' ■ ""V <f)'"=-' ' ■
':!.'■■ .,• ;|t • ■■.'■:
. - our
. p=>c.?3
/■
' ■' - •■' !-r 8'7 », '
OS
•
. 2 n 3 a.
........ «j < to ,i
••• ■ • ' - P • K
1
L Of' »S
, - . • .. fr • • •■*• .
■■ ' '. ■ ■ ■ . trj " ' ' ■•**
i? ■":.'•'• i
• ■ Jfs..
.p?
s ; - .
■ " ' -?
, I ■
< -i
6
»~!tt
■ : • . '
' V '."' <0.
V*
KM?
' s
»*
1
SB * !
K>
•Hrf
B' ' -
5 1
85. >• i
pj
UJ m|
-*i
St 9
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 177
TEST NO. 3.
June 28 to August 6, 1909.
MATERIAL IN BOXES.
Each box had directly under ties 24 in. of engine cinder free from
clinkers, below which was 12 in. of rich loam. The loam was put
into the boxes in layers of 6 in. in depth, firmly compacted, but not
stamped hard. The cinder was filled in and forced under ties by using a
short piece of plank as a stamper. The car was started June 28 and con-
tinued running until July 20, when 45,500 trips had been completed. Water
was put on from the first in such quantity to correspond to one-half inch
rainfall per day. By July 20 there had been added 8^4 in- of water.
The total settlement for 45,500 trips was as follows : Box No. 1, V/2
in. ; box No. 2, S}i in., and box No. 3, 724 in.
For the first few days it was found necessary to raise and tamp the
track twice a day. The total settlement for the first five days was as fol-
lows : Box No. 1, 4 in. ; box No. 2, 4^ in., and box No. 3, 3^ in. The
thirteen days following, in which time more than five times as many trips
were completed, show settlement for box No. 1 of 4J/2 in.; box No. 2, of
zYa in., and box No. 3, of 454 in.
On July 20, after the completion of 45,500 trips, it was thought ad-
visable to begin the second part of test No. 3, to cut off 8 in. of cinder from
the top of box No. 1, and 12 in. from the top of box No. 2, and fill in with
clean trap rock ballast. The chief factor in determining the time at which
to introduce stone ballast was the form of the settlement curve just pre-
vious to July 20. This curve at first fell off rapidly, gradually becoming
less and less steep until the time of change, when it began to show signs
of running nearly horizontally.
Box No. 3 was left as at first filled, and, with the changes in boxes
Nos. 1 and 2 as indicated, the car began running on July 21 and continued
until August 6, having made 40,100 additional trips.
Statement of Conditions.
First part, Second part,
45,500 trips. 40,100 trips.
Each box contained
12 in. of loam and
24 in. of cinder.
8 in. cinder removed and
Box No. 1 J g in trap rock balJast added
> j 12 in. cinder removed and
Box No. 2 j> I2 ;n trap rQck ballast added
Box No. 3 Remained as in first part of test.
The settlement for the second part of the test from July 21 to August
6, was as follows: Box No. 1, 2^4 in. ', box No. 2, 2% in., and box No.
3, 2H in.
The total amount of water on each box during the entire run of
85,600 trips was 1534 in., extending over a period of 32 days, or an average
of about one-half inch per day.
178
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
179
'{.'• . .- , ;• " ,
180
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
181
182
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
183
184
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
185
186
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
-
PF-v"
' V-
l V
fO
or !
,- !
i
* 1
to
i
i i
h
IT.
..
< J
h
j • S J i^
X <
lii
flj s
£*
F
ojij ~ •''• '
• ?
0 o
o
ul .
<
O
10
<
o
-.1. 5 ": i
o z S <=
t -.' ? <
j
li
§1
0")
o
0)
E*
6
ui .
0)
1
n * |
1
i
1
.
s
in
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
187
188
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
189
190
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
191
15
L
-t-
192
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPfrt-OF STONE BALLAST.
193
191
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
195
ft
CDr,
z I
0 o
w
0)
<
c
01
ui I
F !
0
til,
a:
<
D
0
10
0
kJ 1
T j
*H
t
<
a:
1
F*Z
'2<0 £
196
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
197
198
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
199
3
•+- ~z
i 0
4-4-
200
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
201
202
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
203
204
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
205
01
OP
t. 0 _i
? o ~
m o
«?
ni
CO
flav/» o/* Ctn&*r
[J CD CO
0 0 0
epkjccd by J5/or?e QaUaat- A**** Zo
CB CD CDOI
?$?
206 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
TEST NO. 4.
October 19 to December 3, 1909.
First Part.
MATERIAL IN BOXES.
Box No. 1 — 24 in. of granulated furnace slag under ties and 12 in.
of sandy loam below.
Box No. 2 — Same as box No. 1.
Box No. 3 — 24 in. of sandy gravel from Bonhampton Branch, New
York Division, under ties, and 12 in. of sandy loam below.
Water was sprinkled on the boxes during the run to the amount
of one-half inch per day, a total of 8 in. being applied in the first part
and 6 in. in the second part of test, or a grand total of 14 in.
The loam was well forked and all lumps broken, spread evenly to
a depth of 6 in., then compacted with a tamper weighing about 20 lbs.
Each layer was treated in a similar manner and tamped hard enough
to support a man's weight without leaving undue depressions. The
degree of compactness was also tested by prodding with the unsharpened
end of a lead pencil.
The slag in boxes Nos. 1 and 2 was placed carefully upon the loam
sub-grade in layers of 6 in., each being tamped as above mentioned.
Box No. 3, in which gravel was placed upon the loam, was treated
in a similar manner.
On the morning of October 16 the car completed 12 trial trips, when
it was found necessary to shut down on account of the excessive settle-
ment of slag in boxes Nos. 1 and 2. The gravel held much better, but
showed considerable settlement.
Track was raised on October 18, and well tamped ; the necessary
slag and gravel «dded, and the car made ten trial trips, when it became
necessary to shut down again and retamp boxes on account of settle-
ment, when the car made fifty round trips before it again became neces-
sary to shut down since the slag showed little supporting power.
The roadbed external to the boxes was very solid, being made of
limestone screenings, which was subjected to constant wetting and load
and had become very hard.
In order to allow the track to settle uniformly, water was constantly
run upon the roadbed outside of the boxes from a three-fourths inch
hose, and the ties kept pumping. As the slag in boxes Nos. 1 and 2
compacted under the ties, more slag was worked under from time to
time. The gravel in box No. 3 held well — even better than the cinder
similarly used in Test No. 3. On this day, October 19, the car had
completed 735 round trips.
On October 21, the track was raised and the sprinkling of water on
the boxes commenced, by means of a three-fourths inch garden hose
attached to a graduated oil barrel.
The quantity of water put on each box per day was one-half inch,
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 207
one-fourth inch the first thing in the morning and another one-fourth
inch at noon.
On October 23 the slag was developing supporting power, and on
the 25th the track was secure enough to allow the continual running of
the car day and night.
With a few interruptions it ran until November 17, when 45,561
round trips had been completed, the same number of round trips as
were made in the first part of Test No. 3.
The settlement for the first part of the test up to November 17
was as follows : Box No. 1, 12J/2 in. ; box No. 2, 1^/2 in., and box No.
3. &/s in-
The following table gives some idea of the relative compressibility
of the slag and gravel :
Amount of Material.
Put in at Added to
Beginning. November 16. Per Cent. Added.
Box No. 1 — Slag.... 156 cu. ft. 105 cu. ft. 67.3
Box No. 2— Slag 147 cu. ft. 126 cu. ft. 85.7
Box No. 3 — Gravel.. 108 cu. ft. 39 cu. ft. 36.1
Note. — Measurements were made of material in small quantities and
when material was loose, before being placed and packed in boxes.
Second Part.
On November 17 some of the slag and part of the gravel was replaced
by trap rock ballast, as follows :
Statement of Conditions.
First part, Second part,
45,561 trips. 40,060 trips.
12 in. of loam '1 J 8 in. of slag removed and
24 in. of slag J Box No> * \ 8 in. of trap rock ballast added.
( 12 in. of slag removed and
Same as Box No. 1 Box. No. 2 | J2 jn of trap rQck baUast added
24 in. of loam 1 ( 12 in. of gravel removed and
24 in. of gravel J Box No" 3 \ 12 in. of trap rock ballast added.
The stone was carefully added to the boxes so that the surface of
the sub-ballast should not be disturbed. The slag and gravel under
the ties broke off in pieces as large as one's head, and did not crumble
on being dropped upon the ground. Picks were used to loosen both
slag and gravel for removal by shovels.
Nothing unusual was remarked during the second part of Test No.
4, which was finished on December 3, after a total of 85,621 round trips
had been made for the entire test. The curve shows greater settlement
than for Test No. 3, probably due to greater compressibility of sub-
ballast, except in the gravel.
208
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
209
210
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
211
212
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
213
214
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
215
216
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
217
218
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
1
Am
:
\ ..'{-
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
219
220
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
221
222
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
223
224
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
H
-D
X
0
(D
I
0
D
o
&:
z
o
0
-J
<n
2
0
F
u
m
<0
ir>s
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
225
226
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
227
228
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
229
230
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
231
232
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
233
234
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
n
2
It
Li o
xr n
2w
Uj Ul
1
6
F
p
id
<
j
0
6
uJ
..
i
-;
<
mi
•i
r
J 1
; o
j
?i 1
V
**
I
Q i
i ■
0:
>|
D;
!
>j
.6
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
235
WfTff
ul
U >»* £ 8
Hi W h K
2 to 36
«i a io
r n
K
fl
236 DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
TEST NO. 5.
May 19 to August 2, 1910.
First Part.
MATERIAL IN BOXES.
Each box contained exactly 24 in. of engine cinder below bottom
of ties, with about 13 in. of loam below the cinder. The loam had been
well forked, all lumps broken and all small stone eliminated. It was
spread evenly in 4-in. layers, each layer being compacted by tamping
with a tamper weighing about 20 lbs. The degree of compactness was
tested by prodding with the unsharpened end of a lead pencil. When
the last layer of loam was properly tamped, the high places were cut
off to make the surface level to the desired elevation.
The cinder was spread carefully upon the loam sub-grade in 4-in.
layers, each layer being thoroughly tamped as above. The cross-ties
were well rammed with cinder, so that the bottom of each tie was at
the proper elevation with 24 in. of cinder under it.
The car was started on May 19, and ran at intervals until June
24, when 19,210 round trips had been completed. Prior to June 1, water
was sprinkled on the boxes in such quantity as to correspond to a total
of one-inch rainfall, and thereafter on each day that the car ran, one-
half inch of water was thus applied, until on June 24 there had been a
total of 4V2 in. of water applied to each box.
The settlement for the first part of the test was as follows : Box
No. 1, 2^4 >n- ; box No. 2, 2]/% in., and box No. 3, 2V2 in.
Second Part.
On June 24, it was thought advisable to begin the second part of
Test No. 5, by substituting certain depth of clean trap rock ballast
instead of engine cinder. As in previous tests, the chief factor in deter-
mining the time for introducing stone ballast was the form of the
settlement curves just previous to June 24, when the settlement was
becoming less daily, as compared with the first few days of the test.
The decrease in settlement just prior to June 24, indicated that the
materials in the boxes had become well compacted, and in all probability
would not show much more settlement.
The statement of conditions below shows the changes in the ma-
terials in the boxes when the car was again started on June 24, con-
tinuing until August 2, making 93,094 additional round trips, or a total
of 112,304 round trips.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST. 237
Statement of Conditions.
First part, Second part,
19,210 trips. 93,094 trips.
Each box contained
about 13 in. of loam <
and 24 in. of cinder.
/ 6 in. cinder removed and
^ 6 in. trap rock ballast added.
/ 8 in. cinder removed and
I 8 in. trap rock ballast added.
10 in. cinder removed and
' 3 1 10 in. trap rock ballast added.
The settlement for the second part of the test, June 24 to August
2, was as follows: Box No. 1, ^A in- J box No. 2, 5 -is- in., and box No.
3, AV2 in.
The total amount of water sprinkled on each box during the entire
run of 112,304 round trips was equivalent to i%V2 in. of rainfall, extend-
ing over a period of 46 running days, or an average of almost one-half
inch per running day, after June 1.
For several days prior to August 2, the curves showed little ma-
terial settlement, and having made even more trips than was made in
Test No. 3, namely, 85,600, the car was stopped and the boxes opened
on that date.
238
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
239
240
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
241
242
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
243
244
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
245
246
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
x ±
°%
a «
lO
** u *~
2«g
QOTH
03 $ I
0(5
o
(0*0
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
247
248
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
*"K}£ar *^^'-^^^:~ ".; ,,
>'\
.m^mjw:
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
249
250
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
251
252
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
253
a:
■ ■■
K
0
03
X
O
tx.
I
K
O
z
o
Z
o
h
w
UJ
i
~i
M
t it
; i
: 1
254
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
10
O
ffi
x
o
3
O
I
h
O
Z
o
o
-J
(A
z
o
O
u
<0»
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
255
c <
CD -
lO
'- X 2
X
O st
CD % '■
1.5
256
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
257
258
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
259
260
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
261
262
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
O
.a
I
u
3
0
K
I
h
z
0
0
■J
0
V
o
u
^H
fL^L
SIS
|g§ra~^^^
K8H
CO.
0
z
X
O
CD
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
263
X
0
01
X
13
3
0
K
I.
h
Z
;2
0
0
z
r-.
h
O
UJ
-n
< !
ac j
K
ft
hip
o
x j
I O
CD
UJ
D
Z
u
7 \
A
kU
IIS
264
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
DEPTH OF STONE BALLAST.
265
2 ■ B a
o o b o o
3. (i
ij
-■.
(0 « H *.C
M
«? .-
.
•)/ F*-"T.
ff?
uo
H
:
^
SI
I?
I
r 5 i
i?
ri
^
•1
: i
*
0 V
,
~
. 9
M>
•-£*
b u
1 at-n,*
■i
i
* j .
1 V V
"3
?
h
Z
1
*
M
t
iij
9-
oS"^
. Si
ai ■
• 7v4
I , 5 V
V
i
3
X
1
5 T -; '
' g 2
|J J~"B
/.
8 8
e S 8 a 8 13
0 0 o <j 0 0
i 8 8
■a 8 a
* p »
'«
1
0 0
6 0 0
0 o s
o-oo
0
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
In connection with their work for 1910, Committee I — Roadway, had
a sub-committee at work on the question of "Unit Pressure on Road-
bed," and Committee II — Ballast, one on the correlated question of
"Necessary Depth of Ballast," and at a joint meeting of these sub-
committees a paper on "Gravel as Ballast," by C. Brauning, which Mr.
W. M. Dawley had translated from "Zeitschrift fur Bauwesen," Vol.
LIV, Berlin, 1904, was discussed, and accepted as valuable information
for the members of the Association.
It was considered that the paper should be published in a Bulletin
of the Association as a progress report of the work of the committees,
rather than hold it for a final report, and accordingly it is presented
herewith.
266
Appendix C.
(Bulletin 136.)
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
By C Brauning.
Translated from "Zeitschrift fur Bauwesen," Vol. LIV, Berlin, 1904, under
direction of Committee I — Roadway, and Committee II— Ballast.
Owing to its high cost, hard stone, crushed, can only be afforded
for ballast in roadbeds which are heavily taxed with traffic, while
stretches taxed to a less extent must resort, at least for some time to
come, to material near at hand, mostly river or mountain gravel. Still,
increasing speed and weight of rolling stock on these less severely taxed
stretches are making heavier demands upon the ballast, principally in the
direction of greater resistance to change of position of the rails. The
greater carrying capacity of crushed stone is principally due to the many
sharp edges of the individual pieces. This gives it the high resistance
when used as ballast, which is not greatly reduced under shock. On the
other hand, the gravel pieces give way easily under pressure and lose
still further in resistance when subjected to shock. These different char-
acteristics of crushed stone and gravel affect the roadbed, first, in that
they determine the cross-sectional shape of the ballast; secondly, the
support to be given the track, and, thirdly, the shape and spacing of the
cross-ties. While there is ample data at hand regarding the properties
of crushed stone as ballast, available through Schubert's investigations,
the object of this article is to determine to what extent gravel makes
possible a uniform and permanent roadbed.
The observations, therefore, direct themselves first to the conditions
to be met. It was desirable to follow out the changes in different indi-
vidual roadbed stretches and note their greater or lesser durability in
comparison with the peculiar characteristics of the ballast of each stretch.
Previous observations in this direction were not complete (Zeitschrift fur
Bauwesen, 1896, page 546). Hence, they were extended, new trial stretches
under more varying conditions selected, and the measurements themselves
perfected, namely, by more securely anchoring the bench marks outside of
the roadbed. The ballast of the observed stretches consisted of a mix-
ture of coarse and fine gravel with a sand content of 25 to 33 per cent.,
consisting of grains under 1 mm. greatest diameter. The cross-ties were
spaced 750 to 840 mm. The traffic over the roadbed yearly amounted
to about 1.2 million tons. Among the daily trains which covered these
stretches were several which had a velocity of 75 kilometers per hour and
more. The observations were continued two years, the elevation of the
rails was taken every two months, and during affecting weather condi-
tions more often. It was determined that the most important observa-
tions came just previous to the occurrence of, during the time of the
heaviest, and just after the complete disappearance of frost The rail
elevations at the above mentioned times are shown in Figs. 1 to 4, Plate I.
267
268 GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
The horizontal base line indicates the first observed condition during the
autumn, the lines II, III and IV the altered elevations during the severest
time of winter, of spring, and of the following fall, respectively. The
elevations are to the scale 1=1.166, while the lengths are greatly con-
tracted. .3
Under each group of observations is a longitudinal section through
the track which illustrates the composition of the ballast and sub-soil
and the depth of the frost line. The changes observed for the first year
and for the second were so similar that the observations for one year
only are given.
It is to be noted from the illustrations that close relations exist
between the different elevations of the rails and the nature of the soil
upon which the roadbed rests. Every clay and clay-bearing soil drove
the track upward, and as other observations indicated, also towards the
sides. The more uniform such soil is, and the more uniformly it is dis-
tributed, the more uniform the tendency to lift the track seems to be,
and to lower it again after the disappearance of frost. Fig. 2, Plate I,
in its first half, and illustration 1 in its second half give a clear repre-
sentation of this effect. Irregular mixtures of sand and clay, as occur
in earthen embankments such as are formed by dumping led to very
unfavorable action in spots, owing to the fact that the earth, due to the
action of the frost, was unevenly forced upward and outward and did
not by far regain its original position after frost had disappeared (Fig.
4, Plate I). Clean and evenly fine grained sand proved to be quite con-
stant under the action of frost, and a similar absence of the expansive
force of frost was noted in the gravel ballast itself, though it was not
entirely free from earthy constituents.
During the seasons of no frost such apparent influences of the soil
underneath the ballast were not noted. The effect of the deposits, which
came principally into consideration here, changed itself according to the
water-absorbing capacity of the clay-bearing sub-soil, but the contour of
the sub-grade varied within such narrow limits that it was impossible to
observe individual changes. In the summer time the sinking of the rails
was generally very small and hardly measureable. Several times notice
was taken of the rising of the rails up to 2 mm. — however, only at the
hottest time of the year.
In order to illustrate more clearly the changes taking place in the
rail surfaces in relation to the seasons and the condition of the sub-soils,
cross-sectional views illustrating the sinking and rising of distinct groups
of the stretches under observation in continuous line for two years are
given in Figs, ia to 4b, Plate I.
Of all the changing lines, those of Figs. 2 and 2b, Plate I, between
the points 13 to 18, are of particular importance. The rail and cross-ties
here rest on a strong gravel bed, under which clean sharp sand extends
to a level lower than the frost line. The ties are spaced 750 mm. and
the rails are fastened to them with screw-spikes. The extraordinary per-
manence and uniform position of this piece of track indicates that gravel
GRAVEL AS BALLAST. 269
with a large quantity of sand, under proper condition of the sub-soil and
construction of the roadbed, will act as very serviceable ballast
A comparison of wooden cross-tie construction was also made with
longitudinal stringer construction made up of Haarmann's stringer rails,
which, owing to their unfavorable position in the roadbed, are more
sensitive to the changes in the ballast and sub-soil than the wooden
cross-ties. The results are shown in Figs. 5 to 7, Plate 2. Rail section,
as pictured in Fig. 5, stood up comparatively well. The gravel ballast
in this case was mixed with broken stone which had formerly been
tamped underneath the previously existing longitudinal stringer of the
old roadbed. The sub-soil is clean fine grained sand, which in several
spots was permeated with clay, whose effect on the roadbed became dis-
tinctly noticeable. The section of track illustrated in Fig. 6 seems to be
considerably more mobile ; in spite of the fact that the roadbed rested on
strong broken stone_ bed of 300 mm. thickness, the influences of the un-
even clay-bearing sub-soil made themselves felt the same as with gravel
ballast. The most distinct and irregular movements occurred with the
track section shown in the second half of Fig. 7, Plate 2, which rested
on an ordinary gravel bed, resting in turn on a heterogeneous mixture
of clay and sand. The rails were so considerably bent, due to the
heaving through frost, that they had to be replaced. (Compare, also,
Fig. 7a, Plate 2.)
The harmful influence of frost on the roadbed is increased, due to
the fact that the damage resulting therefrom occurs very suddenly, and
as long as the frost continues can be remedied only with great difficulty
and incompleteness. In connection with this, it is not sufficient to take
into consideration only the apparent defects which become noticeable
when riding, but also the small, quickly changing, bulging effects which
the hard-frozen roadbed is obliged to suffer, due to the minor expansions
in the sub-soil, and which defects do not become noticeable when riding
over these stretches. For minor localized heavings cause very consider-
able stresses in the rails, which stresses increase with stiffness of the rail
and the rigidity with which it is frozen in the roadbed. High rails which
are securely fastened to the cross-ties, which are comparatively closely
spaced, are more endangered than weaker rails which rest loosely on the
roadbed. The recent construction of heavy rails and narrow tie spacing
are well adapted to distribute the load over a greater portion of the
ballast, and thereby decrease the demands made on the ballast; but, on the
other hand, make increased demands for more regular construction and
the prevention of all forceful local disturbances of the form of the road-
bed. The nature of the ballast, whether crushed stone or gravel, does not
assist in remedying the influences of the soil upon which the ballast rests.
In order, therefore, that the sub-soil have no influence on the roadbed,
it is necessary that it consist of a material which is constant under the
action of frost, and extends below the frost line. In North Germany
frost extending to a depth of 70 cm. in loose sand and gravel, or a depth
of approximately 55 cm. underneath the wooden ties, should be taken into
270 GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
consideration. Any bed of clean sand will serve as a frostproof sub-soil,
even when the sand is of fine grains.
When the transforming influences of the sub-soil and the weather
are removed, the characteristics of the ballast itself come into play. The
investigations were continued along the line of determining the effects
of these different properties. In purely scientific treatment of the roadbed
it is commonly taken that the ballast is uniformly elastic, and this feature
only is taken into consideration. As a matter of fact, the different por-
tions of the ballast which act as individual supports are not uniformly
elastic. Each load occurring in the operation over the roadbed causes,
with the temporary depression, also a permanent change, however slight.
This permanent set has a definite relation to the unit pressure imposed.
If, therefore, the loads are unequal which are transmitted to the ballast
through the ties, then the set underneath the more heavily loaded ties is
more serious than in the case of the others. Consequently, owing to
this tendency, the original conditions of loading of the ballast are grad-
ually changed, principally in that the pressures under the more heavily
loaded ties gradually diminish and the pressures under the lightly loaded
ties gradually increase, until the condition of loading becomes quite uni-
form. In order to observe these phenomena, a section of roadbed was
purposely unevenly tamped so that a portion of the ties rested solidly on
the ballast, while the other portion was without any support. By repeated
observations it was found that the spaces between the ballast and the
ties gradually diminished, and after six months disappeared entirely.
This is shown in Fig. 8, Plate 2, in which the spaces measured at dif-
ferent times between the tie and ballast (scale 1=1.166) are indicated
by cross-hatching. Hence, ballast supporting cross-ties not uniformly
loaded tends to change itself into a uniformly loaded mass. Of course,
this equalization of the loading does not occur through a uniform sinking
of the rail and ties, but is due rather to more or less prominent local
depressing, and thus amounts to a deterioration of the condition of the
roadbed.
An equal change is experienced by the ballast underneath each tie.
And here, too, the tendency is for the tie to take such a form that the
unit pressures of it in the ballast are equal in all places. Hence, the tie
itself becomes a beam with uniform loading, and the surface of the
ballast underneath the tie assumes, therefore, the shape of the elastic
curve of the tie under this particular condition of loading. This shape
of the surface is present whether the tie is loaded or not (Fig. 1). But
since the passing loads are not uniform, and hence the unit loads on the
ballast vary, the shape of the surface of the ballast becomes the average
of the elastic curves of the tie due to the different loadings. In making
this statement it is assumed that the resistance of the ballast is equal at
all places. If this is not the case, then those placed where the resistance
is not so great as in others will give way until all places are loaded in
accordance with their resistance. This appears regularly as the case
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
271
underneath the ends of the cross-ties, of which mention will be made
later on.
The continual changing of the form of the roadbed is a result partly
of the compression of the ballast, and also, perhaps to a larger extent.
z~-><--^
>(. —
TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTrrrriTT^
Fig. I.
the result of a sidewise spreading. The loading of the bed under and next
to the ties is so continually at variance that an equalization of the pres-
sure cannot take place and the lightly loaded part between the ties is
continually being displaced by the heavily loaded part underneath the ties.
The possible shapes of these sidewise spreadings are treated theoretically
in Dr. H. Zimmermann's "Berechnung des Eisenbahnoberbaues," page 108.
Thus it became desirable, by means of experiments, to get an idea of the
actions as they really took place. For this purpose, therefore, dry sand
of different colored layers was poured behind a pane of glass, and after
a picture of the sand was transmitted to the glass, it was loaded down
with ties 30x60 mm., so that distinct displacements occurred in the sand
bed. By comparison with the original position of the different layers, the
paths of the sand grains under increasing loads could clearly be traced.
The occurrences which took place in this experiment, and which were
repeated several times, were as follows : After the sandbed was entirely
compressed by the imposed load, a sidewise displacement of the sand
began, first in lines which were not distinct, then becoming more distinct,
until eventually very pronounced lines of separation appeared. Several
of these lines are shown in Fig. 2. Although they diverge considerably in
272
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
their longitudinal relation to one another, due to the variation of the
internal friction, nevertheless the theoretical basic shape of the logarith-
mic spiral is recognizable in their curvature. The shape of the lines of
separation is not changed when the ballast is piled up higher than the
ties ; in fact, they continue right on up to the surface.
The body of sand, which separates itself, tends to retain its original
shape, and also seeks to regain the original lines of separation when the
tie is forced deeper into the sand, since when this is the case resultant
resistances of the sand particles sliding over one another are at a min
imum (Fig. 3).
_ Onq 1 n ol surface
of ballast
Underneath the tie the separation of the sand layers did not appear
as uniformly and distinctly as above. At the start of the experiment, a
slender wedge would usually form, with its apex pointing downward.
This wedge would become more blunt as the tie sank deeper into the
sand, and the location of the apex remained comparatively firmly fixed,
so that the lines of separation, extending from the sides, retained their
original position, as is pictured in Fig. 4. On the other hand, however,
Fig.4. Fig. 5.
and more particularly where the sandbeds were deep and the resistances
to the sidewise displacements were greater, there appeared another wedge,
firmly fixed, with its apex pointing upward, from whose sides the sand
particles would glide (Fig. 5). This tendency of the particles to glide
from the sides of the upturned wedge continues so long as the angle "A"
(Fig. s) stays larger than the angle of repose of the material under experi-
ment, for as long as this condition continues the particles of material
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
273
which are being forced seek the path of least resistance and adopt the
next and steepest path to the surface.
Hence, it is not a case of dealing with a distinct shape of separation,
but rather with the nature of the external resistances to these shapes,
which oppose internally the motion of the material. The free develop-
ment of the bodies of separation is hindered in the roadbed by the close
spacing of the cross-ties. The integral parts of the bedding which move
grow less, but the internal resistance becomes greater. When the sandbed
is gradually narrowed, a point is reached where the escape of the particles
no longer is possible, which is due to the equalization of the internal
surface-rubbing resistances and the imposed load. At this point these
internal resistances vary in amounts equal to the variations of the imposed
load. The line of separation in the case of the limited bed approaches
the semi-circle, as observed several times and as its limiting shape as-
sumes the form as shown in Fig. 6. Such a shape, as determined mathe-
matically with the coefficient of friction of sand, is then only possible
when the unit pressures grow from the edges towards the center of the
tie. As a matter of fact, it is readily observable that the center of the
tie will seat more firmly than its edges when driven into narrowly con-
fined sandbeds.
Fig. 6.
Now, if the bed upon which the tie is imposed is confined between
two rigid walls, the resistance of the bed with these walls strongly opposes
the tendency of the bed material to become displaced upwards. But if the
confinement of the bed arises from the neighboring ties, simultaneously
loaded, as is the case in track, moving particles which meet between the
ties oppose one another, and, not finding any confining resistances, drive
themselves upward. Fig. 7 illustrates an experiment with two equally
loaded ties on a confined bed. The distances between the ties chosen were
such that the amounts of material between the ties and between the walls
and the ties were equal, and thus also making the resistance in the two
directions equal. This was approximately the case when a/2 :c= 1:1.3.
(Fig. 7.) The distance between ties when the bed material ceased to
rise up between them appeared to be when a=i.sb. Even with a pressure
274
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
as great as 40 kilograms per square centimeter no rising of the bed
material was noted when the ties were brought closer together than
a=i.5b.
a
Fiq.7.
After these observations of the nature of the movements taking
place in a gravel bed, it became desirable to learn more about the re-
sistances which the gravel opposes to these movements. The heavy
pressures required in these experiments do not occur in the ordinary
roadbed, so it became necessary to depend upon special arrangements
on a smaller scale. The results herefrom cannot be applied directly to
ordinary roadbed practices, since enlarged conditions, such as occur in
practice, would alter the shapes of the material under load; and, further,
since the varying nature of ballast material itself and peculiarities of the
loading in actual roadbed practice cannot be taken into consideration
sufficiently. Hence the object of these particular experiments was to
determine certain relations of the different properties of the ballast mate-
rial which it is assumed would obtain in actual practice. More particu-
larly speaking, it was the object of these investigations to determine
the influence of tie-spacing, the width of ties, the height to which mate-
rial was packed between the ties, and of the nature of the ballast itself.
For the purpose of these experiments iron cases with adjustable walls
were used. They were of such a depth that the movements of the mate-
rials in the bed would not extend to the bottom. A press consisting of a
screw and a heavy spiral spring, which transmitted the pressure imposed
upon the spring to an indicating pointer, was used to load the tie (Fig. 8).
The scale of the indicating device was determined by means of actual
weights. The press was arranged for a pressure as high as 300 kilograms,
but by means of a lever, which could be coupled in, it was possible to
raise the pressures up to 500 kilograms. The ties which were used had a
width ranging from 10 cm. to 80 mm. The bed consists of dry pit gravel,
made up of rounded grains, up to 5 mm. in diameter. No larger particles
were used, since it was desirable to prevent hollow formations in the
gravel bed, owing to the diminished scale which was being used.
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
275
The first experiments were made on single ties ranging in width
from 20 to 60 mm., resting on a bed of fine grained sand, no particles of
which exceeded 1 mm. in diameter. The pressure was increased until
clearly defined movements were discernible in the bed. As a rule, a sud-
den collapsing or release occurred when the pressure reached a certain
point temporarily relieving the pressure imposed. The resistance of the bed
depends upon its width "a" (Fig. 9), the width of the tie "b," and the height
to which the bed material rises along the side of the tie '"h." The influ-
ence of the width of the bed "a" bears a particular relation to the width
of the tie "b." Hence, this influence may be designated by the relation
a/b, through which may be determined the proper tie spacing. The results
of the experiments are demonstrated in Figs. 9a to 9c. In Fig. 9b the
distances between ties are plotted along the abscissa, while the carrying
capacities of the bed in kg. per sq. cm. are plotted along the correspond-
ing ordinates, giving curves for different heights of "h" ranging from o
to 30 mm. When h was o and the relation between a/b was greater
than 7, the carrying capacity remained practically constant. As the dis-
tance between ties decreased the carrying capacity increased, first slowly
and then more rapidly, so that when a/b=2 it was twice as great as
when a/b=3.
The carrying capacity was further increased as gravel was piled up
between the ties. The influence of the spacing was partially compen-
sated by the increasing height of the material between them to the extent
that the carrying capacity was equal in ties spaced narrowly without mate-
276
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
o
iZ
__ \ -____
\___~
--A---
'- AV-
UiL
:~-4V-
*— m
L-- : L
0)
<7>
£__ <2 «0 _ . . . Q
"s».-
1 S__ _
f-VU
2- \ \ \ \
f-4-^t
\tt
\ it
ut
ilt
ii
jjj
00
o
t-
o
o
i0
o
E
E
•i
'N
$
?
u
3
«»
a
9
CO
o
o
ii
j
\
\
(VJ
o
r$
%
c>-
\
,
- fc
o
9
<5
\
\
c
>
i
■»
o
m
o
ir
1
O
o
en
iZ
*-~c->
_t-
E#»j i
OP
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
277
rial between them to ties spaced widely with material packed between
them. The effect of the height to which material is packed between the
ties is particularly demonstrated in Fig. p-c. The several lines are for tie
separations ranging for a/b from 2.6 to 20, while the height to which
material was piled between ties, ranging from o to 80 mm., are the ab-
scissae, and the carrying capacities are the ordinates.
Positive determinations of the action of the widths of the ties could
not be made from the above results. So in order to get at the actual
conditions prevailing in a roadbed, where ties are equally and simul-
taneously loaded, two ties were rigidly bonded together and placed into
an iron box, so that each came very close to the sides of the box (Fig. n).
In order to reduce the friction of the bed material on the walls of the
box, they were lined with glass. Since the ties fitted into the box so that
three sides of each tie were contiguous to the sides of the box, the only
possible escape for the bed material was between the two ties. The
width of the ties in reality, therefore, corresponds to Yz the width of a tie
in actual practice, and, consequently, is indicated by b/2. At this time it
was observed that a wedge with its apex pointing upward appeared
underneath each tie when the material between the ties had reached a
certain height and the material of the bed tended to glide off the sides of
this wedge, exercising a heavy pressure sidewise on the tie. The size of
the gravel particles ranged from 1 to 2 mm., the width of the ties b/2=io
to 50 mm., the height to which the material was piled between the ties
extended up to 130 mm.
o o o 00 °
Glass
>
Fig. II.
w
If,
^^^^^
The results illustrated in Fig. 10-a to 10-d are similar to the ones
reached in previous experiments; however, the effect of tie spacing was
felt at lower values of a/b, approximately when same equaled 4 (Fig.
10-c). As this ratio decreased its influence was still greater than in the
previous case, so that the carrying capacity with a ratio of a/b=2 was
four times as great as when a/b=3. The limit was reached for a sidewise
displacement of the bed material when a/b=i.5 and h=io mm. As the
height h increased, the carrying capacity of the bed, it seems, grew at an
increasing rate (Fig. 10-d). These relations were the more apparent and
more effective as the distance between ties decreased. Here, also, a dis-
tinct influence of the width of the ties was noticeable on the carrying
278 GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
capacity of the bed, as is demonstrated in Fig. io-b for different values of
h, height of material between ties. As the widths of ties increased the
unit pressure increased according to the laws of a straight line, main-
taining a relation quite constant. An increase in carrying capacity is also
proven for this case in Dr. H. Zimmermann's "Berechnung des OberbaueS,"
page 115.
The experiments thus far did not attempt to deal with any different
loading except those free from shock. Hence, the effect of a load in
connection with shocks still remained to be investigated. When ballast is
subjected to impact the friction of the gravel particles rubbing against
one another is temporarily diminished. Gravel ballast, therefore, when
subjected to this condition, behaves as a bed which is loaded fixedly and
whose angle at repose is more flat. In order to approach conditions as
(hey occur in an actual roadbed, the ballast was subjected, by means of
a loaded lever, to a uniform pressure of 1.5 kg. per sq. cm. The case con-
taining the bed was subjected to vibration or impact through a weight
which dropped each time from the same height. The number of impacts
in the time that Ihe tie sank 10 mm. into the bed was taken as the meas-
ure of resistance of the material. As a rule, the tie started in to sink
faster at the start of the experiments, but its rate of entering soon be-
came uniform. The width of the ties was from 39 to 87 mm., and the
height to which the bed material was piled extended in some instances
to 300 mm. The illustration indicated in Figs. 12a and 12b again reveal a
distinct relation with previous results. The effect of the spacing again
became noticeable when a/b=io, and became more apparent when a/b=4
and less (Fig. 12c). The height to which the material was piled along
the side of the tie also affected the resistance in a similar way (Fig. i2f).
The meaning of the width of the ties was also made very apparent, as is
demonstrated in Figs. 12-b to 12-d for different tie spacing. The re-
sistance of the ballast increased rather a trifle faster than would be
indicated by the law of a straight line, under equal pressure, as the dis-
tance between ties decreased. The closer the ties were spaced, and the
higher the material was piled between the ties, the more rapid this
increase became.
The ballast, however, behaved differently under the ends of the ties
than elsewhere. Similarly, as demonstrated above, a body of material
tends to separate itself underneath the end of the tie. But since there
is no other tie to oppose this displacement, the ballast terminating on a
slope, the opposition of this sideward tendency of the gravel underneath
the end of the tie is comparatively small. Hence, the carrying capacity
of the tie at its ends is less than at its center, but it increases from the
ends toward the center of the tie until it reaches those points from each
end where the resistances sidewise and outward towards the ends are
equal. Between these points the carrying capacity is uniform. Since the
support given the tie bears a direct relation to its carrying capacity, the
pressure underneath the tie on the ballast diminishes outward from the
two points described above. The closer the ties are spaced, the greater
e
J*^**~ VJ
V
If
r&
*-3
■ W
f
T3
0)
s_
O
o-S
2! E
tO o
o 5
E _*
c
c*-. —
o «o
^°
JO
£
o
2
o
o
CM
°<
^N
sX
^>
^
<T>
II
^\
\
cO
H
op
V
\
0)
m CD
iZ
N
II
0\fi
S<\|
en
280
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
the carrying capacity of the roadbed becomes, and the nearer to the ends
the ties are, the points from which the pressure on the ballast decreases.
By an experiment with a tie 50 mm. wide, with material piled to a
width of 60 mm. from the end of the tie outward, it was determined,
when the space relation was a/b=3, that the carrying capacity under-
neath the extreme end of the tie was 0.4 kg. per sq. cm., increasing uni-
formly towards the center until a distance of 45 mm. in from the end
of the tie was reached, thence becoming uniform at a pressure of 4 kg.
per sq. cm. If these relative dimensions are applied on a larger scale to
a tie of 260 mm. width, spaced 780 mm. from center to center, the pro-
portions which will result are illustrated in Fig. 13. If the width of the
ballast extending; outward from the end of the tie is unlimited, then C,
the length of the territory of decreasing pressure, diminishes to 180 mm.,
but increases to 400 mm. in the absence of any ballast outward from the
end.
i6o 1
A A A. 'A 1 A AAA
r«=330-
13.
The length of the tie has no influence on the relation of the pressure
at the ends of the tie, but it does affect the load intensity and the length
of the uniformly loaded territory under the middle of the tie. When
determining the length of the ties, consideration should be taken, on the
one hand, that the bending moments do not become too great, and, on the
other, that lightly loaded portion, or portion carrying no load, is properly
supported by the ballast. Since the surface of the ballast adapts itself to
the elastic line of the tie, a short tie, when not loaded, will be supported
at its middle, while a long tie, not loaded, will be supported at its ends.
And, furthermore, the bending moment of a long tie under the rail
increases considerably with its length, which should be taken into con-
sideration with wooden ties, especially when wooden dowels are screwed
in at the place of the greatest bending moment, which would consider-
ably diminish the carrying capacity. Consideration of all those limiting
features seems to determine a tie length of 2.8 meter.
The question of the smallest size of gravel particles and the largest
admixture of foreign material permissible in gravel ballast is of consider-
able significance, from a practical and economical point of view, to those
railroads depending upon gravel for ballast. The carrying capacity of
gravel depends primarily on its internal resistances, which are indicated
Angle of Repose.
31°
ii'
33°
45'
36°
9'
37°
io'
40°
15'
39°
48'
34°
35'
36°
52'
GRAVEL AS BALLAST. 281
by the angle of repose of material. For ordinary dry gravel, the follow-
ing values are determined:
Number. Size of Grains.
I Less than 1 mm.
II 1 mm. to 2 mm.
III 2 mm. to 3.1 mm.
IV 3.1 mm. to 4.2 mm.
V 4.2 mm. to 5.6 mm.
VI 5.6 mm. to 9.2 mm.
Mixture of I, II, VI=i :i :S
Mixture of II, IV=i :i
Hence, the angle of repose increases from 30 to 40 degrees, with increase in
size of the grains. According to the theoretical investigation of Dr. H.
Zimmermann's "Berechnung des Oberbanes," page 116, the carrying capac-
ity of the bed increases very rapidly as the angle of repose of the bed
material increases from 30 to 40 degrees, and at 40 degrees it should be
three to five times as great as at 30 degrees. Now, if experience does not
substantiate such a great variation in carrying capacity, consideration must
be taken of the fact that the internal friction decreases when the materials
are subjected to shock, and that the presence of foreign material is apt to
increase it. Experiments to determine if coarse gravel subjected to heavy
impact was superior to fine grained gravel were not conclusive in results
The size of the gravel particles are not alone in determining the carry-
ing capacity of the material, but the effect of the moisture present and the
condition of material also influence it considerably. Light moisture, as is
usually present at the base of the roadbed, tends to increase the adhesion
between the particles, and, hence, enhances the carrying capacity of the
finer grained gravel. It was found that fine grained gravel in a moist
condition had twice to four times the carrying capacity of the same
gravel in a perfectly dry state; on the other hand, coarse grained gravel
revealed no striking difference between the dry and the moist stage. A
surplus of water, however, loosened up the adhesion of the finer grains
when subjected to quick change in loading. If proper drainage is pro-
vided, then coarse grained gravel can hardly be saturated with water;
while, on the other hand, fine grained gravel may easily be saturated, since
it retained the water up to its point of saturation. In order to determine
the rate at which water is absorbed and again released by gravel, the fol-
lowing experiments were made :
In a watertight box, 500 mm. high, dry sand was piled of a size not
exceeding 1 mm. Water was then poured in until it reappeared on the
surface. The absorption of water amounted to 29 per cent, of the volume
of the sand. The surface water was then drained from the sand through
a series of tap holes, spaced 50 mm. apart, and measured. It was deter-
mined that the amount of water drained at the top was comparatively
small, it was increased as the depth became greater, and became fairly
constant after a depth of 400 mm. had been reached. The reason for this
phenomenon appears to be that the capillary attraction in the upper layers
282
GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
when the water level is high preponderates, but as the same sinks the
attraction decreases. Furthermore, the fine streams of water, as they flow
downward by their own weight, draw water from the upper layers as
long as they will release it. When the highest layers have become dry,
this phenomenon continues downward, as each tap is opened.
The diagram, Fig. 14, represents, by the area bounded by line I and
the X and Y axes, how the water content varied from the top to the
bottom of a bed i;oo mm. deep. The original water content of 29 per cent,
decreased from the bottom towards the top to 4 per cent. Similarly, lines
II, III and IV of this same Fig. 14 illustrate the variation of the water
content of different gravels made up of coarser grains as designated under
the diagram. The water-absorbing capacity of the coarser gravel was
greater than that of the finer gravel, but the release of water, as the
level sank, was more rapid. In fact, gravel of greater than 2 mm. was
practically free from moisture at a height of 130 mm. above the level of
the water. The moisture finally retained after the gravel had been drained
ranged with the different sizes between the narrow limits of 2.5 to 4 per
cent.
500
400
300
ZOO
mm Height of Sand Bed
i
■i
I
i
P
,_ —
\
30 40^, Water Content
I Size of grains less than 1 mm.
II Pit Gravel with 2b % of gra ins less than 1 mm.
EI Size of grains 1 to 2 mm.
IV Size of grains 2 to 4 mm.
Fig. 14.
Hence, it becomes apparent that coarse gravel, though of compara-
tively shallow depth, readily drains itself and becomes dry; but, on the
other hand, the retained water is practically the same for fine and coarse
GRAVEL AS BALLAST. 283
gravel, provided there is sufficient depth. The disadvantages of fine gravel
in this respect may be mitigated by deepening the roadbed. Considera-
tion must always be taken of the possibility of supersaturation of fine
gravel, owing to slower draining capacity under continued rainfall. This
may also occur when the roadbed begins to thaw, and the surface water,
which is released first, can find no outlet into the lower layer, owing to
their continuing in a frozen condition. On the other hand, the tendency
of the ballast to remain frozen under the ties, and so form a solid bed
for them until sufficient time has elapsed for the portion of the ballast
between the ties to thaw, drain to a considerable depth and become dry,
is an advantage.
The principal requirements for a permanent and uniform roadbed
with gravel ballast may, therefore, be summed up as follows :
The sub-soii upon which the roadbed rests should consist, to a depth
cf the frost line, of a material which is not affected by weather condi-
tions, nor, when frozen, heaves upward, thus disturbing the ballast.
The continued settling of the rail bears a distinct relation to the
internal resistances of the ballast. Hence, ballast, as far as it is subjected
to such forces, should consist of material which is uniform in its carry-
ing capacity. When the carrying capacity of the sub-soil, therefore, is not
high or varies greatly, as is the case with all earthy soils, the roadbed
j-hould be of such strength that the individual loads on the ties are evenly
distributed throughout the ballast and uniformly distributed over the sub-
soil. Furthermore, all sidewise and circulating movements should be
confined within the ballast.
In order to meet these requirements, a depth of bed of about 550 mm.
underneath the ties would be sufficient, provided some particularly un-
favorable conditions of the sub-soil did not make a greater depth neces-
sary. A clean sand, readily permitting water to pass through it, would
act well at the bottom of this bed. The actual depth of the ballast should
not exceed 300 mm. underneath the ties in order to prevent mixing with
the bottom layer of sand. Regarding the size of the gravel grains, it is
desirable, in order to secure a ballast which drains readily in its upper
layers, and in order to prevent the undue formation of dust underneath
and following trains, and in consideration of the future increase of fine
grain content due to tamping, to prevent as much as possible the admis-
sion of fine grained particles in the ballast. This, however, only means
particles less than 2 mm. in size. As a matter of fact, a mixture of fine
and coarse grains is desirable, since it permits of a more solid packing of
the gravel underneath the ties than when only coarse gravel is used. But,
due to the moist condition of gravel, it is not very convenient to segregate
the fine particles from the coarser. In order to accomplish this separation,
large coarse screens must be used. This results in a loss of a large and
useful portion of the gravel, and the part remaining is often so little that
the advantage gained by sifting is not warranted, due to the great expense
involved. Under these conditions, therefore, gravel with a 25 per cent,
content of grains 1 mm. or less in size becomes practicable, as long as the
284 GRAVEL AS BALLAST.
conditions are not extraordinary and require an especially strong roadbed.
The width of roadbed bears a certain relation to the length of ties
and the spacing of the ties. It is considered that an extension of the
ballast outwards from the ends of the tie, with their usual length of 2.7
to 28 m., amounting to 300 mm., is sufficient.
As the height to which the ballast is packed increases, the carrying
capacity of the roadbed increases. Hence, material should be piled be-
tween the ties as high as operating conditions will permit.
The width of the tie is also of considerable importance, since with
constant load the unit pressures on the bed are reduced as the area of the
tie increases, and the carrying capacity of the tie increases directly as its
area. A general use of larger wood ties is not permissible, owing to the
high purchase price and the greater difficulty of obtaining the same. It
is desirable to have the ties 2.8 m. in length. Strict consideration should
always be given the proper and uniform spacing of ties and shaping of
the roadbed in order to utilize to the limit the resistance of the roadbed.
Of greater importance than the width of the ties is the spacing of the
ties. As the spacing is decreased two advantages are derived: first, the
unit pressure decreases; secondly, the carrying capacity of the roadbed is
increased. It is just within the limits of tie spacing usually considered
that the relation a/b, ranging from 3^2 to 2 (spacing 900 mm. to 500 mmj,
that the carrying capacity increases at a high rate. (Figs, gd, 10c, and
12c) The limiting feature of decreasing tie-spacing is the ability to
tamp the ties properly. Ties 160 mm. in height can still be tamped with
convenience when separated 350 mm. But this (the relation being 2.3),
600 mm. from center to center, is the lowest limit. This is the one most
effective and simplest means of increasing the strength of the roadbed,
and to utilize it to the fullest advantage, especially on roadbeds which are
fully loaded, is urgently recommended.
The portion of the ballast under the joints requires special considera-
tion, since the impact at these points makes extraordinary demands on
the roadbed. It has been attempted several times to strengthen this part
of the ballast by packing crushed stone underneath the ties supporting the
joint, however without success.
Another way, and the one usually resorted to in order to accomplish
the above, is to bring the two ties supporting the joint as close together
as possible, 500 mm. from center to center. The closer the ties are
spaced outside of this particular territory supporting the joints the less
the difference is between the carrying capacity of the roadbed underneath
the joints and the carrying capacity of the rest of the bed. In order to
further strengtiien the roadbed underneath a joint, it would be effective
to increase the width of the ties supporting the joint. For instance, if the
width of the ties used is 300 mm., and the distance between them from
edge to edge is 250 mm., then the relation between them is 550 — 300=1.83,
as compared with a relation of 600 — 260=2.31 for the ties not underneath
the joints. By means of this decrease in the distance between the ties at
the joints, combined with the increased width, as well as the distribution
GRAVEL AS BALLAST. 285
cf the load ove>- greater surfaces, the carrying capacity of the roadbed
underneath the joints is increased approximately 75 per cent. Since, as
ties are ordinarily furnished, there is considerable variation in sizes, and
hence there should be no difficulty in selecting a sufficient number, approx-
imately 10 per cent, of the proper width, to arrange underneath the joints
for the above purpose.
As a further means of distributing the shock at the rail joints, methods
of combining the two ties underneath each joint by the use of a framework
are being tried out.
All means to increase the resistance of the ballast to impact will not
be complete and sufficient to properly maintain the necessary support and
steadiness of the whole roadbed as long as impacts, due to the passing
traffic, at the rail joints continue to vary on account of the varying dis-
tance between rail ends, variation in the surface elevation of two abutting
rails, wear of the rails and wheel flanges, and other changes in shapes
which result in varying shocks. Hence, the question of a proper support
for the rail joints is primarily a question of the proper joining of rails
with the object of preventing low and loose joints.
CD
c
o
o
>
id
gSmou)55^<\^
in
III llll will 1
[ij'l
4
O
5
1 1| J|lj 1 1|| it 1 II!
■
5*
1
-5*
ttf
ulli
\\\f
&.
^
JlirnTntmlT
1/
-6
UlfTMlllfl
lUfH
' *
lllllfflljj]
\:/\
-■Ci
1 MTTTmtH
' fml
^
IftJItiiflil J
n m
■^
q
o
^
Jll
!::■/ i
i*
^
Hi
K
^S
iff
in
Hi
In
iff
, mil
Ww\\
/!
lifll III
irm
t
N HI ki
4
| Lw^tj jj/ j
JJlllli^tlll
[fflim]
-<5
ililrmlll
Mil
^
itmlll
In
•1
||t|j\l ji
'ill
=§
0%
"0
|| ||]|||
lilli
^
["*
CD E
o
c
X
uJ
.V'i'-':
3>
I
r
1
I
289
Appendix D.
BALLAST.
By George W. Vaughan, Engineer Maintenance of Way, New York Cen-
tral & Hudson River Railroad.
Ballast is that portion of the permanent way of a railway which forms
the firm and dry foundation for the ties and rails, which they support.
It is sometimes distinguished as sub-ballast, ballast proper, and top-bal-
last. Sub-ballast is that portion used as a foundation for the ballast
proper, or as a mat between the ballast proper and sub-grade, made
necessary on account of the poor material forming the sub-grade. Ballast
proper, or under-ballast, is that which lies wholly below the ties and above
the sub-ballast. Top-ballast is that which is filled in around from the
bottom to the top of the ties.
Ballast is necessary for the following reasons :
(a) To drain water from the ties.
(b) To provide a firm and even bearing for the ties and to dis-
tribute the pressure from the ties over the roadbed.
(c) To provide drainage, so as to avoid heaving by frost.
(d) To supply filling material between the ties and to hold them in
place.
(e) To prevent the growth of grass and weeds in the track.
(f) To allow surfacing and raising of track without disturbing the
roadbed.
Ballast is a most important item and upon its quality depends the
condition of the track, also the economy in maintenance and operation.
Ballast material should be carefully selected. A dusty ballast will
cause greatly increased wear on the equipment and on roads with exten-
sive passenger traffic an innumerable number of complaints from the
traveling public, and it is as important to avoid dust and dirt by the use
cf clean ballast as it is to avoid smoke and dirt by the use of hard coal
for fuel.
The best ballast is that which will best form a durable support to the
lies, will not change its consistency when wet, will not disintegrate upon
exposure to the elements, retains its solidity and position under the effects
of traffic, gives good drainage, be free from dust and make an easy-riding
track.
Broken stone and furnace slag drain readily, but burnt clay, sand, etc.,
will retain water more or less and will heave in frosty weather. With
earth or mud ballast good drainage is absolutely essential to enable the
track to be kept in safe and fairly good condition, as water-soaked earth
becomes pasty and squashes up between the ties and over the right-of-way,
and when in such condition it is impossible to tamp, so as to keep the
track in surface.
A good depth of ballast will cheapen the maintenance by keeping the
290
BALLAST. 291
beds of the ties well drained, and it is not economy to economize too much
on ballast.
The depth of ballast varies on different lines and according to the
practice of different engineers, the following may be taken as ordinary
limits:
Sub-ballast 10 in. to 18 in.
Lower-ballast 9 in. to 18 in.
Upper-ballast 6 in. to 8 in.
Totals 25 in. to 44 in.
The materials most generally used are Broken Stone, Furnace Slag,
Gravel, Burnt Clay, Sand, Cinders and Earth.
DEFINITIONS.
Broken or Crushed Stone. — Stone broken by mechanical means into
small fragments of specified size.
Gravel. — Small worn fragments of rock, coarser than sand, from nat-
ural deposits.
Sand. — Any hard granular rock material, finer than gravel or coarser
than dust.
Cinders. — The ashes or residue from coal used in locomotives and
other furnaces, including the sparks from the front end of locomotives.
Slag. — Waste product. A more or less vitrified form of furnace re-
duction of ore. This to include the granulated slag formed by dumping
hot slag into water or any other product of a blast furnace, iron, copper
or lead.
Burnt Clay. — Clay or gumbo, which has been treated with fire.
Mud Ballast. — Any natural material used as ballast, if, when well
drained, will not churn under the ties.
description.
Broken Stone. — This in general is considered the best material for
ballast, as it meets the requirements ; does not freeze nor heave in cold
weather, and can be worked in wet and dry weather alike. Almost any
hard building stone may be used, provided it breaks with an angular frac-
ture and not into thin, flat pieces. Granite, trap, limestone and flint are
mostly used.
Gravel. — This material is more used than any other and is a varying
quality. It may he sandy, dusty or loamy, or else full of large stone, which,
unless removed, will make an irregular and rough riding track. The best
gravel should be clean and coarse, and as far as possible of uniform size
and quality. It does not give as good drainage as stone, but a fairly
coarse and clean gravel generally proves satisfactory, provided plenty of
it is used.
Sand. — This, when clean, sharp and granulated, makes fairly good bal-
last under light traffic, but unless it is very coarse requires constant atten-
292 BALLAST.
tion and renewa':. involving a great deal of maintenance work, as it runs
out from under the ties and is gradually weathered away by the action of
the elements. Where gravel or sand ballast is full of dust it should be
provided by a top dressing of coarse cinders or coarse stone screenings, so
as to avoid dusty track.
Slag. — Furnace slag or cinder is commonly used on roads in the vicin-
ity of blast furnaces and iron works. Coarse slag is about as durable as
broken stone and in some ways almost as good, except that the ties decay
more rapidly from dry rot than in stone ballast. At the present time slag
from blast furnaces and iron works is being furnished in granulated shape.
This is done by dumping the slag into water, the product of which, when
taken out, is similar to and about the same quality as sand ballast. When
first placed in the track it is very dusty, but the repeated rains relieve this
condition. Its drainage qualities are much better than that furnished by
sand ballast.
Burnt Clay. — This is being used in England and other foreign coun-
tries; has extended to this country and is being used extensively in the
West. The most suitable is brick clay, or almost any clay that has not too
much sand, gumbo or clayey earth. Burnt clay is very light and is about
equal to screened locomotive cinders.
Mud Ballast. — Dirt, earth and mud are used, the ballast being com-
posed of natural soil along the road. This is the cheapest material to be
used and generally the most troublesome to maintain. It is of a variable
quality, from sandy to clayey. Unless very sandy, cakes in hot weather
and when any work is done it becomes intolerably dusty. In the winter it
heaves badly by frost and in rainy weather it washes out and in continued
wet seasons, or :n the spring, when the frost is coming out of the ground,
it becomes so solt that it is almost impossible to keep track in safe con-
dition, as the ties churn the saturated roadbed into mud. In other words,
good mud ballast is a continuous performance, every day in the year, Sun-
days included.
SPECIFICATIONS.
BROKEN STONE.
Broken stone ballast shall be made from stone hard enough to prevent
pulverizing under the treatment to which it is subjected, also durable and
tough enough to resist the disintegrating action of the elements where it is
used, or from other stone, acceptable to the Engineer.
When crushed it shall break into angular pieces and the maximum size
shall not exceed pieces which will pass through a revolving screen having
two (2) in. holes, and the minimum size shall lie on a revolving screen hav-
ing three-quarter (24) in. holes.
Stone shall be crushed in suitable crushers ; be clean and free from all
dust, rubbish, dirt and particles three-quarter (%) in. in diameter and
under. If crushed by hand, the stone should be broken in clean places
especially selected for the purpose.
BALLAST. 293
STONE SCREENINGS.
Stone screenings shall be made from the same quality of stone as stone
ballast, as it is a by-product of the crusher. The maximum size shall not
exceed pieces which will pass through a revolving screen having three-
quarter (54) in. holes and the minimum size shall lie on a revolving screen
having one-quarter {%) in. holes. The product shall be free from all dust,
dirt, rubbish and particles that will pass through a one-quarter (%) in.
ring and under.
CINDERS.
Cinder ballast shall be free from ashes, dirt and rubbish.
SLAG.
Slag ballast shall be free from lime, dirt and rubbish, and the product
from the mill, if not quenched in water, should be broken into pieces which
will pass through a revolving screen having two (2) in. holes, and the mini-
mum size shall lie on a revolving screen having three-quarter (54) in.
holes. If slag is quenched in water to form granulated slag, this product
shall be free from dirt, lime and rubbish, or any material that will not
pass through a two (2) in. ring.
GRAVEL.
The best should be clean and coarse, free from dirt, dust, marl lime, and
stone that will disintegrate under the action of the elements, and should
range in size from two (2) in. in diameter to coarse sand. Gravel should
be screened or washed where prevention of dust is an object, but this need
not be done when the traffic is such that it is not objectionable.
SAND.
Fine gravel or sand ballast should be free from dirt, rubbish, marl lime
and pebbles that will disintegrate under the action of the elements, and
should range in size from two (2) in. in diameter to fine sand, a portion
of about 75 and 8c per cent, to 20 and 25 per cent, of coarser material.
BURNT CLAY.
This ballast should be made of clay free from sand or silt. The clay
should be burnt Lard and thoroughly. The fuel used should be fresh and
clean enough to burn with a clean fire. Ballast should be allowed to cool
before loading. Absorption of water should not exceed fifteen (15) per
cent, by weight. Ballast must be free from all worthless material, dirt,
dust and rubbish.
EARTH OR MUD BALLAST.
Ballast should be taken from sub-soil and be of such material that
when placed in the track water will drain off readily from the top.
TOP-BALLAST.
This should consist of the same material as ballast proper, except
when a dustless roadbed is required the upper two or three (2 or 3) in.
294
BALLAST.
should consist of two or three-quarter (2 or tf ) in. stone, slag, screened
gravel or cinders.
SUB-BALLAST.
This should be sand, stone screenings, stone dust, ^»ulated 8^
any material that will form a cushion and dram readily. Sub-ballast
should be clean in* free from dirt and rubbish.
RECOMMENDED PRACTICE.
STONE, SLAG AND GRAVEL.
Coarse stone coarse slag or coarse gravel should be used , if obtain-
-Me on aH h gh peed and heavy freight tracks. When not obtainable, *e
ht^vnaitbLgmaterial should be used, and if a dust less trac *u , de««d
top dress with crushed stone, screenings, crushed slag, washed erave
or cinders. „,-kT™
CINDERS, STONE SCREENINGS AND SAND.
The use of cinders, stone screenings and sand as ballast ^gtm
meiJed for the following situations on Main and Branch Lines with light
tl'affiOn sidings and in yard tracks; as sub-ballast *£JJ^J^
cuts on fills, and through clay bottoms; as sub-ballast on new work
where fills are settling and at places where track heaves from frost.
BURNT CLAY.
The use of burnt clay as a ballast is recommended for the following
SitUaOnnMain and Branch Lines with medium traffic. On sidings as a
top dressing to secure a dustless track.
EARTH AND MUD.
The use of earth or mud is recommended only when more suitable
material Ho. obtainable. If used it should be rounded up ,„ the cente,
of the track, so that water will drain off readily.
RECOMMENDED DEPTH OF BALLAST.
Kind of Ballast. Sub-Ballast. Ballast-Proper. ToP-Ballast^
12 in. to 18 m. o m. to e m.
Crushed stone • . 6 in. to 8 in.
Crushed stone screenings io m. - in. to la in. * ^ . ^
Crushed slag I0 in. to 12 in. 6 in. to Sin.
Granulated slag » £ ^ ^ ^ jg ^ fi ^ tQ g •„.
^raV/ I2in. io in. to 12 in. 6 in. to 8 in.
^an,d I2in. io in. to 12 in. 6 in. to 8 m.
Cinderl, I2in. toiSin. 6 in. to 8 in.
Burnt Clay q in. to n in.
Earth or Mud 2 in to 3 in.
Dust Guard : All kinds of ballast
BALLAST. 295
RECOMMENDATIONS AS TO THE USE OF OIL TO SECURE A
DUSTLESS ROADBED.
Approximately 2,000 gallons of oil are required for each mile of single
track and the first cost is about $80.00 per mile. Oil is usually applied in
June and the one application is sufficient for the year, except where road-
bed is disturbed, when a local application is necessary, which can be made
with a sprinkling pot. The application of subsequent years is thinner and
is sometimes postponed until dust develops, when the cost of applying, per
mile of single track, where the company owns its own oil car, exclusive
of the royalty, is approximately $38.00.
The oil is generally furnished by the Standard Oil Company for this
purpose and appears to be unrefined, from which the more volatile parts
have been removed.
The ballast on which oil is generally used is either cinder, a mixture
of sand and gravel or sand. The oil has no appreciable effect on the effort
to keep good line and surface, except where the ballast is largely sand.
The oil makes the sand incohesive, causing the line and surface to deterio-
ate very rapidly. The oil helps to shed rainwater, but has no apparent
effect on the durability of ballast, except as stated above, in regard to sand
ballast. The oil penetrates usually about one (1) in. on cinder. On sand
it appears to soak down indefinitely.
If clean washed gravel can be obtained or if gravel is only dusty a
short time after being disturbed, the use of oil is not recommended, as
even after the oil is applied, the high-speed trains raise a fine oily dust
which is worse than the clean dust, so that if a dustless roadbed is re-
quired, the recommendations are the use of a top dressing of coarse stone
screenings, crushed slag, burnt clay, screened or washed gravel or screened
cinders.
DESCRIPTION OF BALLAST AS SHOWN BY PHOTOGRAPHS
ACCOMPANYING THIS REPORT:
No. 1. "Trap Rock" from Westfield, Mass.
No. 2. "Limestone" from Clinton Point, N. Y.
No. 3. "Gneiss," "Granite," "Hornblende" and other refuse from an
iron mine at Tilly Foster, N. Y.
No. 4. "Limestone" from South Bethlehem, N. Y.
No. 5. "Marble" from Gouverneur, N. Y. Note the difference in color.
Light portion is direct from the crusher, while the dark portion has been
in track two years.
No. 6. "Flint" and "Limestone" from Akron, N. Y.
No. 7. "Burnt Clay."
No. 8. "Furnace Slag."
No. 9. "Trap Rock" from Little Falls, N. Y.
No. 11. "Sandstone" from Medina.
No. 12. "Limestone" from Pennsylvania.
No. 13. "Limestone" from Bellefonte, Pa.
296 BALLAST.
No. 14. "Screenings" from Akron, N. Y.
No. 15. "Crystalized Sandstone" from Niagara Falls.
No. 16. "Gravel" from Beaver River. This is such gravel as is used
on the Adirondack Division of the New York Central.
No. 17. "Gravel" from Yosts on the Mohawk Division of the New
York Central and is of first quality.
No. 18. "Gravel" from Todd's Pit on the M. & M.
No. 19. "Gravel" from Glenfield Pit on the R. W. & O. Division.
This material is coarse sand and makes very good ballast, though some-
what dusty when put in track.
No. 20. "Granulated Slag" from blast furnace. Sample here shown
is quite coarse and full of black cinders.
No. 21. "Gravel" from Fisher's Pit, Western Division.
No. 22. "Medium Coarse Gravel" from Fisher's Pit, Western Division.
No. 23. "Locomotive Cinder."
BALLAST.
297
298
BALLAST.
BALLAST.
299
300
BALLAST.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE III— ON TIES.
L. A. Downs, Chairman;
H. W. Brown.
W. J. Burton.
L. C. Hartley.
E. D. Jackson.
F. G. Jonah.
H. C. Landon.
F. R. Layng.
D. O. Lewis.
G. W. Merrell, V ice -Chair man ;
Duncan MacPherson.
L. M. Perkins.
J. G. Shillinger.
G. D. SWINGLY.
D. W. Thrower.
H. K. Wicksteed.
H. S. Wilgus.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Ties has had under investigation during the past
year three of the subjects assigned by the Board of Direction, and here-
with respectfully submits its report:
(i) SIZE OF CROSS-TIES REQUIRED FOR THE STRESSES
TO WHICH THEY ARE SUBJECTED.
The stresses to which ties are subjected cannot be considered as hav-
ing no interrelation to the other parts of a roadway. On the contrary,
the size of rail, the load above and the bearing beneath the tie, the subsoil,
the character of the material between ties, the presence or absence of tie-
plates, screw versus common spikes, and many other conditions, actual
and theoretical, must be considered. It was thought best to obtain from
various members opinions along certain lines and for that purpose a set
of questions was prepared (see Exhibit A) by the Sub-Chairman and sent
out by the Secretary to all members. Forty replies, representing about
4 per cent, of membership, or 32 per cent, of the mileage represented in
the Association, were received. These replies have been tabulated (see
Exhibit F and F-i). The preparation of the questions and the tabula-
tion of the answers have required considerable time and patience. The
tabulation is worthy of careful study, for it contains information and
data of much value. Indeed, it is an epitome ot much that is not ger-
mane to but which is closely allied to the topic. The size of Table F is
regrettable, but it is considered that the information in that form is most
readily comparable.
The various sizes of ties already in common use, as prepared by the
301
302 TIES.
Tie Committee, are tabulated on pp. 771-774, Proceedings for 1905, Amer-
ican Railway Engineering Association. This table has been rearranged
in order to tabulate information under the following heads, viz. :
(1) Different number of ties per 30- ft. rail. (See Exhibit B.)
(2) Is a 6x8x8 tie too small; is a larger tie than 6x8x8 undesirable?
(See Exhibit C.)
(3) Different sizes of cross-ties in current use. (See Exhibit D.)
A study of Exhibit B shows a preponderance of mileage and mem-
bership (42.7 and 38 per cent., respectively) in favor of 16 ties to the
30- ft. rail (2,816 per mile), main track. During the six years interven-
ing the railroads seem to have increased the number, for the general
average of a rail-bearing area, as per Exhibit F, is about 40 per cent.,
whereas in 1905 it ran about 35^4 per cent. Exhibit B, however, indi-
cates that in 1905 17 (2,992 per mile) and 18 (3,168 per mile) ties per
30-ft. rail (bearing area of 38 per cent, and 40 per cent., respectively,
based on 8-in. ties) were in strong favor.
Exhibit C was prepared in order to ascertain the feeling as to proper
size of cross-ties. It would appear that 59 per cent, of the mileage voting
believed a 6x8x8 ft. too small, whereas 96 per cent, thought a larger
tie not undesirable.
Exhibit D indicates 22 sizes of cross-ties in current use, with 47 per
cent, of the mileage and 48 per cent, of the membership reported as using
6x8x8, whereas that tie is believed unsatisfactory by 59 per cent. (Exhibit
C) of the voting mileage, and 96 per cent, Exhibit C, believe a larger
tie desirable. These tables all show an inconsistency among the rail-
roads as to what they really do desire. There is no doubt that the senti-
ment is in favor of a larger tie, but the sentiment stage is not overcome.
The length of tie apparently has not been considered so much as
width and depth. Exhibit D shows that of 139,029 miles represented, 25,-
112 miles or 18 per cent, reported ties 8 ft. 6 in. in length. The length
of a tie between recognized limits has a great influence on the distribu-
tion of its superimposed load over the ballast and consequent tie crush-
ing as well as the amount of maintenance work required with poor bal-
last, poor subgrade, or both. Ten and three-tenths (10.3) per cent, re-
ported in favor of a 7x9x8 ft. 6 in. and none in favor of a 6x8x8 ft. 6 in.
(6x8x8 ft. is the most popular).
A. M. Wellington, in his incomparable treatise on "The Economic
Theory of Railway Location," touches admirably on the topic of this
Committee in paragraphs 1044 to 1050, inclusive. The extracts from these
paragraphs as follows are most apropos :
"1044. The number of these (ties) cannot be too great for economy,
until they become so close as to impede tamping, which is when about 40
per cent, of the length of the rail rests upon ties.
"1046 In endeavoring to get the utmost stability at the
least cost the first essential is to use ties as freely as is possible, and the
next essential is to decide between a heavier rail and more tamping to
supply the deficit.
TIES.
303
"1051 The best dimensions for a tie are about. 7 in.
thick, 8 ft. 6 in. long and 7 in. to 9 in. face."
The Committee has been unable to find any data in the publications
of the Association bearing on the crushing strength across the grain of
the various woods used for tie purposes, except on pp. 853-4, Volume
11, Part 2, Proceedings, 1910, American Railway Engineering Association.
That table is intended partially to show the effect of preservative treat-
ment on crushing strength at elastic limit and the average of tests for
various woods is as follows :
Table I.
BEARING STRENGTH OF TIES UNDER THE RAIL TESTS.
(See Proceedings, Vol. n. Part 2, pp. 853-4.)
Natural
Treated
No.
of Teats
Crushing at
E. L.
No.
of Tests
Crushing at
E. L.
Remarks
Red Oak.. .
100
70
30
20
29
249
1090
612
640
688
830
100
70
30
20
29
249
1080
591
618
725
791
1. Crude oil, 529.
1. Crude oil, 373.
1. Crude oil, 655.
The natural crushing strength at elastic limit herein given does not
compare favorably with simlar results obtained by the United States
Government (see Exhibit G), because of the difference in character of
material and moisture content. The Forestry Service Circular 189 (see
footnote page 311 states, "... it is not safe to base working stresses
on results secured from any but green material."
The Director of the Forest Products Laboratory, Forestry Service,
Madison, Wis., furnished the Sub-Committee blueprints of crushing
strength at elastic limit of timber — air dry and green and from which
prints Exhibit G is extracted. This table well illustrates why green
timber for ties should be shunned.
Exhibit E is a list of articles on the relation of the size of cross-ties
to the stresses to which they are subjected, from search made at the
Library of the American Society of Civil Engineers, June 12, 1911.
This list is supplemented as follows :
(1) "Discussion of Committee Report on Ballasting," by W. C.
Cushing; Bulletin 76, June, 1906, American Railway Engineering Asso-
ciation.
(2) "A Study of Stresses Existing in Track Superstructure and
Rational Design Based Thereon," by O. E. Selby; Bulletin 80, October,
1906, American Railway Engineering Association.
(3) "Stresses in Track Fastenings," by W. C. Cushing; Bulletin
104, October, 1908.
(4) 1. "Experiment to Determine the Necessary Depth of Stone
Ballast," being a report of General Manager's Committee, Pennsylvania
Railroad. 2. "Gravel as Ballast," by C. Brauning. (Translated from the
German.) Bulletin 136, June, 191 1.
304 TIES.
(5) Volume 7, Proceedings, 1906 (out of print), American Railway
Engineering Association.
(6) Wellington, A. M., paragraphs 1044 to 1050.
(7) International Railway Congress, Proceedings, 1910, Volume 1,
Question 2, Report No. 1. Strengthening of Track, by J. W. Jacomb-
Hood, Engineer London & Southwestern Railway.
Bulletin 136, June, 191 1, contains an article entitled "Experiment to
Determine the Necessary Depth of Stone Ballast," being a report of the
General Manager's Committee of the Pennsylvania Railroad. This re-
port is based on spacing of white oak ties 16I/2 in. face to face for a 7x9x8
ft. 6 in. tie, which tie spacing is equivalent to 25^ in. center to center,
or 14 ties per 30 ft. rail, which is equivalent to 35 per cent, bearing. That
Committee recommended (page 17) "the use of 24 in. of stone ballast
underneath the ties to meet satisfactorily the conditions that exist to-day
and which will become probably more severe as time goes on, and in
addition to the 24 in. of trap rock ballast beneath the ties, there should be
provided a layer of engine cinders, gravel or an equivalent to act as an
absorbent mat to promptly and properly dispose of the water falling on
the track in such a manner as to prevent its softening the roadbed ma-
terial."
Your Committee is of the opinion that further investigation should
be made upon these lines to ascertain relation of tie spacing to different
depths of ballast.
O. E. Selby, in Bulletin 80, October, 1906, American Railway Engi-
neering Association, treats of the stresses in ties. His recommendation is
12 in. stone ballast directly under tie, superimposed on 12 in. gravel, with
ties spaced 20 in. center to center (45 per cent.).
Thos. H. Johnson's formulae for depth of ballast and tie-spacing for
gravel and stone ballast appear in Bulletin 76, June, 1906.
It came to the notice of the Sub-Committee that the Erie Division of
the Pennsylvania Railroad was experiencing trouble with yellow pine tie
splitting; it therefore wrote to R. L. Roe, Division Engineer, and replies
from his Supervisors, W. E. Brown, J. S. Considine, W. S. Wilson, are
given, as follows :
"In reply to your circular of the 10th inst, concerning effect of heavy
engines on yellow pine ties, would advise that, on that part of the Mary-
land Division between Baltimore and Perryville, where no engines heav-
ier than Di6d were used, yellow pine ties were found equal to oak as far
as the wearing qualities were concerned under the 100-lb. rail without
tie-plates. This was prior to 1905.
"When I came to this division in July, 1905, I found that a fair
percentage of yellow pine ties were used in the main track, some of which
had been in service about three years and were all in fair condition. At
that time only one class E engine was in service. During the next two
years more of this heavier class of engines were used, and in the spring
of 1907 we noticed that some of the yellow pine ties which had been in
service less than a year were beginning to show signs of crushing. With
the increased use of the class E engines the tendency to split seems to
grow more pronounced yearly.
TIES. 305
"The R. & C. (a light traffic line) has a large percentage of yellow
pine ties in track, but fail to notice so marked a tendency in the pine
ties to split as on the Renovo Division, in spite of the fact that very few
of the branch ties are tie-plated.
"Perhaps this difference may be due to the increased tonnage on the
Renovo Division, but the fact that tie-plates are more generally used be-
tween West Creek and Strebor should counteract to some extent the
heavier traffic and we are inclined to attribute the failure of the yellow
pine ties more to excessive axle load on class E engine drivers than to
the number of axles which may be hauled over the division."
"Replying to yours of the ioth, regarding effect of heavy engines on
pine ties, we find that pine ties without tie-plates become crushed and
checked badly under the rail long before they are decayed or otherwise
unfitted for service.
"The application of a tie-plate when tie is in this condition will, of
course, prolong the life to some extent.
"It is the practice at the present time to use plates on all pine ties
when first put in track, and while the greatest amount of service is ob-
tained from the tie by this method, our experience has not been sufficient
in this line to say definitely that they will not crush under the heavy con-
centrated wheel loads where plates are so applied."
"In reply to Mr. H. S. Wilgus' letter of the 8th inst, relative to
crushing our yellow pine ties due to the heavy concentrated wheel loads
of our heavy engines, it has always been my opinion that if we get good
sound yellow pine ties and use tie-plates with them, we will get prac-
tically the same life out of them as we get out of the white oak ties.
"Some years ago when track elevation work was done on the P. B. &
W. through Chester and Wilmington, one of the main tracks was laid in
white oak ties and the other in yellow pine ties. I have been told that a
great many of these pine ties are still in track, while a majority of the
oak ties have been removed. Pine ties without tie-plates soon split and
crush and wear out rather than rot out. We have, however, a great many
now in track on this division that were installed about eleven years ago
with tie-plates and they are in fair condition considering the service they
are giving."
EXHIBIT A.
COPY OF CIRCULAR.
(i) What percentage of a rail length should have a bearing on the
ties? Does the per cent, mean per cent, of linear distance or bearing
area?
(2) Has this percentage any relation to, (a) Kind of timber used for
ties? (b) Kind of ballast? (c) Character of sub-grade? (d) Tangent vs.
curve? (e) Minimum distance between face of ties?
(3) If the percentage is capable of mathematical deduction, please
give the method, etc.
(4) Is crushing hastened by natural checking of ties?
(5) Which class of wood checks most?
(6) Does preservative treatment tend to increase the tendency to
check ?
306
TIES.
(7) Does preservative treatment affect the natural crushing untt
stresses?
(8) (a) With the increased tie consumption and the decreased
available tie supply, can the demand for larger sectional area of ties be
met? (b) If a larger sectional area of the tie is not available, what
would you recommend as next best thing to do — use steel or composite
or what not?
(9) Has the application of screw or square spikes any effect on
crushing?
(10) Relation of kinds of ballast to tie crushing?
(11) Relation of character of sub-grade to tie crushing?
(12) Relation of axle load to tie crushing.
(13) Relation of frequency of maximum axle load as applied to a
tie to tie crushing?
(14) Relation of maximum axle load to weight of rail and conse-
quent tie crushing?
(15) Relation of impact at joints to tie crushing?
(16) Relation of size of tie-plates to crushing of ties?
EXHIBIT B.
DIFFERENT NUMBER OF TIES PER 30-FT. RAIL AND NUMBER OF
MILES OF TRACK REPRESENTED UNDER EACH SUCH NUMBER.
Based on Table published on pp. 771-774, Vol. 6, Proceedings, 1905,
American Railway Engineering- Association.
Roads Voting
Number of Miles
Percentage of
Total Mileage
Voting
No. of Ties to
30-ft. Rail, M. T.
Number
Per cent of
those Voting
15
1,834
1.4
12
9.4
16
55,380
42.7
48
38.0
17
17,805
13.8
21
16.7
18
24,190
18.7
21
16.7
19
4,589
3.5
3
2.4
20
3,249
2.5
3
2.4
14-16
7,180
5.5
2
1.6
15-16
83
—
1
0.8
15-17
154
0.1
1
0.8
15-18
5,984
4.5
1
0.8
15-19
1,416
1.0
1
0.8
16-17
110
0.1
1
0.8
16-18
3,565
2.7
3
2.4
16-19
161
0.1
1
0.8
17-18
3,016
3.0
3
2.4
17-20
153
0.1
1
0.8
18-19
49
0.0
1
0.8
18-21
404
0.3
2
1.6
129,322
100.0
126
100.0
Total in Member-
ship
259,384
990
Per cent of Total
50
13
TIES.
307
EXHIBIT C.
IS A 6x8x8 FT. TIE TOO SMALL? IS A LARGER TIE THAN 6x8x8
FT. UNDESIRABLE?
Based on Table published on page 771, Vol. 6, Proceedings, 1905, Ameri-
can Railway Engineering Association.
Yes
No
Total Miles
appearing
in table
Total voting on
this point
Miles
Per cent
of Total
Miles
Per cent
Miles
Per cent
Is 6x8x8 ft. too small
33,936
2,220
59
4
23,678
51,755
41
96
129,322
129,322
59,614
51,755
45
Is a larger tie than 6x8x8 ft.
undesirable
40
EXHIBIT D.
DIFFERENT SIZES OF CROSS-TIES IN CURRENT USE.
Based on Table published on page 771, Vol. 6, Proceedings, 1906, Ameri-
can Railway Engineering Association.
Miles of Road Using Same
Roads Voting
Miles
Per cent
Number
Per cent
6 x 7 x 8
6 x 8x8
222
65,432
830
191
6,506
13,999
2,498
5,184
14,448
8,100
4,182
1,857
336
5,459
1,440
952
1,869
708
3,024
163
161
1,468
0.2
47.3
0.6
0.1
4.7
10.1
1.8
3.7
10.3
5.8
3.0
1.4
0.2
3.9
1.0
0.7
1.3
0.5
2.2
0.1
0.1
1.0
2
67
4
1
6
16
2
6
13
10
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1.4
48.0
6 x 9x8
2.8
7 x 7x8
0.7
7 x 7x8'6"
7 x 8x8
4.2
11.2
7 x 8 x 8 '6"
7 x 9x8
1.4
4.3
7 x 9 x 8 '6"
9.2
7 x 9x9
7.0
6 x8-10x 8
0.7
6-7 x6-12x 8
1.4
6J— 8x7-llx 8
0.7
7 x 7-9x 8
1.4
7 x9-10x 8
8 x 9 x 8'6"
0.7
0.7
7 x 10 x 8
0.7
7 x 10 x 8 '6"
0.7
8 x 8x8
0.7
7 x7-12x 8
0.7
7 x7-10x 8 , ...
0.7
7 x7-14x8'6"
0.7
139,029
100.0
141
100.0
EXHIBIT E.
BIBLIOGRAPHY ON SIZE OF CROSS-TIES IN RELATION TO
THE STRESSES TO WHICH THEY ARE SUBJECTED.
LIBRARY OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CIVIL ENGINEERS.
Note: This is not a complete search.
"Loadings for Railroad Bridges," Informal Discussion. Transac-
tions, American Society of Civil Engineers, v. 51, p. 106. (Contains a
308 TIES.
brief reference as to the advisability of increasing the size of ties for
heavier railroad traffic.)
"Metal and Reinforced Concrete Ties." (Editorial.) Railroad Age
Gazette, v. 44, p. 593 (May 1, 1908). (On the durability of metal ties.)
"Steel Ties on the Bessemer & Lake Erie Railroad." Railway and
Engineering Review, v. 48, p. 443 (June 6, 1908). (Give size of stand-
ard steel tie and experience in using it.)
"The Life of Steel Ties," by W. C. Cushing. (Railroad Age Gazette,
v. 45, p. 24 (June 5, 1908). (Gives weight and size of ties used in various
European countries, under heavy traffic.)
"Die Eisenschwelle," by A. Haarmann. Stahl und Eisen, v. 28, p.
177 (February 5, 1908). (History of the use of cross-ties and profiles
showing development in size and weight.)
Translation of the same. "The Iron Sleeper," by A. Haarmann. The
Engineer, v. 105, p. 189, 216 (February 21, 28, 1908).
"A Combination Steel and Concrete Tie on the Pittsburg, Fort
Wayne & Chicago Railway." Engineering News, v. 62, p. 205 (February
17, 1910). (The weight of the tie is 800 to 850 lbs., there are fifteen of
these ties in use, carrying a 33-ft. rail length of track.)
"Report No. 8 (Austria, Hungary, Bulgaria, Roumania, Servia and
Turkey) on the Question of Strengthening the Track with a View of
Increasing the Weight of Locomotives and the Speed of Trains (Sub-
ject II, Littera A, for discussion at the Eighth Session of the Railway
Congress)," by Hermann Rosche. Bulletin International Railway Con-
gress, v. 24, p. 1904, 1950 (May, 1910). (Gives speed of trains, wheel
loads of locomotives and rolling stock and dimensions of sleepers.)
"Report No. 9 (all countries, except Austria, Hungary, Bulgaria,
Roumania, Servia, Turkey, America and Great Britain) on the Question
of Strengthening the Track with a View to Increasing the Weight of
Locomotives and the Speed of Trains (Subject II, Littera A, for dis-
cussion at the Eighth Session of the Railway Congress)," by Blum. Bui.
Inter. Ry. Cong., v. 24, p. 2497 (June, 1910). (Tables 1, 2 and 4 con-
tain data on the length, weight, composition and speed of trains and di-
mensions and spacing of sleepers on twenty-one railroads.)
"Report No. 2 (Austria-Hungary, Roumania, Holland, Luxemburg,
Germany and Switzerland) on the Question of Maintenance of Way on
Lines with Heavy Traffic." (Subject IV for discussion at the Sixth Session
of the Railway Congress)," by J. W. Post. Bui. Int. Ry. Congress, v. 14,
p. 21 (March, 1900).
"Report No. 1 (Great Britain) on the Question of Strengthening
the Track and the Bridges, with a View to Increasing the Speed of
Trains" (Subject for discussion at the Eighth Session of the Railway
Congress), by J. W. Jacomb-Hood. Bui. Inter. Ry. Cong., v. 23, p. 571
(July, 1909). (Contains two pages on cross-ties.)
"Report No. 4 (America) on the Question of Strengthening the
Track and the Bridges, with a View of Increasing the Speed of Trains
(Subject II for discussion at the Eighth Session of the Railway Con-
TIES. 309
gress)," by M. L. Byers. Bui. Int. Ry. Cong., v. 23, p. 879 (September,
1909).
"Compound Sleepers on the Michel System," by Hector Michel.
Bulletin International Railway Congress, v. 23, p. 1506 (November, 1909).
(Contains results of experiments made on the Paris-Lyons-Mediterra-
nean Railway, giving curves of deformation of various cross-ties, and de-
termination of what length they should be.)
"La Superstructure des Voies des Chemins de Fer Allemands," by
M. Blum. Revue Generale des Chemins de Fer et des Tramways, v. 31,
Pt. 2, p. 277 (November, 1908). (Gives weight, size, material, etc., of
cross-ties employed on railroads in Germany.)
"La Voie Courante des Chemins de Fer de L'Etat Beige," by Pierre
Decamps. Revue Generale des Chemins de Fer et des Tramways, v. 32,
Pt. 2, p. 251 (October, 1009). (Gives dimension of ties used by the Bel-
gian State Railway in track for heavy and fast trains.)
"Two Foreign Developments in Railway Ties," Engineering News, v.
53, p. 204 (February 17, 19 10).
"Railroad Track Superstructure (Editorial)", Railroad Gazette, v. 42,
p. 326 (March 15, 1907). (A discussion of M. Cuenot's experiments.)
"Track Deformations and Their Prevention," by G. Cuenot. Rail-
road Gazette, v. 42, p. 363, 416, 453, 485, 5*7, 55o, 588, 618, 654, 681, 713,
746, 801 (March 15, 22, 29; April 5, 12, 19, 26; May 3, 10, 17, 24, 31 i June
7, 1907). (Describes experiments and gives conclusions deduced from
them.)
"Note sur les Deformation Permanentes de la Voie," by M. Couard.
Revue Generale des Chemins de Fer et des Tramways, v. 20, Pt. 2, p. 29
(July, 1897). (Contains a page on the influence of cross-ties on the de-
formation of railway track.)
"On Best Method of Maintaining the Track for the Tonnage and
Speed of To-day." Proceedings of the Twenty-fourth Annual Conven-
tion of the Roadmasters and Maintenance of Way Association of Amer-
ica," igo6, p. 15, 40. (Report of the Committee with discussion.) Ab-
stract of same. Railroad Gazette, v. 41, p. 459 (November 23, 1906).
"Steel Ties on the Bessemer & Lake Erie Railroad," by W. M.
Camp. Proceedings of the Twenty-sixth Annual Convention of the Road-
masters' and Maintenance of Way Association of America, 1908, p. 59.
(Discusses the size and weight of ties.)
"Kimball Concrete-Steel Ties." Railway Age, v. 44, p. 386 (Septem-
ber 20, 1907). (A type of concrete-steel tie subjected to the test of
heavy traffic.)
"Versuche mit flusseisern Querschwellen in den Vereinigten Staaten
von Nordamerika," by K. A. Mullenhoff. Zeitschrift des Vereines
deutscher Ingenieure, v. 51, Pt. 1, p. 259 (February 16, 1907). (Describ-
ing and comparing ties and fastenings.)
"The Tie Problem with Special Reference to Concrete Ties," by G.
H. Kimball, Journal Western Society of Engineers, v. 8, p, 561 (October,
1903). (Thirty-six pages.)
310 TIES.
"Evolution des Voies de Chemins de Fer en Vue des Grandes
Vitesees," by Mesanger. Genie Civil, v. 48, p. 93 (December 9, 1905).
(Two pages.)
"Steel and Concrete-Steel Ties on the L. S. & M. S. Ry." Railway
and Engineering Review, v. 46, p. 627 (August 18, 1906.) (Results of
experiments and conclusions.)
"A Review of the Railway Tie Situation" (Editor il). Engineering
News, v. 55, p. 500 (May 3, 1506). (Contains a brief reference to the
size of ties.)
"Report of Committee on Ties." Proceedings American Railway
Engineering and Maintenance of Way Association, p. 29, 35, 62, 68, 70,
72 (508-523), Chicago, 111., 1906. (Contains report and discussion on
the dimensions of ties.)
Extract of same. Railway Age, v. 41, p. 464 (March 23, 1906).
"The Carnegie Steel Tie." Railroad Gazette, v. 41, p. 64 (July 20.
1906). (Two pages, illustrated.)
"Concrete Railroad Ties," by G. H. Kimball. Cement Age, v. 2, p.
763 (April, 1906).
"Steel Cross-Ties," by W. F. Miller. Proceedings, Engineers' Society
of Western Pennsylvania, v. 22, p. 69 CMarch, 1906). (Description of
ties, giving size and examples of their use.)
"The Problem of Track Support," by Samuel E. Duff. Industrial
World, v. 40, p. 301 (August 25, 1906). (Discusses cross-tie system of
track support.)
"Note on the Economic Renewal and Maintenance of Railway Tracks
for High Speed Traffic, Examination of a Vignoles Track, with Cramps,
Wedges and Shock-Absorbers or Deadener Blocks," by L. Schlussel
Bulletin International Railway Cong-ess, v. 21, p. 379 (April, 1907)
(Discusses the effect of traffic on ties, etc.)
"Experiments with Reinforced Concrete Ties in America," by W. M.
Camp. Bulletin International Railway Congress, v. 21, p. 861 (September,
1907). (Experience with ties for high-speed traffic.)
"What will be the Future Railway Track for Heavy Traffic?"
(Editorial.) Engineering News, v. 53, p. 601 ("June 8. 1905). (On the
substitution of concrete longitudinals in place of cross-ties on tracks used
for heavy traffic.)
"New Concrete Ties and Steel Ties." Engineering News, v. 54, p.
349 (October 5, 1905). (Tests under heavy traffic of concrete ties and
steel ties; size is, given.)
"Metal Ties in Germany," by A. Haarmann. Railroad Gazette, v.
35. P- 349 (May 15, 1903). (Description of ties used on an experi-
mental road on the George-Marien-Hutten Railroad.)
"Steel Railroad Ties in Europe," by Foster Crowell. Railroad
Gazette, v. 33. p. 600 (August 30, 1901).
"The Railroad Cross-Tie Problem," by S. Whinery. Railroad Ga-
zette, v. 37, p. 526, 536 (November 4, it, 1904).
TIES.
311
"The Railway Tie Question.'
vember 19, 1903).
"Further Use of Steel and Reinforced Concrete Ties
Engineering Review, v. 44, p. 652 (September 10, 1904).
"Experiments with Steel and Reinforced Concrete Ties
and Engineering Review, v. 43, p. 580 (August 1, 1903).
"The Effect on Track of Modern Equipment and High Speeds," by
P. H. Dudley. Railway Age, v. 35, p. 409 (March 20, 1903). (Contains
references to the effect of traffic on ties.)
Engineering News, v. 50, p. 463 (No-
Railway and
Railway
EXHIBIT G.t
Air Dry
fife * Green
Species
Compression Vertical to Grain
Compression Vertical to Grain
Stress
Area,
In.
Height
In.
No. of
Tests
Per cen
Moist.
Cr. Str
atE.L.
lbs. per
sq. in.
Stress
Area,
In.
Height
In.
No. of
Tests
Per cent
Moist.
Cr. Str.
atE.L.
lbs. per
sq. in.
1. Longleaf Pine... .
2. Douglas Fir
4x5
4x8
4x8
4x4
4x4
4x4
8x5
8x5
8x5
5x5
2x2
4
16
10
8
6
4
16
14
12
8
2
22
44
32
51
49
29
4
3
5
6
57
25.1
20.8
18.1
20.2
24.0
24.8
17.8
16.3
15.1
13.0
13.9
572
732
584
638
613
603
725
757
730
918
926
4x4
4x8
4
16
22
259
25.3
30.3
568*
570
3. Shortleaf Pine...
6x8
5x8
5x8
5x8
5x5
5x2
6x8
6x8
4x6
4x4
8x4
4x4
(Fire
16
16
14
12
8
2
16
12
6
4
8
8
killed)
24
12
12
24
24
277
22
20
53
30
16
38
33.7
37.7
42.8
53.0
47.0
48.5
43.6
40.2
52.8
50.4
67 2
44.6
368
361
366
325
344
400
417
416
478
472
5 Loblolly Pine. . .
8x5
8x5
4x5
2x2
7x6
6x6
4x4
16
8
8
2
15
6
4
12
7
8
57
25
26
6
19.8
22.9
19.5
16.2
18.2
16.8
15.9
602
679
715
697
514
431
488
392
546
7 . Western Hemlock
6x4
6
30
48.7
434
6x8
6x6
6x7
6x3
6x2
6x2
6x2
2x2
16
12
9
14
12
10
8
2
13
14
13
13
12
11
12
186
86.7
83.0
74.7
75.6
66.5
55.0
56.7
75.5
473
424
477
411
430
423
396
569
2x2
2
36
10
924
2x2
2x2
2
2
43
46
31.8
50.4
310
11. White Spruce...
270
1
1
* Partially air dry.
t See United States Department of Agriculture, Forestry Service Circular 189, Forestry Products
Laboratory, Series issued January 25, 1912, "Strength for Structural Timbers."
EXHIBIT F.
SUMMARY OF REPLIES RECEIVED IN ANSWER TO CIRCULAR REGARDING SIZE OF CROSS
TIES REQUIRED FOR THE STRESSES TO WHICH THEY ARE SUBJECTED.
Name of Railroad.
American Creosoting Co
A.T.&S.F
B.&O
B. AO
B.& A
C.&E.I
C. &N. W
C. B. &Q
C. R. I. &P
C.R.I.&P
C. R. R. of N.J
D. &R. G
E.P.&S. W
G.T
I.C
K.&M
L.S.&M.S
L.V
Officer and Title.
A. L. Kuehn,
General Superintendent
R. J. Arey,
Engineer Grand Di-
vision.
E. Stimson,
Chief Engineer Mainte-
nance of Way.
A. W. Thompson,
General Manager.
Moses Burpee,
Chief Engineer.
L. C. Hartley,
Chief Engineer.
C. L. Ransom,
Res. Engineer.
G. H. Bremner,
District Engineer.
J. M. Brown,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
Garrett Davis,
Superintendent.
Jos. O. Osgood,
Chief Engineer.
A. O. Ridgway,
Asst. Ch. Eng.
J. L. Campbell,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way,
M. S. Blaiklock,
Eng. M. Way.
D. W. Thrower,
Roadmaster.
R. P. Black,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
Sam'l Rockwell,
Chief Engineer.
E. B. Ashby,
Chief Engineer.
Mile-
age.
10208
4724
628
966
8020
670
2778
902
4757
2245
175
1663
1432
1
What percentage of a
rail length should have a
bearing on the ties?
It is not proper to state
rail length should ha
This depends on sub-soil
and weight of rail.
40 per cent
36 per cent, for oak and
other ties of similar
crushing strength.
Same all through, as
No. 2.
About 30 per cent
40 per cent
No data.
40 per cent
40 per cent. The reason
I think it is 40 per cent,
is that is about as
many ties as can be
reasonably put under the
rail.
40 per cent
41 per cent. This is
based on the use of 18
ties per 33-ft. rail. Face
of ties 9 in.
Probably 40 to 45 per
cent.
We have 40 per cent. . .
45 per cent
35 per cent, to 40 per
cent.
50 per cent
45 per cent
40 per cent, at least.. . .
la
Does per cent, meai
per cent, of linear dis
tance or bearing area?
that a fixed per cent, t
ve a bearing on tiet
, ballast, kind of woo
Linear distance .
Per cent, of linear dii
tance.
Linear distance beat
ing area increased by us
of tie-plates.
Linear distance
Of the linear distanc
or total area of base c
rail.
Linear distance
Linear distance .
Linear distance .
Per cent, linear dis
tance.
Linear distance. . ..
Linear distance
Bearing area
Bearing area
Per cent, of linear diet
ance
Linear distance
312
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Name of Railroad.
L.& A
L.&N
M.C
M. R. &B. T
M.P
N. Y.C.&H. R
N. Y.C.&H. R
N. Y.C.&H. R
N. Y., N. H. 4 H
N.&W
N.4W
Penna. Lines, S. W. System .
Penna. Lines, N. W. System.
P. & R
P.&R
P. &L.E
P.&L.E
Officer and Title.
F. W. Green,
General Manager.
T. Maney.
General Roadmaster
G. F. Black,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
C. H. Fake,
Chief Engineer.
J. R. Leighty,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
J. V. Neubert,
Engineer Track.
Geo. W. Vaughan,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
Geo. W. Kittredge,
Chief Engineer.
H. L. Ripley,
Engineer of Construc-
tion.
C. S. Churchill,
Chief Engineer.
G. W. Merrell,
Assistant to General
Manager.
W. C. Cushing,
Chief Engineer Mainte-
nance of Way.
R. Trimble,
Chief Engineer Mainte-
nance of Way.
R. B. Abbott,
Division Engineer.
F. S. Stevens,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
J. A. Atwood,
Chief Engineer.
Edwin F. Wendt,
Assistant Engineer.
Mile-
age.
260
4590
932
46
•2829
2047
1951
2889
1509
215
1
What percentage of a
rail length should have a
bearing on the ties ?
About 40 per cent. .
40 per cent
33§ per cent
Most of my experien
one kind of timber and
used, and a class of bal
roads, therefore what o
made would not be of
Cannot answer this
question definitely. See
below.
From J to i
The answers to No. 1
bit on the spacing of the
trains, and whether or
course it is assumed that
as loblolly, cypress,
plated in all main
45 per cent
It seems to me the
questions is almost a ma
ment or experiment on a
piece of track under the
tory expert.
36.4 per cent
40 per cent, without
tie-plates: 30 per cent
on plates.
41 per cent....
See No. 3.
About 40 per cent.
30 per cent, to 35 per
cent.
45 percent
Some time ago the
New York Central Lines
Maintenance of Way
Committee recommend-
ed that 45 per cent, of the
length of the rail should
be supported by cross-
ties. This means 45 per
cent, of the linear dis-
tance.
la
Does per cent, mean
per cent, of linear dis-
tance or bearing area ?
Linear distance
Linear distance
Linear distance
ce has been where but
one size of tie has been
last used on but few
bservations I may have
general value.
Linear distance .
Bearing area .
and No. la depend a good
tie, axle load, speed of
not ties are tie-plated. Of
all soft wood ties, such
cedar, etc., will be tie-
tracks.
Per cent, of length of
rail.
answer to most of your
tter of laboratory experi-
n especially prepared
observation of a labora-
L in ear distance.
Linear distance .
Linear distance .
There is no difference.
Linear distance
Linear distance
Linear distance
313
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
d
a
Name of Railroad.
Officer and Title.
Mile-
age.
1
What percentage of a
rail length should have a
bearing on the ties?
la
Does per cent, meat
per cent, of linear dia
tance or bearing area?
IS
Q., M. & S
F. D. Anthony,
Chief Engineer.
S. B. Rice,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
R. Budd,
Chief Engineer.
W. F. Purdy,
Chief Engineer.
J. Carmichael,
Engineer Maintenance
of Way.
192
89
433
64
548
43 percent
Ifi
R., F. &P
Not less than 34 per
cent.
Approximately 40 per
cent.
36 per cent, to 40 per
cent.
35 per cent
Linear distance. . . ..i
w
8., P.&S
Linear distance 1
38
W.-P. T
W. M
Bearing area, but witl
full face ties should b
same for both.
Linear distance, 90-lb
rail A. S. C, E, section.
Total replies received, 40. Per cent, of
membership, 4 per cent.
Per cent, of mileage, 32.
83644
Has this percentage any relation to
(a)
Kind of timber used
for ties?
(b)
Kind of ballast?
(c)
Character of sub-grade?
(d)
Tangent vs. Curve?
le)
Minimum distance be
tween face of ties?
Yes, there should be
sufficient ties ao that the
wood will not be stressed
beyond a proper work-
ing limit.
Yes
Yes, the distributing
power of the ballast will
affect the number of
ties to be used.
Yes.
Yes, the sustaining
power of the sub-grade
will affect the proper
number of ties to be used.
Yes.
Yes, sufficient ties
should be used to take
care of the excess load-
ing at curves.
Six inches.
Yes, it is dependent
upon strength of timber.
Tie-plates should be used
distribute the load
upon the ties made from
weaker woods.
No, use practically
only soft woods. Mostly
white cedar, and classi-
fication would be im-
possible.
No
Yes, inasmuch
stone ballast has greater
carrying capacity and is
less inclined to motion
under load and impact,
the percentage may be
less than it would be
with gravel or sand.
It may vary with the
bearing capacity of sub-
grade.
No.
Yes
Practically none .
Twelve inches.
Yes, dependent upon
material used for ballasl
and its liability ti
motion.
Usually slightly in-
creased on curves.
Ten inches.
No.
No.
No.
Yes.
Inferior ballast should
have greater bearing.
Yielding a u b-g r a d e
should have greater
bearing.
Greater bearing sur-
face needed on curves.
Eight inches...
Twelve inches.
314
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Has this percentage any relation to
(a)
Kind of timber used
for ties?
This percentage has no
or the alinement.
(bl
Kind of ballast?
relation to the timber in
No.
Practically not, be
cause spacing of ties is
fixed by other condi-
tions.
To some extent .
No, we are using prin-
cipally treated pine ties
None
Not if tie-plates are
used of proper width and
length. If tie-plates are
not used, very soft ties
should be placed close
together.
Good hardwood tim-
ber ties.
It applies to standard
conditions for each
particular piece of main
track, which may vary
with character of busi-
ness done over that
track.
No
Yes, based on white
oak ties, 6x8x8. Per
cent, should vary in-
versely as resistance of
wood to crushing.
(c)
Character of sub-grade?
the ties, kind of ballast
No.
Practically not, al-
though ties might be
placed closer on gravel or
sand, where tamping is
less difficult than with
stone or slag ballast.
To some extent ....
Rock, slag and gravel.
Gravel .
Yes, number of ties
depends on the efficiency
of gravel. Cementing
gravel and slag require
less bearing area for the
rail.
Stone or gravel
This varies with stand
ard of each particular
piece of main track as
above.
No.
Yes, it should vary in-
versely as the firmness
of the ballast.
(d)
Tangent vs. Curve?
character of sub-grade
No.
Not if ballast is suffi-
ciently deep to properly
transfer weights to sub
grade.
No.
Generally sandy and
gravelly earth and loam
Clay
Yes.
Average earth .
This also varies as per
No.
Yes, same as for bal-
last.
(e)
Minimum distance be-
tween face of ties?
The minimum dis
tance between the face ol
ties is about 12 in. and
this necessarily cannot be
very much less as if nar-
rower than that it would
interfere with the use ol
the shovel in taking care
of the ballast, and the
width of the shovel is
about 10 in. Apparently
this would look as
though the minimum
distance between ties at
the present day is deter-
mined by the width of
the shovel. I do not
believe, however, the
standard on this railroad
differs materially from
that on other roads, and
if ties were placed much
closer together it would
be difficult to tamp the
ballast under them.
No Thirteen inches
Yes, but impracticable
to make such change on
account of tamping re
quirements.
Yea.
No distinction .
Both.
Percentage should be
increased on curves.
Both.
We use same number
of ties for rail on tangents
as on curves.
No Maximum. 13VS in
Joints 9 in. Inter-
mediate 13 in.
Yes.
Eleven inches.
Ten inches.
Ten inches .
Ten inches .
See standard blue print
attached and marked
F-l."
Not for curves of less
than 8 or 10 degrees.
Yes, inversely as
thickness of tie.
315
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Has this percentage any relation to
(a)
Band of timber used
for ties ?
No, because it is the
maximum bearing area
that admits proper
tamping.
Strictly with regard to
stresses, yes.
Yes, resistance of tim-
ber to cutting is big
factor.
No, if tie-plates are
used, otherwise percent-
age would vary with
hardness of ties.
We use only hardwood
ties and above data
refer to them.
White oak.
No. Tie spacing lim-
ited by minimum dis
tance between face of
ties required for tamp
ing.
Based on sawed ties
(yellow pine).
No, because no greater
percentage can be used
without too much en-
croachment on room
needed for tamping. If
ties are soft use larger
tie-plates.
No, for reason under
Greater bearing sur-
face probably needed
in soft ballast.
Do not think this is a
factor as far as ties only
are concerned.except that
wave motion of rail and
consequent rail cutting
of ties vary with differ-
ent kinds of ballast.
Independent of kind of
ballast, provided it is
first-class and is suffi-
cient in quantity.
No.
Our road has used
nothing but white oak
timber in the past.
(b)
Kind of ballast?
No, for reason under
Greater bearing sur-
face probably needed
in soft sub-grade.
Same as b
Stone,
cinder.
slag, gravel,
Stone or coarse gravel
No. See a.
No.
Less ties might be
used on stone ballast of
great depth, but where
these conditions prevai
traffic is generally so
heavy that full comple-
ment of ties is needed
No
Stone ballast is used.
(O
Character of sub-grade ?
Not if ballast of suffi-
cient quantity and
quality is used.
Existing sub-grade is
now generally old bal-
last.
No. See a.
No.
Bearing surface not
affected, but if sub-
grade is hard less depth
of ballast is permis-
sible.
No.
No.
No.
The sub-grade is 3 ft.
below top of rail and this
3 ft. is made up of track
one foot, ballast one foot,
sub-ballast one foot. Our
road uses 20 ft. roadbed,
10 ft. on each side of cen-
ter line, in accordance
with the standard of the
Engineering Association.
No.
(d)
Tangent vs. Curve?
(e)
Minimum distance be
tween face of ties ?
No, for reason under
No.
Increased tendency of
rail to cut ties on curve
as compared to tangent
would require more ties
on curves than tangents
to maintain same con-
ditions.
With proper elevation
bearing on curve and
tangent should be treat-
ed the same.
We make no distinc-
tion except to use tie-
plates on curves.
Both
No. See a.
Yes, because it leave
the minimum space be
tween ties within whicl
proper tamping may tx
done.
Greater bearing sur
face probably needec
with thin ties.
Depending on ballas
and roadbed and kirn
and size of^ties.
No Thirteen inches
About 7 in.
Joint ties 10 in., in
termediate ties 12 in.
Ten inches.
Yes. This is the gov
erning point.
If superelevation of
curves is adjusted to
speed, centrifugal force
and gravity are in equi-
librium and bearing sur-
face^should not be chang-
ed.
No.
We make no difference
in the spacing of ties on
tangent or curves. All
track is treated the same
No.
Ten inches.
There should not b
less than 10 in.
The distance betwee
face of cross-ties is 12 ii
We think this distant
gives an opportunity ft
tamping with a tampis
pick and our present ru!
is to space ties 12 ij
apart, which meal
about 20 - in. center
The 45 per cent, rule
not carried out absolut
ly. Ties spaced 12 i
apart are practically
accordance with tl
spirit of this rule.
Eleven inches
316
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Has this percentage any relation to
(a)
Kind of timber used
for ties?
(b)
Kind of ballast?
(c)
Character of sub-grade?
(d)
Tangent vs. Curve?
feO
Minimum distance be-
tween face of ties?
Certainly. It would
depend entirely on class
of timber used. For
soft woods per cent, of
bearing should be in-
creased if tie-plates are
not used.
No
Yes, the less bearing
properties the ballast
has the greater the
per cent, of supported
rail length should be.
No.
Yes. In rock cuts,
hard clay, etc., bearing
per cent, can be at
a minimum of 34 per
cent.; on wet, soft road-
bed, bearing per cent,
should be increased.
No
The bearing surface
should be increased on
curves exceeding a 3
degree.
No.
18 ties and 17 spaces
to 33-ft. rail.
No.
Probably some advan-
tage from larger bear-
ing area on soft ties,
but not in same ratio.
Poor ties make poor
track, no matter how
many be used.
No. Tie-plates are
used on soft woods.
Some advantage from
high-grade ballast with
wide spacing of ties,
but much greater benefit
derived from good bal-
last if full bearing surface
be provided at same
time.
No
Yes; with uniformly
good, firm sub-grade,
smaller per cent, of
bearing surface may be
provided.
No.
Higher per cent, on
curves especially of short
radius, more on account
of gain in holding aline-
ment than for bearing.
No. Hardwood ties
and tie-plates used on
curve.
Twelve inches; less
will interfere with tamp-
ing.
Fifteen inches.
If the percentage is
capable of mathematical
deduction, please give
the method.
Is crushing hastened
by natural checking of
ties ?
What class of wood
checks most?
Does preservative
treatment tend to in-
crease the tendency to
check?
Does preservative
treatment affect the nat-
ural crushing unit stress-
No, excepting very
crudely.
Yes, the crushing
strength across the grain
is reduced by checking.
To a large extent .
Yes.
Wood which seasons
rapidly usually checks
the most; wood like
beech and gum will
check more than oak.
Hardwood; in oak,
ash, elm, eucalyptus.
Red oak family, gum,
beech, chestnut and
other inferior woods.
Not when wood is air-
seasoned and treated
without steaming. If
wood is steamed in
treatment, checking will
usually be more rapid.
No
Based on 20-fix8 ties to
33-ft. rail and 18-7x9
ties to 33-ft. rail.
We do not find check-
ing of ties to any extent.
Believe checked ties
would naturally crush
more easily than solid
timber.
Yes, by allowing de-
cay to start.
In these woods natu-
rally liable to checking in
seasoning the use of salt
sol u t i o n preservative
likely increases the tend-
ency to check.
Are not treating ties to
any extent.
Have not noticed that
treatment by creosote
has any great effect in
this way, but believe
that checking is in-
creased when timber is
treated by the zinc chlo-
ride process.
Not if wood is air-
seasoned for treatment
and not steamed.
Yes, should be deter-
mined by actual tests.
No apparent difference
between treated and un-
treated timber.
Have been advised by
the track supervisors
that they believe the
creosote treatment has a
tendency to soften the
wood and make it more
easily crushed. Have
not confirmed this, and
am unable to express a
conclusion.
Yes.
317
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
If the percentage is
capable of mathematica
deduction, please give
the method.
Is crushing hastened
by natural checking of
ties?
What class of wood Does preservative
checks most? .treatment tend to in-
crease the tendency to
check?
Does preservath
treatment affect the na
ural crushing unit stress
es? ~
I do not think this per-
centage is capable
mathematical deduc-
tion, there being too
many indeterminate fac-
tors. Further more,
within a few years a
great many of our ties
become so deteriorated
they do not retain, by a
large percentage , the
same efficiency in sup-
porting the rail that they
do when new.
18 tics per 30-ft. rail is
about right for proper
tamping.
Too many theoret-
ically indeterminate fac-
tors to reduce to a
forma a.
Do not consider the
matter capable of math-
ematical deduction.
Crushing is no doubt
hastened by natural
checking of ties.
Hardwood checks
more readily than soft
Yes.
Yes.
Probably only in so far
as checking hastens de
cay.
Apparently so, espe-
cially over-treated tie;
where the wood has been
steamed too much and
zinc chloride used.
No.
Yellow pine, untreated
(oak, chestnut and yel
low pine in use).
Have not had experi
ence with all classes of
wood.
Pine ties over- treated,
s per No. 4.
Red oak .
Yes, checking allows
ties to disintegrate fas-
ter, consequently has
tens crushing.
Yes
Beech, oak, gum,
maple, walnut, locust.
Elm.
Problem too much
complicated by inde-
pendent variables.
Need all the ties under
a rail that can be used
and leave room for prop-
er tamping. No mathe-
matics used to deter-
mine this.
Too many i n t e r d e-
pendent variables to
attempt it.
Not unless checks
come close to edge.
No.
Yes.
Beech, maple, hick-
ory.
All hardwoods check,
beech, birch and maple
the worst.
Post oak worse than
white oak. In general,
wood with highest
moisture ratio checks
the most.
Treated ties have a
greater tendency to
check than untreated
ties.
No.
No.
I am not prepared 1
say whether treated ti<
are capable of sustainii
less unit crushing strei
than untreated ties. Aj
parently, the wood :
rendered somewha
more brittle by treatinj
No, think not, b(
never tested it.
Slightly, if at all.
I understand it does,
but cannot speak from
personal observation.
Zinc chloride and high
temperatures naturally
increased the checking
of our pine ties. We now
use creosote only with
out steaming and this
diminishes checking.
No.
Yes, to great extent,
beech and red oak ties
Lessens check.
The checking occurs
while ties are seasoning
and so before treatment
No, ordinarily, but if
heavily steamed; under
old process, yes.
Do not believe it does.
Have made no tests.
Apparently it does, ah
diminishes holding po»
er of driven spikes.
Yes, some processe
particularly ereosot
oils.
Yes, but to small e
tent, varying with diffe
ent types of treatment.
No
Preservative t r e a
ment softens the tii
while the ties are w*
from the treatment, i
they crush more easi
until they become dr;
No
Believe it somewh
decreases elastic limit
compression, especial
in loblolly and yelk
pine ties.
318
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
If the percentage is
capable of mathematical
deduction, please give
the method.
Is crushing hastened
by natural checking of
ties ?
What class of wood
checks most?
Does preservative
treatment tend to in-
crease the tendency to
check?
"Does preservative
treatment affeot the nat-
ural crushing unit stress-
Cannot be mathemat
ically deduced because
of the widely different
character of sub-grade,
ballast, stiffness of rail,
weight of loa"ds, etc.
Percentage given is a
matter of personal judg-
ment and observation
only.
I think the considera-
tion should start from
the roadbed and the
traffic to carry and the
kind (size) of rail to
carry it, to get the maxi-
mum carrying capacity
of track; the wheel load
should be distributed
uniformly over the road-
bed. This involves a
relation between dis-
tance between ties and
depth of ballast. The
proper relation is the one
which will give uniform
distribution at the least
cost for investment and
maintenance and is de-
pendent upon the relation
of cost of ties and ballast
Yes, directly by the
separation of the fiber,
and indirectly by decay,
which follows.
Yes.
I think so.
Of those within ray
knowledge, oaks.
Our experience is al
most wholly with cedar.
Do not know.
Think not.
Possibly creosote soft-
ens the wood.
Practically no expe
rience with treated ties
Zinc treatment seems
Yes.
The majority of our
ties used are yellow pine,
and they check.
The percentage is a
matter of experience and
experiment rather than
mathematical deduc-
tion.
We have given above
our general practice,
which has proved suc-
cessful.
I believe it is.
We think not mate-
rially in hardwood ties.
The harder class of
oaks would, in my opin-
ion, check most.
Chestnut, of which we
use very few.
We have only been
using treated ties to any
extent for two years, so
cannot give satisfactory
reply. If properly treat
ed and a suitable tie
plate to provide for
mechanical wear, I
should think the check
ing would be decreased
This will also answer
No. 7.
I do not know ....
We have not had ex-
perience with treated
ties.
Somewhat.
Yes
Soft
Do not know.
Not with creosote,
unless excessive steam
pressures are used. The
sine chloride process
probably increases tend-
ency to check, as it
increases the moisture
content of the wood.
Do not know.
Answered by No.
I do not know.
No data.
Decreases crushing
strength but very little
unless excessive heating
takes place in the treat-
ment.
319
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
If the percentage is
capable of mathematical
deduction, please give
the method.
Is crushing hastened
by natural checking of
ties?
What class of wood
checks most?
Does preservative
treatment tend to
crease the tendency to ural crushing unit stress-
check? es?
Does preservative
treatment affect the nat-
Percentage of bearing
dependent on tie
spacing, which must be
such as to permit of
tamping. On the Penn-
sylvania Lines we use 18
ties to a 33-ft. rail, which
gives a distance face to
face of ties of 14J^ in.
This gives (with 8-in.ties)
36.3 per cent, of base
bearing on ties.
Clearance needed for
tamping is the determin
ing factor. This space
between ties should be
made as small as pos-
sible.
Conditions vary
through wide range. No
mathematical deduc-
tions can be of much
value.
We have no evidence
that it is.
Not to any great ex-
tent.
Of woods now used
extensively by the Penn-
sylvania Lines, i. e., oak
and yellow pine, oak
checks most. Chestnut,
formerly used extensive-
ly, checks more than
oak.
We use pine, oak and
chestnut; oak checks the
most.
No.
No.
No; it decreases it.
Checking permits en
trance of moisture that
causes decay and there-
fore hastens crushing.
Yellow pine
No.
Don't know.
Don't know.
It is probable that this
percentage was not
worked out mathemat
ically and no doubt it
represents about the
maximum amount of
timber which can be
used under rails in order
to leave sufficient open-
ing between the ties to
give the trackman prop-
er opportunity to success-
fully tamp the ballast
with tamping picks.
Basis of 7-in. x 9-in. ties
on the fiat and 12-in.
working room between
ties.
We have noticed little
or no crushing where
white oak ties are used.
No answer is given
because our experience
has been confined to
the use of white oak
ties.
No
Have no method ex
cept observation, ex
perience, and results of
both.
33-ft. rail equals 396
inches long, 17 ties per
rail with 8-in. face 136
in., percentage .344.
Yes. Particularly as
checking hastens decay
To a very small ex-
tent.
Yea.
Not appreciably
good white oak. It is,
to some extent, in soft or
unsound woods.
(Experience in the soft
northern timber only.)
My experience has only
been with chestnut,
white and post oak; of
these three, chestnut has
the greatest tendency to
check.
Don't know
Whether preservatives
increase the tendency to
check is the question
which we cannot answer,
because in the past
treated ties have not
been used.
Not enough experience
Fir.
Hard, tough-grained
wood.
The wood is usuallj
made softer by the
preservatives to a depth
of about K in. to % in
The net resistance t<
crushing is thereby re-
duced and the unit stress
increased.
It prevents checking
and therefore increase
resistance to crushing t<
some extent.
Don't know.
See No. 6...
Not enough experience Not enough experiene
to permit of reply for to permit of reply fo
favorable comparison, favorable comparison.
Can't say. No ex-
Derience.
Yes.
Have not sufficient
experience to state; do
not think so.
No experience with
preservatives.
Lessens unit crushin
stresses.
320
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
8a
With the increased
consumption and the
decreased available sup-
ply, can the demand for
large sectional area of
ties be met?
8b
If a large sectional area
of tie is not available,
what would you recom-
mend as next best thing
to do, use steel, or com-
posite, or what not?
Has the application of
screw or square spikes
any effect on crushing?
Relation of kinds of
ballast to tie-crushing.
Relation of character
of sub-grade to tie-crush-
ing.
It may bo met in terri-
tories where tie-making
has not yet become a
large industry. It will be
difficult when all present
tie sizes are well estab-
lished.
Demand can be met
for a number of years.
The decreased pro-
duction which is indi-
cated by United States
forest service reports is
due to diminished sup-
ply and indicates that it
will be difficult to secure
a requisite number of ties
of larger sectional area.
Not without a radical
change in practice or
price.
Probably locally but
not generally for many
Yes, as it is counter-
balanced by increase of
timber preservation.
I do not believe we can
demand a larger section-
al area per tie, as the cost
per tie is increased, not
oaly by the additional
size of the tie, but by the
additional cost for hand-
ling and applying, and
increased amount of
ballast (if tie is length-
ened).
The present wood tie
sections are sufficient if
used in the proper num-
ber to give proper bear-
ing, which is entirely
feasible. Ballast depth
must, however, be much
increased. It is feasible
and within limits of
proper economy to place
enough 6'x8*i8' wood
ties under track to prop-
erly sustain axle ioads,
which the present kind
of steel rail will sustain
(per wheel) without ex-
cessive flowing.
Use reinforced con-
crete or steel.
As a first resort,
ties spaced narrowly.
I do not think a satis-
factory substitute for
wood has been brought
out, but I think a com-
posite tie using wood
cushion for rail will be
necessary.
Believe this is a ques-
tion that will have to
be solved soon, but so
far as my knowledge
goes, a solution has not
yet been found. Appar-
ently the practice of
treating ties will con-
serve the available tim
ber supply, at least tern
porarily.
It is available at the
present time.
I do not believe we are
prepared to give up yet
the use of the wood tie
and adopt one of some
other material, but by
the use of heavier rail
and tie-plates we can
still continue to use the
ties that we have, re-
ducing the number to the
rail by one or two if rail
of 100 lbs. or greater
weight per yard is used.
Greater care should be
exercised in the applying
of ties and applying of
tie-plates, and I think
holes should be bored
even for the insertion of
square spikes, all of
which will tend to in-
crease the life of the tie.
If the rail is held close-
ly to the tie, wearing or
crushing is reduced. The
only means of doing this
is to use screw spikes.
Ballast which is firm
and drains quickly and
which allows only a
small amount of motion
will reduce crushing.
Dry timber is stronger
in resisting crushing than
wet timber.
Same as No. 10.
Have no data for com-
parison.
Screw spikes properly
driven or used with
threaded plugs would
preserve the wood fiber
and naturally tend in
some degree to increase
crushing strength.
Have data available
but think that the more
yielding materials have
less tendency to tie-
crushing.
Stone ballast with its
greater bearing capacity
reduces impact and con-
sequently also reduces
tendency to crush. Grav
el and other ballast
composed of small pieces
tend to increase the load
and further tie-crushing,
The better the sub-
grade, the less the ties
have tendency to crush.
This relation would be
similarly indicated by
a variation in bearing
capaoity of sub-grade.
Naturally, yes; but
cannot say from experi-
ence as to the compara-
tive effects of the two
kinds of spikes; would
suppose it preferable to
use screw spikes, and it
is not necessary to re-
drive them so often,
thereby not breaking
up the fiber and spike-
killing the tie.
Crushing is probably
greater in stone and slag
ballast than in gravel
and other lighter bal-
lasts, on account of the
more rigid tamping.
The character of the
sub-grade would evi-
dently have an effect
upon tie-crushing, since
a hard sub-grade with
rigid ballast would give
greater crushing stress
with the impact.
We
spikes
have no screw
in this territory.
The most severe crush-
ing in my experience has
been in gravel ballast,
but that was due to the
frequency of passenger
trains and heavy freight
traffic, which are the
greatest factors in crush-
ing of ties. I would not
put this forward, how-
ever, as an opinion that
gravel is more severe
than other ballast on
ties.
The life of tie is in-
creased by having better
ballast, and, necessarily,
better ballast follows
if there is a good sub-
grade.
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
With the increased
consumption and the
decreased available sup-
ply, can the demand for
large sectional area of
ties be met ?
No.
No.
In my opinion it can
be met for some years to
come.
Yes, by consuming the
supply proportionately
faster.
Yes, by reducing
thickness and increasing
stability of tie-plate.
In my opinion, yes.
Yes.
Increasingly harder to
get large ties.
No.
Do not think it prac-
ticable.
8b
If a large sectional area
of tie is not available,
what would you recom-
mend as next best thing
to do, use steel, or com
posite or what not?
Can't say
Use heavier rail with
tie-plates of ample size
and thickness on all ties.
Adapt the number of ties
to suit the weight of
the rail section as far as
limitations of tie spacing
will permit.
Neither a steel nor
composite tie has been
found which will entire-
ly meet all requirements.
Believe energies should
be directed t o w a r d s
design of a composite
tie.
Am decidedly of the
opinion that the coming
tie will be a steel or
iron tie. Do not expect
to see concrete come
into general use.
Use steel
Do not consider time
has arrived for elimina-
tion of wooden ties.
Steel.
Tie-plates and more
ties.
Use more ties .
Doubt if any substi-
tute will ever be found
for wood ties. Steel O.
K. in certain special
cases. I think ties will
be imported sometime
from South America,
Africa, etc.
Has the application of
screw or square spikes
any effect on crushing '?
Not that I know.
Square spikes injure
the fiber of the wood
and therefore promote
softening around the rail-
seat which reaches out
under the entire base of
the rail, promoting de
cay and crushing.
Have had no experi-
ence with screw spikes,
but believe screw spikes
would possess some ad
vantages in this respect.
Don't know.
Relation of kinds of
ballast to tie-crushing.
Yes, by reducing the
sawing motion between
rail and tie.
No experience with
them. My opinion is
that screw spikes would
appreciably reduce
crushing.
On account of destroy
ing more or less fiber
structure it should slight-
ly increase crushing.
No experience .
Do not think effect
would be perceptible.
322
Doubtless contributes
to some extent to tie-
crushing, but the differ-
ence in this respect be-
tween various kinds of
ballast is not great.
Have no definite rec-
ords.
Have observed no re-
lation.
Relation of character
of sub-grade to tie-crush-
ing.
A poorly drained and
soft sub-grade is injurious
in permitting move-
ment of the ballast.
With proper depth and
character of ballast, can-
not see any relation.
Would not expect ties
to crush much on soft
Missouri mud.
Ties crush more in
rock slag and cementing
gravel than in loose or
other classes.
Stone first, hard slag
and cinders given in
order of ballast that
gives most tie-crushing
The better the ballast
the less crushing will
occur.
The less elastic the
ballast the more the
ties will crush; also the
firmest ballast and the
higher the section of rail
the faster the rail will
wear down and this
must be met by harden-
ing the steel in the rail in
proportion to increase in
stiffness of rail section.
In general, the crush-
ing should vary directly
as the axle load, the
rigidity of the ballast
and sub-grade and as the
rail deflection.
The more resilient the
sub-grade the less ties
crush .
The better sub-grade
the less tie-crushing.
The better the sub-
grade the less crushing
of ties.
Ties will crush easier
on rock sub-grade,
especially where ballast
cushion is insufficient.
See No. 10.
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
With the increased
consumption and the
decreased available sup
ply, can the demand for
large sectional area of
ties be met?
Think not, economic
ally.
Hardly.
For a time, yes, until
it commences to affect
the lumber output; even
then it is only a question
of price.
The demand for wood-
en ties cannot be met,
unless ties suitable for
treating are available
This is purely a matter
of dollars and cents;
large ties can undoubted-
ly be obtained if it is
worth the additional
cost involved.
We think ties having a
face width of from 7 in.
to 9 in., thickness cf 7 in.,
length of 8 ft. 6 in. .spaced
18 to a 33-ft. rail, joint
ties 17 in. c. to c, in-
termediate 24 in. c. to
c, with tie-plates for
heavy loads and traffic,
are sufficient, and such
are procurable.
Yes, by treating soft
ties.
Probably not; at least
not for an unlimited
length of time.
8b
If a large sectional area
of tie is not available,
what would you recom-
mend as next best thing
to do, use steel, or com-
posite or what not?
Use a plate large
enough to distribute the
load and of such con-
struction to permit the
readjustment of the rail
without disturbing the
initial seat of plate on
the tie.
Would recommend
using the area that is
available and do not
Has the application of
screw or square spike
any effect on crushing?
Think the displace-
ment of any part of the
wood under or about
the rail tends to weaken.
We use no screw-
spikes; square spikes
where used in skimming
know yet what to recom-, as much as necessary in
mend as a substitute. I some cases increase tend-
ency to crush.
Do not think the size
of tie is a factor, except
as to thickness. I think
the bearing area on road
beds and rail is the only
thing to consider, and
this is controlled by
distance between ties
Use steel or tie of some
other composition of
permanent construction
that is to take care
of our side-track needs.
The operation of trains
under high speed in
various weather con-
ditions, etc., will not
permit the use of above
tie with safety.
Am open to conviction.
I have not seen any
tie for substitution for
wood that I can uncon
ditionally approve.
We have not investi-
gated other than wood
ties.
Composite.
Do not know.
Have not been used
sufficient length of time
to determine. If proper-
ly supplied with tie-
plates, I think the
crushing would be less.
Probabl3' the crushing
would be greater with
spike than screw because
of more vertical move-
ment after having been
in use a short time.
No data.
Relation of kinds of
ballast to tie crushing.
Not with tie-pin tes
of proper width and
thickness.
Indirectly, yes. The
cutting and disruption
of the fibers of the wood
by the spikes opens up
wood and hastens pro-
cess of decay, which
reduces crushing resist-
ance and facilitates the
mechanical wear of the
wood. Square spike has
much greater effect than
screw spike.
Hard, unyielding bal-
last increases tendency
to crush.
Think it worse in soft
ballast due to greater
wave motion of rail.
If this includes break-
ing, the' softer the road-
bed or ballast, the great-
er the tendency to break;
the harder the ballast,
the greater the tendency
to break.
Ties crush or check
under stone ballast with
the same traffic as under
cinders, gravel, etc.
This on account of track
being more rigid. This
on the assumption that
all the ballast mentioned
above has good drain-
age. This also answers
No. 11.
I believe a good gravel
ballast is better than a
tone ballast to reduce
the tie-crushing.
Our ties are removed
on account of decay,
rather than crushing or
cutting. Cutting of ties
is kept down by use of
tie-plates. And we think
there is not much varia-
tion due to ballast.
Relation of character
of sub-grade to tie crush-
ing.
Same as of ballast.
Think it worse in soft
sub-grade due to in-
creased wave motion of
rail.
Same as No. 10.
Answered by No. 10.
The harder the sub-
grade, the greater would
naturally be the crushing
tendency. With suffi-
cient ballast the effect of
sub-grade upon crushing
can be eliminated.
Very remote with fair
ballasted track.
The more rigid and un-
yielding the ballast, the
greater the tie crushing
Tie-crushing is greater,
therefore, under stone
ballast than under grav-
el.
The more yielding and
elastic the sub-grade,
the more give there is
to the tie, resulting in
less tie crushing.
323
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
With the increased
consumption and the
decreased available sup-
ply, can the demand for
large sectional area of
ties be met?
8b
If a large sectional area
of tie is not available,
what would you recom-
mend as next best thing
to do, use steel, or com-
posite or what not?
Has the application of
screw or square spikes
any effect on crushing?
Relation of kinds of
ballast to tie-crushing.
Relation of character
of sub-grade to tie crush-
ing.
30
No. We have diffi-
culty in getting ties of
our present standard
cross-section, i. e.,
7 in. by 8 in.
No
I think not.
No.
Not ready to answer.
Would recommend
some form of steel tie
having wood insets for
rail-bearing surface, wood
insets to be deep enough
to hold screw spikes.
Use tie-plates not less
than | in. thick and 10 in.
long to cover entire face.
Use preservative process
on all timber in track and
steel or composite ties
(where conditions make
their use economical.
Treat ties and prevent
destruction from wear
by use of properly de-
signed tie-plates of suffi-
cient area and proper
No.
Screw spikes decrease
the crushing, as they
do not work out of
place as readily as
square spikes. They
hold the rail down
against the tie and
eliminate much of the
mpact.
Experience not suffi-
cient to give definite
answer.
If all ties are equally
tamped, so that support
is the same, kind of
ballast does not affect
crushing.
Less crushing on ash
ballast than on stone and
the former is preferable
on roads of light tonnage.
On roads of heavy ton-
nage the additional
tamping required on ash
ballast would more than
offset the increased
crushing if stone ballast
were used, so far as life
of tie is concerned.
The more unyielding
the bed the sooner the
ties crush. Therefore,
ties crash earlier in stone
than in any othei kind
of ballast.
No relation, provided
ties are equally tamped.
More crushing on rigid
sub-grade, except where
sub-grade is so soft that
track is in poor surface
most of the time.
Having traveled over
the timber country
which now supplies the
cross-ties of this section
of the country, it is my
opinion that any demand
for larger sectional area
of ties cannot be granted.
A standard tie at the
present time is practi-
cally 7 in. thick by 8. in.
face. A very few ties
of larger area. can be
secured.
No.
This is a difficult
question to answer, un-
less one has had a long
experience in the use of
steel and composite ties.
At the present time the
P. & L. E. R. R. Co. is
experimenting with both
steel and composite
cross-ties. Steel cross-
ties have been in use four
years. Composite ties
have been under test
during a similar period,
but not one design has
continued in use for
this length of time.
All experience shows
that any opinion re-
specting the merits of
steel and composite ties
is more or less worthless,
unless based on an
experience of a mini-
mum of 10 years. It
is practically certain that
the railroad will be
forced to use other than
wooden ties in the future,
and good judgment re-
quires that the railroads
begin at once to experi-
ment with both steel and
composite cross-ties,
am satisfied that both of
these forms will be
largely used in the future,
but would not hazard a
definite opinion at the
present time. More ex-
perience is necessary in
order to develop the
data whioh should form
the basis of an opinion
No experience,
think not.
We
We have not noticed
any crushing of white
oak ties.
See No. 10.
324
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
8a
With the increased
consumption and the
decreased available sup-
ply, can the demand for
large sectional area of
ties be met?
8b
If a large sectional area
of tie is not available,
what would you recom-
mend as next best thing
to do, use steel, or com-
posite or what not?
Has the application of
screw Or square spikes
any effect on crushing?
Relation of kinds of
ballast to tie crushing.
Relation of character
of sub-grade to tie crush-
ing.
Yes.
In my judgment, no. .
Probably a local ques-
tion not serious on West
Coast.
Do not think so.
Not enough experi-
ence.
Would recommend re
inforced concrete, pro-
vided they have a proper
wood cushion.
When ties cannot be
had of 6 in. x 8 in. cross-
section re-inforced, con-
crete or steel ties will
probably have to be
used. By using large
tie-plates and preserv-
ative treatment, 6 in. x
8 in. timber ties can be
made to answer.
No experience with
screw spikes. Every
time a spike is driven
into a tie it cuts fiber,
weakens the tie and
must affect crushing.
No experience
Screw spikes lessen
crushing effect.
Use steel ties.
Have not used screw
spikes.
Improbable.
Use of wood preserva
tive and tie-plates should
be satisfactory for some
years, then develop a
steel tie.
Square spikes effect
not severe especially
with tie-plates.
Have no data on this
or further questions.
The more rigid the
ballast, the greater the
tie-crushing.
Elastic ballast, such as
gravel or zinc tailings,
should lessen crushing.
Ties crush worse
soft, yielding ballast that
permits "working" of
the ties, or very hard,
coarse ballast that is un-
yielding. Good stone or
gravel of uniform charac-
ter, elastic without being
mobile, is best to pre-
vent tie-crushing.
Probably more mark
ed in stone ballast.
The more rigid the
sub-grade, the greater
the crushing, depending
on the ballast.
Well -drained, solid
sub-grade should lessen.
Same as ballast, very
soft or very hard sub-
grade is worse for crush-
ing than medium.
Soft roadbed or badly
surfaced track increases
tie-crushing.
Relation of axle load
to tie-crushing.
13
Relation of frequency
of maximum axle load,
as applied to a tie, to tie-
crushing.
The greater the axle
load the greater the
crushing. Usually the
greater the axle the
greater the speed. There-
fore, increased axle load
increases crushing in
greater proportion than
direct increase in load-
ing.
Increase in proportion
directly as the weight
increases.
14
Relation of maximum
axle load to weight of
rail and consequent tie
crushing.
Frequency of maxi-
mum axle -loads affects
life of ties so far as failure
by crushing is concerned.
The greater the traffic
tho quicker the ties
will crush.
Relation of impact at
joints to tie-crushing.
Stiffness of rail varies
about as square of its
weight. If rail is not
increased to proper size
for maximum load, tie
cutting will increase.
Maximum axle load
has tendency to increase
crushing in direct pro
portion to rail tested.
Relation of size of tie-
plates to crushing of
ties.
Impact at joints causes
increased cutting of joint
ties.
No data, but believe
if joints be kept in per
feet service that ties
will have less tendency
to crush than if allowed
to remain in improper
surface.
Tie-plates should be of
sufficient size to keep
unit crushing force well
within limits of crushing
resistance of the ties.
Any smaller plate than
this will result in ex-
cessive crushing.
Face of tie covered by
tie-plate will give greater
resistance against and
decreases directly in
proportion as size of tie-
plate decreases.
325
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Relation of axle load
to tie-crushing.
13
Relation of frequency
of maximum axle load,
as applied to a tie, to tie-
crushing.
14
IS
Relation of maximum' Relation of impact at
axle load to weight of joints to tie-crushing,
rail and consequent tie-1
crushing.
Relation of size of tie-
plates to crushing of
ties.
Increasing axle loads
necessitates more equi-
table distribution of
loading to avoid crush-
ing of ties.
Believe the crushing
of ties is greater with
heavy axle loading.
This is interdependent
with rail and track
structure. Actual rela-
tion not known.
Believe the crushing
would be greater with
frequency of maximum
axle load.
This is interdependent! The increased impact
with tie and track at joints is responsible
structure. Actual rela- for increase in tie-crush-
tion not known. ing.
The heavier rail would
lessen the crushing effect
under the maximum axle
load.
Crushing increase;
with load.
Increased axle load
and frequency of trains
increases the crushing of
tie. This also applies
to your questions 13 and
14, but the weight of rail,
tie-plates and ballast are
all a factor in the matter;
that is, with heavier rail
and tie-plates and ballast
the tendency of crushing
is very much reduced.
Directly proportional.
Increase of axle load
has direct effect in in-
creasing the crushing of
the ties in direct propor-
tion to the load.
Would say axle load
and stiffness and width
of flange of rail were
much more closely re-
lated than axle load and
tie.
Would expect crushing
to increase with the
load.
No records .
Proportional .
Proportional
Direct proportion
above.
Undoubtedly frequen-
cy of axle load with a
fixed rail section bears
an important part in the
matter of tie-crushing.
Would expect crushing
to bear a fairly distinct
relation to the frequency
of the application.
No records .
Proportional as to load
in inverse proportion as
to rail.
The greater impact of
high speed, compared
with slow speed, would,
I believe, increase the
tendency to crush. This
is probably increased at
the joints, since they are
naturally tamped to a
rigid foundation more
often than other ties.
Crushing increases
with impact.
Crushing of ties at
joints far exceeds that
at any other part of the
rail, but with heavier
rail, etc., suggested
above, the crushing is
lessened.
The tie-plates of great-
er area and thickness re-
duce the tendency to
crushing.
Believe there would be
no great difference in
the amount of crushing
with tie-plates of an
area equal to the bear-
ing which the rail would
have without a plate.
To obtain proper value
from tie-plates, so far as
the crushing is concern-
ed, they should be of
greater area than the
natural rail contact.
Crushing decreases
with larger tie-plates,
which should distribute
load over full face of tie.
I am unable to say
what the size of tie-
plates should be to the
crushing of ties. This
factor is also controlled
by the weight of rail.
Our present practice is
to use a tie-plate which
affords a bearing sur-
face of nearly double
that of the rail on the
tie. These tie-plates
are the same size for 70,
80 and 100 lb. rail, but
the crushing surface
under the 100-lb. rail is
less than under the light-
er rail, as the stresses
are distributed over
more ties.
In proportion to the The crushing is in-
space over which the creased at the receiving
load is distributed by end of the rail,
the rail, treating the,
rail as a girder.
Maximum axle load is
directly related to
weight of rail or vice
versa.
Deep, heavy rails, dis-
tributing the load over
more ties, would nat-
urally decrease the
crushing.
No records .
Wheel blow on rail
end at joint certainly
must have some effect
on crushing of joint ties.
The greater the im-
pact, the greater the
crushing.
No records
Nearly in direct pro-
portion, when the tie-
plates are of sufficient
strength to equally dis-
tribute the load.
Somewhat depends
upon type of plate and
kind of wood.
The larger the plate
the less the crushing.
The greater the bear-
ing surface, the lesser the
crushing.
326
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Relation of axle load
to tie-crushing.
This has important
bearing on tie-crushing.
The more weight con-
centrated at one point
the greater the crushing.
When speed of trains
is same, tie-crushing
should increase some
in proportion to axle
load.
Tie-crushing increases
with axle load.
The heavier the load
the sooner the ties will
crush.
See No. 10.
Crushing effect varies
directly with weight.
Think it greater under
heavy axle load. Have
no exact data.
Cannot answer.
The heavier the axle
load the quicker the
crushing.
13
Relation of frequency
of maximum axle load
as applied to a tie, to tie
crushing.
This varies in direct
proportion.
Quite frequent .
The increasing the
number of maximum
axle loads increases the
crushing.
The more frequently
the load is applied, the
more rapid the effect.
No effect except when
maximum axle load ap-
plied exceeds elastic
limit in compression.
Crushing effect varies
directly with the number
of applications.
Think it greater the
more frequently maxi-
mum axle load is applied
Have no exact data.
Cannot answer.
The greater tonnage
with heavy axle load, of
course, will permit a
horter life and develop
crushing.
Relation of maximum
axle load to weight of
rail and consequent tie
crushing.
Heavier the rail over
more ties is the weight
distributed and conse
quently crushing is re
duced.
The crushing caused
by maximum axle loads
is reduced by increasing
weight of rail.
Use as stiff a rail as
practicable and spread
load over as many ties
as practicable thereby.
See No. 10 and No. 13.
Same as of No. 12,
of course modified by
stiffness of rail.
Greater axle load re-
quires heavier rail to
prevent increased crush-
ing both on account of
wave motion and unit
stresses, but have no
data as to proportion.
Cannot answer.
If the weight of the
rail is lighter than the
axle load, the greater
the motion which affects
the life of tie. Tie-plates
should not be less than
7 in. or more than 8 in.
wide and should be so
made as to make it
a part of the tie and
not the rail. They
should be of such length
as to prevent them
from cutting in, buckling
or allowing rail to roll
out, depending on traffic
which passes over same.
Relation of impact at
joints to tie-crushing.
Impact at joints very
hard on ties, causing
them to crush rapidly
in case joint is not tight
and in good condition
Will increase crushing
very much.
The greater impact
the more crushing of
joint ties will occur.
If joints of insufficient
strength are used, or
they wear out under the
head of the rail, or bolts
are allowed to run loose,
the sooner the ties will
pound out.
See No. 10 and No. 13
Directly as the force
of the impact.
No data.
Cannot answer.,
Relation of size of tie-
plates to crushing of
ties.
Plates should be as
wide as face of tie and
four inches longer than
width of base of rail.
Size of plate has much
to do with crushing.
When tie-plates are
not of sufficient bearing
area, they tend to in-
crease crushing of ties.
Large tie-plates will
reduce crushing.
Use tie-plates prac-
tically full width of face
of tie and as long only
as the strength of the
plate will allow, without
danger of buckling under
the rail.
Crushing varies in-
versely as the area of
tie-plates and its resist-
ance to deformation.
Diminishes as area ol
plate increases.
There is a very pro-
nounced relation which
seems to be that crush-
ing diminishes with in-
crease in size of plate up
to point where plate
buckles or becomes as
wide as the tie.
Cannot answer. Would
favor larger plates as
it seems to better pre-
vent crushing and cutting
the ties.
327
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Relation of axle load
to tie-crushing.
13
Relation of frequency
of maximum axle load,
as applied to a tie, to tie-
crushing.
14
Relation of maximum
axle load to weight of
rail and consequent tie-
crushing.
Relation of impact at
joints to tie-crushing.
Relation of size of tie-
plates to crushing of
ties.
With the same weight
of rail I believe the
tie-crushing is directly
proportional to the axle
load.
Tie cutting, we think,
is proportional to axle
load and density of
traffic, but reduced by
tie-plates.
Unless the maximum
load is applied very
rarely, I should expect
the tie-crushing to be
directly proportional to
the frequency of the
maximum load applica-
tion.
Under the same maxi-
mum load the crushing
should be less as the
weight of the rail in-
creases.
Tie-crushing, I believe,
is directly proportionate
to the amount of impact
at the joints.
Our minimum axle
load on coal, coke and
ore trains is 43,000 lbs.,
maximum 60,000 lbs.
empty cars, 10,000 lbs.
We have not been able
to observe differences,
except as to frequency
of loads.
Tie-crushing varies
directly with axle load.
Tie-crushing increases
with frequency of appli-
cation.
Tie-crushing probably
increases in direct pro-
portion to increase of
axle loads.
Crushing is less where
axle load is less. Flat
wheels naturally do
much more damage
under heavy load than
where load is light.
The N. & W. Ry. is
generally equipped with
85-lb. A. S. C. E. rail
which has given good
service under above
loads: but we expect bet
ter results with the use of
100-lb. A.R.A. "B" type
rail, purchased since
1910.
Less crushing with
heavier weight of rails.
The heavier, and
therefore stiff er, the rail
in proportion to maxi-
mum load, the greater
the distance over which
the rail will distribute
its load. The more
ties the axle load is
carried by, the less the
tie-crushing.
We have secured good
results by the general
use of a rigid joint;
our standard is the
Bonzano. With ties
spaced as above, we
have not observed more
rapid wear on joint ties
than intermediate.
A large, stiff tie-plate
would undoubtedly re-
duce the tie-crushing
to a minimum.
We think this is sub-
stantially proportional.
The effect of impact
at joints is equivalent
to increasing static axle
loads, and will increase
tie-crushing. Crushing
will be greater with
supported joints than
with suspended joints
Tie-crushing probably
increases in a greater
proportion than frequen-
cy of application of
load. That is, if the
frequency of application
is doubled, crushing
is more than doubled,
Exact relation impos-
sible of statement.
Frequency has very
little effect except in the
case of load over flat
wheels. The higher the
speed of trains, the
greater the impact from
flat wheels.
Weight of rail is, of
course, factor of im-
portance. As weight
(and height) of rail
increases, distribution of
load increases; hence
tendency of tie to crush
decreases.
Crushing effect in-
creases directly with the
maximum axle load and
the base area of road
should vary proportion-
ately. The weight of
rail has not kept pace
with the increase in axle
load.
Impact at joint natu
rally increases amount
of crushing.
Less crushing with
increased width of
plate.
To reduce crushing
to a minimum, tie-
plates should be full
width of tie and project
beyond base of rail as
far as depth of tie-plate
will distribute the load.
Non-uniformity in
tamping ties has con-
siderable effect upon the
crushing. A well-tamped
tio adjacent to too
loosely tamped ties in a
very rigid roadbed will
get the maximum crush-
ing.
Crushing decreases as
size of tie-plates
increases.
The crushing at joint
ties is from 50 per cent,
to 75 per cent, more than
at intermediate ties
This increases to about
200 per cent, after the
ties are in track five or
six years.
Tie-plates should be
made as wide as the ties
and extend not more than
3 in. outside the rail.
Tie-plates greatly de-
crease the crushing. In
fact, a tie-plate designed
as above would practi-
cally prevent crushing
altogether.
Plates should be large
enough to prevent cms
ing.
328
EXHIBIT F— Continued.
Relation of axle load
to tie-crushing.
See No. 10.
The greater the axle
load the greater the tie
crushing; depends also
on character of ballast
and sub-grade.
Practically directly in
proportion to axle load-
ing.
The heavier the axle
load the greater the
crushing tendency in an
increasing ratio; after
passing limit of elasticity
in ballast and sub-grade
entire increment of axle
load tends to crushing.
No data at hand.
Observation shows de-
cided crushing.
13
Relation of frequency
of maximum axle load,
as applied to a tie, to tie-
crushing.
See No. 10.
The greater the fre-
quency of maximum
load, the more rapid the
tie-crushing.
Same as No. 12.
Crushing increases
with frequency, but in
small ratio.
No data at hand.
Tie-crushing probably
not far from direct pro-
portion.
14
Relation of maximum
axle load to weight of
rail and consequent tie-
crushing.
15
Relation of impact at
joints to tie-crushing.
See No. 10.
The heavier the rail
the less the tie crushes.
Weight of rail must be
increased to meet in-
creased axle load.
Heavy rail distributes
axle load and reduces
tie-crushing.
See No. 10.
The effect of impact
at the joint would depend
largely on the kind of
angle bar used. The
bar giving the most
uniform distribution of
load would have the
least tendency to crush.
Tie crushing is most
marked at joints and
depends upon upkeep of
joints.
Crushing is worse at
joint tie due to impact,
but the nearer a perfect
joint be approached the
less such effect becomes.
Tie-crushing more
marked at joints than
elsewhere.
Relation of size of tie-
plates to crushing of
ties.
The P. & L. E. R. R.
Co. is now using tie-
plates with an area of
about 72 sq. ins. White
oak ties are also used.
Tie-plates are joined to
the ties with screw
spikes. This area seems
to be the minimum re-
quired for effectiveness.
The greater the area
and thickness of the tie-
plate the less the crush-
ing of the tie.
Tie-plates should be
increased to meet in-
creased loads. They
should be practically
same width as tie, and
increased in length as
axle loads are greater.
Crushing is worse with
small plates; also worse
with thin plates which
spring under maximum
load and tend to "work"
on ties.
Increase in thickness
of plates has materially
lessened tie-crushing.
329
330
TIES.
O o
IrS
< D
DC
<
L
3?
;3r
3?
31
0-
'o
t-
D
H«3
• •■" -
" *JC •
C 3 O TJ
J C 0 5
/v E ♦• 3
■° . • E .5
•5 • 2 <■*
8 •-*«
TIES. 331
CONCLUSIONS.
So far as your Committee is able to determine it is not feasible to
lay down any fixed rule for the size and spacing of ties based on the
A, B and C classification of density of vtraffic, for the following reasons,
each of which in itself has a certain definite restriction, as well as an
interrelation with all others, viz. :
(i) Character of subgrade varies radically on the same road and
in different parts of the country.
(2) Kind of ballast varies widely.
(3) Necessary depth of ballast varies with weight of axle loads, as
well as density of traffic.
(4) Necessary distance between face of ties varies with weight of
axle load, as well as density of traffic.
(5) Kinds of timber used for ties vary in different sections of the
country.
(6) Width of base of rail (or weight of rail) and use of tie-
plates.
(7) Treated or untreated ties, crushing stress and durability.
(8) Amount of labor spent on track maintenance.
(9) Drainage.
However, in general it may be considered good practice for Class A
and perhaps B roads to space ties 10-in. to 12-in. face to face ; the width of
tie is not so important if 10-in. to 12-in. spacing face to face is fol-
lowed ; provided, however, the minimum width of face of tie is limited
to 7 in.
332 TIES.
(2) TIE RENEWALS IN CONTINUOUS STRETCHES VERSUS
SINGLE TIE RENEWALS.
The Sub-Committee appointed to investigate the comparative merits
of "Tie renewals in continuous stretches versus single tie renewals"
issued the following letter to the heads of the proper departments of the
principal railroads operating in the United States and Canada :
"It is desired to obtain information as to the comparative merits of
"Tie renewals in continuous stretches versus single tie renewals." Will
you kindly give us your practice and opinion in reply to the following
questions :
"(1) What is the practice of your road in renewing ties; tie re-
newals in continuous stretches or single tie renewals?
"(2) Do you think it advisable to renew ties in continuous stretches?
"(3) What would be the advantage of this latter method of tie
renewals?
"(4) What are the advantages or disadvantages of single tie re-
newals?
"(5) Which practice would you recommend?"
Fifty of these letters were sent out and 35 replies were received. It
is noted that all who replied gave the subject the most careful at-
tention, and thereby furnished the Committee with some valuable infor-
mation. The replies as received from the various railroads are as fol-
lows:
Mr. George W. Kittredge, Chief Engineer, New York Central & Hudson
River Railroad:
1. The practice of our road is to renew ties under the method
termed "single tie renewals."
2. No.
3. There are no advantages in renewing ties in continuous stretches,
except that possibly for the first year or two you might get better track
than by renewing singly.
4. The advantages of single tie renewals far outweigh the disad-
vantages ; in fact, I know of no disadvantages. The advantages are :
(1) You are able to let a single tie remain in the track until entirely
worn out, since it has the advantage of the ties on each side of it being
sound.
(2) The track is always kept safe by having a large proportion of
good and comparatively new ties in the track. With continuous renew-
als there comes a time when, even before the ties are entirely worn out,
the track is not safe, and, in order to maintain safety, it is necessary to
take the ties out of track before they would, under other conditions, need
to be removed, thus shortening their lives.
5. Unhesitatingly I recommend the practice of single tie renewals.
Mr. F. S. Stevens, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Philadelphia & Read-
ing:
1. The practice of our road is to "spot in" or renew only such ties
as will not do their work another year on account of being too soft to
carry the load.
TIES. 333
2. Yes, if the track where ties are to be renewed can be taken out
of service while work is being done.
3. Advantages of this method are: That by doing this work with-
out interruption, the labor costs less, by removing the ballast to subgrade
and forking it back, dirt is removed and good drainage restored. By re-
tamping on fresh ballast the greatest of trouble is removed ; i. e., the con-
stant care of looking after and retamping "spotted in" ties for about 2
years after being placed in track.
4. The sole advantage of "spotting in" ties where track can be
taken out of service while renewals are being made, is that when ties
have been taken out of track they are very liable to be wasted or de-
stroyed prematurely. If track cannot be taken out of service to permit
tie renewals without interruption, the increased cost of labor to renew
"out of face" makes this method prohibitive. Therefore, under these
conditions the "spotting in" method is most economical. As far
as consistent with economy, ties should then be renewed in pairs, as
labor costs nearly as much to renew one tie as two. In any event, bal-
last_ should be renewed at same time with ties, as this will make good
drainage. This is important, for, unless air can reach the under side of
ties, water will, and then trouble begins in earnest.
5. Under the conditions which we generally have to work I recom-
mend the practice of "spotting in." However, when conditions permit I
would renew ties "out of face" and would place every tie which will
render further service in some track where its remaining life will be used
to best advantage.
Mr. C. S. Millard, Engineer Track and Roadway, Cleveland, Cincinnati,
Chicago & St. Louis Railway:
1. Single tie renewals.
2. Not unless all ties in continuous stretches are all worn out.
3. We can see no advantage of renewing in continuous stretches,
as under the long run the waste of tie timber would be prohibitive.
4. Advantage of single tie renewal is that you avoid any waste of
tie timber and by that method track is kept in a continuously safe con-
dition.
5. Single tie renewals.
Mr. Samuel Rockwell, Chief Engineer, Lake Shore & Michigan Southern
Railway:
1. We ordinarily renew ties singly.
2. We do not, as a rule, renew ties in continuous stretches.
3. I know of no advantage except that it would probably afford a bet-
ter record of the life of the ties.
4. Advantage of single tie renewal is that only such ties as need to
be renewed are renewed; whereas, "out of face" renewal many ties
which would last longer are taken out and thrown away.
5. I would recommend taking out only such ties as need to be taken
out.
Mr. E. J. Correll, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Missouri Pacific Rail-
way :
1. Single tie renewals.
2. No.
3. I know of none. Would consider it a disadvantage.
4. Disturbs the surface less, is more economical and makes condition
of track mere uniform.
5. Single tie renewals.
334 TIES.
Mr. R. Trimble, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way, Northwest Sys-
tem, Pennsylvania Lines :
i. The practice of our road is to renew only such ties as will not
last another year. This, I take it, is what is termed "single tie re-
newal."
2. No. By doing so the life of the tie is considerably shortened. It
is known that a tie when left in place will last longer than if taken out,
thrown around, loaded and unloaded, and then put in somewhere else. -
The chances are that many ties which would last another year or two
if left in their place, would be wasted and not used elsewhere.
3. I know of no advantages of renewing ties in continuous stretches
that would even compensate for the disadvantages.
4. Advantage of single tie renewals is the resultant economy. I
know of no disadvantage.
5. I recommend single tie renewals.
Mr. C. W. Johns, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Chesapeake & Ohio
Railway :
1. Until recent years it has been the practice of this road to renew
ties in continuous stretches. For the past 2 or 3 years we have tried to
get all of our section foremen on double track to work one track one
year and the other track the next, putting in single ties where required.
On single track the foremen work half the section one year and the other
half the next, putting in single ties where required.
2. No. This method necessarily allows a portion of the track to be-
come unsafe before the ties are renewed; at least, the ties get so soft it is
impossible to maintain good surface, while by slipping in single ties this
condition does not exist and there are always sufficient sound ties under
each rail to maintain proper surface and gage.
3. I know of no advantage of renewing in continuous stretches.
4. Advantage of this method is that you never have any stretches
of rotten or unsound ties and there are always enough sound ties to main-
tain proper surface and gage.
5. I prefer the single tie renewals.
Mr. J. B. Berry, Chief Engineer, Rock Island Lines :
1. Single tie renewals.
2. Not unless they are all decayed or worn out so that they need to
come out at the same time.
3. I know of none.
4. I believe the economy of a railroad demands that no tie should
be taken out until decayed or worn out. The men along the line are
educated to better rules of economy by adopting such methods, and you
never can keep all ties, even if you lay them in a continuous stretch, in
the same condition so that they should all be taken out at the same
time.
5. I favor only taking ties out as stated above.
Mr. William Twining, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Central Railroad
of New Jersey:
1. On this division where slag and engine cinders are used for bal-
last, it is the practice to renew ties singly.
2. Do not think it advisable to renew in continuous stretches.
3. One advantage of renewing in continuous stretches would be that
it avoids, in a measure, frequent disturbance to the ballast bed as well
as the line and surface.
4. The advantage of single renewal is that greater average life of
the tie is thereby secured.
TIES. 335
5. In stone or heavy slag ballast, and under heavy traffic, close re-
newal or practically entire renewal is recommended. In light slag or
cinder ballast, under ordinary traffic, single renewal is recommended.
Mr. L. R. Zollinger, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Pennsylvania Rail-
road:
1. Single tie renewals — method known as "spotting."
2. By no means.
3. There is no advantage.
1 4. Advantage of single tie renewal is economy, permitting of ties re-
maining in that are too good to come out, based on the knowledge that
all material is not the same and does not have the same lasting quali-
ties, and permits of removal of those ties, the lives of which are not up
to the average, when they become unfit for use.
5. We recommend the practice of "spotting."
Mr. H. S. Wilgus, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Pittsburg, Shawmut &
Northern :
1. It is our practice to make single tie renewals.
2. Do not think it advisable to renew in continuous stretches, except
in difficult places.
3. Advantage of renewing in continuous stretches is less frequency
of disturbing roadbed.
4. Advantages of single renewal is getting full value out of all ties.
Disadvantage is in covering greater distance of track and disturbing more
roadbed.
5. Would recommend single tie renewals as being the most eco-
nomical.
Mr. John R. Leighty, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Missouri Pacific
Railway :
1. Single ties as needed.
2. No.
3. Better track than average, once in about 6 or 7 years.
4. Track kept in uniform condition at all times and ties renewed
only when they need to be, instead of before or afterward.
5. I would recommend single tie renewals.
Mr. J. R. W. Davis, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Great Northern Rail-
way:
1. It is the practice of our company to renew ties singly or in groups
of 2, 3 or 4 at a time as their condition may make it necessary.
2. We do not think it advisable to renew in continuous stretches.
3. I doubt there being any advantage in continuous tie renewals.
4. Disadvantage of single tie renewals are yearly disturbances of
track, greater labor cost of distributing and placing ties. Advantage is a
stronger track year for year and less waste of material.
5. We recommend single tie renewals.
Mr. P. C. Newbegin, Maintenance Engineer, Bangor & Aroostook Rail-
road:
1. It is our practice to renew ties singly.
2. Do not think it advisable to renew ties in continuous stretches,
except in locations where paving or other covering must be removed to
reach the ties, and, possibly, on short stretches of track which are under
exceptionally heavy traffic.
3. Advantage of renewing in continuous stretches is that it lessens
336 TIES.
the labor cost per tie and disturbs the roadbed less frequently than mast
be done where ties are removed singly.
4. Advantage of single renewal is that full life of ties can be utilized,
and no ties need be removed until they are worn out. This in all but
exceptional cases would more than balance the saving of cost from remov-
ing in continuous stretches and the disadvantage of more frequent dis-
turbing of the roadbed.
5. Except in rare cases I would recommend single tie renewals. -n
Mr. J. M. R. Fairbairn, Assistant Chief Engineer Eastern Lines, Canadian
Pacific Railway:
1. It is our practice to make tie renewals only as they require it.
2. Would not consider it economy to renew in continuous stretches
and see no advantage gained by this method. It is our practice in the
spring of each year to send a man, well versed in tie conditions, over each
sub-division, and he marks with paint the ties he considers not good
for another year's service, using proper judgment and taking into con-
sideration condition of adjoining ties. These are replaced during the sum-
mer season and if a section foreman considers that a tie has not been
marked which, in his opinion, should be replaced, he takes matter up with
the Roadmaster, who decides whether or not renewal will take place.
3. Only advantage is that it entails less work.
4. Advantages of single tie renewals are that only those ties are
removed which have served their life. In the other case ties are removed
which have another year or two of service in them, so that in renewing in
continuous stretches, there is, therefore, more waste.
5. I, of course, recommend the single tie renewal system.
Mr. S. A. Jordan, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road:
1. Our practice is to renew only those ties that will not last another
year.
2. No. Our ties are inspected every spring by a regular Tie In-
spector, who marks all ties that are to come out.
3. Do not think there is any particular advantage.
4. Believe that renewals as made by the B. & O. are better than in
continuous stretches. By taking out only such ties as will not last an-
other year you get a uniform amount of good timber under your rail.
5. I recommend renewing ties singly.
Mr. W. C. Cushing, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way, Southwest Sys-
tem, Pennsylvania Lines :
1. The practice of our Lines is to renew ties as worn out or de-
cayed, and not in continuous stretches.
2. No, except, possibly, between station platforms or in street cross-
ings where the labor of getting at the ties is great.
3. I believe the following advantages might be claimed for the
method of renewing in continuous stretches: (1) Track could be given
uniform lift, and, when new ties were in place, uniform support would be
furnished them ; (2) Cost of laying in continuous stretches would prob-
ably be less than laying them singly.
4. Advantages of single tie renewals are: (1) The track, as a whole,
is kept in a more uniform condition, as to the quality of the supporting
ties : (2) Only ties that should be removed, account of wear or decay,
need be removed. Disadvantages of this method are: (1) The old bed
of the tie must be dug up to get the new tie in place, or entire track
given sufficient raise to accomplish this result ; (2) Where platforms,
planking or interlocking fixtures must be disturbed to remove ties, this
TIES. 337
disturbance takes place oftener under the single tie renewal system ;
(3) The cost of renewal per tie is probably somewhat higher under this
system also.
5. We would recommend the renewal of ties singly. Because :
(1) The general safe condition of the track is greater; (2) The average
life of the ties, we believe, will be lengthened by the single tie renewal
method, as, when renewing in continuous stretches, many ties are neces-
sarily taken out and lost which might safely be left in the track a year or
two longer if the adjoining ties were good.
Mr. Geo. B. Woodworth, Inspector of Rail, Chicago, Milwaukee & St.
Paul Railway :
1. The practice of our road is to make single tie renewals.
2. From a financial standpoint I do not think it advisable to renew
ties in continuous stretches, since the life of the ties is variable and the
usable ties taken out deteriorate rapidly, and will lose 25 to 50 per cent,
of their usefulness before they can be used again. In special cases it
is more advantageous from every point of view to renew in continuous
stretches, as in tunnels, narrow rock cuts or over very busy stretches of
track where the track can be given over for a short time to a large
force of men.
3. Advantage of renewing in continuous stretches is, that after the
ties are placed, roadbed will not again be disturbed for a long time, and
a better general condition of track can be maintained.
4. Above answer also covers your third question.
5. As a general proposition I should recommend single tie renewals.
Mr. M. C. Hamilton, Engineer Maintenance of Way, New York, New
Haven & Hartford Railroad :
1. It is our practice to renew ties singly.
2. This depends on the local conditions; on four-track sections in-
terior tracks, or adjacent to station platforms, the renewing of ties "out
of face" is considered the economical practice.
3. We do not consider the renewal of ties "out of face" the eco-
nomical practice under normal conditions.
4. Advantages of single tie renewals are greater economy and more
uniform condition of track.
5. I would recommend the renewing of ties singly, except where
unusual conditions demand the other method.
Mr. C. M. James, Engineer Roadway, Atlantic Coast Line:
1. The practice of our road is single tie renewals.
2. Under the conditions existing in this territory, I do not think
it advisable to renew in continuous stretches.
3. The advantage of the above method is in the saving of labor, but
this advantage is outweighed by the disadvantage that material is used.
4. Advantage of single tie renewals is in the fact that full life can
then be gotten from each individual tie.
5. There is no question in my mind but that single tie renewals is
the better practice.
Mr. G. J. Ray, Chief Engineer, Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Rail-
road:
1. Single tie renewals is the method practiced as much as possible.
We find that some of our old foremen have been in the habit of renewing
ties in continuous stretches, and it is hard to break them of this practice,
and there are cases where we permit this method of renewal through
338 TIES.
station grounds where it is more difficult to get at the track, making use
of the better ties taken out for sidetrack purposes.
2. No. If all the ties are in such shape that they should come out,
I do not think the track is in first class shape, and am not an advocate
of permitting track to get in such shape that all ties can consistently be
taken out at the same time.
3. Only advantage is that more ties can be placed at the same cost.
4. Full life of service can be gotten out of every tie, and this advan-
tage of single tie renewal will more than outweigh any advantage in favor
of the former system.
5. Single tie renewals.
Mr. W. L. Breckinridge, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Chicago, Bur-
lington & Quincy Railroad :
1. We practice the system known as "single tie renewals."
2. No, except in special cases.
3. Only advantage I know of in renewing in continuous stretches is
in cases where the life of the rail under heavy traffic about equals the
life of the ties ; that is, in renewing rail where the traffic is heavy, ties
should be renewed in full and unless ties under old rail are almost new,
they should all come out. You will then have a track which will not have
to be disturbed during the life of the new rail on account of tie re-
newals.
4. Single tie renewals is all right, especially on less important main
lines where the life of the rail exceeds that of the tie. We are also able
to keep yearly check on our gage and hold track to a more perfect gage,
since the average efficiency of a proper single tie renewal track is almost
constant, while with a continuous renewal track the holding power of
spikes and general efficiency is on the decrease. Disadvantages of single
tie renewal are: (1) Frequent disturbance of roadbed; (2) Inability to get
a firm and equal bearing on the new ties; (3) Taking up too much time
in the Spring for this sort of work when the track needs picking up ;
(4) Keeping right of way littered each year with new and old ties.
5. I would recommend continuous renewal only when relaying rail
on main line heavy traffic road. In such cases the life of the rail does
not exceed that of the ties. In all other cases I recommend single tie
renewal, as the life of tie timber varies too much to consistently renew in
continuous stretches.
Mr. L. G. Curtis, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road :
1. Our practice is to renew ties singly.
2. No, only under extraordinary conditions.
3. No advantage.
4. The change to single tie renewals gives you sound ties through-
out.
5. Would recommend single tie renewals, excepting in rare cases
where ties are all poor.
Mr. Alexander Bonnyman, General Manager, Atlanta, Birmingham &
Atlantic :
1. Single tie renewals. When a tie shows signs of decay, it is
taken out.
2. No, unless traffic is very heavy and the roadbed of such nature as
to make continuous renewals necessary.
3. No advantage unless under above conditions.
4. Advantage in single renewals is that , full life of every tie is
utilized.
TIES. 339
5. I would recommend that where the earnings of a road demand
economy, ties be renewed singly ; where traffic is heavy and the Company
is able to renew in continuous stretches, that this be done.
Mr. W. J. Towne, Engineer of Maintenance, Chicago & Northwestern
Railway :
1. Tie renewals based upon actual condition of tie, except joint and
center ties ; these are usually renewed together, and if any ties removed
are serviceable elsewhere, they are properly utilized.
2. No, not as a general proposition. In slag or rock ballast I
think it economy to renew continuous to the extent that any ties that
will not last 2 years or more be taken out.
3. Principal advantage would be in securing more uniform rail bear-
ing and economy when the life of the tie would not offset the labor charge
for renewal and less disturbance of track bed result in general economy,
in rail, etc., as well as improved roadbed.
4. Advantage of single tie renewals consists wholly in conservation.
Disadvantages mentioned in reply "three."
5. Depends on character of line, volume of traffic, ballast, rail and
roadbed. In gravel ballast with light traffic would recommend single
tie renewals ; in rock or slag ballast with heavy traffic would recommend
renewal joint and center ties together, and renewal of all ties that would
not last 2 years, both as a matter of economy and other reasons before
named.
Mr. E. F. Mitchell, Chief Engineer, Missouri Pacific Railway :
1. Single tie renewal is the practice of our road.
2. No, we do not think it advisable.
3. The average life of a tie on this system is 8 years. For the sake
of argument assume that the best method of renewing ties in continuous
stretches would be to renew all the ties under 1 rail length in a given
year at one time. Then about 6 years later it would be necessary to re-
new at least a portion of these ties, possibly 50 per cent, of them. The
balance of ties under this rail would probably last from one to four
years.
5. If the ties rotted at the end of 6 years are not "spotted in" or
renewed, as called, in single ties, but, instead of this the entire rail
length is renewed for the purpose of reducing the cost of labor for
renewal per tie, then about one-half the ties under this rail will be re-
newed when they have from one to four years' service left.
Mr. W. D. Taylor, Chief Engineer, Chicago & Alton Railway :
1. Single tie renewals, except where there are 2 or more consecutive
ties to be renewed.
2. Only when renewing in track to be surfaced, as we do not think
it advisable to leave old ties in track that is being surfaced, and then
have to again disturb the track and ballast the next year to change out
the remaining old ties.
3. Advantage of single tie renewals is that fewer tie renewals are
required to keep track in good condition where only the worst ties are
taken out and new ties put in in this way than would be the case where
long stretches of ties are taken out, and the track shaken up and ties
knocked around for spacing.
4. and 5. Answered in the above.
Mr. F. R. Layng, Engineer of Track, Bessemer & Lake Erie Railroad :
1. Single tie renewals.
2. No, I do not think it advisable to renew in continuous stretches.
340 TIES.
3. The cost of renewals per tie (labor only) would be less when
ties are renewed "out of face." This is on account of the fact that only
about half as much ballast per tie would have to be dug out to make
renewals. Disadvantage : In renewing in stretches, when it is decided
that renewals should be made, track is in weakened condition. This
being so, chances are either taken to run the ties a little longer, or, if
the responsibility rests with a man who is timid, renewals are ordered
at a time when most of the ties would last two or three years longer, if
not disturbed. Neither of the above conditions tends to good practice.
The ideal, to my mind, is to get the longest possible life from a tie, con-
sistent with safety, without disturbing it.
I am quite sure the tendency of the average man would be to remove
the ties in ample time so that the result would be to reduce the life per
tie to about five years. This would increase the cost of tie renewals
from 15 to 20 per cent. Inasmuch as tie renewals make up the largest
single item in maintenance expense ; most roads would hesitate to in-
crease same unless some very decided advantage resulted therefrom.
Another disadvantage : It is practically impossible to select ties
which would decay so uniformly that any great length of track could
be renewed without taking out some ties still fit for service. Some use
would have to be found for these ties and they would no doubt be used
in sidetracks. Assuming the following:
Cost of first-class tie delivered along track $0.70
Cost of second-class tie delivered along track 60
Average life of first-class tie in main track 7 years
Average life of second-class tie in siding 7 years
Average life of first-class tie removed from main
and used in siding 3 years
We arrive at the figures given below :
Cost of tie removed from main and put in siding
3 years at 10c per year $0.30
Cost to remove from main track 03
Cost of putting in siding .08
Total cost $0.41
Average cost per year in siding $013 2-3
Cost of second-class ties $0.60
Cost of putting in siding 08
Total cost $0.68
Average cost per year in siding $0.09 5-7
Cost of first-class tie in siding $0.70
Cost of putting in siding 08
Total cost $0.78
Average cost per year in siding $0.11 1-7
The above shows clearly, if my assumption is correct, that it does
not pay to use same in sidings.
4. Advantages of single tie renewals: (1) Effective life of tie is
longer; (2) Average condition of track as to safety is better; (3) Sin-
gle track renewals disturb roadbed less ; (4) Trackmen can arrange work
to better advantage in single tie renewals; (5) Cost of tie renewals con-
TIES. 341
siderably in favor of single tie practice. (Net cost, including everything
connected with this item.)
Disadvantages : I can see no particular disadvantage in the method
of renewing ties singly. The most expensive thing we have is labor and
least amount of labor per tie is expended.
5. Usual argument against single tie renewals, I presume, is that
after making same, track does not ride smoothly or is spotty. Now this
is usually the case, but it is the result of poor maintenance and is not a
necessary evil which follows the practice of single tie renewal. If the
trackmen will properly tamp new ties a week or ten days after they have
been put in, this trouble can easily be taken care of.
Mr. F. D. Anthony, Chief Engineer, Quebec, Montreal & Southern Rail-
way:
1. We renew all ties on this road as necessity requires ; i. e., when
they are decayed, broken or otherwise defective.
2. No.
3. 4 and 5. Tie renewals sometimes occur in continuous stretches,
but this, no doubt, comes under your classification as "single" and
practically all my experience has been on this line.
Mr. Earl Stimson, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way, Baltimore &
Ohio Railroad :
1. Single tie renewals is the practice of our road.
2. No.
3. Can see no advantage of renewing ties in continuous stretches.
4. Advantage of single renewal is in obtaining extreme life of each
individual tie.
5. I would recommend single tie renewals. As a general proposi-
tion would not consider continuous tie renewals as having any advan-
tage unless it might be in first-class track in which treated ties of the
same class of timber were used, equipped with screw spikes and tie-
plates and laid in stone ballast. This is a very unusual occurrence and
it is therefore the reason I answer your third question as I do.
Mr. J. E. McNeil, Inspector Roadway and Track, Atchison, Topeka &
Santa Fe Coast Line :
1. Our practice is single tie renewals.
2. Not advisable on our line, at least, where there is so much dif-
ference in the length of time our ties last.
3. There would be no advantage on western lines.
4. We find that the life of tie timber received at the same time and
cut in the same forest varies from one to five years. To make tie re-
newals in continuous stretches, would, we think, be extravagant. At
one time in the Middle West where we got eight years' service out of
our white oak ties, and the inspection was such as to have them about
the same in quality, we figured on renewing about one-eighth of the
number each year. In this way the work could be done with a small
extra gang.
5. In this part of the country where we have such a variety of
tie timber and their lasting quality is so different, I would recommend
single tie renewals.
Mr. S. M. Braden, General Superintendent, Chicago & Northwestern
Railway :
1. We make tie renewals as needed — very seldom, however, in
continuous stretches.
342 TIES.
2. No, as conditions necessitating continuous renewals would, in
our opinion, indicate improper previous maintenance.
3. Can see no advantage. Increased maintenance expense would
be a disadvantage.
4. Principal advantage in single renewal is less expense, and, in
addition, there is less disturbance as to surface of track.
5. We would recommend the method of single tie renewals.
Mr. J. K. Howard, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Ann Arbor Rail-
road:
1. Single tie renewals. We take out no ties which will last an-
other year.
2. Do not think it advisable to renew in continuous stretches.
3. No advantage in above method.
4. Advantage of single renewal is that only ties unfit for another
year's service are removed and I would call this the more economical
practice.
5. I recommend single tie renewals.
Mr. G. B. Owen, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Erie Railroad :
1. The practice of this road is to renew ties singly.
2. Do not think it advisable to renew ties in continuous stretches.
3. I cannot name any advantage of renewing ties in continuous
stretches.
4. The advantage of single tie renewal is economy and uniformity
in maintenance, and uniformity of track conditions as well as mainte-
nance charges.
5. I would recommend an inspection bv a competent inspector of
the old ties in the track before renewal, and that only such ties be re-
moved which would not give one additional year's service from the
time the inspection was made. This practice, if continued from year to
year, will result in a stronger condition of the roadbed with the employ-
ment of a less number of men per section than would be necessary
where continuous renewals were made. It would also materially assist
the purchasing department in the placing of their contracts for ties.
The disadvantages which developed from our tests in continuous tie
renewals were that a large number of ties were removed which would
give one, two, three or four years' further service. An effort was made
to utilize these ties in other tracks, but it is manifestly a great loss of
labor to remove a tie until it has worn out and then attempt to again
replace it in the track. A further disadvantage resulted in an effort to
reduce the forces on sections where continuous tie renewals were made
in order to make up, in a way, the excessive cost of these renewals. In
a very short time this reduction resulted in bad surface and line so that
in the end there was really no saving in labor.
From the excellent information received it is evident that the gen-
eral practice is to renew ties singly, except in unusual cases at station
platforms, highway crossings, narrow tunnels or interlocking plants
where it requires much labor to get at the ties or to uncover them for
the purpose of renewal.
CONCLUSION.
The Committee recommends the practice of single tie renewals.
TIES. 343
(3) METAL, COMPOSITE AND CONCRETE TIES.
Your Committee was directed to prepare a report on the use of
metal, composite and concrete ties.
During the year the members of the Sub-Committee dealing with
this subject held two meetings — one at Pittsburg, September 5, 6 and 7,
191 1, at which time an inspection of the following ties was made:
Rohm Steel Tie, Sewickley, Pa., Pennsylvania Lines, Northwest Sys-
tem.
Universal Steel Tie, Emsworth, Pa., Pennsylvania Lines, Northwest
System.
Reigler Concrete Tie, Emsworth, Pa., Pennsylvania Lines, North-
west System.
Carnegie Steel Tie, Pittsburg, Pa., Pittsburg & Lake Erie.
Carnegie Steel Tie, McKees Rocks, Pittsburg & Lake Erie.
Universal Steel Tie, Pittsburg, Pittsburg & Lake Erie.
Atwood Steel and Concrete Tie, McKees Rocks, Pittsburg & Lake
Erie.
Bruckner Concrete Tie, McKees Rocks, Pittsburg & Lake Erie.
Snyder Steel Tie, Derry, Pa., Pennsylvania Railroad.
Mechling & Smith Tie, Wilkinsburg, Pa., Pennsylvania Railroad.
Carnegie Steel Tie, Port Perry, Pa., Union Railroad.
Carnegie Steel Tie, Homestead, Pa., Carnegie Steel Company.
Carnegie Steel Tie, North Bessemer to Exposition Park, Bessemer
& Lake Erie Railroad.
And a meeting at Baltimore, Md., November 10, 191 1.
In connection with the following report your Committee wishes to
point out that it is of the opinion that no single design of substitute is
going to meet all the conditions to be found on railway track and there
should be at least two designs or types:
(1) A tie for heavy service, insulated or not insulated, as re-
quired.
(2) A tie for light service, insulated or not insulated, as re-
quired.
It is desirable that any type of non-insulated tie should be capable
of being insulated without having to be removed from the track.
As far as we can see, very few designers have recognized this
distinction and as a result attempt to meet all conditions with a single
design. We believe this is neither desirable nor economical, and that
much better results will be obtained if the tie be designed for special
service.
Your Committee has been somewhat disappointed with the results
obtained with the concrete tie, the concrete and metal tie, and the
asphalt and metal tie, for reasons given in our conclusions.
In regard to steel ties, your Committee was impressed with the
number of steel ties in use on the Union Railroad and the Bessemer
& Lake Erie Railroad. The total number of steel ties on these two
344 TIES.
roads is over one million, or enough to lay 312 miles of track, using
3,200 ties to the mile.
We desire to call attention to the widespread interest that is now
being taken in finding a substitute for the wood tie. This is not con-
fined to any particular section of the country, nor to the steam rail-
roads. The portion of this report covering the Street and Interurbarr
Electric Lines is evidence that these lines are seeking a substitute tie.
In addition to the personal inspection made by the Committee the
following reports have been received from railroads using substitute
ties:
Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Company:
(For previous reports see Vol. 10, Part 1, pp. 504-529; Vol. 12, Part 1,
page 385.)
On October 28, 191 1, Mr. Earl Stimson, Chief Engineer Mainte-
nance of Way, states :
"In reply to your letter of August 26, I would advise that this com-
pany has made no additional installations of any metal or composite
ties. I have nothing further to report thereon."
Bessemer & Lake Erie Railroad:
(For previous reports see Vol. 10, Part 1, page 496; Vol. 11, Part 2,
page 876, and Vol. 12, Part 1, page 371.)
"Up to January 1, 191 1, this company had purchased 563,555 Car-
negie steel ties and during 191 1 we will receive 138,000, making a total
of 702,355 ties to be received by January 1, 1912. The ties if laid con-
tinuously 3,200 to the mile (our standard spacing on main line) would
give 219.5 miles of steel tie track. During the year we also received 20
sets of steel switch ties.
"We have very little, if any, additional information to report this
year. The ties put in at Claytonia in 1904 are still in and there has
been no change in their condition since our last report. The 1,000 in-
sulated ties installed in June, 1506, at Conneaut, Ohio, are still in and
have given no trouble whatever.
"This road will continue to use this type of steel tie in maintenance
and construction work.
"Accompanying this are two photographs, one showing scene of a
derailment near Queen Junction, Pa., and one near Jamisonville, Pa.
Both derailments were caused by a broken flange ; in each case but one
pair of trucks was derailed and the car derailed was a steel car loaded
with 55 tons of ore, so that the gross weight of the car was about 73
tons. These derailments happened in August, 1910, and the ties are
still in the track."
Buffalo, Rochester & Pittsburg Railzmy:
(See previous report. Vol. 12, Part 1, page 371.)
Mr. E. F. Robinson, Chief Engineer, says : "On account of the in-
stallation of automatic block signals, we are removing 1,500 Carnegie
steel ties from the main track, near Ridgway, Pa. It is our intention to
make no further increase in the use of this design of tie, at least for
the present."
Chicago & Alton Railroad:
(See previous reports, Vol. 10, Part 1, page 515; Vol. 11, Part 2, page
893-)
Mr. E. L. Crugar, Assistant Chief Engineer, advised August 28,
TIES.
345
Fig. r. Bessemer & Lake Erie R. R., Near Queen Junction, Pa.
Fig. 2. Bessemer & Lake Erie R. R., Near Jamisonvtlle, Pa.
346 TIES.
1911: "There have been no changes as regards ties in track on this
company's lines. We have put in no metal or composite ties."
(This line placed 63 "Kimball" ties in its southward track, near
Lockport, Illinois, October, 1905.)
Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Railway:
(See Vol. 11, Part 2, page 887; Vol. 12, Part 1, page 383.)
On August 28, 191 1, Mr. C. A. Paquette, Assistant Chief Engineer/
advised : "Answering your letter of the 26th instant, we have no addi-
tional information to give you as to steel ties which are in service in our
main track.
"In November, 1909, there were 20 concrete ties made under the
Israel patent and put in the main track east of Paris, 111., on our St.
Louis Division. On February 12, 191 1, we found it necessary to remove
three of these ties from the track, the ties having failed completely. The
concrete was crushed and the top plate, which reaches half way across
the tie and serves as a support for the rail fastenings, was broken in sev-
eral places. As to the balance of the ties 85 per cent: of them have the
top plate either cracked or broken.
"This experience seems to indicate that these ties are not suitable.
Their life may be considered to be about two or three years, and the
cost is considerably greater than that of wooden ties."
Cornwall & Lebanon Railroad:
On October 16 Mr. A. D. Smith, President and General Superin-
tendent, advised as follows (for design see P. R. R. report) :
"With reference to our experience with the 200 Snyder steel ties
which were installed in our road about five years ago, these ties • are
located on the southbound track of our double track, lying about one
mile west or south of Mount Gretna in a 2-degree curve and on a 1.5
per cent, descending grade. One coat of tar paint was applied when
the ties were put in and another coat during the past year. This is
about the only expense we have been put to in the matter of mainte-
nance.
"A few months ago in passing over this part of the road it was
noticed that the asphalt concrete filling showed signs of disintegration
at the open ends of the ties and upon investigating we found as far
back as the hand could be placed that the filling was loose and in par-
ticles. In order to ascertain how far in this extended the tie was taken
out of the track and in pulling the tie out the filling was left on the
ground under the rails, simply a mass of particles. We imagine that as
a result of this condition whenever the ties are tamped some material
will be dropped from the bottom through the slight raising due to the
tamping. The track foreman reported that he had noticed the mate-
rial loosened in this manner several months ago. The track at this
point is laid with 80-lb. rail and on stone ballast.
"Approximately half a million tons of freight per year pass over this
track in the southward direction, our heaviest locomotives being 75
tons in weight, not including the weight of the tender. During the sum-
mer season eight or ten passenger trains pass over this track daily and
four passenger trains the remaining portion of the year, probably at a
speed of 40 or 50 miles per hour.
"There has been no trouble at all in connection with these ties as
stated, except the recent crumbling of the asphalt filling. Just what the
effect of this would be eventually we are not prepared to say :
Duluth & Iron Range Railroad:
(See previous reports, Vol. 11, Part 2, page 890; Vol. 12, Part 1,
page 384.)
TIES.
347
Mr. W. A. Clark, Chief Engineer, advised August 28, 191 1, that he
has nothing additional to offer. "The ties covered by our last report
are still in the track and giving satisfactory service."
Duluth, Missabe & Northern Raihvay:
Mr. H. L. Dresser, Chief Engineer, under date of September 11,
191 1, writes as follows:
Fig. 3. Israel Sectional Tie.
A FINISHED TIE
SHOWING THE CAST IRON TOP OF ONE SECTION OF .TIE WITH UNDEB SIDE CONSTRUCTION
Fig. 4. Israel Sectional Tie.
"Your letter of September 8,' in regard to a report as to the steel
ties which we have in use on our line ; we have about 22,400 ties of the
Carnegie Steel Company's Section M-21. They were purchased in the
summer of 1908 and we started to put them in the track in the fall after
348 TIES.
the ore business closed, but the work was not completed until the spring
of 1909. Two miles of these were placed on the hill between Duluth and
the yards at Proctor, being placed in the double track, one mile in each
track. This portion of the road had been previously ballasted with
crushed granite and consequently required less work to place them than
it did the others, which were placed where the track crosses the big
muskeg swamp about fifty miles north of Duluth. This is also double
track and we have two and one-half miles of these ties in each track.
This portion of the road had been ballasted with gravel and had always
cost us a great deal to maintain during the summer season on account
of the nature of the soil underneath the roadbed. It was necessary to
keep the track lined with men during the ore season to keep the track in
shape and to keep the rails spiked to line, although we were using tie-
plates, but owing to the shaking and trembling of the ground under-
neath which set up a vibration in the train the rails were continually
spreading and it was necessary to line spike this track every season, and
more or less would have to be lined up two or three times during the
summer.
"We removed the old ballast and replaced it with crushed granite,
leaving the original roadbed underneath the granite sloping from the
center between the two tracks, as shown in the accompanying blue-
print. Owing to this work having been done in the winter when there
was a great deal of snow on the ground and more or less ice, these
tracks required considerable attention during the summer of 1009, but
by the time winter set in we had these tracks in elegant shape and dur-
ing the summer of 1910 we did no more work on them whatever. Of
course, the section men passed over them going to and from their work,
but no work was done in either surfacing or lining during the entire
summer, which was something very unusual for that track. It kept
in very good shape until late in the fall, at which time by careful in-
spection you could see that some places were slightly depressed, but it
was scarcely noticeable in the running of trains. Early in the season
of 191 1 we sent an extra gang over this track and brought it to sur-
face again. Since that time no work has been required on it, although
we have had a large amount of rain in that district this summer.
"We would say that with these ties, placed 18-in. centers as we have
them, carrying 100-lb. rail, it is impossible for a small section crew to
line and surface the track to a great extent, but needs a small extra
gang to handle it, as it is exceedingly heavy and hard to move. How-
ever, it requires so much less attention than our old track with the
wooden ties and 80-lb. rail that we feel there is economy in the use of
these ties, notwithstanding the difference in first cost of the steel and
the wood, and would like very much to have them to place on the entire
length of the main line, but as our tracks run through a forest most of
the way where the settlers are getting out track ties more than any other
material and ship them over our road, our people feel that we ought
to use their product while it lasts, as it will be but a very few years before
all timber suitable for wooden ties lying anywhere near our road will
have been used up.
"The two miles on the hill between Duluth and Proctor have re-
quired scarcely any attention since they were put in place, but the soil
underneath the roadbed at this point is solid clay and has never caused
the trouble the tracks across the big swamp have. There are two light
curves on the latter two miles and we have worn out the new rail which
was placed with the ties in some instances on these curves, but the cost
of surfacing and relining the track has been very light as compared with
the tracks on the wooden ties.
"Accompanying this is a sketch showing our standard section of road-
TIES. 349
bed where steel ties were used, and also a blueprint showing the tie
and fastenings. This print shows a clip and stop on each side of the
rail on each tie, which was the plan suggested by the Carnegie Steel
Company, and when the time arrived they were drilled in this manner,
but we never used the stop on the gage side of the rail, as we looked upon
it as useless. We have, however, used the clip and the stop both on the
outer side of the rail and they have had no trouble with broken clips,
loose bolts, or anything of that nature, and are very much pleased
with the service they have given up to this date."
Elgin, Jolict & Eastern Railway:
Mr. A. Montzheimer, Chief Engineer, advises as follows : "We have
put in this year 500 Carnegie Steel Company ties. These are located on
the main line, between Gary and South Chicago. We are now making
up list of switch ties for next year and expect to be able to make our
next year's renewals of switch ties, consisting of about 350 sets, with
Carnegie steel ties. In addition to above we are planning to use Carnegie
steel ties on all renewals on main line on curves."
EHc Railroad:
(See previous reports, Vol. 12. Part 1, p. 386.)
On October 7, 191 1, Mr. W. J. Harahan, Vice-President, advised as
follows : "No further installation of metal ties has been made since the
report of November 30, 1910, was made, and therefore the Carnegie steel
switch ties at Bergen are the only ties of this character in use. In re-
gard to these ties, .would advise as follows : The original 57 ties are
still in service. One of these ties was broken off outside the rail and
fastenings by derailment of a car August 30, 1911. The derailment was
caused by yardmaster not getting the switch over in time. Otherwise,
these ties are practically as good as new.
"In regard to the fastenings supplied with these ties, they are too
small for the service required of them, and as the effect of rust on them
is very great, they soon fail and have to be renewed. The fastenings
on these ties have all been renewed once, and some of them twice since
the original installation was made, which was in April, 1909.
"As regards the desirability of these steel switch ties compared
with ordinary yellow pine switch ties, would state they compare favor-
ably, except in the matter of fastenings, which feature could be im-
proved very much by the use of heavier bolts and clips, and lohmanized
material."
Galveston, Harrisburg & San Antonio Railway:
(For previous reports see Vol. u, Part 2, page 894.)
Mr. D. K. Colburn, Engineer Maintenance of Way, advises that
they have installed 200 Percival Reinforced Concrete Ties, 100 at Bayou
Sale, La., January 20, 1910, and 100 at Edgewater, Texas, October
22, 1906.
At Bayou Sale the ties were installed under 76-lb. rail, gravel bal-
last. Traffic at this point low speed and rather heavy. The ties are
located at end of double track where fires are cleaned and the concrete
ties are thus far satisfactory in all respects, except that the wood cush-
ions under the rail have been somewhat damaged by fire, but their re-
newal is an easy matter.
At Edgewater «the ties are under 80-lb. A.S.C.E. rail gravel ballast.
Fifty ties at this point were installed consecutively, 18 ties to a 33-ft.
rail, and 50 were placed alternately with cypress ties. Traffic over these
ties is high speed and rather heavy, and at the time of making this re-
port (September 7, 1911), they were in good condition, except for a
few minor cracks.
350 TIES.
(For design of this tie see Figs. 5, 6 and 7.)
In regard to shape of this tie the patentee, Mr. Percival, advises
that the tie is made wider at the top than elsewhere and of somewhat
rounded bottom for the following reasons :
1. For easy tamping.
2. Economy ajid better utilization of reinforcement.
3. For reduction of section and consequent weight.
Mr. Colburn further advises that these ties are made up as follows :
Composition : Six parts clear granite crushed very fine. Two and
one-half parts crushed sandstone (largest piece passes through a one-
inch ring). Two parts Whitehall cement.
Reinforcement :. Three yl-in. corrugated bars in face. One 34-in.
corrugated bar in base.
The bars are bound together with strong wire, making a truss ;
total weight of reinforcement 25 lbs., total weight of tie 445 lbs., cubical
contents of tie 3.385 cu. ft.
Lake Shore & Michigan Southern Railway:
(See previous reports, Vol. 10, Part 1, page 511; Vol. 12, Part 1,
page 384.)
On September 20, 191 1, Mr. Samuel Rockwell, Chief Engineer, ad-
vised : "At one time we had steel ties on several divisions of the road
in experimental stretches, but a few years ago they were all taken out.
One of the chief troubles we had with them was the insulation. A num-
ber of them have now been put in on our Sandusky pier branch where
the speed is limited, and we have no need of insulation, and where we
run in streets part of the way and good permanent construction is
needed. They are well adapted for this service.
"These ties are mostly of the Buhrer nattern. made bv the Carnegie
Steel Company, with four clip fastenings for each tie. They have been
in track for about six years and are in first-class condition at this time.
The Roadmaster is of the opinion that they will last from ten to fifteen
years longer. They hold the track in line, surface and gage very well,
but our people are not yet convinced that they are the tie for our main
line with its heavy high speed traffic."
Lake Terminal Railway (National Tube Company) :
(See previous report, Vol. 11, Part 2, p. 890; Vol. 12, Part 1. p. 384.)
Mr. F. W. Waterman, Engineer, advises, Sept. 5, 191 1: "We placed
18,645 Carnegie Section M-21 steel ties since January 1. 191 1, and expect
to replace all our wooden ties as fast as they are worn out, with steel
ties."
Long Island Railroad:
(See previous reports, Vol. 12. Part 1, page 386.)
Mr. E. M. Weaver, Engineer Maintenance of Way, says, Septenu-cr 6
191 1 : "I have nothing whatever to offer in the way of a report."
Michigan Central Railroad:
(See previous reports, Vol. 12, Part 1, page 386.)
Mr. G. H. Webb, Chief Engineer, on August 29, 191 1, says: "There is
very little to add to my report of November 19, 1910, with the excep-
tion that the few concrete ties which we have in our track at Jackson,
Mich., are still in service, though they are somewhat cracked, but not
enough so as to necessitate their being taken up. We are not contem-
plating any further installations of metal or composite ties at this time."
Northern Pacific Raihvay:
(See previous report, Vol. J2, Part 1, page 384.)
On August 30, 191 1, Mr. W. C. Smith, Chief Engineer, Maintenance
TIES.
351
Fig. 5. Percival Concrete Steel Ties.
Fig. 6. Percival Concrete Steel Ties.
352
TIES.
of Way, advised: "We have made no additional installation during the
past year. In fact, we have removed a few of the metal ties and trans-
ferred some to other points so as not to conflict with automatic block
signals which we have been placing. We are finding it very difficult to
properly insulate them. The few ties which we have in place have given
excellent satisfaction. We are simply using them at a number of points
where engines take coal and water, and where cinders are likely to be
dropped."
--;~r— ~tr I
'. 1 Ji?
U>^I-t2t^O"?i
SIDE ELEVATION
Fig. 7. Percival Reinforced Concrete Tie.
=53*^
nrfa.?
retaining SAfl rtmnmoH BOLT CENTERING
JOINT CLAMP
SECTION AT JOINT SECTION
Fig. 8. Snyder Steel Tie for ioo-lb. Rail.
Pennsylvania Railroad:
(See previous reports, Vol. 10, P'art 1, page 509; Vol. 11, Part 2, page
891 ; Vol. 12, Part 1, page 378.)
Your Committee inspected the "Snyder" ties installed at Derry on
September 6, 191 1. As will be seen from previous reports, 1,600 of these
ties were put in during the summer of 1907 in Conemaugh yard and
966 in Derry yard, both on the Pittsburg Division. In these locations
they are used for heavy but slow traffic. This tie consists of a steel shell
TIES.
353
3/16-in. thick, the ties are 8 ft. long, 7 ins. wide, 7 ins. deep, and open
on the bottom. The interior of the shell is filled with a mixture of
asphalt and crushed stone, the rails are fastened to the tie by bolts and
clips, and these ties weigh 700 lbs. per tie. (See Fig. 8 for details of
tie and fastenings.) Our inspection developed that the metal of the
Fig. 9. Snyder Tie, Pennsylvania Railroad, Derry, Pa.
Fig. 10. Snyder Tie, Pennsylvania R. R., Showing Asphalt Filling
Having Deteriorated.
Fig. 11. Snyder Steel Tie, Pennsylvania Railroad, Derry, Pa.
354
TIES.
tie is in good condition, showing very little if any loss from corrosion,
that the fastenings were holding well, but that on about 20 ties the mastic
was disintegrating so that it was falling out of the ends of the ties.
(See photographs Figs. 9, 10 and 11.)
Your Committee also examined an experimental tie owned by Mech-
ling and Tiechart, Munhall, Pa., of which the Pennsylvania Railroad
has installed 100 near Wilkinsburg, Pa., on the Pittsburg Division. (See
Fig. 12 for the design of this tie.)
STEEL CONNECTION FOR RAIL
SIDE VIEW
WOOD CONNECTION FOR RAIL
Fig. 12. Mechling and Smith Steel Tie, Showing Both Wood and
Steel Rail Connections.
.
It
m
%
H-
f
zi'
ejb 6§3
TEC HEAD TIE BOL T.
CLIPS <S BOL T3 FOR 31V ITCH
JCZ5 INSTALLED ON PFNNA RR.
USrO WITH CAKNSCie 3T£CL TIES. SSLfJ-ei .
DROP FORCE RAIL CLIP NO. 19.
Fig. 13.
TIES.
355
356
TIES.
These ties are installed in a yard track (not insulated) over which
there is a heavy but slow movement. Your Committee thinks this tie is
capable of further development.
Your Committee is advised that this company is about to install six
sets of steel switch ties manufactured by the Carnegie Steel Company.
The section of tie used is the modified "I" beam known as Section M-21
and weighs 19.7 lbs. per ft. The rail is fastened to the tie with a bolt
and clip, details of which are shown in Fig. 13.
Pennsylvania Lines, Northwest System:
(For previous reports see Vol. 10, Part 1, page 505, page 513; Vol.
11, Part 2, page 892; Vol. 12, Part 1, page 383.)
Your Committee examined the following ties in this company's
tracks :
Rohm Steel Tie (see Fig. 14) : Twelve of these ties were placed
in the eastbound main freight track at Sewickley, Pa., June, 1910. They
Fig. 15. Universal Steel Tie.
are still in the track and are giving satisfactory service. The only
trouble these ties have caused has been with the insulation, which Mr. A.
A. Wirth, Division Engineer, pointed out could be taken care of by a
slight change in design. This tie weighs about 260 lbs.
Universal Steel Tie (see Fig. 15) : Ninety-eight of these ties were
installed in eastbound main freight track near Emsworth, Pa., in Decem-
ber, 1910. The Supervisor in charge of this track pointed out that these ties
would be very hard to line on account of the projection of a portion of
the fastening below the bottom of the tie. He also stated that it was
very hard to hold this track in surface.
Reigler Combined Steel and Concrete Tie : Details of this tie will
be found in Vol. 11, Part 2, page 893. Fifteen of these ties were put
in the westbound main passenger track near Emsworth, Pa., May, 1908.
They are still in the track and with the exception of three ties are in
good condition. The three ties referred to show signs of failure under
TIES. 357
the rail, but the inventor thinks that repairs can be readily made so that
the ties will be restored to their original condition. One other feature
noticed by the Committee was that several of the nuts were loose and that
same could not be tightened unless ties are taken out of the track. This
could be taken care of if the shape of bolt were such that it would not
turn in the hole through the concrete.
Pittsburg & Lake Erie Railroad:
(For previous reports see Vol. 10, Part i, page 503; Vol. 11, Part
2, page 883; Vol. 12, Part 1, page 375.)
Your Committee inspected the experimental ties on this road in
September, 1911, and as a result of this inspection would advise as fol-
lows :
Carnegie Steel Ties with Wedge Fastening: The six ties placed in
the northbound main track at Pittsburg Terminal Station, May, 1908, are
still in the track. The fastenings on these ties were for 90-lb. A.S.C.E.
rail and during the past year 100-lb. A.R.A. section B rail has been laid
at this point, without any change in fastening. The Supervisor in-
formed the Committee that they have trouble in keeping the wedges
tight with the new section of rail, and previous report (Vol. 12, Part
1, page 375) states that this same trouble was experienced with the 90-
lb. rail.
With Bolt and Clip Fastening : As previously reported, 3,000 ties
of this design were laid in August, 1907, at McKees Rocks. Last year's
report indicated that the fiber installation on these ties was approaching
the end of its life, yet the Supervisor in charge of this section informed
your Committee that thej had experienced no trouble from this cause
as yet. Your Committee could see, of course, that the fiber is deteriorat-
ing, but they think that in view of the fact that the fiber is placed di-
rectly under the rail and not protected as the later design of this tie is
now furnished (Vol. 12, Part 1, page 734) excellent results have been
obtained from this fiber.
Universal Metal Tie: One hundred of these ties (see Fig. 11 for
plan of this tie*) were installed in northbound main track Pittsburg
Terminal, February, 191 1. No joint ties were placed, as can be seen in
photograph of these ties (see Fig. 16). The ties have not been in long
enough for your Committee to draw any conclusions therefrom.
Atwood Concrete Steel Tie : Five ties of this design were placed
in No. 4 main track, McKees Rocks, Pa., in October, 1908. Your Com-
mittee found these ties in good condition ; track was in good line and
surface and the Supervisor advised that they bad had no trouble with
the insulation. (See Vol. 12, Part 1, page 379, for design of this tie.)
Bruckner Reinforced Concrete Tie : Your Committee were shown
20 of these ties which had not been installed at the time of our inspec-
tion. Photographs of these ties were furnished, however, by Mr. Edwin
F. Wendt, Assistant Engineer, and they are shown in Figs. 17, 18 and 19.
One tie weighed showed a total weight of 345 lbs., while the steel
plates, fastenings, etc., weighed 25 lbs.
International Steel Tie : The International Steel Tie Company, Cleve-
land, Ohio, advise that they have installed 24 of these ties on this road
near Glassport, Pa. Design and photographs of these ties are shown in
Figs. 20-23.
In addition to the above, M'r. Edwin F. Wendt, Assistant Engineer,
has kindly furnished the Committee with the following information in
regard to cost of maintaining Carnegie steel ties mentioned above and
♦See Pennsylvania Lines. N. W.( for plan.
►J
^
u
u
Sz;
E
CO
fe
4
Pi
W
w
<
h
\
(j
K
pq
flH
360 TIES.
which were installed August, 1907 (bolt and clip fastenings), as compared
with a like stretch of wood ties :
Length of Carnegie White
Calendar Experimental Steel Ties, Oak Ties,
Year. Track Section Cost of Labor. Cost of Labor.
1908 4,400 ft. $280.00 $417.00
1909 " " 153-00 95-00
1910 " " 428.00 128.00
191 1 " " 184.00 116.00
These experimental sections of track were built with new material
and new limestone ballast in 1907. The maintenance record begins with
the calendar year 1908.
These ties were laid in the main line freight tracks, equipped with
electric circuits in connection with automatic semaphore signals. Tracks
are used by freight trains only, which run at a speed of about thirty (30)
miles per hour.
During 191 1 it was necessary to resurface the steel tie track three
times and the white oak track once.
During the year 191 1, fiber plates were removed from track on account
Fig. 16. Universal Metal Cross-Tie, Pittsburg & Lake Erie Railroad.
TIES.
361
Fig. 22. International Steel Tie, P. & L. E. R. R , Glassport, Pa.
Fig. 25. International Steel Tie, P. & L. E. R. R., Glassport, Pa.
O-Z -*H "J*!l*<>r>Z ■ 7-
,&-.B-*-'?','Z'E\
a
.«•-?-, «? fif/'fiiZ
^ff-
%
■*Hi
W-
,t-,;-;»)',;y7-/;
^5^
2L
*;r
362
364
TIES.
of being cut by rail base. Twenty bolts in steel tie clips were found to
be loose.
It is now January i, 1912, 52 months since these steel cross-ties were
laid in the track and the record of the insulations shows that no fibers
were renewed previous to 191 1, and in that year only 17 were found de-
fective. There has been, practically speaking, no signal trouble whatever.
Pittsburg Shazvmut & Northern Railroad:
(Previous advices state this company installed about 795 of Car-
negie ties during 1907. See Vol. 10, Part 2, page 885 ; Vol. 12, Part
1, page 383.)
On August 28, 191 1, Mr. H. S. Wilgus, Engineer Maintenance of
Way, says : "I have nothing further to report except that the ties con-
tine to give full satisfaction. No new ties have been installed and
further installation of the metal tie is not contemplated at this time."
Union Railroad:
(For previous reports see Vol. 10, Part 1, page 504; Vol. 11, Part
2, page 378, and Vol. 12, Part 1, page 378.)
Mr. W. S. Gibson, Engineer Maintenance of Way, advises that
they have purchased up to September 1, 191 1, 310,116 Carnegie steel
cross-ties and 392 sets of Carnegie steel switch ties, and that during
the remainder of the year 191 1 they will purchase 30,000 additional steel
cross-ties and 50 sets of steel switch ties.
Your Committee made a careful inspection over a large part of
the main line of this road and they were very favorably impressed with
the service these ties are giving.
Fig. 19. Bruckner Reinforced Concrete Cross-Tie, Pittsburg & Lake
Erie Railroad.
TIES. 366
On this road the Committee inspected 5,000 Carnegie ties with the
wedge fastening (for design see Vol. 10, Part 1, page 504). Mr. Gibson
advised that they had no trouble with the wedges and he further said
he was very much in favor of this fastening as compared with the other
fastenings they have tried.
The Committee tested a number of the wedges and found prac-
tically all of them tight.
Hocking Valley Railroad:
The International Steel Tie Company, of Cleveland, Ohio, advise thev
have furnished 32 of their ties which were installed at Columbus, Ohio.
(See Figs. 24 and 25.)
Fig. 24. International Steel Tie, Hocking Valley R. R.
Altoona & Logan Valley Railway (Altoona, Pa.):
The International Steel Tie Company, Cleveland, Ohio, advise that-
this company have used 550 of their ties. (See Figs. 26 and 27 for photo-
graphs of this track.)
Boston Elevated Railway:
(For previous reports see Vol. 11, Part 2, page 898, and Vol. 12,
Part i, page 387.)
Mr. A. L. Plimpton states that since making previous report they
have installed the following:
1910, 71 Carnegie Ties, Sec. M-25, 14^ lbs. per ft., 7 ft. long; 1911,
1,711 Carnegie ties, Sec. M-25, *4^ lbs. per ft., 7 ft. long; 191 1, 12
Lorain Steel Company ties; 191 1, 614 McDonald concrete ties.
No details are given as to the design of the concrete ties.
Brooklyn Rapid Transit Company (Brooklyn Heights Railroad Com-
pany) :
(See previous reports, Vol. 12, Part 1, page 388.)
Mr. C. L. Crabbs, Engineer Way and Structures, advises, September
22, 191 1, as follows: "We have made no use of metal or composite
ties on this System since the date of information previously furnished
you, about one year ago."
-"366 TIES.
c .;
*r Chicago City Railway:
9> Hi (See previous reports, Vol. n, Part 2, page 898; Vol. 12, Part 1,
^T.page 388.)
— Mr. H. B. Fleming, Chief Engineer, says: "We have just placed an
fc Ujorder with the Carnegie Steel Company for enough steel ties and fas-
^"tenings to lav one mile of track."
Fig. 25. International Steel Tie, Hocking Valley R. R.
Fig. 26. International Steel Tie, Altoona & Logan Valley Ry
TIES.
367
Fig. 27. International Steel Tie, Altoona & Logan Valley Ry.
Fig. 29. International Steel Tie, Cleveland Railways Company.
368
TIES.
Cleveland Railways Company:
The International Steel Tie Company, Cleveland, Ohio, advise that
this company have used 3,300 of their ties. Photographs of this track are
shown in Figs. 28 and 29.
Lake Shore Electric Railway Company (Sandusky, Ohio):
Mr. A. V. Brown, Engineer Maintenance of Way, says :
"The only ties we have installed other than hardwood and cedar
ties are steel ties manufactured by the Carnegie Steel Company, known
as their section M-25. We have installed about iJ4 miles of this style
Fig. 28. International Steel Tie, Cleveland Railways Company.
of tie, using wide base uppermost and bolting 85-lb. A. S. C. E rail rigidly
to these ties by means of their No. 25 fastening. This fastening was
manufactured by the Carnegie Steel Company at our suggestion. Some
of this track has been in use 11 months and up to present time has given
excellent satisfaction, with no signs of deterioration.
"Six inches of concrete is used as sub-base and concrete is also placed
to the top of the ties, same being tamped to place with tamping bars."
Denver City Tramway Company:
(See previous reports, Vol. 11, Part 2, page 898; Vol. 12, Part 1,
page 388.)
Mr. A. M. Evans advises : "We can add no further information,
nor have we made any additional installation of steel ties, nor contem-
plate any in the near future."
TIES.
369
New York State Railways (Rochester, N. Y.):
Mr. B. E. Tilton, Engineer Maintenance of Way, advises :
"We have put in to date 2,035 section M-25 and 10,310 section M-24
Carnegie steel ties. These ties are all laid in concrete, 6 in. of concrete
underneath the ties. No attempt has been made to lay the steel ties on
stone ballast in our city lines on account of the fact that the pavement
cannot be left open long enough to give the ties the necessary tampine
No steel ties have been laid on interurban lines "
Scioto Valley Traction Company (Circleville, Ohio):
The International Steel Tie Company (Cleveland, Ohio), advise that
this line has used 2,200 of their ties.
Twin City Lines:
(See previous report, Vol. n, Part 2, page 897; Vol. 12, Part 1, page
386.)
"This
Mr. Geo. L. Wilson, Engineer Maintenance of Way, says :
company has nothing further to report."
Utica & Mohawk Valley Railway:
(See previous reports, Vol. 11, Part 2, page 897; Vol. 12, Part 1,
page 387.)
Mr. M. J. French, Engineer Maintenance of Way, advises : "We
have used 713 Carnegie M-25, 7~ft. steel ties this year on North Genesee
street, Utica. We have 865 of these steel ties on hand for use next
year on West Dominick street, Rome, N. Y. The Oneida Railway Corn-
et.
Fig. 30. Carnegie Steel Tie M-25, Showing Braces and Bolts for
Girder Rails.
pany, which is an affiliated company, under the New York State Rail-
ways control, has an order placed for 700 of these ties, for use on Madi-
son and Sconondoa streets, in the city of Oneida, N, Y. These ties are
for use with T-rail in concrete construction, the tracks to be paved with
brick."
Virginia Railway & Power Company:
(For previous reports see Vol. 11, Part 2, page 898; Vol. 12, Part
1, page 387.)
Mr. T. Norman Jones, Chief Engineer, advises October 3, 191 1,
that they are laying two miles of track with 115-lb. 9-in. girder rail on
Carnegie M-25 tie with Lorain brace fastening. (See Fig. 30.) We
are using the tie inverted, in other words, with the broad base next to
the rail.
370 TIES.
CONCLUSIONS.
Your Committee respectfully submits the following conclusions :
1. The concrete tie, a combination of concrete and metal tie, or a
combination of asphalt and metal tie has not yet proved a success for
the following reasons :
(a) Fracture caused by vibration ;
(b) Excessive weight and consequent difficulty in handling;
(c) Deterioration of asphalt filling.
2. A combination tie of steel and wood gives promise of develop-
ing an economic substitute.
3. The all steel tie has proved a satisfactory substitute for the
wood tie under heavy medium speed traffic. It ia durable, line and sur-
face can be maintained, has sufficient resiliency and can be insulated.
The fastenings so far in use can and no doubt will be improved.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON TIES.
REPORT OP COMMITTEE V— ON TRACK.
J. B. Jenkins, Chairman; G. J. Ray, Vice -Chairman;
Geo. H. Bremner. H. T. Porter.
A. Bruner. W. G. Raymond.
Garrett Davis. S. S. Roberts.
Raffe Emerson. L. S. Rose.
E. G Ericson. R. O. Rote.
J. M. R. Fairbairn. H. R. Safford.
T. H. Hickey. F. A. Smith.
J. R. Leighty. C. H. Stein.
Thomas Maney. F. S. Stevens.
CURTISS MlLI.ARD. W. J. TOWNE.
P. C. Newbegin. R. A. Van Houten.
R. M. Pearce. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Two meetings of the Committee on Track have been held since the
convention of 191 1 — on June 15 and October 13.
The subjects assigned were:
(1) Present general specifications covering material and workman-
ship for frogs, crossings and switches, including the use of manganese
and other special alloys.
(2 1 Present general specifications for track bolts, nut locks, tie-plates,
common track spikes and screw spikes.
(3) Study designs for main line turnouts.
FROGS, CROSSINGS AND SWITCHES.
Your Committee has revised the plans for Nos. 8, 11 and 16 Rigid
Frogs, No. 11 Spring Frog and for n-ft, 16^-ft., 22-ft., and 33-ft.
switches and submits them for adoption as general plans representing
good practice.
Your Committee has also revised and combined the "General Speci-
fications for Frogs, Crossings and Switches" adopted by the convention of
1910, and the "General Instructions for Ordering or Contracting for Frogs,
Crossings and Switches," submitted to the convention of 191 1 and received
as information, and submits them for adoption as representing good
practice.
At the convention of 1909, the Association instructed the Track Com-
mittee to recommend three standard lengths of switches and three standard
numbers of frogs ; such a recommendation was made, with the modifi-
371
372 TRACK.
cation that a fourth length of switch was added for special cases requiring
frogs of large angle ; the recommendation was embodied in Conclusion
(4) of your Committee's report, which was adopted by the convention of
1910, but was referred back to the Committee by the Board of Direction
for reconsideration.
Your Committee reconsidered and reaffirmed its former action; the
conclusion was not resubmitted, however, excepting as the proposed
lengths of switches and numbers of frogs were embodied in the "General
Instructions for Ordering or Contracting for Frogs, Crossings and
Switches" which was received only as information by the Association at
the convention of 1911.
In determining the lengths of switches your Committee considered it
necessary to provide for the following general classes of turnouts :
(a) Turnouts to be operated over the divergent route at the maxi-
mum practicable limited speed.
(b) Main line turnouts and crossovers to be operated over the di-
vergent route at low speed.
(c) Yard turnouts.
(d) Turnouts requiring frogs of large angle.
The second point considered was the economical cutting of a 33-ft.
rail; the question of using the full 33 ft. as one of the lengths of switch
was very fully discussed by your Committee at meetings held in three
successive years. The main objections to the use of a 33-ft. switch are (1 )
the length being the same as that of stock rail unless a special length of
stock rail is used, one joint of the latter must necessarily come near the
point of the switch and the other joint ahead of and near the heel of the
switch, often necessitating the clipping of the angle bars, and (2) the
great length of laterally unsupported rail.
Your Committee is of the opinion that (1) the location of the joints
of the stock rail 40 inches ahead of the point and heel of switch is not
seriously objectionable and the clipping of the angle bars is not an ex-
pensive operation and does not seriously weaken the joint, and that (2)
switches 33 ft. and even 45 ft. long have been successfully used to such
an extent that there seems to be little ground for apprehension on account
of the length of laterally unsupported rail.
Twenty-seven (27) ft. and 30-ft. lengths have been suggested in lieu
of a 33-ft. length; the angles would be respectively 22 per cent, and 10
per cent, greater than that for 33 ft.
The longest switch points are to be used in those turnouts where the
highest speed is desired. These switch points will necessarily get severe
usage, therefore they should be made from the very best rail. If made
from the second or third rail from the top of the ingot, you have elim-
inated as far as possible any chance of defect in the rail. These rails are
as a rule 33 ft. in length. The lengths of switches recommended can be
made from 33 ft. rails without any waste.
These and other considerations led your Committee to recommend the
TRACK. 373
following length of switch points for the four general classes of turnouts
named above :
(a) 33 ft.; (b) 22 ft.; (c) i6y2-it.; (d) 11 ft.
A purely theoretical investigation of the rate of turning of a locomo-
tive at the switch point and of the angle between the stock rail and a line
passing through truck centers of a car leaving the switch, indicates that an
approximate balance between the deflection through the switch point and
the deflection through the lead is attained when the switch angle equals
one-fourth the frog angle. This proportion has been found to work out
well in practice. It seems to be certain that when the switch angle exceeds
one-fourth the frog angle, the switch point presents the worst feature in
the alinement of the turnout and there is an economic loss both in the
space occupied by the turnout and in the cost of the turnout.
With a 6j4-in. heel distance and J^-in. thickness of point, the above
relation between switch angle and frog angle would make the length of
the switch in feet equal to twice the frog number.
In 1908 the frogs most used appear, from a table compiled by the En-
gineering News, to have been numbers 10, 7, 8, 9, 6, 15, 12, 20, 11, 14 and
16 in the order named; number 10 frogs being used by 55% of the roads
tabulated and number 16 by only 5%. But the roads using No. n's in-
cluded the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy, Great Northern, Michigan Cen-
tral and Northern Pacific and those using No. 16's the Baltimore &
Ohio, Erie and Lake Shore & Michigan Southern. ■
No. 7 frogs are rapidly disappearing, being supplanted by No. 8's ; the
relative number of No. io's is also diminishing, with a corresponding in-
crease in the proportion of frogs of higher numbers.
It seems desirable for Class (A) turnouts to use the highest number
of frog which is economically consistent with the longest switch point;
for Class (B) the great preponderance of present practice is in favor of
No. 10 frogs, but the choice of this frog would leave an unfilled gap between
this and the highest number frog ; besides, a No. 10 turnout with a 16^2 ft.
switch is little better in its worst feature than a No. 8 turnout with the
same switch, while a 22-ft. switch would unduly increase the degree of lead
curve; for Class (C) the trend of present practice, if not the preponder-
ance of practice at this date, is in favor of No. 8 frogs ; for Class (D) no
number of frog can be specified, as this class includes a multitude of
special cases.
Your Committee presents its former recommendation in a modified
form:
i6T/2-it. switch points are recommended for frogs over No. 6 up to and
including No. 10; 22-ft. points for frogs over No. 10 up to and including
No. 14; 33-ft. points for frogs over No. 14 and 11-ft. points for No. 6
and under where they are required.
Nos. 8, 11 and 16 frogs are recommended as meeting all general re-
quirements for yards, main track switches and junctions; new work should
be laid out. so far as practicable, for these three frogs, so as to effect the
374 TRACK.
gradual elimination of frogs of other numbers, lessen the cost of manufac-
ture and decrease the amount of stock carried.
TIE-PLATES AND TRACK FASTENINGS.
No attempt was made to prepare specifications, but your Committee
attempted to formulate principles as to the functions, material and form
of tie-plates and track fastenings. The work has not progressed far
enough at this time to be embodied in a report.
DESIGNS OF MAIN LINE TURNOUTS.
The work of your Committee on this subject is necessarily held in
abeyance pending the adoption of standard numbers of frogs and lengths
of switches.
VERTICAL CURVES.
In order to get the benefit of experience in the use of vertical curves, a
series of questions was asked members of the Association and the replies
tabulated.
Under apparently like conditions, widely different results were
obtained; this leads to the conclusion that the conditions were only
apparently alike and that there must be other unknown conditions. The
data in its present form seems to give very little information of value.
Your Committee will continue its investigations.
CONCLUSIONS.
Your Committee recommends :
(r) That the "General Specifications for Frogs, Crossings and
Switches" be adopted as representing good practice.
(2) That the plans of No. 8, 11 and 16 rigid frogs, No. 11 spring
frog and 11 ft., 16^ ft., 22 ft. and 33 ft. switches be adopted as general
plans representing good practice.
*(3) That the Committee's recommendation as to lengths of switches
and numbers of frogs be adopted.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON TRACK.
*For amendments, see Index.
TRACK 375
GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR FROGS, CROSS-
INGS AND SWITCHES.
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS.
The Company will furnish to the manufacturer specifications and
drawings. The drawings will show rail sections, splice drilling, angles,
alinement, general dimensions and such details as the Company may desire.
When requested, manufacturers shall submit for approval detail draw-
ings showing construction and dimensions of all parts to be furnished in
accordance with these specifications. Conventional shading shall be used
in sectional drawings. All dimensions and distances shall be shown plainly
in figures. The title shall be placed in the lower right-hand corner.
The detail drawings shall be on sheets twenty-two (22) in. wide, with
a border line one-half (J*4) in. from the top, bottom and right hand edge,
and one and one-half (1^2) in. from the left hand edge. The standard
length of sheets shall be thirty (30) in. except that when necessary, longer
sheets may be used and folded back to the standard length. Drawings of
one subject only shall appear on a sheet. Scale of general drawings shall
be i\/2 in. = 1 ft.; details not less than 3 in. = 1 ft.
The drawings of the Company and the manufacturers' drawings
approved by the Company shall be a part of the specifications. Anything
which is not shown on the drawings but which is mentioned in the speci-
fications, or vice versa, or anything not expressly set forth in either but
which is reasonably implied, shall be furnished the same as if specifically
shown and mentioned in both. Should anything be omitted from the
drawings or specifications that is necessary for a clear understanding of
the work or should any error appear in either the drawings or specifications
affecting the work, it shall be the duty of the manufacturer to notify the
Company and he shall not proceed with the work until instructed to do so
by the Company.
INSPECTION.
Material and workmanship shall be at all times subject to inspection
by a duly authorized representative of the Company, who will examine
the material before it is worked in the shop. He will inspect the work
during progress and will also inspect the finished product, with power
to reject materials and workmanship found to be unsatisfactory. He shall
have free access to the shops and mills at any and all times during the
progress of the work.
The acceptance of any material by an inspector shall not prevent sub-
sequent rejection if found defective after delivery or during the progress
of the work and such defective material if furnished by the manufacturer
fhall be replaced by him at his own expense.
376 TRACK.
All facilities, labor and tools necessary for the shop inspection shall b«
furnished at the expense of the manufacturer.
When the manufacturer furnishes the rails, he shall supply the Com-
pany with a certificate of inspection made by some competent person
acceptable to Ihe Company.
MATERIAL.
Rail.
No. i rail, of the section ordered, as called for by the specifications,
shall be used.
Fillers.
Fillers between the main and wing rails and between the main and
easer rails shall be rolled steel. Throat filler blocks, not presenting a
running surface, may be cast-iron.
Raiser Blocks.
Raiser blocks shall be hard cast steel.
Foot Guards.
Metallic foot guards shall be either cast-iron, malleable iron or cast
steel, except that strap foot guards shall be rolled steel. Wooden foot
guards shall be of best quality hard wood.
Bolts.
Bolts shall be of double refined iron or mild steel. Bolt metal shall
have a tensile strength of not less than 50,000 lbs. per sq. in. and an
elongation of not less than 15 per cent, in eight inches. When nicked and
then broken, the fracture shall be free from flaws and unwelded seams.
Rivets.
Rivets shall be made of steel which may contain a maximum of 0.04
per cent, basic phosphorus, 0.04 per cent, acid phosphorus and 0.04 per
cent, sulphur. It shall have an ultimate tensile strength of 50,000 lbs. per
sq. in. It shall bend flat upon itself without fracture and when nicked
and bent around a bar of the same diameter as the rivet rod it shall give a
gradual break with a fine silky uniform fracture.
Reinforcing Bars.
Reinforcing bars shall be of wrought-iron or mild steel.
Plates.
Plates shall be of rolled steel.
Springs.
Springs shall be of the best quality spring steel and of dimensions and
capacity shown on the plans. They shall meet the following tests :
(a) Each spring shall be placed on the testing machine and forced
down solid four times.
(b) After the foregoing, each spring shall be placed on end on a
flat plate, and the distance between the plate and the other end of the
spring measured by means of the standard depth gage ; this measurement
TRACK. 377
being the free length of the spring. The free length must conform to
the plans within J^-in.
(c) Double springs shall be assembled and a load at least 25 per cent.
greater than the rated capacity of the spring shall be applied for thirty
seconds. Upon release neither spring must vary from its original free
length. If either one does so vary, it shall be rejected.
(d) The inner and outer coils of springs shall be coiled in opposite
directions.
Spring Covers.
Spring covers shall be made of malleable iron.
Braces.
malleable iron.
Braces shall be made of forged sted
Stops and Hold-downs.
Stops and hold-downs shall be made of mild steel.
Anti-creeping Device.
Anti-creeping device shall be made of mild steel.
Switch Lugs.
Switch lugs shall be mild steel.
Switch Rods.
Switch rods shall be mild steel.
WORKMANSHIP.
Workmanship shall be first-class. All bends shall be made accurately
in arcs of circles and without injury to the material. Welding will not be
permitted in any part of the frogs or in the switch rails. Planing shall be
such that abutting surfaces will fit accurately together. Ends of rails shall
be cut at right angles to the axis of the rail except where otherwise speci-
fied. All burrs shall be removed.
No paint, tar or other covering shall be used before inspection.
The alinement and surface of all finished work shall be even and true,
and shall conform to the angles specified.
FROGS.
Fillers.
Rolled fillers shall fit the fishing angles and the web of the rail for a
distance of H-in. above and below the base and head, respectively, and
shall maintain the required flangeway. Throat filler blocks shall fit the
rail sufficiently well to maintain the required spacing. Where the brand
of the rail interferes with the fit of the filler the brand shall be chipped
off. Fillers shall be grooved or cut out to fit over rivet heads.
Heel Raiser Blocks.
Heel raiser-blocks shall fit the head, base and web of rail as provided
under rolled fillers.
378 TRACK.
Foot Guards.
Solid Foot Guards shall fit the rail sufficiently well to maintain the
required spacing. Strap guards shall have a minimum thickness of 5^-in.,
of the width shown on plan and shall be fastened to the web of the rail by
bolts or rivets not less than 3/f-in. in diameter.
Bolts.
Bolts must be round and true to size, with square heads and nuts.
Threads must be accurately cut and nuts must have a wrench-tight fit.
Each bolt must be provided with an approved head lock and a nut lock of
approved pattern large enough to give full bearing for the nut. A J^-in.
cotter pin shall, when required, be placed outside of and close up to the nut
after it is tightened. Beveled washers must be used wherever necessary to
give the head and nut a full, square bearing. Separate head lock shall be of
material not less than ?k-in. thick. Washers used under heads may be of
such design as to act as head locks. Bolts must be long enough to allow
the nuts to be brought out from under the head of the rail, with a suitable
washer not less than ^-in. thick, so that the nuts may be readily tightened
with an ordinary wrench.
Rivets.
The diameters of the rivets shall be of full size shown on plan, and
the diameters of the rivet holes shall not be more than -rs-in. greater than
the diameters of the corresponding rivets. The rivets shall be of sufficient
length to provide full, neatly made heads when driven. They shall be
driven tight, bringing all adjacent parts into contact.
Rivets, when not countersunk or flattened, shall have standard button
luads of uniform size for the same size rivets. The heads shall be full and
neatly made and concentric with the holes. When the rivet heads are
countersunk they shall be flush with the plate and fill the holes.
Reinforcing Bars.
Reinforcing bars shall fit the fishing angles and web of rail through-
out their length.
Plates.
Plates shall be flat and true to surface.
Springs.
Springs shall have the ends square with the axis, so that when the
spring is placed on end on a flat surface it will stand perpendicular
thereto.
Spring Covers.
Spring covers shall be of such dimension as to permit a proper work-
ing of the springs and shall be provided with a spring bearing for •'ach end
of the spring.
Braces.
Braces shall fit the head and web of rail accurately.
TRACK.
379
Stops and Hold-downs.
*Stops shall be so placed on plates as to hold the wing rail at i^-in.
opening at the J^-in. point. Hold-downs shall fit stops so as to allow at
least 2 in. horizontal play and not more than ^-in. vertical play.
Anti-creeping Device.
The anti-creeping device shall fit accurately to the parts of the frog
or angle bars.
Holes for Main Bolts.
Holes shall be drilled from the solid. No punching will be permitted
10LLE0 5TEE
WEIGHT
or
RAIL
SIZE
or frog
BOLTS
100
IV
90
IV
SO
IV
10
r
to
V
SECTION A-
NO. 8 RIGID FROG
WEIGHT
OF
RAIL
SIZE
or frog
BOLTS
too
Hi
so
m
BO
lli
70
I'
to
tA
NO. 11 RIGID FROG
except of bottom plates and washers Drilling shall be accurately done,
on bevel where necessary, and holes shall be made <rV-in. less in diameter
than the bolt to be used. Then the parts shall be assembled and the holes
reamed so they are straight and true, with no offsets between the adjacent
parts, and of such size as to give the bolts a driving fit for their entire
length.
"For amendments, see Index.
380
TRACK.
In lieu of the above specification for drilling and reaming, the manu-
facturer may assemble and accurately fit all the parts, before any drilling
whatever is done; after the parts are securely clamped in their correct
positions the holes may be drilled of such a size as to give the bolts a
driving fit for their entire length.
SECTION AA
SECTION BB
SECT/ON CC
WEIGHT
OFRML
5/Z£ OF
FPOGBOLTS
too
Is-
90
n-
80
't-
70
/ '
60
*"
NO II SPRING FROG
SECTION C-C
•height
OF RAIL
SIZE OF 1
FROG BOLTS
WO
/"»"
90
iV
BO
/*
70
SO
V
NO 16 RIGID FROG
Marking.
The number of the frog, maker's name, weight of rail and the date
shall be plainly stamped with 24-in. figures and letters on the flare of one
wing rail for rigid frogs and the flare of both wing rails for spring frogs,
or a plate shall be fastened to the frog with the same information.
TRACK. 381
l
SWITCHES.
Throw.
S in. at center line of No. i rod.
Gage of Track.
4 ft. &y2 in.
Switch Ralls.
Side planing and bending shall conform to a spread at the heel of 6%
in. between the gage lines of the stock rail and the switch rail and a thick-
ness of J4-in. at the point. The bending and planing shall be done so as to
give a straight gage line to the switch rail. The switch rail shall after-
ward be ground down to a thickness of Ms-in. at the point, beginning 2 ft.
back from the point of the switch; the point of the switch shall then be
ground down to a sharp edge with a radius of 1J/2 in. The head of switch
rail shall fit neatly against the head of stock rail from point of switch rail
to point of divergence. The inner edge of the head of the stock rail and
the outer face of the web of the switch rail at the point shall be in the
same vertical line when the switch rail is fitted against the stock rail.
Top planing shall conform to the measurements shown on Fig. 1 and
Table 1.
SfacAr /?a>//—?
Fig. 1.
*Table
I.
Switch.
A. B.
33 ft.
12 ft.
22 ft.
9 ft.
16 ft. 6 in.
5 ft.
11 ft.
5 ft.
Bottom of switch rail shall be planed to fit neatly on base of stock
rail where bases overlap.
The point of switch rail shall be as shown by Fig. 2.
Holes for switch rod lugs and stop blocks shall be §§-in. in diam-
eter and 5 in. center to center. Holes for reinforcing bars shall be §§-in.
diameter. Number and location as provided under Reinforcing Bars.
Lugs.
Lugs shall be as deep as the section of ' rail will permit.
Distance between centers of holes for bolts running through the web
of the rail shall be 5 in. Diameter of holes shall be Sf-in. Switch rod
hnlt hole shall he r J? in. in diameter
♦For amendments, see Index.
382
TRACK.
Switch Rods.
Switch rods shall be M*2^2 in- and shall be held in a horizontal
plane. Bolt holes shall be la's in. in diameter. There shall be at least
iV2 in. of metal at end beyond bolt holes.
Reinforcing Bars.
A reinforcing bar ^-in. thick shall be riveted to each side of each
switch rail and point ends shall be made flush with point of switch rail.
The bars shall be as long as the heel connections will permit. Bars shall
fit against web of rail and shall fill the space between head and flange of
rail. There shall be M$-in. clearance between outer bar and head of stock
rail where the bar projects under the head of stock rail. Top of inner
Not less
thanlj"
Sectionl£ from point
Length
Switch
11
16 6"
22' i 11
33'
Dist.
A
_£
*XL
YK
^Ground to sharp edge
1
Stock Rail
\-
^d^L_
^g^^^ig^- — -f^r--^^
r
Hi
|
Point Rail
~* ' " ■ — j
>
r-A— H
TOP VIEW
Fig. 2 — Details of Point.
bar, where it projects beyond the head of switch rail, shall not be less than
1%, in. below the top of stock rail. The reinforcing bar shall be beveled
to an angle of 45 degrees where it projects beyond the head of the rail.
rivets
Bars shall be fastened to rail with 54-in. . , ' except that at the
first, second and fifth holes, and the holes through which the lugs are
fastened, they shall be bolted. Center of first hole shall be \V2 in. from
point and center of last hole in bar shall be 2 in. from heel end of bar.
Intermediate "v£ s shall be spaced so that there shall be fastenings at
intervals not greater than 12 in.
TRACK.
383
Stop Blocks.
Stop blocks shall be of approved design with holes ii-in. in diameter.
Stop blocks shall be spaced as nearly as practicable at equal intervals be-
tween the end of planing and heel of switch.
Heel Blocks.
Heel blocks shall be of approved design with standard rail drilling.
Bolts and Nuts.
Bolts fastening lugs, stop blocks and foot guards to switch rails shall
HHEN NO. I ROD IS OSEO AS LOCK ROD, TIES MAr BE
3HKEO AS SHOHN Br BROKEN LINES. LOCATION OF
NO. 2 ROD WILL BE CHANGED.
/6' 6' SWITCH
WHEN NO. I ROD IS USED AS LOCK ROD . TIES MAY BE
SPACED AS SHOWN Br BROKEN LINES . LOCATION OF
NO. 2 ROD WILL BE CHANGED.
' 20' 1 22' | 22' I 22' I 22' \ 22' I
I twJ-i IwMfl I j— — 1 I
I \.I2 ^2Q' I 20 J 20' | 20'
11' SWITCH
be 34-in. in diameter. Bolts connecting the lugs with switch rods and the
switch-stand connecting bolt shall be I in. in diameter and machine turned-
384
TRACK.
All bolts shall be provided with nut locks and cotters, fain, bolts shall
have hexagonal nuts and i in. bolts shall have square nuts.
Rivets.
The diameters of the rivets shall be of full size shown on plan, and
the diameters of the rivet holes shall not be more than ds-in. greater than
*
K
<0
386 TRACK.
the diameters of the corresponding rivets. The rivets shall be of sufficient
length to provide full, neatly made heads when driven. They shall be
driven tight, bringing all adjacent parts into contact.
Rivets, when not countersunk or flattened, shall have standard button
heads of uniform size for the same size rivets. The heads shall be full
and neatly made and concentric with the holes.
When the rivet heads are countersunk they shall be flush with the
plate and fill the holes.
Plates.
There shall be on each tie two plates of suitable length %-in. by 7 in.,
planed down to receive the stock rail and braces. Three holes outside
and two inside are required for %-in. lag screws or screw spikes, or for
ordinary spikes, as may be specified, on all switch ties, except the two
head ties, where there shall be three outside and five inside, one of the
inside holes to be in position for spiking the switch.
Braces.
Braces shall be of such a design that 2^/2 in. clearance for detector
bars may be obtained. Three holes for y%-\n. lag screws or screw spikes
shall be provided.
Foot Guards.
Strap foot guards shall have a minimum thickness of 5^-in. and
shall be fastened to the web of the rail by 24-in. bolts or rivets.
Note. — The following members of the Committee approve the report
as submitted herewith : J. B. Jenkins, Chairman ; L. S. Rose, Garrett
Davis, J. R. Leighty, Curtiss Millard, T. H. Hickey, Raffe Emerson,
J. M. R. Fairbairn, H. T. Porter. P. C. Newbegin, W. G. Raymond, S. S.
Roberts, F. A. Smith, R. A. Van Houten, W. J. Towne, H. R. Safford,
R. M. Pearce, C. H. Stein, Thos. Maney.
The following members of the Committee approve the report con-
ditionally ; G. J. Ray, A. Bruner, F. S. Stevens.
The following members dissent from portions of the report : Geo. H.
Rremner. R. O. Rote.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE I— ON ROADWAY.
J. E. Willoughey. Chairman; W. M. Dawley, Vice-Chairman;
J. R. W. Ambrose. W. D. Pence
John C. Beye. A. C. Prime.
D. J. Brumley. Hiram J. Slifer.
W. C. Curd. J. A. Spielmann.
Paul Didier. John G. Sullivan.
R. C. Falconer. F. L. Wheaton.
S. B. Fisher. W. P. Wiltsee.
T. H. Gatlin. R. C. Young.
C. S. Millard. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Roadway respectfully submits its report to the
thirteenth annual convention.
Two meetings of the full Committee were held, both at Chicago, one
on June 23 and the other on November 28.
That each of the four subjects assigned to your Committee might
have attention, the membership of the Committee was grouped into a
like number of sub-committees.
(1) PRESENT FORMULAE OF GENERAL APPLICATION FOR
DETERMINING WATERWAY AREAS UNDER VARYING
CONDITIONS, WITH THE CONSIDERATION
ALSO OF HYDRAULIC FEATURES.
W. D. Pence, Chairman ; John C. Beye, Hiram J. Slifer, R. C. Falconer.
F. L. Wheaton, Sub-Committee.
Your Committee has been considering for several years the possibility
of preparing, or of selecting from the various formulae in common u?e.
one that can be recommended for general application. The investigation
made since the Committee's report to the annual convention in March.
1909, does not warrant the Committee in varying from the opinion then
expressed and accepted by the Association (see Proceedings, Vol. 10, Part
2), to-wit:
"(1) In determining the size of a given waterway, careful considera-
tion should be given to local conditions, including flood height and flow,
size and behavior of other openings in the vicinity carrying the same stream,
characteristics of the channel and of the watershed area, climatic condi-
tions, extent and character of traffic on the given line of road and probable
387
388 ROADWAY.
consequences of interruptions to same, and any other elements likely to
affect the safety or economy of the culvert or opening.
"(2) (a) The practice of using a formula to assist in fixing the
proper size of the waterway in a given case is warranted to the extent
that the formula and the values of the terms substituted therein are known
to fit local conditions.
"(b) Waterway formulae are also used as a guide in fixing or veri-
fying culvert areas where only general information as to the local condi-
tions is at hand.
"(c) The use of such formulae should not displace careful observa-
tion and the exercise of intelligent judgment on the part of the engineer.
"(d) No single waterway formula can be recommended as fitting all
conditions of practice."
To the above the Committee added the following conclusions in its
report to the annual convention, March, 191 1 (Proceedings, Vol. 12, Part
3), to- wit :
"(1) There is a general relationship between the best-known water-
way and run-off formulae. This relationship may be expressed by two
terms, a varying co-efficient and a varying exponent, substantially as shown
by the accompanying diagrams, Figs. 2 and 3.
"(2) The extent of this relationship for large and small areas is
indicated by the Dun waterway data, given in Table 1 and shown graphic-
ally by Fig. 1."
The Committee's work since the twelfth annual convention has been
directed toward the consideration rather of the hydraulic features of the
culvert, and while some progress has been made, the Committee is not
prepared now to make any definite recommendation.
(2) REPORT ON UNIT PRESSURES ALLOWABLE ON ROAD-
BEDS OF DIFFERENT MATERIALS, CONFERRING WITH
THE COMMITTEE ON BALLAST.
R. C. Young, Chairman; J. R. W. Ambrose, C. S. Millard. S. B.
Fisher, A. C. Prime, Sub-Committee.
The Committee has been collecting information for two years for the
purpose of formulating a conclusion as to what unit pressures are allow-
able on the roadbed, and the Committee has come to the conclusion that
since the available data treats of the sustaining power of soils below the
surface, rather than of that of soils peculiarly exposed as the roadbed
is to moisture, to the action of frost, and to the loadings peculiar to train
service, it will be necessary to make experiments to determine the magni-
tude and distribution of the loads transmitted to the roadbed through
ballast of various kinds and also to determine by test the bearing power
of various materials under varying conditions ordinarily attained in the
construction of the roadway. The Committee submits as information the
following memorandum prepared by Mr. W. M. Dawley, its Vice-Chair-
man, after adjournment of the November, 1911, meeting:
"The safe bearing power of soils depends upon their character or
composition, depth of strata, amount of water they contain or are liable
to receive and the degree to which they are confined.
ROADWAY.
389
"Practically all of the published data in relation to the bearing power
of soils is in connection with foundation work for bridges and buildings
and the bearing values given are for loads applied at varying depths below
the surface of the ground, hence on soils more or less well confined, and
serve merely as a rough guide to the bearing power of soils other than
rock when the load is applied at the surface and the soil is unconfined.
"The following table from 'Data' gives the safe bearing value in tons
per square foot of soils and rock which may be placed on uniform strata
of considerable thickness and well confined :
Authority
Character of Soil
i.o:
Baker
G. B.
Francis
Elmer L. Corthell
G. F.
Gebhardt
w. w.
Christie
Min.
Max.
Min. Max.
Min. Max.
Av.
Min. Max.
Min. Max.
ROCK— Granite, etc., in
200
25
15
5
30
20
10
Ledge
Rock 36
Solid Bed
Rock up to
20% of net
Crushing
Strength
Solid 200
ROCK — Limestone, equal
Bed
ROCK— Sandstone, equal
ROCK— Soft and pliable
as shale, equal to poor
ROCK— Broken and well
10.0 15.0
5 to 25
HARD PAN— Gravel and
sand well cemented with
8
6
4
1
10
8
6
2
8
3
3 12
2 8
8.7
5.08
CLAY— Thick beds and
CLAY— Thick beds and
CLAY— Soft, wet, con-
3.0 4.0
2.0
4
2
1.0
1
G RAVEL— Coarse and
dry, well compacted and
5
4
1
2.4 7.75
2.5 8.5
2.25 5.8
1.5 6.2
5.1
4.9
4.5
2.9
6.0 8.0
1.5
8
SAND — Dry, compact,
well cemented with clay.
SAND— Clear and dry,
4
2
o.;
6
4
1
4
2.0
2
QUICKSAND— Marshy
and alluvial soils, silt,
0.5
0.5
"Elmer L. Corthell has tabulated various existing pressures of stable
structures which have shown no settlement. Data were obtained from 178
separate works, in response to letter sent to prominent engineers through-
out the world, requesting their experiences. The average value given. Mr.
Corthell says, is low, and a safe one lies between the average and maxi-
mum. (See 'Allowable Pressures on Deep Foundations,' Corthell, 1906.)
"G. F. Gebhardt gives values which are an average of maximum loads
allowed in most cities under the building laws.
"Richard Delafield, Brevet Major-Gencral, Corps of Engineers, United
States Army, member of Light House Board in 'Memoir on Foundations
in Compressible Soils,' Washington, D. C, 1881, says, on page 13:
" 'The compressibility of oolitic clays can only be overcome by piling,
deep sinking, heavy ramming or heavy weighting. The point of bearing
must be carried below the possibility of upward reaction. The depth of a
foundation in compressible ground ought not to be less than one-fourth
the intended height of the building above ground; that is, for a shaft
of 200 ft., the foundation should be made secure to a depth of 50 ft. by
390 ROADWAY.
piling or by well-sinking and concrete. (Engineer and Architectural
Journal, for 1837.) Masses of concrete, brick or stone, placed on a com-
pressible substratum, however cramped and bound, may prove unsafe.
Solidity from a considerable depth alone can be relied upon. Mere en-
largement of a base may not in itself be sufficient.
"In experiments made by Hugh Leonard (M. A.) at Akra for the
purpose of testing the ordinary undisturbed alluvial soil of Calcutta, 'The
results showed that for Calcutta the weight on the foundation should
not be more than one ton to the superficial foot.' Journal of Royal Insti-
tute of British Architects, 1900, pp. 390-394.
"In Cunningham's Dock Engineering, page 183, speaking of founda-
tions for masonry dock walls, it is stated that 'The maximum intensity
of pressure, at any point, should not exceed a certain limit, dependent
upon the nature of the ground. The safe intensity of pressure on nat-
ural foundations has been determined as follows :
On hard rock 9 to 10 tons per sq. ft.
On soft rock and hard clay.. .2 to 3 tons per sq. ft.
On sand and gravel \l/> to 2 tons per sq. ft.
On compact earth 1 to V/i tons per sq. ft.
On soft, uncertain ground.... J/2 ton per sq.ft.
" 'In the case of natural foundations, care must be taken that there
is no possibility of lateral escape,' and again at page 247, speaking of
Lock Foundations :
" 'As a general rule, hard rock and stiff clay, in which there are no
springs, do not call per se for any artificial covering, except such as may
be judged necessary to protect their surface from the softening and scour-
ing action of water. On the other hand, alluvial deposits, sand, gravel and
other incohesive strata, need the confinement afforded by a superimposed
mass in addition to the lateral support of sheet-piles.
" 'Earth of a porous nature, moreover, is not only unsuitable for a
natural floor, but is equally undesirable as a foundation for an artificial
floor, owing to its efficacy as a medium for the transmission of water
pressure, on which account any covering laid upon it should be both
strong and impervious.' "
Mr. Alfred C. Prime (Pennsylvania Railroad), a member of the Com-
mittee, reports as follows :
ROCK SUBGRADE
"A good quality of rock will stand up under the heaviest axle loads
and under Class 'A' traffic it is sustaining axle loads on one pair of drivers
of 61,500 lbs. without any signs of failure. Considering this load as dis-
tributed over two ties, gives a unit pressure of 850 lbs. a sq. ft. As stated
previously the limit of bearing is unknown, but a good quality of rock
will probably sustain, with proper ballast, the highest axle loads that can
be placed upon it.
CLAY SUBGRADE.
"I never had any satisfaction in maintaining tracks where roadbed
subgrade was composed of clay. It has always resulted in a high main-
tenance cost. The track will get out of line and surface and will require
from one-third to one-half as much work again as where loam or sand
is used. I personally believe that clay should never be used in fills on
account of its high maintenance cost.
"A good grade of yellow clay will under Class 'B' traffic and axle
loads of 61,500 lbs. with 6 in. of cinder ballast just sustain a pressure of
about 900 lbs. per sq. ft. Speed of trains average 60 miles per hour.
SANDY LOAM.
"This has always given me satisfaction where I have used it and
ROADWAY.
391
had to maintain track. Under Class 'A' and 'B' traffic, speed 60-70
miles per hour with a proper depth of ballast it will maintain the heaviest
axle loads that can be placed upon it. I know it is maintaining pressures
of 900 lbs. per sq. ft. and how much more it is capable of sustaining is
unknown.
OCEAN SAND.
"For Class 'C traffic this is a satisfactory subgrade for loads up to
700 lbs. per sq. ft., which is about the limit of economical maintenance.
"A sand subgrade can be made to sustain Class 'B' traffic by raising
track about 18 in. on engine cinders.
"All figures given above are for a single track roadway 20 ft. wide
with slopes ofij4 to 1, and good drainage, with 6 in. of cinder ballast
below base of tie. Tie spacing 22 in.
"The only cheap and inexpensive method for determining unit pres-
sures_ on subgrades known to me, is to spread some pliable substance such
as fairly thin sheet lead on top of your subgrade for a length of say 5 ft.
As long as this remains straight and undeformed your allowable unit pres-
sure on subgrade is not being exceeded, but the moment it becomes cupped
and dished under the ties, the unit pressure for this class of roadbed sub-
grade is too high.
"In connection with this work the report of the M. W. & S. Com-
mittee on Roadbed of the Altoona Railroad Club in May, 1909, on 'Drain-
age of a Four-Track Railroad,' contains some interesting matter, also a
paper by Mr. M. L. Byers in Bulletin of the International Railway Con-
gress for September, 1909."
Mr. F. T. Llewellyn in December, 1898, made some tests to determine
the safe load on soils at New Orleans. Pits 4 ft. x 4 ft. x 5 ft. deep,
water at 18 in. below surface-bottom of pit in blue clay, wood foundation
3 ft. x 3 ft. of 3 in. x 12 in. plank doubled and crossed, with the follow-
ing results:
Load
PerSq. Ft.
Lbs.
Total Load
Lbs.
Settlement in Inches
Dec. 13-17
Dec. 19
Dec. 24
Pit No. 1
T650
1000
1300
6100
9280
12000
1
t
i
1
7
IB
6
Pit No. 2
»»
Pit No. 3
i
Mr. O. E. Selby, Bridge Engineer, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago &
St. Louis Railway (see Proceedings, Vol. 8, pp. 54-59), using the formula
derived by Mr. Thos. H. Johnson (see Proceedings, Vol. 7, pp. 104-105),
calculates the average pressure on subgrade to be 2.4 tons per sq. ft., and
the maximum to be 3.6 tons for 50,000-lb. axle loads spaced 5 ft. centers,
80-lb. rail, 7 in. x 8 in. x 8>y2 ft. ties spaced 20-in. centers on 12 in. of
gravel ballast.
From what has preceded it will be observed that the safe bearing power
of confined soft wet clay, clear dry sand confined in natural beds, quick-
sand, marshy and alluvial soils, silt, etc., all confined, is less than or very
slightly in excess of the pressures calculated by Mr. Selby. If unconfined
their bearing powers will all be somewhat reduced.
Semi-fluid soils such as quicksand, alluvium, etc., should be removed
392 ROADWAY.
where practicable or the foundation carried to a lower stratum, so the bear-
ing power of such need not be considered here.
The bearing power of clay, loam, sand, etc., depends to a great extent
on the amount of moisture present.
Professor Schubler of Tubingen found that ioo lbs. of dry soil would
retain the following amount of water that would not flow off:
Pure Clay : . ' 70 lbs.
Clay Loam 50 lbs.
Loamy Soil 40 lbs.
Sand 25 lbs.
Drainage Farm Journal, August, 1884.
The water which destroys the bearing power of such soils may come
from below by capillary attraction. The vertical capillary movement per
each horizontal square foot per 24 hours being as follows:
In fine sand through 1 ft. vertical 2.37 lbs.
In fine sand through 2 ft. vertical 2.07 lbs.
In fine sand through 3 ft. vertical 1.23 lbs.
In fine sand through 4 ft. vertical 91 lbs.
In medium clay loam through 1 ft. vertical 2.05 lbs.
In medium clay loam through 2 ft. vertical 1.62 lbs.
In medium clay loam through 3 ft. vertical 1.00 lbs.
In medium clay loam through 4 ft. vertical 90 lbs.
See page 65, "Movements of Ground Water," by Franklin H. King and
Charles S. Slichter, Government Printing Office, Washington, D. C, 1899.
If, as Professor Baker says, dry clay will sustain a load of from 6
to 8 tons per sq. ft. and soft wet clay will support but from 1 to 2 tons
per sq. ft, it seems that the bearing power of clays and soils similarly
affected by the presence of moisture should in each case be experimentally
determined for varying percentages of moisture and such drainage ar-
rangements made, and at such depths, as will always secure a per-
centage of moisture low enough to bring the bearing power up to the
load it is required to carry.
BEARING POWER OF SOILS.
Composing Subgrade of Railroad Track.
(After Rankine.)
Let p = Intensity of vertical pressure on subgrade per sq. ft.
Let q = Intensity of vertical pressure at depth d, clear of super-
structure, equals weight per cu. ft. of subgrade soil multiplied by depth d
in feet.
Let d = Depth of soil, clear of track, the weight of which will just
balance the tendency to upheaval due to the load transmitted to subgrade
by the track.
Let <p = Angle of repose of the material composing the subgrade.
Let W = Weight of load per linear ft. of track.
ROADWAY. 393
Let w = Weight per cu. ft. of subgrade soil.
Let b = Breadth in ft. of track and ballast imposing load on subgrade.
The co-efficient of friction is equal to the tangent of the angle of re-
pose, <f>, of the soil composing the roadbed.
If two particles of earth are pressed together by a pair of equal
thrusts p and p' normal to their surface of contact, it requires a pair of
equal thrusts q and q' tangential to that surface to make them slide upon
each other. For the same material, when q is just sufficient to make them
slide, it is a constant fraction of p. The fraction which q must be
of p just to cause slipping is the co-efficient of friction for that material.
Hence, the co-efficient of friction equals q/p.
The condition of equilibrium for a mass of earth in a compound state
of strain is that at every point the obliquity of the stress on the plane
upon which, of all others through the point, the resultant stress is most
oblique, shall itself not be greater than <t>.
Since earth can only sustain thrusts, the principal stresses at any point
will be the two thrusts, and if y be the obliquity of the resultant stress upon
the plane through the point upon which the stress is most oblique, then
Sin y =
P + q
p I -+- Sin y
q I — Sin y
By increasing y, the numerator of the term on the right hand side of
the equation increases, while the denominator decreases, and so the ratio
p/q increases. But 0 is the greatest value of y for which equilibrium is
just possible.
rp i + Sin 0
q I — Sin 0
is the greatest ratio of p to q consistent with equilibrium ; hence, the con-
dition of equilibrium of a mass of earth is most conveniently stated thus ;
that at every point the ratio of the greater to the lesser principal stress
shall not exceed that of (i + Sin 0) to (i — Sin 0).
For earth whose upper surface is horizontal, the vertical stress due to
the weight and the horizontal stress are for all points the principal stresses,
and their intensities are the same for all points on the same horizontal
plane. Generally the vertical is the greater principal stress in any ratio
not exceeding the above ; whenever it exceeds the horizontal thrust by a
greater ratio the earth spreads. But the horizontal thrust may be arti-
ficially increased till it exceeds the vertical in any ratio not exceeding the
above; whenever it exceeds the vertical by a greater ratio, the earth
heaves up.
When the earth at the side of the track is just on the point of heaving
up, for points at depth d the vertical pressure p exceeds the horizontal
394
ROADWAY.
■^
P
a!
>_L_
v
SD^
d
i_
*-
q- p
Fig. I.
reaction q in the greatest possible amount, that earth being on the point
of spreading, that is,
p i + Sin 0
q I — Sin 0'
while for points just clear of the track, p' exceeds q' in the same amount,
that earth being on the point of heaving up, therefore,
p' 1 + Sin 4>
r>
By multiplication
1 — Sin <p'
1 + Sin <f>\ 2
pp' _ /I + Sin 0\:
qq' Vi — Sin <p)
qq
Now p' and q are equal horizontal thrusts on the same horizontal layer ;
canceling these and substituting the following values :
weight per linear ft. of track and locomotive W
p = = —
L.-eadth of track and ballast b
(q' = weight of column of subgrade earth 1 ft. square and depth d = w d)
we have
W /i + Sin <t>\2
b w d
/I + bin <p\:
Vi — Sin <p)
whence
Sin <pj
W /i — Sin 0\2
W /i — bin <p\ :
d(tt.) = — ( I)
wb \i -f- Sin (p/
For example, assume a load of 72,000 lbs. per linear foot of track in-
cluding impact on a roadbed 10 ft. wide or 3.6 tons per sq. ft. on a sub-
grade of dry loam weighing 95 lbs. per cu. ft. with an angle of repose of
1Y2 to 1 or <p = 33° 42'
d = 72Iooo;/i^5548x2=6_2ft(
95x10 Vi + .5548/
the depth at which a sidewise motion of the earth under the track will cease.
If the subgrade should be wet clay weighing 120 lbs. per cu. ft. with
ROADWAY.
395
a co-efficient of friction of .33 an angle of repose of 18° 15', the depth
of earth required to balance the load will be
d = 72'°°° C-^m2-)2^ 164 ft.
120 x 10 \i + .3132/
If the material of subgrade has an angle of repose of 400 and weighs
120 lbs. per cu. ft. the depth will be
d = ^ooo_/i^-^42oy=28ft
120 X IO \I 4- .6420/
+ .6429^
The above analysis suggests a simple field test to determine the bear-
ing power of soils which should be experimented with to determine its
practicability.
The preceding figure is a section of two troughs enclosing earth, and
pressed together with a thrust of intensity p normal to MN, the plane
where the troughs just approach contact, and P is the amount of this
thrust. A thrust of intensity q tangential to the plane MN tends to cause
the earth to slide in two parts along MN ; also Q is the amount of this
thrust. If Q be just sufficient to cause slipping along MN, then the co-
efficient of friction of the earth is,
f
Q
= Tan <f>
If a cube of the soil to be tested be enclosed in the two half boxes as
indicated in the sketch and weighted down with a load P so that the in-
tensity of pressure on the plane MN is approximately that which the
soil will have to bear under the track, and the force Q which is necessary
just to cause slipping along the plane MN be measured by means of a
spring balance; then dividing the amount of Q by the weight of the upper
half of the earth and box plus the load P will give the tangent of tihe
angle of repose from which may be obtained the sine of the angle of re-
396 ROADWAY.
pose which is used in the analysis above to determine the bearing power
of the soil tested.
Tests of this kind might be made, the bearing power of the soil cal-
culated and the result compared with actual full size tests of the bearing
power of the same soil and if found to agree within a reasonable limit a
standard method of conducting the field test could be prescribed and the
unit pressures specified for soils according to their co-efficient of friction
as thus determined.
(3) REPORT ON TUNNEL CONSTRUCTION AND VENTILA-
TION.
Paul Didier, Chairman ; W. M. Dawley, J. A. Spielmann, D. J. Brum-
ley, W. P. Wiltsee, Sub-Committee.
Your Committee made recommendation to the annual convention of
1910 as to the cross-section to which tunnels should be constructed to eon-
form to good practice. The recommendation was adopted (Manual 191 1,
page 43), and the Committee has since that convention confined its atten-
tion principally to the question of ventilation. No definite conclusion has
been reached, but the opinion of the Committee leans to a belief that arti-
ficial ventilation is usually unnecessary in American steam railway tunnels
of less length than 2,000 to 2,500 ft., and that probably the most efficient
form of artificial ventilation for American steam railway tunnels is to
force air into one end of the tunnel by fans powerful enough to drive the
smoke out ahead of the train. This method was adopted for the Elkhorn
tunnel on Norfolk & Western Railway and is admirably described by Mr.
Chas. S. Churchill in the Transactions of American Society of Civil Engi-
neers, Vol. 54, part C. Plants similar to that constructed for the Elkhorn
tunnel have been installed as shown by the record given as Appendix A.
As typical single track tunnels carrying a moderate traffic, there is included
in Appendix A a record as to the clearing of smoke in three single track
tunnels on the Louisville & Nashville Railroad. The Committee has advice
that the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Company is now experimenting on
single and double track tunnel ventilation, but the various methods used
in the different tunnels are at such great variance that no conclusion has
as yet been reached.
(4) REPORT ON THE QUESTION OF AGRICULTURAL DRAIN-
AGE AS IT AFFECTS RAILWAYS.
W. C. Curd, Chairman ; T. H. Gatlin, John G. Sullivan, Sub-Committee.
The Committee during the past two years collected information as to
the drainage laws of the various states, but has never been able to fix
upon a form into which the information can be put so as to make it of
value to the Association. The Committee is of the opinion that further
work along the line of collecting information as to (a) Laws and Assess-
ROADWAY. 397
ments is futile because the laws are changing constantly, and because the
Committee's information is necessarily general and not subject to applica-
tion to specific cases without legal advice; and further, questions affecting
the laws and assessments are, in all railway organizations, handled by the
railway's attorneys. The Committee recommends that it be discharged
from further consideration of the subject as to Laws and Assessments.
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR 1012.
Your Committee recommends that Subjects 1, 2 and 3 be reassigned
and that further consideration of subject 4 be confined to the benefits to
the roadway to be derived by the construction of agricultural drainage
ditches and levees.
Your Committee believes that certain additions can be made to the
specifications as now printed in the Manual, for example, the sodding of
slopes of cuts and fills.
Your Committee directs attention to a resolution passed at its meet-
ing on November 28 :
"Resolved, That the Board of Direction be requested to set aside an
appropriation and to appoint a special committee consisting of members
of the Roadway, Ballast and Track Committees, to make experiments to
determine the magnitude and distribution of the load transmitted to the
roadbed through ballast of various kinds and also to determine by test
the bearing power of various materials under varying conditions ordinarily
found in the construction of the roadway."
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON ROADWAY.
Appendix A.
RECORD OF TUNNEL VENTILATION.
Under Plans of Chas. S. Churchill and C. C. Wentworth.
Location of Tunnel
Date of
Installa-
tion
Rate of
Grade
Loca-
tion of
Fans
Length
of Tun- ! Section
nel, Sq. Ft.
Ft.. J
1
Con-
tents
Cu. Ft.
Cu. Ft.
Air de-
livered
per min.
through
Tunnel
Remarks
N. & W. Ry.
Elkhorn, Coaldale.W.Va
6-01
+1-4%E
Lower
End
3000
ST235
705000
400000
Train ton rating
inc. in 1901, 100
tons.
C. & 0. Ry.
Big Bend, E. Hinton, W.
Va
12-02
§Igth
+0.4%E
Upper
End
6500
ST250
1625000
300000
Train ton rating
inc. 228 tons.
P. R. R.
Gallitzin, W. Altoona,
Pa
4-05
+0.5% W
Lower
End
!
3600 1 ST324
1166400
502000
P. R. R.
Washington, D. C, Sta-
12-07
+0.13%S
Upper
End
Tubes 1 tube
4050 ! 260
Sta. 760 2 6 tracks
3371800
640000
2 tubes, 520 sq.
ft. Station end
variable.
P. R. R.
North and East Rivers,
N. Y. ..
9-10
Special
vent, of
installat
tubes th
ion 14 fa
at are 41
ns for e
35 ft. to
225
mergen
7357 ft.
cy uses
40000 to
111000
B. & 0. R. R.
Kingwood Tunnelton, W.
Va
12-10
+1.0%E
Lower
End
4138
ST352
1458000
600000
Train ton rating
inc. 450 tons.
C. & 0. Ry.
Lewis, Alleghany, Va. . .
6-11
+1.14%W
Lower
End
4026
ST318
1280200
508800
N. Y. C. Lines
Weehawken, N. J
8-11
+ 0.25%E
Lower
End
4365
DT469
2047200
512000
144 trains per
day.
P R. R.
B. & P. Tunnel, Balti-
9-11
+ 1.32%S
Upper
End
4963
DT432
2150000
500000
193 trains per
day.
Letter of R. C. Morrison, Superintendent, Louisville & Nashville
Railroad.
There has never been any trouble to trainmen from smoke in either
Dossett or Solway tunnels, excepting in one instance ; about three months
ago an engineer on the second engine of a heavily loaded double-headed
freight train claims to have been overcome by the gases while passing
through Solway tunnel. We did not consider this claim very seriously.
398
ROADWAY. 399
It was evidently a strike on the part of the engineer against double-head-
ing.
In clear weather after No. 32 passes through these tunnels if no firing
is done immediately before entering the tunnels or during the passage
through the tunnels, it leaves the tunnel practically clear, whereas after
a southbound freight train it takes from ten to fifteen minutes for the
tunnels to clear sufficiently to see through them.
Damp weather affects the clearing of these tunnels very much. In
fact, during very damp weather, doing an ordinary business Dossett tun-
nel never gets entirely clear. This does not apply so much in the case of
Solway tunnel, as this tunnel seems to clear itself better of smoke thanj
any tunnel I have ever known, considering the length.
We keep our trains ten minutes apart passing through both of these
tunnels, both tunnels being protected by electric blocks. I am inclined to
believe that the smoke in both of these tunnels comes out from the far
end in the direction the train is moving, that is, when a train passes
through the tunnel, it starts up a current of air that seems to continue
after the train has passed and has a tendency to draw the smoke through
the tunnel after the train.
During our heaviest business we have never been bothered with delay
to traffic on account of smoke in either of these tunnels.
We have no established rules or instructions governing the method of
firing while passing through tunnels. It is customary on heavily loaded
freight trains, southbound, to put in a heavy fire going into either of these
tunnels. It is very seldom necessary while passing through Dossett tun-
nel, but, on heavily loaded freight trains, they do have to put in a fire once
and sometimes twice while in Solway tunnel.
For the first two weeks in October, average number of trains passing
through these tunnels per 24 hours was 23. Our business, however, is a lit-
tle light. I think I would be safe in saying that we could successfully
operate fifty trains per day through these tunnels without the air becoming
so foul as to delay traffic.
Length of Dossett tunnel 3,520 ft., single track. Grade 0.50 per cent,
rising to south. Train 32 is northbound limited train.
Length of Solway tunnel 2,170 ft., single track. Grade 0.50 per cent.
rising to south. The construction shafts in both tunnels were closed.
Letter of E. E. Snyder, Superintendent, Louisville & Nashville
Railroad.
Muldraugh tunnel is on an ascending grade to the south of 70.3 ft.
per mile. We regard the tunnel as a quick clearing one from smoke and
gases. The hardest feature is on a southbound double-heading train when
the crew of the second engine gets a good dose. All southbound full ton-
nage trains and our through passenger trains are double-headed, helping
engine in front.
There is a little smoke and gas after a northbound freight train but
not a great deal as the trains roll and there is but little exhaust. North-
400
ROADWAY.
bound passenger trains do not work steam through the tunnel. The help-
ing engine always goes through the tunnel and is cut off at Tunnel Hill.
We have about 40 train movements, divided one-half north and one-half
south, per day, not including the return movement of the helping engine.
Letter of J. F. Burns, Roadmaster, Louisville & Nashville Railroad..,
In regard to smoke in Muldraugh's tunnel, M. S. First Division. I at-
tach a statement showing the action of the smoke after passage of south-
bound trains on the 7th inst. (October 7, 1911), from which it appears that
tiains are from one minute to two minutes in going through the tunnel
and the tunnel is clear of smoke in from seven to twelve minutes. It so
happened that the smoke was longest in clearing after passenger train 5
with a Ki engine, and the shortest time was with a double-heading freight
train. I consider this tunnel as very quick clearing. As trains are never
closer together than fifteen minutes in the tunnel, one train never has dis-
advantage from the smoke of a preceding train.
ACTION OF SMOKE IN MULDRAUGH's TUNNEL.
Main Stem First Division After Passage of Southbound Trains on
7th of October, 191 1.
Time Train Going
Time After Engine Got
No. of Train
Engine
Through Tunnel
Through Tunnel Until
Clear of Smoke
73
1112 and 848
2 minutes
7 minutes
2nd 73
1107 and 848
2 minutes
8 minutes
31
881
1J minutes
9 minutes
5 Passenger
153
1 minute
12 minutes
2nd 5
124 and 849
1 minute
11 minutes
17
731 and 849
1J minutes
9 minutes
75
1176 and 849
2 minutes
10 minutes
2nd 75
709 and 848
1J minutes
8 minutes
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XIII— ON WATER SERVICE.
Robert Ferriday, Chairman; J. L. Campbell, Vice-Chair man;
James Burke. E. G. Lane.
H. M. Church. G. C. Millett.
C. C. Cook. A. Mordecai.
G. M. Davidson. W. A. Parker.
A. F. Dorley. C. L. Ransom.
G. H. Herrold. Chas. E. Thomas.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Raihvay Engineering Association:
The Board of Direction assigned the following subjects to your Com-
mittee :
(i) Report on the design and relative economy of track pans from
an operating standpoint.
(2) Present typical plans and specifications for tank supports.
(3) Report on the use of reinforced concrete for water tanks and
supports.
Three meetings were held, all of them in the Secretary's office : June
21, August 28, October 30, 191 1.
It was decided, since the subject of "Water Tanks," including sup-
ports, had been under consideration so long, to request the Board to drop
subject No. 2 and substitute "Deep Well Pumps," approval of which was
given later.
A Sub-Committee on Water Treatment was appointed with the idea
that your Committee should have such a sub-committee every year whose
duties would be to keep informed of the progress in this subject, and make
reports as seemed desirable. The Board was asked to request G. M.
Davidson to become a member of your Committee, and he was appointed
chairman of this sub-committee pending such arrangement.
Sub-Committee A met at Painesville, Ohio, August 19, and the filling,
heating and drainage systems of the Lake Shore & Michigan Southern
Railway track pan installation at that point was explained by Mr. M. U.
Baillierre, Assistant Engineer, who had charge of the construction of the
track pans, plans of which were included in the 191 1 Proceedings.
Sub-Committee B met in the Secretary's office August 4 and
December 9.
The subjects in the hands of your Committee stand as follows:
REVISION OF THE MANUAL.
No changes to recommend until the Association decides on the future
policy now under consideration.
401
402 WATER SERVICE.
(i) THE DESIGN AND RELATIVE ECONOMY OF TRACK PANS
FROM AN OPERATING STANDPOINT.
Report progress. No further report is made for the reason that such
additional data as can be secured is from elaborate tests made by the
Pennsylvania Railroad at Atglen, Pa., which are not yet available. Your
Committee also hope to secure report prepared for a Special Commitfee
of the New York Central Lines by G. W. Vaughan, Engineer Main-
tenance of Way of that railway.
(2) DEEP WELL PUMPS.
Report progress. This subject has not been developed sufficiently
to report otherwise.
(3) USE OF REINFORCED CONCRETE FOR WATER TANKS
AND SUPPORTS.
Complete report is hereinafter submitted with the request that it be
received as information.
(4) WATER TREATMENT.
Report progress.
In view of the brevity of its report, your Committee desires to sub-
mit in Appendix "A," for the information of the Association, a paper
prepared at its request by J. R. Francis, regarding an unusual occurrence
of locomotive boiler corrosion which followed a partial installation of
water softeners. It is quite possible the same trouble may be experienced
by our members under similar conditions, and information regarding the
means for overcoming it will be of value.
Your Committee also have canvassed the membership for opinions
and criticism of the General Specifications for Steel Tanks submitted
last year, and same have been revised and are submitted with the recom-
mendation that they be adopted and published in the Manual.
THE USE OF REINFORCED CONCRETE FOR RAILWAY WATER
TANKS AND SUPPORTS.
As part of its work for the year 1910, the Water Service Committee
was directed by the Association to prepare plans and specifications for a
reinforced concrete water tank. The result of the Committee's work is
published as information in the 191 1 Proceedings.
For the year 191 1, the Committee is directed to report on the use of
reinforced concrete for water tanks and supports.
Many reinforced concrete tanks have been built in America and
Europe ranging in capacity from 10,000 gals, to more than 1,000,000 gals,
each. Published descriptions of a large number of these can be found
by reference to the Engineering Index. A list of about 50 of them is
published on page 124 of the Engineering News of July 27, 191 1.
In connection with the construction of a new concentrator, the Macte-
zuma Copper Company, Nacozari, Sonora, Mexico, built 128 reinforced
concrete tanks of 10,000 gals, capacity each for water and concentrates.
WATER SERVICE. 403
They are water-tight except a little sweating around a few of the pipe
connections in the tank bottom. These tanks are 12 ft. in diameter and
12 ft. high. The form was erected complete and each tank was poured
in one operation, thereby eliminating joints in the shell, which is 6 in.
thick. The bottom is 12 in. thick. A very rich concrete was used. All
of the stone would pass through a screen having J^-in. mesh. The steel
in the shell is stressed 11,400 lbs. per sq. in., not considering the tensile
strength of the concrete. At the bottom of the tank the concrete in the
shell is stressed only 6s lbs. per sq. in. without assistance from the steel.
The concrete in these tanks can carry that stress without breaking. Con-
sequently, the stress is doubtless divided between the steel and the con-
crete and the unit stress must be very low. The vertical reinforcement
of the shell consists of ^-in. rods spaced 12 in. c. to c.
Reinforced concrete tanks have been built either as slandpipes or as
elevated tanks on concrete towers.
The advantages are :
(1) Low maintenance cost.
(2) Great durability.
This may be true only of well-designed, well-built and water-tight
tanks.
The disadvantages are :
(1) Innovation in railway service.
(2) Imperfections in materials and workmanship.
(3) Greater first cost.
(4) Porosity of the concrete.
(5) Shrinkage of the concrete.
(6) Stretch of the concrete.
(7) Difficulty of waterproofing.
(8) Effect of frost on saturated concrete.
(9) Ugliness.
(10) Immovability.
No. 1 will be removed in time if the concrete tank develops sufficient
merit.
No. 2 is more incidental than fundamental, but the making of a strictly
uniform high-grade monolithic concrete construction without local imper-
fections is difficult and requires highly efficient workmanship.
No. 3 may be justified by the advantages named. It can be shown in
some cases that a reinforced concrete tank costs less than a steel tank of
like capacity, but in such cases the design is probably sparing in the use
of steel and concrete. A thin shell and a high stress in the steel are liable
to result in a leaky tank. Generally, when the stress in the steel is low
enough and the tank shell thick enough to insure against leakage, the
cost of a reinforced concrete tank will be greater than that of a steel tank.
No. 4 is the root of much of the trouble with the concrete tank. It
is not an insurmountable difficulty. 'Careful selection and grading of
sand and stone, liberal use of cement, complete and uniform mixing and
proper placing will make a concrete impervious under the pressures re-
quired for railway water service. Serious leaks will be due to local
404 WATER SERVICE.
imperfections rather than to porosity if the tank has been well-designed
and constructed of a proper grade of concrete.
No. 5 is a more fundamental difficulty. Shrinkage of concrete in
setting is inevitable and it is increased by the large proportion of cement
required in water tank construction. This frequently produces cracks,
especially along the joints between successive courses of concrete. Care-
ful and proper making of the joints and judicious steel reinforcement are
necessary to prevent serious shrinkage cracks. The steel dam mentioned
in the accompanying general specifications is a desirable thing in the
joints when the concrete in the first half of the joint has hardened before
the concrete in the second half is placed.
No. 6 is a serious difficulty in the shell of the tank due to elasticity
of the steel reinforcement and its stretch under the water load. Any con-
crete, however dense and impervious in its unstrained condition, can be
stretched beyond its breaking strength and fine cracks through which water
will flow under pressure may be opened therein by stressing the steel within
the elastic limit of the latter. If the tank could be maintained constantly
full of water the moderate leakage due to such stretch would generally
stop through deposits of suspended matter from the filtering water. In
some cases this would be assisted by chemical precipitation. But, under
general service conditions there is a wide fluctuation of pressure and the
elastic recovery of the steel as the pressure drops appears to break down
the plugging action of the leakage above indicated in those cases where
the steel is stretched materially beyond the breaking point of the concrete.
Herein appears to lie a formidable handicap of the concrete tank as
a competitor of the steel tank on the basis of cost. The effectual remedy
appears to be the combination of that low stress in the steel with that
increased thickness of the shell which will limit the stretch of the concrete
so that cracks permitting the filtration of water will not be opened. That
increases the cost of concrete and steel, making the latter approach the
cost of steel in a steel tank.
Your Committee is of the opinion that the ultimate stress of the steel
without assistance from the tensile strength of the concrete should not
exceed 10,000 lbs. per sq. in., and that the minimum thickness in inches
of the concrete at any point should be such that when the total tensile
stress due to water load at that point is diminished, by 3,000 times the
sectional area in sq. in. of the steel at that point, the remaining water load
will stress the concrete at that point 300 lbs. per sq. in., provided that in
no case shall the thickness of concrete be less than 4 in. Your Committee
does not say that concrete will not break under a tensile stress of 300 lbs.
per sq. in., although experiments indicate that concrete of the high grade
required for tank construction may have an ultimate tensile strength of
400 to 500 lbs. per sq. in.
This specification as to thickness of concrete is an arbitrary one in-
tended to secure a minimum and reasonable thickness somewhat in excess
of the thickness of concrete in tanks already constructed in which the
stress in the steel has been 12,000 lbs. or more per sq. in., resulting in
some leakage. The primary object is to secure a minimum thickness of
WATER SERVICE. 405
wall in which tension cracks, if any, will be localized and minute and
through which it would be difficult for water to pass. The size and the
arrangement of the reinforcing rods have an important bearing on the
minimum permissible thickness of concrete. The shrinkage of the con-
crete around large rods in a thin wall is liable to crack the concrete.
The trouble from stretch of the concrete raises the question as to the
practicability of designing a tank shell to be in compression. This could
be accomplished by building the shell as a series of short, flat, abutting
arches convex to the center of the tank with the reinforcing steel sup-
ported by exterior pilasters forming the abutments of the arches, as indi-
cated in the suggested plan and elevation of a section of concrete tank
shell designed to be in compression appearing on the accompanying draw-
ing, showing a general plan and general section for a suggested concrete
standpipe. The radius of the arches may readily be proportioned to
make the total compression in the concrete equal to the total tension in
the steel. The reinforcing rods between the pilasters may be covered by
metal lath and cement plaster. The density and imperviousness of the
concrete in the arches would be increased by the water load. The
polygonal form of the tank with its recessed panels would break the
monotony of a plain cylinder and give the tank an improved appearance.
Doubtless difficulties would arise in the execution of such a design, but
without going into details, the suggestion is offered for what it is worth.
No. 7 arises from 4, 5 and 6. The problem is to find some foreign
substance which, when incorporated with the concrete, will close the per-
centage of voids found even in the best grade of concrete, or, when applied
to the surface, will be impervious and will not crack or peel off. In either
case the trouble is aggravated and the waterproofing largely nullified by
the shrinking and stretching of the concrete unless the latter is properly
reinforced against shrinkage and stretch. Tanks in service prove that
it is practicable to make concrete impervious under ordinary tank pressures
by proper selection, grading and mixing of materials. Soap and alum
incorporated with the concrete in the making and applied as washes to the
surface are probably the best proved and most efficient materials for
effective waterproofing of concrete.
No. 8 is a danger which will be eliminated by successful solution of
waterproofing. Since the latter will require as its base a very dense con-
crete, the quantity of water passing through the latter will be so small
that the action of frost can have little or no effect on such close grained
and practically dry concrete. It is a fact, however, that in our northern
latitudes much disintegration of porous concrete on the water line of lakes
and streams due to the annual effect of the frost season is apparent.
Ugliness is a sin chargeable to some railway structures other than
water tanks. Perhaps a little additional homeliness is not unpardonable
if saved by the grace of utility. Monolithic concrete, especially a form-
marked, joint-marked, leaky efflorescent tank shell possesses a lack of
beauty which is not hidden by frills. The attainment of a water-tight
tank requires a high grade of material and work which will go far toward
making concrete tanks presentable in appearance.
406 WATER SERVICE.
An irremovable objection to the concrete tank is its immovability. A
wooden tank and even a steel tank can be and such tanks are moved from
place to place to meet changing requirements of railway water supply.
Discovery of new and better water supplies sometimes makes changes
in locations of tanks desirable. A concrete tank should be located only
at those points where there is no probability of change.
Considering the obvious merits of the concrete tank, this Committee
sees no reason why railways engaged in permanent reconstructions for
fixed water supplies should not favorably consider a beginning in rein-
forced concrete tank construction. Water- tightness is the important
problem. The stability of this form of construction is well established.
Many existing concrete tanks are practically water-tight. Generally,
leakage is immaterial in amount and objectionable principally as a matter
of appearance and a possible danger account of frost. It is more often
the result of local imperfections, bad joints, and a thin shell and a high
stress in the steel than porosity and permeability in a proper grade of
concrete.
Your Committee submits as information :
(i) General Specifications for Reinforced Concrete Standpipe Water
Tanks for Railways. No plans of tank are submitted with these speci-
fications.
(2) Suggestive sketches consisting of:
An elevation and section of reinforced concrete standpipe tank.
A section through valve box in the foundation.
A plan and elevation for reinforced concrete tank shell designed to be
in compression.
An elevation and section of reinforced concrete tank on a reinforced
concrete substructure.
A plan, elevation and section of reinforced concrete substructure.
The tank should be located away from the main line track and should
deliver water to engines through water columns.
If a roof is required, it should be built as shown. Where ice will
not form to an injurious or troublesome extent and sunlight will not
cause vegetable growth in the water, the roof may be omitted.
For a given amount of available storage and considering piping, frost-
proofing, and collection and disposal of sludge, the standpipe is simpler
and more economical than a tank on a tower, notwithstanding it is prac-
ticable to erect a concrete tower 20 ft. high including foundation at an
expense less than the cost of the foundation and lower 20 ft. of a concrete
standpipe. This refers to railway service. For quantities of water re-
quired only at higher elevations, the concrete tower may readily be more
economical than the standpipe.
The construction of the concrete tank on the concrete substructure
would not differ materially from that of the concrete standpipe, and the
general specifications for the latter may be applied generally to the former.
The substructure may also be used for supporting tanks of wood or
steel. Its general design consists of an octagonal foundation slab and an
octagonal deck slab, the latter being carried on the reinforced columns
WATER SERVICE.
407
GENERAL ELEVATION.
Fig. i — Suggested General Plan for a Reinforced Concrete Sub-
structure and a Reinforced Concrete Water Tank.
(Substructure may be used for Wood or Steel Tanks.)
408
WATER SERVICE.
S3 RS^s
TANK.
**,^WM'A-^
P/PF&M/L 1//T WFLL
^—^^—-^^mM
p**p^**^ I J j| >»„,„„„„
X
GENERAL SECTION ON A- B.
Fig. 2 — Suggested General Plan for a Reinforced Concrete Sub-
structure and a Reinforced Concrete Water Tank.
(Substructure may be used for Wood or Steel Tanks.)
-safe..;
y£'V3f'\ \ '« ' '. ! I i • ■' i 'SRvS\
y^\ X<V\ 'v \ \ 1 ill' ' / ' / / -*vSX '^V
/-! - '->' X \ \ \ > x> . \ \ ' '. I ; / f ' i ' i / / ■'' / -^xvV*
-J-jj-!-> _~
-l-i-frf — —"'"'-- -%'-J
vSK\ / / / / ///ft
X^;<< / / ////ft l
N^oXn.-' ////ft
^ ■ ^>*\\' / * I I I !
<^-V / i : !
! ! '. \ \ \ \ x/s/rs
! \ \ \ >i%'3
I
HALF DECK AND HALF FOUNDATION PLAN
OF SUBSTRUCTURE
SHOWING REINFORCEMENT
i <-Dec/f.
-- mii/imuiiiii'""11"1
Dqor
4—
6
P/p^ notes-.
■ 6 cP
Foundation
>»WlW,'>W)niijWftf
' ' ■'■■'■Ulllll/U/IM
ELEVATION OF SUBSTRUCTURE.
Fig. 3 — Suggested General Plan for a Reinforced Concrete Sue-
structure and a Reinforced Concrete Water Tank.
(Substructure may be used for Wood or Steel Tanks.)
410
WATER SERVICE.
GENERAL ELEVATION
Fig. 4 — Suggested General Design for a Reinforced Concrete
Standpipe.
WATER SERVICE.
411
GENERAL SECTION
Fig. s — 'Suggested General Design for a Reinforced Concrete
Standpipe.
412
WATER SERVICE.
-ftodsmaybe cohered &u
cement morfar on meter bfh.
±£S
-44
3E
SUGGESTED PLAN AND ELEVATION FOR A
CONCRETE TANKSHELL DESIGNED TO BE
IN COMPRESSION
SUGGESTED SECTION
THROUGH VALVE BOX
Fig. 6— Suggested General Design for a Reinforced Concrete
Standpipe.
WATER SERVICE. 413
and the central pipe and valve well resting on the foundation. The plan
shows the general arrangement of the reinforcement. The foundation
slab distributes the load under its entire area, keeps the unit load low
and is favorable to uniform settlement, if any. On a rock foundation
this slab may be omitted. The central well serves for enclosing and frost-
proofing the piping and valves, helps to support the deck and makes the
entire sub and superstructure stable against wind pressure without assist-
ance from the surrounding columns. The plan contemplates a substruc-
ture not more than 20 ft. high above the ground, in which case the col-
umns require no lateral bracing. In the construction of the substructure
the ordinary approved building loads, stresses, materials and workman-
ship for reinforced concrete are acceptable and sufficient. The question
of waterproofing does not enter unless it is desired to make the deck
slab the bottom of the tank when the latter is made of concrete.
These general plans are submitted, not as those which should be
adopted, but as suggestions for a number of good designs which could
be made.
GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR A REINFORCED CONCRETE
STANDPIPE WATER TANK FOR RAILWAYS.
NO PLANS SUBMITTED.
Definitions.
1. The words "company," "engineer," "as shown," "drawings," and
"this Association," appearing in these specifications are defined as follows :
"Company" means the railway company building a tank under these
specifications.
"Engineer" means the engineer of the company.
"As shown" means as shown on the drawings.
"Drawings" means the drawings of the tank herein specified and
forming a part of these specifications, including such working drawings
as the engineer shall prepare or approve.
"This Association" means the American Railway Engineering Asso-
ciation. ,'■.(■!
Kind.
2. This tank shall be of reinforced concrete as shown.
Excavations.
3. In earth, excavation for the foundation should be as deep as the
lowest frost line. In rock, only the excavation for the valve box should
be carried below the action of frost. In earth, the bottom of the excava-
tions should be thoroughly tamped. If the earth will not sustain the
total load, including wind pressure, without material or unequal settle-
ment, the foundation should be supported on piles of the number, size and
arrangement as determined by the engineer. Such piles should conform
to the specifications of this Association for piling as selected by the
engineer.
414 WATER SERVICE.
Foundation.
4. The foundation should be monolithic concrete of the form and
dimensions as shown. If the depth of frost is excessive the foundation
may be carried on broken rock uniformly compacted in the bottom of the
excavation. The top of the foundation should be above the surface of
the ground.
Floor.
5. The tank floor shall be constructed on the foundation as shown.
Valve Box.
6. The valve box shall be constructed as shown. When low
temperatures require to prevent freezing within the valve box, an air
space should be constructed in the middle of the valve box walls as shown.
Shell. .
7. The concrete shell shall be constructed and the connection between
it and the floor shall be as shown. Its thickness should have a proper
relation to the sizes and positions of the reinforcing rods so that the con-
crete will not crack in shrinking around the rods.
Piping and Valves.
8. This tank should be equipped with standard iron pipes and
standard gate valves located in the valve box as shown. The pipes should
pass from the valve box in iron sleeves with lead joints into the tank as
shown. There should be a tank supply pipe, a washout pipe, a water
column supply pipe, and if required, an overflow pipe. For a gravity
water supply, an altitude controlling valve in the valve box or a float
valve in the tank should be placed in or on the tank supply pipe as shown.
The tank supply pipe and the water column supply pipe should extend
above the floor of the tank, but the water column supply pipe should not
rise higher than the top of the water columns served. The washout pipe
should terminate flush with the floor.
Gage.
9. The tank should be equipped with a gage, indicator and float as
shown.
Ladder.
10. The tank should be provided with a ladder as shown.
Concrete.
11. The concrete in the floor, shell and roof shall be a thoroughly
uniform and dense mixture of cement, sand, stone and water, made and
laid in accordance with the specifications of this Association for rein-
forced concrete. The volume of the sand shall be in excess of the voids
in the stone. The volume of the cement shall be in excess of the voids
in the evenly mixed sand and stone. The excess of sand and cement
shall be such as will give the greatest attainable density in the concrete.
The volume of water shall be sufficient to give the concrete a fluidity that
will cause it to flow and mold itself into the forms readily and com-
pletely. An unnecessary quantity of water shall not be used. The engi-
neer shall determine the above specified voids and proportions.
WATER SERVICE. 415
In the foundation, the concrete shall be mixed in the proportions
specified by the engineer and it shall fulfill the requirements of the speci-
fications for concrete of this Association.
Mixing.
12. The concrete should preferably be mixed by batch mixing ma-
chines. The method used shall yield a complete and even mixture.
Cleanliness.
13. All dirt and foreign matter shall be excluded from all materials,
concrete and stages of the work.
Pouring and Mixing.
14. This concrete, after mixing, shall be poured and worked into
final position in the forms before its initial set is complete, and it shall
not thereafter be disturbed. As it is thus placed, it shall be thoroughly
worked throughout by flat thin bladed tools in a manner that will elimi-
nate all voids and air pockets and produce unbroken mortar faces against
all forms and secure perfect contact with every part of all reinforcing
rods therein.
Joints.
15. The surface of concrete in joints should be free of laitance and
all foreign matter and should be rough, fresh, clean and wet when con-
crete is laid thereon. The surface should be covered with a heavy coat
of grout or mortar immediately in advance of placing concrete thereon.
The surface should be thoroughly tooled, scrubbed and washed prepara-
tory to the application of grout and concrete. The new concrete should
be worked into complete contact with the old concrete.
Muriatic acid or equivalent may be used as a help to the tooling and
scrubbing, but all of the concrete penetrated by the acid should be en-
tirely removed.
A metal dam of non-corrosive metal like copper should be inserted
in the concrete joints intended to prevent the passage of water. The
metal should be driven edgewise into the first half of the joint to a depth
equal to half the width of the metal before the initial set of the concrete
is complete. The contact between the concrete and the metal should be
complete and perfect. The edges of the metal should be turned over
90 degrees for anchorage. Joints in the metal dam should be lapped at
the ends in a manner that will secure water-tight joints.
This specification for joints does not necessarily and preferably may
not apply to the joint between the floor and the foundation.
The entire process of making joints shall be as required.
Wetting.
16. Rapid drying out of concrete shall be prevented by regular, fre-
quent and continued wetting of all exposed concrete surfaces until all
danger of arresting setting and hardening is past.
Freezing.
17. Freezing of concrete before it has finally set shall be prevented.
416 WATER SERVICE.
Broken.
18. Any concrete broken or displaced in any manner after having set
shall be removed from the work.
Cement.
19. The cement shall conform to the specifications of this Associa-
tion for Portland cement. It shall retain its original purity and qualities
until it is incorporated into this work. Deteriorated or otherwise dam-
aged cement shall not be used.
Sand.
20. The sand shall be clean, sound and sharp and it shall be of
graded sized grains giving a minimum of voids.
Stone.
21. The stone shall be clean, sound and durable. The word "stone,"
includes broken rock and gravel. The stone shall be of graded sizes
giving a minimum of voids. All of it shall be able to pass through a cir-
cular hole having a diameter of 24-in.
Water.
22. The water shall be clean and free from anything injurious to
the concrete.
Forms.
23. The concrete forms should be made of dressed and matched lum-
ber or of metal. They should be accurately made and erected, be water-
tight, and should have ample strength and rigidity to prevent bending ana
warping under the load and action of the concrete. They should be
erected in such manner as will permit the concrete to be poured and
worked as above specified.
Pointing.
24. Any break in the concrete surfaces, not impairing the integrity
of the structure, shall be pointed by cement mortar as the engineer shall
direct. Any other imperfections in the concrete shall be treated and
remedied as the engineer shall direct.
Reinforcement.
25. The concrete shall be reinforced by metal rods of the kind, form,
size, number and arrangement as shown. They shall be maintained in
required position as they are buried in the concrete, at which time they
shall be free from dirt, paint, oil, grease and scale. Splices in a line of
rods shall be lapped far enough to develop the full strength of each rod.
Throughout the splice, the ends of the rods making it shall be far enough
apart to develop maximum total adhesion of the concrete. Unnecessary
splicing shall be avoided. No splice shall be opposite a splice in an adja-
cent line of rods.
Reinforcing Rods.
26. The rods shall be metal rods, plain or deformed. Their tensile
strength shall be not less than 50,000 lbs. per sq. in. Their elastic limit
shall be not less than 30,000 lbs. per sq. in. Their ductility shall be such
WATER SERVICE. 417
that any rod can be bent 180 degrees on a radius equal to 2 diameters or
sides of the rod without sign of fracture.
Stresses.
27. Assuming the metal rods to carry the water pressure and other
stresses without aid from the tensile strength of the concrete, the stress
per sq. in. in the rods should not exceed 10,000 lbs. Vertical reinforce-
ment in the shell, between the shell and the foundation and across joints
in the concrete should be ample to prevent opening of cracks in the con-
crete. Reinforcement in all necessary directions should be ample to pre-
vent as far as practicable the opening of cracks in the concrete due to its
shrinkage in setting and to its stretching under the water load. The
minimum thickness in inches of concrete at any point should be such that
when the water load in pounds at that point is diminished by 3,000 times
the sectional area in sq. in. of the metal reinforcement at that point, the
remaining water load will stress the concrete not more than 300 lbs. per
sq. in. at that point, provided that in no case shall the thickness be less
than 4 in.
Loading.
28. The weight of water should be assumed to be 63 lbs. per cu. ft.
Wind pressure, acting in any direction, should be assumed to be, in
pounds, 30 times the product of the height by two-thirds of the diameter
of the tank in feet.
Waterproofing.
29. A uniformly dense mixture of concrete as herein specified should
be the primary expedient to secure water-tight concrete. This may be
supplemented by mixing with the concrete some form of waterproofing
compound of proved efficiency or by washing the concrete surface there-
with, or by both.
The engineer shall select the waterproofing material and determine
the proper proportions and methods of application.
Waterproofing by the application of rich cement mortar may be
acceptable if the foregoing specification for making joints in concrete
work is complied with.
^GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR ORDINARY STEEL WATER
AND OIL TANKS.
(Revised November, 191 1.)
Ordinary Tanks Defined.
1. Ordinary tanks are those requiring plates not more than %-m.
thick.
Scope of Specifications.
2. These specifications cover ordinary steel tanks commonly used
by railways for usual service conditions only.
Quality of Metal.
3. The metal in these tanks shall be a special refined steel or open-
hearth steel.
*For amendments, see Index.
418 WATER SERVICE.
The special refined steel shall have a tensile strength per sq. in. not
less than 50,000 lbs. and an elastic limit not less than 30,000 lbs. per sq. in.
It shall contain of
Sulphur Not more than .02 per cent.
Phosphorus Not more than .005 per cent.
Carbon Not more than .02 per cent.
Manganese Not more than .00 per cent.
Silicon Not more than .00 per cent.
The open-hearth steel shall conform in physical and chemical prop-
erties to the specifications of this Association for steel bridges.
For plates not more than ^-in. thick, 5^-in. rivets shall be used. For
thicker plates the diameter shall be ^J-in.
Loading.
4. The weight of water shall be assumed to be 63 lbs., crude oil 56
lbs., and creosote oil 66 lbs. per cu. ft. Wind pressure, acting in any direc-
tion, shall be assumed to be, in pounds, 30 times the product of the height
by two-thirds of the diameter of the tank in feet.
Unit Stresses.
5. Unit stresses shall not exceed the following:
(a) Tension in plates, 15,000 lbs. per sq. in. on net section.
(b) Shear in plates, 12,000 lbs. per sq. in. on net section.
(c) Shear on rivets, 12,000 lbs. per sq. in. on net section.
(d) Bearing pressure on field rivets, 20,000 lbs. per sq. in.
Cylindrical Rings.
6. Plates forming the shell of the tank shall be cylindrical and of
different diameters, in and out, from course to course.
Workmanship.
7. All workmanship shall be first class. All plates shall be beveled
on all edges for caulking after being punched. The punching shall be
from the surface to be in contact. The plates shall be formed cold to
exact form after punching and beveling. All rivet holes shall be ac-
curately spaced. Drift pins shall be used only for bringing the parts
together. They shall not be driven with enough force to deform the
metal about the holes. Power riveting and caulking should be used. A
heavy yoke or pneumatic bucker shall be used for power driven rivets.
Riveting shall draw the joints to full and tight bearing.
Caulking.
8. The tank shall be made water or oil tight by caulking only. No
foreign substance shall be used in the joints. For water tanks, the caulk-
ing shall preferably be done on the inside of tank and joint only; but for
oil tanks the caulking should be done on both sides. No form of caulking
tool or work that injures the abutting plate shall be used.
Minimum Thickness of Plates.
9. The minimum thickness of plates in the cylindrical part of the
tank shall not be less than %-m. and in flat bottoms not less than iVin.
WATER SERVICE. 419
In curved bottoms the thickness of plate shall be not less than that of the
lower plate in the cylindrical part.
Horizontal and Radial Joints.
10. Lap joints shall generally be used for horizontal seams and
splices and for radial seams in curved bottoms.
Vertical Joints.
11. For vertical seams and splices, lap joints shall be used with plates
not more than 2^-in. thick. With thicker plates, double butt joints with
inside and outside straps shall generally be used. The edge of the plate
in contact at the intersection of horizontal and vertical lap joints shall be
drawn out to a uniform taper and thin edge.
Rivet Holes, Punching and Pitch.
12. The diameter of rivet holes shall be i/i6-in. larger than the diam-
eter of the rivets used. The punching shall conform to the specifications
of this Association for such work on steel bridges. A close pitch, with
due regard for thickness of plate and balanced stress between tension on
plates and shear on rivets, is desirable for caulking.
Tank Support.
13. If the tank is supported on steel columns with bracing, the
metal in such substructure shall conform to these specifications, and the
anchorage and workmanship thereof shall conform to the specifications
of this Association for the manufacture and erection of steel bridges.
Painting.
14. In the shop the metal shall be cleaned of dirt, rust and scale
and, except the surfaces to be in contact in the joints of the tank, shall
be given a shop coat of paint or metal preservative selected and applied
as specified by the company.
After being completely erected, caulked and cleaned of dirt, rust and
scale, all exposed metal work shall be painted or treated with such coat
or coats of paint or metal preservative as shall be selected by the railway
company.
Plans and Specifications.
15. Under these specifications and in conformity thereto the railway
company shall cause to be prepared or shall approve detailed plans and
specifications for such tanks, herein specified, as it shall construct. Such
plans and specifications shall cover all necessary tank auxiliaries.
CONCLUSION.
That the specifications for steel, water and oil tanks is good practice,
and should be included in the Manual.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON WATER SERVICE.
Appendix A.
LOCOMOTIVE BOILER CORROSION AND TREATED WATER.
NOTE BY THE COMMITTEE.
The installation of small pumps to discharge a definite quantity of
soda ash, in solution, into water tanks instead of relying upon enginemen
to place the soda ash itself in the engine tender is not new, as a number
of such outfits are in service for the purpose of relieving conditions where
the hardness of water from sulphates occurs at points which are not
equipped with softeners or where the conditions would not justify that
expense, but your Committee believe such installation for the purpose of
preventing pitted flues, as described in this article, is new and it is there-
fore brought to your attention.
Your Committee wish to point out for the benefit of members who
may not have had enough chemistry to fully comprehend the suggestions
which would otherwise occur, that the pitting of flues was stopped by
maintaining in the boiler at all times water slightly caustic from sodium
hydrate, and that control of this causticity was made by continuous chem-
ical examination of samples of water taken from the boilers at the
terminal or at points between terminals as may at times seem desirable,
this examination being for the double purpose of maintaining no greater
causticity than necessary and to furnish data for use in cases of alleged
foaming trouble and failure to use blow-off cocks. It is the practice on
some roads to secure more effective removal of sludge through blow-off
cocks by connecting them to a perforated pipe which is laid on the mud-
ring and thus withdraw the sludge from the entire ring instead of only in
the vicinity of the cock.
The control of boiler waters required to make these caustic soda sta-
tions successful can best be made by a Chemist and Engineer of Tests,
but railroads, suffering from thin traffic as well as bad water and unable
to afford the expense of a man to devote his exclusive services to such
matters, may be able to find a local chemist familiar with water analysis
who would be equipped to do such work.
LOCOMOTIVE BOILER CORROSION AND TREATED WATER.
By J. R. Francis, Indianapolis, Ind. •
During the Fall of 1908, the writer at the time being in charge of the
chemical work for the company, locomotive boiler corrosion of a serious
nature developed on the Peoria & Eastern Division of the Big Four
Railway.
The Division referred to as relates to engine service being divided at
Indianapolis, Indiana, "West End" engines working between Indianapolis
and Peoria (Illinois), and "East End" engines between Indianapolis and
Springfield (Ohio), excepting during unusually busy periods, when engines
were occasionally transferred for several runs from one district to the
other, engines from both districts, however, running into Moorefield round-
420
WATER SERVICE. 421
house at Indianapolis and taking water before leaving Indianapolis on
their runs from Moorefield water softener, the latter being a standard,
Davidson type, continuous system machine, using lime and soda ash in
the usual manner. The water softener referred to had been in continuous
service ten months prior to the first evidence of corrosion troubles, and
had served as the exclusive water supply for the yard engines working in
Moorefield yards, the stationary boilers at Moorefield shops and round-
house, and the road engines, as before stated.
The first evidence of corrosion in boilers of road engines was re-
ported under date of October 8, 1908, in the case of freight engine 6169
on the "East End" giving up train on account of bursted flue, which
upon examination together with entire set of flues, revealed a bad case
of pitting and corrosion. Following this experience in rapid succession
and extending over a period of several months, engine failures due to
pitted flues were frequent, a total of 3,335 flues being scrapped in 1909,
and 1,069 in 1910. At about the time of the first case in question, the
General Foreman of Moorefield shops and roundhouse reported that an
occasional nipple or elbow in the feed pipes of the stationary boiler plant,
between the feed water heater and boilers, had to be removed on account
of being honeycombed by pitting, and that this trouble had developed
after the installation of the water softener, the pipes previous to the
installation of the latter becoming limed up badly from time to time.
Within a short time after this report, yard engine 6522, which had been
in service at Moorefield yards and using treated water from Moorefield
water softener exclusively, was taken to the Division shops at Urbana,
Illinois, where upon being overhauled it was found that the entire set
of flues were pitted so badly that they had to be scrapped. In the light
of the above-mentioned cases, namely, road engines failing on account of
pitted flues, nipple and elbows in feed water line of stationary boiler
plant pitting, and a yard engine turning up with entire set of flues useless
on account of pitting, and in each case the treated (softened) water
having been used exclusively or in part, it is not surprising that sus-
picion pointed, as it did on the part of the Division officials, toward the
water softener ; in fact, it was the only new or unusual thing to be
found in connection with the water service.
Upon investigation, by a process of elimination as it were, it was
found that the stationary boilers of the Moorefield plant were in excellent
condition, with no evidence whatever of any pitting or corrosion ; that
the yard engine in question had been in service at another point where a
hard water had been used before coming to Moorefield yards, and that
the road engines affected were confined to those which were in service
exclusively or most of the time on the "East End." Samples of boiler
waters from all engines coming into Moorefield roundhouse were then
called for, with the object of noting by chemical examination what differ-
ence, if any, existed in the condition of concentrated waters of "East End"
boilers as compared to "West End" boilers. These samples were drawn
at the water gage in a bucket, allowed to cool, bottled, tagged as to
122 WATER SERVICE.
number of engine, East End or West End, dated, and forwarded to the
laboratory for examination. At the laboratory the examination was con-
ducted as follows :
One hundred c. c. of sample was titrated with phenolpthalein indicator
and normal ten hydrochloric acid, the number of c. c. of acid required
being noted and the titration completed with methyl orange indicator, the~
number of c. c. of additional acid required with this indicator noted, and
also the total number of c. c. of acid required with both indicators. For
the purpose of explanation, we will call this operation the "First Step."
Another ioo c. c. of sample was then taken and 30 c. c. of a 10 per cent,
solution of barium chloride added, with phenolpthalein indicator, and the
mixture titrated with normal ten hydrochloric acid, the number of c. c. of
acid required being noted and set down as the "phenolpthalein titration of
the second step."
In arriving at results from the above, the following procedure was
observed : If the acid required with phenolpthalein indicator in the first
step exceeded that required by methyl orange, the difference was charged
to hydrates and reported in equivalents as sodium hydrate. The amount
of acid required with phenolpthalein indicator in the second step was
compared with the amount required with phenolpthalein indicator in the
first step. If less, the difference was multiplied by two and charged to
alkaline carbonates and reported in equivalents as sodium carbonate. The
total acid required by sodium hydrate and sodium carbonate was then
deducted from the total acid required by both phenolpthalein and methyl
orange indicators (the total alkalinity), and the difference, if any, charged
to alkaline earth carbonates and reported in equivalents as calcium
carbonate.
In case the acid required with methyl orange in the first step was
greater than that required with phenolpthalein, the difference was charged
to bi-carbonates and reported in equivalents as sodium bi-carbonate. The
second step was then conducted same as before, the sum of the sodium
bi-carbonate and carbonate substracted from the total alkalinity, and the
difference charged to alkaline earth carbonates and as before, reported as
calcium carbonate.
The use of hydrochloric acid instead of sulphuric acid in the titration
is obvious, on account of the use of barium chloride.
By way of comment on the above procedure, no claim is made for
scientific accuracy, because the steps as outlined are not absolutely ac-
curate. They are, however, sufficiently so to serve the purpose to which
they were put, and reference for explanation in detail will be found in
"Sutton's Volumetric Analysis," under "Titration of Alkaline Salts." Be-
sides the above figures on the samples, we also titrated for the chlorine
content with standard silver nitrate solution in the usual manner, save
that we first carefully neutralized the sample with nitric acid.
The following is a transcript of results of laboratory examinations as
per above, of a few boiler water samples :
WATER SERVICE.
42J
BOILER WATERS EAST END PASSENGER ENGINES
(Corrosion occurring)
(Note absence of Sodium Hydrate in appreciable quantity, and presence of
Sodium Carbonate and Bi-Carbonate)
Parts per 100,000
Date
Engine
Number
Sodium
Carbonate
Sodium Bi-
Carbonate
Sodium
Hydrate
Calcium
Carbonate
Chlorine
October 30, 1908
October 30, 1908
October 30, 1908
November 2, 1908 ....
7077
7113
7071
7071
2.12
2.12
2.12
4.24
6! 84
<L20
0.80
".40
6.00
8.00
8.00
2.00
27.00
30.80
43.00
35.80
BOILER WATERS EAST END FREIGHT ENGINES
(Corrosion occurring)
(Note absence of Sodium Hydrate and presence of Sodium Carbonate and
Sodium Bi-Carbonatc)
Parts per 100,000
Date
Engine
Number
Sodium
Carbonate
Sodium Bi-
Carbonate
Sodium
Hydrate
Calcium
Carbonate
Chlorine
October 31, 1908
November 2, 1908 ....
November 24, 1908 . . .
November 24, 1908 . . .
November 24, 1908 . . .
6595
6577
6571
6586
6597
2.12
2.12
4.24
5.30
4.24
3.36
2.52
1.68
2.52
2.52
1.00
5.00
5.00
3.00
2.00
24.20
16.60
35.20
28.00
29.80
TECHNICAL ANALYSES, WATER SUPPLIES, EAST END
Station No. 1. Moorefield treated water. Total hardness averaging less than 5 grains per
gallon to standard noap solution. Total causticity averaging about 3 grains
per gallon. Sodium chloride average, 3.13 grains per gallon.
cc
S5
O
H
-o
<
a
■6
a
3
0
rfl
0
0
J3
EH
<
C3
a;
•a
0 -
0
0
QOO
O a
si
u
3
£
fe
%
• £
►H
<
H
Q
Grains,
U. S. Gallon
Total Solids
25.62
2.34
23.28
22.08
1.20
.54
.12
13.50
2.37
5.55
21.93
1.16
20.77
19.39
1.38
1.08
.51
11.74
23.94
0.20
23.74
22.14
1.60
1.35
.24
13.43
22.68
3.52
19.16
18.38
0.78
.60
.12
11.03
38.73
3.68
35.08
32.93
2.12
.99
.15
19.00
22.77
2.05
20.72
20.07
.65
.69
.12
10.80
29.01
2.15
26.86
Incrusting Solids
25.26
1.60
Composition of Tncrusting Solids
Hypothetical Combinations:
.81
Iron Oxide and Alumina
.12
14.93
Magnesium Sulphate
Magnesium Chloride
Composition of Non-Incrusting Sol-
ids, Hypothetical Combina-
tions:
6.06
7.12
3.36
3.27
2.95
9.47
.37
2.12
4 26
3.91
.29
.65
4.63
4.77
1.20
5.15
.98
.40
.29
.99
.61
.34
.78
1.60
2.25
6.31
2.61
3.19
S t ation No. 9. Springfield, Ohio, treated water, averaging same as Sample No. 1. Machine
Standard^ American Continuous System. Sodium Chloride average, 1.00
grain per gallon.
424
WATER SERVICE.
BOILER WATERS WEST END PASSENGER ENGINES
(No corrosion occurring)
Parts per 100,000
Date
Engine
Number
Sodium
Carbonate
Sodium Bi-
carbonate
Sodium
Hydrate
Calcium
Carbonate
Chlorine
October 28, 1908
October 28, 1908
October 29, 1908
October 30, 1908 . .
7072
6159
7080
7115
19.08
21.20
19.08
15.60
14.00
18.80
14.60
7.60
2.00
3.00
0.00
6.00
16.40
24.00
18.20
16.40
BOILER WATERS WEST END FREIGHT ENGINES
(No corrosion occurring)
Parts per 100,000
Date
Engine
Number
Sodium
Carbonate
Sodium Bi-
carbonate
Sodium
Hydrate
Calcium
Carbonate
Chlorine
October 28, 1908
October 29, 1908
November 24, 1908 . . .
6591
6584
6589
3.18
4.24
5.30
1.20
1.60
4.00
9.00
5.00
2.00
30.20
19.80
26.00
It will be noted that the average chlorine content of all waters on
the East End is about 1.39 parts per 100,000, and that they do not vary
a great deal. Comparing this average figure with chlorine content of East
End freight engine No. 6571 boiler water, reported above as having a
chlorine content of 35.2 parts per 100,000, we note a concentration of
about 25 times.
Attention is called to this observation for the reason that where the
chlorine content of water supplies within a district are approximately the
same, by comparing the average figure with that found in concentrated
boiler water samples, a figure is obtained which serves as an index to the
concentration of the boiler water and may be used to check up engine
crews working under instructions as to blowing down of boilers, and to
check up round house practice as to washing boilers, changing water, etc.
Concerning the general character of the water supplies of the East
End as reported in the analyses above, as relates to the corrosion experi-
enced, it will be noted that none of them are "acid waters." On the con-
trary, they are so-called alkaline waters, and two are treated waters,
showing, as a result of treatment, a slight causticity. Ordinarily one
would not expect to find corrosion following the use of such waters, and
with corrosion occurring, as it did, with their use, it is quite a temptation
to theorize as to the exact cause of the corrosion. By way of comment
it may be stated that upon chemical examination of corroded or pitted
spots of sections of affected flues, taken while yet moist and before sam-
ples had had time to become oxidized, the content of such pitted vesicles
contained, according to qualitative analysis, ferrous iron and sulphuric
anhydride, while on surfaces of other portions of the sections, alkaline
earth carbonates were in evidence, most of the pitted and corroded spots
on the cleaner flues being universally on the under or lower side.
In searching for a cause for the corrosion, no attention was paid to
the composition of the flues in use, further than to establish the fact
WATER SERVICE. 425
that the flues in service on this Division were no different from flues fur-
nished other Divisions of the company where no trouble was being ex-
perienced in the use of mixed, treated and untreated, waters.
Attention should be called to the fact, however, that many of the
flues affected (not all of them) had been in use some time prior to the
installation of water softeners at each end of the district, and as a conse-
quence were heavily covered with hard scale, the worst corrosion when
appearing in the form of blisters in contradistinction to pitted points,
occurring in its most active form immediately under the edge of adherent
scale. An analysis of a sample of scale, showing:
Per cent.
Silica i-4§
Ferric oxide 17-47
Calcium carbonate 9-32
Calcium sulphate 65.92
Magnesium oxide 562
Ferrous iron Trace
99.81
Considering the ferrous iron and sulphuric anhydride found by
qualitative analysis of contents of pitted vesicles as mentioned, one might
theorize that the sulphates of the alkaline earths had been broken down
under the influence of carbon of organic matter, high heat, pressure, etc.,
but in the examination of the water supplies, no organic matter in appre-
ciable quantity was found. Passing by the exact cause of the corrosion,
since, under the conditions under which it took place, any explanation
would of necessity be hypothetical in its details, the remedy for counter-
acting and stopping the trouble was based on the information obtained
in the chemical examination of the boiler waters of West End engines
as compared to those of the East End. The West End boilers giving no
trouble and being quite caustic in comparison, it was concluded that if
East End boilers had caustic in some form added by the injection of same
into the raw water supplies, thereby keeping the East End boilers slightly
caustic due to "hydrates," that the trouble, pending the installation of
additional standard water softeners, would cease.
This recommendation accordingly went out from the laboratory in
December, 1908, and again in January, 1909, but on account of diversity
of opinion as to the cause of the corrosion, some of the official staff
believing that Moorefield treated water was causing the trouble, the use
of the caustic was not begun until March 5, 1909. On this date the use
of caustic soda at Arcanum (Ohio) water station was commenced. Nine
grains per gallon, in form of solution being injected into delivery line
from the large pump discharging into the wayside tank. The apparatus
used consisted of a "Gould's Plunger Boiler Feed Pump No. 2," Fig.
485, Fairbanks, Morse & Co.'s catalogue 1909, price about $10, and having
a plunger one and a quarter inches in diameter which was attached to
the large pump in such manner that it had a stroke of three inches with
each stroke of the large pump. This small pump was connected to iron
426
WATER SERVICE.
tank having a capacity of about 200 gallons, in which the caustic soda
solution was diluted to the desired strength, and discharged into the dis-
charge line of the large pump. It is advantageous to have the line from
small pump enter the discharge line of the large pump as near the tank
as possible, on account of the gradual deposit in the pipe occasioned by the
interaction of the caustic soda with chemical salts in solution in the
raw water.
On May 1, 1909, a similar outfit was put in operation at Troy (Ohio)
water station, and four grains per gallon of caustic soda used there.
Following these installations at stations named, a passenger engine which
had been overhauled at shops and given an entire new set of flues, was
caused to double the district until 28,000 miles had been made, when sev-
eral flues were removed for examination. These were found to be with-
out any evidence of pitting or corrosion.
During the treatment of these waters as mentioned above, namely,
nine grains per gallon of caustic soda at Arcanum and four grains per
gallon of same at Troy, Ohio, boiler water samples titrated as follows :
BOILER WATERS EAST END PASSENGER ENGINES
(No corrosion occurring at this time)
Date
Engine
Number
Sodium
Carbonate
Sodium Bi-
carbonate
Sodium
Hydrate
Calcium
Carbonate
Chlorine
August 12, 1909
September3, 1909....
7071
7081
3.8
2.12
4.40
2.80
1.00
16.0
13.0
It is proper to explain that passenger engines on the East End on
their runs east, took water at Moorefield water softener, New Castle (Ind.),
Arcanum (Ohio), and, going west, at Springfield (Ohio) water softener,
Troy (Ohio) and Lynn (Ind.). This being true, they received a larger
amount of caustic soda in proportion to the total amount of water used
than did freight engines which used water from all water stations.
BOILER WATERS EAST END FREIGHT ENGINES
During treatment of waters at Arcanum (Ohio), and Troy (Ohio), as mentioned
Parts per 100,000
Total of 59 samples
Date
Engine
Number
Sodium
Carbonate
Sodium Bi-
carbonate
Sodium
Hydrate
Calcium
Carbonate
Chlorine
July, 1909
Total
40 Samples
From 0.85
to
7.42
19 Samples
From 0.84
to
6.72
5 Samples
None
35 Samples
0.16 to S.40
40 Samples
3.00
to
25.40
Av. of 5.43
19 Samples
From 2.12
to
9.54
Av. 2.81
Av. 14.24
19 Samples
From 12.00
to
17.20
Av. of 5.43
Av. of 2.92
Av. of 14.92
It will be noted in the above that out of 59 samples, 35 or about 59
per cent, of them showed presence of sodium carbonate and sodium hy-
WATER SERVICE. 427
drate. Five of them, or approximately 8 per cent., showed sodium car-
bonate, but no sodium hydrate. And that nineteen samples, or about 33
per cent., showed sodium carbonate and sodium bi-carbonate.
It was believed at this time, on account of fewer engine failures
account of flues, that under this treatment the corrosion was under control.
This assumption, however, was likely not true, as it afterwards was demon-
strated that the corrosion did not entirely stop until a causticity due
to "hydrates" was maintained practically all of the time.
The treatment of the waters at Arcanum and Troy, in the propor-
tions already stated, was continued until November 1, 1909, when it
was reduced one-half on account of complaint on the part of enginemen
that the treatment of the water was causing foaming.
It developed later, however, that the greater part of these complaints
was occasioned by an effort on the part of the enginemen to protect one
of their number who had carelessly allowed the water to run low in a
boiler and burned a crown-sheet. This reduction in treatment lowered the
percentage of boiler water samples, showing the presence of sodium hy-
drate so much, that the majority of the samples showed the presence of
sodium bi-carbonate instead.
Within four months after the reduction in the treatment several
engine failures on account of pitted flues again occurred, and on this
account the treatment of the waters at Arcanum and Troy was in-
creased on June 10, 1910, to the figures as at first used, following which
a systematic patrol of the district by the Road Foreman of Engines
quieted the complaints on the part of enginemen concerning foaming,
it being very clearly demonstrated that these complaints had been greatly
exaggerated. Sampling and examination in the laboratory of boiler
waters was continued as before, the object being to raise the causticity
due to sodium hydrate until all boiler samples showed the presence of at
least a slight amount.
This feature was not finally accomplished until a third caustic soda
treating station was established at Maxwell, (Ind.) water station, August
12, 1910, where two grains per gallon was injected into the raw water
supply. With this additional installation in operation no more trouble
was experienced as to samples of boiler waters failing to show the presence
of sodium hydrate in appreciable quantities. This point for the third in-
stallation was selected on account only of its distance from the other in-
stallations. The daily sampling of locomotive boiler waters and chemical
examination, as described, was continued for seven months, during which
time more than 90 per cent, of all samples showed the presence of two to
15 parts per 100,000 of sodium hydrate along with about an equal amount
of sodium carbonate.
Under this treatment the corrosion entirely ceased and no more
trouble on this account was experienced, neither was there any more
complaint of moment on the part of engine crews on account of foam-
ing boilers, the enginemen apparently having learned better how to
handle the boilers under the treatment.
It is also worthy of note that under this treatment the boilers be-
came and remained clean and practically free from scale.
428 WATER SERVICE.
To recapitulate, it is desired to call attention to the fact that between
November i, 1909, and June 10, 1910, when the treatment was reduced,
with corrosion re-occurring as already stated, that the freight engine boiler
waters did not show the presence of sodium hydrate in appreciable amounts
with any regularity. They did, however, show the presence of small
quantities of sodium carbonate and bi-carbonate. It is desired to em-
phasize this point because of the fact that only after a sufficient quantity
of caustic soda had been added to show an appreciable amount in the
concentrated boiler waters, did we succeed in stopping the corrosion.
It is also worthy of note that, in the use of the caustic soda, we at
no time used an amount so large as the equivalent of the half-bound car-
bonic acid of the alkaline earth bi-carbonates in the waters naturally,
therefore it must have followed that the caustic soda so used, when in-
jected into the raw waters, became sodium carbonate and that it was
finally hydrolized within the boiler and partially re-converted into "hy-
drate." The question naturally arises at this point why sodium carbonate
(soda ash) would not have done just as well as sodium hydrate, since
it is obvious that the latter when added to the raw water first became
sodium carbonate and afterwards was in part re-converted by hydrolysis
into "hydrate." In our opinion this probably would have been the case,
since it is clear that sodium carbonate and sodium bi-carbonate are par-
tially hydrolized within a boiler. This point is again clearly brought out
by reference above to the titration of West End boiler water samples from
passenger engines. These samples showing from seven to eighteen parts
per 100,000 of sodium hydrate along with a slightly larger amount of
sodium carbonate, and being accounted for only by the fact that, in ad-
dition to the treated water taken at Moorefield shops, two raw
waters on the West End carry sodium bi-carbonate naturally, one of them
about four parts per 100,000 and the other eight parts per ioo,coo, the
presence of the sodium hydrate occurring on account of the partial
hydrolysis of same within the boiler during concentration.
In our opinion, the features worthy of note concerning the above
experience consists in part of the troubles which may follow the in-
stallation of standard water softening or treating apparatus, where waters
in part only are treated within a district.
Also, in the importance of chemical laboratory examination and con-
trol of boiler waters, where corrosion as described is being experienced,
the features of such control aiming to maintain within the boilers a
causticity due to the presence of "hydrates" in an appreciable amount,
and that whether sodium hydrate or soda ash be used, that it be used
in sufficient quantity and so distributed that boiler water samples upon
chemical examination show an appreciable amount of causticity due to
"hydrates." This plan, in our opinion, insuring a sufficient treatment to
counteract '.!_. "permanent hardness" of all waters used, therefore con-
truinng ordinary corrosion troubles, and doing so without using an undue
excess of reagent, thereby guarding against any unnecessary aggravation
of foaming troubles, due specifically to excessive treatment.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XIX- ON CONSERVATION
OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
E. O. Faulkner, Chairman; William McNab, Vice-Chairman ;
R. H. Aishton. W. A. McGonagle.
Moses Burpee. G. A. Mountain.
F. F. Busteed. W. L. Park.
C. H. Fisk. G. H. Webb.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railzvay Engineering Association:
The Board of Direction assigned the following subjects to your Com-
mittee :
(i) Continue the study of tree-planting and general reforestation.
(2) Continue the study of coal and fuel oil resources.
(3) Continue the study of iron and steel resources.
The Committee held a number of meetings during the year, and its
researches have been along the general lines suggested by the Board of
Direction.
In presenting the report, which is naturally one of progress, the Com-
mittee realizes that there is a great difference between the practical appli-
cation of "Conservation of Natural Resources" to the every-day business
conditions met with by the members of the Association and the purely
sentimental ideals which may be indulged in by the world in general.
It is felt also that while the Committee was originally formed to co-
operate with the National Conservation Commission of this country, as
well as with the Commission of Conservation of Canada, yet its principal
object was to keep under special observation those particular features in
which the railways were directly and practically interested.
It is hoped that the information which the Committee has been able
thus far to collect, may, in the method and form in which it is here given,
be easy of reference as well as productive of practical benefit to our
members, and through them to the railways in general.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
429
430 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
UNITED STATES.
TREE PLANTING AND GENERAL REFORESTATION.
As leading up to the necessity for tree planting and reforestation, it
would seem desirable to consider, first, the extent and location of exist-
ing forests, their annual increment, and the yearly consumption of forest
products.
These questions were very fully reported upon by the National Conser-
vation Commission. The Commission was assisted in its labors by experts
whose papers form the basis of the report. These papers, representing as
they do the original work of experts, form a body of evidence along the
various lines pertaining to the timber resources of the country, which will
be found valuable for reference.
For the purpose of facilitating a thorough examination of any of the
subjects treated in the following report, references are given to these
papers as well as to other sources of information, easily obtainable, and
which present the matter in sufficient detail to enable a careful study of the
various problems to be made.
It was the feeling of the Committee that owing to the magnitude of
the questions involved the best results would be obtained by a general
review of the subject supplemented by a list of references to authoritative
literature. The list of references, while small, is believed to cover the
ground sufficiently for the purpose.*
The original forests of the United States (note A) exceeded in the
quantity and variety of their timber the forests of any other region of
similar size on the globe. Five great forest types were distinguished —
the northern, southern, central, Rocky Mountain and Pacific Coast. The
kinds of timber and extent of these forests are presented in Table i.
Table i.
ORIGINAL FORESTS OF THE UNITED STATES.
Forest.
Kinds of Timber.
Quantity
Billion F. B. M.
Extent
Million
Acres.
Cone-bearing trees predomi-
nating with some hardwoods.
1,000
150
Coniferous forest with yellow
pine predominating. Inter-
spersed with the pine were a
1,000
220
This is the only forest region in
the United States in which
the hardwoods predominated.
1,400
280
Rocky
400
110
1,400
90
5,200
850
*A very complete Bibliography bearing upon the subject-matter of this
report is to be found in Fernow's excellent book, "Economics of Forestry,"
B. E. Fernow, New York, pp. 491-507.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 481
In addition to these timbered areas there were probably 100,000,000
acres of scrubly forest and brush land, chiefly in the West, which has been
and still is a source of much post and fuel material.
The Bureau of Corporations (note B) estimates that there is a total
of about 2,800 billion board feet of standing timber in the country. Of this
about 2,200 billion feet is privately owned, about 539 billion feet is in the
National forests, and about 90 billion feet is on the unreserved public lands,
national parks, state lands, and Indian reservations.
The results of the Bureau's investigation of the amount of standing
timber in the United States may be summarized as shown in Table 2.
Table 2.
STANDING TIMBER IN THE UNITED STATES.
Billion
Privately owned timber in investigation area: Feet.
Pacific Northwest 1,013
Southern Pine Region 634
Lake States 100
1,747
Outside of investigation area 450
2,197
Total owned by Federal Government in National forests 539
Total otherwise owned by Federal Government, owned by states
and on Indian reservations 90
Grand Total 2.826
The earliest attack was upon the white pine of the Northeast, the
original stand of which is almost entirely cut out. From Table 2 it is
apparent that at the present time the two great sources of timber supply,
so far as privately owned timber is concerned, are the Pacific Northwest,
with 1,013 billion ft. and the Southern pine region, with 634 billion ft.
Moreover, 82 per cent, of the standing timber owned by the United States
Government is in the Pacific Northwest, and nearly all of the remainder
is in the other states of the Rocky Mountain region.
The yearly growth of wood (note C) in our forests does not average
more than 12 cu. ft. per acre. This gives a total yearly growth of less
than seven billion cubic feet.
That our forests grow very slowly, although the individual trees of
many kinds grow fast, is our fault. There are about 200 million acres of
mature forest mainly in the northern Rockies and on the Pacific Coast
in which the yearly growth is balanced by decay.
There are 250 million acres, mostly in the Southern mountains and
Southern pine belt, partly cut or burned over, but restocking naturally
with young growth and 100 million acres chiefly in the Lake States and
Southern pine belt which have been cut or burned over upon which young
growth is wholly lacking or too scanty to make merchantable timber.
There is taken from the forest (note D) annually, not including loss
from fire, 23 billion cubic feet of wood or over three times its yearly
growth. This large consumption amounts to 230 cubic feet per capita,
while Germany uses 37 cubic feet and France 25 cubic feet.
Each year there is used 90,000,000 cords of fire wood, 40,000,000,000
board feet of lumber, more than 1,000,000,000 posts, poles and fence rails,
432 , CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
118,000,000 hewn ties, 1,500,000,000 staves, over 133,000,000 sets of heading,
nearly 500,000,000 barrel hoops, 3,000,000 cords of native pulp wood, 165,-
000,000 cubic feet of round mine timbers, and 1,250,000 cords of wood for
distillation.
The condition of the world supply of timber makes us already de-
pendent upon what we produce. There is exported out of the country
one and one-half times as much timber as is brought in, and except for
finishing woods, relatively insignificant in quantity, we must rely upon our
own resources for the future supply.
The Forest Service estimates the yearly drain on the saw timber of
the country at about 50 billion board ft. Without allowing either for new
growth or for any increase in the rate of consumption the total for all the
timber in the United States (see Table 2) would represent about 55 years'
supply, and that for privately owned timber alone only 44 years' supply.
These conditions affect the railroads of the country not only as they
are concerned in the production of timber for their own use, but from the
broader viewpoint of developing the territory traversed by their lines.
The destruction of the timber is followed by a rapid decline of the indus-
tries utilizing the products of the forest with a corresponding loss of
revenue for the roads serving the region.
Turning our attention to the conservation of the forest it will be
seen, (1) that by the introduction of proper forestry methods the annual
productivity of the forest can be considerably increased (note E) and, (2)
that the yearly loss from avoidable causes is much greater than it should
be (note F).
There are 225 million acres of producing forest in the country. On
this area the stand is so open that all the trees could be grown on 145
million acres, which would be producing at the rate of 70 cu. ft. per acre
annually. By growing only the best species this growth can be increased
to 80 cu. ft., an increase of 1,450 million cu. ft.
There is an unutilized area of 80 million acres within our present pro-
ducing forest. There are 135 million acres of absolute forest land within
our virgin or mature forests now unproductive. There are 90 million acres
of waste lands which can be made productive by planting, or by fire protec-
tion all of these areas can be made to produce 80 cubic feet per acre, or a
total of 24,400 million cu. ft.
The total increase possible in the productiveness of our forests is,
therefore, 25,850 million cu. ft.
Only 25 per cent, of the yield of our present producing forest is saw
timber. It can be made from 50 per cent, to 75 per cent, saw timber
through the concentration of growth on the best trees by thinning and
the holding of the crop until it reaches good size. This would mean an
increase, if all our forest land were productive, from 27,000 million board
ft. to between 54,000 million and 81,000 million board ft. per annum.
The enormous loss from fire in our forests every year is a matter of
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 433
common knowledge. The value of standing timber destroyed each season
from this cause has varied from $25,000,000 to more than $100,000,000,
the direct annual loss in recent years averaging considerable over $50,-
000,000. The destruction of young growth, though never included in esti-
mates of fire damage, is a principal item of loss. The natural restocking
of burned-over lands takes place very slowly or not at all
All experiences go to prove that damage by forest fires is practically
preventable. This stage of development has already been reached in
Europe. For example, of 7 million acres in Prussia, an average of only
1,400 acres or one-fiftieth of 1 per cent, was burned over each year during
the period from 1868 to 1895.
Your Committee feels that the railroads by working with the State
Forestry officials can accomplish a great deal of good in the way of pre-
vention of fires started by sparks from locomotives. The Committee is
assembling information from both the railroad companies and the State
Forest officials in regard to the laws governing the subject and the means
used in different parts of the country to reduce the fire risk from this
cause.
It would appear that a concerted action on the part of the railroads
and State officials is desirable as the forest adjacent to the railroad right-
of-way is often left in such a condition after logging operations that it is
a difficult matter to prevent fire starting, even when the greatest precaution
is observed. Several roads are now working with the State Foresters to
accomplish this result ; notably the Chicago & Northwestern in the State
of Wisconsin.
While the chief loss in timber is due to fire, other causes contribute
largely to the prodigious waste which has accompanied our use of the
forest. One-fourth of the standing timber is left or otherwise lost in log-
ging. The boxing of long leaf pine for turpentine has destroyed one-fifth
of the forests worked. The loss in the mill is from one third to two-thirds
of the timber sawed. The loss in the mill product through seasoning and
fitting for use is from one-seventh to one-fourth. Great damage is done
by insects to forests and forest products. An average of only 320 ft. of
lumber is used for each 1,000 ft. which stood in the forest.
Of all the wood in every form now in use in the United States, decay,
fire, insects and saltwater borers destroy not less than the equivalent of
8,000 million board ft. each year. Of these, decay is far the most de-
structive.
The first attempt in this country to prevent decay by treating wood
was in 1838 on the Northern Central Railroad. About a mile of track was
laid with treated ties, but owing to the low first cost of the ties which
were chestnut and oak and were delivered to the railroad at fourteen or
sixteen cents apiece, this did not develop into a permanent industry.
In 1880 for the first time the United States census undertook to ascer-
tain what remained of our timber resources ; it was found that they had
been very rapidly depleted. Realizing the importance of the question the
American Society of Civil Engineers appointed a committee to report upon
434 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
the best methods of preserving wood, in order to lengthen its life. This
committee was appointed in 1880 and after five years of work presented
its report in 1885. This was followed by the movement which has culmi-
nated in the present large wood preservation industry of the country.
In the year 1910, 97,500,000 cu. ft. of timber was treated. Most of this
material consisted of cross-ties. Sixty-three million cu. ft., which consti-
tuted about 65 per cent, of the total, were treated with the creosote treat-
ment and the remainder with zinc chloride and zinc creosote treatment in
the order named.
In the United States the science of forestry is still in the formation
stage. Knowledge of the characteristics and requirements of the many
species of trees composing the forests is limited ; the total amount and dis-
tribution of forest wealth is not accurately known ; and methods of admin-
istration are not yet settled, but are subject to frequent change. In Eu-
rope, on the contrary, forestry as practiced to-day is the result of centuries
of gradual evolution, and is consequently thoroughly systematized and its
methods firmly established (note G). Foreign silvicultural methods are
not usually applicable without change, but the general systems have been
adapted with success to conditions in this country, and should be still more
widely used.
A striking point concerning forestry abroad is the important part
taken by the State in the management of communal and private as well as
of the State forests, and the considerably greater returns obtained under
State management. All communal forests are subject to some form of
State supervision, and many of them are managed precisely as if they were
State property.
Private forests necessary for the protection of water sheds or the wel-
fare of the general public are also subject to State control; they cannot be
cleared, cutting must be done as prescribed by the State, and all cuttings
must be reforested. Other private forests not necessary for protective
purposes can usually be managed as the owner desires, but co-operation
with the State in the management of such forests is common.
With a few exceptions comparatively little attention has been paid by
the railroads to forestry. Tree plantations (note H) have been started in a
number of cases, some of which have been on a large scale, but for the
most part experimentally. Forest planting in some cases may be desirable
when a railroad has waste land for which it has no particular use. It is
a good object lesson to the farmers, and if the plantations are successful
they will net a fair return on the investment and furnish a limited supply
of ties and timber for the future.
It should be observed, however, that it would not be practicable for
the individual roads to plant enough trees to supply their timber require-
ments, and further the critical period of scarcity and high prices would
come before any of the trees so planted would reach maturity.*
•Refer to the paper entitled "Preliminary Report of Sub-Committee on
Future Policy of Railroads with Reference to the Tie Supply," which ap-
peared in the ninth volume (1908) of the Proceedings of the American Rail-
way Engineering and Maintenance of "Way Association.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 435
The information* assembled by the Committee on Ties of this Associa-
tion in 1910 shows what has been done by the railroads in the way of tree
planting ; the situation is very little changed at the present time and in the
opinion of those best able to judge, relief from this source is very
uncertain.
If the railroads wish to provide against future scarcity and excessive
prices with any degree of certainty it will be necessary for them to actively
engage in forestry operations having for their purpose the management of
mature timber lands and the cultivation and reforestation of the cut-over
lands within the forest area. This is an individual problem with every
road, but generally speaking it is the only sound policy which will provide
for the future requirements fifteen or twenty years hence.
Some of the railroads have now undertaken to preserve the timber
lands which they acquired through land grants and otherwise. The South-
ern Pacific in Northern California and Southern Oregon still have quite
large areas of good timber from which they can cut mature trees. The
Northern Pacific has been co-operating with the Government for some
years with a view to finding how best to handle their western holdings and
provide a source of tie supply at the eastern end of their lines. In the
East, the Delaware & Hudson have put about one hundred thousand acres
in the Adirondacks under management.
RECOMMENDATION FOR NEXT YEAR'S WORK.
(a) Investigation of the forest fire laws of the different States as
they apply to railroads.
(b) The best methods to be used by railroads to reduce risk from
fires caused by locomotives.
BIBLIOGRAPHY OF ARTICLES PERTAINING TO THE TIMBER
RESOURCES OF THE UNITED STATES.
Note A. original forests.
Original Forests, R. S. Kellogg, Vol. 2, pp. 179, 180. Report of the
National Conservation Commission, February, 1909, Government Printing
Office, Washington, D. C.
Note B. existing forests.
Amount of standing timber in the United States, pp. 14-20, Summary
of the Report of the Commission of Corporations on the Lumber Industry,
Part I. Standing Timber, February 13, 191 1. Government Printing Office,
Washington, D. C.
The Forests of the United States: Their Use. What We Have, pp.
5-7. Forest Service, Circular 171, December 11, 1909.
Stand of Timber, Herbert K. Smith, Vol. 2, pp. 188-190. Report of
the National Conservation Commission, 1909.
Standing Timber in Possession of the Federal Government, G. M.
Homans, ibed Vol. 2, pp. 192-195.
♦Report of Committee on Ties, appendix C, Timber and Conservation;
Proceedings American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way As-
sociation, Vol. 11, Part 2, 1910.
436 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
Standing Timber Owned by the States, J. Girvin Peters, ibed Vol. 2,
p. 191.
Standing Timber in Wood Lots, Wesley Bradfield, ibed Vol. 2, pp.
181-187.
Note C. estimated annual increment.
What is Produced. Forest Service, Circular 171, pp. 7, 8.
Rate of Forest Growth, E. A. Ziegler, Vol. 2, pp. 203-223. Report "of
National Conservation Commission, 1909.
Note D. annual consumption.
What is Used. Forest Service, Circular 171, pp. 8, 9.
Forest Products, R. S. Kellogg, Vol. 2, pp. 196-202. Report of Na-
tional Conservation Commission, 1909.
Forest Products of the United States, 1909. Bureau of the Census.
Government Printing Office, Washington, D. C. May 19, 191 1.
Note E. increased productivity.
Methods of Increasing Forest Productivity, E. E. Carter, Vol. 2, pp.
270-279. Report of the National Conservation Commission, 1909.
Note F. loss due to avoidable causes.
Stopping Forest Fires, ibed Vol. 1, pp. 61, 62.
Forest Fires, Clyde Leavitt, ibed Vol. 2, pp. 390-468.
Waste and Reduction of Timber Supplies Caused by Insects and
Methods of Prevention and Control, A. D. Hopkins, ibed Vol. 2, pp.
469-497.
Conservative Turpentining, George B. Sudworth, ibed Vol. 2, pp.
498-511.
Conservative Logging, Earle N. Clapp, ibed Vol. 2, pp. 512-546.
Waste in Milling, Louis Margolin, ibed Vol. 2, pp. 547-567.
Waste in Use of Timber, McGarvey Cline, ibed Vol. 2, pp. 568-580.
What is Wasted, ibed Vol. I, pp. 57, 58.
Conservative Turpentining, ibed Vol. 1, p. 64.
Conservative Logging, ibed Vol. 1, pp. 64-66.
Economy in the Mill, ibed Vol. 1, p. 66.
Manufacture of By-Products, ibed Vol. 1, pp. 66, 67.
Wood Preservation, W. F. Sherfesee and H F. Weiss, ibed Vol. 2,
pp. 658-667.
Preservative Treatment of Timber, ibed Vol. 1, pp. 67, 68.
Comparative Statement of Material Treated in the United States dur-
ing the years 1907-1910. Proceedings, Wood Preservers' Association, 1911,
p. 224.
History of Wood Preservation, Octave Chanute, ibed 1909, pp. 13-17.
General Review of Timber Treating in this Country with Special Ref-
erence to the Causes that have and are Retarding Its More Universal
Adoption, J. T. Logan, ibed 191 1, pp. 144-147.
Review of Development in the Timber Treating Industry, ibed 191 1.
pp. 147-156.
Note G. forestry in foreign countries.
Economics of Forestry, B. E. Fernow, New York, 1902, pp. 274-330.
Chapter on "Forest Policies of Foreign Nations."
Cost of Forestry in Different Countries, H. S Graves. Report of the
National Conservation Commission, Vol. 2, pp. 371-374.
Extent to Which Foreign Methods of Forest Administration are
Suited to Conditions in the United States, S. T. Dana, ibed Vol. 2, pp.
375-389.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 437
Note H. tree planting.
Forest Planting, A. S. Peck, ibed Vol. 2, pp. 668-686.
Forest Planting, ibed Vol. i, pp. 62, 63.
Methods Which Should Be Adopted by Private Owners to Insure
the Perpetuation of Our Timber Supply, C. S. Chapman, ibed Vol. 2, pp.
711-747.
Cost of Growing Timber, R. S. Kellogg and E. A. Ziegler, American
Lumberman for December 31, 1910.
Timber Supply in Relation to Wood Preservation, E. A. Sterling.
Proceedings, Wood Preservers' Association, 191 1, pp. 140-144.
LIST OF FIGURES.
Fig. 1. Opposite page 180. Loco cite.
Fig. 2. Opposite page 55 (Fig. 3) Vol. 1, Report of the National
Conservation Commission, 1909.
COAL AND FUEL OIL RESOURCES.
The Sub-Committee dealing with the above subject has read and ex-
amined a large mass of papers and various data, and it is believed that the
following report will prove of value to the Association.
This subject has not heretofore been covered by the Association. The
article relating to relative tests of oil as compared to coal is valuable and
probably new to 80 per cent, of the members. The standard specifications
proposed by Mr. McAuliffe are worthy of endorsement by the Association ;
the Government specifications are also valuable information.
The statistics given in the report are accurate and valuable information.
The essence of the report on this subject is that portion relating to
"Methods of preventing or lessening waste in the petroleum industry."
This paper is by Mr. David T. Day, of the United States Geological Sur-
vey, and is worthy of a great deal of earnest consideration.
♦ADVANTAGES OF OIL AS FUEL COMPARED TO COAL.
The principal advantages incident to burning oil as compared with
coal can be summed up as follows:
(1) Cost. This item depends entirely on relative price at mine and
well, plus freight to point of consumption. In computing freight haul,
tariff rates must govern when moved over foreign lines the actual cost
of moving (not including what is known as fixed charges) ordinarily
used in computing cost over home rails. In making these computations
the fact that from 1,000 to 1,500 lbs. of oil equal 2,000 lbs. of coal must
be taken into account.
(2) Decreased cost of handling oil from cars to engines with prac-
tically no loss by depreciation due to such handling, all coal suffering
badly in passage through coaling plants of whatever type.
(3) The losses by evaporation suffered by coal do not apply to oil,
neither does loss by theft in transit occur, oil reaching engine tenders
unimpaired as to quality and undiminished in quantity.
(4) Saving of time at terminals and increased mileage per engine,
it being unnecessary to cut engines out for flue cleaning; the oil capacity
•From address by Mr. Eugene McAuliffe before International Railway
Fuel Association.
438 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
of tender approximating 150 per cent, of that of coal, making longer runs
possible.
(5) Freedom from physical failure of firemen in extreme hot weather,
the fireman's work being actually lighter than that of the engineer.
(6) Stability of delivery, oil being unaffected by labor conditions
which has made the production of coal in some sections so uncertain as
to necessitate the storage of immense quantities of coal at great expense,
this condition occurring at frequent intervals.
(7) Greater cleanliness in handling passenger trains with almost
absolute immunity from right-of-way fires, saving the cost of fire-guards,
and reducing also claim department losses.
The drawbacks to the use of oil have been in the direction of un-
certain supply. The expense of equipping the average locomotive to burn
oil approximates $800; the cost of constructing steel storage tanks of large
capacity approximating 25c per barrel. The necessary terminal facilities,
however, cost but about 50 per cent, of the amount required to handle coal.
With coaling facilities usually in place, however, the oil facilities when
installed, represent a duplication. Frequently, before the producer is able
to judge his production sufficiently well to warrant the making of definite
contracts, large quantities of "pot" oil must be sacrificed for want of
storage or market facilities. After the production is reasonably well
determined, an interval of time is necessary to transform locomotives,
these factors being embarrassing both to the oil producer and the railroad
consumer. With the development of new fields and the purchase of large
numbers of cars, together with the increased installation of oil-burning
apparatus, this condition will grow less burdensome in the future than it
has been in the past.
The relative cost of oil and coal as a locomotive fuel is governed en-
tirely by local conditions. Any road contemplating the use of oil must
test the grade of oil or residuum it expects to burn against the grade of
coal for which it is to be substituted. Different coals grade within greater
extremes than do oils, which fact, if proper allowance is made for water
and sediment in the case of crude oil purchases, will show a limited varia-
tion in the number of British thermal units per pound of fuel.
♦PETROLEUM AS A LOCOMOTIVE FUEL.
What may be taken as an indication that petroleum, as a locomotive
fuel, is coming into a greater degree of prominence than has hitherto been
accorded this important subject, is the very complete equipment for han-
dling and using this fuel on the Cascade Division of the Great Northern
Railway. The significance of this work is all the more marked owing to
the fact that the region in which this division is located is convenient to
a plentiful supply of high-grade coal and is more than a thousand miles
distant from the source of oil supply — the direct opposite of the situation
which had so much to do with the successful development of locomotive
oil-burning apparatus in the Southwest. The very stumbling blocks to
the satisfactory operation of its Cascade Division by means of coal-burning
locomotives, it appears, will prove a vast boon to the Great Northern, not
only from the fact that by the use of fuel oil will these difficulties be cir-
cumvented, but at the same time there is given promise of a sufficient sav-
ing in the cost of operation to cover the entire cost of the fuel oil receiving,
storage and handling facilities, approximately $300,000, during the first
year of their use.
One of the conspicuous features prompting the change from coal
to oil in this instance was the constant danger of Hre both to the vast
forest preserves through which the line passes, and to the numerous timber
♦Editorial from Railway and Engineering Review, December 9, 1911.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 439
xnowsheds which the road maintains in this locality. Great as was the
relief to be sought from the damages attending the use of coal on ac-
count of fires, the earliest investigations showed the possibility of ma-
terial savings in the cost of the fuel itself, irrespective of the distance
from the source of supply. In addition there was recognized the possi-
bility of reduced cost in handling and transporting the fuel, savings due
to the elimination of losses following the exposure of coal to weather
conditions, theft, etc., and the saving in time owing to the greater con-
venience of oil as compared with coal, besides which the advantage of
being able to concentrate within a single motive power unit every ounce
of power of which the locomotive, as a machine, is capable of develop-
ing and the general effect on the morale of the employes owing to the
greater ease of firing and the improved conditions as to cleanliness, are
items which argue strongly in favor of the use of oil. Other and more
local factors adding to the difficulty of operation in this locality are
heavy mountain grades and extreme weather conditions, through all of
which the Great Northern has set itself the task of maintaining an effi-
cient and dependable transcontinental service. The care with which the
engineers of this road have investigated and perfected this work seems
to insure a successful outcome, which, when it definitely materializes, will
undoubtedly mark the beginning of a much wider application of this fuel
in railway service than at present obtains.
^EVAPORATIVE TESTS— OIL AS FUEL.
A large number of locomotive tests have been made by the Southern
Pacific Company, covering the use of fuel oil as well as in comparison
with coal. The accompanying table shows evaporative results on some
of the most recent tests covering about the heaviest oil firing on the
Southern Pacific in crossing the Sierra Nevada range. Comparisons of
coal and oil from an economic standpoint are most interesting where the
two fuels come in competition, and relative values must largely depend
on the conditions and form of boilers under which either fuel is burned.
Some engine boilers are better adapted for coal than oil, or vice versa,
depending on construction. Comparisons therefore are to some degree a
function of the boiler itself. This was gone into quite thoroughly when
the locomotives were converted and a summary of the results is given
as follows :
Evaporation
2,000 lbs.
Number in Equivalent to
Type of Locomotive. Service. Fuel Oil, Gals.
Eight-wheel 50 144
Ten-wheel 294 151
MiOgul 176 146
Twelve-wheel 67 158
Consolidation 139 162
Atlantic 19 144
Mallet 17 No coal record
These figures are based on evaporative tests before and after con-
version. The comparisons are with ordinary bituminous coal of about 13,-
350 b. t. u. The total number of locomotives accounted for above is 745,
and the mean equivalent is 152 gals, or 3.62 bbls. of 42 gals., equivalent in
heat value to 2,000 lbs. of coal. The average equivalent figures in the table
cover much careful work and are based on equivalent evaporative results
from many service tests. It should be borne in mind that the figures are
♦Extract from a paper read by Mr. Howard Stillman before the Ameri-
can Society of Mechanical Engineers.
440
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
DATA FROM EVAPORATION TESTS OF LOCOMOTIVES, SACRAMENTO
DIVISION, SOUTHERN PACIFIC COMPANY.
Profile of Road, Roseville to Summit
Vertical Scale, l"= 4000 ft.
Horizontal Scale, l"= 20 miles
Elevation above Sea Level.
Max. Grade, Feet imr Mile.
Distance from Roscville
Class of engine.
Service
Date of test
Number of single trips in test
Total time of test <
Actual running time
Miles run ,
Average steam pressure (gage) , lb
Smoke box temperature, deg. f ahr
Total gal. water evaporated
Total lb. water evaporated ...,-.
Total gal. oil burned
Total lb. oil burned ,
Equivalent evaporation, lb. water per
lb. oil
Lb. water evaporated persq. ft. heating
surface per hr
Lb. oil burned per sq. ft. heating surface
per hr
Number of cars in train . .
Weight of train, tons
Gross ton mileage
Gal. water evaporated per 1000 ton ml.
Lb. water evaporated per 1000 ton ml..
Gal. fuel oil burned per 1000 ton miles.
Lb. fuel oil burned per 1000 ton miles.
Boiler efficiency, per cent
Maximum 1. h. p
Mean i. h. p
Dimensions of locomotive
Engine no
Size of cylinders, in
Diameter of drivers, in
Total weight of locomotive, lb
Weight on drivers, lb
Weight of tender, lb
Total heating surface, sq. ft
Feed water heater.heatlng surface, sq. ft.]
10 whee.
Passenger
Consolidation
Freight
May 21 and 26, 1908 June 9 and 11, 1909
17 hr. 39 mln.
13 hr. 55 mln.
315
196.0
797
44147
367642
3951.6
31613
14.14
8.698
0.748
7
342
107730
409.79
3413
34.90
279.20
73.84
1719
1368
231
22X28
63
203300
160000
138070
2994
21 hr. 23 mln.
12 hr. 59 min.
174
196.1
738.5
48103
400858
4328.4
34627
13.95
8.809
0.761
14.5
481
83694
574.75
4790
48.40
387.20
72.83
1470
1222
25S4
22X30
57
208000
187000
134745
3403
Mallet consoli-
dation
Freight
Nov. 6 and 8, 1909
2
29 hr. 2 mln.
18 hr. 11 mln.
174
194.6
451.3
91087
759058
7692.1
61537
16.04
6.392
0.518
24.6
1056
183744
495.73
4131
39.61
316.08
78.52
2486
2057
4001
26 and 40X30
57
425900
394150
169765
6394
1221
Note.— Train weights are the average for the distance hauled and are exclusive of engine and
tender. Tests made under oidinary se vice conditions. Engines unaided. In "water evapor-
ated and oil burned per sq. ft. heating surface per hr.," the figures are for actual running time;
the allowance of 15 gal. of oil and its equivalent In water is made per hi. while standing. In
"gai. and lb. oil per 1000 ton ml.," a deduction Is made of 15 gal. per hr. while standing and
3.5 per cent of oil for evaporating steam for atomizing oil. Quantity of oil burned corrected to
normal temperature of 70 deg. fahr. All measuring instruments calibrated. Analysis of fuel:
Kern River oil; gravity, 15.8 deg. Baume; flash point, 230 deg. fahr.; fire point, 278 deg. fabr.;
commercial weight, 8 lb. per gal.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 441
from service tests and represent oil burned on the main line between ter-
minals only, and not losses in transfer, handling, or firing up, etc. Our Ac-
counting Department uses a figure of 168 gals, or 4 bbls. of oil, equivalent
to one ton of coal. It may be said that with fuel oil, providing engines
are burning it with a fair degree of efficiency, the quality of fuel is a
constant factor. Poor or bad coal as accounting for engine failures
drops from the delay report — "cleaning fires" is abolished.
♦INSPECTION AND TESTS OF FUEL OIL.
SPECIFICATIONS OF FUEL OIL.
Inspection and Tests.
The matter of_ oil inspection, more particularly where crude oil is
purchased, is an important one, and if any considerable volume of
oil is purchased a competent, reliable inspector should be employed, one
able to make the following determinations :
Flash Test. — By flash point is understood that temperature to which
an oil must be heated to give off vapors, which, when mixed with
air, produce an explosive mixture. The results of this test will vary
according to the quantity of air over the surface of the oil, and whether
this be moving or still ; also according to the distance of the testing
flame from the surface of the oil. Furthermore, the size of the flame,
the length of its time of action, its form and dimensions, and, lastly,
the manner of heating of the oil, will all influence the result.
Fire Test. — The fire test of an oil is the temperature at which it
will give off vapors, which, when ignited, will burn continuously. It
is made by continuing to heat the oil (the cover being removed in the
case of a closed tester without slipping out the thermometer) at the
same rate after the flash test is made, and noting the point as indicated
above. The flame is extinguished by a piece of asbestos board and the
heating discontinued. In the case of ordinary oils this point is from
10 degrees to 20 degrees Fahrenheit higher than the flash point.
Specific Gravity. — This is usually affected by the hydrometer; a
hydrometer jar is four-fifths filled with the oil, a Baume hydrometer
introduced into it, and the depth read off to which the instrument sinks
in the oil. This may be effected by placing a strip of white paper
back of the jar and noting the point at which the meniscus of the oil
touches the scale. The temperature of the oil is taken at the same time,
and in case it be not 60 degrees Fahrenheit for every increase of 10
degrees Fahrenheit, subtract 1 degree Baume from the hydrometer
reading. The specific gravity may be found by the formula
140
: — representing the reading Baume at 60 degrees Fahrenheit.
130 -f B. Deg.
Shrinkage. — Frequently at small refineries, or where the residuum
storage capacity is inadequate, oil is pumped into tank cars at a high
temperature and when subsequently cooled to 60 degrees Fahrenheit,
the loss from shrinkage is material. In the event that tank cars
are partially filled in cold weather and the oil allowed to cool materially
below 60 degrees Fahrenheit, care should be taken to see, when subse-
quently topped or filling is completed, that due allowance is made for
increased volume incident to the expansion that will occur if the tem-
perature of the oil is increased, a variation of 20 degrees Fahrenheit
resulting in an expansion of approximately 1 per cent. For these reasons
that feature of the inspection rules (set forth below) covering the shrink-
age should be carefully observed.
♦From address by Mr. Eugene McAuliffe before International Railway
Fuel Association.
442 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
Water Determination. — The matter of determining the amount of
water and sediment contained in crude oil, particularly when purchased
from wells in a water-making field, or storage oil, when stored in
earthen tanks subject to additions of water and sediment test set forth in
the standard specifications.
Standard Specifications.
The following basis for standard specifications covering the purchase
of fuel oil by RAILROAD companies will quite generally cover both
crude and residuum purposes.
General Requirements. — Fuel oil to be distilled or reduced petroleum,
free from sand or other solid matter that will impede or prevent free
handling through ordinary-sized pumps, pipes or burners ; to be of a
viscosity that will permit of its being handled freely at a temperature
of 60 degrees Fahrenheit. Whenever practicable, all free water must
be drawn from working tanks before delivery. Swing pipes in working
tanks must be adjusted to prevent, as far as possible, free water entering
into delivery pumps or lines.
Sampling. — With full length thief. One sample will be taken from
each car promptly after being unloaded, with a thief having automatic
valve at lower end, which closes at instant thief touches bottom of car,
the theory of this thief being to cut out a section of the fluid. When tak-
ing sample, thief should be lowered slowly and the upper end must have
free outlet for air which thief contains when it is inserted into the oil,
thus to admit of liquid replacing the air, without creating undue mo-
tion, suction or pressure at the bottom.
Testing Samples. — Same to permit of the use of gasoline or Centri-
fuge methods, as follows :
Gasoline Method. — Samples should be thoroughly shaken and mixed,
then 50 cubic centimeters of sample placed in a 100 centimeter gradu-
ated glass cylinder, an equal quantity of not less than 68 degrees gasoline
should be mixed with the sample in the graduated glass, the combined
mixture of oil and gasoline should then be thoroughly shaken and sample
heated to a temperature of from 120 degrees to 130 degrees Fahrenheit
and allowed to stand for from three to six hours, the actual per cent,
of water equal to twice the per cent, shown in the graduated glass.
Centrifuge Method. — Samples should be thoroughly shaken and
mixed; then 100 cubic centimeters of sample placed in a 200-centimeter
graduated glass cylinder. An equal quantity of not less than 68 de-
grees gravity gasoline should be mixed with the sample in the graduated
glass; then glass placed in machine and the machine run full speed for
five minutes, when reading should be taken, and machine then run for
another five minutes and second reading taken ; if on second reading
there is any increase over first reading the machine should be run for
another five minutes, making a total of fifteen minutes, when final reading
should be taken, the per cent, of water doubled as before.
Percentage of water and sediment should be taken by representatives
of seller and buyer, and tickets exchanged showing the total percent-
age of water and sediment which each car contains. The buyer shall
be entitled to deduct all water and sediment in excess of one-half of one
per cent, under the usual tests, and may refuse to accept or move cars con-
taining in excess of 3 per cent, water and sediment.
In order to facilitate the movement of cars, the representatives of
buyer and seller may, from time to time, take samples of oil from the
filling lines as cars are being loaded, for the purpose of determining
approximately the quality and condition of the oil being delivered, and
may, for their personal information or for account of their principals, keep
records of such samples.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 443
Adjusting for Temperature. — 'Rack men and inspectors will regulate
the filling of cars, being governed by the temperature of the oil at the
time it is loaded. If cars are partially filled in very cold weather, care
should be taken not to allow the oil to rise in the dome when topping or
refilling is done, care being taken to see that sufficient room is left
for possible expansion. When oil is placed in the car at a temperature
above 60 degrees Fahrenheit an allowance of 1 per cent, in volume for
each 20 degrees Fahrenheit above 60 degrees Fahrenheit should be
made, i. e., 100 gallons on each tank car of 10,000 capacity.
Fire Test. — Buyer may refuse to accept any fuel oil showing a fire
point less than 120 degrees Fahrenheit when tested by the open-cup
Tagliabue method, namely: Heating the oil at the rate of 2 degrees per
minute, test flame to be applied every 2 degrees as temperature of oil is
raised, beginning at 60 degrees Fahrenheit.
Gravity. — Buyer may refuse to accept fuel oil of less than 15 degrees
or more than 30 degrees Baume gravity.
Tank Cars. — Tank cars furnished must be in good order and such
cars must be provided with caps and valves that can be readily adjusted.
Tank cars must be reasonably clean and free from deposits of dirt, sand,
sediment or other material that will appreciably affect the tests of the
quality of the oil. Seller may refuse to accept cars furnished that are not
in the condition above specified, unless instructed to fill cars at buyer's
risk as to loss or quality of oil. Turning oil into cars at racks will be
understood to be an acceptance on the part of the seller.
Receipts. — In the event that the buyer maintains a representative for
the purpose of inspecting shipments of oil furnished under this contract,
such representative will, when tank cars have been loaded, samples taken,
outlet caps and manheads placed, immediately sign receipt furnished by
the representative of the seller, showing: (1) number of refinery, well,
or number of storage tank loading same; (2) station from which car
is billed; (3) car number and initial; (4) car capacity shown in Inter-
state Commerce Commission tariffs; (5) actual capacity as cars are
loaded after allowance for expansion or contraction has been made as
provided for in rules governing adjustment for temperature.
GOVERNMENT FUEL OIL SPECIFICATIONS.
In consequence of the success that has attended the use of heating-
value specifications in buying and selling coal, there has arisen a de-
mand for similar specifications, based on careful tests, to govern the
purchase of fuel oils and the refined products of petroleum. The bureau
of mines has therefore issued technical paper No. 3, by Mr. Irving C.
Allen, on "Specifications for the purchase of fuel oil for the Government,"
with directions for sampling oil and natural gas.
The general specifications for the purchase of fuel oil are given as
follows :
In determining the award of a contract, consideration will be given to
the quality of the fuel offered by the bidders, as well as the price, and
should it appear to be to the best interest of the government to award a
contract at a higher price than that named in the lowest bid or bids
received, the contract will be so awarded.
Fuel oil should be either a natural homogeneous oil or a homo-
geneous residue from a natural oil ; if the latter, all constituents having a
low flash point should have been removed by distillation; it should not be
composed of a light oil and a heavy residue mixed in such proportions as
to give the density desired.
444 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
It should not have been distilled at a temperature high enough
to burn it, nor at a temperature so high that flecks of carbonaceous
matter began to separate.
It should not flash below 60 degrees Centigrade (140 degrees Fahren-
heit) in a closed Abel-Pensky or Pensky-Martens tester.
Its specific gravity should range from 0.85 to 0.96 at 15 degrees Centi-
grade (59 degrees Fahrenheit) ; the oil should be rejected if its specific
gravity is above 0.97 at that temperature.
It should be mobile, free from solid or semi-solid bodies, and should
flow readily, at ordinary atmospheric temperatures and under a head of I
foot of oil, through a 4-in. pipe 10 ft. in length.
It should not congeal nor become too sluggish to flow at o degrees
Centigrade (32 degrees Fahrenheit).
It should have a calorific value of not less than 10,000 calories per
gram (18,000 B. T. U. per lb.), 10,250 calories to be the standard. A
bonus is to be paid or a penalty deducted according to the method stated
under section 21, as the fuel oil delivered is above or below this standard.
It should be rejected if it contains more than two per cent, water.
It should be rejected if it contains more than one per cent, sulphur
It should not contain more than a trace of sand, clay or dirt.
Each bidder must submit an accurate statement regarding the fuel oil
he proposes to furnish. This statement should show: The commercial
name of the oil ; the name or designation of the field from which the oil
is obtained ; whether the oil is a crude oil, a refinery residue or a dis-
tillate; the name and location of the refinery, if the oil has been refined
at all.
The fuel oil is to be delivered f. o. b. cars or vessel, according to the
manner of shipment, at such places, at such times, and in such quantities
as may be required, during the fiscal year.
Should the contractor, for any reason, fail to comply with a written
order to make delivery, the government is to be at liberty to buy oil in the
open market and charge against the contractor any excess of price,
above the contract price, of the fuel oil so purchased.
Complete copies of these specifications may be obtained from the
director of the bureau of mines, Washington, D. C.
♦METHODS OF PREVENTING OR LESSENING WASTE IN THE
PETROLEUM INDUSTRY.
CHECKING UNNECESSARY PRODUCTION.
At present more petroleum is being produced than is necessary for
the legitimate demands of the industry. Within ten years the present
fields will be unable profitably to produce enough for these legitimate
requirements. Inasmuch as the lands now owned by private interests
are leased by rival concerns, it is impossible to prevent each rval from
producing petroleum as rapidly as he desires. The only direction in
which production can be checked is with the petroleum contained in
public lands. Offering such public land for entry at a nominal price
is nothing more than temptation to the private citizen to waste petroleum
by overproduction, since lands yielding hundreds of dollars per rcre
in this product can be obtained for a nominal sum. Every acre >f pub-
lic land believed to contain supplies of petroleum or natural gas should
be withdrawn from every form of entry and should be subjected to an
equitable system of lease. By this means undoubtedly a large mount
of petroleum would be reserved for use when the supply becomes in-
adequate to industrial demands. It should be noted that since the ad-
*From Government Report, "Production of Petroleum in 1910."
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
445
*PRODUCTION OF PETROLEUM IN THE UNITED STATES
FROM 1859-1910, INCLUSIVE.
PRODUCTION OF PETROLEUM IN THE UNITED STATES, 1859-1910,
INCLUSIVE, BY YEARS AND BY STATES, IN BAR-
RELS OF 42 GALLONS.
Year.
Pennsyl-
vania and
New York.
Ohio.
West
Virginia.
California.
Kentucky
and
Tennessee
Colorad
Indiana.
Illinois.
1859
2,000
500,000
2,113,609
3, 056, 690
2,611,309
2,116,109
2, 497, 700
3,597,700
3,347,300
3,646,117
4,215,000
5,260,745
5,205,234
6,293,194
9,893,786
10,926,915
8,787,514
8,968,906
13,135,475
15,163,462
19,685,170
26,027,631
27,376,509
30,053,500
23,128,389
23,772,209
20,776,041
25,798,000
22,356,193
16,488,068
21,487,435
28,458,208
33,009,236
28,422,377
20.314,513
19,019,990
19,144,390
20,584,421
19,262,066
15,948,464
14,374,512
14,559,127
13,831,996
13,183,610
12,518,134
12,239,026
11,554,777
11,500,410
11,211,606
10,584,453
10,434,300
9,848,500
1860
1861
1862
1863
.
1864
1865
1866
1867
1868
1869
:
1870
1871
1872
1873.. .
1874
1875
1876
31,763
29,888
38, 179
29,112
38,940
33,867
39,761
47, 632
90,081
661,580
1,782,970
5,022,632
10,010,868
12,471,466
16,124,656
17,740,301
16,362,921
16,249,769
16,792,154
19,545,233
23,941,169
21,560,515
18,738,708
21,142,108
22,362,730
21,648,083
21,014,231
20,480,286
18,876,631
16,346,660
14,787,763
12,207,448
10,858,797
10,632,793
9,916,370
120,000
172,000
180, 000
180,000
179, 000
151,000
128,000
126,000
90,000
91,000
102,000
145,000
119,448
544,113
492,578
2,406,218
3,810,086
8,445,412
8,577,624
8, 120, 125
10,019,770
13,090,045
13,615,101
13,910,630
16,195,675
14,177,126
13,513,345
12,899,395
12,644,686
11,578,110
10,120,935
9,095,296
9,523,176
10,745,092
11,751,871
12,000
13,000
15,227
19,858
40,552
93, 862
128,636
142,857
262,000
325,000
377,145
678,572
690,333
1877
::::::::::]
4,/>5
4/48
5>64
/726
/,79l
i,096
6,400
/6.000
/ 9,000
6,500
3,000
' 1,500
1,500
1,680
322
5,568
18,280
62,259
137,259
185,331
554,286
76,295
297,612
316,476
368,842
665,482
824,000
594,390
515,746
438,232
361,450
384,934
444, 383
390,278
317,385
460,520
396,901
483,925
501,763
376,238
327.582
331,851
379, 653
310, 861
239, 794
1888
33,375
63,496
136,634
698,068
2,335,293
3,688,666
4,386,132
4,6S0,732
4,122,356
3,730,907
3, 848, 182
4,874,392
5,757,086
7,480,896
9,186,411
11,339,124
10,964,247
7,673,477
5,128,037
3,283,629
2,296,086
2,159,725
1889.. .
1890.
1891
1892
1893
1894
1895
1896
1897
1898
1899
1900. . .
1901
1902
1903
1904
1905
1906
1907
1908
1909.. ..
1910
303,22
307, 36
323,60
385,04
470,17
705,96
1,208,48
1,252,77
1,903,41
2,257,20
2,642,09
4,324,48/
8, 786, 3/
13,984,?
24,382/
29,649>4
33, 427/™
33,09698
55 I.**"
73^0,560
1
J
1
>
1
1
r,
\
1,460
900
675
621
400
300
200
250
500
360
360
200
250
200
998,284
1,217,337
1,213.548
820,844
0 727,767
"639,016
a 468, 774
181,084
4,397,050
24,281,973
33,686,238
30,898,339
33,143,362
Total.
718,292,662
397,658,065
217,059,857
3^02,723
7,112,135 S
,804,593
97,866,951
126,593,490
o No production Tennessee recorded.
•From Government Report, "Reduction of Petroleum in 1910."
446
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
PRODUCTION OF PETROLEUM IN THE UNITED STATES, 1859-1910,
BY YEARS AND EY STATES, IN BARRELS
OP 42 GALLONS— CONTINUED.
Year.
Wyo-
ming.
United
States.
Total valae.
1859.
1860.
1861.
1862.
1863.
1864.
1865.
1867. .
1868. .
1869..
1870. .
1871. .
1872. .
1873. .
1874. ,
1875..
1876.
1877.
1878.
1879.
1880.
1881.
1882.
1883.
1884.
1885.
1886.
1887.
1891.
1892.
1894.
1895.
1897.
1898.
1899.
1900.
1901.
1902.
1903.
1904.
1905.
1906.
1907.
1908.
1909.
1910.
Total
500
1,200
1,400
5,000
18,000
40,000
44,430
113,571
81,098
71,980
69,700
74,714
179,151
331,749
932,214
4.250,779
el2,013,495
c21,718,648
2,409,521
1,801,781
1,263,764
1,128,668
46,551,363
48
54
54
45
50
CO
50
1,450
65,975
546,070
669,013
836,039
4,393,658
18,083,658
17,955,572
22,241,413
28,136,189
12,567,897
12,322,696
11,206,464
9,534, 467
8,899,266
147,460,188
h
132'
a 1,602"
6 2,335
a 757
o3,000
a 2,572
o3,100
O3.500
o4,000
o 15,246
o5,750
03, 615
30
80
10
130
37
170
625
6,472
10,000
37,100
138.911
,366,748
(«)
■»24,128
5^8,765
'.9,218
52,tf,718
2,369
3,455
2,878
3,650
5,475
5.560
5,450
5,400
6,253
8,960
11,542
8,454
«7,000
/9,339
/17,775
/20,056
/115.430
548, 617
917,771
2.958,958
8,910,416
9,077,528
5,000,221
5,788,874
3,059,531
6,841,395
2,000
500,000
2,113,609
3,056,690
2,611,309
2,116,109
2,497,700
3,597.700
3,347,300
3,646,117
4,215,000
5,260,745
5,205,234
6,293,194
9,893,786
10,926,945
8,787,514
9,132,669
13,350,363
15,396,868
19,914,146
26,286,123
27,661,238
30,349,897
23,449,633
24,218,438
21,858/786
28,064,841
28,283,483
27,612,025
35,163,513
45,823,572
54,292,655
50,514,657
48,431,066
49,344,516
52,892,276
60,960,361
60,.475,516
55,364,233
57,070,850
63,620,529
69,389,194
88,766,916
100,461,337
117,080,960
134,717,580
126,493,936
166,095,335
178,527,355
183,170.874
209,556,048
J32.000
4,800,000
1,035
3.209
8.225
20, 896
16,459
13,455
8,066
13,217
23,730
20,503
22,591
21,440
18,100
12,647
7,368
22,982
31,788
18,044
17,210
24,600:
23,512
23,631
25,740
20,476
19,193
20,028
18,858!
17,950
26,963
35,365
30,526
25,906
28,932
35,522
57,691
58,518
40,929
44,193
64,603
75,752
66,417
71,178
94,694
101,175
84,157
92,444
120, 106
129,079
128,328
127,896
993
174
450
754
180
503
464
527
133
822
566
520
70S
638
051
165
252
924
694
457
606
353
340
105
553
463
326
095
279
709
611
359
904
691
335
910
050
455
399
735
749
184
487
328
46,082 190,7,142 239,046
44,149,567
2,378,907,864
2,040,808,758
a Includes the production of Michiti.
b Includes production of Michigan i.\ small production in Oklahoma.
e Includes production of Oklahoma.
& Included with Kansas.
« Estimated.
/ Includes the production of Utah.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
447
vance copies of this report appeared in the public press, the petroleum
producers of Oklahoma have arranged to reduce production in that state.
BETTER COMBUSTION.
The use of petroleum as a form of power is justified on the Pacific
Coast, provided attention is given to securing the maximum amount of
power per unit of oil. This is not consistent with burning oil under
stationary boilers for the production of steam, but prompt study should be
given to the development of internal-combustion engines capable of
using crude petroleum or, more particularly, less valuable residuum.
It should be noted that private enterprise has already done much for
the successful solution of this problem.
RANK OF PETROLEUM-PRODUCING STATES, WITH VALUE OF PRO-
DUCTION AND PERCENTAGE OF EACH, IN 1909 AND 1910.
California
Illinois
West Virginia.
Oklahoma
Pennsylvania.
Ohio
Texas
Louisiana
Indiana
New York
Kentucky
Kansas
Colorado
Wyoming
Missouri
Michigan
Utah
Total.
S30.756,713
19,788,864
17,642,283
17,428,990
15,424,554
13,225,377
6,793,050
2,022,449
1,997,610
1,878,217
518,299
491,633
318, 162
42,286
128,328,487
23.97
15.42
13.75
13.58
12.02
10.31
5.30
1.58
1.55
1.46
.40
.38
.25
California
Oklahoma
Illinois
West Virginia.
Pennsylvania.
Ohio
Texas
Louisiana
Indiana
New York
Kansas
Kentucky
Colorado
Wyoming
Utah
Michigan
Missouri
Total .
Value.
$35,749,473
19,922,660
19,669,383
15,720,184
11,908,914
10,651,568
6,605,755
3,574,069
1,568,475
1,414,668
444,763
324, 684
243, 402
98,330
127,896,328
Percent-
27.95
15.58
15.38
12.29
9.31
8.33
5.16
2.80
1.21
1.11
.35
.25
.20
.08
RANK OF PETROLEUM-PRODUCING STATES, WITH QUANTITY AND
PERCENTAGE PRODUCED BY EACH, IN 1909
AND 1910, IN BARRELS.
1909
1910
State.
Rank.
Quantity
Percent-
age.
State.
Rank.
Quantity.
Percent-
age.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
55,471,601
47,859,218
30,898,339
10,745,092
10,632,793
9,534,467
9,299,403
3,059,531
2,296,086
1,263,764
1,134,897
639,016
310,861
1 25,806
30.28
26.13
16.87
5.87
5.80
5.21
5.08
1.67
1.25
.69
.62
.35
17
01
California
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
73,010,560
52,028,718
33,143,3C2
11,751,871
9,916,370
8,899,266
8,794,662
6,841,395
2,159,725
1, 128, 668
1,053,838
468, 774
239,794
I 119,045
34.84
15.82
West Virginia
Ohio. .
West Virginia
Ohio
5.61
4.73
4.25
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania
4.20
Indiana
Lidiana..
New York
Kentucky
1.03
.54
.50
Kentucky
.22
.12
Michigan
Utah
Michigan
Missouri
Total
.05
Utah
Total
183,170,874
100.00
209,556,048
100.00
448
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
PREVENTION OF WASTE IN EXTRACTION AND IN USE.
Legislation tending to the capping of gas wells in petroleum fields
to preserve the pressure and to prevent the unnecessary encroachment
of water, should be extended to all states where petroleum is produced.
After the practical exhaustion of the field by this encroachment of water,
the remaining petroleum can frequently be washed into smaller but still
profitable pools — a system which is already intelligently used in this
country.
DISCOVERY AND DEVELOPMENT OF SUBSTITUTES.
Alcohol from grain, potatoes and waste products can be used in the
place of petroleum as an illuminant and for power in place of gasoline
TOTAL QUANTITY AND VALUE OF PETROLEUM PRODUCED IN THE
UNITED STATES AND THE AVERAGE PRICE PER
BARREL IN 1909 AND 1910, BY STATES,
IN BARRELS.
1909
1910
State.
Quantity.
Value.
Average
price per
barrel.
Quantity.
Value.
Average
price per
barrel.
55,471,601
310,861
30,898,339
2,296,086
1,263,764
639,016
3,059,531
| 5,750
1,134,897
10,632,793
47,859,218
9,299,403
9,534,467
\ 20,056
10,745,092
$30, 756, 713
318, 162
19.788,864
1,997,610
491,633
518,299
2,022,449
7,830
1,878,217
13,225,377
17,428,990
15,424,554
6,793,050
34,456
17,642,283
$0,554
1.023
.640
.870
.389
.811
.661
1.362
1.655
1.244
.364
1.659
.712
1.718
1.642
73,010,560
239, 794
33,143,362
2,159,725
1,128,668
468,774
6,841,395
3,615
1,053,838
9,916,370
52,028,718
8,794,662
8,899,266
115,430
11,751,871
$35, 749, 473
243.402
19,669,383
1,568,475
444,763
324,684
3,574,069
4,794
1,414,668
10,651,568
19,922,660
11,908,914
6,605,755
93,536
15,720,184
$0,490
1.015
.593
.726
.394
.693
.522
1.342
Ohio
1.074
.383
1.354
.742
Utah
.810
1.338
Total
183,170,874
128,328,487
.701
209,556,048
127,896,328
.610
WORLD'S PRODUCTION OF CRUDE PETROLEUM, 1906-1910,
BY COUNTRIES.
1906
1907
1908
1909
1910
Country.
Rank.
Barrels.
Metric
tons.
Per
cent of
total
produc-
tion.
United States.
Russia
Galicia
Dutch East
Indies
Rouraania
120,493,936
58,897,311
5,467,967
8,180,657
6,378,184
4,015,803
166,095,335
61,850,734
8,455,841
9,982,597
8,118,207
4,344,162
1,000,000
2,010,639
756,226
756, 631
788, 872
59,875
a 30,000
W8,527,355
62, 186, 447
12, 612, 295
10,283,357
8,252,157
5,047,038
3,481,410
2,070,145
1,011,180
1,009,278
527,987
50,966
a 30,000
183,170,874
65,970,350
14,932,799
11,041,852
9,327,278
6, 676, 517
2,488,742
1,889,563
1,316,118
1,018,837
420,755
42,388
a 30,000
1
2
3
4
5
6
8
9
10
11
12
U
209,556,048
70,336,574
12,673,688
11,030,620
9,722,958
6,137,990
3, 332, 807
1,930,601
1,330,105
1,032.522
315, 895
42,388
a 30,000
27,940,806
9,378,210
1,762,560
1 , 495, 715
1,352,289
818, 400
444,374
257,421
177,347
145,168
42,119
5,895
4,000
63.99
21.48
3.87
3.37
2.97
1.87
1.02
1,710,7(58
536,291
578, 610
509.753
53,577
a 30,000
.59
Peru
.40
Germany
Canada
Italy
.32
.10
} .02
Total....
212,912,800
264,249,119
2S5.089.615
298. 326, 073
327,472,256
43,824,304
100.00
a Estimated.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 449
whenever the necessity arises. No practical substitute is known for
mineral lubricating oils. Animal and vegetable oils are excluded as en-
tirely too expensive. The production of artificial petroleum from vari-
ous vegetable and animal waste products has received sufficient study
to indicate the possibility of good results if scientific research is en-
couraged in this direction.
NECESSITY OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.
The most practical recommendation seems to be the encouragement
of scientific research in the study of the conditions of occurrence of
petroleum in the earth, in order to lessen the expense of discovery of
new pools. A second line of scientific research of even greater value should
include fundamental studies of the nature of all kinds of petroleum, with
a view to converting less valuable varieties into higher grades and to
producing greater proportions of the absolutely necessary lubricating oils
from crude petroleum. Such scientific study should be initiated at once
to be of benefit when the present petroleum supply becomes inadequate.
TIME OF EXHAUSTION.
Regarding the limits of time within which the present supply will be
exhausted, it is clear that considering the minimum quantity of petroleum
in the United States as 15,000,000,000 barrels, and continuing the present
rate of increase in production, the supply would be exhausted about 1935.
If the present annual production were continued without increase, 90 years
would be required to exhaust this estimated minimum quantity. A rea-
sonable view of the situation makes it probable that the present annual
rate of production will be increased slightly through the developments
of Illinois, Oklahoma and California, but that within a very few years
a marked decline will be noted, and this will continue with increasing
value for the oil product and an insufficient quantity for the legitimate
demands of the industry after another decade, and that the production, on
a reduced scale, will continue for a long time, but in an amount unsatis-
factory to industrial necessity, except as supplemented from new fields.
RECOMMENDATIONS.
Three conclusions are self-evident from this report :
(1) It is absolutely necessary for the preservation of an adequate
supply of petroleum that all public lands where petroleum is probable
should at once be withdrawn from entry.
(2) A general investigation of the conditions of accumulation of
petroleum and its geographic distribution should be undertaken in order
that the petroleum-bearing public lands may be selected.
(3) Fundamental scientific study of the nature of petroleum, espe-
cially with a view to securing the greatest yields of the most valuable
constituents and even for transmuting one oil into another, is required
for its most intelligent use.
*COAL FIELDS OF THE UNITED STATES.
The coal areas of the United States are divided, for the sake of
convenience, into two great divisions — anthracite and bituminous.
The areas in which anthracite is produced are confined almost ex-
clusively to the eastern part of Pennsylvania, and usually when the
anthracite fields of the United States are referred to, those of eastern
Pennsylvania are meant. These fields are included in the counties of
Susquehanna, Lackawanna, Luzerne, Carbon, Schuylkill, Columbia,
Northumberland, Dauphin and Sullivan, and underlie an area of about
480 square miles. In addition to these well-known anthracite fields of
•Prom Government Report, "Production of Coal in 1910."
450 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
Pennsylvania there are two small areas in the Rocky Mountain region
where the coal has been locally anthracited, although the production from
these districts has never amounted to as much as 100,000 tons in any one
year. One of these localities is in Gunnison County, Colo., and the other
in Santa Fe County, N. M. The coal, although only locally metamor-
phosed, is a true anthracite and of a good quality. In previous years wme
coal, which was classed as anthracite, was mined and sold in New Eng-
land. The productive area was confined to the eastern part of Rhode
Island and the counties of Bristol and Plymouth in Massachusetts. In
1909, redevelopment of the old mines at Portsmouth was in progress, and
the result of rehabilitating these properties and of utilizing the product
will be watched with interest.
The bituminous and lignite fields are scattered widely over the
United States and include an area of something over 496,000 square miles.
The previous classification of these coal areas published in earlier volumes
of the report, "Mineral Resources of the United States," has been
changed as a result of conferences among the geologists working under
Marius R. Campbell on the economic geology of coal. The areas are
divided, primarily, into six provinces, as follows :
(1) The eastern province, which includes all of the bituminous
areas of the Appalachian region; the Atlantic Coast region, which in-
cludes the Triassic fields near Richmond and Deep River and Dan River
fields of North Carolina, and also the anthracite region of Pennsylvania.
(2) The Gulf province, which includes the lignite fields of Alabama,
Mississippi, Louisiana, Arkansas and Texas. (3) The interior province,
which includes all the bituminous areas of the Mississippi Valley region
and the coal fields of Michigan. This province is subdivided into the
eastern region, which embraces the coal fields of Illinois, Indiana and
western Kentucky; the western region, which includes the fields of Iowa,
Missouri, Nebraska, Kansas, Arkansas and Oklahoma ; and the south-
western region, which includes the coal fields of Texas. The Michigan
fields are designated as the northern region of the interior province.
(4) The northern, or Great Plains, province, which includes the lignite
areas of North Dakota and South Dakota and the bituminous and sub-
bituminous areas of northeastern Wyoming and of northern and eastern
Montana. (5) The Rocky Mountain province, which includes the coal
fields of the portions of Montana and Wyoming which are in the moun-
tainous districts of those states, and all the coal fields of Utah, Colorado
and New Mexico. (6) The Pacific Coast province, which includes all of
the coal fields of California, Oregon and Washington.
According to the revised estimates the supply of coal in the ground
when mining began was 3,076,204,000,000 short tons, of which 1,922,979,-
000,000 are considered to be easily accessible, and 1,153,225,000,000 short
tons to be either so deep or the beds so thin that they are accessible
only with difficulty. Classified according to the character of the coal, the
original supply consisted of 21,000,000,000 short tons of anthracite, 1,661,-
457,000,000 tons of bituminous coal, 650,157,000,000 tons of sub-bituminous
coal, and 743,590,000,000 tons of lignite. The total production at the
close of 1910 was 8,243,351,259 short tons, which, including the loss in-
volved in the mining and preparation of the coal, represents an ex-
haustion of 13,395,000,000 tons. The original supply, less the exhaustion
at the close of 1910, leaves as the apparent supply still available 3,062,808,-
972,000 tons, or 99.6 per cent, of the original supply, or in other words,
in all the time since coal mining began in the United States, the draft
upon the original supply, including loss in mining, has amounted to less
than one-half of one per cent. The annual rate of exhaustion at the
present time, as represented by the production of 1910, is 0.025 of one
per cent, of the supply. The quantity of coal still in the ground at the
close of 1010 was 6,000 times the production of that year.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
451
Mgl
■<a p.
g-uj 2
CI i— CO cm o *o
*OCOC
co"cTc
s q r- co -g* ■* co r-i
300 i^w*cCt*(O0CN
co fr-
ee Oi
iO ^
iO ;o
io-<
© 2*0-2
>■ s«~ ©
< a o «3
3>— <Oi— l'«S*O>COt--CO''rfr-C0
1 H tN Ci CS in (N CN C. C^ i-i CK^i
t£
u.St
i oi <n (N co w h t-- oo c
HClCOSOiOCi
J-h^CIOIC
Hp
CM O 0<N *? 00 05 O ■-** GO
I'-ONNOtOO
.-■ IO CN--< rH
3 CM lO »0 "*
. - to o c
400 Nor
r^io'cTco"*
CM CM
if
flQC'tCiOKOiOOHOliOSt
'O i-O '--O TC *r -i- T — ?t io ~ CI ~
•*r a>— •r-CN-^'C^oot-H^j'co^-tO''
tirjNMN -< o* c^" vj --' m t-.' •* c
.-h o h r- t-
HCl Oi-»
OHHwem to o — c. t-- oi a*, oo
[ - C I -r - C J CO C I OO t - O O & 1-" CO
C." X C CJ C N h p- nV N H h I
iMOCftOCN^aOt
ItO «5H
_>^Oi-i fr-CO
CO »0 O Oi to to
tDt-t ^H
IO CO fr- «** -* IO i-i CM CM T-.
_ — -*^ —.
<CM ONr-iCN«DCOHN
O ■ -~<~H
'Sen * •
. >o to • ■
too*
Ofr-
»-i OO
o to
•v »o
05 * •
t- i-H
COO
t>
lOiO
CO to
CO .-<
s
r- oo •■* co
'Op Ol (N
cm<m i-i
© 2. c ©
SfOeot^ocoNO'j'Wc
>p40M(MNC
> rf tO O O CO C
'MrHHCC
liOOiOWfHO'.
^h iO^h CM.-1
jHCJC-f »o to oo
"JCO^OOHMNOrtOfCXt'-t-H^XCMNI'H'tM
OhoSconvhc..
IOOCOCOh-
;--<h-i--CNC
*-* CM
.2 P
*d ©
p§ © 6
3s-g
jHVHoa^noooooioooi
>COtP QOOC.fiQN^Wh.OOlCOi
IO OO Ol .-i iO tOO CO iO O h-CM Ci '
HN>^C0«3H(
i-i CM OOOi-MCM^rCOCOt—
1.5
ES
o a
3'«M
3!>!
■S-a^-s Si23'2 & « S jg.S.H 5 5 oi^ ESS S-S •!=.£££
452
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
SHORT TONS
50,000,000
100,000,000
Pennsylvania
(bituminous)
West Virginia
Illinois
Ohio
Indiana
Alabama
Kentucky
Colorado
Iowa
Wyoming
Tennessee
Virginia
Maryland
Kansas
Washington
New Mexico
Missouri
Montana
Oklahoma
Utah
Arkansas
Texas
Michigan
Other Statss
7,928,120
^^$13,903,913
HB 7 533,088
^3$11,706,187
■■7,121,380
^$7,925,350
B 6,507,997
$5,877,486
B5, 217, 125
$5,835,058
■ 4,921,451
g%| $7,914,709
■ 3911,899
^^$9,764,465
■ 3,508,321
^j $4,877,151
52,982,433,
^$5,328,285
■ 2,920,970
^ $5,329,322
■ 2,646,226
gl $5,867,947
■ 2,517,809
^$4,224,556
■ 1,905,958
g $2,979,213
■ 1,892,176
0$3, 160,965
■ 1,534,967
@ $2,930,771
1660,431
S$l,140,252,
150,000,000
150,521,526
$160,275,302
Figuee 1— Production of coal in the United States in 1910, by States.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 453
*DURATION OF SUPPLY.
The total reserve of easily accessible and now available coal is
estimated at 1,382,780,000,000 tons. The assumption that a constant output
has been reached would be utterly unwarranted. On the other hand, the
adoption of the flat rate of annual increase of 7.36 per cent, would involve
the improbable assumption that the marvelous record of the past and
present will be maintained in the future and the production would con-
tinue to approximately double every decade. Using the waste allow-
ance, on the basis of this constant rate of increase in production, the
1,382,780,000,000 tons available at the close of 1907 would be exhausted
in 107 years, or by 2015 A. D. Against the use of the flat rate of increase
it may well be contended that, just as the rate of increase in population
tends to diminish, so this rapid increase in per capita consumption of
coal cannot persist, and a constant annual production will be reached.
However, the figures set fifty years ago by statisticians for the probable
constant annual production of coal in England have already been ex-
ceeded by over 160 per cent.
Mr. Henry Gannett has made an estimate based upon a decreasing
rate of increase calculated from 20-year averages of production. The
use of 10-year averages is regarded as unsatisfactory for the reason
that one of the decades may consist mainly of a period of prosperity,
while the preceding and succeeding decades contain periods of business
depression. The 20-year period, however, is sufficiently long to include
a period of prosperity with one of business depression. Taking the four
20-year periods since 1828, three rates of increase are obtained which
show a rapid decrease. The hyperbolic curve computed from these
successive rates of increase will indicate the constantly diminishing
rate of increase for the successive 20-year periods. The result obtained
by this method is that the easily accessible and available coal will be
exhausted about the year 2027, and all coal by the middle of that century.
It is recognized that the data upon which this curve has been con-
structed are few and the curve correspondingly weak. However, in the
above estimate all of the data have been given which it is possible to
use, and this estimate is believed to represent the best use that can be
made of the data at hand.
Inasmuch as America leads the world not only in present production
of coal, but also apparently possesses the greatest reserve and certainly
is mining coal at much lower cost than any other country, the obvious
tendency will be for European countries to look more and more tc the
United States for their coal supply. Therefore, while our present coal
production and consumption are practically equivalent, the export of
coal, unless prohibited by federal legislation, must eventually become
a factor and increase the coal production in the United States beyond
the demands of home consumption. On the other hand, powerful in-
fluences will come to bear upon coal production, which favor lengthening
the life of the supply. Thus it is to be hoped that with more improved
methods in the utilization of coal the increased efficiency per unit
may act as a factor in reducing coal consumption, and improved
mining methods should likewise decrease the waste percentage. The
increased utilization of water power should also tend to decrease coal
consumption. Again, as soon as the end appears in sight, prices will
rise and production diminish, and that progressively. This interference
with the law of decreasing increase produced by growing scarcity will,
of course, prolong the life of our coal reserves, but at the same time
will greatly hamper our industries that depend on this fuel.
With so many indeterminate factors whose importance is realized, but
cannot be measured, prophecy must possess a questionable value.
*From Bulletin No. 394, United States Geological Survey.
454 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
WASTE IN COAL MINING.
The principal loss or waste attending coal-mining operations is that
represented by the quantity of coal necessarily left in the ground as pillars
to support the roof. In some cases it is also necessary to leave a
foot or more of coal as a part of the roof, because of the unstable
character of the material underlying the coal, which itself does not
make a good roof. It has also been frequently the case that, where
portions of the coal bed have been of inferior quality, only the high-grade
coal has been mined and the poorer material left. The coal left as pillars,
or as portions of the roof, may be considered a necessary loss, but that
which is left because of its inferior quality cannot be considered un-
avoidable waste in any sense, and is frequently of higher grade than
coals mined and used in other portions of the country.
Enormous quantities of coal have been lost beyond recovery from
the mining of beds lying below, the caving of which, upon the with-
drawal of the pillars, has so broken up the overlying strata as to render
it impossible to recover the coals contained therein. This has been
particularly the case in some of the coal beds of western Pennsylvania,
but much improvement has been observed in this regard within later
years. Notwithstanding the improvement in this respect it is probable
that a large amount of coal will be wasted in the western states, where a
great number of coal beds are closely associated, and also where the
intercalated strata are weak, forming poor roofs to the mines.
There are no exact figures as to the actual loss or waste sustained
through coal left in the mines in conducting the mining operations, but
it has been estimated that it amounts to 50 per cent, of the quantity
produced and marketed. In some cases, through careful mining and where
the conditions are ideal for working, practically all of the contents of
the coal beds are recovered. In other cases, particularly when the
beds are of enormous thickness, the recovery has not exceeded 30 per
cent, of the contents. During the earlier days of mining in the anthracite
regions of Pennsylvania it was estimated that only 40 per cent, of the
coal was marketed. This was partly due to uneconomical methods of
mining, and partly to the large amount of culm, for which there was at
that time no market and which was piled on the ground in unsightly
mountains. At the time of the Anthracite Coal Waste Commission,
which made its report in 1893, 40 per cent, was still considered a maxi-
mum recovery. So far as underground workings are concerned, there has
been no revolution in the methods employed since that time, but there
has been a considerable improvement in the application of those methods,
which has resulted in the recovery at the present time of a materially larger
proportion of the coal in the ground than was the rule at that date. The
earlier methods of mining consisted in leaving comparatively narrow
pillars, and in the mining of large rooms the result was that the pillars
were not strong enough to stand the pressure and were crushed beyond
recovery. It is now customary to use larger pillars between the rooms,
which makes it possible to better control the roof during "robbing"
operations and to eventually recover a larger proportion of the contents
of the bed.
Material improvements have also been made in the methods of the
preparation of coal, so that a much greater proportion of the product
hoisted is now being sent to market in merchantable condition. Part of
this is due to better and more systematic methods of handling, and part
to the saving of small sizes which formerly went to the culm banks.
The higher prices of coal and the development of methods for using
these small sizes have also made it possible, through washing processes,
to rework the small coal formerly thrown on the culm banks, and these
are now furnishing several millions of tons of marketable coal annually.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 455
CANADA.
TREE PLANTING AND REFORESTATION.
The Forestry Branch of the Department of the Interior (Government
of Canada) has, since 1900, been carrying out a scheme of free tree
distribution to farmers in the prairie provinces of Manitoba, Saskatche-
wan and Alberta. During that time some eighteen million trees have
been sent out from the nurseries of this particular branch. The trees
are planted on the homesteads throughout these provinces for wind-
breaks, shelter belts and wood supply. Nurseries have been established
also on some of the forest reserves, and some planting is being done.
In 1894, the Government of the Province of Ontario established a
nursery at the Ontario Agricultural College, Guelph, Ont., and they have
since been distributing trees to farmers throughout that province. This
nursery has since been removed to St. Williams. Ont., where the Pro-
vincial Department of Agriculture has acquired some 1,300 acres of
sandy land, which it is planting up with forest trees. The Province of
Quebec has also established a forest nursery at Berthier, P. Q., but the
distribution from there has, as yet, been small. In a few instances,
planting or sowing has been undertaken in other provinces of the
Dominion by individuals or private concerns.
The Canadian Pacific Railway Company has also taken in hand the
planting of trees of different varieties on the prairies. The trees and
shrubs used are Russian Poplar and Willows, Box Elder, Ash, Spruce,
Scotch Pine, Caragana and Artemosia. A good deal of this work is
done along the cuts, in order that the trees and shrubs may serve as
permanent snow fences.
There is also a permanent plantation at Wolseley, Sask., to deter-
mine the values of different species of trees for tie purposes, as well as
for the correct spacing and mixture. The species selected are native
tamarack, Scotch, red and jack pine, and although the plantation has
not been established long enough to give any reliable figures as to growth,
the results so far have been satisfactory. This plantation is situated
on dry upland prairie. The tamaracks, or larch, used were transferred
from swamp land to the plantation, and the growth on the high land, so
far, has been three times faster than at any time in the swamp. It is
hoped that this plantation will ultimately afford reliable information as to
the selecting and planting of such trees as will eventually be suitable for
tie timber.
Investigations are also being made by the Canadian Pacific Railway
Company as to the value of cut-over and virgin timber lands in selected
locations, in order to determine the value of these lands for permanent
tie reserves. The information obtained from this source is not, as yet,
sufficient to give out anything of a definite nature, but it will be con-
tinued, and in a few years it is also hoped that reliable information
will be obtained regarding this reforestation.
456 CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
The consumption of timber in the year 1910 was as follows:
Lumber 4,901,649,000 ft. B. M.
Square timber 37.962 tons
Shingles 1,976,400,000
Lath 851,953,000
Pulpwood 598,487 cords
Poles 782,841
Cross-ties 9,213,962
Mining timber (round) 52.848,000 linear ft.
Mining timber (sawn) 22,305,000 ft. B. M.
Cooperage (slack), including staves,
heading and hoops 161,641,000 pieces
Cooperage (tight) 8,370,000 pieces
ANNUAL FIRE LOSS.
The information in regard to the annual fire loss is not definite, as
much of the loss occurs in districts so far removed from settlement that it
is impossible to make any reliable estimate. The annual loss from forest
fires will, however, run between 250,000,000 and 500,000,000 ft., board meas-
ure, per annum. In very wet years it might fall below the minimum —
in very dry years it will go over it. The value of the timber destroyed
might be taken at one dollar per thousand at the stump. In the districts
where railways are being constructed, they are the most frequent cause of
fire — at least 50 per cent, of the fires bing caused by them. In the dis-
tricts beyond where the railways are constructed, fires are mostly due
to the clearing of the land by settlers.
COAL AND FUEL OIL RESOURCES.
In the Dominion the aggregate area of coal lands is 29,957 square
miles, containing about 172,100,000,000 tons of the several classes.
Little, as yet, has been done towards ascertaining the loss incident
upon coal mining operations in Canada. Nova Scotia has recently taken
steps to secure this information by issuing coal depletion statement forms
to be filled in by the mine operators. It has been stated by some authori-
ties that for every ton of coal mined, one-half a ton is lost or wasted ;
and in thick beds the recovery probably does not exceed 30 per cent.
The wastes attending coal mining operations may be enumerated as
follows :
(1) Coal lost beyond recovery by mining lowest seams first.
(2) Coal left in pillars to support the roof.
(3) The low grade coal left in the mines.
(4) Slack coal formed during mining operations.
In Western Canada where there are so many seams of great thick-
ness close together, it is looked upon as important that the upper seams
should be mined first, so that any caving as a result of removing the
pillars will not render it impossible to get at the other seams.
CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 457
Great losses have resulted also from improperly burned coal. The
loss in smoke alone with bituminous coal has been estimated at about 10
per cent.
PEAT DEPOSITS IN CANADA.
In round numbers there are 37,000 square miles of peat lands scat-
tered throughout the various provinces.
As a result of investigations carried on in Canada it has been demon-
strated that :
(1) For the economic production of fuel from peat, machinery
driven by power must be substituted as far as possible for manual labor.
(2) That processes so far invented for removing the water content
of the peat by pressure or artificial heat have not hitherto led to profitable
commercial results.
A number of bogs, however, are being exploited to some extent, and
the result of the operation of one of them in particular, viz., the plant at
Alfred, Ont, goes to prove that the production of excellent peat fuel is a
commercial possibility.
It has been found that one ton of peat burned under boilers is equal
to about 5/9 of a ton of coal. It does not clinker, nor give off any ob-
jectionable volatile matter in the form of black smoke, and as a domestic
fuel, it is clean, easily handled and efficient.
CRUDE PETROLEUM.
The waste which occurs in oil production in Canada is not so much
in the oil itself as in the natural gas incident to the oil production. The
oil when obtained, may be sold at once, whereas to sell the gas. long ex-
pensive pipe lines must be laid, franchises obtained from towns or cities
and their market is but limited.
NATURAL GAS IN CANADA.
The production of natural gas in Canada has increased in value nearly
ten-fold during the last eighteen years, and of the total amount the Pro-
vince of Ontario produced about 95 per cent.
Steps were taken by the Ontario Government in 1907 to prevent the
waste of natural gas, and a law was passed levying a tax of two cents per
1,000 ft. with a rebate of 90 per cent, when the gas is used in Canada.
This provision has been very effective.
In Alberta little provision has as yet been made for the plugging
of the gas wells, and many millions of cubic feet have therefore been
wasted annually and extended areas have been more or less drained.
In order to conserve the supply of natural gas, the gas must be utilized
(1) for the purpose for which it is most valuable; (2) in the manner that
will secure the greatest efficiency; and (3) as near as possible to the point
of production. The most valuable uses for natural gas are for domestic
purposes and the development of power.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE VIII— ON MASONRY.
G. H. Tinker, Chairman; F. L. Thompson, Vice -Chairman;
G. J. Bell. W. H. Petersen.
H. E. Boardman. Philip Petri.
C. W. Boynton. J. H. Prior.
T. L. CONDRON. F. E. SCHALL.
L. D. Crear. G. H. Scribner, Jr.
L. N. Edwards. A. N. Taleot.
A. H. Griffith. Job Tuthill.
L. J. HOTCHKISS. A. A. WlRTH.
Richard L. Humphrey. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Masonry has held meetings as follows : At Chi-
cago, on July 12, September I, November 4, 191 1, and January 20, 1912.
The various subjects assigned to the Committee for report were as-
signed to Sub-Committees for investigation.
REVISION OF THE MANUAL.
The Committee recommends no changes in the Manual at this time.
WATERPROOFING OF MASONRY.
In accordance with instructions from the Board of Direction, the in-
vestigation of the waterproofing of masonry has been continued during
the past year. A circular letter requesting information relative to this
subject was sent to the members of the Association. The circular letter
followed, in the main points, the circulars issued in former years, adding
such additional questions as appeared to your Committee called for in
the light of present day practice.
The replies were quite numerous, but only a limited number contained
information on the subject under consideration.
Abstracts from the replies containing information pertinent to the
subject are appended; a perusal of these brings out the fact that while
considerable waterproofing is being done throughout the country, the
methods followed and materials used are much the same as described in
previous reports of the Committee.
From several replies it will be seen that impervious concrete can be
459
460 MASONRY.
made without special waterproofing, by using a suitable gradation of ag-
gregates and the proper amount of cement and reinforcing the concrete
to counteract temperature and shrinkage stresses, and in depositing to use
the proper care and amount of work to secure a dense concrete.
It will also be noticed that in using waterproofing material such as
felt, in connection with coal-tar pitch or asphaltum, fair results are ob-
tained, when the weather conditions are favorable, and when the work
can be done without interference or obstructions and by working con-
tinuously until completed ; it is also noticed that when the work is done
at an unfavorable season, or when work is done in distinct separate periods
and sections, under difficulties such as track operations, undue haste in
completing the work necessitated by special circumstances, the results
have generally been unsatisfactory.
The Committee has not prepared a final report on the subject of
waterproofing; the appended abstracts are submitted as information.
ILLINOIS CENTRAL RAILROAD COMPANY.
Waterproofing double-track steel viaduct, through girders with I-beam
floor encased in concrete. Deck girder approaches with concrete floor.
Waterproofing to protect steel, no head. Waterproofing consisted of
three layers of felt, one layer of burlap, two layers of felt, a mopping of
pitch on the concrete, between each layer of felt and burlap and over all.
The work was completed in 1908 and is satisfactory and no leak on last
inspection in October, 191 1. The waterproofing was protected by a layer
of fine crushed stone and screenings embedded in and covered with pitch.
Expansion was provided in concrete, but no provision for expansion was
made in the waterproofing. The cost of the waterproofing, including the
protection, was 15 cents per sq. ft.
CENTRAL RAILROAD COMPANY OF NEW JERSEY.
Mr. Jos. O. Osgood, Chief Engineer. Supplemental answers given
to Circular 122, November 16, 1909.
Bridge No. 2Q$4, Central Division : No leaks when last inspected in
May, 191 1.
Bridge No. 60^, Central Division : No leaks when last inspected in
October, 191 1.
Bridge No. 42, N. J. S. Division : No leaks when last inspected in
May, 191 1.
Bridge No. 34, Central Division : Leaks appeared along the webs of
main girders during last winter. These were caused by throwing the
snow during the flanging of the tracks along the webs of the girders.
When a thaw set in, the melting snow was held in a pocket in such a
manner as to bring the water above the flashing angle and back of the
waterproofing. This difficulty has been remedied in our later bridges by
placing the flashing angle and carrying the waterproofing at least a foot
above the top of rail. In this bridge the waterproofing was stopped about
on a level with the base of rail.
The cost of forty cents per sq. ft. includes the furnishing and applying
of waterproofing materials and the cost of the protecting brick in place.
The cost of the brick was $8.00 per thousand, f. o. b cars at the work.
Bridge No. 63, Central Division, and 13 other bridges: Leaks ap-
peared along the webs of the girders from the same cause as stated under
Bridge No. 34.
Bridge No. 4^, Manufacturers' Branch: No leaks when last in
spected in May, 191 1, except as stated in former report.
MASONRY. 461
Bridge No. 136, Central Division, Hampton, N. J. : Waterproofed
November, 1910, with four layers of Barrett's Specification Felt and one
intermediate layer of Barrett's Tartex, cemented together with Barrett's
Specification Pitch, waterproofing carried to the under side of flange angles
of main girders. The cost of waterproofing this bridge, including the
brick protection, was $0,273 per sq. ft.
No leaks have appeared up to the last inspection of May, 191 1.
Bridge No. 19, Central Division: Completed September, 191 1. Wa-
terproofed with four layers of Barrett's Specification Felt and an inter-
mediate layer of,Barrett's Tartex, cemented together with Barrett's Speci-
fication Pitch. Protected by brick laid flat with joints poured with pitch.
The cost per sq. ft, including brick protection, was $0,123 for materials
and $0,066 for labor. The brick cost $8.00 per thousand, f. o. b. cars at
the work.
Bridge No. 218, Central Division : A double-track, half-through plate
girder structure about 45 ft. long, with I-beam floor encased in concrete.
Completed November, 1910.
For waterproofing the upper surface of the concrete was given two
coats of Hydrex Waterproofing Paint. As soon as the painting was com-
pleted the ballast was placed immediately on top with no protection for
the waterproofing. Up to the last inspection of May, 191 1, no leaks had
appeared.
The concrete at the main girders was carried up to the flange angles
of the girders which were about 20 in. above the top of rail. The painting
was also carried to that point.
The general practice of this company is still the same as outlined in
the concluding paragraphs of my letter of November 16, 1909, above re-
ferred to.
PENNSYLVANIA LINES WEST OF PITTSBURG.
Mr. R. Trimble, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way, states that the
reply to Circular 122 in 1909 and 1910 contain all the information they
have on the subject.
The latest examinations made show the conditions to be the same as
previously reported.
NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO.
Mr. George W. Kittredge, Chief Engineer, furnishes the following
information :
General Remarks : Trouble experienced in the case of felt and coal-
tar pitch is mostly on account of the poor class of labor used. It does
not prevent leakage when the body walls are not built continuously.
Trouble is also caused by lack of care in joining successive sections of
work, horizontally or vertically.
SUBWAY AT PASSENGER STATION' — BUFFALO.
The subway leading from the Buffalo Passenger Station is of rec-
tangular section, 20 ft. in width and 7 ft. in height inside, serving 12
tracks. The side walls are of monolithic construction similar to ordinary
retaining walls, and the floor is extra thick of the same construction. The
roof is of 20-in. I-beams, with concrete filling between, covered with three
inches of cement, with waterproofing and with a protection of brick on top
of this and under the ballast. The entire outside of walls was covered
with waterproofing consisting of 6-ply tarred felt, each layer put on sep-
arately, with Sarco compound, and outside of this the side walls and the
top are protected with brick laid in cement. The floor is protected by 6-in.
layer of concrete under the waterproofing, the floor itself above the water-
proofing being 10 in. thick, the extra weight being given to prevent float-
462
MASONRY.
N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. CO.
INFORMATION CONCERNING APPLICATION OF WATERPROOFING-1902-1911
Location
Character of the
Structure
Waterproofed
Conditions
Requiring
Water-
Proofing
Head of
Water, if any
Materials
Lsed
Date
Applied
Date
Examined
Remarks
Albany
Subway under tracks
at passenger sta-
tion.
Surface water
j-in. asphalt
Ap. 1902
Ex. 1910
Satisfactory as to
walls; roof leaked
badly; copper sub-
roof put in to take
care of moisture.
Brewster
Coaling station pit. .
6-ft. head
6-ply tar and
Felt
Ap. 1910
Ex. 1910
Leaked badly; repair-
ed by Hydrolithic
compound applied
by the Hydrolithic
company
Buffalo
Scajacuada Creek
arch, 40-ft. span
Surface water
only
i-in. coal tar
pitch
Ap. 1908
Ex. 1910
Good; the only leaks
showing were in ver-
tical joints
Buffalo
Belt Line reinforced
concrete arch
Surface water
only
Tarred felt
coa 1 tar
pitch, s-
in. cement
mortar
Ap. 1908
Ex. 1910
Satisfactory
Buffalo
Belt Line reinforced
concrete arch
Surface water
only
J-in. coating
s t r a ight
run coal
tar pitch
Ap. 1908
Ex. 1910
Satisfactory
Reinforced concrete
arch, Columbia
Street
Surface water
only
j-in. plaster
of 1:2 ce-
ment over
1 layer of
tarred felt
over i-in.
of straight
run coal
tar pitch
Ap. 1909
Ex. 1910
Satisfactory
Onchiota
Concrete arch, 20-ft.
Road bed sur-
face Drain-
age
i-in. coal tar
pitch over
1-in of 1:2
Portl and
cement
mortar
Ap. 1906
Ex. 1910
Satisfactory
Poughkeepsie.
Back of retaining
walls
For surface
drainage
i-in. coal tar
pitch
Ap. 1908
Ex. 1910
Fairly satisfactory
Poughkeepsie.
Back of retaining
walls
For surface
drainage
Medusa
compound
Ap. 1908
Ex. 1910
Water stained; walls
nearly always let
water through at
horizontal joints
where work endsone
day and begins next
Rippleton ....
40-ft.concrete arch . .
Surface drain-
age
i-in. coal tar
Ap. 1906
Ex. 1910
Very little value; leaks
through intrados
every 3 or 4 feet
Troy
4-ft. head
f-in. asphalt
protected
by brick
Ap. 1902
Ex. 1910
Miscellaneous
Retaining walls
Ground and
surface wa-
ter behind
walls
i-in. coal tar
pitch
Ap. 1900
Ex. 1910
Leakage found usually
at horizontal and
vertical joints
where work was dis-
continued
MASONRY 463
age, and prevent its being cracked by the upward pressure of the water.
Waterproofing of sides and floor was made continuous as far as possible.
The conditions requiring waterproofing were as follows : This con-
struction is in a bed of clay which extends about half way up the height
of the subway, the remaining 6 ft. or so is of a loose gravel, so that all
of the surface water coming through the porous matter is held by the
clay under slight head.
The construction of this work was carried on under considerable dif-
ficulty, it being necessary to work while the traffic, which is very heavy
at this point, was going on, and it was possible to build only a part of
the subway at a time, andnot make a continuous job of it. It is probable
that at points where one piece of work left off, and another began, the con-
nection between the waterproofing was imperfect, as cracks began to de-
velop, and the water came into the subway in small quantities in numerous
places almost as soon as completed. This was remedied by careful appli-
cation of */>-in. hydrolithic cement by the Waterproofing Company, on the
inside of the subway, so that the structure is now tight, except the roof,
where on account of the vibration of the trains, it was practically im-
possible to insure an absolutely tight job. Great care was taken to find
all cracks and dig them out, and fill them with hydrolithic cement. The
cost of the hydrolithic waterproofing was about 30 cents per sq. ft, and
has now been on for two years, and has given good satisfaction.
Referring to letter of September 16, 191 1. in the matter of water-
proofing of masonry : I sent on February 10 last considerable informa-
tion on this subject and at this time can only add a few remarks in regard
to waterproofing which we found on the old Park Avenue tunnel roof
where a portion of it was removed at 59th Street.
The roof consisted of iron beams with brick arches which were lev-
eled up with concrete. The waterproofing was placed directly on this con-
crete and was covered with about two ft. of earth which formed the soil
for the parking around the openings in the roof of the tunnel. Drains
were provided so that the water did not stand in the earth. The materials
were of felt and coal-tar pitch, three plies of felt being used. We have
no information as to the method of application or the cost of the work. I
have understood indirectly that this waterproofing was placed when the
tunnel was built, some forty years ago. From recollection of the tunnel
for the past ten years the vegetation over this waterproofing was in such
a state that the waterproofing must be at least twenty years old. The
waterproofing was removed on account of changes we were making last
winter, and it was in fair condition. The paper had become somewhat
brittle, also the pitch was harder than pitches we apply now, but the sheet
of waterproofing was intact and capable of shedding water. Small leaks
would not have been detected; the only protection of the concrete was
the soil placed over it. The waterproofing covered the tunnel roof from
58th to 59th Street, and presumably extends a good deal farther. There
was no provision for expansion joints.
MICHIGAN CENTRAL RAILROAD.
(A) Fifteenth Street Bridge, 3 spans, through plate girders, I-beam
plate ballast floor ; masonry abutments.
(B) Twenty-fourth Street Bridge, 3 spans, I-beam plate ballast floor
on steel bents ; masonry abutments.
(C) Vinewood Avenue Bridge, 3 spans, I-beam plate ballast floor
bridge on steel bents and masonry abutments.
(D) Scotten Avenue Bridge, same as Vinewood Avenue.
(E) Clark Avenue Bridge, same as Vinewood Avenue.
(F) Twenty-third Street Bridge, same as Vinewood Avenue.
(G) Sixteenth Street Bridge, same as Fifteenth Street.
(H) Fourteenth Street Bridge, same as Fifteenth Street
464 MASONRY.
( I ) Beaubien Street Bridge Peninsular Spur, same as Fifteenth
Street.
( J ) Brush Street Bridge Peninsular Spur, same as Fifteenth Street.
(K) Beaubien Street Bridge, 3 spans, built up beams on concrete
bents and concrete abutments. Beams embedded in concrete.
(L) Brush Street Bridge, 3 spans, Bethlehem beams on concrete
bents and abutments. Beams embedded in concrete.
(M) John R. Street Bridge, same as Brush Street.
(N) Tecumseh Road, one 75 ft. through girder span with I-beam
floor and concrete slab on top of 1-bearns.
(O) Beecher Avenue Bridge, 3 spans, built up beams with plate,
ballast floor, on steel bents and concrete abutments.
(P) Twentieth Street Bridge, same as Beecher Avenue.
(R) Military Avenue Bridge, same as Beecher Avenue.
(S) Livernois Avenue Bridge, same as Beecher Avenue.
All the structures mentioned above required waterproofing to keep
floor dry over the streets as follows :
For (A), (B), (C), CD) and (E) : Mop coat of Sarco with \V, in.
sand and Sarco mastic and pouring coat of No. 6 Sarco on top of mastic.
For (F) : M'op coat of Sarco, 1J/2 in. sand and pitch mastic to cover
rivet heads, on top of this 5-ply Barrett Felt and pitch protected by il/j
in. pitch Torpedo gravel mastic.
For (G) : Mop coat of Sarco, ilA in. sand and Sarco mastic to cover
rivet heads, 2-ply Barrett Felt mopped with Sarco No. 6, i1/? in sand aivl
Sarco mastic. Pouring coat of Sarco.
For (H) : Mop coat of Sarco, 1 in. coat of sand and Barrett pitch
to cover rivet heads, 5-ply Barrett Felt mopped with pitch, \l/2 in. of Tor-
pedo gravel pitch mastic with pouring coat of Barrett pitch.
For (I), (J), (K), (L) and (M) : Paint with Sarco Primer, 3-ply.
8 oz. Burlap mopped with Sarco No. 6, il/2 in. Sarco mastic, pouring coat
of Sarco No. 6.
For (N) : Paint coat of Sarco Primer, 3-ply, 8 oz. Burlap mopped
with hot Sarco No. 6, izA in. protection coat of Sarco mastic and Torpedo
gravel.
For (O) and (P) : One and one-half in. Sarco sand and mastic, 3-ply.
8 oz. Burlap mopped with No. 6 Sarco; 1^2 in. Sarco Torpedo gravel
mastic and pouring coat of hot mastic.
For (R) and (S) : One and one-half in. sand pitch mastic, two layers
of felt mopped with Barrett Pitch and one layer of reinforcing felt mopped
with Barrett Pitch ; 1 in. Barrett sand and pitch protection coat.
COST PER SQUARE FOOT OF SURFACE COVERED.
Labor Material Total Completed
(A) 3-9/10 5-5/10 0-4/10 August, 1908
(B) 2-9/10 6-4/10 9-3/10 June, 1909
(C) 2-7/10 6-9/10 9-6/10 September, 1908
(D) 2-5/10 7-2/10 9-7/10 June, 1008
(E) 3-2/10 7-8/10 11 June, 190S
(F) 7 7-4/10 14-4/10 June, T909
(G) 4-7/10 9-7/10 14-4/10 August, 1908
(H) 7-5/10 6-8/10 14-3/10 July, 1908
( I) 20 16-4/10 36-4/10 Done in winter; trouble with snow
and ice December, 1910
( J ) 9-3/io 16-9/10 36-2/10 December, T910
(K) 6-4/10 14-4/10 20-8/10 December, 1910
(L) 9-5/10 15-5/10 25 March, 191 1
(M) 8-5/10 17-1/10 25-6/10 January, 1911
(N) 10 8-6/10 18-6/10 June, 1910
MASONRY. •466
Labor Material Total Completed
(O) 7-3/10 18-8/10 26-1/10 November, 1910
(P) 7-2/10 16-2/10 23-4/10 July, 1910
(R) 4-6A0 10- 14-6/10 May, 1910
(S) S-8/10 10-8/10 15-6/10 May, 1910
(A) Leaks badly over posts at gusset plate connections and small
leaks at nearly all beam connections in northbound track. Leaks at 25
per cent, of beam connections in southbound track.
(B), (C), (D), (E) and (F). No leaks.
(G) Leaks over posts at gusset plate connections only.
(H) Leaks over posts at gusset plate connections only.
(I), (J), (K), (L) and (N). No leaks.
(0) Two small leaks over supporting girder, third panel from
north end.
(P), (R) and (S) No leaks.
EL PASO & SOUTHWESTERN SYSTEM.
Have waterproofed in 1008 about 194,000 sq. ft of concrete lined
reservoirs, using the Sylvester process of soap and alum, two coats of
each, and by painting surface with asphalt and Elaterite waterproofing.
We depended largely upon this waterproofing for water-tightness, and the
concrete was not as rich in cement as it otherwise would have been. Theo-
retically the mixture was 1:2:4; actually, some of it was not quite as rich.
We had considerable trouble with leakage through portions of the con-
crete and, upon examination, such parts were generally found to be evi-
dently porous.
After a period of three years, we find the asphalt and Elaterite coating
to be a pronounced failure on account of peeling off in the winter time
through action of frost. We find the Sylvester process of soap and alum
quite efficient. Except in places where the concrete is evidently quite in-
ferior, the soap and alum has made the concrete watertight. Where the
concrete was good and the work thoroughly done, the water will stand
and roll on the surface of the concrete as it will on plate glass. Of course,
the concrete is not actually as impervious as the glass, but drops of
water on the concrete so waterproofed disappear by evaporation rather
than by absorption.
The sand and gravel used in lining these reservoirs were of a fair
grade only, the maximum size of gravel being 1^2 in. The concrete lining
was from 4 to 6 in. thick. The gravel was not as finely graded as it
should have been and the larger stones were evidently too large for that
kind of work.
The cost of waterproofing with soap and alum was 43/Too cents per
sq. ft. ; with asphaltum 1 4/10 cents and with Elaterite waterproofing made
by the Elaterite Paint Mfg. Co., Des Moines, ij4 cents per sq. ft. (For
former report on this, see Proceedings, Vol. 12, Part 1. page 513.)
A few months ago we completed a reinforced concrete septic tank 30
ft. in diameter and 12 ft. high, with shell .6 in. thick. No waterproofing
was used in this concrete. The latter was theoretically a 1:2:4 mix, but
we actually used a somewhat greater percentage of cement. The sand and
gravel were good. The specifications for the gravel required it all to
pass through a l/>-'m. screen. This tank is entirely watertight except at
the joints between successive courses of concrete. It appears to be demon-
strative of the possibility of making concrete watertight, at least for the
light pressure existing in this particular tank.
First-class sand and stone, carefully graded, to reduce the voids, and
a liberal margin of cement in excess of the voids in the sand and stone,
and thorough uniformity in the mixing and laying are, we believe, more
efficient than anything else in making concrete waterproof. The maximum
size of the stone should not exceed f£'-in. and we think that ^-in. is better.
466 MASONRY.
CHICAGO, BURLINGTON & QUINCY RAILROAD.
In 1909 or 1910 we furnished the Committee with some discussion
on the subject of waterproofing. We have some of this waterproofing in
service for about three years, and where it was properly put on, it is in
good shape.
It will be noted at the right hand end of the blueprint enclosed the
old method is shown. Here the waterproofing passes down over a steep
slope. In some cases the pressure from the ties has forced it down the
slope, tearing it apart. In order to avoid this trouble, the new method
shown at the left hand end of the blueprint was adopted. The slope was
made flat and the burlap was laid over a long piece of gas-pipe, placed at
the top of the slope and withdrawn as the work proceeded, leaving some-
thing in the way of an expansion joint.
This has been quite successful, but if we have more of this kind of
work to do, we shall make the subway slabs the same thickness as the
roadway slabs, thus getting a uniform slope from the center of the street
to the back of the abutment.
We are now engaged in repairing some of this waterproofing where
leaks have occurred. The work was done in frosty weather and we find
that the first ply of burlap was not saturated at all; the second ply begins
to be saturated ; the third one a little more and the fourth and fifth ones
are well saturated.
On all of this cold weather work so far examined, the mastic pro-
tection over the burlap is cracked badly and the burlap at the bottom of
these cracks has rotted. For purposes of comparison with this work, we
have cut out a few pieces of waterproofing from portions of the structure
put in the same year, but where the work was done in warm weather ;
here the waterproofing is in perfect condition. We attribute the cause
of the trouble entirely to the fact that the waterproofing was laid in cold
weather when the concrete surface upon which it was laid was cold, and
the asphalt chilled before it had an opportunity to saturate the burlap.
The original cost of this work was 13-3/10 cents per sq. ft.. 9-3/10
cents being for material and 4 cents for labor. (For former information,
see Proceedings, Vol. n, Part 2, pp. 991-992.)
NORFOLK & WESTERN RAILWAY.
Subway for use of passengers under tracks at Petersburg, Va. Con-
structed of concrete, a 6-in. layer of concrete is placed, on the area of
foundation, upon this concrete against the outer forms 4-in. brick walls
are built, and on the concrete base and against the brick walls the water-
proofing, consisting of a coat of Sarco concrete primer applied hot, a
heavy swabbing of Sarco No. 6 waterproofing and 3-ply membrane No. 16
Sarco Asphalt felt; the felt is lapped so that there is at no point less than
three thicknesses of felt, each thickness being heavily swabbed with hot
Sarco No. 6 waterproofing before succeeding thickness is applied.
The membrane is well swabbed with Sarco No. 6 and while this coat
is still hot a layer of 8 oz. burlap is applied, this layer is also swabbed with
No. 6 Sarco and a second layer of 8 oz. burlap, breaking joints with the
first, is laid.
The last layer of burlap when dry is swabbed with hot Sarco.
The concrete walls, floor and steps of the subway are then built
against the waterproofing above described.
The concrete subway roof reinforced with steel rails and expanded
metal, laid with a crown of 1 in. for drainage is waterproofed by a mat
of 2-ply burlap and 3-ply felt laid as described for sidewalls, except that
the burlap is laid first or on the bottom of the mat. The roof waterproof-
ing is protected from cutting by the ballast by a layer of i*4 in. of Sarco
Asphalt M'astic applied in two coats of 3%-in. each, with lapped joints.
MASONRY. 467
This work was done about a year ago and has proven satisfactory.
Cost of waterproofing complete about 50 cents per sq. fr.
CHICAGO CITY RAILWAY COMPANY.
Car Houses and Car Repair Shops. Advise that the old roofs are
about the same as they were a year after completion; no new leaks have
developed since that time. (See Proceedings, Vol. n, Part 2. page 971.)
Particular attention is called to the design of roof over the addition
to the Thirty-eighth and Cottage Grove car house, constructed a year and
a half ago and to this date shows no sign of a leak. No waterproofing
was used, water tightness was obtained by dense concrete reinforced to
resist shrinkage and temperature stresses. The body of the roof slab was
mixed in 1 :2 -.4 with 54-in. top finish cement and sand 1 13 mix. On this
structure, expansion joints were used. Size of stone specified was to
pass a 34-in. TinS and under. The concrete was mixed very wet.
INDIANAPOLIS WATER COMPANY.
Mr. William Curtis Makee calls attention to the Clear Water Reser-
voir at Riverside Pumping Station. Indianapolis, 257 ft. by 377 ft. with
walls 10 ft. high, floor, walls and roof built monolithic; built in 1907 and
examined in 191 1 and showing no leaks. The cover is flat and supports
two feet of soil, drainage being carried off by means of open jointed drain
pipes laid on the cover. No waterproofing was used.
Concrete was of dense construction reinforced with steel bars for
shrinkage and temperature stresses. Proportions 1 cement to 6 un-
screened bank gravel ; head of water contained 8 ft.
Also calls attention to three filter covers each 200 by 350 ft. joined at
the center for a length of 350 ft. to a partition wall 14 ft. high. The
covers are laid on a slope of 5/10 per cent, and required to shed storm
water; 2 ft. depth of screened cinders are placed on the covers. No
leaks, except slight seepage at junction of entrance to flat slab.
The work was completed in ioo5 and last examination in 191 1 shows
the results above noted. No regular expansion joints were used; the en-
tire roof slides on supporting walls on paraffin joint. The mixture was
1 cement, 2 parts of sand and 4 parts of stone mixed very wet. The water
pressure was 10-ft. head on dividing walls. There are some leaks in
dividing walls due to the aggregate stratifying; the leaks being in hori-
zontal seams and quite small.
PHILADELPHIA & READING RAILWAY.
(Waterproofing of Masonry, P. G. & N. Elevated.)
Refers to report of November 1, 1909, on the same subject with sup-
plement as published in Proceedings, Vol. 12, Part 1, page 510.
No noticeable difference in the number of leaks is apparent except
perhaps that the total amount of leakage is not so great and those struc-
tures originally reported as water tight are still in the same condition.
Last inspection was made in September, 191 1.
In regard to new work, this is reported under three heads : (a)
Bridge on Contract No. 11, P. G. & N. Elevated; (b) Waterproofing of
steel Viaduct between Brown and Jefferson Streets; (c) Bridge over
Master Street — all located in the City of Philadelphia.
(a) Consist of nine half-through plate girder four-track bridges.
Total area of bridge floors, 56,500 sq. ft.
(b) Top of deck plate girder four track viaduct. Total area of
waterproofing, 197,300 sq. ft.
(c) Deck plate girder span with buckle plate floor. Area, 3,050 sq. ft.
The protection of the steel work of bridges and of street underneath
required the waterproofing and applies to all cases.
468 MASONRY.
Materials used for (a) and (b) natural rock asphalt mastic V/2 in.
thick applied in two coats and supported by 1 -.3 :6 concrete filling in
troughs of steel floor. And for (c) five layers Genasco felt protected with
irick laid on concrete filling of buckle plate floor.
The cost for (a) is reported at 24 cents and 31 cents per sq. ft, for
(b) 24 cents per sq. ft. and for (c) 26 cents per sq. ft. These costs in-
clude, in all cases, the concrete. Under (a) the troughs were 12 in. deep,
and under (b) 6 in. deep.
Under (a) one-half of each bridge completed October, 1910; balance
June, 191 1 ; (b) one-half completed in December, 1910; balance May, 191 1 ;
(c) completed December, 1910.
Very few leaks have appeared under any of the nine bridges under
(a) except in two places where the old work joined with the new on ac-
count of connecting the two sections. This joint has given trouble along
one girder.
(b) Is generally tight except at expansion joints; these joints occur
about every 150 ft., and are now being treated with a laver of pure asphalt
with a high melting point and a low brittle point, placed over the joint.
One-half of the viaduct has been so treated and proved very effective.
(a) and (b) No protection of waterproofing was used; ballast rest-
ing directly on the mastic. For (c) the waterproofing is protected with
a layer of hard brick laid in waterproofing compound.
ST. LOUIS & SAN FRANCISCO RAILROAD.
Reports on reinforced concrete beam subway bridge — 2 spans, 25 ft.
and 12^2 ft., supporting 3 tracks. Waterproofed by using 16 parts old
process coal tar, 4 parts Portland cement, 1 part kerosene, applied hot
by means of a brush. The tar was heated first and kerosene and cement
added ; 3 heavy coats used on top, 2 heavy coats on rear face of abutments.
Cost of labor $0.00519 and for materials $0.00418, or a total of $0.0092
per sq. ft. of surface treated.
Work was completed in October, 1910, and examined in October, 1911,
and no leaks discovered. No protection to the waterproofing was used;
12-in. ballast ties on top of the reinforced slab and cinder filling was used
against the abutments of each joint.
One expansion joint over supporting columns protected by raising
concrete along each side of joint. The surface of the entire structure is
small and sloped for drainage.
PITTSBURG & LAKE ERIE RAILROAD.
Reports waterproofing on five 40 to 50 ft. four-track half deck and
through girder bridges. Floor stringers spaced 15 in. center to center.
Space between floor stringers filled with concrete.
Waterproofed to protect the metal work and also against dripping to
the street under bridge.
Waterproofing consisted of Sarco No. 6 waterproofing with 8 oz.
open mesh burlap; i?4 lbs. of 1:2 cement mortar protection over water-
proofing.
On the clean dry surface of concrete floor was applied a coating of
Sarco Concrete Primer thin enough to penetrate the recesses of the con-
crete. Primer in some cases being too heavy was thinned with gasoline.
After the primer dried (requiring about one hour) a heavy coating of hot
Sarco No. 6 Waterproofing was applied and while the material was still
hot a layer of 8 oz. open mesh burlap was laid.
To apply the burlap on the hot Sarco, first have it rolled on a 2-in.
round stick and start unrolling immediately after applying the Sarco, ex-
ercising care to keep it straight and free from folds. Follow closely the
unrolling of burlap by brooming with a rattan broom. This method was
followed until three layers of burlap was applied.
MASONRY. . 469
On top of the last layer of burlap a heavy coating of hot Sarco was
applied. As soon as convenient, after the Sarco waterproofing was ap-
plied, a i2i-in. thickness of i :2 cement mortar was laid.
Cost of labor $0,026 per sq. ft. treated and $0,044 for material, making
a total of $0,070 per sq. ft. treated for 3 bridges on which complete data
were kept. Results obtained were reported in paragraph 7, Bulletin 130,
Masonry Committee reports on "Waterproofing." Last examination made
September 25, 191 1.
For the Sharon Road Bridge and Lion Lane Bridge: No leaks in
concrete roof apparent. A few rivets in the girders show that at some
time water must have passed through waterproofing.
Leopard Lane Bridge: Under No. 1 track water is dropping slowly
at three places. At six other places indications point that water has been
dropping at some time and at a few other places in girders indications are
that water has passed through rivet holes at some time.
Third Street Bridge: No. 1 track, no leaks. No. 2 track, five places
at edges of floor-beams indicate that water has come through and at two
of these places it was dropping slowly at last inspection. Track No. 3,
two places water dropping. Track No. 4, no leaks.
Second Street Bridge: A good many leaks show at this bridge. This
is the bridge on which an unfavorable report was made before and there
is no indication of any decided change. Leaks show at edges of floor-
beams and girders. Water is slowly dropping through at many of the
rivets.
The reason advanced for the unfavorable condition of waterproofing
on these bridges is that the concrete was not allowed to set up naturally,
artificial heat having been applied to dry it preliminary to applying the
Sarco Primer, and in some cases the waterproofing was applied in un-
favorable weather conditions.
Have just completed bridge at Aliquippa, which was waterproofed in
the same manner as those above described but with all conditions favor-
able for a fair test, such as dry concrete on which to apply the first coat
(Primer) and dry and warm weather during the time the waterproofing
was applied. It will be interesting to observe the results in connection
with this structure which is known as the Third Street Subway at
Aliquippa.
Another reason advanced for the failure of the waterproofing outlined
in the first paragraph is that the cement mortar cover may be broken under
impact of traffic and the ballast may have cut the waterproofing.
Third Street Subway, Aliquippa, Pa.: This is a ballast bridge, 288 ft.
wide, and supporting about 20 tracks. The distance between abutments
is 40 ft. and a line of columns supports the floor structure at the center.
The floor is made of 15-in. 80-lb. I-beams, 44 ft. long, spaced 15 in.
c. to c. and filled between with 1 13 :S concrete.
The structure is waterproofed with Sarco No. 6 waterproofing, with
2-ply. of 8-oz. open mesh burlap, using same method given in answer to
question No. 4 of Circular dated September 16, 191 1, except that two layers
of burlap were used.
The area covered was 14,000 sq. ft.
Sarco Primer, 151 gals. @ $0.35 per gal $ 52.85
Sarco No. 6, 16,200 lbs. @ $35-6o per ton 288.36
Burlap, 1,560 lbs. @ $o.oS per lb 124.80
Total cost of material $466.01
Total cost of labor 251.38
Total cost of labor and material $7 17.39
470 MASONRY.
Material cost $.033 per sq. ft.
Labor cost $.018 per sq. ft.
The waterproofing was protected by T?4-in. cement covering made ot
1 :2 mortar. The area covered 13,320 sq. ft.
Sand used, 52 tons @ $0.65 $ 33.80
Cement, 131 bbls. @ $0.85 111.33
Labor 103.00
Total $248.15
Material cost $.011 per sq. ft.
Labor cost $.008 per sq. ft.
The waterproofing was applied at different times between May and
August, 191 1, under favorable weather conditions and is in good condi-
tion at this date, October 5, 1911.
SANTA FE RAILWAY SYSTEM:
(Waterproofing of Scale Pits and Hopper Pits for Mechanical Coal
Chutes.)
Pits were about 5 ft. deep and water level was within 1 ft. of surface.
Three-ply Hydrex felt was used on one scale pit with poor results ; used
ironite, a paint, on one scale pit with fair results ; used 8 per cent, hydrated
lime mixed with dry cement on coal chute pits obtaining good results.
The mix of the mortar was 1:1 and the concrete 1:1:2. No record was
kept as to cost. The work was done three to five years ago and, when
examined about six months ago, there were no leaks.
LONG ISLAND RAILROAD.
(Reinforcing Concrete Floors for Steei Bridges Carrying Railroad
Tracks.)
Six layers of pitch, four of felt and one (the middle) reinforced by
cloth, each layer thoroughly swabbed with hot pitch on the felt. The
total cost per square foot of surface treated from 12 to 20 cents. The
work was done from 1908 to date — 10 bridges. First-class results were
obtained and on last examination, October, 191 1, there were no leaks.
The waterproofing is protected by brick, the cost of which is included in
the above figures. No expansion joints were used in any of the floors.
Have used, in the construction of a small concrete water tank at
Long Island City, inside plaster with mortar mixed 1 cement, 1 sand and
2 gals, soft soap and about 2 qts. of granulated alum per barrel of cement.
The results obtained are not stated
CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY.
(Waterproofing Subways.)
McPhillips Street Subway: Deck of subway of steel plate. Water-
proofing used dry felt, tarred felt, burlap and Gilsomite asphalt, applied
as follows :
On the steel deck is laid a layer of dry felt, then a layer of tarred felt
with asphaltum, over this is laid two layers of burlap each mopped with
asphaltum, then a layer of tarred felt mopped with asphalt, over this is
laid a layer of tarred felt not mopped and last a layer of dry felt. The
cost of this waterproofing was 12^2 cents per sq. ft. The work was com-
pleted in 191 1 and at last inspection during October, 191 1, was found
satisfactory. Two small leaks appeared along joint made with previ-
ously constructed waterproofing. Waterproofing is protected by a coat
of tar concrete 4 in. thick. The cost of this protection is 9 cents per sq.
ft. ; this is not included in the above price for waterproofing.
MASONRY. 471
The work covers 10,500 sq. ft. Expansion is taken care of by the
layers of dry felt.
Rachael Street Subway: Reinforced concrete deck waterproofed by
burlap and pitch, using five layers of burlap and pitch between each
layer. The work was completed in 1908 and is fairly satisfactory. On
last examination in October, 191 1, a few small leaks showed. No pro-
tection to waterproofing was used. The ballast was laid directly on top
of the waterproofing.
Weston Shops (Winnipeg): Deck of subway, old rails encased in
concrete. Waterproofing material, burlap and asphaltum.
The concrete was first covered with a layer of asphaltum on which
is laid one thickness of burlap, then a layer of asphaltum, then another
thickness of burlap and then a good covering of asphaltum over all. The
total cost of this waterproofing is 8y2 cents per sq. ft. The work was
done in November, 1910, and results obtained are satisfactory; last exam-
ination in October, 191 1, showed no leaks. No protection was used over
the waterproofing. Gravel was laid directly on the waterproofing.
Union Station (Regina) : Conditions requiring waterproofing; sur-
face water and leakage from tank and pipes leading from dam to round-
house, gardens and various buildings. Materials used were cement mortar
and pitch. The waterproofing was applied as a plaster against the wall
and afterwards given a good coating of pitch. The cost of the waterproof-
ing labor was 1.93 cents; the cost of waterproofing material was 2.72 cents;
total cost of waterproofing per square foot of surface treated was 4.88
cents, this includes superintendence. Work was completed in August,
191 1, and from an inspection made during October, 1911, the results ob-
tained are apparently remarkably good. No protection was used. Back
filling was placed directly against waterproofing.
UNION AND SOUTHERN PACIFIC SYSTEMS.
Brick Depot Building: Coating brick walls on interior with asphaltum
paint, before applying plaster; the paint used was Toch Brothers B. I. W.,
applied with spraying machine or three-coat work with brush. The cost
of the work was 11 to 13 cents per sq. yd. applied with spraying machine.
The work was done in 1907 and at last inspection, September 30, 191 1, the
plaster was found to be dry and decorating in good condition.
Hospital Building Basement: Used 5 per cent. Medusa compound,
first mixed dry with cement, then added to other aggregate, proportion
one part cement, one part sand and five parts stone, size of stone 34-in. to
iJ4 in. The mixture was so-called wet mixture (water appearing freely
on surface). The work was done in 1909 and upon last inspection, Sep-
tember 28, 1911, the walls and floor were dry, no leaks and no moisture
appearing. The cost of the work account waterproofing was increased
$1.10 per cubic yard.
Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Co.: Waterproofing con-
crete wall, built 1 :3 :5 mixture, blue cross cement, ordinary run of gravel
and sand, maximum size of gravel passed 2-in. ring. Head of water 6 ft.
Waterproofing consisted of Wunners Bitumen Emulsion, mixed 2Y2 pints
of this material with one bag of cement and 2^/2 cu. ft. of sand, adding
water to plaster consistency applied to surface of wall; the work was
done September 1, 191 1, and at last inspection, October 28, 191 1, showed
small amount of surface water but no apparent leaks.
The cost was about 10 cents per sq. ft. of surface waterproofed.
PENNSYLVANIA LINES.
Enclosed are blueprints of statement corrected to include the water-
proofed bridges, Twelfth to Twenty-sixth Streets, in our Chicago Track
Elevation Work. This is a record of the method of waterproofing used in
472
MASONRY.
WATERPROOFING BRIDGE FLOORS— METHODS USED AND RESULTS OBTAI NED.
Pennsylvania Lines West of Pittsburg, Southwest System.
Street
Track No.
Method of Waterproofing
Year
Applied
Result of Inspection
April, 1909 April, 1910
April. 1911
Ashland
1
2
3
4
5
6-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1906
1906
1906
1907
1907
No leaks
No leaks
Leaks badly
Leaks badly
No report
No report
No report
No report
No report
No report
4 leaks
4 leaks
5 leaks
4 leaks
6 leaks
Paulina
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Driveway
8
9
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
3-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1906
W06
1906
1906
1907
1907
1907
1906
1907
1907
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
6 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
26 leaks
No report
Several leaks
Several leaks
7 leaks
8 leaks
No leaks
15 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
2 leaks
No report
No report
No leaks
7 leaks
6 leaks
8 leaks
3 leaks
5 leaks
5 leaks
4 leaks
8 leaks
4 leaks
Wood
1
2
3
4
5
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1906
1906
1906
1906
1907
No leaks
16 leaks
4 leaks
Several leaks
No report
13 leaks
9 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No report
10 leaks
10 leaks
10 leaks
10 leaks
10 leaks
Lincoln
I
2
3
4
&
6
7
Driveway
8
9
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-j>ly Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
S-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-pJy Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
3-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
19Q6
1906
1906
1906
1907
1907
1907
1906
.1907
1907
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
4 leaks
3 leaks
4 leaks
10 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No report
2 leaks
No report
7 leaks
7 leaks
11 leaks
17 leaks
5 leaks
10 leaks
19 leaks
10 leaks
10 leaks
9 leaks
Robey
1
2
3
4
5
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1906
1906
1906
1906
1907
No leaks
No leaks
24 leaks
Several leaks
No report
15 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
1 leak-
No report
7 leaks
26 leaks
5 leaks
19 leaks
19 leaks
Hoyne
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Driveway
8
9
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
3-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1906
1906
1906
1906
1907
1907
1907
1906
1907
1907
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
4 leaks
lleak
No leaks
15 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
8 leaks
No report
No leaks
8 leaks
13 leaks
18 leaks
6 leaks
18 leaks
6 leaks
19 leaks
19 leaks
9 leaks
9 leaks
35 leaks
Leavitt
1
2
3
4
5
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt ConcreteTop
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt ConcreteTop
1906
1906
1906
1906
1907
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
18 leaks
9 leaks
2 leaks
5 leaks
No report
9 leaks
22 leaks
22 leaks
12 leaks
13 leaks
Oakley
1
2
3
4
5
Iron "Bark Concrete Top
Iron Bark Concrete Top
5 ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1905
1905
1906
1906
1907
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
Leaks badly
Leaks badly
No leaks
14 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No Report
3 leaks
6 leaks
6 leaks
6 leaks
17 leaks
Western
1
2
3
4
5
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
4-ply Barretts Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1907
1907
1905
1905
1907
No leaks
10 leaks
No leaks
Several leaks
Several leaks
5 leaks
3 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No report
8 leaks
9 leaks
9 leaks
23 leaks
33 leaks
Note. — Bridges located In Chicago.
MASONRY.
473
WATERPROOFING BRIDGE FLOORS-Continued.
Street
Track No.
Method of Waterproofing
Year
Applied
Result of Inspection
April, 1909 April, 1910
April, 1911
Marshall
1
2
3
4
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
5-ply Hydrex Felt Concrete Top
1908
1908
1908
1908
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks,
No leaks
1 leak
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
34th
1
2
3
4
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
1904
1904
1904
1904
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks- very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
8 leaks
8 leaks
10 leaks
8 leaks
35th
1
2
3
4
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt.
1904
1904
1904
1904
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
8 leaks
8 leaks
9 leaks
7 leaks
36th
1
2
3
4
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
Concrete and Asphalt
1904
1904
1904
1904
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
Leaks very badly
6 leaks
8 leaks
7 leaks
6 leaks
Archer
1
2
3
4
Concrete — Wire Mesh
3-ply Hydrex Felt
3*-ply Hydrex Felt, no Concrete
on Top
Concrete and Asphalt Mastic
; 1904 1 No leaks
1904 j No leaks
1904- No leaks
1904 No leaks
3 leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
No leaks
1 leak
1 leak
No leaks
Western
1
2
3
4
Concrete — No Waterproofing
Concrete — No Waterproofing
Concrete — No Waterproofing
Concrete — No Waterproofing
1905 1 Leaks very badly
1905 Leaks very badly
1905 j Leaks very badly
1905 | Leaks very badly
3 leaks
16 leaks
2 leaks
6 leaks
39 leaks
36 leaks
31 leaks
30 leaks
Normal
1
Asphalt Mastic
1904 No report
15 leaks
30 leaks
Wallace
1
Asphalt Mastic
1904 j No report
No leaks
No leaks
Lowe
1
Asphalt Mastic
1904 1 No repdrt
14 leaks
36 leaks
Union
1
Asphalt Mastic Blocks
1904
No report
9 leaks
27 leaks
Emerald
1
2
Side Track
Asphalt Mastic Blocks
Asphalt Mastic Blocks
Hydrex Felt
1904
1904
1907
No report
No report
No report
20 leaks
8 leaks
4 leaks
6 leaks
15 leaks
12 leaks
Halsted
1
Hydrex Felt
1906
No report
lleak
No leaks
Mill
All Tracks
Sandusky
6-ply Barretts Felt.BrickoaTop
1909
7 small leaks
24 small leaks
Darby
6-ply Barretts Felt, Brick on Top
1909 1
1 small leak
7 small leaks
Note.— Above-named bridges located ia Chicago, excepting last three,
which are in Columbus.
474 MASONRY.
all of our track elevation bridges, and the results of inspections made from
time to time thereafter.
All of the bridges were of trough floor, the troughs being filled with
concrete, the waterproofing applied, and a protection coat of concrete or
brick added on top of the waterproofing.
The cost of applying this waterproofing was as follows :
Twelfth Street 51.3 cents per sq. ft.
Ogden Avenue 50.0 cents per sq. ft.
Fifteenth Street 47.4 cents per sq. ft.
Sixteenth Street 49.3 cents per sq. ft.
Eighteenth Street 43.1 cents per sq.ft.
Twenty-first Street 39.3 cents per sq. ft.
Twenty-second Street 23-3 cents per sq. ft.
Twenty-third Street 57.3 cents per sq. ft.
Twenty-fourth Street 48.3 cents per sq. ft.
Twenty-fifth Street 48.4 cents per sq. ft.
Twenty-sixth Street 70.0 cents per sq. ft.
The above costs cover the concrete filling in the troughs, waterproof-
ing the protection coating of concrete or brick, and the concrete parapet
walls at the ends of the bridges. We have not added any material or
substance to concrete, to make it impervious. We have not used a per-
centage of hydrated lime in any of our concrete, in an endeavor to make
it impervious.
METHODS OF PATCHING AND REPAIRING PLAIN AND
REINFORCED CONCRETE.
Your Committee having been instructed to collect data and prepare
a report on "Methods of Patching and Repairing Plain and Reinforced
Concrete," reports as follows :
A circular letter, under date of July 14, 191 1, was sent to members
of the Association, requesting information on this subject, to which let-
ter more than one hundred replies have been received. Nearly all of the
replies contain useful information, but as the same methods are frequently
described by several writers, a selection has been made from these replies
and is presented as an appendix to this report.
The various methods referred to may be described as follows :
(1) Wet Method: The surface of the old concrete is thoroughly
roughened, cleaned and drenched with water and covered with a cement
grout. Then the new concrete is mixed to a sloppy consistency and ap-
plied, being held in place till set by forms, as required.
Comment: From the reports received it appears that many suc-
cesses and many failures have followed this method. Where it has been
successful, that result probably has been due to painstaking care and
expense being employed in the preliminary cleaning and thorough wetting
of the old concrete surfaces before the new concrete is applied.
(2) Moderately Dry Method: The surface of the old concrete is
thoroughly roughened, cleaned and drenched with water and powdered
with cement or painted with cement grout — after which the new concrete
is applied and thoroughly tamped against the old surface. Generally,
such patches are kept moist by sprinkling them with water for several days.
MASONRY.
41$,
Comment: The same comment applies here as to the wet method.
(3) Dowel Method: This is a modification of the two preceding
methods and is generally used for other than horizontal surfaces, although
it may be applied to the latter. The new concrete may have afiy consist"
ency to meet the particular conditions Or the ideas of the Engineer i«
charge,, but usually a fairly wet concrete is used. This method includes
drilling holes and setting dowels into the old concrete, with projecting
ends to engage into the new concrete. Sometimes steel bars cr metal
fabric are connected to these dowels to further insure permanency of the'
patch.
Comment: This method can be made uniformly successful, but can-
not always be applied. Where any considerable mass of new concrete
is to be connected to old concrete this is the only safe method to pursue.
(4) Wedge Method: This method includes the cutting out of de-
fective concrete in such a manner as to undercut the surrounding good!
concrete so that the new concrete will be held in place, when Set, by"
the shape of the binding edges of the old concrete.
Comment: The difficulty of undercutting concrete so as to secure-'
such edges is too great to make this method applicable in ordinary case?,,
and, except where a considerable depth of new concrete is to be put in,
such undercutting could not be successfully done, as concrete cannot be
cut so as to leave sharp, clean edges.
(5) Cleaning with Steam: This is a method of cleaning surfaces
of old concrete preparatory to putting on a patch of new, or of cleaning
the top of a rough concrete floor before applying the "finish coat."
The surface of the old concrete is brushed as clean as possible with stiff
brushes and then gone over at least twice with a steam jet— an ordinary
piece of half-inch gas pipe makes a very satisfactory jet nozzle. This
short length of pipe is connected to a steam hose so that it can be readily
moved about. The steam is supplied by the boilers of the mixer or
noisting engines. The steam will clean and heat the concrete surface,
leaving it perfectly dry, so it is important to thoroughly drench the sur-
face with water after cleaning with steam. In cold weather it is found
advantageous to use hot water. Immediately after the surface is thor-
oughly cleaned and drenched, the new concrete is applied.
Comment: Excellent results have followed the use of this method
of cleaning, but it is essential that the surface of the old concrete be
thoroughly drenched with water after using the steam jet, otherwise
the new concrete will not adhere to the old.
(6) Cleaning with Acid: This method includes washing of the
surface of the old concrete with a solution of hydrochloric (muriatic)
acid (one part acid to two parts water), after which the surface must be
carefully and thoroughly washed to remove any free acid.
Comment: This is a very commonly applied method of cleaning
old concrete surfaces preparatory to placing new concrete against them,
and, by many, is considered the only safe one to use, especially where
a "finish coat" is to be put on after the concrete base is set.
476 MASONRY.
CONCLUSIONS
Your Committee presents the following conclusions as to the methods
of repairing defective or worn surfaces of concrete:
(i) In all cases the surface to be repaired must first be thoroughly
cleaned of all loose material, laitance and dust and the clean, rough, sound
concrete exposed to receive the patch. Probably the best method of
cleaning is by means of a steam jet.
(2) After cleaning, the surface to be repaired must be thoroughly
saturated with water, not simply moistened, but so thoroughly drenched
that the old concrete will not absorb water from the new mortar or
concrete used in patching. If possible, the surface should be kept covered
with water for several hours.
(3) If the repair or patch is to be made on a vertical or sloping
surface and is not to be more than V/2 in. thick, the surface of the old
concrete, while it is still wet, should be spattered or splashed with a
cement grout, following this immediately with a fairly stiff plaster coat
of mortar made of the same proportions of cement and sand as was used
in the original concrete, but never richer than 1 cement to 2.V2 sand.
This plaster coat should not be thicker than J^-ih. and each coat should
be forced into the surface, but not dragged with a trowel. The sur-
face of each coat, except the final coat, should be "scratched" to give a
bond for the next coat. This plastering should preferably begin at the
top and progress downward, and only enough time be allowed to permit
each coat to receive its initial set before the next coat is applied. The
final coat should be finished with a wooden float and only enough water
used to properly finish the surface. This patch should be kept damp and
protected from sun or frost till fully set up.
(4) If the repair or patch or "finish coat" is to be made on a
horizontal or nearly horizontal surface, the surface of the old concrete
should be slushed and broomed with a thin cement grout, following this
immediately with a wet mortar made of 1 part cement and 2*4 parts sand
or granite screenings and of the full thickness required (not less than
J/2-in. thick, however). When this mortar begins to take its initial
set, it should be floated or troweled to such a finish as may be desired.
(5) If the repair or patch is to be made on a vertical or sloping
face and is to be more than il/2 in. thick, it will be advisable to embed
dowels into the old concrete, as deeply as the thickness of the proposed
patch, and spaced sufficiently close together to firmly anchor the patch to
the old concrete. The dowels must be wedged into the old concrete and
it will be advisable to fasten wires, metal fabrics or bars to the dowels,
in the case of extensive patching, as an additional safeguard. The patch-
ing may then be done with mortar without forms, or with wet concrete
supported by forms, depending upon the thickness and the extent of the
patch.
(6) If the repair or patch is to be made on a horizontal or nearly
horizontal face and of considerable thickness, dowels may be used, or
MASONRY. 477
the concrete may simply be reinforced by fabric or bars without using
dowels — treating the patch as a block of masonry.
(7) Care must be taken not to have thin edges on patches. To avoid
this, it may be necessary to cut out sound concrete around a piace to be
patched, so as to give deep edges to the patch. If possible, the edges
should be undercut.
ABSTRACT OF REPLIES.
Lincoln Bush, Consulting Engineer: "During the years 1900 to 1909,
inclusive, the Lackawanna Railroad put in 907,000 cu. yds. of concrete. In
building this masonry the general practice for concrete work done from
1900 to 1903 was to make the body of the masonry in proportions of I :3 :S,
with a 2-in. surface finish in the proportions of about 1 :2 :2.
"The concrete built from the years 1903 to 1909, inclusive, which was
generally in the proportions of 1 :3 15 for the entire wall without any
1:2:2 mixture for a facing coat, has given by far better results than the
work done with the 2-in. facing. My observation and experience show
that the defects and shelling off of the 2-in. facing may not take place for
a period of two or three years after the work is finished and that these
defects and the shelling off continue.
"I advocate very strongly the use of a uniform mixture for the entire
wall, omitting the surface coat of richer proportions and, if it is desirable
and necessary to have a special surface finish for ornamentation or other
purpose, to obtain such finish by bush hammering, treatment with acid or
rubbing and washing while concrete is green, using crushed stone of such
size as will give the desired surface effect."
Frank H. Alfred, General Superintendent, Cincinnati, Hamilton &
Dayton Raihvay: "Small imperfections in finish, we repair with stiff
cement grout immediately after the removal of the forms. We aim to sim-
ply fill in small cavities, not by plastering, but by working the grout into
each individual cavity, finishing afterwards, while the grout is green, by
rubbing with a small block of wood.
"Larger cavities we fill whenever weather conditions are favorable.
In filling such cavities, we aim first of all to thoroughly clean the cavity
of all loose stone, cement and dirt. We are very particular about clean-
ing the cavity, using for the purpose a weak solution of acid, if necessary,
later washing all remaining acid from the cavity. We then use one to
two grout or a lean concrete mixture, mixed rather stiff. This mixture
we are very particular to thoroughly mix, that is, if mixing by hand,
where three turnings would suffice for ordinary concrete, we give the ma-
terial intended for patching some eight or a dozen turnings. In depositing
this material in the cavity we seldom use anything resembling a form to
retain it in place, but put the material in with trowels in small layers,
thoroughly working it into place. If the mixing and depositing is thor-
oughly done, such repairs will be permanent."
W. J. Harahan, Vice-President, Erie Railroad: "At Hornell, in 1907,
one of the forms on the retaining walls, over a section 12 ft. in height and
20 ft. in length, bulged about 5 in. at the bottom near the center and the
bulge radiated from this point to nothing at the sides and top. On ac-
count of being on a sidewalk and the appearance very noticeable, this
extra width was scabbled off; this scabbling left a rough and uneven
surface. The finishing surface was put on with a mixture of one part
cement to three of sand made into a dry mortar ; the surface of the rough
wall was wet down thoroughly while finish was being applied. Commenc-
ing at the top and at one end of the section, this mortar was nut on with
a float, a small amount at a time, starting at the top and carrying it to the
bottom in sections of about 2 ft. in width ; the work was carried on
uninterruptedly in this manner until the!, whole area was covered. The
thickness of this veneer is generally one inch, but there are places where
4TS MASONRY.
the scabbling was irregular and where it is from 2 to 3 in. thick in spots.
There has been no indication of checking and the appearance of the wall
is generally the same in color as the remainder, which was made of con-
crete i :2^ :5> and there is no reason to believe that, from this time on,
there will be any failure.
"At Buffalo, on an abutment composed of a mixture i :2j^ :5, after
the forms were removed, a point about 2 ft. above the foundations indi-
cated a break in the mixture in that it showed a sand streak. The jentire
abutment was gone over with bush hammer as a test, but there was not
further indication of this predominance of sand. The point referred to
was cut over an area 4 ft. high, 8 ft. long and 18 in. deep from the face
of the wall. In taking this out 2 in. of the hard concrete was removed to
be sure that all of the sand had been taken out, and a cross-section showed
that at 8 in. back from the face the material was removed for a distance
of 6 inches higher and wider than the opening at face of wall and then cut
back 10 in. deeper, this in order to dove-tail the new concrete into the old.
It happened that there were some one-inch corrugated bars left over from
reinforcement. From this three vertical and two horizontal rods were in-
serted about on the line of the offset ; that is, about the middle of the
hole. Then it was filled in with 1 :2 14 concrete and after setting up was
bu:u hammered. This work was done on June 10, 191 1, examination made
on July 22, 191 1, did not show any indication of shrinkage of the new con-
crete from the old concrete, and no indications, by sound, of any cavi-
ties."
L, W . Walter, Cement Inspector, Erie Railroad: "Of these three
processes, that of 'pouring' permits of the use of mortar or concrete and is
resorted to when the surface to be bonded is very irregular or when the
bulk of the applied material is too great to permit of plastering or tamping.
This process involves the erection of forms and the depositing of con-
crete or mortar in the usual way, but further requires that the material
be very wet, and that it be agitated near the surface of the old concrete
to bring the new material in the closest possible contact with the old. This
method is frequently unsuccessful and should be resorted to only when the
bulk of the applied material is so great as to make the cost of plastering
or tamping prohibitive. It is of course understood that when this or any
other method is used it is necessary to remove all loose particles from,
and to thoroughly drench the surface of the concrete.
"In the process of plastering on old concrete surfaces which have
been scabbled or roughed, both the conditions and the requirements are so
varied that results are frequently not satisfactory. Plaster will adhere
to surfaces prepared by furring or roughing, as is customary in prepar
ing the scratch coat to receive another coat in straight plaster work, but
in plastering irregular concrete surfaces it is necessary to use very wet
mortar. This gives it a tendency to loosen from the surface, by its own
weight, thereby forming hollow areas which will be further loosened by
frost. where there is considerable moisture present, or by expansion and
contraction due to temperature changes.
"The practice of tamping mortar against old concrete surfaces, whether
it be to fill voids caused by air bubbles, or whether the surface be honey-
combed or on surfaces made rough by scabbling, is one which I would
personally recommend, as I have tried it under varying conditions and
have not had a failure. In tamping mortar to rough surfaces I would pro-
ceed in the following manner : Working downward from the top of the
area to be treated I would remove all loose particles and would wash
the surface of the old concrete with a brush. The sand and cement for
use in the mortar should be the same kind and proportions as that used
in the concrete, provided it be not richer than 2^ parts of sand to one
part of cement, and should be thoroughly mixed dry and water added by
sprinkling until a semi-plastic consistency is had. In tamping the mortar
MASONRY. 479
against the surface to be treated, I would work downward from the top
of the area in order that the water used in wetting the surface of the
concrete would not run down over the newly applied coat. When the
surface has been brought to the proper plane, it should be floated with a
wooden float, and only such amount of water should be used in the final
floating as may be necessary to produce a dense surface. This water may
be applied by means of a brush or by dipping the float in vi ater.
"It is found in practice that a rather dry mortar, such as may be
tamped, and not plastered, on a concrete surface, is less apt to loosen
from contraction and expansion due to temperature changer and will more
nearly resemble, in color, the adjoining natural surface.
"In such work as renewing the top or wearing which has loosened
from the base of concrete pavements, on account of its having been placed
after the base had set, the tamping process is a success. It is necessary,
however, that the base of the concrete be firm, and advisable that the
base be washed with a neat cement wash and the new top be well floated.
This, in my opinion, is the most difficult patch work to be encountered
and is the best argument I have to offer in favor of using, for patch
work, a relatively dry mortar.
"For patching honey-combed surfaces I would recommend tamping to
the exclusion of the old practice of plastering."
/. M. Meade, Engineer Eastern Lines, Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe
Railway: "In one small abutment the bridge foreman allowed the weight
to be placed upon it too soon, when a wedged shaped piece of the abut-
ment broke out with about half of the bridge seat as the base, and extend-
ing down three or four feet on the face of the abutment, to the point of
the wedge. The broken face was thoroughly roughened up and form built
around it and concrete of the same mixture was very thoroughly tamped
into position.
"On some reinforced work we did last winter the section foreman
knocked off a part of the form in connection with his track work, and in
doing so knocked off several corners of the concrete. We built up forms
around these and thoroughly tamped in a rich mixture of equal amounts
of sand and cement, and today the break cannot be detected.
"Several concrete steps in Newton, Kansas, were replaced several
years ago by roughening the surface and putting in nails for dowel pins.
This was thoroughly tamped with a rich mixture and has never shown any
signs of failure.
"The secret in patching concrete seems to have been in having a rough
surface to work on, and in thoroughly tamping the concerete and putting
in dowels or anchors, of any kind, wherever possible. Also in leaving it
in the forms until it was thoroughly set."
F. E. Schall, Bridge Engineer, Lehigh Valley Railroad: "A double
track ribbed abutment, supported by piling, broke in two about the center
line, and opened up a crack about 1^4 in. wide (due to settlement and
leaning of piling in foundation) ; after movement of piling ceased, a
V-shaped opening about one foot wide and about 6 inches deep was cut
in the face of the abutment and that opening filled with comparatively dry
concrete; after setting of this concrete, the crack was filled with con-
crete grout. A slight crack due to contraction of concrete appeared along
the edges of the V-shaped patch but is of no consequence. The patch
has been in place about il/2 years and is giving satisfaction."
H. F. Hamilton, Resident Engineer, Great Northern Railway: "I wish
to say that I had occasion a few days ago to look over Bridge 434, and
found that the new concrete had adTiered very nicely to the old surface and
was apparently as solid as if placed at one time. Method used was to
scabble off with a pick and bull point the concrete affected by the frost.
480 MASONRY.
Then to wash the surface exposed with water, scrubbing with a stiff
broom. This was then gone over with i .3 solution of muriatic acid and
again washed. New concrete was applied as soon afterwards as possible
and put on very wet. At two or three places about four feet above the
ground line there was a hollow sound to the concrete, and it appeared that
there was not a very good bond in about an inch or so from the surface.
As there was a slight bulge in the surface of the wall, I think this is some
additional put on with a trowel after the forms were removed. I believe
the above methods will give good results, but this depends on how clean
the old surface is made and the keeping of the new concrete damp for a
week or so after being placed." .
/. A. Atzvood} Chief Engineer, Pittsburg & Lake Erie Railroad.
"Cut out all loose concrete and wash it off thoroughly, then apply a thin
wet mixture of mortar of about one to one, allowing it to set for about
an hour or more in order that it will adhere to the old concrete and not
slip away when the concrete is put in. We then use a wooden float to
rub the outer surface. If the patches are too large we insert steel dowels
in the old concrete."
E. A. Hadley, Engineer of Design, Missouri Pacific Railway: "Thor-
oughly clean the surface of the old concrete, with a stiff brush, remove ail
loose particles and foreign material. If the surface to be patched was
smooth, the same was made rough by the use of hand drill.
"After the surface was prepared in this manner, the same was washed
down with clean water, and a thin layer of cement mortar mixed one to
two. spread on the surface, and a rich mixture of concrete immediately
placed on the bed of the mortar.
"The tops of several retaining walls were repaired in this manner un-
der my direction, and the face of a bridge pier, on which the forms had
bulged, was cut down to a true surface and patched up in this manner.
"This work was done in the early fall of 1909 and was examined by me
personally in December, 1910, and it was found that the patched surfaces
were in perfect condition, with no signs of cracking or peeling, and no
hollow sound was emitted when the surface was struck a sharp blow
with a light hammer."
C. E. Carhvright, Consulting Engineer: "The surface of the old con-
crete is carefully picked so that all loose material is removed and irreg-
ular holes are cut so that a mechanical bond will be made between the
old and new concrete. If the concrete will be subject to blows iron
dowels will be set at different angles and well grouted.
"Before placing the new concrete the old surface will be thoroughly
soaked with water for a couple of days. It will then be well_ brushed out
with a steel brush and water and immediately before pouring the con-
crete a coat of neat grout will be brushed in.
"If the repair is large reinforcing steel will be used, the ends being
well grouted into special holes drilled for the purpose."
F. L. Wheaton, Engineer of Construction, Delaware, Lackawanna &
Western Railroad: "We do not allow surfaces to be washed or plastered
with either neat cement or cement and sand after the forms are removed,
as this invariably scales off in time and leaves an unsightly appearance.
We do in some cases allow surface to be smoothed by use of plain water
and carborundum, or cement bricks, rubbing off the white lime dust after
surface is dry, but prefer surfaces to remain without treatment of any kind,
which can be done if sufficient care is taken with forms.
"Where bony or porous places occur in face, due to improper spading
or a leak in forms, which allows cement and sand to escape, we require
voids to be filled immediately upon removal of forms with cement mortar
of same proportions as used in the body of concrete and smoothed with
MASONRY. 4*1
wooden float, not troweled. We seldom have any trouble with this mor-
tar falling out and if done in time is seldom noticeable.
"One of the worst defects in concrete faces, and one which rarely
develops until some time after the completion of the structure and, there-
fore, is hard to repair, is caused by the failure to remove the sludge which
invariably rises to the surface of wet concrete and forms a slimy coating
of variable thickness at the end of each day's work. If this is allowed to
remain, and the next day's work deposited thereon, it will later dissolve,
leaving a more or less ragged line of demarkation on the surface. While
this is inexcusable, it sometimes occurs and we then chisel it out in the
form of a dovetail, filling with cement mortar and stone screenings, tak-
ing care that mixture is not made too rich, otherwise, there will always
remain too great a contrast in color. This should be floated off with
wooden float or wire brush so as not to leave a glossy finish. We do not
depend on new concrete adhering to old, but cut out imperfection to suffi-
cient depth and dovetail in the patch."
Hunter McDonald, Chief Engineer, Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis
Railway: "The only method which I have tried for restoring the sur-
face which has been worn off or cracked away by failure of the top coating
to adhere to the concrete beneath, is to apply to the old concrete a solu-
tion of one part hydrochloric acid and two parts of water, permitting it
to stand about fifteen minutes, then washing it off thoroughly and apply-
ing the top finish. This has been tried in only a few isolated cases and
the success of the efforts has not been sufficiently demonstrated for lack
of time.
"I have understood that in a reinforced concrete building the floor
finish put on the rough surface by this method has, in many instances,
come loose. Whether this is due to bad workmanship or an imperfect
process I am unable to say.
"In finishing the floors of a reinforced concrete warehouse I required
that the top surface should be applied within three hours after the laying
of the concrete. This plan has worked well in every instance, except
where rain came up and roughened the floor after the finishing had been
done. These rough places I have endeavored to grind out, but have found
no successful means of doing so. Efforts to patch them out by applying ad-
ditional finish have been unsuccessful on account of the fact that we did
not remove the top coating for a sufficient depth. The feather edges of all
patches will grind off."
G. W. Vaughan, Engineer of Maintenance of Way, New York Central
& Hudson River Railroad: "It is the usual custom, when necessary, to
patch or add to old concrete, to use a hose with water under pressure, or
a brush with water and thoroughly clean the old concrete with a view of
removing every particle of loose material and dirt and leaving same per-
fectly solid and clean. Then we dust dry cement over the old work and
scrub it in thoroughly until all of the spaces in the surface of the old
concrete have been filled with the dry powder. This is slightly moistened
and the new concrete applied.
"In building concrete abutment piers or on retaining wall work, when
for any reason, the work is stopped for a time and the top becomes set,
it is usually customary to thoroughly wash the set concrete and make it
perfectly clean, then mix up a thin grout and pour it on, after which the
fresh concrete may be applied. We have experienced very little trouble
with this method and it seldom shows a seam. However, to build an ex-
tension on an abutment or a retaining wall at the end, a seam nearly al-
ways develops.
"Sometimes when applying a patch we have been successful in
handling same somewhat different than first described, by simply cleaning
away all loose particles of concrete, then thoroughly wetting the old con-
482 MASONRY.
crete and applying a small quantity at a time of new, letting it partially
set before putting on more ; following this process until the work has
been built out to its original surface. This would apply particularly to
large patches, where if all applied at once, its own weight might cause it
to sag and fall away from the old work, unless we went to the expense
of putting in dowels.
"For instance, at Poughkeepsie we have patched the underside of the
protection concrete in this manner and it has been most successful. The
conditions are extremely bad at this place on account of the old concrete
being covered with a coat of soot, grease and smoke from the exhaust
of engines. This was scrubbed with lye and water and then washed off
with the clear water before applying the patch. We would not have any
trouble with this under ordinary conditions, as it lasted well until the cold
weather came on, so that when the hot exhaust from the locomotives, the
stacks standing directly under the concrete, came in contact with same,
the temperature was so suddenly changed that it caused the concrete to
shell off. We do not believe that patched concrete can be made to stand
under these conditions.
"In some instances, the surface of the concrete to be repaired, has
been first roughed up and then kept thoroughly saturated with water for
several hours. Then a coating of cement mixed two to one is thoroughly
troweled on and kept moist for a considerable period of time. A very
good way to keep the surface moist is to place several layers of burlap
on top of the fresh surface and keep the burlap soaked with water.
"Where the surface to be repaired is of a considerable thickness,
\Y2 in. and upward, anchor pins are used, spaced about four to a square
foot of surface. This is particularly effective where the surface is per-
pendicular.
"In some cases our experience has been that about the only successful
way to do this kind of work is to cut out the old work, dove-tailing it and
putting in anchor bolts and care should be taken to see that the old work
is roughened up and dove-tailed, care being taken to avoid feather edging.
Also in doing this class of work care should be taken to see that the new
concrete is not mixed too soft, as it should be of such consistency that it
can be lightly rammed.
"In repairing concrete work, where netting is used on the outer sur-
face, care should be taken to see that the old concrete is removed back
of the netting, so as to get a bond with the netting.
"Ordinarily the methods of patching and repairing, as outlined above,
have been successful."
F. L. Thompson, Engineer of Bridges and Buildings, Illinois Central
Railroad: "In general, our practice in patching small surfaces is as fol-
lows : A mortar is made up with the same proportions of cement and
sand as has been used in the concrete which is to be patched. This mor-
tar is quite stiff and considerable pressure is used in applying it to the
cavity which is first cleaned and thoroughly wet. After the mortar has
partially set the surplus is rubbed off with a wooden float, leaving the
surface of the patch flush with the surface of the wall.
"To lighten the patch and make it as near the color of the old work
as possible, a small quantity of lime paste is added to the mortar. Where
there are deep cavities, it is sometimes necessary to partly fill them and
after the mortar has set make a second application."
H. Rettinghouse, Division Engineer, Chicago & Northwestern Rail-
way: "I have had several cases, when horizontal surfaces, especially
bridge seats had been damaged by frost, to a depth of from four to eight
inches. After removing the frozen and spoiled concrete, we chipped the
surface down to a nearly uniform level, equal to the deepest frozen spot.
In one case which I have in mind, the entire bridge seat of a three track
MASONRY. 481
bridge had been severely damaged by frost. We placed dowel pins in
squares of two feet, securely anchoring them in the sound concrete, then
carefully and thoroughly cleaned and washed off the entire surface and
placed new concrete. We performed work of that kind early this spring
(in April), and recent inspection would indicate that it is an entire suc-
cess
''During the past three years, we have successfully jacketed with con-
crete, old masonry, which had badly deteriorated. The method pursued
was the use of hook dowel pins and expanded metal. The jackets varying
from ten to fourteen inches in thickness. We took great care to remove
all deteriorated and loose portions of masonry, cleaning out joints, etc.,
and have been entirely successful in securing a perfect adhesion of con-
crete jackets to the old masonry, so much so, indeed, that we are grad-
ually treating all our more or less deteriorated masonry of bridges on the
Towa Division in this manner. We have, unfortunately, a great deal of
poor stone in bridge masonry. Some years ago, before I came to this
territory, there had been a great many back walls of bridges built up with
from four to eight inches of concrete on top of old masonry, on account
of track being raised by ballasting. In all of these cases no dowels were
used and the method proved a failure."
C. H. Fake, Chief Engineer, Mississippi River & Bonne Terre Rail-
way: "In a larger case I_ was successful, where, in building two abut-
ments for a deck girder bridge, the abutments were found to be two feet
too far apart. The abutments were both on solid rock, so there was no
danger from uneven settlement and a two-foot slab was patched on as
follows : The face of one of the abutments was scabbled until thor-
oughly roughened. Holes about iTA to 2 in. diameter were drilled in the
roughened face a foot to a foot and a half deep and an area of a hole
to 1 V* to 2 sq. ft. They were not drilled in rows or to line, but irregular
and promiscuously. Bolts of 1% in. iron with swelled end and split, with
wedges were driven into these holes, not tight enough to damage the old
concrete but firmly enough so they could not be pulled out. These bolts
were carefully grouted, leaving the ends stick out from 1 ft. to 22 in. The
form was then built and concrete of the same proportions as the abut-
ments was filled in and in course of a couple of months the girder was
put in place. The end of the girder, 64 ft. long, rested on this patch
which on one end of abutment is about 7 ft. high and other end 10 or
more feet high. The work has been done between eight and nine years and
no sign of separation has shown."
H. L. Ripley, Engineer of Construction, New York, New Haven &
Hartford Railroad: "The method we have used with success is to knock
off all loose concrete ; go over the surface with a mason's point and break
a new face on the stone aggregate; wash down the surface thoroughly
with scrubbing brushes and a water, or better yet a steam jet; wet the
surface until it has absorbed practically all the moisture the concrete will
take up ; paint on a wash of neat cement ; as soon as it commences to set
put on under considerable pressure a plaster coat of new concrete. (If
any oil has been used around the concrete a steam jet is about the only
method I know that will entirely remove it).
"By keeping the new concrete moist (not drenched) and protecting it
from the direct rays of the sun by curtains or otherwise, we have met
with fair success in patching old concrete using this method. Of course,
concrete must be absolutely protected from frost during the work and
for three or four days afterward."
L. B. Merriam. Civil Engineer, Winnipeg: "I have frequently used
the ordinary method of thoroughly cleaning the surface to be patched,
484 MASONRY.
then soaking the original concrete at the place where the patch is to be
made. I believe my success has depended entirely upon using a sufficient
quantity of water in the soaking process. The water should be applied ac
intervals or constantly for a period of at least ten hours, preferably for
twenty-four hours before the patch is put on. Those failures that I have
had indicated that the original concrete had robbed the new concrete of
its water before the final set was completed owing to the application of
water for too short a period prior to placing the patch. I have plastefed
large surfaces successfully where the body concrete was thoroughly satur-
ated before applying the plaster."
George W . Kittredge, Chief Engineer, New York Central & Hudson
River Railroad: "Our practice on all the breaks where there is a hole
of not more than 2 in. in depth to fill up, has been to clean off the
surface of the concrete thoroughly, wet it and then apply about a half
inch of mortar, allowing this to stand until it has dried out slightly,
when another coat of about the same thickness is applied; this process
being repeated until the hole is filled up flush with the face of the con-
crete from which the piece has been broken, after which it is floated. In
most cases the repaired spot can hardly be detected, and I do not know
of any cases where the pieces have broken out again.
"At different times we have used the following method: Square out
the holes, making the area at the back of the hole larger than on the face,
and fill it up with mortar. This shape of hole served to key in the new
piece. This method was not as satisfactory as the one which is described
above, as the patches show more plainly, and it was also somewhat more
expensive."
E. B. Temple, Assistant Chief Engineer, Pennsylvania Railroad: "At
South Fork, Pa., we built a retaining wall in the winter of 1909-1910. The
weather was unusually severe, and before the concrete set properly the
surface concrete was frozen. In the spring, the face of the wall showed
signs of disintregation ; and, after a careful examination, it was decided
to remove as much as possible of the faulty concrete. This was done by
picking the surface with a small hand pick to a depth varying from 1 to
18 in. The body of the wall thus exposed was good substantial concrete,
and was carefully cleaned. Dowels of steel were driven into this surface,
the dowels being placed about 6 in. apart, and to these dowels a light
reinforcing mesh wire was firmly attached. The forms for the face of the
wall were then placed ; and, after the concrete had been thoroughly wet,
the forms were carefully backfilled with cement and sand in the propor-
tion of approximately 1 part cement to 2 of sand. This wall has been stand-
ing for about fifteen months, and apparently is in as good condition today
as when put in place."
A. Q. Campbell, Assistant Superintendent, Oregon Short Line Rail-
road: "The methods that I have used in this work have varied to a cer-
tain extent with the class and the nature of the material to connect with.
The most successful method I have used has been the channelling of the
old concrete, say one inch deep and one inch wide, or the width of a
chisel, these channels to be made in the surface of the old concrete in the
shape of a checker board, the size of the squares depending on the size of
the surface to be covered.
"I successfully covered a depot platform in this way with ij^ in.
topping, that has now been in service for four years with but one or two
cracks coming in same. The success with which the covering is put on
in the case of sidewalks or beams would depend very largely on the class
of material used in the concrete and the nature of the old concrete. I
have in some instances sprinkled the face of the old concrete with cement
MASONRY. 485
before applying the patching mixture, which has acted very successfully.
So much in cases of this kind depends on the nature of the old concrete
and the personal factor of the man doing the work, as well as the mate-
rial to be used in the patching mixture, that what may be successful in one
place would not be successful in another. My experience has been that the
best material for making a patching mixture is crushed screenings, of
about the ratio of one to two. Where heavy masses are being joined to-
gether the channelling of the old mass has in most cases been sufficient to
make successful bond."
T. E. Calvert, Chief Engineer, Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Rail-
road: "The old concrete is thoroughly cleaned and wetted and about %-
in. of mortar put on. When this has set enough to become stiff the surface
is roughened with the point of a trowel and another layer of similar thick-
ness put on ; this is continued until the hole is filled, the surface being
finished flush with the old concrete.
'We have patched holes 3 and 4 in. deep and with an area of 2 or 3
sq. ft. successfully. Some of this work has stood for three years without
signs of trouble. We have not succeeded in making patches less than ij^
in. thick stick, as the mortar cracks and scales off."
G. J. Ray, Chief Engineer, Delaware, Lackazmnna & Western Rail-
road: "The only extensive job which we have had to contend with was a
concrete bridge consisting of several 33-ft. arches. The concrete in this
structure showed signs of either poor cement or acid bearing water used
in making the concrete, with the result that it scaled off in large quantities
every year. It was an easy matter to dig down into the solid concrete,
but if the solid concrete was exposed for any length of time it again would
start to deteriorate. The entire structure was repaired by covering the
same completely with from a foot to eighteen inches of reinforced con-
crete, the new concrete being bonded to the old by a large number of
dowel pins, which were drilled into the old concrete and fastened in a
substantial manner. This repair job has proved to be very satisfactory.
To make the work permanent the entire outside of the old structure was
excavated and properly waterproofed."
W. H. Courtenay, Chief Engineer, Louisville & Nashville Railroad:
"Our practice has been that when the forms are removed we patch such
surfaces where the mortar did not come out to the forms by merely
washing them clean and plastering over the defective surface with fresh
mortar. Such patches are unsightly, but they generally hold."
Fred G. Simmons, Superintendent, C. & M. of Way, Milwaukee Elec-
tric Railway: "One reason why new concrete does not adhere perfectly to
old is that in hardening the fresh concrete shrinks in volume, pulling away
from the contact sides and leaving air spaces between the two surfaces.
These spaces are small at first, but with changes of temperature, vibra-
tion, etc., gradually widen out until there is not enough adhesion between
the patch and the body of the concrete to hold the former in place. The
metal mesh firmly attached to the main mass of concrete and being part
of the patch overcomes this trouble."
/. P. Congdon, Supervising Engineer, Oregon Short Line Railroad:
"Cut off the surface of the concrete to be patched so as to remove ail
dust and laitance and give a surface of good, hard concrete. Roughen
this surface with pick or otherwise so that it will present pockets or irreg-
ularities into which the patch can key.
"Wet the surface thoroughly. Sometimes it is dusted with neat
cement, but good results have been obtained without this. Patch the
486 MASONRY.
spot with concrete or mortar, depending upon the size of the patch, of the
same consistency and mixed in the same way as the original concrete. This
will prevent difference in the contraction and expansion of the masonry
and also keeps the color uniform providing the same cement is used.
"After the concrete is well set rub the surface down with a wooden
float. The surface is usually wet with water, to which considerable ce-
ment has been added to give it the color of the concrete. Sometimes ja
cement or sand brick is used. Very good results have been obtained in
this way on our work."
C. F. Lozveth, Chief Engineer, Chicago, Mikvaukee & St. Paul
Railway: "The surface of the old concrete is first well roughened up
with track chisels to secure the removal of all old mortar surface and
any loose stones are at the same time taken out. The surface is then
thoroughly wetted to avoid any danger of the removal of any moisture
from the new concrete or mortar by capillary action. A thin wash of
neat cement of about i-i6~in. thick is then painted on the roughened sur-
face. To this is then applied a thin coat of about lA'in. of mortar made in
the same proportions as that used in the adjacent concrete. To this is
immediately applied the new concrete which is well tamped into place.
Whenever conditions are such as will permit it, small dowels are drilled
into the old concrete to serve as anchors of the old and new work.
"Where a concrete surface has pockets in it which require patching,
a mixture of mortar similar to that used in the balance of the work is em-
ployed, being mixed stiff as practicable to avoid shrinkage, and the face
of the patch worked with a wooden instead of a steel float to secure a sur-
face in harmony with the balance of the work."
Edivin F. Wendt, Assistant Engineer, Pittsburg & Lake Erie Rail-
road: "When the surface of a concrete structure fails on account of
frost having had access to it before the concrete is thoroughly set, it is a
doubtful question whether it can be resurfaced so that permanently good
results are accomplished. This is also true in cases where surfaces have
been damaged from any cause. If a small surface is to be repaired we
have obtained good results by cutting out all damaged parts and, in addi-
tion, cutting into the surface from two to four inches, and if this does not
pass reinforcing steel cut the sides of section taken out 'to an angle of
about sixty degrees to the surface, then the surface to be repaired should
be freed of all loose gravel and dust and thoroughly saturated with wa-
ter, using a hose if good pressure can be obtained. If water pressure is
not obtainable use a stiff brush and thoroughly wash the surface. Next
we apply to this rough, clean, saturated surface a neat cement grout about
the consistency of thick whitewash, using a good whitewash brush. This
should be well rubbed in, then immediately applying a mortar of one of
cement to two of good clean sand in half-inch layers, allowing each layer
to take its initial set, roughening the surface before the succeeding layer
is applied and carrying on this process until the original surface is
reached. The patched surface should be kept moist and protected from
the sun or anything adverse to good results in concrete structures, until
the patched surface has taken its final set. We have applied this method
of repairing to plain concrete, such as walls, roofs of bridges, machin-
ery foundations, sidewalks, etc., and, in one particular case of patching a
machinery foundation we found it intact after five years of use."
W. L. Darling, Chief Engineer, Northern Pacific Railway: "We have
found that wherever concrete is patched or~repaired in thin surfaces that
failure almost surely results. Wherever concrete work has disintegrated
on the surface or has become damaged, as it sometimes does by the ac-
tion of ice on concrete that has not yet thoroughly set, it has been re-
MASONRY. 487
paired by cutting out a block of sufficient dimensions then drilling dowels
into the old structure, the bond between the two being assisted by roughing
up the old concrete and cleaning with a wire brush."
Samuel Rockwell, Chief Engineer, Lake Shore & Michigan Southern
Railway: "I have attempted this at a number of different times and under
a number of different conditions, but have never had any very marked
success, especially when the patches were small. It is largely the same
problem as filling teeth, and, as with that, it is necessary to prepare a
cavity in such a way that it will assist to hold the patch. Then, if the
sides are carefully cleaned and wet, a patch can be put on that will hold
and show but little, but all attempts at plastering up shallow holes with-
out such preparation are abominations pure and simple, as is also any
attempt to wash or plaster over the general surface of concrete."
W. S. Thompson, Division Engineer, Pennsylvania Railroad: "It has
been my experience that such work is very unsatisfactory and I have
never been successful in making a good job. In case the surface scales,
it is usually better to bush-hammer the surface smooth and let it go. This
applies to surface defects."
G. J. Bell, Division Engineer, Santa Fe: "Have never made any re-
pairs that could be considered a success. We brush the loose particles
from the concrete to be repaired, then drench with clear water until thor-
oughly soaked and sprinkle a little neat cement before the mortar or con-
crete is put on. Have never made any repairs that were entirely satis-
factory."
R. B. Abbott, Division Engineer, Philadelphia & Reading Railway:
"The first thing done is to scrape or pick off thoroughly all those portions
of concrete. The damaged face is then roughened up and holes 6 in.
deep drilled therein, spaced about 2 ft. apart. The diameter of each
hole is roughly 4 in. and the outline is made irregular. Enough of the
old work is removed so that the new coat will have a minimum depth
of 1 in. Along the perimeter of the damaged surface, the concrete is
cut out to a depth of 2 in. with a slight overhang so that the old con-
crete will tend to lock in the new. The damaged surface is then brushed
with a 1:1 cement wash.
"Commencing at the extreme lowest point of the work the form is then
built up 1 ft. at a time so that each filling can be thoroughly tamped.
A mixture of one part cement to two parts fine sharp sand is used in the
actual work of restoring the surface.
"After the material has set and the form been removed, the surface
is again wetted and treated to a 1:2 cement wash. This is a refinement,
however, and is only employed where the maximum of neat finish is
required. For ordinary railroad work, we have not found it necessary
except in cases where the boards used in the forming were rough and
warped."
METHODS OF DEPOSITING CONCRETE UNDER WATER.
Pursuant to the instructions of the Board of Direction, letters and
circulars of inquiry were sent to the members of the Association, request-
ing information on the subject of "Methods of Depositing Concrete Un-
der Water." This inquiry embodied the following questions:
(1) Methods used for depositing concrete.
(2) Depth of water.
(3) Results.
488 MASONRY.
(4) Precautions necessary to secure desired results.
(5) A statement of the cost of plant and relative cost of deposit-
ing concrete per cubic yard, as compared with concrete deposited by the
usual methods, will be of value in this investigation.
Seventy-one replies were received, fifty-six of which contain in-
formation of value, covering nine methods of depositing, viz., bottom-dump
bucket, tremie (a closed chute), sacks, sacks withdrawn, paper bags,
open chutes, open depositing, pneumatic grouting of broken stone, con-
crete blocks. From an examination of the replies, the Committee draws
the following :
CONCLUSIONS.
(1) Concrete may be deposited successfully under water, if so
handled as to prevent the washing of the cement from the mixture.
(2) Cofferdams should be sufficiently tight to prevent current through
the pit, and the water in the pit should be quiet.
(3) The concrete should be deposited :n place either by means of
a drop-bottom bucket or a tremie, and should not be allowed to fall
through the water.
(4) Where a bucket is used, it should be carefully lowered to the
bottom and raised to the surface, so as to cause as little disturbance as
possible of the water.
(5) Where a tremie is used, it should be kept filled with concrete
up to the top of the water level, and the discharge end should be kept
buried in the freshly deposited mass to prevent emptying, and raised a
few inches at a time as the filling progresses.
(6) The surface of the concrete must be kept as nearly level as
possible to avoid the formation of pockets which will retain laitance and
sediment.
(7) Where concrete is not deposited continuously, all sediment
should be removed from the surface of the concrete, by pumping or other-
wise, before depositing fresh concrete.
(8) The concrete should be a 1:2 14 mixture and of a "quaking"
consistency.
(9) Freshly deposited concrete should not be disturbed.
(10) In open water, where the flow of water through the pit cannot
be prevented, concrete should be deposited in cloth sacks.
An abstract of replies containing information is presented with this
report.
ABSTRACT OF REPLIES.
Moses Burpee, Chief Engineer, Bangor & Aroostook Railway:
1 a. A box of one cubic yard capacity was used, with double leaf trap
bottom, leaves hinged on opposite edges, making bottom of box "V"
shaped at center, trap bottom tripped with tag line. The box, when filled,
was covered with canvas fastened at four corners, b. On special oc-
casions a tremie was used, but for general purposes the trap bottom box
MASONRY. 489
was preferred. 2. Any depth. My experience about 15 ft. 3a. Perfectly
satisfactory. 3b. Tremie method satisfactory. 5. Cost was not kept for
comparative purposes. It would probably exceed ordinary concreting, not
more than fifty cents per cubic yard.
F. L. Thompson, Engineer Bridges and Buildings, Illinois Central
Railroad: ia. Bottom dump buckets. The bucket was covered before
placing under water, and the concrete dumped on the bottom of founda-
tion, b. Telescope chutes extending through the water to the bottom
of foundation, c. Depositing concrete in cloth sacks. 2. From 5 to 50
ft. 3a. Good results with proper handling. I consider this the best
method, b. Good results with proper handling, c. Fair results, however
not so good as by methods (a) and (b). 4a. Bucket should be lowered
to within 2 ft. of the bottom, and then tripped, letting the contents
deposit slowly, without moving the bucket, b. A continual stream of
the concrete should be kept through the chute, the bottom of the chute
being kept within a few inches of the foundation.
/. P. Snow, Consulting Engineer: ia. Tremie. b. Bottom dump
bucket. 2. Five to 30 ft. 3. Good in all cases. Bottom dump buckets
so made that the concrete is enclosed in the bucket when the bottom opens,
gives better results on small jobs than a tremie. The cost of installing a
suitable traveler is too great on a small job to make a tremie pay. 4. To
keep the stone from separating, and to keep the outside of the work solid
with no voids, the tremie should be carried on a traveler capable of mov-
ing over any part of the work, and operations on a layer commence and
finish in the interior of the work, so that the depositing will be con-
tinuous at the sides of the work. Layers should not be over 2 ft. thick.
T. W. Fat'herson, Division Engineer, Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific
Railway: ia. Collapsible bucket with boom and hoisting engine for
heavy work. b. Funnel and tube on light work when mixing is done by
hand. 2a. Fourteen feet. b. Twelve feet. 4. Water should not be agi-
tated by pumping while concrete is being deposited, else the cement will
be washed out of the concrete.
Walter H. Norris, Bridge Engineer, Maine Central Railroad: 1.
Wooden spout about 18 in. square. 2. Fifteen feet. 3. Good. 4. Keep
the spout full of cement to exclude water and prevent wash. 5. About
50 cents per cubic yard more than by usual method.
E. H. Connor, Chief Engineer, Missouri Valley Bridge and Iron Com-
pany: 1, Bottom dump bucket. 2. Eight to 20 ft. 3. Good, hard
cement. 4. Keep depositing continuously, until all the concrete is in
position.
C. E. Smith, Superintendent, Sabine & Northern Railway: ia.
Tremie. b. Bottom dump bucket, orange peel or clam shell. 2. Twenty
feet. 3. Hard uniform texture. 4. Very rich mixture, 1 :2 :3 very wet.
/. L. Simmons, Bridge Engineer, Rock Island Lines: 1. Bottom
dump bucket. 2. About 10 ft. 3. Very satisfactory. 4. Lower the
bucket as far as possible before depositing concrete, thus preventing the
concrete from dropping through the water for any great depth.
C. H. Fake, Chief Engineer, Mississippi River & Bonne Terre Rail-
zuay: We have filled cement or other sacks with concrete, tying mouth of
sack with slip knot ; lowered it into place and pulled string to untie knot,
then withdrawn sack carefully. This serves the purpose fairly well on
490 MASONRY.
small job. b. We have used spout on larger jobs, feeding the concrete
slowly and carefully. 2. Two to 6 ft. 3. Presumed to be good. No
examination has been made, but no settlement or movement has occurred.
4. Deposit with cars and avoid haste.
/. M. Brown, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Chicago, Rock Island
& Pacific Railway: 1. Eight years ago concrete was deposited under
water, covering an area of about 40 ft. in length and 16 ft. in width. This
was in a pit excavated in sand with cofferdam about same. The depth
of the concrete was about 2 ft. It was a 1:2:4 mixture, the work being
limestone crushed to about 1^2 in. The depositing was done through a
wooden box or tube about 12 in. square and about 25 ft. in length. This
tube was suspended from a derrick, the boom of which swung over the
entire area concreted. At the bottom of the tube was a slide which was
opened after the tube was filled with concrete. The concrete was then fed
into thft 'ube continuously, while it was moved over the area. The tube
was dropped to the bottom of the water, and gradually raised as the con-
crete was deposited. 2. About 11 or 12 ft. 3. Everything that could
be desired. The concrete was deposited practically level. Water was
pumped out after the concrete had been allowed to settle for about 10
days. 4. The mixture must be homogeneous, and deposited as quickly as
possible after being mixed. Running water should be avoided.
Charles S. Churchill, Chief Engineer, Norfolk & Western Railway:
ia. Three years ago this company removed a concrete pier built in
1889 in about 20 ft. of water. This concrete was deposited in cast iron
shell in which piles had already been driven. It was deposited by means
of a telescope tube, the bottom of which was always kept close to the top
of the concrete, as it flowed out of the tube into the water contained in-
side the cast iron shell, b. More recently a bottom dump bucket has been
used, filled with concrete and lowered into place before the bottom was
opened, the bottom being opened by a diver. The amount of concrete so
placed was not great, because the object of placing it in this manner way
to seal the bottom of cofferdam. After the cofferdam was sealed, the
water was pumped out. 2a. About 25 ft. b. Thirty ft. of water. 3a.
On removal the concrete was found to be in a very fair condition, al-
though not so solid as it would have been, had it been deposited above
water level. This was due to the fact that as thoroughly tamping could
not be carried out, partly on account of being under water, and partly on
account of the piles, b. On unwatering the cofferdam, the character of
the concrete was found to be good. 4. We have found in all cases when
concrete has been deposited in sea water, and has been allowed to set
before making any additions, that there was on top surface of finished
course of concrete a thin deposit, which was evidently a precipitate of the
cement with sea water, and that it was necessary to remove this thin coat-
ing before any adhesion could be secured between any two layers of the
concrete.
G. H. Scribner, Jr., Contracting Engineer: 1. When there are piles
in the foundation, it is best to use two tubes, one being the larger, ar-
ranged so that it will slide up and down on the upper and smaller tube.
I have also put grout into gravel bottom of 3 ft. in thickness by
this same method. 2. This method can be used to a depth of 40 ft. 3.
The pier of Manchac draw span for Illinois Central Railroad was put in
in the above manner, an iron casing being used for pier with piles driven
in foundation. Good results. Grouting gravel by same method satis-
factory. 4. Tamp to prevent arching between piles. 5. Two outfits (four
tubes), a one-half yard mixer was kept running to about one-half of its
capacity.
MASONRY. 491
Hans Ibsen, Bridge Engineer, Michigan Central Railroad: ia. Tremie
consisting of 12-in. square wooden pipe handled by hand power, b. De-
posited by Lockwood Automatic concrete buckets. 2a. Tremie from
4 to 20 ft. b. Buckets 26 ft. 3b. In all cases concrete was found to
have set well at the place where it was deposited by buckets. There was
from 2 to 3 in. of soft sediment on top of hard concrete when water was
pumped out, but concrete underneath this was in good condition. 4a. In
using tremie, care must be taken to keep same full of concrete while the
work is going on and in not lifting it too far from the bottom b. Bucket
should be closed at top while being lowered through the water and care
should be exercised that it is not raised too rapidly, so that the suction
will retain the concrete in the bucket too long. 5a. The cost of deposit-
ing by tremie is probably about twice as much as by ordinary methods,
due to the fact that concrete cannot be deposited in bulk, but has to be
dumped on a platform and shoveled into the tremie. b. Depositing by
buckets should cost very little more than depositing in the dry, when work
is of such an extent as to require a plant for depositing by bucket
method.
L. B. Martin, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Illinois Traction System:
I. Dry mixture was slowly dumped by wheelbarrows into the water until
it had reached the surface of the water ; then dumping was continued
in same place and the accumulation worked down with a shovel until it
had covered the whole excavation. 2. Two to 3 ft. 3. Very good. Con-
crete set up satisfactorily in 24 hours. 4. Mixture should not be dumped
in such a manner as to separate the coarse aggregate from the cement and
sand. It should not be thrown into the water with a shovel. It is a
good idea to have the mixture very damp before it is deposited in
water, as the coarse and fine aggregate will adhere to each other better
in this way.
C. G. Delo, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Chicago Great West-
ern Railroad: 1. Bottom dump buckets were lowered to the bottom, un-
latched, and raised slowly. 2. Fifteen ft. 3. Some of the cement was
removed and found to be first-class. 4. The unlatched bucket should be
raised slowly to prevent wash. 5. Cost practically the same as when
handled by ordinary derrick and bucket.
F. S. Stevens, Engineer Maintenance of Way, Philadelphia & Reading
Railway: ia. By means of a tube in still or enclosed water, the tube being
raised slightly from time to time to allow concrete to escape from the
bottom, b. I have also known of the use of paper bags. c. I have known
of the use of burlap sacks. 2. Any depth in still water. 3a and b. Satis-
factory results, c. Fairly satisfactory, but paper-bag method is probably
better. The paper to be broken, and as much of it as possible withdrawn
after concrete has reached its bed. 4. The water must be enclosed to cut
off current, and to prevent escape of cement.
W. H. Courtenay, Chief Engineer, Louisville & Nashville Railroad:
ia. A large number of piles in sea water were protected from attack by
teredo by covering the submerged portions of piles with from 2 to 4 in.
thickness of concrete. Forms were placed around the piles and then
the concrete was deposited by pouring it through a tube. b. A bridge
pier, built many years ago, was partially undercut by the river, and an
attempt was made to fill the space vertically under the pier with con-
crete. The concrete was mixed moderately dry, and poured through an
8-in. wrought iron pipe from the track level, c. For a bridge foundation
recently constructed in 30 ft. of water, the cofferdam was first built of
steel piles. Wooden bearing piles were then driven within the cofferdam
492 MASONRY.
and cut off at the level of the river bed. The material around these
piles was then excavated to a depth of about 4 ft. with centrifugal pumps,
and then about 4 ft. of concrete deposited between heads of the piles
by running it through iron pipes, the idea being to place 4 ft. depth of
concrete around the piles before attempting to pump out the water from
within the cofferdam, for, on account of the nature of the bottom, it was
not feasible to pump the water out otherwise. 2a. Water ranged from
about 18 ft. down. 3a. Successful. At times, however, mud at the
bottom of the forms became mixed with concrete, greatly impairing the
strength of the concrete. Upon examination by diver, some of this
concrete was found to be good and some bad. 3b. During the progress
of this work, the surface of the water within the cribs was at all times
covered with a thick foamy scum. This work was constructed 20 years
ago, and has given no trouble. 3c. After this concrete had been deposited
and set, an effort was made to pump out the interior of the cofferdam,
which was not successful. Examination by a diver disclosed the fact
that the concrete in one spot of limited area was inferior in quality, and
the water pressure was such as to create a blowout through this inferior
concrete. The poor concrete was excavated by diver, and good concrete
substituted, by lowering it in bags and having it placed by a diver, after
which the water within the dam was pumped out, and the remainder of the
pier constructed. 4. Although, as a general proposition, it would seem
that concrete can be deposited under water at less cost than would be
necessary for constructing water-tight cofferdams, and pumping the
water out of the foundation before concrete is placed, the experience of
the writer leads him to believe that it is generally unsatisfactory and should
not be resorted to if foundations can be pumped out at reasonable cost.
E. I. Cantine, Contracting Engineer: 1. In 1891 it seemed impossible
to lower the water for pier foundation as part of the construction of granite
viaduct at Viaduct, Idaho, on the line of the Northern Pacific Railway.
The usual cofferdam sheet-piling construction had been followed and an
attempt was made to use the pumps to lower the water to the elevation
of bottom of foundation; this seeming impossible, the concrete was de-
posited under water by use of circular pipe. This delivered the con-
crete at desired elevation below cut-off of piles. 3, Satisfactory. Founda-
tions are standing and are in good condition. _ 4. There should be a
continuous flow of concrete to reduce to a minimum separation of con-
crete beneath the water which tends to wash cement from the mixture.
H. T. Douglas, Jr., Chief Engineer, Wheeling & Lake Erie Railway:
1. We have had no experience except with cofferdams or caissons con-
structions. One of the most fruitful sources of disaster to poor concrete
and which sometimes results in disaster to structure is the presence of
flowing water in the foundations of concrete construction, carrying away
the greater part, if not all, of the cement from the mixture. The best
results that I have seen in the use of concrete under water was to mix
the concrete, tie it up in bags and deposit these bags around on the out-
side of the foundations to give stability to the cofferdam and for the
further purpose of lessening the amount of leakage. To place concrete
in any foundation where water is in motion, in my judgment, would re-
sult, without doubt, in failure.
A. C. Everham, Assistant Chief Engineer, Kansas City Terminal
Railway: ia. At Detroit, Mich., in the construction of the Detroit River
Tunnel, there was deposited about 100,000 cu. yds. of concrete through
tremie pipes, the concrete being mixed upon a scow and poured in
tremie, the lower end of which was always kept embedded in the soft
concrete or in the mud at the bottom of the river. The concrete was
MASONRY. 493
placed around the steel tubes which formed the waterproofing of the
tunnel and was retained by cross partitions and a wooden form on the
outside of the tubes, thus forming a ''pocket" which permitted the con-
crete to set with minimum of disturbance. The mass of concrete for the
enclosed tube was about 56 ft. wide at the top, about 32 ft. deep, and, when
under water, about 40 ft. of water. On account of the pockets and lower
end of the tremie pipe always being in soft cement, there was little, if
any, disturbance of the cement in the concrete, ib. In Toledo, Ohio, last
year there was built by the C. H. & D. an ore dock of reinforced con-
crete, supported on piles, the lower y/2 ft. of which was deposited in water.
Concrete was mixed on a scow and carried by pipe from hopper to
point of deposit. The first few batches were deposited in the open water
without protection, and possibly some of the cement was lost. 3a. The
character of the concrete was ascertained as nearly as possible by taking
samples with a calyx drill and obtaining a great many cores, from which
several were selected at random and submitted to compression tests in the
crushing machine. Of four cores taken thus at random, the concrete
being a 1:3:6 mixture, there was found an average crushing strength
of 3.239 lbs., the maximum being over 4,000 lbs. In order to compare
this concrete with concrete placed under normal conditions in retaining
walls, some cores were taken from a retaining wall at Detroit with same
grade of concrete. Of four samples, the average was 2,320 lbs., as
against 3,239 lbs. of the four samples deposited by tremie. 3b. On ex-
amination this concrete was shown to be of excellent quality.
E. D. Jackson, Assistant Engineer, Baltimore & Ohio Railroad:
ia. Bottom dump buckets, lowered to a little above the surface of concrete
deposited before emptying, b. A spout of a size which can be conven-
iently raised or lowered, and the outlet moved to accommodate the dis-
charge of concrete when required. 2. Five to 15 ft. 3. Masonry piers
(concrete) in Mississippi River, which have proved successful construc-
tion, were on pile foundation; also piers in Rum River, near Anoka.
Minn., Great Northern Railway. 4. Tight cofferdams should be used, as
far as possible, to prevent any wash of current. Courses of an even thick-
ness throughout should be maintained while depositing the concrete.
Lewis Kingman, Office Engineer, National Railways of Mexico: I.
In several cases we have used No. 10 centrifugal pumps, and have low-
ered the water as much as possible, then excavated 3 or 4 ft. below the
water level. We used a 12-in. spout, with a hopper at top end. We kept
the lower end of this spout practically embedded in concrete and the
spout and hopper full of concrete. 2. Not over 4 ft. 3. O. K. 4. The
deposit of concrete should be made without allowing the water to wash the
cement out of the mixture.
H. L. Ripley, Engineer of Construction, New York, New Haven &
Hartford Railroad: 1. Bottom dump buckets, preferably cylindrical, with
height two or three times the diameter, bottom opening full size. Bucket
should be lowered until same rests on bottom, latch released and bucket
raised slowly to prevent concrete from separating. 2. Eighteen to 20 ft.
maximum rise and fall of tide ; outside of dam, 6 ft. 3. Twenty-four hours
after depositing 10 ft. of concrete, the water was pumped out and a de-
posit of laitance averaging less than Vz-'m. was removed from the top
of the concrete; after the surface was thoroughly cleaned, concreting
was continued. The percentage of laitance will depend upon the care
exercised in placing concrete. 4. Bucket should be lowered to the bot-
tom carefully before latch is released. After bucket is opened, it should
be raised slowly to deposit concrete directly on the bottom, thus pre-
venting the material from separating. Concrete should not be disturbed
494 MASONRY.
after it is deposited. 5. An ordinary ^2-yd. Ransom mixer discharged into
cylindrical buckets set on a lower platform ; a derrick handled the buckets,
which were unlatched by a jerk line. Cost no more than lowering concrete
into ordinary open forms of equal depth.
Frank H. Alfred, General Superintendent, Cincinnati, Hamilton &
Dayton Railway: 1. We have used a spout of 10-in. metal pipe, having
at its top a hopper large enough to hold a batch. This spout and hopper
we handled with a derrick, the hopper being filled. We raised the spout
and hopper a small amount until the concrete ran out of the hopper, and
not out of the spout proper, which was always kept filled with concrete.
2. Three to 20 ft. 3. A very good quality of concrete. 4 A rich mix-
ture, about 1:2:4, should be used, and thoroughly mixed. Apparatus
should be carefully manipulated to prevent concrete from running out of
spout. Mixture should be rather stiff, and deposited in two layers.
Care should be used alongside of forms ; worked best from form toward
center. Forms must be tight to prevent current.
E. B. Temple, Assistant Chief Engineer, Pennsylvania Railroad: 1.
Last year there was successfully constructed a truss bridge across the
Schuylkill River in connection with the Philadelphia Terminal improve-
ments, where was deposited concrete under water for four piers of the
bridge. The method pursued was as follows : A cofferdam of 12 in. by 12 in.
timbers was built near the shore and sunk at low tide on the site of the
pier. All possible excavating was done with a dredge previous to sink-
ing the dam, and the rock foundation was cleaned as thoroughly as
could be done by dredging. After the box, which, of course, was open
at the bottom, was placed, a suction hose was used to remove material
that could not be taken out by the dredge, or that drifted into the tide
during the setting of the box. The bottom was also carefully examined
by divers. Concrete was then deposited by means of a bottom dump
bucket, with a cover on top. The bucket was lowered carefully to
within 2 ft. of the bottom, and after resting a moment the bottom was
released and the concrete gradually settled into place. The top of the con-
crete was kept as level as possible by having the buckets dumped uni-
formly over the entire surface. This concrete was carried up to within
2 ft. of low water and allowed to set for at least a week before the cut-
stone piers were started, ib. A bridge was constructed, in 1902, over the
Schuylkill River in about the same depth of water as the one above referred
to, by the usual method of pumping out the dam, so that the concrete
could be deposited in the open air all the way down to the rock. Sev-
eral months were consumed in the attempt, and finally from about 6 to 8
ft. of the foundation had to be constructed under water, as it was im-
possible to keep the dam tight at the bottom and pump out all of the
water. 2. The water in the deepest pier was 40 ft., and no trouble
whatever was experienced in this method of construction. 5. The cost of
a plant for depositing the concrete in this way would practically be the
same as for depositing it in the open air. The stone and sand were
brought to the site on scows, and the concrete mixer and derricks
were also on floating equipment. With such a plant, and following the
usual method of pumping out the cofferdams before depositing the con-
crete under water, the cost would be about $25 per cu. yd. By de-
positing the concrete, as done in this case, the cost averaged about $21
per cu. yd. These, apparently, high prices include excavation or dredging,
cofferdams and all cost in connection with the operation.
R. N. Begien, Assistant to General Manager, Baltimore & Ohio
Railroad: ia. In still water less than 12 ft., after solid foundation is
secured and made level, concrete should be mixed 2 sand and 4 stone,
MASONRY. 495
stiff enough to bear a man immediately after being mixed. This should
then be lowered to the bottom of water in round drop-bottom buckets,
holding from one-half to three-quarters of a cubic yard. The concrete so
placed should be kept reasonably level over the entire surface. If the water
is of greater depth than 12 ft, a diver should be employed. After concrete
is deposited, it should not be disturbed any more than possible, b. Con-
crete to be deposited under running water should be placed in cloth
sacks filled two-thirds full and sewed at the extreme top, and lowered
in drop-bottom bucket or scale box. By using care a good level and solid
mass can be obtained, and foundation put in any reasonable depth of
water. 3. We have known of concrete to be put in in this way, and have
never heard of any failure. 4. Careful workmanship, absolutely no haste,
thorough supervision of each man, as well as using the best of materials.
The work should be carried on as continuously as possible. 5. The same
plant necessary for putting in cofferdam work, where water has been
pumped out, will install concrete in water. In my opinion, such a plant
would cost approximately $2,000. Where concrete can be put in founda-
tion for $6 per cu. yd., it would cost in still water about $7.50 per CU- yd.
In running water, where cloth sacks are used, the cost would be about
$9.50 per cu. yd.
F. W. Gilcreast, Chief Engineer, Lehigh & Nezv England Railway:
1. All pumping of water should be stopped and concrete deposited by
means of a spout, the bottom of which being 2 or 3 in. above the level
of the concrete and moved about slowly. Care should be taken to keep
the spout full of concrete. 2. Ten to 15 ft. 3. Good. 4. Foundation
must be enclosed to stop all flow of water Concrete should be mixed as
dry as possible and spread evenly over foundation in layers about 6 in.
at a time.
W. C. Smith, Chief Engineer of Maintenance of Way, Northern
Pacific Railway: 1. Bottom dump bucket of 2-yd. capacity, no top
cover. A tremie in some cases. Usually deposited in a crib sunk by open
excavation or for sealing the bottom of a cofferdam where character of
bottom is such that dam cannot be pumped out. 2. Thirty to 45 ft. 3.
Satisfactory in all instances observed. In all cases where cribs have been
pumped out after footing has been deposited through the water, concrete
has been found to be sound and as well set up as material deposited in
open air. 4. Concrete should be deposited continuously and carried in
even layers across the bottom of the excavation in order to prevent the
formation of pockets of laitance. It is very important that there be no
interruption in depositing concrete through the water after same has once
been begun. Cribs or cofferdams must be tight and no flow of enclosed
water permitted. Bucket must be down on same mass when dumped,
and care used in withdrawing bucket to prevent lifting and dropping the
load through the water. 5. It is but little more expensive to deposit
concrete through the water by means of a bucket than to deposit with a
bucket in open excavation.
George H. Bremner, Engineer, Illinois District, Chicago, Burlington
& Quincy Railroad: 1. Caissons filled with dry mixture of concrete
and water. Bottom dump buckets, lowered windlass, were used for de-
positing. 2. About 50 ft. 3. Water was pumped out the following day and
concrete was in good condition.
Joseph 0. Osgood, Chief Engineer, Central Railroad of Nezv Jersey:
ia. In long, narrow walls the operation has been commenced at one end
and concrete deposited in bottom dump buckets until the concrete showed
above the level of the water, from which point an ordinary bucket
496 MASONRY.
was used and the concrete deposited on top of portion showing above
water, gradually forcing the concrete below water toward opposite end
from which the operation was commenced. The level of the concrete
was kept nearly on a plane with the level of the water, by which means the
setting of the concrete was slow, and the mass was forced gradually for-
ward without having the concrete roll down the side. The water beyond
the concrete remained clear during the whole of the operation, b. Bottom
dump bucket, with lid or cover over the top. 2a. Three to ten feet. The
operation was commenced at the 3-ft. end. b. About 10 ft. 3. Very good
4. The flow of the water must be cut off in such a way that there will be
no current in the area in which the wall is to be constructed, b. Bucket
must be so constructed that there will be no rush of water through it
and the concrete while being lowered. 5. Cost nc greater than for de-
positing by usual methods above water. Building dam to cut off the cur-
rent is an added expense.
John D. Isaacs, Consulting Engineer, Harriman Lines: la. Bottom
dump bucket lowered slowly through the water and dumped when rest-
ing on the bottom, b. Tremie, handled by means of a winch, derrick or
chain hoist, and moved to any desired position by means of a trolley
way. c. Concrete blocks, molded and permitted to become thoroughly set
in open air. 2a. Twenty-two to 55 ft. b. Six to 135 ft. 3a. Good in all
cases. Probably better results can be attained by this method than by
the use of a tremie. In one instance work was discontinued for several
months, and the surface of the concrete in the form at this time being
about 8 ft. below the surface of the water. Examination showed that the
upper surface of the concrete had taken a very hard permanent set,
and that the character thereof was fully as good as concrete placed above
water. In the structure herein referred to, about 4,000 cu. yds. of concrete,
included in piers below water, was handled bv method above described,
b. Generally good, but in cases of deep foundations where tremie had to
be lifted to clear bracing of cofferdam and tops of piles, it is possible
that the results are not so good as though the operation were carried on
continuously, since the charge in the tremie drops and the recharging
has to be done through the water in the tube. c. Good. This method is
especially adapted to locations where it is impossible to avoid current
in the water. 4. There should be practically no current in the water.
Bottom dump method. The bucket should rest upon the foundation before
the concrete is dumped. Bucket should be raised and lowered so as to
cause least disturbance of water possible. Tremie method. The con-
crete should be permitted to run out at the discharge end as fast as it is
deposited in hopper end. Concrete should be distributed in as even layers
as possible. Laitance or other inert materials which may have accumu-
lated by reason of discontinuance of operations should be cleaned off be-
fore additional concrete is deposited. The amount of cement in the mix-
ture should be slightly over that used for depositing the dry in order to
offset any loss which may occur by wash. 5. The relative cost depends
much upon the depth of water through which the concrete is deposited.
Cost data kept for constructive work on the Oregon-Washington Rail-
road & Navigation Company indicate a cost of approximately $t.oo per
cu. yd. for depositing with bottom-dump bucket when it would cost 75
cents per cu. yd. in the dry. Under similar conditions the cost with the
tremie was about $1.40 per cu. yd.
R. Budd, Chief Engineer, Spokane, Portland & Seattle Railway: ia.
Bottom-dump bucket, having single leaf, about 34-yd. capacity b. Tremie
consisting of steel pipe of about 24 in. diameter choked down to 12 in. at
lower end. c. Two wooden tremies of same diameter throughout entire
length. 2a. Six ft. b. Fifteen ft. c. Twelve ft. 3a. Successful, b. As
MASONRY. 497
concrete would not flow freely, bottom-dump bucket was substituted, c.
Successful. Charges were very seldom lost, and when this did happen,
an extra quantity of cement was used in refilling the tube. 4a. Bucket
should be of large capacity, and should be handled slowly under water
Bucket should rest on bottom before it is dumped. Bottom constructed
with two leaves is better than with one, as it causes less disturbance of
the water, c. Tremies should be handled very slowly to avoid disturb-
ance of the water. Avoid losing charge. Tube should be of same diameter
throughout, and it is well to have hopper at upper end.
M. J. Caples, Vice-President, Chesapeake & Ohio Railway: 1. Con-
crete was placed in loosely woven gunny sacks and dropped through the
water into position. The concrete in bags was leveled with long poles
as the work began. 2. Six ft. 3. This work was done twenty-one years ago,
when concrete was used much less than it is to-dav. The object in view in
depositing this concrete was to even up the foundation for a bridge abut-
ment. The foundation was limestone rock, as I recall it, about 50 cu. yds.
of concrete being used in this way. The abutment built upon this founda-
tion is still in excellent condition.
F. L. Wheaton, Engineer of Construction, Delaware, Lackaivanna &
Western Railroad: ia. Bottom-dump bucket with lid, first landed on
bottom of foundation, after the water had become still, was carefully
raised, leaving the concrete upon the bottom, b. Movable chute. Chute
should be filled with concrete to a point above the water line, raised
and moved with a derrick, allowing concrete to flow out the bottom as
fast as it is deposited on top. 3. Very satisfactory. 4. The concrete
should be mixed much drier for use under water than for use above,
as in this way there is less danger of the cement washing out of the
aggregate. 5a and b. The cost of depositing concrete by these methods
is only slightly more than if water were pumped out.
Lincoln Bush, Consulting Engineer: 1. I have used steel buckets
for this purpose, with opening at the bottom. The buckets were lowered
to full depth before the concrete was deposited. 2. About 15 ft. 3.
Very satisfactory. 4. Buckets should be tight, to prevent flow of water
through the concrete in lowering, lowered full depth before concrete is
deposited. Before the day's work is started, the inert deposit on top of
concrete which has accumulated from previous day's work should be
pumped off. This can be done by lowering suction pipe down on the
concrete, and moving the suction about over entire area, the concrete
of previous day's work having set sufficiently to prevent the removal
of the cement by pumping.
A. J. Himes, Engineer Grade Elimination, New York, Chicago &
St. Louis Railroad: ia. Concerning the deposition of concrete under
water, my experience has been confined to comparatively shallow depths.
I have used a rough wooden box as a substitute for a tremie. b. I
have permitted concrete to slide gently into the water through chutes,
first forming a pile of concrete in form of cone, and permitting it to
raise to the surface of the water, then, as further concrete is deposited,
the mass is permitted to extend horizontally under its own weight. This
method gives very good results, c. I have placed concrete under water
in gunny sacks. The use of the sacks was, of course, a simple device to
prevent the washing of the concrete, d. I have inspected the deposition
of concrete 50 ft. below water surface under compressed air, where air
pressure was allowed to decrease as the surface of concrete rose, so that
the water surface was maintained at approximately the surface of the
concrete. 2a and b. Comparatively shallow, d. Eighty feet. 3a. Very
good results, b. Very good results, d. Wholly successful for depths
498 MASONRY.
as great as 80 ft. 4. The concrete should be mixed rather wet, and
all agitation thereof should be avoided after it has been placed in the
water. Workmen generally seem determined to stir up the concrete
and shovel it around beneath the water, and it is oftentimes hard to
overcome this disposition. The only precaution necessary is to insure
that the surging or washing of the water does not wash the cement
from the aggregate. Any method which will prevent this condition will
be successful, in so far as the proper hardening and durability of the
concrete is concerned.
*Job Tutliill, Assistant Engineer, Kansas City Terminal Railway:
ia. Filled 8 ft. in bottom of a circular sheet pile crib with a cubical
box having bottom in halves, hinged to the sides. Box closed and
handled with load by one rope, and placed where concrete was
wanted, then box dumped by second rope similar to the way orange peel
buckets are handled, and pulled in. 2. Fourteen feet. 3. Very satis-
factory. The concrete was nearly level and spread out against sides of
crib when pumped out. 4. Handle carefully. After the steel tubes
forming the river section of the La Salle Street Tunnel under Chicago
River, Chicago, 111., had been sunk in place, it was necessary to con-
struct a cofferdam at each end of the tubes, behind which the water
could be pumped out, permitting connections to be made to the land sec-
tions. At each end of the river section there was a timber crib 11 ft.
wide, securely fastened to the tubes and reaching 3 ft. above the surface
of the river. From the ends of these cribs pockets, approximately
i7z/2 ft. square, were formed by driving Friestedt steel sheeting of from
50 to 65 ft. in length. Within these pockets the depth of water ranged
from 45 to 53 ft. On account of this extreme depth, it was not deemed
advisable to fill the pockets entirely with clay, but to fill the bottom with
concrete to a depth below water level of about 37 ft., and in the same
operation fill the space between the shell of the tubes and the bottom
of the excavation. Reference to the accompanying sketch will give a
clear idea of the construction of the cribs, pockets, etc. An attempt was
made to deposit concrete by the tremie method, by use of a 12-in. diameter
pipe and permitting the concrete to spread from the bottom end _ of the
pipe. This method did not prove successful on account of the difficulty
of keeping tremie full of concrete, and the difficulty of manipulating the
same in this depth of water. An examination by diver indicated a con-
siderable segregation of the sand and stone to the extent that this method
was abandoned.
The following method was then determined upon: Gas pipes, ilA in.
diameter, were bent to the radius of the tunnel tubes and placed so that they
would discharge at varying distances underneath the tubes. Four of these
pipes were placed in each pocket and rigidly fastened in position by sub-
marine divers. As indicated on accompanying sketch, these pipes did not
have well points attached to the ends. In addition to the bent pipes,
each pocket contained twelve to fifteen 2-in. diameter pipes, equipped with
well points, stripped of the netting, at bottom ends, and placed so as to
be about 2 ft. above the bottom of the excavation. The top end of all
pipes was threaded for attachment to the grouting machine. About 5 ft.
of broken stone was then spread over the bottom of the pocket and grout
under a pressure varying from 35 to 100 lbs. per sq. in. was then forced
through the pipes to fill the voids in the layer of stone.
In general, the grout consisted of a mixture of about five bags of
cement to one barrow of torpedo sand. All lumps, gravel, etc., which
would clog the well points, were removed from the cement and sand
before mixing. The grout was thoroughly mixed before being put into
the McMichael's compressed air mixer. After placing the bottom course
as above, a second set of pipes and another layer of broken stone were
♦Acknowledgment is made of valuable information furnished by the
engineers of the La Salle Street Tunnel, Chicago, for use in this abstract.
MASONRY. 499
placed and grouted as before. This process was continued until the de-
sired height of concrete was obtained. This method made use of quite a
large number of pipes, as it was impossible to remove them after the
grouting was complete. The method used in the south cofferdam was
similar to that used in the north, except that in the main section of the
pockets, only one set of pipes was used. After these had been put in
position, the whole volume of broken stone was deposited. Grout was
then forced through the pipes, and as the grouting continued, the pipes
were worked up and down through the mass of stone until the voids
were filled. This method appeared to be as successful as that used in
the north dam, although about three hundred bags less of cement were
used. During the operation of grouting, whenever the grout was flowing
freely into the voids, the pressure was from 40 to 50 lbs. per sq. in.,
but when the voids were practically filled, this pressure became 90 to 100
lbs. The operation at all times continued until no more grout could be
forced into the pipes. After the concrete had sufficiently set, the remain-
ing volume of the pockets was filled with clay; the north dam proved in all
respects securely watertight, leaks were slight, and the water apparently
flowed along the line of separation between the clay and the concrete. In
the south dam, one bad leak developed, the water apparently coming from
the river underneath the concrete.
John R. Leighty, Engineer Maintenance, Missouri Pacific Railway:
1. Wood forms were made from 3x6 piers and set on solid rock bot-
tom of river ; concrete lowered into form in steel buckets with swing-
ing drop bottom ; bottom unlatched and bucket lifted, allowing concrete
to drop to bottom of form. 2. Two to six feet. 3. Three small piers
were built up to about 1 ft. above surface of water, and false work
was placed upon them to carry the ends of the two double-track spans,
175 ft. each, under traffic of one hundred trains per day. After use of
about three months, they were abandoned. They did the work without
any trouble. 4. The forms were built of rough lumber and were not
water tight. Buckets were lifted carefully, so as to agitate water as
little as possible.
1
J. R. IV. Ambrose, Engineer Grade Separation, Grand Trunk Ry.
System: r. Box chute with funnel arrangement on top. 2. Six to
10 ft. 3. Good where water remains quiet. 4. Box must be filled
and kept filled.
C. D. Purdoii, Chief Engineer, St. Louis & Southwestern Railway:
ia. Tremie. b. Bottom-dump bucket. 3. Appear to have been satis-
factory, as no trouble has been experienced with any of the foundation
so deposited. 4a. Tremie should be kept full and deposit made in small
quantities, b. ' Bucket should touch bottom before it is opened, so that
the concrete may pass through as little water as possible.
W. A. Clark, Chief Engineer, Duluth & Iron Range Railroad: l.
About 6,000 cu. yds. were deposited by means of bottom-dump bucket
in ore dock foundation. Trial with tremie in this case did not seem to
secure equally as good results. 2. Four and one-half feet. 3. Drill
cores were not secured, so that results were not absolutely known, but
samples deposited in same way and afterwards removed and examined,
showed very little separation. 4. Bucket should have large discharge
opening and have canvas cover, to decrease washing and consequent
separation. In this case water was at a temperature of 32 degrees and 28
degrees Fahrenheit, and so retarded the setting of the cement that there
was danger of slight wave action causing separation, so it was thought
necessary to heat the water with a steam jet to a temperature of 45 to
50 degrees.
500
502 MASONRY.
George W. Boschkc, Chief Engineer, Oregon-Washington Railroad
& Navigation Company: i. Bottom dump bucket with single line. 2.
From no to 135 ft. 3. First-class. 4. The material should be distributed
evenly and buckets covered before reaching bottom, which can be done
by using single line. This arrangement is patented by George T. Forsyth,
Portland, Oregon. 5. Derricks were used, the same as those used on
shore. The only difference in cost of plant is additional length of cables
and additional time necessary for lowering to greater depth.
Robert Armour, M'asonry Engineer, Grand Trunk Railway System:
ia. Tremie or spout, b. Bottom-dump bucket. Both have been used
to a limited extent only ; both good. Bottom-dump bucket generally
preferable_ as being more easily handled. Bucket should be of largest
size practicable, and have cover. 2. Five to 8 ft. 3. There has been
no subsequent examination by diver or unwatering, but concrete set well,
and there is no failure to report. Either method is, without doubt, satis-
factory, if used with care. 4. A slow, regular movement of tremie, with
bottom raised just enough to allow concrete to flow out. b. Bucket
should be discharged when it is close to bottom. Rich concrete should
be used, thoroughly mixed, of "quaking" consistency. Materials should
not be used dry, as air in voids when displaced by water carries
cement with it. Disturb it as little as possible after placing it.
REPORT ON WORK OF JOINT COMMITTEE ON CONCRETE
AND REINFORCED CONCRETE.
The Joint Committee on Concrete and Reinforced Concrete held a
meeting at Atlantic City, June 30, 191 1, at which time the work of the
Committee was gone over and the previous record carefully studied, with
the view of putting it in shape for final report.
The work of revising the report was allotted to a number of sub-
committees. Although these committees have reported back and the data
put in shape to again present to the Committee as a whole, the meeting
has not been called for ratification of the report ; therefore, your Com-
mittee can only present a progress report, believing that the work of the
Joint Committee on Concrete and Reinforced Concrete will be finished
sometime during the present year.
UNIFICATION OF PORTLAND CEMENT SPECIFICATIONS.
(Specifications for Natural Cement were not considered.)
Early in the year 1911 two Government Boards or Committees were
appointed to deal with the question of Cement Specifications. One of
these, appointed by the Chief Engineer of the United States Army, was
instructed to revise Professional Papers No. 28 ; the other was made up of
representatives from the various departments, appointed by the head of
each department. This Committee was instructed to prepare and report
to the departments a single Standard Specification for the Government.
This body was known as "The Departmental Committee for the Unifica-
tion of Government Specifications for Portland Cement."
On September 12 the Army Board held a meeting at which repre-
sentatives from the various engineering bodies interested in cement sped-
MASONRY. 503
cations, from the Association of American Portland Cement Manufacturers
and representatives from one or two commercial laboratories, were in
attendance. At this meeting the Army Board received suggestions for
the revision of Professional Papers No. 28.
Following this meeting the Departmental Committee issued a tentative
specification, which was sent out with request for criticism and suggestion.
On November 24 a meeting was held at Washington which was at-
tended by representatives from the Departmental Committee, the Army
Board and the American Railway Engineering Association. Committee
C-i, American Society for Testing Materials, and Committee on Uniform
Tests for Cement, American Society of Civil Engineers, were not repre-
sented, though they had previously accepted the invitation to be present.
It was apparent that the tendency of the Departmental Committee was to
adhere quite closely to the standard adopted by the American Society
for Testing Materials, which is also the standard of this Association.
On November 27 a meeting was held in Philadelphia, attended by
representatives from the Committee on Uniform Tests for Cement, Ameri-
can Society of Civil Engineers, Standard Specifications for Portland Ce-
ment (C-i), American Society for Testing Materials, and through its
membership on Committee C-i this Association was represented. The
Association of American Portland Cement Manufacturers and the Depart-
mental Committee were also represented. The principal question before
this meeting was that of Uniform Methods, and an agreement was reached
on every point excepting the use of the Vicat Needle vs. Gilmore Needle
in determining time of set, and Vicat Needle vs. Ball Test in determining
normal consistency.
On January 8, 1912, representatives from the Departmental Committee
and Committee on Uniform Tests for Cement of the American Society of
Civil Engineers met with the Army Board to further consider the points
of difference in the respective specifications. Agreement had been reached
upon all points excepting those previously mentioned, and at this meeting
the representatives of the American Society of Civil Engineers expressed
preference for retaining the Vicat Needle, but offered to compromise and
accept the Ball Method as the means of determining normal consistency
if the Government representatives would accept the Vicat Needle as the
method of determining the time of set.
After due consideration the Government representatives were con-
vinced that the Gilmore Needle should be retained in their specifications ;
also, that the Ball Test for determining normal consistency is preferable
to the Vicat Needle, and a specification which agrees with the standard of
this Association in other particulars was approved by the Departmental
Committee and the Board of Engineer Officers and recommended for
adoption as a United States Government Standard Specification for
Portland Cement.
The Committee on Uniform Tests for Cement, upon making their re-
port to the American Society of Civil Engineers in January, stated that
they had been unable to get together with the Army Board and the De-
partmental Committee on Methods of Tests, and, considering their work
504 MASONRY.
finished, asked to be dismissed. The Committee was accordingly relieved
from further duty.
CONCLUSIONS.
Your Committee recommends the adoption of the following con-
clusions :
(i) That the conclusions in reference to Miethods of Patching and
Repairing Plain and Reinforced Concrete be approved as good practice.
(2) That the conclusions in reference to Methods of Depositing
Concrete Under Water be approved as good practice.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON MASONRY.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XI— ON RECORDS AND
ACCOUNTS.
H. J. Pfeifer, Chairman; M. C. Byers, Vice -Chairman;
J. M. Brown. Guy Scott.
Edw. Gray. W. A. Christian.
E. E. Hanna. G. J. Graves.
Henry Lehn. C. W. Cochran.
J. H. Milburn. G. T. Warren.
C. W. Pifer. H. Stephens.
Committee.
To the Members of American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Records and Accounts respectfully submits here-
with its report :
The Board of Direction assigned the following work to your Commit-
tee for the current year :
(i) Make a comprehensive study of the forms in the Manual which
were adopted a number of years ago.
(2) Study the economical way of managing a storehouse so as to
assure a minimum stock of materials at all times.
(3) Make concise recommendations for next year's work.
The following Sub-Committees were appointed :
Sub-Committee A — Study of Forms in Manual: C. W. Cochran,
Henry Lehn, J. H. Milburn, Guy Scott, H. Stephens, G. T. Warren.
Sub-Committee B — Economical Storehouse Management: J. M.
Brown, W. A. Christian, G. J. Graves, Edw. Gray, E. E. Hanna, C. W.
Pifer.
EXPLANATORY STATEMENT.
Two meetings were held during the year ; one of Sub-Committee B at
St. Louis on October 23, 191 1, attended by Messrs. Brown, Byers and
Pfeifer, and another of the entire Committee at Chicago on November 28,
191 1, attended by Messrs. Byers, Brown, Christian, Graves, Milburn and
Pfeifer.
The Committee devoted by far the greatest part of its time to sub-
ject (2), the first point discussed relating to the scope of the instructions
as follows : Should the internal economy of the storehouse be solely con-
sidered, or should the effects of storehouse management on the broader
economies of maintenance and operation be also taken into consideration.
As the first involves a storekeeping rather than a maintenance or operating
problem, the Committee decided to base its investigation and report on the
second interpretation.
505
506 RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS.
Material and labor are required in the construction, maintenance and
operation of railroads ; and since it is impossible to secure materials when,
and in the quantities required, by direct purchase, a reserve stock is ac-
cumulated which is drawn upon to meet the demands as they arise.
The following figures are taken from the report of the Interstate
Commerce Commission for the year ending June 30, 1909:
Operating expenses of the railroads of the United States for the year
ending June 30, 1909, amounted to $1,599,443,410 (p. 75).
Machinists, carpenters, other shopmen, section foremen, other track-
men, other employes and laborers, whose efficiency depends to a great
extent on their having proper materials and tools, received in wages
$466,138,215, or about 29 per cent. (p. 46) of the entire operating expenses.
The general balance sheet for the same period gives the value of ma-
terials and supplies on hand at $206,849,619 (p. 82). Five per cent, per
annum on this sum is $10,342,481, about 2.2 per cent, of what was paid
during the year to the classes of employes above mentioned
Assuming that it is possible to reduce the stock on hand to the ex-
tent of 50 per cent, the saving per annum would be only 1.1 per cent, of
the amount paid annually in wages to the above mentioned employes, so
that even a slight loss in their efficiency through failure to secure materials
and tools as required, will soon absorb much more than the amount saved
by reduced investment in stock. It would seem, therefore, that the most
important function of a storehouse is the prompt delivery of materials and
tools so that delays to labor resulting from their lack may be reduced to
a minimum.
CONCLUSIONS.
It is recommended —
(1) That no changes be made in the forms appearing in the Manual.
(2) That the following statement embodies the general principles
governing the economical management of a railway storehouse :
REASONS FOR MAINTAINING A STOREHOUSE.
The object of a storehouse is to provide material and tools when re-
quired so that the cost of work may be a minimum, bearing in mind the
factors of deiay to work or labor, also interest on investment in stock.
The following essential elements enter into the problem :
(a) Standardization. — The standardization of materials and instruc-
tions in regard to their use will reduce to a minimum the number of items
of material of the various classes which should be carried in stock. The
amount of each item which should be carried in stock will depend upon
the rate of consumption, time required for the purchase and delivery of
material, and also upon local conditions.
(b) Classification of Material. — This is necessary so as to reduce
to a minimum the cost and time of handling. An approved classification
should be followed in making requisitions.
(c) Stock Account. — An account should be kept of stock showing
at all times a record of receipts, disbursements and amount on hand.
RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS. 507
Stock should be replenished when the amount of any item has been re-
duced to a fixed minimum. Inventories should be made at stated periods.
A proper stock account furnishes a check on excessive supply and obsolete
material.
(d) Distribution. — When material is shipped, notice should be sent
to consignee showing partial or complete filling of requisition and if par-
tial, when final shipment may be expected.
(e) Organization.— The storekeeper's place in the general organiza-
tion should be so fixed and adjusted that the measure of his efficiency is
primarily, the promptness and accuracy with which he fills requisitions, and,
secondly, his ability to hold down the stock investment to the lowest
amount consistent with the first requirement.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XVI— ON ELECTRICITY.
George W. Kittredge, Chairman; J. B. Austin, Jr., Vice-Chair man;
R. D. Coombs. C. E. Lindsay.
A. O. Cunningham. W. S. Murray.
L. C. Fritch. J. R. Savage.
George Gibes. W. I. Trench.
G. A. Harwood. H. U. Wallace.
E. B. Katte. Committee.
To the Members of the American Raihvay Engineering Association:
Your Committee presents herewith its second annual report, its first
annual report appearing in Vol. 12, Part 1, of the Proceedings of the
Association for the year 191 1, which report contains the History and
Bibliography.
The Association directed that the outline of Committee work for the
year 191 1 be as follows:
(1) Continue the consideration of the subject of Clearances.
(2) Continue the preparation of Standard Specifications for Over-
head Transmission Line Crossings.
(3) Report on effect of electrolytic action on metallic structures and
best means of preventing it.
(4) Method of insulation and protection.
In accordance with the instructions of the Board of Direction, that
two subjects would be the maximum for the action of the convention, your
Committee has confined itself to the following subjects:
(1) Clearances.
(2) Transmission Lines and Crossings.
Two meetings have been held in New York, one on August 7, 191 1,
at which were present Messrs. Kittredge, Coombs, H. A. Currie (repre-
senting Mr. Katte), Harwood, Lindsay and Savage, and at New York on
January 29, 1912, at which were present Messrs. Kittredge, Austin, Coombs,
Fritch, Gibbs, Harwood, Katte. Lindsay and Trench.
The balance of the work of the Committee has been done by corre-
spondence and by the chairmen of the Sub-Ccmmittees on "Clearances''
and "Transmission Lines and Crossings," Messrs. Harwood and Coombs,
respectively.
509
510 ELECTRICITY.
CLEARANCES.
At the last meeting of the Association at which our report was con-
sidered it was decided that in view of the fact that the American Railway
Association had a Committee on Clearance Lines and the American Elec-
tric Railway Engineering Association also had a Committee on Clearance
Lines, and because of the fact that the Committee on Electricity had not
been able for various and sundry reasons to reach conclusions with them
and agree upon lines satisfactory to all concerned, to accept the report on
clearance as one of progress only, with the idea of prior to the next meet-
ing agreeing with the other associations mentioned upon lines that would
be satisfactory to all.
The chairman of the Sub-Committee on Clearances has subsequently
been in communication with representatives of the committees of the other
two associations mentioned with the result that the diagram "A," shown
on page 525, is now submitted as the recommended clearance lines for
equipment and permanent way structures adjacent to third rail and for
third rail structures.
It is believed that similar diagrams will be recommended to the
American Railway Association by the Committee on Electric Working and
by the Committee considering the subject of Clearance of the American
Electric Railway Engineering Association.
Diagrams have been obtained from all the principal railwavs in the
United States using third rail showing outlines of their third rail struc-
tures and from some of the principal steam railroads diagrams showing
outlines of maximum equipment. These various diagrams are made a
part of this report and were used as a basis in establishing clearance lines
for third rail structures, permanent way structures adjacent to third rail
and equipment.
On page 524 there also appears a table showing "Data regarding
Third Rail Clearances," which is made a part of this report and which has
been prepared from information recently received from various companies
with a view of ascertaining what proportion of track mileage, of roads
using both steam and electricity, will clear the recommended clearance
lines.
From an inspection of this table it will be noted that out of a total
mileage of 1,988.04 using steam and electricity, 9"3-8o miles will clear. It
will also be noted that the mileage not. clearing is mainly interurban elec-
tric roads which handle steam equipment as secondary traffic and ele-
vated roads in cities which do not handle steam equipment.
At the last meeting of the Association the definition for "Third Rail
Gage" as follows was adopted :
"Distance, measured parallel to plane of top of both running rails,
between gage of running rail and center line of third rail."
It is now proposed changing the definition to read as follows:
"Third Rail Gage. — Distance measured parallel to plane of top of both
running rails between gage of nearest running rail and inside gage line of
third rail."
ELECTRICITY. 511
TRANSMISSION LINES AND CROSSINGS.
The Sub-Committee Chairman, Mr. Coombs, has been working in
conjunction with Committees of the National Electric Light Association,
American Institute of Electrical Engineers, American Electric Railway
Association, Association of Railway Telegraph Superintendents, and rep-
resentatives of the telephone and telegraph companies, in connection with
the preparation of specifications for overhead crossings of electric light
and power lines, and the following specification is submitted which is
identical with the specific tions that have been adopted by the other asso-
ciations mentioned, excepting in paragraphs Nos. 10, 13, 18, 24, 29, 31, 32,
34, 45, 49, 51, 55, 60 and 61, which changes it will be noted by comparing
the specifications are in line with more clearly expressing the condition
or of making them more satisfactory from the point of view cf the rail-
roads.
For the convenience of the members the paragraphs mentioned are
given as Appendix "B" to this report in the form in which they have been
adopted by the other associations mentioned above.
RECOMMENDATIONS.
(A) The Committee recommends for adoption by the Association:
(1) Definition: "Third Rail Gage. — Distance measured parallel to
plane of top of both running rails between gage of nearest running rail
and inside gage line of third rail."
(2) The lines shown on diagram "A" as equipment clearance lines.
(3) The lines shown on diagram "A" as permanent way structure
adjacent to third rail clearance lines.
(4) The lines shown on diagram "A" as third rail structure clear-
ance lines.
(5) The adoption of the Specifications for Overhead Crossings of
Electric Light and Power Lines.
(B) The Committee recommends a continuation of work already out-
lined, particularly consideration of clearance for overhead third rail work-
ing conductors, electrolysis and insulation and the consideration of any new
information that may develop in reference to maintenance organization and
relation of track structures, and asks for such other direction or instruc-
tions as seem necessary or desirable.
Respectfully submitted for the Committee,
George W. Kittredge,
Chairman.
Appendix A.
*SPECIFICATIONS FOR OVERHEAD CROSSINGS OF ELECTRIC
LIGHT AND POWER LINES.
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS.
Scope.
1. These specifications shall apply to overhead electric light and
power line crossings (except trolley contact wires), over railroad right-of-
way, tracks, or lines of wires ; and, further, these specifications shall apply
to overhead electric light and power wires of over 5,oco volts constant
potential, crossing, or constructed over telephone, telegraph or other similar
lines.
Location.
2. The poles, or towers, supporting the crossing span preferably shall
be outside the railroad company's right-of-way.
3. Unusually long crossing spans shall be avoided wherever prac-
ticable.
4. The poles, or towers, shall be located as far as practicable from
inflammable material or structures.
5. The poles, or towers, supporting the crossing span, and the adjoin-
ing span on each side, preferably shall be in a straight line.
6. The wires, or cables, shall cross over telegraph, telephone and simi-
lar wires wherever practicable.
7. Cradles, or overhead bridges, shall not be used.
C'sarance.
8. The side clearance shall be not less than 12 ft. from the nearest
rail of main-line track, nor less than 6 ft. from the nearest rail of
sidings. At loading sidings sufficient space shall be left for a driveway.
9. The clear headroom shall be not less than 30 ft. above the top of
rail under the most unfavorable condition of temperature and loading.
For constant potential, direct-current circuits, not exceeding 750 volts,
when paralleled by trolley contact wires, the clear headroom need not ex-
ceed 25 ft.
10. The clearance of alternating-current circuits above any existing
wires, under the most unfavorable condition of temperature and load-
ing, shall be not less than 8 ft. wherever practicable. For constant
potential, direct-current circuits, not exceeding 750 volts, the minimum
clearance above telegraph, telephone and similar wires may be 2 ft. with
insulated wires and 4 ft. with bare wires.
11. The separation of conductors carrying alternating current, sup-
ported by pin insulators, for spans not exceeding 150 ft., shall be not less
than:
Line Voltage. Separation.
Not exceeding 6,600 volts 14V?. in.
Exceeding 6,600, but not exceeding 14,000 24 in.
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000 30 in.
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 35,000 36 in.
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000 45 in.
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 70,000 60 in.
*For amendments, see index.
512
ELECTRICITY. 513
For spans exceeding 150 ft. the pin spacing should be increased,
depending upon the length of the span and the sag of the conductors.
Note. — This requirement does not apply to wires of the same phase
or polarity between which there is no difference of potential.
With constant potential, direct-current circuits not exceeding 750
volts, the minimum spacing shall be 10 in.
12. When supported, by insulators of the disc or suspension type, the
crossing span and the next adjoining spans shall be dead-ended at the
poles, or towers, supporting the crossing span, so that at these poles,
or towers, the insulators shall be used as strain insulators.
13. The clearance in any direction between the conductors nearest
the pole, or tower, and the pole or tower shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Clearance.
Not exceeding 10,000 volts 9 in.
Exceeding 10,000, but not exceeding 14,000 12 in.
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000. 15 in.
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 35,000 18 in.
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000 21 in.
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 70,000 24 in.
Conductors.
14. The normal mechanical tension in the conductors generally shall
be the same in the crossing span and in the adjoining span on each side,
and the difference in length of the crossing and adjoining spans gen-
erally shall be not more than 50 per cent, of the length of the crossing
span.
15. The conductors shall not be spliced in the crossing span nor in
the adjoining span on either side.
16. The method of supporting the conductors at the poles, or
towers, shall be such as to hold the wires, under maximum loading, to
the supporting structures, in case of shattered insulators, or wires
broken or burned at an insulator, without allowing an amount of slip
which would materially reduce the clearance specified in paragraphs
No. 9 and No. 10.
Guys.
17. Wooden poles supporting the crossing span shall be side-guyed in
both directions if practicable, and be head-guyed away from the crossing
span. The next adjoining poles shall be head-guyed in both directions.
Braces may be used instead of guys.
18. Strain insulators shall be used in guys from wooden poles carry-
ing any power wire of less than 6,600 volts, provided the guys are not
through grounded to permanently damp earth. Strain insulators shall
not be used in guying steel structures, nor required on wooden poles
carrying wires, all of which are 6,600 volts or more, provided the guys
are through grounded to permanently damp earth.
Clearing. "', ■"■-.]
19. The space around the poles, or towers, shall be kept free from
inflammable material, underbrush and grass.
514 ELECTRICITY.
Signs.
20. In the case of railroad crossings, if required by the railroad
company, warning signs of an approved design shall be placed on all
poles and towers located on the railroad company's right-of-way.
Grounding.
21. For voltages over 5,000 volts, wooden crossarms, if used, shall
be provided with a grounded metallic plate on top of the arm, which shall
be not less than H-in. in thickness and which shall have a sectional area
and conductivity not less than that of the line conductor. Metal pins
shall be electrically connected to this ground. Metal poles and metal
arms on wooden poles shall be grounded.
22. The electrical conductivity of the ground conductor shall be ad-
justed to the short-circuit current capacity of the system and shall be
not less than that of a No. 4 B. & S. gage copper wire.
Temperature.
23. In the computation of stresses and clearances, and in erection,
provision shall be made for a variation in temperature from — 20 de-
grees Fahrenheit to + 120 degrees Fahrenheit. A suitable modification
in the temperature requirements shall be made for regions in which
the above limits would not fairly represent the extreme range of
temperature.
Inspection.
24. If required by contract, all material and workmanship shall be
subject to the inspection of the company crossed; provided, that reasonable
notice of the intention to make shop inspection shall be given by such
company; if such notification is not given, the company crossed shall be
furnished with certified reports of shop inspection of material and work-
manship made by a properly qualified inspector. Defective material shall
be rejected, and shall be removed and replaced with suitable material.
25. On the completion . of the work, all false work, plant and rub-
bish, incident to the construction, shall be removed promptly and the site
left unobstructed and clean.
Drawings.
26. If required, by contract, ( )
complete sets of general and detail drawings shall be furnished for
approval, before any construction is commenced.
LOADS.
27. The conductors shall be considered as uniformly loaded through-
out their length, with a load equal to the resultant of the dead load plus
the weight of a layer of ice ^2-in. in thickness, and a wind pressure of
8 lbs. per sq. ft. on the ice-covered diameter, at a temperature of o
degrees Fahrenheit.
28. The weight of ice shall be assumed as 57 lbs. per cu. ft.
(0.033 lbs. per cu. in.).
29. Insulators, pins and conductor attachments shall be designed to
withstand, with the designated factor of safety, the tension in the con-
ELECTRICITY. 515
ductors under the maximum loading, assuming the conductor to be
broken on one side of the structure.
30. The pole, or towers, shall be designed to withstand, with the
designated factor of safety, the combined stresses from their own weight,
the wind pressure on the pole, or tower, and the above wire loading on
the crossing span and the next adjoining span on each side. The wind
pressure on the poles, or towers, shall be assumed at 13 lbs. per sq. ft.
on the projected area of solid or closed structures, and on iVz times the
projected area of latticed structures.
31. The poles, or towers, shall also be designed to withstand the most
unfavorable condition of the loads specified in paragraph 30, combined
with the unbalanced tension of
Two broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 5 wires or less.
Three broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 6 to 10 wires.
Four broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 11 or more wires.
32. Crossarms shall be designed to withstand the loading specified
in paragraph 30, combined with the unbalanced tension of the wire, which,
when broken, produces the highest fiber stress in the arm.
33. The poles, or towers, may be permitted a reasonable deflection
under the specified loading, provided that such deflection does not reduce
the clearances specified in paragraph No. 10 more than 25 per cent, or
produce stresses in excess of those specified in paragraphs Nos. 65 to 69.
FACTORS OF SAFETY.
34. The ultimate unit stress divided by the allowable stress shall be
not less than the following :
Wires and cables 2
Pins 2
Insulators, conductor attachments, guys 3
Wooden poles and crossarms 6
Structural steel 3
Reinforced concrete poles and crossarms 4
Foundations 2
Note. — The treating of wooden poles and crossarms is recommended.
The treatment of wooden poles and crossarms should be by thorough
impregnation with preservative by either closed or open-tank process.
For poles, except in the case of yellow pine, the treatment need not ex-
tend higher than a point 2 ft. above the ground line.
Insulators.
35. Insulators for line voltages of less than 9,000 shall not flash over
at four times the normal working voltage, under a precipitation of water
of 1/5 of an in. per minute, at an inclination of 45 degrees to the axis of
the insulator.
36. Each separate part of a built-up insulator, for line voltages over
9,000, shall be subjected to the dry flash-over test of that part for five
consecutive minutes.
37. Each assembled and cemented insulator shall be subjected to its
drv flash-over test for five consecutive minutes.
516 ELECTRICITY.
The dry flash-over test shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Test Voltage.
Exceeding 9,000, but not exceeding 14,000. . . . 65,000
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000. .. . 100,000
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 35,000. .. . 125,000
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000. .. . 150.000
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 60,000. . . . 180,000
Exceeding 60,000 3 times line voltage
Each insulator shall further be so designed that, with excessive po-
tential, failure will first occur by flash-over and not by puncture.
38. Each assembled insulator shall be subjected to a wet flash-over
test, under a precipitation of water of 1-5 in. per minute, at an inclination
of 45 degrees to the axis of the insulator.
The wet flash-over test shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Test Voltage
Exceeding 9,000, but not exceeding 14,000. .. 40.000
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000. . . 60,000
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 35,000. . . 80,000
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000. . . 100,000
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 60,000. . . 120,000
Exceeding 60,000 twice the line voltage.
39. Test voltages above 35,000 volts shall be determined by the
A. I. E. E. Standard Spark-Gap Method.
40. Test voltages below 35,000 volts shall be determined by trans-
former ratio.
MATERIAL.
Conductors.
41. The conductors shall be of copper, aluminum, or other non-
corrodible material, except that in exceptionally long spans, where the
required mechanical strength cannot be obtained with the above ma-
terials, galvanized or copper-covered steel strand may be used.
42. For voltages not exceeding 750 volts, solid or stranded con-
ductors may be used up to and including 4/0 in size ; above 4/0
in size, stranded conductors shall be used. For voltages exceeding 750
volts, and not exceeding 5,000 volts, solid or stranded conductors may be
used up to and including 2/0 in size; above 2/0 in size, conductors
shall be stranded. For voltages exceeding 5,000 volts, all conductors
shall be stranded. Aluminum conductors for all voltages and sizes shall
be stranded.
The minimum size of conductors shall be as follows :
No. 6 B. & S. gage copper for voltages not exceeding 5,000 volts.
No. 4 B. & S. gage copper for voltages exceeding 5,000 volts.
No. 1 B. & S. gage aluminum for all voltages.
Insulators.
43. Insulators shall be of porcelain for voltages exceeding 5,000
volts.
ELECTRICITY. 517
44- Strain insulators for guys shall have an ultimate strength of
not less than twice that of the guy in which placed. Strain insulators shall
be so constructed that the guy wires holding the insulator in position
will interlock in case of the failure of the insulator.
Strain insulators for guys shall not flash over at four times the
maximum line voltage, under a precipitation of water of 1/5 in. per min-
ute, at an inclination of 45 degrees to the axis of the insulator.
Pins.
45. For voltages of 5,000 and over, insulator pins shall be steel,
wrought iron, malleable iron, or other approved metal or alloy, and shall
be galvanized, or otherwise protected from corrosion. Pins shall be locked
with cotter, nut, or other device, to prevent raising out of the socket or
hole in the crossarm.
Guys.
46. Guys shall be galvanized or copper-covered stranded steel cable,
not less than 5/16-in. in diameter, or galvanized rolled rods of equivalent
tensile strength.
47. Guys to the ground shall connect to a galvanized anchor rod,
extending at least one foot above the ground level.
48. The detail of the anchorage shall be definitely shown upon the
plans.
Wooden Poles.
49. Wooden poles shall be of selected timber of approved species,
peeled, free from defects which would decrease their strength or durability,
not less than 7 in. minimum diameter at the top, and meeting the re-
quirments as specified in paragraphs 17, 30, 31 and 34.
Concrete.
50. All concrete and concrete material shall be in accordance with
the requirements of the Report of the Joint Committee on Concrete
and Reinforced Concrete.
STRUCTURAL STEEL.
51. Structural steel shall be open-hearth, in accordance with the
Manufacturers' Standard Specifications.
52. The design and workmanship shall be strictly in accordance
with first-class practice.
53. The form of the frame shall be such that the stresses may be com-
puted with reasonable accuracy, or the strength shall be determined by
actual test.
54. The sections used shall permit inspection, cleaning and painting,
and shall be free from pockets in which water or dirt can collect.
55. The length of a main compression member shall not exceed 150
times its least radius of gyration. The length of a secondary compression
member shall not exceed 180 times its least radius of gyration.
56. The minimum thickness of- metal in galvanized structures shall
518 ELECTRICITY.
be %-in. for main members, and %-in. for secondary members. The
minimum thickness of painted material shall be J-4-in.
PROTECTIVE COATINGS.
57. All structural steel shall be thoroughly cleaned at the shop
and be galvanized, or given one coat of approved paint.
Painted Material.
58. All contact surfaces shall be given one coat of paint before
assembling.
All painted structural steel shall be given two field coats of an
approved paint.
The surface of the metal shall be thoroughly cleaned of all dirt,
grease, scale, etc., before painting, and no painting shall be done in
freezing or rainy weather.
Galvanized Material.
59. Galvanized material shall be in accordance with the Specifica-
tions for Galvanizing Iron and Steel (Appendix).
Bolt holes in galvanized material shall be made before galvanizing.
FOUNDATIONS.
60. The foundations for steel poles and towers shall be designed to
prevent overturning.
The weight of concrete shall be assumed as 140 lbs. per cu. ft. In
good ground, the weight of "earth" shall be assumed at 100 lbs. per cu. ft.
In swampy ground, special measures shall be taken to prevent uplift or
depression.
61. The top of the concrete foundation, or casing, shall be not less
than 12 in. above the surface of the ground or extreme high water.
62. When located in swampy ground, wooden crossing and next ad-
joining poles shall be set in barrels of broken stone or gravel, or in
broken stone or timber footings.
63. When located in the sides of banks, or when subject to washouts,
foundations shall be given additional depth, or be protected by cribbing
or riprap.
64. All foundations and pole settings shall be tamped in 6-in. layers,
while back filling.
WORKING UNIT STRESSES.
Obtained by dividing the ultimate breaking strength by the factors of
safety given in paragraph 34.
Structural Steel.
Lbs. per sq. in.
65. Tension (net section) 18,000
Shear 14,000 1
Compression 18,000 — 60 -
ELECTRICITY.
519
Rivets, Pins.
66. Shear 10,000
Bearing 20>°°0
Bending 20>oo°
Bolts.
67. Shear 8>5QO
Bearing T7.ooo
Bending 17,000
Wires and Cables.
Lbs. per sq. in.
68. Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, 4/0, 3/0, 2/0. .25,000
Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, 1/0 27,500
Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, No. t 28,500
Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, No. 2, 4, 6. ...30,000
Copper, soft-drawn, solid, B. & S 17,000
Copper, hard-drawn, stranded, B. & S 30,000
Copper, soft-drawn, stranded, B. & S 17,000
Aluminum, hard-dr'n, stranded, B. & S. gage under 4/0.-12,000
Aluminum, hard-dr'n, stranded, B. & S. gage 4/0 and
nvPr ".SOO
Untreated Timber.
Bending.
69. Eastern white cedar 600 lbs. per sq. in.
Chestnut 850 lbs. per sq. in .
Washington cedar 850 lbs. per sq. in.
Idaho cedar 850 lbs. per sq. in.
Port Orford cedar 1150 lbs. per sq. in.
Long-leaf yellow pine 1100 lbs. per sq. in.
Short-leaf yellow pine . . 05O lbs. per sq. in.
Douglas fir 1000 lbs. per sq. in.
White oak 95© lbs. per sq. in.
Red cedar 700 lbs. per sq. in.
Bald cypress (heartw'd) 800 lbs. per sq. in.
Redwood ..'..'. 850 lbs. per sq. in.
Catalpa 500 lbs. per sq. in .
Juniper 550 lbs. per sq. in .
L— Length in inches.
D = Least side, or diameter, in inches.
Compression.
L
. 600 (
. 850
• 850
• 850
■ 1150
.IIOO
• 950
.1000
. 950
. 700
. 800
. 850
. 500
550
60 01
SPECIFICATION FOR GALVANIZING FOR IRON OR STEEL.
These specifications give in detail the test to be applied to galvanized
material. All specimens shall be capable of withstanding these tests.
520 ELECTRICITY.
Coating.
(A) The galvanizing shall consist of a continuous coating of pure
zinc of uniform thickness, and so applied that it adheres firmly to the
surface of the iron or steel. The finished product shall be smooth.
Cleaning.
(B) The samples shall be cleaned before testing, first with car-
bona, benzine or turpentine and cotton waste (not with a brush), and
then thoroughly rinsed in clean water and wiped dry with clean cotton
waste.
The sample shall be clean and dry before each immersion in the
solution.
Solution.
(C) The standard solution of copper sulphate shall consist of com-
mercial copper sulphate crystals dissolved in cold water, about in the
proportion of 36 parts, by weight, of crystals to 100 parts, by weight, of
water. The solution shall be neutralized by the addition of an excess of
chemically pure cupric oxide (Cu O). The presence of an excess of cupric
oxide will be shown by the sediment of this reagent at the bottom of the
containing vessel.
The neutralized solution shall be filtered before using by passing
through filter paper. The filtered solution shall have a specific gravity of
1. 186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit (reading the scale at the level of the
solution) at the beginning of each test. In case the filtered solution is
high in specific gravity, clean water shall be added to reduce the specific
gravity at 1.186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit. In case the filtered solution is
low in specific gravity, filtered solution of a higher specific gravity shall
be added to make the specific gravity 1.186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit.
As soon as the stronger solution is taken from the vessel containing
the unfiltered neutralized stock solution, additional crystals and water
must be added to the stock solution. An excess of cupric oxide shall
always be kept in the unfiltered stock solution.
Quantity of Solution.
(D) Wire samples shall be tested in a glass jar of at least 2 in. in-
side diameter. The jar without the wire samples shall be filled with
standard solution to a depth of at least 4 in. Hardware samples shall
be tested in a glass or earthenware jar containing at least :/2 pint of
standard solution for each hardware sample.
Solution shall not be used for more than one series of four
immersions.
Samples.
(E) Not more than seven wires shall be simultaneously immersed,
and not more than one sample of galvanized material other than wire shall
be immersed in the specified quantity of solution.
The samples shall not be grouped or twisted together, but shall be
ELECTRICITY. 521
well separated so as to permit the action of the solution to be uniform
upon all immersed portions of the samples.
Test.
(F) Clean and dry samples shall be immersed in the required
quantity of standard solution in accordance with the following cycle
of immersions.
The temperature of the solution shall be maintained between 62
degrees and 68 degrees Fahrenheit at all times during the following test:
(1) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
(2) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
(3) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
(4) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
After each immersion the samples shall be immediately washed in
clean water having a temperature between 62 degrees and 68 degrees
Fahrenheit, and wiped dry with cotton waste.
In the case of No. 14 galvanized iron or steel wire, the time of the
fourth immersion shall be reduced to V2 minute.
Rejection.
(G) If after the test described in section (F) there should be
a bright metallic copper deposit upon the samples, the lot represented
by the sample shall be rejected.
Copper deposits on zinc or within 1 in. of the cut end shall not
be considered causes for rejection.
In the case of a failure of only one wire in a group of seven wires
immersed together, or if there is a reasonable doubt as to the copper
deposit, two check tests shall be made on these seven wire-; and the
lot reported in accordance with the majority of the sets of tests.
Note.— The equipment necessary for the tests herein outlined is as
follows :
Filter paper.
Commercial copper sulphate crystals.
Chemically pure cupric oxide (Cu O).
Running water.
Warm water or ice, as per needs.
Carbona, benzine or turpentine
Glass jars at least 2 in. inside diameter by at least 41/ in. high.
Glass or earthenware jars for hardware samples.
Vessel for washing samples.
Tray for holding jars of stock solution.
Jars, bottles and porcelain basket for stock solution.
Cotton waste.
Hydrometer cylinder 3 in. diameter by 15 in. high.
Thermometer with large Fahrenheit scale correct at 62 and 68 degrees.
Hydrometer correct at 1.186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit.
Appendix B.
PARAGRAPHS IN SPECIFICATIONS FOR OVERHEAD CROSS-
ING OF ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER LINES AS
ADOPTED BY OTHER ASSOCIATIONS RE-
FERRED TO IN REPORT OF COMMIT-
TEE ON ELECTRICITY.
10. The clearance of alternating-current circuits above any existing
wires, under the most unfavorable condition of temperature and loading,
shall be not less than 8 ft. wherever possible. For constant potential,
direct-current circuits, not exceeding 750 volts, the minimum clearance
above telegraph, telephone and similar wires may be 2 ft. with insulated
wires and 4 ft. with bare wires.
13. The clearance in any direction between the conductors nearest
the pole, or tower, and the pole, or tower, shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Clearances.
Not exceeding 14,000 volts 9 in.
Exceeding 14,000 but not exceeding 27,000 15 in.
Exceeding 27,000 but not exceeding 35,000 18 in.
Exceeding 35,000 but not exceeding 47,000 21 in.
Exceeding 47,000 but not exceeding 70,000 24 in.
18. Strain insulators shall be used in guys from wooden poles carry-
ing any power wire of less than 6,600 volts. Strain insulators shall not
be used in guying steel structures, nor required on wooden poles carry-
ing wires all of which are 6,600 volts or more.
Inspection.
24. If required by contract, all material and workmanship shall be
subject to the inspection of the company crossed; provided that reason-
able notice of the intention to make shop inspection shall be given by such
company. Defective material shall be rejected, and shall be removed and
replaced with suitable material.
29. Insulators, pins and conductor attachments shall be designed to
withstand, with the designated factor of safety, the tension in the con-
ductors under the maximum loading.
31. The poles, or towers, shall also be designed to withstand the
loads specified in paragraph No. 30, combined with the unbalanced ten-
sion of:
Two broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 5 wires or less.
Three broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 6 to 10 wires.
Four broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 11 or more wires.
32. Crossarms shall be designed to withstand the loading specified
in paragraph No. 30, combined with the unbalanced tension of one wire
broken at the pin farthest from the pole.
34. The ultimate unit stress divided by the allowable unit stress shall
be not less than the following :
522
ELECTRICITY. 523
Wires and cables 2
Pins 2
Insulator, conductor attachments, guys 3
Wooden poles and crossarms 6
Structural steel 3
Reinforced concrete poles and crossarms 4
Foundations 2
Note: — The use of treated wooden poles and crossarms is recom-
mended. The treatment of wooden poles and crossarms should be by
thorough impregnation with preservative by either closed or open-tank
process. For poles, except in the case of yellow pine, the treatment need
not extend higher than a point 2 ft. above the ground line.
Pins.
45. For voltages of 5,000 and over, insulator pins shall be of steel,
wrought iron, malleable iron, or other approved metal or alloy, and shall be
galvanized, or otherwise protected from corrosion.
Wooden Poles.
49. Wooden poles shall be of selected timber, peeled, free from de-
fects which would decrease their strength or durability, not less than 7 in.
minimum diameter at the top, and meeting the requirements as specified
in paragraphs 17, 30, 31 and 34.
51. Structural steel shall be in accordance with the Manufacturers'
Standard Specifications.
55. The length of a main compression member shall not exceed 180
times its least radius of gyration. The length of a secondary compres-
sion member shall not exceed 220 times its least radius of gyration.
60. The foundations for steel poles and towers shall be designed to
prevent overturning.
The weight of concrete shall be assumed as 140 lbs. per cu. ft. In
good ground, the weight of "earth" (calculated at 30 degrees from the
vertical) shall be assumed as 100 lbs. per cu. ft. In swampy ground,
special measures shall be taken to prevent uplift or depression.
61. The top of the concrete foundation, or casing, shall be not less
than 6 in. above the surface of the ground, nor less than 1 ft. above ex-
treme high water.
;24
ELECTRICITY.
boc <u ID
so£
o
:o
. ;0
: : '. « :
:<m .
o
. t-
. .0
. . .0 .
. in :
.00 .
:o .
1a
"oo
• ' LO
' * to ■
' Tf •
"in •
"C5 "
CO
" ' ^f
• ■ -to •
* * ' 1-i '
;o3 ;
;to •
•«< laai
O N O O C-l
OlOlflOCO
•OOO to b-
■ eooi to icci
•"•* <M *<^ Or-t
•iH <M rH
0)T3
b04) 13 ®
•2goS5
: : : ■ 0 : • •
: : 0 : : - :
■ « . . . .
. . :© . • :
. . co . . ; .
c-i ' ' ' '
• • -ci ' ■ •
■ "o • • . •
; ;oj ; ; • ;
d c ^ fl
~ ft""
O <N> o O <M • ,_| O O '
•^''•W^ OH^O
y 02 t, • B3
3 <u ca fto)
<Z-~Z- - ^ z-
O (1)
Q d
8 -8
H fc
hr 0)
Q >
g*
0
H
Q
m Cp,c
W ID 3 a
- £- - bH Z- - (H- Z>H
: o
O 4)
Z>H
1 "O
P4 0)
(HA* " fH
4> ft
■a o
■^1
T-lC"lCO-^i^,cot^ 00OH-
Oo
i+S >
5 £2
4>'£
5o5i
02 O fe G
PQPQZU
01 s.
ri to
«
•1«
^ c
c 3i£
o K
"d O :M
; dp- ai a) 1-
5.JJSSZ Oh
O
o
; «a o
"a >>d
C d^Pn
^ d c
4>n» .
o-gdcs™b .
■so
®
H d >,
01 4>_i
O •" *^ Co
tni: d
O -i'O
>. n.„
' cwj: C
ELECTRICITY.
525
4-/i't>J 6a/<jurij /sajp&u jo ab'ec)'
s«*
I
b^o b I
<5 S 5 Si ^§ S *
*|l 5.1
£ ? 1> £*£ °N « N
Is
11
■§*§
I*
r&
^
*,
At ^ I
M«i til
* Jill Rt {
vNllil ft! *
« ^
* 9
H
I
526
ELECTRICITY.
te*
Hi
I
ELECTRICITY.
527
52S
ELECTRICITY.
ELECTRICITY.
529
/ts#j£> eberiQ
aSenQ-f
Is
3
530
ELECTRICITY.
J
I
~7-
/
J
ELECTRICITY.
531
//0j£c//t/ur>SJO &&/>&£) ,
532
ELECTRICITY.
<0
!
ELECTRICITY.
533
im/p*6*"*)-}
534
ELECTRICITY.
ELECTRICITY.
535
536
ELECTRICITY.
23_RRs_S\. .__/__ ~JE&— -S3_ 4I_ J. 23 I JR.R
1484494
63373
1231734
3771975
2049551
Total Number of Failures
16799
1039957
Tons Laid
224331
CLASSIFIED RAIL FAILURES DIAGRAM I.
Comparison between different WEIGHTS OF RAIL.
BESSEMER STEEL
Record for Period of One Year ending Oct. 31. 1910.
See Sheets Nos. 72. 73 and 74 for names of Railroads and Tons Laid.
15 RRs.
TbnsLaid
289 1 55
— 22.
629647
21 _
400173
12,
3624 73
Total Number of Fai lures
9 RRs.
Tons Laid
97335
169
I3S
611
592
210
243
584
407
75
IS
-
lis
19
1
II
L5
?;:a
-
3
2
—
-
1.6
....
4
7
-
9
7
-
9
4
d.2_
— •
s
l_
16 ,1
U2
-
7.
7
-,^
A.[_h
y
M
If
LS
0,5
<&
lA.
1
"(H
AS.
1
U
ftjj
3S,
1
Mftj
JZ
1
lA
1
^az
1
&
1
y
1
^M
xi
J^
||
UmrlUu
1
5
f
3
1
1
*:
i
<*>
1
*
*
<ti
1
*
5:
*
1
^
5:
V,
1
i;
X
OQ
1
■K
Si
<*>
1
i:
i
*
I
1
*
S
00
1
1
*
5
Tangent Curve
T.
c.
T.
c.
r
c.
Tangent
Curve
IOOLB.
90
85
80
7SL8.
CLASSIFIED RAIL FAILURES DIAGRAM 2.
Comparison between different WEIGHTS OF RAIL.
OPEN HEARTH STEEL.
Record' for Period of One Year ending Oct. 31,1910-
See Sheets A/oe. 75 and 7S for names of Railroads and Tons Laid.
. -r' 7 -■■■ ■■'-- SEC C\S
:- --* _
Record for Per
8ESSEMEQ STEEL.
V. 1910.
See Sheets Nos~ 77. 7
79.80end8lfcrnSmescf#a
was tnd T
ins Lmkt
\er Ry.AssoCiah'on Type,
tftSeettfyCMt f«p»
r-- -_--- >_-- :■.■-..-=- j- -■->'==-• ?--,"- c-vs 3r fl^/z.
OP£/V *£>
RTH STEEL.
5^ 5-?-S Vi -J 53 ,?---.-\.' \r- "£~
es ::■' ",,■ ~:jj$ snc Tons u
tfd
CLASSIFIED RAIL FAILURES.
Diagram i.
Comparison between different Weights of Rail
Bessemer Steel.
Diagram 2.
Comparison between different Weights of Rail —
Open-Hearth Steel,
Diagram 3.
Comparison between different Sections of Rail —
Bessemer Steel.
Diagram 4.
Comparison between different Sections of Rail —
Open-Hearth Steel.
Diagram 5.
Comparison of Failures at different Lengths of Lifc
— All Kinds of Steel.
UJ
111
- --
"" III
KIT"
"TTTI
--- --j—
TTTT
-
jl
1
1
Is
W
3
r
-'
J' -
!
1
i— 4
— J-
B !
1
f 1
I
I : ~
1
s ll
E
1
1
i j
ffli
y i - !
: I =
i|| \
1
1
I
I
1 1 ft
li
1 a
j i
I T
I
i
1
D
1 !
= 1 ' p
J lu il-
^;"d S
1 1
' 1
J J L
II III
-tflt
h = =
Il a
7 ' la ^lil
m 1
lUIl
J=l
' I1!1
H If!!!! 1
B
j" n
1
|
1 1 '
il
111MW Bfc IIMIHI
ill
j ii il mi i iii
p li1 ,
CpJ
y
lit =i
1 1 it1
■ " h
1 1 __
2
~_
E
1 =
- --.- -
1 !| g'l i §1 'i j#|Ll ill i II jB|||
2 Ip |
II 1 1 H 1
- i i -■' ^ir
tw i'J»
i_ - -:~
Lw, -„ --:_--- * • - n 1 1 1 1 1 1 J i n^ '^..hi :. --;;:.:-- r f - : mmmmMm^mmmm
r4lH l^JiP?«M|F*|^P?jri :
Ltt#^ill5iMi5l^llllN|lf
P?:", '".= : , ' ; " ;"
^illW* ;:"';pI|'pK
too \ 90 [as j«j|» n H ioo [ 90 \ es \ eo p| is ft
100 \ 90 \ 85 \eo\ 75 fs| «70 |9o| 55 |»|w|s! /
JO \sO\ 85 |«Jp| 75 p /£W |s| 55 | BO f?| 75 fSf /<30
Pj 55 | 50 p| 75 p| /£W |s| 55 | SO Jsj 75 |s
100 ^| 55 |«| 75 W /05 |§| 55 \So\ 75 100 Jsjs
i 55 SO] 75 K
o In 1 Year / fa 2
_'~.? Jto<
4-foS
5*6
6/07 ~'o8
3 to 9 9 to 10 Over 10 Years.
ELECTRICITY.
537
538
ELECTRICITY.
5
£
I- I.KCTRICITY
a
2k
Id
.40
ELECTRICITY.
<0
I
II
ELECTRICITY.
541
P*te*3f3 ujais&MtyJOM
\
\
<c k :* •»
S|
8
i
g
542
ELFXTRICITY.
i
t
ELECTRICITY.
543
544
ELECTRICITY.
ELECTRICITY.
545
546
ELECTRICITY.
S
I
i
i
ELECTRICITY.
547
548
ELECTRICITY.
IP
<0 -
ELECTRICITY.
549
550
ELECTRICITY.
s^l f
I
I
ELECTRICITY.
551
I
V
552
ELECTRICITY.
kl i
ELECTRICITY.
553
8
k
"m
$
^
I
554
ELECTRICITY.
ELECTRICITY.
555
1
I
556
ELECTRICITY.
I
S3 I
3
s i
REPORT OF COMMITTEE IV— ON RAIL.
Chas. S. Churchill, Chairman; R. Montfort, V ice-Chairman;
F_ B. Ashby, John D. Isaacs,
J. A. Atwood, Thos. H. Johnson,
A. S. Baldwin, Howard G. Kelley,
J. B. Berry, C. A. Morse,
M. L. Byers, George W. Kittredge,
W. C. Cushing, J. T. Richards
F. A. Delano, J. P. Snow,
P. H. Dudley, A. W. Thompson,
C. H. Ewing, Robert Trimble,
C. W. Huntington, M. H. Wickhorst,
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee presents the following report :
During 191 1, meetings were held at Chicago, March 20, 191 1; Atlantic
City, June 29, 1911; Chicago, November 14, 1911; New York, November
23 and 24, 1911; New York, February 13, 1912.
At the meetings held in New York, November 23 and 24, representa-
tives of the Manufacturers' Committee were also present. In addition to
the above meetings, several meetings of the Sub-Committees were also held.
Reports have been submitted during the year, as a part of the Rail
Committee's work, as follows :
(A) A Study of Seventeen Good Service Rails, by Robert Trimble
and W. C. Cushing (Bulletin No. 135, May, 1911), with notes by M. H.
Wickhorst. These rails contained carbon within or a little above the
usual limit for 85-lb. rails, namely, 0.45 to 0.55. With this carbon the
phosphorus was close to 0.10 or above, the manganese was mostly within
the usual limits of 0.80 to 1.10. Some of the rails were of fairly uniform
composition throughout the section as indicated by the etching, but others
were more or less segregated. This study did not perhaps lead to any very
definite results, but indicates that under some conditions segregated rails
high in phosphorus, and possibly also in carbon, may give long service,
although it does not define these conditions either of track or material.
(B and C) Rail Failure Statistics for the Year Ending October 31,
1910, and Segregation and Other Rail Proprties as Influenced by the Size
of Ingot, by M. H. Wickhorst (Bulletin No. 137, July, 1911).
Mr. Cushing made a study of the Rail Failure Statistics and below
are his comments on the subject:
559
560 RAIL.
(i) Study of these general statistics does not furnish accurate and
specific information so as to determine the value of different sections of
rail, because :
(a) The conditions of traffic are different.
(b) The conditions of roadbed are different.
(c) The conditions of ingot making and rolling practice are so differ-
ent that the quality of the material varies widely, and, at the present time,
this difference in quality of the material eliminates differences in section ;
nevertheless, when the time comes that the difference in quality of ma-
terial will be less, the influence of the section will be more apparent, for
there is no doubt that one section is stiffer and stronger than another ac-
cording to the distribution of the material. Inasmuch as we are endeavor-
ing to eliminate the differences in quality of material and bring it to a
high state of perfection, we should not, in the meantime, lose sight of
the desirable features of the rail section, but keep them constantly in
mind, so that when we arrive at a good quality of metal, we will also have
a desirable rail section.
(2) A study of these general statistics tends to disclose unusual re-
sults, and were it not for their compilation, we would not have much in-
formation relative to the difference between Bessemer and Open-Hearth
steel and concerning the various alloys.
(3) The general statistics are also important, in showing a relation
between broken rails and failure of head, web and base.
(4) Their tabulation discloses the difference between Steel Com-
panies when the sections and chemical composition are practically the
same.
The report by Mr. Wickhorst covers an investigation made at the
South Works of the Illinois Steel Company, to throw light on the rela-
tionship of the size of ingots of Bessemer Rail steel to the segregation of
the metalloids, locations of pipes and blow holes, and the properties of
ihe rails. This investigation showed that under the conditions of the tests,
the carbon, phosphorus and sulphur collected or segregated toward the in-
terior and upper part of the ingot and that, in a general way, such segre-
gation increased as the size of the ingot increased. The manganese also
segregated some, but to a much smaller extent, while the silicon showed
little or no tendency to segregate.
The elements which segregated as described also showed a lowering
in the top part of the ingot, below the average composition of the steel,
and this lowering extended downward along the sides of the ingot. The
"negative" segregation increased in general as the size of the ingot in-
creased and also extended down further along the sides of the ingot.
There was also a region of negative segregation in the interior and lower
part of the ingot, but the lowering of the elements was not as great in
this region.
This investigation also indicated that the material was distributed in
RAIL. 561
the rail bar about the same, relatively, as it was in the ingot from which
the rail bar had been rolled.
(D) Tests of Rail Steel Ingots and Derivative Shapes Made at Water-
town Arsenal, being a Review by M. H. Wickhorst of the Report Published
by the Watertown Arsenal (Bulletin No. 139, September, 1911).
This report covers a digest and analysis of the Government investi-
gation at the Watertown Arsenal of rail steel ingots and derivative shapes
as embodied in the Report of Tests of Metals, etc., made at the Water-
town Arsenal for the year 1909.
The work indicated that the interior cavities of an ingot cooled di-
rectly after pouring are about the same or slightly less than in a similar
ingot placed in the soaking pit and then cooled. This same result was also
indicated as true of blooms made from such ingots.
It was shown that almost the full tensile strength and ductility of the
metal of the lower part of the ingot were obtained rolling to about one-
tenth of the original cross-section, but with the metal of the upper part
of the ingot it was necessary to reduce the cross-section to one-twenty-
fifth or less of the original amount.
A great many etchings were made and it was shown that the structure
of the cross-section as developed by etching varies from the top to the
bottom of the ingot and that each structure finds its counterpart in suc-
ceeding shapes and at about the same proportionate distance from the
top end. It was also shown that the structure was considerably altered by
changing the position in which the ingot was allowed to cool, as for in-
stance allowing it to cool on its side after stripping.
(E) Influence of Rolling Temperature on the Properties of Bessemer
Rails, by M. H. Wickhorst, November, 191 1.
This report covers an investigation made at the works of the Carnegie
Steel Company to determine the influence of the temperature of rolling
on the properties of Bessemer Rails. This work indicated that the ductil-
ity and deflection in the drop test were influenced little, if any, by the
rolling temperature. The number of blows that it took to break the
rails in the drop test was uninfluenced by the temperature of rolling. The
yield point and tensile strength in the tension tests were influenced little,
if any. The elongation in the tension test decreased some as the temp-
erature increased. The influence of temperature showed most prominently
in the tension test, in the reduction of area, which decreased as the temp-
erature of rolling increased. The size of the grain, as shown by the micro-
scope, increased as the temperature increased.
In this report it is also pointed out that the ductility in the drop test
with the head of the rail in tension more nearly indicates the ductility
of the interior metal as measured in the tension test, than does the ductil-
ity in the drop test with the base of the rail in tension, which is usual in
inspection work.
Each report mentioned above gives a short summary of the matter
562 RAIL.
contained in it, but the main principles that seem to have been brought out
by the year's work are brought out in the brief reviews above.
The general plan of our research work during the year has been to
direct attention to some one item which enters as a factor in the properties
of the finished rail and attempt to obtain definite information concerning
its influence by the experimental method of obtaining as great a range as
practicable in the one item under consideration, but leaving all other con-
ditions as near alike as obtainable in the several experiments. It is thus
hoped to establish in the course of time the metallurgical principles and
laws that apply to the manufacture of steel rails.
(i) The first item of work for the Rail Committee according to the
instructions for 191 1, was to recommend changes in the specifications for
steel rails.
Considerable work has been done during the past year in the prepara-
tion of specifications, and the specifications submitted herewith are
recommended by your Committee. Some paragraphs, such as Nos. 5, 6,
14 and 15, are not to be considered as final, it being thought that the
Committee did not have sufficient information in its possession to make
these sections in the specifications mandatory.
One of the sections in question, No. 14, refers to the ductility test.
The requirements, in the specifications, for ductility are somewhat
lower than some members of your Committee think desirable, and it is
hoped that sufficient information will be obtained during the coming year
to enable the Committee to make some revision in these respects.
Paragraph No. 15, referring to deflections as a method of classifying
rails, is also tentative. It is the intention when sufficient data is at hand
to prescribe maximum and minimum limits for deflections under the drop
test.
(2) Present recommendations on standard rail sections.
The Committee reports progress.
(3) Continue investigation of the breakage and failure of rails and
present summary of conclusions drawn from reports received.
Bulletin No. 137, July, 191 1, contains the rail failure statistics for the
year ending October 31, 1910, and the conclusions in regard to the matter
are presented in that report.
(4) Report on the results obtained from the use of Open-Hearth and
Special Alloy Steel Rails, and the Chemical Composition of such rails.
Bulletin No. 137, referred to above, containing the report of the rail
failure statistics, also gives all the information that the Committee has in
regard to Open-Hearth and Special Alloy Steel Rails.
In regard to the remaining part of the outline of work for the year
191 1, the Committee reports no progress.
The Committee desires to call attention to the valuable services ren-
dered by Mr. M. H. Wickhorst, Engineer of Tests, for the Committee.
RAIL. 563
Mr. Wickhorst has succeeded in winning the confidence of the Manufac-
turers and has thereby succeeded in securing their co-operation in the
work which is being done. Considerable light has been thrown upon the
subject by these investigations of Mr. Wickhorst, and it is hoped that
in the future considerable good will be accomplished as a result of the
investigations.
Your Committee desires to acknowledge the very generous manner in
which the various Rail Manufacturers have offered us the material and
facilities of their mills to carry on this research work. The condition of
co-operation that we are working under is very gratifying and, it would
seem, must work toward the best interests of the railroads, the steel mills
and the general public.
The Committee recommends the following lines for investigation dur-
ing the coming year :
(i) Recommend changes in specifications for steel rails.
(2) Present recommendations on standard rail sections.
(3) Continue investigation of the breakage and failure of rails and
present summary of conclusions drawn from reports received.
(4) Report on the results obtained from the use of Open-Hearth and
Special Alloy Steel Rails, and the Chemical Composition of such rails.
(5) Present reports on the results of tests made on the various kinds
of rail in conjunction with the Manufacturers' Committee on the revolv-
ing machine at South Chicago.
(6) Report on standard drilling for rails.
Special Investigations by Mr. Wickhorst.
(1) Test Open-Hearth Steel in ingots of various sizes.
(2) Influence of height of ingot with usual cross-section —
(a) Bessemer Steel ;
(b) Open-Hearth Steel.
(3) Influence of temperature of rolling on high carbon Open-Hearth
steel.
(4) Drop Tests. Influence of temperature of test piece on ductility
and deflection in drop test.
(5) Tests with reciprocating machine, especially to determine in-
fluence of interior segregation.
(6) Influence of Titanium —
(a) Bessemer Steel ;
(b) Open-Hearth Steel.
(7; Influence of thickness of mold on segregation and cavities, cast
in sand and in molds of various thickness —
(a) Bessemer Steel ;
(b) Open-Hearth Steel.
(8) Influence of methods of cooling on the cooling beds, especially
with high carbon steels ; also the effects of cold straightening.
(9) Influence of the temperature of the liquid steel when poured
into molds.
564 RAIL.
(10) Experiments with methods of casting ingots for improvement,
as regards blow holes, pipes, etc.
(ii) Drop Tests, Permanent Set, Ductility, etc.
(a) Influence of carbon.
(b) Influence of phosphorus.
(c) Influence of manganese.
(d) Influence of span of supports.
(e) Influence of moment of inertia.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON RAIL.
RAIL.
565
AMERICAN RAILWAY ENGINEERING ASSOCIATION.
SPECIFICATIONS FOR CARBON STEEL RAILS.
1912.
INSPECTION.
Access to Works.
1. Inspectors representing the purchaser shall have free entry to the
works of the manufacturer at all times while the contract is being exe-
cuted, and shall have all reasonable facilities afforded them by the manu-
facturer to satisfy them that the rails have been made in accordance with
the terms of the specifications.
Place for Tests.
2. All tests and inspections shall be made at the place of manufac-
ture, prior to shipment, and shall be so conducted as not to interfere un-
necessarily with the operation of the mill.
MATERIAL.
Material.
3. The material shall be steel made by the Bessemer or Open-Hearth
process provided by the contract.
CHEMICAL REQUIREMENTS.
Chemical Composition.
4. The chemical composition of the steel from which the rails are
rolled, determined as prescribed in Section 7, shall be within the following
limits :
For Bessemer Process
For Open-Hearth Process
Elements
70 lbs. and over,
but under 85 lbs.
85 - 100 lbs.
inclusive
70 lbs. and over,
but under 85 lbs.
85 - 100 lbs.
inclusive
0.40 to 0.50
0.80 to 1.10
0 20
0.10
0.45 to 0.55
0.80 to 1.10
0.20
0.10
0.53 to 0.66
0.60 to 0.90
0.20
0.04
0.63 to 0 76
0.60 to 0 90
Silicon not to exceed .
Phosphorus not to exceed . .
0.20
0.04
Modification of Carbon for Low Phosphorus.
5. When the material used at any mill is such that the average phos-
phorus content of the ingot metal used in the Bessemer process is run-
ning below 0.08 and in the Open-Hearth process is running below 0.03,
and if it seems mutually desirable, the carbon may be increased at the
rate of 0.035 f°r eacb 0.01 that the phosphorus content of the ingot metal
used averages below 0.08 for Bessemer steel, or 0.03 for Open-Hearth steel.
566 RAIL
Average Carbon.
6. It is desired that the percentage of carbon in an entire order of
rails shall average as high as the mean percentage between the upper and
lower limits specified.
Analyses.
7. In order to ascertain whether the chemical composition is in ac-
cordance with the requirements, analyses shall be furnished as follows :
(a) For Bessemer process the manufacturer shall furnish to the in-
spector, daily, carbon determinations for each heat before the rails are
shipped, and two chemical analyses every twenty-four hours representing
the average of the elements, carbon, manganese, silicon, phosphorus and
sulphur contained in the steel, one for each day and night turn respectively.
These analyses shall be made on drillings taken from the ladle test ingot
not less than one-eighth inch beneath the surface.
(b) For Open-Hearth process, the makers shall furnish the inspectors
with a chemical analysis of the elements, carbon, manganese, silicon,
phosphorus and sulphur, for each heat.
(c) On request of the inspector, the manufacturer shall furnish drill-
ings from the test ingot for check analyses.
PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS.
Physical Qualities.
8. Tests shall be made to determine :
(a) Ductility or toughness as opposed to brittleness.
(b) Soundness.
Method of Testing.
9. The physical qualities shall be determined by the Drop Test.
Drop Testing Machine.
10. The drop testing machine used shall be the standard of the Amer-
ican Railway Engineering Association.
(a) The tup shall weigh 2,000 lbs., and have a striking face with a
radius of five inches.
(b) The anvil block shall weigh 20,000 lbs., and be supported on
springs.
(c) The supports for the test pieces shall be spaced three feet be-
tween centers and shall be a part of, and firmly secured to the anvil. The
bearing surfaces of the supports shall have a radius of five inches.
Pieces for Drop Test.
11. Drop tests shall be made on pieces of rail not less than four feet
and not more than six feet long. These test pieces shall be cut from the
top end of the top rail of the ingot, and marked on the base or head with
gage marks one inch apart for three inches each side of the center of the
test piece, for measuring the ductility of the metal.
RAIL 567
Temperature of Test Pieces.
12. The temperature of the test pieces shall be between 60 and 100
degrees Fahrenheit.
Height of Drop.
13. The test piece shall, at the option of the inspector, be placed
head or base upwards on the supports, and be subjected to impact of the
tup falling free from the following heights :
For 70-lb. rail 16 feet
For 80, 85 and 90-lb. rail 17 feet
For 100-lb. rail 18 feet
Elongation or Ductility.
14. Under these impacts the rail under one or more blows shall show
at least 6 per cent, elongation for one inch, or 5 per cent, each for two
consecutive inches of the six-inch scale, marked as described in Section 11.
Permanent Set.
15. It is desired that the permanent set after one blow under the
drop test shall not exceed that in the following table, and a record shall
be made of this information.
Permanent Set
, measured by
Rail
Middle Ordinate in Inches
in a Length of 3 Feet
Section
Weight
per Yard
Moment
of Inertia
Bessemer Process O.-H. Process
A.R.A.-A
100
48.94
1.65 1.45
A.R.A.-B
100
41.30
2.05
1.80
A.R.A.-A
90
38.70
1.90
1.65
A.R.A.-B
90
32.30
2.20
2.00
A.R.A.-A
80
28.80
2.85
2.45
A.R.A.-B
SO
25.00
3.15
2.85
A.R.A.-A
70
21.05
3.50
3.10
A.R.A.-B
70
18.60
3.85
3.50
Test to Destruction.
16. The test pieces which do not break under the first or subsequent
blows shall be nicked and broken, to determine whether the interior
metal is sound.
Bessemer Process Drop Tests.
17. One piece shall be tested from each heat of Bessemer steel.
(a) If the test piece does not break at the first blow and shows the
required elongation (Section 14), all of the rails of the heat shall be
accepted, provided that the test piece when nicked and broken does not
show interior defect.
(b) If the piece breaks at the first blow, or does not show the
required elongation (Section 14), or if the test piece shows the required
elongation but when nicked and broken shows interior defect, all of the
top rails from that heat shall be rejected.
(c) A second test shall then be made of a test piece selected by the
inspector from the top end of any second rail of the same heat, preferably
568 RAIL.
of the same ingot. If the test piece does not break at the first blow, and
shows the required elongation (Section 14), all of the remainder of the
rails of the heat shall be accepted, provided that the test piece when
nicked and broken does not show interior defect.
(d) If the piece breaks at the first blow, or does not show the required
elongation (Section 14), or if the piece shows the required elongation but
when nicked and broken shows interior defect, all of the second rails from
that heat shall be rejected.
(e) A third test shall then be made of a test piece selected by the
inspector from the top end of any third rail of the same heat, preferably
of the same ingot. If the test piece does not break at the first blow and
<>hows the required elongation (Section 14), all of the remainder of the
rails of the heat shall be accepted, provided that the test piece when nicked
and broken does not show interior defect.
(f) If the piece breaks at the first blow, or does not show the required,
elongation (Section 14), or if the piece shows the required elongation but
when nicked and broken shows interior defect, all of the remainder of
the rails from that heat shall be rejected.
Open-Hearth Process Drop Tests.
18. Test pieces shall be selected from the second, middle and last
full ingot of each Open-Hearth heat.
(a) If two of these test pieces do not break at the first blow and show
the required elongation (Section 14), all of the rails of the heat shall be
accepted, provided that these test pieces when nicked and broken do not
show interior defect.
(b) If two of the test pieces break at the first blow, or do not show
the required elongation, or if any of the pieces that have been tested under
the drop when nicked and broken show interior defect, all of the top
rails from that heat shall be rejected.
(c) Second tests shall then be made from three test pieces selected by
the inspector from the top end of any second rails of the same heat, prefer-
ably of the same ingots. If two of these test pieces do not break at
the first blow and show the required elongation (Section 14), all of the
remainder of the rails of the heat shall be accepted, provided that the
pieces that have been tested under the drop when nicked and broken do not
show interior defect.
(d) If two of these test pieces break at the first blow or do not show
the required elongation (Section 14), or if any of the pieces that have
been tested under the drop when nicked and broken show interior defect,
all of the second rails of the heat shall be rejected.
(e) Third tests shall then be made from three test pieces selected
by the inspector from the top end of any third rails of the same heat,
preferably of the same ingots. If two of these test pieces do not break at
the first blow, and show the required elongation (Section 14), all of the
remainder of the rails of the heat shall be accepted, provided that the
RAIL. 569
pieces that have been tested under the drop when nicked and broken do not
show interior defect.
(f) If two of these test pieces break at the first blow or do not show
the required elongation (Section 14), or if any of the pieces, that have
been tested under the drop when nicked and broken show interior defect,
all of the remainder of the rails from that heat shall be rejected.
No. 1 Rails.
19. No. 1 classification rails shall be free from injurious defects and
flaws of all kinds.
No. 2 Rails.
20. (a) Rails,- which, by reason of surface imperfections, or for
causes mentioned in Section 30 hereof, are not classed as No. 1 rails, will
be accepted as No. 2 rails, but No. 2 rails which contain imperfections in
such number or of such character as will, in the judgment of the in-
spector, render them unfit for recognized No. 2 uses, will not be accepted
for shipment.
(b) No. 2 rails to the extent of 5 per cent, of the whole order will
be received. All rails accepted as No. 2 rails shall have the ends painted
white and shall have two prick punch marks on the side of the web near
the heat number near the end of the rail, so placed as not to be covered
by the splice bars.
DETAILS OF MANUFACTURE.
Quality of Manufacture.
21. The entire process of manufacture shall be in accordance with
the best current state of the art.
Bled Ingots.
22. Bled ingots shall not be used.
Discard.
23. There shall be sheared from the end of the bloom, formed from
the top of the ingot, sufficient metal to secure sound rails.
Lengths.
24. The standard length of rails shall be 33 feet, at a temperature of
60 degrees Fahrenheit. Ten per cent, of the entire order will be accepted
in shorter lengths varying by 1 foot from 32 feet to 25 feet. A variation
of one-fourth inch from the specified lengths will be allowed. No. 1 rails
less than 2>2> feet long shall be painted green on both ends.
Shrinkage.
25. The number of passes and speed of train shall be so regulated
that on leaving the rolls at the final pass, the temperature of the rail will
not exceed that which requires a shrinkage allowance at the hot saws,
for a rail 23 feet in length and of ico lbs. section, of six and three-fourths
inches and one-eighth inch less for each ten lbs. decrease in section.
570 RAIL.
Cooling.
26. The bars shall not be held for the purpose of reducing their
temperature, nor shall any artificial means of cooling them be used after
they leave the finishing pass. Rails, while on the cooling beds, shall be
protected from snow and water.
Section.
27. The section of rails shall conform as accurately as possible to
the template furnished by the Railroad Company. A variation in height
of one-sixty-fourth inch less or one-thirty-second inch greater than the
specified height, and one-sixteenth inch in width of flange, will be per-
mitted ; but no variation shall be allowed in the dimensions affectmg the
fit of the splice bars.
Weight.
28. The weight of the rails specified in the order shall be maintained
as nearly as possible, after complying with the preceding Section. A vari-
ation of one-half of 1 per cent, from the calculated weight of section, as
applied to an entire order, will be allowed.
Payment.
*2Q. Rails will be accepted and paid for according to actual weights.
Straightening.
30. The hot straightening shall be carefully done, so that gagging
under the cold presses will be reduced to a minimum. Any rail coming
to the straightening presses showing sharp kinks or greater camber than
that indicated by a middle ordinate of 4 inches in 33 feet, for A. R. A.
type of sections, or 5 inches for A. S. C. E. type of sections, will be at
once classed as a No. 2 rail. The distance between the supports of rails
in the straightening presses shall not be less than 42 inches. The supports
shall have flat surfaces and be out of wind.
Drilling.
31. Circular holes for joint bolts shall be drilled to conform accurately
in every respect to the drawing and dimensions furnished by the Railroad
Company.
Finishing.
32. (a) All rails shall be smooth on the heads, straight in line and
surface, and without any twists, waves or kinks. They shall be sawed
square at the ends, a variation of not more than one-thirty-second inch
being allowed ; and burrs shall be carefully removed.
(b) Rails improperly drilled or straightened, or from which the burrs
have not been removed, shall be rejected, but may be accepted after being
properly finished.
*Amend to read, "29. Rails accepted will be paid for according to actual
weights."
RAIL. 571
Branding.
33. The name of the manufacturer, the weight and type of rail, and
the month and year of manufacture shall be rolled in raised letters and
figures on the side of the web. The number of the heat and a letter in-
dicating the portion of the ingot from which the rail was made shall be
plainly stamped on the web of each rail, where it will not be covered by
the splice bars. The top rails shall be lettered "A," and the succeeding
ones "B," "C," "D," etc., consecutively ; but in case of a top discard of
twenty or more per cent., the letter "A" will be omitted. Open-Hearth
rails shall be branded or stamped "O. H." All markings of rails shall be
done so effectively that the marks may be read as long as the rails arc in
service.
Separate Classes.
34. All classes of rails shall be kept separate from each other.
Loading.
35. All rails shall be loaded in the presence of the inspector.
572 RAIL.
Appendices to Report of Committee IV — On Rail.
Your Committee submits the following statements as Appendices to
its report. They consist of :
(A) A Study of Seventeen Good Service Rails, by Robert Trimble
and W. C. Cushing (Bulletin 135, May, 1911), with notes by M. H.
Wickhorst.
(B) Rail Failure Statistics for the Year Ending October 31, 1910;
Comparative Wear of Bessemer, Open-Hearth and Nickel Steel Rail
on Pennsylvania Railroad, by Jos. T. Richards, Chief Engineer Main-
tenance of Way.
(C) Segregation and Other Rail Properties as Influenced by the
Size of Ingot, by M. H. Wickhorst (Bulletin 137, July, 1911).
(D) Tests of Rail Steel Ingots and Derivative Shapes Made at
Watertown Arsenal, being a Review, by M. H. Wickhorst, of the Report
published by the Watertown Arsenal (Bulletin 139, September, 191 1).
(E) Influence ef Rolling Temperature on the Properties of Bes-
semer Rails, by M. H. Wickhorst (Bulletin 143, January, 1912).
(F) Hearing before Railroad Commission of Indiana (Bulletin 144,
February, 1912).
Appendix A.
A STUDY OF SEVENTEEN GOOD SERVICE RAILS
By
Robert Trimble and W. C. Cushing.
With discussion by
M. H. Wickhorst, Engineer of Tests — Rail Committee.
This report covers a study of seventeen Bessemer rails that gave good
service on the Pennsylvania Lines West of Pittsburgh, ten of them on
the Northwest System, the reports of which were furnished by Mr.
Trimble, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way, and the other seven on
the Southwest System, the reports of which were furnished by Mr. Cush-
ing, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way. The rails gave from seven
to seventeen years' service in main tracks and were removed under direc-
tions of Messrs. Trimble and Cushing for special examination. The tests
(which were made by R. W. Hunt & Co.) consisted of the following:
i. Etching of a section with picric acid.
2. Etching of a section with sulphuric acid.
3. Analysis of borings from the interior of the head.
4. Tensile strength of a sample from the interior of the head, from
eleven of the rails.
5. Five transverse microphotographs along the center line of the rail,
one at the top and the others at J4 in-> V2 in., Y$ in. and 1 in.,
respectively from the top, from each rail, etched with picric-
acid and magnified about 65 diameters.
These various reports and other information were presented to the
Rail Committee and then edited for publication as this report by M. H.
Wickhorst. The rails were given numbers from 1 to 17, inclusive, the
first ten being rails examined by Trimble, and the other seven examined
by Cushing. The main information concerning these rails is shown in Table 1,
and for more convenient comparison the carbon, phosphorus, manganese,
tensile strength and elongation are shown graphically in Fig. 1. The
present specification limits for carbon, phosphorus and manganese are
shown on the diagrams, namely, carbon, .45 to .55 per cent ; phosphorus,
not exceeding .10 per cent., and manganese, .80 to 1.10 per cent. Although
we have no standard tensile requirements, I show a line at 12 per cent,
elongation, as Bessemer rail steel should give this amount below the
Report No. 18, April, 1911.
578
574
RAIL.
OOfOlOH CSOOMMOl Ol CO Ci CJ OC LOW
"* Oi t— t- iO rf CO Tf <X> ^ "* CO "^ t- i-t CO*T5
OOOOO OiH i-H i-h i-H rH ,-t iHOt-H HO
IfllflH^O Olt-COHH TJ-COCO00CD 00 O*
00 O O O C- OOOC5050 OOOt^Oi oi>
MCH^W ^
^t4 O CO ^ LO H*< • ■ » • •■
OOOOO o
C"- l.ft 00 V ©* tf> OO H CI t> ^r|«0 0)H CO «£>
ci co >— (ir:oo t cr. o o oi q Oi m h o hoi
,H ,_, ,_, y-t j-i r-«©7-*i-tO 0©i-*tHi-H 1-i O
iCCOt-OH HNOIOCO OIWMHM LO <X>
r-~ lo o o tp Ciu^oooct- i>- 1> ci a; U5 hi>
-<r us •* io «> m^T-rj''**' lo *<* "^ 10 m 10 ■**<
CO tf5 h- rH
bo .
CO CO coco
> 03 toeooc -j- m
oooo oooco oo
Cl^lOOO Irt lO -H '■J' Tf 00 O
HC1HH MtiHHH HO
w
HhS
CI O M O W
HEihcHEH HH
<!WM<!<! <Jh3JJJ J^M^J JJ
as <d <d a> o)
bo bo oo oo'bo
a> a3 a> a> a3
CCCCC
v& co c3 cd d
OOOOO'
•^i in w to 03
(m— — c •« —
m O O O O
c c a a a
0)
03 43 03
be
oo oo bo
0)
03 03 03
C
(-1
c c c
i-
J- — ■—
Rj
p
u
ooo
03 03
00 00
03 03
- -
(U 03.
•-o '.O C~ t- t—
H • .HW
HH
c
KKtfKtf
«««««'
.«« . .
o . .oo
OO
■g
pHtf««p;
K«K««
^ « „• A
en com
coco
OQ
CLkkkPn
Ph pL, fL, PL. Oh
*'*N«i
«H
tlMCO^lO U5t— 00CJ5O HMMTflO CO t-
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
575
86 Lb RaiLs.
Yearns
Service
16
16
17
17
17
17
14
14
I41
14
If
15*
1*
II
(1
?i
7
Curve or
2°
2°
T
T
rt
2°8'
40'
£°ao
40* 2&o
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
High or
Low RaiL
H
L
L
M
L
H
L
L
H
H
Section
P R R
AS.
PRR
ASCE
rYa.iL
Number
1
8
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
13
»4
15
16
17
A^
B
B
A
A
A
L
L
L
L
L
A
B
A
L
L
L
Kl 50_
5 *,
-30
—
~
o
<: .to _
a.
—
—
---
—
—
—
X .-40.
5: «»
—
,£" l4QoOO_
to
' I20/ooo _
fc IOq«oo_
*
0-1 .6-
FIG. i.
576 RAIL.
brittle zone near the top of the ingot. In both Table I and Fig. i, I show
the probable ingot position of the rail as indicated by the etchings ; A
means the top rail of the ingot, B means the second rail, and L means
that the rail is probably from the lower part of the ingot.
The carbon results -are within the prescribed limits, or only a little
above, except in rail 5, which shows carbon .641 per cent. The phos-
phorus is above .10 per cent, in over half the cases, and in several of
them very much so, namely :
Rail 5 :i8o. per cent phosphorus
"' 4 156 " "
" 6 146 " " "
" 2 135 " "
These rails also show carbon above .55 per cent, and the etching
indicates them to be A rails except that rail 2 seems to be a B rail. The
manganese is pretty well within the specified limits, except that several
rails show a little below the minimum. The elongation in the eleven
rails of which tensile tests were made showed very well except in rails 12
and 14, which gave low elongations. The etchings indicate these to be
A rails.
Most of these rails would be called good commercial rails, and
although some of them come outside the specified limits for carbon and
phosphorus, there is not a sufficiently high combination of these elements
to result in very brittle or fragile material, except in rail 5 and possibly
also in rails 4 and 6. Unfortunately, no tensile tests were made on these
rails, but rail 5, at the location where the analysis was made, must, it
would seem, have been very brittle material, and would have been ex-
pected to result in a split head. According to the record, this rail was
in service on the low rail of a 2° 08' curve on the westbound track west
of Crestline, Ohio, for ten years, changed to the high side and left in
service for seven years more. The microphotographs show that at the
top of the head and 54 ni- below the top the metal is of low carbon, prob-
ably not over .35 or .40 per cent., although below this the metal is of high
carbon, as shown by the analysis, namely, .641 per cent, but still the rail
seems not to have flowed badly while on the inner side of the curve.
Whether this means that the rail was not subjected to very severe, or there
was some other reason for its long service, I cannot say.
On the high rail of a curve the rail seems not to be particular!}'
subject to failure, and in this connection the following figures will be
interesting. In Reports 12 and 13, covering studies of failed rails, Mr.
Gushing included 52 split Bessemer rails, and these were distributed as
follows :
Straight High Rail Low Rail
Line. of Curve. of Curve. Total.
25 rails 4 rails 23 rails 52 rails
48 per cent. 8 per cent. 44 per cent. 100 per cent.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS. 577
As to what the relative probability is of failure on straight line and
on curve, the above figures do not show, as we cannot say the number
of miles of track represented by the above failures, but they would seem
to indicate that the liability to failure is about 15 per cent on the high of
what it is on the low rail.
Conclusion. — This study indicates that the present specifications for
Bessemer rails are consistent with long service and that under some
conditions a segregated rail high in phosphorus, and possibly also carbon,
may give long service, although it does not define these conditions, either
of track or of material.
REPORTS OF INDIVIDUAL RAILS.
The rest of this report deals with statements concerning the indi-
vidual rails, photographs of sections etched with picric acid and five
microphotographs of each rail. The following abbreviations are used :
C = carbon.
P = phosphorus.
S = sulphur.
Mn = manganese.
Si = silicon.
E. L. = elastic limit.
T. S. = tensile strength.
Elong. = elongation.
Red. area = reduction of area
578
RAIL.
RAIL i.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled April, 1893,
heat 890. High rail of 2-degree curve, east of Highland, Pa., grade .87
per cent. In service 16 years. Rail was originally in eastbound track.
In 1904 this became eastbound freight track. Some of this rail still in track
in good condition. Speed on main track, 60 miles per hour. Speed on
freight track, 40 miles per hour.
C .475, Mn .85, P .127, Si .040, S .043.
Fig. 2. Rail i, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
579
Fig. 3. Rail i, at Top of Head.
Fig. 4. Rail i, *4 in- Below Top
Fig. 5. Rail i, }/i in. Below Top.
Fig. 6. Rail i, Va in. Below Top. Fig. 7- Rail i, i in. Below Top.
mlcrophotographs of rail i, magnified about 65 diameters-
i80
RAIL.
RAIL 2.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled December, 1892,
heat 4803. Low rail of 2-degree curve, east of Highland, Pa., grade .87 per
cent. In service 16 years. Rail originally in eastbound main track. In
1904 this became eastbound freight track. Some of this rail still in track
in good condition. Speed on main track, 60 miles per hour. Speed on
freight track, 40 miles per hour.
C .556, Mn 1.05, P .135, Si .090, S .050.
Fig. 8. Rail 2, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
581
Fig. g. Rail 2, at Top of Head. Fig. 10. Rail 2, l/i in. Below Top.
Fig. 11. Rail 2, ]/2 in. Below Top.
Fig. 12. Rail 2, 24 in. Below Top. Fig. 13. Rail 2, 1 in. from Top.
Microphotographs of Rail 2, Magnified About 65 Diameters.
582
RAfL
RAIL 3.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled August, [892.
heat 2753. On tangent, eastbound track, East Division, west of Crestline.
O. In service 17 years. Some still in track in good condition.
C .497, M'n 1.01, P .118, Si .076, S .031.
Fig. 14. Rail 3, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
583
yx ■ ■. y; t ■. j.\r-
*2» ^'■^h-^^.J-
Fig. is. Rail 3, at Top of Head. Fig. 16. Rail 3, J4 in. Below Top.
Fig. 17. Rail 3, >4 in. Below Top.
Fig. 18. Rail 3, %. in. Below Top. Fig. ig. Rail 3, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 3, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
584
RAIL.
RAIL 4.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled August, 1892,
heat 2764. On tangent, eastbound track, East Division, west of Crestline,
O In service 17 years. Some still in track in good condition.
C .560, Mn 1.04, P .156, Si .075, S .044.
Fig. 20. Rail 4, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
585
Fig. 21. Rail 4, at Top of Head. Fig. 22. Rail 4, % in. Below Top.
Fig. 23. Rail 4, l/2 in. Below Top.
^,^9$^>
/.■■■,'■■■
Fig. 24. Rail 4, 54 *N- Below Top. Fig. 25. Rail 4, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 4, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
586
RAIL.
RAIL 5.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled April, 1892,
heat 1872. High rail 2 degrees, 08 minute curve, East Division, west of
Crestline, O., westbound track. In service 17 years. Rail originally on low
side of curve, but was changed to high side, probably about 1903.
C .641, Mn .70, P .189, Si .051, S .053.
Fig. 26. Rail 5, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
587
Fig. 27. Rail 5, at Top of Head.
><$£^ ■
rt
4j#" ^1
j 1 ....^
Fig. 28. Rail 5, J4 in. Below Top.
I"
A
)«i
■*•
K 1
Fig. 29. Rail 5, J<£ in. Below Top.
Fig. 30. Rail 5, H in. Below Top. Fig. 31. Rail 5, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 5, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
588
RAIL.
RAIL 6.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled April, 1892,
heat 1894. High rail of 2 degrees, 08 minute curve, westbound track, East
Division, west of Crestline, O. In service 17 years. Rail was originally
on low side, but was changed to high side, probably about 1903.
C .591, Mn .69, P .146, Si .049, S .044.
Fig. i>2. Rail 6, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
589
'- ~%
Fig. 33. Rail 6, at Top of Head. Fig. 34. Rail 6, J4 in. Below Top.
Fig. 35. Rail 6, P2 in. Below Top.
Fig. 36. Rail 6, Ya in. Below Top. Fig. 37. Rail 6, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 6, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
590
RAIL.
RAIL 7.
Illinois 85-lb: P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled November, 1895,
heat 39420. Low rail of o degree, 40 minute curve, westbound track, West
Division, east of Valparaiso, Ind. In service 14 years.
C .452, Mn .87, P .098, Si .168, T. S. 112,120 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
71,470 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 20.5 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 37.39 per cent.
Fig. 38. Rail 7, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
591
^"^S
^¥
%^E£e?\
y&*&4
Fig. 39. Rail 7, at Top of Head. Fig. 40. Rail 7, % in. Below Top.
Fig. 41. Rail 7, ^ in. Below Top.
Fig. 42. Rail 7, ^ in. Below Top. Fig. 43. Rail 7, 1 in. Below Top.
Microphotographs of Rail 7, Magnified About 65 Diameters.
592
RAIL.
RAIL S.
Illinois 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled November, 1895,
heat 39503. Low rail of 2 degrees, 20 minute curve, West Division, east of
Valparaiso, Ind. In service 14 years, laid 1896.
C .489, Mn .96, P .ioi, Si .142, T. S. 121,240 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
70,900 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 18 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 37.59 per cent.
Fig. 44. Rail 8, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
593
Fig. 45. Rail 8, at Top of Head. Fig. 46. Rail 8, $4 in. Below Top.
Fig. 47. Rail 8, rA in. Below Top.
■■■■***»•■
V-«/^:;iL
Fig. 48. Rail 8, 54 in. Below Top. Fig. 49- Rail 8, 1 in. Below Top.
mlcrophotographs of rail 8, magnified about 65 diameters.
594
RAIL.
RAIL g.
Illinois 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled November, 1895,
heat 39420. High rail of o degree, 40 minute curve, westbound track, West
Division, east of Valparaiso, Ind. In service 14 years, laid 1896.
C .480, Mn .91, P .102, Si .163, T. S. 116,450 lbs. per sq. in., E. L
74,940 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 18.5 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 31.74 per cent.
y I ■
J^***.,
r
Fig. 50. Rail 9, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS
595
Fig. si. Rail g, at Top of Head.
Fig. 52. Rail g, % in. Below Top.
Fig. S3. Rail g, Yz in. Below Top.
Fig. 54. Rail g, $4 in. Below Top. Fig. 55. Rail g, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL g, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
596
RATL.
RAIL so.
Illinois 85-lb. P. R. R. section bessemer steel, rolled November, 1895,
heat 39513. High rail of 2 degrees, 20 minute curve, westbound track, West
Division, east of Valparaiso, Ind. In service 14 years, laid 1895.
C .478, Mn 1.01, P .097, Si .149, T. S. 117,580 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
66,230 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 19 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 30.11 per cent.
Fig. 56. Rail 10, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
597
Fig. 57. Rail 10, at Top of Head. Fig. 58. Rail 10, ^4 IN- Below Top.
Fig. 59. Rail 10, l/2 in. Below Top.
Fig. 60. Rail 10, YA in. Below Top. Fig. 61. Rail 10, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 10, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
598
RAIL.
RAIL n.
Carnegie 85-lb. A. S. C. E. section, heat 10639, rolled March, 1899.
Laid May, 1899, on straight line, and removed August 4, 1910. In service
11 years.
C .579, Mn 1.04, P .094, Si .149. T. S. 121,650 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
88,840 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 16 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 22.21 per cent.
Fin. 62. Rail ii, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
599
Fig. 63. Rail ii, at Top of Head. &H Fig. 64. Rail ii, J4 in- Below Top.
Fig. 65. Rail ii, 14 in. Below Top.
V"\
'- ■>«: ■-*■•♦*-
.,*: -y v ■ :
*\-<r>
'XU^ _•/.
T^^fe
Fig. 66. Rail ii, ?4 in. Below Top. Fig. 67. Rail ii, i in. Below Top.
mlcrophotographs of rail ii, magnified about 65 diameters.
600
RAIL.
RAIL 12.
Illinois, South Works, 85-lb. P. R. R. section, rolled in November,
1894. Laid January, 1895, on straight line, removed July 18, 1910. In
service iSjA years.
C .476, Mn 1.06, P .091, Si .133, T. S. 113,450 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
82,160 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 6.5 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 4.75 per cent.
Fig. 68. Rail 12, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
601
Fig. 69. Rail 12, at Top of Head. Fig. 70. Rail 12, J4 in. Below Top.
Fig. 71. Rail 12, Yt. in. Below Top.
' 4*$jL
• ■ ™ ■ "'■
•
•yl$|r
Fig. 72. Rail 12, % in. Below Top. Fig. 73- Fail 12, 1 in. Below Top.
Microphotographs of Rail 12, Magnified About 65 Diameters.
602
RAIL.
RAIL 13.
Carnegie 85-lb. P. R. R. section, rolled December, 1892. Laid Janu-
ary, 1893, on straight line, removed July 26, 1910. In service 17V2 years.
C .493, Mn 1.06, P .126, Si .149, T. S. 116,510 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
79,720 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 18 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 26.39 per cent.
Fig. 74. Rail 13, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
60c
Fig. 75. Rail 13, at Top of Head. Fig. 76. Rail 13, J4 in. Below Top.
Fig. 77. Rail 13, 14 in. Below Top.
Fig. 78. Rail 13, Y\ in. Below Top. Fig. 79. Rail 13, 1 in. Below Top.
Microphotographs of Rail 13, Magnified About 65 Diameters.
604
RAIL.
RAIL 14.
Carnegie 85-lb. A. S. C. E. section, rolled March, 1899. Laid April,
1899, on straight line, removed March, 1910. In service 11 years.
C .591, Mn .78, P .119, Si .079, T. S. 117,540 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
78,730 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 4 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 5.57 per cent.
Fig. 80. Rail 14, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
605
Fig. 8i. Rail 14, at Top of Head. Fig. 82. Rail 14, % in. Below Top.
Fig. 83. Rail 14, *A in. Below. Top.
Fig. 84 Rail 14, yi in. Below Top. Fig. 85. Rail 14, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 14, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
006
RAIL.
RATL 15.
Carnegie 85-lb. A. S. C. E. section, rolled March 1899. Laid May, 1899,
on straight line; removed July 29, 1910. In service 11 years.
C .558, Mn .96, P .101, Si .118, T. S. 118.440 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
83,850 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 15 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 19 per cent.
Fig. 86. Rail 15, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
607
Fig. 87. Rail 15, at Top of Head. Fig. 88. Rail 15, % in. Below Top.
Fig. 89. Rail 15, y2 in. Below Top.
Fig. 90. Rail 15, 24 in. Below Top. Fig. 91. Rail 15, 1 in. Below Top.
Microphotographs of Rail 15, Magnified About 65 Diameters.
608
RAIL.
RAIL 16.
Carnegie 85-lb. A. S. C. E. section, rolled November, 1902. Laid
August, 1903, on straight line ; removed August 19, 1910. In service 7
years.
C .515, Mn 1 .08, P .113, Si .135, T. S. 117,580 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
85,580 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 18.5 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 28.43 per cent.
Fig. 92. Rail i6, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
609
A /"*> '-If* M
& i a.
Fig. 93. Rail 16, at Top of Head. Fig. 94. Rail 16, ^4 in. Below Top.
Fig 95. Rail 16, V2 in. Below Top.
M'«mrJr&:,
Fig. 96. Rail 16, 54 in. Below Top. Fig. 97. Rail 16, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL l6, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
610
RAIL.
RAIL 17.
Carnegie 85-lb. A. S. C. E. section, rolled January, 1903. Laid Feb-
ruary, 1903, on straight line ; removed August 20, 1910. In service 7 years.
C .476, Mn .79, P .096, Si .056, T. S. 102,900 lbs. per sq. in., E. L.
74,940 lbs. per sq. in., elong. 23.5 per cent, in 2 in., red. area 38.82 per cent.
Fig. 98. Rail 17, Etched with Picric Acid.
A STUDY OF GOOD SERVICE RAILS.
611
Fig 99. Rail 17, at Top of Head. Fig. 100. Rail 17, % in. Below Top.
Fig. ioi. Rail 17, y2 in. Below Top.
Fig. 102. Rail 17, 54 in. Below Top. Fig. 103. Rail 17, 1 in. Below Top.
MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS OF RAIL 17, MAGNIFIED ABOUT 65 DIAMETERS.
Appendix B.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE IV— ON RAIL.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
The Committee on Rail submits, for your information, the Rail Fail-
ure Statistics for the year ending October 31, 1910. The work of col-
lecting and compiling these statements, as well as the study of the sta-
tistics, was done by Mr. Cushing. The work entailed in compiling and
digesting the statistics is quite large. After the receipt of the various
reports, a great deal of correspondence was necessary to supply small
omissions or clear up uncertainties, all of which required time, with the
result that it has taken until the middle of June to finish the work.
The Committee decided not to publish all of the detail statements
submitted. These can be secured, upon request to the Secretary, by any-
one desiring to make use of them.
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS FOR ONE YEAR ENDING
OCTOBER 31, 1910.
The responses to the American Railway Engineering Association
circular have been much more complete than before and show that the
majority of the railroads are now keeping a record of their rail failures.
Answers were received from 125 companies, 42 of whom either have no
information to furnish or the reports were too incomplete to be of any
service. Eighty-three companies furnished statistics of failures relating
to 11,759,039 tons of rail.
The report consists of the following divisions :
(1) A tabulation of the information received from each company, pp.
1 to 63.
(2) A summary by sections, weights and kinds of steel, pp. 64 to 71.
(3) A tabulation of data for Diagrams 1 to 5, pp. 72 to 86.
(4) A report of failures classified according to the position in the ingot,
pp. 87 to 141.
(5) A report on the comparative wear of special rails, pp. 142 to 162.
(6) Diagrams 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5, showing the comparison of failures
graphically for different studies.
These details will not be printed with this dige§t, but can be pro-
cured from the Secretary by anyone desiring them,
613
614
RAIL.
c
■aE
td
a
mti a
it
ft
=3
&
2
c =
3 a>
cUcO
to
•eg
B
c c ,, S
03
O
oi
0
1I|i
u.
3^2
S.S
03 =>,2 03
'3
.3.S°8.E
So g o3'E r
1 ,3'3 8'E
^QhPj^! S C
O c
6 >>ft B
00|0
mS
c
» - ^ -
0
X
c
5
X
C
c
c
I
P-
1
c
c
X
u
c
£
1 =
c
C
a
E
ft
7
c
Eh
c
c
ft
E
0
>
0
0
-; —
5 :
2
cs cj
11
s
%
At
c
c
PC
0 c
020:
-
1
2
C
o
10 m
CN
to
m
—
0
0
a.
ti
t>.
o
a
—
c;
onoc
DQ
O
*-< <N
<M
01
N C
N c
c-i
a
a
— —
0
0
oooooooo»oooo
ja
ffl c
ooc
C -c
^ OS
— . :/:
:i /:
CI
a>
00
O
rH
«
-
-1
•*
rt
rt
w
"-1
-1
■T3
-
00
-
:^
00 0
O C
a
02
ft
r -
0 c
0
>o
cocoiocoeo-^poooccooer
o
ia -r
ujTfw:
«©•«*
lO CD
IQ -1-
IC ■*
-*
0
c
C3
*o 0
t4
oof
oc
»o 0 't c
—
'T4 a: O CN
•OC
c,7
•T
9sio7
rorogc-
22c
cr
-
^c
Ph
'^ c
a
—
*H
"H
a)
E
of
B
2
0
>
r
1
C
E
'5
c
x
c
">
>-
r
E
-£
r
•E
'c
E
'S
1
D it
'e
E
c,
1
) V
"c
.8
c
c
a
I
%
e
1
c
E
r
|
a
S
0
c
1
1
_; c
E —
'c
SSC
HP
Izsk
c
S5SC
ChH
<-
.-
4
mOww
o>
ED
t- u
0 a 0 c
O
E £ £
f=F
F
ESSE
-
SEEE
at
yt:
fc
fe
asss
c
00c
8) C
a
r r c -
O 03 O C
S S S m
O CD Q> a
0 a
O 8
c
0
O 0) 0) 0)
mfflo:
«ff
PC
pppppppc
IS
cscafflc:
pace
pqp:
PC
PC
ffiEPMPQ
g
o
-<PQp£
pp<
PC
WW
l1*?"?^
w>
B
B
£
B
HS
<<c
<<
<
do
<<<«c
OC
OC
C
C
OO
o
02
P^PhCC
£p:
pq
02 cocoa:
CO
pjtfp^a
03 CC
ma:
cc
a,
02 QQ 02 CO
<■<<
«
<
0«!<P-
ft
<<<;<<
-<<:
«
<
<
^«<00
OC
OC
c
e
0 0 »o »o
-2 t-
OC
3
C53 00 00 0C
00 00000c
£s
»
1
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS.
615
CO
f
3
■3
so
g
s
o
H
=8
c
T3
3
c
c
o
e
O
3>
a
3
Q
&
a
0
9
c3
a
3
►2 =8
Z .2
=8o
IS
O
•8 o
0)
=3
a
B
M
23
T3
•w
&
■a
c
(3
>
a
h
o
33 &
C3
a
O
'3
a
ja
1
c
a
o
(LI
0
S
o
0
s
B
M
O
s
n
o
3
o
«8
a
o
a
"a
os
an
M
o m
bo a
c3>
■a
o
03
id
J3
-C CD
ja
O
33
«
ffl
B
Hi
u
a
s
OH
CM
fc
M
c
o o
£ 5 ^
1 1 85
D w w
O <! < O O O
-2S
o o>
|'S6
Ph-S'S
|p333
$3333
1£s
£0
00*00*00*000
O 0*0 O -* *0 *0
0000*00*00*000 000000 • 00000*000000000000000000 £2r^rt! '2312!
3§OONONONOM O OS QO -h F^ O • t^ O IK 00 0« 35*- 06*- 0«0 0**0 CB !©Q« OB CO C» 00 ^ ^ °°. ! ^ ^ ^
OS CO OS ■ *o
CM O CO -^ O
000 • o — •
<M*ococ©ioo*oo<N*oeNiioaseNiioiococo • coco*ocn*oo*ocococo ^^^^^^S^^S^^^^^S iSSS
Ba£>CCNO00O00<DN«l>10i>l0OCDN • CO r— o CO t- l^ 00 co t— CO *0 t- *o O *o CO iO r- *o t- CO t- co t— 00 • "<r *o CD
^ __, _« ^-, *-t O
OOO O O OJO ZJ> 1 ^— '
OS OS OS OS
o 01 O 01 OS o
—1 o — « o o ~^
OS OS OS OS OS OS
33
33
:33
33
33
33 :
33
33
§33
33
33
33
=8
=8
£^
c
=8
a
0
i
.S
=«
=8
E
1
1
| 1
.i i
°3^
X
: 1
'5 ">
>
, 0
—
c
7
S C oq O
n e-i h
"o »
OH
O ^ C3 a> ,^ ^ r^ --
aatnKaKMWW
000000000
"Em Em
c3 03 C3 «
aaaaaaaaa
00000000
< < < << Wh H
< «sj •<! <<! <)o o
33 33 33 3333 33co 05 0
a W H H
dodo
hh a
dd d
Z Z ai ai co m aj coco cdco33
-< «< <i< << <JOOO<!«i!<J-«)ai <J<! <<0<3
o 00 00 o
00 CO 00
00 iomo
616
RAIL.
1
■A
6
c
O
^
•-»
2
o
c
s
1
6
a.
iJ
<c
3
■s
E
i
.S
h3
o
Ti
s
S5 i
1
o
'3
pq-
i
a
<3
o
E
c
S
CO
=3 d
• Pi
. J3
i
v.
. c
tfPM
p
fa
o
a
O if)
. »
.►J
O s!
2 1
'•3
*^
c
PQ
o
PC
E
._
o
PJ.2
*2
fiP
a o
.2 a I
0
03
S a
~ -
.«
n
s
U
o
(J
'/
u
pq
0
PL.&
P3
UPm
PhU
WOO
+3
§
C m
1]
11
13
X
w
X
a
—
-d
-3
pq
-TJT3
a
S3
0
g
—
8> •?
J3 w
<D 05 SI
W M u ,- -
o3 o3 ct <J
.« .US .* „
J2=3 -rj
esO
e3 °<
a
a
3>i
d> . — o
£
fao. Q.Q. t-D-Cl.**
O
CO
a.
a
pq
CO
pq
pq
pq
CO
pqcq
O
pqco
coco
pqco co P3
a
o
<M
■O"
CO
!5
'55
2
e»
US
£1
GO
o
oo
o
o
a
o
"3
a
s
c
c
c
_
c
c
ooc
mo
»OOOoOOO O !>■ O
GO
ocmo
eq cj
l»
(M
ci
<N
Tl
CJ
-him
O0<l
a
a -
a -
o a
a us
■a a
a e
ooo
ooc
>MO
oo«o
o »o o o »o U5 >o
O
*
c
OlOlOO O CO
8
©
a
GO
fc
o
7
~
oo
o-<
oo
O
: a.
CC T
■a -*
u~ S
--3 -i-
»o -r
io 5
IQ -r
U5 IC
o»o»c
tO-*u
5 kO •«* lO -^ -^
»T3 -^i to lO CO >0 t—
t~
o
t^
oc
c
OJ 00
fa
(3
s
1
7
T
1
c
c
1
3
OE
E
-
Vr
1
Y7
CO<T
2 g 2
o 2 o
a
a
c~
oocr
Ci
CiO
»-( ^
^H
*-»•-
t-l «-4
fa
s
03
CO
3
E
(i
c
E
a
P
<
1
a
=
03 m
S
a
a
c
a
03 ol
03
■R
i T
1) «
°K
P
i
0 tub
ill
03 03 O
•J O Q
"3
9
E
a
E
-
!
i
Jt
Jtt
b^ S
3S
= c
. 03
e
i
7
-
!=
« 03 C3
H) e
O
PC
C.
L
> C.
1-
L
H
tj
ShJ O
P5L
oc;
o"aJ
coo
: "3
o
: !S
01
s
in o
s
fflg
Si?
i i i w
<
<
I
IB <
<u
'. <
(D '
<b a>
pq
c
> PC
ft
1 ff
pt
ft
PC
PC
ft
PQff
PQ
OP
PQff
) pq pq O
pa
p
5 t
3 C
r -
: &
1 &
3 P=
3 &
5 &
3 :&
3 i
a
: w&
J W W H
o
<
<
« C
> «*
i C
C
> C
) C
) C
) C
) PJC
i <:
o
: OC
) o o o
o
s
CO
PS
p
5 a
3 P
3 a
i o
i v
j a
5 a
5 a
j pja
5 Ph
CQ0
> cQcy
2 CO CO CO
<
*■
1 <
5 C
) -a
; <
J <
I -
1 <
J <
J Ph<I
: <
<a
^ <<
1 <! <! <J
if org
; oc
> o
0>i-
i mit
> o o o
o
a
a
3 o
c
J
> t-
t>
a
oa
No. of
Failures
per 10,000
Tons Laid
> c%a
> t^
oa
•> MO
> CO -*< CO
:
3 t^.
CO
o
1 D
1 c-
1 T
1 c
B
3 r
* U
3 «
•> t*
> a
c
»■
1 CO
h i-'
"-
r-
a
3 a
c
>
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS.
617
_j
od
OC
CD
>->
K
s
&
Es
m
a
o
O
00
«§ 5
h)
-*
n
>i
cq
00
o CO
cd J4
•a
3
C
a
P-
c
(-
a
— *» >>
O . 02 .2
« 1 >
QJ O J3
i-3 «
=3 o
3 a
ng Valle
li Valley
Lines—
h. Valley
Pacific.
Lines—
&S. F.
lia.
em Paci
ng & La
are & B
Pacific.
3 Centra
hore&M
Trunk.
■& a
ra J -
S a -c
w -o
c
iz
d^3 2 -2 » <» o a 9 '3 .2 9H^-S 5 » ^ .2 §8 S
-
4 4 4
T3 -a
a
iw a
£
-
a
cr
n ~
T
9
>s
T3 -C
■C
~
m 1ST
SWtr
a * g § -s
b! fcl &
o o Sf
■e -a 3
S
g
3
0,1—
O —
<-
s
■J
a
*
H
cc
a tr
■w ■*-
W tr
"2 '**■
c3 •
c3ja j:
^ 2 ° ° s
Is °8 & & *
k
P-
Mac
CC
(1
^
a
a
' ft
L
a
00 OC
w a
cqoo PC
m Pc
P=l OC
oo oo pq
10
>c
.-
lO
c
o
O
o
c
c
c
a
o
e
o
CO
o
1Q
o 3
C) CI
ci
o
Cl Cl
o
C! 7
IM
c
Cl
c
c
c
OS3
O C
S3 C
IOC
>o c
oc
OK5
»o cc
o
OC
o
oc
o —
oc
cl oc
— X
C i V
f\ s
►H 0(
a
o —
-HCO^H
c
<r
a
e
C
c
c
o
a
K
o
o
o
—
o
O
O
-
ui
W
lO
o
cz
o
cc
oo>*
«* re
oo a
O IC
not-
I- -
oio
oo
lO
IOC
M >C
IOC
no
r/3-f
o -+
• o -t-
m -i-
■^lO
iOcou"
>o iO «o
oc
X
a
a
o
o
03
03
OS
-o
1
cc
cc
I
i
<o
cm.
a
oa
o
1
Y
CI
C
A
BO
c->
2
00
a
93
o
—
_j
1
1
T
C
T
2
=
o:
a
~
OS
C5
CC
Oi
ca
>
»
cS
aj
s
a
£
i
a
OB
1
c*
>
<n
E
d
=
B
B
C
^
°c
B
t
E
1 b
a
B
2
1
E
a
c
1
■a
i
'c
c
b
C
1 b
c
■
'c
J
c
b
0
f
b
a
E
'3
i
a
o
S
S3
-5
a
a
-
r—
L
C
pq
M
u
h-i
u
>
K
u
U
u
u
h-1
(J
u
a
U
3
t-5
■ Q
H
0
0
a
a
tr
a
0
a
0
o
j« tr
a
0
tr
J
0
3
a
0
a
1
0
cr
3
D
n
w
ft
cc
&
c
cc
PO
PC
tapq
&
cc
C
PQ
PC
pq
Ch
cq
pq
CC
pq
CC
pq
ca
pq
o
H
H
w
w
W
a
a
W
w
W
<5
<j
K
H
W
H
H
H
«
m
O
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
O
O
o
O
O
O
O
o
00
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
CO
DC
oo
OO
PC
Pi
00
oo
00
00
00
od
00
a
od
<
<
«!
<!
«*
<!
O
<
<
O
P^
<
O
<!
<J
<4
<
<!
<
<;
<4
O
<
<
1C
a
a
a
o
a
o
o
o
o
o
o
to
■n
0
oc
at
cc
cr
—
—
a
a
OS
OS
oc
03
00
CO
00
03
OS
CTi
00
93
O
oo
t~
CO
t^
-*
—
x
in
»Q
-f>
CI
s
DO
-f
cc
eci
i-C
o
o
O
03
03
OS
03J
CO
o
CO
r^-
CO
0B
o
CM
cc
-r
»o
CO
Cl
c
CM
cc
CO
CC
CC
00
CC
*
■*
-r
■<#
■*
618
RAIL.
DQ ^
d
O
6
4
ias? i i ^
£fi § 1 ^
sS^ a a /
O
s
3
3, ;!, , | '■*
3 K
•3 i-i
h3
a
o
"3
c
<y pc
°3 ^
a
|
a ■» =5 ^
=3 » >
°3
,d £ M <3 03 "c
*
PC
« 3 .
" s |
J3 (-
3
gj'!
el
PC
r
-
F-
o .1:
3 C
ta
c
0
Sx C
o
reQ^
Ph Pi <_
<
>
L
L
O H
P
c
PQ P
hQ c
CQ
+3
TO CO
.3 9
X
T
c:
T
T
s
■5
t:
T
• X
m'T
« tr
-
*
t
w .
tr
P
„
•0
\ cc
a =
,45 S[r
c
f-
C
«5 l&
e3 ^=
h u
o c
B
die
caja-<-
M r-
CO
«
<
K
«fe
*
Jl
=8 "S
*
•k
OS "«
tj
a
-
c
0> Tj'~
o
Cm
reCQC
DC
a.
PI
l»
re
a,
p
03 ff
re
re
CQUre
PQ 03
PQ
0
a
P.
n
03
ooo
IB
"-
-So
oo
C
C
o
O
1"
i
1
DD
•CS
CM
<N
c
CJ C
*"H
NO-io
ON-
CS CM CN
IM cs
CN
0000000000"OCMOO»OOOOOOCMOOOOOOO
O
£
CI c
cm
00
— X
iH X
:i /:
rH _
^h oo Oi 00 <M OC
i— i CO OS OC
-HOO-h
a
—
~
C
—
C
~
o c
-* c
o
0)
Ph
c
c
a
03
a
00 IB
IB ^
oe ic
ONCOiOiflfc
OO CC CO
o
•■«*
u: -?■
«3 -r
OTf
e
OC
a
OS o-
=
o
w;
u
05 *? 7
<=
'T
o
c
o o
2 3
§
-
<c
c
s
-
-
io a-
o o-
C
s
2 S
o
-
H *""
^^
s>
! e3
OS
3
03
_a
a
B
E
_e
T
—
E
.s
DL
«
a
a
a
a e
. -0 S
3
8
c3
&
3
!&*
c
a
B
1
^
-
E
c
B
£
a
F
e c
J J<
Ai
0
D
—
o
0
» cj
sS^
<_
C
M
h-
(_.
~
fe
O C
L
L.
O C
PQ i-C
J
o'©
-5
cm
Kg?
i i
■HWsr
M
0
a
a
a
a
o a
o
OPQP
PC
cc
P
co
PC
PQ
ffi
PQ P
PC
P
PQ P
ZOP
CQ
<wpq
H
R
H
m
K
O
W
H
P
H
W W
w w
w
§
<dc
C
C
C
c
C
c
C
<c
U
O C
o o
o
a
DQ
#03 03
re
re
03
03
re
CQ
cc
03 K
Pi
re
re re
03 03
re
^<<<
-«!
<
0
0
<
O
<
O <l
<!
<!
<! -^
< <
<
OOC
ira o
o
m
lO o
o o
caoo cr
c
c
-
00
OC
oo
-
•XS
o. of
0,000
s Lai
HffiC
l-~ cc
■t
■<t
CO CM
-H o
oo
OiOOCC
OC
OC
0C
X
r~ t-
t^ t~
•7 aj'-1 O
N
lO cc
r*
cc
Oi o
*-l CM
CO
4 r*
<*
-I
<r
IC
"■
>c
u-
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS.
619
Pi
<
>
•w
tfbi
c
.a o
.2'J2
a a
=> O
-
sa
1
CO tCZ
cj o
P* •
gtf
5 «
* -8
o pq o cq
s§ -a -3
S CQ CQ
O -13 to
fc> Z 0 co %
a
Ji -sal*
»«8 =3
■w°8
CQ CO DQ PQ 00 CO X CQ O X X
K ffi
s w s
Or> be oj) ,~
o jj d 33
o <t> —
U X CQ X XXCQCQ CO
^ ^3 T3 bO bO
fin X X CQ CQ
o> o> jj ._;
o
O
o
=8
=8
°8
X
a
/
a
X
^- — — — CM .-< M CM
'/: r? o co i-H
O ^ Tl O O
^h ^h CM ONM Ol ~h tM (M
o o a o c a la
00HO>H«rt©
OWNCCOO
t>. 00 O GO CM GO i— t 00 •— t CO »-i CO •-< 00 *-t O
^- O O ^H »-. ^H O ^h O
- cs co o as
O fH W rH
OiOO COO COcO*OtOtO»OiOiO
Tt<ioo vio -^ l': t m Tf io t io
'f iO c: d to O 03 O
tOCO'rfiO^cO-^iO
aa cocoooioioooocx co co co
CO TjiiOTj<tO-*?itOiOCO-^r»-Tp ^iq^i
o ^ cs X; £;
1-H O O ^~H
II II
■* «-i GO CCi
oo ao
i T
^H -H O —
I I I §
o o o 2
s 5
=5 01
O CQ
'5> * s- fe
'a b 5 S
3 2 C-«
J hJ o o oh oj
O O =3 kQ O PQ O
©fljoSSSSooj*- 35 53 35 <5 53 53 '• 55ci533ci5a5<i5a5<S
CC CQ CQCC CQ CQ PQ CQ CQO PQCQ « ffl ffl CQO CQCQpQPQCQpqpqcq
s
H :
H
o
<i
o>>
o
CO
=8
CQ
cc-a
. 3
CO
<
QO
oo
occo
oo
a
CQ
W :
HH
H
H
H
o
<!
O :
OO
O
O
O
X
«
88 X
ccco
X
X
X
<j
<
<JPh
<<
<
-«)
<)
<j
<<
H
H
W
<<
^
d
>> :
d
d
T
tf
Pi
CO K
=3 ^
CO
CO
OP-l<i«i<dQO«i^
CO 5C CO
co -o CO
o >o oo
CiGO GOCS
tO «5iC *C *0 *0 "O
CM CO -rpiO CO
io »o to to
iO ~4 CN CO
•CO OOCOCOGOCOGOCOG©
620 RAIL.
In Vol. 12, Part 2, page 143, et seq., will be found the drawings of
nearly all of the rail sections referred to, an effort having been made to
make this collection of drawings as complete as possible, for future refer-
ence.
GENERAL SUMMARY (PP. I TO 63).
In considering the statistics as tabulated, all lots of less than 1,000
tons have been ignored, as they usually lead to exaggerated results.
The number of failures range from o to 1129 per 10,000 tons of new
rail laid.
There were no failures reported for the various lots of rail listed in
Table 1.
It will be noticed, however, that nearly all of these lots are of the
years 1909 and 1910, the rail being thus too new to have begun failing.
In the few cases where the rail is of an earlier date, it is quite likely
that the poor rails have already been weeded out.
In addition to the above, there are many lots in which there was only
one failure, or even but two or three, but to have listed them also would
have required too much space.
For these various lots, the prescribed chemical constituents run about
as follows :
For P. .10 the C. runs from .43 to .58.
For P. .085 the C. runs from .55 to .65.
For P. .06 the C. runs from .55 to .68.
For P. .04 the C. runs from .63 to .76, and even .80.
For P. .03 the C. runs from .70 to .85.
The 1 129 failures per 10,000 tons were of the 90-lb. A.S.CE.
chromium-nickel rail of the year 1909, on the Central Railroad of New
Jersey, the chemical composition of which is not given. The rate of
failure is higher than ever, and it will be found on page 61 that 70 per
cent, of them were breakages and nearly all the rest split heads. The
failures are characteristic of this product, the breakages occurring from
hair-line cracks, and the "split heads" being longitudinal seams instead of
the usual split head. After the first shower after being laid, dark purple
stains appear.
In Table 2 the maximum number of failures in diminishing order
down to 50 have been listed for convenience in studying the effect of the
specified chemical composition, and Table 1 should be considered in con-
nection with it.
We are forced to conclude, after an examination of both tables, that
the specified chemical composition does not account for all the differ-
ences, although it undoubtedly has its effect and must be kept within
certain limits in order to prevent disastrous results.
For instance, why were there fewer failures of 90-lb. A.R.A.-B
Cambria rail (No. 57) on the Baltimore & Ohio, or of 100-lb. A.R.A.-B
Carnegie (71) on the Bessemer & Lake Erie, than of 100-lb. A.R.A.-B
Carnegie rail (1) of the same specified composition on the Baltimore
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS. 621
& Ohio? It is considered possible that the failures of Baltimore & Ohio
No. I might be due to a small discard, as low as 5 per cent., as a very
large percentage occurred in "A" rails.
Again, is C. .65 to .80 too high when P. is .04 for the 90-lb. A.R.A.-B
Bethlehem rail (2) on the Baltimore & Ohio? We cannot tell, because
there are considerably fewer failures in the case of the 90-lb. A.S.C.E.
Bethlehem (24) on the Lehigh Valley, with C. .70 to .80 and P. .04, and
indeed with the same composition the Baltimore & Ohio had no failures
of their 100-lb. A.R.A.-B Bethlehem and Cambria rails, in Table 1. In
the case of the Lehigh Valley, a possible explanation is that their discard
was from 15 to 20 per cent.
The failures of 85-lb. P. S. Gary, Nos. 31 and 73, on the Pennsyl-
vania Lines, have been traced in almost every instance to the former
practice of protecting the ingot stools with scrap material, and it has
been found since the practice was stopped, in 1909, that the number of
failures has been greatly reduced. The experience with the Gary rail
on the Union Pacific, the Southern Pacific, and the Rock Island Lines
has been precisely the same.
In the case of Nos. 5, 7 and 12 on the Big Four, Northern Pacific
and Union Pacific, respectively, breakages were the most predominant
kinds of failures, being 90-lb. A.S.C.E. Carnegie rail, 85-lb. A.S.C.E.
Carnegie rail and 80-lb. A.S.C.E. Lackawanna rail, and the question
naturally arises: Is it due to the high specified carbon .50 to .60?
Breakages are also predominant in 8 and 9, in the case of 75-lb. A.S.C.E.
Illinois rail on the Chicago, Indianapolis & Louisville Railway and of
75-lb. B.&M. Lackawanna rail on the Boston & Maine, with much lower
carbon specified. Furthermore, in the case of the St. Louis & San Fran-
cisco No. 87, 85-lb. A.S.C.E. Illinois rail and Union Pacific No. 84, 90-lb.
C.S. Illinois rail, we have a low number of breakages with the same
specified high carbon.
Central Railroad of New Jersey No. 22, 90-lb. A.S.C.E. Carnegie rail
is very high in hardeners, C. .54 to .64 and Mn. 1.05 to 1.30, and has a
pretty considerable number of failures, but not as many as in the case of
others with lower hardeners, such as Chicago, Indianapolis & Louisville
No. 8, 75-lb. A.S.C.E. Illinois, C. .40 to .50 and Mn. .75 to 1.05.
However, where breakages are predominant, they are found to be in
most cases of the higher specifications for carbon, .48 to .58 and .50 to .60
in the case of Bessemer rail, while it is not so pronounced in the case of
Open-Hearth. It may possibly be considered, therefore, that those are a
little beyond the limits for P. .10.
It is difficult to understand why breakages are prevalent in the case
of Central Railroad of New Jersey No. 14, 90-lb. A.S.C.E. Bethlehem
Open-Hearth, with C. .57 and P. .031, unless it is the difficulty usually
experienced by a mill when just beginning a new process of manufacture.
On page 71 is a condensed summary for all rail, which shows very
clearly the superiority of Open-Hearth over Bessemer steel. The average
number of failures per 10,000 tons of new rail laid for Open-Hearth is
622
RAIL.
S3
3
OSO
©
OS ©
OSO
OSO
o
OSO
o
©l-H
O-H
O^H
O— i
O^H
OS OS
3S
OS OS
OS OS
OS OS
OS
OS OS
OS
W
CM CO
CO«ti
CO *o
COO
CM
u
d
M
Jj
03
ft
<u
03
PQ
•
H|nHr,
HH
H*
t- OS
CM
coos
00<N
lO CO
o
9
«
H
00(N
wo
OSi-H
OS CM
C^i-I
O
<D
^
J3
s
'3
_3
ft
'3
^3
ft
£
•^ OS
o*
CO Oj
COlO
coco
01
03
+5
m
O
E-i
*5
CD
t>0
o3
e
co
W
O CO
O CO
CO CO
o-^
o
■^»o
io -<f
coco
CO -^
CO
g
CO
o
ta
a>
ft
J3
03
'3
ft
*
T3
03
O
0)
«
.fl
00^.
^ CO
OS CO
CO b-
1-H os
00 *
CO
W3 Tfl
GO
t^.iC
COLO
t- CO
CM
UO T*
CO
GO
pq
V
3
5)
ft
«
OS CO
-* 00
HO -^
IC
CO CO
<N<N
o
a
a>
,«
g
ft
O "■**
m
t^T*
COO
»bco
OS
CO 05
*#
(M CO
HN
~HCO
^w
CM CO
W5
ft
1
"S
Tj
■g
^_
a
-C
'1
u
0
a
o
*n
o
*o
o
oo
*o
b
'8
o
OS
OS
CO
CO
►J
3
w
H
<!
3
0
2;
<n .
< 5
ft ^
ft d
a |
3 z
p ft
H m
ft §
O 2
u ft
< H
*•«
2 02
O W
M PJ
ft S
02 <i
*ft|
£ fe I
ft °
# ft
w s
^ 3 I
Q &
ft*
O ft
£5
§3
o ft
ft ^
£°
□Q Q
ft «
o%
ft «
ft .
Q
w
o
W5
d
C.S.
Lacka.
A. S. C. E.
CD
Mo. P.
P. R. R.
B.&M.
A. S. C. E.
C.S.
•
o
CO
d
ft
A. R. A.-A.
Dudley
A. S. C. E.
Camb.
CO
d
A. S. C. E.
P. S.
A. R. A.-A.
Mo. P.
Q.
ft
Mo. P.
P. R. R.
P. S.
A. S. C. E.
Q.
A. R. A.-A.
o
d
S. F.
G. N.
A. R. A.-A.
A. R. A.-B.
C.S.
D. L. & W.
A. S. C.E.
03
ft
A. R. A.-A.
G. N.
D. L. &W.
A. S. C. E.
C.S.
A. R. A.-B.
o
ft
d
A. R. A.-B.
A. R. A.-A.
P. &R.
A. S. C. E.
Dudley.
P. S.
N. Y. N. H. & H.
P. R. R.
OJ
ft
N. Y. N. H. &H.
A. R. A.-B.
P. S.
P. R. R.
A. R. A.-A.
P. & R.
A. S. C. E.
Dudley
*-<CNicOT*iosor~oo
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS. 623
iiy2, as against 33 for Bessemer. In this table the alloys do not show
to very good advantage, but upon examination in detail it will be found
that the poor results are due to special cases.
Examining the details of this same table, the kinds of failures are
classified as follows, and a comparison with the six months ending Octo-
ber 31, 1909, is given, taken from the previous report :
One Year Ending Six Months End-
Oct. 31, 1910. ing Oct. 31, 1909.
"Broken" 2914% 19%
Head failures 5554% 66y2%
Web failures 7% Sy2%
Base failures &l/2% 6%
The above are subdivided as follows in Table 3 for the different
weights of rail and between Bessemer and Open-Hearth steel, the com-
parison being also given for the 1909 period :
Breakages form a larger percentage than before and are largest for
100-lb. Bessemer, except in the case of 72-lb. and 78-lb. This may be
due to a difference in classification, as the head failures are fewer. The
web failures have rather diminished, while the base failures have increased
in some cases and diminished in others. As to which failures predom-
inate, as between Bessemer and Open-Hearth, there is not much differ-
ence.
If, from pages 64 to 70, we endeavor to determine the superiority
of different rail sections by the relative number of failures per 10,000 tons
or new rail laid, we arrive at the results given in Table 4.
If N.Y.N. H.&H. 100-lb. section stands first when made of Bessemer
steel, why does the same section stand seventh when made of Open-
Hearth, and so on? The reason is, of course, that the section of rail
does not control the quality of material, although it should have some
effect on it, because some sections of material are better rolling sections
than others, and undoubtedly some sections are stronger than others
when the quality of the material is the same. At the present time, how-
ever, the quality of the material is so variable that neither minor differ-
ences in sections nor in chemical composition have serious weight. Ulti-
mately, however, when the art of rail-making becomes more refined,
they ought to have weight, and, consequently, in the meantime, should
not be entirely lost sight of. These points will be further brought out in
the study of the diagrams which follow :
DIAGRAM I — COMPARISON BETWEEN DIFFERENT WEIGHTS OF RAIL, BESSEMER
STEEL.
The information for this diagram is tabulated on pages 72 to 74.
As in former reports, the head failures are the most numerous and those
for the 90-lb. rail again lead. Those for 95-lb., 85-lb. and 80-lb. come
next and are about the same in number, while the 100-lb. and 75-lb. are
closely the same.
The number of breakages are a little more numerous for 85-lb. than
for 75-lb., while the web and base failures are quite insignificant.
624 RAIL.
DIAGRAM 2 — COMPARISON BETWEEN DIFFERENT WEIGHTS OF RAIL, OPEN-
HEARTH STEEL.
The information for this diagram is tabulated on pp. 75 and 76.
The superiority of Open-Hearth over Bessemer steel is again empha-
sized in this diagram as compared with No. 1. The breakages and head
failures for the 80-lb. predominate and are quite few for all the others.
DIAGRAM 3 — COMPARISON BETWEEN DIFFERENT SECTIONS OF RAIL, BESSEMER
STEEL.
The information for the construction of the diagram is tabulated on
pp. tj to 81.
Diagram 1 showed that the greatest number of head failures occurred
in the case of 90-lb. rail. This diagram shows that they are most
numerous in the case of A.R.A.-B, C.S. and A.S.C.E. sections.
The A.R.A.-B is on the Baltimore & Ohio and is No. 1 in Table 2,
and there is nothing peculiar about the specified chemical composition.
The C.S. is Nos. 27, 33 and 42 of Table 2 on the Oregon Short Line,
Union Pacific and Illinois Central, respectively, and the specified chemical
composition is somewhat different from the general run, having C. .50 to
.60 for the first two, and .55 to .65 in the last, with, however, lower P.,
viz., .085.
The next largest number of head failures occurred in the case of
A.R.A.-A 85-lb., then C.B.&Q. 85-lb. and Cambria 80-lb. The first is
No. 35 of Table 2 and is Bessemer rail of the Illinois Steel Company on
the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe. It is a section designed by that com-
pany in accordance with the principles laid down by the American Railway
Association, as that Association did not make any specific design for 85-lb.
rail. The specified chemical contents are in accordance with the usual
practice, and the reason for the numerous head failures and breakages
is not apparent. The C.B.&Q. 85-lb. is No. 4 of Table 2 and has higher
carbon than is usual, .48 to .58.
With reference to breakages, the largest number in diminishing order
are in the case of A.R.A.-A 85-lb. (35), D.L.&W. 90-lb., C.S. 90-lb. (27,
33 and 42), Cambria 540, Dudley 100-lb. (85) and A.S.C.E. 90-lb. The
A.R.A.-A 85-lb. on the Santa Fe and the C.S. 90 have already been
spoken of above. The D.L.&W. rail is shown on page 15, but the chem-
ical composition is not given. It is a 1908 lot of 4,192 tons of Lackawanna
rail. The Dudley 100-lb. was somewhat high in phosphorus.
It is noticeable that all failures of A.R.A.-B 90-lb. rail are more
numerous than A.R.A.-A 90-lb., but the reverse is the case with the 100-lb.
section.
The web failures of the P.&R. 100-lb. are rather noticeable. This
is Maryland 1910 rail of the following composition :
C 55 to .65
P 07
Mil 90 to 1. 00
Si 20
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS.
625
It is thought they were due to sponginess, and the presence of slag in
"A" rails.
In Table No. 5 is given a statement of number of head failures per
10,000 tons of new rail laid, in diminishing order, with the object of trying
to discover whether the different sections of rail have any influence on
the number of head failures, i. e., whether a thin or heavy head is the
better, or whether a stiff or low section is the better. Opposite to each a
letter has been set, indicating whether the section has a heavy or thin
head and whether it is of stiff or low design, using the A.R.A.-A as stand-
ard for thin head and stiff design and A.R.A.-B as standard for heavy
head and low design ; except in the case of 85-lb. C.P.R. is used as stand-
ard for thin head, the Dudley for the stiff design, and the P.S. for heavy
head and low design.
TABLE 5— STATEMENT OF HEAD FAILURES PER 10,000 TONS OF RAIL LAID
IN DIMINISHING ORDER
Section
Weight
Tangent
or
Curve
Number of Head
Failures
per 10,000 Tons
Heavy
or
Thin Head
Stiff
or Low
Design
A. R. A.-B
A. R. A.-A
Cam. 540
90
85
80
85
85
90
90
90
100
85
95
75
100
100
80
90
85
100
95
85
90
100
75
100
100
90
C
T
T
C
T
T
C
T
C
C
C
T
T
T
T
C
c
c
T
T
T
C
C
T
C
C
60.8
40.7
27
25.5
22.9
22.7
20.1
18.3
16.9
16.4
15.3
14.7
14.3
13.8
13.8
13.1
11.8
11.6
11.1
11.1
10.8
10.7
10.6
9.2
9.1
8.4
H
T
T*
T
T
T
H
H
T
T
T
T
H
H
H
H
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
H
T
L
S
A. R. A.-A
C. B. &Q
s
L
C.S
S
c.s
s
A. S. C. E
P. &R
L
L
C. B. &Q
L
B. &A
L
C.S
s
A.R.A.-A
A. S. C. E
A. S. C. E
A. S. C. E
P.S
S
s
L
L
L
A.R.A.-A
B. &A
S
L
A.S.C.E
A. R. A.-A
S
S
s
C.S
s
s
P.S
L
G. N
L
Of the ioo-lb.,' the N.Y.N.H.&H. 100-lb. section makes the best
showing, and can be classed as stiff section with heavy head.
The next best is the A.R.A.-B of heavy head and low design, and
then the P.S. of heavy head and low design, while last year the A.R.A.-A
of thin head and stiff design preceded.
Of the 90-lb. the first is the A.R.A.-A of thin head and stiff design
and then the Great Northern of thin head and low design, while last year
the Great Northern came first.
Of the 85-lb. the Mo. Pac. comes first and then the P.R.R. and P.S.,
both of heavy head and low design.
Of the 80-lb. the best showing is made by the A.R.A.-A of thin head
and stiff design and then the Dudley of heavy head and stiff design.
626
RAIL.
DIAGRAM 4— COMPARISON BETWEEN DIFFERENT SECTIONS OF RAIL, OPEN-HEARTH
STEEL.
The information for the diagram is tabulated on pp. 82 to 84.
It presents a very different appearance from Diagram No. 3 and again
shows the superiority of Open-Hearth over Bessemer rail. We are re-
minded, however, by some irregularities that Open-Hearth steel is not
perfect and there are defects of manufacture or material to be overcome
in its case, as well as in the case of the Bessemer.
The greatest number of head failures is of P.R.R. 100-lb., the next
C.B.&Q. 85-lb, the next Mo.Pac. 85-lb. and then A.S.C.E. 90-lh, the two
latter being about equal.
In order to determine the effect, if any, of chemical composition, the
percentages of ingredients are given below :
P. R. R. 100
Pa. Steel 1905
C. B. & Q. 85
Beth. 1908
Mo. P. 85
C. F. & I. 1910
A. S. C. E. 90
Bethlehem 1907-1909
C. R. R. of N. J.
L. V. R. R
C. .85
P. .012
Mn .65
Si. .041
.55 to .67
.04
.70 to 1.00
.63
.06
.85
.20
.57
.031
.82
.70 to .80
.04
.80 to 1.05
The P.R.R. rail was but a small experimental lot, made by the Penn-
sylvania Steel Company in 1905, and may have been too hard with the
high carbon, although the phosphorus is very low. On the other hand, the
C.B.&Q. and the C.R.R. of NJ. rail may have been too soft. The Mo.
Pac. rail was reported by the Denver & Rio Grande, no reports at all
having been received from the Missouri Pacific.
There is nothing else unusual in connection with the diagram, except
the number of breakages of A.S.C.E. 90-lh, the composition of which has
already been given above. The best showing has been made by the
A.R.A.-B 100-lb, A.RA.-A 100-lb, C.S. 75-lb., S.Fe 90-lb. and P.&R. 100-lb.
The A.R.A.-B is Bethlehem, Cambria and Maryland 1910 rail on the
B. & O., Illinois Steel 1009 on the Chicago & Northwestern, Bethlehem
1910 rail on the Erie, and Algoma 1910 rail on the Michigan Central, the
chemical composition of which conforms with the usual limits, except that
a portion of it on the Baltimore & Ohio has pretty high carbon, .65 to .80,
for .04 phosphorus.
The A.RA.-A is Maryland, Bethlehem and Pennsylvania 1910 rail,
on the Central Railroad of New Jersey, and Gary 1910 rail on the Rock
Island. The chemical composition differs in each case and is as follows :
Pennsylvania
Maryland
Bethlehem
Gary
c.
p.
Mn.
Si.
.70 to .85
.04
.60 to .90
.20
.62 to .75
.04
.60 to .90
.20
.70 to .83
.04
.60 to .90
.20
.63 to .76
.04
.60 to .901
.10 to .20]
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS. 627
It will be noted that, in some of these cases, the carbons are even
higher than above, and the phosphorus lower.
The C.S. 75-lb. is Bethlehem 1909 and C.F.&I. 1907-1910 rail on the
Oregon Railroad & Navigation Company, and Maryland 1906 on the Ari-
zona & Eastern. The O.R.R.&N.Co. rails ought to be very soft with
C. .45 for P. .025. The Maryland rail ought to have been classed as Besse-
mer with .085 phosphorus.
The Santa Fe 90-lb. is Illinois 1909 and 1910 steel, with C. .59 to .72,
P. .04, Mn. .60 to .90 and Si. .20.
The P.&R. 100-lb. is Pennsylvania 1909 and 1910 steel with C. .70 to
.85, P. .03, Mn. .60 to .90 and Si. .20.
Last year there were no head failures of N.Y.N. H.&H. 100-lb., but
this year there are some breakages of 10,741 tons of Bethlehem 1908 and
1910 rail with C. .70 to .77, P. -02 to .035, Mn. .70 to 1.00 and Si. .10 to .21.
In addition to the above there is but one failure of 9,825 tons of Penn-
sylvania steel for 1908 to 1910, with C. .71 to .90, P. .009 to .028, Mn. .60 to
.90, Si. .05 to .13 and S. .02 to .079. It is to be noted that there are a few
base failures with this section, and reference to Vol. 12, Part 2, page 149,
will show that it has a thin base.
It was also mentioned last year that there were very few failures of
the D.L.&W. 90-lb., while this year there are some breaks. It is Bethle-
hem 1908-1910 rail, with C. .67 to .80, P. .04, M'n. .75 to 1.05, Si. .20 and
S. .05.
Last year there were no failures of the Dudley 100-lb., but this
year there are a few, principally head failures. There are but a few tons,
4,404, divided between Lackawanna and Bethlehem, in 1908 and 1909.
DIAGRAM 5 — COMPARISON OF FAILURES FOR DIFFERENT PERIODS OF LIFE.
The information for the diagram is tabulated on pp. 85 and 86.
There are comparatively few failures during the first year, the prin-
cipal exception being P.R.R. 100-lb.
The most failures occurred from the first to the sixth year.
FAILURES WITH RESPECT TO THEl POSITION IN THE INGOT, PP. 87 TO 141.
The marking of the rails to distinguish the position in the ingot has
become very general, and the reports were much more complete than ever
before.
For convenient reference, Table No. 6 has been made from the re-
ports. The failures of "A" rails are the most numerous, but there are
also very many failures of "B" and "C" rails and no inconsiderable
number of "D" and "E", while there are occasional ones even lower down.
Unless there is an improvement in the making of the ingots, it will re-
quire the elimination entirely of the "A", "B" and "C" rails to be sure of
having only sound ones in the track. As this would mean a great waste of
material, with resultant loss of economy, it emphasizes the necessity
for continued study of rail manufacture in order to obtain rails as nearly
faultless as possible, without extravagance.
628
RAIL.
^OOWQOCNNMN^OOiUS^OOOOaoON^OOOOiNMrt-HiOQOaooooO^iCOJCiOOCOtDiOCC*
^-.i-H CO
.-^*-i^^-i -(CHCON
* C* *0 *->*$< — C* *Q M ■'H'HO
5i-iiO'*'*«CO00C*<C>T-<'*J<cOe*OSi-il-~N^
■ CS • OO Ci • ^
■ W •iC'-HOO -NNCCinOiOOJ
• c$co*-t -<ho<d«cd
■ uj^ttHHM .^^o^'-^-* -OOiO^O 'NO~h*0 -OWN00
W CD • »-H CO -CO
■-^<N»-<00
.rH^iiOM^^NiHMCOiNOOiOH ■ CO -h •<*< lO C* ~l <M CC CS 00
OO ^ ^ it* -CO *-»<N
•fhC3NOOCCW<00
•^iC CIO OO
■MC:0«»CNNH
■OWQO^i-i'*C>«NINNecWO
©' § ©' ©"g ©"g « ■g'gd'g© -doi^d •©' 3 ■ d'g cid S'g g^"gg cs •'gd'gcjo-^
SJ 0 C3 03 M C3.3 d— OS* ^=3 *— «3 ~— S— CS 03 c3 =3 3 3 c3 .2 JS.3.2 c3 3 — «J c! * 3 03 *i
«' *
.Sod
ssssasssaEssessHHESEsassssacSssEcsasEEsaaasss
©©©©©©©©©©©©0©0©C;©©©©C>OCJ— —wC-yi-C-wwOi-O £*©©©©©©©©
<-i;<<;mfpw'w'^ ; : : : : : : : : [^<<^n(a^a^^^ . . :hhhh«h«w
<<<;^<ij«5iQQQ >..tf : : : : : :c^(^<<<'i<<<<<oooo'^ ■ | idddocJOVO
'3 v.
SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOiOiO»-OiOW3iO»CiOiO
OCOCOOOOOOOOOCOOOC«C.03 0)fflOClC©0'.0»aO©O©0»00l»00 00(»C0Q0Q0M
o^.s.so^oo
tf
*=h*'l"fl
3J
^o
"3*0
3 Spjoj
•-C c! 08
..5.s.s.Stftfdd«£c'dd££B::w
kWiJiJ_u_u_1..u,; . u o jj .. -o'er?
IJIJbdd^pIe!-*
&Z.Z
nd£(2si«««d£d££££££^««o^M««£2u^
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS.
629
^h ~h CM i-H — t Oa ^** i-H CM CO CO t* ^ «-• cOt-i*^ rtWCO
*# QO CO
OO CO CO
3 o
00-^ — « -* O"
OK
©hh^do^cjom r— co
W i« i-t Tp W N W i-H CM
OO i-l GO
CD -** CM -^ CO
CN i-t --H -CO CO*H
^h CM COCN
1 i-r CllO i-t CM ■**< i-t
■* to CO iO *"- ^ C^ ~H CM CO CO CO COCOCO
i-<CNOSCOTt<I>>COCO
CO^ft CO
^h . »c »o i-H ■** CO 00
~* -** ~t
COCMt^CM~HQOTf*CO
CO'* r-l ^ -M
-h CO CM "HiO-t • CO —i CO r*. CM CM i-t
i-h ^H • CM ~H CM
CMCM^^CMCMCJiOSCMt^-^CMCMCOTP —ii-(^«CM'-<fHiOCM
r^cs^cot^CMCM-^i:
i-h ~h co ^*«
•o o -j
CM ^ ■*
N ^ (D
c3 g a> ©
"fi cj'Sb'3)
03 S c8 03 — — O ca
B 03 fh 03 Bfifl tt
c a K3-* a g cja g gja
S 03 « © 03 ffl — 0) 05-3— 4)
-' oj oj
2 ©^
gSxjI
6§
03 oj
OPh
|°2.S°|
,"§ CO S «< 00 o
31&113
WhOOSW
ddddddddddddddddd
66666666
s a
.2 J .3
o-c?
fcP^p^OOQ
111°?"^^ : : w««w : : :<y
pj<i-<<i<!-<d°8 : : dodo | : :=8
^'aiiii^ala^P^^-i^-tJ-JjClOO -ax^-^p^d
•5 w a
p «i <i
bf>H
'S t,
w »o iC «o WJ iO »o o
aoaoccQoccooooQO
soooooooooC'^oo©©© io io ic « »o u; w io
)OOOOOOOQO>0)aO)0>0!0>Q OOOOOOOOCOOOOOOO
tftf c c s=8^U
d,a,(2(2(2doiz;
jtf~-^««><
tfjrtdjtfdJaJS^
*1d5o«
fio?
tfP^««P^«.-af<Pq 3°8 m>^1
•8 3 5 ^^.-jtftfjj.
^Z _y jj jj ni ^J ^J ►_]
•a =8 <««««*-;«
CiJ^pIfcPM^fSfcddtnpQ&hJQOO ^Z^df^PLifSd
!5 2
"3 "3
< « «
•a pi «
mod
630 RAIL.
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF SPECIAL AND ALLOY RAIL, PP. 142 TO 162.
Several of the companies are making trials of experimental lots of
both Special Bessemer and Open-Hearth steel, and with different alloys,
such as ferro-titanium, nickel, chromium-nickel, etc., but in some instances
the results have not been very satisfactory, The failures are given in de-
tail on pp. 61, 62, 63, 67 and 68. and the record of wear on pp. 142 to 162.
The average number of failures per 10,000 tons of rail laid for the differ-
ent kinds tested are as follows :
Open-Hearth Steel, with ferro-titanium 12
Bessemer Steel, with ferro-titanium 13^
Bessemer Steel, with nickel 96
Open-Hearth Steel, with chromium-nickel 640
Ferro-Titanium Treatment:
The record for failures is bad on the Central Railroad of New Jersey,
being 1,019 per 10.000 tons of rail, but the quantity tested is very small —
373 tons. This is 90-lb. A.S.C.E. section, rolled by the Lackawanna Steel
Company in 1909, with C. .45 to .55, P. .10, Mn. .84 to .114, Si. .20 and
F.T. .3. Other lots of the rail have made a better showing. The failures
E.rc thought to be due to imperfect rolling and not to the ferro-titanium.
The comparative wear tests were made on the Baltimore & Ohio, Lake
Shore & Michigan Southern and New York Central Lines.
The following tests are being made on the Baltimore & Ohio :
90-lb. A.R.A.-B Maryland Bessemer rail with ferro-titanium is being
compared with Maryland Open-Hearth rail on Kessler's Curve. The per
cent, of area of head abraded was 3.8 and 4.4 for ferro-titanium and 4.2
for Open-Hearth in four months.
Also 100-lb. A.S.C.E. Maryland Bessemer steel with ferro-titanium
was compared with Maryland Bessemer steel on the same curve, and in
one year ten months the per cent, of area of head abraded was 9.5 for
ferro-titanium and 17.7 for Bessemer. This Bessemer rail was worn out
and replaced by Cambria Bessemer, which wore 6.4 per cent, in less than
six months.
On the Lake Shore & Michigan Southern, ico-lb. A.S.C.E. Lackawanna
steel with ferro-titanium is being compared with ordinary Bessemer rail.
In some of these tests not much superiority is shown for the ferro-
titanium, while in others there is considerable.
On the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad, 80-lb. Dudley
Lackawanna steel with metallic titanium .033 is being compared with 80-lb.
Dudley ordinary Bessemer, the record for one year and six months show-
ing less wear for the ordinary Bessemer than for the ferro-titanium, al-
though the difference is but slight.
It will thus be observed that up to the present time the results are
conflicting, the one good test on the Baltimore & Ohio perhaps being due
to the higher carbon, while the other tests, where the results are about
the same, are with the usual carbon for that quality of steel.
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS. 631
The large number of failures on the Central Railroad of New Jersey,
mostly broken base, is rather alarming and discouraging.
Steel with Chromium-Nickel :
The record for 90-lb. A.S.C.E. Open-Hearth rail with chromium and
nickel on the Central Railroad of New Jersey has been very bad so far as
failures are concerned, there having been 1,129 per 10,000 tons of rail
laid, mostly breakages. It is Bethlehem steel, 1909 manufacture, but
the chemical composition is unknown.
Small lots have also been tested on the B. & O. and the Erie, with
a large number of failures. That on the B. & O. is 90-lb. A.R.A.-B
Bethlehem rail, 1909 and 1910, with 595 failures per 10,000 tons, and that
on the Erie, 90-lb. A.S.C.E. Bethlehem 1909 rail with 289 failures per 10,-
000 tons, both on page 63. The amount of nickel is 2 per cent, to 2*/2
per cent., and the chromium .5 per cent, to .9 per cent. In the case of the
B. & O. the carbon is rather low for Open-Hearth steel, while on the
Erie it is more nearly the usual amount.
A small lot on the New York, Ontario & Western has given better
results, and also a larger amount on the Lehigh Valley, although the
number of failures, especially breakages, is very considerable.
Comparative tests for wear are being conducted by the Baltimore
& Ohio and the Lehigh Valley Railroad.
The Baltimore & Ohio is comparing 90-lb. A.R.A.-B Bethlehem steel,
containing nickel and chromium, with ordinary Bethlehem Open-Hearth
rail on different curves, ranging in degree from 4 deg. 30 min. to 9 deg. 30
min.
The results are variable, in one case the chrome-nickel showing a
greater percentage of wear than the Open-Hearth, while in other cases
the Open-Hearth shows 50 per cent, greater wear than chrome-nickel,
the duration of time being one and one-half years. It is difficult to under-
stand the difference, as the respective kinds of material are the same in
each case.
When compared with ordinary Cambria Bessemer rail, the per cent,
of area of head abraded was from 2T/2 to 3 times as much for the Bessemer
rail as for the chromium-nickel rail.
In the Lehigh Valley tests, 90-lb. A.S.C.E. Bethlehem steel, with nickel
and chromium, was compared with ordinary Open-Hearth rail and the
per cent, of area of head abraded in from 8 to 18 months was 70 per cent,
greater in the case of the Open-Hearth than of the chrome-nickel.
Rail of Mayari Ore:
A test is being conducted by the Pennsylvania Lines of 85-lb. P. S.
Pennsylvania Steel Company's Open-Hearth rail of Mayari ore from Cuba,
and in ten months ordinary Maryland Bessemer steel shows twice the wear.
The chemical composition is: C. .805, P. .022, Mn. .87, Si. .17, S. .035,
Nickel .97 and Chromium .21. It will be noted that it is a chromium-
nickel rail, but of very different composition from the tests cited above.
632 RAIL.
Manganese Steel:
The Norfolk & Western is comparing 85-lb. A.S.C.E. manganese steel
with ordinary Carnegie Bessemer, and up to the present time the per
cent, of area of head abraded is a trifle over three times as much for
the Bessemer as for the manganese. The composition of the manganese
rail is: C. .77, P. .06, Mn. 9.93, Si. .25, S. .038, and the test has lasted
for nineteen months.
On the Lake Shore & Michigan Southern, 85-lb. P. R. R. manganese
rail of the Pennsylvania Steel Company is being compared with ferro-
titanium steel, and in eight months the ferro-titanium shows a little more
than twice as much wear as the manganese.
Miscellaneous:
The Baltimore & Ohio made a comparative test between 90-lb.
A.R.A.-A Illinois steel and 90-lb. A.R.A.-B Carnegie steel on a 7 deg.
curve. In two years the per cent, of area of head abraded was 23.4 for
the "A" and 13.4 for the "B".
The Baltimore & Ohio compared the wear of 90-lb. A.R.A.-B Bethle-
hem Open-Hearth rail with Cambria Bessemer on a 7 deg. 5 min. curve,
rnd in one year the per cent, of area of head abraded was 9.8 for the Open-
Hearth and 26.9 for the Bessemer.
The Lake Shore & Michigan Southern compared 80-lb. A.S.C.E. rail
made by the electric process of the Illinois Steel Company with ordinary
Bessemer rail, with the result that in eight months but little difference
between them was shown.
The New York Central & Hudson River Railroad compared basic
Open-Hearth rail of Bethlehem and Lackawanna manufacture, 100-lb.
Dudley section, with ordinary Bessemer rail, same section, with but little
difference in the comparative wear in a year and one-half.
RAIL FAILURE STATISTICS. 633
THOUGHTS RESULTING FROM' THE STUDY.
The most of the thoughts stated in Vol. 12, Part 2, page 28, may be
repeated after this study, but some additional comments will be made :
(1) Study of these general statistics does not furnish accurate and
specific information so as to determine the value of different
sections of rail, because :
(a) The conditions of traffic are different.
(b) The conditions of roadbed are different.
(c) The conditions of ingot making and rolling practice are so
different that the quality of the material varies widely, and,
at the present time, this difference in quality of material elimi-
nates differences in section ; nevertheless, when the time
comes that the difference in quality of material will be less,
the influence of the section will be more apparent, for there
is no doubt that one section is stiffer and stronger than an-
other, according to the distribution of the material. Inas-
much as we are endeavoring to eliminate the differences in
quality of material and bring it to a high state of perfec-
tion, we should not, in the meantime, lose sight of the de-
sirable features of the rail section, but keep them con-
stantly in mind, so that when we arrive at a good quality of
metal we will also have a desirable rail section.
(2) A study of these general statistics tends to disclose unusual re-
sults, and were it not for their compilation, we would not have
much information relative to the difference between Bessemer
and Open-Hearth steel and concerning the various alloys.
(3) The general statistics are also important, in showing a relation
between broken rails and failure of head, web and base.
(4) Their tabulation discloses the difference between Steel Companies
when the sections and chemical composition are practically the
same.
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF BESSEMER, OPEN-HEARTH AND
NICKEL STEEL RAIL ON PENNSYLVANIA RAILROAD.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
The Committee on Rail submits for your information the following
statement and accompanying Exhibits "A" and "B," from Mr. Joseph T.
Richards, Chief Engineer Maintenance of Way, Pennsylvania Railroad, in
regard to comparative wear of Bessemer, Open-Hearth and Nickel Steel
rail on the Pennsylvania Railroad.
June 22, 191 1.
Mr. Chas. S. Churchill,
Chairman, Committee on Rail. American Railway Engineering Asso-
ciation, Roanoke, Va.
Dear Sir : — From what I can gather from the progress reports of the
work of the Committee to date, particularly the reports made to the
Committee by Mr. Wickhorst, I am impressed that we are doing a great
deal of work, but along the line which may be called experimental — we are
to a degree hunting something new in the composition of rail, like
''Chromium" and "Nickel."
If I am correct, I believe our Committee should turn its attention to
perfecting the rail as we know it under the present well worked out
analyses and specifications. If we fail in doing this, as railroad men I
believe we are not doing our part, because a good rail can be made under
our specifications and well-known composition, if the mill practice is right.
Experimenting outside of this line is "only beating around the bush,"
and working with a line ahead as long as a life line, and we will be con-
tinuing the long chase very much as we have been for the last generation,
whereas, to get the rail we are seeking for requires prompt action in the
direction above outlined.
I am firmly convinced that the mills can make a good rail. We all
know very well what the mill practice did in making the old "John Brown"
and "Charles Cammel" rail more than forty years ago at the crude mills
and under the imperfect specifications of that time.
We have had Open-Hearth rails made by the mills and tested under
heavy tonnage on our main line near Union Furnace, Middle Division, on
a 6-deg. curve in the eastbound track, carrying both passenger and freight
trains. The analyses of these rails are shown on the diagram presented.
On this sheet is also marked the wear and life of the rail. (See diagrams
marked Exhibit "A.")
635
C36 RAIL.
It will be observed that the carbon was high and the phosphorus low.
The comparison was : Open-Hearth, Carbon .79, Phosphorus .024, shown in
red; Open-Hearth, Carbon .896, Phosphorus .009, shown in blue; Open-
Hearth, Nickel, shown in green, and ordinary Bessemer, shown in black.
As we are developing the Open-Hearth rail I would call special atten-
tion to it in this test. It is shown in measurement No. 3 that the Bessemer
rail was worn out and removed from track after service of 405 days, so
that it is not shown in the following measurements, No. 4 to No. 8.
As to the Nickel Rail, High Carbon and Open-Hearth — the last meas-
urement was taken after being in use 818 days. This High Carbon rail did
not fail or break during the test, and was not nearly as much worn in 818
days as the Bessemer was in 405 days.
This shows the value and economy in using the High Carbon Open-
Hearth rail, and we were so delighted that we thought great progress had
been made. In asking the mills to reproduce this rail we have met with
some success, although in some cases they have failed to give us rail that
will come up to this test in durability; but it impresses me as a member
of the Committee that we should work on the principle of the Economy
Engineer, who emphasizes the importance of working on the "ratchet prin-
ciple," i. e., holding on to what he has and adding to it, rather than allow-
ing himself to slip back.
Of course, I am speaking of Open-Hearth rail, because the Bessemer
process might well be eliminated, for the reason that, as we all know,
ore suitable for Bessemer steel has practically disappeared, and the mills
have largely been rebuilt for the Open-Hearth process. We are marking
time when we pay too much attention to the Bessemer process.
In the long line that we are following in rail making I will give you
another statement (see Exhibit "B") to show the results from Open-
Hearth rails made under specifications in 1907 prepared jointly
by the mill men and railroad men, and it is rather surprising to see this
following about two years after our trial of 1905, in which an Open-Hearth
rail was found to last so well and not break in track. I think the poor re-
sults shown in this statement are largely due to the fact that these rails
have been too low in carbon and consequently too soft. It has turned out
so badly that some of the railroads have reported to me that this rail is
no better than Bessemer rail; yet it will be noted that the railroads have
paid $31.00 to $35.00 per ton for this rail, when the ordinary rail was
selling at $28.00 per ton.
It is a well-known principle that as the phosphorus is decreased carbon
should be increased. It can safely be done, and will give us a rail that
will wear longer and not break.
As to the Titanium and Chrome-Nickel rail — i. e., experimenting with
these new elements, I see no objection whatever — it is all proper in its
way as a side issue ; but it is slow, and should in no way hold back our
perfecting the Open-Hearth rail, as we know it from mill practice and
srecifications.
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIL. 637
As a further statement, I will give you the result of the Titanium rail
placed in track on one of our branch lines — the Tyrone Division.
Four tons of 85-lb. P.R.R. section of rail, with a percentage of
Titanium, was laid on a 13-deg. 50-min. curve, Tyrone Division, P.R.R., in
September, 1908. The composition was as follows :
Carbon 53
Phosphorus 074
Manganese 91
Silicon 098
Sulphur 056
This rail was removed worn out in November, 1909 (14 months).
Ordinary Bessemer lasts on this curve 12 to 15 months; hence the
Titanium rail did not show any marked superiority.
We have another test of about 95 tons of Titanium rail, which was
laid on the Buffalo Division in June, 1910. The time has been too short
to produce results, but it may be of value for a future report.
Respectfully,
(Signed) Jos. T. Richards,
Chief Engineer M. W., and Member of Committee.
638
RAIL.
2
O
co <o en
«Vj Cn «v5 K
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIL.
639
U
u
X
640
RAIL.
O
Hi
o
H
m
W
H
W
>
H
<
Pi
<
o
u
^ ^ ? ^
^ ^ ^ ^
X
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIT,
641
c
o
•e
u
c
o
■e
U
■a
x
642
RAIL.
o
03
o
H
en
W
H
W
>
Oh
^
°£> ^ ^ S>
o
u
COMPARATIVE WEAR. OF STEEL RAIL.
643
U
u
X
644
RAIL.
o
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIL.
645
U
tr>~
646
RAIL.
O
w
w
H
CO
•J
W
u
p
H pi
<
>
CO Ph
w
o
t/3
w
W
>
U
u
u
M
J ffi
u
<n <o <n
ill
^ 19 ^
<h p> ^>
^ *o ^
-.-
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL
RAIL.
647
U
U
648
RAH-
§
<
-J
W
H
U
00 CO ?0
^ ^ &
VO ^o ^
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIL.
649
c
o
■8
u
650
RAIL.
O
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIL.
651
c
o
u
Rl
U
652
RAIL.
ft
O
o
H
W
H
W
>
i— i
H
<
<
c
u
co «n <n
rr ^r >
to jo ^
5 5 S?
5
M
<
K
COMPARATIVE WEAR OF STEEL RAIL.
653
c
o
u
u r.
J W
O
^ /'
\ I
w
O
j.
O
&Q o
O o i
£* 3
K S 5
ft z
O
#
o
w
o
«
o
►J
ac
ft
6
o
w
u
00O CO CO
coo
O »it>o o O
co 00 o o o
t- O OC>J
o o > >
■w « o 0
«"• o c
o o o
IOO
o o
Of-.
« © o
O 0 > > >
*'*' o o o
OO *3 *. «
tot- o o o
•it >, «
.£ e
a >■
I s
oPJ
gO
5a
II
■? J. §5
I?-
5
'J— o 3
S.al:
" co a
o o.d.2 £
Os 073.=
^s o
.q2 °
*2 Ja=.2*
o oT g ■
u o t- >- 2
» £ p,XI c
"So5 &
= £°'%£
£2 0*
g c o n
am--1
a *°
0.-.T3 .
§o§o^
■OpiSo o —
— .0 -* &o
iOȣ3iC CO - .
8 -°- ;»>
<J 0 "2 §"2 S 2
o g o g c-t
t> CO P ' *s
O 3 - 41
fa a O^ ',
O _S
CO , J2 lO r.
a c3 • a
— as a . B oj
08 o +- ■
«a-s"S5 1
o g a S -
o g a'S 5
s
-5
0
—
-
0
w
c-.
X
"5
i
e
0
'J
c
a
i
>T1
73
03
0
—
^s
BJ'S
S
=
2
2
•-
0
E
Appendix C.
SEGREGATION AND OTHER RAIL PROPERTIES A
INFLUENCED BY SIZE OF INGOT.
By
M. H. Wickhorst, Engineer of Tests, Rail Committee.
This report covers an investigation to throw light on the relationship
of the size of ingots of Bessemer rail steel to the segregation of the metal-
loids, locations of pipes and blow holes, and the properties of the rails.
A series of five ingots was made of the following bottom sizes', all 5 ft.
high, namely, 12 in. x 12 in., 15 in. x 15 in., 18 in. x 18 in., 20 in. x 24 in. and
25 in. x 30 in. These were split open, one-half used to obtain borings
for a chemical survey of the ingot, and the other half for etching. Another
similar set of ingots was rolled into rails with only sufficient discard from
the top of the bloom to allow rolling into rail, and the entire rail bars
from these ingots were used for drop tests, etchings and chemical analyses,
except that no rails were rolled from the 12-in. ingot, as an attempt to do
so resulted in a "cobble" on account of the small size of the ingot.
Finally, two other sets of rails are to be rolled from the 15 in. x 15 in.,
18 in. x 18 in., 20 in. x 24 in. end 25 in. x 30 in. ingots. These are
intended for service tests on the Cumberland Division of the Baltimore &
Ohfo Railroad, one set on the high rail of a 5-degree or 6-degree curve,
and the other set on the low rail.
MANUFACTURE.
The steel used was all Bessemer steel made from- Lake Superior ores.
The iron from the blast furnaces was poured into a mixer, from here. it was
weighed into a ladle, poured into the converter and blown,, scrap steel
being .added' during the blowing. After blowing, spiegel was added to
the. converter, the metal was poured into an intermediate ladle, then into
the pouring ladle and finally into, the molds through a i^-in. nozzle. The
various series of ingots were made from different heats, , as one . set
required almost a whple heat, but were all made from s.teel of about the
same composition. The work was done at South Chicago at the South
Works of the Illinois Steel Company, who very generously furnished all
the material, labor and facilities for splitting, analyzing and otherwise
testing the ingots and rails from two heats of steel. As these tests
involved considerable expense, the special thanks of the Rail Committee
—*
Report No. 19, June, 1911.
655
656
RAIL.
are due to the officers of the Illinois Steel Company for their generosity
and efficiency in doing this work.
The amounts of materials used to make the two heats are shown in
table i.
TABLE I — BESSEMER AMOUNTS.
Heat No 4,520 5,731
Purpose Ingots Rails for test
Mixer metal, lbs 28,100 30,200
Scrap steel, lbs 2,200 1,800
Spiegel, lbs 3,520 3,380
Special samples of the mixer metal and the spiegel gave the results
shown in tables 2 and 3.
TABLE 2 — MIXER METAL.
Heat. C. P. S. Mn. Si.
4520 4.00 .091 .032 .70 1.68
5731 3-89 -094 -050 .68 1. 1 8
TABLE 3 — SPIEGEL.
Heat. C. P. S. Mn. Si.
4520 4.44 .102 .... 11.50 1.08
5731 4.30 .085 .010 12.00 1.40
The various Bessemer operations occurred at the times shown in
table 4.
TABLE 4 — TIME OF BESSEMER OPERATIONS.
Heat 4520 5731
Date 3-23-1 1 4-5-1 1
Started blowing 2.19 p. m 10.16 a. m.
Finished blowing 2.31 p. m. 10.27 a. m.
Time used to blow 12 min. 1 1 min.
Started to pour into ladle 2.32 p. m. 10.29 a- m
Started to pour into molds 2. 38^ 10.36 a. m.
Time from finish of blowing to start of pouring into
molds 7^2 min. 9 min.
Finished pouring into molds 2.49 p. m. 10.46 a. m.
As stated above, five different sizes of ingots were made, and the
dimensions and weights of the molds used are shown in table 5. Previous
to casting the molds were sprayed with tar. In order to avoid having
the size of mold either increase or decrease, as the height of metal
in the ladle decreased, the ingots were poured in the following order,
15 x 15, 20 x 24, 12 x 12, 25 x 30 and 18 x 18.
Size 12x12
Height 62^4 hi.
TABLE 5 — MOLDS.
15x15 18x18 20x24
63 in. 74,y2 in. yyY2 in.
25x30
81 in.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
657
&
658
RAIL.
Bottom, inside.... 12^x12^ 15 xi5lA i8&xi8# 20^x24^ 25^x30^
Bottom, outside.. 21 1^x21 5^ 24 x24l/2 26^x26^ 30 X34 41 X45
Top, inside io^xio5/6 13^x13^ i6^xi6}4 18^x22^ 24 x20j^
Top, outside 17^x17^ 20^x20^ 21^x22 26^x30^ 35 X40J4
Weight, lbs 3,600 4.500 5,300 8,600 15,700
INGOTS.
The first set of ingots was used direct for chemical survey and etch-
ing of longitudinal sections, ingot numbers as follows: 12x12, IL4; 15x15.
Fig. 2 — Ingots after Splitting.
IL5; 18x18, IL6; 20x24, IL7; 25x30, IL8. After pouring, they were switched
around at intervals for about 20 minutes, and were then allowed to cool
in the molds. Fig. 1 is a view of the ingots on their stools in the molds,
showing a rather interesting assortment. In addition to the test ingots,
the metal left in the ladle made another ingot of about 5,000 lbs. The
dimensions and weights of the test ingots when cold are shown in table 6.
IL7
IL8
20x24
25x30
59^ in.
58^ in.
19^5x23^
24ifx29^
I8^X22J4
23^x28^
7,000
10,600
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 659
TABLE 6— INGOTS.
Ingot No IL4 IL5 IL6
Ingot size 12x12 15x15 18x18
Length 60 in. 59 in. 60 in.
Size, bottom 12x12 14^x14% i8Axi8^t
Size, top ioyAynoy2 I3j4xi3-fe i6j4xi6ffe
Weight, lbs. 2,000 3,000 4,600
When cold, the ingots were split open (across the small diameter in
the case of the oblong sections), by first slotting on opposite sides to a
depth of four to six inches, with a tool about -)4 inch wide, and then
splitting under the steam hammer by means of wedges. It might be stated
that when broken these ingots gave off the odor of ammonia from the
fracture, and also turned phenolphthalein paper red. The fractures, which
showed up the pipes and blow holes nicely, are reproduced in Fig. 2,
which shows the hve ingots together. It will be noted that the "pipe"
or shrinkage cavity goes deepest in the smallest ingot, and becomes less
deep as the size of the ingot increases. The per cent, of the height of
the ingot that the pipe extends downward from the top is very roughly
as follows:
12x12 ingot 80 per cent.
15x15 " 75
18x18 " 60
20x24 " 40
25x30 " 35
These figures refer simply to the shrinkage cavity and not to the
blow holes.
One-half of each ingot was then planed down to below the fractured
surface and finally finished by hand filing. These were then etched with a
10 per cent, water solution of copper ammonium chloride by leveling the
surface of the ingot, pouring on the solution and allowing it to remain
for several minutej. The surface was then washed off with a hose and
scrub-brush, and then water containing a little ammonia poured over
the surface to prevent a slight rust discoloration. The etched surface
was then photographed at once while wet. It was hoped that the etching
would show a "structure" corresponding to the distribution of the carbon,
but this did not prove to be the case with the condition of the surface
and method used. The photographs showed the cavaties and blow holes
very nicely, however, and are reproduced in following figures :
Fig. 3. 12x12 ingot.
Fig. 4- 15x15 mgot.
Fig. 5. 18x18 ingot.
Fig. 6. 20x24 ingot, 20-inch diameter.
Fig. 7. 25x30 ingot, 25-inch diameter.
These figures represent surfaces below the axis of the ingot, and
therefore the pipes do not show in them, but cavities and blow holes in
660
RAIL.
Fig. 3— Etched Section of 12x12 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
661
Fig. 4— Etched Section of 15x15 Ingot.
662
RAIL.
Fig. 5— Etched Section of 18x18 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
66.:
Fig. 6 — Etched Section of 20x24 Ingot, 2o-inch Diameter.
664
RAIL.
■■
Fig. 7— Etched Section of 25x30 Ingot, 25-iNCH Diameter.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
665
Vertical
Rows
A B C D £
I
5
10
15
20
% *5
K 30
, 35
%
o
so
60
70
80
90
99
o o o o o
o o o o 6
o o o o o
o o o o o
o o o o <>
O O O O <)
00006
00000
00006
000 00
000 o 0
00000
H6Lt
•5
i> o o o <p
Vr
o 9 <j> <|> ( >
-f-diam. -*\
j£ <£««»!. —
OOOO6
pIG g — Drilling Diagram for Ingots.
666
RAIL.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
667
the upper part of the ingot are well shown. The condition of "sponginess"
extends downward about the same distance from the top in all the ingots,
namely, about 30 per cent. The blow holes toward the axis of the ingot
had a coating of slag appearing very much like a coat of varnish, while
those near the walls of the ingot appeared to be free from such slag
coating.
ANALYSES OF INGOTS.
One of the halves of each of the split ingots was used for making
a chemical survey of the ingot, the drillings for analysis being taken
as shown on the drilling diagram, Fig. 8. It will be noted that we
obtained five vertical rows of drillings from one-half of the section,
making a total of 75 samples, less the number of samples that could
not be obtained, due to cavities in the ingot. The five ingots, after drill-
ing, are shown together in Fig. 9. On each sample determinations were
made of carbon (by combustion), phosphorus, sulphur, manganese and
silicon, and the results are shown in tables as follows :
12x12 ingot, tables 7 to 11 inclusive.
15x15 ingot, tables 12 to 16 inclusive.
18x18 ingot, tables 17 to 21 inclusive.
20x24 ingot, tables 22 to 26 inclusive.
25x30 ingot, tables 27 to 31 inclusive.
TABLE 7 — CARBON IN 12X12 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
I
5
.48
10
•50
15
•53
20
•53
25
•55
30
■57
35
• 5g
40
.58
50
08
60
.61
70
.58
80
.60
90
.61
99
•63
B.
48
50
54
57
53
50
59
bo
59
00
58
59
60
61
62
Vertical
Row..
C.
D.
.46
•49
.67
.78
.69
■ 77
.64
■70
.61
.67
.58
.66
.62
.62
•59
.62
.61
.60
.61
•58
• 59
• 58
• 50
• 56
•57
56
.61
.61
E,
45
82
77
71
70
69
69-
6q
55-
60
5*
56
56
61
668
RAIL.
TABLE 8 — PHOSPHORUS IN 12X12 INGOT.
Per Cent,
Vertical Row.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
I
068
058
066
.062
5
063
067
10
067
077
116
171
.188
15
08'
084
108
169
.162
20
082
078
097
114
• 157
25
084
080
088
116
.142
30
092
093
094
111
.116
35
089
099
101
102
.114
40
09-r
099
100
099
.101
50
098
099
100
099
.009
60
.092
.096
.100
091
.094
7o
095
006
098
086
.084
80
096
095
.098
089
.085
90
094
096
090
089
.085
99
.092
.092
093
093
• 093
TABLE 9 — SULPHUR IN 12X12 INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical
Row.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.023
.019
023
.020
5
.020
.022
10
.022
.027
.041
.060
.070
15
.029
.026
.039
059
.064
20
• 032
.031
•037
.041
.058
25
.031
• 032
•034
.042
.058
30
•034
.034
.032
.042
.044
35
.031
.032
•037
.038
.044
40
.032
•034
•037
.035
•039
50
•033
.034
•034
• 033
• 034
60
• 033
• 033
• 035
.032
•033
70
.032
•034
• 033
.031
.030
80
.032
.032
•034
• 033
.033
90
•035
•037
.033
.029
.029
99
.031
.033
•033
• 033
■033
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
669
TABLE 10 — MANGANESE IN 12X12 INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical Row.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
I
• 95
•97
.98
.98
5
•97 .
.98
IO
.96
.99
1.04
1.08
1.08
15
.98
.98
1.03
1.04
1.08
20
1. 01
1. 00
1.02
•99
1.04
25
1.02
1. 00
*
1.02
1.03
1. 00
30
1.02
1.02
1. 01
1.03
1. 01
35
.98
.98
1. 00
1. 01
1. 01
40
.99
• 99
.98
• 99
1. 00
50
1. 00
• 99
1. 01
• 99
.98
60
98
1 .00
1. 01
•97
.98
70
1. 00
.98
• 99
• 99
.98
80
.98
1. 00
1. 01
.96
.98
90
.98
1. 00
•97
1. 00
•97
99
.98
•97
1. 01
.98
.98
TABLE
1 1 — SILICON
IN 12X12
INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical Row.
from
Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.144
.144
.141
.141
5
•134
.141
10
.136
• 137
• 137
.140
•137
15
•134
• 134
•139
.136
•143
20
•138
.136
.138
•143
.136
25
.I36
.138
• 133
.140
.141
30
■133
.136
.138
.136
.126
35
•135
.128
•135
• 136
•131
40
.126
.128
.126
.126
•125
50
•131
.141
• 137
.136
•133
60
•135
.126
•131
.123
•134
70
.124
• 139
•131
.123
.128
80
.128
.132
• 135
•133
•137
90
.130
.140
•134
.122
.127
99
•139
.133
.129
•125
.127
G70
RAIL.
TABLE 12 — CARBON IN 15X15 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
I
47
44
44
52
42
5
39
46
10
39
46
64
15
41
48
70
78
79
20
43
53
65
74
82
25
53
50
65
66
69
30
55
52
56
63
7i
35
59
54
58
58
61
40
55
55
59
59
69
50
54
56
58
55
S6
60
55
•55
58
57
56
70
55
55
55
54
53
80
54
•55
53
52
5i
90
•5i
•53
.56
50
50
99
54
54
55
55
57
TABLE 13 — PHOSPHORUS IN I5XI5 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
1
079
065
5
054
074
10
055
069
15
060
074
20
080
084
25
087
075
30
•094
080
35
094
089
40
.094
097
50
098
099
60
098
098
70
093
o95
80
.094
094
90
093
096
99
.091
092
C.
D.
E.
060
.084
054
121
120
.165
181
124
.162
198
115
.130
136
092
•125
148
104
.106
114
109
.107
135
106
.096
105
103
.098
090
097
.091
087
094
.087
086
091
.084
084
092
.092
092
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
671
TABLE 14-
-SULPHUR
IN ISXI5
INGOT.
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
B.
c.
D.
E.
i
.026
.022
.021
.028
.020
5
.018
.026
....
10
.019
.025
•039
15
.019
.025
.050
.070
.076
20
.024
.025
•043
.060
.085
25
.038
.026
.040
.047
.056
30
.040
.029
•033
.046
.061
35
•034
•033
•033
.040
• 045
40
.O42
.042
.044
.041
•059
50
•039
.042
•045
.042
.041
60
•039
.041
.044
.042
•039
7o
•033
•033
.032
.031
.030
80
•033
.032
.032
.032
.030
90
•034
.032
.038
.038
.036
99
•039
.041
.041
•039
• 039
TABLE 15— MANGANESE IN 15x15 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
1.03
1.02
■99
.98
•98
5
1. 00
.96
10
•97
.98
1.03
15
•94
•99
1.07
1. 10
1 -15
20
• 99
•99
1.06
1.09
1.08
25
•99
1. 00
1. 01
1.07
1.07
30
•99
•99
. 1. 01
1.05
1.07
35
• 99
1. 00
1.03
1.03
i-03
40
.98
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00
1.04
50
• 99
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00
60
.98
.08
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00
70
1. 00
1. 01
•99
• 99
•98
80
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00
.98
.98
90
■99
1. 00
.98
■97
•97
99
•97
-97
•97
•97
•97
672
RAIL.
TABLE l6 — SILICON IN 1 5x15 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
B.
1
.130
150
5
.128
125
10
•134
128
is
.130
130
20
.130
128
25
.132
124
30
.124
126
35
.125
.122
40
.128
118
50
.126
117
60
.113
no
70
• 131
.127
80
.124
124
90
.120
122
99
.114
TABLE 17—
108
-CAR
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
B.
1
•47
53
5
•45
47
10
• 47
52
15
.46
5o
20
.48
48
25
• 52
56
30
•54
56
35
•55
57
40
•53
57
50
• 54
57
60
•57
54
70
•5i
53
80
•53
55
90
■54
55
99
•54
55
C.
D.
E.
160
145
155
134
137
137
137
129
132
136
130
126
133
130
128
125
132
133
126
112
132
128
118
122
138
122
122
112
118
123
118
118
114
119
112
118
113
120
128
124
CARBON IN l8xl8 INGOT.
Vertical Row.
C.
D.
.46
50
•52
.58
62
•57
75
•59
73
.61
62
.62
62
.62
58
•52
54
• 50
51
•54
52
• 52
52
. =2
<#
•49
47
•53
52
■So
73
61
59
54
51
50
47
45
52
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
673
TABLE l8 — PHOSPHORUS IN l8xl8 INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical Row.
from Top.
A.
B.
C. D.
E.
i
.064
.092
.067 .072
069
5
061
.069
.085
10
059
.085
. 104 . 128
15
067
.072
.098 .173
20
.086
.072
. 102 . 154
...
25
082
.087
.108 .112
192
30
089
.091
.111 .112
149
35
094
.098
.113 -107
126
4°
092
.100
.110 .101
101
50
096
.101
.105 .099
096
6o
096
.099
.097 .096
000
70
095
.096
.091 .089
082
80
093
.097
.093 .084
075
90
097
• 093
.084 .078
P77
99
091
•093
.094 .092
090
TABLE 19 — SULPHUR IN l8xl8 INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical Row.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.019
.031
.022
.025
027
5
.019
.020
.028
10
.019
.024
.029
.040
15
.021
.022
• 035
.060
20
.024
.025
.032
.058
25
.029
• 030
•039
.040
081
30
•033
■ 034
.041
.040
063
35
• 036
.036
.041
.040
045
40
.028
• 037
.040
.040
040
50
• 034
.039
•037
.039
034
60
.029
.032
•033
.031
028
7o
• 034
.031
.029
.030
029
80
•034
• 037
■034
.032
030
90
• 035
• 035
•033
.028
025
99
•034
■033
•035
• 034
034
674
RAIL.
TABLE 20 — MANGANESE IN l8xl8 INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical Row.
from
Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.90
96
.98
94
96
5
•93
92
.96
10
.92
96
•97
97
15
• 94
97
•99 1
04
20
.96
93
1. 00 1
04
25
•97
.98
1. 00 1
.01 1
09
30
•95
.96
.99 1
.01 1
05
35
•99 1
00
1. 00 1
.01 1
01
40
• 95
97
• 99
•97
98
50
.96
97
•97
•97
98
60
• 98
98
•98
•97
95
70
.98
97
.98
•97
97
80
1.03 1
03
1.02 1
.00
99
90
1.02 1
.01
1. 01
.98
94
99
1.03 1
03
1.03 1
.00 1
02
TABLE 21 — SILICON IN l8xi8 INGOT.
Per Cent.
Vertical Re
w.
from
Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
• 125
142
150
124
124
5
.125
130
128
10
.119
127
126
123
15
128
140
135
151
20
.139
133
134
148
...
25
.140
136
134
137
149
30
.129
130
128
129
128
35
•133
128
128
126
134
40
.140
142
138
143
141
50
.140
.138
136
134
130
60
.138
137
136
142
137
70
.147
144
143
130
133
80
.142
141
136
135
141
90
• U7
134
134
.142
134
09
• 137
137
129
137
138
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
675
TABLE 22 — CARBON IN 20x24 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
i
.40
• 39
48
39
41
• 5
.41
.46
IO
.41
•5i
56
59
15
•43
•5i
57
77
20
.46
•47
66
78
••
25
• 47
•52
60
63
85
30
• 54
•55
59
59
7i
35
.56
•54
59
59
66
40
•55
•55
60
62
65
50
•54
.56
58
55
55
60
•56
• 56
58
55
53
70
•56
• 56
56
52
48
80
•54
• 55
53
5o
47
90
•54
•55
52
50
49
99
• 55
•54
55
53
54
TABLE 23-
-PHOSPHORUS
[N 20X24 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E
1
•055
.050
074
.050
056
5
.051
.067
10
.054
•073
• 085
099
15
.058
•075
.085
.165
20
.064
.072
•093
•135
25
.071
.080
.094
.102
.199
30
.088
.O96
.107
.099
.136
35
.090
.097
.iog
.096
.149
40
.097
.098
.112
.104
.109
50
.094
.097
.104
.097
.088
60
•009
.097
099
.092
.081
70
•095
.097
.096
.089
.080
80
1094
.099
.092
.085
.078
90
.006
.098
.088
.085
.084
99
.094
.O94
• 093
•093
.094
676 RAIL.
TABLE 24 — SULPHUR IN 20X24 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
B.
c.
D.
E.
1
.018
.016
.030
.016
017
5
.017
.023
10
.019
.024
.028
.034
15
.019
.025
.027
.065
20
.022
.026
.031
• 055
25
.023
.028
•031
.041
084
30
.031
•033
.037
.036
061
35
.036
■ 037
.041
•035
058
40
•034
•034
•039
.040
045
SO
.031
• 035
•037
•034
030
60
■033
.031
•034
• 033
032
70
•033
• 035
.033
.032
028
80
.032
•033
• 033
.028
027
90
•035
.036
.031
.027
029
99
.031
.032
•033
.032
032
TABLE 25-
-MANGANESE IN 20X24
INGOT.
Per Cent.
from
Top.
A.
B.
c.
D.
E.
1
.92
.94
•97
1. 00
99
5
.90
•94
10
.92
•95
•99
1. 00
15
•95
•98
1. 00
1. 10
20
•94
•97
•99
1.07
...
25
.96
1. 00
1.03
1.04 1
10
30
.98
1. 00
1.04
1.03 1
09
35
1. 01
1 .01
1.02
1. 00 1
.03
40
• 99
1. 00
1.09
1.02 1
.02
50
I.C2
1. 00
1. 01
• 99
97
60
•99
1. 00
1.03
1.02
.98
70
•99
1. 00
1. 01
•95
.96
80
1. 00
1. 01
1. 00
1. 01
97
90
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00
1. 00 1
01
99
•99
• 99
•99
1. 01 1
02
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
677
TABLE 26 — SILICON IN 20X24 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.120
• 137
133
•152
.129
5
.122
.124
10
.128
.130
130
.140
15
.124
.123
124
.130
20
.123
•135
134
.142
25
• 125
.121
126
■ 133
• 134
30
.130
.127
137
.128
• 133
35
• 134
• 137
134
.130
• 135
40
• 133
• 131
133
.130
.128
50
.128
• 133
131
• 133
.127
60
.129
• 133
.130
• 135
.124
70
.132
.128
• 125
.129
.129
80
.130
.138
.130
.132
.130
90
.132
• 134
.136
.129
.130
99
.129
.132
.132
• 134
.132
TABLE 27 — CARBON IN 25x30 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
• 47
.40
.46
48
49
5
.42
• 37
.41
59
61
10
• 39
• 45
.60
62
IS
•42
•47
.66
88 1.
04
20
.42
• 49
.66 1
00 1
18
25
.46
•5i
• 76
85
88
30
.46
• fo
.66
69
77
35
• 47
• 56
.65
68
77
40
• 53
.56
.62
64
70
5o
•5i
•54
.60
55
52
60
•52
■ 57
•54
54
49
70
• 55
•56
•55
•5i
49"
80
•54
•54
•49
.46
45
00
• 53
■ 5,3
•4«
.48
48
99
•54
•54
•54
•55
•54
678
RAIL.
TABLE 28 — PHOSPHORUS IN 25x30 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.074
.062
.066
.086
.083
5
.052
.064
.066
.108
.116
10
.052
.064
.110
.110
15
• 053
.072
.121
.205
• 295
20
.065
.072
.110
.265
.302
25
.062
.077
.128
•174
.199
30
.072
.078
.120
.142
.174
35
.070
.083
.121
.132
.176
40
.087
.080
.117
.122
• 134
50
.089
.088
.106
.101
• 095
60
.094
.100
.096
.094
.082
70
•09s
.100
.100
.089
.080
80
.094
.102
.085
.076
.072
90
.094
• 095
.085
.082
.083
99
• 093
.096
•095
• 995
• 095
TABLE 29 — SULPHUR IN 25x30 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.027
.022
.022
027
.030
5
.017
.020
.022
039
• 039
10
.013
.020
• 035
.040
15
.020
.024
.041
084
.124
20
.023
.026
•043
no
.164
25
.029
.032
• 055
072
.083
30
.027
.027
.043
053
.068
35
.027
.031
• 043
047
.072
40
.031
.029
.044
048
.058
50
.031
.030
.041
039
• 035
60
• 035
.038
.036
037
.031
70
.032
.040
.044
032
.027
80
.034
• 043
.032
038
.026
90
.036
.036
.030
029
.031
99
• 035
.032
.037
037
.041
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
679
TABLE 30 — MANGANESE IN 25x30 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.91
94
95
95
96
5
.92
92
92 1
01 1.
02
10
.91
94 x.
03
1.
04
15
.92
94 1
00 1
18 1
24
20
•95
96 1.
01 1
19 1
26
25
•95
.96 1
05 1
12 1
15
30
• 95
96 1.
06 1
08 1
10
35
•95
96 1
03 1
04 1
07
40
•97
96 1.
03 1
04 1
03
50
.98
.98
99
98
08
60
.98
.98
98
97
96
70
.98
• 99
99
98
98
80
.98
99
98
97
97
90
.98
.98
96
96
96
99
• 98
.98
98
97
98
TABLE 31—
SILICON IN
25x30 INGOT.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
c.
D.
E.
1
.116
.150
136
123
128
5
.122
.122
125
.132
134
10
.127
•139
131
137
15
.130
.122
143
.144
152
20
.132
■ 133
.140
.158
.150
25
.120
.126
140
• 139
137
30
•133
• 133
• 139
.141
144
35
.136
.136
139
144
147
40
•139
.136
135
138
144
50
.138
.130
138
136
135
60
.130
.136
138
.136
136
70
.130
.130
134
133
130
80
.127
.130
.130
.130
128
90
.128
• 131
135
• 137
139
99
.132
.132
.132
• 134
.130
1)80 RAIL.
Probably the five samples from the bottom of the ingot represent
pietty well the average steel in the ingot, and the average results are shown
in table 32.
TABLE 32 — AVERAGES OF SAMPLES 99A-B-C-D AND E.
Ingot. C. P. S. Mn. Si.
12x12 (.616) .0926 .0326 .984 -I31
15x15 552 .0918 .0398 .970 .119
18x18 532 .0920 .0340 1.022 .136
20x24 542 .0936 .0320 1. 000 .132
25x30 542 -0948 .0364 -978 -132
Average 54 -093 -Q35 -99 .13°
The general average of each element shown in the table can probably
be taken as representing the heat. The carbon in the 12x12 ingot shows
.616 per cent., which is considerably higher than in the other ingots,
namely, .542 per cent., and it has been omitted in obtaining the general
average, although it can probably be taken as correct for the 12x12 ingot,
as the determinations were thoroughly checked.
A study of the analyses shows that in general the extreme variations
in composition at any given distance from the top of the ingot are shown
by the axis and the walls of the ingot, in the upper part of the ingot
the axis showing considerably higher carbon, phosphorus and sulphur
than the walls, while in the lower part of the ingot the axis shows lower
amounts of these elements. Manganese also shows a similar separation,
but to a much smaller extent. Silicon remains fairly evenly distributed
throughout the ingot. In order to show conveniently the changes of
composition from the top to the bottom of the ingot, I give in Figs. 10
to 14, inclusive, carbon, phosphorus and sulphur diagrams for the five
ingots. The distance from the top of the ingot, in per cent., is plotted
horizontally, and the amount of the element vertically, and both the axis
and the wall are represented. These diagrams show some very inter-
esting results, and should be studied closely. The average carbon, phos-
phorus and sulphur in the heat, as deduced above, are shown on the dia-
grams, and it will be noticed that the axis shows very strong segrega-
tion of the carbon, phosphorus and sulphur in the upper part of the
ingot, while in the lower part of the ingot these elements go somewhat
below the average amount, or show "negative" segregation. Close to the
top the axis shows negative segregation also. The wall of the ingot
shows negative segregation in the upper third, and about the average
composition in the lower half of the ingot. The maximum carbon found
in the axis, the minimum in the axis in the lower half of the ingot, and
the minimum amount found in the wall, are shown for the several ingots
in table 33.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
681
12 x 12 INGOT
Side
10 2.0 30 40 5 0 €0 ?0 SO 90 100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 9o too
CentcT
' J03S
I
<*«-<£
Side.
10 20 30 40 50 GO 70 60 90 \60
Percent from Top ©/ Imgot
Fig. 10 — Carbon, Phosphorus and Sulphur Diagrams of the 12x12
Ingot.
682
RAIL.
15x15 INGOT
IO 20 30 40 50 60 7Q 80 90 loo
Percent /rom Top o/ Ingot
Fig. 11 — Carbon, Phosphorus and Sulphur Diagrams of the 15x15
Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
18x18 I NG-OT
.80
.60
O
K.40
8
O20
.'60
(0
o
Pp80
to
o
5^°
»•©-■
10 20 Jt 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 loc
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 60 90 100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 SO 90 loo
Percent from Top 0/ Ingot
Fig. 12 — Carbon, Phosphorus and Sulphur Diagrams of the 18x18
Ingot.
684
80
o
20
0.| 2
$08
>04
08
k06
fi<04
">o2
RAIL.
20x24 INGOT
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 KX
tO 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 loc
IO 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 loo
Per cert t from Top o/ Ingot
Fig. 13 — Carbon, Phosphorus and Sulphur Diagrams of the 20x24
Ingot.
25x30 INGOT
120
f-oo
fc«0
o
0
^.40
20
o
.28
.24
5-20
k
o
<I6
R.
0.12
.08
.04
16
k.,2
R.08
(004
fO 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 loc
IO 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 SO IOO
Percent from Tojo of Ingot
Fig. 14 — Carbon, Phosphorus and Sulphur Diagrams of the 25x30
Ingot.
686
RAIL.
Axis
Wall
Minimum.
Minimum
• 55
.48
•5o
•39
•45
•45
•47
.40
• 45
•39
TABLE 33 — MAXIMUM AND MINIMUM CARBON.
Axis
Ingot. Maximum.
12x12 82
15x15 82
18x18 80
20x24 85
25x30 1 • 18
The average carbon in the heat was .54 per cent., except in the
12x12 ingot, where it was about .62 per cent., as explained above. Why
this difference should have been I cannot say, but of the causes that
can be conjectured, a reasonable one seems to be that the additional
carbon may have been absorbed from the tar used to spray the molds.
It must be recognized, however, that this explanation is purely a con-
jecture. The maximum segregation is seen from the diagrams to occur
at about 10 to 20 or 25 per cent, from the top of the ingot. In general,
the maximum segregation seems to occur about 20 per cent., by distance,
from the top of the ingot, which would be about 15 per cent., or a little
more, by weight, and in general the per cent, of segregation increases
as the size of the ingot increases, as indicated by table 34.
TABLE 34 — POSITIVE SEGREGATION OF CARBON.
Maximum
Ingot. Carbon. Increase.
12x12 82 32 per cent.
15x15- 82 52
18x18 80 48
20x24 85 57
25x30 1. 18 119 "
The per cent, of segregation in the 12x12 ingot is probably greater
than shown above, due to the uncertainty of the average carbon.
The lowest carbon content or greatest negative segregation occurs
close to the top of the ingot. Considering the walls of the ingot, the
least carbon is found about 5 per cent, from the top, and it gradually
increases until the average carbon is reached, somewhat above the middle
of the ingot, when the amount remains about constant the rest of the
way down. In other words, in the upper third of the ingot the walls
are softer than the average steel, The per cent, of greatest decrease of
carbon is shown in table 35.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
687
TABLE 35 — .NEGATIVE SEGREGATION OF CARBON.
Minimum
Ingot. Carbon. Decrease.
12x12
15x15
18x18
.48
23
per cent.
•39
28
"
•45
17
"
.40
26
"
•39
28
"
20x24
25x30
The per cent, of the maximum decrease, as shown in this table, seems
to bear no relation to the size of the ingot.
The maximum phosphorus found in the axis, the minimum in the
axis in the lower half of the ingot, and the minimum phosphorus found
in the wall, are shown in table 36 for the several ingots.
TABLE 36 — MAXIMUM AND MINIMUM PHOSPHORUS.
Ingot.
12X12
15X15
I8xl8
20X24
25X30
Axis.
Wall.
ax.
Increase.
Min.
Min. Decrease.
188
102%
.084
.063 32%
198
113%
.084
• 054 42%
192
106%
•075
• 059 36%
199
114%
.078
• 051 45%
302
225%
.072
• 052 44%
No samples for analysis were taken from the axis between 1 per cent,
and 25 per cent, from the top from the 18x18 and 20x24 ingots, account of
cavities or sponginess, but a study of the diagrams in connection with the
results in table 36 seems to show that the segregation of phosphorus in-
creases as the size of the ingot increases. The average phosphorus in the
heat was about .093 per cent., and the maximum segregation of phosphorus,
or increase above the average amount, ranged from about 100 per cent,
in the 12x12 ingot, to over 200 per cent, in the 25x30 ingot.
The greatest negative segregation of phosphorus in the wall of the
upper third of the ingot ranged from 32 to 45 per cent, showing a slight
tendency to increase with the size of the ingot.
In table 37, the results for sulphur are given similar to the ones
given for phosphorus.
TABLE 37 — MAXIMUM AND MINIMUM SULPHUR.
Ingot. Max.
12x12 070
15x15 085
18x18 081
20x24 .084
25x30 164
Axis.
Wall.
Increase.
Min.
Min.
Decrease.
100%
.029
.020
43%
143%
.030
.018
49%
131%
.028
.019
46%
140%
.027
.017
51%
369%
.026
.013
63%
688 RAIL.
The average sulphur in the heat was .035 per cent., and the maximum
segregation ranged from 100 per cent, in the 12x12 ingot, to 369 per cent.
in the 25x30 ingot. The greatest negative segregation of sulphur in the
wall of the ingot ranged from 43 per cent, to 63 per cent., increasing in
general somewhat with the size of the ingot.
From the above discussion and the diagrams, it will be noted that
the greatest segregation occurred with the sulphur, the next in per-^
centage with the phosphorus, arid carbon ranked third in per cent, of
segregation. Another point of interest is that the various elements
segregate together, that is, the concentrations occur in the same areas,
although the percentages differ for the different elements.
In order to show more clearly than the tables the separation of the
elements into areas of different concentrations, Fig. 15 is given, show-
ing the distribution of phosphorus throughout the ingot for each of
the five different ingots. These diagrams show regions of six different
concentrations of phosphorus, as follows :
A — Below .070 per cent.
B — .070 to .085 per cent.
C — .085 to .105 per cent.
D — '.105 to .135 per cent.
E — .135 to .175 per cent.
F — Above .175 per cent.
The same diagrams would represent regions of different concentra-
tions of carbon and of sulphur, but phosphorus was selected for this
purpose, as it seems to have been very uniform throughout the heat
before pouring, while the average carbon in the 12x12 ingot seems to
have been materially higher than in the other ingots, and the sulphur seems
to show some variations, although of considerably less importance.
The amounts of carbon and sulphur represented by the above regions
would be about as follows :
Carbon.
Sulphur.
A
Below .47 per
cent.
Below .024 per cent.
B
•47 to .51 "
"
.024 to .030 " "
C
■51 to .57 "
"
.030 to .042 " "
D
.57 to .66 "
"
.042 to .055 '
E
.66 to .77 "
"
.055 to .070 '
F
Above .77 "
"
Above .070 " "
The area of maximum concentration indicated by F, and for which
the minimum limit of .175 per cent, phosphorus has been chosen, is seen
to lie in the upper part of the ingot, and also to extend lower down
into the ingot as the size of the ingot increases. The middle of this
region extends from about 10 per cent, of the length from the top of
the 12x12 ingot, to a little over 20 per cent, from the top in the 25x30
ingot. By weight the amounts would be several per cent. less. Area
C represents steel of average composition, while B represents steel with
negative segregation. AH the ingots show some of the B area in the
lower part of the ingot, but its proportionate amount increases in general
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
689
1 1
i i i
i i
1 1
x^Mc
llll^
■-.
=^$^2
o "'
^3 >-'
3 o
Uh
690 RAIL.
as the size of the ingot increases. The greatest negative segregation is
seen in area A at the top of the ingot, which contains less than .070
per cent, phosphorus. This area includes the walls of the upper part
of the ingot, and is seen to extend downward along the walls an in-
creasing distance as the size of the ingot increases. The area A would
also represent carbon below about .47 per cent., with the average in the
steel .54 per cent. The distance that area A extends downward from
the top along the walls of the ingot, and the distance downward that
it is necessary to go along the walls to reach the average of .093 per cent,
phosphorus and .54 per cent, carbon, are shown in table 38.
TABLE 38 — NEGATIVE SEGREGATION IN WALLS OF INGOT.
Area A extends Distance of Average
Ingot down from top. Steel from top.
12x12 13% 30%
15x15 15% 30%
18x18 15% 35%
20x24 24% 35%
25x30 30% 50%
RAILS FOR SPECIAL TESTS.
A second series of five ingots was made similar to the first series,
for rolling into rails for drop tests, etchings and chemical analyses,
with ingot numbers as follows: 12x12, II9; 15x15, II 10; 18x18, II 11 ;
20x24, II 12 ; 25x30, II 13. After stripping, the three smaller ingots were
placed into a soaking pit at the rail mill, and after remaining in the pit
for two hours, were rolled into rails of 100 lbs. A. R. A. -type B sec-
tion, Illinois Steel Company section 10030, making only sufficient
cropping from the ends of the blooms to allow of rolling into rails. On
account of its small size the 12x12 in. ingot gave trouble by catching
in the various rolls, and finally made a "cobble" in the roughing rolls.
The 20x24 in. and 25x30 in. ingots were too large to enter the bloom-
ing rolls of the rail mill, so they were first bloomed down at the
structural mill at South Chicago, after heating in the soaking pit. The
20x24 in- ingot was in the soaking pit 2 hrs. 20 min., bloomed to 16x16
in., reheated for V2 hr., bloomed to 14x14 in. and cut in two. The
second heating was not intended, but was necessary, because, after the
first blooming, the bloom had become too cold to shear in two. The
25x30 in. ingot was in the pit 2 hrs. 40 min., rolled to 16x16 in., and
the bloom cut in two. These blooms were then brought to the rail mill,
put into the soaking pit for 3 hrs., and rolled into rails as above. The
two parts from the 25x30 in. ingot were each cut in two, after bloom-
ing to about 8x8 in., as the rail bar would otherwise have been too long
for the runways. The rail bars of the 15x15 and 18x18 ingots were each
rolled in one piece, the 20x24 ingot in two pieces, and the 25x30 ingot in
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 691
four pieces. There were no croppings from any of the rail bars, except
from the 25x30 ingot.
The weights of the individual rails are shown in table 39.
TABLE 39 — WEIGHTS OF RAILS.
Ingot number II 10
Ingot size 15x15
Rail A 1,085
B 1,109
C 660
D
E
F
G
II
11 II
11 12
11 13
18x18
20X24
25x30
1,100
1,076
1,107
1,128
1,095
1,102
1,120
990
1,114
1,000
1,075
i,H5
1,098
1,080
936
1,100
1,097
1,110
Total 2,854 4,348 6,270 8,825
The several croppings from the rail bar of the 25x30 ingot were
as shown in table 40.
TABLE 40 — CROPPINGS FROM 25x30 RAIL BAR.
A rail, top end 44 lbs.
B " back end 120 "
C " top end 75 "
D " back end 260"
F " back end 296 "
Total 795 lbs.
The total weights of the ingots, as determined from the weights
of the rails, and the bloom and rail croppings, are shown in table 41.
TABLE 41 — WEIGHTS OF INGOTS.
Ingot number II 10 II 11 II 12 II 13
Ingot size 15x15 18x18 20x24 25x30
Rails 2,854 4,348 6,270 8,825
Bloom Crops — -
Top 97 115 118 218
1st intermediate 125 115
2nd intermediate 113 109
Bottom 103 78 115 130
Rail crops 795
Total 3,054 4,54i. 6,741 10,192
The lengths of the full-length rails were measured, and are shown
in table 42.
692
RAIL.
TABLE 42 — LENGTH OF RAILS.
Ingot number U 10
Ingot size 15x15
Rail A
B .... 33' o"
C
D
E
F
G
H
II 11
18x18
33' 0%'
33 0%
II 12
20x24
32' 1 1 24'
32 n 34
11 13
25x30
33' oy4f
32 nVs
33 oy&
33 °lA
32 nVs
33 o
The saws are usually set for this section for a shrinkage of 6^4 in.,
and this was the allowance in this case, although I did not measure
the saw setting at the time these rails were rolled.
The various rails in this series were divided into units of one-third
rail, or 11 ft. each, for drop tests, analyses and etchings. From each
unit 1 ft. was cut for etching and analysis, then 5 ft. for drop test
with the head in tension, and the other 5 ft. for drop test with the base
in tension. The pieces from each rail were given numbers as folV)ws :
No. 1. 1 ft. Analysis and etching.
2. 5 ft. Drop test, head tension.
3. 5 ft. Drop test, base tension.
4. 1 ft. Analysis and etching.
5. 5 ft. Drop test, head tension.
6. 5 ft. Drop test, base tension.
7. 1 ft. Analysis and etching.
8. 5 ft. Drop test, head tension.
9. 5 ft. Drop test, base tension.
The distance of each test piece from the top of the ingot, expressed
in lbs., is shown in tables 43 to 46, inclusive. The samples for analysis,
and the section for etching, were taken from the lower end of the
i-ft piece, and the distances are shown to the lower end of the piece,
but the 5-ft. pieces were struck in the drop test at the middle of the
piece, and the distances are calculated to the middle.
TABLE 43 — TEST PIECES OF 1 5X1 5 INGOT — LBS. FROM TOP OF INGOT.
Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs.
II10A1 130 II10B1 1,215
A2.
A3.
A4.
A5.
A6.
A7.
A8.
213
380
496
579
746
862
945
A9 1,112
B2.
B3-
B4.
B5-
B6.
B7-
1,298
1465
1,581
1,664
.1,831
• 1,947
Test. Lbs.
II 10 Ci 2,324
C2 2 407
C3 2,574
C4 2,690
C5 2,773
B8 2,030
B9 2,197
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 693
TABLE 44 — TEST PIECES OF l8xl8 INGOT — LBS. FROM TOP OF INGOT.
Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs.
11 ii Ai 148 II 11 Bi 1,248 II 11 Ci 2,376 II11D1 3,496
A2 231 B2 1,333 C2 2,459 D2 3,579
A3 398 B3 1,498 C3 2,626 D3 3,746
A4 514 B4 1,614 C4 2,742 D4 3,862
A5 597 B5 1,697 C5 2,825 D5 3,945
A6 764 B6 1,864 C6 2,992 D6 4,112
A7 880 B7 1,980 C7 3,108 D7 4,228
A8 963 B8 2,063 C8 3,191 D8 4,311
A9 1,130 B9 2,230 C9 3,358
TABLE 45 — TEST PIECES OF 20X24 INGOT — LBS. FROM TOP OF INGOT.
Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs.
II12A1 151 II12B1 1,227 H12C1 2,322
A2 234 B2 1,310 C2 2,405
A3 401 B3 1,477 C3 2,572
A4 517 B4 1,593 C4 2,688
A5 600 B5 1,676 C5 2,771
A6 767 B6 1,843 C6 2,938
A7 883 B7 1,959 C7 3,054
A8 966 B8 2,042 C8 3,137
A9 1,133 B9 2,209
TABLE 45 — CONTINUED.
Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs.
II12D1 3,550 II 12 Ei 4,625 II12F1 5,723
D2 3,663 E2 4,708 F2 5,806
D3 3,8oo E3 4,875 F3 5,973
D4 3,916 E4 4,991 F4. ....6,089
D5 3,999 E5 5,074 F5 6,172
D6 4.166 E6 5,241 F6 6,339
D7 4,282 E7 5,357 F7 6,455
D8 4,365 E8 5,440 F8 6,538
D9 4,532 E9 5,607
TABLE 46 — TEST PIECES OF 25x30 INGOT — LBS. FROM TOP OF INGOT.
Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs Test. Lbs.
II 13 Ai 295 II 13 Bi 1,392 II 13 Ci 2,699 H13D1 3,813
A2..... 378 B2 1,485 C2 2,782 D2 3,896
A3 545 B3 1,652 C3 2,949 D3 4,063
A4 661 B4 1,768 C4 3,065 D4 4,179
A5 744 B5 1,851 C5 3,148 D5 4,262
A6 911 B6 2,018 C6 3,315 D6 4,429
A7 1,027 B7 2,134 C7 3,431 D7 4,545
A8 1,110 B8 2,217 C8 3,514 D8 4,628
A9 1,277 B9 2,388 C9 3,681 D9 4.795
694 RAIL.
TABLE 46 — CONTINUED.
Test, Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs. Test. Lbs.
II13E1 5,412 U15F1 6,492 H13G1 7,888 II 13 Hi 8,985
E2 5,494 F2 6,575 G2 7,971 H2 9,068
E3 5,662 F3 6,742 G3 8,138 H3 9,235
E4 5,778 F4 6,858 G4 8,254 H4 9,351
E5 5,86i F5 6,941 G5 8,337 H5 9,434
E6 6,028 F6 7,108 G6 8,504 H6 9,601
E7 6,144 F7 7,224 G7 8,620 H7 9,717
E8 6,227 F8 7,307 G8 8,703 H8 9,800
E9 6,394 F9 7,474 G9 8,870 H9 9,967
DROP TESTS.
Six drop tests were made of each full length rail, three with the
head in tension, and three with the base in tension, in the standard
rail drop test machine. The tup was 2,000 lbs., the height of drop was
20 ft., the supports were 3 ft. apart, and the anvil was the standard
spring-supported anvil of 20,000 lbs. The deflection was taken as the
distance between a 3-ft. straight edge and the part of the rail where
struck by the tup. Gage marks 1 inch apart were put on the side in
tension for a distance of 6 inches, and the stretch of each inch was
determined after the rail was broken. The results of the drop tests are
shown in the following tables :
Table 47 — 15x15 Ingot.
Table 48 — 18x18 Ingot.
Table 49 — 20x24 Ingot.
»l VIJ Ul « J ; TabIe 50—25x30 Ingot.
In these tables the permanent deflection, after the first blow, would
represent the stiffness of the rail under impact, and the elongation of
the inch which stretched most at breaking would represent the ductility
of the metal. The number of blows which it took to break each rail is
also shown.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
695
TABLE 47 — DROP TESTS OF I 5X1 5 INGOT.
H
II 10 A2
A3
A5
A6
A8
m q u-,
o c
Head
Base
Base
Base
Head
.2^
do ^
£pq Q £
i -Inch Marks After Failure,
i. 2. 3. 4. s. 6.
i. os 1.08 1.09 1 08 1.06
1.54 1.06 1.08 1. 11 1. 13 1. 13
1.58 1.04 1.08 1. 10 1. 12 1. 13 1. 12
1.53 1. 10 1. 12 1. 16 1. 16 1. 14 1. 10
1.70 1.06 1. 11 1. 16 1. 19 1. 18 1. 13
Remarks.
Tested base
tension by
mistake.
A9 Base 3 1.65 1.06 1. 10 1. 12 1. 14 1. 14 1. 12
II10B2 Head 3 1.70 1.09 1.14 1.18 1.20 1.18 1.14
B3 Base 1 .... Neglected to put on gage marks.
B5 Head 3 1.69 1.12 1 . 14 1.20 1.19 1.15 1.09
B6 Base 1 .... 1.02 1.03 1.03 1.03 1.03 1.02
B8 Head 4 1.68 1.17 1.22 1.22 1.19 1.14 1.10 Not broken.
Bent sidewise.
B9 Base 3 1.68 1.06 1. 10 1. 13 1. 14 1. 12 1. 10 Diagonal break
not at bend.
II 10 C2 Head 3 1.65 1.09 1.13 1.15 1.14 1.11 1.07 Broke at sup-
port.
C3 Base 1 1. 00 1.02 1.02 1.02 1.02 1.02 Broke at sup-
port.
C5 Head 4 1.72 1.09 1.14 1.18 1.18 1.17 1.12
696 RAIL.
TABLE 48 — DROP TESTS OF l8xl8 INGOT.
d -2*
fflo vw „; t>J2
** fc'S ° & eW i-Inch Marks After Failure.
H ffiH fcg Q 2 i- 2. 3. 4- 5- 6. Remarks.
11 11 A2 Head 5 1.92 1.17 1.24 1.32 1.36 1.32 1.22 Not broken.
Base split.
A3 Base 4 1.73 1. 13 1. 16 1. 18 1. 19 1. 19 1. 12
A5 Head 1 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.06 .... 1.04
A6 Base 4 1.60 1.14 1.19 1.20 1.18 1.12 1.08
A8 Head 1 1.07 1.09 1.09 1.08 1.06 1.04
A9 Base 4 1.58 1. 11 1. 15 1.17 1.17 1.14 ....
II11B2 Head 2 1.69 1.05 1.07 1.09 1.10 1.09 1.06
B3 Base s 1.64 1. 13 1. 18 1.21 1.21 1.20 1.17
Bs Head 4 1.61 1.14 1.20 1.25 1.25 1 21 1.20 Broke at sup-
port.
B6 Base 5 1.70 1.11 1.16 1.22 1.26 1.26 1. 21 Broke at sup-
port.
B8 Head 4 1.74 1. 14 1. 19 1.24 1.25 1.22 1. 15
B9 Base 5 1.68 1.18 1.20 1.20 1.17 1.14 1.11 Broke at sup-
port.
II 11 C2 Head 3 1.79 1.07 1 . 12 1.15 1.18 1.15 .... Base cracked
under tup
1st blow.
1. 65 1. 11 1. 15 1. 17 1. 17 1. 16 1. 12
1.70 1.08 1. 12 1. 18 1.22 1.22 1. 18
1. 71 1.08 1.08 1. 13 1. 13 1.08
1.70 1. 12 1. 16 1. 17 1. 17 1. 13 1. 10 Flange broke.
1.64 1. 10 1. 14 1. 17 1. 18 1. 18 1. 16
1.80 1.08 1. 10 1. 14 1. 21 1.24 1.24
1.64 1. 14 1. 17 1.18 1. 17 1. 14 1. 10
1.75 1. 14 1. 18 1.23 1.23 1. 14
1.66 1. 10 1. 15 1. 17 1. 17 1. 16 1. 12
1.68 1.06 1. 10 1. 14 1. 16 1. 17 1. 14
•c3
Base
4
cs
Head
3
C6
Base
3
cs
Head
3
Cg
Base
4
II11D2
Head
5
D3
Base
3
D5
Head
4
D6
Base
3
D8
Head
3
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
697
TABLE 4Q DROP TESTS OF 20X24 INGOT.
w
c
pq.c
O G
fflH
n .
.2 £
-M COO .8
0 &^pq i-Inch -Marks After Failure.
£5p2 i- 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Remarks.
li 12 A2
Head
4
I.96 I. 13 I. 18 I.24 J. 22 I. 18 I. 12
Laminated.
A3
Base
4
I.80 I. 12 I. 17 I. 18 I. 17 I. 14 I. IO
Broke at sup
port.
A5
Head
2
I.84 1.08 I. II I. 13 I. 14 I.08
A6
Base
3
I.76 1.08 I. 12 I. 14 I. 13 I. II I.08
A8
Head
2
i. 71 1.07 i. 10 — i. ix i. 10 1.07
Ao
Base
3
1.66 1. 12 1. 13 1. 12 1.09 .... 1.08
II12B2
Head
1
. ... 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.06 1.06 1.04
B3
Base
3
1.59 1. 10 1. 12 1. 12 1. 11 1.08 1.06
BS
Head
2
1.66 1.08 1. 10 1. 13 1. 13 1. 10 1.07
B6
Base
3
1.62 1.08 1. 10 1. 12 1. 12 1. 12 1. 10
B8
Head
2
1.66 1.04 1.06 1.08 1. 10 1. 11 1. 12
B9
Base
3
1.64 1. 10 1. 13 1. 16 1. 16 1. 12 1. 10
11 12 C2
Head
2
t.64 1.08 1. 12 1. 17 1. 17 1. 13 1.09
C3
Base
3
[.72 1.06 1.09 1. 15 1.20 1.22 1. 16
C5
Head
3
[.64 1. 11 1. 18 1.20 1. 18 1 14 1.09
C6
Base
3
[.64 1. 11 1. 16 1. 18 1. 18 1. 14 1. 10
C8
Head
3
[.64 1. 10 1. 16 1.22 1.22 1. 19 1. 12
11 12 D2
Head
4
[.69 1. 14 1. 18 1.20 1.20 1. 16
D3
Base
5
[.62 1. 16 1. 19 1. 19 1. 18 1. 14 ....
D5
Head
4
[.72 1. 15 1.20 1.24 1.23 1. 18 1. 11
D6
Base
5 1
.58 1. 12 1. 17 1.20 1.22 1.20 ....
D8
Head
4 J
.65 1. 18 1.24 1.26 1.22 .... 1. 10
Do
Base
4 l
.62 1. 12 1. 16 1.20 1.20 1. 18 1. 14
11 12 E2
Head
4 i
.74 1. 18 1. 21 1.20 1. 11 1.06
E3
Base
5 i
.65 1. 15 1.20 1.22 1.22 1. 18 1. 12
E5
Head
4 I
.69 1 . 14 1. 18 1. 21 1.22 1. 17 1. 13
E6
Base
5 J
.72, 1 10 1. 14 1. 19 1.20 1.20 1. 18
E8
Head
4 1
.75 1.08 1. 10 1. 13 1. 19 1.22 1.22
Eg
Base
3 i
.69 1.08 1. 12 1. 14 1. 16 1. 15 1. 13
Broke at sup
port.
11 12 ¥2
Head
3 1
.74 1. 10 1. 14 1. 17 1. 17 .... 1. 10
F3
Base
3 1
.68 1.08 1. 11 1. 15 1. 17 1. 17 1. 15
F5
Head
3 1
.68 1. 14 1. 21 1.25 1.25 1. 19 1. 12
¥6
Base
4 1
.70 1. 10 1. 14 1. 18 1. 17 1. 16 1. 13
F8
Head
I
... 1.02 1.04 1.04 1.05 1.04 1.03 \
_arge horizon-
tal flaw in
head.
H98 RAIL.
TABLE 50 — DROP TESTS OF 25x30 INGOT.
a .2*
m o mh ^ 3.2
*J £ g °^ i^ffl i-Inch Marks After Failure.
£ Sh 2WQ2 ^ 2- 3- 4- 5- 6. Remarks.
II13A2 Head 5 2.12 1. 19 1.24 1.26 1.24 1 . 18 1.14 Not broken.
A3 Base 4 1.93 1. 12 1. 17 1.22 1.26 1.26 1.23 Laminated in
web.
A5 Head 3 1.92 1.12 1 . 18 1. 21 1.20 1 . 16 1.11
A6 Base 5 1.82 1.08 1.14 1.18 1.24 1.32 1.36 Base not
broken.
A8 Head 2 1.86 1.07 1 . 10 1 . 14 1.15 1.J4 1.10
A9 Base 2 1.82 1.07 1. 10 1. n 1. 12 1. 11 1.08
II 13 B2 Head 1 .... 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.08 1.08 1.07
B3 Base 3 1.78 1. 12 1. 16 1. 19 1.24 1. 18 1. 14
B5 Head 1 1.02 1.04 1.05 1 .07 1.05 1.04
B6 Base 2 1.72 1.06 1.08 1.10 1.11 1.10 1.07
B8 Head 1 .... 1.02 1.04 1.07 1.08 1.07 1.06
B9 Base 2 1.72 1.07 1.08 1. 10 1. 12 1. 11 1.08
[1 13 C2 Head 2 1.68 1.09 1.09 1.08 1.06 1.06
C3 Base 2 1.66 1.04 1.07 1. 10 1. 12 1. 14 1. 12
C5 Head 2 1.68 1.04 1.07 1.10 1.15 1.20 1.15
C6 Base 4 1 .62 1.09 1. 14 1. 18 1.20 1.22 1. 17
C8 Head 2 1.68 1.05 1.07 1.10 1.11 1.10 1.07
C9 Base 4 1.59 1. 12 1. 15 1. 17 1. 17 1. 16
[1 13 D2 Head 3 1.52 1.07 1.12 1.16 1.19 1. 17 1. 12
D3 Base 4 1.58 1. 11 1. 16 1. 18 1. 16 1. 16 1. 12
D5 Head 3 1.60 1.08 1.12 1.18 1.18 1.17 1.12
D6 Base 4 1.58 1. 10 1.16 1.18 1.18 1.17 1.14
D8 Head 3 1.65 1.12 1.18 1.20 1.18 1.14 1.08
D9 Base 4 1.58 1.06 1. 10 1. 14 1. 18 1. 18 1. 15
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
699
TABLE 50 — CONTINUED.
in
<L>
H
d
PQO
0 c
M-l if)
O £
6 O
.2 £
i-Inch Marks After Failure.
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Re
narks.
11
13 E2
Head
2
1. 61
1.04 1.07
I.IO I. II ]
.11
1.09
E3
Base
3
1.58
1.08 1. 12
I. 14 I. 14 1
.12
1.08
ES
Head
2
1.74
1.08 1. 10
I. 12 I. 12
.09
1.07
E6
Base
4
1.60
1.08 1. 12
LIS I-I5 J
.14
I.IO
Broke at both
supports.
E8
Head
2
1.72
1. 12 1 . 16
I. l6 I. 15
•13
1.07
Eg
Base
3
1.66
1 . 08 1 . 1 1
I. 14 I. l6
•15
11
13 F2
Head
3
1.70
1.06 1. 12
I. If 1.20
.18
1. 14
F3
Base
4
1.67
1.08 1. 12
I.l6 I. l8
.18
1.16
F5
Head
4
1.76
I. IO LIS
I. 20 I. 23
.26
1.20
F6
Base
5
1-77
I. 12 I. 18
I . 20 I . 20 1
.18
1. 14
F8
Head
3
1.74
I. 14 I. l8
I . 20 I . 20 1
.16
1 . 10
Only
bas
side of
e broken.
Fg
Base
4
1.70
I . 12 I. l6
I. 18 I. l8
.16
1.14
n
13 G2
Head
5
1.86
I. IO I. 14
I.2I I.25 ]
• 32
1.28
■
G3
Base
5
1.72
I. 12 I. 17
I. 20 I . 20
[.18
1. 14
G5
Head
3
1.84
I.06 I. II
I. l6 1.22
[.22
1. 18
G6
Base
3
i-73
I. 12 I. 13
I. l6 I. l6
r-i3
1.08
G8
Head
4
i.8g
I.IO I. 12
I. l8 I.23
[.27
1.26
Gg
Base
4
i-73
I. 14 I. l8
f.22 I.2I
.18
1 -13
11
13 H2
Head
3
1.80
I. 12 I. l6
I . 22 I . 20
.16
I.IO
H3
Base
4
1-73
I . 13 I.20
I . 22 I. 24
[.23
1.18
H5
Head
5
1.78
I. 14 I.24
T.36 1-45
[-39
1.26
H6
Base
5
1.72
I. IO i. 14
I. 16 I. 18
[.17
1. 16
Not
broken.
H8
Head
4
1. 71
1-23 I.34
i . 36 i . 2g
[.20
1 .13
Hg
Base
4
1.74
1. 15 I -17
1.18 1 . 15
[-13
1.08
700 RAIL.
DUCTILITY.
The results showing the ductility of the rails in the drop test, are
shown in Fig. 16, in which the distance of the piece tested is shown
horizontally in pounds from the top of the ingot and the elongation of
the metal at breaking is shown vertically. The per cent, of elongation
of the inch which stretched most is taken as representing the ductility.
A close study of these diagrams proves very interesting. Consider-""
ing the 18x18, 20x24 and 25x30 ingots, it will be noticed that the
rail bar at the top end shows a good ductility, which rapidly decreases as we
pass through a "brittle zone" about 20 per cent, from the top of the
ingot. The ductility again increases until a distance of about 50 per cent,
from the top of the ingot is reached, after which the change of ductility
is not great. The rail bar from the 15x15 ingot shows a somewhat
similar result, except that the brittle zone starts in with the topmost
pieces tested, although it is possible, or even probable, that the material
of good ductility at the top of this small ingot was cut off with the portion
which it was necessary to crop off the top end of the bloom before rolling.
Another point of considerable interest is that the top half of the ingot
shows greater ductility when tested with the base in tension than with
the head in tension, especially in the brittle zone, but the lower half
shows somewhat greater ductility when tested with the head in tension.
This does not, however, necessarily mean that the rail from the lower
part of the ingot would stand more impact with head tension, since a
given impact causes considerably more stretch when the head is in tension
than when the base is in tension, although the deflection of the rail is
about the same.
In order to more conveniently compare the results from the different
ingots the average results in the head tension tests are shown together
in Fig. 17, and the results of the base tension tests are also shown
together by themselves, also in Fig. 17. Two of the base tension results
of 15x15 ingot, Nos. II 10 B6 and II 10 C3, gave very low elongation.
It seems very probable that these results were abnormal and were not
used in drawing the average curve. Likewise, the last piece from the
20x24 ingot tested with head tension, broke with very low elongation, evi-
dently due to an internal flaw in the head, and this result was not con-
sidered. It will be noticed that in the brittle zone, which is about 20
per cent, from the top of the ingot, with head tension, fracture occurs
at about 6 or 7 per cent, stretch, and the ductility is about the same
in the various ingots. In the lower half of the ingot the elongation goes up
over 20 per cent., increasing somewhat with the size of the ingot. At the
top of the ingot also the elongation is over 20 per cent. With base tension
the minimum elongation is about 12 per cent., except in the 18x18 in-
got, which showed a minimum of 17 per cent. In the lower half of the
ingot the elongation is about 20 per cent, for the different ingots. As
already explained, the 20x24 and 25x30 ingots had to be bloomed down
somewhat and cut in two before the rail mill could take them. The
two parts of the 20x24 ingot showed a continuity of results in the drop
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
mi
/5x/5I/VGOT
4- -heacd. tension
\"*~6ase tension
200©
40OO
2.00O
4000
DROR TESTS
100 Lb Bessemer Rails
ARA typeB seotion-2,eoolbTup
SO ft drop - 3ft supports
zpoo ipoo e,ooo
Pounds from Top of Ingot
10,000
Fig. i6 — Elongation Diagrams with the Individual Results Plotted.
ro2
RAIL.
2 ooo
*fpoo
6,000
8000
/Oraoo
Fig.
Pounds jrom Top 0/ Ingot
17 — Average Elongation Diagrams for the Various Sizes of Ingots.
Average Duct i Lit y 0/ RaLL
5
for aLL sizes of ingots
Bessemer SteeL
\\
\n
6a.se t
'TJSIOT1
'"'/*
^&——
-head t<
'xston
30
<^20
.0
& 10
8
o
o 20 40 6 0 <?0 loo
Percent of- Uleight from Top of Ingot
Fig. 18 — "Characteristic" Elongation Curves of ioo lb. A. R. A. Type
B Section Rails Made of Bessemer Steel from
Various Sizes of Ingots.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
70;
tests, but in the 25x30 ingot, the upper end of the lower half shows a
considerable drop in ductility in both the head tension and base tension
tests. Why this should be I am unable to say.
The ductility curves of the various sized ingots are a good deal
alike, and one average curve for head tension and another for base
zo&
gooo 4,000 6,«©c 6>ooo
Pounds J™™ Top of Ingot
I 'O.ooo
Fig. 19 — Deflection Diagrams with the Individual Results Plotted.
tension, representing distance from top in per cent, of total weight of
ingot, represent the various ingots nicely. I show such curves in
Fig. 18, and these may be called the "characteristic" ductility curves
of these rails made from Bessemer steel. The point of most interest
and importance is probably the zone of least ductility, which occurs at
about 20 per cent, from the top of the ingot, and in this zone the
704
RAIL.
ductility, when the rail is tested with the head in tension, is about half
of what it is when tested with the base in tension. In the lower half
of the ingot the rail shows a little more ductility when tested with the
head in tension.
DEFLECTION.
The results of the drop tests, showing deflection or permanent set
after the first blow, are plotted in Fig. 19, in which the distance from
Deflection after First BLocu
Drop tests /OO lb bessemer ra i is - ARAtype B-
SpooLb tup - 20 Jt drop - 3ft support s — Curves rep-
resent average of /react and base tension resuLtS.
2-M
<ooo ^000 6/>oo Qpoo
Pounds jrom Top 0/ Ingot
IO.o<x
Z-ot
ZO 40 60 80 loo
Percent from Top 0/ Ingot
Fig. 20 — Average Deflection Curves.
the top of the ingot in pounds is plotted horizontally and the deflection
is plotted vertically. It will be noticed that the deflection is greatest
in the rail from the top of the ingot, least at a distance varying from
about 20 to 45 per cent, from the top of the ingot, and greater again
in the lower part of the ingot. The deflection is a little greater all
along the rail bar when the rail is tested with the head in tension than
when tested with the base in tension, although the average difference
amounts to only several hundredths of an inch. Tn Fig. 20 I give curves
showing the average of the head tension and base tension results for
each ingot, one set of curves on the basis of distance from the top of
the ingot in pounds, and the other set on the basis of distance from the
top in per cent, of the total weight of the ingot. The deflection with
head tension would average slightly greater than shown, and with base
tension slightly less. These curves indicate that the zone of least? de-
flection or of maximum stiffness under the drop moves downward? as
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
705
the size of the ingot increases, and they indicate roughly that these
zones occur at the following distances from the top of the ingot :
15x15 ingot 20 per cent.
18x18 " 25
20x24 " 30 "
25x30 " 40
The average minimum deflection ranges between 1.60 and 1.65 inches.
The average maximum deflection of the 15x15, 18x18 and 20x24 ingots is
about 1.70 inches, and of the 25x30 ingot it is about 1.78 inches, except
at the top of the ingot where it is greater.
NUMBER OF BLOWS.
The number of blows which was applied to each piece of rail tested
is shown for convenience of comparison in table 51. The number given
Rail.
A
Piece
Number
2 and 3
5 and 6
8 and 9
TABLE 51 — NUMBER OF BLOWS.
15X15
Ingot.
H.T. B. T.
1 3
4
3 3
18x18
Ingot.
H. T. B. T.
5 4
1 4
I 4
20x24
Ingot.
H.T. B. T.
4 4
2 3
2 3
25x30
Ingot.
H. T. B. T.
5 4
3 5
2 2
H
2 and 3 3
5 and 6 3
8 and 9 4
2 and 3 3
5 and 6 4
8 and 9
2 and 3
5 and 6
8 and 9
2 and 3
5 and 6
8 and 9
2 and 3
5 and 6
8 and 9
2 and 3
5 and 6
8 and 9
2 and 3
5 and 6
8 and 9
706
RAIL.
shows the number of blows which broke the rail, except in a few cases
where the rail did not break. These results are plotted in Fig. 21 for
more convenient comparison. It will be noticed that with the head in
tension all of the ingots gave one or more tests that broke on the first
blow from 20 ft. With the base in tension the 15x15 ingot gave three
tests that broke on the first blow, although, as already noted, these seem
^6
to
"*"* 4
g.
i-
O o
s
r
4
2
0
Fig.
_. base tension
2,ooo
4,ooo
I8*W Ingot
4,ooo
DROP TESTS
Number of 6iows applied
base tension /°
\
- 0—0-0 -o--o
V
20x24. Ingot
head tension
Z,o»o
4,ooo
6,000
8poo /Or«ot
2,Ooo 4,ooo 6,000 Bpoo IO,ooo
Pounds f-rom Top 0/ Ingot
21 — Diagrams of the Number of Blows that Broke the Rails in
the Drop Test.
to be abnormal, due possibly to some delays in rolling or other unexplained
cause. The 18x18 and 20x24 ingots, with the base in tension, gave a
minimum number of three blows in any one test. With the 25x30 ingot
ihc minimum was two blows. The general appearance of the various
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
707
diagrams suggests that the upper part of the ingot stands a decreasing
total height of drop with the base in tension,, as the size of the ingot
increases.
ANALYSIS OF RAILS.
As already explained, analyses were made of samples taken each
eleven feet along the rail bar. From each section three samples were
7b />e of/nax/'/nu/n d/a/neter*
Fig. 22 — Drilling Diagram for Borings for Analysis from Rails.
taken as shown in Fig. 22, A from the upper corner of the head, B from
the interior of the head near its junction with the web, and C from near
the edge of the flange, which are the locations recommended by the Rail
Committee in March, 191 1. The analyses are shown in tables 52 to 55,
inclusive.
TABLE 52 — ANALYSIS OF RAILS, 15x15 INGOT.
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn.
10- A- 1
Ai
•39
• 135
.029
.065
•94
Bi
•44
•137
•039
.081
•94
Ci
•43
•133
.029
.065
.89
10- A -4
Ai
•5i
.144
.046
.098
•94
Bi
•56
.146
.061
.119
•97
Ci
•50
• i47
.046
.094
•94
70S
RAIL.
table 52 — analysis of rails, 15x15 ingot — Continued.
Marked Carbon Sil. Sul. Phos. Mn.
10-A-7 Ai .49 -138 046 .094 .98
Bi
Ci
10-B-1 Ai
Bi
Ci
10-B-4 Ai
Bi
Ci
10-B-7 A 1
Bi
Ci
io-C-i Ai
Bi
Ci
10-C-4 Ai
Bi
Ci
•134
• 139
• 134
.126
.118
• i39
.126
.126
.142
.138
.144
.130
.130
•134
• 134
.130
.130
.052
.047
.046
.044
.044
.048
•043
.043
.044
.042
.042
.042
.044
.044
.044
.040
.046
102
094
097
097
098
098
095
096
094
.090
092
094
090
093
093
087
,092
TABLE S3 — ANALYSES OF RAILS, l8xl8 INGOT.
Vlarked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn.
11-A-1
Ai
•35
.144
.027
.061
.89
Bi
■56
.148
.056
.117
•97
Ci
.40
.141
.029
.064
•91
11-A-4
Ai
•44
.140
•034
.078
.88
Bi
.66
•147
.084
.164
1. 00
Ci
•45
.148
•039
.082
.89
11-A-7
Ai
•49
• MS
.046
.092
•93
Bi
.64
•143
.078
•154
1. 00
Ci
.48
•143
•045
•095
•93
ii-B-i
Ai
•49
.138
.044
.096
.92
Bi
•56
• 139
•053
.108
•93
Ci
•49
.138
.044
•093
•9i
11-B-4
Ai
.48
.136
.044
•093
.92
Bi
•49
.138
.049
.100
•93
Ci
•49
.136
•049
.096
94
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
709
table 53— analysis of rails, 18x18 ingot — Continued.
Markec
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mr.
11-B-7
Ai
•50
134
.046
095
.92
Bi
.48
131
.044
090
.92
Ci
■49
135
•045
093
•93
ii-C-i
Ai
•49
136
.046
095
.92
Bi
•45
131
•045
088
.91
Ci
•49
130
.044
093
.92
11-C-4
Ai
•49
M3
.046
095
•92
Bi
.48
144
•043
085
.92
Ci
•49
139
.044
093
•93
11-C-7
Ai
•49
139
.046
094
.92
Bi
.46
139
.041
083
•91
Ci
•45
136
.044
095
•92
ii-D-i
Ai
•50
144
.044
095
.91
Bi
.46
141
.040
083
.90
Ci
••51
135
.042
092
•9i
11-D-4
Ai
•50
147
•045
095
.92
Bi
•47
138
.046
081
.91
Ci
•49
145
.044
092
.91
11-D-7
Ai
.50
133
.048
093
•94
Bi
•47
135
.047
091
•93
Ci
.46
136
.046
094
•93
TABLE 54 — ANALYSES OF RAILS, 20X24 INGOT.
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn.
12-A-1
Ai
•4i
.131
.029
.063
•94
Bi
.40
•133
.029
.061
.91
Ci
•45
.128
.030
.065
.92
12-A-4
Ai
•45
.128
.032
.077
•94
Bi
•47
•131
.040
.088
•93
Ci
•42
.127
.029
.069
.91
12-A-7
Ai
•47
•133
•043
.087
93
Bi
.64
•137
.067
•135
•99
Ci
.49
• 139
•043
.086
•93
12-B-1
Ai
•52
•134
.048
.094
•93
Bi
•59
.136
.069
•134
1. 00
Ci
•5i
•131
.048
.094
•94
1710
RAIL.
TABLE
54 — ANA
LYSIS
Marked
Carbon
12-B-4
Ai
49
Bi
.60
Ci
•49
12-B-7
Ai
49
Bi
•58
Ci
.48
I2-C-I
Ai
52
Bi
•56
Cr
■50
I2-C-4
Ai
•50
Bi
•53
Ci
50
I2-C-7
Ai
•5i
Bi
49
Ci
•52
I2-D-I
Ai
•50
Bi
.48
Ci
50
12-D-4
Ai
47
Bi
.48
Ci
.46
12-D-7
A 1
52
Bi
•49
Ci
•51
12-E-1
Ai
•51
Bi
.48
Ci
•5i
12-E-4
Ai
•51
Bi
•47
Ci
5i
12-E-7
Ai
•5o
Bi
45
Ci
.50
12-F-1
A 1
•52
Bi
47
Ci
•51
rails, 20x24 ingot — Continued.
Sil. Sul.
131 -050
132 -065
132 .049
135 -048
141 .059
136 .048
145 -047
145 052
137 -045
144 .044
145 .044
147 -045
134 048
132 .047
132 .046
143 .044
143 043
144 .044
134 .048
134 .047
135 -046
133 044
127 .042
135 044
130 .046
128 .043
131 .049
134 -044
134 039
132 .044
132 .044
130 .039
126 .043
133 .046
131 .040
131 046
'hos.
Mn.
.097
•95
.125
•98
.096
•95
.094
•95
.114
•98
.094
•94
•095
•95
.102
•95
•093
•93
.096
•94
.097
•93
■095
•93
.098
•97
•095
•94
.096
.96
.094
•93
.O96
•93
.092
.92
•095
.96
.094
•95
•095
•95
097
•95
O93
•94
•095
96
.097
•95
.089
•92
.096
•95
O95
•93
.084
•91
•093
•95
•094
•95
085
•93
O92
94
.094
•95
.083
•92
•093
•94
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
711
table 54 — 'Analysis of rails, 20x24 ingot — Continued.
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn.
12-F-4
Ai
•5i
.130
.044
.092
•93
Bi
•47
.130
.044
.087
.92
Ci
•5i
• 131
.047
094
•94
12-F-7
Ai
•50
.130
.049
.096
•94
Bi
•5i
.132
•045
.094
.92
Ci
•5i
.138
.041
.092
.92
TABLE 55 — ANALYSES OF RAILS, 25x30 INGOT.
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn.
13-A-1
Ai
•35
•152
.025
•055
.89
Bi
•35 '
•152
.024
.048
.89
Ci
.38
•134
.027
063
.88
13-A-4
Ai
■33
.130
.027
•057
■87
Bi
•49
■ 139
.042
.098
■95
Ci
■37
.130
.029
.063
.88
13-A-7
Ai
.41
.126
.029
.065
.88
Bi
•51
•153
.046
.092
•97
Ci
.42
.129
.036
.071
.88
13-B-1
Ai
.40
.130
•034
.068
.89
Bi
.66
.161
.081
.160
1.04
Ci
.40
.129
.029
.065
.00
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul. i
Phos.
Mn.
13-B-4
Ai
•44
.130
.036
.076
•91
Bi
■77
• 152
.025
.210
1.06
Ci
•45
• 131
.032
.072
.91
13-B-7
Ai
•44
.129
.037
.072
.89
Bi
•79
.146
.136
.187
1.08
Ci
•43
.128
.032
.066
.89
13-C-l
Ai
•45
.130
.030
.077
•93
Bi
.72
•134
.102
.174
1.04
Ci
•45
• 134
■033
•075
.92
13-C-4
Ai
•44
.129
•037
.077
•93
Bi
.61
•152
.085
•155
1. 00
Ci
•45
•131
.041
.080
•95
I3-C-7
Ai
•43
.129
.040
.084
89
Bi
•58
•139
.067
.128
98
Ci
•50
.130
.042
.092
•94
712
RAIL.
table 55 — analysis of rails, 25x30 ingot — Continued.
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn
13-D-1
Ai
.48
144
•039
090
92
Bi
•52
135
•045
106
•94
Ci '
•50
142
.040
093
.92
13-D-4
Ai
•50
130
.048
094
•96
Bi
•57
136
.060
123
•97
Ci
•49
130
.046
095
•9i
13-D-7
Ai
•50
126
.047
096
•94
Bi
•53
144
.057
117
•95
Ci
•51
150
.051
099
•93
13-E-i
Ai
■50
134
.049
IOI
.92
Bi
•50
130
•055
109
•94
Ci
.48
140
•045
094
.91
13-E-4
Ai
•49
160
.047
097
•93
Bi
•52
144
•057
109
.92
Ci
•47
134
.043
093
•9i
13-E-7
Ai
•50
138
.048
103
.92
Bi
•52
125
.052
105
•96
Ci
•47
128
•045
096
•94
13-F-l
Ai
•49
148
.048
097
•92
Bi
•47
138
•049
094
.92
Ci
.48
136
•045
094
•93
13-F-4
Ai
•51
134
•053
IOI
•95
Bi
•44
141
•039
087
•93
Ci
•50
128
.049
097
•93
13-F-7
Ai
•49
.144
.048
098
•94
Bi
•43
143
.042
081
•92
Ci
•49
145
.046
095
•93
13-G-1
Ai
•47
128
.043
095
•93
Bi
•39
127
039
075
.89
Ci
.48
.128
.044
095
•94
13-G-4
Ai
•49
•135
.040
095
95
Bi
•42
138
.038
075
•92
Ci
•49
.141
.042
094
-94
13-G-7
Ai
•47
i34
•045
092
•94
Bi
•39
140
.038
073
.89
Ci
•50
•134
•045
094
•97
13-H-i
Ai
•49
130
.046
093
•94
Bi
.40
132
•033
074
.88
Ci
•SO
.146
•045
089
.92
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
713
table 55 — analysis of rails, 25x30 ingot — Continued.
Marked
Carbon
Sil.
Sul.
Phos.
Mn
13-H-4 A 1
.46
• 135
•043
.092
•93
Bi
•44
.136
.041
.080
.90
Ci
■49
•134
•045
•005
91
13-H-7 Ai
•47
.142
.046
.092
.91
Bi
•47
.136
.046
.091
.92
Ci
•SO
.136
•045
.092
.91
In order to show the chemistry in convenient form for comparison, I
have plotted the carbon results from the corner of the head and from
•60
•40 £
20
s*0
o
-0.40
U20
o
20
g-r »«$
J*9^_|_
/Sx/S Irtaot
I I
Z.OOO
4poo
S.occ
4<ooo
^©-C^BvJ-qL
Carbon in /Rails
Interior of head
near web
«--— Upper corner of head.
4S7o
eOx24 Ingot
2.000
4,000
6,000
S,ooo / 0,000
-80
.60
AO
.20
2,ooo 4 000 6,000 8000
Pounds from To-p 0/ Ingot
Fig. 23 — Diagrams of Carkon in Rails.
714
RAIL.
the interior of the head in Fig. 23, in which the distance from the top of
the ingot in pounds is shown horizontally and the per cent, of carbon is
shown vertically. In a general way, these diagrams show conditions
already found in the ingot. The average carbon in the heat, as indicated
by the samples from the upper corner of the head in the lower end of
the rail bar, was .49 per cent. The interior of the rail at the top end of the
rail bar shows negative segregation, but going down the ingot, it soon
develops considerable positive segregation, which reaches a maximum at
about 20 per cent, by weight from the top. The lower end of the rail
bar again shows negative segregation in the interior. The outer portion
of the section of the rail, as shown by the samples from the upper cor-
ner of the head, shows negative segregation in the top end of the rail bar,
which gradually becomes less as we go downward, until the average car-
bon content is reached, which then remains about constant for the rest
of the bar. The point at which the average carbon is reached seems in
general to be farther down from the top as the size of the ingot increases,
varying from about 15 or 20 per cent, to about 35 per cent. I say, in gen-
eral, since the rail bar from the 20x24 ingot seems to show less variation
as regards both positive and negative segregation than the rail bar from
the 18x18 ingot. Similar diagrams for phosphorus are shown in Fig. 24
and for sulphur in Fig. 25, and they show distributions for these two
elements similar to the carbon distribution. The maximum amounts of
carbon, phosphorus and sulphur found in the interior of the head, with
the samples taken as explained and the percentages of increase above the
average in the heat, are shown in table 56.
Ingot
15x15
18x18
20x24
25x30
Ave. in heat
TABLE 56 — SEGREGATION IN RAILS.
Carbon — Phosphorus —
Max. Increase Max. Increase
.56 14% .119 27%
.164
•135
.210
.094
.66
.64
•79
35%
3i%
61%
75%
44%
123%
•49
Sulphur —
Max. Increase
.061
33%
.084
83%
.069
50%
.136
195%
.04:
5
The concentrations found in the rails were not as great as found in
the ingots, but in the ingots it will be remembered that the maximum
concentrations were found in the axis, while the samples taken from the
rails were some distance from the axis of the section.
Table 57 shows the minimum amounts of carbon, phosphorus and
sulphur found in the upper corner of the head and also shows the per-
centages of decrease below the average in the heat.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
715
2,ooo ^}<ooo 6,000 Q/>oa
Pounds from 7ojd of Ingot
f0,ooo
Fig. 24 — Diagrams of Phosphorus in Rails.
716
RAIL.
Ingot
15x15
18x18
20x24
25x30
Ave. in heat
TABLE 5/ — NEGATIVE SEGREGATION IN KAILS
Carbon — — Phosphorus —
Min. Decrease Min. Decrease
.39 20% .065 31%
•35
.41
•33
29%
16%
33%
.061
.063
•055
36%
33%
43%
.49
.094
Sulphur
Min. Decrease
.029 37%
.027 41%
.029 37%
.025 46%
.046
In this table the percentages of decrease are in some cases less than
found in the ingots, and in other cases more.
Sulphur in Rails
Interior of head,
near web
— -•—Upper corner of hea.cC
2.ooo *?/>oo 6000 8,000 IO,ooO
Pounds from T073 0/ Ingot
Fig. 25 — Diagrams of Sulphur in Rails.
A comparison of the analyses from the upper corner of the head and
from the edge of the flange shows that in the great majority of cases the
results are closely alike, and it would seem unnecessary to take borings
from the flange except for some special purpose.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
tj:
RAIL ETCHINGS.
Sections were cut each eleven feet along the rail bars and etched
with a concentrated solution of copper ammonium or copper potassium
chloride. Photographs of the etched sections are reproduced in figures
as follows :
15x15 Ingot — Figures 26 to 33, inclusive.
18x18 Ingot — Figures 34 to 45, inclusive.
20x24 Ingot — Figures 46 to 63, inclusive.
25x30 Ingot — Figures 64 to 87, inclusive.
It will be noted that the sections from the upper part of the ingot
show streaks and spots which correspond with the condition of spongi-
ness found in the ingot. There may also be a dark area or "dark core"
in the interior of the section corresponding with the region of strong
segregation found in the ingot. The sections from the lower part of the
ingot also show a core, but of lighter color, or a "light core," which cor-
responds to the region of negative segregation in the ingot found by
analysis. This light core shows up most prominently in the largest ingot.
The figures showing the etched sections from the smaller ingots do not
show the light core prominently, and in fact it does not always show well
in the original etching.
• ;;f !
Fig. 26— Etched Section i ft. from Top End of A Rail, 15x15 Ingot.
718
RAIL.
Fig. 27 — Etched Section 12 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 15x15 Ingot.
Fig. .28 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 15x15 Ingot
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
719
Fig. 29 — Etched Section i ft. from Top End of B Rail, 15x15 Ingot.
Fig. 30 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 15x15 Ingot.
F20
RAIL.
Fig. 31 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 15x15 Ingot
Fig. 32— Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of C Rail, 15x15 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
721
Fig. 33 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 15x15 Ingot
Fig. 34 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of A Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
722
RAIL.
Fig. 35 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
ia|
!*
.<n
JIA7
^^^k
Fig. 36 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 72:;
Fig. 37— Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of B Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
Fig. 38-Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
724
RAIL.
Fig. 39 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
Fig. 40 — -Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of C Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
Fig. 41 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
Fig. 42 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
r26
RAIL.
Fig. 43 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of D Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
Fig. 44— Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of D Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
727
Fig. 45 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of D Rail, 18x18 Ingot.
Fig. 46 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of A Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
728
RAIL.
Fig. 47 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 20x24 Ingot
Fig. 48 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
729
Fig. 49 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of B Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 50 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
730
RAIL.
Fig. 51 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 52 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of C Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 731
Fig- 53 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 54— Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
732
RAIL.
Fig. 55 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of D Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 56 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of D Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
738
Fig. 57 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of D Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 58 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of E Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
m
RAIL.
Fig. 59 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of E Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 60 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of E Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
Fig. 6i — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of F Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 62 — .Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of F Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
RAIL.
Fig. 63 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of F Rail, 20x24 Ingot.
Fig. 64 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of A Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
737
Fig. 65 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 25x30 Ingot
Fig. 66 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of A Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
738
RAIL.
Fig. 67 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of B Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 68 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
738
Fir,. 69 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of B Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 70 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of C Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
74o
RAIL.
F\r,. y\ — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 72 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of C Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. "41
Fig. 73 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of D Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 74 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of D Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
742
RAIL.
Fig. 75- — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of D Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 76 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of E Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 743
Fig. 7J — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of E Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 78 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of E Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
744
RAIL.
Fig. 79 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of F Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 80 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of F Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 745
Fig. 8i — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of F Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 82 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of G Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
746
RAIL.
Fig. 83 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of G Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 84 — Etched Section. 23 ft. from Top End of G Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT.
747
Fig. 85 — Etched Section, i ft. from Top End of H Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
Fig. 86 — Etched Section, 12 ft. from Top End of H Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
748
RAIL.
Fig. 87 — Etched Section, 23 ft. from Top End of H Rail, 25x30 Ingot.
SUMMARY.
1. This report covers an investigation to throw light on the relation-
ship of the size of ingots of Bessemer rail steel to the segregation of the
metalloids, locations of pipes and blow holes, and the properties of the
rails. A series of five ingots was made of the following bottom sizes, all
5 ft. high, namely, 12 in. x 12 in., 15 in. x 15 in., 18 in. x 18 in., 20 in. x 24
in. and 25 in. x 30 in. These were split open, after cooling in the molds,
one-half used to obtain borings for a chemical survey of the ingot, and the
other half for etching. Another similar set of ingots was rolled into rails
with only sufficient discard from the top of the bloom to allow rolling
into rail, and the entire rail bars from these ingots were used for drop
tests, etchings and chemical analyses, except that no rails were rolled
from the 12-in. ingot, as an attempt to do so resulted in a "cobble" on
account of the small size of the ingot. The 15 x 15 and 18 x 18 ingots
were rolled direct into rails according to the usual practice at South
Chicago, but the 20 x 24 and 25 x 30 ingots were too large for the rail
mill and were first bloomed down to about 14 x 14 or 16 x 16 in. in a two
high mill, cut in two, brought back and placed into the rail mill soaking
pits and then rolled into rails. In this there was a considerable divergence
from the usual practice.
The statements and conclusion in this nummary refer to Bessemer
steel, made under the conditions prevailing in these tests, the object of
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 749
which was stated in the previous paragraph, and proper care must be
used when applying them to other material and other conditions. The
rail section tested was the ioo-pound A. R. A. type B section.
Especial attention is called to the fact that the investigation of the
ingots was necessarily made after they had been allowed to become cold ;
a condition which does not obtain in regular rail mill practice, and one
which it is often claimed exaggerates the size of the pipe as compared
with ingots which are not allowed to cool.
2. With ingots five feet high and varying in cross-section from
12x12 inches to 25x30 inches, the "pipe" or shrinkage cavity extends down-
ward a decreasing distance as the diameter of the ingot increases. The
variation is from about 80 per cent, in the small ingot to about 35 per
cent, in the largest ingot.
3. The condition of "sponginess" extends downward about 30 per
cent, from the top in all the ingots.
4. The blowholes around the axes of the ingots were slag-coated,
while those close to the walls seemed to have a clean metallic surface
free from slag.
5. The chemical survey of the ingots shows a concentration or seg-
regation of carbon, phosphorus and sulphur, and to a much smaller extent
also of manganese, in the upper part of the ingot around the axis. The
concentration increases in general as the size of the ingot increases. The
increases above the average content of the steel vary from 32 per cent,
in the 12x12 ingot to 119 per cent, in the 25x30 ingot in carbon, from 102
per cent, to 225 per cent, in phosphorus, and from 100 per cent, to 369 per
cent, in sulphur.
6. The top of the ingot along the axis shows a decrease in the above
elements, and the axis also shows some decrease in the lower part of the
ingot. The region figured as a percentage of the total volume of the ingot
covered by this metal of lower content of metalloids increases in general
as the size of the ingot increases.
7. In the upper part of the ingot the outside portion or walls of the
ingot show negative segregation or decrease of carbon, phosphorus and
sulphur. The negative segregation is greatest at the top and gradually
becomes less until the average composition of the steel is reached, when
the walls remain of about the average composition for the rest of the
distance to the bottom of the ingot. The greatest decrease is, roughly,
about 25 per cent, in carbon for all the ingots. The greatest decrease in
phosphorus ranged from 32 to 45 per cent., and in sulphur from 43 to 63
per cent., showing a tendency to increase as the size of the ingot increases.
The distance that the negative segregation in the wall extends downward
from the top of the ingot increases as the size of the ingot increases,
ranging from about 30 per cent, to about 50 per cent.
8. Drop tests were made of the complete rail bars from 15x15, 18x18,
20x24 and 25x30-inch ingots. The ductility of the material was deter-
mined by putting gage marks one inch apart over a space of six inches
on the part in tension, and the per cent, of stretch in the inch which
W RAIL.
stretched most at failure in the drop machine, is taken as the measure
of ductility. Both with the head in tension and with the base in tension,
the rail bar at first decreases in ductility as we go down the ingot, until
the minimum ductility is reached at about 20 per cent, by weight from the
top of the ingot for all sizes of ingots. Then the ductility again increases
until the middle of the ingot is reached, when the ductility remains about
constant for the rest of the bar. With the head in tension the minimum
ductility is about 6 per cent, elongation, and with the base in tensiop
about 12 per cent. In the lower half of the ingot the rail shows more
ductility with the head in tension than with the base, averaging about
23 per cent, elongation with the head in tension, and about 19 per cent,
with the base in tension. These are average results, applying to all sizes
of ingots.
9. The deflection or permanent set in the drop test was measured
after the first blow from a height of 20 ft. of a tup of 2,000 lbs. and with
a span of supports of 3 ft. The deflection is greatest at the top end of
the rail bar and gradually becomes less as we go down the ingot, until
a minimum deflection is reached at distance varying from about 20 per
cent, to 40 per cent, from the top. That is, the rail bar is stiffest at about
this distance from the top. The zone of maximum stiffness moves down-
ward as the size of the ingot increases, 20 per cent, applying to the 15x15
ingot and 40 per cent, to the 25x30 ingot. The minimum deflection is,
roughly, the same for all the ingots, but the maximum seems to increase
in general with the size of the ingot. Passing the zone of maximum stiff-
ness, the deflection again increases, but does not become as great as
in the extreme top end. The deflection with the head in tension is slightly
greater than with the base in tension.
10. The zone of minimum ductility corresponds roughly with the
region of greatest interior segregation, and the zone of maximum stiffness
corresponds roughly with the region where negative segregation in the
walls of the upper part of the ingot ceases.
11. In the zone of minimum ductility all the rail bars failed under
one blow of the tup with the head in tension, while in the more ductile
regions the rail may stand four or five blows with the head in tension.
With the base in tension in the ductile regions the rail may stand four
or five blows with all the rail bars. In the zone of least ductility and
with the base in tension the number of blows necessary to break the rail
becomes less as the size of the ingot increases, the number of blows
varying from two to three or four.
12. Analyses of samples from the finished rail bar indicate that the
distribution of the elements is about the same as in the ingot.
13. The carbon, phosphorus, sulphur and manganese in general seg-
regate together ; that is, they collect into the same regions, although the
percentages of concentration differ.
14. The samples from the upper corner of the head and from the
edge of the flange show practically the same composition in almost all
cases.
INFLUENCE OF SIZE OF INGOT. 751
15. Etchings of sections of rail from the upper part of the ingot
show streaks and spots which correspond to the region of sponginess
in the upper part of the ingot. Etchings of rail sections from the upper
part of the ingot may also show a "dark core" corresponding to the region
of strong segregation found in the ingot, and from the lower part of the
ingot may show a "light core" corresponding to the region of negative
segregation.
16. In conclusion, I wish to again acknowledge the prompt and effi-
cient work done by the Metallurgical, Chemical and other departments of
the South Works of the Illinois Steel Company in carrying out this
investigation.
Appendix D.
*TESTS OF RAIL STEEL INGOTS AND DERIVATIVE
SHAPES MADE AT WATERTOWN ARSENAL.
DIGEST AND ANALYSIS.
By
M. H. Wickhorst, Engineer of Tests, Rail Committee.
This report is intended primarily as a digest and analysis of the
investigation of rail steel ingots and derivative shapes made at Water-
town Arsenal, Mass., under the direction of James E. Howard, and
shown in "Tests of Metals, etc." for 1909. Its main purpose is to de-
termine, if possible, what conclusions may be drawn from the results
of the tests.
The general method of the work is explained on page 5 of "Tests
of Metals," as quoted below: (Unless otherwise stated, page numbers
hereafter refer to "Tests of Metals," 1909.) "Beginning with the ingot.
the structural state of the metal was examined by taking cross sec-
tions and longitudinal sections. This method was carried through the
various successive derivative shapes, and the results obtained are shown
in the large number of illustrations which form the body of the report.
The illustrations are so arranged as to show the progressive changes
in the character of the metal from its initial state in the ingot to its
final condition in the finished product. Tensile test bars were taken at
successive stages of the rolling, from the blooming passes to the rail
mill."
The greater part of the work was devoted to Bessemer rail steel,
five acid Bessemer heats being made for this series of tests, each heat
furnishing six ingots about 19^x20^2 in. at the bottom and about 5 ft.
high. The schedule of tests and operations is shown on page 14 and is
herewith given as table 1 :
CAVITIES IN INGOTS AND SHAPES.
The Report contains a great many interesting and very well executed
illustrations of longitudinal and transverse sections of ingots and shapes,
both plain and etched, and they throw considerable light on the matter
of cavities, blow holes and general sponginess in the ingot and succeed-
ing rolled shapes. A number of the longitudinal sections of ingots and
blooms are reproduced herewith as Figs. 1 to 9, inclusive. Fig. 1 shows
♦Report No. 20, September, 1911.
753
754
RAIL.
Table i — Schedule of Bessemer Ingots and Their Treatment,
eeat NO. 1.
Distin-
guishing
marks.
Treatment of ingot.
Time in furnace.
Remarks.
Hours.
Min-
utes.
1A
IB
1C
ID
IE
IF
Cooled in vertical position without
soaking.
Soaked and then, cooled in vertical
position.
Charged hot and soaked as usual . . .
do
Rolled into blooms and then cut
in center at shears.
Rolled into 75-pound section rails.
Rollefl into blooms, then cut in
center at shears.
Rolled into 75-pound section rails.
1
1
1
6
6
30
30
30
00
00
Laid on side to cool immediately
after stripping, head side up;
reheated.
do
HEAT NO. 2.
2 A
2B
2C
2D
2E
Cooled in vertical position without
soaking.
Soaked and then cooled in vertical
position.
Cnarged hot and soaked as usual . . .
.do..
Laid on side to cool immediately
after stripping, head side up;
reheated.
....do
1
30
1
30
1
9
30-
00
9
00
Rolled into blooms and then cut
in center at shears.
Rolled into 75-pound section rails.
Rolled into blooms, then cut in
center at shears.
Rolled into 75-pound section rails.
HEAT NO. 3.
3A
3B
3C
:!D
RE
Cooled in vertical position without
soaking.
Soaked and then cooled in vertical
position.
Charged hot and soaked as usual . .
...do
Laid on side to cool immediately
after stripping, web side up; re-
heated.
....do
1
30
1
30
1
9
30
00
9
00
Rolled into blooms and then cut
in center at shears.
Rolled into 75-pound section rails.
Rolled into blooms, then cut in
center at shears.
Rolled into75-po'und section rails.
HEAT NO. 4.
4 A
4B
4C
4D
4E
Charged hot and soaked as usual . .
do
.do.
.do
.do.
1
30
1
40
1
2
2
50
00
10
2
20
Rolled through third roughing
pass.
Rolled through filth roughing
pass.
Rolled through, squabbing pass.
Rolled through first forming pass.
Rolled through second forming
pass.
Rolled through finishing pass.
HEAT NO. 5.
5 A
&B
5C
5D
5K
5F
Charged hot and soaked as usual . . .
.do
do
Cooied in vertical position jreheated
... .do
do
1
30
1
30
1
30
8
00
8,
00
8
00
Rolled 3 passes in bloom mill.
Rolled 6 passes in bloom mill.
Rolled 9 passes in bloom mill.
Rolled 3 passes' in bloom mill.
Rolled 6 passes in bloom mill.
Rolled 9 passes in bloom mill.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 755
a longitudinal section one inch from the axis of an ingot that was
cooled in a vertical position without soaking, and Fig. 2 shows an axial
longitudinal section of a similar ingot which was first soaked for il/>
hours' and then cooled in a vertical position. For the purpose of com-
paring the interior cavities in the two treatments of the ingot, the com-
parison is best made with axial longitudinal sections, but unfortunately
such a section is not shown for the first ingot, and Fig. 3 is given, show-
ing a longitudinal section one inch from the axis of the second ingot.
A study of these three figures shows that the central ''sponginess" or
"honeycomb" extends downward to about the middle in both ingots, al-
though most of it is confined to the upper third. The difference between
the two is not great, but the central sponginess seems to have been
aggravated, if anything, by the soaking given the second ingot before
final cooling. The sponginess in the walls of the direct-cooled ingot
extend downward about 25 per cent, from the top, and in the soaked ingot
it extends downward a somewhat greater distance, or about 30 per cent.
It should also be stated that the direct-cooled ingot showed a large
transverse crack about the middle, covering almost the entire cross
section of the ingot.
Next are given three illustrations of longitudinal axial sections of
blooms at different stages of reduction from ingots which were charged
hot and rolled after soaking 11/, hours. Fig. 4 shows -an axial section
of a bloom after the third pass, reduced to 18.3x18.6 in. from about
19^x20^ in. The central sponginess extends down to about the middle
of the bloom with most of it contained in the upper third and the
peripheral sponginess extends downward about 25 or 30 per cent. Fig.
5 shows a section of a similar ingot after six passes, bloomed to 12.5x19.3
in., and Fig. 6 shows one after nine passes bloomed to 11.7x12.7 in. or a
reduction to about one-third of the original cross-sectional area. Here
again the central sponginess extends down to about the middle of the
bloom with most of it in the upper third of the bloom, and the cavities
are seen to have been not closed up by a two-thirds reduction. The small
peripheral holes seem to have been largely closed up after the sixth
pass or about one-half reduction, and after the ninth pass do not show
in the photograph of the planed surface. The reproductions of etched
sections, however, given in the Report, show them distinctly.
The next three illustrations, Figs. 7, 8 and 9, show axial longitudinal
sections of blooms at different stages of reduction, of ingots that had
been allowed to cool in a vertical position and then put in the furnace
for eight hours. Fig. 7 shows a bloom after the third pass, Fig. 8 shows
one after the sixth pass, and Fig. 9 shows one after the ninth pass. The
same remarks apply to these blooms that have been made regarding the
previous ones, except that the cavities in the upper third of the bloom
compose a somewhat smaller part of the volume of the material than in
the blooms made from ingots which were at once placed in the soaking
pit. This corresponds to what was found on examination of the ingots
before any work of rolling was done on them.
"5fi
RAIL.
Fig. i— Ingot i A, Cooled in Ver-
tical Position Without Soak-
ing. Longitudinal Section i
In. from Axis.
pIG 3— Ingot i B, Soaked and
Cooled in Vertical Position.
Longitudinal Section i In. from
Axis.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 757
Fig. 2 — Ingot i B, Soaked and
Cooled in Vertical Position.
Axial Longitudinal Section.
Fig. 4 — Bloom After 3rd Pass
18.3 x 18.6 In. from Ingot 5 A,
Charged Hot and Soaked as
Usual. Axial Longitudinal
Section.
758
RAIL
Fig s-Bloom After 6th Pass 12.5 x 19.3 ]?■ from Ingot 5 B. Charged
Hot and Soaked as Usual. Axial Longitudinal Section
of Small Diameter.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
759
Fig. 6 — Bloom After o/th Pass,
11.7x127 In. from Ingot 5 C.
Charged Hot and Soaked as
Usual. One Surface on Axial
Plane and Other i In. from
Axis.
he. 7 — -Bloom After 3rd Pass,
18.3 In. Sq. from Ingot 5 D,
Cooled in Vertical Position ane
Then Put in Furnace for i.
Hrs. Axial Longitudinal Sec-
tion.
760
RAIL.
Fig. 8 — Bloom After 6th Pass,
12.4 x 19.4 In. from Ingot 5 E,
Cooled in Vertical Position and
Then Put in Furnace for 8
Hrs. Axial Longitudinal Sec-
tion.
Fig. 9 — Bloom After 9th Pass,
11.3x12.7 In. from Ingot 5 F,
Cooled in Vertical Position
and Then Put in Furnace for
8 Hrs. Axial Longitudinal
Section of Upper Half of Bloom.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
761
The above discussion concerning ingots and blooms indicates : First,
that the upper third of the ingot is very spongy; second, that the cavities
compose a little larger part of the volume of the material, both of the
ingot and of the bloom, where the ingot is soaked without first cooling
down; third, that the cavities are distributed in the bloom about as they
were in the ingot from which it was rolled.
Beyond the bloom the interior of the shapes is represented mostly
by etched cross sections and they show that the larger cavities persist
well toward the finished rail. The smaller cavities seem not to show
directly in the plain surfaces of the much-reduced sections, but the etched
sections show spots and streaks corresponding to the cavities in the ingot
and bloom, although the spots and streaks seem to be more numerous
than the cavities shown by the cross sections of the ingot and bloom.
CARBON IN BLOOMS.
Carbon determinations by color are shown in the Report, on two axial
longitudinal sections of blooms, one after the sixth blooming pass and the
other after the ninth blooming pass, the ingots having been charged hot
-7b 70
IO 20 30
Location jrom Top oj BLoom
Fig. 10 — Carbon in Blooms.
^0 ~L 50
Bottom »-
and soaked as usual. From each bloom samples were taken from twelve
longitudinal rows of holes. The holes in each row were spaced apart
about two per cent, of the length of the bloom and were numbered, be-
ginning with one at the top end of the bloom. At any given distance
762 RAIL.
from the top end of the bloom, the extreme differences of carbon in
the cross section are generally shown by the samples at the axis and
in the walls of the bloom, as shown by a study of the results, following
page 93 for the bloom from ingot 5B after the sixth blooming pass, and
following page 99 for the bloom from ingot 5C after the ninth blooming
pass. In order to show the variations of composition throughout the
bloom, I have plotted the carbon for two of the rows of samples of
each bloom, row G representing the axis of the bloom and row L repre-
senting the wall, as shown in Fig. 10 herewith. The per cent, of carbon
is plotted vertically, and the number of the hole from the top end of
the bloom is plotted horizontally. Other work has indicated that the
samples from the wall of an ingot below the middle represent fairly
closely the average steel of the ingot, and assuming this to hold with
the present blooms, the average carbon in these blooms was about .50
per cent.
At the top end of the bloom the axis shows carbon below the average
or negative segregation, reaching a minimum at about 6 or 8 per cent,
from the top, but the carbon soon increases and shows considerable
positive segregation, reaching a maximum at about 24 per cent, from the
top end of the bloom from ingot 5B, and at about 22 per cent, in the
bloom from ingot 5C. Toward the middle of the bloom, the carbon at
the axis again gets down to about the average, and in the lower quarter
again shows some negative segregation, coming up to about normal at
the bottom. The negative segregation in the lower quarter is well shown
in bloom 5C, but through only a small percentage of the length in bloom
5B.
The walls of the upper part of the bloom show negative segrega-
tion of carbon, which rises until the average carbon content of the bloom
is reached and it then in general remains about the average for the
rest of the distance down the bloom. Successive samples from the
wall in the upper part of the bloom show considerable variations in car-
bon, but the average content is reached at about 25 per cent, down from
the top end in bloom 5B, and about 35 per cent, down in bloom 5C.
The maximum and minimum carbon found in these blooms is shown
in table 2 herewith.
TABLE 2 — MAXIMUM AND MINIMUM CARBON.
Bloom sB. Bloom 5C.
Axis, maximum 85 .77
Axis, increase 70% 54%
Walls, minimum 34 -37
Walls, decrease 32% 26%
TENSILE TESTS.
Tensile tests were made of specimens taken at various stages from
the ingot to the finished rail, and the results are interesting as having
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 763
60:
Cl
0
N
M
EOU-UOOOQ
'5-
3'.
Fig. 11 — Locations of Tensile Specimens from Longitudinal Slice of
Ingot iA Passing Through Axis.
Fig. 12 — Locations of Longitudinal Tensile Specimens from Upper
Side of Bloom, iE.
• u; 13 — Locations of Longitudinal Tensile Specimens from Section
After Third Roughing Pass, 4A.
[';•!
Rail.
Frr,. 14 — Locations of Longitudinal Tensile Specimens from S&tihx
After Fifth Roughing Pass, 4B.
Fig. 15 — Locations of Longitudinal Tensile Specimens from Section
After Squabbing Pass, 4C.
Fig. 16 — Locations of Tensile Specimens from Section After First
Forming Pass, 4D-
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. T>>~
a bearing on the question of the amount of work or reduction necessary
in rolling to develop the full physical qualities of the steel. In table 3
I give a list of the illustrations which are herewith reproduced, show-
ing how the tensile test specimens were taken from the different shapes.
The specimens as tested were .798 diameter, which equals a sectional area
of .50 sq. in., and the gage length was 10 in.
TABLE 3 — ILLUSTRATIONS OF LOCATIONS OF TENSILE SPECIMENS.
Fig. Number From page of
Pass. of this Report. Tests of Metals.
Ingot 11 65
Bloom 12 in
Third roughing 13 169
Fifth roughing 14 241
Squabbing 15 291
First forming 16 335
The areas of the various passes represented by tensile tests are
shown in table 4.
TABLE 4— AREAS AT VARIOUS PASSES.
Area,
Pass. sq. in.
Ingot, top, 18x19 342
Ingot, 5 per cent, from top 345
Ingot, 25 per cent, from top 357
Ingot, 50 per cent, from top 371
Ingot, 90 per cent, from top 393
Ingot, bottom, 19.5x20.5 400
Bloom, 7.65 in. x 7.8 in 59-7
Third roughing pass 32.2
Fifth roughing pass 24 . 3
Squabbing pass 178
First forming pass 14- l
Second forming pass 10.8
Finished rail, 75 lb 7-4
In order to show up more conveniently than shown by the tables,
the relation between the distance from the top end of the shape and the
tensile properties, I have plotted the tensile strength and elongation for
the various passes, of metal representing the axis of the section, and
also the exterior of the section, showing the distance from the top end
of the shape in per cent., horizontally, and the tensile strength and
elongation vertically. The various tables of tensile results given in
Tests of Metals, which I have drawn from for these diagrams, are shown
in table 5 herewith.
7©6
RAIL.
TABLE 5-
TENSILE TESTS.
Fig. Number
of this Report.
•• 17
Pass.
Ingot
Bloom 18
Third roughing pass 19
Fifth roughing pass 20
Squabbing pass 2 [
First forming pass 22
Second forming pass 23
Rail 24
From page of
Tests of Metals.
82
152
232
282
327
368
416
583
These various tests are all from heat No. 4, except those on the
ingot, which was ingot A of heat 1, and those on the bloom, which were
made from ingot iE. The interior metal is represented in the diagrams
in the shapes from the third roughing to the first forming pass, inclusive,
JJj 0,50,000
RNj2b,ooo
20
IA3
Side oj- INGOT
"£ ft: fc
Cr 0/ "x 10
Si "* 0
2
6
A
0
6
0
8
0
100
Percent /row Top 0/ /ngot
Fig. 17 — Tensile Tests from Side of Ingot.
and the results used for plotting are of the test pieces taken from the
center of the section or the web. The test pieces were almost .8 in.
in diameter, and in the shapes of large sectional area represent fairly
well only the axial metal, but in the smaller shapes considerable of the
exterior metal is also included. The exterior metal, or what was the
wall of the ingot, is represented in the diagrams in the shapes from
the ingot to the first forming pass, inclusive. In the ingot the samples
were taken from the middle of the side, but in the other shapes the
samples were taken from the upper corners, that is, the corners which
would later make the upper corners of the head, and for the diagrams
I have used the average of the two upper corner results. The bloom
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
7»M
was not a normal one, as it had been placed on its side to cool im-
mediately after stripping, but it is entirely probable that the corners were
set when this was done and probably the results may be used along with
the others for the present comparison. I could not, however, use the
interior results from this bloom. The diagrams of the second forming
and the finishing passes show results from the center of the head, which
would represent metal originally between the axis and the wall of the
ingot, although the results can probably be taken as approximating the
axial metal. On the diagrams showing the second forming pass, I have
also shown the results from the base as an interesting comparison.
Considering now the various diagrams, Figs. 17 to 24, inclusive, it
will be noticed that the metal of the ingot is fragile, having a low tensile
strength (below 50,000 lbs. per sq. in.), and but little stretch. Passing
on to the bloom, Fig. 18, where the metal has been reduced from about
400 sq. in. at the bottom of the ingot to about 60 sq. in. in the bloom,
it will be noticed that the metal at the corners of the bloom has acquired
100,0
"k>$ 75,ooo
*
£ 1.50,000
(0"O 25,ooo
20
I IS"
S "- 0
IE
Upper Corners 0+ BLOOM
>
2
0
4
0
a
0
8
0
100
Percent /rom Top £rtcL of Shape
Fig. 18 — Tensile Tests from Corners of Bloom.
a tensile strength of about 110,000 lbs. per sq. in., and an elongation
of about 14 per cent, in 10 inches, except the sample from the top end
of the bloom, which showed weak and brittle. Unfortunately, we have
no results of the interior metal in the normal bloom, but the results seem
to show that the exterior metal acquires almost its full physical prop-
erties in its reduction to the bloom.
The tensile strength and elongation curves of the third roughing
pass, Fig. 19, again show good physical properties of the metal from
the upper corners of the head, except at the upper end of the shape,
but the axial metal shows low strength and low elongation, except in
:68
RAIL.
the lower quarter of the shape, where fair physical properties are shown.
It is also interesting to note that the top end of the shape also shows
fair properties at the axis. The curves of the fifth roughing pass, Fig.
lOO.ooo. , ■ <D
^£75/>oo
fc--
8j£
<S<0
^ l^50ooo
a
„ R.
0)
•v) «
£-025,ooo
fc
£
20
t:
.o+i R
&£Q'°
tfck *^
s« ~.
Oft. R
ThLrd Roug h img Pass
• Center- of section
o l/pper corners of head.
20 40 60 80 IOC
Percent from Tap End oj Shape
Fig. 19 — Tensile Tests from Third Roughing Pass.
20, show results similar to those just described, but there is considerable
increase in the elongation where it was low before. The tensile strength
of the exterior metal also shows some increase in the upper quarter
1 00,ooo
Ch £75,000
Si
<0 50,ooo
OJ ^N
'*• *> 2 5ooo
20
Si - 0
Fifth Roughing Pass
• Center- of Sect con
o— . — Upper corners 0/ head
20 40 60 80
Percent from Top End of Shape
Fig. 20 — Tensile Tests from Fifth Roughing Pass.
of the shape, but the tensile strength of the axial metal has decreased
in the region between 20 per cent, and 40 per cent, from the top end
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
769
of the shape. It is again interesting to note that the top end shows
fair physical properties, this time across the whole section. In the
squabbing pass, Fig. 21, there is considerable improvement of the tensile
!00,«06 , ^_ -"- P— 0— ■ — T- g-1 — °~ "" T ■ 1 1*1
*»k 50,000
00 Q,
4)
It
ScfuabbcTig Pass
* Center of Section
o Upper corners of head
20
It-S
•s * *
•«* o_
2 0 40 60 80
Percent from Top End. of Shape
Fig. 21 — Tensile Tests from Squabbing Pass.
strength of the axial metal, but a drop in the elongation of this meta
in the region between 20 and 60 per cent, from the top end.
The curves of the first forming pass, with an area of 14. 1 sq. in.
100,000
W*75,ooo
25 1^50,000
*
ft
■o '***
10
First Forming Pass
• Center of section
o Upper corners of head
4D
20 40 60 80
Percent from Top End 0+ Shape
Fig. 22 — Tensile Tests from First Forming Pass.
Fig. 22, are particularly interesting and should be studied closely, as we
seem here to have developed almost the full physical properties of both
770
RAIL.
the exterior and interior metal. The tensile strength of the metal at
the upper corners of the head is seen to first go up and then remain
roughly even for the rest of the length of the bar. The strength of
the interior metal starts at about 95,000 lbs. per sq. in., increases until
it reaches a maximum at about 25 or 30 per cent., of about 116,000
lbs., then decreases again until a minimum is reached at about 80 per cent.,
of about 99,000 lbs., and then increases again to about 107,000 near the
bottom end of the bar. These strengths of both the exterior and interior
metal follow closely the distribution we have already found of the carbon
in the bloom. The strength curves of Fig. 22 and the carbon curves of
Fig. 10 have a similarity that is rather interesting. The ductility in the
/ 00,000
t* ft
$75.<
ft K.
k50,<
Vi Oj
r> O25,ooo
ft^
20
J* ft .K
B Op.
p Q) ■■•>
O R R
«*i 0
10
jfi.
•*
-y-v
*=«**=
,~~^-f>
g ^
* ""^
- — q-j
4E
Second For mi
• Sa TTtjatc s /ro
m head
0 Samples from base
«^q
— 0
o=d3=
®"»
/
-6
p**^S>5
~o-"
2
0
4
0
6
0
e
0
100
Percent -from Tbjo End 0/ Shape
Fig. 23 — Tensile Tests from Second Forming Pass.
first forming pass shows in a very general way some increase as we go
down the bar. Fig. 23 shows curves of the metal from the second form-
ing pass representing the centers of the head and the base, and there-
fore mostly what was interior metal in the ingot, but not axial metal.
These curves are somewhat similar to the ones of the first forming pass
just discussed. Fig. 24 shows just a few results from the head of the
finished rail.
From the above discussion it may be gathered that the metal in
the walls of the ingot takes comparatively little work or reduction to
impart to it what may be called its full physical properties of tensile
strength and ductility. In fact, these are practically reached in the
bloom at six reductions, except at the top end. The axial metal at the
bottom of the ingot also soon reaches its full qualities, but in the upper
half of the ingot it must be carried through the first forming pass or
25 reductions before this point is reached.
In order to show up somewhat more clearly the rate of improvement
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
771
of the physical qualities of the steel as the process of reduction pro-
ceeds, the tensile properties have been plotted on the basis of times
reduced ; that is, the ratio of the area of the original cross section of
the ingot to the area of the shape. For this purpose four distances in per
cent, from the top end have been selected as typical of the different
regions to be found in the ingot, namely, 5 per cent., 25 per cent, 50
per cent, and 00 per cent. The times reduced in rolling at these dis-
tances for the different passes are shown in table 6 herewith. The ex-
pression, ''times reduced," means the same as times elongated, and while
perhaps not a strictly correct expression, its convenience probably justifies
its use in this report, and its meaning will be the ratio above explained.
I00,«
75,
50,
,<CO
— m
*»"■ !
«F
OOO
Rati
Samples from head
?0
***>•
10
n
2
0
4
0
6
0
8
0
100
a, £
O O 1
* J!
Percent from Top End 0/ RaiL Bar
Fig. 24 — Tensile Tests from Head of Rail.
table 6 — reductions in various passes.
Distance from top of shape.
Pass. 5% 25% 50% 00%
Bloom 5-8
Third roughing 10.7
Fifth roughing 14-2
Squabbing 194
First forming 24.5
Second forming 31.9
Finishing 467
Fig. 25 shows the metal at 5 per cent, from the top of the ingot at
the various stages of reduction. The metal originally in the corner of
the ingot is weak and brittle until the stage of about 14 reductions is
reached, while the axial metal reaches fair qualities somewhat sooner.
The metal at 25 per cent, from the top end is shown in Fig. 26, and
it will be noted that the exterior metal shows very fair qualities of
6.0
6.2
6.6
II. I
ii-5
12.2
147
15.3
16.2
20.1
20.9
22.1
25.2
26.3
277
33-1
48.3
34-3
36.2
50.2
53-2
RAIL.
5js£ 75.000
(/) *• 5 O.ooo
«J ft.
I"
..O
CM
7^
=*===*
-head
Me fat ai 5 percent
from top end 0/ shape
• Center 0/ section
O Upper corners of head
Fig. 25 — Metal at 5 Per Cent from Top at Various Stages of
Reduction.
— *^° O-t-head
I00/Ooo
r>.
5 £
-u—
^75,000
<0 . 50.000
\.
"> .£25,000
Metal, at /Z.O percent
from tojo end 0/ shape
• Center of section
O— — — Upper corners of head
20
ft
0 5° "10
O— -
y— *
o-«-
>
head
O ft R
>*i "~ 0
y
X
/
Fig.
TO 20 30 40 50
26 — Metal at 25 Per Cent from Top at Various Stages of
Reduction.
20
30
fri
Times
Reduced
<:
n*
0
E
£
k
Jo
0
<0
■Kl
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 77.']
strength and ductility in the bloom at six reductions, and its full qualities
are reached at about 20 reductions, showing a tensile strength of about
105,000 lbs. with about 16 per cent, elongation in 10 inches. The axial
metal at 25 per cent, does not reach its full qualities until about 25 re-
ductions is reached at the first forming pass, and even here the test
pieces would contain some of the outer metal. Fig. 27 shows the metal
at 50 per cent, and here the exterior metal shows good qualities from
the bloom on with but little, if any, improvement beyond this stage,
but the axial metal does not reach its full qualities until over 25 reduc-
tions is reached in the first forming pass or beyond. Fig. 28 shows the
metal at 00 per cent., and here again the exterior metal shows its full
(O fc50,ooo(£
*>^25,600
B
-^"G
Metal at DU percent
from top end of shape
• ' Center 0/ section
O Upper corners of head
10
ZO 30
k.
Tcmes Reduced
•v.
0
0)
■0 £ !;
<0 -2 £
Fig. 27 — Metal at 50 Per Cent from Top at Various Stages of
Reduction.
qualities in the bloom with but little or no improvement beyond this
stage. The axial metal also shows its full qualities at the third rough-
ing pass at twelve reductions. We have no results before this stage
of reduction, which is unfortunate, as it would be very interesting to
see whether the axial metal at the bottom of the ingot also reaches its
full qualities in the bloom.
This study indicates that the metal in those portions of the ingot
where it is of fairly even composition and free from sponginess, soon
reaches its full physical qualities of tensile strength and ductility. Ten
reductions, or a reduction to one-tenth of the original cross-sectional
area of the ingot, suffices, but the interior portion of the upper part of
774
RAIL.
the ingot requires 25 or more reductions to have its full qualities de
veloped, that is, the original cross-sectional area of the ingot must be
reduced below four per cent.
TENSILE TESTS OF RAILS.
Vol. 2 of Tests of Metals contains an interesting series of tensile
tests of samples from the head of the rail bar from ingot D of heat 1,
charged hot and soaked in the usual manner. The test specimens were
.798 in. diameter with a sectional area of .5 sq. in. and a gage length
of 10 in., and were taken along the whole length of the rail bar, from
the middle of the head. The results of the tensile tests are collected
<M n.
-J!
20
fc s ..
Vi 0
Metal at Z/CJ percent
/rom top end 0/ snape
* Center of section
O— -Upper corners of head
^..-5^:2=.
te==j
20
30
-head-
"to
50
Times Reduced
Fig. 28 — Metal at 90 Per Cent from Top at Various Stages
Reduction.
on pages 485 and 486, and I have plotted the tensile strength and elonga-
tion in Fig. 29 herewith on the basis of per cent, of distance from the
top end of the rail bar. It will be noted that starting with a tensile
strength of about 107,000 lbs. per sq. in. at 6 per cent., the strength
rapidly goes up until a maximum of about 129,000 lbs. is reached at 14
per cent. The strength then gradually drops until a minimum is reached
of about 102,000 lbs. at 86 per cent., after which it rises again, reaching
about 111,000 lbs. near the bottom end of the bar. The elongation in
10 in. starts at 12 per cent, reaches a minimum of 8 per cent, where
the tensile strength is greatest, and then gradually increases until 18
per cent, is reached at about 82 per cent, from the top, after which it
again drops somewhat.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
775
In this series of tests, then, we again -find a distribution of the tensile
properties along the bar, corresponding in a general way to the dis-
tribution found of the carbon ' in the interior of the bloom.
A similar series of tensile tests from the head of the rail was made
of ingot F of heat i, which was laid on its side to cool immediately
after stripping, head side up, and then reheated. With an ingot kept
in the usual vertical position there is a concentration of carbon, phos-
phorus and sulphur and of blow holes, in the interior and upper part
of the ingot, and the effect of placing the ingot on its side to cool im-
mediately after stripping and while the interior is still liquid, would be,
it would seem, to orient the above-mentioned condition along almost
the whole of the side uppermost in cooling, in this case, into the head of
the rail for most of the length of the rail bar. The results of the tests
IZ!y>eo
« 5 0»c
,J 25,oo
20
2 t k:
£«
**— «■ V «w»
Head of Rati
Ingot ID charged, hot and
soakad as usuctt
20 40 60 60
Percent from Top £r?d of Rait Bar
Fig. 29 — Tensile Tests from Head of Normal Rail.
too
are shown on pages 551 and 552 of Tests of Metals, and I have plotted
these in Fig. 30 herewith in the same manner as the previous results.
At 6 per cent, from the top of the rail bar the results are a good deal
the same as in the normal rail, but the elongation at once decreases,
and the tensile strength soon follows, so that at 20 per cent, the ductility
is practically all gone and the tensile strength down to 70,000 lbs. per
sq. in. The tensile strength again goes up quickly, but afterwards varies
considerably between about 98,000 and 121,000 lbs. per sq. in. The elonga-
tion also remains low, varying mostly between 2 and 6 per cent, until
about 89 per cent, is reached, when it is about the same as in the normal
rail for the rest of the rail bar, namely, above 15 per cent. The tensile
strength is also about normal for the bottom 10 per cent.
T7<;
RAIL.
These tests shozv, then, that the effect of placing the ingot on its
side to cool immediately after stripping, head side up, is to render the
metal in the head generally weak and brittle in tensile test, except for
about 10 per cent, from each end of the rail bar, where the metal ex-
hibits its normal properties, due, presumably, to having set previous to
stripping.
ETCHINGS OF CROSS SECTIONS.
The Tests of Metals contains, a great many most excellent repro-
ductions of iodine etched cross sections of shapes from the ingot to the
finished rail, showing the progressive change both from one end to the
other of the ingot or bar, and also through the various passes. Start-
ing from the top end of a shape, the structure as developed by etching
l25;ooo
5£
75,.
50,
25,c
ao
ki o
Head of Rati
ingot IF Laid on side imme-
diately after stripping,
head side up; reheated.
100
20 40 60 60
Percent j-rom Top End »/ RaiL Bar
Fig. 30 — Tensile Tests from Head of Rail Made from an Ingot that
Had Been Laid on Its Side to Cool Immediately After Strip-
ping, Head Side Up, and Reheated.
progressively changes to the bottom end, and each region has its char-
acteristic structure. The various structures can, perhaps, be fairly well
represented by distances of 10, 20 and 65 per cent, from the top end
of the shape. At 10 per cent, the larger sections contain cavities of
various sizes, distributed throughout the section, while the smaller sec-
tions show spots with a somewhat similar distribution, but more numerous.
At about 20 per cent, all passes, except, perhaps, the largest sections,
show a dark "core" with some dark spots distributed around. In the
lower part of the shape, as typified by sections at about 65 per cent.,
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 777
the sections also show a core, but it is apt to show light. This lighter
colored core first shows up about half way down, increasing in area
until a distance of about 90 per cent, from the top end is reached,
when the cross section becomes almost structureless on etching.
Figs. 31 to 56, inclusive, are given to show the progressive changes
through the different passes for distances of about 10, 20 and 65 per cent,
from the top end of the shape, and table 7 (page 40 of this report) shows
the pages of Tests of Metals, 1909, from which these are reproduced.
Fig. 31 — Quarter Ingot, Cross Section Slice, i B 4, 11.26% by
Distance, 10.4% by Volume, from Top of Ingot.
Fig. 32 — Sixth Blooming Pass, Quarter Section 5 B 4 — 10.3%
from Top of Ingot.
RAIL.
fife *2
Fig- 33 — Ninth Blooming Pass, Quarter Section 5 C 3-
9.1% from Top of Ingot.
Fig. 34 — Third Roughing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 A
14.47% from Top End of Shape.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 779
FJG- 35 — Squarbing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 C 8 — 8.84% fkom
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 36 — First Forming Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 D 12 — 9.89% from
Top End of Shape.
780
RAIL.
Fig. 2>7 — Second Forming Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 E 14—9.69% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 38 — 75~LB- Rail, Cross Section Slice 4 F 16 — 9.89% from
Top End of Rail Bar.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 781
Fig. 39 — Quarter Ingot, Cross Section Slice i B 8 — 23.79% by Distance,
22.2% by Volume from Top of Ingot.
Fig. 40 — Sixth Blooming Pass, Quarter Section 5 B 7 — 20.2% from
Top of Ingot.
782
RAIL.
Fig. 41— Ninth Blooming Pass, Quarter Section 5C11 — 21.6%
from Top of Ingot.
Fig. 42 — Third Roughing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 A 16—24.72% from
Top End of Shape.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 783
Frc. 43 — Fifth Roughing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 B 16 — 17.04% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 44 — Squabbing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 C 16 — 19.77% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 45 — First Forming Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 D 30 — 19.62% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 46 — Second Forming Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 E 44 — 21.85% from
Top End of Shape.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES.
Fig. 47 — 75-lb. Rail, Cross Section Slice 4F41 — 21% from Top
End of Rail Bar.
Fig. 48 — Quarter Ingot, Cross Section Slice i B 22 — 67.64% by Dis-
tance, 65.7% by Volume, from Top of Ingot.
786
RAIL.
Fig. 49 — Sixth Blooming Pass, Quarter Section 5 B 21 — 63% from
Top of Ingot.
Fig. 50 — Ninth Blooming Pass, Quarter Section 5 C 37 — 62% i-rom
Top of Ingot.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 787
Fig. 51— Third Roughing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 A 43 — 64.49% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 52 — Fifth Roughing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 B 66 — 67.52% from
Top End of Shape.
RAIL
Fig. 53 — Squabbing Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 C 83 — 73.43% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 54 — First Forming Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 D 97 — 65.23% from
Top End of Shape.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 789
Fig. 55 — Second Forming Pass, Cross Section Slice 4 E 130 — 68.39% from
Top End of Shape.
Fig. 56 — 75-LB. Rail, Cross Section Slice 4 F 140 — 64.83% from Top
end of Rail Bar.
"'.HI
RAIL.
TABLE / — PAGES OF TESTS OF METALS, IQOp,
on which are shown etchings of cross sections, which are reproduced
as figures of this report.
10 Per Cent.
20 Per Cent.
65 Per Cent.
Pass.
Page
Fig.
Page
Fig.
Page
41
95-18
99-20
165-11
237-10
287-10
331-16
371-13
575-13
Fig.
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
Ingot
23
95-3
99-1
165-3
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
27
95-6
99-7
165-5
237-2
287-5
331-6
371-6
575-4
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
Third roughing
Fifth roughing
287-3
331-4
371-2
575-2
First forming
Rail
The rails made from ingot 3F are interesting, as showing how the
interior structure as developed by etching may be changed by manipulat-
ing the ingot. This ingot was laid on its side to cool immediately after
stripping, web side up, and then reheated for 9 hours. Four etched sec-
tions of rails are herewith reproduced as Figs. 57 to 60, inclusive, at dis-
Fig. 57— 75-LB. Rail, Cross Section Slice 3 F 16— 10.80% from Top End
of Rail Bar. Ingot Laid on Side to Cool, Immediately
After Stripping, Web Side Up.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 791
Fig. 58— 75-lb. Rail, Cross Section Slice 3 F 39— 20.51% from Top End
of Rail Bar. Ingot Laid on Side to Cool, Immediately
After Stripping, Web Side Up.
Fig. 59 — 75-lb. Rail, Cross Section Slice 3 F hi— 50.41% from Top End
of Rail Bar. Ingot Laid on Side to Cool, Immediately
After Stripping, Web Side Up.
792
RAIL.
Fig. 60 — 75-lb. Rail, Cross Section Slice 3 F 173 — 74.71% from Top End
of Rail Bar. Ingot Laid on Side to Cool, Immediately
After Stripping, Web Side Up.
tances of approximately 10, 20, 50 and 75 per cent, from the top end
of the rail bar, and it will be noted how the streaks and spots have
been oriented toward the side that was "uppermost in the cooling ingot.
There is now a similarity of appearance along practically the whole bar,
except that the upper third of the length of the bar shows some spots
on the side that was below in cooling, which spots are generally absent
in the lower part of the length.
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 79J
SUMMARY.
i. The Report of Tests of Metals, etc., made at Watertown Arsenal,
Mass., for the year 1909, is devoted largely to tests of rail steel ingots
and derivative shapes. Etchings were made of sections of the ingot and
of successive shapes to the finished rail, and the report consists largely
of the illustrations of these etchings, showing the changes in structure
from one end of a shape to the other, and through the successive shapes.
Tensile test bars were also taken at successive stages of the rolling, and
a carbon survey of two blooms is also given.
2. Below are given statements of the various conclusions that seem
to be indicated by the tests as applying to the Bessemer steel dealt with
in this investigation, and to the conditions under which it was made,
and care should be exercised when applying them to other steel and
other conditions of manufacture. The ingots were about 19^x20^4 in.
at the bottom and 5 ft. high.
3. Examination of ingots shows that the upper third of the ingot
is very spongy, that is, it contains a great many cavities of various sizes.
The sponginess, in general, tapers toward the center.
4. Examination of successive shapes shows that the larger central
cavities persist well beyond the blooming passes, and that the spongi-
ness extends downward from the top end of the shape about the same
proportionate distance as in the ingot.
5. The cavities of a cold ingot, which had been placed in the soak-
ing pit directly after stripping, and then cooled down, constitute a little
larger part of the volume of the ingot than where the ingot is cooled
down directly without soaking.
6. The cavities of a cold bloom made from an ingot which had been
placed in the soaking pit directly after stripping, and rolled into a bloom
upon removal from the soaking pit, also constitute a little larger part
of the volume of the bloom, than where the ingot is first cooled down
after pouring, reheated and then rolled into a bloom.
7. A carbon survey of two blooms shows that, starting from the
top end of the bloom, the axis at first shows negative segregation of
carbon, that is, carbon below the average in the steel, reaching a minimum
at about 6 or 8 per cent, from the top, but the carbon soon increases
and shows considerable positive segregation, reaching a maximum at
about 22 or 24 per cent, from the top end. About half way down, the
carbon at the axis again reaches the average amount, and in the lower
half again shows some negative segregation, coming up to about the
normal at the bottom. The maximum segregation of carbon was 70 per
cent, in one bloom and 54 per cent, in the other, above the average con-
tent.
794 RAIL.
The walls of the upper part of the bloom show negative segregation
of carbon, which rises until the average carbon content of the bloom
is reached at about 25 or 35 per cent, from the top end. The greatest
negative segregation was 32 per cent, in one bloom and 26 per cent, in
the other, that is, the carbon was this much below the average content
of the bloom.
8. Tensile tests were made of specimens taken at various stages
from the ingot to the finished rail, and they throw light on the question
of the amount of work or reduction necessary in rolling to develop"
the full physical qualities of the steel. The results indicate that the
metal in the walls of the ingot takes comparatively little work or reduc-
tion to impart to it what may be called its full physical properties of
tensile strength and ductility. These are reached in the bloom, except
at the top end. The axial metal at the bottom of the ingot also soon
reaches its full physical properties, but in the upper half of the ingot
it must be carried well toward the finished rail before these properties
are fully developed.
Where the metal is of fairly even composition and free from spongi-
ness, it reaches its full physical qualities of tensile strength and ductility
at about ten reductions or a reduction to one-tenth of the original cross
section of the ingot, but the interior portion of the upper part of the
ingot requires 25 or more reductions to have its full physical qualities
developed, that is, the cross-sectional area must be reduced below 1/25
of its original amount.
9. Tensile tests were made of specimens taken from the center of
the head of a rail bar which was made in the usual manner, and were
taken along the whole length of the bar. The tensile strength corre-
sponds, in a general way, with the distribution of the carbon in the
interior of the bloom, that is, it first goes up as we go down the bar,
reaching a maximum at 14 per cent, down, then the strength gradually
drops until a minimum is reached at 86 per cent, down, after which
it rises again. The maximum tensile strength in this bar was 129,000
lbs. per sq. in., and the minimum was 102,000 lbs. The elongation, in
general, varied inversely as the strength between limits of 8 per cent,
in 10 inches and 18 per cent.
10. A similar series of tensile tests was made on specimens from
a rail bar made from an ingot that had been laid on its side to cool im-
mediately after stripping, head side up, and then reheated. The effect
of this treatment of the ingot is to render the metal of the head gen-
erally weak and brittle in tensile test, except for about 10 per cent, from
each end of the rail bar, where the metal exhibits its normal properties.
11. Etchings were made of cross sections of shapes from the ingot
to the rail, showing the progressive change from one end of the shape
to the other, and also through the various passes. Each region along
the length of the shape has its characteristic structure. Near the top
end, the ingot and larger passes show holes generally distributed, while
the smaller passes show spots and streaks on etching. About one-fifth
WATERTOWN TESTS OF INGOTS AND SHAPES. 795
or one-fourth way down, the sections, particularly the smaller ones, show
a dark core with a few spots and streaks. The cross sections from the
bottom half of the shapes also show a core, but entirely different in
appearance, and it generally shows lighter colored. Each structure finds
its counterpart in the succeeding shapes and at about the same propor-
tionate distance from the top end.
12. Among the illustrations are etchings of cross sections of a rail
bar made from an ingot that had been laid on its side to cool imme-
diately after stripping, web side up, and then reheated. This treatment
of the ingot changes the structure entirely and its effect is to orient
the spots and streaks along the side that was uppermost in cooling and
for most of the length of the rail bar.
Appendix E.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE ON THE
PROPERTIES OF BESSEMER RAILS
By
M. H. Wickhorst, Engineer of Tests, Rail Committee.
This report covers an investigation to throw light on the influence
of the rolling and finishing temperature on the properties of Bessemer
steel rails. A series of five ingots, all of the same heat, were rolled into
85-lb. rails, all in the same manner except as to temperature of rolling.
A range of temperature was used from "cold" rolling to very hot rolling,
corresponding to shrinkages in a 33-ft. rail, varying from an average of
6J4 in. on the first rail-bar to an average of 7 in. on the last rail-bar.
The rails were then examined by means of drop, tensile and microscopic
tests and in addition an ingot of the same heat was split open and a
chemical survey made of it. The rails were made at the Edgar Thomson
Works at Braddock, Pa., of the Carnegie Steel Company, who kindly
furnished a heat of steel and all the means and facilities involved in
carrying out the tests, and the thanks of the Committee are due to the
various officers of the Carnegie Steel Company for their kindness and
the efficient manner in which the work was carried out.
MANUFACTURE.
The steel used was Bessemer steel made from Lake Superior ores.
The iron from the blast furnaces was poured into a mixer from which
it was weighed, poured into the converter and blown, scrap steel being
added at the same time. After blowing, the metal was poured into the
teeming ladle, the spiegel, in liquid condition, being poured in at the
same time, and the mixture was then poured into the molds. The amounts
of materials used to make this heat (No. 4,824 of August 24, 191 1) are
shown in table I.
TABLE I — BESSEMER AMOUNTS.
Mixer metal 30,600 lbs.
Scrap steel 2,500 "
Spiegel 3,280 "
Total 36,380 "
Report No. 21. November, 1911.
797
798 RAIL.
Analyses of special samples of the mixer metal and spiegel and of the
regular heat sample, taken about the middle of the heat, gave the results
shown in Table 2.
TABLE 2 — ANALYSES.
C. P. S. Mn. Si.
Mixer metal 4.27 .089 .060 .62 1.38
Spiegel 4.20 .099 .014 10.52 1.50
Heat sample 487 .095 .067 1.10 .19
(I was told that the mixer metal generally contained less carbon than
shown above, and it was conjectured that this sample may possibly have
had an excess of graphite.)
The various Bessemer operations occurred at the times shown in
table 3.
TABLE 3 — TIMES OF BESSEMER OPERATIONS.
Date Aug. 24, 1911
Started blowing 8.29 a. m.
Finished blowing 8.40
Time used to blow 11 min.
Started to pour into ladle 8.40 a. m.
Started to pour into molds 8.43
Time from finish of blowing to start of pouring into molds. . . 3 min.
Finished pouring into molds 8.52 a. m.
The heat made seven ingots and a "butt," six of which were used for
the experimental work. The ingots were about i8^4 in. by 19^ in. at the
bottom, about 51 in. high and weighed about 4,400 lbs. each. After strip-
ping, the ingots were placed in the soaking pit in a vertical position in
the usual manner, and after soaking varying lengths of time were roiled
into blooms about g]/2 in. square in seven passes. The discard from the
top of the bloom was as small as practicable to allow of satisfactory roll-
ing. The bloom was cut in two, the two halves were placed in a re-
heating furnace and, when raised to the desired temperature, were rolled,
without being held at any stage, into 85-lb. rails in 13 passes, as follows :
seven roughing, five forming and one finishing pass, making a total of
20 passes from the ingot to the rail. Just before entering the finishing
rolls, the rail-bar was flooded with strong jets of water to knock off the
scale. The section used was the Pennsylvania Railroad System, 85-lb. P.
S. section, illustrated on page 162, Vol. 12, part 2, 1911, Proc. Am. Ry.
Engr. & M. W. A. Each ingot made four rails.
As stated, there were seven ingots in the heat. The first ingot of
the pouring was not used for this test work and the fourth was used
for splitting open and making a chemical survey. Ingots 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7
were given test numbers respectively as follows : ET6, ET7, ET8, ET9
and FT10, and were used for making rails for test. The fourth ingot
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 799
was given test number ETu. The six ingots were all placed in the
soaking pit about the same time (about 9.50 a. m.), but drawn at differ-
ent times, as the making of the test rails proceeded. The lengths of time
they were in the soaking pit are shown in table 4.
TABLE 4 — TIME IN SOAKING PIT.
Ingot Time in Pit. Used For.
ET6 1 hr. 29 min Rails
ET7 2 " 23 " "
ET8 2 " 25 " "
ET9 3 " 12 " "
ET10 3 " 13 " "
ETu 2 " 24 " Splitting
The lengths of time that the pairs of blooms from each ingot were
in the reheating furnace are shown in table 5.
TABLE 5 — TIME IN REHEATING FURNACE.
Blooms from Ingot. Time in Furnace.
ET6 30 min.
ET7 17 "
ET8 32 "
ET9 38 "
ET10 55 "
The temperatures of the various rail bars were determined after
leaving the finishing rolls by means of a Thwing radiation pyrometer, the
tube of the instrument being directed toward the top of the head of the
rail. The shrinkages were also determined by measuring the saw set-
tings and the rails after cooling. These temperatures and shrinkages
are shown in table 6.
TABLE 6 — SHRINKAGES AND FINISHING TEMPERATURES.
Shrinkage, Inches. Temperature.
A B CD A&B C&D
Ingot. Rail. Rail. Rail. Rail. Rails. Rails.
ET6 63-16 67-16 62-16 65-16 935°C 94o°C
Average 64-16 9380
ET7 67-16 611-16 67-16 68-16 965° 9600
Average ... 68-16 „ 9630
ET8 612-16 615-16 610-16 615-16 9850 9950
Average ... 6 13-16 9900
ET9 614-16 7 3-i6 613-16 73-16 10250 10300
Average ... 7 10280
ET10 615-16 73-16 614-16 71-16 10200 10250
Average ... 7 I023°
It will be noted that for the first four ingots there was a graded
difference of finishing temperature and of shrinkage, but the last was
800
RAIL.
about the same as the one previous, although it had been intended to have
this finished the hottest. The range in finishing temperature of the head
of the rail as measured with a radiation pyrometer, between the average
of the four rails of ingot ET6 and ET9 was go°C, and the range in shrink-
age was 54 in-. or from 6% to 7 in.
The lengths of the cold rails, their camber and whether "head sweep"
or "base sweep" are shown in table 7. In sawing the rails, the two rails
from each half-ingot were sawed at one time. The setting for the first
pair of saws that cut the A and C rails was 33 ft. 6 11-16 in., and for
the second pair that cut the B and D rails was 33 ft. 6*A in.
TABLE 7 — LENGTHS AND CAMBERS OF RAILS.
Length.
Rail. Ft. in.
ET6A 33 08-16
B 33 01-16
C 33 09-16
D 33 03-16
ET7A 33 04-16
B 32 11 13-16
C 33 04-16
D 33 o
ET8A 32 11 15-16
B 32 11 9-16
C 33 01-16
D 32 11 9-16
ET9A 32 11 13-16
B 32 11 5-16
C 32 11V&
D 32 11 5-16
ET10A 32 11 12-16
B 32 11 5-16
C 32 11 13-16
D 32 11 7-16
Camber.
in.
H
itI
A
%
H
ilA
%
2
iVs
Vs
Concave.
Head or
Base Side.
Head
Head
Base
Head
Base
Head
Base
Head
Base
Head
Base
Head
Base
Head
Rail ET6D was classified on inspection as a No. 2 rail, due to rough-
ness at the under corner of the head at two or three places near the
middle of its length, and rail ET7D was also so classified on account of
a flaw in the web near the middle of its length.
The various discards from the blooms and the rail bars and the
weights of the ingots are shown in table 8.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
801
ETil
Fig. i — Longitudinal Section of Ingot ETii about % in. from Axis.
Drilled for Analysis.
802 RAIL.
TABLE 8 — DISCARDS — WEIGHTS OF INGOTS.
ET6 ET7 ET8 ETo ETio
Discard from bloom, top 235 270 220 278 334
Discard from bloom, bottom 185 108 185 260 204
Discard from rail bar, top 21 54 57 67 63
First intermediate .... 46 43 47 53 59
Second intermediate 43 52 59 86 70
Bottom 34 49 45 49 52"
Total discard 564 576 613 793 782
Weight of four rails 3,740 3,740 3,740 3,740 3,740
Total weight of ingot 4,304 4,316 4,353 4,533 4,522
The weight of ingot ET11, which was used for splitting and chemical
survey, was 4,580 lbs., weighed whole after cooling.
INGOT.
As stated the fourth ingot of the pouring, given test number ET11,
was set aside for direct examination after soaking 2 hrs. 24 min. This
ingot was split across the small diameter and planed to a smooth
surface. Fig. 1 shows this longitudinal section about 34 in. from the
axis of the ingot and after drilling for analysis. It will be noted that
the central cavity extends downward from the top about one-third the
length of the ingot, with a few smaller holes still lower. The general
sponginess at the top of the ingot extends downward about 15 per cent.
This ingot was 51 in. high, i8J4 x *9/4 in- at the bottom and 17x1834
in. at the top.
ANALYSES OF INGOT.
This section of the ingot was drilled for a chemical survey, the
samples for analysis being taken as shown on the drilling diagram, Fig. 2.
It will be noted that we obtained five vertical rows of drillings from
one-half of the section, making a total of 75 samples, less the number
that could not be obtained, due to cavities in the ingot. The thick half of
the ingot was used and the drilling cut through the axial plane. In addi-
tion, two samples were taken from the bulge at the bottom of the ingot and
called samples 100D and 100E. The ingot after drilling is shown in
Fig. 1. On each sample determinations were made of carbon (by com-
bustion), phosphorus and sulphur, and on samples 99A, B, C, D and E,
and 100D and E, the manganese and silicon were also determined as
representing the average in the ingot. The results on carbon, phosphorus
and sulphur are shown in tables 9, 10 and 11, respectively. The
manganese and silicon are shown in table 12.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
803
Vert ica.L
Rows
A B C D if
/
0 O O O (>
5
O O O O <|)
1
10
o o o O <)
15
O O O O <)
1
20
o o o O <)
% 25
O O O O <)
a
£ 30
O O O O (
>
Si
Z.
, 35
o o o o <
)
«.
£ 40
o o o o <
>
E
0
k
^K
50
o o o o <
>
(i
U
&
V
i{ eo
o o o o <
>
**il
Q
70
D O O O <
>
HoUs
#v
am.- /"rfjep.
80 <
b o o o <
>
■*
"3
U»
90 (
> 9 <}) <j> <
>
«
99 [(
i -i diam ^
) O O O <
)
Fig. 2 — Drilling Diagram for Ingot.
804
RAIL.
TABLE 9-
-CARBON
IN INGOT
ETII.
Per Cent
from Tor.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
i
•415
470
•435
•453
.419
5
•473
455
.482
•472
•493
10
•525
510
•532
15
•514
395
•542
•834
20
•531
523
•554
.624
25
•530
■519
.528
•599
30
•515
523
.568
.482
.662
35
.518
•515
•535
•523
■530
40
•540
483
•529
.464
•519
50
•514
.501
.464
.502
.446
60
.489
•435
.486
.426
•459
70
•513
524
.482
.480
•452
80
•503
•497
.492
•457
.411
90
•515
•445
■497
•454
.468
99
.492
•471
.491
•489
•483
100
.482
•494
TABLE IO — PHOSPHORUS IN INGOT ETII.
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
1
.068
064
055
070
062
5
.077
080
075
074
080
10
.085
075
082
15
.086
082
075
184
20
.091
080
092
"5
25
.090
090
088
117
30
.092
090
098
098
095
35
.092
083
103
105
096
40
.091
095
089
075
098
5o
.082
091
077
086
100
60
•095
094
099
080
080
70
.100
081
090
105
084
80
.076
097
093
092
088
90
.092
095
090
088
086
99
.089
094
095
092
096
100
095
094
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
80£
TABLE
11—
-SULPH
Per Cent.
from Top.
A.
B.
i
O58
061
5
069
060
IO
OS8
059
15
069
061
20
07I
074
25
O70
074
30
083
073
35
075
083
40
O77
074
50
079
069
60
07I
074
70
O78
075
80
O76
078
90
074
074
99
079
076
100
TABLE I
2 — MANGA!
JESE A
Per
Cent
from To]
x A.
Manganese
99
100
1.04
99
100
■19
SULPHUR IN INGOT ETII.
c.
D.
.049
048
.067
048
.047
•OS7
136
.074
118
.065
099
.085
093
.074
081
.079
082
•073
067
.068
069
.070
072
.067
066
.069
063
.077
069
084
•054
.061
104
092
075
086
065
075
070
067
073
073
B.
■17
c.
D.
E.
1.15
1. 12
115
I.04
1.08
•17
.18
■19
.18
.18
P. S. Mn. Si.
.093 .076 1.08 .18
.095 .067 1. 10 .19
closely except as to sulphur.
Probably the seven samples at the bottom of the ingot, 99 A, B, C,
D and E and 100 D and E, represent fairly closely the average steel in
the ingot and I give below their average composition, and, for compari-
son, the results on the heat sample :
C.
Average of seven bottom samples 486
Heat sample 487
It will be noticed that the two results agree
where there is a difference of .009 per cent, more as shown by the aver-
age of the samples from the bottom of the ingot.
At any given distance from the top of the ingot the extreme variations
in composition are, in general, shown by the axis and the walls of the
ingot, and, to show conveniently the changes from the top to the bottom
of the ingot, I give Fig. 3, showing the plotted results for carbon, phos-
phorus and sulphur for the axis and the wall of the ingot, showing the
amount of the element vertically and the per cent, from the top of
the ingot horizontally. Where samples could not be obtained from the
axis on account of cavities, the results from row D were taken as repre-
806
RAIL.
senting the axis. Lines are also shown representing the average carbon,
phosporus and sulphur in the ingot. It will be noticed that the axis at
the top shows negative segregation of the three elements, but the amounts
increase rapidly and show considerable positive segregation, reaching
SO
fc-60
o
U
.20
16
R
2-08
.04
.16
^>.08
.04
TO 20 30 40 50 «0 70 60 90 i«
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 IM
20 30 40 50 60 70 BO
Per cent from Top of Ingot
90
100
Fig. 3 — Cakbon, Phosphorus and Sulphur in the Axis and Wall of
Ingot ETii.
a maximum at about 15 per cent, by distance from the top of the
ingot. At about halfway down, the elements again reach the aver-
age amount in the ingot and continue to decrease, showing some
negative segregation in the lower half of the ingot. The amounts again
rise close to the bottom and reach the average content of the ingot.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
801
The wall of the ingot also shows negative segregation of the three
elements at the top, but the amounts gradually rise until the average
amount is reached, about 15 to 20 per cent, by distance from the top,
after which it remains roughly uniform.
The maximum positive segregation found at the axis and the maxi-
mum negative segregation found in the wall ore shown in table 13.
TABLE 13 — POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE SEGREGATION.
Carbon. Phosphorus. Sulphur.
Maximum at axis 834 .184 .136
Increase 72% 98% 79%
Minimum in wall 415 .068 .058
Decrease 16% 27% 31%
A
10%
yz/A
cavity ^
%
20%
30%
^&///
40%
\cX
v/V/X/N
50%
Vyv
60%
70%
NcStS/N^
%£
80%
90%
Fig. 4 — Distribution of Phosphorus in Ingot ETii. A, Below .070:
B, .070 to .085; C, .085 to .105; D, .105 to .135; E, .135 to .175;
F, Above .175.
808 RAIL.
It was considered unnecessary for the purposes of this investiga-
tion to determine the manganese and silicon on all the samples, as other
work has shown that manganese segregates to a much smaller extent than
the carbon, phosphorus or sulphur, and silicon shows no noticeable
segregation.
Fig. 4 is given to show the separation of the phosphorus into regions
of different concentrations, and the same diagram can be taken to repre-
sent the distribution of the carbon and sulphur. Six concentrations o-f
phosphorus were selected, as shown in lable 14, and the approximate
amounts of carbon and sulphur represented by these regions are also
shown in the same table.
TABLE 14 — REGIONS OF VARIOUS CONCENTRATIONS.
Phosphorus. Carbon. Sulphur
A Below .070 Below .45 Below .060
B 070 to .085 .45 to .48 .060 to .068
C 085 to .105 .48 to .53 .068 to .080
D 105 to .135 .53 to .60 .080 to .100
E 135 to .175 .60 to .70 .100 to .125
F Above .175 Above .70 Above .125
It should be stated that there is considerable irregularity in the results
and the various regions are not sharply defined as shown on the dia-
gram, although they are correct in a very general way. The region of
greatest concentration is shown by F in the upper part of the ingot sur-
rounding the "pipe," about 15 per cent, from the top by distance, and prob-
ably about 10 per cent, by weight. The top 5 per cent, of the ingot
shows considerable negative segregation, with a region of milder nega-
tive segregation for about 10 or 15 per cent, below this, and there is also
a region of some negative segregation in the interior and lower part
of the ingot.
TESTS MADE OF RAILS.
The entire rail-bar of each of the ingots used for rails was used
for drop tests, tensile tests and microphotographs, and was divided into
units of one-third rail length, or 11 ft., each. From each 11 ft., 1 ft. was
cut for tensile tests, then 5 ft. for drop test with the head in tension,
and the other 5-ft. piece was used for drop test with the base in tension.
From each i-ft. piece three tensile tests were made, one from the upper
corner of the head, one from the interior of the head near its junction
with the web, and the third from the flange. Microscopic tests were made
of the three tensile test pieces from the top end of the rail. From each
rail, then, nine tensile tests and three microscopic tests were made. In all.
nine pieces were cut from each rail, as shown in table 15.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 809
TABLE 15— TESTS FROM EACH RAIL.
No. i — i ft. Tensile and microscopic tests.
Drop test, head tension.
Drop test, base tension.
Tensile tests.
Drop test, head tension.
Drop test, base tension.
Tensile tests.
Drop test, head tension.
Drop test, base tension.
The distance of each piece from the top of the ingot, expressed in
lbs. and in per cent., is shown in tables 16 to 20, inclusive. This distance
is figured to the middle of the test piece.
I-
-1
ft.
2-
-5
ft.
3-
-5
ft.
4-
-1
ft.
5-
-5
ft.
6-5
ft.
7-
-1
ft.
8-5
ft.
9-
-5
ft.
TABLE 10—
-TEST PII
ICES OF INGOT
ETO — DISTA
NCE FRO
M TOP
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent.
ET6AI..
. . 270
6.3
ET6B1..
..1,205
28.0
A2..
• • 355
8.3
B2..
..I,200
30.0
A3..
• • 497
11-5
B3..
••1,432
33-3
A4..
.. 582
13-5
B4..
■•1,517
35-2
A5..
.. 667
15.5
B5..
. . 1,602
37-2
A6..
.. 809
18.8
B6..
• • i,744
40.6
A7..
.. 894
20.8
B7..
. . 1,829
42-5
A8..
• ■ 979
22.8
B8..
..1,914
44-5
A9..
. .1,121
26.0
B9..
• .2,056
47-8
ET6C1..
. .2,229
51-8
ET6D1..
• -3,164
73-6
C2..
• 2,314
53-8
D2..
• -3,249
75-5
c3..
• .2,456
57-0
D3..
• -3,391
78.8
c4..
• .2,541
59-i
D4..
• -3,476
80.8
c5..
. .2,626
61. 1
D5..
• .3,561
82.8
C6..
. .2,768
64.4
D6. .
• -3,703
86.1
c7..
. .2,853
66.3
D7..
• .3,788
88.1
C8..
• .2,938
68.3
D8. .
• -3,873
90.0
c9..
..3,080
71.6
D9..
• .4,015
93-3
TABLE 17-
-TEST PIECES OF INGOT
ET7 — DISTANCE FROM TOP.
Test. •
Lbs.
Per Cent.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent.
ET7A1..
•• 338
7-8
ET7BI..
..1,273
29-5
A2.
■ • 423
9-8
B2..
..i,358
31-5
A3.
••• 565
I3-I
B3..
..i,5oo\
34-8
A4.
, . . 650
I5-I
B4..
..1,585
36.8
AS-
• ■■ 735
17. 1
B5..
. .1,670
38.7
A6.
... 877
20.3
B6..
..1,812
42.0
A7.
. . . 962
22.3
B7..
..1,897
44.0
A8.
...1,047
24-3
B8. .
. . 1 ,982
46.0
Ag.
...1,189
27.6
Bg..
. .2,124
49-3
810
RAIL.
ET7C1
Ci
• ••2,303
53-3
C2
...2,389
55-3
c3
•••2,530
58.6
C4
...2,615
60.6
cs
. . .2,700
62.6
C6
. . . 2,842
65-9
C;
. . . 2,927
67.9
cs
.. .3,012
69.8
c9
• ••3,i54
73-1
ET7D1...
•3,238
75-0
D2...
■3,323
77.0
D3...
• 3,465
80.3
D4...
• 3,550
82.3
D5...
•3,635
84.3
D6...
■3,777
87.5
D7...
.3,862
895
D8...
•3,947
91-5
D9...
.4,089
94.8
TABLE l8 — TEST PIECES OF INGOT ET8 — DISTANCE FROM TOP.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent
ET8A1
. . . 291
6.7
ET8B1...
.1,226
28.2
A2
... 376
8.7
B2...
• i,3H
30.1
A3
... 518
11.9
B3...
•i,453
33-4
A4
... 603
13.9
B4...
.1,538
35-3
A5
... 688
15-8
B5...
.1,623
37-3
A6
. ... 830
19.1
B6. ..
•1,765
40.5
A7
... 915
21.0
B7...
.1,850
42.5
AS
. . . .1.000
23.0
B8. ..
• i,935
44-5
Ao
1,142
26.2
B9...
• 2,077
47-7
ET8C1.
.. .2,267
52.1
ET8D1...
.3,202
73-5
C2
...2,352
54.0
D2...
•3,287
75-6
c3
...2,494
57-3
D3...
•3,429
78.8
c4
•••2,579
59-3
D4...
.3,514
80.7
C5
. . . 2,664
61.2
D5...
■3,599
82.7
C6
...2,806
64-3
D6...
■3,741
86.0
c7
. . .2,891
66.5
D7...
.3,826
88.0
C8
. . .2,976
68.4
D8...
•3,9n
90.0
C9
...3,u8
71.6
D9...
■4,053
93-2
TABLE 19 — TEST PIECES OF INGOT ET9 — DISTANCE FROM TOP.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent
ET9A1..
• 359
7-9
ET9B1.
..1,294
28.6
A2..
• 444
9.8
B2.
• •1,379
30.5
A3..
. . 586
12.9
B3-
••i,52i
33-6
A4..
. . 671
14.8
B4.
. . 1,606
35-5
As-.
•• 756
16.7
B5-
. .1,691
37-4
A6..
. . 898
19.8
B6.
..1,833
40.5
A7-.
• 983
21.7
B7.
..1,918
42.4
A8..
..1,068
23.6
B8.
. .2,003
44-3
A9..
. .1,210
26.8
B9.
• .2,145
47-4
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
811
ET9CI..
. .2,368
52.3
ET9D1..
.3,303
730
C2..
• -2,453
54-2
D2..
.3,388
74-9
P3-.
• -2,595
57-3
D3..
• 3,53o
78.0
c4..
. .2,680
59-2
D4..
•3,615
79-9
c5..
• .2,765
61.1
D5..
• 3,700
81.8
C6..
. .2,907
643
D6..
•3,842
85.0
c7..
• 2,992
66.1
D7..
•3,927
86.8
C8..
■ .3,077
68.0
D8. .
.4,012
88.6
C9..
• -3,219
71.2
D9..
• 4,i54
918
TABLE 20 — TEST PIECES OF INGOT
ETIO — DISTANCE FROM TOP.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent.
Test.
Lbs.
Per Cent
ET10A1 . .
. . 411
9-i
ET10B1..
• i,346
29.8
A2..
.. 496
11.0
B2..
• i,43i
31-7
A3..
.. 638
14.1
B3..
•1,573
34-8
A4..
• • 723
16.0
B4..
..1,658
36.7
A5..
.. 808
17.9
B5..
• 1,743
38.6
A6. .
• • 950
21.0
B6. .
.1,885
41.7
A7..
.•1,035
22.9
B7..
.1,970
43-6
A8. .
. .1,120
24.8
B8..
■ -2,055
45-5
A9..
. .1,262
27.9
B9..
• -2,197
48.6
ET10C1..
. .2,410
53-3
ET10D1..
• -3,345
74.1
C2..
• -2,495
55-2
D2..
• -3,430
76.0
c3..
• -2,637
58.3
D3-.
• -3,572
79.1
c4..
. .2,722
60.2
D4..
• -3,657
81.0
c5..
. .2,807
62.1
D5..
• -3,742
82.9
C6..
. .2,949
65-3
D6..
- .3,884
86.0
c7..
• .3,034
67.2
D7..
• -3,069
87.9
C8..
• 3,119
69.1
D8. .
• -4.054
89.8
Cg..
• .3,261
72.2
Dp..
. .4,196
92.9
DROP TESTS.
Six drop tests were made of each rail, three with the head in tension
and three with the base in tension. The tup was 2,000 lbs., the height of
drop was 18 ft., the supports were 3 ft. apart, and the anvil was the
standard spring supported anvil of 20,000 lbs. The deflection or set was
taken as the distance between a 3-ft. straight edge and the part of the
rail where struck by the tup. Gage marks 1 inch apart were put on the
side in tension for a distance of 6 inches, and the length of the space
which stretched most at failure was determined and taken as a measure
of the ductility of the rail. The results of the drop tests are shown in
table 21 to 25, inclusive, showing the test number, the distance from the
top of the ingot in per cent, of the weight, whether head or base in ten-
sion, the set after the first blow, the number of blows that it took to break
the rail and the per cent, of stretch of the inch that stretched most at
failure. The averages of each test piece location of the various rail-bars
are shown in table 26.
812
RAIL.
TABLE 21 — DROP TESTS, INGOT ET6, AVERAGE SHRINKAGE, 6 4~l6 IN.
Per Cent. Head or Set No. Maximum
Test
From Top
Base in
I St
of
Elongation
Remarks.
Number.
of Ingot.
Tension.
Blow.
Blows.
Per Cent.
ET6A2
8-3
Head
1.80
2
10
A3
1 1-5
Base
1.69
2
14
AS
15-5
Head
1.65
2
11
A6
18.8
Base
1.67
4
23
A8
22.8
Head
1.68
3
19
A9
26.0
Base
1.66
4
20
ET6B2
30.0
Head
1.60
4
18
Not broken.
B3
33-3
Base
1.72
4
20
B5
37-2
Head
1.68
4
20
B6
40.6
Base
1.67
4
18
B8
44-5
Head
1.71
3
21
B9
47-8
Base
1.67
4
18
ET6C2
53-8
Head
1.78
3
21
C3
57-0
Base
1.72
2
6
Broke about 5 in.
from support.
C5
61.1
Head
1.87
3
22
C6
64.4
Base
1.78
4
19
C8
68.3
Head
1.80
4
19
Co
71.6
Base
1.80
3
12
Broke at support.
ET6D2
75-5
Head
1.76
4
30
D3
78.8
Base
1.72
S
32
Not broken.
D5
82.8
Head
(2.02)
2
12
Not broken
through head.
D6
86.1
Base
1.80
5
20
D8
00.0
Head
1.78
3
26
Broke near sup-
port.
Do
93-3
Base
1.80
5
24
Average
I-73I
3-5
19.0
TABLE 22 — DROP TESTS, INGOT ET7,
AVERAGE SHRINKAGE, 6 8-l6 IN.
Per Cent.
Head or
Set
No.
Maximun:
1
Test
From Top
Base in
1st
of
Elongatior
1 Remarks.
Number.
of Ingot.
Tension.
Blow.
Blows
. Per Cent
ET7A2
9.8
Head
Broke
1
6
A3
13-1
Base
1.70
3
14
As
17. 1
Head
1.63
3
18
A6
20.3
Base
1.68
3
13
A8
24-3
Head
1.65
2
10
Ao
27.6
Base
1.68
4
20
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
813
ET7B2
3i-5
Head
1.74
2
10
B3
34-8
Base
1.65
5
24
B5
38.7
Head
1.76
2
10
B6
42.0
Base
1-73
4
17
Broke near sup
port.
B8
46.0
Head
1.66
2
14
B9
49-3
Base
1.71
5
20
ET7C2
55-3
Head
1.77
4
23
■
C3
58.6
Base
1-73
3
18
C5
62.6
Head
1.70
5
20
C6
65-9
Base
1.72
5
20
C8
698
Head
1.76
4
26
c9
73-1
Base
1.78
3
16
ET7D2
77.0
Head
1.80
5
33
Not broken u
head.
D3
80.3
Base
1.81
4
22
Broke near sup
port.
D5
84-3
Head
1.77
5
27
D6
87.5
Base
1.78
5
22
D8
91-5
Head
1.77
4
24
Dp
94-8
Base
1.70
4
22
, 1.728
46
18.7
TABLE 23 — DROP TESTS, INGOT ET8, AVERAGE SHRINKAGE, 6 I3-I6 IN.
Per Cent. Head or Set No. Maximum
Test ■
From Top
Base in
I St
of
Elongation Remark
Number.
of Ingot.
Tension.
Blow.
Blows
. Per Cent.
ET8A2
8-7
Head
1.81
2
10
A3
1 1.9
Base
1.69
2
10
A5
15-8
Head
1.67
2
10
A6
19.1
Base
1.68
2
10
A8
23.0
Head
1.69
3
16
Ao
26.2
Base
1.66
4
17
ET8B2
30.1
Head
173
3
18
B3
33-4
Base
1.65
4
18
B5
37-3
Head
• 175
3
20
B6
40.5
Base
173
3
23
B8
44-5
Head
1.76
4
24
Bo
477
Base
174
5
22
'
814
RAIL.
ET8C2
54-0
Head
1.76
3
20
C3
57-3
Base
1.70
4
20
c5
61.2
Head
1.81
3
17
C6
64-3
Base
1.72
4
20
C8
68.4
Head
1.80
3
24
c9
71.6
Base
1.70
5
18
ET8D2
75-6
Hea.-
1.79
4
24
D3
78.8
Base
1.70
5
23
D5
82.7
Head
1.80
5
23
D6
86.0
Base
1.70
4
23
D8
90.0
Head
1.82
5
28
Dg
93-2
Base
1.78
4
25
Average
1-735
3-6
19-3
TABLE 24 — DROP TESTS,
INGOT ET9, AVERAGE SHRINKAGE, 7 IN.
Per Cent.
Head or
Set
No.
Maximum
Test
From Top
Base in
I St
of
Elongation Remarks.
Number.
of Ingot.
Tension.
Blow.
Blows.
Per Cent.
ET9A2
9-8
Head
Broke
1
4
A3
12.9
Base
1.63
3
8
A5
16.7
Head
1.78
2
10
A6
19.8
Base
1.71
5
22
A8
23.6
Head
1.76
2
17
A9
26.8
Base
1.72
4
20
ET9B2
30.5
Head
1-73
4
23 "|
B3
33-6
Base
1.65
4
18
B5
37-4
Head
1.72
4
21
B6
40.5
Base
i-75
5
18
B8
44-3
Head
1.71
4
24
B9
47-4
Base
i-75
3
18
ET9C2
54-2
Head
1.80
4
22
c3
57-3
Base
1.70
5
20
C5
61.1
Head
1.82
4
22
C6
643
Base
1.71
4
22
C8
68.0
Head
1.77
4
24
C9
71.2
Base
i-73
5
24
ET9D2
74-9
Head
1.92
5
31 Broke at support.
D3
78.0
Base
1.84
5
24 Not broken.
D5
81.8
Head
1.85
5
29
D6
85.0
Base
1.85
4
26
D8
88.6
Head
1.86
4
34
D9
91.8
Base
1.86
4
25
Average
1.709
3-9
21. 1
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
815
TABLE 25 — DROP TESTS,
INGOT ETIO, AVERAGE SHRINKAGE, 7 IN.
Per Cent.
Head or
Set
No.
Maximum
Test
From Top
Base in
ISt
of
Elongation Remarks.
Number.
of Ingot.
Tension.
Blow.
Blows
. Per Cent.
ET10A2
11.0
Head
Broke
1
5
A3
14.1
Base
1.70
2
11
A5
17.9
Head
i-75
2
10
A6
21.0
Base
1.67
3
14
A8
24.8
Head
1.71
2
9
Ag
27.9
Base
1.78
3
16
ET10B2
31-7
Head
1.80
4
19
B3
34-8
Base
1.71
5
22
B5
38.6
Head
1.72
3
18
B6
41-7
Base
1.72
5
20
B8
45-5
Head
1.70
4
22
Bo
48.6
Base
1.76
5
20
ET10C2
55-2
Head
1.83
4
29
C3
58.3
Base
174
3
18
C5
62.1
Head
1.84
5
23 Not broken.
C6
65-3
Base
1.83
3
15
C8
69.1
Head
1.83
3
22
c9
72.2
Base
1.78
4
24
ET10D2
76.0
Head
1.89
3
20
D3
79.1
Base
1.81
5
27 Broke at sup
D5
82.9
Head
1.86
4
36
D6
86.0
Base
1.86
4
26
D8
89.8
Head
1.86
4
33
Do
92.9
Base
1.83
4
22
Average .
1.784
3.S
20.0
TABLE 26— AVERAGE RESULTS IN DROP TESTS.
Per Cent.
Head or
Maximum
Test
From Top
Base in
Set
Number
Elongation
Number.
of Ingot.
Tension.
1st Blow.
of Blows.
Per Cent.
A2
9-5
Head
1. 805
i-4
7.0
A3
12.7
Base
1.682
2.2
11.4
A5
16.6
Head
1.696
2.2
11.8
A6
19.8
Base
1.682
3-4
16.4
A8
237
Head
1.698
24
14.2
A9
26.9
Base
1.700
3-8
18.6
816
RAIL.
B2
30.8
Head
1.720
3-4
17.6
B3
34-0
Base
' 1.676
4-4
20.4
B5
37-8
Head
1.726
3-2
17.8
B6
41. 1
Base
1.720
4.2
19.2
B8
45-0
Head
1.708
3-4
21.0
B9
48.2
Base
1.726
4.4
19.6
C2
54-5
Head
1.788
3-6
23.0
C3
577
Base
1.718
3-4
16.4
C5
61.6
Head
1.808
4.0
20.8
C6
64.8
Base
1-752
4.0
19.2
C8
68.7
Head
1.792
3-6
23.0
c9
7i-9
Base
I.7S8
4.0
18.8
D2
75-8
Head
1.832
4.2
27.6
D3
79.0
Base
T.776
4-8
25.6
D5
82.9
Head
1.820
4.2
25-4
D6
86.1
Base
1.798
4.4
23-4
D8
90.0
Head
1.818
4.0
29.0
D9
93-2
Base
1-794
4.2
23.6
rage. ..
• - - 1.750
3-6
19.6
DUCTILITY IN DROP TESTS.
As stated, the inch space which stretched most at failure was taken
as the measure of ductility of the piece of rail tested, and the elongation
results are shown in Fig. 5. One set of diagrams represents the results
with the head in tension and the other set with the base in tension, the
elongation of the inch which stretched most being represented vertically
and the distance from the top end of the ingot in per cent, of the total
weight being represented horizontally. It will be noticed that in general
the curves for the various rail-bars fall within a zone, crossing and re-
crossing each other with but little, if any, relationship to the tempera-
ture at which the bars were rolled. The most prominent exceptions are
with the rail-bar ET6 which had the lowest rolling temperature, and
rail-bar ET7 which had the next higher rolling temperature. Considering
the results with the head in tension it will be noticed that ET6 gave
one low result toward the lower end of the bar, and all the results of)
the A and B rails of ET7, except one, showed low ductility. With the
base in tension, two of the tests of the C rail of ET6 showed much
lower elongation than the average and fell considerably below the zone
of results.
Whether these low elongation results of the two rail-bars that were
rolled at the lowest temperatures are in some way a function of the
lower rolling temperature, cannot be determined from these few results,
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
817
but since one rail from each of these bars had some surface flaws sufficient
to classify them as "No. 2" rails, the query naturally arises whether
such poor ductility results and the surface flaws which occurred in these
rails may not have been due in some way to the lower rolling tem-
A
40 60 80
Pe-rce-nt from Top of Ingot
Fig. s — Ductility of Rails in Drop Test in Relation to Distance from
Top of Ingot.
818
RAIL.
perature. Judgment on this matter must, however, be withheld until we
can obtain the returns from more extended experience.
In order to show the average ductility in more convenient form, I
give Fig. 6, showing one average ductility curve for the head tension
results and another for the base tension results. Starting at 10 per cent,
from the top of the ingot, the elongation with the head in tension starts
at about 8 per cent, and continuously rises as we go down the ingot,
reaching about 21 per cent, at 00 per cent, from the top. The base
tension results are similar, but show more ductility in the upper part of
20 40 60 60
Percent from Top of Ingot
Fig. 6— Average Ductility in Drop Test with the Head in Tension
and with the base in tension.
the ingot and less in the lower part, starting with about 12 per cent,
at 12 per cent, from the top and reaching about 24 per cent, at 90 per cent,
down. The ductility also seems to be about stationary, for the space be-
tween 40 per cent, and 65 per cent., although this feature may perhaps be
peculiar to this lot of tests. In my report No. 19 on the influence of size of
ingot, with ingots about 60 in. high the minimum ductility was found at
about 20 per cent, from the top, but in this case with an ingot about 51 in.
high the ductility increases continuously beyond 10 per cent, from the
top. The experiments, unfortunately, did not cover material closer to
the top, so we can say nothing of its ductility in this region.
DEFLECTION.
The results showing the permanent deflection or set on the first blow
under 18-ft. drop show but small differences between the different rail-bars.
Fig. 7 shows the average deflection curves for the head tension, the base
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
819
tension and the general average results, the set on the first blow being
shown vertically and the distance from the top of the ingot in per cent, of
the weight being shown horizontally. This set includes the local indenta-
tion caused by the tup. It will be noted that starting at about 16 per cent,
the average set is 1.69, and it increases continuously to 1.81 in. at 90 per
cent, down, an average increase of about 7 per cent., although the rate of
increase varies in different regions. It looks also as if the deflection is
greater closer to the top also, but the data are insufficient to determine this.
The set with the head in tension averages about .04 in. greater than with
the base in tension.
20 <{0 60
Percent /rom Top 0/ Ingot
Fig. 7 — Set of Rails Under i8-ft. Drop.
100
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE IN DROP TEST.
The average drop test results of the 24 test pieces from each rail-bar
and the general averages for all the rail-bars are shown in table 27 show-
ing the shrinkage, set after the first blow, number of blows from 18 ft.
that it took to break the rail and the elongation of the inch that stretched
most at failure.
TABLE 27 — GENERAL AVERAGE RESULTS IN DROP TESTS.
Shrinkage,
Ingot. inches.
ET6 64-16
ET7 68-16
ET8 613-16
ETo 7
ET10 7
Average 6 1 1— 16 1.750
Set,
Number
Elongation
1st blow.
of blows.
per cent.
I-73I
3-5
19.0
1.728
3-6
18.7
1-735
3-6
19-3
1.769
3-6
21. 1
1784
3-5
20.0
3.6
19.6
820
RAIL.
These results are shown graphically in Fig. 8, which should be studied
closely in connection with the table as they summarize the important
points brought out by the investigation as revealed by the drop tests. Ac-
cording to these results the temperature at which the rail's are rolled has
no very decided influence on the rails as developed by the drop test. The
average set for each rail-bar is the average of 24 test pieces, 12 with the
head in tension and 12 with the base in tension, but as the top piece,
which was tested with head in tension, broke on three of the rail-bars
on the first blow, the set could not be obtained, and for obtaining the
average was assumed to be 1.81 in., the average of the two which did not
break on the first blow. There seems to be a very slight increase of de-
20
=^=f20
fc
elonotfte'on^
1 eg
' £>
U6$
J*
Mi 12
0
1
0
8
.8*>
K$
0 "S
*$4
.4
77.
*mber 0/ 6Loims
1 1
>
6*/«" 6*/,a" 6'W 7"
S h rink age.
Fig. 8 — Results of Drop Test in Relation to Shrinkage.
flection as the temperature increases, but the differences are small, rang-
ing from about 1.73 in. to 178. The ductility also seems to increase a
little as the temperature rises, the averages for the entire rail-bars rang-
ing from 18.7 per cent, to 21. 1 per cent. The average ductility of the
bars with the lowest rolling temperatures is lowered considerably by a few
very low results on those bars. The number of blows that it took to
break the rails, or the accumulatied foot-lbs. of work, was just about the
same for the different rail bars.
TENSILE TESTS.
Three tensile tests were made from each third o\ a rail length along
each of the rail-bars, one sample from the upper corner of the head marked
INFLUENCE. OR ROULTNG TEMPERATURE.
821
a, one from the interior of head near the web marked b, and one from the
flange marked c, as shown in Fig. 9. The samples from the corner of the
head and the flange were taken from the side that was uppermost in
rolling. The test pieces were 10 in. long turned to J/2 in. diameter for a
gage length of 2 in. and the ends were Y hi. diameter. The tests were
■r-4
\t~tv
/o-
'"^D/am.
LD/am.
-H
-A ,"
Tejf P/ece f#r 7e/?s//e 7?sf
Fig. 9— Tensile Test — Test Piece and Locations.
made in a 200,000 lb. Olson test machine and the pieces were held with
wedge grips. The yield point was determined by means of a Capp's mul-
tiplying dividers. The results of the tests are shown in tables as follows:
Table 28 Yield point.
Table 29 Tensile strength.
Table 30 Elongation in 2 in.
Table 31 Reduction of area. !
Table 32 Ratio of yield point to tensile strength. \
822 RAIL.
TABLE 28 — YIELD POINT, LBS. PFR SQ. IN.
per cent.
Test
from
Piece.
Ingot 6.
Ingot 7.
Ingot 8.
Ingot 9.
Ingot 10.
Average.
top
Aia
68,170
64,700
64,300
64,160
65,210
65,308
7.6
Aib
65,820
64,640
65,360
65,540
63,980
65,068
Aic
64,040
66,940
64,240
66,000
64,700
65,184
A4a
66,740
66,630
65,260
64,820
63,840
65,458
14.7'
A4b
74,890
72,960
70,810
73,630
70,820
72,622
A4C
68,040
66,740
68,265
70,020
67,300
68,073
A7a
67,760
66,020
64,910
65,280
65,520
65,898
21.7
A;b
71,020
68,770
66,440
65,780
65,000
67,402
Aye
69,280
68,770
78,610
67,360
67,500
70,304
Bia
67,640
66,380
66,360
67,910
66,140
66,886
28.8
Bib
68,500
67,250
63,430
70,555
64,160
66,77g
Bic
71,420
67,740
67,760
68,470
68,130
68,704
B4a
68,420
65,870
66,020
66,080
64,140
66,106
35-9
B4b
62,710
61,280
62,680
64,550
63,580
62,960
B4C
66,990
77,860
66,460
68,060
66,100
69,094
B7a
64,395
65,980
66,480
65,060
64,500
65,283
43-0
B7b
63,040
61,950
62,920
63,780
62,200
62,778
B7C
66,990
68,830
66,940
67,140
66,700
67,320
Cia
66,820
67,400
68,740
66,500
65,360
66,964
52.6
Cib
61,130
61,740
62,120
61,710
61,340
61,608
Cic
68,820
68,880
67,980
67,780
77,890
70,270
C4a
66,690
66,120
65,090
64,280
65,270
65,670
59-7
C4b
60,630
60,220
61,000
60,040
60,420
60,462
C4C
70,450
66,740
68,740
67,020
67,350
68,060
C7a
67,760
67,260
64,480
65,210
64,300
65,802
66.8
C7b
62,020
61,790
60,340
60,120
58,590
60,572
C7C
69,180
67,200
67,920
68,100
67,400
67,960
Dia
64,500
65,060
66,630
63,950
64,800
64,988
73-8
Dib
63,940
61,800
60,800
59,98o
58,440
60,992
Die
68,370
69,815
68,640
66,450
66,160
67,887
D4a
66,410
65,920
65,390
64,230
64,450
65,280
80.9
D4b
62,150
60,220
59,720
58,500
57,960
59,7io
D4C
66,940
67,350
65,690
65,900
65,58o
66,292
D7a
66,940
66,940
65,130
65,120
63,340
65,494
86.7
D7b
60,880
61,140
60,520
57,600
57,060
59,440
D7C
64,060
67,240
66,140
66,240
63,900
65,696
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
823
TABLE 29 — TENSILE STRENGTH, LBS. PER SQ. IN.
Average
per cent.
Test
from
Piece.
Ingot 6. Ingot 7. 3
ngot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average.
top.
Ala
114,010 i
13,350
[13,910
[16,450
115,020
[14,548
7.6
Aib
117,010 ]
16,325
[19,920
[26,550 ]
19,105
[19,782
Aic
114,480 i
15,025 i
12,530 ]
15,680 ]
19,200
[15,383
A4a
121,250
[ 18,200
[16,500
[16,450
[18,400
[18,160
14-7
A4b
129,800 i
22,520
15,800
13,700
[16,600
[19,684
A4C
117,250 ]
20,390 i
18,600 ]
19,540 ]
20,300
19,216
A7a
121,750 ]
16,820 1
19,080
19,250 ]
18,000
[19,340
21.7
A7b
129,400 ]
20,640
[28,400
20,300
109,800
[21,708
A7C
1 18,200
[18,500
[23,500
[21,660
[22, IOO
[20,792
Bia
121,680 ]
19,450
[18,300
20,220
[l8,700
[19,668
28.8
Bib
123,950 i
26,350 i
20,630 i
22,700 ]
23,730 1
23,472
Bic
118,880 ]
22,600
[21,500 ]
25,830 ]
2I,800
22,122
B4a
117,780 ]
19,150
[18,700
[18,800
[ 18, IOO
[18,506
35-9
B4b
114,580 ]
14,310 i
17,080 ]
18,65c i
22,750
17,474
B4c
120,020 ]
20,810 ]
21,070 ]
21,150 ]
22,500
21,110
B7a
117,780 ]
16,660
[18,190
[18,700
[21,750
[ 18,816
43-0
B7b
1 16,250 ]
14,580
15,640 i
16,650 ]
17,200
[16,064
B7C
121,040 ]
18,500 i
20,380 i
20,840 i
21,250
20,402
Cia
116,610 ]
17,900
17,880 ]
i7,95o
18,850
[17,838
52.6
Cib
116,750 1
12,940
[14,050
16,450
[I7,IOO
15,458
Cic
108,000 ]
19,100
23,010 i
25,170
22,900
19,636
C4a
117,780 ]
17,180
[ 18,660
18,450
[l8,4IO
[18,096
59-7
C4b
1 12,780 ]
14,080 i
14,350 i
13,250 i
18,400
[14,572
C4C
H9,350
120,280
[23,070
[22,300
[22,110
21,422
C7a
116,090 ]
18,290
[ 16,500
120,490
[ l8,200
[17,914
66.8
C7b
112,480 ]
14,780
[12,830 ]
14,620 i
13,450
[13,632
C7C
1 19,290 ]
20,830
21,560
[23,740
[23,050
[21,694
Dia
1 16,560 !
[16,550
[17,780
[19,600
[ 19,400
[17,978
73-8
Dib
113,040
12,220
[12,530
[12,750
[14,550
[13,018
Die
117,420 I
18,470
[20,010
21,700
22,250
19,970
D4a
II9,O20 j
16,910
[18,400 ]
18,690
[17,350
1 18,074
80.9
D4b
II3,IOO
[ 10,800
[12,190
[11,850
11,400
[11,868
D4C
119,160
[18,250
[21,090
[22,000
[19,450
[19,990
D7a
117,820
[16,870
17,700
[18,560
[17,950
[17,780
86.7
D7b
1 10,800 s
11,820
12,200 ]
09,660
U9,350
[12,766
D7C
"5,790
[17,180
1 17,690
r 20,660
17,850 )
[17,834
824 RAIL.
TABLE 30 — ELONGATION, PER CENT. IN 2 IN.
Average
per cent,
from
Test
Piece. Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 0. Ingot 10. Average, top.
Aia 18.5 15 15.5 16.5 9 14.9 m
Aib 17.5 15 9 15 5 12-3
Aic 18.5 IS 10 l6-5 *4 H-8
A4a
16.5
19
15
11
17-5
15-8
14.7
A4b
5
5-5
4
3
4
4-3
A4C
14
17-5
12.5
10.5
15
13-9
A7a
16
17
18
18
17-5
17-3
21.7
A7b
IS
5
10.5
6
4-5
8.2
A7C
17
16.5
17
17-5
16.5
16.9
Bia
17
18
16
17
16
16.8
28.8
Bib
14
15
14
6
10
11.8
Bic
16.5
18
IS
16
14
1 5-9
B4a
19
18.5
15-5
15-5
17.5
17.2
35-9
B4b
19
10
16
8
12
13
'
B4C
18.5
18.5
16
15
17
17
B7a
18.5
16.5
16
15
17
16.6
43-0
B7b
18
14
15-5
6
11
12.9
B7C
18
17
15-5
16
17
16.7
Cia
17
16.5
16
18
17.5
17.0
52.6
Cib
18
17
16.5
17-5
17-5
17-3
Cic
17
15-5
17
16
17-5
16.6
C4a
18.5
18.5
18.5
18
18
18.3
59-7
C4b
20
19-5
i4S
18.5
17
17.9
C4C
17-5
18
17
16.5
16
17.0
■
C7a
17
18
18.5
17
17-5
17.6
66.8
<C7b
16
18
18
18
19
17.8
C7C
16
14-5
17
17
17
16.3
Dia
17
16.5
16.5
16.5
17.5
16.8
738
Dib
16.5
17
16
17
18.5
17
Die
16.5
17
16
17-5
17-5
16.9
D4a
19
19
17-5
18
17-5
18.2
80.9
D4b
19
19
18.5
18
18
18.7
'
D4C
19
19
17
16.5
17-5
17.8
D7a
18.5
19
18
18
18.5
18.4
86.7
D7b
19-5
18.5
18
18.5
18.5
18.6
D7C
19-5
19
J8.5
18
18.5
18.7
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 825
TABLE 31 — REDUCTION OF AREA, PER CENT.
Average
per cent.
Test from
Piece. Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average, top.
Aia 30.8 15.7 21.9 23.7 7.8 19.98 7.6
Aib 28.4 21.5 23.9 20.1 4.3 19-64
Aic 27.8 19-0 9-7 22.5 16.5 19- 10
A4a 26.7 30.8 20.8 8.2 23.3 21.96 147
A4D 40 3-2 2.3 2.4 3.2 3.02
A4C 14.6 31.4 12.7 10.1 19.8 17.72
A7a - 25.0 25.1 29.1 27.8 25.4 26.48 21.7
A7D 9.7 5.1 10.9 6.0 3.6 7.06
A7C 24.0 25.0 26.0 25.5 25.7 25.22
Bia 23.7 34.4 23.3 23.6 20.5 25.10 28.8
Bib 16.4 31.4 29.0 5.2 7.5 17.90
Bic 21.9 31.5 21.2 23.6 20.8 23.80
64a 35.1 30.8 22.9 19.7 28.0 27.30 35-9
B4b 34.4 9.0 21.2 7.8 10.9 16.66
B4C 35.0 36 21.9 19.7 27.5 21.54
B7a 34.1 22.9 22.6 20.8 24.7 25.02 43.0
B7b 30.5 25.7 20.8 52 9-8 18.04
B7C 28.4 23.6 21.5 19.0 25.4 23.58
Cia 27.5 24.5 21.9 31.5 27.1 26.5 52.6
Cib 30.1 26.4 23.6 24.7 26.1 26.18
Cic 25.0 14.3 25.4 23.6 25.8 22.82
C4a 341 321 30.8 28.5 18.7 28.84 59.7
C4b 347 33-1 23.3 30.8 22.6 28.00
C4C 32.4 28.4 23.6 25.8 27.4 27.52
C7a 24.7 31.0 30.2 24.3 28.5 25.74 66.8
C7b 19.8 29.8 26.4 25.0 28.8 25.96
C7C 24.4 28.4 26.4 22.6 24.3 25.22
Dia , 26.7 25.4 24.0 25.8 28.2 26.02 73.8
Dib 24.3 24.7 21.9 25.7 27.1 24.74
Die 24.3 24.0 21.9 25.1 24.3 27.92
D4a... 29.2 32.8 29.8 28.8 25.7 29.26 80.9
D4b 27.1 30.8 25.4 26.1 27.4 27.36
D4C 28.1 31.8 25.8 26.4 26.4 27.70
F>7a 35-4 347 29.5 28.5 27.4 31.10 86.7
D7b 31.4 27.8 27.1 30.5 28.0 28.96
D7c 347 31-8 29.0 28.5 31.2 31.04
826 RAIL.
TABLE 32 — RATIO YIELD POINT TO TENSILE STRENGTH, PER CENT.
Average
per cent.
Test from
Piece. Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average, top.
Aia 59.8 57.0 56.5 55-1 56.6 57 7.6
Aib 55-3 55-6 54-5 5i-7 57-9 55
Aic 56.1 58.2 57-1 57-1 54-3 56.56
A4a 55-i 56.3 56.7 55-6 53-9 55-52 14.7
A4D 57.8 59.6 61.2 64.8 60.7 60^2
A4C 58.1 55-4 57-5 58.5 55-9 57.08
A7a 55-7 56-5 54 1 54-7 56.0 55.40 21.7
A7b 55-0 57-i 5i-7 54.2 59,2 55-44
A7C 5&-6 58.0 63.6 55-2 55-2 58.12
Bia 55-6 55-6 56.1 56.4 55-6 55-86 28.8
Bib 55-2 53-2 52,6 57-6 51.8 54-o8
Bic 60.2 55-2 55-8 544 56.0 56.32
B4a 582 53-2 55-7 55<6 54*6 55-46 35-9
B4b 54-8 53-6 53-5 54-4 51-8 53-62
B4C 55-6 64.5 54-8 56,2 54.0 57.02
B7a. 54-7 56.6 56.2 54-9 53-0 55-08 430
B7b 54,3 54-1 54-4 54-8 53$ 54-14
B7c 55-3 58.0 55-5 55-8 55-0 55-92
Cia 57-3 57-2 58.3 56-3 54-9 56.80 52.6
Cib 52.4 54-7 54-5 53-0 52-3 53-38
Cic 63.7 57-8 55-2 54-i 63.4 58.84
C4a 56.7 56.3 55-6 54-2 55- 1 55-58 59-7
C4b 53-8 52-8 53-3 53-0 51.0 52.78
C4C 58.9 55-3 55 8 54-8 55- 1 55-98
C7a 58.3 56.8 55-3 54- 1 54-4 55-78 66.8
C7b 55-2 53.8 53-5 52-5 5i-6 53-32
C7c 580 55-6 55-8 55-0 54-7 55-88
Dia 55-3 55-7 56,6 53-5 54-2 55-06 73-8
Dib 55-6 S5-0 54-0 53-2 510 53-76
Die 58.2 58.9 57.1 54.7 540 56.58
D4a 55-8 563 55-2 54- 1 54-9 55-26 80.9
D4b 54-9 54-3 53-2 52.3 52.Q 53-35
D4C 56.1 56.9 54-2 54-0 54-9 55-22
D7a 56.8 57-2 55-4 55-Q 53-7 55-62 86.7
D7b 54-9 547 54-4 52-7 47-8 52.00
D7C 56.2 57-3 56.2 55-Q 54-2 55-78
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
827
The average results of the five rail-bars are shown in Fig. 10, plotted
in relation to their distance from the top of the ingot, the distance from
the top in per cent, being shown horizontally and the various results of
yield point, tensile strength, elongation and reduction of area, being shown
vertically. It will be noted that in the samples from the corner of the
head and from the flange the yield point and the tensile strength are about
uniform along the length of the bar, with perhaps a slight upward tend-
ency down to about 20 per cent, from the top. The yield point and the
l25,oo«
■ft .
>>«> ^100,000
SJ0J to****
50,<
y * I 25
3»k k
20
ft
-S^ ft
<5 ft. ""
15
10
Xi
w
— d, corner of head.
"t>> LTiterior of head.
C, fLang&
20 4 0 60 80 100
Percent from Top of Ingot
Fig. 10 — Average Results of Tensile Tests in Relation to Distance
from Top of Ingot.
tensile strength of the samples from the flange average about 2,000 lbs.
more than those from the corner of the head, the yield point averaging
about 68,000 and 66,000 lbs., respectively, and the tensile strength about
120,000 and 118,000 lbs., respectively. The samples from the interior
of the head, however, do not show uniform yield point and tensile
strength along the bar, These at first increase in the upper part of
the ingot to above the results from the corner of the head and the
flange and, in the lower part of the ingot they are less, corresponding
in a general way to the distribution of the hardening element, carbon and
phosphorus
828 RAIL.
The elongation and reduction of area of the samples from the corner of
the head and the flange increase continuously in a general way as we go
down the ingot, and the samples from the corner of the head run a
little higher in both properties than those from the flange. In the
corner of the head the elongation runs from about 15 per cent, in 2
in. at 10 per cent, down, to about iSy2 per cent, at 85 per cent, down, and
in the flange it runs about one per cent, lower. The reduction of area
in the corner of the head runs from about 21 per cent, at 10 per cent,
down, to about 30 per cent, at 85 per cent, down, and in the flange it
averages about 2 per cent, less in the upper part of the ingot but about
the same in the lower part of the ingot. In the interior of the head the
elongation and reduction of area start about the same at 8 per cent, down
as in the other locations, but they fall off to only a few per cent, at about
15 per cent, down, after which they again rise, and for the lower half of
the ingot are about the same as in the corner of the head and the flange,
or a little higher.
The averages of the 12 results from each section location of each of
the rail-bars and the general average of the 36 results from each rail-bar
are shown in table as follows:
Table 33 Yield point.
Table 34 Tensile strength.
Table 35 Elongation in 2 in.
Table 36 Reduction of area.
Table 37 Ratio of yield point to tensile strength.
TABLE 33 — AVERAGE YIELD POINTS.
Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average.
Corner of head.. 66,853 66,190 65,807 65,233 64,739 65,761
Interior of head. . 63,060 64,420 63,011 63,482 61,962 63,366
Flange 67,956 68,675 68,115 67,388 67,392 67,903
General average.. 66,512 66,150 65,644 65,359 64,698 65,677
TABLE 34 — AVERAGE TENSILE STRENGTHS.
Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average.
Corner of head. .118,177 117,277 117,708 118,634 118,427 118.059
Interior of head.. 117,495 ? 15,947 116,301 116,427 116,952 116,624
Flange 117,421 119,161 120,329 121,689 121,230 119,964
General average.. 11 7,698 117,461 118,110 118,916 118,869 118,216
TABLE 35 — AVERAGE ELONGATIONS, PER CENT. IN 2 IN.
Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average.
Corner of head.. 17.70 17.62 16.75 16.54 16.75 17.07
Interior of head.. 16.45 14-45 14-20 12.62 12.91 14-15
Flange 17-32 17-12 15.70 16.08 16.45 16.54
General average.. 17.16 16.40 15.55 15.08 15.37 15-92
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
829
28.35
25-56
25.10
2377
26.10
22.37
21.31
1745
16.60
20.36
24.40
22.09
22.70
24-59
24-43
25.04
22.99
21.75
21.67
2363
TABLE 36 AVERAGE REDUCTIONS OF AREA.
Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average.
Corner of head. .29.33
Interior of head.. 24.23
Flange 26.71
General average.. 26.78
TABLE 37 — AVERAGE RATIOS OF YIELD POINT TO TENSILE STRENGTH.
Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot 9. Ingot 10. Average.
Corner of head. .56.44 56.22 55.97
Interior of head.. 54.93 54-87 54-23
Flange 57-91 57-59 56-55
General average. . 56.48 56.24 55.58
1 2.5,ooo
^ >
So r^c-
Oj C0«O 75,000
54-95
54-74
55-70
54-51
53-35
54-37
55-4Q
55-55
56.60
54-95
54-56
55-50
•Corner c J- head, a.
Interior of head, 6>
' /• ta.77cjre,
Fig. 11-
6"//6 6®/© .6 ,s//6 7
Shrinkage*
-Results of Tensile Tests in Relation to Shrinkage.
830
RAIL.
The average results of each of the three section locations are plotted
in Fig. ii in relation to temperature of rolling, the shrinkage in a 33-ft.
rail being plotted horizontally, and the yield point, tensile strength, elonga-
tion and reduction of area being plotted vertically. It will be noted
that the yield point seems not to be influenced by the temperature of
rolling. The tensile strength is likewise not influenced, except that the
flange seems to increase a little in tensile strength as the shrinkage or
temperature of rolling increases. The elongation of the corner of the
head and of the flange decreases a little as the rolling temperature in-
crease*. The decrease of elongation in the interior of the head is more,
ranging from about 16.5 per cent, in 2 in. at 6 4-16 in. shrinkage, to
about 12.8 per cent, at 7 in. shrinkage. The influence of the rolling
temperature is seen most prominently, however, in the reduction of area
which decreases as the temperature increases. The range in the corner
of the head is from about 29.3 per cent, at 6 4-16 in. shrinkage down
to about 24J/2 per cent, at 7 in. shrinkage, in the flange from about
26.7 per cent, to about 23.7 per cent., and in the interior of the head
from about 24.2 per cent, to about 17 per cent.
DUCTILITY IN DROP TESTS AND TENSION TESTS
COMPARED.
A comparison of the ductility of the rails as measured in the drop
test and in the tension test, is interesting, and Fig. 12 is given, showing
20 40 60
Percent from Top 0/ Ingot
Fig. 12 — Ductility in Drop Test and Tension Test Compared.
the comparison, the distance from the top of the ingot in per cent, of
weight being plotted horizontally and the per cent, elongation vertically.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 831
The curves of the average elongation in the head tension and in the
base tension tests are reproduced as representing the ductility in the
drop test. The curve showing the average elongation in tension of the
samples from the interior of the head and another curve showing the
average of the samples from the corner of the head and from the flange,
are given as representing the ductility as measured in the tension test.
In the tension test the elongation is measured on a test piece J^ in.
diameter and in a gage length of 2 in., and includes the local necking
down where fracture occurs. In the drop test the elongation is measured
in a gage length of I in., this being the inch of six i-in. spaces which
stretches most at fracture. Observation of the fractures in the drop
test has shown that the fracture generally starts at some point within
the section and not at the outside where the greatest stretching occurs.
In tests with the head in tension, with rail from the upper and segrej
part of the ingot, the fracture generally starts in the interior of the
head well down toward the web, but with rail from the lower part of
the ingot the fracture starts nearer to the top surface, or sometimes it
may start at the surface, where the material is stretched most. In tests
with the base in tension the results are of a similar nature, although
they do not show up as prominently because the base is thinner, and
also possibly because the segregated metal is closer to the neutral axis
and may not influence the result so readily. In other words, the initial
point of the fracture in the drop test generally occurs, not where the
greatest stretching occurs, but internally at some point of lower ductility.
In the tension test, the exterior metal as represented by the flange and
the corner of the head, shows good ductility along the whole rail-bar,
although there is a general increase as we go down the ingot from about
14^2 per cent, elongation in 2 in. at 10 per cent, from the top, to about
18J/2 per cent, elongation at 90 per cent. down. The results from the
interior of the head near the web, however, differ considerably from
these, and while there is fair ductility near the top, the elongation drops
off to less than 5 per cent, at about 15 per cent, from the top. It then
rises again and in the lower part of the rail-bar averages slightly above
the results from the exterior of the section.
In the drop test, with the base in tension, the elongation, as measured
in this test, runs from 12 per cent, to 24 per cent, between the limits
mentioned above along the rail-bar. With the head in tension there is
also a continuous increase in the same part of the rail-bar, but the
differences in elongation are much greater, ranging from 8 per cent, to
27 per cent. In this respect there is considerable similarity between the
ductility of the interior metal as measured in the tension test of samples
from the interior of the head and the ductility as measured in the drop
test with the head in tension. It would seem, therefore, that this latter
test may be more useful to ascertain the ductility of the interior metal
832 RAIL.
than the drop test with the base in tension, as is usual in inspection
work.
MICROSTRUCTURE.
Microphotographs were made of the etched ends of the three tensile
test p:'eces from the top end of each rail. The pieces were polished,
etched with nitric acid and magnified 50 diameters in the photographs.
In Figs. 13 to 27, inclusive, are reproduced the etched cross-section s~"
from the top end of the C rail of each of the five ingots. Figs. 13 to
17, inclusive, show the cross-sections from the upper corner of the head
from the "top" side, that is, the side that was uppermost in rolling,
Figs. 18 to 22, inclusive, those from the interior of the head, and Figs.
23 to 27, inclusive, those from the "top" flange. These photographs show
the grains of "pearlite" inclosed in the web of "ferrite," and, in general,
the grains are smallest in the flange, somewhat larger in the corner of the
head and largest in the interior of the head. The main purpose of the
microscopic tests was to determine the influence of the rolling tempera-
ture on grain size, and table 38 is given, showing the approximate num-
ber of grains per .001 sq. in. of cross-section for each of the 60 samples
examined.
TABLE 38 — GRAINS PER .001 SQ. IN.
Test Piece. Ingot 6. Ingot 7. Ingot 8. Ingot g. Ingot 10. Average.
Aia 120 80 50 45 50 69
Bia 100 95 75 45 35 70
Cia 100 100 50 80 90 84
Dia 80 60 60 60 50 62
Average ..100 84 59 58 56 71
Aib 55 55 40 -20 20 38
Bib 30 25 25 18 20 24
Cib 100 85 45 40 25 59
Dib 50 50 35 25 20 36
Average . . 59 54 36 26 21 39
Aic 180 140 100 85 85 118
Bic 150 100 50 45 50 79
Cic 140 100 90 50 50 86
Die 80 70 40 40 40 54
Average ..138 103 70 55 56 84
Gen. Ave... 99 80 55 46 44 65
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 833
Fig. 13— Ingot 6, Shrinkage 6% in. Fig. 14— Ingot 7, Shrinkage 6l/2 in.
Fig. 15 — Ingot 8, Shrinkage 6 13-16 in.
Fig. 16 — Ingot 9, Shrinkage 7 in. Fig. 17— Ingot 10, Shrinkage 7 in.
Cross Section Microphotographs from the Upper Corner of the Head
of the Rail, from the "Top" Side or Side Uppermost in Rolling. Top
End of C Rail. Etched with Nitric Acid and Magnified 50 Diameters.
SCiB
7 C i B
Fig. 18— Ingot 6, Shrinkage 6^4 in. Fig 19— Ingot 7, Shrinkage 6^2 in.
Fig. 20 — Ingot 8. Shrinkage 6 13-16 in.
Fig. 21 — Ingot 9, Shrinkage 7 in. Fig. 22 — Ingot 10, Shrinkage 7 in.
Cross Section Microphotographs from the Interior of the Head of
the Rail near Its Junction with the Web. Top End of C Rail. Etched
with Nitric Acid and Magnified 50 Diameters.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE.
835
•C\s4
Fig. 23 — Ingot 6, Shrinkage 6J4 in- Fig. 24 — Ingot 7, Shrinkage 6l/i in.
Fig. 25 — Ingot 8, Shrinkage 6 13-16 in.
Fig. 26 — Ingot 9, Shrinkage 7 in.
Fig. 27 — Ingot 10, Shrinkage 7 in.
Cross Section Microphotographs from the Flange of the Rail, from
the "Top" Side or Side Uppermost in Rolling. Top End of C Rail.
Etched with Nitric Acid and Magnified 50 Diameters.
836
RAIL.
The average results for the four rails of each ingot are plotted in
Fig. 28, the shrinkage being shown horizontally and the number of grains
per .001 sq. in. vertically, for each of the three locations in the section.
It will be noted that as the rolling temperature increases, the number
of grains per unit of area of cross-section decreases ; that is, the size
of the grain increases. In the flange the number of grains per .001
sq. in. runs from 138, in ingot 6, with the lowest rolling temperature,
160
£*I20
fiangQ
1
*^
<>j£ corner
1 <
t> 80
?/ head
■'
^r— ^ *
«0
.£40
z*
0
interior
of head
II
6*/,4' <?«//«" 6'V/6
Shrinkage.
Fig. 28 — Size of Grain in Relation to Shrinkage.
rpO
down to 55 or 56 where the temperature was hottest. In the corner
of the head the range is from 100 down to 56, and in the interior of the
head from 59 to 21.
SUMMARY.
1. A series of five ingots from one heat of Bessemer steel was rolled
into 85 rails, all in a similar manner, except as to the temperature at
which they were rolled. One ingot was rolled ''cold" and the tempera-
ture was increased with the succeeding ingots, finally rolling the last
ingot very hot. The ingots were about 18^2 x 19^ in. at the bottom,
about 51 in. high and weighed about 4,400 lbs. each. After soaking in
the usual manner, the ingots were rolled into blooms about 9^2 in.
square and a smaller discard than usual made from the top. Each
bloom was then cut in two, the two parts reheated at the same time,
and were rolled into 85-lb. P. S. section rails (Pennsylvania Railroad
System), four rails being made from each ingot. In addition one ingot
of the same heat was used for splitting open and making a chemical sur-
vey, this ingot having been placed in the soaking pit and then cooled
down. This work was all done at the works of the Carnegie Steel Com
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 837
pany, who kindly furnished all the material and facilities for the test
work.
2. The rails were examined hy means of drop, tensile and micro-
scopic tests. The comparison ingot was split open to determine the in-
terior condition as regards cavities, and analyses were made of about
75 samples from one side of a longitudinal section near the axis to de-
termine the distribution of the carbon, phosphorus and sulphur.
3. The shrinkage after sawing varied from 6% in. in a 33-ft. rail,
as the average of ihe four rails from a whole rail-bar, to 7 in. The
temperature of the head of the rail just after leaving the finishing rolls,
determined by a heat radiation pyrometer, varied from 940 deg. C. to
1,030 deg. C, a range of 90 deg. C.
4. The upper 15 per cent, of the comparison ingot was spongy with
blow holes generally distributed, and the central cavity extended down-
ward about one-third way from the top.
5. The axis of the ingot showed considerable segregation of the
carbon, phosphorus and sulphur, reaching a maximum at about 15 per cent
by distance from the top. The maximum increases found were 72 per
cent, in carbon, 98 per cent, in phosphorus and 79 per cent, in sulphur,
above the average content of the ingot. The axis also showed a little
negative segregation in the lower part of the ingot.
6. The walls or outer part of the section showed negative segrega-
tion at the top part of the ingot for a distance of about 15 or 20 per
cent, down, after which the composition is about the average to the bottom
of the ingot. The greatest decreases amounted to 16 per cent, in carbon.
27 per cent, in phosphorus and 31 per cent in sulphur below the average
content of the ingot.
7. The ductility in the drop tests was determined by putting gage
marks one inch apart for a distance of three inches each side of the
middle longitudinally on the side in tension, and measuring the space
which stretched most at failure.
8. The tests covered the rail-bar from about 10 per cent, from the
top down to about 90 per cent, from the top, and the remarks below refer
to this part of the rail-bar. In both head tension and base tension tests
the ductility, as an average of all the rail-bars, increased continuously
along the rail-bar, starting from the top end. With head tension the
range was from about 8 per cent, to about 27 per cent, and with base
tension from about 12 per cent, to about 24 per cent.
9. The permanent deflection or set was measured under the first
blow of a 2,000-lb. tup falling from a height of 18 ft., with a span of sup-
ports of 3 ft. The set measured was the distance between a 3-ft. straight-
edge and the part of the rail where struck by the tup.
10. As an average of the head tension and base tension results, the
set at about 16 per cent, by weight from the top of the ingot was 1.69 in.
and increased continuously down the rail-bar until at 90 per cent, down
it was 1. 81 in., an average increase of about 7 per cent., although the
838 RAIL.
rate of increase varied in different parts of the bar. The set with the
head in tension averaged about .04 in. greater than with the base in
tension. The results from the bar above 16' per cent, from the top were
insufficient to allow of conclusions, but it seems that the set was greater
than at 16 per cent. down.
11. Differences of rolling temperature corresponding to shrinkages
of 6% in. to 7 in., in a 33-ft. rail, resulted in only small differences in the
rails as determined by the drop test. The deflection seems to have
increased slightly as the temperature increased, the averages of the bars
ranging from 1.73 in. to 1.78 in. The ductility also seems to have in-
creased some with an increase of temperature of rolling, ranging from
18.7 per cent, to 21. 1 per cent, for the averages of the bars. The number
of blows that it took to break the rails averaged just about the same for
the different bars, namely, 3J/2 blows.
12. Tensile tests were made along the rail-bars from three locations
in the section, the corner of the head, the interior of the head near
its junction with the web, and the flange.
13. Considering the average results of the five bars, the yield point
and tensile strength were about uniform along the bar in the samples from
the corner of the head and the flange, with perhaps a slight upward ten-
dency down to about 20 per cent, from the top. The flange averaged about
2.000 lbs. higher than the corner of the head both in yield point and ten-
sile strength, the yield point averaging about 68,000 and 66,000 ibs.,
respectively, and the tensile strength about 120,000 and 118,000 lbs.,
respectively.
The yield point and tensile strength of the interior of the head at
first increase to above the results from the two other locations, and
in the lower part of the ingot they are less, corresponding in a general
way to the distribution of the hardening elements, carbon and phosphorus.
14. The elongation and reduction of area of the corner of the head
and the flange increased continuously, in a general way, downward of
the ingot, the corner of the head showing a little higher in both properties
than the flange. In the corner of the head the elongation averaged from
15 per cent, in 2 in. to 18J/2 per cent., between the limits of 10 per cent,
and 85 per cent, down from the top of the ingot and in the flange the
results were about 1 per cent lower. The reduction of area in the corner
of the head ranged from 21 per cent, to 30 per cent, in the same region,
and in the flange it averaged about 2 per cent, less in the upper part of
the ingot, but about the same in the lower part.
In the interior of the head the elongation and reduction of area started
at upper part of the ingot about the same as in the other locations, but
they soon fell off to only a few per cent, at about 15 per cent, down,
after which they increased, and in the lower half (if the ingot they were
about the same as in the corner of the head and the flange, or were a
little higher.
INFLUENCE OF ROLLING TEMPERATURE. 839
15. Differences of rolling temperature corresponding to shrinkages
of 6% in. to 7 in. in a 33-ft. rail, resulted in little or no differences in the
yield point. The tensile strength was likewise not influenced, except that
the flange seems to have increased a little in tensile strength as the
temperature of rolling increased.
16. The elongation of the corner of the head and the flange decreased
a little with increase of temperature, but the interior of the head decreased
more in elongation with increase of temperature, ranging from about 16.5
per cent, in 2 in. at 6% in. shrinkage to about 12.8 per cent, at 7 in,
shrinkage.
17. The influence of the temperature of rolling, as determined by the
tensile test, is seen most prominently in the reduction of area, which de-
creased as the temperature increased. The range in the corner of the
head was from about 29.3 per cent, at 6%. in. shrinkage down to about 24^2
per cent, at 7 in. shrinkage, in the flange from about 26.7 per cent, to
about 23.7 per cent, and in the interior of the head from about 24.2 per
cent, to about 17 per cent.
18. A discussion is given comparing the ductility as developed by
the drop test and the tension test. In both tests the ductility increased
in a general way, downward of the ingot, except that the ductility of the
interior metal in the tension test was at its minimum at about 15 per cent,
from the top. The exterior metal shows good ductility, as shown by the
tension test, along the whole rail-bar, but the interior metal is of very low
ductility at about 15 per cent, by weight from the top. This seems to show
its influence in the drop test, to some extent in the tests with the base in
tension, but more prominently in the tests with the head in tension.
19. Microphotographs were made of etched sections from three loca-
tions in the section ; namely, the upper corner of the head, the interior
of the head near its junction with the web, and the flange. As the rolling
temperature increased, the number of grains per unit of area decreased,
that is, the size of the grain increased. In the flange the number of
grains per .001 sq. in. averaged from 138 with the lowest temperature
used to 55 with the highest temperature used. In the corner of the head
the range was from 100 down to 56, and in the interior of the head from
59 to 21.
20. Finally, the influence of the temperature of rolling, as ascer-
tained by the tests made, may be summed up as follows : The ductility
and deflection in the drop test were influenced little, if any, by the tem-
perature. The number of blows that it took to break the rails in the drop
test was uninfluenced by the temperature of rolling. The yield point and
tensile strength in the tension tests were influenced little, if any. The
elongation in the tension test decreased some as the temperature increased.
The influence of temperature showed most prominently, in the tension
test, in the reduction of area, which decreased as the temperature o(
rolling increased. The size of grain, as shown by the microscope, increased
as the temperature increased.
Appendix F.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
On January 8, 1912, the following order was issued by the Railroad
Commission of Indiana :
STATE OF INDIANA.
RAILROAD COMMISSION OF INDIANA. ,
Inquiry as to the condition of steel rails now being manufactured, )
purchased and put in by the railroad companies operating in - No.
the State of Indiana. )
Whereas, It is the duty of this Commission "to keep informed as to
the condition of railroads and railways with reference to the security
of the public,"' and
Whereas, This Commission is advised that the steel now manufac-
tured and put in on the railways in this state is inferior to the lighter
grades heretofore used, and that there is a difference of opinion between
the manufacturers and carriers as to whether this steel should be still
heavier to sustain the heavier equipment and loads, or should be of such
better quality as were said lighter grades :
Therefore, Upon consideration, a formal inquiry by the Commission
as to this matter is now instituted and commenced.
It is Ordered, That the General Managers, General Superintendents,
Engineers in charge of Maintenance of Way, and Expert Testers of new
steel, and such Purchasing Agents, and such authorities 00 steel rail
manufacture, and such roadmasters as the Commission may hereafter
summon shall attend a conference on this subject at Room 83 of the State
House on Tuesday, February 20, 1912, 10 a. m.
It is Further Ordered, That any expert on steel rail manufacture and
use, who may desire to give the Commission scientific or practical in-
formation on this subject, may appear and be heard at said conference,
to the end that such concerted course of action may be adopted by the
Commission as will tend to secure for use on the railways of this State
a high grade of steel, as perfect as to materials and manufacture and shape
and weight as can be practically made. It is understood that the Com-
mission will ask the aid and counsel of the American Railway Associa-
tion, who have collected a great deal of valuable data and information on
this subject.
It is Ordered, That the Secretary transmit a copy of this order to
each steam and interurban railroad operating in the State of Indiana.
I, J. L. Reiley, Secretary of the Railroad Commission of Indiana,
hereby certify that the above and foregoing is a true and complete copy
of the order issued by the Commission on the 8th day of January, 1912.
Given under my hand and seal this 8th day of January, 1912.
(Signed) J. L. Reiley,
Indianapolis, Indiana. Secretary.
841
842 RAIL.
A meeting between Mr. W. J. Wood, Chairman of the Railroad Com-
mission, and Mr. W. J. Jackson, Chairman of the Special Committee on
Relation of Railway Operation to Legislation, to determine the hest method
for conducting the hearing, resulted in the appointment of a committee
of railway nun t< > arrange for the information on the rail question which
was to lie presented to the Commission. This committee was as follows:
Mr. F. A. Delano, Receiver, Wabash Railroad; Mr. Fairfax Harrison,
President, C. I. & L. Railway; Mr. G. L. Peck, General Manager, Penn-
sylvania Lines ; Mr. W. C. Cashing, Chief Engineer M. of W., PenrP
sylvania Linos. South West System, and Dr. P. H. Dudley, Consulting
Engineer, New York Central Lines.
At a conference between the members of this committee, on Febru-
ary 9, a sub-committee consisting of Dr. P. H. Dudley, Dr. Thos. H. John-
son and Mr. W. C. dishing, with the latter as Chairman, was appointed
to draw up statements of the work which had been done by the railway
companies in the past for the improvement of rail design and specifica-
tions, to be read before the Commission as the statement of the railway.-.
The sub-committee divided this task up into three parts, each member
taking one part, as follows :
Part I: The early history of rail development up to the time the subject
was taken up by the American Society of Civil Engineers, together
with the questions of relative quality of earlier and later rails, and
foreign rail steel as compared with American, by Dr. P. H. Dudley.
Part II: The history of the connection of the American Society of Civil
Engineers with rail design and specifications, together with the ques
tions of lower carbon and heavier rail sections, by Dr. Thos. H.
Johnson.
Part III: The question of the improvement of rail design and specifica-
tions from the American Society of Civil Engineers' report in 1893
to the present time, together with a discussion on the subject of
fixed percentage of discard, by Mr. W. C. Gushing.
These papers were prepared in the very short time allotted, and read
before the Commission at its hearing on February 20, and are submitted
with this report.
in addition to the above, addresses were made, upon request of Chair-
man Wood, by Mr. F. A. Delano, Mr. E. J. Buffington. Dr. Benjamin
and Mr. R. Montfort, after which the hearing was adjourned until April 2.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE IV— ON RAIL.
Part I.
THE HISTORY, DEVELOPMENT AND USE OF RAILS BY RAIL-
ROAD COMPANIES OF THE UNITED STATES
FROM 1830 TO DATE.
BY P. H. DUDLEY.
The inception, projection and construction of 350,000 or more miles
of track and equipment in the United States, nearly one-half of that of
the world, by private enterprise, in the past eighty years, represent an
expenditure of energy and capital without parallel by older nations, and
express by deeds the abiding faith of the people in the growth, welfare
and stability of this great country.
Our railroads were installed to furnish the most efficient means of
inland transportation, to develop a new country of vast extent of territory.
great diversity of topographic features and climate, yet of limited accumu-
lation of capital, but rich in natural resources, to be converted by indus-
try into wealth.
The opening of the Stockton & Darlington Railway in England, Sep-
tember 27, 1825, by George .Stephenson's "Locomotion" having only a flue
boiler, therefore of limited steam generating capacity, indicated that
steam could replace horse power for railroad transportation, snd the re-
sult was received with great interest in this country.
This was followed by a charter for the Mohawk & Hudson Railroad in
1826. Several other lines were chartered in the United States, the Balti-
more & Ohio, the Delaware & Hudson Canal Company, the Camden &
Amboy and the Philadelphia & Columbia Division of the Pennsylvania
Railroad. The construction of the lines was commenced, and in 1830
there were 23 miles in operation. (See Table 1.)
The railroads at their inception were local affairs of few miles in
extent, and without previous experience in construction and operation
the tracks and equipment were of necessity only in the experimental stages
of development, and some tracks had not been constructed sufficiently
strong to demonstrate the possibilities of steam railroad transport.
The Delaware & Hudson Canal Company's Railroad was designed and
constructed for steam power, but when the locomotive "Stourbridge Lion,''
built in England, arrived in 1829 and made a short run it was found too
heavy for the track, and abandoned, a great disappointment to the advo-
cates of steam power.
Work was commenced upon the Mohawk & Hudson Railroad in 1830,
after Stephenson's "Rocket," with its multitubular boiler, at the trials at
Rainhill, England, October, 1829, had fulfilled the stipulation and won
the prize of five hundred pounds sterling, offered by the Liverpool &
843
844 RAIL.
Manchester Railway Company for the best engine, and the result gave a
world-wide impulse to steam railroad transportation.
The first ten miles of the Philadelphia & Columbia Railroad, strap
rails were laid upon stone sills, which were in continuous parallel lines.
The strap iron rails were fifteen feet long and were attached by small
spikes driven into cedar plugs in the stone sills. Seventy-one and six
tenths (71.6) miles were laid with rolled edge rails with chairs. The,
strap iron rails and wooden stringers were, however, generally employed
for the first railways, but did not form a smooth and substantial track
and by their frailty forced our civil and mechanical engineers to develop
the American type of locomotive and equipment. They were resourceful
men and brought up in the trying school of experience and they proved
equal to the great task.
It will be noticed from Table I that in 1840 only 2,818 miles had been
constructed. Nearly all of the first railroad companies were bankrupt and
passed into receivers' hands, owing to the great expense and cost of operat-
ing mi tracks which had been built as permanent structures to endure
for many years, hut were destroyed by the generated wheel effects of
three to four tons upon the drivers, and one and one-half to two tons on
the wheels of the ordinary rolling stock. All of the early strap iron rails
were imported from England or Wales, as rolling mills had not been
built in this country.
The strap iron rails were increased to one and one-half inches m
thickness and three inches in width, and between 1840 and 1850 so many
accidents occurred from their use that in New York State, in 1844, their
further employment was discontinued.
Robert Stevens, in 1830, for the Camden & Amboy Railroad designed a
"T" section of iron rail, nearly similar to those of the present type in
use. That is the only form of the early rail which has remained as a
survival of the fittest of the many different sections employed. Fear-
shaped iron rails were imported from England, and many of these, made
out of refined iron, lasted several years under the light wheel loads, but
when they increased to ten or twelve thousand pounds upon the drivers
the rails failed with great rapidity.
The mileage in 1800 had increased to 30,626 miles on iron rails. The
eight-wheeled passenger car was soon followed by the eight-wheeled
freight car, constituting, with the four-wheel front truck locomotive, dis-
tinct types of American equipment.
The physical properties of the iron were adequate only for the in-
stallation of the railroads, but proved inadequate when the driving wheel
loads reached ten and twelve thousand pounds, and when the speeds of
trains attained twenty-five and thirty miles per hour the iron rails broke
and laminated with such rapidity that the operations of the railroads
were conducted with great difficulty and expense.
Broken rails were so numerous in the sixties that the railroad offi-
cials tried the Booth steel-capped rail, which had a surface of about one-
RAIL. 845
quarter 04) in. of crucible steel rolled on to a stem of wrought iron,
hut the surfaces were not welded and did not last long in the track.
Bessemer's invention to make steel by blowing air for fifteen to
twenty minutes through molten iron of five or more tons in a converter
and burn out the three to four per cent, carbon of the cast-iron, and sub-
sequently recarburize it, giving it the percentage of carbon required for
the steel, was. after some failures, successful. The iron selected had to
be low in the impurities, phosphorus and sulphur, for none could be re-
duced in the acid-lined converter. The output of steel rails was large
compared to the output of iron rails.
Bessemer rails were rolled in England and tried by many of the
railroads, commencing about i860, and in 1863 a number of trial orders
were placed for similar rails in this country. The cost at the time of
one hundred to one hundred and twenty dollars per ton, in gold, to which
was added the premium of forty or more per cent, in our currency, forced
the railways to use as light a section as possible of the steel. Many of
the sections of 56 to 58 lbs. per yard, four inches in height with com-
paratively a thick base but thin heads, were imported and tried. The
steel rails in places of severe service would outlast ten to fifteen of the
best iron rails which could be secured. Bessemer steel works were in-
augurated in this country about 1866.
The sections were only four to four and one-quarter inches in height,
and the deflections of the rails under the passing wheel loads permitted
nearly the entire concentration of the wheel load on each cross-tie. The
rail sections were not stiff enough to distribute only a small part of the
load in the wheel spacing and while the cost of maintenance for track
work was high the loss of metal per yard was quite small. The light
sections did not permit the development of the wheel loads and enlarge-
ment of the locomotives and cars as much as was desired by the rail-
roads for the demands of transportation. The loss of metal per yard in
service proved to be so small that the consensus of opinion was general
that from the excellent wear of the thin-headed sections a residual sec-
tion might be designed of sufficient strength to carry the traffic and add
to the head the amount of metal desired for wear. The base of the
rails were made thinner and fifty per cent, or more of metal put into the
heads of the rails. These sections when rolled out of practically the
same chemical composition did not give the results of former sections,
owing to more massive heads and coarser structure of metal incident to
the greater heat units in the metal of the head to cool.
The change in this form of section was made by a committee of
Engineers in about 1870 and sections they recommended were in service
in 1874. The excellent results which they expected to obtain were not
secured in subsequent service and the increased demands of transporta-
tion for better and smoother rails that would reduce the generated wheel
effects of the moving trains was so important and there was such a
diversity of opinion in reference to the sections of rails that in 1878 I de-
signed my Track Indicator and constructed a car in which the measure
S4G RAIL.
ment;s of the undulations of the tracks could be made Passing over sev-
eral of the important lines, the New York Central & Hudson River Rail
road, the Boston & Albany Railroad, Philadelphia & Reading and Balti-
more & Ohio, it was found that rails in the track had characteristic per-
manent sets. These I could classify, and while the railroad companies
thought they could make their tracks as smooth as they desired by more
ballast and labor, it was shown by repeated inspection of the tracks that
while they might temporarily improve the surface of the track it did not'
remain but a short time before it was more or less out of surface.
One part of the mechanism of the apparatus summed the und'niatioris
in the rails under the special truck, into feet and inches per mile, by which
a comparison could be made of the different conditions of the track per
mile. It also recorded by large diagrams, on a scale of one inch of paper
to fifty feet of track, the actual vertical undulations and low joints in the
tracks. The conditions or smoothness of the steel was an important
factor, and also the stiffness of the rails.
This led to the design of the five (5) in. 80-lb. rail for the New York
Central & Hudson River Railroad in 1883, which was rolled and placed
in the tracks in 1884. By adding fifteen pounds to the ordinary 65-lb.,
four and one-half (4TA) in. rails, then used for the heaviest service, and
making an 80-lb. section, five (5) in. high, the actual stiffness of the sec-
tion was increased sixty-six per cent, over the ordinary 65-lb., four and
one-half in. rail.
There was a great difference of opinion as to what would be the
value of the increased stiffness for track purposes, the majority of opin-
ions being that the value obtained would not be equal to the increased
cost.
The section was rolled and placed in the tracks in July, 1884, and
demonstrated at once that the increased stiffness in the rail was of de-
cided advantage to the stability and capacity of the track, and raised the
standard of maintenance.
Several of the Eastern roads adopted either a five (5) in. 80-lb. sec-
tion or one of heavier weight, the Pennsylvania Railroad making a five
(5; in. 85-lb. section.
I made for the Boston & Albany Railroad a five (5) in. 95-lb. section
and rolled it out of 0.06 phosphorus and 0.65 carbon steel for their heavy
gradients and sharp curvature. They commenced to lay the rail in 1891
and completed the entire line in 1897.
I had stated on my condensed diagrams in 1883, for the Boston &
Albany Railroad, after I had designed the five (5) in. 80-lb. rail, and
before it was rolled, that it would be possible to reduce the undulations
per mile, as measured by my car, to two and one-half feet, or between
the fifteenth and sixteenth line on my condensed diagram, by similar stiff
sections. When the line was completed in 1897 and I had made the in-
spection, the average for the entire four hundred miles of track was
fifteen and forty-two hundredths on the condensed diagram.
RAIL SIT
In 1892 my six (6) in. 100-lb. rail was laid through the tunnel of the
Harlem Line. This gave a greater stability to the track than was possible
in sections with five and one-eighth (SJ/i) in. 80-lb. rails.
TONNAGE UPON DIFFERENT WEIGHTS OF RAILS.
The four and one-half-in. 65-lb. section of the New York Central &
Hudson River Railroad, in service eight and one-half years in the Fourth
Avenue Tunnel, carried 51,000,000 tons, with a loss of about one-quarter
of an inch in depth of the metal upon the head of the rail. This was
an English make of rail with a heavy base and thin head. The five-in.
80-lb. section which replaced this section was in service eight years and
carried 65,000,000 tons, with a loss of about one-eighth of an inch of metal
upon the head before it was removed. The six-in. 100-lb. New York
Central section, which was rolled in 1892, and replaced the five-in. 80-lb.
section, was removed in July, 1899, carried 95,000,000 tons, and is still
in yard service. The loss of metal on the top of the head of the rails,
in all the sections in the tunnel, was about twice as rapid as it was from
the same tonnage outside.
The six-in. 100-lb. section of rail in 1895 of 0.06 phosphorus and 0.65
in carbon on the "Inbound Main" from 1895 until August, 1907, carried
375,000,000 tons with a loss of about one-eighth of an inch in depth on
the head of the rail.
The light earlier sections could carry from 60,000,000 to 75,000,000 tons
before they were rough and unsuitable for passenger traffic, and when
in a location where the tonnage was only 250,000 to 500,000 tons per
month, would last in the track many years. The heavier sections which
replaced the light ones carried much greater tonnages from the increase
in the density of traffic. Their larger area of metal also gave them a
capacity for greater tonnages.
The 100-lb. rails in the Fourth Avenue Tunnel at the present time
carry daily from one hundred and fifty to two hundred train movements.
The tonnage per month is in some places nearly as much as the light rails
were subjected to in one or two years' service.
Table 1 shows the increase in freight ton miles from 1890 to 1900,
nearly doubled, while it trebled for 1910.
It has often been stated that the reason why the former rails seem
to last so well was due to the elimination of the poorer ciuality of rails
by the service in the track. This statement is not the complete explana-
tion. The older rails were cold rolled by the light wheel loads until the
surface was sufficiently hardened to bear the recent heavier loads without
much increased abrasion. New rails of the same section and practically
the same physical properties would, when subjected to heavier wheel
loads, lose more of the metal by wear, before the surface was rolled as
hard as the former sections, and their rate would be much faster.
It is not considered advisable at the present time to make the com-
position of the rails which are to be subjected to the present heavy wheel
loads so hard that at first they will entirely resist the cold rolling effect
848 RAIL.
of the passing wheels. It is better to make the physical properties oi
the rails such that a slight flow of the metal will take place under the
various worn wheel treads which will run over the rails, and in this way
the surface will accommodate itself to the average treads passing over
the heads, the surface becoming gradually hard, and in a short time the
flow is practically arrested.
In rails which are too soft the surface may be worn away by the wheel
loads before it becomes sufficiently hardened for the long wear, or the driy-.
ers slip on the rails, producing a layer so hard as to require their removal
from the track.
Table i also shows another important matter. The mileage shown
for 1830 to 1850 had been constructed mostly with strap iron rails. The
mileage 1850 to 1870 was mostly iron rails, though about one-fifth was
steel rails. The mileage for 1880 was more than one-half of it laid with
steel rails, while that shown for 1890, 1900 and 1910, the mileage would
be mostly steel. It would have been impossible to have constructed the
mileage shown for 1910 without the invention of Bessemer steel. We
have in the United States about 40,000,000 tons of steel in the track,
of which 2,500,000 tons are of basic open hearth steel.
The possibility of developing the railroad mileage of the world has
been due to a great extent to the study given in all countries to the
manufacture of the steel rails. I was a delegate to the International
Railway Congress, London, 1895, and Reporter for the United States on
the "Nature of Metal for Rails," Sixth Session of the Congress at Paris,
1900. I was also Reporter for America at the Seventh Session of the
Congress at Washington, D. C, 1905, on "Rails for Fast Lines," and also
a Delegate to the International Congress, Eighth Session, at Berne, 191c.
Collecting information for the United States railroads, and being famil-
iar with the practice in England, Germany, France, Belgium and Switzer-
land, where the wheel loads are much lighter than in the United States,
has given me an opportunity to study the comparative tracks in reference
to the rail sections and composition in the various countries.
Basic Bessemer steel and Basic open hearth steels are used abroad
in Germany, England, also in Africa, and the different delegates stated
that the wear on the rails under their light wheel loads, particularly on
the curves, was much more rapid than was desired. The temperatures
in those countries do not fall as low as they do in our Northern states and
Canada. They use higher carbon rails in France as a rule than we do
in this country, with excellent effect. Their wheel loads are also much
lighter and they maintain their rotundity for a longer period than the
wheels here, under our heavier wheel loads and long distance runs.
One of the problems confronting the railroads to-day, in those states
where the temperatures fall to 20 and 40 degrees below zero, is to secure
a sufficiently homogeneous metal in the 33 and 36-in. wheels for the entire
circumference of the tire or wheel tread to maintain its rotundity. The
36-in. wheels make 560.2 revolutions per mile, and with their static load of
five tons, the accumulated tonnage upon the tread of the tire or wheel would
RAIL. 849
be 2,8o'i tons for each mile run. The tonnage for the run FrOih New
YOrfc to Chicago would he 2./00,oco Ions, from Boston to Chicago, 2,800, •
000 tons and from New York to St. Louis 3,200,000 tons.
The locomotive drivers of 79 in. in diameter make 255.3 revolutions
pei* mile. The Pacific type engines have static loads of 14.3 tons per
driver, consequently the static load per mile run upon the metal is t,,<)5\
tons. These figures are sufficient to show that their tonnage upon each
portion of the bearing surface on the tread repeats the load for each revo-
lution and for high speed trains with great rapidity, consequently the
accumulated tonnage on the tires and wheels enlarges according to the
distance run.
THE EFFECT OF COI.D ON KAILS IN A PERMANENT WAV.
First, the direct one which affects the metal, decreasing its ductility but
increasing its tensile strength, elastic limits and modulus of elasticity to a
slight extent and making it more sensitive to shocks.
Second, indirect effect by contraction of the metal which may set up
the tensile stresses of some magnitude in the rails before the ends render
in the splice bars. The intensity of this effect on the rails is greater in
countries subject to low temperatures near or below zero, and subject to
cold waves from the North, where the temperatures fall many degree;
below zero, or fall in a short time and continue cold for a few days until
broken by a warm wave from a tropical climate.
The experience of the railroad? in the Northern and Western states
this winter is more severe than ever before experienced. The effects have
been so great that rails which have heretofore been quite free from break-
ages have been rendered more susceptible to the wheel effects of the
passing trains and a larger number broken than ever before reported.
Such conditions have been studied quite extensively for the purpose to
render the rails more ductile or of greater tenacity and toughness to
withstand the shock of passing wheels in temperatures of from 20 to
40 degrees below zero.
The service tests of rails of large ductility or tenacity and tough
ness of metal in large tonnages, scattered in many states, show during the
past winter an almost entire freedom from breakages and indicate that
much has already been accomplished. It is now possible from a definite
chemical composition to determine what ductility or toughness may be
secured when the steel is properly purified in the bath, and thus increase
the factor of safety in the output of the rails.
To most Engineers of Maintenance of Way who are not conversant
fully with the actual steps of the different processes of manufacture it
seems that a specification for chemical composition and a few subsequent
tests for quality would be sufficient to secure rails to withstand the pres-
ent service. This is by 110 means the case, for it is only by a knowledge
of the manufacture of the steel and its subsequent use in the track that
one obtains the requisite knowledge to provide for the various conditions
of service to which rails are subjected.
S50
KAIL.
It is the duty of users of rail to advise the manufacturers of the type
and as far as possible the cause of failures and breakages of rails in the
tracks.
The gathering of statistics of rail failures of the past few years
and discussing them with the manufacturers has resulted in a co-opera-
tion to improve the quality of the output.
I was present on the 15th instant at a conference of the Presidents
and Rail Manufacturers, in New York, in which the subject was thor-
oughly discussed. The Presidents from the Northern and Western States'
stated that they had experienced lower temperatures and for a longer
period to that date than had previously occurred in all their experience in
railroading. The Eastern roads have experienced the effects of these low
temperatures for a number of years and found it necessary to make some
preparation for them.
I have been making a series of observations and tests for some years
in anticipation of severe climatic conditions, and the recent results seem
promising. It has been, however, necessary to develop the manufacture
of the steel to the highest state of the art and subject the product to severe
tests in the track to see what has been accomplished.
The results so far indicate that decided progress has been made. This
has come from a large experience in dealing with tenacity and toughness
in rail steels for the past two decades. The results of this work have
been carefully studied for the benefit of our service.
Should it seem advisable to supply some illustrations of the early sec-
tions to show what work has been required to develop a suitable section
for the present railroad service, it would be a pleasure to supply them.
It must be remembered that with the present wheel loads and high
speeds of the train movements, the time factor for reversal of the stresses
under the wheels and in the wheel spacing has been materially shortened
by the present schedules.
The wheel loads also require stresses of large magnitude to be dis-
tributed in a shorter time than was necessary with slower speeds and
lesser wheel loads.
The question of recent sections will be treated more in detail by Mr,
Johnson in Part II, and specifications by Mr. dishing in Part III.
1830
1840
1850
1860 1870
1880
1890
1900
1910
Miles of lines operated
exclusive of side
tracks, yards and ter
23
2,818
9,1)21
30,62f) 52.922
93,296
163,597
199,875
76,207,047
11,847,785
1,265,880
19,288,301
192,556
258,784
141,599,159
16,039,007
2,023,702
37,210,720
239,652
349,159
255,528,643
Passengers one mile,
Locomotive weights
without tenders (tons 1
Freight cars — total <•;•-
-
33,949,936
4,271,000
74,043,000
Part II.
STEEL RAILS.
INVESTIGATIONS BY THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CIVIL ENGINEERS.
BY THOS. H. JOHNSON.
The first action taken by an organized body of engineers in relation
to the character and quality of the rails used on the railroads of this
country was had by the American Society of Civil Engineers in 1874, in
the appointment of a Committee to investigate and report on "The Form.
Weight, Manufacture and Life of Rails."
This Committee made a progress report in June, 1874, again in May.
1875, and a final report in June, 1876.
At these dates the use of steel rails was in its infancy, and compara-
tively few had been laid on American railroads. Such as had been laid
had been down too short a time to warrant the Committee in drawing
conclusions in regard to them; hence, the reports of this Committee
dealt almost exclusively with iron rails, with only incidental reference to
the use of steel, and therefore they have no bearing on the questions
now before us.
Steel rails first appeared as an established commodity in the market
reports in 1868. From the first they rapidly began to displace the old
iron rails, and in 1882 the latter had ceased to appear as a market com-
modity.
Sections.
During the first fifty years of railroad development many different
sections had come into use, and there was no common standard. In
1887 the American Society of Civil Engineers again appointed a Commit-
tee, this time charged to consider "the proper relation to each other of the
sections of rails and wheels." This Committee made a progress report in
1888, and a final report in 1889, and in the following year, 1850, following
the subject still further, another Committee was appointed to prepare and
submit to the Society a series of '"Standard Sections," for rails of different
weights per yard.
The Committee made a preliminary report in 1891, and a final report
in 1893. This latter report was accompanied by a series of sections for
rails, weighing from 40 lbs. to 100 lbs. per yard, varying by intervals of
5 lbs. These sections were approved by the Society, and promulgated as
the "A.S.C.E. Standard Sections."
They met with favor and were adopted by many railroads, so that in
a very few years about two-thirds of the output of the rail mills con-
formed to those sections.
851
852 RAIL.
Specifications.
As might be expected, with the engineers of the country acting inde-
pendently, with imperfect understanding as to the effect on the finished
product of different elements in different proportions, accented by more
or less variation in the process, as practiced at different mills, a large
number of specifications came into existence, differing in their require-
ments as to chemistry and physical requirements.
The oldest specification now before the writer bears date 1876, and
makes no mention of the chemistry. It required a tensile test from each -
heat, the test piece to be cut from the head of the rail.
The next issue of the same specification, 1879, requires that the car-
bon shall be between 0.30 and 0.50 per cent., but it is silent as to other
elements. In later issues, manganese and phosphorus were added, and
still later silicon.
This is probably typical of the process of development of rail specifi-
cations generally, but, as already stated, the resulting specifications dif-
fered from each other in many respects.
With the growing prosperity of the country, there was an increas-
ing demand on the transportation facilities, which led to a gradual in-
crease in the weights of rolling stock. This was met by the engineers
by correspondingly increasing the strength of the rails. But it was soon
found that the larger sections wore out faster on curves than the smaller
sections had done. This was due to the fact the larger sections cooled
more slowly and underwent a partial annealing rendering the metal softer
and less resistant to the grinding action of the flanges against the side
of the head. Some engineers sought to remedy this by specifying an
increased proportion of carbon, varying with the size of the section. This
added still further to the diversity of the specifications.
Part III.
THE QUESTION OF THE IMPROVEMENT OF RAIL DESIGN
AND SPECIFICATIONS, FROM 1893 TO THE PRESENT TIME.
BY W. C. CUSHING.
The period between 1893, the year of the adoption of the standard rail
sections of the American Society of Civil Engineers, and the First An-
nual Convention of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance
of Way Association in 1900, was occupied by the railway engineers in the
study of the behavior in the track of the rails rolled according to the new
designs, which were rapidly put into service by the different railroads
of the country.
A preliminary meeting of the railway engineers was held in Chicago
on October 21, 1898, for the purpose of organizing the American Railway
Engineering and Maintenance of Way Association, and at that meeting a
committee was appointed to draft the Constitution and By-Laws.
On March 30, 1899, the permanent organization of the Association
was effected in Buffalo, by the adoption of the Constitution and the elec-
tion of officers.
As stated in the Constitution, the object of the Association was the
advancement of knowledge pertaining to the scientific and economic
location, construction, operation and maintenance of railroads, and the
means to be employed for this purpose were to be :
(1) Meetings for the reading and discussion of papers, and social
intercourse.
(2) The investigation of matters pertaining to the objects of the
Association, through Standing and Special Committees.
(3) The publication of papers, reports and discussions.
The real and final object was, however, for the members to ex-
change information and experience with each other and to bring about the
unification, as much as possible, of specifications for the purchase of the
large amount of material and supplies used by railroads, which ought to
result in the mutual benefit of the manufacturers and the railway com-
panies.
In order to hear the first reports of Standing Committees, the first
convention was held in March, 1900, in Chicago, and among the Standing
Committees was one on Rail.
The report of the Committee was largely historical, but it was de-
veloped at that and subsequent meetings that the subject was going to be
853
854 RAIL.
one of the most important and most interesting of those to come before
the Association in the future, and in closing the discussion, the President
said :
"Of course, we realize that we do not expect to exhaust the subject
at this meeting, or in the next, or in our lifetime, but we are simply
laying the foundation now for our future work, and I presume at the
next meeting the Committee will not be still 'fuller' than they are now.
but that there will be more of them present and that they will continue
the consideration of this matter."
The work of the Committee of the American Society of Civil Engi-
neers was undertaken with the object of improving the design or cross-
section of rails, and did not undertake the preparation of specifications for
their manufacture or inspection, but each railway company issued its own
specifications, which were not specifications for manufacture, but for in-
spection. These specifications differed from each other in various de-
tails, such as the method of testing, the allowable variations from the
templates, the smoothness of the surface and the workmanship generally,
while but little was said about the chemical composition. Indeed, this
state of affairs must have been quite annoying and expensive to the rad
manufacturers, and, as all railroads were striving for exactly the same
object, viz., to obtain the best material which would make an absolutely
safe steel rail, the unification of the specifications seemed to be very de-
sirable, and if it could be brought about, the existence of the Association
would be entirely justified.
At the Annual Convention in 1901, it was ascertained that the rail
sections or designs of the American Society of Civil Engineers were in
use by about 70 per cent, of the railroads of the country, and it soon de-
veloped in the discussion that the rail steel in use by the railroads was not
giving very good satisfaction. This dissatisfaction pertained to all sections
of rails, and the railway engineers thought that the trouble was largely
due to the temperature of rolling being entirely too high, leading to the
expression of one member that "the material was squirted through the
rolls." The engineers of the rail manufacturers, who were also members
of the Association, contended, on the other hand, that the fault was due
to the rail sections, and especially to the thin base designs of the Ameri-
can Society of Civil Engineers. It thus developed that the railway engi-
neers believed the trouble was entirely due to improper processes of manu-
facture, while the rail manufacturers' engineers placed the fault on the
design of the rail cross-section.
It was apparent, therefore, that the committee must study both the
question of design and the question of rail manufacture, the latter with the
special object of devising tests and methods of inspection which would
more surely determine whether the material came up to the requirements
of service or not. It was quite evident that this work would be of long
RAIL. 855
duration, because it was necessary that more study than ever before should
be placed upon both the question of rail design and its manufacture, and
it would be necessary to proceed slowly and carefully, in order to avoid
the misinterpretation of statistics and information. Sir Lowthian Bell
is reported to have said, at the London meeting of the American Society
of Civil Engineers, in 1900, that "As he had been 25 years a manufacturer
of rails and 25 years a director in the North Eastern Railway, he repre-
sented both maker and user, and he had at his disposal 3S,coo analyses
to go upon in making deductions. From these he could prove and dis-
prove everything that could be said for or against any composition of a
rail — a facility beloved by the expert."' It is well for any investigator not
to forget Sir Lowthian Bell's remark. It has been brought home to the
Rail Committee many times in its prolonged investigation.
Prior to this time, so much had been said by railway engineers about
the necessity for rolling at lower temperature that, in 1900, the Kennedy-
Morrison process of holding rails just before the final passes until they
came to the desired temperature, after which they were put through the
final passes at that temperature, was introduced by the Carnegie Steel
Company, and great expectations of the value of the results were held.
At the same time other rail manufacturers began rolling at lower temper-
ature and claimed to accomplish the same results. The process did not,
however, give the results expected, as the effect was only skin deep, for
when the skin wore off, the ordinary metal was exposed underneath.
The rails rolled after its introduction developed rather more failures than
usual, and since that time the value of rolling at low temperature has been
rather uncertain. This experience is mentioned to show that the value of
many changes in process of manufacture can only be developed after long
experience, which is one of the reasons why an investigation of this kind
is bound to cover a long period of time.
In 1895. at Zurich, Switzerland, the International Association foi-
Testing Materials was organized to bring about "the development and
unification of standard methods of testing, for the determination of the
properties of materials of construction, and of other materials, and also
the perfection of apparatus for that purpose." On June 16, 1898, or but a
few months prior to the organization of the American Railway Engineer-
ing and Maintenance of Way Association, there was formed, at Philadel-
phia, the American section of the International Association, which, a few
years later, was renamed "The American Society for Testing Materials."
The American section was composed of manufacturers as well as of con-
sulting engineers, railway engineers, and others, and had already begun
the study of rail specifications. Therefore, at its Annual Convention in
1901 the Rail Committee of the American Railway Engineering Associa-
tion submitted the rail specifications recommended by the American
Branch of the International Association for discussion, in order to get
the subject under way.
Specifications for steel rails have always consisted of three general
parts :
856
RAIL.
(i) Chemical requirements or properties;
(2) Physical requirements; and
(3) Details of manufacture.
Up to that time the various railway companies emphasized one or
mure of these parts, according to their individual preference or experience.
Some almost ignored the chemical requirements, others were more or less
elaborate in their physical requirements, while some barely touched upon
details of manufacture, and others treated the subject quite elaborately.
Chemical Requirements or Properties.
The chemical properties of these proposed specifications for Bessemer
steel rails were those of the Carnegie Steel Company, and they arc to-
day the standard chemical specifications of all the steel rail manufacturers.
and of the American Society for Testing Materials, with scarcely any
alterations. They were as follows:
50-60 lbs.
60-70 lbs. 70-80 lbs.
80-90 lbs.
90-100 lbs.
.38 to .48 .40 to . 50
.10 .1(1
. 20 . 20
.70-1.00 ,75-1.05
.43 to .53
.10
.20
.80-1.10
.45 to .55
.10
.20
Manganese 70-1 . 00
.80-1.10
The specifications for foreign use were practically the same.
The only changes which have been made in these specifications by
the steel manufacturers and by the American Society for Testing Mate-
rials up to the present time are to make the carbon for 60 to 70-lb. rail .3?
to .45, and the manganese for 90 to 100-lb. rail .84 to 1.14.
With few exceptions, the railroads of the United States have accepted
these chemical constituents as recommended by the rail manufacturers,
because they have considered that the chemical properties were only a
minor part of the specifications for rail steel, compared with the physical
requirements.
To show that the railway engineers have been justified in taking
this view of the matter, the following quotation is made from an artick
in the Journal of the Franklin Institute for [889, by Capt. R. W. Hunt,
once a manufacturer of steel rails and now a steel rail inspector of wide
experience :
"Rails made by John Brown & Co. of England, and put down on
American railroads some years ago. have been generally held up as ideal
rails, and the American makers for a long time supposed that when these
rails did wear out so that they could lie analyzed the secret of their good
service would be told. As an illustration of how little regularity or purity
of chemical composition influenced the wear, 1 call your attention to the
analyses of thirteen of John Brown rails, all of which had filled years of
faithful service and have been selected as bright examples of what good
rails should be :
RAIL.
857
C.
Si.
Ph.
S.
Mn.
Cu.
1
0.35
0.39
0.36
0.70
0.36
0.44
(1 45
0.30
0.24
0.37
0.32
0.35
0.28
0.08
0.071
0.103
0.306
0.069
0.208
() 102
0.087
0 068
0.051
0.089
0.069
0.032
0.128
0.156
0.125
0.111
0.153
0.098
0.128
0.148
0.131
0.096
0.145
0.077
0.084
0.068
0.155
0.060
0.008
0.131
0.059
0.105
0.181
0.104
0.050
0.077
0.099
0.053
0.742
0.662
0.815
0.681
0.621
1.046
0.616
0.625
0.645
0.639
0.745
0.945
0 312
0 048
2
3
4
5
6
0.32
Trace
0.016
0.143
7
8
0.056
9
0 005
10
11
12
Trace
Trace
13.
"You will observe that carbon ranged from 0.24 to 0.70; silicon from
0.032 to 0.306; phosphorus from 0.077 to 0.156; sulphur from 0.050 to
0.155, an(J manganese from 0.312 to 1.046.
"These 13 rails, taken as a whole, were chemically a 'poor lot,' but
physically most excellent."
Physical Properties.
Two general methods for testing the physical requirements had been
in use up to the year 1900, viz., a bending test of a small bar lA in. to
•)4 in. square and 10 in. to 20 in. long, and a drop test, which consisted
in letting fall a weight of about 2, coo lbs. on a piece of rail with a span
of 3 to 4 feet. Some railways used one method, some the other and some
both, but by iqco the small bar test had been generally abandoned in
favor of the drop test.
It was customary to make a test of every fifth heat of steel, and to
let the weight fall from varying heights, according to the pleasure of the
maker of the specifications. The proposed specifications of the American
branch retained this method of testing the physical properties by dropping
the weight of 2,000 lbs. on every fifth heat of steel, from a height of 16
ft. for rail weighing 55 to 65 lbs. per yard, 17 ft. for rail weighing 65 ro
75 lbs. per yard, 18 ft. for rail weighing 75 to 85 lbs. per yard, and 19 ft.
the rail weighing 85 to 100 lbs. per yard, but these conditions were not
accepted by the American Railway Engineering Association, as there was
a strong feeling among the railway enginers that more severe condi-
tions of testing were necessary. They felt that the chemical properties
could be left to the greater experience and chemical knowledge of the
rail manufacturers, but that they must be the ones to prescribe the physi-
cal tests which the finished rails must ^and in order to be accepted for
such important service as carrying the railway traffic of the country. In
1904, therefore, the Engineering Association decided that each heat, instead
of every -fifth heat of steel, must be tested, and that the height of the
drop should be increased.
It was also ascertained that the rail butts heretofore tested under
the falling weight had been from the bottom of the ingot, and it was now
made a part of the specifications that the test piece should be taken from
858 RAIL.
the top of the ingot, on account of the probability that the metal would
be less perfect at that end.
Testing every heat instead of every fifth heat, as formerly, was con-
sidered little short of a revolution in the method of testing at that time.
Details of Manufacture.
Except in the case of a few companies, the specifications in regard
to details of manufacture were not elaborate, the specifications being con-
fined almost entirely to allowing for variations from the standard tem-
plate and from the length of the rail, to smoothness and perfection of
finish, to branding, etc.
In view of the agitation for colder rolling, the Pennsylvania Railroad
had introduced into its specifications in iqoo a clause requiring that the
rail at the last pass should be at a red heat, preferably a dull red, but in
iooi they replaced it with a so-called "Shrinkage Clause," which was in-
tended to control the temperature of the rail when being finished, by pre-
scribing that the shrinkage, after the rail was sawed, should not exceed
a certain number of inches. This clause was also introduced into the pro-
posed specifications of the Engineering Association, making an additional
requirement in the details of manufacture.
Lately there has been a great deal of argument on the part of the
rail manufacturers to have the railway engineers specify a definite per-
centage of discard from the ingot, in order to cut off material which is
more subject to segregation and more liable to have interior defects from
the shrinkage cavity, gas bubbles, etc., but the railway engineers have-
rigidly set their faces against such a requirement, because they feel that
they are much better safeguarded by the clause introduced into the specifi-
cations of the American branch of the International Association of Test-
ing Materials, which was that "sufficient material should be discarded
from the top of the ingots to insure sound rails."
When that clause was adopted, in 1901, and for a number of years
afterwards, the positions of the rail manufacturers and the railway engi-
neers were reversed, the railway engineers believing that it was best to
specify a definite amount of discard, while the rail manufacturers took the
opposite view. It was well expressed by an engineer of one of the steel
companies, who said : "I do not think this Association, nor any other,
should state definitely how much should be sheared from the bloom.
The matter is entirely one-sided. If we agree here that 25 per cent, shall
be sheared from the bloom, we might assume that would settle it, but it
will not. The Association will be perfectly safe in making the claim that
sufficient shearing will be done to eliminate piping. If the manufactur-
ers can remove the piping by shearing 15 per cent., they will not agree to
shear 25 per cent. The object in shearing is to get rid of the piping, and
the only matter of agreement will be to reach the point where sufficient
shearing is done to remove the piping. For that reason, I think the As-
sociation will make a mistake I" demand that 25 per cent, be sheared off."
The railway engineers of to-day unanimously agree with that point
of view, and their positon has been further strengthened by an additional
KAIL. s:'!l
test, which will be described later. Furthermore, the records of rail
failures which have been kept for a number of years disclose the incon-
trovertible fact that, where a 15 per cent, discard might do for one ingot,
50 per cent, would not be adequate for another.
In 1902, the American Society of Civil Engineers deemed it advis-
able, in view of the continual criticism of the sections of rail which they
had previously designed, to take up once more the study both of rail de-
sign and specifications, and accordingly a committee was appointed for the
purpose.
The Committee of the American Society for Testing Materials also
continued its study of the rail question, and joint meetings of all three
committees were held so that each would derive benefit from the work of
the other.
On April 25, 1906, the Committee on Standard Rail and Wheel Sec-
tions was appointed by the American Railway Association, and on Octo-
ber 24, 1906, the Committee was directed to report in addition on the sub-
ject of specifications for the manufacture of steel rails, in connection
with its report on standard sections. The rail manufacturers were asked
to co-operate with the committee by sending representatives to study the
question with it at its meetings, and in addition the committee employed
disinterested men of national reputation in their knowledge of steel mak-
ing and the properties of steel, to give expert advice on the subject. After
many meetings together a report was submitted, October 30, 1907, con-
taining the recommended rail sections and specifications, both for Bes-
semer and Open Hearth steel.
Further advice was obtained from disinterested persons who had a
wide knowledge of the properties of steel and its manufacture, and final
report was submitted by the committee on April 22, 1908, with the rec-
ommendation that there were many details of the development and the
following up of the results in service of the new types of section, rolled
under the new specifications, which would require considerable time and
much careful study, and that they could be more efficiently and more
appropriately handled by the American Railway Engineering Association.
The sections and specifications were, therefore, referred to the American
Railway Engineering Association, with the request that they, follow up the
question in its various details and keep a careful record of the results,
with a view to determining whether any changes should be made, either
in the specifications or designs.
As the question of discard was dealt with in these reports quite fully,
it is advisable to make quotations therefrom, because the earnest consid-
eration given to the question led to the development of an additional
test, which is considered of great importance in determining the quality
of metal by eliminating a large number of the so-called "piped rails," or
rails with interior defects :
"In the matter of discard, there was a desire on the part of the rail-
road members to arrange for a greater discard, and a strong disposition to
insist upon a uniform minimum percentage. The manufacturers, how-
860 RAIL.
ever, presented considerable evidence which tended to show that a fixed
minimum percentage requirement would be not only unfair but unscien-
tific, claiming that the extent of piping and segregation is influenced by
the size of the ingot, the rate of pouring into the mould, and other details
of mill practice
"With regard to the discard question, the Committee has always been
of the opinion that it would be preferable to test the finished product
rather than specify as to details of mill manufacture
"In pursuing its investigation of this discard question, the Commit-
tee received a suggestion from Mr. Win. Metcalf to the effect that it
would be reasonably practicable to apply the above theory to the manu-
facture of rails by arranging to test to destruction a number of rail butts
representing a certain portion of the total output, and to base rejections
on the results of these tests
"In order to avoid the unnecessary waste of good material, the Com-
mittee set about to devise means by which the rejection of defective ma-
terial could be insured without requiring an arbitrary and definite per-
centage of discard in every case, and a Committee of the Pennsylvania
Railroad System pursuing the same line of investigation had adopted a
tentative specification which provided for a physical test of this nature,
and which further provided that when physical defects were discovered ail
top rails of the heat should be rejected. This would result in a discard
of about 25 per cent, to 30 per cent, of the entire metal in the heat when-
ever physical defects were discovered, and it was felt that a requirement
of this nature would not only provide for the rejection of defective mate-
rial, but would insure the greatest care on the part of the manufacturer.
"A trial lot of the rails of a section corresponding to Type 'B' was
recently rolled under these specifications as to discard, and the results con-
vinced the Committee that a development of this idea would prove the
best solution of the discard problem."
In connection with the Details of Manufacture, an important addi-
tion was made by requiring that the brand on the rail should also con-
tain a letter marking the position which the rail originally occupied in
the ingot, so as to enable a study to be made of the effect of that position.
On June 5, 1907, a committee of the Civil and Mechanical Engineers
of the. Pennsylvania Railroad System and two rail manufacturers was
appointed to take up the study of the rail question, and design new rail
sections and recommend new specifications, with the object of improv-
ing the quality of the material used in rails manufactured for that System.
The first meeting was held on June 12, 1907, and the new rail designs,
known as the "P. S." sections, were adopted on September 20, 1907. Ten-
tative specifications were recommended on November 15, 1907, and 10,000
tons of rail rolled in accordance therewith. They were subsequently
modified, on criticism of the manufacturers, and issued February 4, 1508.
The new rail designs of the Pennsylvania Railroad System and the
American Railway Association provided for a more even distribution of
the metal in the head, web and base, and for a thicker base, to meet the
RAIL. 861
views of the rail manufacturers, who believed that a better distribution
of the metal would result in an improved quality, due to more favorable
rolling conditions. All of these sections are still in service and are being
closely watched to determine whether the expected improvement will be
realized.
The Pennsylvania Railroad System specifications have been modified
several times, in the light of additional experience, and contain the im-
provements which have been brought about from time to time through
the experiences and researches of its own committee and the commit-
tees of the other associations.
So far as the chemical requirements are concerned, they are prac-
tically the same as adopted by the Rail Manufacturers, and other associa-
tions.
The Physical Requirements are determined by the Drop Test with the
standard machine, and, in addition, the test piece is nicked and broken to
reveal the presence or absence of interior defect.
In the Details of Manufacture, the discard is required to be sufficient
to secure sound rails, and the shrinkage clause to regulate the tempera-
ture of rolling is retained. The rails are marked for position in the
ingot, for the purpose of subsequent identification, in order to study the
effect of that position.
Similar studies and investigations are being conducted by the New
York Central Lines, the Harriman Lines, Baltimore & Ohio Railroad.
Norfolk & Western Railway, Lehigh Valley Railroad, Reading Railway
and other companies, and the specifications are being improved as new
knowledge is obtained. The first named company has been foremost in
the study of the effect of Titanium in steel making.
Through the assignment of the rail question to the American Rail-
way Engineering Association by the American Railway Association, the
work of the Committee was given an official character, and its real work
commenced. The first thing of importance accomplished was the intro-
duction of a standard drop testing machine at all the rail mills, so that the
results obtained at any one mill were comparable with those obtained at
any other. Up to that time, 1908, machines of different design and set-
ting were used, and the results were unreliable. With the year 1909 began
the collection of a large amount of information, obtained from research
work, bearing on the disputed points of rail manufacture, and on prov-
ing or testing.
In 1910, the specifications for Bessemer rail formerly adopted by the
American Railway Engineering Association were withdrawn, and new
ones, for both Bessemer and Open Hearth, were presented for considera-
tion by the Association, which embodied all the improvements in the
methods of determining the physical properties and the details of manu-
facture which had been brought forward up to that time. It was recog-
nized, however, that numerous disputed points could only he cleared up
by experimental research conducted by a trained engineer physicist, and
accordingly such an investigator was added to the Committee to devote all
862 RAIL.
his time to that work. The Engineer of Tests, M. H. Wickhorst, since
his appointment, has heen constantly busy with research work, and has
added a great deal to our knowledge of the subject.
He has made reports on the following subjects:
Influence of Carbon on Deflection.
Drop, Bending and Tensile Tests on Bessemer, Titanium Bessemer,
and Open-Hearth Rails, rolled by different mills, including chemical an-
alyses and etched sections.
Investigation of a Split Head Rail. ..
Segregation, as Influenced by Fire Clay on Ingot.
Strength of Rail Head.
Drop Tests of Rails — Effect of Impact Energy variously distributed.
Flow of Rail Heads under Wheel Loads.
Segregation and other Rail Properties as influenced by Size of Ingot
Tests of Steel Rail Ingots and derivative shapes made at Watertown
Arsenal.
Influence of Rolling Temperature on the Properties of Bessemer
Rails.
In all of this work, Mr. Wickhorst has been afforded every facility by
the rail manufacturers for carrying on the investigations, and their ma-
chinery, material and laboratory assistants have been placed at his dis-
posal. In addition, their officers have been freely consulted by the Com-
mittee, and have attended some of its meetings.
While at the present time the American Railway Engineering Associa-
tion has not adopted standard specifications for rails, yet it has had con-
stantly before it for consideration and study a set of proposed specifica-
tions which have embodied the best knowledge of the subject, and they
have been changed from time to time in the light of new experimental
investigation. The most energy has been devoted to the improvement of
methods of testing to determine the physical properties, and practically no
changes have been made in the chemical requirements from the standard
specifications of the rail manufacturers. The railway engineers prefer to
subject the finished material to such tests as will cast aside the defective
rails. Their specifications, therefore, include many additional tests over
those in use ten years ago. The results of the work of the American
Railway Engineering Association have been closely followed by the Rail-
way Companies and vice versa, so that the specifications of the Railway
Companies have been improved from time to time, and now embody the
additional tests devised. Rails have been rolled in accordance with these
new specifications for several years, and it is believed that a marked
improvement is apparent in the rails being laid in the tracks since their
adoption.
February, 1912.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XVII— ON WOOD
PRESERVATION.
Eakl Sixmson, Chairman; E. H. Bowser, Vice-Chair man;
G. M. Davidson. E. A. Sterling.
If. B. Dick. C. M. Taylor.
\V. W. Drinker. Dr. H. von Schkenk.
Dr. W. K. Hatt. Charles Yoder.
V. K. Hendricks. C. E. Knickerbocker.
George E. Rex. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
The Board of Direction assigned to your Committee the following
subjects :
(i) Continue investigation of the proper grouping of the different
timbers for antiseptic treatment.
(2) Compile available information from service tests.
(3) Investigate the merits of various preservatives, giving special
attention to oil from water as tar and to the use of refined coal-tar in
creosote oil.
(4) Report on the advisability of revising the adopted specifications
for creosote oil.
(5) Recommend forms for the inspection of preservative processes.
(6) Present specifications for impregnation with creosote oil.
(7) Report on the value of impregnation with crude oil.
(8) Report on the value of brush coating and dipping.
A Sub-Committee was assigned to the consideration of each one of
these subjects.
Two meetings of the Committee were held at the Association rooms,
Chicago; one on October 11, 1911, those present being Earl Stimson.
Chairman ; E. H. Bowser, Vice-Chairman ; H. B. Dick, Dr. W. K. Hatt,
V. K. Hendricks, George E. Rex, E. A. Sterling, C. M. Taylor, Dr. H. von
Schrenk, C. E. Knickerbocker; the other meeting on December 7, iqii,
those present being Earl Stimson, Chairman ; E. H. Bowser, Vice-Chair-
man : V. K. Hendricks>, G. M. Davidson, Dr. W. K. Hatt, H. B. Dick,
E. A. Sterling, C. M. Taylor.
(1) GROUPING OF TIMBERS FOR ANTTSEPTTC TREATMENT.
The Sub-Committee on Grouping was instructed to continue the
investigations of the proper grouping of timbers for antiseptic treatment.
Last year arrangements were made for a series of co-operative experi-
ments at several plants to determine the best method of grouping various
863
864 WOOD PRESERVATION.
species in different regions. These tests have not been completed, but
scmie progress has been made, the results of which' are submitted as
Appendix "A" to this report. During the coming year additional experi«
mental work will be done at several plants. This work will be system-
atized, so that uniform results will be obtained and as definite a basis
as possible established for grouping under representative conditions.
Considerable time must elapse before the experimental work will be
brought to a point where final conclusions can be drawn. Past expe-
rience, however, has demonstrated certain fundamental facts in relation
to grouping, and it is recommended that such principles as have received
recognition in standard practice be embodied in the Manual. These
fundamentals can be elaborated upon in the future as additional informa-
tion becomes available.
The principles recommended at the present time for insertion in the
Manual are as follows :
(i) Ties of approximately the same period of seasoning should he-
grouped together for treatment; green ties should never be mixed witii
seasoned ones.
(2) Pine ties should be separated on the basis of heartwood and sap-
wood; it would also be advisable in some cases to group hardwoods O"
the same basis, but it is not generally practical to do so.
(3) Grouping on the basis of species and families, as, for example,
red oaks, pines, beeches, etc., if a further division into hardwood classes
is made with pine, is usually a satisfactory practice. From this it fol-
lows that red oak. beech, long-leaf pine, loblolly pine and gum should be
treated separately. Birch and bard maples and certain other combi-
nations, depending on the locality, can be grouped together to advantage.
(4) The separation in the yard, on the basis the ties are to be
grouped for treatment, is an essential and economical practice.
(2) RECORDS FROM SERVICE TESTS.
The recommendations of the report of the Committee for 191 1
included the recommendation that certain sections of track be selected
on each railroad for the purpose of making accurate tests covering the
life of treated and untreated ties. To ascertain the extent to which this
had been done in the past, and the results which have been obtained,
the Committee sent out a circular letter, the replies to which are abstracted
in Appendix "B" to this report.
(3) MERITS OF VARIOUS PRESERVATIVES.
Your Committee was directed to give special attention to the merits
of oil from water gas tar and to the use of refined coal-tar in creosote oil.
Sufficient information has not been obtained to enable report to be made
on these subjects at this time. The investigations will be continued the
coming year.
WOOD PRESERVATION. 865
(4) REVISION OF THE ADOPTED SPECIFICATIONS FOR
CREOSOTE OIL.
After careful consideration it seems desirable to change the first
clause in the adopted Specifications for Creosote Oil to provide that it
shall be a pure product from coal gas tar or coke oven tar and free
from any foreign admixture, including coal gas tar or coke oven tar.
With this change, the entire specifications for creosote oil will read
as follows :
STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR CREOSOTE OIL.
The oil used shall be the best obtainable grade of coal-tar creosote ;
that is,- it shall be a pure product obtained from coal gas tar or coke oven
tar and shall be free from any tar, oil or residue obtained from petro-
leum or any other source, including coal gas tar or coke oven tar; it
shall be completely liquid at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade and
shall be free from suspended matter; the specific gravity of the oil at
thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade shall be at least 1.03. When dis-
tilled by the common method — that is, using an eight (8) ounce retort,
asbestos covered, with standard thermometer, bulb one-half (^2) inch
above the surface of the oil — the creosote, calculated on the basis of the
dry oil, shall give no distillate below two hundred (200) degrees centi-
grade, not more than five (5) per cent, below two hundred and ten (210)
degrees centigrade, not more than twenty-five (25) per cent, below two
hundred and thirty-five (235) degrees centigrade, and the residue above
three hundred and fifty-five (355) degrees centigrade, if it exceeds five
(5) per cent, in quantity, shall be soft. The oil shall not contain more
than three (3) per cent, water.
In addition to the above standard specification, the two following
grades can be used in cases where the higher grade oil cannot be pro-
cured. It should be understood that where it is necessary to purchase
grades No. 2 and No. 3 consideration should be given to the use of a
greater quantity of creosote oil per cubic foot.
SPECIFICATIONS FOR NO. 2 GRADE CREOSOTE OIL.
The oil used shall be the best obtainable grade of coal-tar creosote ;
that is, it shall be a pure product obtained from coal gas tar or coke
oven tar, and shall be free from any tar, oil or residue obtained from
petroleum or any other source, including coal gas tar or coke oven tar ; it
shall be completely liquid at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade and
shall he free from suspended matter; the specific gravity of the oil
at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade shall be at least 1.03. When
distilled by the common method — that is, using an eight 18) ounce
retort, asbestos covered, with standard thermometer, bulb one-half (lA)
inch above the surface of the oil — the creosote, calculated on the basis of
the dry oil, shall give not more, than eight (8) per cent, distillate below
two hundred and ten (210) degrees centigrade, not more than thirty-
five (35) per cent, below two hundred and thirty-five (235) degrees cen-
tigrade, and the residue above three hundred and fifty-five (355) de-
grees centigrade, if it exceeds five (5) per cent, in quantity, shall be soft.
The oil shall not contain more than three per cent, water.
SPECIFICATIONS FOR NO. 3 GRADE CREOSOTE OIL.
The oil shall be the best obtainable grade of coal-tar creosote; that
is, it shall be a pure product obtained from coal gas tar or coke oven
866 WOOD PRESERVATION.
tar and shall he free from any tar, oil or residue obtained from petro-
leum or any other source, including coal gas tar or coke oven tar; it
shall be completely liquid at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade and
shall be free from suspended matter ; the specific gravity of the oil at
thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade shall be at least 1.025. When dis-
tilled by the common method — that is, using an eight (8) ounce retort,
asbestos covered, with standard thermometer, bulb one-half (lA) inch
above the surface of the oil — the creosote, calculated on the basi^ of
the dry oil, shall give not more than ten (10) per cent, distillate below
two hundred and ten (210) degrees centigrade, not more than forty (40^
per cent, below two hundred and thirty-five (235) degrees centigrade,
and the residue above three hundred and fifty-five (35s) degrees cen-
tigrade, if it exceeds five (5) per cent, in quantity, shall be Noft. The
oil shall not contain more than three (3) per cent, water.
No change is recommended at this time in the "Specifications for
Analysis of Creosote Oil," except that this heading should be changed
to read "Specifications for the Fractionation of Creosote Oil." This
specification merely covers the fractionation and does not cover the chem-
ical analysis which would be necessary in order to determine the presence
of adulteration. The determination in regard to adulterants can be made
chemically in several manners with the same results, and there does not,
therefore, seem to be the necessity for preparing a complete specification
covering chemical analysis that there is for preparing the specification
covering the fractionation, the latter giving different results when made
by different methods.
For the purpose of obtaining more information in regard to the rel-
ative merits of the flask and retort for the fractionation of creosote oil,
and also for the purpose of obtaining other information on which to
base further consideration of the specification for fractionation, it has
been arranged that various samples of creosote oil be submitted to the
various railroads for analysis by various methods, the reports obtained
being submitted in writing to the Committee as soon as possible for action
by the Committee next year.
(5) FORM'S FOR REPORTING INSPECTION.
It is found that the various railroad and timber-treating companies
have their own forms for the inspection and recording of the various
preservative processes, each meeting their own peculiar conditions, although
similar in the essential details. Your Committee is not now prepared to
submit report on this subject, but will continue its consideration the
coming year.
(6) SPECIFICATION FOR IMPREGNATION WITH
CREOSOTE OIL.
A specification for impregnation with creosote oil has already been
adopted by the Association and is contained in the Manual. It is the
sense of your Committee that this specification is in accordance with
good practice, and no change is recommended.
WOOD PRESERVATION. 867
(7) VALUE OF IMPREGNATION WITH CRUDE OIL.
Your Committee is not in position to report at this time and recom-
mends the continuance of the subject for the coming year.
(8) VALUE OF BRUSH COATING AND DIPPING.
A circular letter was sent out making inquiry as to these methods of
treatment. Out of thirty-eight replies, thirty-one report that neither
process has been used, and seven report that no definite conclusions can
be drawn from their experience. It is recommended that further con-
sideration be given this subject.
CONCLUSIONS.
It is recommended:
(i) That the four principles of Grouping of Timbers, as given
under subhead (i), Grouping of Timbers for Antiseptic Treatment, be
accepted for insertion in the Manual.
(2) That the revised Standard Specifications for Creosote Oil, and
the Specifications for No. 2 Grade and No. 3 Grade Creosote Oil. as
given under subhead (4"), Revision of Adopted Specifications for Creosote
Oil, be adopted.
(3) That the heading "Specifications for Analysis of Creosote Oil,''
as it now stands in the Manual, be changed to read as follows: "Speci-
fications for the Fractionation of Creosote Oil."
OUTLINE OF WORK FOR 1912,
Your Committee recommends :
(1) Continue investigations of the merits as a preservative of od
from water gas and the use of refined coal-tar in creosote oil.
(2) Continue the compilation of available information from Service
Tests.
(3) Continue the investigation of the proper grouping of the dif
ferent timbers for antiseptic treatment.
(4) Continue consideration of the revision of the Specifications
for Fractionation of Creosote Oil.
(5) Report on the value of impregnation with crude oil.
(6) Report on the value of brush coating and dipping.
(7) Report on methods of accurately determining the absorption
of creosote oil, including check of gage readings and the keeping of
corrected records.
(8) That the Board of Direction assign the work of drawing up a
Standard Specification for Timber for Treatment to a Joint Commit-
tee of the Committee on Wood Preservation and the Committee on
Grading of Lumber.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON WOOD PRESERVATION.
Appendix A.
GROUPING OF TIMBERS FOR ANTISEPTIC TREATMENT.
CHICAGO TIE AND TIMBER PRESERVING COMPANY.
The information furnished by this company covers the treatment of
red oak and mixed beech ties by the Card process. The weights as
given in the table are not taken from selected lots, but cover the daily
practice. The cubical contents in each charge was estimated by displace-
ment. The computations from the daily log sheets were made by the
Forest Products Laboratory :
Beech (mixed)— Card Process
(includes- gum, elm, basswnod, etc. )
Weight Absorption No. Ties
Oak — Card Process.
Weight Absorption No. Ties
per cu. ft. per cu. ft.
used
Pounds
Pounds
42
14.6
2,670
43
14-3
7,5i6
44
14.6
19.472
45
13-7
32,727
46
13.8
32,498
47
1 3-8
10,323
48
144
1,569
49
50
13-9
1,113
5i
13-3
2,228
52
13.2
1,668
53
12.5
2,308
per cu.
ft. per cu. ft.
used
Pounds
Pounds
37
20.6
507
38
18.7
1,723
39
21.6
57i
40
18.5
2,818
4i
19-3
1,707
42
18.4
3,972
43
17.4
1,702
44
17.0
5,H4
45
17.1
3,414
46
17.2
3.982
47
15-7
4,027
48
15-6
4.553
49
14.9
Total
2,313
■36,463
Total 114,092
The table and accompanying diagram show clearly that the absorp-
tion per cubic foot with both mixed beech and red oak ties falls off as
the treating weights of the ties increase. Thus the absorption of red
oak at 42 lbs. per cu. ft. is about 14^ lbs. of solution, and at 53 lbs. per
cu. ft. about I2J/2 lbs. For mixed beech the difference is even more
marked, varying from about 21 lbs. of solution at 37 lbs. per cu. ft. to
15 lbs. absorption at a treating weight of 49 lbs. per cu. ft.
GUI.FPORT CREOSOTING COMPANY.
No report submitted.
WOOD PRESERVATION.
860
INTERNATIONAL CREOSOTING >V CONSTRUCTION COMPANY.
No report submitted.
KETTLE RIVER COMPANY.
Report that they never reached the point of making any actual ex-
periments.
DIAGRAM SHOWING THE ABSORPTION OF RED OAK AND MIXED
BEECH TIES AT VARIOUS TREATING WEIGHTS PER CU. FT.
CARD PROCESS.
<
1
it
O 20
Ik!
ID
a.
in i«
3
(
1
<
>
2 18
5
c
>/
j
0
If) 17
(
' c
>> /<
/ c
>
0
r
O 16
1-
0.
/<.
1
01
? r
Mix
zv
bEE
;cri
<
14
A
3
<
J
Ret
;> C
Al^
1
t
(
> -
!
-j
3 — <
> <
)
13
5 — c
>
— (
Weight or TTE5 iN L&5. petr. Cu. Ft: at Time or "Treatment
Basis 114,092 Red Oak Ties; 36,463 Mixed Beech Ties.
Treated by the Indiana Zinc-Creosoting Company, Terre Haute, Ind., July,
1909— January, 1910.
NORTHERN PACIFIC RAILWAY.
The report submitted concerns the seasoning and treatment of pine,
oak, beech, elm, ash and hemlock crossties at the Paradise, Mont., plant
870 WOOD PRESERVATION.
of the Northern Pacific Railway. The data were compiled by the Forest
Products Laboratory.
Two ties of each of the above species, with the exception of the
birch and hemlock, of which foiir ties were used, were piled to air-season
in a shed where the air was artificially heated. All were hewn ties
7 in. by 9 in. by 8 ft. and contained an average of sapwood for Minne-
sota timber. The ties were weighed from time to time to ascertain the
rate at which they were seasoning; Fig. 1, in the accompanying diagram,
showing graphically the results obtained. After the ties had seasoned
to the minimum weight shown in the figure they were placed in the treat-
ing cylinder and given a Lowry treatment, all being treated in exactly
the same manner. Fig. 2 shows the amount of creosote absorbed by the
ties under these conditions. Just before treatment the ties had the fol-
lowing weights :
Pine 1 10.50 lbs.
Oak 164.25
Birch I53-50 '
Elm 135.75
Ash 1 26.00
Wisconsin hemlock 168.00 "
Of special note is the rate at which hemlock seasoned, as compared
with the other woods, and the large amount of oil absorbed by the ash
ties as compared with those cut from oak and hemlock, it being approxi-
mately four times as great.
PENNSYLVANIA RAILROAD COML'AXY.
At the Mt. Union and Greenwich plants of the Pennsylvania Railroad
definite experiments are under way to determine the length of time to
season the different species handled, the results from various methods
of piling and the period of seasoning which will give the best results
from the standpoint of treatment. As the experiments have not been
in progress long enough to arrive at a definite solution of the several
points, it will only be possible at this time to outline the nature of the
work.
The experiments at the two plants are to be identical in character,
the tests at Mt. Union to be made with beech, maple and red oak and
at Greenwich with beech, red oak, black gum and sap pine.
Two definite lines of experiments are under way. In the first 2;
ties of each species are to be weighed and piled 7x1, and at the end of
each month two ties of each kind will be weighed and treated. This
work was started in April, 191 1, but another series will be conducted
later to determine the inHueuce of climatic conditions in different seasons
of the year. The data eventually produced should indicate the rapidity
with which each species seasons and show after what period of season-
ing the treatment is most effective.
Wool) PRESERVATION.
871
0
5
r \
o \
Ptrir-
Oak.
r
LI
If i t*i
15
IL
O
Asri
h
r
■j
u
K
U
Cl-
in
o
_)
LI
F
IT)
O
Z
Wl5CCt
Isiri He
-lLOCK_
i
IO 1ST TO 25" J>0 VS AO A3 50
"5EA30NIMG PERIOD -RAYS
Fic i — Rates of Artificial Air Seasoning of Untreated Ties.
Fig.2-
A&50RPTIOr
or Creosote (Lowry Process
or Air 5easomed TTes
1
Asri
1
tO V5 30 55 .4-0 -43 SO 55 SO
ad50rptioh- poumds per.1te
Fig. j — Absorption of Creosote (Lowry Process) of Air Seasoned Ties.
872 WOOD PRESERVATION.
The second line of experiments will be a comparison of the 7x7 witfc
the 7x1 piling systems, and of open blocks as compared with solid ones.
In this test a whole block (six piles square) of oak ties at Mt. Union
were piled solid 7x7; adjoining this was a block of ties 7x7, but with
2-foot alleys between each two rows of piles; while another adjoining
block was piled according to the Company's present system, with the
7x1 arrangement in the piles, 2- ft. alleys between each two tiers of
piles and 4-ft. alleys between the blocks. In each of these experimental
blocks a large number of ties has been weighed, marked and placed in
various places in the different piles; yet in each block the marked ties
will be in approximately the same position. These ties are to be left
for 8 or 0 months, and just before treatment the marked ties will be
weighed and the comparative rates of seasoning noted.
TEXAS TIE AND LUMBER PRESERVING COMPANY.
This company reports that the grouping and seasoning of pine ties.
as described, is in connection with the Rueping empty-cell process.
"We have carried the segregation of pine timber a little further than
is customary when we can do so and have tried to separate, when possible,
ties that had more than 50 per cent, sapwood from those that had less and
treated them in different charges. Our ties at Somerville are also divided
approximately 50 per cent, hewn and 50 per cent, sawn, and of our sawn
ties we get approximately 65 per cent, heartwood ties with very little sap,
and of our hewn ties we get only about 10 per cent, of long-leaf ties,
which have very little sapwood on.
''In treating ties with the Rueping process we find, for instance, that
we have to put in from ten to fifteen pounds more air in the sawn tie
that are 65 per cent, heartwood than we do in the hewn ties that are only
10 per cent, long leaf, with small sapwood to leave in the same amount
of oil at the finish of the treatment. We also find when we separate
the hewn ties in saps and hearts that we have to make about 15 lbs.
difference in the air to leave in the amount of oil when the tie is treated.
This is about the extent of our findings on this subject, and it may not be
of interest to those not using the Rueping process.''
Appendix B.
RECORD OF SERVICE TESTS.
OF
any
i on
is of
with
they
can
t all
•ules
rted
;ame
:orm
light
fere
■ring
De-
eady
year
pre-
ions
data
•555.
bsti-
3ro-
)ers,
55.
APPENDIX B
RECORD OF SERVICE TE5TS
Us^
Qnof E~jr MoTW
t
' '
■"' ■
>-*
?
...-,
■<".
'--
De5cr>p
?=
,.„
-•'
-J-'.
5S
■'-
-
If
,,.,
"■
■~
OiTWrt
-^K
ss:
"^
^
JS*
=
,. . ,<.fl
e- ;■
<V-.— ».,..-^,l:»ir--H
"V
"ill^
'^'
-
i—
«*
-
-
i
-
> -
,-.'
,,,„
~
^Sf
;:-;;
»
B
-4T7
■-: '
- DO
ooo
»'
- =
_:„, -
."
,„,..
.—
,
,U
Wl„,n .-...-..,-.,
■*-■■.-
BO*
50^
UM
*-
-„-.
-j0-q|
616
soo
»"
»)l4.
MO •
0.00
DOO
RM il !!,-„, $«*.
W
:,,
ssSS
..'
^.-.5
Hi
-V„. IjhNIMVAIh
V*
SM5U™
MS',
5
g|
*•»-
*-=-
=
sS ir~
— 7 *
iHv~
'. ..
Vnngmn
-7>: :" -- .
-=;r -'.': E-.5f
Variou,
--.-.-
«
-
[
-
E
«.
K-r.
-
—
=55
^,.
■ p
"""
B-
—
-2-
Jz
;n~45
-
•■"•
—
,,
Pen.4u-.Jr, -*«T *fpt
Vrt.k.y ftbfW'
_.'.•"
-■*
Hl'o
REPORT OF SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON GRADING OF
LUMBER.
Dr. Hermann von Schrenk, Chairman; B. A. Wood, Vice-Chairman;
D. Fairchild. W. H. Norris.
R. Koehler. F. B. Walker.
A. J. Neafie. C. W. Richey.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Special Committee on Grading of Lumber lias not held any
formal meetings during the year, the discussions having been carried on
by correspondence. The Committee wishes to re-submit the Definitions of
Defects and Lumber Grading Rules submitted in its report last year, with
certain slight changes, indicated below. The Committee believes that they
fairly represent Specifications for Maintenance of Way Lumber as it can
be purchased in the market to-day. The rules submitted may not suit all
conditions. It is pointed out, however, that the acceptance of these rules
by the Association, with a proviso that individual grades can be departed
from where the requirements of any particular road seems to make same
necessary, will represent a great step forward in bringing about uniform
rules for the grading of lumber. It appears to the Committee that slight
differences of opinion, concerning one or more grades, should not interfere
with the acceptance of these rules in a general way.
The rules as submitted last year have been changed so as to bring
them into harmony with those already published in the Manual. The De-
scriptions and Definitions of Defects are in accord with those already
adopted by the Association ns standard. There have been added this year
Grading Rules for Cypress Lumber.
RECOMMENDATIONS.
Your Committee recommends that the Lumber Grading Rules as pre-
sented last year, subject to the corrections and including the additions
made below, be adopted as standard.
*Following is a list and reference to the Proceedings where the data
included in these recommendations can be found :
(i) Classification and Grading Rules for Douglas Fir (pp. 5,48-555,
Vol. 12, Part 3, Proceedings for 191 1).
(2) Specifications for Douglas Fir Structural Timbers. (Substi-
tute for paragraphs 38-51, inclusive, pp. 556, 557, Vol. 12, Part 3, Pro-
ceedings, the Specifications for Douglas Fir Bridge and Trestle Timbers,
as given on pp. 143 and 144, Manual, 191 1. For paragraphs 54 and 55,
*See also Bulletin 133, March, 1911.
873
874 GRADING OF LUMBER.
page 557, Vol. 12, Part 3, Proceedings, substitute paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 6 and
7, as given on page 145, Manual, 1911).
(3) Classification, Grading and Dressing Rules for Northern Pine,
including White and Norway Pine and Hemlock (pp. 565, 577, Vol. 12,
Part 3, Proceedings, 1911).
(4) Classification, Grading and Dressing Rules for Southern Yellow
Pine (pp. 578-600, Vol. 12, Part 3, Proceedings, 1911). (For paragraphs
43-59> inclusive, substitute paragraphs 1-14, inclusive, as given on pp. 141
and 142, Manual, 1911.)
(5) Standard Specifications for Construction Oak Timbers (pp. 601-
606, Vol. 12, Part 3, Proceedings, 1911).
(6) Classification and Grading Rules for Cypress Lumber and Shin-
gles, presented in this report.
Respectfully submitted,
SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON GRADING OF LUMBER.
Appendix E.
CLASSIFICATION AND GRADING RULES FOR CYPRESS
LUMBER AND SHINGLES.
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS.
Cypress lumber shall be graded according to the following rules and
specifications, bearing in mind that as no arbitrary set of rules and speci-
fications can be maintained in every case, much must be left to the common-
sense and best judgment of the inspector:
1. Lumber shall be manufactured and shipped in standard lengths and
thicknesses.
2. Tank, ist and 26. and worked partition shall be graded from the
poorer side.
3. Select lumber, flooring, ceiling, bevel siding and finishing shall be
graded from the better or finished side, but the reverse side should in no
case be more than one grade lower.
4. All lumber shall be tallied surface or face measure, the tally counted
up, and the one-quarter or one-half added to the total where the lumber is
one and one-quarter or one and one-half inches thick, and 2 in. and thicker
to be multiplied by the thickness.
5. In the measurement of all lumber, fractions exactly on the one-half
foot are to be given alternately to the buyer and the seller ; the fractions
below the one-half foot are to be dropped, and all fractions above the one-
half foot are to be counted to the next higher figure on the board rule.
6. In "line boards," pieces 14 ft. and longer shall be given the ad-
vantage in grade ; pieces 12 ft. and shorter shall be reduced in grade.
7. Recognized defects in cypress are knots, knot holes, shake, splits,
wane, worm holes, stained sap and peck.
STANDARD DEFECTS.
8. A standard knot is sound and not to exceed i]4 in. in diameter.
9. A small sound knot is one not exceeding Y\ in. in diameter.
10. Two small knots not to exceed in extent or damage one 1^4 in.
knot.
11. One straight split not to exceed in length the width of the piece.
12. Worm, grub, knot and rafting pin holes not exceeding in damage
one iJ4 'n- knot.
13. Ordinary season checks shall not be considered a defect in any
grade.
14. Ordinary season checks are such as occur in lumber properly
covered on yard, or season checks of equal size in kiln-dried lumber.
15. Bright sap is not a defect in select or below.
16. Pin worm holes, sound knots and stained sap shall not be con-
sidered a defect in No. 1 barn or below.
875
876
GRADING OF LUMBER.
Standard Sound Knot.
Rotten Knot.
GRADING OF LUMBER.
877
Two Small Knots Equal to One Standard Knot.
Small Sound Knot.
878
GRADING OF LUMBER.
STANDARD LENGTHS.
17. All random standard length stock may be furnished in odd
as well as even foot lengths, but there shall not he to exceed 20 per cent,
of odd lengths in any one item.
18. Tank stock and No. 1 barn shall he 8 ft. and longer.
19. 1st and 2d and select shall be 10 to 20 ft.
20. Finish, flooring, ceiling, partition, bevel and drop siding shall be
10 to 20 ft.
Pec
KY L.YPRESS.
21. Moldings and battens of all sizes 6 to 20 ft, in both odd and even
foot lengths, but not exceeding 10 per cent, of 6, 7, 8 and 9 ft. lengths.
22. No. 2 barn, 6 ft. and longer.
23. Cull or peck, 4 ft. and longer.
STANDARD FINISHED SIZES OF CYPRESS.
24. All lumber shipped in the rough (except 8/4 in. No. 1 and No. 2
"Dimension," which grades may be %-in. under or J4_m- over tne size
specified, both in thickness and width) shall be of sufficient thickness to
S2S to standard thickness, as follows :
25. 4/4 lumber SiS or S2S shall be 13-16 in. thick.
26. 5/4 select, 1st and 2d clear, selected common tank and tank lum-
ber SiS or S2S, shall be xTA in. thick.
27- 5/4 peck, No. 1 and No. 2 barn and finishing lumber SiS or S2S,
shall be 1 1-16 in. thick.
28. 6/4 select 1st and 2d clear, selected common tank and tank lumber
SiS or S2S, shall be i^j in. thick.
GRADING OF LUMBER. 879
29. 6/4 peck, No. I and No. 2 barn and finishing lumber SiS or S2S,
shall be 1 5-16 in. thick.
30. 8/4 lumber, except No. 1 and No. 2 barn or dimension SiS or
S2S shall be 1^/4 in. thick.
31. 8/4 No. 1 and No. 2 barn or dimension SiS or S2S shall be ify&
in. thick.
32. 10/4 lumber SiS or S2S shall be 2*4 in. thick.
33. 12/4 lumber SiS or S2S shall be 2^4 in. thick.
34. All lumber SiE takes off }i in. S2E, y2 in.
35- All flooring shall be S2S and C. M.
36. 4/4 flooring shall be 13/16 in. by 2J4 in., 3TA in., 4% i"-> Sl4 in-
face.
37. 5/4 flooring shall be 1 1/16, 6/4 shall be 1 5/16, by same widths
as 4/4.
38. Y% ceiling shall be worked 5/16 in., SiS only.
39- ZA ceiling shall be worked 7/16 in., SiS only.
40. Y% ceiling shall be worked 9/16 in., SiS only.
41. Va, ceiling shall be worked 11/16 in., SiS only.
42. All widths of ceiling to be the same as flooring, unless otherwise
specified. Ceiling up to 3% in. face to have one bead on one edge and ceil-
ing wider than 3% in. face to be beaded center and edge.
43. Partition to be finished the same as ceiling, but on both faces.
44. Drop siding shall be worked 54 in. by 3% in., 4% in., 5% in.,
y% in., g% in. face, S2S and C. M. or shiplapped.
45. Bevel siding or bevel cribbing shall be worked J4 in. less in width
than the rough strip measure.
TANK STOCK.
46. This grade shall be random widths, and will not be furnished
in specified widths, and shall be graded from the poorer side.
47. This grade shall be 5 in. and wider, il/2 in. to 4 in. thick and 8 ft.
and over in length. Pieces up to 7 in. shall be free from sap. Pieces 7 in.
to 13 in. may have 1 in. of sound sap on one edge, not to exceed half the
length and half the thickness of the piece. Pieces 14 in. and wider may
have 1 'n. of sound sap on both edges not to exceed half the length and
half the thickness of the piece. In all widths sound knots that do not
impair usefulness for tank purposes may be admitted.
FIRST AND SECOND CLEAR.
48. This grade shall be random widths, and will not be furnished in
specified widths, and shall be graded from the poorer side.
49. This grade shall be 8 in. and wider, 1 in. to 4 in. thick and 10 ft.
and over in length. Pieces 8 in. to 10 in. may have 1 in. of bright sap on
each edge, or its equivalent on one or both edges, otherwise they must be
clear. Pieces 10 in. and under 12 in. may have i% in. of bright sap on
880 GRADING OF LUMBER.
each edge or 3 in. on one edge, and may have one standard knot or its
equivalent. Pieces 12 in. wide may have 2 in. of bright sap on each edge,
or 4 in. on one edge and may have one standard knot; or, in lieu of sap,
may have two standard knots or their equivalent. Pieces wider than 12
in. may admit of defects as specified above in proportion as width in-
creases. Pieces 10 in. and wider may admit of cne end split, which shall
not exceed in length the width of the piece. Pieces 12 in. and less in
width, free from other defects, may have bright sap across one face at one
end, but this sap shall not exceed in length one-tenth of the length of the
piece. In pieces 13 in. and wider bright sap is not a defect.
SELECTS.
50. This grade shall be random widths, and will not be furnished in
specified widths, and shall be graded from the better side, but the reverse
side shall not be of a lower grade than No. 1 shop or No. 1 barn.
51. This grade shall be 7 in. and wider, but will not be furnished
wider than 12 in. ; shall be 1 in. to 4 in. thick, 10 ft. and longer. Pieces
10 in. and under in width shall admit two standard knots or their equivalent
and an additional standard knot or its equivalent for every 2 in. in width
over 10 in. Pieces free from other defects, 10 in. and over in width, to ad-
mit pin worm holes on one edge one-tenth the width of the piece. Bright
sap is not a defect in this grade. Slight wane on pieces 10 in. and over in
width is allowed on one edge not over 3 ft. in length. When no other
defect appears, slight amount of stained sap may be allowed. Pieces 10 in.
and wider may admit of one end split, which shall not exceed in length the
width of the piece.
SELECTED COMMON TANK STOCK.
52. This grade shall be 4 in. .wide, or wider, iY2 in. and 2 in. thick,
8 ft. and over in length. Sound sap no defect in this grade, but must be
free from unsound knots or other defects that extend through the thick-
ness of the piece, and must be square edged to work the full length
of the piece.
NO. I BARN OR DIMENSION.
53. This grade shall be specified widths only, shall be 3 in. and wider,
1 in. and thicker, 8 ft. and over in length, admitting sap, bright or stained,
shake, season checks, knots, pin worm holes, a small amount of peck on
one side and one edge, or very slight peck on both sides and both edges of
pieces comparatively free from coarse defects ; which defects, however,
shall not be sufficient to seriously impair the strength, or prevent the use
of each piece for "common" purposes in its full length and full width..
NO. 2 BARN OR DIMENSION.
54. This grade shall be specified widths, 3 in. and wider, 1 in. and
thicker, 6 ft. and over in length, admitting all the defects allowed in No. 1
GRADING OF LUMBER. 881
barn, but same may be larger and coarser, and in addition will admit
peck on both sides ; however, the defects shall not be sufficient to prevent
the use of each piece in full length and full width for low-grade fencing
and other very common purposes.
CULL OR PECK.
55. This grade may be random or specified widths 3 in. and wider,
1 in. to 4 in. thick, 4 ft. and over in length. Shall admit all pieces below
the grade of No. 2 boxing, and shall also admit the product of that part
of the log known as "pecky;" however, each piece shall have sufficient
strength and nailing surface to permit its use as a low grade boxing, crat-
ing, sheating and foundation material.
FINISHING.
56. Shall be specified widths 4 in. and wider, 1 in. to 2 in. thick, 10 ft.
and over long, and shall be graded from the better side, A, B and C, but
the reverse side should not be more than one grade lower. All grades of
finish, rough or SiS or S2S may vary J4 in- from the width specified.
57. "A" Finish. — Pieces 4 in. and 5 in. wide shall be clear of sap,
knots and other defects. Pieces 6 in. wide may have 1 in. of bright sap:
or in lieu of sap one small sound knot. Pieces 7 in. and 8 in. wide may have
2 in. of bright sap, or in lieu of sap one small sound knot. Pieces 9 in.
and 10 in. wide may have 3 in. of bright sap, or in lieu of sap two small
sound knots, or 1J/2 in. of bright sap and one small sound knot. Pieces
12 in. wide may have 4 in. of bright sap, or in lieu of sap one standard knot,
or two small sound knots, or 2 in. of bright sap and one small sound knot.
Pieces 14 in. or wider may have more defects in proportion as the width
increases.
58. "B" Finish. — Pieces 4 in., 5 in. and 6 in. wide may have 2 in. of
bright sap and one or two small sound knots, or in lieu of knots may have
all bright sap. Pieces 7 in. and 8 in. wide may have 3 in. of bright sap and
two small sound knots, or in lieu of knots may have all bright sap. Pieces
9 in. and 10 in. wide may have 4 in. of bright sap and one standard knot
or three small sound knots, or in lieu of knots may have all bright sap.
Pieces 12 in. wide may have 6 in. of bright sap and one standard or four
small sound knots, or in lieu of knots may have all bright sap. This
grade will not be furnished wider than 12 in.
59. "C" Finish. — All widths in this grade shall admit small sound
knots, stained sap, pin worms and other defects except shake; but none
that will prevent the use of same in its full width and length as a paint
grade, and will admit pieces containing one coarse defect which can be re-
moved by making two cuts with a waste of not to exceed 5 per cent, in the
one piece removed, but which pieces are otherwise "B"' grade or better.
This grade will not be furnished wider than 12 in.
60. "D" Finish. — All widths will admit sound knots, stained sap, pin
worms, slight shakes, and other defects ; but none that will prevent the use
882 GRADING OF LUMBER.
of same in its full width and length as a common paint grade. This grade
will not be furnished wider than 12 in.
SIDING.
61. Siding shall be 4 in. and 6 in. in width, 10 ft. to 20 ft. in length,
and graded from the finished side, A, B, C and D.
62. "A" Siding. — May have 1 in. of bright sap on thin edge, and may
contain one small sound knot.
63. "B" Siding. — May have any amount of bright sap, or if not all
bright sap, may have three small sound knots, shake, split or pin worm holes
not exceeding in damage the three small knots as above, and may have
slight wane on the thin edge. In the absence of other defects a small
amount of stained sap will be permitted.
64. "C" Siding. — May have one to five knots, the whole not aggre-
gating over 3 in. in diameter, or knots, splits or other defects that can be
removed in two cuts with waste not exceeding 10 per cent, of the length,
or may have small amount of stained sap and pin worm holes not exceed-
ing in damage the five small knots above described.
65. "D" Siding. — May have stained sap and pin worm holes, or may
have other defects that will not cause a waste to exceed one-third the piece.
FLOORING AND CEILING.
66. Shall be specified widths, 10 ft. to 20 ft. in length and graded
from the finished side, or if both sides are finished, it shall be graded from
the better side, A, B, C and D.
67. "A" — May have bright sap on one edge one-fourth its width, other-
wise must be clear.
68. "B" — May have one-half of its face bright sap if otherwise clear,
or in lieu of sap, may contain two small sound knots, or may have a split
not to exceed 9 in. at one end.
69. "C" (10 to 20 ft.) — May have all bright sap, or may have one to
five knots, the whole not aggregating over 3 in., or knots or other defects
that can be removed in two cuts with waste not exceeding 10 per cent,
of the length, or may have three pin worm holes, or may have check or
split at one end, not to exceed 10 per cent, of the length.
70. "C" (4 to 9 ft.) — May have all bright sap, small sound knots,
stained sap, pin worm holes and other defects except shake, but none that
will prevent the use of each piece the full length.
71. "D" — May have stained sap and pin worm holes, or may have
unsound knots or other defects that will not cause a waste to exceed one-
third the piece.
PARTITION.
72. Shall be same widths and lengths as flooring and ceiling, but shall
be graded from the poorer side, A, B, C and D, same grading to apply as in
flooring and ceiling.
GRADING OF LUMBER. 883
72,. Shall be graded No. 1 and No. 2.
74. 1 in. by 1 in. shall be Headed and S4S to 13-16 in. by 13-16 in.
75. iH in. by 1% in., shall be Headed and S4S to 1 1-16 in. by
1 1-16 in.
76. iy2 in. by il/2 in. shall be Headed and S4S to 1 5-16 in. by 1 5-16 in.
77. 1 in. by 3 in. shall be Headed and S4S to Y\ in. by 2^/2 in.
78. No. 1. — Shall be well manufactured, bright sap, no defect and may
contain one small sound knot.
79. No. 2. — Shall admit stained sap, sound knots, pin worm holes,
slight shake, and pickets thrown out of the No. 1 grade because of poor
manufacture.
80. Battens, both flat and O. G, are not moldings. Same are in-
variably used with "common" lumber and shall, therefore, be graded No.
1 barn and better, admitting all defects allowed in No. 1 barn, but none
that will prevent the use of each piece in full length for Batten purposes.
Y% in. Battens shall be 1 in. strips S2S to 13-16 in. by 2^/2 in. and re-
sawed, or 1 in. by 2V4 in. to 3 in. S2S and resawed. Unless otherwise
specified, Y% in. or flat battens shall be S2S only and resawed.
81. O. G. Battens shall be manufactured in the sizes and pattern
shown in the Universal Molding Book.
CAR ROOFING AND SIDING.
82. "C and Better" Grade. — This grade will admit sound knots,
stained sap, pin worm holes, very siight shake and other defects, but none
that will prevent the use of each piece in its full width and length for
car roofing and car siding ; may be random or specified lengths and may be
worked to pattern specified and graded from pattern side or S2S and C M
and graded from the better side.
car lining.
83. Shall be specified widths and 8 to 20 ft. in length. Will admit
tight knots, stained sap, pin worm holes, slight shake and other defects,
but none that will prevent the use of each piece in its full width and length
for car-lining purposes.
84. Bests. — A dimension shingle, 4, 5 and 6 in. in width, 16 in. long,
each width packed separately, 5 butts to measure, 2 in., to be all heart
and free of shake, knots and other defects.
85. Primes. — A dimension shingle, 4, 5 and 6 in. in width, 16 in. long,
each width packed separately, 5 butts to measure 2 in., admitting tight
knots and sap, but free of shake and other defects, but with no knots within
8 in. of the butts.
884 GRADING OF LUMBER.
86. This grade may contain shingles clipped two-thirds of the width
and one-eighth of the length on the point.
87. Star a Star. — A random width shingle 3 in. and wider, 14 in.
to 16 in. long, otherwise the same as primes.
88. Economy. — Dimensions 4, 5 and 6 in., each width separately
bunched, admitting sap and sound knots, may have slight peck 5 in. from
butts, imperfections on points no objection and admitting 14 in. shingles.
89. Clippers. — All shingles below the above grades which are sound
for 5 in. from the butts, worm holes and slight peck excepted, random
widths 2^2 in. and wider.
90. The count of our manufacture of shingles, of all grades, is based
on 4,000 linear inches in width, making 1,000 standard shingles, conse-
quently there would be only 667 6-in. shingles packed and counted as
1,000 standard shingles ; 5 in. dimension being counted in like proportion.
91. In making re-inspections of shingles, one bundle out of 20 bundles
taken at random, shall be cut open, the results of this investigation to form
the basis of arriving at the grade of the entire shipment.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE VI— ON BUILDINGS.
Maurice Coburn, Chairman; M. A. Long, P'ice-Cliairman;
G. W. Andrews. A. T. Hawk.
W. G. Arn. N. H. LaFountain.
J. P. Canty. E. N. Layfield.
O. P. Chamberlain. H. A. Lloyd.
D. R. Collin. John S. Metcalf.
C. G. Delo. J. W. Orrock.
W. T. Dorrance. W. F. Schultz.
C. H. Fake. W. S. Thompson.
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee on Buildings has held several meetings during the
year at Chicago, Pittsburg and Buffalo, besides various meetings of sub-
committees.
The following subjects were assigned the Committee by the Board of
Direction:
(i) Report on the advantages and disadvantages of various types of
freight house floor construction.
(2) Continue the study of roof coverings.
(3) Present principles covering the design of inbound and outbound
freight houses.
(4) Continue the study of concrete coaling stations.
The Committee reports progress on subject (1) Report on the ad-
vantages and disadvantages of various types of freight house floor con-
struction.
No recommendations are made as to revision of the Manual.
ROOF COVERINGS.
The Committee presents as information some miscellaneous correc-
tions and additions to last year's report on roofing. As yet the report is
incomplete.
The Committee had hoped this year to present specifications for coal-
tar pitch, but we were unable to offer sufficient inducements to extract the
necessary information.
Page numbers refer to the annual report in Vol. 12, Part 1.
Page 589, last paragraph: A single asphalt fluxed by a single oil is
ordinarily an imperfect and unsatisfactory roofing material. Like a cut
back tar pitch, it lacks stability. The oil is liable to separate out, some-
times supposedly by capillary attraction into the felt, leaving a brittle com-
pound. The successful asphaltic roofing compounds are ordinarily com-
posed of several different materials.
885
8SG BUILDINGS.
Page 590, last paragraph : Elaterite occurs in Utah in territory near
where gilsonite is found, and has much the same appearance, but is found
only in narrow veins. Its qualities are considerably different from those
of gilsonite, said to be in part due to the presence of considerable sulphur.
From it is made a high-priced product which is supposed to be espe-
cially valuable as a constitutent of the protective coating of ready roofs.
We are of the opinion that some products advertising elaterite contain it
in only small quantities, if at all.
Page 591, paragraph 2: Rock Asphalt or Mastic Rock. — There is also
bitumen saturated limestone of which that found in Uvalde Countv, Texas,
is an example.
Page 591, last paragraph : The first two sentences should be changed
to read as follows : "Eastern oils are largely made up of compounds of
the paraffine series, which vary in consistency from comparatively thin
oil to hard scale paraffine."
There are other members of the paraffine series which are light gases.
Page 592, paragraph 1 : The method of distillation of California oils
profoundly modifies the character of the residual.
Page 592, paragraph 2 : The blown oils are coming to be more appre-
ciated. They can be made into a very uniform product of great value for
many purposes, and now that certain patents covering them are expired,
their use will probably broaden considerably.
Page 592, paragraph 4 : The bitumen in the coal-tar includes, besides
the hydrocarbons, other organic compounds, which are, however, present
in roofing pitch only in small quantities.
Page 593, last paragraph: Water Gas Tars. — In making carburetted
water gas, the procedure is as follows : Steam is blown through a bed
of incandescent coal or coke, where it is broken up, forming blue water
gas, which consists of about equal quantities of hydrogen and carbon
monoxide. This gas, which has no illuminating value, is passed into a
second chamber, which is filled with checker brick and which has been
previously raised to a high temperature. Into this chamber is sprayed
petroleum oil, which, by the intense heat, is broken down into permanent
gas and a tar consisting, in the main, of aromatic hydrocarbons similar
to those occurring in coal-tar. This permanent gas is of high illuminat-
ing value and imparts its luminosity to the blue water gas, while the tars
drop out further on in the process of manufacture. It is from this tar
that water gas tar pitch and other products are obtained.
Water gas tar contains some free carbon, but usually not over 2 per
cent. Its pitch is not acted upon by water. There is a very general opin-
ion among practical roofing men that the water gas tar products are less
stable than the coal tar pitches, but we cannot find that there has been any
accurate proof of this. Its small percentage of free carbon materially in-
terferes with its value as a roofing pitch. It is said that carbon can be
added, but we doubt the commercial practicability of such a scheme.
Page 596, paragraph 6: Burlap decays much more readily than the
average cotton felt.
BUILDINGS. 887
Page 597, last paragraph: To combat severe conditions encountered
like those at locomotive engine houses, instead of the dry sheet, an
asphalt or oil-saturated felt is sometimes used. This does not so readily
deteriorate. One roofer uses for this purpose asphalt asbestos sheets,
which are perhaps better yet.
Page 600, last paragraph : General specifications for an asphalt
built-up roof cannot well be prepared because of the differences in ma-
terials, and ordinarily must come from the manufacturers of the ma-
terials.
The successful laying of an asphalt built-up roof in cold weather is a
difficult matter. If the asphalt is hot enough to be properly handled, there
is chance of charring the felts. On steep slopes thorough mopping is
difficult and there is chance of danger to the men. One of the chief rea-
sons for deterioration of the asphalt is supposed to be gradual absorp-
tion, due to capillary action of the flux into the felt.
Page 601, second paragraph : Asbestos Asphalt Built-Up Roofings. —
It is claimed that asbestos felt, acting as it does more as a protection to
the layers of waterproofing material and not merely as a medium for
carrying them, does not have any capillary action on the oil fluxes, and
that the bitumen is so protected that it retains its elasticity and water-
proofing qualities much longer than with the other types of felt. If this
point is sustained, asbestos felts have a superiority for asphalt roofing
over the ordinary felts which may more than overbalance the increased
costs. While the experience obtained from this material is not nearly as
extended as that which has been had from rag felts, these roofings have
been in use for about eleven years, and we have so far found nothing to
disprove this claim.
The asbestos felt has advantage due to its freedom from action by
fire and decay, and it is claimed that the asbestos roofings have a consid-
erable value in their blanketing influence on fires inside the building cov-
ered, which the ordinary felts do not have, points the value of which we
consider have been overemphasized. The asbestos felt is not in any dan-
ger of being charred by hot asphalt which sometimes happens with rag
felts.
The asbestos built up roofings also avoid the gravel or slag necessary
with the ordinary "wool" felt built-up roofing. This freedom from the
use of gravel or slag with its tendency to roll. or be washed off the roof
into the gutters would seem to be of some advantage. This also makes it
easier to locate a leak and leaves the asbestos roofings much lighter in
weight than the other types, an advantage which is probably to some ex-
tent offset by the insulating power of the much greater amounts of ma-
terial used with the "wool" felt. As with all built-up asphalt roofings,
difficulties encountered in the mopping make a slope of not more than
three inches to the foot desirable.
Tar has not been successfully used with asbestos felts.
As compared with a five-ply tar and gravel roof a four-ply asbestos
roof will ordinarily cost at least from one to two dollars more a square.
888 BUILDINGS.
A three-ply roof is supposed to give good results over concrete, but for
wood sheathing it would seem to be approaching too closely to the condi-
tions met with in ready roofing, for first-class work.
Page 609, paragraph 2: Concrete Roofings. — The Asbestos-Portland
. cement shingles seem to be gaining ground. The different manufacturers
use different methods and the results obtained must be used with caution,
as it is claimed that the methods of manufacture have an important bear-
ing on the results which may be expected. Shingles of this type are said
to have been successfully used abroad for many years. Recent changes
are said to have much improved the quality of the material.
For small buildings, or where the design is such as to make tile un-
desirable, they have especial advantages. The growing difficulty of ob-
taining good slate should tend to increase their sale. Their cost is some-
what greater than good slate, but their uniformity is such that they can
more successfully be laid French or diagonal method than can slate. A
considerable saving can be made by laying them French method, but we
do not consider this good practice especially with large sheets (see dia-
gram). The material is somewhat brittle and with this method consid-
erably greater amounts of breakage are to be expected, especially on the
points.
When new, some water may be absorbed, but as they grow older this
defect tends to disappear.
The corrugated sheets should have value as a substitute for corru-
gated iron sheets. They must be laid with good fastenings and sufficient
lap to insure against leakage. They must not be nailed. Some of these
materials are strengthened by wire mesh and some with perforated steel
sheets grading toward the metal protected by asphalt and asbestos.
Gutters.
Gutters for many classes of railway buildings may and should be
omitted. This is more particularly true of buildings with steep roofs near
tracks where cinders from passing locomotives roll down the roof into the
gutters and in time, unless more care is taken to keep them clean than is
usual in railway buildings, the downspouts become choked and fail to
carry off the water.
Gutters may be of metal, wood, or be formed in roof of the materials
used in the construction of the roof, the latter being ordinarily preferable
where the design of the building permits.
Wood gutters are usually of Ogee form on the outside and owing to
the thickness of shell the capacity is small for the size of the gutters.
They are made in three sizes, 3x4, 4x5 and 4x6. The capacity of these
sizes is, however, scarcely more than one-fourth the same size of metal
gutters of equal outside dimensions. They are the most durable kind of
gutters for buildings exposed to smoke and cinders. They are usually
made of fir, white pine or cypress and should be painted inside and out
every few years.
Metal gutters are made of copper, galvanized steel, iron, tin or zinc.
For permanent buildings, copper is preferable. All joints should be sol-
BUILDINGS. 889
dered and riveted with not less than four rivets for smaller sizes and
should be well braced at least every four feet and proportionately increased
in number for larger sizes. The common grades of galvanized "steel often
used cannot be depended on for more than two or three years. Some of
the refined irons now on the market should be of value for this purpose.
Cast-iron gutters are used to a limited extent.
Gutters may be built in the roof, or hanging, as the design of the
building requires. Hanging gutters, which are easier to repair, and which
do not damage the building if defective, are generally preferable. They
should be given as much slope as practicable to the various downspouts
and the outer edge of hanging gutters should be low enough to avoid
chance of damage by possible backing up of water due to stopped-up gut-
ters and conductor pipes.
Copper gutters should be given a coat of linseed oil and tin gutters a
coat of iron oxide paint soon after hanging, and galvanized iron should
not be painted until about a year of exposure to the weather unless a
special acid treatment is applied to provide a surface which will hold the
paint. If a galvanized iron roof is used where copper gutters are applied,
care should be taken to insulate or separate the two metals so that gal-
vanic action will be prevented.
FLASHINGS.
The following definitions, together with the diagrams, are presented
as information concerning flashings. The numbers accompanying the dif-
ferent diagrams refer to the numbers of the definitions.
(i) Flashings are the mechanical unions between roof surfaces and
other parts of the structure intersecting and bounding the plane of the
roof, and between roofs in different planes.
(2) Vertical Flashings are flashings between roofs and other parts
of the structure which intersect the plane of the roof and extend through
or above the roof. (Examples: Walls, parapets, combings, soil pipes.)
(3) Lateral Flashings are flashings between roofs and other parts
of the structure which bound the roof or which intersect the plane of the
roof without extending above it, or, flashings between roofs in different
planes. (Examples: Cornices, eaves, gutters, leader heads, ridges, hips,
valleys.)
(4) Head Flashings are flashings which are approximately at right
angles to the general slope of the roof, at the top of the incline.
(5) Side Flashings are flashings which are approximately parallel to
the general slope of the roof.
(6) Foot Flashings are flashings which are approximately at right
angles to the general slope of the roof, at the foot of the incline
(7) Expansion Flashings are flashings built of two independent parts,
each of which is respectively an integral part of the roof, and of the ad-
joining structure.
(8) Base Flashing is that part of an expansion flashing which is an
integral part of the roof.
890 BUILDINGS.
(9) Cap or Counter Flashing is that part of an expansion flashing
which is an integral part of the adjoining structure.
(10) Continuous Flashings are flashings which are integral parts of
both roof and adjoining structure, without slip or expansion joint.
(11) Protective Flashing is that part of a continuous flashing which
is an integral part of the adjoining structure, but which does not form an
expansion joint with a base flashing.
(12) Homogeneous Flashings are flashings built of the same ma-
terials as the roof.
(13) Mixed Flashings are flashings formed of materials other than
materials of the roof. (Examples: A metal base flashing for a felt
roof.)
(14) Natural or Structural Flashings are flashings which are formed
structurally integral with the roof or adjoining structure. (Example: A
cap flashing built into a raglet in a parapet wall.)
(15) Artifical Flashings are flashings which are not structurally in-
tegral with either the roof or the adjoining structure. (Example: A
"base" or "continuous" flashing supported upon the adjoining structure
by adhesion of materials, or outside cleats.)
The accompanying diagrams are designed to be only illustrative of the
distinctions denned above. No effort has been made to formulate recom-
mendations for details of applications of different materials under differ-
ent conditions.
The report has been signed by Maurice Coburn, M. A. Long, G. W.
Andrews, J. P. Canty, O. P. Chamberlain, D. R. Collin, C. G. Delo, W. T.
Dorrance, C. H. Fake, C. F. W. Felt, A. T. Hawk, E. N. Layfield, W. G
Arn.
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON BUILDINGS.
8
fe I b i, ^
eels
ri
fe
S Q
892
BUILDINGS.
BUILDINGS.
893
894
BUILDINGS.
BUILDINGS.
y//////////.'::y///////////y///A
Details of Flashing and Counter Flashing for Roofs and Walls.
896
BUILDINGS.
45fTI/VG FOJ2 SZ./ZT^&OOF
M/xeo c*p «/?5y/,v6
Off HEAP P/.rfS/1/i\G
FOOT FZ.jZSJYIsYG sSCrfZ/V&T
N° 2-6-8-9-11-14
Details of Flashing and Counter Flashing for Roofs and Walls.
BUILDINGS.
897
'«gS
a; ,Crt O
.-J-'-1 fc. *j t3
O *J *-> 0>
•° d •-• '£ -0
(•So?-
en v<M 0J CJ rt
g t-iSaw
» <D ■
CD
0)
-*-* — Ui TO
■aiSS-S'S'e
"O c 03 Jj £ —
5 '^ — '*-'_- TD
- S £ >•<: c
i. XJ ta t, .2
a) — 3! cm
-^ S --Q
cS P . P
t. +j o s-. r c
cfl in sz <a o <ti
C H-> 01
- tn o3 w
£ ta-7 45 a.c
c <1>
0) > >. .,
4)
N
tn tn
o — **-*
03 o '
o>
M>J-7v^9) «
•S 4><iS>bfl
^ « C ^
tn o> +-> to +j
o . O
» tn O -5 ra
a> 0) 0 .
in bo „ *-•" <u
d C t,« - >
C <n S C 5
i . , w a 4)
_• >>£• c o £
i £o^*
50 C i ■g .S Ml
*■* V c o c
°tDO mftBl
O . bD""1
g°ftrart§
<i JU oS G of w
a '7—9'
cd,Qr-< C5
REPORT OF COMMITTEE IX— ON SIGNS, FENCES
AND CROSSINGS.
C. H. Stein, Chairman;
H. E. BlLLMAN.
G. E. Boyd.
L. C. La wto n.
E. R. Lewis.
A. M. Funk, J'ice-Clhiirimiu ;
J. B. Myers.
F. M. Patterson.
C. H. Splitstone.
W. D. Williams.
Committee/
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
The following subjects were assigned your Committee by the Board
of Direction :
(i) Continue the investigation of ways and means for securing a
proper quality of fence wire to resist corrosion and secure durability.
(2) Report on the relative advantages and disadvantages of the dif-
ferent kinds of fence posts.
(3) Report on the best form of track construction and flangeways
at street crossings in paved streets.
(4) Report on the relative advantages ami disadvantages of the
different kinds of telegraph poles.
A general Committee meeting was held at the Fort Pitt Hotel, Pitts
burg, Friday, September 22, 191 1, at 10:00 a. m., which discussed the sub-
jects assigned. Those present were C. H. Stein, Chairman; H. E. Billman,
G. E. Boyd, E. R. Lewis, L. C. Lawton, W. D. Williams.
In the afternoon the Committee visited the Donnra plant of the
American Steel and Wire Company, and investigated their process of
making wire from the ingot to the finished woven wire product.
The Committee decided to devote its attention to the first three sub-
jects assigned by the Board of Direction, and also to investigate the gen-
eral subject of miscellaneous signs for railroad purposes. A series of
questions were prepared for submission to the various railways with a
view to determining the practice in vogue at this time and to secure the
benefit of data that had been accumulated from experiments made in recent
years with various forms of fencing wires, and by various processes, as
well as with various kinds of wooden and concrete fence posts. Replies
were received from 44 railways of the United States and Canada, repre-
senting 61,000 miles of track, which developed the following information :
(1) 28 roads are using woven wire exclusively;
6 roads are using barb wire exclusively;
2 roads are using ribbon wire exclusively ;
5 roads are using both barb and woven wire.
900
SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS. 901
Woven wire 49 in. to 55 in. in height appears to be generally used.
Specifications in use refer merely to method, form of erection, and style
of fence, and give practically no consideration to quality of wire or process
of manufacture. The wire companies seem to control this latter feature
exclusively. In a couple of cases compliance with the specifications of
the American Railway Engineering Association is recommended but not
explicitly demanded. Only two of the roads are making any experiments
in the development of the subject. Experiments in one case, started April
1, 1909, are being conducted with wires grouped in four classes, as follows:
(a) Galvanized after weaving;
(b) Ordinary dip process;
(c) Special galvanized ;
(d) Sherardized.
When examination was last made, less than a year ago, (a), galvanized
after weaving, was found to be in perfect condition; (b), ordinary dip
process, began to corrode during the first year. The corrosion was
not so rapid during the second year, but was sufficiently pro-
gressive to indicate that deterioration would soon become serious, and
the wire go to pieces at points where stay wires were woven around the
longitudinal ones; (c), special galvanized, was found to be in excellent
condition. No corrosion was apparent, and the wires were still bright.
This process is still in an experimental stage, and investigations will be
continued, (d), Sherardized. This is a process in which the wire is
placed in air-tight receptacles and zinc flue dust packed about it. The
receptacles are then heated for a given period of time at a temperature
somewhat below the melting point of zinc, the zinc forming a coating over
the wires. At the time the test was commenced, this process was not yet
far advanced, and later developments may give some promise of success.
The results in this case, however, were not good.
Similar tests were commenced under the auspices of the American
Society for Testing Materials on the grounds of the Carnegie Technical
School, Pittsburg, Pa., on September 26, 1908. The results of these tests
will be watched with interest and profit. Several rolling mills are now
rolling what is claimed to be a pure metal, running about 99.95 per cent,
pure iron, and exceedingly low in sulphur, carbon and phosphorus. This
is being used for a variety of purposes, and we understand that it can be
drawn into wire. This may develop into a proper material for wire
making purposes with efficient rust resisting properties.
Copper clad wire is also a form of material that is attracting consid-
erable attention. This consists of a steel core surrounded by a copper
jacket applied by mechanical means. The American Consul at Birmingham
recently called the attention of the State Department of this Government
to the announcement in a British Journal of a new rust-proofing process
for iron and steel that is said to be cheap and efficient.
The article to be protected is boiled in a solution whose proportions
are: Water, one gallon; phosphoric acid, four ounces, and one ounce of
90^ SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS.
iron filings. This produces a black non-corroding coating that is durable.
These different products and methods will be further investigated during
the coming year.
It might be stated that English roads use a much heavier wire than
those in this country, usually No. 4 to No. 6 gage. All of it is unwiped,
and it is said they use a better grade of spelter than we do.
At the present time, undoubtedly the wire galvanized after weaving
has proved most durable and efficient, but only certain forms of weaving
appear at this writing to be adapted to that process. Progress is being
made, however, and if tests now being conducted demonstrate that this
is the only manner in which desired results may be obtained, the larger
wire mills will discover a means of accomplishing it if the railway com-
panies insist upon it.
(2) Report on the relative advantages and disadvantages of the dif-
ferent kinds of fence posts.
Nine roads which replied to circular are beginning to use concrete
posts, and we know of others using them, which gave us no information.
Experiments have been conducted for too short a period, however, to enable
them to make a definite statement as to their durability, economy and
efficiency.
The tendency toward the use of concrete posts, however, is becoming
very pronounced, and we should in the course of the next year or so be
able to secure some very valuable and satisfactory information. The prices
for concrete posts appear to vary between 18 and 40 cents, but the figure
largely prevailing for the most popular form of post now on the market is
18 to 22 cents. Since the cost of the various kinds of wood posts now in
use ranges from 12 cents to 40 cents, the prevailing cost being 12 to 15
cents, the difference is not so great as to act as a prohibition to the use of
concrete. The woods used are necessarily those native to the road and
consist of Oregon fir ; red, white and Michigan cedar ; black, yellow and
honey locust; catalpa; tamarack; mulberry, juniper; hois d'arc, chestnut:
white and pin oak.
Several forms of metal posts are now being manufactured, and it is
claimed by a large manufacturer that they will have a life of at least thirty
years and can be delivered at reasonable distances at a price of 23 cents
f. o. b. line of road. These will also receive our attention during the cur-
rent year, in connection with the further investigation of concrete posts.
(3) Report on the best form of track construction and flangeways at
street crossings in paved streets.
The customary practice is the very old one of turning an old light
rail on its side and backing it up with wood plank, planking solid with
wood or planking next to rail and paving with blocks or brick between.
The rail or plank forms the flangeway. Five roads of the forty-four
referred to use some special form of rail or flangeway through paved
SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS. 903
streets. In several of the cases a 141-lb. girder rail is employed with
suitable compromise bars at each end to connect to the tee-rail sections.
In three cases a special form of rolled filler or flangeway, similar to angle
bar construction, with extension beyond the rail head similar to street
car flangeways, is being considered and gives promise of successful appli-
cation. Correspondence is now in progress with the steel company to roll
a trial order, and it is hoped the experiment may be made during the course
of this year, which would perhaps enable us to make a definite recom-
mendation at the next convention.
(4) Report on the relative advantages and disadvantages of the
different kinds of telegraph poles.
This subject was not investigated, as very few experiments have thus
far been conducted with this form of construction. The industry is grow-
ing, however, and attention will be given it this year.
SIGNS FOR RAILROAD PURPOSES.
There is a growing demand for uniformity of signs for all railroad
purposes. It is obvious that it would be a desirable end to be obtained
if all signs for use in giving information to ihe public or employes were
of a similar design in all parts of the country. The Committee has been
investigating the subject with the purpose of producing uniformity, and
securing substantial and economic signs, but has not progressed to the
point where a conclusion can be reached. It will recommend the subject
for definite recommendations at the next convention.
Much information has been received in regard to the foregoing sub-
jects, but it has not been in a sufficiently substantial form, nor in the
nature of such new information, that would warrant the Committee in
making any recommendations in the shape of conclusions. The various
subjects, however, are in a progressive stage, and with the mass of informa-
tion now at hand it appears that the Committee will be enabled at the
next convention to put the matters in definite shape.
We have been handicapped very much in failing to secure information
from our letters of inquiry. Many roads from whom we expected to get
beneficial data have failed entirely to reply to our circulars for informa-
tion. It is possible that this is due to the fact that there are so many
committees of the Association reporting on so many different subjects
that it is practically impossible for the engineering officers to compile the
necessary information and satisfy all of the inquiries. The solution to
this problem would, therefore, be that fewer subjects should be assigned
for investigation and thus relieve the roads of the great amount of labor
that is now necessary in securing and compiling the data on the multitude
of subjects on which information has been sought during past years.
The matter of a proper quality of fencing wire to resist corrosion and
secure durability has been under consideration by the American Society
904 SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS.
for Testing Materials, and we would, therefore, make the following
recommendations :
(i) That the Hoard of Direction instruct our Committee to endeavor
to co-operate with a similar committee of the American Society for Test-
ing Materials in reaching a conclusion on this latter subject.
(2) That subjects Nos. 2, 3 and 4. assigned last year, be reassigned
for study and a report made when the Committee considers that it has
sufficient data to warrant conclusions.
(3) That the Board of Direction assign the subject of "Uniform
Railway Signs for all purposes as applicable to the Public and to Railway
Operation."
Respectfully submitted,
COMMITTEE ON SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE XVI— ON ECONOMICS OF
RAILWAY LOCATION.
A. K. Shurtleff, Chairman; R. N. Begien, Vice-Chairman;
C. Frank Allen. Fred La vis.
WlLLARD BEAHAN. C. J. PARKER.
C K. Conard. F. W. Smith.
A. C. Dennis. Francis Lee Stuart.
C. P. Howard. Walter Loring Webb.
W. A. James. M. A. Zook. .
Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Committee realizes that some of the members of our Association
may be disappointed in its failure to produce a report having some logical
conclusions. The failure to report at the 191 1 convention was explained
at the time, but during the past year the Committee has been greatly
encouraged in its work by the receipt of considerable valuable operating
information.
Under date of October 26, 191 1, the Chairman was able to send to
such members of the Committee as had shown any interest in the work a
tabulated statement by accounts of the operating costs of nine large
railways, comprising 13 per cent, of the main track mileage of the
United States, over 18 per cent, of the freight train mileage, and over
16 per cent, of the passenger train mileage. In some cases the more
important accounts covering "Conducting Transportation" were separated
between Passenger and Freight Service, which will be of particular
value to your Committee in the final analysis of the questions to be
considered.
In addition to the cost data, infoimation has been tabulated covering
the density of traffic per mile of main track in train miles, car miles
and ton miles.
The working members of your Committee have been devoting such
time as they could spare to the study of the statistics tabulated, and to
a portion of them it becomes apparent that no fixed values can be
established for distance, curvature, rise and fall, or gradient. A care-
ful study of the data covering costs by primary accounts apparently
indicates that costs in some of the accounts vary with the number of
train miles and the ratio of freight train mileage to passenger train
mileage.
905
906 ECONOMICS OF RAILWAY LOCATION
In other cases the logical unit of variation is the ton mile, or car
mile depending entirely on the account in question. Further, the density
of traffic both as to tiain mileage and ton mileage enters into the costs.
The result is that your Committee has refrained from presenting any
conclusions for your consideration until it has had time to thoroughly
digest the information now at hand.
A portion of your Committee believes that each case must be con-
sidered by itself, with a probability that the values used for the unit
costs will vary widely, depending on local conditions of traffic with
reference to car loading, character and density of traffic, etc., and in
some cases on climatic conditions.
Your Committee hopes to present a report during the coming year
which will show one or more methods of practical analysis of the question
covering conditions that exist with each case.
Respectfully submitted,
A. K. Shurtleff, Chairman.
REPORT OF SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON UNIFORM
GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
J. C. Irwin, Chairman. W. G. Atwood, Vice -Chair man.
E. F. Ackerman. H. C. Phillips.
W. L. Breckinridge. J. H. Roach.
R. G. Kenly. H. A. Woods.
E. H. Lee. C. A. Wilson.
C. A. Paquette. Committee.
To the Members of the American Railway Engineering Association:
Your Special Committee on Uniform General Contract Forms presents
progress report as follows :
The Committee was instructed by the Board of Direction to report
on "General Contract Forms."
General meetings of the Committee were held as follows: At Bur-
lington, Vt., August 30, 1911, attended by J. C. Irwin, Chairman; W. G.
Atwood, C. A. Paquette, J. H. Roach, H. A. Woods; at Buffalo, N. Y.,
September 29, 191 1, attended by J. C. Irwin, Chairman; E. H. Lee, C. A.
Paquette, H. A. Woods, C. A. Wilson.
The text of the report of the Committee, published in Bulletin 133,
of March, 191 1, was thoroughly discussed and revised, and the reports
of the Committee on Buildings, published in Bulletin 68, and of the
Special Contract Committee, made at the Tenth Annual Convention in
2909 and published in Bulletin 108, have been studied. As the report of
March, 191 1, in Bulletin 133, was not acted upon, the following portion
of that report may be repeated:
"The plan of having an agreement form of two pages separate from
the general contract conditions and as referred to on page 11 76 oi the
Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Convention, is approved by this Com-
mittee, and the agreement form presented in that report has been recon-
sidered and revised and is presented herewith with recommendations for
adoption.
"In small or unimportant contracts this agreement form, which is
designated as Form A, may be used alone, but in larger contracts the Gen-
eral Conditions statement designated as Form B may be inserted, using
the agreement form as a folder with the introductory page at the begin-
ning of the contract and the signature at the end.
"Specifications relating to the particular work can either be included
in the folder or attached to the back.
"The Committee has, in the agreement, made the 'Contractor' the
party of the first part, and the 'Company' the party of the second part,
and has, therefore, in preparing the 'General Conditions,' placed the pro-
visions relating especially to the duties and rights of the 'Contractor' first
and those relating to the duties and rights of the 'Company' last."
907
908 UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
The Committee has considered and presents herewith, for discussion,
the form suggested for Agreement A, and also the following sections
for the General Conditions B :
i. Bond.
2. Contractor's Understanding.
3. Intent of Plans and Specifications.
4. Permits.
5. Protection.
6. Rights of Various Interests.
7. Consent to Transfer. -2
8. Superintendence.
9. Timely Demand for Points and Instructions.
10. Report Errors and Discrepancies.
11. Preservation of Stakes.
12. Inspection.
13. Defective Work or Material.
14. Insurance.
15. Indemnity.
16. Settlement for Wages.
17. Liens.
18. Work Adjacent to Railroad.
19. Risk.
20. Order and Discipline.
21. Contractor Not to Hire Company's Employes.
22. Intoxicating Liquors Prohibited.
23. Cleaning Up.
24. Engineer and Chief Engineer Defined.
25. Power of Engineer.
26. Adjustment of Dispute.
27. Order of Completion. Use of Completed Portions.
28. Changes.
29. Extra Work.
30. Property and Right of Entry.
31. Unavoidable Delays. Extension of Time on Parts of Work.
32. Suspension of Work.
37. Monthly Estimate.
The Committee has discussed, but not formally acted upon, the fol-
lowing Sections, 33, 34, 35, 36 and 38.
The Committee especially presents for approval :
(1) The general scheme of having the two-page general agreement,
Form A, as a folder, within which the other portions of the contract can
be bound, thus permitting a concise contract form or a large contract
form, according to the requirements of the case.
(2) The Agreement — Form A — as presented herewith.
(3) Sections 1 to 32 and Section 37 of B General Conditions.
For next year's work recommendations are made as follows:
(1) Reconsider standard contract form so far as presented in the
light of discussions presented at the convention or by letter.
(2) Complete the construction of final sections of contract.
(3) Consider advisability of having any supplementary standard
forms in conjunction with Uniform General Contract Form, and prepare
such contract forms as may be considered advisable.
Respectfully submitted,
SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON UNIFORM
GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS 909
CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT
A — AGREEMENT.
This Agreement, made this day of in
the year by and between
party of the first part, hereinafter called the Contractor, and
party of the
second part, hereinafter called the Company.
Witnesseth, That, in consideration of the covenants and agreements
hereinafter mentioned, to be performed by the parties hereto and of the
payments hereinafter agreed to be made, it is mutually agreed as follows:
The Contractor shall furnish all the necessary transportation, ma-
terials, superintendence, labor and equipment, and shall execute, con-
struct and finish, in an expeditious, substantial and workmanlike manner,
to the satisfaction and acceptance of the Chief Engineer of the Company.
in accordance with the plans hereto attached or as herein described, and
the following general conditions, requirements and specifications, form-
ing part of this contract.
The work covered by this contract shall be commenced ;
and be completed on or before the
day of , 191
910 UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
And in consideration of the completion of the work described herein,
and the fulfillment of all stipulations of this agreement to the satisfac-
tion and acceptance of the Chief Engineer of the Company, the said
Company shall pay, or cause to be paid, to said Contractor, the amount
due the Contractor, based on the following prices :
This agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be binding upon the
legal representatives and successors of the parties respectively.
In Witness Whereof, The parties hereto have executed this agree-
ment in the day and year first above written.
Witness :
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS. 911
CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT.
B. GENERAL CONDITIONS.
Bond.
1. The Contractor agrees, at the time of the execution and delivery
of this contract and before the taking effect of the same, to furnish and
deliver to the Company a good and sufficient bond of indemnity to the
amount of dollars, as security for the faith-
ful performance, by the Contractor, of all the covenants and agreements
on the part of the Contractor contained in this contract. The security
in such bond of indemnity must be satisfactory and acceptable to the Com-
pany.
This bond shall remain in force and effect in such amount, not greater
than that specified, as shall be determined by the Chief Engineer, until
the final completion and acceptance of the work.
Contractor's Understanding.
2. It is understood and agreed that the Contractor has, by careful
examination, satisfied himself as to the nature and location of the work,
the conformation of the ground, the character, quality and quantity of
the materials to be encountered, the character of equipment and facilities
needed preliminary to and during the prosecution of the work, the gen-
eral and local conditions, and all other matters which can in any way
affect the work under this contract. No verbal agreement or conversation
with any officer, agent or employe of the Company, either before or after
the execution of this contract, shall affect or modify any of the terms
or obligations herein contained.
Intent of Plans and Specifications.
3. All work that may be called for in the specifications and not
shown on the plans, or shown on the plans and not called for in the
specifications, shall be executed and furnished by the Contractor as if
described in both these ways ; and should any work or material be required
which is not denoted in the specifications or plans, either directly or in-
directly, but which is nevertheless necessary for the_ proper carrying out
of the obvious intentions thereof, the Contractor is to understand the
same to be implied and required, and shall perform all such work and
furnish any such material as fully as if they were particularly delineated
or described.
Permits.
4. Permits of a temporary nature necessary for the prosecution of
the work shall be secured by the Contractor. Permits for permanent
structures or permanent changes in existing facilities shall be secured
by the Company.
Protection.
5. Whenever the local conditions, laws or ordinances require, the
Contractor shall furnish and maintain, at his own cost and expense, neces-
sary passageways, guard fences and lights and such other facilities and
means of protection as may be required.
Rights of Various Interests.
6. Wherever work being done by Company forces or by other Con-
tractors is contiguous to work covered by this contract the respective
rights of the various interests involved shall be determined by the En-
gineer, to secure the completion of the various portions of the work in
general harmony.
912 UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
Consent to Transfer.
7. The Contractor shall not let or transfer this contract or any part
thereof (except for the delivery of material) without consent of the
Chief Engineer, given in writing. Such consent does not release or
relieve the Contractor from any or all of his obligations and liabilities
under the contract.
Superintendence.
8. The Contractor shall constantly superintend all the work embraced
in this contract, in person or by a duly authorized manager acceptable
to the Company.
Timely Demand for Points and Instructions.
9. The Contractor shall not proceed until he has made timely demand
upon the Engineer for, and has received from him, such points and in-
structions as may be necessary as the work progresses. The work shall
be done in strict conformity with such points and instructions.
Report Errors and Discrepancies.
10. If the Contractor, in the course of the work, finds any discrepancy
between the plans and the physical conditions of the locality, or any errors
in plans or in the layout as given by said points and instructions, it shall
be his duty to immediately inform the Engineer. Any work done after
such discovery, until verified, will be done at the Contractor's risk.
Preservation of Stakes.
11. The Contractor must carefully preserve bench marks, reference
points and stakes, and in case of wilful or careless destruction, he will
be charged with the resulting expense and shall be responsible for any
mistakes that may be caused by their unnecessary loss or disturbance.
Inspection.
12. All work and materials shall be at all times open to the inspec-
tion, acceptance or rejection of the Engineer or his duly authorized repre-
sentative. The Contractor shall at all times provide reasonable and neces-
sary facilities for such inspection.
Defective Work or Material.
13. Any omission or failure on the part of the Engineer to dis-
approve or reject any work or material shall not be construed to be an
acceptance of any defective work or material. The Contractor shall re-
move, at his own expense, any work or material condemned by the En-
gineer, and shall rebuild and replace the same without extra charge, and in
default thereof the same shall be done by the Company at the Contractor's
expense — or}> in case the Chief Engineer should not consider the defect
of sufficient importance to require the Contractor to rebuild or replace any
imperfect work or material, he shall have power, and is hereby authorized,
to make any deduction from the stipulated price that he may deem proper.
Insurance.
14. The Contractor shall secure in the name of the Company and
for its benefit, policies of fire insurance on such structures and in such
amounts as shall be specified by the Chief Engineer not exceeding
Indemnity.
15. The Contractor shall indemnify and save harmless the Com-
pany for and from all claims, demands, payments, suits, actions, re-
coveries and judgments of every nature and description brought or re-
covered against it, by reason of any act or omission of the said Con-
tractor, his agents or employes, in the execution of the work by or in
consequence of any negligence or carelessness in guarding the same.
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS. 913
Settlement for Wages.
16. Whenever, in the opinion of the Chief Engineer, it may be neces-
sary for the progress of the work to secure to any of the employes of
the Contractor any wages which may then be due them, the .Company is
hereby authorized to pay said employes the amount due them or any lesser
amount, and the amount so paid them, as shown by their receipts, shall be
deducted from any moneys that may be or become payable to said Con-
tractor.
Liens.
17. If an established lien be filed against the Contractor for labor
or material furnished in the performance of the work, the Company is
hereby authorized to pay and discharge the same, if it shall deem best
so to do, and to deduct the amount so paid from any moneys which
may be or become due and payable to the Contractor.
Work Adjacent to Railroad.
18. Whenever the work embraced in this contract is near the tracks,
structures or buildings of this Company or of other railroads, the Con-
tractor shall use proper care and vigilance to avoid injury to persons
or property. The work must be so conducted as not to interfere with
the movement of trains or other operations of the railroad; or, if in
any case such interference be necessary, the Contractor shall not pro-
ceed until he has first obtained specific authority and directions there-
for from the proper officer of the Company and has the approval of the
Engineer.
Risk.
19. The work in every respect shall be at the risk of the Contractor
until finished and accepted, except damage or injury caused directly by
Company's agents or employes.
Order and Discipline.
20. The Contractor shall at all times enforce strict discipline and
good order among his employes, and any employe of the Contractor who
shall appear to be incompetent, disorderly or intemperate, or in any other
way disqualified for or unfaithful to the work entrusted to him, shall
be discharged immediately on the request of the Engineer, and he shall
not again be employed on the work without the Engineer's written consent.
Contractor Not to Hire Company's Employes.
21. The Contractor shall not employ or hire any of the Company's
employes without the permission of the Engineer.
Intoxicating Liquors Prohibited.
22. The Contractor, in so far as his authority extends, shall not
permit the sale, distribution or use of any intoxicating liquors upon or
adjacent to the work, or allow any such to be brought upon, to or near
the line of the railway of the Company.
Cleaning Up.
23. The Contractor shall, as directed by the Engineer, remove from
the Company's property and from all public and private property, at his
own expense, all temporary structures, rubbish and waste materials re-
sulting from his operations.
Engineer and Chief Engineer Defined.
24. Wherever in this contract the word Engineer is used, it shall be
understood as referring to the Chief Engineer of the Company, acting
personally or through an assistant duly authorized in writing for such
914 UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
act by the Chief Engineer, and wherever the words Chief Engineer are
used it shall be understood as referring to the Chief Engineer in person,
and not to any assistant engineer.
Power of Engineer.
25. The Engineer shall have full power to reject or condemn all
work or material, which, in his opinion, does not conform to this con-
tract ; to direct the application of forces to any portion of the work
which, in his judgment, requires it; to order the force increased or
diminished, and to decide every question that may arise between the
parties relative to the execution of the work.
Adjustment of Dispute.
26. All questions or controversies which may arise between the Con-
tractor and the Company, under or in reference to this contract, shall
be subject to the decision of the Chief Engineer, and his decision shall
be final and conclusive to both parties.
Order of Completion; Use of Completed Portions.
27. The Contractor shall complete any portion or portions of the
work in such order of time as the Engineer may require. The Company
shall have the right to take possession of and use any completed or par-
tially completed portions of the work, notwithstanding the time for com-
pleting the entire work or such portions may not have expired ; but such
taking possession and use shall not be deemed an acceptance of the work
so taken or used or any part thereof. If such prior use increases the
cost of or delays the work, the Contractor will be entitled to such extra
compensation, or extension of time, as the Chief Engineer may determine.
Changes.
28. The Company shall have the right to make any changes that may
be hereafter determined upon, in the nature or dimensions of the work,
either before or after its commencement, and such changes shall in no
way affect or void this contract. If such changes diminish the quantity
or extent of the work to be done, they shall not. under any circumstances,
be construed as constituting, and shall not constitute a claim for damages
or for anticipated profits on such work.
In case quantities in the completed work vary from the quantities
shown on the original plans, and provided for in the specifications, then
the final payment shall be adjusted on the basis of unit rates specified
in this contract.
Note. — First paragraph of Section 28 to be used in unit price and
force account contracts, i. e., in all contracts not on lump-sum prices.
Should be omitted in lump-sum contracts.
Extra Work.
29. No bill or claim for extra work or material shall be allowed
or paid unless the doing of such extra work or the furnishing of such
extra material shall have been authorized in writing by the Engineer
before any part of such work was done or material furnished.
The price for such work shall be determined by the Chief Engineer,
who may either fix a unit price or a lump-sum price, or may, if he so
elects, provide that the price shall be determined by the actual cost, to
which shall be added per cent, to cover general expense and
superintendence, profits, contingencies, use of tools, Contractor's risk and
liability. If the Contractor shall perform any work or furnish any ma-
terial which is not provided for in this contract, or which was not author-
ized in writing by the Engineer previous to the doing of the work or the
furnishing of material, said Contractor shall receive no compensation for
such work or material so furnished, and does hereby release and dis-
charge the Company from any payment therefor.
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS. 915
If the Contractor shall proceed with such extra work or the furnish-
ing of such extra material after receiving the written authority therefor,
as hereinbefore provided, then such work or material, stated in the written
authority of the Engineer, shall be covered, governed and controlled by
all the terms and provisions of this contract, subject to such prices as
may be agreed upon or fixed by the Chief Engineer.
If the Contractor shall decline or fail to perform such work or furnish
such extra material as authorized by the Engineer in writing, as afore-
said, the Company may then arrange for the performance of the work in
any manner it may see fit, the same as if this contract had not been
executed, and the Contractor shall not interfere with such performance
of the work.
Property and Right of Entry.
30. The Company shall provide the lands upon which the work under
this contract is to be done, except that the Contractor shall provide land
required for the erection of temporary construction facilities and storage
of his material, together with right of access to the same.
The Contractor shall not enter upon said lands, nor ship any ma-
terial or equipment, until he has received written notice from the En-
gineer that he may proceed with said work or any part thereof.
Unavoidable Delays; Extension of Time on Parts of Work.
31. If the Contractor shall be delayed in the performance of the
work from any cause, for which the Company is responsible, he shall, upon
written application to the Chief Engineer at the time of such delay, be
granted such extension of time as the Chief Engineer shall deem equitable
and just.
Suspension of Work.
32. The Company may at any time stop the work, or any part thereof,
by giving ten (10) days' notice to the Contractor in writing. The work
shall be resumed by the Contractor in ten (10) days after the date fixed
in the written notice from the Company to the Contractor so to do. The
Company shall not be held liable for any damages or anticipated profits
on account of the work being stopped, or for any work done during the
interval of suspension. It will, however, pay the Contractor for expense
of men and teams necessarily retained during the interval of suspension,
provided the Contractor can show that it was not reasonably practicable to
move these men and teams to other points at which they can be engaged.
The Company will further pay the Contractor for time necessarily lost
during such suspension at the rate of per cent, per annum
on the estimated value of all equipment and fixtures owned by the Con-
tractor and employed on the work which are necessarily idle during such
suspension, said rate of per cent, per annum being understood
to include depreciation, interest and insurance. But if the work, or any
part thereof, shall be stopped by the notice in writing aforesaid, and if
the Company does not give notice in writing to the Contractor to resume
work at a date within of the date fixed in the
written notice to suspend, then the Contractor may abandon that portion
of the work to suspend and he will be entitled to the estimates and pay-
ments for such work so abandoned, as provided in Sections
of this contract.
Annulment, Contractor's Fault.
33. Discussed, but not acted upon by the Committee.
Annulment, Without Fault of Contractor.
34. Discussed, but not acted upon by the Committee.
916 UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
Removal of Equipment in Case of Annulment.
35. Discussed, but not acted upon by the Committee.
Measurement and Approval of Work.
36. Discussed, but not acted upon by the Committee.
Monthly Estimate.
37. So long as the work herein contracted for is prosecuted in ac-
cordance with the provisions of this contract, and with such progress as
may be satisfactory to the Chief Engineer, the said Chief Engineer will,
on or about the first day of each month, make an approximate estimate
of the proportionate value of the work done and of material furnished
or delivered upon the Company's property at the site of the work, up to
and including the last day of the previous month. The amount of said
estimate, after deducting per cent, and all previous payments,
shall be due and payable to the Contractor at the office of the Treasurer
of the Company on or about the 20th day of the current month.
Final Estimate.
38. Discussed, but not acted upon by the Committee.
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION ON RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
(For Report, see pp. 65-6S.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
F. D. Anthony. H. E. Hale. C. H. Stein.
A. S. Baldwin. E. R. Lewis. John G. Sullivan.
J. B. Berry. G. W. Merrell. E. E. R. Tratman.
W. M. Camp. C. A. Morse. Walter Loring Webb.
H. M. Church. H. T. Porter. Edwin F. Wendt.
L. A. Downs. E. T. Reisler. C. C. Wentworth.
C. H. Ewing. L. S. Rose. H. S. Wilgus.
Robert Ferriday.
The President: — We will now take up the report of the Committee
on Rules and Organization. Mr. Osgood, the Chairman of the Commit-
tee, at the last minute, was prevented from coming here, so that he has
not had an opportunity to instruct the other members of his Committee
fully as to the preliminary announcements. Mr. F. D. Anthony will be
kind enough to state the general work of the Committee in order that the
report may be discussed.
Mr. F. D. Anthony (Quebec, Montreal & Southern) : — The report of
the Committee is well set forth in Bulletin 141, and I do not know that
there is much to say on the subject except to leave it to the convention
for criticism.
The President : — The first recommendation of the Committee is on
the first page, in which they state, "That no change be made in the Gen-
eral Rules for the Government of Employes of the Maintenance of Way
Department heretofore adopted by the Association." Then they state
"That to the rules heretofore adopted by the As30ciation be added Instruc-
tions as follows :" Then follows a list of 26 rules. What is your pleas-
ure in regard to the consideration of these instructions or rules? If
agreeable we will adopt the usual course, and have the Secretary read
each paragraph, and any members having any criticisms to make will
please state them; the adoption of each separate paragraph will not be
put to vote, except in the case of a dispute, or something of that nature.
(The Secretary then read the paragraphs under the heading Instruc-
tions.)
The Secretary: — "(1) The roadbed, ballast and track shall conform
to the standard plans. No changes in the sections shown shall be made
without proper authority.
"(Note: It is understood that cross-sections for wet cuts will be
included in the standard plans.)
919
920 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
"(2) All ditches, including intercepting ditches on the upper side
of cuts, must be kept clean.
"(3) Where heaving or wet spots develop, special drainage shall be
provided."
The President: — Mr. Tratman has a suggestion to make in regard to
No. 3.
Mr. E. E. R. Tratman (Engineering News) : — My suggestion is that
after the word "develop" we insert the words "investigation as to cause
must be made," so that it will read, "Where heaving or wet spots de-
velop, investigation as to cause must be made and special drainage pro-
vided."
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — We might add "Investigation" to every rule of
similar nature. Investigation is a foregone conclusion. The Committee
think that is unnecessary.
The President: — Do you wish to make any motion as to that, Mr.
Tratman ?
Mr. Tratman:— No.
The Secretary: — "(4) Before re-ballasting track, line and grade
stakes shall be set by the Engineer. All unsuitable material shall be re-
moved and the roadbed widened to proper section, the waste material being
used to widen banks, or otherwise, as may be directed.
"(5) Track must be kept in good line and surface while ballasting,
open track avoided as far as practicable, and such track carefully watched."
Mr. Tratman : — It seems to me that sentence is rather long, especially
as it deals with two distinct subjects. I propose that it be divided into
two parts, to read, "Track must be kept in good line and surface while
ballasting. Open track must be avoided as far as practicable, and such
track carefully watched."
Mr. F. D. Anthony : — That is merely a matter of punctuation.
The President: — Is the Committee willing to accept it?
Mr. F. D. Anthony : — No ; we would prefer to let the rule stand as
recommended in the report.
The President: — Do you wish to make a motion? Any further
criticism?
The Secretary: — '"(6) After ballast is distributed it shall be trimmed,
and the track lined and surfaced to conform to the standard plans."
Mr. Tratman : — I seem to be coming unduly to the front here, but it
seems as if that paragraph could be changed grammatically and be im-
proved by wording it as follows : "After ballast is distributed, it shall be
trimmed to conform to the standard plans, and the track lined and sur-
faced." We do not line and surface to the standard plans (as worded in
the original), but the track is to be trimmed to the standard plans.
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — It is my opinion and also the opinion of one
other member of the Committee that rule No. 6 is not right, as ballast
is usually distributed in anticipation of a lift. It seems to me the lift is
the first thing after the distribution of the ballast, and I would suggest
DISCUSSION. 921
this : "After ballast is distributed and the track lifted, the track should be
lined and surfaced and the ballast trimmed to conform to standard plans."
(Motion seconded and carried.)
The Secretary: — "(7) Where track is bonded, ballast must be kept at
least one inch below the base of rail. At road crossings, platforms, etc.,
where this is not practicable, only clean gravel or rock ballast shall be
used."
Mr. Tratman : — I move that the word "electrically" be inserted before
"bonded." We all know what "bonded" means, but as these are rules to
be sent out for trackmen and track officials, I think it should be explained
more fully.
The President: — The Acting Chairman says there is no objection to
making that change.
The Secretary :—" (8) Ties stored along right-of-way shall be piled
to conform to the standard plan.
"(Note: The standard plan should show the minimum distance to
the nearest rail.)
"(9) The ties in track must be inspected at stated times each year
and those which will not last until the next inspection marked for re-
newal.
"(10) The renewal of ties shall be started when directed by the
'.'7... v. When ties are being renewed, the line and surface
shall be corrected and ballast trimmed."
Mr. H. M. Church (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I would like to change the
last three words of Rule 10 "and ballast trimmed," so that it shall read,
"unsuitable material removed and ballast trimmed."
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — There is no objection to that.
The Secretary: — "(11) All defective ties removed from track shall
each day be placed for burning or loading on cars."
Mr. Tratman : — I propose a little grammatical change there. In-
stead of "shall each day," substitute "removed from track each day shall
be placed for burning or for loading on cars."
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — The Committee does not see any object in
changing the wording as recommended.
The Secretary:— "(12) The S!E$ shall frequently in-
spect ties removed from track to see if any have been removed which
might have remained in the track with safety until the next inspection."
Mr. Tratman : — >I think that could be simplified in the second line ;
instead of "if any have been removed which might have remained," sub-
stitute "if any of them have been removed." That makes it a little less
involved.
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — There is no objection to that correction.
The President : — The Committee accepts that.
The Secretary: — "(13) Ties shall be spaced according to the stand-
ard plans. All ties shall be placed square to the line of rails. The out-
side ends on double tracks, and the ends on one side throughout on single
track, must be lined parallel with the rail.
022 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
"(14) The heart side of ties must be turned down. The largest and
best tics shall be selected for use at joints. Twisted or badly hewn ties
must not be notched, but the bearings must be made true with the adze."
Prof. Walter Loring Webb (Consulting Engineer) :— I think the last
sentence is a little indefinite. It says, "Twisted or badly hewn ties must
not be notched, but the bearings must be made true with the adze." I
suppose what is intended is that ties shall be hewn so that there is a good
surface, instead of there being a mere notch. It seems to me the reading
could be improved a little, to bring out the real meaning, for even a notch
may have the surface I'rvic, which evidently is not what is intended. It
might be made to read, "Twisted or badly hewn ties must not be notched,
but must be hewn for the full length of the tie," of words to that effect.
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — The intention of the Committee is that they
shall be properly adzed. But not notched — it is a question of forming the
surface. What would you suggest as a change?
Mr. E. R. Lewis (Michigan Central) : — I assume we all realize the
immense importance of the proper method of laying ties. The first
sentence of Rule 14 reads: ''The heart side of ties must be turned down."
So far as I know, this is a dogma of railway rule books; a positive order,
leaving absolutely nothing to the judgment of the practical trackman
who has been laying tics for fifty years. This rule most vitally concerns
the whole track structure, the very foundation of it. It affects the con-
struction and maintenance of all railways.
I opposed this rule in the Rules Committee of my own road and I
oppose it here, because I believe it is wrong and I believe it impossible
of successful application. I am rather curious to know its origin. I
would like to ask the Committee why a tie should not be laid heart side
up.
In the actual manual labor of laying track, in the direct charge of
maintenance and construction work, I have had this problem pretty close
in front of me for over twenty years, and I presume others have had
more experience. I have studied it from all angles, and I have investi-
gated many hundreds of thousands of ties with this very point in view.
I am aware that this rule is contained in the Rule Books of a great many
of the best railways in this country. So much the worse for the Rule
Books. They are wrong. The tracks of these very roads, whose Rule
Books contain this rule, arc not laid in accordance therewith. I make
this statement without fear of contradiction, because I know it to be im-
possible, because I know that these roads have their ties not so laid.
What is the tie for? This definition is taken from the Manual of this
Association: "The tie is that transverse member of a railway track
which supports the rails and by means of which the rails are retained in
position." The purposes mentioned in this definition cannot be best
served by placing the tie heart side down. The heartwood of the tie
is denser than the sapwood. Its cell walls are thicker and the cells con-
tain less moisture when the wood is green. Therefore it loses less moisture
when the wood is seasoning. The cell walls of the sapwood are thinner
DISCUSSION. 923
than the cell walls of the hardwood, the cells arc larger; the sapwood
is not so dense, and cannot hold the spike as well. Witn the sap side up,
you get only the point of the spike into the densest wood. Jn the less
dense sapwood the neck of the spike has a tendency to work out ot gage
and give way a little more than does the point. \\ hat is especially neces-
sary is to get the neck of the spike, that part of the spike nearest to the
rail, where it will do the most good and hold the gage best. When any
timber starts to check, it checks from the sap siae first; because the
sapwood loses sap first, loses more of it, and allows shrinkage to take
place more quickly, also it shrinks more than the heartwood. The heart-
wood being denser contains less moisture and absorbing less moisture is
longer lived than the sapwood. The sapwood will dry out, check and warp
away from the heart side of the stick. This applies to all sorts of timber
as any timberman will agree. In the town where 1 reside we cut some-
thing like two hundred million feet of timber every year. Every lumber-
man in the Saginaw Valley has agreed with me that timber will warp
away from the heart; every lumberman in every other valley will tell
you the same thing. Therefore I say that the tie should be laid heart side
up, because any shrinking and warping of the tie is away from the heart
side. Therefore the heart side is the convex side. Now, you cannot get
a good bearing for a tie unless you lay it with the convex side up. If you
lay it with the concave side up you are working against the law of grav-
ity, and you obtain a rocking chair effect instead of a stable foundation for
a railway.
Ask any good, practical laborer how to lay a tie and he will tell you
"belly up." This is the trackman's rule the world over. I estimate that
90 per cent, of the ties that are laid in track are perceptibly warped or
crooked. They are not precisely straight. There is a choice of bearing.
I do not think any track foreman ever should allow a tie to be put in the
track without choosing the bearing, the side which should go up. Irre-
spective of sap side or heart side, he must get the convex side up.
According to the Government's statistics, about 80 per cent, of the 125,-
000,000 ties bought by the railways of the United States in 191 1 were
hewn ties. This hewn tie is a pole tie. A man going into the business of
making ties is not going to pick out timber which has to be split and
worked out on four sides. He picks out pole timber that requires work-
ing on only two sides. The other timber is worked up into something else
more valuable to him. Sawed ties are manufactured from large logs ; all
the boards possible being sawed from four sides of the stick, leaving
a box heart tie. You cannot put the heart side of such a tie up or the
heart side down. The heartwood is in the center. The same is true of
the pole tie.
Besides being wrong in principle, I believe this first sentence of Rule
14 is unnecessary. In only 5 or 10 per cent, of the ties is the heartwood
on one side. Even that 5 or 10 per cent, we should not lay wrong side up.
In the past, when we used untreated ties, most of them failed us through
decay. In the future, with the crcosoted tie, it will be the other way.
924 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
We will lose our ties through wear, and we want the best wearing wood
where it will do the most good. We want the heart side where it will
do the most good. Put it where it will give the greatest amount of wear.
There is one best way of doing everything. There is only one best
way of laying a tie and that is to lay it the best way. Why not say so?
To this end I move that this part of Rule 14 be amended to read: "Ties
must be laid so as to obtain the best bearing." We want the best rail-
way, and we cannot get it unless we lay the ties convex side up.
Mr. Robert Ferriday (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis) : —
I second the motion.
(The motion carried.)
Mr. L. S. Rose (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis) : — 1 ask
why the rule is made to square the ends of the ties on double track on the
outside.
Mr. F. D. Anthony : — My impression is that is a pretty general prac-
tice. That was the decision of the Committee, and I am personally not in
a position to explain it.
The President: — Do you make any motion?
Mr. Rose : — I have not any motion to make. I know that is pretty
common practice. I have seen some track laid where the ties were squared
on the inside. There ought to be some reason for it. Personally I would
square the ties on the inside on double track just for the looks of it.
The President: — The Acting Chairman of the Committee is unwilling
to accept the suggestion, so unless some motion is made we will pass to
Rule 15.
The Secretary: — "(15) Whenever spikes are drawn from ties,
wooden tie plugs must be driven into all holes except in ties which are
to be renewed that season. In replacing spikes they should be driven into
the plugs."
Mr. L. A. Downs (Illinois Central) : — I think we should make some
reference to the use of treated plugs in treated ties.
The President: — Have you any suggestion for a complete sentence?
Mr. L. A. Downs : — Add to the present paragraph, "When spikes are
withdrawn from treated ties, plugs of treated material should be used."
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — It seems to me that rule is general. It does not
refer particularly to either treated or untreated ties. These rules may
be supplemented by such special rules as local conditions may require.
It seems to me this rule is general enough.
The Secretary: — "(16) In unloading rails from cars they should be
skidded or otherwise carefully lowered to avoid injury. Where it is neces-
sary to drop them, both ends must be dropped together and the greatest
care taken to avoid their falling on hard and uneven surfaces."
Mr. E. R. Lewis : — In the interest of brevity, I would move that the
last sentence of Rule 16 be eliminated. I understand that it is put in
there for emphasis, but there is emphasis in brevity. I think if we say:
"In unloading rails from cars they should be skidded or otherwise care-
fully lowered to avoid injury," we have said all that is necessary.
DISCUSSION. 926
Mr. L. A. Downs : — I second the motion in the interest of good prac-
tice and not for the sake of brevity.
Mr. H. T. Porter (Bessemer & Lake Erie) : — As I understand it, the
second sentence is provided for those cases where they have not the
equipment to carefully lower the rails. On a sandy roadbed, with rea-
sonable care, you can drop the rails without danger of breaking, and I
would judge that a very large percentage of the rails in this country are
unloaded without their being skidded or lowered carefully with some
device.
Mr. E. R. Lewis: — I think the first sentence covers that point. If
you carefully drop them, you carefully lower them.
Mr. Ferriday : — I would suggest the word "unloaded" in place of
"lowered."
The President : — There is a motion before the Association, ti has
been moved and seconded that the second sentence of Rule 16 be elim-
inated.
(A vote was taken on the motion and it was lost.)
The President: — Any further discussion?
Mr. F. D. Anthony :-*-Mr. Tratman's correction, striking out the word
"new" in the first sentence, has been accepted.
The Secretary: — "(17) The bottom of the new rail and the bearing
surface of the tie shall be cleaned before the new rail is laid.
"(18) When replacing rail with rail of the same section, only two
rows of spikes shall be drawn ; in replacing with rail of a different section,
three rows of spikes shall be drawn.
"(19) In laying new rail, standard expansion shims shall be used.
The temperature of the rail shall be taken by placing the thermometer on
the rail. The openings between 3s ft- rails shall be in accordance with the
table.
"The rail should be laid without bumping and, when practicable, laid
rail by rail."
Mr. Ferriday: — If it is permissible, I would like to return to Rule 18.
I do not think the rail section should determine whether two rows of
spikes shall be left or three rows. It depends upon certain parts of the
section. I know that in a great many cases but two rows of spikes are
drawn, in laying rails of different sections, although the sections are
quite different. It depends upon the gage of the track, and the difference
in sections, that is, the width of the base and the width of the head.
1 would make a motion to add, after that paragraph, the words, "if neces-
sary."
The President : — That is accepted by the Committee.
The Secretary: — "(20) The rails shall be brought squarely into
line and at least two bolts tightened before spiking. All joint bars shall be
securely fastened with the full number of bolts, tightening those at the
center first. At permanent connections of rails of different sections step
chairs and offset splices must be used."
Mr. Tratman : — I propose that after Rule 19 there should be added a
926 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
paragraph, giving the specia1 requirements for expansion spacing in tun-
nels. The figures which are given in the table under Rule 19 are for open
track. Some railways note on their tunnel plans that above a certain tem-
perature all rails shall be laid close, but not bumped together. I think
it would be well to insert a paragraph relating to spacing in tunnels and,
possibly, on long bridges, where expansion joints have to be considered.
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — I think the Committee had in mind that this
would come under the head of special rules to govern local conditions?
However, if the convention wants to insert that rule, I would like to hear
it discussed.
The President: — Any discussion? The Committee does not feel like
accepting that paragraph, unless there is a motion adopted by the Asso-
ciation.
Mr. Tratman : — In Rule 20 the terms "step chairs" and "offset splices"
are used. Then in Rule 22 the term "compromise joints" is used. Those
are three names for one device, and I think in Rule 20 the words "com-
promise joints" should be used.
Mr. F. D. Anthony: — Do you mean in place of offset joints?
The President: — Do you mean "compromise" instead of "offset?"
Mr. Tratman: — Either use the two or change it. I would move
that "offset splices" be changed to "compromise joints."
The President : — The Committee will accept "compromise splices."
The Secretary: — "(21) All spikes must be driven vertically with
the face in contact with the base of the rail. They should not be straight-
ened while being driven. The rail must be full spiked and the spikes
staggered so that the outside spikes shall be on the same side of the tie
and the inside spikes on the opposite side.
"(22) In making temporary connections in main tracks an old rail
should be cut and fastened to the new rail, using compromise joints when
necessary. Switch points shall be used for this purpose only during the
presence of the Track Foreman."
Mr. L. A. Downs : — I move that we eliminate the last sentence.
(Motion seconded and carried.)
The Secretary: — "(23) After new rail is laid the track must be lined
and surfaced.
"(24) All kinked or crooked rails must be straightened before being
laid ; if bent in service they must either be removed or straightened."
Mr. A. S. Baldwin (Illinois Central) : — This says, "If bent in service
they must either be removed or straightened." After straightening, I
think it is unsafe to lay them back in the main track.
Mr. F. D. Anthony : — This does not say they shall be laid back in the
main track. It may be laid in a siding.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — The presumption from the context is that that
is what is referred to.
Mr. Hunter McDonald (Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis) : — Does
it necessarily mean that a rail is unsafe because it has been straightened?
Do I understand Mr. Baldwin to mean that? If that is true, the curv-
DISCUSSION. 927
ing of rails is bad practice. I recall having straightened as many as
2,000 rails, some of which are still in service to-day, and that was twenty
years ago.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin: — It is true that the curving of a rail is, in a
measure, the bending of it. Of course, by the roller rail bender, so-
called, it is a very gradual process, and I have seen cases where surface
bent rails in the main track were taken out and straightened and then
relaid in the main track, and I found they were liable to breakage at the
point where the straightening had been done, and I have known of quite
a number of cases where they did break at that point. From the nature
of steel, it seems to me it is not a safe practice to take a surface bent
rail and straighten it and put it back into the main track, under very high,
heavy service.
Mr. H. T. Porter: — A surface-bent rail means a rail that is bent
vertically. Any power that is sufficient to bend it, is liable to damage the
structure of the rail, but a rail can be bent sideways or horizontally be-
cause, on account of the section, it is not so stiff in that dire:tion. So it
can be bent sideways and horizontally and straightened again and put back
in the track again without taking any great chances. I do not think this is
intended to refer to surface-bent rail, but that it means rails bent out
of line.
The President: — Any further discussion? There is no motion before
the house.
Mr. C. C. Wentworth (Norfolk & Western) : — I merely want to call
attention to the fact that switch points are bent cold almost invariably
before they are planed, and we do not find them breaking.
Mr. C. A. Morse (Santa Fe) : — It seems to me these rules are rather
too general for a railway, for the reason that we have first, second, third
and fourth class track. We build light branches for the development of
a country and take most anything and lay it there. To make a rule that
you cannot straighten a bent rail is impracticable, because none of us
follow it.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin:— I think after a rail has been bent that is kinked,
as referred to in the first part of this rule, and then straightened, it should
be treated as if it were a second-quality rail. After we get from the mills
a new second-quality rail, it does not come up to the first-class specifica-
tions and we use it for switch leads in points of main line where there
is no very high speed, and other places like that, and after a rail has been
kinked I think it should be treated as a second-quality rail, and be put to
the same uses as a second-quality rail.
Mr. E. R. Lewis : — I move that Rule 24, as printed in Bulletin 141, be
adopted.
(Motion seconded and carried by a rising vote, resulting as follows:
For, 41 ; opposed, 24.)
The Secretary:— "(25) Rails for curves of 2 degrees and over should
be curved before being laid. In curving or straightening rails, the rail
bender must be used."
928 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
Mr. S. A. Jordan (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I would like to ask the
members of the Committee what kind of a rail bender they would use in
curving the rail for a 2-degree curve and get anything like a uniform
curve in the rail.
Mr. F. D. Anthony:— Do you mean what style of machinery?
The President :— The Committee says it is unable to answer that
question.
Mr. H. E. Hale (Missouri Pacific) : — I move that it be changed to rea"d
4 degrees instead of 2.
Mr. C. A. Morse: — The rule says that the rail bender must be used.
I understand there are some roads in the country that have not been
using a rail bender on the outside rail. They curve the inside rail and
then spring the outside rail to gage with it. We have done that in a
few cases on our road, and have found it very satisfactory, rather tend-
ing to get away from the short kinks that are there, whether you can
see them or not, when the rail bender is used.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. McDonald: — May I ask the Chairman whether the Manual shows
whether any action has been taken on this matter in the past? I think
it has already been fixed at 2 degrees.
The President : — A hasty examination of the Manual does not show
any action to have been taken, but the Chair rules this will be a matter
for the editor of the Manual to take care of when the time comes to
print this. Rule 25 has, therefore, been changed to read "4 degrees"
instead of "2," unless there is a division requested.
Mr. John G. Sullivan (Canadian Pacific) : — The word the is a definite
article, and it would lead one to believe that the Committee had a special
kind or make in mind. I would suggest a rail bender.
The President: — The Committee accepts that.
The Secretary: — "(26) When surfacing (picking up low joints or
other low places), the general level of the track must not be disturbed."
Mr. J. B. Berry (Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific) : — I move to strike
out everything in the parenthesis. There cannot be two different kinds
of low joints. Surfacing means picking up the track, and it is covered
by the balance of the rule.
The President : — The Committee accepts that. The rules are now
open for a motion to adopt them as a whole as amended.
Mr. C. A. Morse : — Before doing that, there is a question on Rule 26,
as amended by Mr. Berry. It would read, "When surfacing, the general
level of the track must not be disturbed." I think that is misleading. If
you are surfacing to a face, you certainly have got to disturb the surface
of the track and any track has got to be surfaced to a face occasionally.
The President: — Do you wish to move to put those words back?
Mr. C. A. Morse : — .Not exactly those words.
The President : — The words were eliminated by consent of the Com-
mittee and not by vote; therefore, it is subject to amendment, if you
wish.
DISCUSSION. 929
Mr. W. M. Camp (Railway and Engineering Review) : — Does not
Rule 4, on reballasting, cover that point?
Mr. H. T. Porter: — I would like to offer an amendment to Rule 26,
as follows: "When picking up low joints or other low places, the general
level of the track must not be disturbed." The word "surfacing" is a
general term and applies to lifting track, when you are simply lifting
one side or lifting joints, or when you are lifting up a foot in order to
put in new ballast; so that "surfacing" is the general term; whereas, as
I read it, this clause is to warn the foreman that, when he is simply pick-
ing up low joints and other low places, they must not disturb the general
surface of the track. Now, that is a source of a great deal of difficulty
on track maintenance. Old, experienced foremen can often go through a
section, in the spring and early summer, and put it in first-class shape
with little or no effort, whereas I have seen a young foreman, when it
was only necessary to pick up his joints at low places, do more harm
to the track than he did good by attempting to do what this rule says
he must not do, namely, not disturb the general level of the track.
Mr. C. H. Stein (Central Railroad of New Jersey) : — I would like
to call attention to the fact that this reads, "when picking up low points"
—a typographical error, no doubt. I think this would read better, "when
picking up joints or other low places, the general level of the track must
not be disturbed," and not duplicate the word "low," because that is
very clear by inference.
Mr. H. T. Porter:— I accept that.
Mr. G. W. Merrell (Norfolk & Western) :— I would like to ask if the
word "maintained" would not be better — "the general level of the track
shall be maintained?"
Mr. C. H. Ewing (Atlantic City Railway) :— I hope the motion
will not carry. I think all of us know that surfacing simply covers pick-
ing up low joints and low spots. Raising track is an entirely different
proposition; so that the rule as agreed to by the Committee should stand.
Mr. Camp: — I think it is a little unfortunate that those words "pick-
ing up low joints and other low places" were eliminated because they ex-
plain what the Committee meant by the word "surfacing."
I am heartily in accord with this paragraph, because I do not believe
that track should be raised out of face unless grade stakes be set for the
lift, and that is provided for in Rule 4. I agree with Mr. Porter when he
says that a great deal of injury to track is done by raising it entirely out
of face when really all that is needed is to pick up the low spots. On
this point the paragraph in question is important.
Were those words stricken out by motion?
The President :— They were stricken out by the Committee itself on
suggestion of a member of the house.
Mr. E. T. Reisler (Lehigh Valley) :— I would like to ask the intention
of the Committee, in case bringing up a low joint does not make the
track level.
930 RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
The President :— Any further discussion on the motion? The motion
is to change Rule 26 to read, "When picking up joints or other low
places, the general level of the track must not be disturbed."
(Motion carried.)
The President: — The Instructions as amended now stand for action
by the convention and I desire to read the rules for the consideration
of reports.
(The President read the same.)
What is the pleasure of the convention in regard to these Instruc-
tions ?
(A motion was made to adopt the Instructions as amended.)
Mr. Edwin F. Wendt (Pittsburgh & Lake Erie) : — I desire to offer
a statement respecting Rule 24 before this motion passes. Every rule
under the head of "Rail," on pagi 67, seems to refer to the laying of new
rails for the first time. In Rule 24 the second paragraph refers to rails
bent in service. Therefore, it seems to me that Rule 24 should be divided
into two sections. The first section relates to new rails being laid for
the first time and the second section refers to rails which have already been
in use and have become bent. I think we are a little inconsistent in mix-
ing up rails bent in service with rails which have not yet been in the
track; and, furthermore, I do not like Rule 24, especially in its relation
to the attitude of public bodies, such as railroad commissions and courts
of law, with respect to what is called "kinked" rails. I would like to ask
the Committee if they will eliminate the second section of Rule 24, which
refers to rails which have been in service and bent, either by reason of
imperfectly balanced locomotives, or from some other cause — omit that
entirely and allow the first section of the Rule to be consistent with the
others ? And if the Committee will accept that, I would like them to elim-
inate the word "crooked" and let it read "kinked rails must be straight-
ened before being laid."
Mr. H. T. Porter: — It seems to me that all these rules, from 16 to 26,
apply to laying rails, whether new or relaying rails. As far as Rule 24
is concerned, I would be very glad to see that word "crooked" eliminated.
The rest of it I would like to see remain.
The President : — The Chair will have to rule that that is not strictly
in accordance with the discussion on the motion as it is now put. There
has been no second to either suggestion so far.
Mr. H. S. Wilgus (Pittsburg, Shawmut & Northern) :— If it is not
too late, I would like to refer to Rule 25. It seems to me that the Rule
refers to the construction of entirely new track. It does not apply to
rail replacement, and it seems that a sentence may be added, reading like
this: "However, for renewals it will not be necessary to curve the rail;
it may be sprung into place."
The President: — The Chair thinks it is out of order to amend any
particular Rule now, in view of the fact that this motion for adoption
has been put.
DISCUSSION. 931
Mr. Stein : — It seems to me that these paragraphs 16 to 26, inclusive,
refer to the laying of new rail and not the renewal of rail with other
second-hand rail ; that the title of these paragraphs should be changed and
it should specify new rail instead of simply "rail." It appears to me as if
there is confusion in those various classes, and that confusion seems
to have carried itself through the minds of the Committee, because they
appear to have had in mind, in clause 24, that it might be a replacement
of rail in the track with other second-hand rail. I think the title should
be "new rail," if this refers to new rail.
The President: — The question is demanded.
(A vote was then taken and the motion was carried.)
The President : — 'The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of
the Association.
DISCUSSION ON SIGNALS AND INTERLOCKING.
(For Report, see pp. 69-76.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON SIGNALS AND INTERN-
LOCKING.
,' L. R. Clausen. Hunter McDonald.
W. H. Elliott. L. S. Rose.
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Sig-
nals and Interlocking, of which Mr. A. H. Rudd is Chairman. In the
absence of the Chairman, Mr. L. R. Clausen, the Vice-Chairman, will
present the report.
Mr. L. R. Clausen (Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul): — The Com-
mittee on Signals and Interlocking was assigned four subjects, which
appear en page 69. The Committee has no report on subjects 2, 3 and
4. The Committee has a report on subject 1, and they have also
submitted a revised table of insulation resistances for rubber-covered
wires. The table of insulation resistances is changed as the result of
investigations of the Committee of the Railway Signal Association and
was submitted to that Association at its annual meeting in October
last, and by vote of the convention the table of insulation resistances
was submitted to letter ballot and approved. The changes are com-
paratively slight and in order to make the American Railway Engineer-
ing Association specifications conform to the Railway Signal Association
specifications, the Committee would desire to have this revised table
approved by this Association. I make a motion to the effect that the
revised table of insulation resistances shown on page 70 be adopted by
this Association.
Mr. W. H. Elliott (New York Central & Hudson River) :— I
second the motion.
Mr. Hunter McDonald (Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis) :— I
move that the table of insulation resistances be adopted in accordance
with Rule 16-g, as provided in the General Rules.
Mr. Clausen : — We accept the amendment.
The President: — The motion is that this revised table be adopted
for publication in the Manual.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Clausen : — The adoption of the table of insulation resistances
carries with it the approval of the same table for the specifications of
cables, both braided and lead-covered, which are covered by conclusions
2 and 3, at the top of page 70. I would, therefore, as representing the
Committee, move the adoption of this same table, to be included in the
DISCUSSION. 933
specifications for mineral matter, rubber-compound insulated, braided
cables, and also for rubber-compound insulated lead-covered cables, as
covered by conclusions 2 and 3.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Clausen : — The instructions to the Committee, No. 1, are as
follows : "Continue investigation of outline and description of a com-
prehensive and uniform signal system, suitable for general adoption,
conferring with proper committee of the American Railway Association."
A report of the Signal Practice Committee of the Railway Signal
Association has been submitted to the Railway Signal Association
and has been rejected by that Association. In view of that fact the
Committee presents the report which is found on pages 71-4, as
information. I move that the report as indicated on these pages be
received as information.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. L. S. Rose (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis) : — I
move that the report on pages 75-6 be received as information.
Mr. Clausen : — I failed to cover the entire report ; the motion
should have included pages 75-6.
The President: — The Chair will accept that, without any motion,
that it includes the minority report also.
The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of the Association.
DISCUSSION ON IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
(For Report, see pp. 81-88.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON IRON AND STEEL
STRUCTURES.
F. J. Bachelder. Thomas Earle. Albert Reichmann.
A. S. Baldwin. E. A. Frink. O. E. Selby.
E. C. Brown. J. M. Meade. John G. Sullivan.
J. L. Campbell. H. T. Porter. Edwin F. Wendt.
C. H. Cartlidge.
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on Iron
and Steel Structures, of which Mr. C. H. Cartlidge is Chairman. We
will ask the Chairman of the Cotnmittce to make the opening state-
ment.
Mr. C. H. Cartlidge (Chicago, Burlington & Quincy) :— Your
Committee reports on the following subjects:
Subject No. I — Investigation on Impact and Secondary Stresses:
Appendix B contains a report from Prof F. E. Turneaure, Chairman
of Sub-Committee on Impact, giving an outline of the work done by the
Committee during the past year.
Subject No. 2 — Influence of Theory, Experiment and Experience on
Bridge Design : It was unanimously decided by the Committee that it
was unable to report adequately on this subject, and the request is
therefore made that the subject be dropped.
Subject No. 3— Rules for Instruction and Guidance of Inspectors in
Mills, Shop and Field : The Committee reports progress. The Chair-
man of the Sub-Committee has received discussion from two of the
members of his Sub-Committee, and will probably be able to submit s
paper giving the results of their findings during the next few months.
Subject No. 4 — Design of Built-up Columns : The tender of the
services of this Committee to collaborate with the Joint Committee of
the American Society of Civil Engineers was made and very promptly
accepted. Sufficient time has not yet elapsed to permit the organization
of any actual work on this subject. The program proposed by the
American Society of Civil Engineers Committee is very elaborate and
comprehensive and when carried out will immensely increase our knowl-
edge of the subject. In order that this Committee do any practical
work on this subject, it will be necessary to have funds. Your Com-
mittee understands, of course, that none of the funds of the Association
are available for this purpose. We feel warranted, however, in recom-
mending that individual roads be asked to contribute for the purpose of
934
DISCUSSION. 935
making these tests. This work and that of the Impact Committee are
original research work and it is hardly necessary for us to point out
the ultimate value of the work done in the manner in which it has
been done. It will probably be necessary in the near future to take
cognizance of these experiments in our specifications for design, but the
Committee does not recommend that any change be made at present,
nor until further experiments on secondary stresses have been made, and
if possible, considerable work on columns. The Committee will present
later a more definite report of the probable amount of money needed
for the first year's work. It is expected that this will be very small
and that it can easily be raised.
Subject No. 5 — Specifications for Erection of Steel Bridges: The
Committee presents for the consideration of the Association a set of
specifications, revised in accordance with the discussion at the last con-
vention and with the written discussions from members and others re-
ceived since the convention.
The recommendations of the Committee are as follows :
(i) That the specifications for Bridge Erection be adopted and
printed in the Manual.
(2) That the report of the Impact Committee be received as in-
formation.
(3) That no change be made at present in the specifications for
steel railway bridges printed in the Manual.
I move the adoption of the specifications for the erection of rail-
road bridges printed in Appendix A.
The President : — We will read each one of these sections contained
in Appendix A, as was done in the previous case.
The Secretary: — "1. The Contractor shall erect, rivet and adjust
all metal work in place complete, and perform all other work herein-
after specified.
"2. The Contractor shall provide all tools, machinery and appli-
ances necessary for the expeditious handling of the work, including
drift pins and fitting up bolts.
"3. The method of erection and plans for falsework and erection
equipment shall be subject to approval by the Engineer, but such
approval shall not relieve the Contractor from any responsibility. False-
work will be built by * Falsework material of
every character will be provided by the *
"The temporary structure for use during erection and for maintain-
ing the traffic shall be properly designed and substantially constructed
for the loads which will come upon it. All bents shall be thoroughly
secured against movement, both transversely and longitudinally. The
bents shall be well secured against settling, and piles used wherever
firm bottom cannot be obtained. Upon completion of the erection, the
temporary structure, if the property of the Railway Company, shall be
removed without unnecessary damage, and neatly piled near the site or
936 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
loaded on cars, as may be directed. If the property of the Contractor,
it shall be removed in a manner subject to the approval of the Engineer.
"Falsework placed by the Railway Company under an old structure
or for carrying traffic may be used as far as practicable by the Con-
tractor during erection, but it shall not be unnecessarily cut or wasted."
Mr. A. S. Baldwin (Illinois Central) : — I would ask the object of
the third clause of Section 3, which provides that "Falsework placed
by the Railway Company under an old structure or for carrying traffic
may be used as far as practicable by the Contractor during erection,
but it shall not be unnecessarily cut or wasted.'' That, it seems to me,
is a special case, and does not apply here. You cannot make a rule
of that kind to apply to all cases. I would suggest the elimination of
that clause. You have already provided for the falsework in the first
paragraph of the section, and here comes a modifying clause which
might cause complication, and I think it should be a case for special
arrangement between the Contractor and the railway at the time the
contract was made.
I move that the third paragraph of clause 3 be eliminated.
Mr. H. T. Porter (Bessemer & Lake Erie) : — It is not an uncommon
thing to put bents under a truss that has become light. I had a case
where I had to do that, so I took up the question with a bridge com-
pany as to a plan of falsework which could be used in the erection of
a new structure. They put the falsework under our old bridge and
used it when they came to erect a new bridge.
Then in another case, where the old bridge was wrecked by a
washout and an engine going onto it, we had to build a trestle across
the river in order to keep the traffic open, so we built our trestle over
the river, and it was used for falsework by the Contractor in erecting
a truss. This is a specification for erection, and I call your attention
to the fact that this covers cases that do happen in ordinary experi-
ence, and I see no objection to leaving it in here. It simply makes
the specification more complete.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — The trouble is there are no two cases that
will be alike, in all probability, and consequently it cannot be covered
by a general rule. I think it is! well to call attention to matters like
that, and I suggest the following modification —
The President : — There is a motion now before the house to elimi-
nate the paragraph.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — I withdraw the motion.
(Seconder agreed, and the motion was withdrawn.)
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — I make a motion that this clause be modified
as follows : "If falsework has been placed by the Railway Company
under an old structure, or for carrying traffic, the use of it by the
Contractor must be subject to a special arrangement, to be made with
the engineer of the Railway Company."
DISCUSSION. 937
Mr. O. E. Selby (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis) :— I
think that the clause as it stands does not represent a special case,
but a very usual case. It frequently happens that falsework has been
placed under a bridge for the purpose of strengthening a weak bridge, to
enable it to carry the traffic, and it would be unwise to throw it away and
not take advantage of it for erection purposes.
I do not see how it would lead to complications with the Contractor,
because it represents an existing condition at the time bids are asked for
and the contract is let. If the falsework is there, it is there when
the bidder examines the job, and he is expected to examine the job
and take note of all the existing conditions. I think that the existence
of that falsework should be taken cognizance of, and the way it is put
in the specifications here does that in a satisfactory manner.
Mr. J. M. Meade (Santa Fe) :— I wish to say that the Santa Fe
has done a great deal of work, almost exactly as outlined in this re-
port, and I strongly endorse what Mr. Porter says. I believe we should
leave that paragraph in the specifications as written.
Mr. Cartlidge : — In making these specifications we desired to adapt
them as widely as possible to any conditions which are to be met with.
It is possible, of course, that we have tried to cover some conditions
which are not so nearly universal as some of the others covered. On
the other hand, it seems to the Committee that any clause such as
this, which may not meet with the approval of the Engineer or the
Railway Company letting the contract, can be eliminated in the draft
of the contract made at the time the work is let. These specifications
are not intended to be used verbatim, but as a model or guide for
drawing up specifications. With that explanation of the purpose of the
specifications, we think that some of the clauses may be allowed to
stand as being suggestions for practice, rather than clauses which must
be incorporated in all contracts.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — I think the members have misunderstood the
object that I had in view in making this motion. It is not that the
falsework should not be used ; it is, of course, in the line of economy
that anything that is existent on the railway should be used; but I
wanted to have the clause so worded that the Railway Company would
be sure to get proper credit for it. Take a case in which a Railway
Company is about to let a contract for the erection of all its bridges
for a year. The Contractor, in figuring for these bridges, would figure
on the falsework for all of the bridges ; then, at any point where he
found falsework, there would be that much net gain to him to which
he was not entitled, whereas, if the provision is made in the way I
have proposed where the Contractor comes to a bridge for which the
falsework has been provided, it becomes necessary for him to make
a special arrangement for that bridge with the Railway Company and
the Railway Company gets credit for the material put in.
Mr. Porter: — If this clause is left in the specification, then it does
938 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
not have to be handled as a special matter, and if a iailway is letting
a contract for all of its bridges for a year, and takes competing bids,
if this clause is in the specification, the chances are that some of
these contractors, at least, will take this into consideration, in making
their bids, and the Railway Company would get a lower bid than if
this clause is left out. If the clause is left out of the general speci-
fication, the Engineer may omit to take it into consideration when he
calls for bids, so I think it is the proper place for it and it should
remain.
Mr. F. J. Bachelder (Baltimore & Ohio) : — This clause seems to
be covered in the forepart of the section. It says : "The method
of erection and plans for falsework and erection equipment shall be
subject to approval by the Engineer, but such approval shall not relieve
the Contractor from any responsibility. Falsework will be built by
* Falsework material of every character will
be provided by the * " That, it seems to me,
covers these particular cases, and we could eliminate the latter clause.
(The motion was lost.)
The Secretary: — "4. The work shall be prosecuted with sufficient
force, plant and equipment to expedite its completion to the utmost
extent and in such a manner as to be at all times subordinate to the
use of the tracks by the Railway Company, and so as not to interfere
with the work of other contractors or to close or obstruct any thor-
oughfare by land or water, except under proper authority.
"Reasonable reduction of speed will be allowed upon request of the
Contractor.
"Tracks shall not be cut nor shall trains be subjected to any stop-
page except when specifically authorized by the Engineer.
"The Contractor shall protect traffic and his work by flagmen fur-
nished by and at the expense of the Railway Company. The Contractor
shall provide competent watchmen to guard the work and material
against injury."
Mr. E. A. Frink (Seaboard Air Line) : — The second paragraph of
this section reads : "Reasonable reduction of speed will be allowed
upon request of the Contractor." That means that upon the request
of the Contractor the Railway Company will issue a "slow order"
limiting the speed over the structure to a certain degree. I think
there should be a clause added specifying that the Railway Company
will not be responsible for any injury to the property or structure of
the Contractor, due to failure on the part of the Railway Company to
carry out the "slow order." I say that for this reason : In one case
in our experience on the Seaboard Air Line we had a "slow order"
over the structure and the Contractor was engaged in building a coffer-
dam which he tied up to the structure. Some of the trains over the
structure exceeded the speed limit and the Contractor thereupon set
DISCUSSION. 939
up a claim, which he substantiated in court, that the Seaboard Air
Line was responsible for the damage to his work because it did not
maintain the slow order. Therefore, Mr. Chairman, I move to amend
that paragraph by adding: "The Railway will not thereby in any way
incur any responsibility for damage to the work or materials of the
Contractor for failure to maintain such reduction in speed."
Mr. Thomas Earle (Pennsylvania Steel Company) : — It seems to
me that the addition of this clause would nullify the balance of the
paragraph. What is the advantage of a slow order to a Contractor
if he knows beforehand that he is not to expect that slow order to
be fulfilled, and in addition if there is a slow order of thirty miles
an hour and a train goes through at sixty miles an hour and the
Contractor's plant is destroyed and he has to pay for it, of what
benefit is the clause to him? It will add a burden on the Contractor,
but in the end the Railway Company will pay for all such clauses,
because the Contractor must eventually be reimbursed for all such
expenses by his customers, who, in this particular case, are the rail-
ways.
Mr. J. L. Campbell (El Paso & Southwestern) : — I agree with the
remarks of the speaker who has just preceded me. I do not think
we can enforce a clause of that kind. I do not believe that you can
release a Railway Company from proper responsibility by the insertion
of such a clause, and I believe it would impair the force and effective-
ness and dignity of the work of this Association to put such a clause
as that in the specification.
Mr. F. J. Bachelder : — This clause does not specify the speed re-
striction which is to be placed on the structure. It simply provides
for a reasonable reduction of speed. I think the clause should stand
as written.
Mr. Frink: — It is true that this clause does not specify the speed
limit, but when you, at the request of the Contractor, do lower your
speed, then you have to specify that speed limit. If the Contractor
asks for a reduction of speed, you ask the operating department to
put on a reduction, and then you have fixed the speed limit.
In answer to Mr. Campbell, I will say it is like this — if you put
a four-mile slow order on the train, and some trains go through at
eight miles per hour, if the Contractor can bring witnesses to testify
that the train passed over the structure at eight miles per hour and
his work was injured, then you are liable. It does not require a speed
of sixty miles an hour; it does not require a speed of more than six
miles an hour. It is simply a question of whether the Contractor can
get witnesses to testify that the speed of the train was greater than
the limit of the slow order and injured his work. This may in some
cases impose a hardship on the Contractor, but I think if you do not
put it in it may in more cases impose a hardship on the Railway
Company.
940 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
Mr. Albert Reichmann (Resident Engineer, American Bridge Com-
pany) : — I think the words, "reasonable reduction of speed will be
allowed," are sufficient. In my opinion the word "reasonable' takes
care of that.
Mr. John G. Sullivan (Canadian Pacific) : — The trouble with this
clause is this — that in case the Contractor asks for a certain speed and
the speed is exceeded, if anything happens, the Contractor will en-
deavor to make the Railway Company responsible. Would it not be
better to say "a reasonable reduction of speed will be allowed on the
recommendation of the company's Engineer?'' Leave it in the hands
of the Engineer, rather than the Contractor. He is responsible merely
for the work, and if the structure is going to fail by running trains at
sixty miles an hour he is not going to allow it.
Mr. C. H. Stein (Central Railroad of New Jersey) : — I favor the
clause just as it reads. I believe the point that has been raised is
practically covered by a succeeding paragraph which reads : "The
Contractor shall protect traffic and his work by flagmen furnished by
and at the expense of the Railway Company." It is the business of
the Contractor to see that these flagmen carry out their instructions
and hold the speed of the trains down to the limit placed on them
by the Engineer in charge and the operating department, so that I do
not think it is necessary to introduce any additional clause in these
specifications.
Mr. Porter : — I offer an amendment to read as follows : "Reason-
able reduction of speed, upon request of Contractor, can be provided for
in the contract."
The President : — That is so different from the amendment already
proposed that it cannot be received.
Mr. Porter : — The point I want to make is that in some contracts
you do not want any reduction of speed whatever, and you may require
the Contractor to take out the old bridge and put in a new bridge, in
between trains, without either stopping or delaying the trains. This
being a general specification, the contract let under this specification
entitles the Contractor to a reasonable reduction of speed if he should
so request.
(The motion was lost.)
. Mr. E. C. Brown (Carnegie Steel Company) : — Is it not a fact
that some railway companies do not admit of any reduction whatever
in the speed? It seems to me that this clause should take cognizance
of that fact.
Mr. Cartlidge : — I have practically the same answer to make to
Mr. Brown as I made to Mr. Baldwin, that the specification attempts
to cover all cases, and such clauses as apply to particular cases, which
are not required at the time of letting the contract, may be very readily
eliminated.
DISCUSSION. 941
The Secretary :— "5. If, under the contract, work train or engine
service is furnished the Contractor free of charge, such service shall
consist only in unloading materials and in transferring the same from
a convenient siding to the bridge site. Other engine service shall be
paid for by the Contractor at the rate of $ per day per
engine, the time to include the time necessary for the engine to come
from and return to its terminal. When engine service is desired, the
Contractor shall give the proper railway officials at least 24 hours'
advance notice and the Railway Company will furnish the service as
promptly as possible, consistent with railroad operations.
"When derrick cars are used on main tracks, their movements shall
be in charge of a train crew, and the expense of the crew and any
engine service other than as noted above shall be charged to the Con-
tractor."
Mr. A. S. Baldwin: — I think it is good practice to require the
Contractor to pay part of the cost of the work train service. Where
the full expense of the work train service is paid for by the Railway
Company, the contractors call for work trains where they could be
avoided and are negligent in letting them go, and I have made it a
practice to give a price for the service of the work train per day that
will about divide the cost between the Railway Company and the Con-
tractor.
Mr. Cartlidge : — The Committee spent more time over that clause
than any other in the specification. It is a very difficult one to cover.
The practice is very widely variant on different roads, and we have
this further point to consider: In making a specification, if the speci-
fication does not set forth the conditions under which the Contractor
must make his bid, he is likely to add something for good measure to
cover the question at issue : in other words, if he has an indefinite
amount of train service to pay for, he will put in his estimate a flat
price sufficient to cover all that he will have to pay, and it is necessary
in a general specification either to put all of it at the expense of the
Railway Company or all of it at the Contractor's expense. It will be
very easy to amend these specifications for particular cases, but it would
be very difficult so to word them as to provide for all cases which may
arise in practice.
The Secretary : — "6. When transportation of equipment, materials
and men is furnished free over the Railway Company's line, it shall be
subject to such conditions as may be stated in the contract."
Mr. Edwin F. Wendt (Pittsburgh & Lake Erie) : — I do not wish
to oppose this section, but I rise to state that for some years our
company followed the practice of furnishing free transportation for
materials and work train service. There is so much difficulty in con-
nection with this practice that we found it convenient to abolish it,
and at the present time we compel all contractors to bid on just one
condition, namely, the bid shall include all transportation of both men
and materials and all cost of work train service. Where this practice
942 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
can be followed, the Engineer has a great deal less trouble in connec-
tion with his field work and his accounts, and I believe this is the
practice to which we are rapidly tending in our country to-day.
The Secretary : — "7. The Railway Company will furnish all ma-
sonry to correct lines and elevations, and, unless otherwise stated in
the contract, will make all changes in old masonry without unneces-
sarily impeding the operations of the Contractor. The Railway Com-
pany's engineers will establish lines and elevations and assume re-
sponsibility therefor, but the Contractor shall compare the elevations,
distances, etc., shown on plans, with the masonry as actually constructed
as far as practicable, before he assembles the steel. In case of dis-
crepancy, he shall immediately notify the Engineer.
"8. Cars containing materials or plant shall be promptly unloaded
upon delivery therefor, and in case of failure to do so the Contractor
shall be liable for demurrage charges. Material shall be placed on skids
above the ground, laid so as not to hold water, and stored and handled
in such a manner as not to be injured or to interfere with railroad
operations. The expense of repairing or replacing material damaged by
rough handling shall be charged to the Contractor. The Contractor,
while unloading and storing material, shall compare each piece with
the shipping list and promptly report any shortage or injury discovered.
"9. When traffic is to be maintained it will be carried on in such a
manner as to interfere as little as practicable with the work of the
Contractor.
"Changes in the supporting structure or tracks required during
erection shall be at all times under the direct control and supervision of
the Railway Company."
The Secretary: — "10. Unless otherwise specified, metal work in
the old structure shall be dismantled without unnecessary damage and
loaded on cars or neatly piled at a site immediately adjacent to the
tracks, and at a convenient grade for future handling, as may be
directed. When the structure is to be used elsewhere, all parts will be
matchmarked by the Railway Company ; when the old bridge is com-
posed of several spans the parts of each shall be kept separate.
"11. Material shall be handled without damage. Threads of all
pins shall be protected by pilot and driving nuts while being driven in
place.
"Light drifting will be permitted in order to draw the parts to-
gether, but drifting for the purpose of matching unfair holes will not
be permitted. Unfair holes shall be reamed or drilled.
"Nuts on pins and on bolts remaining in the structure shall be
effectively locked by checking the threads.
"All splices and field connections shall be securely bolted prior to
riveting. When the parts are required to carry traffic, important con-
nections, such as attachments of stringers and floor beams, shall have at
least fifty (50) per cent, of the holes filled with bolts and twenty-five
(25) per cent, with drift pins. All tension splices shall be riveted up
DISCUSSION. 943
complete before blocking is removed. When not carrying traffic, at
least thirty-three and one-third (33 J/3) per cent, of the holes shall have
bolts.
''Rivets in splices of compression members shall not be driven until
the members shall have been subjected to full dead load stresses. Rivets
shall be driven tight. No recupping or calking will be permitted. The
heads shall be full and uniform in size and free from fins, concentric
and in full contact with the metal. Heads shall be painted immediately
after acceptance.
"Rivets shall be uniformly and thoroughly heated and no burnt
rivets shall be driven. All defective rivets shall be promptly cut out
and redriven. In removing rivets the surrounding metal shall not lie
injured; if necessary, the rivets shall be drilled out."
M'r. Earle: — The fourth paragraph of section 11 reads: "All splices
and field connections shall be securely bolted prior to riveting. When
the parts are required to carry traffic, important connections, such as
attachments of stringers and floor beams, shall have at least fifty (50)
per cent, of the holes filled with bolts and twenty-five (25) per cent.
with drift pins." I think 50 per cent, with drift pins and 25 per cent,
with bolts will give better results. Drift pins absolutely fill the holes,
and if you have drift pins and bolts, both in the same splice, the drift
pins will carry all the stresses, as they are the only ones actually in
contact.
Mr. Cartlidge: — I think it is conceded that not all rivets fill all
the holes and that a good many of our structures are being carried on
friction.
Mr. Earle: — If the drift pins fill the hole, that is the first thing
which will be affected. The hole is absolutely filled with the drift pin
and the bolt cannot offer any frictional resistance until the drift pin
begins to move.
Mr. Cartlidge : — The style of drift pins with which I am familiar
are tapered and the largest diameter of the drift pin is the diameter of
the rivet hole, and that diameter occurs in only one place in the length
of the drift pin. It is a little difficult to see how such a pin can be
any better than a bolt ; that is, a tapered drift pin in a cylindrical hole.
Mr. Selby : — These specifications are intended to represent recom-
mended practice, and to a great extent common practice, and I would
ask Mr. Earle if he knows of it being common practice to use two-thirds
drift pins and one-third bolts?
Mr. Earle : — That is practically the way we do work where we
carry heavy traffic. It is seldom we have to carry heavy traffic on
steel work of that kind, but, where we do, that is the way we do it,
if it has the approval of the Engineer.
As far as the drift pin is concerned, quite a distance of the upper
end of the drift pin is cylindrical, and it is always driven so far that
the cylindrical part of the drift pin will be entirely in the hole.
Mr. Cartlidge :■ — It is the opinion of the Committee that it is diffi-
944 IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
cult to insure that the cylindrical part of the drift pin shall coincide
with the cylindrical part of the hole. But I will state that the opinion
of the Committee is, as far as common practice goes, the bolts should
be the larger proportion and the drift pins in the minority, and that
this practice represents the better practice followed by the railways.
The Secretary: — "12. Correction of minor misfits, and a reasonable
amount of reaming shall be considered as a legitimate part of the
erection.
"Any error in shop work which prevents the proper assembling and
fitting up of parts by the moderate use of drift pins, and a moderate
amount of reaming and slight chipping or cutting shall be immediately
reported to the Engineer and the work of correction done in the
presence of the Engineer, who shall check the time expended.
''The Contractor shall render an itemized bill for such work of
correction for the approval of the Engineer.
"13. Holes for all anchor bolts, except where bolts are built up
with the masonry, shall be drilled by the Contractor after the metal is
in place and the bolts shall be set in Portland cement grout.
"14. Bed plates resting on masonry shall be set level and have a
full even bearing over their entire surface; this shall be attained by
either the use of Portland cement grout or mortar, or by tightly ram-
ming in rust cement under the bed plates after blocking them accurately
in position.
"15. The * will frame and place the per-
manent timber deck.
"16. The paint will be furnished by * and
shall be of such color, quality and manufacture as may be specified.
"Surfaces inaccessible after erection, such as bottoms of base plates,
tops of stringers, etc., shall receive two coats of paint before assembling
in place. After erection, the entire structure shall receive two coats of
paint, allowing enough time between coats for the first coat to dry
before applying the second. No paint shall be applied in wet or freezing
weather, nor when the surface of the metal is damp. Painting shall be
done in good and workmanlike manner, subject to strict inspection dur-
ing progress and after completion, and in accordance with special in-
structions which shall be given by the Engineer. All metal shall be
thoroughly cleaned of dirt, rust, loose scale, etc., before the paint is
applied.
"17. The Contractor, after completion of the work of erection, shall
remove all old material and debris resulting from his operations and
place the premises in a neat condition.
"18. During the entire progress of the work the Contractor shall
have a competent superintendent in personal charge and shall employ
only skilled and competent workmen. Instructions given by the En-
gineer to the superintendent shall be carried out the same as if given
to the Contractor. If any of the Contractor's employes by unseemly
♦Insert "Railway Company" or "Contractor" as the case may be.
DISCUSSION. 945
or boisterous conduct, or by incompetency or dishonesty, show unfitness
for employment on the work, they shall, upon instructions from the
Engineer, be discharged from the work, nor thereafter be employed
upon it without the Engineer's consent.
"19. The work of erection shall at all times be subject to the
inspection and acceptance of the Engineer.
"20. The Contractor shall assume all responsibility for loss or
damage to his own work, materials or plant, due to any cause ; also,
for all loss or damage to the Railway Company's materials or property,
and to other property adjacent to the railroad, due to causes within
his reasonable control.
"The Contractor shall assume all responsibility for injury to the
workmen and the public, or to any individual ; and in case of accident
or suit he shall defend the suit in person and relieve the Railway
Company from all costs and expenses, and pay any judgments that
may be recovered thereon.
"The Contractor shall comply with the laws and ordinances affecting
the manner of doing work; shall take out all necessary permits and
comply with their requirements, and shall take such precaution as may
be necessary to protect life and property."
Mr. Cartlidge : — After talking this last section over with the Com-
mittee, I move the elimination of section 20 from the specification, as
it is properly a clause of the contract and not of the specification.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "21. The Contractor shall carry such liability in-
surance as is necessary to protect himself and the Railway Company
against loss or damage caused by injuries to his men, and shall furnish
the Railway Company a bond in form and of a surety acceptable to
the Railway Company, providing for the faithful performance of the
work and all matters pertaining thereto, in such sum as shall be speci-
fied in the contract."
Mr. Cartlidge : — The Committee wishes to move the elimination of
section 21 also on the same ground.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary : — "22. The term "Engineer," as used herein, shall
be understood to mean the Chief Engineer of the Railway Company, or
his accredited representative."
The President: — These proposed specifications are now before you
for action.
Mr. Wendt : — I move that these specifications be approved for
publication in the Manual under "General Rule 16-g."
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Cartlidge: — I move that the report of the Impact Committee
be received as information.
(The motion was carried.)
The President :— The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of
the Association.
DISCUSSION ON WOODEN BRIDGES AND TRESTLES.
(For Report, see pp. 77-SO.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON WOODEN BRIDGES AND
TRESTLES.
G. A. Mountain. C. C. Wentworth.
The President: — The report of the Committee on Wooden Bridges
and Trestles will next be disposed of. Mr. C. C. Wentworth, the
Chairman, will make the opening statement.
Mr. C. C. Wentworth (Norfolk & Western) : — Mr. Chairman and
gentlemen, the work assigned to the Committee last year was, first,
to report on the formulas for use in determining the strength of
sheet piling; second, to report on equipment required for pile driving;
third, to collect information on special methods of driving sheet
piles in cofferdams where conditions do not permit the use of ordinary
equipment; fourth, to collect information on actual experience on the
bearing power of piles and on the practical results of the use of
formulas; fifth, to report on the use of guard rails for wooden bridges
and trestles; sixth, to report on fire protection of wooden bridges
and trestles. Of the above subjects those numbered i, 4, 5 and 6
were considered. It seemed to the Committee that the pressure
against steel sheet piling in place was something that was yet to be
determined, and I am glad to be able to say that Cornell University
is about to undertake a series of experiments to determine just what
that pressure is. The experiments which they will undertake are
not precisely those given on pp. 78 and 79, of Bulletin 141, but along
different lines. This the Committee is not at all objecting to, because
it gives the problem an additional point of attack; and the more
points of attack we can give it the better. As for collecting informa-
tion on the other three subjects, I beg to say a very large amount
of data has been brought together. This has been formulated and
tabulated and put in shape for the use of the Committee during the
coming 3rear, but the present Committee does not wish to make any
recommendation to this meeting for its adoption. I make a motion,
then, to receive our report as a progress report and information.
The President: — Would anyone like to say anything on either
of these subjects mentioned by the chairman?
Mr. G. A. Mountain (Canadian Railway Commission): — Does this
include the whole of the report?
The President: — Yes; you can make remarks on any subject.
Mr. Mountain: — Under subject 5, I would like to ask for informa-
tion, whether that is a necessity where oil-burning engines are used.
Mr. Wentworth: — Mr. Mountain, as we have simply adopted this
as a progress report, I think we had better not take the matter up in
detail.
The President: — Tt would be perfectly proper to answer accord-
ing to your individual opinion if you liked.
(The motion was then carried.)
The President: — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of
the Association, 946
DISCUSSION ON YARDS AND TERMINALS.
(For Report, see pp. 89-92.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON YARDS AND TERMINALS.
C. E. Lindsay. C. H. Spencer.
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on
Yards and Terminals, of which Mr. C. H. Spencer is Chairman. The
Chairman of the Committee will make the preliminary announcement.
Mr. C. H. Spencer (Washington Terminal Company) : — The Com-
mittee on Yards and Terminals have done a great deal of work this
year in the collection of data on three of the subjects assigned to
the Committee: (i) report on typical situation plans for passenger
stations, etc.; (2) report on developments in the handling of freight
by mechanical means; (3) report on developments in the design and
operation of hump yards.
The information received was of such a nature that it was thought
best to hold this over for a future report, a portion of which is to be
written in the coming year.
The work presented to the Association this year is in tue way of
a report on subject (4), report on typical situation plans for a division
engine terminal, which will be found on page 91. The Committee is
a large one, representing about seventeen or eighteen different roads,
and naturally a great deal of discussion occurred on this subject and
the report presented is the boiled-down opinion of the Committee
after the examination of a large number of plans of engine terminals
that were presented for the consideration of the Committee.
The Secretary: — "(1) The engine terminal should be so located
as to afford easy access to both Main Line and Yards, with the fewest
possible reverse or conflicting movements."
Mr. Spencer: — I move the adoption of conclusion No. 1.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "(2) The facilities provided should be arranged
to permit of the most direct and rapid handling of an engine in its
terminal in the order of its needs."
Mr. Spencer: — I move the adoption of conclusion No. 2.
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River): — I
agree with the conclusion except it does not state in what order of
needs the facility should be provided.
The President: — It is very general.
Mr. Lindsay: — The Committee provides that coal shall be taken
when going out. From a motive-power standpoint that is desirable,
947
948 YARDS AND TERMINALS.
but from an operating standpoint and considering the question of
time after the engine is ordered, it is desirable to coal an engine
coming in, so that there will not be any necessity for its delay after
it is ordered in going to its point of departure. The plan does not
provide any facility for coaling an engine coming in, and if the plan
was modified so that it might be possible to coal the engine coming
in or going out, in the same manner that they take water coming in
or going out, the conclusion would be much more desirable.
The President: — This is simply offered as information, and the
conclusions need not affect the plan at all.
Mr. Spencer: — I call attention to the fact that provision is made
in the plan for coaling on the inbound track ? one track is placed next
to the coal wharf for that purpose.
Mr. Lindsay: — Side coaling arrangement?
Mr. Spencer: — Yes.
(The motion to adopt conclusion 2 was put to vote and carried.)
The President: — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of
the Association.
DISCUSSION ON BALLAST.
(For Report, see pp. 95-300.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON BALLAST.
H. E. Hale. C. E. Lindsay. C. A. Morse.
Walter Loring Webb. S. N. Williams.
The President: — We will next consider the report on Ballast.
Mr. H. E. Hale is Chairman; Mr. Hale will please make the opening
statement.
Mr. H. E. Hale (Missouri Pacific): — The Ballast Committee would
like to have the Association approve the definition of "Depth of Bal-
last" first, and then the conclusions of the three sub-committees.
The definition is as follows:
"Depth of Ballast. — The distance from the bottom of the tie to the
top of the subgrade." (For definition of "subgrade," see Manual,
191 1, page 16.)
Prof. Walter Loring Webb (Consulting Engineer): — As a matter
of information, I would like to ask that the definition of sub-grade
in the Manual be read.
The Secretary: — "Subgrade: The tops of embankments and bot-
tom of cuttings ready to receive the ballast."
Mr. Hale : — The conclusion on page 97, proper depth of ballast
to produce uniform pressure on the subgrade, etc., I move be adopted.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. C. A. Morse (Santa Fe) : — Regarding this report, which is
based on the Pennsylvania experiment, on the value of cinders to
help make up the 24-inch depth of ballast, we had an experience ten
or fifteen years ago on a piece of line about twenty miles in length,
with a foot and a half or two feet of cinders for ballast. We covered
this with ten inches of slag ballast, and for at least four years we
were having to work on that slag ballast continuously on account of
the settlement of the cinders under it. While it showed up well as
an experiment, it did not show up well in practice with us.
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River) : — I
am sure the Committee, in using the words "cinder ballast," does not
preclude gravel ballast or better ballast?
The President: — No; the Committee would be glad to add gravel,
if that would tend to make it more acceptable to the Association. If
there is no further discussion, the question will be put.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Hale: — Under the heading of "Physical Tests of Stone for
Ballast," your Committee recommends:
"For the description of the physical tests of stone for ballast as
recommended by the Association and full instructions as to how the
samples should be obtained and shipped to the Government, see Pro-
ceedings of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of
Way Association, Vol. 11, Part 2, pp. 910-914, and report of Ballast
949
950 BALLAST.
Committee of 1912. If blueprints of the machines used in making the
tests are desired, they can be obtained from the Department of Agri-
culture, United States Government, Washington, D. C."
Mr. Chas. S. Churchill (Norfolk & Western) :— While I think that
this test may be all right, it is one that the railroads cannot ordinarily
make, because they do not have ready at hand a diamond drill of
this size, and do not have the means of cutting this core required in
the test. We have been conducting, for several years, a test by means
of cubes cut with a chisel and the relative strength of every stone
can be determined in that way, just as well as it can by means of
the cores. Therefore, while I do not wish to suggest that this test be
not agreed to, I think there should be some latitude given for another
form of compression test, such as can be readily made by any rail-
road without going to the Government.
Mr. Hale: — The physical tests of stone which are recommended
in the Manual are covered by a description in the Proceedings of the
Association and are made by the Government at Washington. They
were originally started for testing material for wagon roads, and
they were the most complete set of physical tests for stone that your
Committee could find, and the fact that the Government makes them
at Washington for any railroad or corporation or individual free of
charge by sending the sample to the Government, made it, in the
opinion of the Committee, very advantageous to accept these tests
as described by the Government for use by the Association. It
makes a very uniform test and is readily comparable with other
stone known to the railroads. A sample of stone desired by Govern-
ment for test is easily obtained by following the proposed instructions
in the Manual.
I move that that be incorporated in the Manual.
(The motion was carried.)
The President: — There are no further conclusions by this Com-
mittee, the one on page 102 simply being a recommendation in regard
to the continuance of the work. Would any member like to ask any
questions of the Committee? If not, the Committee will be dis-
missed, with the thanks of the Association.
Prof. S. N. Williams (Cornell College): — I would like, as a mem-
ber of the Committee on Ballast, to express the high appreciation
which the Committee has for the experiments made by the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad Company in reference to the necessary depth of stone
ballast, and if it is not too late I would like to have a resolution
passed, expressing our appreciation, as I know this matter has been
of great service to us, and is one of those things we cannot properly
reward in any other way. I personally feel very grateful to Mr.
Cushing and the company and also to the United States Department
of Agriculture for the help they have given us in our Committee
work. I make this as a motion.
(The motion was carried.)
DISCUSSION ON TIES.
(For Report, see pp. 301-370.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON TIES.
W. M. Camp. George W. Kittredge. C. A. Morse.
W. C. Cushing. C. E. Lindsay. W. L. Seddon.
L. A. Downs. Hunter McDonald. Edwin F. Wendt.
John C. Sesser. L. C. Fritch.
The President :— The, next report is that of the Committee on
Ties, of which Mr. L. A. Downs is Chairman. Mr. Downs will make
the opening statement for the Committee.
Mr. L. A. Downs (Illinois Central) : — Mr. Chairman, the Com-
mittee on Ties was assigned six different subjects to make a study of
and report, and we have reported on three. First, "the size of cross-
ties required for the stresses to which they are subjected," and the
conclusions to that are found on page 331. The second was, "tie re-
newals in continuous stretches vs. single tie renewals." The conclusion
to that is found on page 342, and the third one we reported on is "the
use of metal, composite and concrete ties ;" the conclusion of that is
found on page 370. I would suggest that we take them up in order.
First, "The size of cross-ties required for the stresses to which
they are subjected." We sent out circulars and were very much grati-
fied at the number of replies that we received, and you will find in
Exhibit F, which commences on page 312 and ends on 329, some valua-
able information from members of the Association who replied to our
questions and gave their experiences on different phases of the subject.
On page 331 you will find our conclusions, which I will read :
"So far as your Committee is able to determine it is not feasible to
lay down any fixed rule for the size and spacing of ties based on the
A, B and C classification of density of traffic, for the following reasons,
each of which in itself has a certain definite restriction, as well as an
interrelation with all others, viz. :
"(1) Character of subgrade varies radically on the same road and
in different parts of the country.
"(2) Kind of ballast varies widely.
"(3) Necessary depth of ballast varies with weight of axle loads,
as well as density of traffic.
"(4) Necessary distance between face of ties varies with weight of
axle load, as well as density of traffic.
"(5) Kinds of timber used for ties vary in different sections of
the country.
"(6) Width of base rail for weight of rail) and use of tie-plates.
951
952 TIES.
"(7) Treated or untreated ties, crushing stress and durability.
"(8) Amount of labor spent on track maintenance.
"(9) Drainage.
"However, in general it may be considered good practice for Class
A and perhaps B roads to space ties 10-in. to 12-in. face to face; the
width of tie is not so important if 10-in. to 12-in. spacing face to face
is followed; provided, however, the minimum width of face of tie
is limited to 7 in."
I move the adoption of the conclusions.
The President: — The conclusions just read have been moved for
adoption.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) :— It occurs to me that
the Committee has left out a very important consideration in regard
to the stresses to which ties are subjected. I think they should give
us some information on what stresses ties are really being subjected
to with our heavy wheel loads, and before we adopt these conclusions
we ought to have some information on that line, and for that purpose
I think it would be better to refer the subject back to the Committee
for next year's work. The conclusions given are not definite and they
do not give us much information, except in the instance of the last
paragraph, and I doubt very much whether all the members of the
Association will agree with the Committee on the last clause of their
conclusion. There are many members who think that the width of the
tie is an important question, even if the spacing is 10 to 12 inches, and
it occurs to me that the conclusions as they now stand are hardly
suitable for adoption.
Mr. L. A. Downs : — The first nine paragraphs enumerated are
restrictions, rather than conclusions. The last paragraph is a con-
clusion that the Committee saw fit to make after taking into considera-
tion the nine reasons why a fixed rule cannot be set for A, B and C
traffic. It is a very hard matter to determine the stresses in ties, and
we enumerated nine objections, after carefully considering the proposi-
tion as to why a fixed rule cannot be adopted for the railways to
follow, and then we came to the conclusion in the last paragraph which
we have up for adoption.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — What I have in mind is this — in designing a
bridge we assume a certain load. In designing a track we assume
practically no load, and I think the time has come when we should
pay more attention to the designing of track structure, just as we do
to the designing of the bridge structure. We should assume certain
heavy wheel loads and ballast conditions and design the track structures
to conform to these, just as we do in the case of the bridge structure.
I assume that this is an important subject for the railways. I am of
the opinion that many of us think that the ties are too small, and are
being subjected to too heavy stresses, and we should have more in-
formation on that line.
DISCUSSION. 953
Mr. L.; A. Downs : — In designing a bridge you have something to
start out with ; you have an absolute foundation, which is solid. You
build the abutments and design the bridge for certain wheel loads.
You have absolutely known factors to work on. In designing a track
structure you must figure on subgrade, which is an uncertain quantity.
As we enumerated in these nine paragraphs, we cannot lay down any
fixed rule on account of the nine reasons given — the kind of ballast
varies, the depth of ballast varies, the kind of timber used for ties
varies, and there are various other reasons, and it is a very different
subject altogether from a bridge proposition, where you have to start
with some known quantity to work from.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I do not quite agree with the Chairman of the
Committee. We can assume conditions which we can hope to reach.
While the bridge structure is a different proposition, yet the principle
is the same. We can assume certain conditions of ballast, foundation
and load, and design the structure accordingly.
Mr. W. M. Camp (Railway and Engineering Review) : — I take
issue with M'r. Fritch. If he wishes the Committee to arrive at the
design of the tie by mathematical investigation, I think his proposition
is impracticable. Theoretical men have been trying to do that for the
past thirty or forty years, and they have made all kinds of assump-
tions, but I have never seen a result that seemed to be worked out
on practical considerations. In designing a bridge one has a truss or
plate girder which rests upon supports at two points and the remainder
of the structure hangs clear. In the tie we have nothing hanging free,
and the strength of the tie depends to a large extent on the stability
of the ballast or the earth supporting it.
Now, in reference to the conclusion as expressed in the last para-
graph, I agree with the Committee if they intend what is my under-
standing of it, and that is, that the width of the tie, so long as it is
up to standard size, is relatively not important. Of course, if it could
be construed to include a culled tie, I would not support the conclu-
sion ; but if the necessary wrords were inserted to make it understood
that the tie referred to is a tie of standard width of face, or larger,
then I would agree with the Committee.
Many times we find the tie spacing referred to as a certain dis-
tance from center to center. If the ties vary in the width of face,
that method of spacing is not a proper one. It results in a more
uniform bearing surface to space the ties from face to face, rather
than from center to center.
The President : — The Committee says it will admit that.
Mr. J. L. Campbell (El Paso & Southwestern) : — Many of the
railways are still carrying their track across steel bridges and wooden
bridges on wooden ties, and it seems to me if we should assume the
conditions which undoubtedly exist, or nearly exist on the bridges, we
might arrive at some conclusions along the lines which Mr, Fritch
954 TIES.
suggested. I believe it would be a good thing to determine just what
the unit stresses are in a case of that kind.
Mr. C. A. Morse (Santa Fe) : — In discussing this tie question,
and in figuring on adopting a resolution for the Manual, it seems to
me we should not put anything in the Manual except what would be
of particular benefit. We all know that we are up against the varying
conditions set forth by the Committee to start with, and their report
reminds me a good deal of the Underwriters' Code, which gives you a
lot of negatives, but does not tell you what you can do.
We are up against this proposition, but there are a lot of different
practices in vogue on the various roads, and it seems to me the Com-
mittee should take these conditions as they exist and investigate as to
what is the best practice on all the roads, or on the various roads,
and give a recommendation based on the best practice. As I under-
stand the conclusion offered by the Committee, it practically gives no
recommendation at all. I do not know how the rest of the members
use the Manual, but every once in awhile, when I get up against some-
thing that causes me trouble, I hunt up the Manual to see what other
people are doing. If I simply found the conclusion in the Manual as
given by the Committee, it would be of no value.
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River) : — I speak
in support of the position taken by Mr. Fritch. Assuming a stable
condition of subgrade and a desirable condition of ballast, the maximum
spacing of the ties would be determined by the height of rail and the
weight of it. The minimum condition would be established largely by
the method of track work and kind of tool used for tamping. Between
these two conditions there would be a wide range of possibilities. I
believe it is possible to assume conditions and determine with reason-
able accuracy what is the best type of construction.
Mr. John C. Sesser (Great Northern) : — I wish to say that we
have ties that have a face dimension of over 18 inches. I believe that
the size of the tie should be limited.
Mr. Edwin F. Wendt (Pittsburgh & Lake Erie) : — This proposition
may be stated in another way. There is a very practical matter which
comes before engineers. In one section of the country it may be said
that a standard tie is 6 inches by 8 inches by 8 feet long. In another
section of the country it may be said that the standard tie is y inches
by 8 inches by 8 feet 6 inches. The managements of railways are
demanding from time to time the reasons why it is necessary to pur-
chase the higher standard of ties ; that is, a tie 7 inches thick instead of 6
inches thick and one that is 8 feet 6 inches long, instead of 8 feet.
It would be very helpful to the engineers if this Committee would
approach this subject from the reverse standpoint from that which has
been followed and first determine the stresses to which various ties
are subjected and then draw a conclusion as to what size of tie is the
DISCUSSION. 956
most economical under the loads which prevail in the railway practice
of to-day.
Mr. L. A. Downs: — In Exhibit F you will notice in regard to
question No. n the variety of answers received to that question from
the different members of the Association who have given this subject
study. Exhibit D shows the various kinds of ties used by the differ-
ent railways and the number of miles on which a certain size of tie
is used, and the number of miles on which another size of tie is used.
Without having something definite to work on from the bottom, as we
have in bridge work, it is very hard to determine stresses in ties.
Of course, it is an easy matter to refer the report back to the
Committee for further consideration, investigation and report, but we
must have some foundation to work on, and I think the conclusion as
presented shows that we have considered something that is good practice.
The President : — I desire to make a statement on behalf of the
Board of Direction. In assigning this subject to this Committee the
Board had in mind that the report would be made on two lines, one
line which the Committee has reported on to-day and the other line
in harmony with what Mr. Fritch and Mr. Wendt have just stated. We
knew, of course, when the subject was assigned that it required a num-
ber of assumptions to come to any conclusion regarding a subject of
this kind, but because this subject is hard we did not consider that we
ought to balk at it. A great many European engineers have already
made studies on this line, and the Board thought it was about time
that the engineers in this country took it up and tried to furnish some
additional light.
It certainly is a very interesting study, and it will not do any harm
to have such a study made. In going over this matter yesterday the
Board mistrusted that a misinterpretation of the subject had been made
by the Committee, and they, therefore, proposed a rewording of the
instructions in line with what Mr. Fritch has already stated, namely,
that they would like to have a study of possible stresses in the ties,
and from that work to a rational design or size for a tie.
The Committee admits that they have been unable as yet to draw
any conclusion from the collection of facts sent by the railways. It
is, therefore, a very interesting subject for the Committee to pursue,
and the Board would very much like to have the Committee do that,
if the Association, after this explanation, feels that it is a good thing
to do.
(The President put to vote the motion for the adoption of the
conclusions on page 331, but the motion was not agreed to.)
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I move this portion of the Committee's report
be referred back to it for further consideration ; that it be received as
information as at present submitted, and that the Committee give
additional study to the subject along the lines of the remarks on the
subject.
956 TIES.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. L. A. Downs: — The second subject referred to the Committee
was "Tie renewals in continuous stretches vs. single tie renewals." We
sent out fifty letters to the different railways, asking certain questions
in connection with this subject, and we were much gratified to receive
thirty-five replies. The Committee considered these replies and came
to the conclusion which appears on the bottom of page 342 : "The
Committee recommends the practice of single tie renewals." I move
that the conclusion be adopted.
Mr. Hunter McDonald (Nashville, Chattanooga & St Louis) : — I
rise with a good deal of timidity to take issue with the Committee. I
did not receive the Committee's circular. If I had done so, what I
have to say now would have been printed in their report. I do not
think it is sufficient reason to adopt this method of tie renewal as the
policy of the Association simply because it is the common practice in
this country. The replies received by the Committee to its circular
and the statements of the Committee do not show that there have been
any very great or deep investigations as to cost and other factors. They
simply express the opinion that it is the best policy, without giving any
facts to back up that opinion. I think this habit, you might say, of
single tie renewals has grown up because of conditions for which none
of us are responsible — because the managements of the railways are un-
willing to incur the initial expense necessary to introduce another policy ;
in other words, if it should be shown to be desirable to have 12 inches
of ballast under your track, and your ties all put in at one time, on
given stretches of track, so that it would require very little work to
be done for five or six years, it would entail necessarily a large initial
expense, which would continue until the entire division had been so
overhauled. After that time, I am firmly convinced that the cost of
maintaining the track would be very much less than it is under the
present policy.
Another reason why this habit has grown up is because of the
waste of the remaining life in cross-tie that would come out under this
renewal plan. There would undoubtedly be ties in the track that would
last at least two years, and the Roadmaster would come along and
criticise the section foreman for taking it out. On the other hand, if
that tie was left in the track, in order to secure the additional length
of life, which would probably represent 30 cents in value left in the
tie, I believe it would require at least one dollar in labor to keep the
track in condition while the value of the tie was being extracted. The
labor thus expended is a concealed loss.
I realize that" this problem is one that depends on a good many
variable conditions ; among them are the life and price of ties, cost and
efficiency of labor, density of traffic, depth and condition of ballast,
condition of the underlying roadway and the standard of excellence to
which the track has to be maintained. I have endeavored to ascertain
DISCUSSION. 957
what the labor costs are for maintaining the track in accordance with
the plan recommended by the Committee. I have sought from our
own accounts and from the accounts of other roads to find it out. I
have found an utter lack of uniformity in the method of keeping road-
way labor accounts, and it is simply impossible to make any comparison
between the present method and any other method. I think we need
a much closer analysis of our labor costs than we are now securing
under the Interstate Commerce Commission distribution of costs. I
think it would be well for our Committee on Records and Accounts to
endeavor to formulate some standard subdivision of roadway and
labor costs in order that' we may arrive at some definite knowledge by
which we may compare these things.
For the past eight or ten years one of our Roadmasters has been
very diligent in observing the small amount of labor required to main-
tain stretches of track on which all the ties had been renewed at one
time and he was so much impressed with the reduction in the labor
cost of subsequent maintenance of these stretches that he received
permission to try one experimental mile. That was put in in 1008, and
we were paying 40 cents for first-class white oak ties. The track was
laid with 80-lbs. rails; more than half the mile consists of 2-degree
curves running in opposite directions, with 450 feet of tangent between
them. The grades are slightly undulating. The freight traffic amounts
to 2,000,000 tons per annum, and there are ten regular passenger trains
per day, running at a maximum speed of 75 miles. The heaviest freight
engines weigh 346,000 lbs., with a maximum axle load of 48,300. The
heaviest passenger engine weighs 314,000 lbs., with a maximum axle
load of 51,300 lbs. There was 9 inches of clean ballast under the track
and a 3-inch additional lift was given. The cost was as follows:
3,000 ties at 40 cents $1,200.00
1,263 cubic yards of ballast at 50 cents 631.50
Labor putting in ties and ballast and dressing up 844.00
Total, per mile $2,675.50
A close account has been kept of the cost of maintaining this mile
of track. The section foreman has been given special instructions to
report each month the amount of labor expended in maintaining this
track in line and surface. For the first year the cost was $23; second
year, $29.80; third year, $35.20. We have just gone through the winter
of the fourth year, and estimate the total expense will be $50; the
fifth year we estimate at $75; and the sixth year, $110; in other words,
we do not expect to renew any of the cross-ties in that mile of track
inside of six years. This view, I think, is concurred in by a committee
of engineers from an eastern road who visited our line. The cross-
ties are all of first-class white oak. The average of the above figures
for the cost of maintenance of the track per annum for six years would
be $53-83-
958 TIES.
Assuming that this track would run six years without any serious
overhauling, one-sixth of the initial expense to put it in would be
$445.83, and with the estimated annual expense for maintenance $53.83
would give an average cost per annum per mile of $499.66.
We do not know how this compares with results on other roads
or even on our own line. We hope, however, to be able to tell you
something about it in the near future. Since this mile was put up the
results have been so encouraging that we are now carrying out the
same policies on 45 miles of stone-ballasted track on that division.
From the best information I can get I believe the cost per annum
of carrying out the policy recommended by the Committee, putting the
price on the same basis as I have stated with reference to this experi-
ment, would be about as follows :
Ties $154-44
Labor putting in 77.22
One and one-half inches of ballast every two years 118.50
Labor surfacing and applying ballast 250.00
Labor of maintaining 100.00
Total $700.16
This, as you see, would make a difference of about $200 a mile.
Naturally, we assume that the ballast is clean to start with. I have
taken no account of the fact that at the end of the first six years the
necessary raising of the ballast, after it is overhauled again, would not
require as much as three inches, and the annual cost would, therefore,
be somewhat reduced.
We lack some standard method of comparing the excellence of
our track. We can send a dynagraph car over the track, and get
some idea as to what the line and surface condition is, but if we
could devise some simple method of comparing the condition of the
tracks with some standard, it would greatly simplify the matter of
comparing cost of maintenance.
Mr. C. A. Morse:— In line with what Mr. McDonald said, I will
say that on the Santa Fe we have a stretch of 55 miles of what we
call an experimental track. Upon 22.5 miles we dug the track out
and laid the ties to face, as Mr. McDonald suggested. We put in 12
inches of rock ballast, used creosoted ties, 3,200 to the mile, 90-lb. rail,
and we have divided up our sections, so as to have them divide at
either end of this 22.5-mile stretch, with an idea of keeping an account
of the cost of renewals and repairs to see how it will compare with
the renewal of ties individually. It has rather struck everyone that
has looked at it that it may turn out that that will be the proper way
to carry on renewals. We expect to get at least ten years out of
these creosoted pine ties. On the basis that our rail has to be renewed
at the end of ten years, it has seemed to us that the proper way to carry
DISCUSSION. 959
on the renewal of ties would be to renew the ties to face at the time
you renewed your rail.
Mr. W. M. Camp : — I will suggest that there is abundant opportunity
at hand with almost any railway engineer to determine the relative
economy of the method of renewing ties in continuous stretches, with-
out going into specially conducted experiments. This opportunity may
be found on any piece of new track. On such track, after the roadbed
and ballast have become consolidated, there is an interval of several
years during which no tie renewals have to be made ; so that the ex-
pense of maintaining the track surface, with the disturbing element
of tie renewals eliminated, can be ascertained. This average yearly
expense should be taken in connection with the proportional yearly
cost of renewing all of the ties at one time, as soon as the conditions
may warrant; and in addition the expense of getting the track into
normal surface condition and the ballast into the normal state of com-
pactness, after the general overhauling; and in addition, still, the waste
of timber in ties thrown out that would do for further service. The
average annual expense of these various items, collectively, can then
be compared with the usual expense of maintaining track in timber
and in surface where the ties are renewed in patches, and solely with
regard to their condition, individually, as to decay.
Mr. W. L. Seddon (Seaboard Air Line) : — I think the results
mentioned by Mr. McDonald and Mr. Morse are predicated on a much
more uniform basis than the average railways get, and it seems to
me that their conclusions are not based on the average results secured
by the average railway. I think it is the uniform experience that when
a new track is laid, that it is a very much more expensive proposition
to keep this track in condition by renewing all the ties at one time
than it would be to replace the ties one at a time. In the South,
where we use pine ties and cypress ties, we begin to take out some
of the ties from the track four years after the track is laid, while some
of the ties remain in service fifteen years. I do not think it is fair
to criticise the Committee's results by comparing what they propose
with track laid with selected ties or treated ties. I think the Com-
mittee's conclusions are correct.
(The President put the motion on the adoption of the conclusion,
which was approved.)
Mr. L. A. Downs: — The third and last subject assigned to the
Committee was "the use of metal composite and concrete ties," and
the conclusions are given on page 370. I move that the conclusion
No. 1 be adopted.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. L. A. Downs : — I will state in regard to the second conclusion
that the Committee has not gone far enough in its investigations to .be
able to report anything definite, but the Committee has found that it
promises to develop.
960 TIES.
Mr. George W. Kittredge (New York Central & Hudson River) :—
I move that the conclusion be accepted as information.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. L. A. Downs : — I move that conclusion No. 3 be accepted
as information.
(The motion was carried.)
The President : — The Committee has furnished us with some very
excellent information, giving the experience of the railways with refer-
ence to different kinds of ties. It is extremely valuable. The Com-
mittee is dismissed with the thanks of the Association.
WRITTEN DISCUSSION ON REPORT OF COMMITTEE ON TIES.
Mr. W. C. Cushing (by letter) : — The report of the Committee on
Ties is always looked forward to by the members of the Association on
account of its interesting statement relative to the progress and develop-
ment in the use of concrete and metal ties, as well as for the treatment
of the other subjects embodied in it, and the report this year is no excep-
tion to the rule. Our information with reference to the concrete and
steel ties under examination from time to time has been brought down to
date.
The relative life of wcoden and iron or steel cross-ties is a subject
of much speculation, because no metal ties have been in use in this country
for a sufficiently long period to enable their life to be accurately deter-
mined, and consequently we keep looking to Europe, and especially to
Germany and Switzerland, where the metal tie is most widely used in
Europe, for information of that nature.
The writer, therefore, submits the latest note on the subject, taken
from the Bulletin of the International Railway Congress, No. 2, February,
1912:
"THE LIFE OF WOODEN AND IRON TRANSVERSE SLEEPERS.
By Mr. Cauer.
(Zeitung des Vereins deutscher Eisenbahnverwaltungen.)
"One of the most important advances made in technical matters is the
recognition that in determining the value of any technical system, one of
the most important considerations is its economy. Naturally we strive
for perfection in our designs. But even the most ingenious design is to
be condemned, if it does not prove economically satisfactory; there is no
justification for taking the technical point of view alone and declaring a
design satisfactory, if it is not so from the economic point of view as
well. Hence, it is very satisfactory if a question of very great economic
importance, such as the life of superstructure materials and especially of
transverse sleepers, is brought nearer to solution, as has been done by
the work of Mr. Biedermann, permanent way and traffic inspector in Ger-
many. Short particulars of his first paper in the Organ fur die Fort-
schritte des Eisenbahnwesens and of a more detailed lecture to the
Verein fiir Eisenbahnkunde have already been published in the Zeitung
des Vereins deutscher Eisenbahnverwaltungen. Considering the great
importance of this question, we give a more detailed account of Mr.
Biedermann's investigations and their results, as described in the lecture
jn question.
DISCUSSION. . 961
"Mr. Biedermann takes as his basis that the superior superstruc-
ture is that which for an equal outlay gives the greatest advantages, or
that for which a greater outlay is justified economically by important
technical advantages. In this connection he considers more especially
the question of what are the most advantageous sleepers ; as regards this
point, technical opinion varies widely. While England, France, Belgium,
Holland and Austria, in short nearly all other European countries except
Switzerland, and also the United States of America, use wooden sleep-
ers nearly exclusively, the German railways have very extensively
adopted iron sleepers. But the different railway administrations in Ger-
many are also not unanimous on the subject. At the end of 1909 about 31
per cent, of the total track of the German railways was laid on iron
transverse sleepers. An important factor as regards this ratio is the
system of the Prussian-Hessian State Railway; 30.4 per cent, of its
track was on iron sleepers. The practice of the other State railway ad-
ministrations in this respect is noteworthy. While Saxony, Oldenburg and
Mecklenburg have no iron sleepers, except on experimental sections,
Baden, on the other hand, has iron sleepers nearly exclusively. Bavaria,
with a total of 12,000 kilometers (7,450 miles), has about 3,900 kilo-
metres (2,420 miles) laid on iron sleepers, and Wurtemberg, with a total
3,500 kilometres (2,175 miles), has nearly 1,800 kilometres (1,120 miles) on
iron sleepers, that is, more than half. On the other hand, Alsace-Lorraine,
with 4,400 kilometers (2,735 miles), has only about 350 kilometers (218
miles) on iron sleepers,, or 8 per cent. It is specially noteworthy that
Saxony, a busy industrial state with much traffic, follows the examples of
England and Belgium. These countries, although their iron works and
rolling mills are highly developed, still use wooden sleepers, which they
cannot obtain from their own forests, while Baden, poor in iron works, but
rich in forests, has since 1890 been adopting iron sleepers at a quicker rate
than even Prussia.
"The cost of procuring iron sleepers, even if we allow for the higher
value of the wornout sleepers, is materially higher than that of wooden
sleepers. Thus, for instance, according to Mr. Biedermann, the price of a
standard iron sleeper on the Prussian-Hessian State Railway was 6.55
marks ($1.64) in 191 1, while that of a standard pine sleeper, pickled with
creosote, was 4.20 marks ($1.05). The iron sleeper must accordingly
present great advantages, if this much higher expenditure is to be justi-
fied.
"Mr. Biedermann is now of opinion that in this respect the compara-
tive life of two different sleepers is a criterium of their technical value.
The life, he states, registers 'automatically and conscientiously the tech-
nical advantages and disadvantages together with the quality coefficients
which are to be used in a technical and also economical comparison. They
represent a summary of the incommensurable alleged or real technical
advantages and disadvantages.'
"These assertions go somewhat too far. Thus the more or less easy
or difficult maintenance of the gage and alinement of the track is of con-
siderable importance in determining the technical value of a system of
sleepers not only because this maintenance costs more or less, but also
because a track which is easy to maintain is on the average in better con-
dition for the traffic. Moreover, there are other considerations, such as
the nature of the ballast, which depends on the kind of sleepers used, the
greater or lesser stability of the track when a train passes, the suitabil-
ity for switches, the greater or lesser difficulty of using the sleepers again
when alterations are made, etc. ; all of these are of importance when con-
sidering the merits of the system, and they find no expression in a mere
statement as to the life. But subject to these limitations, we are able to
agree with Mr. Biedermann to this extent, that the life of the sleeper is the
962 TIES.
most important factor in determining whether the higher price of a system
of sleepers is justifiable, but it will also be necessary to consider the cost of
bajlasting and of maintenance.
"Mr. Biedermann next sets forth that it is not a question of the life
of a few specially favorable cases, but of the mean life of a given system,
and that we have hitherto had no information about this point. While
the limits of the mean life of wooden sleepers have been gradually de-
termined by observations made during the last seventy years in countries
in which there are railways, we have to depend, as regards the length of
life of iron sleepers, on a few isolated observations, or even on esti-
mates. Thus railway engineers have made estimates of the life of iron
sleepers varying between fifteen and fifty years.
"As against this Mr. Biedermann emphasizes that reliable figures can
only be obtained if a considerable length of track laid uniformly with
sleepers of one kind is kept under observation during a longer period of
years, and if the ratio is determined of the yearly replacement of sleep-
ers (reckoned as length of track) to the total length of the railway net-
work in question. For this purpose, Mr. Biedermann has devised a
graphic method, which he then applies to the figures concerning the lay-
ing and the maintenance of sleepers, published in the statistics of the Ger-
man Reichseisenbahnamt. In his calculations he uses, not the number of
the sleepers, but the length of track equipped with the sleepers in question.
"This graphic method, which the lecturer explained in detail with the
help of lantern slides, can only be briefly described here. As a basis the
simplified assumption is made that the track in question laid on uniform
sleepers has only been renewed once in course of maintenance. Laying
the sleepers and maintenance are represented by two curves whose ab-
scissae represent the time since the sleepers, in question were laid or main-
tenance began ; while the ordinates represent the total sleepers used up to
the time in question; in the case of the laying curve, the sleepers
originally laid; in the case of the maintenance curve, the sleepers
aised for maintenance. The ordinate of the maintenance curve is always
smaller than the ordinate of the laying curve for the same year, because
the sleepers laid during late years have not arrived at the period of regu-
lar renewal. If we consider a period of time from the point of view of
the sleepers renewed in it, then the last ordinate of the maintenance curve,
which represents the sum of all the renewals made during the period in
question, corresponds to an equal ordinate of the laying curve, a number
of years ago, which represents the sum of the sleepers laid up to the
period in question. In this the assumption is made that the renewal has
extended exactly over the period the laying curve covers up to the ordi-
nate in question. The mean center of the part of the laying curve extend-
ing thereto represents the mean time of laying all the sleepers ; the mean
center of the whole maintenance curve (up to the last ordinate) the mean
time of the renewals. Accordingly the horizontal distance between these
two mean centers represents the mean life of the sleepers which have been
replaced. In the case of the older tracks, sleepers were replaced two
or more times ; in these cases the method is supplemented by another
method, allowing for this repeated replacement, and there is also
a furthr supplementary method. In addition, special attention has to be
paid to the switch sleepers, and corrections or subsidiary calculations are
necessary when wooden sleepers have been replaced by iron sleepers or
vice versa, when the system of iron longitudinal sleepers was adopted and
when it was abolished, finally, also, in order to allow for the constantly
varying number of sleepers used per unit length of track.
"The lecturer then applied his method in order to determine the
mean life of the wooden and iron transverse sleepers used on the Prus-
sian-Hessian State Railway. He found that the mean life of wooden
DISCUSSION. 963
sleepers differed but slightly from that of iron sleepers, in fact, it was
slightly lower in the case of iron sleepers. In both cases it varied be-
tween about 15 and 20 years. Similar results were obtained when this
method was applied to the iron sleepers of the Baden State Railway.
"Mr. Biedermann himself remarks that these results are to be inter-
preted with caution. The wooden sleepers renewed include oak and
beechwood sleepers, formerly used in greater quantities ; moreover the time
covers the older years before the increasing traffic made the many im-
portant improvements since adopted necessary, such as the newer systems
of pickling, the use of treenails, reducing the spaces between sleepers,
using longer sleepers, fastening the rails more securely, etc. But accord-
ing to Mr. Biedermann the figure determined by him for the life of
wooden sleepers is especially lowered by the fact that he treats all the lines
taken over by the Prussian State Railway as newly laid lines, whereas
in reality the sleepers of these lines were already in part considerably
worn. On the other hand the life determined for the iron sleepers, which
in some cases is less than 15 years, is too low, for all the sleepers are in-
cluded which were used in the early years of experiment; now it is only
comparatively recently that the present heavy and good shapes are used
while, as in the case of wooden sleepers, the number of sleepers per rail
length is increased, and the quality of the ballast is also continually being
improved. Taking everything into consideration, Mr. Biedermann draws
the conclusion that the present creosoted pinewood sleeper, when hard
broken stone is used as ballast, will have a life of 18 to 20 years, and
that the life of iron sleepers will hardly exceed this. On the other
hand, the new iron ribbed sleeper should have a life of 34 years, taking
into consideration its higher price, and the more expensive fastenings and
ballast required, if it is to be economically equal to a wooden sleeper hav-
ing a life even of only 15 years. According to M'r. Biedermann, this de-
cides the economic contest in favor of the creosoted pinewood sleeper.
"Mr. Biedermann's statements met with much approval ; in opposition
to them, one speaker specially emphasized that it was only comparatively
recently that the original shape of the iron sleepers, which proved un-
satisfactory, was altered and more suitable designs were introduced, so
that the life determined by the lecturer was much too short, and that
the question of the economy therefore still remained an open one. The
following criticisms of Mr. Biedermann's researches may also be brought
forward.
"In the first place, what he only incidentally remarks must be em-
phasized, that his graphic method only gives the mean life of the sleepers
which have actually been taken out and renewed, not that of all the
sleepers laid. Hence, particularly in the case of lines where the sleepers
have not yet attained the longest age or even the average age of the kind in
question, it gives too low figures for the mean life, for the sleepers which
are renewed do not include just those which have the longest life. On old
lines this error it is true becomes reduced to a minimum, but it always
remains, so that it may be said that the Biedermann method always gives
too low values for the life, which in the case of old lines approach the
true values asymptotically. Now this fact must affect and have an un-
favorable effect, as regards iron sleepers, on the results of Mr. Bieder-
mann's investigations, for the newer designs of these sleepers have not
yet been in use during the period of time which may be estimated to
represent their average life, and accordingly there are probably still many
of them having a long life which do not at all appear in the calcula-
tions. On the other hand, Mr. Biedermann does not take into consider-
ation the cost of maintenance, which is greater, particularly the first few
years, with iron sleepers than with wooden sleepers, and accordingly is
unfavorable to iron sleepers in making an economic comparison. It must
964 TIES.
also be taken into consideration that during alterations wooden sleepers
frequently become useless which otherwise could still have remained in
use for a much longer number of years, while iron sleepers do not show
this disadvantage. It remains doubtful what influence the rebuilding of
stations has from this point of view exercised on the life of the iron and
wooden sleepers as determined.
"Finally, the statistics utilized by Mr. Biedermann give no informa-
tion about the reasons why the wooden and iron sleepers were renewed.
Wooden sleepers are, as a rule, finally taken out, also in the case of sid-
ings, if they have become so damaged by the traffic and by the repeated
fixing of the rails that the screws no longer hold. The question then
arises in the case of iron sleepers, to what extent the reason for renewal
was their becoming damaged in a similar way, to such an extent that they
became useless, and to what extent other causes were operative, which
could be removed or ameliorated by increasing the weight of the sleepers,
or improving their shape or the fastenings.
"But even if we assume that the life of iron sleepers as compared with
that of wooden sleepers should prove on careful investigation (which
would involve sundry other points which it would take too long to dis-
cuss here) to be considerably more favorable than as determined by Mr.
Biedermann, yet the difference as calculated by him is so great that in
comparing the two kinds of sleepers, the scale seems to turn strongly in
favor of wooden sleepers. Hence, it would be very desirable that the
administrations using iron sleeners on the large scale should give par-
ticulars of their experience, which would probably elucidate the reasons
why the sleepers were renewed and show what final conclusions can be
drawn so as to settle the problem of the sleepers."
DISCUSSION ON TRACK.
(For Report, see pp. 371-386.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON TRACK.
F. J. Bachelder. C. H. Ewing. C. A. Morse.
J. B. Berry. L. C. Fritch. H. T. Porter.
Geo. H. Bremner. J. B. Jenkins. L. S. Rose.
W. M. Camp. George W. Kittredge. J. A. Spielmann.
J. L. Campbell. C. E. Lindsay.
The President :— The next report is that of the Committee on Track,
of which Mr. J. B. Jenkins is Chairman. Mr. Jenkins will make the pre-
liminary statement for the Committee.
(Mr. Jenkins read the preliminary statement of the report, and
said:)
Mr. J. B. Jenkins (Baltimore & Ohio) :— Your Committee has re-
vised the plans for Nos. 8, n and 16 Rigid Frogs, No. n Spring Frog
and for n-ft., i6J/2-it, 22-ft, and 33-ft. switches and submits them for
adoption as general plans representing good practice.
Your Committee has also revised and combined the "General Speci-
fications for Frogs, Crossings and Switches," adopted by the convention of
1910, and the "General Instructions for Ordering or Contracting for Frogs,
Crossings and Switches," submitted to the convention of 191 1 and received
as information, and submits them for adoption as representing good
practice.
At the convention of 1909, the Association instructed the Track Com-
mittee to recommend three standard lengths of switches and three stand-
ard numbers of frogs ; such a recommendation was made, with the modifi-
cation that a fourth length of switch was added for special cases requir-
ing frogs of large angle ; the recommendation was embodied in Conclusion
(4) of your Committee's report, which was adopted by the convention of
1910, but was referred back to the Committee by the Board of Direction
for reconsideration.
Your Committee reconsidered and reaffirmed its former action; the
conclusion was not resubmitted, however, excepting as the proposed lengths
of switches and numbers of frogs were embodied in the "General In-
structions for Ordering or Contracting for Frogs, Crossings and Switches."
which was received only as information by the Association at the con-
vention of 191 1.
In determining the lengths of switches your Committee considered it
necessary to provide for the following general classes of turnouts:
(a) Turnouts to be operated over the divergent route at the maxi-
mum practicable limited speed.
965
966 TRACK.
(b) Main line turnouts and crossovers to be operated over the di-
vergent route at low speed.
(c) Yard turnouts.
(d) Turnouts requiring frogs of large angle.
With regard to the second and third subjects assigned to the Commit-
tee, the Committee has been studying the question of track fastenings
and has made good progress, but has nothing as yet to report.
In regard to the third subject, "Study Designs for Main Line Turn-
outs," we considered it necessary to hold that subject in abeyance pend-
ing the adoption of three standard numbers of frogs and three standard
lengths of switches, provided it is the wish of the Association to adopt
such standards. If the Association wishes to adopt a greater number of
standards, the Committee will prepare designs in conformity with those
standards, and then the range of our study will be much larger.
On the first subject we originally submitted the plans for frogs
and switches as a part of the specifications, but there has been some ob-
jection on the part of some members of the Association on account of
the plans being in too great detail, and on the part of others because they
are not in sufficient detail. Part of the Association considered that the
plans should not be a part of the specifications, another part, apparently,
thought the specifications should be accompanied by complete and detailed
plans. The Committee, at the last convention, submitted plans for these
frogs and switches, which we have subsequently gone over carefully
and revised ; we also revised and combined the "General Specifications for
Frogs, Crossings and Switches," which were adopted in 1910 with the
"General Instructions for Ordering or Contracting for Frogs, Crossings
and Switches," which were submitted in 191 1, and received only as in-
formation ; we now wish to submit them for adoption. We wish to sub-
mit the specifications and the plans separately.
At the request of the President, the Committee will ask action on
conclusion No. 2, that the plans of No. 8, No. 11 and No. 16 rigid frogs,
No. 11 spring frog and 11 ft., \6l/2 ft.. 22 ft., and 33 ft. switches be
adopted as general plans representing good practice. We ask action on
this under Rule 16-g. The adoption of these plans has no bearing on
conclusion No. 3, which recommends these frog numbers and lengths of
switches. The adoption of conclusion No. 2 only carries with it the rec-
ommendation of these plans for these frog numbers and lengths of
switches. The plans, it may be stated, are general plans, principally for
dimensions. I move that conclusion No. 2 be adopted with recom-
mendation to publish in the Manual.
(The motion was seconded and carried.)
The President : — It is open for discussion.
Mr. J. L. Campbell (El Paso Southwestern) :— Referring to the plans
for the 33-ft. switch on page 385, as a matter of information, I would
like to ask if the Committee came to any conclusion in relation to the
joints in the main line rails. As far as I see, this plan does not show
the location of any of the joints; and also whether or not the Commit-
DISCUSSION. 967
tee has considered special rail lengths for these turnouts. How does the
Committee propose to handle turnouts in case the proper length does not
make up commercial lengths of rails? Where would the Committee put
the joints in the main line for this switch?
Mr. Jenkins : — -The Committee has considered both questions raised.
In regard to the joint for the 33-ft. switch, we consider that the best
practice would be to use a 60-ft. stock rail.
The President: — Any additional remarks on this motion?
Mr. Jenkins : — The plans for the switches are general plans and are
the ones the Committee had in mind in drawing up the specifications, al-
though we wish to detach them from the specifications. The specifica-
tions say, "Heel blocks shall be of approved design, with standard rail
drilling." The plan itself says : "Filler of approved design." We could
not indicate more than one form of heel block on the plan, so we only
indicated the one shown.
Mr. J. A. Spielmann (Baltimore & Ohio) : — Mr. President, on page
381, first paragraph, .five inches is recommended for throw of switch. I
would like very much to know how the Committee arrived at this conclu-
sion. I think five inches is more than necessary and that 4l/2 inches is
quite sufficient.
Mr. Jenkins : — There is sometimes a little drag in the switch point
in throwing the switch, especially with the longer switches ; this inter-
feres somewhat with the fiangeway, and with some of the heavier sec-
tions with the broader head, 4^ inches does not seem to be quite suffi-
cient and slA seems to be preferable. In other words, the switch rail
does not always take the same curve when the switch is thrown and does
not always leave the same distance between the stock rail and the back of
the switch.
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River) : — The draw-
ings on pp. 382, 383, 384, 385, all have relation to the drawing Fig. 2,
page 382, and you will note that the first pair of holes, 5 inches apart,
are 1J/2 inches from the point. That, I believe, is done at the behest of
some of our signal friends who desired to put on a modern type of front
rod for the locking apparatus at interlocking, and that requires alternate
spacing of ties. If it is safe to allow the switch point to project (as it
will for the use of the head rod of that type in those holes) over a foot
beyond the first rod, it would be better, it seems to me, to adopt the alter-
nate spacing of ties shown here, rather than the primal one, because it
would be safe to fasten a head rod at these first pair of holes and between
the ties. I do not consider the alternate spacing of the ties shown on
the plans as necessary in any way whatever, and it is objectionable be-
cause it necessitates a change in these ties when changing from a hand-
thrown switch to an interlocked one. The plates on the first two ties
are also unnecessarily long.
Mr. Jenkins : — We do not think that all roads would want the first
spacing of ties shown, but some of them would prefer the alternate spac-
ing, so we have shown both of them qn the plans for that reason. If
968 TRACK.
any road desires lo use the first spacing for interloeKed switches and
considers that the hest practice, there is no reason why they should not
follow that spacing throughout.
The President: — If there are no further remarks, the motion will be
put on the adoption of this resolution to go in the Manual.
(A vive voce vote not being definite, a rising vote was then taken,
as follows : In the affirmative, 23 ; opposed, 13, which caused hearty
laughter.)
Mr. Jenkins : — The Committee asks consideration of the third con-
clusion. This recommendation was made with full knowledge of the
consequences. We were asked by the Board of Direction, or rather by
the Association itself, to recommend three frogs and three lengths of
switches. We thought it necessary to include the fourth length of switch
for industrial sidings and other short turnouts, where such turnouts are
required. In recommending these three lengths of switches, with one ad-
ditional length for special cases, we took the 33-ftl rail as a basis and
took such fractional parts of that length as to cut the rail economically,
making the lengths 33, 22, i6l/2 and 1 1 feet. Our principal reason for
doing this is that we want the very best rail for the longest turnout, and
we can probably get the best rail by using a 33-ft. length. We will prob-
ably also want to specify that this rail shall come from a certain part of
the ingot. As to the frogs, we are perfectly aware, in recommending
No. u's, that there are very few of them in use at the present time and
that more roads use No. 10 than any other number of frog ; but if we
adopt a No. 8 for yards and No. 10 for main line turnouts, that only
leaves us one other turnout to use for both the low and the highest re-
stricted speed, and while the No. 11, with the 22-ft. switch point, will
answer for the low-speed turnout controlled by interlocking just about
as well as the No. 12, while the No. 16 will answer fairly well for the
highest restricted speed, because the deflection of an engine through the
lead of No. 16 is about the same as that through the 33-ft. switch point.
So the No. 11, if we are confined to three numbers, will answer the pur-
pose of the present No. 10 and 12, while the No. 16 will answer the
purpose of the 14, 15, 16, 18 and possibly the 20. As to the No. 8's : I
think the present practice for yard turnouts is tending very strongly to-
wards No. 8, so that our recommendation in that regard is not at vari-
ance with practice. Another reason for the No. 11 is that if we adopt a
standard for general use, we want to take that number of frog which will
give the most economical use of the rails, and if you will refer to the
table of practical leads in the Manual, you will find that a No. 11 is best
suited for that purpose.
Our Committee would like definite action on this, either adoption, or
rejection with further instructions, because our study of main line turn-
outs depends on your action on this conclusion. If the Association thinks
that three numbers of frogs are not sufficient, we will very gladly take up a
recommendation for a greater number ; but the Committee itself feels that
these three frogs are sufficient. Of course, every railway which uses No.
DISCUSSION. 969
io's would not want to tear out all the No. io's and put in No. irs; but
there is no necessity for doing so. When new work is laid out it can
be done with No. n's and eventually the railways will come to these
three standards, which will be economical standards. I move the adop-
tion of conclusion 3, and that the recommendation be published in the
Manual.
(The motion was seconded.)
The President:- — The subject is now open for discussion.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) : — Mr. Chairman, the
Chairman of the Committee has given me a suggestion in his remarks that
might make that conclusion acceptable, that in all new work, the length
and the switches, the numbers of frogs recommended by the Committee
be adopted.
The President: — New work and renewals?
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — No, not as broad as renewals — in all new work.
Mr. Jenkins : — The recommendation of the Committee itself is that
all new work should be laid out, so far as practicable, with these three
frogs, so as to effect the gradual elimination of frogs of other numbers,
lessen the cost of manufacture and decrease the amount of stock carried.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — Then I move it be included in No. 3.
The President: — There is no objection to putting those words in the
conclusion.
Mr. George W. Kittredge (New York Central & Hudson River) ***;>.,
I am not altogether satisfied with the reasons given why we should go
from No. 10 to No. 11. I know a great many roads that use No. 10 quite
generally, and it was only a few years ago that a No. 10 frog was consid-
ered one of the maximum numbers to be used in any location.
Mr. Jenkins : — It is in the lead that we use the rail to better advan-
tage. We have a 33-ft. rail and practically no cutting, with the No. 11
frog and a 22-ft. switch point. Take the No. 10 frog; for the best re-
sults we ought to have a slightly shorter switch point, somewhere around
20 ft. Of course there is not very much difference practically, but a
No. 11 frog with a 22-ft. switch point would give a little better turn-
out than a No. 10, and will give but little sharper turnout than a No.
12, which is now very generally used for low-speed turnouts which are
controlled by interlocking.
Mr. C. A. Morse (Santa Fe) : — I favor the motion, for the reason
that I think if we are going to work plans out, as the Chairman says,
and get results in regard to our frogs and switches, that we will have
to come to some standard. On our road we have been through
the agony of changing standards. We could not wait for the Associa-
tion and we adopted 8, 10 and 14. I think 8, 11 and 16 are all right.
In regard to Mr. Fritch's proposition to add to that a new frog, I do
not believe any road that has adopted a set of standards is going to
change them to go with this, but there are a good many roads, I pre-
sume, that are about up to the point where they will have to change
their standards, the same as we were a few years ago when we were
970 TRACK.
using 6!/2 and 9. We finally adopted 8, 10 and 14. I favor the recom-
mendation.
Mr. W. M. Camp (Railway and Engineering Review) : — 'What degree
of turnout curve results from the combination of a No. 11 frog and a
i6l/2-it. switch point?
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I want to offer the suggestion that conclusion 3
be subdivided into two parts, one governing recommendation in regard
to length of switches, and one in regard to number of frogs. It is pos-
sible that some can agree on the number of frogs, who would not agree
on the switches, and vice versa.
The President: — There is no objection to that; so the motion will
be revised to include frogs only. The Association will consider that the
motion is revised so as to include frogs only at the present time.
Mr. J. L. Campbell : — In that connection I wish to suggest that it
probably would be of interest to a great many members of the Asso-
ciation to hear from the engineers who have adopted and use a 33-ft.
switch rail.
The President : — We will wait until we come to that part.
Mr. Kittredge: — We have already adopted the plans for Nos. 8, 11 and
16 frogs. It might be a little inconsistent if we voted any other way than
to adopt the frogs.
The President: — We are not adopting the numbers in adopting the
plan.
Mr. Jenkins: — The No. 11 frog, with 22-ft. switch point, takes four
33-ft. rails for the lead curve, one of which is cut to 32.85 or i^ inches
cut off of one of the four rails.
Mr. Lindsay: — Is Fig. 2 adopted by our adoption of conclusion No. 2?
Mr. Jenkins : — It was not so intended. Figs. 1 and 2 are a part of the
specifications.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Jenkins : — I move that the Committee's recommendation in re-
gard to lengths of switches be adopted, with recommendation to publish
in the Manual.
(The motion was seconded and carried.)
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I move to amend the recommendation by specify-
ing the switches 11 ft., i6y2 and 26 ft.
(The motion was seconded.)
Mr. Jenkins : — It is the opinion of the Committee that 26 ft. does
not give quite a small enough angle for the highest restricted speed for
junctions; that we should use as long a switch point as possible, and
that in addition we want to use the full length of rail in order to have
every possible assurance of getting the very best rail for that switch
point. I would like to hear from Mr. Porter on that subject.
Mr. H. T. Porter (Bessemer & Lake Erie) : — Several years ago, when
the matter was brought before the Committee, they came to the conclu-
sion that for high-speed crossovers and turnouts, it was desirable to have
as long a switch point as practicable, under the conditions that we were
DISCUSSION. 971
working with. After conferring with the railmakers of this country we
found that 93 or 94 per cent, of the rail which they sent out was to a
standard of 33-ft. lengths. Now I suppose it is not necessary at all to tell
anyone who has had any experience with switches that if we could get
a switch point 100 per cent, better than anything we ever saw, it would
be a very desirable thing. Therefore, we felt that we should get the best
possible rail, considering every little detail. If you accept the 33-ft rail,
then you can specify just the part of the ingot it comes from. The rails
being rolled now are marked A, B, C, D, depending on whether the top
rail of the ingot, the middle rail of the ingot, or the last rail of the
ingot. So we can put it in the power of the engineers to specify where
that rail shall come from, and they can do that with the 33-ft. length
switch, or with switches made out of 33-ft. length rails. Five per cent, of
the rails are, as a rule, of shorter lengths, dropping down according to
the various specifications, either a foot at a time or two feet at a time. So,
if you have a 26-ft. switch, the chances are you will get it out of a shorter
rail. So much for the rail. Another object in having the longest rail
we could get was to make the curve in the lead as light as possible. In
France they are using now, at their junctions, a rail 39 feet and some
inches long, and they are using them successfully and are maintaining a
speed through the switches, even on the branch line, of 62 miles an hour
without a shock. That seems to be the tendency in France, and I believe
in some of the other European countries, they are making experiments in
the same direction. So we feel that we ought to at least go as far as 33
ft. in order to get as light a curve as possible.
After adopting the switch point that gave us the lightest curve in the
lead, it was figured out by one of the members of the Committee to put
the frog on a par with that condition, a frog that would give a curve pro-
ducing the same deflection as an engine passing through that point, and
it was found to be a No. 16 frog. So, for the purpose of getting the best
rail, the lightest curve, and to get a point that would give the same de-
flection as the curve of a No. 16 frog, we feel that we ought to use a 33-
ft. point. Furthermore, we feel that we ought to try, in a measure, to
keep pace with the other countries in trying to get leads whereby we can
obtain speeds the same as they are doing in Europe.
Mr. J. B. Berry (Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific) : — In looking at
the bottom of. page 386, I find five members of this Committee who do
not agree with this report, and I would like to ask the Chairman why.
It occurs to me that perhaps they have some such a reason as I would
suggest. We have passed a resolution here that we accept the plans for
the frogs as a whole. I think there are probably very few who would
object to Nos. 8, 11 and 16 rigid frogs, but some of us might seriously
question whether we wanted to adopt No. 11 spring frog. While the As-
sociation passed them altogether, it seems to me these five members had
something in mind as I have suggested. It may be unwise to commit this
Association to that type of a spring rail frog; others of us believe there
is equally as good, if not a better, spring rail frog, and it would seem
972 TRACK.
The President : — Mr. Berry, I do not think you are in order on the
frog question now. This is strictly on the switch points. The resolution
for the frogs has been passed.
Mr. Berry: — I thought the split switches were concluded. Here is
this
The President: — This is on switch points.
Mr. Berry : — What did those five members say about switch points,
those who dissented from the majority of the Committee?
The President: — Any remarks from the Committee?
Mr. Berry : — When I am in order, I wish you would put me right,
and I will start in again.
The President: — We will now adjourn and the remaining questions
will be taken up in the morning, on the length of switches, and also the
specifications.
(Adjourned until 9 o'clock a. m., Wednesday.)
The President : — The further consideration of the report of the Com-
mittee on Track will now be taken up. The consideration of the report
was suspended last evening while we were discussing conclusion 3 on
page 374, with reference to the lengths of switches and number of frogs,
and this question is now open for discussion. Mr. Jenkins, the Chairman
of the Committee, will continue the presentation of the report.
Mr. Jenkins : — The question was asked yesterday as to the particulars
in which the dissenting members of the Committee disagreed with the
majority; I did not have all the letters with me at that time, but I think
I have all the information here at the present time.
Mr. George H. Bremner disagreed, not in regard to the conclusions,
except that he wished the conclusions "presented" as representing good
practice, instead of "adopted" as representing good practice. He also
objected to some portions of the presentation of the facts in connection
with the choosing of the numbers of frogs and lengths of switch points,
evidently taking that part of the report as an argument. I did not have
that intention. I wanted to give the facts for and against rather than to
present an argument for the conclusions of the Committee.
Mr. Rote writes : "I am willing to agree that the report of the Com-
mittee represents good practice, but I am not willing to agree to a re-
port favoring the switch with the raised switch rail for the solid-plated
frog over flat switch and a frog on individual tie-plate. As you perhaps
know, our company (Lake Shore) uses the flat switch and does not use a
single solid plate under ordinary frogs, and, therefore, I do not approve
of the findings of this Committee in this respect."
Mr. Ray writes: "I am willing, of course, to go on with the Com-
mittee, assuming that the majority are in favor of the report as sub-
mitted. I do not agree, however, with the Committee on the recommended
length of switch for frogs over No. 14, that is, 33-ft. switch points. I do
not believe that the 33-ft. switch point is in every way practical. Your
plan does not indicate how the stock rail joint is to be made or where
it is to be placed. Furthermore, I do not see the advantage of a No. 11
DISCUSSION. 973
over a No. 10 frog for ordinary yard work. You are given permission
to sign my name to the report with the understanding that I do not agree
with the recommendations referred to above."
It may be stated that I do not think there is any disagreement be-
tween Mr. Ray and the rest of the Committee concerning the relative
merits of the No. 10 and No. u frog for ordinary yard work. The
Lackawanna uses No. 10 almost entirely for yards, while most roads use
7's and 8's, and some roads 6's, in similar places.
Mr. Bruner writes: "I subscribe to the Committee report, excepting
the detail drawings of frogs and switches and frog numbers."
Mr. Stevens writes: "In relation to the report of the Track Com-
mittee, I have crossed and marked out such portions of the proposed text
as in my opinion should be omitted and have signed a copy and returned
it to you by mail."
The portions marked by Mr. Stevens are several slight changes in
that part of the report which precedes the conclusions, and crossing out
three paragraphs on page 372 following "(d) Turnouts requiring frogs of
large angle." Mr. Stevens wished me to omit these three paragraphs as
not being a proper portion of the argument. As stated before, I consider
this as introductory rather than as an argument for the position of the
Committee. Mr. Stevens wanted the conclusion in regard to switch points
to read 22-ft. points for No. 10 frogs instead of 16^2 points. He wanted
conclusions No. 1 and 2 to read : "The Committee recommends General
Specifications, etc., as representing good practice," and "The Committee
recommends the General Plan, etc., as representing good practice."
His only objections are in regard to those two points mentioned. I
would like to state that the question of 33-ft. switch points has had a
great deal of discussion covering a period of about three years, in the
Committee, and the Committee is very nearly unanimous in concluding
that 33-ft. switch points are desirable. It is to be remembered that 30-ft.
switch points came into use when the longest rail rolled was 30 ft., and
it was not possible at that time to have a stock rail without a joint. Now
with the 33-ft. switch point we can very readily obtain a 60-ft. stock rail,
when it is desired to have an A No. 1 track. On the other hand I do not
think that the 33-ft. stock rail, with the 33-ft. switch point, will make
a bad job, or a job that you would be ashamed to have in your main
track at fairly high-speed points, if the switch is properly looked after.
Mr. Berry: — I hope I proved yesterday that I was a good soldier by
quitting when I got orders. It occurred to me, after thinking over the
matter, that perhaps the Chairman misunderstood what I said in the' be-
ginning of my talk yesterday, and that was that while the switch poims
were under discussion there were probably five members of this Com-
mittee who dissented from the conclusions of the Committee. We had
already voted and passed upon the question of frogs ; we had not heard a
word from the dissenting members, and we were rapidly approaching a
vote on split switch points without hearing from them. I discovered one
of the dissenting members on the floor of the house, and I asked him
974 TRACK.
afterwards why he did not go up on the platform, and he said, there was
no room. As a side issue, let us provide room for the members. He is
on the platform this morning, however. -
Mr. Chairman, with that understanding I did talk to the point about
switch points, but I had this in mind.
The President: — The Chair apologizes to the "good soldier."
Mr. Berry: — The Committee had said that the length of the switch
points was so bound up with the question of the numbers of frogs that
if you disturb one you would disturb the other, the vote had got past
frogs. In my opinion, I thought we ought to give the dissenting mem-
bers a chance to say something, and while I was not privileged to speak
about frogs, as it had passed, I took exception to some of the conclusions
and thought the dissenting members might have the same views in regard
to the matter, hence went into the frog question first. If I had started on
the switch points first and reached the frogs later, I suppose it would
have passed through. That was the reason why I thought the five dissent-
ing members ought to have something to say. This Association wants to
know everything there is about a subject, so that it can pass upon it in-
telligently. This Committee were intending to incorporate in the Manual
and Proceedings the recommendation in regard to frogs and split switch
points, with five dissenting members. To me it is a very important thing
what we put in the Manual. We, nearly all of us, in times of doubt, go
to the Manual or Proceedings to see what is best to do. As long as the
members of this Association do that, outsiders will do it. As an evidence
of the effect, of placing matter in the Manual, I would like to read from
the Chicago Record-Herald of this morning, under the title, "For Third
Rail Plan." It says :
"It is regarded as certain that the standard will be adopted, and its
approval will mean that every railroad in the country agrees to the specifi-
cations that have been prepared. At the present time some roads have
a third rail located several inches from the tracks, a number construct-
ing it at a low level, and others at a much higher level."
You can see what the newspaper says before these Proceedings ap-
pear in the Manual, and I know that a great many people outside of this
Association take whatever they find in the Manual as the best practice
and find fault with other people who do not.
I think we ought to let the five members say something or have their
views thoroughly understood.
There is another question. This report says that 55 per cent, of the
railroads — not of the mileage — use No. 10 frogs. They do not say any-
thing about the length of switches, but 15 feet is the usual length, so you
see there is over one-half of the roads in this Association still using a
No. 10 frog, with a split switch presumably 15 feet long. Is it justifiable
to go to a i6j4-foot split switch and incidentally a No. 11 frog? We
can readily see why we go to the shorter split switch and a No. 8 frog,
because we have had a great deal of trouble in maintaining a No. 7.
We can also understand why it is desirable to use a No. 30 or 33-foot
DISCUSSION. 975
switch with a 16-foot frog, because they are on high-speed lines, but a
i6j/2-foot split switch with No. 10 frog is a different proposition. We
have, none of us, had trouble maintaining them, and it is a question whether
we want to change from No. 10 to No. u frogs. It was not to find fault,
but I wanted these five members to have something to say, so that the
Association could vote upon it intelligently.
There is another important thing I would like to bring up. Every
railroad in this Association that has from 5,000 to 10,000 miles of rail-
road, has in stock anywhere from $5,000,000 to $io,oco,ooo in its supplies.
I think everyone will say that the storekeepers and the officers are con-
tinually objecting to getting so many different parts. If a No. 15 split
switch is good enough and a No. 10 frog, why add, even on new work,
No. 11? It makes simply so much additional material to carry in stock,
and I thought perhaps this might have been the opinion of the dissenting
members, hence I would like to have it clearly brought out by them what
their objections are, so that before the vote is taken on the split switches
we might understand their objections, and perhaps this Association would
like to reconsider its decision upon the frog question after they had heard
from the five members.
I like to abide by the decisions of this Association, but I am free to
confess, and one of the dissenting members said he thought that this was
not the best practice, there are a number of members in this Association
who feel the same way. If we are tied down to one thing, with only a
single illustration, it may embarrass some of us.
The President : — Do any of the members of the Committee desire to
say anything?
Mr. L. S. Rose (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis) : — I wish
I could talk like Mr. Berry— we could get by with this report. I think the
Chairman has explained the dissension of the dissenting members. He
has read the letters giving the reasons that they do not care to sign the
report in full. He has explained that it is not the question of the length
of switches, except in one case, it is some other detail. There is a little
difference of opinion as to how this report should be worded. It is a
large Committee and practically, as the Chairman says, agrees with the
exception of details. One of the dissenting members is here, and I sus-
pect he will talk for himself. It is not a question of safety. The lengths
of switches and the numbers of frogs are figured out, we think, on a scien-
tific basis. It is not anything very radical. It will not put anybody in
court if they do not adopt it, because it is a question of standards, not
of safety. We might have a switch that conformed to these standards
that would not be as safe as some switch that did not. It might be a
question of the size of the rail or some other detail. I do not think that
the safety question can be brought up, it is a question of design. Mr.
Berry also says that we carry large stocks. I submit that the frog and
switch stocks change very rapidly on a well-regulated railroad. They
are worn out. Also we were instructed to give a recommendation for
976 TRACK.
three lengths of switches, for three numbers of frogs, to keep the stock
down, so that when a road adopted this recommendation there would
be only three to carry and that would take care of all needs. We tried
to give four, but the convention said, "No, only three."
I further think that we have got the best three. No road need change
their standards if they do not care to, and they will not get into trouble
about it — but we think we have the best three. We can take care of junc-
tions the best that anyone can take care of them, up to our present art.
We might change our plan on switches a little; might have curved
switches, but we do not think we are up to that yet. The roads do not
want to carry so many different kinds in stock. They want a switch
that they can use anywhere. A few years ago, I think two or three, a
circular was sent out by the International Railway Congress, asking what
roads were increasing the speeds at junctions, and nearly everybody made
a report. The question of getting trains over the railroads and getting
them through junctions quickly, is important; it saves time. The 33-foot
switch will take care of that, the No. 16 frog will take care of it. We
have one for yards and one for yard turnouts, and I submit it is better to
take the recommendation of this Committee than to take some other
recommendation that has not been given study.
Mr. George H. Bremner (Chicago, Burlington & Quincy) : — This re-
port was very carefully considered by the Committee, and I think the
Chairman is to be congratulated that he got as near a unanimous opinion
from the Committee as he has, and that the Committee have come as
near together as they have in these conclusions.
There is no dissent in the Committee from the fact that the practice
recommended in these conclusions is good practice. Conclusion No. 1 is
unanimously agreed to. On the other two conclusions there is consider-
able difference of opinion, as you have heard, and a number of members
of the Committee do not agree that they represent the best practice, al-
though they all agree that they represent good practice.
Considering the number of frogs, it is very questionable whether a
No. 8, a No. 11 and a No. 15 will fulfill all conditions. It is not likely
there are more than two or three, if there are any roads in the country
that have frogs of these three numbers as their standard, not but many
roads have some of them as standards, but to use the combination as pre-
sented by the Committee would probably change the practice of every road
in the country to some extent. By a fuller study of the situation on the
various roads, a combination of frog numbers might be found which
would only change the practice of a part of the roads in the United
States and Canada, and still give fully as good results. The frog num-
bers recommended do not nearly represent the needs common to most
roads. The No. 15 frog, for instance, is not the only frog that is used
for terminals, nor can it be claimed as the best. Some roads use 20's, some
use 24's, some possibly 22's for their ends of double tracks and similar
places. Frogs lower than No. 8 are very common, in fact they are gen-
DISCUSSION. 977
eral in yards where it is necessary to save room and where the work is
done by switch engines, so that the limits prescribed by the numbers of
the frogs submitted is inside of what is to-day good practice and also, it
may be, the best practice. Frogs are all the time becoming sharper on
account of the higher speed, heavier and stiffer engines and longer equip-
ment; so that where to-day the Committee recommends a No. 8, a few
years ago they would have recommended a No. 6, and a No. o. will be
better in the very near future. Likewise a No. 15 is likely to be replaced
by a No. 20, or even higher frog. Practice is constantly changing and
track material is being improved very rapidly at the present time.
Concerning the length of switch points, those recommended are good
practice, but they are not the only good practice, and the same arguments
in regard to their lengths will apply that apply to the numbers of the
frogs. There are few roads in the United States to-day that are using 33-
foot switch points to a great extent, although they can be used. I note
German roads are beginning to use switch points even longer than that.
They have been trying switch points with a fixed heel. The heel on all of
our switch points is pivoted. By the use of this fixed heel they get a
curved switch point, which, if it can be properly made, I think we will
all admit is very desirable, and it is very likely to come, if we can find a
construction that will make a proper fit for the point against the stock
rail. They have a special section of rail for this switch point, and I see
no reason why the practice may not become the practice in this country.
The use of a special shaped head, and of hardened steel or toughened
steel for our points is surely within the lines of reason and economy,
if a proper design can be made by which we can get a curved switch
point for high-speed trains. Consequently, while this question is open,
I think it is proper for this convention to adopt these resolutions, not as
the action of the convention as recommended practice to bind the Asso-
ciation, but as good practice which we can agree to but not recommend
as the best practice.
Mr. Jenkins: — Mr. Chairman, I wish to call attention particularly to
the fact that two of the dissenting members dissented more from the
text of the argument than from anything else; that they objected to my
introducing matter which weighed against the Committee's report. My
intention, and I think the wish of most of the members of the Com-
mittee, was to present full information to the Association, so that the
subject could have proper consideration, and two of the dissenters simply
objected because my argument was not strong enough.
Mr. Rose: — Is there a motion before the house?
The President : — There is a motion before the house for the accept-
ance of this.
Mr. C. H. Ewing (Atlantic City Railroad) : — I would like to ask the
Committee if they can advise us the difference in the angle of a 30-foot
switch and a 33-foot switch.
Mr. Jenkins : — Just 10 per cent, difference,
978 TRACK.
Mr. Ewing: — What is that in minutes?
Mr. Jenkins : — It is approximately six minutes.
Mr. L. C. Fritch :— I think perhaps the convention could reach a con-
clusion, or a unanimous opinion on this subject if the form of the rec-
ommendation were changed. It has developed in this discussion that the
general practice on main line turnouts is No. 10, and there is a very wide
practice in the use of No. 15 on high-speed turnouts. If the recommenda-
tions were changed to read something like this: "That for yard work
No. 8 frogs are recommended as good practice, for general main line
turnouts No. 10 or 11 frogs are considered good practice, and for high
speed turnouts No. 15, 16, or a higher number of frogs are good practice."
This, however, departs from the instructions of the Committee. The
Committee is following its instructions to make recommendations for
a minimum number of frogs and switches, to be adopted as good practice,
but we have discussed this matter for five or six years and do not seem
to be any nearer a conclusion than we were five years ago, and I doubt
if we ever will reach a conclusion on three numbers of frogs, or three
switches, and I would suggest that this form of recommendation be
changed.
Mr. Rose : — I do not think we agree with Mr. Fritch on that.
The President : — It would not be advisable to make any change now,
without a motion for reconsideration, because the length of frogs has
been passed upon already.
Mr. Rose : — I mean as an argument. I do not think we can agree
to put in that sort of a recommendation. We have tried that before,
and we have been instructed. I would not agree to that anyway.
The President: — The motion before the house is that the 11, 16^2, 22
and 33-foot switch point lengths be adopted and put in the Manual.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — Was not that amended by changing it to read
n, 16H and 26?
The President : — It was not seconded, as I recollect.
A Member : — I second it.
The President : — Then the amendment will be put first.
Mr. Rose : — I asked a little while ago if there was a motion before
the house and I had in mind Mr. Fritch's motion. I think we should
discuss his side of it before we put it to a vote, if that is the question.
The President: — The amendment before the house is that the lengths
of 22-foot and 33-foot switch points be combined into one of 26 feet in
length.
(The amendment was put to vote and lost.)
The President : — We will now vote on the original motion as stated.
(The vote on the original motion not being definite, a standing vote
was called for and 58 voted in the affirmative, 14 opposed.)
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — I move to reconsider the question of the number
of frogs recommended by the Committee to be adopted as representing
good practice-.
(Motion seconded by Mr. Berry.)
DISCUSSION. 979
The President : — Did the mover of the motion vote for or against the
motion as originally adopted?
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I did not vote on the question of frogs.
(The President put the motion of Mr. Fritch, and it was not
adopted.)
Mr. Jenkins : — I move that this conclusion be printed in the Manual,
under General Rule 16-g.
In connection with these specifications, I wish to state that these were
before the Association last year in a slightly different form. The sub-
stance of the specifications is practically the same as that which was
considered paragraph by paragraph last year, but it has been rearranged
and the general instructions and general specifications combined ; we took
all reference to frog numbers and length of switch points out of the
specifications, so as to have them acted on separately and rejected if the
convention saw fit to reject them, without impairing the specifications.
Tbe specifications this year, therefore, do not contain the drawings of
frogs and switches which they contained last year, at the time they were
considered, but the specifications carry with them Fig. i on page 381 and
Fig. 2 on page 382, showing the planing of the switch point and the de-
tails of the point, giving the dimensions of the holes and distances from
center to center.
If the convention does not wish to take the time to go through these
specifications paragraph by paragraph, as we did last year, we could
simply act on it as a whole. I move, in order to save time, that we con-
sider the specification as a whole without reading it paragraph by para-
graph.
The President : — In view of the facts stated by the Chairman of the
Committee it seems to be a good plan, considering that you have had this
Bulletin before you for some time, to take the course recommended by
the Chairman of the Committee, and with your consent the Chair will
simply ask those who have made up their minds that they want to make
some special criticism on some particular paragraph to make such criti-
cism, without the necessity of reading the specifications in detail, after
which the specifications will be presented to you as a whole.
Mr. F. J. Bachelder (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I would suggest that under
"Foot Guards," we add a clause that foot guards shall conform to the
requirements of State laws in the States for which the material is ordered.
In some States the law specifies a certain type of foot guard.
The President: — Does not that go in any case without saying?
Mr. Bachelder : — It would save time to have it definitely understood.
The President : — Do you make that as a motion ?
Mr. Bachelder: — Yes.
(Motion not seconded.)
Mr. Lindsay : — Under "Bolts," the specifications differ from the specifi-
cations previously submitted in omitting the "U. S. standard." The
previous specification required that the bolts must be round and true to
980 TRACK.
size, with the U. S. standard square heads and nuts, and the thread should
also be specified. I refer to the second paragraph on page 378.
Mr. Rose:— That was done on a motion made by Mr. Ewing. He
wanted that cut out so that we could use a special bolt.
The President :— Any additional criticism?
Mr. Lindsay: — I think that the word "spring" should be substituted
for the word "wing" at the top of page 379.
Mr. Jenkins:— It may be either "spring rail" or "wing rail," but the
Committee will accept the suggestion.
Mr. Lindsay : — On page 381 under Fig. 1 there is a table which shows
the length A. B. for the different lengths of switches; figuring that out
in feet per inch, the first one is 1 inch in 16 feet, the second one 1 in
12, and the remainder 1 inch in 62A feet. I think the 16-foot 6-inch switch
would be very much better if A. B. was longer. I move the substitution
of 7 feet for 5 feet in the length A. B. in that switch.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Lindsay: — I ask for information concerning Fig. 2, page 382, if
the distance A is the theoretical distance or the practical distance?
Mr. Jenkins : — That is the theoretical distance. I will explain that as
the heel distance of the switch is 6% inches, and the distance of the gage
line from the stock rail is *4-inch, it makes a difference of 6 inches for
the length of the switch, consequently the theoretical distance from the
bend of the stock rail to the point of switch is just 1/24 the length of
the switch.
(The specifications as amended were then put to vote and carried.)
The President : — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of the
Association.
DISCUSSION ON ROADWAY.
(For Report, see pp. 387-400.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON ROADWAY.
W. M. Dawley.
The President : — The next is the Committee on Roadway. In the
absence of the Chairman, Mr. W. M. Dawley, the Vice-Chairman, will
make the opening remarks in regard to the report.
Mr. W. M. Dawley (Erie) : — The subjects assigned to the Roadway
Committee have not been carried out to a conclusion. There was, for
the first subject of discussion, the formula for general application, for de-
termining waterways under various conditions with consideration of the
hydraulic features. We have been considering for several years the pos-
sibility of preparing or selecting, from various formulae, in common use,
one that should be recommended for general application. The investiga-
tion made since the Committee's report to the annual convention in March,
1909, does not warrant the Committee varying from the opinion then ex-
pressed and accepted by the Association.
The Committee's work since the twelfth annual convention has been
directed toward the consideration rather of the hydraulic features of the
culvert, and while some progress has been made, the Committee is not
prepared now to make any definite recommendation.
On the second question, "unit pressures allowable on roadbeds of dif-
ferent materials, conferring with the Committee on Ballast," no definite
conclusion has been reached, because of a lack of information obtainable.
There is nothing published in the way of literature covering the condi-
tions as they exist under the roadbed, that is, defining the bearing power of
soils, as we use them in railroad work, and before any conclusion can
be drawn it would be necessary to make some full-sized tests, as in actual
practice, and measure by some means yet to be determined what actual
pressure is transmitted to the roadbed through the ballast, and how it
varies, both longitudinally and transversely of the track.
On the third subject, "Report on tunnel construction and ventilation,"
some information was collected and published merely as information, and
the Committee has some other material relating particularly to ventilation
of subways in cities, and ventilation of the Hudson and Manhattan tubes,
under the Hudson River, but that has not yet been published. The chair-
man of the sub-committee, Mr. Paul Didier, advises that he has consider-
able information, but has been unable to work it into shape on account of
being so busily engaged in constructing tunnels, he has not had time to
theorize.
The fourth subject, "The question of agricultural drainage as it affects
railways," the Committee during the past two years collected information
981
982 ROADWAY.
as to the drainage laws of the various states, but has never been able to
fix upon a form into which the information can be put so as to make it of
value to the Association. The Committee is of the opinion that further
work along the line of collecting information as to (a) Laws and Assess-
ments is futile because the laws are changing constantly, and because the
Committee's information is necessarily general and not subject to applica-
tion to specific cases without legal advice; and further, questions affecting
the laws and assessments are, in all railway organizations, handled by the
railway's attorneys. The Committee recommends that it be discharged
from further consideration of the subject as to Laws and Assessments.
The recommendation of the Committee on subjects I, 2 and 3 is that
they be reassigned for further consideration, and subject 4 be confined to
the benefits the railways will derive by the construction of agricultural
drainage ditches and levies.
The Committee has been collecting information for two years for the
purpose of formulating a conclusion as to what unit pressures are allow-
able on the roadbed, and the Committee has come to the conclusion that
since the available data treats of the sustaining power of soils below the
surface, rather than of that of soils peculiarly exposed as the roadbed
is to moisture, to the action of frost, and to the loadings peculiar to train
service, it will be necessary to make experiments to determine the magni-
tude and distribution of the loads transmitted to the roadbed through
ballast of various kinds and also to determine by test the bearing power
of various materials under varying conditions ordinarily attained in the
construction of the roadway.
I would suggest that the Committee on Ties be added to that.
The President : — 'No action on the part of the Association is neces-
sary, as these are progress reports. The Committee has furnished us a
starter for some valuable information in regard to unit pressures, and
we will hope for a continuation along that line. The Committee is dis-
missed with the thanks of the Association.
DISCUSSION ON WATER SERVICE.
(For Report, see pp. 401-428.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON WATER SERVICE.
J. B. Berry. Robert Ferriday. F. E. Schall.
Geo. H. Bremner. C. E. Lindsay. W. F. Steffens.
J. L. Campbell.
The President :— The next Committee is that on Water Service, Mr.
Robert Ferriday, Chairman. The Chairman will make the opening re-
marks in regard to the report.
Mr. Robert Ferriday (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis) : —
The Committee has no changes to recommend in the Manual until the
future policy now under consideration is decided. On the subject of
"the design and relative economy of track pans from an operating stand-
point," the Committee reports progress.
On the subject of deep well pumps we report merely progress, be-
cause the subject has not been developed sufficiently to report otherwise.
On the subject of the use of reinforced concrete for water tanks
and supports, this report is submitted as information. The Committee-
believes it is an interesting and impartial statement of the subject. The
field of reinforced concrete is being rapidly expanded, and it may de-
velop that the use of such material for this purpose can be made with no
doubt of definite success, but the Committee did not feel prepared to offer
conclusions one way or the other until its performance had become more
definitely determined.
A sub-committee on water treatment has been made part of the Com-
mittee organization for the purpose of keeping that subject alive and
reporting any developments. There is nothing to report at this time, but
the Committee submits, in Appendix A, for the information of the Associ-
ation, a paper prepared at its request by J. R. Francis, regarding the
unusual occurrence of locomotive boiler corrosion, which followed a
partial installation of water softeners. It is quite possible that some
conditions may be experienced by our members, under similar conditions;
and information regarding the means for overcoming it may be of value.
Your Committee has canvassed the membership for opinions and criti-
cisms of the general specifications of steel tanks submitted last year, and
same have been revised. The Committee was anxious to include with
the specifications for open-hearth steel also those for a material which
would resist rust better than ordinary steel, and they are included as
printed in the Bulletin. But through an error the circular issued to the
membership failed to include the specifications for refined steel and it has
since appeared to the Committee desirable to omit the specifications for
refined steel for the present, and with the consent of the convention, the
983
984 WATER SERVICE.
Committee desires to amend the specifications as follows and to submit
same for the Manual.
If there are no objections I would recommend that we take up the
specifications for steel tanks, paragraph by paragraph, and I can outline
the changes that we desire to make:
(i) Change the title to read as follows: "General Specifications for
Steel Water and Oil Tanks."
"i. Ordinary Tanks Defined. Ordinary tanks are those requiring
plates not more than 5^-in. thick.
"2. Scope of Specifications. These specifications cover ordinary steel
tanks commonly used by railways for usual service conditions only."
(2) Combine paragraphs 1 and 2 to read : "1. Scope of Specifica-
tions. These specifications are intended for steel tanks requiring plates
not more than 54-in. thick."
(3) Change the numbering of the paragraphs in consequence of con-
solidating paragraphs 1 and 2.
"3- Quality of Metal. The metal in these tanks shall be a special
refined steel or open-hearth steel.
"The special refined steel shall have a tensile strength per sq. in. not
less than 50,000 lbs. and an elastic limit not less than 30,000 lbs. per sq. in.
It shall contain of
Sulphur Not more than .02 per cent.
Phosphorus Not more than .005 per cent.
Carbon Not more than .02 per cent. "\
Manganese Not more than .00 per cent.
Silicon Not more than .00 per cent.
"The steel shall conform in physical and chemical properties to the
specifications of this Association for steel bridges.
"For plates not more than ^-in. thick, §^-in. rivets shall be used.
For thicker plates the diameter shall be 24-in."
(4) Change paragraph 3 in the Bulletin to read, "2. Quality of Metal.
The metal in these tanks shall be open-hearth steel. This steel shall con-
form in physical and chemical properties to the specification of this Associ-
ation for steel bridges."
"4. Loading. The weight of water shall be assumed to be 63 lbs.,
crude oil 56 lbs., and creosote oil 66 lbs. per cu. ft. Wind pressure, acting
in any direction, shall be assumed to be, in pounds, 30 times the product
of the height by two-thirds of the diameter of the tank in feet.
"5. Unit Stresses. Unit stresses shall not exceed the following:
(a) Tension in plates, 15,000 lbs. per sq. in. on net section.
(b) Shear in plates, 12,000 lbs. per sq. in. on net section.
(c) Shear on rivets, 12,000 lbs. per sq. in. on net section.
(d) Bearing pressure on field rivets, 20,000 lbs. per sq. in.
"6. Cylindrical Rings. Plates forming the shell of the tank shall be
cylindrical and of different diameters, in and out, from course to course.
"7. Workmanship. All workmanship shall be first class. All plates
shall be beveled on all edges for caulking after being punched. The punch-
DISCUSSION. 985
ing shall be from the surface to be in contact. The plates shall be formed
cold to exact form after punching and beveling. All rivet holes shall be
accurately spaced. Drift pins shall be used only for bringing the parts
together. They shall not be driven with enough force to deform the
metal about the holes. Power riveting and caulking should be used. A
heavy yoke or pneumatic bucker shall be used for power driven rivets.
Riveting shall draw the joints to full and tight bearing.
"8. Caulking. The tank shall be made water or oil tight by caulking
only. No foreign substance shall be used in the joints. For water tanks,
the caulking shall preferably be done on the inside of tank and joint only;
but for oil tanks the caulking should be done on both sides. No form of
caulking tool or work that injures the abutting plate shall be used.
"g. M'inimum Thickness of Plates. The minimum thickness of plates
in the cylindrical part of the tank shall not be less than J^-in. and in flat
bottoms not less than Tjj-in. In curved bottoms the thickness of plate shall
be not less than that of the lower plate in the cylindrical part.
"10. Horizontal and Radial Joints. Lap joints shall generally be used
for horizontal seams and splices and for radial seams in curved bottoms.
"n. Vertical Joints. For vertical seams and splices, lap joints shall
be used with plates not more than ->£-in. thick. With thicker plates, double
butt joints with inside and outside straps shall generally be used. The
edge of the plate in contact at the intersection of horizontal and vertical
lap joints shall be drawn out to a uniform taper and thin edge.
"12. Rivet Holes, Punching and Pitch. The diameter of rivet holes
shall be -rs-in. larger than the diameter of the rivets used. The punching
shall conform to the specifications of this Association for such work on
steel bridges. A close pitch, with due regard for thickness of plate and
balanced stress between tension on plates and shear on rivets, is desirable
for caulking."
(5) Change paragraph 12 in the Bulletin to read, "11. Rivets, Rivet
Holes, Punching and Pitch. For plates not more than )^-in. thick, 5^-in.
rivets shall be used. For thicker plates, J^-in. rivets shall be used. The
diameter of rivet holes shall be tt-in. larger than the diameter of the
rivets used. The punching shall conform to the specifications of this
Association for such work on steel bridges. A close pitch, with due
regard for thickness of plate and balanced stress between tension on
plates and shear on rivets, is desirable for caulking."
"13. Tank Support. If the tank is supported on steel columns with
bracing, the metal in such substructure shall conform to these specifica-
tions, and the anchorage and workmanship thereof shall conform to the
specifications of this Association for the manufacture and erection of
steel bridges."
(6) Change paragraph 13 in the Bulletin to read, "12. Tank Support.
If the tank is supported on a steel substructure, the latter shall conform
to the specifications of this Association for the manufacture and erection
of steel bridges, except that allowance shall be made for wind pressure,
but not for impact."
986 WATER SERVICE.
Mr. W. F. Steffens (Boston & Albany) :— I should like to ask the
Committee why they change from the unit stresses adopted by the Com-
mittee on Iron and Steel Bridges?
Mr. Ferriday : — These specifications were drawn up by the Commit-
tee with the help of Prof. Pence and Mr. A. F. Robinson, who has built
a number of tanks during the last sixteen years.
Mr. Steffens : — I should like to ask the Committee if they would be
willing to put that in the shape of a factor, a constant, in other words,
against the specifications for steel bridges. It is rather awkward to have
two sets of unit stresses, one for bridges and another for tanks.
Mr. Ferriday : — I do not think that would be satisfactory. I do nor
believe it would be desirable to have to make a computation from the
specifications for steel bridges. I see no objection to including them
just as given.
The President : — Have you any motion ?
Mr. Steffens : — I move that the unit stresses be referred to the
corresponding specifications for steel bridges, with a corresponding reduc-
tion factor.
The President : — There being no second, we will pass on.
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River) :— Do I
understand that the cylindrical sections as required in paragraph 6 alter-
nate, first in and then out?
Mr. Ferriday: — 'Yes.
Mr. Lindsay: — I think the reference to the specification for steel
bridges would require a person to have a full set of the bridge specifica-
tions. Why could not these clauses be embodied in the specification?
Mr. Ferriday: — I think it has been the practice of all the committees,
for the sake of brevity, to refer to the other specifications, without re-
peating them in detail. In the case of the Masonry Committee, they
refer to the specifications for cement, and that is the reason it was done
here.
The President: — Any further discussion on No. 12, as revised?
Mr. Ferriday: — The Committee wishes to make the following change
in that paragraph: "12. Tank Support. If the tank is supported on a
steel substructure, the latter shall conform to the specifications of this As-
sociation for the manufacture and erection of steel bridges."
The President: — Is there any discussion on the revised form of 13?
Mr. Lindsay: — I make the same comment as before. As to Mr.
Ferriday's comment about our cement specification, I would say that our
cement specification is an entity, it is a complete specification in itself, but
the specification for steel bridges goes into a great many things not
involved in Water Service, and we would have to go over the specifica-
tion and pick out the paragraphs here and there, to get what we wanted,
and we would have to rearrange them, to get the matter complete.
The President :— Your idea is that if the extract is not too long, it
can be embodied in the specifications for ordinary steel water and oi!
tanks ?
DISCUSSION. 987
Mr. Lindsay : — Yes.
The President : — I think the Committee would accept that general
practice.
Mr. Ferriday: — "14. Painting. In the shop the metal shall be cleaned
of dirt, rust and scale and, except the surfaces to be in contact in the
joints of the tank, shall be given a shop coat of paint or metal preservative
selected and applied as specified by the company.
"After being completely erected, caulked and cleaned of dirt, rust and
scale, all exposed metal work shall be painted or treated with such coat
or coats of paint or metal preservative as shall be selected by the railway
company."
Mr. Campbell, Chairman of the Sub-committee which prepared this
report, feels that we should not accept Mr. Lindsay's suggestion.
Mr. J. L. Campbell (El Paso Southwestern) : — I feel, and I believe
it is the feeling of the Committee, that the specification paragraph 13,
now paragraph 12, as amended, should stand as it has been amended by
the Committee. These are general specifications and they avoid going
into specific details, and it appeared to the Committee that by reference
to the specifications for steel bridges, the Association has a specification
governing the designing and erection of the substructure, which would
meet the case. When it comes to the matter of designing a particular
structure, as to that particular part of the water tank, the supports, we
immediately go into the field of bridge engineering, and we would nat-
urally turn to the specifications for the designing of a steel structure tak-
ing stresses similar to those carrying railway trains, and it would seem
to the Committee to be a very simple thing merely to refer to these specifi-
cations, and that it is not necessary to go into detail and embody these
specifications in the general specifications for water tanks. It will con-
siderably lengthen the latter specifications if we do that. The stresses
that occur in the substructure are quite different from those in the shell.
and it would be necessary for us to include all the specifications covering
the designing of columns, and that sort of thing.
Mr. George H. Bremner (Chicago, Burlington & Quincy) : — It would
seem to be proper to refer to the other specifications printed in the Man-
ual, but the Committee should at the same time give us the location of the
specifications and give the numbers or the paragraphs in the bridge specifi-
cations that are needed to complete the water and oil tank specifications,
so that they can be readily accessible to the members without going
through the entire bridge specifications.
Mr. F. E. Schall (Lehigh Valley) : — Do I understand that the columns
for steel substructure of tank are to be designed under the requirements
of specifications for steel railroad bridges? No indications as to require-
ments for compressive unit stresses are given. The tank proper is to be
designed for unit tensile stress of 15,000 lbs. per square inch, or about
50 per cent, higher than is allowed for railroad bridges, not considering
impact; this unit stress in my judgment is about right: the compression
unit stresses should be gaged in the same manner.
988 WATER SERVICE.
The President: — The Committee intends to recommend that the sub-
structure shall be designed in accordance with the specifications for steel
bridges.
Mr. Schall: — The specifications are not clear as to this requirement.
The compression unit stresses for steel bridges are based on impact be-
ing added to stresses.
The President: — That section was changed to read as follows: "If
the tank is supported on a steel substructure the latter shall conform to
the specifications of this Association for the manufacture and erection
of steel bridges." That is the recommendation of the Committee.
Mr. Schall: — What is the reason for allowing a practically 50 per
cent, increase in tension stresses for tanks over those allowed for in
steel bridges (excluding impact in the latter), and building the columns
under the unit stresses for steel railroad bridges making the columns
heavier than they need be?
Mr. Ferriday: — I do not believe I quite understand the point. The
unit stresses given in paragraph 5 are intended to cover the tank.
Mr. Schall : — The Committee provides for a specific unit stress in
tension for the shell of the tank, based upon a static load, and intends
to apply for the column supports the unit stresses of steel railroad bridges
which are based upon addition of impact.
The water tank specifications are not complete without providing a
clear requirement for compression unit stresses and also providing unit
stresses for shop and field rivets.
Mr. J. L. Campbell : — That is quite true, and the Committee took that
into consideration. The members of such substructure will be light in
many cases, and it requires a certain thickness of metal for a proper
margin against corrosion and for other considerations, and the Committee
believes it will be found that the substructure for a water tank designed
in accordance with the specifications for steel bridges will not be expensive
in the use of material, and will not put more material in the substructure
than should be there in any case.
Mr. J. B. Berry (Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific) : — I suggest the
preparations of plans and specifications as to tools for erection, and I
do it for this reason — when we started to equip our line with steel tanks,
it had to be done by division forces. We looked everywhere as to the
best and most economical plan to erect the tanks. We finally got up a
set of drawings of tools, and had them criticized. I believe it would be a
good thing for this Committee to collect such information and recommend
the best class of tools for the erection of such tanks, so that the mem-
bers of the Association will have the benefit of that information.
Mr. Ferriday : — I move that the specifications for steel water and oil
tanks, as amended, be adopted and included in the Manual.
(The motion was put to vote and carried.)
The President: — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of
the Association.
DISCUSSION ON CONSERVATION OF NATURAL
RESOURCES.
(For Report, see pp. 429-45S.)
list of speakers taking part in discussion on conservation of natural
resources.
William McNab.
The President : — The first business this morning will be the report of
the Committee on Conservation of Natural Resources, Mr. E. O. Faulk-
ner, Chairman. In the absence of Mr. Faulkner, the report will be pre-
sented by Mr. McNab, the Vice-Chairman.
Mr. William McNab (Grand Trunk) : — I regret very much the ab-
sence of the Chairman of this Committee, Mr. Faulkner. As his imme-
diate deputy, however, I will say that the compilation of this report has
given the Committee a great deal of pleasure. It is submitted at pres-
ent merely as a report of progress and for information, but it is the pur-
pose of the Committee to continue the work on the present lines, by keep-
ing in touch with the National organization in the United States, as well
as with a similar one in the Dominion of Canada.
The President : — The Committee simply reports progress and the Com-
mittee is dismissed with the thanks of the Association. They have given
us a lot of splendid information in their report and we feel very grateful
to them.
989
DISCUSSION ON MASONRY.
(For Report, see pp. 459-504.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON MASONRY.
A. W. Carpenter. C. E. Lindsay. E. V. Smith.
R. D. Coombs. Hunter McDonald. G. H. Tinker.
L. G. Curtis. P. C. Newbegin. E. E. R. Tratman.
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on
Masonry, of which Mr. G. H. Tinker is Chairman. Mr. Tinker will make
the opening statement.
Mr. G. H. Tinker (New York, Chicago & St. Louis) :— The Com-
mittee on Masonry held four meetings during the year, all at Chicago.
The Board of Direction assigned six subjects for its investigation and
also directed that the Committee appoint sub-committees to act with the
Joint Committee on Concrete and Reinforced Concrete and the Joint
Committee on Uniform Specifications for Portland Cement.
The various subjects have been assigned to sub-committees and work
has proceeded upon all subjects. In accordance with the directions of the
Board, we present final reports upon two subjects only; upon a third
subject, the waterproofing of masonry, we submit abstracts of the replies
received to a circular sent out by the Committee. This is presented as
information at the present time, it being the intention of the Committee
to follow the matter up with a final report at a later date. This subject
the Committee has had under consideration for several years, during
which time it has been engaged in collecting data upon which to base a
final report.
Upon the subject of "Methods of Patching and Repairing Plain and
Reinforced Concrete," the matter presented by the Committee will be found
on page 474. The Committee sent out a circular of inquiry upon this
subject and received a great many replies, over one hundred, in fact.
There were so many replies, a number of them describing practically the
same method of work, that only a selection has been presented in the
form of abstracts to show the substance of the information received. The
conclusions of the Committee upon this subject are given on page 476.
There are seven conclusions. The Committee asks that these conclu-
sions be approved under Rule 16-g for publication in the Manual.
"Your Committee presents the following conclusions as to the methods
of repairing defective or worn surfaces of concrete:
"(1) In all cases the surface to be repaired must first be thoroughly
cleaned of all loose material, laitance and dust and the clean, rough, sound
concrete exposed to receive the patch. Probably the best method of
cleaning is by means of a steam jet.
990
DISCUSSION. 991
"(2) After cleaning, the surface to be repaired must be thoroughly
saturated with water, not simply moistened, but so thoroughly drenched
that the old concrete will not absorb water from the new mortar or
concrete used in patching. If possible, the surface should be kept covered
with water for several hours.
"(3) If the repair or patch is to be made on a vertical or sloping
surface and is not to be more than iT4 in. thick, the surface of the old
concrete, while it is still wet, should be spattered or splashed with a
cement grout, following this immediately with a fairly stiff plaster coat
of mortar made of the same proportions of cement and sand as was used
in the original concrete, but never richer than 1 cement to 2^4 sand.
This plaster coat should not be thicker than ^-in. and each coat should
be forced into the surface, but not dragged with a trowel. The sur-
face of each coat, except the final coat, should be "scratched" to give a
bond for the next coat. This plastering should preferably begin at the
top and progress downward, and only enough time be allowed to permit
each coat to receive its initial set before the next coat is applied. The
final coat should be finished with a wooden float and only enough water
used to properly finish the surface. This patch should be kept damp and
protected from sun or frost till fully set up.
"(4) If the repair or patch or 'finish coat' is to be made on a
horizontal or nearly horizontal surface, the surface of the old concrete
should be slushed and broomed with a thin cement grout, following this
immediately with a zvet mortar made of 1 part cement and 2^2 parts sand
or granite screenings and of the full thickness required (not less than
*/2-in. thick, however). When this mortar begins to take its initial set,
it should be floated or troweled to such a finish as may be desired."
Mr. P. C. Newbegin (Bangor & Aroostook) : — Referring to Con-
clusion 4 as to the methods of repairing defective or worn surfaces of
concrete, I ask why in one case the Committee recommends mortar of
the same standard as the original structure and not in the other?
Mr. Tinker: — There is no very good reason for the difference, except
that in the case of a horizontal surface there is not the tendency for the
mortar to fall off that there is on a vertical surface. In both cases a
very rich mortar is not successful. It cracks too much. Therefore, we
limit it to 1 to 2T/2. There is less cracking and less shrinkage if the
two mortars are of the same consistency.
(Conclusion 4 was adopted as presented.)
Mr. Tinker: — "(5) If the repair or patch is to be made on a vertical
or sloping face and is to be more than 1^2 in. thick, it will be advisable
to embed dowels into the old concrete, as deeply as the thickness of the
proposed patch, and spaced sufficiently close together to firmly anchor the
patch to the old concrete. The dowels must be wedged into the old
concrete and it will be advisable to fasten wires, metal fabric or bars to
the dowels, in the case of extensive patching, as an additional safeguard.
The patching may then be done with mortar without forms, or with wet
992 MASONRY.
concrete supported by forms, depending upon the thickness and the ex-
tent of the patch.
"(6) If the repair or patch is to be made on a horizontal or nearly
horizontal face and of considerable thickness, dowels may be used, or
the concrete may simply be reinforced by fabric or bars without using
dowels — treating the patch as a block of masonry."
Mr. A. W. Carpenter (New York Central & Hudson River) : — Does
paragraph 6 refer to patches more than V/2 inches thick? The preced-
ing paragraph refers to a patch more than il/2 inches thick. Paragraph
6 does not give any definite thickness.
Mr. Tinker : — This refers more especially to a rather thick block of
concrete, in the nature of a replaced bridge seat, which might be from 6
inches to 2 feet thick. In that case it goes a little outside of the designa-
tion of a patch.
Mr. E. V. Smith (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I notice that in paragraphs
5 and 6 there is no mention of the size of the dowel or the number of
dowels to be put in. I ask the Committee if they considered that?
Mr. Tinker: — That would be regulated by the size of the patch, and
the method to determine that would be to consider the cross-section of
the patch and the amount of shrinkage stress which could be obtained,
putting in dowels enough to withstand the shrinkage stress.
(Conclusion 6 was adopted as presented.)
Mr. Tinker: — "(7) Care must be taken not to have thin edges on
patches. To avoid this, it may be necessary to cut out sound concrete
around a place to be patched, so as to give deep edges to the patch. If
possible, the edges should be undercut."
(Conclusion 7 was adopted as presented.)
Mr. Tinker: — The second subject upon which we present conclu-
sions is upon "Methods of Depositing Concrete Under Water."
Mr. Hunter McDonald (Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis) :— Mr.
President, pardon me, but before we take up the consideration of methods
of depositing concrete under water, I wish to ask the Committee a few
questions relating to this matter of patching concrete. I want to know
if the Committee has made any investigation of the different patented
methods that are being so extensively advertised, and I refer especially
to one which seems to be a modification of what is known as the old rust
joint, a mixture of emery grindings, Portland cement and salamoniac.
The percentages, I believe, are about 49 of iron filings, 49 of Portland
cement and 2 of salamoniac. The mixture has been patented, and the
manufacturers are endeavoring to sell it at the rate of 5 cents a pound.
They produce samples of the effects and efficiency of the method, and I
want to know if that method, or any other of the various mixtures, have
been brought to the attention of the Committee, and whether they gave
them consideration and decided to turn them all down.
Mr. Tinker:— This Committee has not considered definitely mixtures
of that kind, perhaps for the reason that the attention of the Committee
DISCUSSION. 993
was not called to them, at least until after the report had been formu-
lated.
I may say, in general, that the Committee is inclined to frown on
patented mixtures. The Committee does not believe in them. In this part
of our report we refer to the patching of concrete. The mixture to which
Mr. McDonald has referred is in the nature of a foreign substance which
is placed upon the concrete. It is not, strictly, a patch. There are a num-
ber of substances which can be made to adhere to the surface of con-
crete and produce a different finish. For instance, on a concrete floor,
there are a number of substances which will make a more or less orna-
mental finish, but they are not strictly patches. The idea of a patch is
that a concrete surface which is either imperfect or broken, must have
its surface restored, by putting a patch of concrete upon it.
Referring to the patent mixtures, this particular mixture, as has been
said, is about one-half Portland cement, about one-half iron filings and a
small percentage of salamoniac, all comparatively cheap materials, and
it is being sold at five cents a pound. If the cost of Portland cement by
the pound is computed it will be seen that the cost of this mixture at five
cents a pound figures out about 15 times the cost of Portland cement.
That may be one reason why we did not consider it. Portland cement
is plenty good enough.
Mr. McDonald : — I did not know that the Committee expected this
section to be confined to the method of patching concrete with concrete.
If they are convinced that they have arrived at the best method of patch-
ing concrete and the plan they propose is all right and will work in
all cases, then I think the Committee's report is proper. On the other
hand, if there are patented methods of patching worn places in concrete
surfaces that are superior to the method recommended by the Commit-
tee, I think we ought to know it whether they are patented or not.
Mr. L. G. Curtis (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I inquire if the Committee
has made any use of what is known as Ransomite for the preparation of
the surface of concrete before the application of the new surface is made.
The Baltimore & Ohio has used a great deal of it, with good success, so
far as my information and experience goes, and I would like to inquire
as to that point.
Mr. Tinker : — In the abstracts of the replies to our circular which we
give in the report, there will be found a number of methods recommended
for preparing the surface of the concrete, one of which is the acid method,
which is a good method. I understand that the use of the Ransomite
mixture is an acid method of treating the surface of the concrete. The
Committee has said nothing about that in the conclusions. It is referred
to in the preliminary discussion. The Committee recommends, as the best
method, the use of a steam jet.
The President : — We will now proceed to the consideration of the
methods of depositing concrete under water.
Mr. Tinker :— Five items were considered under this head : Methods
used for depositing concrete ; depth of water ; results ; precautions neces-
994 MASONRY.
sary to secure desired results ; statement of the cost of plant and relative
cost of depositing concrete per cubic yard.
Upon the last item not much information was obtained, for the rea-
son that many railroads do not have these costs. The -work is often
done by contract and the cost is not available, and if the work is done
by the company forces, the cost is often obscured, so that it is not easily
obtained. There is some little information upon this point which will be
found in the abstracts of the replies.
"(i) Concrete may be deposited successfully under water, if so
handled as to prevent the washing of the cement from the mixture.
"(2) Cofferdams should be sufficiently tight to prevent current
through the pit, and the water in the pit should be quiet.
"(3) The concrete should be deposited in place either by means of
a drop-bottom bucket or a tremie, and should not be allowed to fall
through the water."
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River) : — 'Does that
section exclude all the other methods, confining us to the drop-bottom
bucket or a tremie?
Mr. Tinker : — It does not exclude the other methods. There are
situations where the other methods may be used, but we do recommend,
from the information received, especially for a work of magnitude, that
these two methods are preferable. One of these methods may be pre-
ferred in one case and the other method in another case.
Mr. Lindsay :<— I had in mind some work on a bridge, where we had
riprap that was torn loose, and we put the concrete down dry, in sacks,
in sixteen feet of water, with quite a strong current flowing, and got very
good results.
Mr. Tinker: — "(4) Where a bucket is used, it should be carefully low-
ered to the bottom and raised to the surface, so as to cause as little disturb-
ance as possible of the water.
"(5) Where a tremie is used, it should be kept filled with concrete
up to the top of the water level, and the discharge end should be kept
buried in the freshly deposited mass to prevent emptying, and raised a
few inches at a time as the filling progresses.
"(6) The surface of the concrete must be kept as nearly level as
possible to avoid the formation of pockets which will retain laitance and
sediment.
"(7) Where concrete is not deposited continuously, all sediment
should be removed from the surface of the concrete, by pumping or other-
wise, before depositing fresh concrete.
"(8) The concrete should be a 1:2:4 mixture and of a 'quaking'
consistency."
Mr. R. D. Coombs (Consulting Engineer) : — If conclusion No. 1 is re-
tained, should it be necessary to specify the exact mixture in No. 8, and.
would it not be possible in some cases to use a leaner mixture?
Mr. Tinker : — It is undoubtedly true that concrete of a different mix-
ture, or leaner mixture, might be successfully used. The danger, with
DISCUSSION. W5
concrete under water is that some of the cement will be washed out, and
for that reason the mixture should be fairly rich. The Committee thought
i :2 :4 is fairly rich, and perhaps not too rich.
"(9) Freshly deposited concrete should not be disturbed.
"(10) Where the flow of water through the pit cannot be prevented,
concrete should be deposited in cloth sacks."
Mr. E. E. R. Tratman (Engineering News) : — The wording of con-
clusion No. 10 does not seem to cover work which is done in open
water. The use of the words "through the pit" seems to imply work done
in a cofferdam. A large amount of work, both on the lakes and the sea-
coast, is done in open water, such as pier and harbor work. I would
suggest the words "in open water or'' be prefixed to the present con-
clusion, so that it will read, "In open water or where the flow of water,"
etc.
(On motion, duly carried, the conclusions were adopted as a whole.)
Mr. Tinker : — The Joint Committee on Reinforced Concrete expected
to have a final report in print at this time, but it has not yet been pub-
lished. The Joint Committee on Uniform Specifications for Cement had
several meetings and finally failed to agree. The Departmental Commit-
tee of the Government has adopted a specification, and the American
Society of Civil Engineers has adopted its own specification.
The work of this Committee was brought to a close too late to do
anything more than make a statement of it in the report. It would be
desirable to have the Committee take the subject up for further considera-
tion and make a report next year.
That covers the work of the Committee, and we ask that the con-
clusions adopted be printed in the Manual under Rule 16-g.
(The motion was carried.)
The President : — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of the
Association and commended for their excellent work.
DISCUSSION ON RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS.
(For Report, see pp. 505-507.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON RECORDS AND ACCOUNTS/
H. J. Pfeifer.
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on
Records and Accounts, of which Mr. H. J. Pfeifer is Chairman. The
Chairman will make the preliminary statement.
Mr. H. J. Pfeifer (Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis) : —
The Committee was directed to make comprehensive studies of the
forms in the Manual, and of the economical way of managing a store-
house. We recommend no changes in the Manual. The Committee
devoted practically all of its time to the study of the storehouse propo-
sition. The first question that presented itself was : Should the Com-
mittee study only the internal economy of the storehouse, or should it
also take into consideration its relation to the other departments of
the railroad? From the standpoint of Maintenance of Way Depart-
ment, it seemed that the latter view was the correct one. The Com-
mittee offers its conclusions shown on page 506, and I move their
adoption.
"It is recommended —
"(1) That no changes be made in the forms appearing in the
Manual.
"(2) That the following statement embodies the general principles
governing the economical management of a railway storehouse:
"Reasons for Maintaining a Storehouse. — The object of a store-
house is to provide material and tools when required so that the cost
of work may be a minimum, bearing in mind the factors of delay to
work or labor, also interest on investment in stock.
"The following essential elements enter into the problem:
"(a) Standardization. — The standardization of materials and in-
structions in regard to their use will reduce to a minimum the number
of items of material of the various classes which should be carried in
stock. The amount of each item which should be carried in stock will
depend upon the rate of consumption, time required for the purchase
and delivery of material, and also upon local conditions.
"(b) Classification of Material. — This is necessary so as to re-
duce to a minimum the cost and time of handling. An approved
classification should be followed in making requisitions.
"(c) Stock Account.— An account should be kept of stock show-
ing at all times a record of receipts, disbursements and amount on
996
DISCUSSION. 997
hand. Stock should be replenished when the amount of any item has
been reduced to a fixed minimum. Inventories should be made at
stated periods. A proper stock account furnishes a check on excessive
supply and obsolete material.
"(d) Distribution. — When material is shipped, notice should be
sent to consignee showing partial or complete filling of requisition and,
if partial, when final shipment may be expected.
"(e) Organization. — The storekeeper's place in the general or-
ganization should be so fixed and adjusted that the measure of his
efficiency is, primarily, the promptness and accuracy with which he fills
requisitions, and, secondly, his ability to hold down the stock invest-
ment to the lowest amount consistent with the first requirement."
(The motion was carried.)
The President : — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of
the Association.
DISCUSSION ON ELECTRICITY.
(For Report, see pp. 509-558.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON ELECTRICITY.
J. R. W. Ambrose. J. B. Jenkins. G. A. Mountain.
F. J. Bachelder. E. B. Katte. H. J. Pfeifer.
W. S. Bouton. George W. Kittredge. A. F. Robinson.
R. D. Coombs. J. H. Milburn. Earl Stimson.
L. C. Fritch.
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on Elec-
tricity, of which Mr. George W. Kittredge is Chairman.
Mr. George W. Kittredge (New York Central & Hudson River) : —
This Committee, following out the instructions of the Board of Direction,
has carried to a conclusion two recommendations, the question of clear-
ances, and transmission line crossings.
The Committee felt, until quite late in the year last past, that it was
going to have difficulty in presenting conclusions on these two subjects,
which would be satisfactory, and it was only at the very last meeting
that the matter was cleared up in such a way as to enable us to unite in
making reports which v/e believe will be acceptable to the Association and
the public generally.
Our recommendations are contained on page 511. I move the defini-
tion of "Third Rail Gage," reading as follows, be adopted and inserted
in the Manual :
"(1) Definition: 'Third Rail Gage. Distance measured parallel to
plane of top of both running rails between gage of nearest running rail
and inside gage line of third rail.' "
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Kittredge : — 'The second recommendation is the adoption of the
lines shown on diagram "A" as equipment clearance lines.
I move the adoption of recommendation 2.
Mr. J. B. Jenkins (Baltimore & Ohio) :— I understand that Mr. Mil-
burn, of the Baltimore & Ohio, has something to say on that recommenda-
tion.
Mr. J. H. Milburn (Baltimore & Ohio) : — In taking up the question
of clearance for the Baltimore & Ohio System, and trying to establish a
standard for our use, I considered the diagram as presented by this Com-
mittee, and found that the line which is represented on this diagram as
suggested for design of equipment was a line that, if adhered to, would
put out of business some of the rolling stock which we have to handle,
not only of the Baltimore & Ohio, but of other companies. Our third
rail is a short distance above the running rail and level top contact, and
998
DISCUSSION. 999
we have had cases where rolling stock has injured the corner of the
covering of the third rail, which is some distance outside of the lines
proposed here for third rail construction. I had no intention of making
any remarks on this, but being called to the floor I have said what I
did because I think this diagram is prett\ liberal from a third rail point
of view and not quite as liberal as it should be from a motive-power
point of view.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) : — The Baltimore & Ohio
is represented both on this Committee and on the Committee of Clear-
ances of the American Railway Association, so that any objections which
the Baltimore & Ohio had were taken under consideration. I do not
know whether the Chairman has stated that this diagram will also be
presented to the American Railway Association, by its Committee, at the
next meeting of that Association, so that if this Association adopts this
clearance diagram it will be in harmony with the American Railway
Association report.
Mr. W. S. Bouton (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I ask if the diagram which
goes below the top of the rail conflicts with the timber guard rail on
bridges ?
Mr. Kittredge : — The diagram shows that the clearance for equipment
does not come below the timber guard rail. We are discussing the clear-
ance line for the design of equipment.
(The recommendation was adopted as printed.)
Mr. Kittredge: — "(3) The lines shown on diagram 'A' as permanent
way structure adjacent to third rail clearance lines.
"(4) The lines shown on diagram 'A' as third rail structure clear-
ance lines.
"(5) The adoption of the specifications for overhead crossings of
electric light and power lines."
I want to say a word or two in regard to this report and to lay
before the Association the matter as it stands at the present time. Within
the last four months the four Associations — the National Electric Light
Association, the American Institute of Electrical Engineers, the American
Electric Railway Association and the Association of Railway Telegraph
Superintendents — acting jointly, have made a report which corresponds
very nearly with the report of your Committee. There are differences
between the report of the Joint Committee of these four Associations
and our report in paragraphs 10, 13, 18, 24, 29, 31, 32, 34, 45, 49, 51, 55,
60 and 61. In some of these paragraphs the changes are simply those of
words. In one case the word "practicable" is used for the word "pos-
sible," and in another place where it says "Treated poles are recom-
mended," it really means that where wooden poles are to be used, they
shall be treated. In all cases of difference the phraseology in our
report is the better, we think.
The reason it pleases me to dwell so much on this subject is that it
is a very great advantage to have a report which will be accepted and
1000 ELECTRICITY.
acknowledged by the principal societies, associations and companies inter-
ested. As it is now, particularly in the State of New York, the railways
can control the crossings over their rights-of-way, but they have, very
little to say about crossings which occur in highways. The crossing com-
panies have rights which apparently are co-extensive with those of the
railways and almost any old thing does for a crossing in a highway. It
is, of course, very desirable, in the first place, that we get safety, and in
the second place good construction at highways as well as at private cross-
ings.
We believe that if we will accept their report, using their phraseology,
we will be in a very much better condition than if we do not. Some of the
members of the Joint Committee were brought into line only after a
great deal of hard work and they have shown a disposition to negative
their whole joint work and let things stand as they are at the present
time, if this Association does not accept specifications which are the same
as theirs. How much truth there is in that and what would actually
happen is only a matter of conjecture. It is therefore a question of
policy whether or not in matters of secondary importance we shall accept
their figures and specifications rather than our own.
The President : — We will now take up the "Specifications for Over-
head Crossings of Electric Light and Power Lines," by paragraphs. If
Mr. Osgood is present, we will be glad to have him enter into the dis-
cussion.
The Secretary: — "i. Scope. These specifications shall apply to over-
head electric light and power line crossings (except trolley contact wires),
over railroad right-of-way, tracks, or lines of wires; and, further, these
specifications shall apply to overhead electric light and power wires of
over 5,000 volts constant potential, crossing, or constructed over tele-
phone, telegraph or other similar lines.
"2. Location. The poles, or towers, supporting the crossing span
preferably shall be outside the railroad company's right-of-way.
"3. Unusually long crossing spans shall be avoided wherever prac-
ticable.
"4. The poles, or towers, shall be located as far as practicable from
inflammable material or structures.
"5. The poles, or towers, supporting the crossing span, and the ad-
joining span on each side, preferably shall be in a straight line.
"6. The wires, or cables, shall cross over telegraph, telephone and
similar wires wherever practicable.
"7. Cradles, or overhead bridges, shall not be used.
"8. Clearance. The side clearance shall be not less than 12 feet from
the nearest rail of main-line track, nor less than 6 feet from the nearest
rail of sidings. At loading sidings sufficient space shall be left for a
driveway.
"9. The clear headroom shall be not less than 30 feet above the top
of rail under the most unfavorable condition of temperature and loading.
DISCUSSION. 1001
For constant potential, direct-current circuits, not exceeding 750 volts
when paralleled by trolley contact wires, the clear headroom need not ex-
ceed 25 feet."
Mr. G. A. Mountain (Canadian Railway Commission) :— I ask the
Committee in that connection what they do with trolley wires. I see
they except trolley contacts in clause 1 ; with reference to the clearance
of 25 feet, have they any recommendation to make on that?
Mr. Kittredge: — We have no recommendation about that.
The Secretary : — "10. The clearance of alternating-current circuits
above any existing wires, under the most unfavorable condition of temper-
ature and loading, shall be not less than 8 feet wherever practicable. For
constant potential, direct-current circuits, not exceeding 750 volts, the
minimum clearance above telegraph, telephone and similar wires may be
2 feet with insulated wires and 4 feet with bare wires.
Mr. Kittredge : — The only difference in this paragraph and that of
the joint report is the word "practicable" in the third line. The joint
report uses the word "possible."
Mr. R. D. Coombs (Consulting Engineer) : — As I understand it, the
request of the Committee is that the Joint Committee report be adopted
in order to conform to what has already been done by the other asso-
ciations and by the Telephone and Telegraph Companies.
Mr. Kittredge : — I would move, for the sole purpose of getting a
contract which is similar in all respects, that we adopt the word "pos-
sible" instead of the word "practicable." We think that the advantages
to be derived from having a uniform contract in this particular outweigh
the disadvantages of having one in which one word is not as good as some
other word.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — '"11. The separation of conductors carrying alter-
nating current, supported by pin insulators, for spans not exceeding 150
feet, shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Separation.
Not exceeding 6,600 volts - 14^ in.
Exceeding 6,600, but not exceeding 14,000 24 in.
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000 30 in.
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 35.000 36 in.
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000 45 in.
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 70,000 60 in.
"For spans exceeding 150 feet the pin spacing should be increased,
depending upon the length of the span and the sag of the conductors.
"Note. — (This requirement does not apply to wires of the same phase
or polarity between which there is no difference of potential.
"With constant potential, direct-current circuits not exceeding 750
volts, the minimum spacing shall be 10 in."
Mr. H. J. Pfeifer (Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis) : —
I notice that the maximum line voltage is 70,000 volts. The Terminal
1002 ELECTRICITY.
Railroad Association now has an application for a crossing over its right-
of-way, carrying 100,000 volts. I would like to know what provision
should be made in a case of that kind.
Mr. Kittredge :— The Committee has not discussed that. It might
come up for discussion next year.
Mr. J. R. W. Ambrose (Grand Trunk) : — I was just going to bring
up the same point. We have several crossings to-day of 110,000 volts.
The President: — That seems to be a subject for further considera-
tion on the part of the Committee.
The Secretary: — "12. When supported by insulators of the disc or
suspension type, the crossing span and the next adjoining spans shall be
dead-ended at the poles, or towers, supporting the crossing span, so that
at these poles, or towers, the insulators shall be used as strain insulators.
"13. The clearance in any direction between the conductors nearest
the pole, or tower, and the pole or tower shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Clearance.
Not exceeding 10,000 volts 9 in.
Exceeding 10,000, but not exceeding 14,000 12 in.
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000 15 in.
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 35,000 18 in.
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000 21 in.
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 70,000 24 in.
Mr. Kittredge : — That paragraph varies from the report of the Joint
Committee as shown on page 522 in that our report contains one more
division. The Joint Committee's report, first line, says, "not exceeding
14,000 volts, 9 inches." We have "not exceeding 10,000 volts, 9 inches,-'
"exceeding 10,000, but not exceeding 14,000, 12 inches." After discus-
sion, and for the reasons indicated in discussing paragraph 10, your Com-
mittee recommends the adoption of paragraph 13, as shown on page 522,
and I so move.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary : — "14. Conductors. The normal mechanical tension
in the conductors generally shall be the same in the crossing span and in
the adjoining span on each side, and the difference in length of the cross-
ing and adjoining spans generally shall be not more than 50 per cent, of
the length of the crossing span.
"15. The conductors shall not be spliced in the crossing span nor in
the adjoining span on either side.
"16. The method of supporting the conductors at the poles, or towers,
shall be such as to hold the wires, under maximum loading, to the sup-
porting structures, in case of shattered insulators, or wires broken or
burned at an insulator, without allowing an amount of slip which would
materially reduce the clearance specified in paragraphs Nos. 9 and 10.
"17. Guys. Wooden poles supporting the crossing span shall be side-
fcuyed in both directions if practicable, and be head-guyed away from
DISCUSSION. 1003
the crossing span. The next adjoining poles shall be head-guyed in both
directions.
"18. Strain insulators shall be used in guys from wooden poles carry-
ing any power wire of less than 6,600 volts, provided the guys are not
through grounded to permanently damp earth. Strain insulators shall not
be used in guying steel structures, nor required on wooden poles carrying
wires, all of which are 6,600 volts or more, provided the guys are through
grounded to permanently damp earth."
Mr. Kittredge: — This paragraph varies from the paragraph of the Joint
Committee in that beginning on the second line we have inserted the
words, "Provided the guys are not through grounded to permanently
damp earth," and at the end of the paragraph we have added the words
"provided the guys are through grounded to permanently damp earth."
This paragraph is so important that we could not change it. In a
conference which lasted over an hour, Mr. Osgood, the Chairman of the
Joint Committee, led me to believe, in fact he finally told me, that he
would undertake to have his associates adopt No. 18 as written by us
provided we would adopt the others as written by him. I move the
adoption of paragraph 18 as written here.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. R. D. Coombs : — I assume that this would be the proper time to
read a letter to the Association on behalf of the Joint Committee. The
Joint Committee was organized by placing on the Committee of the
National Electric Light Association the Chairman of the corresponding
committee of each of the associations interested, so that one Committee
could do the work, and therefore, when we speak of the Committee of the
National Electric Light Association, it refers to the Joint Committee and
their report.
The letter which I shall now read for Mr. Farley Osgood was written
before the action of the Committee to-day was known :
"The action of the Committee on Electricity of the American Rail-
way Engineering and Maintenance of Way Association in not unanimously
approving and formally recommending for adoption the Overhead Cross-
ing Specification, as drawn by the Joint Committee appointed for that
purpose, leads me, as Chairman of the Joint Committee, to call to your
attention some important facts concerning the specification and action
on the same by other Associations in the hope that the matter may be
reconsidered by your Association, with a view of establishing this year
a national standard specification for crossings of overhead lines, which
will become a fact if your Association, also a participant in the formula-
tion of the work, and the last one to act, and the only one up-to-date to
disagree, can so adjust its desires concerning changes in the specification,
as to make it possible for them to adopt it now, as written, for the sake
of unanimity of action just at this time.
"The specification, as written, has been formally ratified and adopted
by the National Electric Light Association ; American Institute of Elec-
trical Engineers; Association of Railway Telegraph Superintendents;
Engineering and Standards Committee of the American Electric Railway
Engineering Association, the matter now being up for letter ballot by that
Association, requiring under their rules a delay of one year; American
1004 ELECTRICITY.
Telephone and Telegraph Company ; Western Union Telegraph Company ;
Postal Telegraph-Cable Company. The Sub-committee on Crossings
of the Committee on Electricity of the American Railway Engineering
and Maintenance of Way Association has recommended the adoption of
the specification to the general Committee on Electricity.
"In view of these facts, there was not the least doubt in anybody's
mind as to the formal adoption by the General Committee on Electricity
of the specification as recommended by their own sub-committee, whose
Chairman was a member of the Joint Committee which formulated the
specification, and we learn with much regret that your Sub-committee
Chairman is obliged to report that your Committee, even now, feel that
a few changes should be made before final approval for adoption.
"For convenience of discussion and examination, we attach hereto
a list of clauses of the specification which were recommended by your
Committee for change, and for convenience sake, we have listed both
the specification, as written, clauses and suggested changes in two ways ;
one of the lists showing the changes written into the clauses in red ink,
and the other list showing the sections side by side in parallel columns.
"A study of the changes recommended brings out the rather remark-
able fact that alterations are recommended in only thirteen paragraphs
out of a specification of some twenty-eight printed pages, and the Joint
Committee which formulated this specification originally honestly believes
that the differences between the specification as written and as suggested
are so slight, in that they are of no great engineering importance, that
on a careful reconsideration of this matter by the Committee on Elec-
tricity, they may find it possible to waive their objections for the moment,
and recommend for formal adoption this specification as written, in order
that all the Associations represented in the Joint Committee may accept
the work and launch it as a national standard.
"The Joint Committee does not feel that the suggested changes, as
indicated in the attached lists, are in any way improper or undesirable, and
in fact, a number of them, we believe, may improve the specification, espe-
cially in clearness of expression, but do not feel that the structural re-
sults are materially altered, and certainly are not sufficiently changed to
be a reason for preventing the universal adoption of the specification.
"The list of names of the Joint Committee shows that the men form-
ing the same are of very wide experience in the field of work under dis-
cussion, and are representative of all conflicting interests in overhead
construction work, and the fact that so many engineers have agreed upon
a specification mutually in Committee, and the fact that the Associations
and large companies represented by these men have approved the specifi-
cation, is a very strong indication that the specification must be a good
one and sufficiently safe for our mutual purposes, and it is such a great
improvement over anything which has ever before been offered that we
feel it our real duty to ask you to reconsider this matter in the broadest
possible way, and in fairness to the national overhead construction situ-
ation, as a whole, which represents a vast number of conflicting interests
of which the steam railroads are one, and an important one, although
many of the other large interests, the Committee believes, are quite as
important, both from an engineering and financial standpoint, and, there-
fore, we feel that their judgment in formally adopting the specification
drawn by their representatives should have a great deal of weight with
your Association, our last member of the General Committee to join
hands with us.
"Our plea of reconsideration is made as a matter of engineering pol-
icy and in the cause of a mutually broad and universal specification, which
you, of course, realize has been the desire of all parties interested in this
DISCUSSION. 1005
matter for a number of years, and we most respectfully urge that your
Association adopt the Overhead Crossing Specification exactly as written.
"We would further suggest that after your Association has adopted
this specification as written, that it at once make a recommendation to
the Joint Committee covering the changes it desires, in order that the
Joint Committee may take them up promptly, having them discussed and
worked out by the various representatives of the interests concerned, and
worked into the specification at the first opportunity for revision whicli
presents itself.
"The Joint Committee believes that this action on the part of your
Association will be a healthy one, and as all the representative parties
formulating the specification will have formally adopted the same, each
Association, or each individual engineer, will then be in a position to
criticize the specification in detail, and the Joint Committee, which is a
standing one, will be in a position to take care of such criticisms formally
and effectively, and the results of the use of the specification in the field
will thus become known to the Joint Committee, and all desirable changes
can be made from time to time, so that eventually we should have a
specification which will be as perfect as a specification can be, and having
started with this one as a sound base, each year's changes can be worked
out from the needs of the field engineers discovering weaknesses in the
work as it stands to-day, which method we believe to be rational, and
quite the best one from the standpoint of all construction engineers or
Associations affected by this specification."
The Secretary : — "19. Clearing. The space around the poles, or
towers, shall be kept free from inflammable material, underbrush and
gras<.
"20. Signs. In the case of railroad crossings, if required by the rail-
road company, warning signs of an approved design shall be placed on all
poles and towers located on the railroad company's right-of-way.
"21. Grounding. For voltages over 5,000 volts, wooden crossarms,
if used, shall be provided with a grounded metallic plate on top of the
arm, which shall be not less than % inch in thickness and which shall
have a sectional area and conductivity not less than that of the line con-
ductor. Metal pins shall be electrically connected to this ground. Metal
poles and metal arms on wooden poles shall be grounded.
"22. The electrical conductivity of the ground conductor shall be ad-
justed to the short-circuit current capacity of the system and shall be
not less than that of a No. 4 B. & S. gage copper wire.
"23. Temperature. In the computation of stresses and clearances,
and in erection, provision shall be made for a variation in temperature
from — 20 degrees Fahrenheit to +120 degrees Fahrenheit. A suitable
modification in the temperature requirements shall be made for regions
in which the above limits would not fairly represent the extreme range
of temperature.
"24. Inspection. If required by contract, all material and workman-
ship shall be subject to the inspection of the company crossed; provided,
that reasonable notice of the intention to make shop inspection shall be
given by such company; if such notification is not given, the company
crossed shall be furnished with certified reports of shop inspection of
material and workmanship made by a properly qualified inspector. De-
1006 ELECTRICITY.
fcctivc material shall be rejected, and shall be removed and replaced with
suitable material."
Mr. Kittredge: — This is one of the paragraphs in question. On the
fourth line it says : "If such notification is not given, the company
crossed shall be furnished with certified reports of shop inspection of
material and workmanship made by a properly qualified inspector." These
words do not appear in the report of the Joint Committee, and for the
reasons stated I move the adoption of paragraph 24 of the Joint Com-
mittee report.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "25. On the completion of the work, all falsework,
plant and rubbish, incident to the construction, shall be removed promptly
and the site left unobstructed and clean.
"26. Drawings. If required, by contract,
( ) complete sets of general and detail drawings shall • be fur-
nished for approval, before any construction is commenced.
"27. The conductors shall be considered as uniformly loaded through-
cut their length, with a load equal to the resultant of the dead load plus
the weight of a layer of ice Yz inch in thickness, and a wind pressure of
8 lbs. per square foot on the ice-covered diameter, at a temperature of
o degrees Fahrenheit."
Mr. A. F. Robinson (Santa Fe) : — It seems to me the provision for
load is hardly sufficient ; when ice gathers on wires it seldom forms in a
circle, it is oblong and hangs to one side of the wire. That would vitiate
the use of a wind pressure of 8 lbs. per square foot, because it is strik-
ing more nearly on a plane surface than it would if blowing against the
cylinder. It also seems to me it would be better if we could arrive at a
uniform load per linear foot, without respect to the size of the wire, size
of the supporting cable or anything of that sort. It is a matter of very
small moment when you work it out. If you take a 1 ^4-inch wire it
means about 1.4 lbs. per linear foot, and it seems to me we could cut nearly
all of that out and put a provision in that the wires shall be figured for
10, 15 or 20 lbs. per linear foot, and not say anything about the ice or
anything of that sort.
I would offer that as a suggestion for the consideration of the Com-
mittee in future revisions of the specification.
The Secretary : — "28. The weight of ice shall be assumed as 57 lbs.
per cubic foot (0.033 lbs. per cubic inch).
"29. Insulators, pins and conductor attachments shall be designed to
withstand, with the designated factor of safety, the tension in the con-
ductors under the maximum loading, assuming the conductor to be broken
on one side of the structure."
Mr. Kittredge : — This is another paragraph that differs from the Joint
Committee report, and I move the adoption of paragraph 29, of the Joint
Committee report.
(The motion was carried.)
DISCUSSION. 1007
The Secretary: — "30. The pole, or towers, shall be designed to with-
stand, with the designated factor of safety, the combined stresses from
their own weight, the wind pressure on the pole, or tower, and the above
wire loading on the crossing span and the next adjoining span on each
side. The wind pressure on the poles, or towers, shall be assumed at 13
lbs. per square foot on the projected area of solid or closed structures, and
on \l/2 times the projected area of lattice structures."
Mr. Ambrose : — In designing your towers, should you not assume
one span broken?
The President: — Section 31 takes care of that.
The Secretary: — "31. The poles, or towers, shall also be designed to
withstand the most unfavorable condition of the loads specified in para-
graph 30, combined with the unbalanced tension of
Two broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 5 wires or less.
Three broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 6 to 10 wires.
Four broken wires for poles, or towers, carrying 11 or more wires."
Mr. Kittredge : — Mr. Chairman, this paragraph contains the words,
"The most unfavorable condition," which the paragraph of the Joint Com-
mittee does not contain. For the reasons already stated I move the
adoption of paragraph 31 of the Joint Committee.
Mr. E. B. Katte (New York Central & Hudson River) :— I believe
in co-operation and in standards, but not in the adoption of a standard
unless it is something that is as good as we can make it. This Com-
mittee has had a little longer to consider the specifications than the so-
called Joint Committee, and at the largest meeting that your Committee
on Electricity ever held, it was agreed to make the modifications as
printed in the report. I believe that it has been generally admitted by all
of the other committees that the changes are good and that they should
be made. I have been told that the other committees would consider
these modifications and in all probability would accept some, if not all
cf them, at their next meetings. During the months following these
meetings, if you do not adopt the revised specifications we will be
lagging behind the other associations. Our specifications will contain
thirteen clauses which are improper or at least ambiguous. On the other
hand, if we adopt to-day the specifications as modified and printed in your
Bulletin, we will be six months in advance. Next fall the other asso-
ciations will, perhaps, adopt the specifications that are before you to-day :
then we will have co-operated in obtaining a joint standard specification
and one that does not contain thirteen objectionable clauses.
Mr. R. D. Coombs : — I am compelled to disagree with Mr. Katte, be-
cause the main argument for warning this Association not to make changes
is to obtain a uniform national standard, and the engineering differences
are so slight that personally I do not believe that construction will be
impaired during that six months.
Mr. Katte : — This Association has already adopted one change, namely,
clause 18. The specifications will not be uniform now. As long as you
1008 ELECTRICITY.
have made one change, why not make all the other admittedly desirable
changes ?
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — There is something to be said on both sides ot
this question. If we were independent and could say, "We will adopt
our own specifications," the chances are the other associations would
throw them out, and at about 90 per cent, of the crossings we would
have to take whatever they would give us, and for the sake of uniformity,
I believe that half a loaf is better than none at all ; so I think we ought
to adopt these specifications, with the exception of clause 18.
(The question was called for and, on vote, duly carried.)
The Secretary : — "32. Crossarms shall be designed to withstand the
loading specified in paragraph 30, combined with the unbalanced tension of
the wire, which, when broken, produces the highest fiber stress in the
arm."
Mr. Kittredge : — This paragraph differs from the Joint Committee
report, in that it uses the words, "which, when broken, produces the high-
est fiber stress in the arm." For the reasons already stated, I move tht
adoption of paragraph 32, shown on page 522 of the joint report.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary : — "33. The poles, or towers, may be permitted a rea-
sonable deflection under the specified loading, provided that such deflection
does not reduce the clearances specified in paragraph No. 10 more than
25 per cent, or produce stresses in excess of those specified in paragraphs
Nos. 65 to 69.
"34. The ultimate unit stress divided by the allowable stress shall
be not less than the following :
Wires and cables 2
Pins 2
Insulators, conductor attachments, guys 3
Wooden poles and crossarms 6
Structural steel 3
Reinforced concrete poles and crossarms 4
Foundations 2
"Note. — The treating of wooden poles and crossarms is recommended.
The treatment of wooden poles and crossarms should be by thorough
impregnation with preservative by either closed or open-tank process.
For poles, except in the case of yellow pine, the treatment need not ex-
tend higher than a point 2 feet above the ground line."
Mr. Kittredge : — This last paragraph contains a difference in the first
sentence of the note. The joint paragraph reads, "The ultimate unit stress
divided by the allowable unit stress shall be not less than the following,
etc." For the reasons already stated, I move the adoption of the para-
graph shown on pages 522 and 523.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "35. Insulators. Insulators for line voltages of less
than 9,000 shall not flash over at four times the normal working voltage,
DISCUSSION. 100!>
under a precipitation of water of 1/5 of an inch per minute, at an in-
clination of 45 degrees to the axis of the insulator.
"36. Each separate part of a built-up insulator, for line voltages over
9,000, shall be subjected to the dry flash-over test of that part for five eon--
secutive minutes.
"27. Each assembled and cemented insulator shall be subjected to
its dry flash-over test for five consecutive minutes.
"The dry flash-over test shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Test Voltage.
Exceeding 9,000, but not exceeding 14,000 65,000
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000 100,000
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 3S,coo 125,000
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000 150,000
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 60,000 180,000
Exceeding 60,000 3 times line voltage
"Each insulator shall further be so designed that, with excessive po-
tential, failure will first occur by flash-over and not by puncture.
"38. Each assembled insulator shall be subjected to a wet flash-over
test, under a precipitation of water of 1/5 inch per minute, at an inclina-
tion of 45 degrees to the axis of the insulator.
"The wet flash-over test shall be not less than :
Line Voltage. Test Voltage.
Exceeding 9,000, but not exceeding 14,000 40,000
Exceeding 14,000, but not exceeding 27,000 60,000
Exceeding 27,000, but not exceeding 3S»ooo 80,000
Exceeding 35,000, but not exceeding 47,000 100,000
Exceeding 47,000, but not exceeding 60,000 120,000
Exceeding 60,000 twice the line voltage
"39. Test voltages above 35,000 volts shall be determined by the
A. I. E. E. Standard Spark-Gap Method.
"40. Test voltages below 35,000 volts shall be determined by trans-
former ratio.
"41. Conductors. The conductors shall be of copper, aluminum, or
other noncorrodible material, except that in exceptionally long spans,
where the required mechanical strength cannot be obtained with the above
materials, galvanized or copper-covered steel strand may be used.
"42. For voltages not exceeding 750 volts, solid or stranded con-
ductors may be used up to and including 4/0 in size ; above 4/0 in size,
stranded conductors shall be used. For voltages exceeding 750 volts, and
not exceeding 5,000 volts, solid or stranded conductors may be used up to
and including 2/0 in size ; above 2/0 in size, conductors shall be stranded.
For voltages exceeding 5,000 volts, all conductors shall be stranded-.
Aluminum conductors for all voltages and sizes shall be stranded.
The minimum size of conductors shall be as follows:
No. 6 B. & S. gage copper for voltages not exceeding 5,000 volts.
No. 4 B. & S. gage copper for voltages exceeding 5,000 volts.
1010 ELECTRICITY.
No. i B. & S. gage aluminum for all voltages.
"43. Insulators. Insulators shall be of porcelain for voltages exceed-
ing 5,000 volts.
"44. Strain insulators for guys shall have an ultimate strength of
not less than twice that of the guy in which placed. Strain insulators
shall be so constructed that the guy wires holding the insulator in position
will interlock in case of the failure of the insulator.
"Strain insulators for guys shall not flash over at four times the
maximum line voltage, under a precipitation of water of 1/5 inch per
minute, at an inclination of 45 degrees to the axis of the insulator.
"45. Pins. For voltages of 5,000 and over, insulator pins shall be
steel, wrought iron, malleable iron, or other approved metal or alloy, and
shall be galvanized, or otherwise protected from corrosion. Pins shall
be locked with cotter, nut, or other device, to prevent raising out of the
socket or hole in the crossarm."
Mr. Kittredge : — This paragraph varies from that of the joint report
in that the last sentence of this paragraph does not appear in the joint
report, "Pins shall be locked with cotter," etc. For the reasons already
stated, I move that paragraph 45, on page 523, be adopted.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "46. Guys. Guys shall be galvanized or copper-
covered stranded steel cable, not less than 5/16 inch in diameter, or gal-
vanized rolled rods of equivalent tensile strength.
"47. Guys to the ground shall connect to a galvanized anchor rod.
extending at least 1 foot above the ground level.
"48. The detail of the anchorage shall be definitely shown upon the
plans.
"49. Wooden Poles. Wooden poles shall be of selected timber of ap-
proved species, peeled, free from defects which would decrease their
strength or durability, not less than 7 inches minimum diameter at the
top, and meeting the requirements as specified in paragraphs 17, 30, 31
and 34."
Mr. Kittredge: — Mr. Chairman, this varies from the joint report para-
graph in that the joint report paragraph omits the words, "of approved
species." For the reasons already given, I move the adoption of para-
graph 49, on page 523.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary : — "50. Concrete. All concrete and concrete material
shall be in accordance with the requirements of the Report of the Joint
Committee on Concrete and Reinforced Concrete.
"51. Structural steel shall be open-hearth, in accordance with the
Manufacturers' Standard Specifications."
Mr. Kittredge : — This paragraph differs from the Joint Committee
paragraph in that the word "open-hearth" is omitted in the joint specifi-
cation. For the reasons already stated, I move the adoption of paragraph
51, page 523.
Mr. Earl Stimson (Baltimore & Ohio) :— It would be interesting to
DISCUSSION. 1011
me to know why the Committee prepared these specifications, knowing the
Joint Committee specifications were already in existence, and recommend-
ing them for adoption, and even going so far as to state that their own
specifications were more satisfactory, and now be willing to modify them
to conform to the joint specifications in every respect.
Mr. Kittredge : — When these specifications were adopted by your Com-
mittee and sent for printing in the Bulletin, we were led to believe by the
Joint Committee that if they varied in any particular it would be just as if
we had thrown over their whole specifications. Afterward, when we met
several members of the Joint Committee and explained to them our im-
movable position in regard to clause 18, they said they would undertake to
modify their clause 18 to meet ours, if we would modify the others to
meet theirs. That is the sole and only reason we have for recommend-
ing as we do.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary : — "52. The design and workmanship shall be strictly
in accordance with first-class practice.
"53. The form of the frame shall be such that the stresses may be
computed with reasonable accuracy, or the strength shall be determined
by actual test.
"54. The sections used shall permit inspection, cleaning and painting,
and shall be free from pockets in which water or dirt can collect
"55. The length of a main compression member shall not exceed 150
times the least radius of gyration. The length of a secondary compression
member shall not exceed 180 times its least radius of gyration."
Mr. Kittredge: — This varies in that the "150" of our report is "180"
of the Joint Committee report and the 180 of our report, on the last line,
is 220 in the joint report. For the reasons already stated, I move the
adoption of paragraph 55, page 523.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary : — "56. The minimum thickness of metal in galvanized
structures shall be % inch for main members, and % inch for secondary
members. The minimum thickness of painted material shall be % inch.
"57. All structural steel shall be thoroughly cleaned at the shop
and be galvanized, or given one coat of approved paint.
"58. Painted Material. All contact surfaces shall be given one coat
of paint before assembling.
"All painted structural steel shall be given two field coats of an
approved paint.
"The surface of the metal shall be thoroughly cleaned of all dirt,
grease, scale, etc., before painting, and no painting shall be done in freez-
ing or rainy weather.
"59. Galvanized Material. Galvanized material shall be in accordance
with the Specifications for Galvanizing Iron and Steel (Appendix).
"Bolt holes in galvanized material shall be made before galvanizing.
"60. The foundations for steel poles and towers shall be designed to
prevent overturning.
1012 ELECTRICITY.
"The weight of concrete shall be assumed as 140 lbs. per cubic foot.
In good ground, the weight of 'earth' shall be assumed as 100 lbs. per
cubic foot. In swampy ground, special measures shall be taken to prevent
uplift or depression."
Mr. Kittredge: — This varies from the Joint Committee report in that
the latter has a bracketed clause which says, "Calculated at 30 degrees
from the vertical." For the reasons already stated, I move the adoption
of paragraph 60, page 523.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "61. The top of the concrete foundation, or casing,
shall be not less than 12 inches above the surface of the ground or ex-
treme high water."
Mr. Kittredge : — This varies from the Joint Committee report in
that the Joint Committee report says, "The top of the concrete founda-
tion, or casing, shall be not less than 6 inches above surface of the ground,
nor less than 1 foot above extreme high water." For the reasons already
stated, I move the adoption of paragraph 61, on page 523.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary :- — "62. When located in swampy ground, wooden cross-
ing and next adjoining poles shall be set in barrels of broken stone or
gravel, or in broken stone or timber footings.
"63. When located in the sides of banks, or when subject to wash-
outs, foundations shall be given additional depth, or be protected by crib-
bing or riprap.
"64. All foundations and pole settings shall be tamped in 6-inch
layers, while back filling.
"Working Unit Stresses. — Obtained by dividing the ultimate breaking
strength by the factors of safety given in paragraph 34.
Lbs. per sq. in.
"65. Structural Steel. Tension (net section) 18,000
Shear 14,000
Compression 18,000-60-
r
"65. Rivets, Pins. Shear 10,000
Bearing 20,000
Bending 20,000
"67. Bolts. Shear 8,500
Bearing 17,000
Bending 17,000
"68. Wires and Cables. Copper, hard-drawn, solid,
B. & S. gage, 4/0, 3/0, 2/0 25,000
Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, 1/0. .. .27,500
Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, No. 1.. 28,500
Copper, hard-drawn, solid, B. & S. gage, Nos.
2, 4, 6 30,000
Copper, soft-drawn, solid, B. & S 17,000
Cupper, hard-drawn, stranded, B. & S 30,000
DISCUSSION. 1013
Copper, soft-drawn, stranded, B. & S 17,000
Aluminum, hard-drawn, stranded, B. & S. gage,
under 4/0 12,000
Aluminum, hard-drawn, stranded, B. & S. gage,
4/0 and over 11,500
"69. Untreated Timber. East- Bending. Compression.
ern white cedar.. 600 lbs. per sq. in.. 600(1 — —-)
Chestnut 850 lbs. per sq. in. . 850
Washington cedar 850 lbs. per sq. in. . 850
Idaho cedar 850 lbs. per sq. in. . 850
Port Orford cedar 1150 lbs. per sq. in. .1150
Long-leaf yellow pine... 1 100 lbs. per sq. in.. 1 100
Short-leaf yellow pine. .. 950 lbs. per sq. in. . 950
Douglas fir 1000 lbs. per sq. in. .1000
White oak 950 lbs. per sq. in. . 950 "
Red Cedar 700 lbs. per sq. in. . 700
Bald cypress (heartw'd) 800 lbs. per sq. in. . 800
Redwood 850 lbs. per sq. in. . 850
Catalpa 500 lbs. per sq. in. . 500
Juniper 550 lbs. per sq. in. . 550
L = Length in inches.
D = Least side, or diameter, in inches.
"SPECIFICATIONS FOR GALVANIZING FOR IRON OR STEEL.
"These specifications give in detail the test to be applied to galvanized
material. All specimens shall be capable of withstanding these tests.
"(A) Coating. The galvanizing shall consist of a continuous coating
of pure zinc of uniform thickness, and so applied that it adheres firmly
to the surface of the iron or steel. The finished product shall be smooth.
"(B) Cleaning. The samples shall be cleaned before testing, first with
carbona, benzine or turpentine and cotton waste (not with a brush), and
then thoroughly rinsed in clean water and wiped dry with clean cotton
waste.
"The sample shall be clean and dry before each immersion in the
solution.
"(C) Solution. The standard solution of copper sulphate shall con-
sist of commercial copper sulphate crystals dissolved in cold water, about
in the proportion of 36 parts, by weight, of crystals to 100 parts, by weight,
of water. The solution shall be neutralized by the addition of an excess
of chemically pure cupric oxide (Cu O). The presence of an excess of
cupric oxide will be shown by the sediment of this reagent at the bottom of
the containing vessel.
"The neutralized solution shall be filtered before using by passing
through filter paper. The filtered solution shall have a specific gravity of
1. 186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit (reading the scale at the level of the sola-
1014 ELECTRICITY.
tion) at the beginning of each test. In case the filtered solution is high
in specific gravity, clean water shall be added to reduce the specific
gravity at 1.186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit. In case the filtered solution is
low in specific gravity, filtered solution of a higher specific gravity shall
be added to make the specific gravity 1.186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit.
"As soon as the stronger solution is taken from the vessel containing
the unfiltered neutralized stock solution, additional crystals and water must
be added to the stock solution. An excess of cupric oxide shall always be
kept in the unfiltered stock solution.
"(D) Quantity of Solution. Wire samples shall be tested in a glass
jar of at least 2 in. inside diameter. The jar without the wire samples
shall be filled with standard solution to a depth of at least 4 in. Hard-
ware samples shall be tested in a glass or earthenware jar containing at
least l/z pint of standard solution for each hardware sample.
"Solution shall not be used for more than one series of four im-
mersions.
"(E) Samples. Not more than seven wires shall be simultaneously
immersed, and not more than one sample of galvanized material other
than wire shall be immersed in the specified quantity of solution.
"The samples shall not be grouped or twisted together, but shall be
well separated so as to permit the action of the solution to be uniform
upon all immersed portions of the samples.
"(F) Test. Clean and dry samples shall be immersed in the required
quantity of standard solution in accordance with the following cycle of
immersions.
"The temperature of the solution shall be maintained between 62
degrees and 68 degrees Fahrenheit at all times during the following test :
"(1) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
"(2) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
"(3) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
" (4) Immerse for one minute, wash and wipe dry.
"After each immersion the samples shall be immediately washed in
clean water having a temperature between 62 degrees and 68 degrees
Fahrenheit, and wiped dry with cotton waste.
"In the case of No. 14 galvanized iron or steel wire, the time of the
fourth immersion shall be reduced to Yi minute.
"(G) Rejection. If after the test described in section (F) there
should be a bright metallic copper deposit upon the samples, the lot repre-
sented by the sample shall be rejected.
"Copper deposits on zinc or within 1 in. of the cut end shall not be
considered causes for rejection.
"In the case of a failure of only one wire in a group of seven wires
immersed together, or if there is a reasonable doubt as to the copper
deposit, two check tests shall be made on these seven wires and the
lot reported in accordance with the majority of the sets of tests.
DISCUSSION. 1015
"Note. — The equipment necessary for the tests herein outlined is as
follows :
"Filter paper.
"Commercial copper sulphate crystals.
"Chemically pure cupric oxide (Cu O).
"Running water.
"Warm water or ice, as per needs.
"Carbona, benzine or turpentine.
"Glass jars at least 2 in. inside diameter by at least 4^ in. high.
"Glass or earthenware jars for hardware samples.
"Vessel for washing samples.
"Tray for holding jars of stock solution.
"Jars, bottles and porcelain basket for stock solution.
"Cotton waste.
"Hydrometer cylinder 3 in. diameter by 15 in. high.
"Thermometer with large Fahrenheit scale correct at 62 and 68 de-
grees.
"Hydrometer correct at 1.186 at 65 degrees Fahrenheit."
Mr. Kittredge : — I move the adoption of specifications for overhead
crossings, as amended.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Kittredge : — The recommendation of the Committee is the con-
tinuation of work already outlined.
Mr. A. F. Robinson : — I may be a little bit late, but I want to call
attention to two or three items in these specifications we have adopted
that are not consistent with our specifications for structural material, and
to suggest that a small committee of one or two persons be appointed to
confer with the Committee on Electricity, suggesting these minor changes,
which they wish put up to the Joint Committee later on for adoption.
These changes will make the specifications consistent with our printed
specifications, and with ordinary working conditions, and I think will
be a decided improvement. I am not offering this with any idea of
objecting to the specifications as a whole, but simply to make them con-
sistent all the way through. I think it could be handled very easily in
this manner, so that the Committee on Electricity can get the matter
into shape for presentation to the Joint Committee.
Mr. F. J. Bachelder (Baltimore & Ohio) :— I would 'like to ask if the
manufacturer's- standard specifications mentioned in paragraph 51 are
the same as the specifications of this Association.
Mr. Robinson : — That was one of the items I had in mind in speak-
ing.
The President: — Mr. Robinson, will you write a letter to the Chair-
man of the Committee?
Mr. Robinson : — Yes, I will, and cover all the features I have in
mind.
Mr. Kittredge : — The Committee would not only gladly accept such
a letter, but would gladly accept the names of any individuals whom Mr.
1016 ELECTRICITY.
Robinson might suggest, who would prove valuable members of the Com-
mittee. We would be glad to have two or three more good members and
would welcome more such men as Mr. Robinson refers to.
Mr. Ambrose : — Is it understood that the Committee will take up these
higher voltages at once? We have several crossings now in existence
carrying 110,000 volts and would be glad to have some recommendation.
Mr. Kittredge : — I would suggest that such a letter be addressed to
the Board of Direction, so that it will come before the Committee in the
regular formal way.
The President : — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of" the
Association. There has been an immense amount of work done in this
connection.
DISCUSSION ON RAIL.
(For Report, see pp. 559-862.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON RAIL.
Chas. S. Churchill. George W. Kittredge. John G. Sullivan.
R. D. Coombs. C. E. Lindsay. G. H. Tinker.
W. C. Cushing. W. L. Seddon. Robert Trimble.
L. C. Fritch. W. F. Steffens. Walter Loring Webb.
James E. Howard.
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on Rail,
Mr. Chas. S. Churchill, Chairman. The Chairman is requested to make
the preliminary statement.
Mr. Chas. S. Churchill (Norfolk & Western) :— The report of the
Rail Committee begins at the top of page 560. We have there, in the
first place, the answer to our instruction No. 3, "Continue the investiga-
tion of breakage and failure of rails." This being a study of failed rails
up to October 31, 1910, with conclusions.
"(1) Study of these general statistics does not furnish accurate and
specific information so as to determine the value of different sections of
rail, because (a) The conditions of traffic are different; (b) the condi-
tions of roadbed are different; (c) the conditions of ingot making and
rolling practice are so different that the quality of the material varies
widely, and, at the present time, this difference in quality of the material
eliminates differences in section ; nevertheless, when the time comes that
the difference in quality of material will be less, the influence of the sec-
tion will be more apparent, for there is no doubt that one section is
stiffer and stronger than another according to the distribution of the
material. Inasmuch as we are endeavoring to eliminate the differences in
quality of material and bring it to a high state of perfection, we should
not, in the meantime, lose sight of the desirable features of the rail sec-
tion, but keep them constantly in mind, so that when we arrive at a good
quality of metal, we will also have a desirable rail section.
"(2) A study of these general statistics tends to disclose unusual re-
sults, and were it not for their compilation, we would not have much in-
formation relative to the difference between Bessemer and Open-Hearth
steel and concerning the various alloys.
"(3) The general statistics are also important, in showing a relation
between broken rails and failure of head, web and base.
"(4) Their tabulation discloses the difference between Steel Com-
panies when the sections and chemical composition are practically the
same.
1017
1018 RAIL.
"The report by Mr. Wickhorst covers an investigation made at the
South Works of the Illinois Steel Company, to throw light on the rela-
tionship of the size of ingots of Bessemer Rail steel to the segregation of
the metalloids, locations of pipes and blow holes, and the properties of
the rails. This investigation showed that under the conditions of the tests,
the carbon, phosphorus and sulphur collected or segregated toward the in-
terior and upper part of the ingot and that, in a general way, such segre-
gation increased as the size of the ingot increased. The manganese also
segregated some, but to a much smaller extent, while the silicon showed
little or no tendency to segregate.
"The elements which segregated as described also showed a lowering
in the top part of the ingot, below the average composition of the steel
and this lowering extended downward along the sides of the ;no;ot. The
'negative' segregation increased in general as the size of the ingot in-
creased and also extended down further along the sides of the ingot.
There was also a region of negative segregation in the interior and lower
part of the ingot, but the lowering of the elements was not as great in
this region.
"This investigation also indicated that the material was distributed in
the rail bar about the same, relatively, as it was in the ingot from which
the rail bar had been rolled.
"(D) Tests of Rail Steel Ingots and Derivative Shapes Made at Wa-
tertown Arsenal, being a Review by M. H. Wickhorst of the Report Pub-
lished by the Watertown Arsenal (Bulletin No. 139, September, 191 1.)
"This report covers a digest and analysis of the Government investi-
gation at the Watertown Arsenal of rail steel ingots and derivative shapes
as embodied in the Report of Tests of Metals, etc., made at the Water-
town Arsenal for the year 1909.
"The work indicated that the interior cavities of an ingot cooled di-
rectly after pouring are about the same or slightly less than in a similar
ingot placed in the soaking pit and then cooled. This same result was
also indicated as true of blooms made from such ingots.
"It was shown that almost the full tensile strength and ductility of the
metal of the lower part of the ingot were obtained rolling to about one-
tenth of the original cross-section, but with the metal of the upper part
of the ingot it was necessary to reduce the cross-section to one-twenty-
fifth or less of the original amount.
"A great many etchings were made and it was shown that the structure
of the cross-section as developed by etching varies from the top to the
bottom of the ingot and that each structure finds its counterpart in suc-
ceeding shapes and at about the same proportionate distance from the
top end. It was also shown that the structure was considerably altered by
changing the position in which the ingot was allowed to cool, as for in-
stance allowing it to cool on its side after stripping.
"(E) Influence of Rolling Temperature on the Properties of Bes-
semer Rails, by M. H. Wickhorst, November, 191 1.
"This report covers an investigation made at the works of the Car-
DISCUSSION. 1019
negie Steel Company to determine the influence of the temperature of
rolling on the properties of Bessemer Rails. This work indicated that the
ductility and deflection in the drop test were influenced little, if any,
by the rolling temperature. The number of blows that it took to break the
rails in the drop test was uninfluenced by the temperature of rolling. The
yield point and tensile strength in the tension tests were influenced little,
if any. The elongation in the tension test decreased some as the temper-
ature increased. The influence of temperature showed most prominently
in the tension test, in the reduction of area, which decreased as the tem-
perature of rolling increased. The size of the grain, as shown by the
microscope, increased as the temperature increased.
"In this report it is also pointed out that the ductility in the drop test
with the head of the rail in tension more nearly indicates the ductility
of the interior metal as measured in the tension test, than does the ductil-
ity in the drop test with the base of the rail in tension, which is usual in
inspection work.
"Each report mentioned above gives a short summary of the matter
contained in it, but the main principles that seem to have been brought out
by the year's work are set forth in the brief reviews above."
That shows the work that this Committee has done during the year.
I will refer now to the requirement, "Present recommendations on
standard rail sections." The Committee reports progress on this. We
think that the information that is coming, not yet tabulated, on rail fail-
ures for the period ending October 31, 191 1, together with information that
has come in since that date, is going to be of such assistance that this
Committee can make very rapid progress upon this question. Therefore
the Committee reports progress only on this instruction.
We have carried investigation of the failure of rails up to October
31, 1910. Similar statements and conclusions will be prepared and pub-
lished in the course of probably two months on the tabulation of rail
failures for the period ending October 31, 191 1.
The Committee was further instructed to report on the results ob-
tained from the use of Open-Hearth and Special Alloy Steel Rails,
and the chemical composition of such rails.
Bulletin No. 137, referred to above, containing the report of the rail
failure statistics, also gives all the information that the Committee has in
regard to Open-Hearth and Special Alloy Steel Rails.
I have simply referred to these few items so that the members of the
Association will catch quickly the salient features of the report.
With these remarks of the work in general, I wish now to refer to
page 562 of Bulletin 143, and take up the matter beginning with sec-
tion 1 :
"(1) The first item of work for the Rail Committee according to the
instructions for 191 1, was to recommend changes in the specifications for
steel rails.
"Considerable work has been done during the past year in the prepara-
tion of specifications, and the specifications submitted herewith are rec-
1020 RAIL.
ommended by your Committee. Some paragraphs, such as Nos. 5, 6,
14 and 15, are not to be considered as final, it being thought that the Com-
mittee did not have sufficient information in its possession to make these
sections in the specifications mandatory.
One of the sections in question, No. 14, refers to the ductility test.
The requirements, in the specifications, for ductility are somewhat
lower than some members of your Committee think desirable, and it is
hoped that sufficient information will be obtained during the coming year
to enable the Committee to make some revision in these respects.
"Paragraph No. 15, referring to deflections as a method of classifying
rails, is also tentative. It is the intention when sufficient data is at hand
to prescribe maximum and minimum limits for deflections under the drop
test."
The Committee, therefore, asks that the specifications we recom-
mend be now considered and that they be adopted as good practice, and
to that end I would suggest that we take up the specifications so that they
may be discussed and passed upon by paragraphs.
The President : — With the consent of the Association, the Secretary
will read the specifications paragraph by paragraph and will pass from
one to the other without formal action, unless some motion is made.
The Secretary: — "1. Access to Works. — Inspectors representing the
purchaser shall have free entry to the works of the manufacturer at all
times while the contract is being executed, and shall have all reasonable
facilities afforded them by the manufacturer to satisfy them that the
rails have been made in accordance with the terms of the specifications.
"2. Place for Tests. — All tests and inspections shall be made at the
place of manufacture, prior to shipment, and shall be so conducted as not
to interfere unnecessarily with the operation of the mill.
"3. Material. — The material shall be steel made by the Bessemer or
Open-Hearth process provided by the contract.
"4. Chemical Composition. — The chemical composition of the steel
from which the rails are rolled, determined as prescribed in Section 7,
shall be within the limits set forth in the table. (See page 565.)"
The President: — We have with us to-day at our invitation Mr. James
E. Howard, of the Bureau of Standards, and if he is present in the room
I would be glad to have him make some remarks. You all know Mr.
Howard ; he has been present at our meetings before.
Mr. James E. Howard (Bureau of Standards) : — Mr. President arid
Gentlemen: In regard to the general subject of rail, it has been my priv-
ilege to make a number of tests on different occasions, and I feel very
gratified at this opportunity of making a few remarks before you. The
work your Committee has in hand is advancing the subject very mate-
rially and so far I think it has proceeded in a highly satisfactory manner.
It seems, however, that some features connected with the rail situa-
tion ought to be considered which are perhaps a little out of the usual
order, in addition to what we have heretofore directed our attention to.
In regard to matters of test — specifications — I never feel like tying
DISCUSSION. 1021
myself down very closely to specifications. They are necessary, but not
all that is needed.
I will refer to a few of the features which have just been suggested
by reading paragraphs in your specifications. As to this question of
ductility and the deflections in the drop tests, when we come to analyze
the case, it seems that the drop test means simply this — that it gives us an
indication of well-worked metal. I do not know that it does very much
more. If we have the composition of the steel and it is cast in an ingot
and reduced thirty or forty times, we have good evidence when it reaches
the form of a rail that it is well-worked steel. I do not know that we
could secure better evidence that it has been well-worked than the fact
that it has become a rail, so the drop test, in that respect, merely shows
we have secured what we know we have.
In regard to the deflection, what does that mean further than that
one ordinate of a stress-strain curve has been reached. If we make a
tension test of steel we get its elastic limit, and as it is stretched at dif-
ferent intervals beyond also the total extension, and the contraction area.
Now, we are not content usually with just one ordinate of that charac-
ter, and I would request, for consideration, whether the drop test car-
ries with it quite enough information in this respect. We wish to know
something about the elastic limit of the material, and we do not know
what that is from the results of the drop test.
Then it goes back to the question of what elastic limit is needed in
steel rails. It comes to the definition or recognition of what fiber stresses
you have in rails. I do not know what fiber stresses are involved in
rails in the track. Some of the gentlemen present may be in possession
of definite information, but it is doubtful. Earlier tests which I had the
pleasure of conducting showed that the fiber stress per ton on the wheels
varied with different types of engines and different wheels of the same
engine, so that I feel that in general the specifications and tests had not yet
touched upon some of the vital points.
Then, again, in regard to the extension due to the drop test, we are
stretching the metal in the most favorable direction. If we had the same
ductility in the crosswise direction that we have longitudinally, I do not
think there would be so many base fractures. The crescent-shaped frac-
tures are due to a want of structural soundness, which is very evident
when the bases are bent in a crosswise direction, but these defects are not
apparent when we stretch the material in a lengthwise direction.
I hope I am not criticising too many features at this time, but it seems
that these are the things which we ought to consider in addition to those
features which now are covered by specifications.
Concerning the question of chemical analysis, the few observations
that I have made have shown that the composition of the rail in its cross-
section may vary considerably. I will not say it generally varies so much
as witnessed in a recent case, but in a recent case the carbon at the outer
portions was 0.44 per cent, to 0.45 per cent., while at the center of the head
it was as high as 0.77 per cent. That variation in composition is quite wide,
1022 RAIL.
but do you find in the test ingot very much clew to what actually reaches
you in the rails? Should not the rails themselves now and then be care-
fully analyzed for the purpose of determining whether segregated parts
of the ingot were used or whether the outer portions of the rails are not in
a measure decarbonized? There are reasons for thinking there is need
for such procedure.
Doubtless there are other features of importance which do not at this
time occur to me, but I should be very happy to answer any questions
that I may be able to answer, if anyone present would kindly make the
inquiries ; however, these are the salient features which to me seem de-
sirable to consider, and their consideration may aid in securing a better
material.
The President : — Have you any criticism to make on this particular
paragraph that we have just read in reference to the chemical composition
proposed for these specifications? We would be glad to know what you
think in regard to that.
Mr. Howard : — The chemical composition carries with it the idea
of certain physical properties. First, to consider what the physical prop-
erty should- be and then work back from that to the chemical composition.
We have in that case to go back to the fiber stresses which are involved
and until they are defined we cannot reach a definite conclusion ; that is,
considering the rail as a beam subjected to bending stresses. As to the
wheel pressures, cold-rolling on the running surface of the head, that is
still another question. In general, low-carbon steel responds quickly to the
cold-rolling of the wheel, and we do not have a very high stress before
the elastic limit is reached. Higher carbon steel than a mild one is
certainly necessary. But there is danger in going too far, getting too high
a carbon, introducing great brittleness, therefore, I am inclined to favor
a medium carbon ; doubtless the zone of safety lies around 0.65 per cent,
to 0.70 per cent., or a little outside of those limits.
The President: — For open-hearth, Mr. Howard?
Mr. Howard : — I am not prepared to make a distinction between the
two kinds of steel at the present time.
This feature of ductility is one to be considered and we do know this
— that when a material is subjected to repeated alternate stresses it may
be ruptured without the display of any ductility whatever. If we have
a very low carbon steel, although one of great ductility at the outset,
when this is subjected to a comparatively low fiber stress, in alternate di-
rections, we very quickly reach a brittle fracture. That metal will fail
without any display of ductility, and the hardest steel can hardly do less.
It is necessary to start with considerable stiffness or strength in the ma-
terial to resist bending stresses. The ductility which you find in the
drop test is inherent to the new material and not to that which has been
repeatedly strained. It is not necessary that the overstraining force
reaches the elastic limit of the material, to bring about that final state of
brittleness. Too soft a metal is undesirable to use. If the metal is a strong
one, a higher stress can be endured repeatedly without impairing the final
DISCUSSION. 1023
ductility or such ductility as the metal may incidentally be called upon
to develop. That leads to the use of rather high carbons and to be con-
servative, I think around 0.55 to 0.70 is a fair limit.
The dangers of higher carbon, as I see them, are somewhat along
these lines : With high carbon steel, and high wheel pressures, we
reach an unsatisfactory internal condition. To follow the action of
the high wheel pressures, they move the metal on the surface of the
head and induce internal strains of compression. These internal strains
may be of considerable magnitude, and when they exist there must be
a tensile component in the steel below it. In that case we have below
the running surface of the head, metal which is put into tension, and
if structurally unsound there is an opportunity present for an incipient
fracture to develop. To show that the stresses from a disturbing
cause like those under consideration are considerable, I would mention
an example, referring to a steel forging, one which had walls zV*
inches in thickness. The metal of that cylinder was so disturbed by
hammering with a hand hammer that the bore was measurably en-
larged. The dimensions of this cylinder were 8 inches; bore, 15 inches
outside diameter. Hammering the outside surface of the cylinder, the
bore was enlarged nearly one-thousandth of an inch. Turning off one-
eighth of an inch of metal, on a side, restored the diameter of the
bore to its primitive dimension. That showed that the internal strains
in a zone only ^-inch thick were capable of stretching the balance
of 3J/i inches and making its effect measurable. It meant several thou-
sand pounds stress per square inch to do that, so that it is possible
that the cold-rolled surface of the head of the rail may have in it
internal strains amounting to a number of thousand pounds per square
inch, and that coupled with that fact we may have a decarbonized ex-
terior, with a hard center, the decarborized exterior responding easily
to the rolling of the wheels, the hard interior, through its natural lack
of ductility, not responding so well, we have presented ample oppor-
tunity, it would seem, for starting a fracture in the hard steel.
These are features which are regarded as important in considering
what the composition of the steel should be and would lead to limiting
it to the range in carbon which I have mentioned, and to the exercising
of care to see that the steel in the finished rail is fairly uniform in its
composition from the exterior surface to the center of the head.
Mr. Churchill : — You stated that you did not wish to express your-
self as to the chemical analysis as between open-hearth and Bessemer —
do you not think that the lowering of the phosphorus we get in the
open-hearth is a very valuable item to balance the large amount of
carbon in the Bessemer steel? I believe you think that and I want to
bring out that point.
Mr. Howard : — I think that is undoubtedly true, but the effect of
these metalloids, which is well recognized, and which I quite concur in,
justify us in keeping them to the minimum.
Mr. G. H. Tinker (New York, Chicago & St. Louis) : — The speci-
1024 RAIL.
fication states that silicon is not to exceed 0.20. I ask if it would not
be proper to have also a low limit on the silicon; say that it should
not go below 0.13?
Mr. Howard:— In regard to the general chemical problem, I would
not like to go too far in expressing an opinion. I would prefer to
turn that over to the steel men.
Mr. Robert Trimble (Pennsylvania Lines) :— Mr. Howard has talked
about the large internal strains which are set up. Take a steel with
an ultimate tensile strength of about 150,000 pounds per square inch;
how much internal stress can be set up in that steel necessary to cause
a fracture?
Mr. Howard : — The internal stresses that can be set up in a steel
can easily reach its elastic limit. If the steel had an elastic limit of
say from 35,000 to 45,000 pounds per square inch, we could closely
approach that stress.
Mr. Trimble: — You could not go over that?
Mr. Howard : — No ; then we would get a display of ductility.
Mr. Trimble : — I understood you to say it might go over 100,000
pounds per square inch?
Mr. Howard : — No ; I do not think I mentioned that. When the
steel is disturbed (overloaded) by cold-working, internal strains are
certain to result. When a beam is bent transversely, while the load is
sustained, one side will necessarily be in tension, the other in com-
pression, but a beam which is given a permanent bend, so as not to
spring back straight again when the load is released, will have internal
strains from the inside to the outside, described as follows : First ten-
sion, then compression, then the neutral axis, then tension and then
compression on the very outside — that is what you will find in a bent
beam, one which has been bent beyond its elastic limit. In the case of
straightening rails, and it is impractical to straighten them except when
cold, then you will get the combination of internal strains just de-
scribed and in such a state of equilibrium that a few pounds load will
be sufficient to remove some of the initial straightening. Such a result
cannot be avoided. That is one of the conditions we have to reckon
with, and there is no escape from it. Observations show that very
little additional stress on a cold straightened rail will put back some
of its former deflection, that we cannot escape from, and the intensity
of the internal strains may coincide very closely with elastic limit of
the material.
Mr. C. E. Lindsay: — I would like to ask Mr. Howard if in his opinion
the process of annealing would permit the parts to adjust themselves and
relieve internal strain?
Mr. Howard : — Annealing certainly does restore it. Steel responds
very readily to annealing temperatures. Internal strains introduced
by cold working can also be put in with great facility by heating
and quenching. Heat a cylinder to not exceeding 1,000 degrees Fahr-
enheit, quench with cold water from the bore, and initial compression
DISCUSSION. 1025
of 40,000 pounds per square inch may easily result. These internal
strains may be eliminated by annealing. The annealing, to be effi-
cient, has to be carried on at such a temperature that the metal does
not have at that time an appreciable elastic limit. Steel appears to
have some strength at all temperatures up to fusion, but it is of
a viscous nature at the higher temperatures. When those softening
viscous temperatures are reached, there is very little or no real elastic
limit, and if the steel is then slowly cooled internal strains will be
eliminated.
Mr. Churchill : — So far as Mr. Howard's statement refers to No.
4 alone, in behalf of the Committee I would state that the chemistry
is the chemistry of the best rails that we have in service to-day, and
have had for years. It is not the extreme, one way or the other.
In carbon it is the limit prescribed in a number of both manufacturers'
and other specifications that have been used recently, and the limits
are those within which the manufacturers say they can work, and
therefore we want to make especially clear the fact that there is no
departure whatsoever in the chemical part of the specifications from
what has been regarded for years as good practice.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) : — Some manufacturers
in the Bessemer process recommend 0.43 to 0.53 as the limit of carbon
for 85 to ioo-lb. rail. I would like to have the Committee state if
they think that lower limit would not be more satisfactory than the
limit of 0.45 to 0.55.
Mr. Churchill : — We do not think that the little variation of the
two points — two-hundredths in carbon — has any bearing in a lower
limit. This is a workable range, 0.45 to 0.55, that the manufacturers
have been endeavoring to adhere to ; and they are, we think, keeping
their rails more within those limits in recent years than they were
before. The long series of tests reported last year in the second
volume of Proceedings shows how nearly it is practicable to keep a
rail within the specified limits as to chemistry. We think, therefore,
there is no advantage gained in slightly modifying either the lower
limit or the higher limit. If there was anything to be gained, of
course, the Committee would be ready to consider it. I would say
that this fourth paragraph has been passed upon by the Manufac-
turers' Committee as well as the Rail Committee and agreed to.
The President :— Any further discussion on No. 4? If not, the
Secretary will read No. 5.
The Secretary :• — "No. 5. Modification of Carbon for Low Phos-
phorus. When the material used at any mill is such that the average
phosphorus content of the ingot metal used in the Bessemer process
is running below 0.08 and in the Open-Hearth process is running
below 0.03, and if it seems mutually desirable, the carbon may be
increased at the rate of 0.035 f°r eacn °01 that the phosphorus con-
tent of the ingot metal used averages below 0.08 for Bessemer steel,
or 0.03 for Open-Hearth steel."
1026 v RAIL
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — Before we pass No. 5, I do not think it is
quite clear enough. It says : "When the material used at any mill
is such that the average phosphorus content of the ingot metal used
in the Bessemer process is runing below 0.08 and in the open-hearth
process is running below 0.03, and it seems mutually desirable, the
carbon may be increased at the rate of 0.035 for each 0.01 that the
phosphorus content is lower" — that means the decrease of the phos-
phorus. If you want the lower phosphorus, you want the higher
carbon. Therefore, I think it should show the decrease of 0.035.
Phosphorus content would be clearer.
Mr. Churchill : — No ; it is the other way.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — Where you have decrease in the phosphorus,
you can raise the carbon. It does not seem quite clear to me.
Mr. Churchill : — I think if you will reread that carefully it will
be clear — that question has been carefully discussed — "for each decrease
in the 0.01 phosphorus." It is desirable, under consent, to raise the
carbon by the amount stated. The point is that some mills, in their
natural process, obtain Bessemer steel below 0.08 in phosphorus, cer-
tainly below 0.10. The result would be if we had, for example, 0.06
phosphorus with the carbon also running low, an abnormally soft rail.
On the other hand, some open-hearth mills naturally run their phos-
phorus down to the neighborhood of 0.01. In such cases as that
it is allowable to increase the carbon, under agreement, by 0.03 to
each 0.01 in phosphorus below 0.03. However, it is not a require-
ment in the specification ; it is a matter of mutual consent or agree-
ment, after the contract is made or after the work is in progress of
making the rails.
The President: — Any additional discussion on No. 5?
Mr. Tinker : — I would like to ask why the Committee changed
this specification from the ordinary practice at present. The manu-
facturers furnish manganese determinations on every fifth heat. This
specification requires only two determinations a day. I think it is
desirable to have as full information as we can get on all of the
elements.
Mr. Churchill: — We find this to be the general practice, and it
was agreed to as being such. There may be some exceptional cases,
where the determinations are made more often. On the other hand,
I want to call to the attention of the members that we have now
specified the elements the average of which are to be furnished.
In some other specifications this was not called for. Now we have
specifically named all these elements, so there may be no misunder-
standing. This paragraph was fully discussed between our Committee
and the Manufacturers' Committee and agreed to in this form.
The Secretary : — "6. Average Carbon. It is desired that the per-
centage of carbon in an entire order of rails shall average as high
as the mean percentage between the upper and lower limits specified.
DISCUSSION. 1027
"7. Analyses. In order to ascertain whether the chemical com-
position is in accordance with the requirements, analyses shall be
furnished as follows : (a) For Bessemer process the manufacturer
shall furnish to the inspector, daily, carbon determinations for each
heat before the rails are shipped, and two chemical analyses every
24 hours representing the average of the elements, carbon, manganese,
silicon, phosphorus and sulphur contained in the steel, one for each
day and night turn, respectively. These analyses shall be made on
drillings taken from the ladle test ingot not less than one- eighth inch
beneath the surface, fb) For Open-Hearth process, the makers shall
furnish the inspectors with a chemical analysis of the elements, car-
bon, manganese, silicon, phosphorus and sulphur, for each heat. (c)
On request of the inspector, the manufacturer shall furnish drillings
from the test ingot for check analyses.
"8. Physical Qualities. Tests shall be made to determine: (a)
Ductility or toughness as opposed to brittleness. (b) Soundness.
"9. Method of Testing. The physical qualities shall be deter-
mined by the Drop Test.
"10. Drop Testing Machine. The drop testing machine used shall
be the standard of the American Railway Engineering Association,
(a) The tup shall weigh 2,000 lbs., and have a striking face with
a radius of 5 inches. (b) The anvil block shall weigh 20,000 lbs.,
and be supported on springs, (c) The supports for the test pieces
shall be spaced three feet between centers and shall be a part of, and
firmly secured to, the anvil. The bearing surfaces of the supports
shall have a radius of five inches.
"11. Pieces for Drop Test. Drop tests shall be made on pieces
of rail not less than four feet and not more than six feet long. These
test pieces shall be cut from the top end of the top rail of the ingot,
and marked on the base or head with gage marks one inch apart for
three inches each side of the center of the test piece, for measuring
the ductility of the metal."
Mr. Churchill : — I want to call attention to the fact that the test
pieces are to be marked with the gage, on either the head or the base,
which allows it to be tested either with head up or head down. I
make that note especially, because it is one of the points raised by
Mr. Howard. Undoubtedly rails break oftener in track from top
of head down. Hence a drop test with top of head down is a safe
check. This was made the subject of a special report by Mr. Wick-
horst, and you are all familiar with it, I think, as it is given in a recent
Bulletin.
The Secretary: — "12. Temperature of Test Pieces. The tempera-
ture of the test pieces shall be between 60 and 100 degrees Fahrenheit."
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — That was changed from 120 degrees to 100
degrees, was it not, Mr. Chairman of the Committee? I would like
1028 RAIL.
to know the purpose of that change from 120 degrees, upper limit, to
100 degrees.
Mr. Churchill: — It was felt by many that 120 degrees was too
high a limit, and would result in not giving a correct gage on the
results of the test ; 100 degrees is easily secured, and it was thought
advisable to keep the test piece within the ' lower range at the time
the tests were being made.
The Secretary : — "13. Height of Drop. The test piece shall, at
the option of the inspector, be placed head or base upward on the
supports, and be subjected to impact of the tup falling free from
the following heights :
For 70-lb. rail 16 feet
For 80, 85 and 90- lb. rail 17 feet
For 100-lb. rail 18 feet
"14. Elongation or Ductility. Under these impacts the rail under
one or more blows shall show at least 6 per cent, elongation for one
inch, or 5 per cent, each for two consecutive inches of the six-inch
scale, marked as described in Section 11."
Mr. Churchill : — I wish to call the attention of the members to
the fact that this is an important addition to general specifications
heretofore issued. Mr. Howard referred to this matter. If you will
refer to page 818 and page 830 of this Bulletin, in which our specifi-
cations are printed, you will find diagrams showing that the elonga-
tion and ductility varies with the other tests. We all know that one
of the best tests of steel is the elongation and contraction in 8 inches,
or 2 inches, as the case may be, in tests of structural steel. We
want to use a test for rail that can quickly be made, and at the
same time bring out this same comparative information, and if you
will refer especially to) the diagrams on page 830, you will see that
the ductility test shows correspondence to a very fair degree with
tensile tests, for example, and on the preceding page you will see
comparisons between reduction of area and elongation. In other words,
by this ductility test we get a quick means of finding the toughness
or ductility of the material in rail somewhat similar in results to
those secured by the longer method, impracticable of use, we think, in rail
manufacture — that is, the turning down of a specimen, and subjecting
it to a test for tensile strength, reduction of area and elongation.
Mr. John G. Sullivan (Canadian Pacific) : — I would like to ask
two questions : First, I see there is only one limit — "must show at
least 6 per cent, elongation." Now, is it not a fact that the elongation
bears a direct ratio to the middle ordinate, and is it not easier to
measure the middle ordinate in a chord of three feet than it is to
measure the elongation by measuring the distance between points
and, as the unit will be greater, will you not get more accurate
results? This on the assumption that there is a direct ratio between
the two.
DISCUSSION. 1029
Mr. Churchill : — We do not agree that there is a direct ratio
between the two. We started out a few years ago with the idea
that the permanent set would be something of a guide, that it would
give an idea of the character and uniformity of the material ; but
if you will refer to Part 2 of last year's Proceedings, you will find
that there were very great variations on the permanent set meas-
urements. Mr. Wickhorst has since reported upon »this same matter,
and we find, in brief, that the permanent set is not a uniform gage;
that the minimum ductility is a better gage, and it is for that reason
that it is suggested. The permanent set is given in the next para-
graph, and we hope we can fix limits in the course of time to deter-
mine that the material is not too soft.
The President: — What is your second question, Mr. Sullivan?
Mr. John G. Sullivan : — That answers the second one.
Mr. R. D. Coombs (Consulting Engineer) : — Is there any difference
in the result of the test, depending on whether the rail is tested head
up or head down ?
Mr. Churchill : — Mr. Wickhorst brings that out very plainly in
the latter part of this Bulletin. Head down for the upper portion
of the rail bar shows a little less elongation than with head up ; in
the rest of the bar the reverse is true. The safest course is, therefore,
to take head down. We have made it allowable for the inspector
to make the test either way.
Prof. Walter Loring Webb (Consulting Engineer) : — I would like
to ask if there should not be some specification as to stiffness of the
springs which support the anvil block. It states merely that they
should be supported on springs. I think it would make quite a dif-
ference whether those springs were abnormally stiff or abnormally easy.
Mr. Churchill : — That is all given in the specifications for the
standard drop testing machine adopted by the Association a few
years ago.
Mr. R. D. Coombs : — Based upon what the Chairman of the
Committee said a moment ago, would it not be desirable, though I
do not make this as a motion, to add to that paragraph some state-
ment to the effect that it is desirable to test in one way rather than
the other?
The President : — Not at the present time, Mr. Coombs.
The Secretary: — "15. Permanent Set. It is desired that the per-
manent set after one blow under the drop test shall not exceed that
in the following table, and a record shall be made of this information."
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — The Committee, in commenting on section 15,
says that it is the intention, when sufficient data are at hand, to
prescribe maximum and minimum limits for deflections under the
drop test, and that this method of classifying rails is only tentative.
I do not think any of us would reject any rails on this specification,
and it occurs to me that that paragraph could just as well be left out
1030 RAIL.
of these specifications until we have reached definite conclusions where
the maximum and minimum could be fixed. While, of course, it is
a question of getting information and records, I believe we can
spend our time better in getting physical tests of rails and not include
this at the present time until we have reached some definite data
that will give us a maximum and a minimum that we can reject
rails upon or accept rails.
Mr. Churchill: — I will state that it is easy to measure the per-
manent set at the time the elongation is measured, and with the elongation
secured the permanent set becomes the check on too soft material. We
want this information and we hope it will be taken. It is not an item
mandatory or as a basis of condemning the rail, but we think that we will
soon have a figure for the maximum set to determine when a rail is too
soft. We sometimes receive rail that is too soft. Some of us have, I
think, within the last two years set aside heats of steel that have been
found to be too soft.
The Secretary: — "16. Test to Destruction. The test pieces which do
not break under the first or subsequent blows shall be nicked and broken, to
determine whether the interior metal is sound."
Mr. Churchill: — I would explain, in behalf of the Committee, that
this test shows, first, whether or not the material is too brittle, and the
test to "destruction" shows whether enough discard has been made to
secure sound material.
Mr. R. D. Coombs: — My question is partly answered, I think, b}r
what Mr. Churchill has just said. My question was in reference to
the use of the word "sound." If the metal were really unsound,
would not the drop test show it? It is a question of what is meant
by "sound."
Mr. Churchill: — No, sir; a pipe rail is not discovered by a simple
drop test alone.
The Secretary: — "17. Bessemer Process Drop Tests. One piece
shall be tested from each heat of Bessemer steel.
"(a) If the test piece does not break at the first blow and shows
the required elongation (Section 14), all of the rails of the heat shall
be accepted, provided that the test piece when nicked and broken does
not show interior defect.
"(b) If the piece breaks at the first blow, or does not show the
required elongation (Section 14), or if the test piece shows the re-
quired elongation but when nicked and broken shows interior defect,
all of the top rails from that heat shall be rejected.
"(c) A second test shall then be made of a test piece selected
by the inspector from the top end of any second rail of the same
heat, preferably of the same ingot. If the test piece does not break
at the first blow, and shows the required elongation (Section 14), all
of the remainder of the rails of the heat shall be accepted, provided
that the test piece when nicked and broken does not show interior
defect.
DISCUSSION. 1031
"(d) If the piece breaks at the first blow, or does not show the
required elongation (Section 14), or if the piece shows the required
elongation but when nicked and broken shows interior defect, all of
the second rails from that heat shall be rejected.
"(e) A third test shall then be made of a test piece selected by
the inspector from the top end of any third rail of the same heat,
preferably of the same ingot. If the test piece does not break at the
first blow and shows the required elongation (Section 14), all of the
remainder of the rails of the heat shall be accepted, provided that the
test piece when nicked and broken does not show interior defect.
"(f) If the piece breaks at the first blow, or does not show the
required elongation (Section 14), or if the piece shows the required
elongation but when nicked and broken shows interior defect, all of
the remainder of the rails from that heat shall be rejected."
Mr. Churchill: — In behalf of the Committee, I wish to explain
that this method of testing, or rather the additional number of tests,
are made primarily to discover, of course, anything that is defective,
and secondly, and of almost equal importance, so as not to throw
away any good material. We have proved, in the last two years,
that the making of tests is very quickly done in this manner and
that they are not costly. There is very little expense connected with
it. This form of testing can be quickly made; and the result of these
three trials, if necessary, on a Bessemer heat of steel, will reduce to
a minimum the amount of material that is thrown away and will
save all good material.
Prof. Walter Loring Webb: — I do not see the necessity of the
words "or subsequent" at the end of the first line of No. 16, because
it would seem as if all those tests which follow depend on the first
blow. As far as I can see, it does not depend on any subsequent
blow.
Mr. Churchill: — That brings out the point I probably should have
explained before. In No. 13, the question of ductility is described —
how we get it. Now it is conceivable and it often does happen that
the full ductility of the metal is not secured under one blow, in an
18-foot drop, therefore we make a second blow. In case we have not
6 per cent, elongation, for example, even a less drop than 18 feet
may be used for the second blow. We want to find what is the total
ductility of the rail; if it is over 6 per cent, in the inch, it is an ac-
ceptable rail under that test. Therefore, there may be more than
one blow necessary before the ductility is determined or the rail is
broken. Next, if the rail does not break in developing ductility, we
want to go on with the breaking to destruction, to find out the
character of the inner metal as far as the eye can determine, that is,
to find out whether there are any interior flaws.
Mr. W. L. Seddon (Seaboard Air Line): — I would like to ask the
Committee whether they have considered at all the breaking of a
piece from the top of each ingot for soundness. It seems to me that
1032 RAIL.
the drop test and the breaking of the rail for soundness is all right
so far as that ingot goes, but it does not seem to me that that would
necessarily tell us anything about the soundness of the top rails of
the other ingots.
Mr. Churchill: — The method is the carrying out of the general
practice in all steel testing. We do not test every ingot of any struc-
tural steel. From our present information we think it would not be
possible to keep the mills running and test every individual ingot.
We do not say that as a finality. It is certainly in the right line to
test more ingots. We propose to test a good deal more under these
specifications than we have tested heretofore. We believe that under
this testing method — or the expansion of this method later, that we
may be able to reduce the chemistry requirements.
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — Mr. Seddon has brought up a point which I was
going to touch on after the drop test on the open-hearth had been
read, but as he has brought up the point I would like to discuss it
now. It seems to me we have reached a point where we ought to
quit taking a chance on accepting a lot of rails about which we know
nothing, in regard to the soundness of the material. The only way
we can arrive at that is to take a test piece from each ingot and test
it to destruction. Now, while it is said that this seems to be imprac-
ticable, and at the present time will delay the mills in their operation,
yet by providing the necessary equipment, it should not take much
time. It need not be a test piece of the full length, as specified here.
A shorter test piece can be taken, and if it does involve a slightly
additional cost, it certainly will be worth the expense. The specifica-
tions are a great advance over previous specifications, especially in
the open-hearth process, where a test piece from three ingots is re-
quired, but if there are sixteen to nineteen or more ingots we have
to take a chance on the balance. We know nothing positively about
them, and it occurs to me, if we have a test of this kind, including
the primary tests mentioned, which are all right as far as that goes,
and then require some secondary test made for soundness, something
on the following order, it would be desirable:
"In addition to the primary tests above provided, the remaining
ingots not tested shall be subjected to the following tests, to insure
sound rails from each individual ingot.
"A test piece shall be taken from the 'A' rail and if, when nicked
and broken, shows no interior defect, all the rails of that ingot shall
be accepted. If, when nicked and broken, it shows interior defects
the 'A' rail of that ingot shall be rejected, and a test piece taken from
the 'B' rail. If the test piece, when nicked and broken, shows no
interior defect, all the remaining rails of the ingot shall be accepted.
If the test piece, when nicked and broken, shows interior defects all
the rails above and including the 'B' rails of the ingot shall be re-
jected, and a test piece taken from the 'C rail and tested in the same
manner, and this process shall be continued until the remainder of
DISCUSSION. 1033
the rails of the ingot are tested wherever the presence of interior de-
fects is developed."
Mr. Churchill: — I presume you make that as a suggestion.
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — Simply as a suggestion.
Mr. Churchill: — We would prefer that you turn that suggestion
over to us and let us work on it. We think, during the coming year,
we can go on with the work along this line. We do not think your
suggestion can be carried out at present. The whole intent of para-
graphs 17 and 18 is to encourage tests. This Association was respon-
sible, a few years ago, for increasing the number of tests from one
in five heats to one in each heat. You know what difficulty we had
to convince not only members but the manufacturers as well, that
that could be done. The manufacturers and others are modifying
their views, and I believe, as we use these specifications, all will
soon be in hearty accord in multiplying tests. The same labor force
is constantly at the drop testing machine, and I see no reason in the
world why, if any question is raised about any ingot or any test, an
inspector should not say, "We will go and test the next ingot;" and
especially is that true in open-hearth steel, where the heats are larger.
But you notice we have provided for three tests in the Bessemer
heat, which is far ahead of anything before. The principle that is
laid down here, as far as the tests are concerned, is a well-defined
principle applied in testing all materials used by railroads and every other
class of work. Bridge material is tested in this method, not by
every ingot. Wheels are tested by this method, not by every ingot;
axles, everything we use, are tested under this general scheme. If
we find that a decided improvement can be gained under your sug-
gestion, we are in for it, and I think the manufacturers will be in
for it, if we can show that.
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — I do not want to be understood as criticising
the Committee in any way.
The President: — They are here for criticism.
Mr. L. C. Fritch- — I think we have made a great improvement,
especially on the question of tests on open-hearth steel. I believe this
will work both ways. I think we are rejecting a lot of rail now that
will be accepted.
Mr. John G. Sullivan: — For information of the Committee, one
of our Canadian mills proposed voluntarily that they would sell us
rails on the test of top piece at every ingot, at 50 cents per ton
extra. Did I correctly understand Mr. Churchill to state that he was
going to keep hammering a rail until he got that ductility?
Mr. Churchill: — If the test piece does not break on the first blow,
and at the same time.
Mr. John G. Sullivan: — I think we would be getting on dangerous
ground. I would be very much afraid of that.
Mr. Churchill: — Why so? It is the same process that we adopted
in getting the ductility, under the static test; we carry it out to a
1034 RAIL.
failure. I think it would be a mistake to say that a rail must show a
given ductility as a minimum, with an 18-foot drop. I speak now of
ioo-lb. rail. If that rail will stand the 18-foot drop, we have not
at that time gotten a measure of what the ductility is. Hence, an-
other drop may be made, though it may be of less height than 18 feet.
It is shown by withstanding the first drop that it is not brittle, but
we have not the full measure of the ductility.
Mr. John G. Sullivan: — What I would be afraid of would be this:
I think we all agree that the drop test is the physical check '011
chemical composition, and if the material is at all uniform we should
get a uniform deflection or percentage of ductility with a uniform
weight dropping a uniform distance. If, however, the majority of
the rails gave prescribed results on receiving one blow, it would
indicate to my mind that the rail that had to be hit two or three
times was either high in phosphorus or carbon, and that while that
particular piece might stand this treatment, I would be afraid of
some of the other rails from the same heat of ingot.
Mr. Churchill: — Remember this is the top rail of the ingot, which
is in all probability the worst piece there is.
Mr. John G. Sullivan : — I had never heard of that second dropping
before, and I should like to ask for information, have any rails been
accepted under that specification?
Mr. Churchill: — Yes.
Mr. John G. Sullivan: — How many of those have to be hit half
a dozen times or twice to get ductility? Is it the general thing or the
exception? If it is the exception, I would be afraid of it.
Mr. George W. Kittredge (New York Central & Hudson River) : —
For the information of the Association, the specifications of the New
York Central Lines have required subsequent blows if the ductility is
not brought out on the first blow. All the rails accepted by the New
York Central Lines have been subjected to that test for a great
many years.
Mr. Seddon: — Do I understand, if one of these three rails breaks
and the other two stand up, that the whole heat is accepted?
Mr. Churchill: — This is accepting an ingot on the best two out of
three. We had only one test heretofore; now we get three.
Mr. Seddon: — You are accepting something where one shows bad.
Mr. Churchill: — We would not use the bad one. The top rail
would be discarded.
Mr. Seddon: — The top rail of that single ingot?
Mr. Churchill: — Yes, sir.
The Secretary: — "18. Open-Hearth Process Drop Tests. Test
pieces shall be selected from the second, middle and last full ingot of
each open-hearth heat.
"(a) If two of these test pieces do not break at the first blow
and show the required elongation (Section 14), all of the rails of the
DISCUSSION. 1035
heat shall be accepted, provided that these test pieces when nicked
and broken do not show interior defect.
"(b) If two of the test pieces break at the first blow, or do not
show the required elongation, or if any of the pieces that have been
tested under the drop when nicked and broken show interior defect,
all of the top rails from that heat shall be rejected.
"(c) Second tests shall then be made from three test pieces selected
by the inspector from the top end of any second rails of the same
heat, preferably of the same ingots. If two of these test pieces do
not break at the first blow and show the required elongation (Section
14), all of the remainder of the rails of the heat shall be accepted,
provided that the pieces that have been tested under the drop when
nicked and broken do not show interior defect.
"(d) If two of these test pieces break at the first blow or do not
show the required elongation (Section 14), or if any of the pieces
that have been tested under the drop when nicked and broken show
interior defect, all of the second rails of the heat shall be rejected.
"(e) Third tests shall then be made from three test pieces se-
lected by the inspector from the top end of any third rails of the
same heat, preferably of the same ingots. If two of these test pieces
do not break at the first blow, and show the required elongation
(Section 14), all of the remainder of the rails of the heat shall be
accepted, provided that the pieces that have been tested under the
drop when nicked and broken do not show interior defect.
"(f) If two of these test pieces break at the first blow or do not
show the required elongation (Section 14), or if any of the pieces
that have been tested under the drop when nicked and broken show
interior defect, all of the remainder of the rails from that heat shaM
be rejected.
"19. No. 1 Rails. No. 1 classification rails shall be free from
injurious defects and flaws of all kinds.
"20. No. 2 Rails, (a) Rails, which, by reason of surface im-
perfections, or for causes mentioned in Section 30 hereof, are not
classed as No. 1 rails, will be accepted as No. 2 rails, but No. 2 rails
which contain imperfections in such number or of such character as
will, in the judgment of the inspector, render them unfit for recog-
nized No. 2 uses, will not be accepted for shipment.
"(b) No. 2 rails to the extent of 5 per cent, of the whole order
will be received. All rails accepted as No. 2 rails shall have the ends
painted white and shall have two prick punch marks on the side of
the web near the heat number near the end of the rail, so placed as
not to be covered by the splice bars.
"21. Quality of Manufacture. The entire process of manufacture
shall be in accordance with the best current state of the art.
"22. Bled Ingots. Bled ingots shall not be used.
1036 RAIL.
"23. Discard. There shall be sheared from the end of the bloom,
formed from the top of the ingot, sufficient metal to secure sound
rails."
Mr. Seddon: — Is there not some possibility of going to the 39-
foot rail?
The President: — The question of longer rails is being studied.
Mr. Seddon: — I think we ought to try to get a longer rail.
The President: — That is under investigation.
Mr. W. F. Steffens (Boston & Albany): — Is it necessary to jn-
clude any statement as to the fact that this 10 per cent, of short rails
shall not come at one time? In a case with which the Chairman is
acquainted the manufacturers tried to ship the entire order of shorts
first.
Mr. Churchill: — I do not see how we can control that matter. It
is one of the things that can be fixed in the contract between the
buyer and the purchaser under mutual agreement.
The Secretary: — "24. Lengths. The standard length of rails
shall be 33 feet, at a temperature of 60 degrees Fahrenheit. Ten per
cent, of the entire order will be accepted in shorter lengths varying
by 1 foot from 32 feet to 25 feet. A variation of % inch from the
specified lengths will be allowed. No. 1 rails less than 33 feet long
shall be painted green on both ends.
"25. Shrinkage. The number of passes and speed of train shall
be so regulated that on leaving the rolls at the final pass, the temper-
ature of the rail will not exceed that which requires a shrinkage al-
lowance at the hot saws, for a rail 33 feet in length and of 100 lbs.
section, of 6-y\ inches and % inch less for each 10 lbs. decrease in
section.
"26. Cooling. The bars shall not be held for the purpose of re-
ducing their temperature, nor shall any artificial means of cooling
them be used after they leave the finishing pass. Rails, while on the
cooling beds, shall be protected from snow and water.
"27. Section. The section of rails shall conform as accurately
as possible to the template furnished by the Railroad Company. A
variation in height of 1/64 inch less or 1/32 inch greater than the
specified height, and 1/16 inch in width of flange, will be permitted;
but no variation shall be allowed in the dimensions affecting the fit
of the splice bars."
Mr. Lindsay: — What can be done to check the overfilling or the
underfilling of the head of the rail? Very often we get a rail with
too much metal in the center of the head or too little metal in the
center of the head, and while it might comply with the specifications
as to height, it would be objectionable.
Mr. Churchill : — I think the careful using of the template on the
part of the inspectors will result in checking that. These are the
usual limits.
DISCUSSION. 1037
The Secretary: — "28. Weight. The weight of the rails specified
in the order shall be maintained as nearly as possible, after complying
with the preceding section. A variation of one-half of 1 per cent,
from the calculated weight of section, as applied to an entire order,
will be allowed.
"29. Payment. Rails will be accepted and paid for according to
actual weights."
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — It occurred to me that Section 29 would read
a little better if it were changed to read, "Rails accepted will be paid
for according to actual weights."
Mr. Churchill: — We accept that.
The Secretary: — "30. Straightening. The hot straightening shall
be carefully done, so that gagging under the cold presses will be re-
duced to a minimum. Any rail coming to the straightening presses
showing sharp kinks or greater camber than that indicated by a
middle ordinate of 4 inches in 33 feet, for A. R. A. type of sections,
or 5 inches for A. S. C. E. type of sections, will be at once classed
as a No. 2 rail. The distance between the supports of rails in the
straightening presses shall not be less than 42 inches. The supports
shall have flat surfaces and be out of wind.
"31. Drilling. Circular holes for joint bolts shall be drilled to
conform accurately in every respect to the drawing and dimensions
furnished by the Railroad Company.
"32. Finishing, (a) All rails shall be smooth on the heads,
straight in line and surface, and without any twists, waves or kinks.
They shall be sawed square at the ends, a variation of not more than
1/32 inch being allowed; and burrs shall be carefully removed.
"(b) Rails improperly drilled or straightened, or from which the
burrs have not been removed, shall be rejected, but may be accepted
after being properly finished.
"33. Branding. The name of the manufacturer, the weight and
type of rail, and the month and year of manufacture shall be rolled
in raised letters and figures on the side of the web. The number of
the heat and a letter indicating the portion of the ingot from which
the rail was made shall be plainly stamped on the web of each rail,
where it will not be covered by the splice bars. The top rails shall
be lettered 'A,' and the succeeding ones 'B,' 'C,' 'D,' etc., consecu-
tively; but in case of a top discard of 20 or more per cent., the letter
'A' will be omitted. Open-hearth rails shall be branded or stamped
'O. H.' All markings of rails shall be done so effectively that the
marks may be read as long as the rails are in service.
"34. Separate Classes. All classes of rails shall be kept separate
from each other.
"35. Loading. All rails shall be loaded in the presence of the
inspector."
Prof. Walter Loring Webb: — I would like to ask why, at the be-
ginning of Section 26, the word "bars" is used instead of "rails"?
1038 RAIL.
Mr. Churchill : — Those are not yet rails. They are in the process
of being made rails; therefore, they are bars.
The President: — Does anyone wish to make any remarks on these
specifications before a motion is put for their adoption?
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — Mr. Chairman, I move that the specifications,
as amended, be adopted.
The President: — For printing in the Manual?
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — Yes, sir.
The President: — Any remarks on the motion?
(The motion was carried.)
The President: — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks oj
the Association.
DISCUSSION ON WOOD PRESERVATION.
(For Report, see pp. 863-S72.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON WOOD PRESERVATION.
S. R. Church. L. C. Fritch. C. H. Spencer.
R. D. Coombs. V. K. Hendricks. Earl Stimson.
L. G. Curtis. C. E. Lindsay. Dr. Hermann von Schrenk.
S. B. Fisher. Hunter McDonald. Walter Loring Webb.
E. A. Frink. W. L. Seddon. S. N. Williams.
The President: — The next report is that of the Committee on
Wood Preservation, Mr. Earl Stimson, Chairman. We will have the
opening statement by Mr. Stimson.
Mr. Earl Stimson (Baltimore & Ohio): — Mr. Chairman, before
taking up the consideration of the report, I want to call attention to
a few typographical errors. On page 863, under "Work assigned by
Board of Direction," paragraph 3, second line, the sixth word should
be '"gas." On page 864, from the top of the page, paragraph 3, the
second line, the word "beeches" should be "beech." In the same line,
next to the last word, the word "hardwood," should be "heartwood."
On page 865, under "Revision of adopted Specifications for Creosote
Oil," the clause in the fourth line, under "standard specifications for
creosote oil," namely, "including coal-gas tar or coke-oven tar,"
should be placed after the word "tar" in the third line, making that
line read, "and shall be free from any tar, including coal-gas tar and
coke-oven tar, or oil or residue," etc. The same correction is to be
made under Specifications for No. 2 Grade Creosote Oil, the changes
occurring in the same . lines, and also the same correction under
Specifications for No. 3 Grade Creosote Oil. With these corrections
we will take up the consideration of our report.
The Board of Direction assigned eight subjects for the consider-
ation of the Committee. Following the instructions with reference to
making up reports, we selected two of these subjects upon which to
report conclusions. These two subjects are: "the grouping of timbers
for antiseptic treatment," and "the revision of the adopted Specifica-
tions for Creosote Oil."
Under the grouping of timbers for antiseptic treatment, I will
state that arrangements were made last year for a series of co-opera-
tive experiments at various plants to determine the best method of
grouping different species in different regions. These tests are not
completed, but progress to date is reported in Appendix E of this re-
port. "Past experience has demonstrated and your Committee recom-
1039
1040 WOOD PRESERVATION.
mends that such principles as have received recognition in standard
practice be embodied in the Manual." These principles are given
in this paragraph, there being four. Another subject which received
consideration of the Committee, and which, to my mind, is of great
importance and interest to the Association, is the record of service
tests. Last year the Committee recommended, and the recommenda-
tion was adopted, that certain sections of track be selected on each
railroad for the purpose of making accurate tests, covering the life
of treated and untreated ties. We wrote to various roads making
inquiries as to whether such tests had been inaugurated, and, if so,
to obtain data and information bearing on such tests. In Appendix
R you will find this information tabulated. It is the intention of the
Committee that this form a nucleus of a permanent record of service
tests, to be added to from year to year.
Aside from the tests reported in this tabulated statement, we
received too late to include in it, the record of forty service tests
from the Forest Service. These will be added to this record and pub-
lished next year. The Committee is going to make a very strenuous
effort to keep up this record and make it as complete as possible. It
is hoped it will form a source of very valuable information to the
Association.
Your Committee was also instructed to investigate the merits of
various preservatives, specifying oil from water gas tar and the
use of refined coal-tar in creosote oil. While the Committee instituted
investigations along these lines, it does not feel in a position this
year to make a report. If so ordered by the Roard of Direction,
our investigations will be continued during the coming year and a
report will be made at some subsequent meeting.
The second subject upon which the Committee reports in a defi-
nite manner is "the revision of adopted Specifications for Creosote
Oil." We will take this up later.
On other matters which were assigned to the Committee for con-
sideration we report progress. These are forms for reporting in-
spection, the impregnation of crude oil, and the value of brush coat-
ing and dipping. There was not very much information to be found
on these subjects, and we will continue our hunt for more during
the coming year.
The Committee was further asked to prepare specifications for
impregnation with creosote oil. A specification has already been
adopted by the Association and is contained in the Manual. As this
specification represents good practice, the Committee does not recom-
mend any changes in it. With the consent of the Chair and the
Association we will now consider our recommendations for this year.
These will be found on page 864, the four principles recommended
for the grouping of timbers for treatment. These we present for
adoption by the Association, for insertion in the Manual.
DISCUSSION. 1041
"(i) Ties of approximately the same period of seasoning should
be grouped together for treatment; green ties should never be mixed
with seasoned ones."
Mr. Hunter McDonald (Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis): —
Mr. Chairman, I understand the province of this Committee is that
of wood preservation. There seems to be a tendency on the part of
the Committee to confine its activities entirely to ties. Should not
that first clause refer to something else besides ties? I think it is
just as important to group dimension timber as it is ties.
The President: — It is intended to cover all kinds of wood.
Mr. McDonald: — I think it should be made to read that way then.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — This grouping applies more particularly to
ties rather than the longer timbers. The bulk of the timber treating
for railroads is confined to ties, and from a railroad standpoint the
treatment of ties at the present time is the one of greatest interest.
Mr. McDonald: — There is no doubt about that, but the point I
make is if this Committee's province is considered tie preservation
only, then this clause is right and proper, but if it is timber preserva-
tion, it should be made inclusive of all kinds of timber.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — We can, by a very simple process, widen the
scope of our recommendations by substituting the word "timbers"
for "ties," if that is what the Association wants. I move that the
first recommendation, as presented, be adopted.
The President: — The first conclusion is on page 867, but it refers
to four headings, on page 884. I will ask the chairman to read each
one separately, as the motion applies to each one separately.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — "(2) Pine ties should be separated on the
basis of hardwood and sapwood; it would also be advisable in some
cases to group hardwood on the same basis, but it is not generally
practical to do so.
"(3) Grouping on the basis of species and families, as, for ex-
ample, red oaks, pines, beech, etc., if a further division into heartwood
classes is made with pine, is usually a satisfactory practice. From
this it follows that red oak, beech, long-leaf pine, loblolly pine and
gum should be treated separately. Birch and hard maples and certain
other combinations, depending on the locality, can be grouped to-
gether to advantage.
"(4) The separation in the yard, on the basis the ties are to be
grouped for treatment, is an essential and economical practice."
Mr. C. E. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River): — Does
paragraph 4 refer to the storage yard only?
Mr. Earl Stimson: — Yes, sir. I move the adoption of para-
graph 4.
(The motion was carried.)
The President: — Next is page 867, conclusion No. 2. Before mak-
ing any motion I will ask the chairman to read each one of them
separately and make a separate motion.
1042 WOOD PRESERVATION.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — The only change in the standard specification
tor creosote oil is with reference to specifically excluding coal-gas tar
and coke-oven tar. I will read the present specification and then as
it is revised:
"The oil used shall be the best obtainable grade of coal-tar creo-
sote; that is, it shall be a pure product obtained from coal gas tar or
coke oven tar and shall be free from any tar, including coal gas tar
or coke oven tar, oil or residue obtained from petroleum or any other
source; it shall be completely liquid at thirty-eight (38) degrees centi-
grade and shall be free from suspended matter; the specific gravity
of the oil at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade shall be at least
1.03. When distilled by the common method — that is, using an eight
(8) ounce retort, asbestos covered, with standard thermometer, bulb
one-half (^2) inch above the surface of the oil — the creosote, calcu-
lated on the basis of the dry oil, shall give no distillate below two
hundred (200) degrees centigrade, nor more than five (5) per cent,
below two hundred and ten (210) degrees centigrade, not more than
twenty-five (25) per cent, below two hundred and thirty-five (235)
degrees centigrade, and the residue above three hundred and fifty-five
(355) degrees centigrade, if it exceeds five (5) per cent, in quantity,
shall be soft. The oil shall not contain more than three (3) per cent,
water."
I move that this change in the specificat'ons be adopted.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Earl Stimson: — There seems to be a demand for a specifica-
tion for creosote oil somewhat less stringent than our standard speci-
fication. In fact, it seems necessary to have such a specification in
order to meet the grade of oil that we are oftentimes obliged to
purchase. For this purpose the Committee submits specifications for
a No. 2 grade oil and for a No. 3 grade oil. The specification for
the No. 2 grade creosote oil reads as follows:
"The oil used shall be the best obtainable grade of coal-tar creo-
sote; that is, it shall be a pure product obtained from coal gas tar or
coke oven tar, and shall be free from any tar, including coal gas tar
or coke oven tar, oil or residue obtained from petroleum or any
other source; it shall be completely liquid at thirty-eight (38)
degrees centigrade and shall be free from suspended matter; the
specific gravity of the oil at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade shall
be at least 1.03. When distilled by the common method — that is,
using an eight (8) ounce retort, asbestos covered, with standard ther-
mometer, bulb one-half (j4) inch above the surface of the oil — the
creosote, calculated on the basis of the dry oil, shall give not more
than eight (8) per cent, distillate below two hundred and ten (210)
degrees centigrade, not more than thirty-five (35) per cent, below
two hundred and thirty-five (235) degrees centigrade, and the residue
above three hundred and fifty-five (355) degrees centigrade, if it ex-
DISCUSSION. 1043
ceeds five (5) per cent, in quantity, shall be soft. The oil shall not
contain more than three per cent, water."
I move the adoption of this specification for a No. 2 grade creo-
sote oil.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western): — I would like to have
some information on the real purpose of drawing these two separate
specifications for creosote oil. What will be the difference in the
cost between the specifications No. 2 and No. 3?
Mr. Earl Stimson: — I do not think we are prepared to state just
what will be the cost. That is a matter depending on market price.
As I understand the creosote situation, we are very seldom able to
get a creosote oil that conforms strictly with the standard specifica-
tion. Still the inference is that we pay the same for it as for the
high-grade oil. Now the idea is that we place the modified specifica-
tions in the hands of our Purchasing Agent, and if he cannot get the
oil according to the standard specification, he will be able to accepl
one that will meet one or the other of the modified specifications,
with some corresponding modification in price.
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — I think three grades are too many; two in
most cases are enough. It seems to me we should insist upon the
very best grade of creosote oil. That is the very life of our timber
treatment. We are all investing a lot of money in it, and we should
not accept inferior oils. I think we should consider very carefully
the adoption of three grades. I realize at times it is difficult to se-
cure the first grade, but it seems to me the third grade is too low
for us to accept. A slight difference in the grade of the oil will
seriously affect the treatment, while the difference in the cost of the
oil will be very slight. So we will be throwing away a lot of the
value of our timber treatment by accepting an inferior grade of oil.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — As a matter of fact, there is now quite a
large quantity of oil that comes within the No. 3 grade that is being
purchased at the standard grade price. This revision of the specifi-
cations was given very careful consideration by the sub-committee,
composed of some of the leading lights in the timber treating world,
men who are specialists in that line, and as long as the discussion is
started, I will call upon the chairman of the sub-committee that
drafted these specifications to defend any attacks made upon them.
Mr. Hendricks, will you please explain to the Association just why
we recommend these three grades?
Mr. V. K. Hendricks (St. Louis & San Francisco): — Some of the
roads are getting a grade of creosote that will not come under No.
2 and will come under No. 3, and they have to have the creosote,
and that was the reason the third grade was recommended by the
Committee. For instance, the Chicago & Northwestern is forced to
take creosote that does not come within No. 2. That was the reason
for adopting the third specifications.
1044 WOOD PRESERVATION.
Prof. S. N. Williams (Cornell College) : — I would like to inquire
if the Committee would please give us an approximate idea of the
difference in values of these three grades.
Mr. Hendricks: — The Committee is not able to do that. There
is too much that is unknown about the value of creosote, and the
valuable constituents of it. The Committee did at one time consider
the question of trying to assign relative merits to the different speci-
fications, but it was entirely impracticable to do so with the present
knowledge.
Prof. Williams: — Is there much difference in the cost?
Mr. Hendricks: — That depends upon the market conditions and
the location, so that we do not see that we can give any information
on that question.
Mr. W. L. Seddon (Seaboard Air Line) : — I think the way to look
at this is not so much the question of the difference in the cost of the
oil, but as to how the low-grade oils will act in preserving the timber,
whether timber treated with No. 2 oil will stand as much as timber
treated with No. 1 oil, and whether timber treated with No. 2 will
stand as much as with No. 3. Before we recommend No. 2 and No. 3
oil specifications, we ought to have some information with reference
to what the effect on the timber is going to be.
Mr. Earl Stimson : — Most of us are now using oil corresponding
to the proposed No. 2 or No. 3 oil and have gotten very good results.
Dr. von Schrenk will please explain this question more fully.
Dr. Hermann von Schrenk (Consulting Timber Engineer) : — Per-
sonally, I have always advocated the use of strictly No. 1 high-grade
specification oils, on account of the desirability of getting the very
best that we can possibly find. The Committee find, however, that
for several years, owing to the tremendous increase in the creosoting
industry in this country, and owing to the absence of a sufficient
supply of high-grade standard oil, a great many railroads were buying
(using the present standard specification) creosote oil which, as a
matter of fact, did not come up to it. In other words, we had a
state of affairs of having the Purchasing Agent sent out to purchase
a material under a specification, and as one Chief Engineer expressed
it, "When we asked him whether the oil he obtained came up to that
specification, he said, 'Why, we buy it under the specification but
it by no means meets it.'" I asked him, "What do you do?" He
said, "We make a terrible fuss about it and then we take it." The
object of the specifications Nos. 2 and 3 was largely to do away with
that rather anomalous situation. I think the Committee pointed out,
in the middle of page 865, answering one of the questions put, that
in using specifications Nos. 2 and 3, it should be understood that if
they have to be used, consideration should be given to the use of
greater quantities of creosote oil per cubic foot of wood, than would
be used if specification No. 1 is used. The Committee meant to give
the impression that wherever possible the railroad company should
DISCUSSION. 1045
try to buy under the specification No. I, and where that could not be
obtained they should try No. 2, and where they could not get No. 2,
they should buy No. 3, with the understanding that they would use
more of it per cubic foot. In presenting grades 2 and 3 we wish to
have it clearly understood that they are inferior in value to No. 1
specification, but nevertheless they might be used, and we would get
away from the anomalous position of depreciating the value of No. 1
specification, and get a price reduction.
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — It seems to me we ought to stick to our
standard specifications for one grade of oil until we have had some
experience as to the effect of No. 2 and No. 3 grade oil. If any one
is asking for bids on No. 1 and getting No. 2 or No. 3, he should
investigate it. The proper proceeding might be to refer specifications
No. 2 and No. 3 back to the Committee for a report next year, and
so, in the light of this information, the Association can act upon the
adoption of the other specification. Also, whether it would not be
sufficient to have a standard specification on No. 1 and No. 2. It
seems to me we will lower our standard in accepting so many grades.
Mr. E. A. Frink (Seaboard Air Line): — It seems to me the one
purpose is to get as long life as we can of the timber treated. We
ought to find out, first, whether No. 2 grade will give as long life as
No. 1. If not, we want No. 1; and usually it is the case where a
sustained demand is made for one product, we get that product. I
understand the known sources of supply are not utilized. Enormous
amounts go to waste every year in this country. If there were a de-
mand for that No. 1 grade, I think the supply would soon fill it.
Mr. Lindsay: — I would like to ask Dr. von Schrenk, is it practic-
able to refine the No. 2 and No. 3 grades up to the standard of No. 1?
Dr. von Schrenk: — No, sir; if that were the case we would insist
absolutely on No. 1. I think I voice the sentiment of the Committee
when I say that we should all stand absolutely for the highest grade
standard. In other words, we want to recommend that as the standard
that should be used and the inclusion of grades 2 and 3 is simply
recognizing the natural state of affairs. The natural state of affairs
is that these oils cannot be bought under No. 1 specifications, be-
cause they are not there; they do not exist. I think we ought to
stand by our high-grade specifications, but the grades 2 and 3 are
simply given to help out those roads which, for geographical or other
reasons, are unable to get No. 1 creosote oil, and with the warning,
if they buy creosote oil, they ought to approximate No. 1 standard.
Mr. S. B. Fisher (Missouri, Kansas & Texas) : — There is another
reason why I think we should have the lower grades of creosote.
The indications with us are that soft ties will wear out before they
decay, and we may wish to get cheaper grades of creosote to pre-
serve those ties until they wear out. For that reason I am in favor
of lower grades of creosote.
1046 WOOD PRESERVATION.
Mr. R. D. Coombs (Consulting Engineer): — It seems to me the
question is largely one of money. It may be perfectly proper to use
a cheaper grade of oil for a cheaper class of work, and I would sug-
gest that the Committee might properly advise the relative ultimate
cost of work of different grades, taking into account the larger
quantity of the cheaper grades.
(The President put the motion for the adoption of specification
No. 2, and a vive voce vote was indecisive; whereupon a rising vote
was taken, resulting in 83 votes in the affirmative and 7 in the nega-
tive.)
Mr. Earl Stimson: — "The oil shall be the best obtainable grade of
coal tar creosote; that is, it shall be a pure product obtained from
coal gas tar or coke oven tar and shall be free from any tar, including
coal gas tar or coke oven tar, oil or residue obtained from petroleum
or any other source; it shalS be completely liquid at thirty-eight (38)
degrees centigrade and shall be free from suspended matter; the
specific gracity of the oil at thirty-eight (38) degrees centigrade shall
be at least 1.025. When distilled by the common method — that is,
using an eight (8) ounce retort, asbestos covered, with standard ther-
mometer, bulb one-half (J4) inch above the surface of the oil — the
creosote, calculated on the basis of the dry oil, shall give not more
than ten (10) per cent, distillate below two hundred and ten (210)
degrees centigrade, not more than forty (40) per cent, below two
hundred and thirty-five (235) degrees centigrade, and the residue
above three hundred and fifty-five (355) degrees centigrade, if it
exceeds five (5) per cent, in quantity, shall be soft. The oil shall not
contain more than three (3) per cent, water."
I move the adoption of the specification for the third grade creo-
sote oil.
Mr. C. H. Spencer (Washington Terminal Company) : — I suppose
what I have to say will do no good. I have always stood for good
practice. I do not believe the adoption of these low-grade oils con-
stitutes good practice. Dr. von Schrenk told us a few moments ago,
or indicated to us, that the difficulty is going to be met by using
more oil in the tie. I would like to ask, for information, if it is a fact
that those in charge of the creosoting plants are able to, or if they
actually will, use more of the lower-grade oil to meet the difficulties:
I feel that we are going to be met, when we specify the No. 1
specification for our ties, by the question, "Why will not the No. 2
or the No. 3 do?" The Committee in making this report does not give
us any basis on which we can make a reply to this question. What
are we going to say as to the relative values of this oil? What reply
are we going to make when we are asked as to the relative life of
a tie that is creosoted with No. 2 oil or No. 3 oil, as compared with
No. 1? Or what reply will we make to a question as to the cost,
the relative values?
DISCUSSION. 1047
I really believe that the suggestion made by Mr. Friteh should have
been carried out, that this matter be referred back to the Committee
fcr further consideration and report, that we might have a clearer
idea of what we are doing when we are specifying No. I. Therefore,
Mr. Chairman, unless sufficient explanation can be made, I wish to
amend that motion that has just been made, to the effect that speci-
fication for No. 3 oil be referred back to the Committee for further
consideration and report as to quality and values of the creosote
specified.
Mr. L. C. Friteh: — In seconding the amendment I would like to
say that many of us are treating our timber with all the oil we car.
get into it. How are you going to get more oil of the lower grades
into the timber when we specify the use of all the oil you can get
into it? You are up to the point of the limit of penetrability. I do
not think that argument will stand.
As far as the refinement of the oil is concerned, I question
whether it is not possible to refine the lower grade oil into higher
grades; it is a matter of distillation.
I think we are making a mistake to open the doors to an inferior
grade of oil, and I hope the amendment, for No. 3 being referred
back to the Committee, will carry.
Mr. Hendricks:— How long do your ties last, treated with all the
creosote oil that can be put in?
Mr. Earl Stimson: — I also ask Mr. Friteh whether ke knows he is
getting the standard grade creosote?
In answer to Mr. Spencer, this Committee does not feel as though
it is recommending to the Association any poor practice. We are
merely submitting specifications that meet the conditions that are
imposed upon the users of creosote oil.
Mr. L. C. Friteh:— In answer to the Chairman of the Committee,
I wish to say that if I am not getting first-grade creosote oil it is
my fault, and it is the fault of every other railway man who has this
matter in charge, if he does not get first-grade creosote oil when he
buys that grade. You do not analyze it and test it properly, or you
would know whether or not you get first-grade oil.
In regard to the suggestion of the Committee, I think it is very
valuable, but there is a commercial condition which we must meet.
and I do not think we are prepared to meet it now. We have not
enough light on the subject and we are simply asking for a little more
time so that the subject may be thoroughly investigated in order that
we do not make a mistake when we take action.
Prof. Williams: — It seems to me the object of the amendment has
been provided for by the Committee itself, as you will see by reference
to page 866, where it says that samples are to be submitted to the
various railways for analysis and the information to be reported to
the Association next year.
1048 wood preservation:
M'r. C. H. Spencer: — I submit that this Association is not organ-
ized for the purpose of meeting all of the conditions that obtain on
the various railways of the country. We are here to recommend
good practice to our railways and not to meet all the conditions,
which, for various reasons, different railways have to contend with.
Prof. Walter Loring Webb (Consulting Engineer): — I think the
question involved here is like the question of buying different grades
of lumber. It would be very nice to always use the highest grade of
lumber, but we cannot. It is a matter of practical business. As I
understand, from what these experts have told us regarding creosote
oil, some creosote oil will always be of a relatively lower grade, as
it comes out of the still. There will always be a market for it, and
if railways want to use that lower grade, just as they may want to
use the lower grades of lumber, we have simply to provide specifi-
cations so that these different grades can be used properly. We do
not recommend that any railway shall use this third grade of creosote
oil, but we simply define what the third grade of creosote oil shall be,
just as we define the various grades of lumber.
Mr. Seddon: — We do know something about the comparative life
and usefulness of various grades of lumber, and we are willing to
consider various grades of creosote oil if we know something about
them, but at the present time the Committee is not prepared to tell
us either their value or the effect upon the timber, and I do not think
this Association should recommend creosote specifications unless the
Committee can put us in the possession of such information as will
enable us to go to the Chief Engineer, or the responsible official of
the railway, and say, "Let us buy No. 3 creosote oil, and we will get
such and such results from its use." I confess there is nothing here
in this report that I can see that gives us that information.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — I wish, in answer to that statement, to say
that we feel these specifications are all right, and meet the conditions
that confront Purchasing Agents when they go into the market to
buy creosote oil. We do say that we are not prepared to state how
many cents less per gallon the grades of oil No. 2 and 3 will cost
as compared with the standard grade, or how many years, more or
less, the ties which are treated with No. 2 and No. 3 oil will last
as compared with the standard grade oil. This must be deter-
mined by practical experience. No doubt many of the good results
obtained on railways in creosoting have been obtained by the use of
an oil below the standard grade, but conforming to the proposed No.
2 and No. 3 grade of creosote oil.
I have the greatest confidence in my Committee. (Applause).
I will say right here that most of these gentlemen on this Com-
mittee know a great deal more about the creosote business than I
do, and than most of those present do, because they have been associ-
ated with the scientific study and practical use of creosote oil for many
years, therefore, I most earnestly recommend to the Association the
DISCUSSION. 1049
adoption of the recommendations of this Committee. In a way, I
infer that possibly some of the speakers have not had quite as broad
an experience with this subject as some of the members of this Com-
mittee (Applause), and, for this reason I feel all the more justified in
urging our recommendations for adoption.
Mr. L. C. Fritch: — We appreciate the fact many of us are
ignorant on this subject, but the confession of ignorance is often-
times the first step to finding out something about a thing. The
chairman has said it is for the Purchasing Agent that these specifi-
cations are made. How about the Engineers? The Engineer must
use the creosote oil. The Purchasing Agent will say to the Engineer:
"Shall we buy No. i, No. 2, or No. 3 oil?" What can the Engineer say in
answer to that question? The Engineer does not know the values
of these respective grades of oil for treating timber. We want to
know what we are doing before we adopt these specifications.
Mr. Earl Stimson: — In answer to that last remark, let the Pur-
chasing Agent get bids. That is really the only way we can tell
regarding the respective costs of these different grades of oil.
Mr. L. G. Curtis (Baltimore & Ohio):— It looks to me that the
only way we can tell as to what the No. 1 grade is worth, what the
No. 2 grade is worth, and what the No. 3 grade is worth is to adopt
the specifications and then try them out. It is just as certain of our
members have said, and certain members of the Committee have
said, that there have been a great many ties treated, but we do not
know what has gone into them. Now, let us put these specifications
into effect and find out what the result really is.
Mr. Lindsay : — As I understand it, the difference between specifi-
cation No. 2 and specification No. 3 is only a small percentage in spe-
cific gravity; one is 1.03 and the other 1.025. I ask Dr. von Schrenk
what percentage of the total output of creosote oil would be rejected
if he did not have No. 3 specification?
Dr. von Schrenk: — That is almost impossible to answer, because
the volume of oils differ from week to week and month to month,
depending on the fluctuation of the production of the output, and on
peculiar accidents which occur in the distilling operation. The only
reason why a very small difference is made in the specifications is
simply to give an actual specification for the actual oil as we find the
railways actually buying in millions of gallons every week. To
further justify these specifications — I feel that really we are getting
very finicky on these specifications of creosote oil — I will say that I
made a trip over some English railways not very long ago and I
find specifications in use in England that run all the way from away
above our standard specification to away below our No. 3, and they
have been using some of that oil for forty years and the ties in many
cases have been twenty-five and thirty years in use on the English
railways.
1050 WOOD PRESERVATION.
As the Chairman has stated, we are not recommending anything
that will be at all dangerous or experimental, but oils of the character
of grades Nos. 2 and 3 have been used for from 75 to 100 years or
more the world over and a lot of them have been worse than the
No. 2 and 3 grade, and all we are doing is to endeavor to get an op-
portunity for some of the oils to be used with positive recommenda-
tions concerning their use.
The statement has been made by one of the speakers that some
of us are pumping our timber full of oil. If the timber is being
pumped full of standard creosote oil, very well; but if they are pump-
ing the timber full of No. 2 and 3, the answer which may be made to
that is if they pump full of No. 1, they are spending more money
than is necessary, and the maximum amount that can be pumped in
of No. 3 is about what should go in. I do not think we are recom-
mending anything experimental or doubtful.
The President: — Is Mr. S. R. Church, Manager of the Railroad
Department of the Barrett Manufacturing Company, of New York,
present?
Mr. S. R. Church: — I thank you, Mr. Chairman, for an oppor-
tunity to speak on the subject in which I am very much interested
indeed; and I think what Dr. von Schrenk has just said has probably
done more to enlighten some of you who are not particularly well
posted on this matter than anything the Committee has said before.
The point is there is really no essential difference between the three
grades of oil which your Committee has recommended. They are all
pure coal-tar creosotes. I think I can say without fear of contradic-
tion that the reputation of coal-tar creosote as a preservative, both
abroad and in this country, was established before any oil of as high
specific gravity, or with as high distillation range as your standard
specification requires, was produced or was in use, that is, in large
quantities. Therefore, the recommendation for these three grades
does not involve any experiment. It is simply, as your Committee
has already stated, a matter of recognizing existing conditions and
enabling a road to have a specification which can be met by the oil
producer.
The question has been raised as to whether it will be possible
to refine any of these oils of lower distillation range to make them
comply with specification No. 1. That could be done, but only at the
expense of a large loss of creosote oil, and increasing, therefore, the
cost of the preservative.
It is not true, as someone stated, that there is any surplus of raw ma-
terial in this country from which creosote oil can be obtained. The
amount of tar going to waste is very negligible. The manufacturers
are doing everything in their power to get the highest possible
percentage of creosote and the best possible quality of creosote from the
tar. We are continually endeavoring to obtain enlarged outlets for the by-
DISCUSSION. 1051
product which results in the manufacture of high-grade creosote, and I feel
safe in saying that the average quality of the creosote will improve with
time. I also feel safe in saying that the average quality of the creosote
produced to-day is of proven value and that timbers treated with enough
of the preservative, using any of these three oils, need cause no anxiety
as to their life.
Mr. Lindsay : — I ask if there is any difference in the degree of
penetration of dense woods in the use of the lighter oils — will the
lighter oil penetrate any more deeply in the dense wood than the oil
covered by the No. I specification?
Mr. Earl Stimson: — I will answer that by saying no.
The President: — The motion for adoption has been amended to
one for recommittal with instructions, and we will vote on the
amendment first, if the discussion is finished.
(The question was put, and the motion was lost.)
The President: — We will now vote on the motion to adopt the
recommendation of the Committee covering No. 3 grade creosote oil.
(The motion was carried.)
Mr. Earl Stimson: — I now move the adoption of the third con-
clusion of the Committee which reads: "That the heading 'Specifi-
cations for Analysis of Creosote Oil,' as it now stands in the Manual, be
changed to read as follows : 'Specifications for the Fractionation of
Creosote Oil.' "
(The motion was carried.)
The President: — The Committee has no further conclusions to
offer, and is dismissed with the thanks of the Association. They
have furnished us with some excellent work.
DISCUSSION ON GRADING OF LUMBER.
(For Report, see pp. 873-884.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON GRADING OF LUMBER.
L. C. Fritch. Dr. Hermann von Schrenk.
The President : — The next committee is the Special Committee on
Grading of Lumber, Dr. Hermann von Schrenk, Chairman. We will hear
from Dr. von Schrenk.
Dr. Hermann von Schrenk (Consulting Timber Engineer) : — Mr.
President and Members, the Special Committee on Grading of Lumber
has continued the work this year which was begun last year, reports of
which were published in Bulletin 133. The report of the Committee last
year, as you will remember, gave a list of grading rules, submitted by
various national organizations for various classes of maintenance of way
lumber, it being thought if we had a standard specification (with defini-
tions of defects) for maintenance of way lumber, as well as a list of com-
mercially obtainable grades, it would go far towards unifying standards
for the purchase of maintenance of way lumber. During the present year
the Committee has continued its efforts with various organizations and
presents in its report this year specifications for the grading of cypress.
There are still two or three organizations which have not formulated their
reports, and it is hoped that the work of the Committee will be brought
to a conclusion during the coming year.
In the recommendation as made in this report, the Committee wishes
to call your attention to the fact that they have this year very carefully
gone over the rules, as submitted last year, and have endeavored to bring
them, as far as they could, into harmony with the rules and specifica-
tions already adopted, as printed in the Manual. In order to avoid re-
printing the entire report of last year, which was rather bulky, they have
simply called attention, in the paragraphs at the bottom of page 873, to
the changes in the Bulletin as submitted last year, in order to make it
conform to the recommendations already in the Manual ; and we wish at
this time to recommend the adoption of the rules as submitted last year,
with the corrections as indicated in the present report, with this change.
At the time the report for 1912 was submitted, it was thought that it
would probably be printed sufficiently far in advance of the meeting of
the convention to give the members a chance to criticise the rules sub-
mitted.
Owing to the fact that the report has only been out a short time, I
will take it upon myself, as Chairman of the Committee, trusting that the
other members will agree, to withdraw recommendation 6, and move that
the other rules as submitted last year be adopted at this time.
1052
DISCUSSION. 1053
The President: — The Chair will suggest, gentlemen, that these previ-
ous appendices, beginning with A, Classification and Grading Rules
for Douglas Fir, be acted upon by the Association in bulk ; thai
is, each appendix by itself, as there has been ample opportunity for the
members to make any notes of criticisms they desire to bring forward.
Each appendix therefore will be taken up as a whole, and the Association
members are asked to criticise it. If no criticisms are offered, or no
amendments are made, you will be asked to pass the appendices one by
one. Is the Association willing to have that action taken?
(On vote, the suggestion of the President was carried.)
The President: — Each appendix will, therefore, be read by title and
a vote will be requested.
The Secretary:— "(Appendix A) Classification and Grading Rules for
Douglas Fir."
Dr. von Schrenk : — I move that the Grading Rules for Douglas Fir,
printed in Appendix A of Bulletin 133, with the corrections submitted
in this year's report, as indicated in paragraph 1, be adopted.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "(Appendix B) Classification, Grading and Dressing
Rules for Northern Pine, including White and Norway Pine and Hem-
lock."
Dr. von Schrenk : — I move that the Classification Rules for Northern
Pine, including White and Norway Pine and Hemlock, as given in Ap-
pendix B, of Bulletin 133, subject to corrections as given in paragraph
3 of this year's report, be adopted.
(The motion was carrie.d.)
The Secretary: — "(Appendix C) Classification, Grading and Dressing
Rules for Southern Yellow Pine."
Dr. von Schrenk : — I move you that the Classification Rules for South-
ern Pine, as given in Appendix C, Bulletin 133, subject to the correc-
tions as indicated in paragraph 4 of this year's report, be adopted.
(The motion was carried.)
The Secretary: — "(Appendix D) Standard Specifications for Con-
struction Oak Timbers."
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) : — I would like to ask the
Committee if this work is the result of a joint conference with the lum-
ber associations.
Dr. von Schrenk :— Yes, sir; it is the result of about four years' work.
I move the adoption of Appendix D, Standard Specifications for Con-
struction Oak Timbers, as printed in Bulletin 133, subject to corrections
in paragraph 5 of this year's report.
(The motion was carried.)
Dr. von Schrenk: — Appendix E, as given in Bulletin 144, is submit-
ted as information only, and no action is necessary.
The President : — The Committee is dismissed with the thanks of the
Association.
DISCUSSION ON BUILDINGS.
(For Report, see pp. 885-899.)
list of speakers taking part in discussion on buildings.
Maurice Coburn.
The President : — The next report is that of the Committee on
Buildings, of which Mr. Maurice Coburn is Chairman. Mr. Coburn
will make the opening statement.
Mr. Maurice Coburn (Vandalia) : — The Committee has not pre-
sented any conclusions this year and our report is presented as informa-
tion.
The Committee has endeavored to add to the work of the previous
year in connection with roofing. We have found a few errors in the
technical discussions, which we have endeavored to correct, referring
to the pages in the report as published last year. These are not of
any great importance. Perhaps the one about water-gas tar is as
important as any.
We have tried to get some further information, as suggested at
the convention last year, about the asphalt-built-up roofs, but did not
succeed in getting anything definite. We also had in mind an endeavor
to get a specification for coal-tar pitch for built-up roofing, but we
did not succeed in getting that. We do not know whether we are
going to be able to get one that is going to be of any value.
We have discussed the asphalt-asbestos built-up roof, and have
also added some information about gutters and flashings. We hope
during the coming year to fill out this information and complete the
work on roofings, presenting particularly the principles which should
govern in the design of flashing. The Committee has also done a
good deal of work in connection with freight house floors, but we
decided that it was not yet wise to present what we have.
We also wish to call attention to the death of Mr. Metcalf, who
has been for a good many years one of the most valuable members
of the Committee, a man whom we all learned to thoroughly respect.
We feel his loss very much.
The President :— Do any members wish to make any remarks on
the report of this Committee? If not, they are dismissed with the
thanks of the Association.
1054
DISCUSSION ON SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS.
(For Report, see pp. 900-904.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON SIGNS, FENCES AND CRUSS-
i INGS.
C. H. Stein.
The President: — We will call on the Committee on Signs, Fences
and Crossings, Mr. C. H. Stein, Chairman.
I would like to announce that we are very desirous of having
lots or good discussion, and I hope the members will feel free to
get up and criticize the report as much as they wish. Mr. Stein will
make the opening statement.
Mr. C. H. Stein (Central Railroad of New Jersey) : — Mr. Chair-
man, I wish to state, in briefly reviewing the report of the Committee
on Signs, Fences and Crossings, that it is distinctly a progress report
this year. The first subject assigned was to continue the investigation
of ways and means for securing a proper quality of fence wire to
resist corrosion and secure durability. This subject has been under
discussion and consideration for the past three or four years and a
great amount of data has been secured, particularly during the past
year. Practical investigations have been conducted by a member of
the Committee, and there is also a series of investigations in progress
on the part of the Committee of the American Society for Testing
Materials. We do not feel that at this time these investigations and
experiments have reached a point where we can definitely come to a
conclusion; hence the matter should be continued for another year
at least, and we believe that at its expiration we will be in a position
to announce something to the Association upon which it can take
action. We have received the co-operation of the large wire manu-
facturers, and that has helped us very much in the investigations that
we have made. At the present time there are four processes of galva-
nizing wire under investigation. One is the galvanizing after weaving,
the other the ordinary dip process, the third the special galvanized,
and the fourth the sherardized. As stated in the Bulletin, the galva-
nizing after weaving and the special galvanized appear, at this writing,
to be giving the best results. The investigation and observation of
these wires are still in progress and we will probably learn some-
thing about it during the course of this year.
The second instruction was to report on the relative advantages
and disadvantages of the different kinds of fence posts. Letters of
inquiry were submitted to the various railways and we discovered
that very few experiments have been made, so far as the knowledge
of the Committee went, from information received, in regard to the
use of concrete or other styles of posts than wood. I believe there
1055
1056 SIGNS, FENCES AND CROSSINGS.
are about nine roads that have been making tests of concrete posts,
but not for a sufficiently long time to enable them to give us suffi-
cient information on the subject. We propose to look into the matter
further, and we think with the groundwork that we have done that
we will be enabled to develop some facts during this year that will
be of some interest to the Association.
I think two years ago the Committee was directed to report on
the best form of track construction and flangeways at street cross-
ings in paved streets. The Committee made certain recommendations
in regard to this subject, but it was found after these recommenda-
tions were made that the processes they had recommended had not
been actually tried out in practice. The Committee has been investi-
gating along these lines, but because of the fact that no actual ex-
perimentation had been made it was found difficult to recommend any-
thing, or to prepare plans, as the Board of Direction suggested, to
show just what the Committee was endeavoring to arrive at. Since
that time, however, the Committee has speculated upon this subject
and we have prepared certain tentative plans, and we are negotiating
with the steel manufacturers now, and it is thought that during the
course of this year the Committee will be able to arrange with the
steel manufacturers to roll a few of the rolled fillers that were pro-
posed for flangeways through street crossings and try them out in
actual practice. This, it is thought, will be a distinct move in the
line of progress on this subject.
There is one other matter that forcibly presented itself to the
Committee during this year, and that is that there was a growing
demand for uniformity in the styles of signs for all railway purposes,
not only for the information of the public, but for that of the rail-
way employe as well. The Committee conducted some little investi-
gation along these lines and felt that, preliminary to actual injunc-
tions from the Board of Direction, that it ought to do something
so that if it were seen fit in the wisdom of the Board of Direction
to assign this subject to them, that they would have a foundation
to work upon and the Committee proposes to recommend that the
Board of Direction assign this subject to it for consideration and
discussion and possible conclusions during the next year.
I want to state in connection with this subject that during
the past year, more particularly than ever before, the public utility
commissions of the various States are taking some notice of this sub-
ject. A few months ago I happened to be summoned before the
Board of Public Utility Commissioners of the State of New Jersey
in reference to it, and it was their wish at that meeting to direct us
to adopt a certain style of sign for railway crossings. I believed at
the time that perhaps other boards of public utility commissioners
and State Commissions of various kinds would perhaps take up
the suggestion, if they have not already done so, from the action taken
in New Jersey, and I thought this, perhaps, was a propitious time
DISCUSSION. 1057
for the Association, through its Committee, to discuss this subject
and I told the Commissioners of the State of New Jersey that the Com-
mittee was already giving some consideration to this matter and was
going to suggest it to the Association at its next meeting, which is the .
present one.
I have learned only recently that the commissioners of several
other States have actually taken up this subject and in one instance,
1 believe, have actually directed the style of crossing sign that the
railroads of that particular State should adopt. Now, it is our opinion
that it is highly inexpedient that the boards of public utility com-
misioners and the railway commissions of the various States should
direct any special design of sign until such time as we have given
some thought and some study to this subject.
Therefore, the Committee wishes to present the matter to the
Association as a live topic for consideration, and we believe that it
v/ould be well for us in this respect, as much as in other of our oper-
ations, to have uniformity, so that individuals, when traveling from
the Atlantic to the Pacific or from the Northern States to the Gulf
of Mexico, will see that there is a distinct wording of signs, distinct
character of signs, to indicate the purposes for which they are in-
tended. Automobilists, for instance, no matter through what States
they travel, may know by the very form of the sign that it represents
on all railways a railway crossing. It seems as if these standard
signs ought to be adopted from the standpoint of efficiency, utility
and economy for the railways, and the Committee, therefore, pro-
poses to recommend that this subject be given it, for its considera-
tion and, therefore, we present the following recommendations:
(i) That the Board of Direction instruct our Committee to en-
deavor to co-operate with a similar Committee of the American So-
ciety for Testing Materials, in reaching conclusion on the subject of
a proper quality of fence wire to resist corrosion and secure dura-
bility.
(2) That subjects Nos. 2, 3 and 4 assigned last year be reas-
signed for study and report; that is, the relative advantages and
disadvantages of the different kinds of fence posts, the best form of
track construction and flangeways at street crossings and paved
streets, and the relative advantages and disadvantages of the differ-
ent kinds of telegraph poles.
(3) That the Board of Direction assign the subject of "uniform
railway signs for all purposes as applicable to the public and to
railway operation, for study and conclusions."
The President: — Do any of the members wish to make any re-
marks on the progress report of this Committee? Do any of the
members desire to say anything in regard to concrete posts?
If there is no discussion, the report of the Committee will be re-
ceived and the Committee dismissed with the thanks of the Asso-
ciation.
DISCUSSION ON ECONOMICS OF RAILWAY LOCATION.
(For Report, see pp. 905-906.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON ECONOMICS OF RAILWAY
LOCATION.
L. C. Fritch. A. K. Shurtleff.
The President — 'The next is the Committee on Economics of Rail-
way Location, of which Mr. A. K. Shurtleff is Chairman. Mr. Shurtleff
will make the opening statement.
Mr. A. K. Shurtleff (Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific) :— Mr. Presi-
dent and Members, the report of this Committee is found in Bulletin
144. The Committee has received one compliment on their report; that
was from the Secretary, and he complimented us because of the brevity of
the report. There was one most excellent reason for the brevity — we
had nothing to say, and we tried not to say it. The Committee feels a
little more cheerful than it did last year, as we have received some data
from railways which we consider extremely valuable, but it takes time to
digest this. I will say that we have a number of members on this Com-
mittee who are good workers and willing workers. One or two of them
have told me that they were ashamed to tell me how much work they
had done and how little it showed in the final results. The Chairman
feels the same way about the work that he has done. In digesting this
information, it takes an enormous amount of work to accomplish a little
for the final results. We trust that next year we will be able to give
you, in a substantial form, something in the line of conclusions.
Mr. Begien informs me that the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad is still
tabulating the results of those extensive tests they have been making, and
this will eventually be given to the Association. I know of nothing further
the Committee has to say. We have no apologies because we have not
been able to give a report. We have been working, but are unable as yet
to give anything that we think should be placed before the Association.
The President: — Does anyone wish to make any remarks?
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) :— Mr. Chairman, I would
like to say, on behalf of the Committee, that in order that the work of
this Committee be effective, the membership must make up its mind to
furnish them data. The Committtee cannot carry on its work unless the
Association furnishes it good, reliable data on which to work.
Mr. Shurtleff : — I want to say in reference to Mr. Fritch's remarks,
that after the last annual convention a number of the roads gave us most
excellent data for the work, and the Committee feels grateful to those
who have furnished that information.
The President :— The Committee will be dismissed with the thanks
of the Association.
1058
DISCUSSION ON UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT
FORMS.
(For Report, see pp. 907-916.)
LIST OF SPEAKERS TAKING PART IN DISCUSSION ON UNIFORM GENERAL
CONTRACT FORMS.
C. Frank Allen. J. E. Greiner. A. R. Raymer.
W. G. Atwood. J. B. Jenkins. J. P. Snow.
A. S. Baldwin. R. G. Kenly. W. F. Steffens.
J. B. Berry. E. H. Lee. C. H. Stein.
E. C. Brown. C. E. Lindsay. G. D. Swingly.
C. Dougherty. Hunter McDonald. W. I. Trench.
E. A. Frink. C. A. Morse.
The President : — The Committee on Uniform General Contract
Forms will please come forward. Mr. W. G. Atwood, the Vice-Chairman,
will make the statement of the work of this Committee.
Mr. W. G. Atwood (Lake Erie & Western) : — This Committee has
had meetings, as shown, and in addition the Chairman of the Committee
and myself met with the Chairman appointed by the Bridge Builders'
Association, who were also working on a general contract form. The
contract which they had drawn differed some from the form that we
proposed, but after the meeting we were substantially in agreement. The
Committee asks the approval of the convention to the general idea which
we have set out of having a short agreement which can be used, when
desired, in place of letter agreements, which are very common. If
we desire a formal contract instead of the acceptance of the proposition
by letter, we can use the agreement which we have shown under Form A.
In cases of larger work, where more detail is desired, we propose the
general condition shown under Form B, the idea being to print the
Form A so that the Form B can be bound in it, together with such
other clauses as may be desired by the person using the contract. We
have, in addition to working with the steel manufacturers; gone over
a large number of contract forms in use by various roads, and have also
considered the work presented by the Building Committee several years
ago. The form, as we have presented it, is unfortunately incomplete, as
the Committee has not finally agreed on clauses covering annulment
of contract on account of the contractor's fault, annulment of the con-
tract without fault of the contractor, removal of equipment, measure-
ment and approval of work, and final estimate.
The Committee recommends that the work be continued in order
that those clauses may be completed. With these clauses we considered
that we had covered about all the ground that it is practical to cover in a
1059
1060 CONTRACT FORMS.
general contract of this kind. When applied to specific cases, it will
probably be generally necessary to add certain clauses, covering each
case.
The President : — Will you read the construction contract as pro-
posed, by paragraphs? We will wait after each paragraph for criticism.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — "Construction Contract (A — Agreement) —
This agreement, made this day of in the
year by and between
party of the first part, hereinafter called the Contractor, and
party of the second part, hereinafter called the Company.
"Witnesseth, That, in consideration of the covenants and agreements
hereinafter mentioned, to be performed by the parties hereto, and of the
payments hereinafter agreed to be made, it is mutually agreed as follows:
"The Contractor shall furnish all the necessary transportation, ma-
terials, superintendence, labor and equipment, and shall execute, construct
and finish in an expeditious, substantial and workmanlike manner, to
the satisfaction and acceptance of the Chief Engineer of the Company
in accordance with the plans hereto attached or as herein
described, and the following general conditions, requirements and speci-
fications, forming part of this contract.
"The work covered by the contract shall be commenced
and be completed on or before the
day of , 191. .,
"This agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be binding upon the
legal representatives and successors of the parties respectively.
"In Witness Whereof, The parties hereto have executed this agree-
ment in the day and year first above written.
"Witness : "
Mr. E. C. Brown (Carnegie Steel Company) : — Is it not unusual to
nominate the Contractor as party of the first part in agreements with
the railroads.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — I would say that the practice is not at all
uniform. We had under consideration, 1 think, probably fifty contract
forms, and it was done about an equal number of times in each way. It
is really a matter that the Committee did not consider of any very great
importance. However, the Contractor's signature appears first on the
contract, and for that reason it seems that he should be the party of
the first part.
Mr. J. P. Snow (Consulting Engineer) : — I would like to ask the
Committee if they feel it is worth while to say that either the Con-
tractor or the Company is the party of the first part or the party of the
second part? Oftentimes an agreement states that such a party "will
be hereafter called the contractor" or "the railway," or "the company,"
or some characteristic name. Is it not better to use some such form
than to speak about "party of the first part" and "party of the second
part?" It is my preference.
DISCUSSION. 1061
Another thing that occurs to me is that there is nothing apparently
in this form that tells what the job is. It seems to me that the first line
or the first sentence of an agreement should state what the job is, so that
in running over your files you can easily recognize the paper that you
are trying to find. Again, it is often necessary to refer to the job in
the document, especially in the articles of agreement under B ; and my
preference is to name the work which is to be done, give it a distinctive
title, and say that it will hereafter be called "the work." Then you
can refer to it without stringing out the full name. In this way we
have "the work," "the contractor" and "the purchaser," whoever it may
be — the railway, the company, or some man's name, or the corporation.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — In reply to Mr. Snow's first criticism I would
say that we have found the practice of naming the parties to the contract
as the first and second party is very largely a matter of preference. In
my own experience I have found one or two attorneys who insisted that
it should be in this way. I have also heard of other attorneys who in-
sisted it should be in the way Mr. Snow states. I think that is largely a
matter of preference. The Committee thought this was the better way
in which to set it out.
In regard to the naming of the work in the first portion of an agree-
ment, that could readily be cared for by a heading. Mr. Snow will
find, below the next clause, a blank provided for a description of the
work. That changes the order which he suggests, but it is on the first
page of the contract.
Prof. C. Frank Allen (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) : —
Mr. President, in relation to the question of omitting the words "party
of the first part" and "party of the second part," it is, of course, a well-
recognized fact that in contracts there must be definitely at least two
parties. Sometimes the description of one of the parties is somewhat
elaborate, and if there is a clear distinction made between those two
parties, the contract on the whole is somewhat clearer, and apparently
a sharp distinction between the two parties does more clearly establish
who the two parties are, if there is an opportunity to put it in this
form. It does not impress me as unnecessarily encumbering the con-
tract, but it does, from my standpoint, add somewhat to its clearness.
Mr. Snow : — In reference to the definition of the work, my idea
is to have the first sentence simply give a title to the job and say after-
wards that "hereafter it will be called the work." The reference, lower
down, where the blank is provided for the description of the work, is
necessary also, because the work must be defined with a good deal of
definition, more than you would want to put into the initial sentence.
My idea is that there shall be three distinct terms used for reference
all through the agreement, "the work," "the contractor," and the party for
whom the work is to be done.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin (Illinois Central) : — I agree with Mr. Snow in his
suggestion as to the better wording, at the opening clause of the con-
tract. I think, as arranged here, it is a mixture of two forms. It
1062 CONTRACT FORMS.
is rather the older form in which the parties were named as the first and
second parties to a contract to take the place, of course, of repetition of
names. At the same time undoubtedly that frequently makes one have to
refer back to the first part of the contract to refresh one's mind as
to who was the first and second party. Subsequent to that the method
has become very common of naming one as a Contractor and one as the
Railway Company. I would suggest that "party of the first part" and
"party of the second part" be removed.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — I will call the attention of both of the former
speakers to the fact that this clause reads, "party of the first part,
hereinafter called 'the Contractor,' and blank, party of the second part,
hereinafter called 'the Company.'" In the clauses in Form B the two
parties to the contract are spoken of in that way.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin: — What is gained by naming them as parties
of the first part and second part if not referred to thereafter in the
contract by the same terms? If they are referred to as "Contractor"
and "the Railway Company," the terms "party of the first part" and
"party of the second part" are probably not used again.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — No ; we do not use "party of the first part"
and "party of the second part." That is a legal form and some of the
lawyers consider it necessary. I don't know personally whether there
is any legal objection to withdrawing "party of the first part" and "party
of the second part" from this one clause or not, but it doesn't seem to
me there is any objection to leaving it there.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — I move that in the third line "party of the
first part" be eliminated, and in the fourth line "party of the second
part" be eliminated.
Mr. A. R. Raymer (Pittsburgh & Lake Erie) : — An operating com-
pany when making contracts quite frequently includes the name or
names of one or more lessee companies, which companies together are
called the "first party" or the "second party," etc., as the case may be
For this reason the form used by the Committee is preferable
Mr. A. S. Baldwin : — I have seen a great many contracts drawn up
in which several parties were combined in one, by referring to such and
such parties "hereinafter collectively called so and so," giving them a
name that identifies them by name all the way through the contract,
which of course answers the same purpose.
Mr. C. H. Stein (Central Railroad of New Jersey) : — I want to em-
phasize the view which is taken by Mr. Raymer. I do not believe we
could afford to get up the contracts in any other form. I think there
should be some specific designation similar to the one outlined by the
Committee. I believe that almost from time immemorial this has been
substantially the form in which the contracts have been gotten up, and
it frequently happens that the names of contracting parties are so
much alike that even we, who are familiar with the general character
of the contract but not entirely familiar with the specifications of
it, are obliged to be very careful in reading the contract in order to
DISCUSSION. 1063
fully understand what obligations rest upon the respective parties. In
my own experience when it has been referred to as "party of the first
part" and "party of the second part," I would be obliged to refer to
the indication in the preamble to the contract to distinctly understand what
particular person was obligated by that particular specification. If names
so nearly alike had simply been mentioned it would have been almost
impossible to separate them in our minds, and would have made us
prone to error in a proper interpretation of the contract. For that
reason, I believe, if this paper, as prepared by the Committee, was sub-
mitted to the legal departments of the railroads, they would direct that
the contract be prepared just in the form that has been arranged for
by the Committee. For that reason I think the Committee's report should
stand and that the Association should not set aside all the edicts of the
legal fraternity and assume to itself the prerogative of how a contract
of this kind should be prepared. If the Association thinks there is any
question as to the propriety of this character of contract, it had better
be submitted to the legal department of some of the railways and get
their advice in the matter before the Association arbitrarily says 'cut
this thing out," or "cut that thing out." This question is of too much
importance to be put aside by mere resolutions.
M'r. J. B. Berry (Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific): — I suggest the
Committee leave a blank line or two after the description of the parties —
there are frequently three or more parties to any contract.
Mr. E. A. Frink (Seaboard Air Line) : — I call attention to the last
clause, "In witness whereof the parties hereto have executed this agree-
ment in , the day and year first above written." It
seems to me that date is incorrect, for the reason that a contract is made
and completed on the day when the proposition has been accepted, but
need not necessarily be signed until some time thereafter, and, therefore,
instead of that clause referring to the date first above written, which
appears at the head of the contract, it seems to me it should show the
date when the contract was actually signed.
Mr. Raymer : — I make one suggestion. The contract follows the
usual form in saying, "in accordance with the plans hereto attached."
We know this is an idle term, because in most railway contracts it is im-
possible to attach the plans to the contract, and I think a different form
should be used ; for instance : "In accordance with the plans identified
by the signatures of the parties hereto." This will identify the plans
and render unnecessary the words "in accordance with the plans hereto
attached."
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — In regard to the criticism of the last clause there
is a misprint. The word "in" should be "on." Jt is my opinion that
the contract does not become in force and effective until it is signed.
In fact, a contract supersedes by law any prior agreement, verbal or
written. The contract is supposed to embody all such agreements, and
it does not seem to me the last clause should be changed as suggested.
1064 CONTRACT FORMS.
In regard to Mr. Raymer's criticism, it is, of course, a fact that some-
times the complete plans are not attached to the contract, but that is
covered by the words "or as herein described." If the plans are not
attached to the contract, the description of the work would necessarily
include the plans that woidd be required to cover the entire work.
Mr. Raymer : — That is true, but there is another point. In work
of any magnitude, the detail plans are usually not all completed at the
time of the letting of the contract. It may be necessary to make
changes in the plans during the progress of the work by agreement with
the Contractor. The original plans referred to in the contract should be
specifically marked. For this reason it is desirable to have the plans
identified by the signatures of the parties to the contract
To bring the matter before the meeting in proper form, I move
that the phraseology now contained in the report of the Committee, "in
accordance with the plans hereto attached" or "as herein described," be
changed to read as follows: "In accordance with plans identified by the
signatures of the parties hereto."
(The motion was lost.)
M'r. W. F. Steffens (Boston & Albany) : — Do I understand that there
is to be space left for a description of the plans? As the forms now
read, the blanks left for necessary or extra writing apply to the beginning
and date of completion of the contract. Should there not be a space pro-
vided in the contract to identify the plans "as herein described?"
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — It hardly seems to the Committee that in
general it is necessary to definitely describe each plan attached. We
say, "in accordance with the plans hereto attached." They become
part of the contract, but it is a matter of detail arrangement. This
contract form probably will not be used very extensively exactly as
it is printed, especially as to the spacing of blanks, and I am inclined
to think the suggestion of Mr. Steffens is in the line of a detail which
it would not be necessary to cover in this general form.
Prof. Allen : — The Railway Company is very likely to have several
blank forms of contract ; one a short form, with small blanks ; and
another with larger blanks, and the Railway Company has ample oppor-
tunity to print its own forms with such additional blanks as may seem
desirable.
Mr. J. B. Jenkins (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I suggest that the blank
space immediately above, for describing the work to be done, could
also be used to describe the plans to be used, and in connection with the
motion just lost I would suggest that the contract reads: "As herein
described," and these plans could be very readily described as being
identified by the signatures of the contracting parties.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — I would move that the fii st recommendation
of the Committee that the form of construction contract A, as presented
by the Committee, be approved.
(The motion was carried.)
DISCUSSION. 1065
The President : — We will now take up the "Construction Contract"
B, General Conditions, and it will be read by sections.
(Mr. Atwood read the construction contract by sections.)
"i. Bond. The Contractor agrees, at the time of the execution and
delivery of this contract and before the taking effect of the same, to
furnish and deliver to the Company a good and sufficient bond of in-
demnity to the amount of dollars, as se-
curity for the faithful performance, by the Contractor, of all the cove-
nants and agreements on the part of the Contractor contained in this
contract. The security in such bond of indemnity must be satisfactory
and acceptable to the Company.
"This bond shall remain in force and effect in such amount, not
greater than that specified, as shall be determined by the Chief En-
gineer, until the final completion and acceptance of the work."
Mr. C. A. M'orse (Santa Fe) : — What is intended to be meant by the
words "to furnish and deliver to the Company a good and sufficient
bond?" Would it not be well to say the Treasurer of the Company
in referring to the Railway Company?
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — That practice varies with different companies.
In the case of some companies the Chief Engineer controls it, in some
cases the Treasury, and in some cases the Legal Department, and in some
cases all three.
"2. Contractor's Understanding. It is understood and agreed that
the Contractor has, by careful examination, satisfied himself as to the
nature and location of the work, the conformation of the ground, the
character, quality and quantity of the materials to be encountered, the
character of equipment and facilities needed preliminary to and during
the prosecution of the work, the general and local conditions, and all
other matters which can in any way affect the work under this con-
tract. No verbal agreement or conversation with any officer, agent or
employe of the Company, either before or after the execution of this
contract, shall affect or modify any of the terms or obligations herein
contained.
"3. Intent of Plans and Specifications. All work that may be called
for in the specifications and not shown on the plans, or shown on the plans
and not called for in the specifications, shall be executed and furnished
by the Contractor as if described in both these ways ; and should any
work or material be required which is not denoted in the specifications
or plans, either directly or indirectly, but which is nevertheless necessary
for the proper carrying out of the obvious intentions thereof, the Con-
tractor is to understand the same to be implied and required, and shall
perform all such work and furnish any such material as fully as if
they were particularly delineated or described.
"4. Permits. Permits of a temporary nature necessary for the
prosecution of the work shall be secured by the Contractor. Permits
for permanent structures or permanent changes in existing facilities shall
be secured by the Company.
1066 CONTRACT FORMS.
"5. Protection. Whenever the local conditions, laws or ordinances
require, the Contractor shall furnish and maintain, at his own cost
and expense, necessary passageways, guard fences and lights and such
other facilities and means of protection as may be required."
Mr. C. A. Lindsay (New York Central & Hudson River) : — What is
the object of making the distinction between "permits of a temporary
nature" and "permits for permanent structures ?" It seems to me the
line is hazy and might lead to confusion, unless the Committee has some
special object in making the distinction.
Mr. W. G. Atwood: — The Committee has already boiled down sdme
clauses bearing on this matter which were much longer. It is intended
that the Contractor shall obtain permits, for instance, such as the open-
ing of a street, for the erection of false work or similar temporary
work, while it is intended that it shall be the duty of the Company to
secure permits in such cases as the permanent change of grade or the
position of a sewer or water pipe. Anything that is of a permanent
character will be cared for by the Company, and if it is a temporary ob-
struction it will be the duty of the Contractor to secure the permit.
"6. Rights of Various Interests. Wherever work being done by
Company forces or by other Contractors is contiguous to work covered
by this contract the respective rights of the various interests involved
shall be determined by the Engineer, to secure the completion of the
various portions of the work in general harmony.
"7. Consent to Transfer. The Contractor shall not let or trans-
fer this contract or any part thereof (except for the delivery of ma-
terial) without consent of the Chief Engineer, given in writing. Such
consent does not release or relieve the Contractor from any or all of his
obligations and liabilities under the contract.
"8. Superintendence. The Contractor shall constantly superintend
all the work embraced in this contract in person or by a duly authorized
manager acceptable to the Company.
"9. Timely Demand for Points and Instructions The Contractor
shall not proceed until he has made timely demand upon the Engineer
for, and has received from him, such points and instructions as may be
necessary as the work progresses. The work shall be done in strict
conformity with such points and instructions.
"10. Report Errors and Discrepancies. If the Contractor, in the
course of the work, finds any discrepancy between the plans and the
physical conditions of the locality, or any errors in plans or in the
layout as given by said points and instructions, it shall be his duty to im-
mediately inform the Engineer. Any work done after such discovery,
until verified, will be done at the Contractor's risk.
"11. Preservation of Stakes. The Contractor must carefully preserve
bench marks, reference points and stakes, and in case of wilful or care-
less destruction, he will be charged with the resulting expense and shall
be responsible for any mistakes that may be caused by their unnecessary
loss or disturbance.
DISCUSSION. 1067
"12. Inspection. All work and materials shall be at all times open
to the inspection, acceptance or rejection of the Engineer or his duly
authorized representative. The Contractor shall at all times provide
reasonable and necessary facilities for such inspection.
"13. Defective Work or Material. Any omission or failure on the
part of the Engineer to disapprove or reject any work or material shall
not be construed to be an acceptance of any defective work or material.
The Contractor shall remove, at his own expense, any work or material
condemned by the Engineer, and shall rebuild and replace the same with-
out extra charge, and in default thereof the same shall be done by the
Company at the Contractor's expense — or, in case the Chief Engineer
should not consider the defect of sufficient importance to require the Con-
tractor to rebuild or replace any imperfect work or material, he shall
have power, and is hereby authorized, to make any deduction from the
stipulated price that he may deem proper."
Mr. Steffens : — The last sentence is pretty radical, giving the Chief
Engineer authority to make any deduction from the stipulated price
that he may deem proper for defective work. Unless there is an ar-
bitration clause that is pretty dangerous from the Contractor's stand-
point. "As agreed upon by the parties" would be acceptable reading.
Mr. W. G. Atwood: — The Committee felt that perhaps this clause
was somewhat radical, not quite in the way Mr. Steffens suggests. It
is unusual, I think, in contracts to permit the Chief Engineer to accept
work that is not up to specifications. I think all of us have had ex-
periences where we have condemned work and ordered it torn out when
we felt that it was not up to specifications, but would perhaps have
performed its service. This paragraph leaves an opportunity to use
the defective work and allows the Chief Engineer to make a deduction.
I do not believe it is practicable to make that a matter of agreement.
(There was no change in the section.)
"14. Insurance. The Contractor shall secure in the name of the
Company and for its benefit, policies of fire insurance on such structures
and in such amounts as shall be specified by the Chief Engineer not
exceeding
"15. Indemnity. The Contractor shall indemnify and save harmless
the Company for and from all claims, demands, payments, suits, actions,
recoveries and judgments of every nature and description brought or re-
covered against it, by reason of any act or omission of the said Con-
tractor, his agents or employes, in the execution of the work by or in
consequence of any negligence or carelessness in guarding the same.
"16. Settlement for Wages. Whenever, in the opinion of the Chief
Engineer, it may be necessary for the progress of the work to secure
to any of the employes of the Contractor any wages which may then
be due them, the Company is hereby authorized to pay said employes the
amount due them or any lesser amount, and the amount so paid them, as
shown by their receipts, shall be deducted from any moneys that may
be or become payable to said Contractor."
1068 CONTRACT FORMS.
Prof. Allen: — A question occurs as to this section, whether it is
possible that the amount of money that is reserved and payable will
in all cases be sufficient to safeguard the Company. A Contractor may
do a certain amount of work that proves of very little value to the Com-
pany and the workmen who did the work may have a mechanic's lien
against the Company; this clause apparently does not sufficiently pro-
tect the Company ; it has occurred to me that it would be wise to
have a provision in the bond looking to matters of that sort. This
form of contract is not to be accepted in full at the present: time, because
it is incomplete in parts,and I make this suggestion to the Committee
so that there may be opportunity to take care of this matter if they see
fit, either here, or, probably, better, in the bond.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — I think the bond generally does take care of
that.
Mr. Hunter McDonald (Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis) : — I
ask the Committee if they intend, in the second line of the clause, the
word "employes" to mean also "sub-contractors?"
Mr. W. G. Atwood:— I think that was the intention of the Committee.
"17. Liens. If an established lien be filed against the Contractor
for labor or material furnished in the performance of the work, the
Company is hereby authorized to pay and discharge the same, if it shall
deem best so to do, and to deduct the amount so paid from any moneys
which may be or become due and payable to the Contractor."
Mr. Raymer : — The no-liens laws are different in different States.
In Pennsylvania it is customary with us to have a "no-lien" clause. The
law requires a copy of the contract and some additional information
to be filed at the County courthouse ; after complying with these require-
ments the Company is not responsible for liens. These liens some-
times develop after the final payment has been made. I ask the Com-
mittee if there is any objection against having a "no-lien" clause included
in this contract?
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — It seems to the Committee that the case men-
tioned by Mr. Raymer and other cases which might occur under various
State laws would be special cases that the road using the contract would
have to cover in a special clause which they would insert in the con-
tract to meet local conditions. The lien laws do vary quite generally
in different States. It might be that in Pennsylvania this clause would
have to be materially changed.
"18. Work Adjacent to Railroad. Whenever the work embraced in
this contract is near the tracks, structures or buildings of this Company
or of other railroads, the Contractor shall use proper care and vigilance
to avoid injury to persons or property. The work must be so conducted
as not to interfere with the movement of trains or other operations of
the railroad; or, if in any case such interference be necessary, the Con-
tractor shall not proceed until he has first obtained specific authority
and directions therefor from the proper officer of the Company and
has the approval of the Engineer."
DISCUSSION. 1069
Mr. J. E. Greiner (Baltimore & Ohio) : — Suppose there is some other
property adjacent to the railway which is not railway property— how arc
you going to take care of that?
In a highway for instance?
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — I think that is generally covered in another
clause — the clause on protection.
"19. Risk. The work in every respect shall be at the risk of the
Contractor until finished and accepted, except damage or injury caused
directly by Company's agents or employes.
"20. Order and Discipline. The Contractor shall at all times enforce
strict discipline and good order among his employes, and any employe
of the Contractor who shall appear to be incompetent, disorderly or in-
temperate, or in any other way disqualified for or unfaithful to the work
entrusted to him, shall be discharged immediately on the request of the
Engineer, and he shall not again be employed on the work without the
Engineer's written consent."
Prof. Allen : — Would it be an advantage to have that read "any em-
ploye of the Contractor who shall appear to the Engineer to be in-
competent?" That places the responsibility a little more clearly, although
che inference from this reading would be to the same effect.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — The request is to be made by the Engineer
according to this clause.
Prof. Allen : — My suggestion would make it a little more definite
Mr. W. G. Atwood: — "21. Contractor Not to Hire Company's Em-
ployes. The Contractor shall not employ or hire any of the Company's
employes without the permission of the Engineer."
A Member: — What does that mean?
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — This perhaps covers two things. The Con-
tractor sometimes steals a man from you, very much to your detriment,
and I have heard of cases where masonry inspectors, for instance, have
been employed as "pumpers" somewhat to the loss of the masonry.
"22. Intoxicating Liquors Prohibited. The Contractor, in so far
as his authority extends, shall not permit the sale, distribution or use of
any intoxicating liquors upon or adjacent to the work, or allow any such
to be brought upon, to or near the line of the railway of the Company.
"23. Cleaning Up. The Contractor shall, as directed by the En-
gineer, remove from the Company's property and from all public and
private property, at his own expense, all temporary structures, rubbish
and waste materials resulting from his operations.
"24. Engineer and Chief Engineer Defined. Wherever in this con-
tract the word Engineer is used, it shall be understood as referring to
the Chief Engineer of the Company, acting personally or through an
assistant duly authorized in writing for such act by the Chief Engineer,
and wherever the words Chief Engineer are used it shall be understood
as referring to the Chief Engineer in person, and not to any assistant
engineer.
1070 CONTRACT FORMS.
"25. Power of Engineer. The Engineer shall have full power to
reject or condemn all work or material, which, in his opinion, does not
conform to this contract; to direct the application of forces to any portion
of the work which, in his judgment, requires it; to order the force in-
creased or diminished, and to decide every question that may arise be-
tween the parties relative to the execution of the work.
"26. Adjustment of Dispute. All questions or controversies which
may arise between the Contractor and the Company, under or in refer-
ence to this contract, shall be subject to the decision of the Chief En-
gineer, and his decision shall be final and conclusive to both parties.
"27. Order of Completion; Use of Completed Portions. The Con-
tractor shall complete any portion or portions of the work in such order
of time as the Engineer may require. The Company shall have the
right to take possession of and use any completed or partially com-
pleted portions of the work, notwithstanding the time for completing the
entire work or such portions may not have expired; but such taking
possession and use shall not be deemed an acceptance cf the work so
taken or used or any part thereof. If such prior use increases the cost
of or delays the work, the Contractor will be entitled to such extra com-
pensation, or extension of time, as the Chief Engineer may determine."
Mr. Steffens : — Between sections 26 and 27, it seems that there should
be inserted an arbitration clause. This clause makes the Chief Engineer
the sole judge of all disputes, whereas an arbitration clause very often
saves us from annoying lawsuits.
Mr. W. I. Trench (Baltimore & Ohio) : — I have prepared an addi-
tion to paragraph 27 to meet a condition I have lately encountered, the
case being one in which a Contractor failed to properly locate his plant
in the beginning and also failed to remove it. in time to avoid delay
to the work, and also failed to remove portions of his plant after com-
pletion of parts of the work, which seriously delayed a portion of the
work to be done by the Company, and to remedy this, I move that an
addition be made to paragraph 27 as follows :
"The Contractor shall locate his plant only after careful study of
the plans and consultation with the Engineer in charge, so as not to
interfere with any work to be performed by the Company during his
occupation of the premises ; if to facilitate the work temporary location
has been permitted, the Contractor shall immediately upon demand of
the Engineer remove such plant or portion of plant at his own expense.
If the Contractor fails to make said removal, the Company may do it
at his expense.
"The Contractor shall remove the plant from finished portions of the
work immediately on demand of the Engineer in charge. If he shall
fail to make such removal, it may be done by the Company at his
expense."
(The above addition was put to vote, but was not adopted.)
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — "28. Changes. The Company shall have the
right to make any changes that may be hereafter determined upon, in
DISCUSSION. 1071
the nature or dimensions of the work, either before or after its com-
mencement, and such changes shall in no way affect or void this con-
tract. If such changes diminish the quantity or extent of the work to
be done, they shall not, under any circumstances, be construed as con-
stituting, and shall not constitute a claim for damages or for anticipated
profits on such work.
"In case quantities in the completed work vary from the quantities
shown on the original plans, and provided for in the specifications, then
the final payment shall be adjusted on the basis of unit rates specified
in this contract.
"Note. — First paragraph of section 28 to be used in unit price and
force account contracts, i. e., in all contracts not on lump-sum prices.
Should be omitted in lump-sum contracts."
The first paragraph of section 28 is intended to be used in unit
price contracts, and the second paragraph in lump-sum contracts.
Prof. Allen : — Is it not necessary to have some provision that changes
shall not void the contract? Is it not necessary that such a provision
shall be inserted, in the case of the lump-sum contract? Is it not as
necessary in one case as the other?
M'r. W. G. Atwood : — The Committee will consider the suggestion
made by Prof. Allen in regard to that clause and perhaps change it.
Mr. Lindsay : — Section 28 provides for changes in unit price and
force account contracts, and provides that in contracts not on those
terms — i. e., lump-sum contracts — that the first paragraph should be
omitted. How does the Committee propose to take care of changes in
lump-sum contracts ?
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — Prof. Alien's suggestion was in the same line,
and the Committee said they would revise that clause.
"29. Extra Work. No bill or claim for extra work or material shall
be allowed or paid unless the doing of such extra work or the furnish-
ing of such extra material shall have been authorized in writing by the
Engineer before any part of such work was done or material furnished.
"The price for such work shall be determined by the Chief Engineer,
who may either fix a unit price or a lump-sum price, or may, if he so
elects, provide that the price shall be determined by the actual cost, to
which shall be added per cent, to cover general expense
and superintendence, profits, contingencies, use of tools, Contractor's risk
and liability. If the Contractor shall perform any work or furnish any
material, which is not provided for in this contract, or which was not
authorized in writing by the Engineer previous to the doing of the work
or the furnishing of material, said Contractor shall receive no compensa-
tion for such work or material so furnished, and does hereby release and
discharge the company from any payment therefor.
"If the Contractor shall proceed with such extra work or the fur-
nishing of such extra material after receiving the written authority there-
for, as hereinbefore provided, then such work or material, stated in the
written authority of the Engineer, shall be covered, governed and con-
1072 CONTRACT FORMS.
trolled by all the terms and provisions of this contract, subject to such
prices as may be agreed upon or fixed by the Chief Engineer.
''If the Contractor shall decline or fail to perforin such work or
furnish such extra material as authorized by the Engineer in writing,
as aforesaid, the Company may then arrange for the performance of
the work in any manner it may see fit, the same as if this contract had
not been executed, and the Contractor shall not interfere with such per-
formance of the work."
Mr. Greiner: — It seems to me that the last part of the second para-
graph of section 29 is rather hard on the Contractor. Conditions may
arise where the Contractor is compelled to do some work not covered
in the contract, in order to protect his work, or something that has not
been anticipated, and it may be necessary to do that at a time in advance
of notice from the Engineer, and as this paragraph reads he would get
no pay for it at all. It seems to me that this part of the paragraph
should be worded just a little differently, so that if you have a condi-
tion like that, there would not be any injustice done.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — The Committee has felt that it is necessary to
draw this contract as rigidly as it is drawn. The Engineer is an
arbitrator and he is supposed to be fair to both parties. The final de-
termination in any case would go to the courts if there was a disagree-
ment, and we feel we have covered this matter of extra work as fairly
to both parties as it is possible to do it and protect both parties. An unfair
Engineer can, of course, by the enforcement arbitrarily of certain clauses
of a contract work great hardships, but I do not believe it is possible to
draw a contract, if there is unfairness on either side that will prevent
an appeal to the courts.
Mr. Greiner : — The Engineer will have no authority at all on this
point. If the Contractor should perform any work, or furnish any ma-
terial, which was not provided for in the contract, or authorized in
writing by the Engineer, previous to the doing of the work, or the
furnishing of the material, the Contractor would receive no compensation
for such work or material.
The point I am trying to make is that if the Contractor should do
work not called for in the contract, that he be paid for it, provided the
Engineer shall see fit to authorize it in writing, even after it is started.
According to the language used in this section, the Engineer has no
right to authorize it, after the work is started, even if it is absolutely
necessary.
Mr. Jenkins : — I think the clause as it stands deters the Contractor
in some cases from doing necessary extra work in the absence of the
Engineer, because he might be afraid he would not get the proper authori-
zation, even after the work is done, and might be afraid that authoriza-
tion, if issued, would not enable him to collect any money.
Mr. L. C. Fritch (Chicago Great Western) : — I think Mr. Greiner's
point can be covered if we leave out the words "previous to the doing of
the work or the furnishing of material."
DISCUSSION. 1073
Mr. Lindsay: — In the first paragraph, page 51, in line with the sug-
gestion of Mr. Fritch, it would be necessary to eliminate the words "after
receiving the written authority therefor."
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — The Committee will accept the amendment.
Mr. G. D. Swingly (Baltimore & Ohio) :— The article reads, "Will,
however, pay the Contractor for expense of men and teams necessarily
retained during the interval of suspension." I would like to know when
it would be considered that they were necessarily retained. It seems to
me there might be some time fixed after which they will not be paid. That
might go on for a long time and might amount to quite an item of ex-
pense.
Mr. W. G. Atwood: — I think that is covered by the statement, "pro-
vided the Contractor can show that it was not reasonably practicable to
move these men and teams to other points at which they can be engaged.''
The Committee feels that if the Company stops the work temporarily and
forces the Contractor to hold his men and equipment on the work, that
he ought to be paid for it. In cases where the Contractor cannot use
them on other portions of the work, he is entitled to payment until such
time as the Company either annuls the contract, or allows the Contractor
to proceed with the work.
Mr. Lindsay: — I would like to ask if it is necessary to put in the
words "in sections," near the bottom of paragraph 32? Would it not be-
better to read, "as provided in this contract" ?
Mr. A. S. Baldwin: — This clause, as drawn, leaves latitude for a great
deal of dispute between the Contractor and the Engineer as to the value
or amount of the time that is lost. We have made it a practice to name
the price per day that should be charged for teams under those circum-
stances, and require the Contractor to make it part of his contract, and
likewise specify that payment would be for men on monthly time only.
This precludes the Contractor from bringing in an excessive claim.
The President :— Mr. Swingly, do you wish to say anything further?
Mr. Swingly : — It is also my idea that the Contractor should be paid
for teams which are necessarily idle on account of temporary stoppage
of the work; but it seems to me that we might name a time limit, be-
cause it might be necessary to hold up the work for a considerable period
of time and give the Contractor a very good chance to keep his men and
teams there at our expense, and if he did not have other contracts it
might be more profitable for him to keep his men and teams there and
not try to get them away.
Mr. A. S. Baldwin :— We cover that by naming a price that barely
more than lets the Contractor out, with both men and teams. The result
is he is after the Engineer to get started just as much as the Engineer is
desirous that the Contractor get started.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — "30. Property and Right of Entry. The Com-
pany shall provide the lands upon which the work under this contract
is to be done, except that the Contractor shall provide land required for
the erection of temporary construction facilities and storage of his ma-
terial, together with right of access to the same.
1074 CONTRACT FORMS.
"The Contractor shall not enter upon said lands, nor ship any ma-
terial or equipment, until he has received written notice from the Engineer
that he may proceed with said work or any part thereof.
"31. Unavoidable Delays ; Extension of Time on Parts of Work.
If the Contractor shall be delayed in the performance of the work from
any cause, for which the Company is responsible, he shall, upon written
application to the Chief Engineer at the time of such delay, be granted
such extension of time as the Chief Engineer shall deem equitable and
just.
"32. Suspension of Work. The Company may at any time stop the
work, or any part thereof, by giving ten (10) days' notice to the Con-
tractor in writing. The work shall be resumed by the Contractor in ten
(10) days after the date fixed in the written notice from the Company
to the Contractor so to do. The Company shall not be held liable for
any damages or anticipated profits on account of the work being stopped, or
for any work done during the interval of suspension. It will, however, pay
the Contractor for expense of men and teams necessarily retained during
the interval of suspension, provided the Contractor can show that it was
not reasonably practicable to move these men and teams to other points
at which they can be engaged. The Company will further pay the Con-
tractor for time necessarily lost during such suspension at the rate of
per cent, per annum on the estimated value of all equipment
and fixtures owned by the Contractor and employed on the work which
are necessarily idle during such suspension, said rate of per
cent, per annum being understood to include depreciation, interest and
insurance. But if the work, or any part thereof, shall be stopped by the
notice in writing aforesaid, and if the Company does not give notice in
writing to the Contractor to resume work at a date within
of the date fixed in the written notice to suspend, then the
Contractor may abandon that portion of the work to suspend and he will
be entitled to the estimates and payments for such work so abandoned,
as provided in Sections of this contract.
"33- Annulment, Contractor's Fault. Discussed, but not acted upon
by the Committee.
"34. Annulment, Without Fault of Contractor. Discussed, but not
acted upon by the Committee.
"35. Removal of Equipment in Case of Annulment. Discussed, but
not acted upon by the Committee.
"36. Measurement and Approval of Work. Discussed, but not acted
upon by the Committee.
"2,7- Monthly Estimate. So long as the work herein contracted for
is prosecuted in accordance with the provisions of this contract, and with
such progress as may be satisfactory to the Chief Engineer, the said Chief
Engineer will, on or about the first day of each month, make an approxi-
mate estimate of the proportionate value of the work done and of ma-
terial furnished or delivered upon the Company's property at the site of
the work, up to and including the last day of the previous month. The
amount of said estimate, after deducting per cent, and all
DISCUSSION. 1075
previous payments, shall be due and payable to the Contractor at the office
of the Treasurer of the Company on or about the 20th day of the current
month.
Mr. E. A. Frink (Seaboard Air Line) :— In our work, we have found
it saves a good deal of trouble if we require the Contractor, before the
first monthly payment, to file with us a schedule of prices for material
on specified price contracts and labor and material on lump-sum contracts.
Then, in making up the estimates the inspector on the ground makes up
an estimate of the work done, makes up a regular form showing his
estimate. That is examined by the Contractor, or the Contractor's fore-
man, and if it is satisfactory, it is signed by both parties and sent to the
home office for payment. In that way we avoid all discussion with the
Contractor about whether he has or has not been allowed as much as he
ought to be allowed.
Mr. Berry : — I would like to ask the Committee whether the mem-
bers have consulted with their law departments in regard to the bond and
contracts.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — The New York Central Lines' members of the
Committee have, and we have found that in various States that various
roads' law departments disagree about the same thing. There are un-
doubtedly things in this contract which some law departments will not
approve and will change, but I do not believe it possible to draw a gen-
eral contract of this kind that will satisfy all law departments. We think
that the provisions we have put in this form are legal, and they have been
gone over with some lawyers.
Mr. Berry : — 'The membership on this Committee is scattered through-
out the country, and it seems to me that the law departments of the com-
panies with which these members are associated should be consulted in
regard to the matter. It is 'skating on pretty thin ice nowadays unless
they are consulted in advance and know all about it ; they are a party
to it and have got to defend it. Our department always consults them
in matters of that kind. Not only that, but my superior officers ask
whether I have asked the law department. I would not like to vote, and
1 think a good many members would not like to vote until they knew
the law department had approved the bond and contract.
Mr. E. H. Lee (Chicago & Western Indiana) : — In reference to Mr.
Berry's remarks, it was the aim of the Committee, in preparing this form,
to cover the -general conditions. The Committee realizes that it is a
matter of impossibility to prepare any general form which will receive
the approval of the legal departments of all the roads. In fact, the speaker
knows of one case within the last year or two, where the legal repre-
sentatives of four or five separate Chicago roads were asked for an opin-
ion on identically the same proposition, where there were as many differ-
ent opinions rendered. The Committee, therefore, feels that the form
should be taken as subject at all times to the approval of the legal de-
partment of any Company that uses it.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I think the Committee is to be congratulated on
the excellent form of the contracts which they have given us, especially
1076 CONTRACT FORMS.
the short form, and for more extensive work the long form ; but I be-
lieve with Mr. Berry, that before we vote on the adoption of this, it
ought to be referred back for a legal opinion. There are five clauses
which were discussed, but not acted upon by the Committee. It seems
to me it would be proper to receive this report as information and have
the Committee report finally next year. In the meantime many of us
can use this form, but we should get a final report on it for next year.
Mr. Berry : — In the absence of the lawyers, I think I will have to
defend them. One of the members of the Committee and I have been on
an Engineers' Committee. I found that no two Engineers agreed. How-
ever, these same Engineers got together and agreed upon a contract and
the work is going forward. I believe the lawyers will finally agree upon
a form.
Mr. R. G. Kenly (Minneapolis & St. Louis) : — I agree with the
proposition made by Mr. Fritch, that these contract forms be referred
back to the Committee, that we formulate the specifications, have them
printed, send them in the form of a circular letter to every railroad repre-
sented in this Association, and ask them to reply with an opinion of their
legal department as to the phraseology and legal terms of the specifica-
tions. Then let the Committee tabulate them and report to the Associa-
tion with at least a statement of the majority of the opinions of the
various legal departments.
Mr. Curtis Dougherty (Cincinnati, New Orleans & Texas Pa-
cific) : — If not out of order, I would like to ask the Committee if they
considered any provision to cover the case where the Contractor becomes
insolvent and unable to carry the work forward, and the work has to be
undertaken by the Company.
Mr. W. G. Atwood : — I would say that that is covered, or will be
covered in one of the clauses which the Committee have been consider-
ing for annulment ; this is one of the clauses which we are considering
but are not ready to submit. Among the reasons given for annulment of
the contract by the Company is on account of the work not progressing
with reasonable speed and the inability of the Contractor to meet his
financial obligations.
Mr. L. C. Fritch : — I move that the report of the Committee be re-
ceived as information and be referred back to the Committee for final
report next year.
(The motion was seconded and carried.)
Mr. Jenkins: — I move that the Association thank the Committee for
its good work.
(The motion was seconded.)
Mr. Kenly: — I would like to amend that to cover the < ctive mem-
bers of the Committee, and you will have to read the names of those at-
tending the various meetings to find out who were the active members.
(The motion was carried.)
The President: — The Committee will be dismissed with the thanks
of the Association.
AMENDMENTS.
AMENDMENTS TO COMMITTEE REPORTS.
REFERENCE TO AMENDMENTS MADE TO COMMITTEE REPORTS AT THE THIRTEENTH
ANNUAL CONVENTION.
RULES AND ORGANIZATION.
(For Report, see "p. 65-68; discussion, pp. 919-931.)
Amend clause (6) to read as follows :
"(6) After ballast is distributed and the track lifted, the track
should be lined and surfaced and the ballast trimmed to conform to
standard plans."
Amend clause (7) to read as follows :
"(7) Where track is electrically bonded, ballast must be kept at
least one inch below the base of rail. At road crossings, platforms, etc.,
where this is not practicable, only clean gravel or rock ballast shall be
used."
Amend clause (10) to read as follows:
"(10) The renewal of ties shall be started when directed by the
...\... When ties are being renewed, the line and surface
shall be corrected, unsuitable material removed and ballast trimmed."
Amend clause (12) to read as follows:
"(12) The shall frequently inspect ties removed
from track to see if any of them have been removed which might have
remained in the track with safety until the next inspection."
Amend clause (14) to read as follows:
"(14) Ties must be laid so as to obtain the best bearing. The
largest and best ties shall be selected for use at joints. Twisted or
badly hewn ties must not be notched, but the bearing must be made true
with the adze."
Amend clause (17) to read as follows:
"(17) The bottom of the new rail and the bearing surface of the
tie shall be cleaned before the rail is laid."
Amend clause (18) by adding thereto, at the end, the words, "if
necessary."
Amend clause (20) and (22) by substituting the term "compromise
splices" for the terms "step chairs" and "offset splices."
Amend clause (22) further by striking out the last sentence.
Amend clause (25) to read as follows :
"(25) Rails for curves of 4 degrees and over should be curved
before being laid. In curving or straightening rails, a rail bender must
be used."
1079
1080 AMENDMENTS TO COMMITTEE REPORTS.
Amend clause (26) to read as follows:
"(26) When picking up joints or other low places, the general level
of the track must not be disturbed."
IRON AND STEEL STRUCTURES.
CFcr Report, see pp. 81-88; discussion, pp. 934-945.)
Amend the "Specifications for Erection of .Steel Railway Bridges" by
emitting clauses 20 and 21, and renumbering clause 22 to read No. 20.
BALLAST.
(For Report, see pp. 95-300; discussion, pp. 949. 950.)
Add to conclusion on page 97, regarding depth of ballast, the words
"gravel or," at the end of the fourth line.
TRACK.
(For Report, see pp. 37T-3S6; discussion, pp. 965-9S0.)
Amend conclusion 3 on page 374 to read as follows :
"(3) That for all new work, the Committee's recommendations
as to lengths of switches and numbers of frogs be adopted."
Amend clause relating to "Stops and Hold-downs," at top of page
379, to read "spring rail," in the first line, instead of "wing rail."
Amend Table I, page 381, third line, under A. B., to read "7 ft." in-
stead of "5 ft."
WATER SERVICE.
(For Report, see pp. 401-428; discussion, pp. 983-988.)
Amend by changing title of Specifications, on page 417. to read as
follows : "General Specifications for Steel Water and Oil Tanks."
Amend clauses 1 and 2 to read as follows :
"1. Scope of Specifications. These specifications are intended for
steel tanks requiring plates not more than -Hs i"- thick."
Change the numbers of the succeeding clauses, in consequence of
consolidating clauses 1 and 2.
Amend the fourth paragraph of clause 3, page 418, to read as follows :
"2. Quality of Metal. The metal in these tanks shall be open-hearth
steel. The steel shall conform in physical and chemical properties to the
specifications of this Association for steel bridges."
Amend clause 13, page 419, to read as follows :
"12. Tank Support. If the tank is supported on a steel sub-
structure, the latter shall conform to the specifications of this Association
for the manufacture and erection of steel bridges, except that allowance
shall be made for wind pressure, but not for impact."
ELECTRICITY.
(For Report, see *y\ 509-558; discussion, pp. 998-1016.)
Amend clause 10 of the Specifications for Overhead Crossings of
Electric Light and Power Lines, page 512, to read as follows :
AMENDMENTS TO COMMITTEE REPORTS. 1081
Substitute the word "possible," in the third line, for the word "prac-
ticable."
Amend clause 13, page 513, by omitting the second line in the table,
reading, "Exceeding 10,000 volts, etc."
Amend clause 24, page 514, by omitting the words "if such notifica-
tion is not given, the company crossed shall be furnished with certified
reports of shop inspection of material and workmanship made by a
properly qualified inspector."
Amend clause 29, pp. 514 and 515, to read as follows:
"29. Insulators, pins and conductor attachments shall be designed
to withstand, with the designated factor of safety, the tension in the
conductors under the maximum loading."
Amend clause 31, by omitting the words "the most unfavorable
condition," on the first and second lines.
Amend clause 32, page 515, to read as follows:
"32. Crossarms shall be designed to withstand the loading specified
in paragraph 30, combined with the unbalanced tension of the one wire
broken at the pin furthest from the pole."
Amend clause 34, page 515, to read as follows:
"34. The ultimate unit stress divided by the allowable unit stress
shall be not less than the following, etc."
Amend the "Note" to read : "The use of treated wooden poles and
crossarms is recommended," etc.
Amend clause 45, page 517, by omitting the last sentence, beginning
with the word "Pins."
Amend clause 49, page 517, by omitting the words, "of approved
species," in the first and second lines.
Amend clause 51, page 517, by omitting the words, "open-hearth,"
in the first line.
Amend clause 55, page 517, by changing the figures "150," on the
first line, to read "180," and the figures "180," on the last line, to read
"220."
Amend clause 60, on page 518, by adding the following clause in
the second line, after the word "earth (calculated at 30 degrees from the
vertical)."
Amend clause 61, page 518, to read as follows:
"61. The top of the concrete foundation, or casing, shall be not
less than 6 in. above the surface of the ground, nor less than 1 ft. above
extreme high water."
RAIL.
(For Report, see pp. 559-862; discussion, pp. 1017-1038.)
Amend clause 29, page 570, to read as follows :
"29. Payment. Rails accepted will be paid for according to actual
weights."
WOOD PRESERVATION.
(For Report, see pp. 863-872; discussion, pp. 1039-1051.)
Amend clause (3), page 864, by substituting the word "beech" for
the word "beeches," in the second line ; also, by substituting the word
"heartwood" for the word "hardwood."
1082 AMENDMENTS TO COMMITTEE REPORTS.
Amend the "Specifications for Creosote Oil," on pp. 865-6, as fol-
lows : Transpose the words "including coal gas tar or coke oven tar,*'
in the fourth line of the three specifications to follow the word "tar," in
the third line of each specification.
BUILDINGS.
(if or Report, see pp. 885-899; discussion, p. 1054.)
Amend diagram on page 863, Fig. 4, top line, to read "Side Flash-
ing," instead of "Head Flashing." Also, change heading on Fig. 2-10
to read "Continuous Head Flashing" instead of "Continuous Foot Flashy
'trig."
UNIFORM GENERAL CONTRACT FORMS.
(For Report, see po. 907-916; discussion, pp. 1059-1076.)
Amend clause 29, pp. 914-5, by omitting the words "previous to the
doing of the work or the furnishing of material," in the eighth line of
the second paragraph, and the words "after receiving the written authority
therefor," in the second line of the third paragraph.
MONOGRAPHS.
THE DESIGN OF RAILWAY BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
(Bulletin 140.)
By J. H. Prior, Assistant Engineer, Engineering Department Chicago,
Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway.
INTRODUCTORY.
Approximations from available statistics show that some $60,000,000
are at present invested in bridge abutments, and as this figure is being
increased each year by the value of new work, these structures can be
said to have an importance which warrants a fairly extended examination
of the present art of their design.
The following paper gives the result of an investigation ordered
by Mr. C. F. Loweth, Chief Engineer of the Chicago, Milwaukee & St.
Paul Railway, and made by the writer.
A railway bridge abutment is ordinarily a masonry structure, such
as is shown in Fig. 1, which gives vertical support to one end of a
steel span and gives whatever lateral support to the embankment "A,"
adjoining, is necessary to prevent the embankment from slipping into
the stream.
IHSiHH^HH^HHi
♦•. - -Iff ^ ■
^^H IMIIIl)
^■■■B? Z^tk
'"^H.itfcrf ^$1 *W*~mW"19l**\WPl!*'~' "
*>' ■■ "fc^ * *' '
Fig. 1 — Plain Concrete Wing Abutment, Type B:!
1085
1086
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
The most common type, Fig. i, has a cross-section similar to that
shown in Fig. 2, in which "a" is the bridge seat, consisting of a horizontal
surface carrying the steel span ; "b" is the back wall which supports the
embankment and prevents its spilling forward on the bridge seat; the
base "e" of the back wall "b" being made of such width as will make the
back wall stable against overturning on account of the lateral pressure
"R-i" of the earth; "c" is the main body of the neatwork, and must
have sufficient base "f" so that it will also be stable against overturning
from the lateral pressure of the earthwork "R-2 ;" "d" is the footing,
which must have a base "g" large enough to carry all the vertical loads,
and offset "h" large enough to keep the pressure at the toe of the footing
"R-3" within the allowable limit.
Fig. 2
Plan
Wincj Abutment
Fig. 5
The three principal types of abutments are the wing abutment, Fig.
3 ; U abutment, Fig. 4 ; and T abutment, Fig. 5. These three types, which
are the oldest as well as the most important, were developed when stone
masonry was the only material available to the designer.
In the wing abutment, Fig. 3 and Fig. 1, the span is supported on
the bridge seat '"a," and the wings "b" keep the embankment from slip-
ping into the stream. In the U abutment, Fig. 4 and Fig. 6, the span is
supported on the bridge seat "a," and the wings "b" are made parallel
to the track, thus giving the lateral support to the embankment which is
required to extend the embankment to the bridge seat. In the T abut-
ment, Fig. 5, the span is carried on the bridge seat "a" and the floor is
supported directly back of the bridge seat by the stem "b" of the abut-
ment, which carries the track back to a point where the embankment is
of sufficient height to support it.
Some of these older types, which were best adapted to stone, masonry,
have exerted considerable influence in later designs executed in the newer
materials of plain concrete and reinforced concrete, often in situations
where the old design was poorly adapted to the newer material.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1087
ABUTMENTS BUILT OF STONE MASONRY.
The wing abutment, Fig. 3; U abutment, Fig. 4; and T abutment,
Fig. 5, are referred to as type Ai, type A2, and type A3, respectively,
when constructed of stone masonry. As railway structures, some of these
t)pes are rapidly becoming obsolete, but as they are the prototypes of all
present designs and exerted considerable influence on later designs exe-
cuted in different material, they are given some mention.
E le vat/ on
Plan
U-A butment
Fis-
4-
p — n
Fa
£ le vat ion
3-
Plan
T- Abutment
Fig. 5
The wing abutment of stone masonry, type Ai, is often found to be
of such a design that the section of the abutment along the center line
of track is about as shown in Fig. 8. This might have been a creditable
design in the day in which it was made, but at present it is not much
of an exaggeration to say that this cross-section represents everything
that an abutment should not be. The batter on the front of this abutment
is slight, and the bridge seat is thus set so far forward over the footings
that the resultant of the vertical loads and lateral pressure of the earth-
work is located so near the front edge of the footings that the pressure
on toe is excessive for ordinary foundations. Without any increase of
material in the cross-section, this cross-section can be revised to that
shown in Fig. 9, with reduction in the toe pressure, as shown in the figures,
from 7l/2 tons to 4.07 tons per square foot, or about 45 per cent reduction.
While the cross-section is not increased in area, the change from Fig.
8 to Fig. 9 is accompanied by a greater cost, on account of the increase
in the length of the span, due to moving bearing from the point P,
in Fig. 8, to the point P-2 in Fig. 9. This would amount to an increase
in the length of the span of 5 ft. and an additional cost of $250.00, which
is only 5 per cent, additional cost for one abutment. Although this
increase in the cost of the steelwork incident to changing the outline
1088
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
of the cross-section is a small percentage, it probably accounts for the
nearly vertical front faces of the abutments, and the bridge seats located
near the front of the footings in the design of many old abutments, which
can be found in every railway office. The cross-section, Fig. 8, is taken
from the details of an abutment dated 1887.
Fig. 6 — Stone Masonry U Abutment, Type A2.
The U abutments of stone masonry, type A2, Fig. 4 and Fig. 6, have
a section as shown in Fig. 10, which is a cross-section at right angles to
track along the line "dd" of Fig. 4. In this abutment the side walls "a,"
which retain the fill "f," are usually built with a base thickness "e" equal
to 0.4 of the height "h." For an abutment 14 ft. in width, the backs
of the two side walls "a" would intersect at the point "b" when "h"
was equal or greater than 17.5 ft. Thus an abutment built of this design
would be a solid mass of masonry below the point "b," as shown in
Fig. 10. For this reason they show only small economy over the wing and
T abutments for heights from 12 ft. to 24 ft., as illustrated in Fig. 11.
In Fig. 11 the cubic yards of masonry in abutments, exclusive of
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1089
footings and copings for various heights, are platted as ordinafes with
the height from the top of footing to bottom of coping as abscissas.*
yggse of Pail ^
Fig.O
Defective Cross-Section
Abutment.
Fig. 9
Improved Cross-Section
Abutment.
The small economy of the neatwork of U abutments, shown in Fig.
ii, is lost if the same slope of embankment of ilA to i, which was used
in determining the length of the wing walls of the wing abutments, is
used to determine the length of the side wall of the U abutment.
The T abutment of stone masonry, type A3, Fig. 5, has a cross-section
at right angles to the track, as shown in Fig. 12. It can be seen from
Fig. 12 that the cross-section of the T abutment would resemble very
closely the cross-section of a U abutment if the height of the U abut-
ment was much greater than 17.5 ft., and an examination of Fig. 11 will
show that there is no great difference in volumes or cost between the
T abutment and the other two types.
There was not much uniformity in the design of the stone abutments,
and data concerning them are scarce and meager ; therefore, the curves
showing the volumes of these abutments in Fig. 11 can only be considered
approximate.
•Volumes taken from old standards of a western railway
shown in Baker's Masonry, pp. 357-363, Wiley & Sons. 1905.
company.
1090
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
e=.4-h
77777777777777777>,
\ffl
Cnos>s sect/or? et-ct at-
ria h 1~- cznc? I e. s to track.
r/3.
10
Fig.li
3' IO' 15' £0' B5' 50' 35' 40' 45' 50'
Height - top of 'foot/no to bottom of coo/r>c7
F/3 //
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS. 1091
ABUTMENTS OF CONCRETE, PLAIN AND REINFORCED.
In addition to conforming to the ordinary laws of structural design,
there are a number of properties which have an unusual importance in the
design of bridge abutments.
Properly designed abutments should have the following properties,
which may be called major requirements, because they affect the integrity
of the structure :
mi. The neatwork should be stable against overturning by revolving
on the line k, Fig. 2, at the intersection of the front face of the neatwork
and footing, and should also be safe against crushing on the same line.
m:. The abutments should be stable against sliding, either by the
neatwork sliding on the footing or the footing sliding upon the founda-
tion bed.
m3. The pressure of the toe of the footing upon the foundation
should not be excessive.
They should have the following properties, among others, which may
be called minor requirements :
ni. The abutments should protect the bank against scour.
n2. The abutments should prevent the embankment drainage from
washing away the shoulder of the bank adjacent to the back wall.
n3. The abutments should provide a joint which will support the
track in an easy and continuous manner from embankment to super-
structure.
n4. The abutment should be easily drained.
As by far the greater number of abutments being built are either
of plain or reinforced concrete, the term "Design of Bridge Abutments"
at present means the design of bridge abutments in concrete masonry.
All the abutments mentioned in the following, together with the
three abutments mentioned in the foregoing paragraphs, have been tabu-
lated in Appendix A for ease in reference.
In order to compare the properties and economy of the various types,
it was necessary to assume the same conditions in the design of all types.
The more important assumptions which were made for this purpose are
as follows :
(1) The height of the abutment is the distance "H" of Fig. 25
from the base of rail to the natural ground.
(2) Slope of fill 1V2 to 1.
(3) Slope of the natural ground away from stream or bridge opening
4 to 1.
Type Bi.
The plain concrete masonry abutment without reinforcement in the
back wall, type Bi, is shown in Fig. 13.
As this abutment is designed without steel reinforcement of any
kind, its design is made in a similar manner to the wing abutment of
stone masonry, type Ai, previously described. The cross-section of the
1092
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
Plan
-Base, of Rail
L.L+EP. 4(>1,000
E P. only 556,00dfo4._
Max. load pe
i pile <f6 tons
C~ B a se of Rail
r^/qy 4^560 Total
Inaction
Section "A "on 5ection"B"on 5ection"C"
S of Track. <£ of Track.
Type 3/ Plain Concrete Wing Abutment
with Plain Concrete Backwcr/I
Fia. 15
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1093
abutment, marked "section B on center line of track in Fig. 13," is
determined about as follows :
The distance "h2," from the base of rail to the top of the bridge
seat "a,"' is determined by the depth required by the floor, girders and
bearings of the superstructure ; and in new work the abutment must
conform to these dimensions. The dimension "e," which is the width
of the back wall at its base, is taken as 4/10 "h:" if the lateral pressure of
the earthwork tending to overturn the back wall is alone considered, or
it is taken at 5/10 "hi" if a slight further provision is made for the
overturning action of frost in the bank. The width of the bridge seat
"m" is determined by the width required for the superstructure bearings
plus whatever distance "j" is required to keep the bearings back far
enough from the outer edge of the bridge seat to prevent the outside
corner of the bridge seat from being sheared off in a diagonal direction.
The position of the ground line and the character of the foundation
determine the distance "hi" from the base of rail to top of footing. If
the base of the neatwork "f" is made 4/10 of the distance "hi," the neat-
work is stable against overturning or crushing on the line "k," at the
lower front edge of the neatwork. The dimension "f" together with the
width of bridge seat "m" and thickness of back wall "e" having been
determined, we have the choice of setting the bridge seat and back wall
vertically over the rear edge of the footing, as shown in Fig. 13 and by the
full lines in Fig. 14, or we can locate the bridge seat and back wall nearer
the front of the footing, as shown by the dotted lines in Fig. 14, and
thus decrease the length of our superstructure at the expense of an
increased bearing on the toe of the foundation.
~, — j- - -Po5it/or? (a)
l 1
Position (7)
Fig. 14
The design of the cross-section entirely without reinforcement leaves
this type with two important defects. If the outline of the neatwork,
marked position 1, and shown by dotted lines in Fig. 14, gives excessive
toe pressure, it is desirable to alter the outline of the cross-section to
about that of position 2, shown by full lines in Fig. 14. The object in
1094 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
changing the outline from position i to position 2 is to move the point
of application of the forces "pi" and "p2," Fig. 13, toward the back of
the footing, thus moving the resultant "p5" also toward the back of the
footing, and consequently decreasing the pressure on the front edge of
the neatwork and the toe of the foundation. But in an abutment, in which
the back wall contains no reinforcement, these forces cannot be moved
toward the back of the footing by any great amount on account of the
large width "e" of the base of the back wall, which is made from .4
to .5 of "h2."
Fig. 15 shows an abutment, type B2, of the same height as the abut-
ment, type Bi, Fig. 13, except that the back wall "lb" is reinforced against
overturning by some }i in. by 14 ft. bars. The addition of these bars
permits the base "e" of the back wall "b" to be made 2 ft. 5 in. in width
instead of 4 ft. 10 in. in width in type Bi. This decreased width of
back wall base permits the point of application of the resultant of the loads
"pi" and "p2" to be moved an average distance of 6 in. toward the back of
the footings, by this means decreasing the pressure on the toe of the
footings from 3.7 tons to 3.2 tons pressure on natural foundation, at no
additional cost in the abutment, and at an additional cost of only $100
in the superstructure.
The other defect is due to the absence of bars in the foundation of
type Bi and is shown by a comparison of the cross-section of the abut-
ment marked "Section B on center line of track" in Fig. 13, with the
section "C" in the same figure.
In Section "B" the maximum load comes on the piles located nearest
to the toe of the footing. The load on each pile is determined by the
total number of piles and by their location with reference to the resultant
of all the loads on the abutment, marked "p5" in Fig. 13. If foundation
conditions were encountered which made it desirable to decrease the
maximum bearing on piles of 26 tons in Section "B," or to decrease the
total number of piles without increasing their loading, it could be ac-
complished by moving some of the piles, marked "q" m Section "B,"
forward to about the position shown on Section "C," thus increasing
the projection of the footing beyond the neatwork from 1 foot in Section
"B" to 2 feet in Section "C." To reinforce the cantilever beam "s-t"
against bending, some bars must be placed at the bottom of the footing,
crossing the section of maximum moment "r-s ;" but if it is required
to build the entire abutment without reinforcement, these bars cannot be
used, and instead the neatwork must be increased by changing the face
of the neatwork from the line "s-u'' to the line "v-w," thereby increasing
the volume of the neatwork by 16 yards and that of the footing by 5
yards.
Type B».
Abutment type B2, Figs. 15 and I5a , is similar to abutment type Bi,
Fig. 13, except that the two defects just described are remedied. The
defect first mentioned, which is the absence of bars in the back wall, is
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1095
\ f Base of Rail
Plan
/-Base of Rail
£5,560 Total
fe" Traction
Max. load per
pile, £5 tons
Sec tion "A "on
<£ of Track.
Section"B"on
<£ of Track.
Type Be Plain Concrete Wing Abutment
with R.ein forced Concrete B a ckwa/l
Fig. 15
1096
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
eliminated in Fig. 15 and the second defect, which is the absence of rein-
forcement in the footing, is eliminated in Fig. i5a . The saving in abut-
ment type B;, due to altering the cross-section from that shown in Fig.
15 to the one shown in Fig. i5a , is approximately $90.00.
The two abutments are similar in other respects so that all of the
following descriptions of the properties of abutment type B2 apply equally
to abutment type Bi.
/Base of Rail
Abutment Type E>z
Fig 15a
The abutment type B2, shown in Fig. 15, is a wing abutment built
practically of plain concrete masonry. This type is by far the most
widely used, and is an economical abutment for certain heights. The
position of the resultant of all the loads on the abutment "ps," and the
loading per pile, also entered in Fig. 15, show that this abutment has
the major requirements "mi" mentioned on page 9.
An examination of Section B also shows that the abutment satis-
fies the requirement called "m2," which states that the neatwork should
be stable against sliding on the footing, and the footing stable against
sliding on the foundation bed.
The angle of inclination of the resultant "ps" in Section B shows
that the horizontal component of the force which the abutment exerts
upon its foundation is 31 per cent, of the vertical component. This is
less than coefficient of friction of nearly all foundation beds, except, per-
haps, wet clay. The stability against sliding is assisted by the back fill
in front of the abutment and the pressure against the wing wails of that
portion of the bank which extends in front of the wing walls. This
abutment conforms to the minor requirement "m" to "n" page 9 in as
large a measure as any other type.
It is sometimes stated that a wing abutment affords greater pro-
tection to the bank against scour than any other type, but it can hardly
be said that the protection afforded by the abutment is complete. If
only the end of the bank be considered, as shown in the elevation of the
abutment in Fig. 15, the protection is complete, especially if the wing walls
are of such a length as to bring the top of the wing wall close to the
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
4£'-0"
109T
5/c/e. El evert Ion
<5'-5" 2
'-O" 3'
5"
1
1
1
h
*)
j
41
A
•T)
4
if
ii
^^
V
y
\J
1
\
W
[_
At.
?i '
i" S'-3i"
3'- 5i" /"-
\'-f
Plan
7'- 6
7-6"
Ha IF 5ecf/'on
"Ft - F) "
Ha IF Front
E I e v a f/on
Type. B5- Plain Concrete. "U " A butm en t- Fi lied
Fig. II
1098
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
ground. But, if the side of the bank be considered, as shown in Fig. 18,
it will often be found necessary to protect the toe of the bank by
rip-rap similar to that shown in the figure, and without this rip-rap
the protection afforded by the heavy wing walls at the end of the
bank is not far enough extended. Fig. 19 shows the situation where a
bank which has been washed away from behind a wing abutment has
been replaced and protected with rip-rap.
Fig. 18 — Toe of Embankment Protected by Rip-rap.
Abutments of this type do not cause the drainage water to wash
away the corner of the bank adjacent to the back wall at "x" on Fig.
15, but at the lower point "y" on the bank, Fig. 15, where the amount
of the drainage water is greater, there seems to be a tendency to wash
the portion of the bank adjacent to the end of the wing wall, and, therefore,
this point is often found protected by loose rip-rap, as shown in Fig. 20.
It is possible with this abutment to provide a joint between the bank
and superstructure which will support the track in as easy and continuous
a manner as any other abutment, especially if a ballasted floor is useds
as shown in Fig. 21.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1099
Fig. 19— Embankment Protected by Rip-rap After Washout.
Fig. 21— Track Rails and Ties Continued Over Ballast Floor Bridge.
1100
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
Fig. 20— Portion of Bank Adjacent to the End of Wingwall Protected
by Rip-rap.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS. 1101
Type B3.
The U abutment of plain concrete masonry, type B3, is shown in
Fig. 17. This abutment is designed substantially in the same manner
as the U abutment of stone masonry, type A2, page 6, except that the
side walls, C4, are made long enough to provide for an embankment slope
of 1 J/2 to I, as experience shows that the slopes at the end of the embank-
ment cannot be made much steeper than the side slopes of the same
embankment.
This lengthening of the side walls d of abutment B3 to take care of
the 1% to 1 embankment slopes, results in making the neatwork yardage
for abutment B3 greater than for abutment B2. This difference in yard-
age in the neatwork is overcome by the lower foundation costs of abut-
ment B3 so that the total cost of abutment B3 is somewhat less than
abutment B2 for heights over 23 feet, as shown in Fig. 45.
Type Be.
An examination of Section B, Fig. 15, shows that it is more difficult
to make provision in an abutment to resist the lateral forces "p3" and "P4"
tending to overturn the abutment than it is to take care of the vertical
loads "px" and "p2."
The lateral forces are exceeded in magnitude by the vertical forces,
but the vertical forces are directly opposed by the equal and opposite
reaction on the foundation, whereas no such equal and opposite reaction
can be placed on the line "p3" continued, which shows the direction and
location of the lateral pressure of the earthwork. As a consequence it
would seem that a considerable economy could be effected in a design
in which the lateral forces "p3" and "p*" were eliminated or greatly dimin-
ished. In abutments B5, Fig. 22 ; B0, Fig. 23 ; B7, Fig. 24 ; and B«, Fig.
25, little provision is made for resisting the lateral pressure of the earth-
work. Instead, provision is made for diminishing the lateral pressure
by omitting the wings and allowing the bank to spill around in front of
the abutments.
Abutment type B5, Fig. 22, consists, as shown in the elevation and
Section B, of two short piers, which carry a beam "c-i," the top of which
forms the bridge seat "a." The earthwork is kept off the bridge seat
by the back wall "bi" and the side walls "b2." The bank is permitted to
run around in front of the abutment to the point "z" where the natural
slope of the fill intersects the ground line.
If an abutment type B5 and an abutment type Bi were so located
as to have their bridge seats in the same position, the abutment B5 would
give a smaller waterway than the abutment type Bi by the distance
from "z" to "zi" in Fig. 22, to which the fill extends in front of the
abutment. In order to get the abutment B5 on the same basis for com-
parison as the other abutments, it is necessary to add to the cost of abut-
ment Bs the cost of extending the superstructure so as to permit the
location of the abutment to be moved from "z" to "zi." As shown in
1102
9'-0"
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
5'-0" 9-0"
<H>-<H£-
" e'-o"/'-t "
zxx>-<>
-SKHMB-
<p cp <p cp
/■Bcfse of Rail-
Level
CO
oy^k /
<^i> ^*0ȴ\ i
mwhjimia.
^r*°- z,
l&
-Natural Grounc/
Pile, Plan
Location Diaaram of Abutments
"' I5-0"- 6"ctrs.
L.L, Thru5t
b£,000 Lbs.
Ecrrth Thrust
5L>, 500 Lb &.
Without Earth
n Front
Without Tract/on \
967,000 Lbs.
Section "B"on <£ o-f 7~rack.
Type. B$- Plain Concrete. Pier Abutment
Fig. £2
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1103
t'-j', 9® £'- & '* SS '- 6 "
yBase of Rail- Level -Tanc?ent
\ L l Thru 5 r
^7G.500 Lbs
£44 000 Lbs
Plan
Without Tr£3ctior>\
/ 105 OOO L bs
1077 950 Lbs
Section "B" on <£ o-f Trcrck.
Type- Bfr-Plain Concrete Pier Abutment
FlQ. 2 5
1104
t-
:\
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
15-0"
6'-<?"
<> <±> c> <±> <t> ct>
6'-0"
0990999
^!6
fBase of Rail- Level - Tangent
^Natural C round
Location Diagram of A butments
Half Elevation
Rein force ment
not Shown
Z * 5-0" Dowels
I'O" Cfrs.
Half Section
thru Backwa//
Section "A "<at
4l of Tracks
E& o"
Tract/on
4 5.560Lbs
<£ Bearlna
Plan
£arth Thrust
I &.OOO Lbs.
Without Earth
in Fron t
Without Traction
3 75,000 Lbs
Earth thrust
on stale, ex-
tension s or
back wall
30,400 lbs.
L.L. Thru st
73, OOO Lbs
E_arth Thru si
1 4c. OOO Lbs.
355,000 Lbs
Section "B" Thru Co unterfort
Type. 37 - Con crete. Pier Abutment
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
/5'-0"
1105
6" 6'-0'
o 6 6 o cb cb o
6'-0"/'-h
<M)~0 6 0 (H>
(p 9 $ () Q Q tfr
/Base of /?ail- Level - Tangent
1 Natural Ground
Location Dicfaram of A butmen
All bars
footings
Batter £i' "to 1-0"
Half Elevation He* if Section
Reinforcement thru Backwcr//
not Sho/vn
o"
Sect/ on "A" art
<t of Tr& c k^
SI VI
3> -
frcfct/on at
4 5, 560 Lbs
f<£ B ear ma
Earth thrust
on s/de. e.x-
ten s/ons of
back, rva //
5 0, &00 Lbs
L.L. Thrust
45,000 Lbs.
Earth Thrust
47, SOO Lbs.
With Traction
595,000 Lbs
Without Traction
5&IOOO Lbs
Plan
Sec tion " B "at <£ of Track.
Type B & - Cone r&te. Pocket A hutment
Fin. £0
1106 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
Fig. 43b, this element of cost is an important item, amounting to 59 per
cent, of the total.
Type B8.
Abutment type B6, Fig. 23, is similar to abutment type Bs, Fig. 22,
except that the beam "ci" in abutment B5 is replaced by a pier "c" in
abutment B0. The side walls "b" of abutment B5 are revolved 900 and
form a continuation of the back wall "hi" in abutment B8. The abutment
possesses no special features not shown on the drawing.
Type B7.
Abutment B7, Fig. 24. is similar to abutment B6, Fig. 23, except
that reinforced concrete has been substituted for plain concrete at ever}
point where the change seemed to promise a saving.
Type B8.
Abutment Bs, Fig. 25, is in turn similar to abutment B-, Fig. 24, ex-
cept that instead of carrying the neatwork down to the natural ground,
the neatwork has been made only deep enough to distribute the loads
from the superstructure and to provide a bearing on the tops of the piles.
The concrete of abutment Bs consists of a shallow concrete beam,
the upper side of which forms the bridge seat "a" (shown in Section
B), the lower side resting on a pile foundation.
On account of the natural slope which was assumed in these com-
parisons, the piles do not extend out of the ground and into the bank
for as great a distance as they would if the ground were level along the
line "z"-"zi," Fig. 25, and therefore give a more stable support than
if the ground line had been assumed level. On the whole the conditions
assumed were rather favorable to this type of abutment. As the piles
in this abutment are above the ground water line, they must be creosoted,
and concrete or creosoted piles have been figured in the estimate. The
piles have been shown battered longitudinally to add to the width of
the base of the foundation and its stability, and it is thought that this
batter is not a difficult thing to secure from a construction standpoint.
Experience with abutments similar to type Bs, but with vertical piles,
shows that there is sometimes a tendency for the bank to crowd the
abutment forward against the steel spans. The battered piles, shown in
Fig. 25, will partly remedy this defect. After having made this pro-
vision there is still, however, a tendency to crowd and two additional
precautions must be taken. First, the abutment must receive somewhat
more than the usual attention from inspectors. Second, it should be
made to support only the expansion bearing for the girder in order
to prevent any movement in the abutment producing undue stresses in the
adjacent girder span.
It was originally intended that the abutments Bi to Bs should only
include abutments built throughout of plain concrete, except for a small
amount of reinforcement in the back wall, footings, or other places where
tension stresses were high. All of the foregoing abutments, except B7
and B8) conform to this classification. Abutments B7 and Be, however,
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1107
resemble abutments BB and B8 in the feature of having the fill extend
forward from the abutment at its natural slope without restraint. They
were, therefore, included in what were termed the group of plain con-
crete abutments, although structurally they should be classed with the
reinforced concrete abutments, of which a description follows.
Type Ci.
The reinforced concrete wing abutment type d, shown in Fig. 26,
is similar to the abutment type B2 of Fig. 15, except that it is constructed
of reinforced concrete instead of plain concrete. Commencing at the
bottom, abutment G consists : first, of a pile foundation ; second, of a
deep footing slab "d," which distributes the vertical loads and furnishes
a means of anchorage. Resting on slab "d," as shown in Section A-A,
is a curtain wall "c2" which gives lateral support to the earth. The cur-
tain wall is prevented from being tipped outward by the buttresses "c3,"
which are anchored to the slab "d." If the abutment is properly pro-
portioned, the curtain wall "c2" could not be pushed outward by the
lateral pressure of the earthwork without carrying with it the buttresses
"c3" and without lifting the slab "d" from the pile foundations and also
lifting the entire weight of the earth which rests vertically on the
slab "d."
At the front of the abutment, the curtain wall "c2" is given a hori-
zontal offset "ci" as shown in Section E-E to provide for the bridge seat
"a." The curtain wall is carried up vertically from the bridge seat "a, '
forming the back wall "b" shown in the same section.
figse of Rail-^, y
Fi3- lG
a
The abutment shown in Fig. 26 has many of the properties of abut-
ment type B2 but has no particular advantage over it; the introduction
of buttresses not decreasing the cost of neatwork and the provisions for
anchoring buttresses to the footings greatly increasing the cost of foot-
ings for fills above 20 ft. Fig. 26 does not, however, show the best
design that can be made of reinforced concrete wing abutment. It
contains the two defects of the bridge seat set too far forward and
footings with insufficient projection in front of the neatwork, referred
to in pp. 11 and 12, in discussion of type Bi.
1108 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
31'- 9" 7>. 7-9", 7'- 9V7" 3/ -9"
Half P Ian of Footing 5
Il'-O" l'-9"/-3'-0"
Half Plan
Re sultan
£.100,000
I "3\ars
'540,500 Lt>5 Total Span Load
^4-5,560 Lbs Total ii"Bars
Tractive Force c3
All vert and nor bars
in counter fort s C3
and curtain wa/ls Cz
j'un/ess otherwise noted
d-0"Ctrs 5-l£"Bar3
d/4-6'\ <i"Bars 91'Ctrs
/3'-0" Max ioaa per
pile cl tons
d-^ 4lGl' [z"Bars 9"Ctrs.
5e Ction "A- A"
"5ection"E- E"near <£of Track
Type C, - Rem forced Concrete Counterfort Abutment
Fiac6
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1109
If these defects are corrected we have an improved abutment, such
as shown in the cross-section, Fig. 26a . This abutment, called type
Cia , is cheaper than that shown in Fig. 26 and costs considerably less
than type B2 for heights above 28 ft. ; estimates showing that it costs
about 10 per cent, less than type B2 for the 36 ft. height and 25 per
cent, less for the 50 ft. height which is outside the limits of our diagram.
If, in addition to the economies shown in Fig. 26a , the sections of
all walls and buttresses are reduced to the minimum which can be placed
by experienced workers under proper supervision, the economy of type
Cia over B2 is still further increased.
Type C2.
Abutment type C2, Fig. 27, is a U abutment of reinforced concrete.
It resembles the U abutment of plain concrete in external appearance.
Structurally, however, it is quite different.
It consists in plan of a rectangular box open at the top and at the
embankment end, which is filled with earth. The track is directly sup-
ported on the earth filling. The sides of the box "c*" are prevented
from being forced outward by the lateral pressure of the earth by ties
"c3" which connect the two opposite sides "c*." The front of the box
is the curtain wall "c2," which is a beam between the two side walls "C4,"
and restrains the lateral pressure of the earthwork in longitudinal
direction.
Commencing at the bottom, then, this abutment consists of foundation
"d," which supports the front curtain wall "c2" and the two side walls
"cu" The front curtain wall <lCj" and the two side walls "c4" form
three sides of a rectangle, the fourth side toward the enbankment re-
maining open. The front curtain wall "c2" is carried upward to the
point "a," where it is offset in horizontal direction, forming the beam
"ci," the upward surface of which is the bridge seat "a." From "ci"
the wall is carried upward forming the back wall "b." The ends of
beam "ci" rest on the side walls "o," or on an enlargement thereof "c5,"
and the front edge of the beam "ci" rests upon the front curtain wall "c2."
It is apparent that this type should result in considerable saving in con-
crete over the same type constructed in plain concrete, which is called "B3."
If the design C2, Fig. 27, were to be constructed of plain concrete,
the side walls "c" would have to be made about as shown by the dotted
lines "e— e" in order to make them stable against overturning.
Considering only the upper portion of the side walls "C4," where
the economy of introducing the tie is least apparent, a comparison of
restraining the side wall against overturning by means of a tie or by
means of its own weight is shown in Fig. 28. One square inch of metal
is imbedded in the rectangular concrete tie "h i f g/' and carries a load
of 13,500 pounds at the assumed unit stresses, and if this tie is 5 ft. above
the corner "k" on which the side wall tends to rotate, the effective moment
against overturning furnished by the tie is 67,500 ft. lbs.
Let "pi" represent the weight of the concrete in the triangle "b a c."
1110
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
4-Z-O" B~~-
Pomfx-
45,5601 1 to
I Un i -form Bear-mc
B ~~~ I 75 Tons per 5c?. Ft
"beef ion erf <£_ of Trcrctc
'' 6 \\i,f°i, ' 5'~6 ",|, 5 'g " ^;°iffJ''6 "
H^ Point
9'0"
9--0"
\5"> IZ"
^Affeep- ho
Half Section i Half Elevation
"B - B " I
Half 5ect/on\Hcfi f Plan
"A- A" I
Type Cg- Rein forced Con crete "U '" a burment
filled- Long Side War II $
F,3. 21
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1111
Let "m" be the center of gravity of the triangle "b a c." Assume the
lever arm of the force "px" to be equal to the lever arm of the force "p2,"
which represents the stress in the tie bar. If the sketch is representative,
it will take 3.38 yds. of concrete at 4,000 lbs. per cu. yd. to produce the
same resisting moment by means of the force of gravity as is produced
by the tie rod "p2," which ties the two walls together.
Comparing the quantities in the foregoing paragraphs, we have :
(1) Gravity retaining wall:
3.38 yds. of concrete for one side wall.
6.76 yds. of concrete for two side walls.
6.76 yds. at $5.00 per cu. yd. (material, mixing and placing
same) $33.80
(2) For the thin wall with steel tie :
15 linear ft. of one inch square steel bar, at 3.4 lbs. per linear
ft =51.1 lbs.
51. 1 lbs. at zl/2 cents per lb $ 1.78
15 cu. ft. of concrete = .56 yards.
.56 cu. yds. at $10.00 per cu. yd 5-6°'
$7-38
The above approximate comparison of a small part of the C2 abut-
ment with the corresponding part of Br. abutment gives a ratio between
the parts compared, of 21 per cent.
Fig.
£&
As shown in Fig. 44 the actual cost of the type C2 abutment is
about 75 per cent, of the B3 abutment. The foregoing comparison is.
therefore, only a rough analogy. It illustrates, however, in a general
way the source of economy of abutment type C2.
This abutment type C2 easily satisfies the requirements of "nil" and
"m?." against overturning, of page 9. The width of footings, measured
along the center line of track, which is effective against overturning of
type B2, is 13 ft. 9 in. That of type Ci is 18 ft. The corresponding
dimension on abutment C2 is the distance from the front to back of
abutment, or 45 ft.
It is true that the wing walls of abutments B2 and Ci protect, perhaps,
five times as much of the embankment against scour as does abutment C-,
1112 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
but if we compare the protection afforded by either type B2 or C2 with
the total amount of bank protection required, the difference between the
two abutments in this respect is not much. One of the defects of this
abutment is that practically all of the surface water from the track for
the entire length of abutment must drain past the point "x," Figs. 27
and 29. As the amount of water is considerable it tends to wash away
the embankment at the end of the wing wall, as shown in Fig. 29. The
washing of the bank at this point is, of course, an important matter, as
the material is washed away at a point not far from the end of the
track ties and requires much more attention than if the material was
washed away at the end of the wing wall, as shown in Fig. 20.
In Fig. 30 is shown an abutment of an entirely different structure,
but which is exactly the same as abutment C2, as far as drainage is con-
cerned. Fig. 30 shows the loose rock and boards necessary to maintain
the shoulder of the bank on account of drainage. Drainage openings
are provided in the. front and side walls of abutments C- ; but even with
this provision it is not as easy to drain as type B2 or G, unless it is
rilled with porous material.
Type C3.
In Fig. 31 abutment type C2 is shown in dotted lines and is shown
to be 42 ft. in length. If the approach span is lengthened, the face of
the abutment can be moved from "a" to "b," thus shortening the abut-
ment by 16 ft. This shortened abutment, which is shown in full lines,
is called type G, and is similar in every way to type C2 except that it
requires a longer approach span and that it permits the fill to spill around
the front of the abutment.
Type G.
Abutment type G, Fig. 32, and all of the abutments which follow
have one feature differing from any of the abutments previously mentioned.
Abutments G, C5, Co and C7 have the common feature of carrying the
track directly on the body of the abutment over the entire length of the
abutment instead of on the bank. Commencing at the top, abutment type
G, Fig. 32, consists of a slab "a;" resting on the side walls "c4," the
side walls in turn resting on the footings "d." The side walls "d" are
tied together in front by the curtain wall "c2;" this curtain wall being
offset to form the bridge seat "a" and the back Avail "b" in a manner
similar to that used in abutment type C2. The curtain wall "c2" of
abutment G is not required to carry any of the lateral pressure of the
earthwork, however, as in this abutment the earth is allowed to spill
into the interior of the abutment and around on the outside, assuming-
its natural slope from "x" to "z," here assumed at ilA to 1. The side
walls "a" are tied together by the ties "c;."
To save material and to equalize the pressure of the earthwork on
both sides of the side walls "cj," two large openings "cc" are made
in the walls. The portion of the side wall remaining between the open-
ings "c,/' forms a column ; and the portion of the side walls above the
openings forms a beam between columns. A portion of the completed
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1113
1114
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
abutment type d having one panel only, is shown in Fig. 33. The open-
ings are shown circular on top, although structurally they could have been
as easily made square.
Abutment €< has an advantage over abutment C> in that its founda-
tion loads are less, due to the fact that the interior of the abutment is
kl
ig'wv.." .qgifr-gH" ' r-r. —
& £ :*jjj$
SflHilMmf'- v
V ■
Ak ]*> ^tea1- a ^A
Fig. 30 — Loose Rock and Boards Required to Maintain the Shoulder
of the Bank Against Drainage Water.
4-e-o"
^Abutment ^
C5 !
*- , \ f Abutment
A butment Type C5 shown in fu/l //res.
Abutment Type C> shown in dotted //nes.
Type C3 Re in Forced Concrete. "U"
Abutment- Filled- Short _ 3idewafl5
F/tj.5/
only partially filled with earth. The side walls of C« are subjected to
practically no unbalanced lateral pressure of the earthwork. It has
the disadvantage that it requires a considerable amount of material for
the construction of the floor slab "a2," and as a consequence it does
not show much economy for low fills.
In Fig. 34 a completed abutment of this type with the fill in place is
shown. The embankment in Fig. 34 has an average slope along the face
of the side wall of about 1 to 1 instead of the slope 1V2 to 1 which
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1115
Poinf'X'l
Base of /?ail
v leep-ho'e
B- > Uniform Bearing
1 4 Ton 5 per 3a. Ft
Section at <£ o-f Track.
C\f a?r5v (f Stirrups/?)
j Bars)
f-
5'£'
Br
£c>f5
5^
?y
H
5'i
S5V\5
5'-0
y-o
9'-0"
13
Bars
9'-0"
•-O"
e Bars-
Section of Slab
9 '- O " , 9'-0"
Alpfe
All vertical bars
shown except m
the walls, are
Half Section .Half Elevation
"B - B "
Half Section\Ha/f Plan
"ft - A "
Type C^- Rein forced Concrete "U" Abutment- Co ve recY
Fiq. 3£
1116
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
u
w
[2h
'^ ;'"'"^- r
IP^^HH^BHJjffiHBHHi
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1117
was used in the design in Fig. 32. The quantities for abutment type d
were all figured on a 1/2 to 1 slope, so that at a later point when we
compare the costs of various types it is not necessary to make allowance
for rip-rap used with type Ci, Fig. 34. Fig. 35 is a general view of the
bridge in which a type C4 abutment was used at each end. The abutment
on the left-hand side is the same abutment which is shown in Fig. 34.
As there are practically no unbalanced lateral earthwork pressures
in action against abutment G, no provision need be made to make it
conform to the requirements "mi," "m2" and "m3" on page 9. This abut-
ment gives, perhaps, slightly less protection to the embankment against
Fig. 34 — Completed Abutment, Type d, Fill in Place.
scour than abutment C2, but it will probably not wash away at the
shoulder of the embankment at "x," as drainage for the top of the
abutment is provided through holes in the sides of the floor slabs. It
is, of course, easily drained, and if a ballasted deck is used on the girder,
as shown in Fig. 35, it provides a continuous support of the same char-
acter for the track on the abutment and on the superstructure, as shown
in Fig. 36. The ties in the foreground, Fig. 36, are the ties of the pile
trestle which have not yet been removed, the trestle having just been
replaced by an earth embankment.
Type Ca.
Abutment type G, Fig. 37 and Fig. 38, consists in general of six verti-
cal posts "ci" and "c5)" which support the slab "a2." At the bottom they
1118
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
are tied together by the footings "di" and "d2." The footings "d," and
"d2" act partly as foundation beams and partly as ties, which hold the
bottoms of columns in their true relative position and afford them sup-
port against any unbalanced lateral pressure of the earthwork.
pIG. 35_Span Supported on Type C< Abutments.
pIG 36 — Track Supported on Slabs of Type d Abutment.
Ties in the Foreground are the Ties of the Pile Trestle Which Have
Not Been Removed, the Trestle Having Just Been
Replaced by an Embankment.
A/ote. "A"
Dotted line. incJ. /crates
position of foot/ng for
which cfuan titi e s were
frjurec/.
5 lab and beam
same a5 in
first bay
4b,560 Lbs To tat
Tractive. Force
l4'-\&"
]
-5'%0,000 Lbs. Total Span Load
l-§"*?d'-0"{St/rrups /5-e" {Bav<e of Rail
Part 5ec f/on"/Q- A
53-6"
r-~B
U u.-l U(j/ It U1 U
Front Ele vcff/on
uuu u #
Column reinforcement not shown in efevat/on
5 ide, E fe,va fion
/4'-0"
Footing P/an
Sec fion "B-B"
Showing Bent "A"
Type, C 5 - Rein-Tor cect Cone rete Arch Abutment
Fig. 57
1120
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
At the top the cross beam c8 spans transversely between the posts a.
Two posts and the cross beam c3 form a single bent, such as the one
called "A" in Fig. 23.
At the top, also, longitudinal beam c6 spans longitudinally between the
bents "A." By this arrangement the slab a2 is supported on four sides, the
two ends of the slab resting on cross beams c3, and the two sides of the
slab are supported by longitudinal beam Ce.
At the front of the abutment the posts "c5" are made much heavier,
as the beam "c3" which connects them together at the top carries the
weight of the adjacent span of the superstructure, and also carries one
end of a slab "a2." The divisions mentioned are only those which have
Fig. 38 — Completed Type C5 Abutment.
to be made in order to execute the design ; the structure itself being
tied together by steel in all directions so as to resemble a monolith.
In service this abutment has all the advantages and disadvantages of
type d, which it resembles structurally in many respects. As it is
somewhat more open than type d, it drains itself a little better. A com-
pleted abutment of this type is shown in Fig. 38. The opposite side of
the same abutment after filling is shown in Fig. 39, and a general view
of a bridge having an abutment of this kind at each end is shown in
Fig. 40. The abutment at the right end of Fig. 40 is the same abutment
of which a nearer view is shown in Fig. 39. The rip-rap shown in Fig.
39 was due to the special requirement of the situation where this abut-
ment is built and would not ordinarily be required.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE A HUTMENTS.
1121
Abutment shown in Fig. 37 is the design of W. S. Lacher.*
The first abutment of this character of which the writer had knowl-
edge was built by the Illinois Central Railroad and photographed, but
never published.
Type C8.
A T abutment of reinforced concrete type Ca is shown in Fig. 41.
The stem of this abutment consists of a slab "a2," which is supported
longitudinally along its center line by the central wall of the stem "d."
The wall is carried vertically down to the spread footings "d."
Fig. 39 — Completed Abutment, Type C5, Fill in Place.
The floor "a2" with the wall "c*" are given lateral stability against
overturning by the front curtain wall "c2" and by the reinforcement on
both faces of the wall "c4," which extends directly into the footings.
The curtain wall "c2" is carried up to form the bridge seat "0" and the
back wall "b" is in the same manner as in the G abutments.
This abutment has the defect that it is not safe under a derailed
locomotive. The derailed locomotive produces in this structure much
greater stresses than in the other types.
If we increase the reinforcement to take care of the exceptional case
of a derailment, we need a quantity of steel nearly double that shown in
*A similar abutment, called Fig. 6, is described in the article by Wm.
M. Torrence in the "Engineering News," January 11, 1906. Also in the
"Engineering News," August 18, 1910, pp. 180 — "Abutments for the New
York State Barge Canal."
1122
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
the table, increasing the cost of reinforcing steel practically $400 and
filling the structure so full of bars that the cost of laying the concrete
would be largely increased.
Provision for derailment in this structure is, therefore, out of the
question, and its weakness under a derailment must stand a grave defect.
We can offer little additional information concerning type C6 and the
following type C-, other than that shown on the drawings. The ad-
vantages and defects of the several features of these abutments are the
same as the advantages and defects of the same features in the fore-
going abutments, which were described more fully.
Type Ct.
The trestle abutment type Cr, Fig. 42, in a general way is a con-
crete trestle of sufficient length to carry the track from the point "z,"
or from the end of the superstructure, to the point "x," where the bank
Fig. 40 — Bridge Terminated at Each End With Type Co Abutments.
has attained its full height. Commencing at the top, this abutment con-
sists of two standard U-shaped trestle slabs "a2" which contain the
ballast, which in turn supports the ties and rails: These slabs rest on
the neatwork of the bents "c" and "ct," which are ordinarily reinforced
concrete trestle bents with spread footings "d." To resist unbalanced
longitudinal pressure of the earthwork and also to add longitudinal
stability to the abutment, the struts "c3" are introduced between the
tops of the bents "c2" and "C4," and the struts "di" introduced between
the bottoms of the same bents. In addition to acting as struts these
members "c3" and "di" combine the three bents and the two spans into
two rigid quadrilaterals. The trestle bent "c2" at the front end of the
abutment is made considerably thicker than the bents "<u" in the bank
in order to leave room for the bridge seat "ai." In service this abut-
ment is much like C< and C5. Structurally it resembles C* more closely
in that the floor "a" is a separate member and can be placed after the
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
<£ '- O "
1123
/O'-O"
47-6"
Uniform Be. arm a I ^_ Tons per Sq Ft
E ' I e. vor t ion
14 - 6 "
y-
tz
15'- e"
9'-0"
5'-6"/'-
Bars IP" Ctry.s /'■(?" 5'-6"t ^ P
"^- ■ ' 1 T ■
Bar 5 6" Ctrs
fill bars -;" 5a
Half 5ect/on\Haif Front
" fit - A" | £ I e v a t / on
Foot i na Plan
Type. C h~ Rem forced C on c re t e "T"'A b u trnen +
F,3 4-,
1124
Point' 'Xl
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
4d'-0"
Lbs-
Uni-form Bearmcr /^ Tons per Sa f~f
E I e vcff i on
9'- 6
9 '-6'
5-6"
6'-0"
5-9" 4-6'
1-6'
4-6" 4'- 6"
9-6"
A// bars in piers
ornai I ' onqifudinal
struts^ ^"square.
9'- 6"
i"8ars l'-0"Ctrs
Half Section
"E> - A "
Ha IE E leva f ion
Her if
"B
Section
- B"
Ha/E Plan
Slabs Re moved
Type. C-[-Reinforceaf Concre-te.
Trestle Abutment
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1125
abutment has been built. The remaining portion of the abutment forms
a complete structure without the slab. The slab is only used to afford
direct vertical support to the track..
MEMORANDUM ON TOTAL COSTS OF VARIOUS TYPES.
Figs. 43a to 43g, on inserts, pp. 44-45, are tables which show the man-
ner in which the total estimated costs of the foregoing abutments were
made up.
Ficj.45
These tables should give dependable estimated costs, as the division
of the total costs into their elements has been carried as far as could
be conveniently done.
The tables show the quantities as well as the unit costs and make it
possible for the reader to substitute different unit costs for those shown,
where the conditions are such that the unit costs given in the table would
not apply. It is not believed, however, that any ordinary changes will
affect the relations between the totals.
Figs. 44 to 64 contain curves which compare the cost of the several
abutments for different heights and for different types. On Fig. 44 the
total cost of abutments are platted as ordinates to the heights platted
as abscissas. Each of the Figs. 46 to 5S, inclusive, shows the total cost
of one type and shows also the manner in which the cost of that type is
divided between neatwork, foundation, embankment, etc. In each figure
from 59 to 64 are platted curves showing a single element of cost in
all the abutments, Fig. 59 containing curves which compare the total
cost of neatwork of any type with the total cost of neatwork in any
other type, and Figs. 60 to 64, inclusive, contain similar curves for the
foundation, floor, embankment, additional length of superstructure and
falsework.
The total cost of the various types of concrete abutments are platted,
Fig. 44, the following being omitted :
Type Bi is omitted, except for the 28 ft. height, the design having
so many defects that it did not seem worth while to estimate its cost for
other heights.
Type B4, T abutment, is omitted because most of its properties can
be obtained from an examination of the figures and curves illustrating
Type B3.
Curves showing the cost of all the other types are platted.
1126 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
The objection most frequently made to abutments types C2 to Ct is
their high cost, especially, it is said, if constructed by men experienced
mostly in the construction of plain concrete work.
On account of this objection the principal unit costs for this type
were taken rather high, as it was believed that there was enough economy
in the design of some of these types to more than offset the highest unit
cost which could be reasonably selected. Examination of Fig. 44 will
show that this prediction was substantially correct.
In order to furnish information as to the cost of these abutments
if lower unit prices were selected, the curves shown in Fig. 44 have been
reproduced in Fig. 45. The total costs have been reduced, however,
so that Fig. 45 shows average low costs under ordinary circumstances,
which are about 37.5 per cent, less than those shown in Fig. 44.
In examining these cost curves the following should be noted :
Types Ce and Ct are untried, and unexpected weaknesses may develop
in their use.
C» does not take care of derailment.
B5, B8, B7, B3 or C- cannot be used where much scour is anticipated
or where the highwater is near the bridge seat, without the use of rip-rap,
whose cost has not been included.
It should be observed that the necessity of carrying the footings
further below the ground will make a proportionately greater increased cost
in types Bi to B7 than in types C» to C7.
The use of any type of superstructure which gives a less depth of
bridge seat below base of rail will mean a greater proportionate increase
in cost in types Bi to B7 and Ce than in types Ci to C5 and C7.
With these points in mind the cost curves permit the reader to draw
his own conclusions as to the relative economy of the various types in
different situations.
Type Ci is highest in cost of any abutment for heights over 21 ft.
As previously mentioned, this type is created by the substitution of rein-
forced concrete in a mediocre design intended for plain concrete, making
the least number of changes in the design which would permit the use
of the new material.
If this design is improved, as shown in Fig. 26a , its cost can be re-
duced by an amount which will make it of less cost than type B2, for
heights above 28 ft. If, as mentioned on page 27, advantage is taken of
other known refinements in design of abutments of this character, its
cost can be still further reduced.
The equality of cost shown for types B5, B8 and B7 is not accidental
but is due to the similarity of these types, and is explained by an examina-
tion of Figs. 59, 60, 62, 63 and 64, which show that not only the total
cost of these abutments is alike, but that the cost is proportioned in a
similar manner, in all abutments between neatwork, foundation, fill, addi-
tional length of superstructure and falsework.
For nearly all heights types C3, C8 and C7 are the lowest in cost of
those types in which the neatwork is carried to a sufficient depth to place
footings on the natural ground.
1127
Estimate of Quantities and Coats
Height
In Ft.
Item
Itatiotl
F o o t ; 1 n . n
Cu. Yds.
of Exca-
vation
Piles
Cu.Yds.
of Fill
False-
work
Change in
Length of
Bridge One
Abutment
FirBt
Total
Engng.A
Inold- Grand
entals Total
Cu. Yda.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Ste*!
Sq. Yds.
of Forma
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
h
13
Quant -
ities
Unit
Coet
60
$5.00
8300
2 70
39
121
$1.30
$145
31
85.00
$105
0
33
81.30
538
65
$1.50
$98
0
170
$0.35
$43
0
.71 ft.
$61.00
543
$771
.5*
838
$809
20
Quant -
ltles
Unit
Cost
160
$5.00
5800
370
it
220
81.20
8264
56
$5.00
$380
0
49
$1.30
$59
120
81.50
$180
34
$8.00
$373
600
$0.35
8150
0
3.79 ft.
$61.00
$170
$3134
Si
$109
$3393
Bl
28
Quanti-
ties
Unit
Cost
406
{5.00
82030
0
435
81.20
$510
103
$5.00
8515
0
63
81.20
$76
260
81.50
$390
71
88.00
$568
1500
$0.35
$375
$50
4.43 ft.
$61.00
$370
$47f>3
5*
5339
$5023
B3
28
Quant-
it les
Unit
Cost
387
85.00
81935
370
11
430
$1.30
$504
103
85.00
$510
0
60
$1.30
873
260
81.50
$390
64
$8.00
$513
1500
$0.25
$375
$50
6.04 ft.
$61.00
$368
$4735
5fi
$336
$4961
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
696
85.00
53480
370
11
638
$1.30
8754
143
85.00
$710
0
75
81.20
$90
400
$1.50
$600
108
$8.00
$864
3100
$0.25
$775
$50
8.38 ft.
$61.00
$511
$7843
. 5*
$393
$8335
B3
13
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
74
85.00
8370
0
135
81-30
8150
31
85.00
8155
0
0
60
$1.50
890
0
60
$0.25
815
$100
0
0
0
$880
si
844
$934
30
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
229
$5.00
$1145
0
285
81.20
$343
59
85.00
$395
0
0
115
$1.50
$173
0
250
80.25
863
$300
.85 ft.
$61.00
853
$3370
. 5*
$113
$3383
38
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
496"
$5.00
$3480
0
450
$1.20
$540
103
$5.00
8515
0
0
310
$1.50
$315
0
525
$0.25
$131
$300
1.53 ft.
$61.00
$93
$4374
Bit
$319
84593
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
Coat
880
$5.00
$4400
0
780
$1.30
$936
137
$5.00
$685
0
0
290
$1.50
8435
0
1075
$0.25
$269
$400
2.27 ft.
$61.00
$139
87364
si
$363
$7637
1127
Estimate of Quantities and Costs
Height
In Ft.
Item
Haatwork
F o o t i n e n
Cu. Yds.
of Exoa-
vat ion
Piles
Cu.Yds.
of Fill
Engng.4
Incid-
entals
Grand
Total
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yde.
of Forms
Cu. Yda'.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forme
False-
work
Length of
Bridge One
Abutment
B5
13
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
36
35.00
8130
540
$19
64
$1.30
$77
36
$5.00
$130
0
0
45
$1.50
$68
0
76
$0.25
$19
0
10 ft.
$61.00
$610
5$
$53
$1106
30
Quant-
it iee
Unit
Cost
52
$5.00
$360
540
$19
96
$1.30
$115
35
$5.00
$135
0
0
48
$1.50
$73
37
$8.00
$316
400
$0.35
$100
0
33 ft.
$61.00
$1340
$112
$2359
38
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
80
$5.00
$400
945
3i*
$33
134
$1.20
$161
35
$5.00
$135
0
0
46
$1.50
$69
32
$8.00
$356
960
$0.35
$340
$45
34 ft .
$61.00
$3075
$170
$3574
36
Quant -
itiee
Unit
Cost
103
$5.00
$515
945
$33
172
$1.30
$206
36
$5.00
$180
550
zy
$19
0
68
$1.50
$103
45
$8.00
$360
1860
$0.35
$465
$60
46 ft.
$61.00
$3800
5$
$237
$4977
h
13
Quant-
lties
Unit
Cost
33
$5.00
$160
435
$15
74
$1.30
$89
30
$5.00
$150
275
$10
0
50
$1.50
$75
0
70
$0.25
$18
0
7.6 ft.
$61.00
$460
5%
$49
$1036
30
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
58
$5.00
$290
480
zh
$17
103
$1.30
$124
24
$5.00
$130
0
0
45
$1.50
$68
28
$8.00
$224
400
$0.35
$100
0
19.6 ft.
$61.00
$1300
si
$107
$3350
38
Quant -
lties
Unit
Cost
97
$5.00
$485
480
$17
154
$1.20
$185
39
$5.00
$145
0
0
53
$1.50
$80
35
$8.00
$280
935
$0.35
$334
$45
31.6 ft.
$61.00
$1930
5%
$170
$3571
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
Coat
148
$5.00
$740
385
3**
813
200
51.20
$240
49
$5.00
$345
1090
z\t
$38
0
70
$1.50
$105
54
$8.00
$432
1800
$0.25
$450
$60
43.6 ft.
$61.00
$3660
5$
$349
$5333
1127
Estimate of Quantities and Costs
Height
in Ft .
Item
Neatwork
Foot 1 n e s
Cu. Yds.
of Exca-
vation
Piles
Cu.Yds.
of Fill
False-
work
Change in
Length of
Bridge One
Abutment
Engng.A
Incid-
entals
Grand
Total
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lb s • of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
Cu. Yds.
of Cono.
the. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
B7
12
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
27
85.50
$149
745
$36
71
$1.30
$85
15
$6.50
$98
73&
3if
$36
0
35
$1.50
$38
19
$8.00
$153
76
$0.25
$19
0
8.2 ft.
$61.00
$500
5f.
$55
$1148
20
Quant -
ities
Unit
Cost
45
85.50
$248
781
lit
$37
97
$1.20
$116
19
$6.50
$133
985
$34
0
32
$1.50
$48
37
$8.00
$316
420
$0.25
$105
0
30.2 ft.
$81.00
$1330
5$
$107
$2354
38
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
67
$5.50
$369
1050
$37
137
$1.30
$164
34
$6.50
$156
1040
$36
0
46
$1.50
$69
33
$8.00
$364
970
$0.25
$243
$45
33.3 ft.
$61.00
$1960
. 5*
$167
$3510
36
Quant -
ities
Unit
Cost
88
$5.50
$484
1310
lit
$43
174
$1.30
$309
$6.50
$189
1350
lit
$44
0
58
$1.50
$87
43
$8.00
$344
1900
$0.25
$475
$60
44.2 ft.
$61.00
$2700
5$
$333
$4866
B8
13
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
25
$6.50
$163
480
!*'
$17
65
$1.30
$78
15
$6.50
$98
610
lit
$31
0
37
$1.50
$41
19
$8.00
$153
76
$0.35
$19
0
8.2 ft.
$61.00
$500
555
$54
$1143
30
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
35
$6.50
$163
480
lit
$17
65
$1.20
$78
15
$6.50
$98
610
lit
$21
30
$1.30
$34
3
$1.50
$4
19
$8.00
$153
425
$0.25
$106
0
30.3 ft.
$61.00
$1330
5f»
$95
$1988
38
Quant -
Ities
Unit
Cost
25
$6.50
$163
480
$17
65
$1.30
$78
15
$6.50
$98
610
$31
31
$1.30
$36
0
31
$13.50
$363
1010
$0.25
$253
S45
33.2 ft.
$61.00
$1960
. 5*
$147
$3083
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
35
$6.50
5163
480
lit
$17
65
li.ao
$78
18
$6.50
$117
610
lit
$31
35
$1.30
$43
0
31
$15.00
$315
1975
$0.25
$494
$60
44.3 ft.
$61.00
$3700
5$
$300
$4307
Flo. 43c.
■
1127
Estimate
of Quant
ities and
Costs
Height
in Ft.
Item
N e
a t w o
r k
F o o t i n p
Cu.Yds.
of Exc.
Piles
Cu.Yds.
of Fill
Falne-
«ork
Engng.
and
Inoi-
Grand
Total
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
8q. Yds.
of Forms
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
cl
13
Quant -
itiee
Unit
Cost
38
$6.50
$247
680
$34
130
$1.20
$144
34
$6.50
$156
700
3i#
$25
32
$1.20
$38
79
$1.50
$119
0
171
$0.25
$43
0
$96
$893
30
Quant -
ities
Unit
Cost
100
$6.50
8650
5050
$177
316
$1.30
$379
45
$6.50
$393
2380
$83
48
$1.30
<>58
183
$1.50
273
0
630
$0.25
$158
0
i3<r
$349
$2330
38
Quant -
ities
Unit
Cost
183
$6.50
$1190
9950
$348
608
$1.30
$730
113
$6.50
$735
7754
zy.
$271
80
$1.30
$96
358
$1.50
$537
85
$8.00
$680
1703
$0.25
$436
0
13$
$603
$5615
36
Quant -
it ies
Unit
Coat
306
$6.50
$1989
16600
$581
1007
$1.30
$1208
176
$6.50
$1144
13070
3i#
$422
86
$1.30
$103
603
$1.50
$903
141
$8.00
$1138
3450
$0.35
$963
0
13$
$1001
$9341
C3
13
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
37
$6.50
$341
3440
$85
134
$1.30
$161
10
$5.00
$50
200
14
$1.20
$17
30
$1.50
$45
0
80
$0.35
$20
$10
$51
$ 687
30
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
103
$6.50
$663
6730
$336
349
$1.30
$419
20
$6.50
$130
900
zU
$33
34
$1.20
$41
65
$1.50
$98
0
300
$0.35
$75
$30
8f,
$137
$1851
38
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
189
$6.50
$1339
13130
3i#
$435
60S
$1.20
$733
37
$6.50
$241
1180
3*#
$41
41
$1.30
$49
130
$1.50
$195
0
630
$0.35
$158
$30
8*
$347
$3337
36
Quant -
it ies
Unit
Cost
304
$6.50
$1976
30000
zU
|700
1015
$1.30
$1318
43
*5,00
$310
840
$39
74
$1.30
69
140
$1.50
«310
54
$8.00
$433
1300
$0.35
$300
$30
si
$416
»5610
Fig. i
13d.
1127
Estimate of Quantities and Coete
Hoi»ht
in Ft .
Item
Floor
llltllrt
Cu. Yds.
of Fxca-
vatlon
Piles
Cu.Yds.
of Fill
False-
work
Change in
Length of
Bridge One
Engn».
Incl-
Crand
Total
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. tin.
of Forme
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lob. of
Stc?l
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
Cu. Yds.
of Cono.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
13
Unit
Cost
0
0
0
29
36.50
3189
1875
tit
166
103
31.20
3124
11.5
36.50
375
405
514
0
35
51.50
838
0
80
80.35
320
310
40 ft.
861.00
8244
.8*
863
8943
20
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
0
0
0
68
"6.50
3 442
4400
3154
198
81.20
3239
18
36.50
8117
630
tit
522
0
36
31.50
854
0
350
80.25
S63
330
10.0 ft.
361.00
8610
9',
8138
31958
-"'
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
0
0
0
104
36.50
3 676
67.20
Jit
5235
345
31.20
3414
29
56.50
5189
1020
536
0
63
81.50
895
0
690
80.25
8173
330
16.0 ft.
861.00
8976
8*
8336
'3050
36
Quant-
ities
Cost
0
0
0
160
36.50
11040
10350
tit
8363
535
81.20
3642
39
f.6.50
Sie9
1000
335
0
55
81.50
383
43
58.00
3336
1300
80.35
8335
330
32.0 ft.
861.00
81340
5351
84733
13
Unit
8
56.50
"52
2180
tit
5 76
48
32.50
3120
31
»6.50
3202
1950
tit
568
25 |99
£ 50fl SO
$65 f#"9
16
55.00
380
400
514
81.20
529
60
81.50
590
0
70
80.35
819
330
10JS
895
81046
30
Unit
C0 3t
15
36.50
398
4100
tit
5144
81
52.50
3203
69
36.50
3449
4340
tit
5152
A 5 l£24.
2 5ofi 20
31
36.50
3203
2110
tit
574
47
51.20
556
100
31.50
3150
0
300
50.35
550
840
10*
3300
83300
28
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
21
55.50
3137
5370
tit
S201
lis
32.50
(268
114
56.50
3741
7180
tit
3251
too
zso
J250
2 98
1.20
|35S
41
86.50
3267
2790
398
65
31.20
578
130
31.50
5195
0
550
80.35
S138
(60
10*
8306
33368
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
27
46.50
0176
7360
A*
f25e
148
32.50
3370
175
86.50
31138
11000
tit
3385
g 50
| 51"
55*
'1.20
i, I
68
35.00
3340
1500
34 1
353
94
51.20
5113
320
81.50
8330
63
38.00
3496
1050
80.35
8263
360
10*
8493
85428
Fig. 43c
1127
Estimate of Quantities and Coats
Height
in Ft .
Item
Floor
Ou. Yds.
of Exca-
vation
Piles
Ou.Ydn.
of Fill
Falso-
nork
Change In
Length of
Dridgo One
Abutment
F.njns.4
Incid-
entals
Grind
Total
Cu. Vdo.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Vde.
of Forma
Cu. Ydo.
of Conr.
Lbs. of
fit eel
Sq. Yde.
of Forms,
Cu. Yds.
of Conn.
bba. of
Gteel
Sq. Ydn.
of Forms
C5
20
Quant-
Unit
Coat
30
86.50
S195
2740
3$*
596
80
51.20
S96
49
{6.50
3319
3S68
593
130
$1.20
3156
48
36.50
8312
2373
(83
0
67
{1.50
5101
26
58.00
8208
239
30.35
560
3 100
2.2 ft.
861.00
8140
10)1
3196
33155
28
Quant-
Cost
48
{6.50
3312
5250
Jit
$184
135
51.20
3163
90
56.50
{585
6873
3i(t
3241
250
81.20
$300
84
36.50
3546
7198
3852
0
130
31.50
{195
44
5a. oo
3352
550
30.35
8138
3300
0.5 ft.
$61.00
330
10*
$350
8384 7
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
Coat
51
06. 50
{332
5296
3j*
{185
140
51.20
5168
125
fG.,50
8813
8923
3312
345
31.20
3414
113
36.50
3735
9853
5345
0
145
81.50
{318
53
38.00
3416
1050
30.35
8363
$300
8.0 ft.
Sfil.00
8490
10*
8489
55379
41
Unit
Cost
81
86.50
8527
7781
(272
200
31.30
5240
234
36.50
31521
15165
3i*
5531
570
31.30
5684
153
56.50
3995
13354
3439
0
244
Si. 50
3366
80
88.00
$640
1913
SO. 35
5478
$300
5.3 ft.
861.00
8320
10*
$730
38033
C6
12
Quant-
ities
Coat
13
56.50
585
1038
336
33
52.50
583
33
36.50
$315
1084
338
80
31.20
396
20
36.50
{130
890
;£#
331
31
31.20
525
50
81.50
375
0
63
30.35
316
8io
10*
384
} 934
20
it loo
Unit
23
16.50
$150
1835
3j((
564
58
?2.50
5145
72
56.50
3468
3365
w
383
177
81.30
3313
33
86.50
{215
3000
W
370
37
31.20
844
83
31.50
8135
0
334
80.35
$56
320
10*
J165
81817
se
Quant-
ities
Unit
Coat
33
{6.50
$215
2633
3i#
592
84
«3.50
8310
133
36.50
8865
4371
3iK
3153
301
31.20
5361
50
86.50
3335
5066
Sl77
53
81.30
362
130
*1.50
3195
0
467
80.25
8117
830
10*
8280
{3082
30
quant-
ities
Unit
43
JO. 50
f2eo
3430
$120
108
52.50
5270
208
56.50
51352
6840
A*
3339
471
31.20
5565
82
36.50
8533
8330
Mt
3391
82
Si. 20
{98
200
51.50
3300
0
1100
80.35
8350
$30
10*
$433
$4761
1127
3a to 43g.
ESTIMATE OF QUANTITIES AND COSTS.
Est imate of Quantities and Costa
Height
Item
Floor
II e a t * o r *
F o 0 t i n e s
Cu. Yds.
of Exc.
Files
Cu.Yds.
of Fill
False-
work
Enene, &
incid-
entals
Grand
Total
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forn.s
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
Cu. Yds.
of Cone.
Lbs. of
Steel
Sq. Yds.
of Forms
c7
13
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
12
$6.50
$78
2960
5104
54
$3.50
$135
34
$£.50
$156
910
$32
76
$1.20
$91
14
$5.00
870
250
11
18
$1.30
$33
40
$1.50
$60
0
60
80.35
♦is
0
6*
♦63
$834
30
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
31
16.50
#137
5170
1161
91
$2.50
$328
58
$6.50
$377
2190
3±#
$77
186
$1.30
$223
36
$6.50
$169
1380
$40
31
$1.30
$37
70
$1.50
$105
0
190
$0.35
$48
0
B<f,
$130
$1760
38
qruant-
Unit
Cost
41
$G.50
8267
10100
Ht
$354
129
43.50
$333
87
$6.50
3390
3j#
$115
383
$1.30
$340
36
$6.50
$234
1910
3i*
$67
37
fl.20
$44
100
$1.50
$150
0
500
$0.35
$125
0
8'"
8307
$2793
36
Quant-
ities
Unit
Cost
45
86.50
3293
11100
3^
$309
16G
$3.50
$415
145
$6.50
$943
5480
3itf
$193
451
$1.20
$541
61
$6.50
$397
3340
$113
53
$1.20
$64
150
$1.50
$235
0
950
$0.25
$238
0
Bf.
$305
84115
1127
(44- J J 1 | 1 1 1 ITTTT
-'tt^I
•-
Nlv ^v., ''-vv
'^
""-^ ^v^ ~ *-
V^oo^
\
\
r
Vv* ^ 4
4,. :<;^C
"-^4:
« -
^\ v---
<N
«
4_ _ ^-^
V. S "N^v
ii
-V.
\
«7
£| 15 „>>
S.
•n.
-.
-
M § X\
^ V^ft ^ ^
%*
\
s
"S"'**
^.
'.
§ 5 ^ ■*- -SJ
^^s ^ N^
*&•**_.
„
^
tl
^ ti £ ? - «>
^v* ^ v" s^.
"SS^is
_
^
i
^"v^ ^~_
^ks.1*.
"-
4-"%
X
>J ^ ? | *
^
rs>
4^
*o
■*»
k4 . ^
^
H
!■** ^°* -
^4
•s
"•i^
^N
1*1 ^h'^o, £
'o
^>
^N
V^*H*f$fi5 1
^
^s~
,
?cr •*?■*; ft<"cV^^ - -
=^4
^4
■
|<ii:«{^« ^iPt^^ai^
'^
J>
-X
,
1 Hi
U'l^^^H^h
~"
^
_\
S
Ny
i
t:
8^^S§c^«^
-^CNi
v
|
^.M^^M!^ — -
~v
V
^
-,
s
J,
»
O^i^U uJoi^^R
;J
ftj "^ 1*1 «0 S- qj ^ s Hi "1 t K) O K
s
1^
&
.
0^
N
'
? £&f&&£ 1 MIR^
^4 "
N.,
■,i
oo
j as
y«
Ll
ll"
u -
<-_e/,c,£' 'ji ' s> <;>/ 7f<j<?^ -t
L4
■-
:n<ja
3„0
>■=
:o-i
-
c\ 9 ^ o o 9
0 Q 0 0 §
as a a a
;i
0
r
0
::
(
.
ST * o * ° "S
os ] to | o i- r- -0
o « a 5 §
MS "> «) * *
*
m
"
i
c
5
■Cs
q; ^
V *
in k.
v.
o
I
C3
''
t
"'
■
I-
l;
;
CS
j
1
.*
a
-
•
■*•
t
t
1]
i
!
4~
I
(1
«1
•
\
S
■3";
1
.'
■
c
..v*
T
m
si
0
tv
§
<k
0
10
r
v^
1.
r^
P
>0
5
*
■u
ni
v
l>
<k
^
0
ft
■k
0)
0
0
IV
0
^
\
+-
%
m
V
0
u
tr,
k-
•:
0
-
U)
i
<•,
k
6
'-.
St
In. h and 45
COSTS OF ABUTMENTS OF VARIOUS HEIGHTS.
<c
(
G ly
IJ
(j
"
-
0
"if
-
' —
p*-
^
\
\
M
r
\
.
"
-
N
'
\
\
.
\
+t-
1*
>,
s
\
\
w
V
■\
*--
■I
"
^
^
S
\
s
1
,\
V—
-
\
\
\
*v
V
\
tl
El ^ ^
0 ^ 5 £ Q. Q. Q. Nu^i^Ks
U ' ' i i i i gl i i I I i 1 I
^ co iQ oq cffOQ >Q (J u 0 U U 0 U U
0. ^^^|b^ $ ^^^^(b
^~
k-
\
\
\
\
\
\
«
*r\
* ^»
^
\
&*
:\
kx
\^
'
~~~.
\
\
\
\
v
>'
f-
^
■^
Sj
\
\l
\
\
\
\
\l
^.
^
^5
\
0
V
o\
\s
>\
r
5
\
\
">s
\
V
V
V
.,\
\
P*1
r«-'^
\
\
\\
-n
rt
V.
V>
\
\
-v
\
\
V
\
O
"^
s,
*.,
\\
\
\\
f~
^ v-
-s
.\
s
^_
1
\
\
\
0
v^_
»o
\
\
\\
\\
K
x
v*x
sN
0
. \
v
\
N
v
\
s.s
^
\
A
V
N,
\
\\
s
\
i
lj—
\\
\\
\
>i-
s
*o
\ \
^^5
Vi
iw
\
1
111
m
0,
(71
;?
^
*
"m
//.
p
4
— 4.
= i
u
-*->
40
= ^
j><> 4:. 011
0"
>'*;',
i'!<
u'lj
'■•"
-.1'
0
8
0
?;
l
8
\
•1
-1
0
ft
i.
1"
M
8
CVi
$
Cs
I
'j
is §
Q
1127
-~
II
j
fl[
Of
1?
'
r ■-..
HQ4?
j
J
i
'
\
\
N\
V-
-V-
\-l
1
^
I
V
\
\
\
V
\
. v.
\
V
a
^
0
^
\
*
G\\\
\
1
\
\
\
T
\
«
\
\
\
, i\
\
k o k ns
k «i k c J> . Q
0 ^ c S-| ^ os- y
U ^ « i « H ^2 * ' ' " ' ?
s £ i a C $ c ^<3iii<c^k
n i i i i i i u i i i i i i i
^ «o m id m to tr {js (j u 0 u JCfJ
~ * v v v v u ^"""tiwSS
\
V
V
11
s
^
>.
ii
\
5 -
\
\
,3
i
!\
\
Q
v"
\
-1
T-
tf
j
v
\
\N
J_
-'
<»'
i
\
\
&
M
1
1'
1
\ -
K
\
'
\
\
0
*
\
'\
^
A
<\
\
V
I
\\
\
\y
J,
ii
\
V1:!
^
■ 'ij
\:i'
\
{
1
a
V
i\
\\
1
\
\
\\
A
\
1
.
V
K
'1
I
\
N
Y
\
i\\f
%
y>
"
$*
s.
a
■r: '
■f ->
,^
tn
?e>
"3
.a
uc
J-
,.=»
&u>
->=>_,
j/
0 4
3
it
u"0
ft
L" T!
UC,
3
0
Q
0
'■
0
f.
1
15
HI
»<
h
,
"'.
0
0
1127
Ij
iff
$ 0
«? tf
u
(j U
iJ_IOjj U
U
~~
^
.Sin
5*fcs
\
% "*>
v"\
ri")
v.-
%b.
\ \
\>N\
•0
•^
\
\\\^
^
^
■S^
^
\ 'w;
('V'^1
a
El k ,<
*!■■-• n°?^^^t
o § s a a a a. ^u^ii^KP
0 ' ' ' ' '- '„ ^ L ' ' ' L, '* s
;> to1 «? «? oo io <o § Cu^u i?u u u
k»h«»! J » •»»« «n
^
.
\\^\
?Q
'«.'
v<..
\
\\\
\
?*>
N^
\\
*^\
-V
\\
v\
8
'o
~*k
o\
X
0
^
\^N
*k,
v >\
^
\\ N
N
\
%.
I ^
0
\\
"1
\. ^
>l
N\
^
^
^x
So
. "vTl'V CHl
\\
A i
w
\
ft
\s
\v
\\
Ab
\
Vr
\\
\V\
X
*l \
L)
iff h
C-IO//0,
cu+nqt3
auo t*
■>qz> ^s-c
a +u*<.
uyu&Q
■U3
0
0
Ci
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
«1
0)
5
01
«0
r-
to
m
^
Kl
cu
0
1127
Figs. 59, 60, 62.
COST OF NEATWORK OF ABUTMENT.
COST OF FOUNDATION OF ABUTMENT.
COST OF EMBANKMENT.
IOCI I I UIUUUI
rer - Mease Insert Foldout here
rage Warier
iisert Foldout
er - Please Insert Foldout here
3age Marker
lsert Foldout
^aae. Marker
:er - Please Insert Foldout here
'age Marker
isert Foldout
. - PL6XSE INSERT FOLDOUT H€W
6 KAXKKtK
PJ FOLDOUT
lease Insert roldoiit In
Mar*
roldoiil
let - J^fea^e Jngeff ^iJ&uf here
aye J$$af^er
$erf f^fcW
- Please Insert Foldoul here
ffi
rker
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1127
1
.t r -
a
t-
>6
-
1
7
I
i i
> /
-h^
-
zs
V
,i
/
/,
&
^
4A
&
f*
H
>—
1
t
*
IN
{)
'.-
■U
1
C
/
01
f
i
k
/
+>
3
P<A
'JC
1
/
<
j
'
j)
/
li
/
0)
1
/
C
2
5C
>d
1
0
1
i
1
i
/
,Q
1
i
/
'i
1
Vi
/
■k
e
CC
■>o
i
~t
'
r'
in
/
IJ/
f
0
/
<
/
U
/
r
/
/
/
/
i
/.
>C
0
/
^
/
'
<■
f
\
t
,
■
o
/
/
/
y
\
f
■
r
K
7"
A
y
/£
~>G
0
•
n
/,
•
{
/
V
/
K
y
/
|
^
5
0
')
„
/'
f
!,
r
s
'
_
_-
-
-f
■/ e
k'
**"
f
r
e
vy
S
^
Ji5
r
!
n
«
si
'"
ir
'
(
•^
hi
s
z
■VL
t>/
■X:
C
—
"
'.
n-
ii
3
—
--
--
"-
fi-
-
— (-
-"
1
10' 15' £0' 25' 50' 35'
Heiqht of crbufme.nt,- bar se of re? if
to qrounaf I eve f art toe. of 5/ope^
Type. B&
Fig. 46
1128
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
i
— h
ii
3=
7
H
Hi
L
*==
■, ;
6
5<
76
>-
—
-(
/
X,
i
i
X
A
/
/
5
5
SX
?"
11
-4
p
■3/*
3
-
/
r-
t
.'
./
•5
t
--
—
-4
€>
£?-
S^
'
■v
/
0
/
ti
r
i
3
5.
3(
3
i
c
/
'
1
r
1
1
Q)
1
I
E
*»
3
Pi
^C
3
/
/
i
5
'
/
-Cs
1
-r<
/
f
C5
1
/
Il-
s
5
0
0
'
/
ls
r
\
0
0
%
'
^s
I,
|5
;C _
\ A
-\l
'/
ja.
'+-
2
£3
?«
1
'-
V
k
-k
-, -
r\
<u
0
{ 1
A
V
V
/
/
50-
/
/
/
5(
?<
7
/
/
*c
/
i
/
/
t
>
-fck
/
'
/(
2r
>£
>
/
/
W
/
-
\<
--
-
+
\\
.c
U-
./
\<
0)
'
il
)'
>
45*
G
0
/
Y
_£_
..
^
"C^r
..
,-
/h
?
V
pi
•f
-'-
<!
;=>^
;
-r
...
--
1
^
/
ri
r"
_ £!,
C
=^-U4==--
--
-T
/<?' 15' ao' 25' 30' 35'
Height of abutment,- ba^e- of rail
to ground leve.1 art toe* o-f s/opo^
Type, B3
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1129
5
5
3
>
5
0
3
)
)
/
/
/
4
5
P
3
r
/
?
'
/'
V
m
t
/
t.
/
*os
s
O
P
3
/
■*-
/
^3
/
/
Q
*■
3
5
?i
'
•k
■
F:
/
/
5
5
O
r<
1
/
/
,■
_>
■
/
_c
&,
/
j!
t»
/
<
-
£
,?
5
?
i
/
>,
0
/
i
'.
t-
«
i
(
%
/
J
■ /
'
\
?•
•k
f
0
p.
3
/
<h
U)
^
/
(■
■
•0
o
)/
o
y
0
/
(i
/
/
/.
X
^c
r
■'
e-
/
£
$
&
/
'C
~>a
c
0
>'
>
<
<\
/
-f-
f\
Vl
)j_
-~
"■
'
hj
"
.-■
5
Ot
p
.
-.'
r7
a
f
-
--
r<
, J
"-i
c^
< i
i
^
~
-/
O
-
~-
-
-
/<?' /5' <?<?' <?5' JO' 35
/-/eight of abutment, - b ase. of rail
to grounaf /eve/ at toe- of s/op&^
Type. B5
Fiq. 4&
1130
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
5
5(
7C
1
/
5
(9
-J(
?
/
/
0
/
'■'
/<
/
4
5<
It
?
'
/
/
10
/
^
fc
/
4
<?<
?C
p
/
/
0
/
/
i;
3
5<
?C
b
c
5
5
■0
3
PC
1C
i
/
/
/
Ci
1
,'
<tf
/'
*
C
a
5C
K
i
f'
0
j
\J
/
l
6
/
o
.V
•
^
\
A
'
■k
a
9C
>C
y
}/
<"
r
U)
0.i
1
>«*
--
0
A
y>,
/
u
/
V
'
/
c
i
/.
56
o
/
/
\\
—
/
(
p.
/
\
/
/
/(1
■>c
c
/
\\
'
n
£,
«--
.<
9
\o
,,
*-
,sr1
i&
2
■ r
'1
./,/
o
,f
4
'
I
fl
ija
r
0,
l^
5
0(
?
/
-_
i
'-
__
i"
£■
//
i
.-.<
0
[--
—
f
•a
3
>£
e.
n
o
"
L
/£>' /5"' ao' S5' 30' 35'
Height of abutment, - ba^e. of rail
to q round level at toe. of slopes
Type. S6
Fig.
4-9
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1131
"
5
5
?c
?
5
0(
>c
J -
/
7 -
4
5<
j a
1
. /
-0?
s
^
££-
Is
J
IS
4-
c?<
'X
)
T
■s.
7
u
0
-V
z
c
.5
5(
~'C
1
a)
/
5
<5
5
9<
-JC
/
J
1
/
01
~7
^'
e
?
5C
~>c
_f~
Jf.^'
0
/
-»<£'
(
~?
/■^^
1°
_)<
*£-
V
t
■k
?.
?(
->c
j>
7- &
•
»i
y S-
u
\
r £^
U
.'
V
c/
A
1/
$4
1
5C
•)C
\,
/
-,^S
V
22
/
l^i
/
&z
t
*v
It
>C
o
x(
t
V
— ,~-i^-
c
/
^£^7^
'
r-
^ -"" — — -"'So.'?
5
0
Q
/
r
sri-'S
^UCL^^ -
_■- — 'S^^5"
—
m~
— ~~
,. — ^
^i// -=--
-"" T
,-F'a/ t'Qwo'"^
o
-
'-
■"
± -^ -- .
/<?' /5' fO' £5V 30' 35'
Height of abutment,- bcrse. of rcri/
to qrounc/ /eve/ crt toe, of slopo-
Type, B 7
Fig
.50
1132
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
5
5
?<
'
5
■9
?l
■)
•7
5
■)(.
'
"1
(.
/
J3
4
£?<
K
->
/
V
/
/
')
^
/
<0
*>
c-
3
^
:Z
<<
)/
*"
)
'\
■k
c
/
E
/
i.
5
3,
'JC
1
J
&
)
<
UA
/
(I)
x,
\>,
e
2
5i
'>c
>
o]
o
,<•
Y,
t
r^
r
\>,
k
i
•k
2
?<
bc
t
■ \
V;
6
'
U
(
/
v
>>
n
K,
/
;.
VI
/-
A
fo
c
<ri
'/
/
f
V
w!
v-
n
i
/
»:d
>d
>o
r
V
<"
~.r
*
1 /
0
/
f
5
0
■}
<
n
fi
a
J
-'
u
ir-
~r
f
7
r
,- 1
/
^
^,
-f-
a
It
' £
r
'C
I/1
fc
C
--
-
--
»•
--
"
"""
IO' 15' SO' ?5' 30' 35'
Hei cjht o-f abutment,- base, o-Trcr//
to ground level at toe of slopes-
Type- Be
Fig. 51
3
5*5
/
*
*
—
/
/
■=i
!ff
\r.
/
4j>
/-
' /
W
(•-
7
£_
i
/
/
/
/
«)
k
St?
<s
/
/
i
u
/
(1
/
>
/
r'
r
1
/
t
/
/
■k
/
k
0
//
f
3
OC
>c
/
/U/
/
1
\
,7
i
*]
h/
A
^
'
//
'J
CN
r
7
/
3
PC
"vC
K
g
w
/
/(
i
c.
/
I
r
/
/
1.
(/
s
e
JC
)C
i
.
-k
/
C
<0
r
/
0
j
,-
u
/
<!
<?
7£
>c
i
'
i
1
■1
1
/
/
/
/
N
/
•V
/
A
rc
o>
/
/
/
'
/
,(
i /
/
c
/
K
;
,-
,0
/
z1
/
(
/
fd
)/
/<:
?c
'C
*»
{/
v
/
r>
/
/
/
tv
/,
/
ii
y
lx
/
fj
!>
^
/
5
0
3
•
/
t
-'
''
F
;"/
1
d
10' 15' ao' ?5' 30' 55
Hei ghf oT abutment,- base, o -Trail
to ground leve.1 at toe. oT slopo-
Type, C/
Fiqz5t
1134
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
6
?c
K
5
5C
'<C
/
/
/
1
/
5
Ot
>a
/
1
/
v
i
/
K!
/
4
5C
o
1
1
i
<0
j
k
1
/
is
4
Ot
It
i
i
s
1
I
-J,
/
1
if
c
1
**
3
K
o
/
*'
/
Q
1
V
i
i
AC
/
5
1
/
t
"3
3
DC
•c
1
/
•0
i
/
ft
/
/
/
,
a)
/
/
n
?
?C
•o
/
/
/
/
Pi
/
/
c
/
/
•k
/
/
in
E
C'C
><3
/
/
0
/
/
0
.
i
*
/
/
/
y
i
>C
0
/
:
/
■'
/
V
/
,■'
'/
/
,
I
n
vc
o
*
\
'
I
<
/
P
''
V
K
-
0
5
0
3
<
-/
a
1 '
c
r;
0
! j
(,7
/
-
F
!i
f
"^
c
"
"
""
IO' 15' SO' £5' 30' 55'
Heicjhfo-fabufrr>en-f-,-bc?5e. o-Frcti/
to ground I eve./ at toe. of s /ope^
Type, C2
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1135
10'
15' SO' 25' 30'
Heiqht of abutment,- base of nail
to ground level at toe- of s/ope>-
Type, C3
Fig. 54
1136
DESIGN
c
F
1
BI
a
D
G
E
y
VI
$t
IT
A'
t*
S»
fT
s
6
->■
•>c
>
5
5C
rC
1
/
\
/
5
Ot
ic
>
W
X
y
^
1
1
4
5c
■>c
1
1
/
/
c
O
/
/
fc
/
\
4
OC
~>C
/
n
/
13
/
/
k
/
+
3
5(
JC
T~
/
r-
/
ti)
;
1
5
+,
/
S
3
V<
:<c
ii
15
r
/
0
e
5t
>c
*
o\
/
^
|ij
^
a
V
-k
/
,\<
v
m
e
OC
'>0
e
V
J
/
\(
V
/
/
r,
'
A
(
1.
5C
0
/
/
/
.--
/
/
•
j
/
/
\\
/
•
Al]
it
>C
0
/
/<
/■
)j:
/
1
,j
/
4!
/
X
fi
i
rt
$•
^.
f
li
ny
rJ
S
_-
3;
b
V
1
'
pi
aj
—
ir
rj
-f
t
>
v
>
u
ii>
£
>
/=v
//
O
__
-
— '
-
—
v
-/
~<s?
?5
ei
V<
?r\
$
/<?' IB' £0' 25' 30' 35'
Height of abutment, - base, of rail
to groan c/ /eve/ at toe, of s/ope^-
Typo- C4.
F/cj. 55
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1137
V-
-7i
St
>t
)~
■A
/
/
/
-
/
-
/
,1
i.i
1
•i
tf)
r.
i /
1 -
{.
^
/
/
v.
->
/
0
*
/
l
I
Q
/
"*
>
3
5l
oc
?
•k
j
3
O
OC
?
£
jj
/
](
l-
is
/
V
'..
<ii
l
rl
V
rt
-i
r
/
r.t.
'
0
z
i%
>
o
2
5c
pc
p
>
^
/
CV
t>
/
V
/
■k
i
10
e
■?(.
>c
>
y
n
«»*
u
f
i<2
i>
.f,
\c;
>
,
'
r>L
'i-
>
-K
/ -
h
5C
PC
r.
'.-
-
0,
S
i}
{-■■'
N
-
,'
r
'
:.'
h
?c
yj
rn
,
'
?<
iy
1^
,
.'
--
—
--
-1
~v
'\$
-1
/
z
r
t
5
a,.
?
r*
flri
M
fl«
.f
p
//
t
/
\i
f
£
9u
1
t
y
£
^
"'
-j
1
\A
F
a
1 1
■id
n
u
n
<.
<*
■k
U
~/
o
s
i?(3' 25' JC 35' 40' 45
He/ g'ht of abutment,- base- of ra/ I
to ground level at toe. of slopes
Type, Cs
Fig.
56
1138
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
eo
oo
55
?t
^C
or
1
J -
+ A -
4'
-j>,
0
f
Jsl If
_J>" ,
t
V
Us
£/
\
4C
>oc
J
I
0
(_
fc
4
t
_ L
k ^
+.
V
-oc
?
Z_
c
OJ
/_
K
■k
3
5£
~)0'
7
o
IS
(1)
c
/
0
p .
jD
P
,0
>•
V
<
•
ID
c<
11
?
/
0
'
_/
u
/
/
>
//
/
ti
>0(
?
<
P/
z
\
-WJ-'
r^v
0
/
£
,J[
i
.''
IC
><?£
? /
a
/
t
^
rJ
/■
^-^
C
, + '>
p
/
^
#->^
_.-<'
/
X
[J
r+
/- --"■=1"
A
OO
y
f;
'
r
--'
■—
"
_.- —
t- —
--'"
^,~ — -^'
F
/'/
/
o
= =.■: —
— _
~r~
"
..
—
IO' 15' £0' 25' 50' 35'
Heiaht of abutment, - base, of rcri!
to ground level at toe, of s/opo^
Type. Oe
Fi<j.
51
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1139
6
•x
->c
5
5 1
7C
5
O
9t
-1
4
5:
?c
)
U)
4T
J'
?t
)
y
0
5
/
(J
V
^
/
c
4
/
■k
Q
3
5
?(
7
/
/
/
5
/
/
/
"3
3
O
-?<:
J
/
-CI
/
fi
2
5>
7C
?
C
o
K
■k
10
2
0
?(
?
0
u
/
•
1
pc
)C
!
/
c:
J
/
■<
'
/
/
—
-
/<
?*:
■>c
■
/
^
ir
--
■
/
V
r V
<■
/
,rl
e.
|f
^
x
->
/-
-'
•"
w
i<
{.'.
5
o
■J
,-
^_
r
p
r?L
A
<.
\„
■"
—
■?>
--
--
F
//
1
r~
,
-
O
_
t*
r/
/<?' 15' SO' 25' 50' 35'
Hei cjht of abutment,- base- of rail
to ground lava! art toe. of slopes-
Type. C 7
Fig. 5<5
1140
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
£
5
P
CO \>
!5 Q-c 5
CD +*
O i i *• i i S r i i » ■
L) 1 "1 'O S^l (V ,W It ^r* S
^cqcqcqCOOq ^OJoUO
■VA
-n
V
P5\
^
-\
£
^v
X
I
S;
5
x-^
^
1^1
C
5 "K
5 «
'§ S 0
*3
Cost of floor for one abutment
in dollars
Cost ofadct/tional length of superstructure charged to each abutment^- Q lO
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1141
F-L-MIIV LC^/Vl..<C /£ /YliH OLS/VS< r f-i CSU / /fl£/V 1 J
Type. Bz~ Wing Abutment, Reinforced Backwa/1
Type B3- U- A butmen t, Filled.
Type Bs - Pier Abu tmen t.
Type B& -Pier Abutment.
Type By-Pier Abutment.
Type B8- Pocket A butmen t.
REINFORCED CONCRETE MASONRY ABUTMENTS
Type Cs- U- Abutment, Filled, Long Side walls.
Type- C*,- U- Abutment, Fit/eat, short Side w& /Is.
Type C4- U-A butment, Covered
"Type. C5- Arch Abutment.
Type Cb-~T- A butm en t.
4f<
jp
^(j
■?o
<hi
_3J
-O
11 )
5C
IO
g
0
u
,c
-k
£t
>d
k
V
£
■i-
-0
r
c5
ia
ZC
?c
Q)
1
0
t.
&
y
/5
0
0
k
0
10
»
s
<
-5
/O
0
0
t-
fi
u
/
~*
_
-~J
I i—
5C
5
.-
—
-■
'■*"'
r
'A
C
;•*
^i
^
ffS
S«
By
%
-*
,--
~-A
—
...
--
Ce,
r-
"^
Cs
r=
=^=
"^
^
Q
Ci
__-_
rfi
5*=
-K
JJc
O
,/,s
-1
»*
&«
37
^a
O
/
0'
/
5'
?0
y/'
<?
5'
3
0'
5
5'
Height oF a butment , - base oF rail to ground level at toe oF slope
Diagram Showing Cost of Fa / se won fie
fop A butmen f 5 of Various Heights
Fig. 64
1142 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
CONCLUSION.
The writer finds that a general statement about the foregoing abut-
ments has to be qualified in so many directions that it becomes merely
a group of more or less disconnected facts.
Inspection, however, will show that the cheapest abutments for the
higher fills, Cs, Ce, Ct and Bs, are those in which no provision is made to
restrain the lateral pressure of the earthwork, but where instead the
earthwork is allowed to spill forward to its own natural slope.
Fig. 43 shows the principal elements in the design of an abutment
which resists the lateral pressure of the earthwork instead of avoiding^
it and in which the resistance to the lateral pressure of the earthwork
tending to overturn the abutment is provided by the weight o+ the abut-
ment neatwork. In this type the designer has little freedom and is in
danger of producing a design which tends to be unstable on account of
high foundation pressure at the toe of the abutment.
Looking at Fig. 43, we can see that the overturning moment around
the point "k" at the intersection of the face of the neatwork and footings,
is P3.I3, in which "p3" is the lateral piessure of the earthwork, and "13"
its lever arm, measured from the point "k."
In a similar manner the resisting moment is P2.I2 in which "p2" is
the resultant of the vertical loads and '%" the lever arm around "k."
With so many elements fixed, the ways in which the required sta-
bility can be obtained are few and not subject to much variation.
First, the resisting moment "P2.I2" can be increased by altering the
outline of the abutment from that shown in full lines to that shown in
dotted lines, thereby inceasing the lever arm from "L" to "b." It is plain
that the length of the lever arm can only be slightly increased by this
means.
Second, the moment of resistance "p>.h" can also be increased by
increasing the force "p^" and thus, of course, the moment of stability
of the neatwork around the point "k." But in abutments of ordinary
proportions any increase in "p2" results in an increase in the pressure
"pr" on the toe of the footing. If no provision were made for this
increased pressure on the toe of the footing, the increased stability of
the neatwork on the footing would have been obtained at the expense
of decreased stability of the abutment as a whole, due to excessive toe
pressure.
On the other hand, as soon as departure is made from the gravity
abutment, the greatest latitude is obtained for the ingenuity and skill
of the designer. The types mentioned in this paper are only a few of
the large number of abutment types which promise considerable economy.
A number of such abutments, designed under the direction of H. C.
Lothholz, but which are outside the limits of this paper on account of
their character or size, are shown in Figs. 65, 66, 68, 69, 70 and 71.
As the minimum sections adopted are more liberal in the reinforced
concrete abutments than in the plain abutments, it is probable that there
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS. 1143
is a wider margin for new economies in the reinforced than there is in
the plain abutments. In the reinforced abutments a minimum section of
i ft. 3 in. was used in a few places, but at the greater number of points
the minimum thickness of concrete adopted was I ft. 9 in. to 2 ft. without
regard to the load which it was to carry. If we compare the above thick-
ness of reinforced concrete section with the thicknesses shown in Fig.
72, which is a drawing from a foreign textbook,* it would seem that the
possible economies have not been exhausted.
*Der Eisenbeton in Theorie und Konstruktion, Rudolph Saliger, Leipzig,
1911. Alfred Kroner Verlag.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
114f
Section at <£ of Track-
Half] Ha /f
Sec t. ! Etc v
Plan
Fiq. 6&
Line Diagram Abutment Spokane River Bridge.
=».*■-• r " '•■
'
r
^
-■ -^ ■' '■"■' ■ •"
? £„' +
la" ^UU9:-H
m -
''&ds
L ' '
■I ;
SfifiBj
*^~
*
A •• ' i»'*i
f*£ *
S$ ••'
^^^^^H
fc^^^"i
Fig. 69 — Abutment Spokane River Bridge. Abutment Contains Open-
ings for Under Crossings.
114fi
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
3-m
Sect/on at <£ of Track.
Half
Sect."A-A"
4zzz?
LAiz
A/6?//" A/C7/f
Half
Plan Secf'B- B"\E leva f Ion
Fig. lO
Fig. 70 — Line Diagram Abutment Sixteen Mile Bridge.
Fig. 71— Abutments Sixteen Mile Creek Bridge on C. M. & P. S. Ry.
Near Lombard, Mont.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
1147
r-ii"(o.5m)
\Ground Level}
Fig. 1<L
1148 DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
WRITTEN DISCUSSION ON "DESIGN OF RAILWAY BRIDGE
ABUTMENTS."
Mr. J. L. Campbell (EI Paso & Southwestern) :— Referring to "The
Design of Railway Bridge Abutments," by J. H. Prior, Assistant Engineer,
Chicago, .Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway, in the November, 1911, Bulle-
tin. 1 enclose herewith Fig. 73, showing a type of buried abutment
which we have found more economical than wing abutments for high
tikments. Referring to this figure, the buried abutment involves the
use of a concrete pier and a deck plate girder, both of which are in-
cluded in the comparative estimates that follow. The pier is assumed
to replace a wing abutment in position.
Buried Abutment 22 Ft. High.
Excavation, 44 cu. yds. at $1.00 $44.00
Concrete, 177 cu. yds. at $7.00 1,239.00
Riprap, 150 cu. yds. at $1.50 225.00
Steel, 18,000 lbs. at 354c 675.00
$2,183.00
Wing Abutment 22 Ft. High.
Excavation, 90 cu. yds. at $1.00 $90.00
Concrete, 290 cu. yds. at $7.00 2,030.00
Excess embankment, 445 cu. yds. at 20c 89.00
Riprap, 50 cu. yds. at $1.50 75.00
$2,284.00
Buried Abutment 30 Ft. High.
Excavation, 50 cu. yds. at $1.00 $50.00
Concrete, 238 cu. yds. at $7.00 1,666.00
Riprap, 240 cu. yds. at $1.50 360.00
Steel, 37,000 lbs. at 354c 1,388.00
$3,464.00
Wing Abutment 30 Ft. High.
Excavation, 140 cu. yds. at $1.00 $140.00
Concrete, 540 cu. yds. at $7.00 3,780.00
Excess embankment, 1,350 cu. yds. at 20c 270.00
Riprap, 80 cu. yds. at $1.50 120.00
$4,310.00
The comparative estimates assume the ground to be level. Ordi-
narily the foundation of the abutment is higher than that of the pier.
in which case the cost of the abutment is reduced. In some cases no
riprap is required.
DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS. 1149
Referring again to Fig. 73: The embankment is assumed to be
30 ft. high. The pier and the embankment span, 40 ft. long, are a more
economical arrangement than the elimination of the pier and extension
of the adjacent span to the buried abutment. For example, assume the
adjacent span to be a 60-ft. deck plate girder, and that it extends to the
abutment, making a girder span 100 ft. long. The comparative esti-
mate is then as follows :
For Single Span.
1 100 ft. girder, 160,000 lbs. at &/4C $6,000.00
For Pier and Embankment Span.
Excavation, 30 cu. yds. at $1.00 $30.00
Concrete, 140 cu. yds. at $7.00 840.00
1 40 ft. girder, 37,000 lbs. at 3^4c 1,387.50
1 60 ft. girder, 67,000 lbs. at 3^4 c 2,512.50
$4,770.00
The difference in favor of the arrangement shown in Fig. 73 wi!i
increase rapidly as the height of the embankment increases. Modern
railway construction involves many bridges connecting embankments
IQ'-O"
Reinforcement in backwaf/ not shown
-UTTTTST
\t_J
Fig. 7 5
too high for wing abutments. The buried abutment is an economical
substitute when designed with due regard to the character of its founda-
tion and of the embankment surrounding it. For embankments in which
the material is stable even when wet, the type of buried abutment
i i5o DESIGN OF BRIDGE ABUTMENTS.
shown will generally be found to have the necessary stability. However,
numerous high embankments in many parts of the country do not be-
come stable for several years after being built, in which case it is often
difficult to determine the proportions and minimum dimensions required
in a high abutment buried in such an embankment. When high em-
bankments start to run off the right-of-way, as they sometimes do, it
is not always the case that that portion of the embankment in front of
the buried abutment gives very much support to the latter.
Mr. J. H. Prior :— Mr. Campbell's estimates on his buried abutment
as a substitute for a wing abutment would seem to bear out the find-
ings of this paper; that an abutment of this general character is more
economical for moderate and high fills than a wing abutment.
The buried abutment and wing abutment which he mentions cor-
respond in a general way, as far as design is concerned, to our abut-
ments B-6 and B-2, and if his estimated costs are platted on figures 44
and 45, it will be seen that the total costs bear a similar relation.
We agree with his figures which show that it is cheaper to obtain
the increased length of bridge required by the buried abutment by
means of an additional approach span than it is to obtain this increased
length by increasing the length of the end span.
isqql
Appendix A.
SUMMARY OF THE VARIOUS TYPES OF ABUTMENTS
DESCRIBED IN THIS PAPER.
SUMMARY OF THE VARIOUS TYPES OF ABUTMENTS
DESCRIBED IN THIS PAPER
I. Stone Masonry Abutments :
Type Ai, Wing Abutments;
Type A;, U Abutments;
Type A3, T Abutments;
II. Plain Concrete Masonry Abutments:
Type Bi, Wing Abutments, plain concrete back wall;
Type B.., Wing Abutments, reinforced concrete back wall;
Type B5, U Abutments, filled ;
Type B,, T Abutments;
Type Bs, Pier Abutment, transverse beam on concrete columns
Type B8l Pier Abutment, plain concrete buttress;
Type Bi, Pier Abutment, reinforced concrete buttress,
Type B», Pocket Abutment ;
II. Reinforced Concrete Masonry Abutments:
Type Ci, Counterfort Wing Abutments;
Type G, U Abutments, filled, long side walls;
Type Ci, U Abutments, filled, short side walls ;
Type C, U Abutments, covered ;
Type Ci, Arch Abutments ;
Type CB, T Abutments;
Type G, Trestle Abutments.
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING FOR LOCOMOTIVES.
• (Bulletin 138.)
By M. H. Wickhorst.
The method of locomotive tonnage rating and the train resistance
tables described in this paper were first worked up by the Laboratory
of the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad about the year 1902, and
were presented by the author in a paper before the Western Railway
Club, March 17, 1903. The paper was later revised and the tables con-
siderably extended, under the direction of the author, under date of
September 3, 1908, and it is these that now constitute the present paper.
Credit for such merit as this work may possess is due to a number of
persons, and the work of revision in particular was done mostly by
Mr. W. A. Pownail, of the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad
Laboratory at Aurora, 111. Permission to publish this material was kindly
given by Mr. H. E. Byram, Vice-President, Chicago, Burlington & Quincy
Railroad. This revision was used as a code of instructions for those
doing tonnage rating work on the road mentioned.
1151
TONNAGE RATING OF LOCOMOTIVES.
CHICAGO, BURLINGTON & QUINCY RAILROAD COMPANY.
In establishing a tonnage rate for an engine we aim to load the
engine up to near its maximum pulling capacity and yet not load it so"
heavily that it will stall on any of the hills, or be on the road an excessive
length of time.
The work of engine rating consists of: (i) Determining the maximum
working tractive force the engine can maintain under average conditions
over the ruling grade; and (2) to balance this with an equal amount
of total train resistance on the ruling grade. We have tractive force
formulae and curves of train resistance from actual tests which are
worked up into tables convenient for use in this work. These are given
later on in this article.
The tonnage rater, in rating a division, must first get an alinement
and grade profile of the division and make a careful study of the grades,
curves, etc., for the purpose of determining the ruling grade and esti-
mating about what percentage of the maximum tractive force an engine
can consistently maintain and get over the road with in good time and
without stalling. There is also the question of momentum grade as
affecting the ruling grade. This will be explained later.
He should also, if consistent with operating conditions, divide the
main runs of the division into rating divisions whenever there is a
sufficient change in ruling grade to warrant two different rates. For
instance, one run on the Galesburg Division of the Chicago, Burlington
& Quincy Railroad is from Quincy to Galesburg; from Quincy to Bush-
nell is 70 miles, with a ruling grade of 0.7 per cent. ; from Bushnell to
Galesburg is 30 miles, with a ruling grade of 0.3 per cent. As Bushnell
is a point where there is a great deal of freight to fill up with, there
should be two rates for the Quincy-to-Galesburg run. If there were no
important points where freight originated between Quincy and Galesburg,
we would probably make a straight through rate from Quincy to
Galesburg.
Having settled on these, the rater will consult the equated tonnage
tables for the grade in question, and using the predetermined tractive force
as the train resistance, he will get a trial rate.
The next step is to ride engines hauling this trial rate and see how
the estimate works out in practice. There are many local influencing
conditions which cannot be seen on the profile chart, such as differences
in roadbed, speed limits, some grades being protected from winds by
trees or cuts, overworking of firemen, etc. Very often sidings or the
1X52
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING. 1153
approach to them will be on a heavy grade, so that if an engine had to
stop to head in at one of them, it would be unable to start the train
again. The approach to crossovers, home semaphores, or any place
where trains have to be stopped under ordinary operating conditions, are
similar instances that have to be considered in making the rate. If,
however, to consider such a point would lower the rate very materially
and if the point in question were one where wise despatching would
eliminate most of the stops at the place, it should be ignored in making
the rate. These will show up on the trial trips, and the rater can, in
a few trips, check up his rates and readjust, if necessary, for the final
rating.
If a train averages less than ten miles an hour between terminals
(except on runs of less than ioo miles), the engine and train crew are
on the road an excessive length of time. In practice we find that ordi-
narily if an engine be loaded so that her average speed in motion is twenty
miles an hour, the average speed between terminals will not fall under
ten miles per hour.
Outside the ability of the engine to handle her train, density of traffic
and efficiency of despatching are factors to be considered. The ques-
tion of speed is an important one, and the engine rater should keep
accurate record of stops and time on road on his trial trips, and rate
accordingly.
The length of the division is another influencing factor. On a short
division, of say, 60 miles in length, it is economy, traffic permitting, to
load the engines a little more heavily; whereas, on a 160-mile division the
rate should be lowered on account of excessive time on the road, the
possibility of heavy or clinkered fires, etc.
Following is the method of arriving at the equated tonnage rates:
TRACTIVE FORCE.
(1) Tractive Force at Tender Drazvbar.
For figuring the maximum tractive force that an engine may develop
at the tender drawbar on level track for simple engines, we use the
following formula :
TF= —
D
Where P = maximum boiler pressure in lbs. per sq. in.
d == diameter of cylinder in inches
j = stroke in inches
D = diameter of drivers in inches
T F = tractive force in pounds.
This formula assumes that the mean effective pressure in the cylinders
at full stroke is 92 per cent, of the maximum boiler pressure, and that 92
per cent, of the work done by the cylinders is transmitted back to the
drawbar behind the tender.
1154 EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
For compound engines we use the following formula, working com-
pound :
.85 P d\s
Two cylinder compounds, 1 F = — — r
D (r + 1)
, ^V 1.7 P d\s
Four cylinder compounds, TP = ~~~ 7
£>(r+i)
.85 Pdfc
Two cylinder compounds working simple, T F = •-
Where di = diameter of low pressure cylinder in inches
r = ratio of cylinder volumes (LP^-PTP)
d. = diameter of high pressure cylinder.
(2) Tractive Force on Grade.
On a grade the tractive force of an engine is less, due to the fact
that she must lift her own weight up the hill, which absorbs some of
the work performed by the cylinders and leaves less to develop at the
drawbar.
The amount to be deducted for this engine grade resistance is found
by the following formula :
Engine Grade Resistance = 20 W G;
Where W = weight of engine and tender in tons
G = grade in per cent.
(3) Net Working Tractive Force.
Having obtained the maximum effective tractive force at tender draw-
bar, a certain allowance must be made for small drops in steam pressure
as affecting the tractive force, and for an occasional stuck brake, excess
of billed over actual tonnage, etc., as affecting train resistance. A
variable and sometimes very considerable allowance has to be made de-
pending on the profile of the road ; i. e., where the run as a whole is hard
and the grades long, we take from 80 per cent, of the tractive force
down to as low as 65 per cent, on the lower grade divisions. An ex-
ample of this would be a division of perhaps 120 miles with a large
amount of 0.3 per cent, grade ; this would probably be rated as a 0.3 per
cent, grade using 65 or 70 per cent, of the tractive force as the total
train resistance over this grade. If sufficient allowance were not made
we would find that while the engine would probably take the train over
without stalling, the time would be very slow, the fire would get in bad
shape, and on the low-grade divisions with our heavy power the fireman
would be unable to stand the work.
To find, therefore, the net working tractive force, we take a certain
predetermined percentage of the drawbar tractive force (afterwards
checked by road test), and subtract from this the engine grade resistance.
The resulting net tractive force is the same as the total train resistance
over the ruling grade, and is the figure that determines the rate.
For convenience in working rate schedules and calculating, tables
are given, showing tractive forces, weights and amount of heating sur-
face for the different classes of engines of the Chicago, Burlington &
Quincy Railroad. (See Fig. 1.)
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
1155
TRAIN RESISTANCE.
Train resistance consists of three primary resistances, as follows :
(i) Acceleration resistance.
(2) Grade resistance.
(3) Friction.
Acceleration and grade resistances are elementary resistances, de-
pendent only upon the amount of tonnage, and not upon the form of the
tonnage, such as in empty or loaded cars, etc. Friction is a compound
resistance dependent upon a good many conditions, such as kind of cars,
load in cars, condition of track, condition of trucks, wind, temperature
of air, curves, etc. The composition of train resistance is shown be-
low :
f Acceleration Resistance, depends on ton
nage only.
Train
Resistance
Grade Resistance, depends on tonnage'
only.
' Journal. Depends on design '
and lubrication.
Rolling. Depends on solidity
of roadbed.
'20 lbs. per ton
for 1 per cent,
grade, or about
.4 lb. for each
foot per mile of
grade.
Friction
Flange.
Curve
' Sliding of one tread,
in each pair, on the
rail.
Flange Friction.
Varies trom 2^
to 12 lbs. per
ton.
Side bearings and center plates
cause flange friction.
!Wind against body of
car.
Flange Friction.
Note — Flange friction consists of that due to curves, side bearings
and center plates, winds, etc.
(1) Acceleration Resistance.
In rating slow freight trains acceleration resistance need very seldom
be considered, except on momentum grades. Here it comes as negative
resistance, and will be considered later under the head of momentum
grades.
(2) Grade Resistance.
This, generally, is the largest component of the freight train resist-
ance, and is dependent only on the tonnage on any given grade. The
grade resistance per ton may be figured by the following formula :
Where rs = 20 G
re = grade resistance in lbs. per ton
G = grade in per cent.
1156 EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
(3) Friction.
As stated above, the frictional resistance varies considerably. The
friction expressed in pounds per ton drawbar pull increases as the speed
increases, decreases as the gross weight of a car and its freight increases,
and increases, in a general way, as the temperature of the air decreases.
It varies for freight cars at freight speeds between limits of about 2
lbs. per ton and 12 or more lbs. per ton. Fig. 2 shows some curves of
friction resistance of freight cars at speeds of 20 miles per hour. These
curves show the relation between the gross weight per car in tons plotted
horizontally, and the resistance per ton in pounds plotted vertically for
four different weather conditions, as follows :
(1) Temperature above 30 degrees Fahrenheit, and not much wind.
(2) Temperature between zero and 30 degrees Fahrenheit, or strong
head or side wind, or frosty rail.
(3) Temperature between zero and 30 degrees Fahrenheit and strong
head or side wind, or temperature below zero and not much wind.
(4) Temperature below zero with strong head or side wind.
The curve showing resistance of freight cars in summer weather
(above 30 degrees Fahrenheit) is the result of dynamometer tests by
the Pennsylvania Railroad, and various results obtained by us fall in
well with this curve.
The curve showing friction of freight cars for the third weather
condition is one obtained by the Burlington from dynamometer tests dur-
ing the winter of 1900-1901. This curve was formerly used for the re-
sistance of cars in 10 degrees Fahienheit to 30 degrees Fahrenheit
weather, but we found that there was too wide a gap between the winter
rates derived from this curve and the summer rate ; i. e., for calm winter
days an engine could easily take considerably more than the old winter
weather rate, especially on the low-grade division. Accordingly, between
these two curves was placed another curve for calm winter weather, or
windy summer weather, and road tests indicated that rates derived from
this curve were about right.
The curve for very severe winter weather was obtained by arbitrarily
adding 2 lbs. per ton to the No. 3 curve. This seems to give the right
result for grades 0.6 per cent, or over ; for grades of 0.5 per cent, or
lower, we deduct 10 per cent, from our No. 3 or "C" rate to get the
"D" rate. This diagram also gives a curve of grade resistance based on
the above formula.
Knowing the grade, the gross weight of a car, and the general weather
condition, the total resistance per ton is found by adding together the grade
and friction resistances per ton as found from these curves.
MOMENTUM GRADES.
Where the grade is not too long, the momentum, or the work stored
in the train as motion, can often be used to help get the train over the
grade. A body in motion has an amount of work stored in it dependent
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING. 1157
upon its speed, and this stored work can be used to overcome the force
of gravity, or in other words, take a train a certain distance up a hill.
The amount of work so stored increases as the square of the speed. A
body moving 30 miles per hour has sufficient work stored in it to carry
it vertically upward about 30 ft. ; one moving 60 miles per hour sufficient
for 120 ft., etc. Therefore, a train approaching a hill at 30 miles per hour
could be taken a vertical distance of 30 ft., due to the momentum, pro-
vided the friction were otherwise taken care of. On a grade 30 ft. to the
mile this distance along the track would be one mile ; on a 60-ft. grade,
one-half mile, etc. Where this momentum is to be expended, or to run
out, in a given distance, the propelling force can be expressed as a pull
of so many pounds per ton, or as a certain total drawbar pull at the
head end of the train, or as so much negative grade, thus cutting down
the actual grade and producing a lower virtual grade. For our pur-
pose the simplest method is to express momentum as so much negative
grade and its value may be figured by the following formula :
x
Where Gm = equivalent grade in per cent.
V — speed in miles per hour
x = distance traversed during retardation, in feet.
Where a minimum speed of five miles per hour at top of grade is
assumed, the equivalent grade would be determined as follows:
V*— '25
Gn> = 3-5 r
X
For convenience we show Fig. 3, from which can readily be obtained
the equivalent grade in per cent., having the speed of approach and
length of grade, based on this formula. Having the actual grade and
the momentum expressed as equivalent grade, the virtual grade is equal
to the actual grade minus the momentum grade. The actual resistance
of the train is, then, that due to the virtual grade plus the friction.
TRACTIVE FORCE AT SPEED.
Where the speed is above 8 or 10 miles per hour, the maximum
tractive force cannot be sustained on account of the inability of the boiler
to furnish sufficient steam, and when calculating tonnage rates on mo-
mentum grades, it is necessary to determine the average tractive force
from the bottom to the top of the hill. It might be well to mention here
that some engines are a bit over-cylindered ; i. e., their tractive force
figured from the cylinders is higher than the boiler can maintain, even
at lower speeds. On the low-grade lines, where the train has to run at
a considerable speed over the ruling grade, such engines should really
be rated on their boiler capacities. This falling off of tractive force due
to limit of boiler is shown for our various engines at speeds up to 40
miles per hour in Fig. 4.
1158 EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
The tractive force shown on these curves as limited by the boiler
is obtained by the following formula :
_ .. ' 375 X -43^ e
Tractive t orce = — R
S
Where H = heating surface in sq. ft.
S = speed in miles per hour
R = the total resistance in pounds of the engine and tender.
The expression .43 H gives the maximum cylinder horsepower of
the locomotive assuming an evaporation of 12 lbs. of water per square
foot of heating surface per hour, and a cylinder water rate of 28 lbs.
of water per horsepower hour. This is a formula given by Professor
Goss and the results of our locomotive tests agree well with it, so we have
375 X -43 H
adopted the same. The expression converts horsepower into
cylinder tractive force. Now to convert this cylinder tractive force
into drawbar tractive force we must subtract R, the total resistance of
the engine and tender. R is gotten by multiplying the weight in tons of
the engine and tender with half load of coal and water by the resistance
per ton at given speed as obtained from curve in Fig. 5. This curve
is the average of the engine resistance curves of engines C, B. & Q.
1967, 1989, 3156, C. & A. 340, and Erie 1776, all of which engines were
pulling full tonnage on the tests from which these curves were taken.
The tractive force shown on the above-mentioned sheets of curves,
at the average speed, will generally be found satisfactory. In figuring
on a momentum grade it is necessary to know the speed limit of the
division for freight trains, and whether there are any permanent slow
orders at foot of hills due to bad curves, crossover, etc. It is hardly
safe to regard as a momentum grade any grade over ilA miles long or
one that has several reverse curves on it.
EQUATED TONNAGE TABLES.
Having the total resistance per ton of any given train and the maxi-
mum working tractive force of the engine, the thing is now to get sufficient
tonnage to just make total train resistance to balance this tractive force.
The number of tons that will give this total resistance will, of course,
vary with the load per car and the weather conditions, increasing as
the load per car increases, and decreasing as the weather conditions
become more severe. For operating use we get up a rate table, showing
the number of tons for various number of cars in the train and for
four weather conditions, namely :
Rate "A" — Temperature above 30 degrees Fahrenheit and not much
wind.
Rate "B" — Temperature between zero and 30 degrees Fahrenheit, or
strong head or side wind, or frosty rail.
Rate "C" — Temperature between zero and 30 degrees Fahrenheit,
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING. 1159
and strong head or side wind, or temperature below zero and not much
wind.
Rate "D" — Temperature below zero, with strong head or side wind.
The method in detail of obtaining these tables is shown in Fig. 6.
EXPLANATION OF METHOD.
The tables in Fig. 6 show method used in calculating equated tonnage
tables. The various tonnages shown all have the same drawbar resist-
ance of 20,ooo lbs., and are calculated for a 0.5 per cent, grade at freight
speeds of 20 miles per hour. The method is to make a column of gross
car weights from 10 tons to 60 tons, column 1. In column 2 is shown
the resistance per ton of cars of the various gross weights. This includes
the grade and the friction resistances per ton. Next we divide 20,000
by the resistance per ton, and get column 3, showing the various tonnages
having the total train resistance of 20,000 lbs. Then by dividing the num-
ber of tons by the gross weight per car we get column 4, showing the
number of cars in the train corresponding to the various tonnages. The
columns of tons are then interpolated to the nearest even figure divisible
by 5 and corresponding to an even number of cars divisible by 5 and
placed in column 12, which is the column as finally used in rate schedules.
Having column 12, the columns 5 to 10, inclusive, are obtained from
columns 11 and 12 by multiplying by a suitable factor. For example,
columns 5 and 6 are the intermediate steps in getting the "B" rate, and
are gotten by use of the factor .83, the ratio of resistance per ton of
a 40-ton car on a 0.5 per cent, grade in warm weather (curve 1), to
the resistance per ton of a 40-ton car on a 0.5 per cent, grade in zero
to 30 degrees Fahrenheit weather (curve 2). This ratio or factor would
vary slightly between the 10-ton car and the 60-ton car ; the factors shown
are gotten by taking an average of the ratios for the cars of following
weights: 10, 11, 12, 14, 16, 18, 20, 25, 30, 40, 50 and 60 tons. The
tons and cars thus obtained are interpolated to even figures and the
tonnage placed in column 13, opposite the proper number of cars. The
other columns are obtained similarly by using the suitable factor selected
from table shown on the print.
Tables have been made showing the tonnages for grades from 0.3
per cent, to 1.6 per cent., and for total train resistances from 10,000 to
35,000 lbs. When, therefore, we have decided on the maximum working
tractive force on a given grade, we simply select from the set of tables
the suitable schedule and give this as the tonnage rate schedule for the
engine. For practical use the rates thus decided upon are gotten out on
tonnage rating sheets for each division, which show the number of cars
and tons for the different rating divisions and for all classes of engines
on that division. A page from the time-card of the Aurora Division of
the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad, showing engine rates on
that division, is given with this article as Fig. 7.
1160
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
•J
r
0
i
d
M
■
a
•
•
i
u
u
i
cC
D
o
z
u
I
: Q
M
u !
j
<n 3
& \
2 j
i i
< !
j
I
h
I
«
y
T
M
2
N
5
91
3
0
0
o
o
5
cm
9,
CO"
3
]
r
0
o
o
CM
o
o
o
r;
uo
o
CO
2tf
«1
0
0
8
a
o
LA
O
if
o
a
u
j
ft."
1
■a
0
fM
o
!
o
i
0
in
(l
isl
¥
5
<0
ID
0
V9
o
e
CO
o
ID
|
<M
3
<>
q:'
ip
*
0
CD
r
0
13
0
o
<0
fO
N
<5
O
r.
o
o
n
n
N
2
i
0
0
0
o
p
*■
o
o
CM
iO
cm
c
r-
s
N
oT
o
r*
0
o
o
r
p
o
10
t
en"
r-
M
IP
IP
'J
10
■>j>
N
x
0
o
0
,0
o
o
m
O
P>
in
F
J
3
N
0
0
0
0
rO
O
in
it
rJ'
s
(J
in
CJ
h
Ifl
o
o
M
0
0
*
ill
isl
I
t
<
<n
i
0
a
o
o
s
3
o
o
r-
5
ID
o
II
^
^
5
IS
U)
O
O
0
d
2
^
CM
X
'ol
CM
*
O
N
o
a
c0
o
o
CM
Itf
CO
r
to
I
X
E
Q
r
o
o
o
o
p
*
'£!
a
<
It
o
r
0
o
i
o
r
m
CM
r-
in
«5
*
0
rJ
o
o
o
ro
s
CM
i
P-
r-
>n
I
'4
0
r
o
o
5
o
o
r-
£
iM
in
ip
CM
X
E
0
0
0
5
o
o
s
o
o
n
s
CO
oS
O
C-J
or
CM
0
N
O
O
O
m
CO
o
o
M
«6
m
co
*
(0
0
vn
in
I
•
■a
X
'2
0
£
o
o
5
5
O
O
P
f
+
^
*
2
5
8
CM
§
N
O
O
CO
Lf)
CM
O
CM
c0
a:
M
>
0
IP
0
o
N
8
(M
«
CM
<5
o
en
o'
o
CO
t*
m
o
r
ip.
X
o
ip
o
0
CM
0
e
<i
P
'g
M
r-
0
o
C>J
0
o
M
rj
M
o
o
to
in
CM
O
*
cJ
o
0
O
N
o
o
Ul
Ul
N
i
i
CM
i
<M
rf
»<
'-4
CM
IS
a
8
Id
<M
t
a
s
in
r
n
<
0
0
ID
o
o
F
o
o
M
lO
s
r
DC
X
in
0
0
O
U3
OS
N
0
CM
n
to
r
m
to
P
N
K
'oJ
N
P4
U)
0
o
o
M
en
r)
o
o
10
s
,1
to
a
(31
N
■A
Si
I
0
10
o
o
*
5
8
o
CM
E
a+
v5
CJ
X
2
r
o
o
CM
O
J)
s
CM
o
o
<t
r
CM
$
u>
CM
•1
P
3
o
cm
Ul
o
ID
O
8
3
o
0'
o
2
o
o
o
©
cm-
is!
o
i
t
s
or
CM
in
>
0
N
0
o
in
M
CM
o
o
o
p
cO
IP
o
•J
to
vn
<
J
£
Id
Q
Z
J
>
J
<
P
i0
at
u
>
a:
Q
ft
U
or:
P-
r
5
u
J
cC
o
U.
>
Of
r
a
Hi
i
o
u
U
<
u.
DC
3?
o
z
E
u
I
in
in
<
j
0
in
qC
u
o
z
J
)-
0
<
5
>n
or
Ui
>
m
io
u
a:
Z
<c
u
h
u
u
0
u.
Ul
>
J
<
2
K
I
O
u
u
J
<£
£
3i
o
z
E
uJ
X
in
J
/I
a:
Ui
Q
z
>
0
I
<
5
in
>
a
/)
U
a:
a.
I
<
UJ
u
J
a:
o
u.
U
>
P
o
<t
H
m4
I
u
O
IT
3
in
0
z
1
ul
1
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
1161
;::::u»9:::i::::::::::::::::
::..'■ ;::■;::: .:.•:
Fig. 2 — Curves of Train Resistance, Frictional and Grade.
1162
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
1163
speed >h miles per. hour. — *»
Fig. 4 — Curves of Tractive Force of Engines of C. B. & Q. R. R.
1164
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
1165
^8.1
P
'-0
If)
o
p
(33
0
(TV
33
0
51
c
Ul
m
i?>
o
in
0
6
Ul
t
o
Ul
p
0
Ul
0
0
*
0
<0
lit
HlH
p
CO
00
05
IT)
CO
0
ffi
0
ffl
ul via *
0 ov o
^ a j> <
tt VO tf
0 <i« J
in
h
<
J
in
in
ff>
0
if)
0
p
ff>
o
SI
0
0
m
i"
0
0
Ul
0
0
ti
0
0
0
Ul
«1
0
in
N
0
p
si
0
0
Ul
i
d
0
(0
i
z
I.I
r-V°
?
si
si
ir>
in
Ifl
SJ
O" 0
[1
0 1-
D3
0
4-
0
(i)
0
0
0
0
0
in
si
0
in
0
10
0
M
0
m
M
Ul
a
0
rJ
in
0
0
0
♦
0
*
O
in
*
rO
r*!^
0
o
o
SI
?
p
ffi
<
0
o
O
0
si
0
N
N
Ul
4-
id
0
r
0
0
i«
0
I"
0
10
0
U)
IC
0
0
in
m
in
in
Ul
r
Ul
in
5
sJ
<
t-
7
S 3
< s
Ul
8
p
©
ffl
O
IM
m
u O
£
n
0
m
o
Ul
0
in
0
Ul
O
in
0
in
O
Ul
o
0
si
+
in
10
;**
<
U
0
<T>
P
tf
<3
r
p
I!)
ii*
in
♦
*
i«
H
a
z
tfl
CO
CO
to
op
03
00
03
iO
* ■
u
h
P
<
0
0
J
p?|hJ
(S
p
(0
00
U3
0
ill
O
01
o
ffl
ffl
4
fi
u
<j
i
i-
?
m
ui
r?
a:
2
P
n
h'ih"
ffl
rn
IT.
*
CI
in
Ifl
in
in
ffi
«
0 JJ
■n
z
z
p
3*
J
tfl
iq
m
<0
(0
a
j
HI
a
*
(9
SI
oO
(0
in
in
in
r
M
r*l
in
r
o
a
a:
«J
0
Z
(f
U z
<D
ffl
o
-
si
Ul
si
io
*
X r
5*
•; 2
u
<n
cO
r
r
r
IP
It
«
*
+
ro
0 i
CL
in
0
o
n
id
0
fl
n
O
Ul
0
a
LI
Ul
in
0
'J
r I
£
z
ill
»
m
m
in
iO
0
A
it
Hi
*
r
(1
s
r-V"
ip
EC
Ul
5 *
h J
o
«■-
ffi
iii
ff>
0
o
o
(j
N
N
n
ui
z
0
p
17
r-
P
Ji
lO
3
a
u
*
0
ffl
<
J
0
0
5
ID
r
r
ID
»1
*
Ul
0
*
|<1
a
P
Si
si
N
a>
II
0
0
r
4
htf|i-J
V3
3D
if
T
p
p;
CO
10
cO
s
l/l
CO
i/
u
h
tC
"J ■"" u
• I
r II
SO
r
P
si
+
0
Ifl
0
0
(0
a
0
0
o
it
0
r
0
0
rvl
rJ
Ifl
Ul
rJ
Ul
•i
M
0
0
In
|fl
o
09
|0
Ul
m
Ul
Ul
r-V
It
to
$
*
ffi
a
ffl
sJ
ffl
in
<
«
*
vj>
It
r
M
vO
O
0>
P
U X
i;1
o , o 8
Z l< T
vi 5S i
VI i w
T J Vl U
1,1 J 2 t-
< 5 < o
<
ei
r
it
<0
u>
J)
it)
ID
*
0
si
tO
*
m
U>
p
u
-
0
0
09
p
p
4
in
<T
(^
p
PI
d
* i
<
z
P
p
iO
0
p
(J
(J
r
0
ffi
N
(0
ffl
J
'Ul
Ul
m
0
0
IS
Cl
i
z
0
F
i
u
i
i
r
§ e £
1 I P « P J
r < «i So 5 5
k 0 u t v
t u r Jo vi -
l < i '8
uZ< <>
fi
*
Is
10
it
ffi
in
in
in
in
+
4
n
0
m
cvl
O fc £ r
:<*#<
<
u^r
£ ^8
!
r
0
u
<
r « i
o JJ <
a
-
M
«•
It
(0
0
0
n
0
0
II)
0
IB
-
u
'1
M 1-
.d 5' .'» J
r
■PC
F
r *
h
1-
Fig. 6 — Sample Data Sheet Showing Method of Calculating Equated
Train Resistances In Tons of Train.
*On grades of 0.5 per cent, and under the D rate is 90 per cent, of the
C rate.
1166
EQUATED TONNAGE RATING.
1
[ON
"
o
0
265
285
310
330
350
375
395
415
435
465
600
530
560
505
630
llslsssslsslip? :
I J 1
o
|| | § | S S § i § | 3 S 3 |
ISIlslil'gllil8 !
: j
n
2S|SS|SS2SS||| ;
gSSsslillslsiS 1
1 1 *
ssslllsslssssi 1
1 -8
w s
> 5
3 s
t
c
3
53
omouioiooiooiooiootno
oiooiootoowowowow
ooio)oto(-sioii)inioi^r)
I 111
si |
o-anasa-ivo ox vxoaMam
vioaNaw ox ouaasaivo
i"e
O
P
< »
1 A
VI „
W g
H
Ph
S
o
a
8SSSS825S5SS8S j
S S g ? 2 8 3 8 8 8 S S S 8 f- g
H-^H
o
n
2 | | S S S 8 | | S 3 § § § |
'58S8S5S8888388S
i W
h"h
s s 3 s § i i 1 § 1 1 a ! i :
s^s^gsssssn^
I w a
<
II1IIIII lllll 1 1
S££g;2SS£g2SS£SS
6
o .
►H V.
3
K
O
a
3
a
£j
oiootooinowowotoowo
otooiooinotoomotnoioou]
OOOlCQCDt-NCDtDlfltO^^CJOCN
s 1
vxoaNaw ox vaosnv
aaAio ox vioaNaw
aaiao ox vnoihvhs
VNoaavHs ox vsnvatb
1
B A
o a
8
o
0
o8o55SSS8883°88
»2 111 Is 1 all a II
I llri
a
1 slsss 35 1 Is 1 II?
28
SgggSSPSSSSPSS
m
I:
la la 1 III 1 lllll
£ 1
<
I 1 § g g g i g 1 1 1 § 1 i 1
s s
8S2S SS8SS8S8S8
! a a
*
c
E
5
5
I
a
5°
oifloiooinowowoinoioo
oo>o>(DooNN(0(otou>^^nn
O a
omo io omotoo io omoin
JJ1
*
FHOHOT OX 3QA70
O-IOa OX NO33B0 HajI3H
VJJMVAV8 01 VHOHOV
««
|S|
C!
& W
s t>
0
a
w
<
Pi
^
o
p
C4
K
LJ
<
< o
pt.
W
o
8
en
W
H
H
<
&
p2
i — i
w
£
<
'A
to
/,
qn
H
fe
EQUATED TOim AGE for .3$ GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - 12,500
Ho.
Of
000
10
,500
11
,000
Bars
A
B
c
D
A
B
G
D
A
B
c
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
760
810
70
730
785
840
65
755
815
870
70G
60
785
620
845
680
905
730
610
55
820
650
555
880
710
595
945
760
640
575
50
855
685
580
520
920
750
625
565
985
795
670
600
46
900
725
610
550
965
795
655
590
1030
840
705
635
40
945
765
650
585
1015
845
695
625
1G80
885
745
670
35
995
805
690
620
1065
895
740
665
1135
930
790
710
30
1050
855
735
660
1120
950
790
710
1190
980
840
755
25
1105
905
790
710
1175
1000
840
755
1245
1040
895
805
20
1170
960
845
760
1235
1050
895
805
1305
1100
955
860
15
905
815
950
855
1015
915
10
5
So.
of
Sara
11,
500
12 1
OGO
12,
500
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
870
925
80
835
895
950
75
865
925
980
70
895
710
955
760
1015
820
65
930
740
990
790
675
1050
860
715
60
965
770
655
1030
830
700
630
1090
900
745
670
55
1005
810
685
615
1070
870
730
655
1130
940
775
700
50
1050
850
720
650
1115
910
765
69G
1180
980
810
730
45
1G95
890
755
680
1165
960
805
725
1230
1030
850
765
40
1150
940
796
715
1220
1C00
845
760
1285
1080
895
805
35
1205
990
840
755
1275
1050
895
805
1340
1120
945
850
30
1260
1040
890
800
1330
1100
950
855
1400
1160
1000
9G0
25
1320
1090
950
855
1390
1160
1010
910
1460
1210
1060
95E
20
1380
1140
1010
910
1070
960
1120
1010
15
1070
960
1130
1015
10
*
Note. — Tables showing
jiven in Bulletin 138.
train resistance from 12,500 to 35,000 lbs. are
1167
EQUATED T 0 B H A G E for .4$ GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - IS, 500
no.
of
:
10,5C(
Hi
oco
Cars
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D.
A
B
c
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
615
665
710
60
640
690
735
625
55
665
565
710
610
760
650
555
60
690
590
505
740
635
540
790
675
680
520
45
720
615
530
475
770
660
670
510
820
700
605
540
40
750
640
560
505
800
685
600
540
860
730
636
570
35
785
670
590
530
835
715
630
570
885
760
670
600
30
820
710
625
550
870
750
665
600
920
790
706
630
25
850
750
660
595
910
790
700
630
960
830
740
665
20
900
790
695
625
955
830
740
665
1015
870
780
700
15
960
830
740
666
1016
880
795
715
1075
920
830
745
10
5
795
715
Bo.
of
Cara
11,500
12,000
12,
600
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
750
795
70
730
775
820
65
755
800
670
846
60
780
660
826
700
606
876
640
55
806
690
590
855
730
630
660
905
770
665
600
60
836
715
615
550
886
760
655
590
935
800
695
625
45
870
746
845
580
920
790
685
620
970
830
726
660
40
905
775
675
610
956
820
720
650
1006
865
760
685
35
940
810
710
640
990
860
755
680
1040
905
796
716
30
976
850
745
670
1026
900
790
710
1080
960
830
745
26
1015
890
780
700
1070
940
826
740
1125
990
870
780
20
1070
930
825
740
1130
990
870
780
1185
1040
915
825
15
875
785
925
830
970
870
10
6*
IK
E Q 0 A T E D T 0 H H A G E for .5ff GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - 1£,500
Ho.
of
lq^ooo
lO.BOG
11,
000
Cars
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
G
• D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
615
55
560
600
635
50
580
620
535
655
560
515
45
600
520
470
640
560
500
450
680
590
530
475
40
625
545
485
435
665
585
520
470
705
620
560
495
35
650
575
505
455
695
615
540
490
735
650
575
615
30
680
605
530
480
725
645
565
510
770
680
600
540
25
715
635
565
510
760
675
600
540
805
710
635
570
20
750
665
600
540
795
705
635
570
840
745
670
600
15
790
700
635
570
835
740
675
610
880
780
710
640
10
5
830
740
670
600
875
780
715
645
745
670
No.
of
Cars
11,500
- r- ^
12,
500
12,
A
B
C
D
A
B
c
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
675
700
60
655
695
725
630
55
675
575
715
610
560
750
650
585
50
695
600
545
735
630
575
515
775
675
605
545
45
720
625
565
510
760
660
595
535
805
700
625
560
40
750
655
585
525
790
690
615
555
835
730
650
585
35
780
685
610
550
825
720
645
580
870
760
680
610
30
815
720
640
575
860
750
675
605
905
790
715
646
25
850
605
895
790
710
640
940
830
750
675
750
675
20
885
785
710
640
930
830
746
670
975
870
785
706
15
925
825
745
670
970
870
785
705
1015
910
820
740
10
5
785
705
825
740
855
770
1169
EQUATED HIIAGE for .6j6 G R A D B
Beeietances 10,000 - 12,500
lo.
of
lO.ooo
10,
BOO
11,
000
Cars
A
B
C
B
A
B
c
B
A
B
C
B
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
650
50
500
635
570
500
45
520
465,
555
490
590
520
466
40
540
475
430
675
510
445
610
540
485
426
25
560
495
445
390
596
630
475
630
560
505
445
30
580
520
460
410
615
560
495
436
666
585
625
465
£6
605
545
485
430
640
575
520
460
660
610
560
490
20
635
570
510
450
670
600
545
485
T10
635
580
516
15
665
600
545
485
705
630
575
516
746
665
610
545
10
5
700
630
575
520
740
660
606
650
780
700
640
585
Ho.
Of
11,500
12,
000
12,
600
Cars
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
B
100
96
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
600
635
65
585
620
665
676
60
605
535
640
566
510
676
595
535
46
625
555
490
660
686
520
460
695
616
560
486
40
645
576
510
450
680
605
640
475
716
636
570
505
66
665
596
630
470
700
630
660
496
740
660
690
525
60
690
6S0
555
490
725
656
685
615
766
690
615
545
25
720
645
580
516
766
680
610
640
795
715
640
570
20
750
670
610
640
786
705
635
565
825
740
670
695
15
785
700
640
670
815
735
670
595
855
770
706
625
10
6
820
730
670
610
850
766
706
635
740
660
1170
EQUATED T 0 H B A G E for .7$ GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - 12,500
So.
of
Cars
10.000
10,500
11,600"
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
606
45
460
490
520
480
40
470
430
500
460
416
535
490
435
35
485
445
400
355
515
475
425
360
650
606
460
405
30
506
460
410
370
535
490
435
395
570
520
465
420
25
525
475
430
385
555
505
455
410
595
540
486
440
20
550
495
455
410
580
525
480
436
620
560
610
460
15
575
520
480
435
605
545
505
460
645
585
535
485
10
605
550
505
460
640
580
636
485
670
610
560
510
5
530
485
515
"Bo.
of
Cars
lit
500
IS,
000
12 ,
500
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
i
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
675
50
535
560
500
590
626
45
550
500
575
520
470
605
545
495
40
565
515
460
416
690
540
485
435
620
565
516
460
35
585
530
476
430
610
560
500
450
640
585
525
476
30
605
550
490
445
635
580
520
466
665
605
645
490
25
630
570
510
465
660
600
540
485
690
625
565
510
20
655
590
535
485
685
620
565
510
716
650
590
635
15
680
620
560
510
710
645
590
635
740
680
615
560
10
705
650
585
535
740
670
615
660
765
700
640
585
5
560
586
1171
EQUATED TONNAGE for .8$ GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - 12,500
No.
of
10,
000
10,
500
11,000
Dars
A
B
G
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
96
90
85
*i
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
465
40
425
450
405
480
435
35
440
400
360
465
420
385
350
495
450
410
375
30
455
415
375
345
480
435
400
365
510
465
425
390
25
470
430
390
360
495
450
415
380
525
480
440
405
20
490
450
410
375
515
470
435
395
545
500
460
420
15
510
470
430
395
540
490
455
415
570
520
480
440
10
535
490
455
415
565
510
480
440
595
540
505
466
6
480
440
505
465
530
490
No.
of
Cars
a,
12,
000
12,500
A
B
C
C
D
A
B
C
D
D
A
B
ioo
95
90
85
80
75
-
70
65
60
55
50
500
525
45
490
515
470
540
495
450
40
505
455
415
530
485
440
400
555
505
465
420
35
520
470
430
375
545
500
455
415
570
520
480
435
30
535
485
445
410
560
515
470
430
585
535
495
450
25
550
500
460
425
580
530
490
445
605
550
510
465
20
570
520
480
440
600
550
510
465
625
670
530
485
15
595
545
500
460
625
575
530
485
650
595
550
505
10
5
625
570
525
485
650
600
555
510
675
680
575
550
1172
EQUATED T 0 H II A G E for .9# GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - 12,500
No.
of
Cars
10,000
10,
500
11,000
A
B
C
C
D
A
B
C
D
D
A
B
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
405
430
35
395
355
415
375
350
440
400
375
30
410
370
345
320
430
390
365
335
455
415
390
360
8S
425
385
360
335
445
405
380
345
470
430
405
375
20
440
400
375
350
465
425
395
360
485
450
420
390
15
460
420
395
365
485
445
415
375
505
470
440
405
10
480
440
415
385
505
465
435
395
530
490
460
425
5
435
410
Mo.
of
11,.
12,500
500
lc»
JOU
Cars
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
loo
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
460
485
40
450
410
475
430
400
500
455
420
35
465
420
395
365
490
445
415
385
515
470
435
405
30
480
435
410
380
505
460
430
400
530
485
450
420
25
495
450
425
395
525
480
445
415
550
500
465
435
20
515
470
440
410
545
500
465
430
570
520
485
450
15
535
490
460
425
565
520
485
450
590
540
5C5
470
10
555
510
480
445
585
540
505
470
610
560
525
490
5
1173
^^"B T 0 B H A G E f o r l.Og Q R A p S
Resistanoes 10,000 - 12,600
Ho,
Of
Cars
10
OGO
10.
500
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
. .. _ _
C
s
A
B
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
360
380
355
400
375
30
370
340
320
300
390
365
335
315
415
385
366
335
25
380
350
330
310
405
375
345
325
430
395
366
345
20
395
365
340
320
415
385
360
340
445
410
380
360
15
410
380
355
335
435
405
375
355
460
425
395
370
10
430
400
375
350
455
425
395
370
480
445
415
390
5 '
396
370
390
Ho.
of
Oars
11,500
12,
000
12,500
A
B
C
D
A
B
A
B
C
D
C
D
LOO
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
405
435
400
455
420
35
420
390
365
445
410
386
360
465
430
400
375
30
435
400
376
350
460
425
395
370
450
445
410
385
25
450
415
385
360
476
440
410
380
496
460
425
395
20
465
430
400
375
490
455
425
395
510
475
440
410
15
485
450
416
390
510
475
440
410
530
495
460
435
10
5
505
470
435
410
530
495
460
430
550
515
480
450
1174
EQUATED T 0 B H A G E for 1.156 GRADE
assistances 10,000 - 18,600
So.
of
Care
' 16.000
10.600
11.000
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
66
80
75
TO
6B
60
55
60
45
40
56
350
370
50
540
315
360
336
380
355
330
305
£5
350
326
306
280
370
345
326
300
396
370
345
320
20
565
340
320
295
385
360
340
315
410
386
360
335
15
380
355
325
310
400
576
365
350
425
400
375
350
10
5
395
370
360
326
415
390
370
345
440
415
390
365
5o.
of
11,500
lE^OOO
12,600
Jars
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
LOO
95
90
85
80
75
70
66
60
55
£0
46
40
400
420
55
390
360
410
380
430
400
380
355
50
400
370
350
326
420
390
370
345
440
410
390
365
56
415
386
366
340
435
405
380
366
465
426
400
375
SO
450
400
380
355
450
420
395
570
470
440
4].5
390
16
446
416
396
370
465
436
410
386
485
455
430
406
10
460
430
410
385
480
450
425
400
500
470
446
420
5
1175
EQUATED TONNAGE for 1.2ft GRADE
RaBiatanoea 10,000 - 12,500
No.
10,000
10.500
n.
000
of "
Care
A
B
C
n
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
^
85
80
75
70
65
feO
55
50
45
40
35
30
315
330
310
350
330
310
25
325
305
285
270
340
320
300
285
360
340
320
300
20
335
315
295
280
355
330
310
295
375
355
330
310
15
350
330
310
290
370
345
325
305
390
370
345
320
10
365
345
325
305
385
360
340
320
405
385
360
335
5
380
360
340
320
400
375
355
335
420
400
375
350
No.
of
11,500
12,000
12
.500
Cara
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
*
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
360
380
355
395
370
30
370
350
325
305
390
365
345
325
405
380
360
340
25
380
365
335
315
400
375
355
335
420
395
370
350
20
395
370
345
325
415
390
365
345
435
410
380
360
15
410
385
360
335
430
405
380
355
450
425
395
370
10
425
400
375
350
445
420
395
370
465
440
410
385
5
440
1
395
370
1
415
. . . .
390
|
425
400
1176
B Q 0 A T E D T 0 H H A G E for 1.8
Resistances 10,000 - 12,500
G R A DE
»0.~
10
000
"10"
of
Cars
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
D
A
_..-U
B
,000
C
B
10Q
95
90
66
80
76
70
66
60
56
50
46
40
66
20
205
326
305
330
340
320
200
£80
£6
£0
15
10
6
215
226
325
250
270
£96
205
215
230
350
i
£80
290
300
215
220
—
260
270
280
290
306
336
346
366
370
386
315
225
325
260
265
296
305
315
330
345
275
285
296
306
320
350
360
370
386
400
330
340
350
365
280
210
220
230
245
260
290
300
210
220
225
5o.
of
2ara
11,600
1£,
000
500
A
B
0
B
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
B
LOO
95
90
66
80
76
70
66
60
65
60
45
40
36
20
250
260
340
2£0
365
376
350
360
335
310
385
396
265
275
256
226
£6
£0
15
10
6
270
280
390
405
420
360
360
370
386
400
220
240
260
266
280
305
316
326
335
350
385
396
410
425
370
380
290
405
345
355
365
380
400
220
330
340
355
270
405
416
430
445
285
395
410
425
265
376
386
400
226
345
365
370
385
1177
B Q U A T B D T 0 H S A G B for l.H GHAH
Eesistano68 10,000 - 12.R00
do.
of
Cars
10.000
10.500'
11.000
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
B
100
95
90
65
60
-
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
305
325
305
£5
£0
15
10
5
300
310
3£0
335
£85
£95
305
320
£66
275
285
300
£50
260
270
£65
315
325
335
350
300
310
320
335
280
290
300
315
265
276
285
300
335
345
355
370
385
315
326
335
350
370
295
305
315
330
345
£80
290
300
315
330
Ho.
of
Cars
11,500
12,000
12,500
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
B
A
B
C
B
100
95
90
86
80
76
70
66
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
345
325
355
365
345
320
306
370
380
360
360
336
320
£5
£0
16
10
5
355
365
376
390
405
335
346
355
370
385
310
320
330
345
360
295
305
315
330
345
376
385
395
410
366
366
375
390
330
340
350
365
380
315
325
335
350
365
390
400
410
425
370
380
390
405
345
355
365
380
395
330
340
360
366
380
1178
Q 0 A T E J T 0 H H A S E for 1.4# 0 R A D B
Resistances 10,000 - 12.500
Ho.
10^000
10. BOO
11.000
of
Cars
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
S
A
B
C
B
100
95
90
85
80
76
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
80
305
£6
286
270
256
300
285
270
315
300
280
£65
20
295
280
266
260
310
£96
£80
266
325
310
290
£75
15
306
290
278
£60
320
505
290
276
335
820
300
285
10
316
300 285
270
330
515
300
285
350
330
316
800
5
525
310 295
£80
346
330
310
296
366
346
330
315
Ho.
of
11,500
12.000
12,500
Cars
A
B
0
D
A
B C
D
A
B
C
B
100
■
95
90
86
60
76
70
65
60
56
60
46
40
35
30
320
306
340
320
305
366
386
320
25
330
316
295
280
360
330
315
300
365
345
330
315
20
340
325
305
290
360
340
325
310
375
8bb
340
325
15
350
335
315
300
370
360
355
320
385
365
350
335
10
365
345
330
316
385
365
360
335
400
380
365
350
5
380
360
346
330
400
380
365
350
415
395
380
365
1179
EQUATED TOHHAGE for 1.5$ GRADE
Resistances 10,000 - 12,500
Bo.
of
io.Ooo
16,500
11,000
3ars
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
265
255
280
265
250
295
280
265
250
20
275
265
250
245
290
275
260
255
305
290
275
260
15
285
275
260
250
300
285
270
260
315
300
285
270
10
295
285
270
260
310
295
280
270
325
310
295
280
5
310
295
280
270
325
310
295
____ _
280
— _
340
325
310
295
Ho.
of
11,500
12,000
12,500
Sara
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
A
B
C
D
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
305
320
305
330
315
25
310
295
280
260
325
310
285
275
340
325
310
290
20
320
305
290
270
335
320
305
285
366
335
320
300
15
330
315
300
280
345
330
315
295
360
345
330
310
10
340
325
310
290
355
340
325
305
375
355
340
320
5
355
340
320
305
370
355
335
320
390
370
355
336
r
1180
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
(Bulletin X45.)
By L. C. Fritch, Chief Engineer, Chicago Great Western Railroad.
INTRODUCTORY.
The Storage Battery is rapidly coming into prominent use in various
operations in railway service, such as Train Lighting, Station Light-
ing, Signaling and Interlocking, Operation of Drawbridges, Motor Truck
and Motor Car Propulsion, Telephone and Telegraph work, Supplement-
ing the Load on Current Supply Systems, and numerous other uses to
which it is readily adapted.
A brief outline of the theory and principal characteristics of the stor-
age battery is herein submitted with the thought that it will prove of some
service to the Engineer in solving the problems that daily confront him in
his work. An effort has been made to present the subject in an elementary
form and as briefly as consistent, and although the entire subject is not
fully treated, it embodies the essential features of a branch of the electrical
field which is daily becoming more and more important in railway opera-
tion.
HISTORY.
The principle of the Storage Battery has been known for over one
hundred years. Gautherot in 1801 discovered that a secondary current
could be obtained from a cell which consisted of two silver or plati-
num electrodes immersed in a common salt solution.
The cell was first charged by passing a current through it, then
breaking the charging current ; he connected the two electrodes to the
terminals of a galvanometer and obtained a momentary deflection, in-
dicating a flow of current in a direction opposite to the charging cur-
rent.
While the discovery of the principle of the storage, or secondary,
battery may be said to date from 1801, no further development of note
was made in its application to practical use until 1842, when Sir William
Grove constructed a gas battery, which established the first progress to-
ward a commercial accumulator.
Grove's battery consisted of a pair of platinum strips immersed in
dilute sulphuric acid, each strip being surrounded on top and sides by
a closed glass tube, which collected the gas developed in charge, and kept
1181
1182 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
each gas in contact with its respective electrode and some of the adjoin-
ing acid surface. After a charge was passed through this battery and
its terminals, then connected with a galvanometer, a small current in
reverse direction was perceived for some time, until the oxygen and
hydrogen developed by the charge gradually became absorbed by the
platinum and recombined to form water. While this was an important
advance over the discovery of Gautherot, it resulted in no practical value,
and with all the development since Grove's time it has failed of com-
mercial value.
In i860 Plante, a Frenchman, developed the next important step in
storage battery development, which was destined to prove of great com^
mercial value. His experiments consisted in making a cell using lead
strips instead of platinum, immersed in dilute sulphuric acid. This
cell on being charged yielded a considerable reverse, or "secondary,"
current. Plante's important discovery was that each time such a cell
was charged and discharged the quantity of "secondary" current in-
creased, and further experiments developed that, not merely discharging,
but charging in the reverse direction each time, the capacity was brought
up rapidly. By these discoveries batteries of sufficient capacity to render
them commercially valuable were produced. The subsequent develop-
ments and changes made in the Plante type of battery have been along
the same fundamental lines, so that to Plante must be accorded the honor
of first having developed a commercially practicable storage, or sec-
ondary, battery.
Plante found that the lead plate which was connected to the nega-
tive pole of the primary source of power became coated with a film of
dark brown peroxide of lead, and the lead plate connected with the posi-
tive pole was coated with spongy, metallic lead. Each time the charging
current was reversed, more of the metallic lead became peroxidized and
the gradual accumulation of this film of "active material" on both plates
caused the increased capacity of the cell.
Plante arranged a large series of cells, through which he continually
passed a current, first in one direction and then in the reverse, the dura-
tion of charge gradually increasing, and by this process the plates accu-
mulated considerable thickness, respectively, of active porous lead and
lead peroxide on their surfaces. After one to two months of this forma-
tive process, the plates were ready for use.
The "forming" process for converting solid lead into active material
was tedious and expensive, and the next progress made consisted in over-
coming this difficulty. Plante's experiments were made during a time
when electricity had limited uses, and not until the dynamo was per-
fected was the urgent necessity of storage batteries imminent.
In 1881 Faure, another Frenchman, discovered a process of forming
the plates of batteries without the tedious and expensive process used by
Plante. Instead of electro-chemically treating the surface of the metal-
lic lead plate, Faure covered the surface with lead oxide in the first in-
stance. A single charge was then sufficient to convert this into lead
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1183
peroxide on the one plate and metallic lead upon the other. This in-
vention marked the last stride toward the perfection of the storage bat-
tery for practical use.
At the same time and working entirely independently of Faure,
Brush, in America, arrived at the same results as did Faure, so that in
this country we give to Brush the honor of producing the battery known
as the "pasted plate" battery.
All lead battery plates made at the present time are either after the
Plante type, where part of the metallic lead plate is chemically acted upon
to produce the active material, or else after the Brush-Faure, or pasted
type, where the active material, usually in the form of an oxide of lead,
forms an integral part of the original plate.
Great improvement, however, has been made in details of design,
construction and process of manufacture, which have collectively brought
the lead battery up to a high state of perfection and of great commercial
importance and value.
About ten years ago Thomas A. Edison assigned himself the task of
perfecting a new type of storage battery, one that would be light, dur-
able and compact and free from the difficulties inherent in the lead-
sulphuric acid battery. After nearly ten years of unremitting toil, re-
peated failures and triumphs and at the expenditure of vast sums of
money, he has succeeded in perfecting a type of battery which is a dis-
tinct departure from the old battery practice.
The principle of electro-chemical action in the active materials is the
same as in any other type of "secondary" battery, but instead of using
lead plates and sulphuric acid as an electrolyte, Edison uses steel plates,
nickel plated, with steel tubes and pockets, respectively, to contain the
active material in the positive and negative plates, the active material
consisting of nickel hydrate for the positive plate, and iron oxide for
the negative plate, and the electrolyte being a solution of about 21 per
cent, of potassium hydrate and a small percentage of lithia.
The use of these elements provides a combination that is practically
free from the corrosive effects of the lead-sulphuric acid batteries.
The Edison battery has now been in commercial use about three and
one-half years, and sufficient length of time has hardly elapsed to deter-
mine its life and efficiency, as far as economy of cost is concerned,
compared with the lead battery, which latter has been in practical use
for upwards of thirty years.
THE LEAD-SULPHURIC ACID STORAGE BATTERY.
THE PRINCIPLES OF THE STORAGE BATTERY.
The function of a storage battery in transforming the energy of
chemical combination into electrical energy is practically the same as
that of a primary battery. The storage battery has the additional prop-
erty of being able to be recharged by the passage of a current in the
1184 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
reverse direction through the cell. This reversal of current reverses
the chemical reactions which had taken place during the discharge, and
restores the cell to its original condition.
THE LEAD CELL.
Until quite recently the only type of cell that has been exten-
sively adopted in commercial service of all kinds is the lead cell. This
cell consists of two lead plates or two groups of such plates which con-
stitute, respectively, the positive and negative electrodes, immersed in a
solution of dilute sulphuric acid. Each plate consists of a metallic sup^
port, or grid, which acts as a support for the active material, and
at the same time serves to conduct the electric current to the point
where connection is made to the external circuit. The active ma-
terial of the positive plate, when fully charged, consists of lead
peroxide represented by the symbol PbO?. This lead peroxide in a
healthy cell has a dark chocolate brown color. The active material
of the negative plate in a fully charged cell is spongy metallic
lead, and is slate gray in color. During discharge the peroxide is re-
duced to a lower state of oxidization and combines with a portion of
the sulphuric acid in the electrolyte forming lead sulphate (PbSOO,
which being insoluble remains on the plate. At the same time the spongy
metallic lead of the negative plate becomes oxidized, and also combines
with a portion of the sulphuric acid of the electrolyte, forming sulphate
of lead on the negative plate. During discharge, therefore, it will be
seen that the electrolyte loses some of its sulphuric acid, and becomes
weaker. When the cell is recharged the lead sulphate on the two plates
is decomposed, the sulphuric acid is restored to the electrolyte, while
the active material on the positive plate again becomes lead peroxide,
and on the negative plate spongy metallic lead.
The chemical action above described may be expressed in the form
of the following equations :
PbO* + HaSO« = PbSO, + H,0 + O (i )
Pb + H..SO4 = PbSO + H, (2)
(1) + (2) = Pb02 + Pb+2H.S04 = 2PbS04 + 2HaO (3)
Equation (1) represents the reactions which take place at the posi-
tive plate, and equation (2) at the negative plate during charge, and
equation (3) the combined effect or fundamental equation of the stor-
age battery and is the reaction which takes place on discharge.
CHARACTERISTICS OF THE LEAD CELL.
The open circuit voltage of the lead storage cell is from 2.05 to 2.1
volts. This applies to a cell which has been allowed to stand for a
sufficient length of time on open circuit to acquire its true voltage read-
ing. Immediately after charging a cell, its open circuit voltage will be
somewhat higher, due to bubbles of hydrogen and oxygen gas retained
in the plates, as well as to concentration of acid in the pores of the
plates. Immediately after discharge, especially at high rates, the open
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1185
circuit voltage will be somewhat low, owing to the exhaustion of acid in
the pores of the plates. After standing for some time, the open circuit
voltage is gradually restored to the normal value, and this occurs
whether the cell is fully charged or is considerably discharged. The
open circuit voltage of a cell cannot, therefore, be used as an indication
of the state of charge of the cell.
During discharge the voltage of a cell will drop below its open cir-
cuit value, t^is drop being clue to two different causes, namely, the in-
ternal resistance of the eel.', whose effect is instantaneous, and the so
called polarization, which appears more gradually. This drop in voltage
increases as the cell becomes more nearly discharged. It varies with
the rate of discharge, and with the temperature. The final voltage at
the end of a discharge at the normal or eight-hour rate will be ap-
proximately 1.75. At higher rates it will be somewhat lower.
During charge, the voltage of the cell will rise above the open cir-
cuit voltage by an amount dependent also upon the rate of charge, and
the temperature. During charge at normal rate the voltage of the cell
gradually rises, varying from about 2.15 to 2.3 volts, and toward the end
of the charge this voltage rises rapidly until it reaches a maximum,
which may be anywhere from 2.5 to 2.8 volts, depending upon the rate,
temperature, acid density, and age of the cell. On account of these
variations, the actual cell voltage is not a satisfactory indication of the
completion of the charge. The most reliable way of determining when
a cell is fully charged is to continue the charging current at constant
rate until the cell voltage and the specific gravity of the electrolyte cease
to increase and become constant. (Fig. 1.)
The capacity of a storage battery cell is usually stated in ampere
hours, based upon a rate of discharge which will exhaust the cell in a
period of eight hours. This rate is called the normal rate, and the
capacity which the cell will give at this rate in ampere hours is called
the normal capacity. The capacity of a cell in ampere hours is decreased
by increasing the rate of discharge, so that a cell which will give 20
amperes for eight hours, or 160 ampere hours, will give 40 amperes for
about three hours, or 120 ampere hours, and will give 80 amperes for
one hour, or 80 ampere hours. The relations between the discharge
rate and the capacity given above are approximate, and vary some-
what with the design of the cell and the type of plate. A rating of
seven hours at the normal rate and one hour at four times the normal
rate is quite, usual. (Fig. 2.)
The capacity of a cell in ampere hours is also affected by the tem-
perature, and in the vicinity of 70 degrees F. the normal capacity is re-
duced about 6/10 of 1 per cent, for a reduction of one Fahrenheit de-
gree, but the capacity also increases with rise in temperature at about
same rate.
During discharge, as noted above, the acid density becomes reduced
owing to the combination of the sulphuric acid with the active mate-
118C THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
^
«*> CM V. <S*
0>
00
K
N
N N N N
*<
"<
v:
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1187
^. (V^ rv, \
1188 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
rial of the plates. The variation in the density of the electrolyte is,
therefore, a very accurate measure of the state of charge of a cell, pro-
vided proper correction is made for temperature, and for the loss of
water due to evaporation, provided also that a sufficiently free circula-
tion of electrolyte is secured to insure uniform density. The specific
gravity of the electrolyte in a cell when fully charged varies from 1.200
to 1.300, depending on the type of cell. The higher gravity is employed
in cells where the quantity of electrolyte is small compared with the
bulk of the plates. In common practice electrolyte having a specific
gravity of 1.200 is referred to as twelve hundred acid, or sometimes,
though erroneously, as twelve hundred degree acid.
LEAD BATTERY CHARACTERISTICS.
The more important characteristics inherent in the operation of lead
batteries are due to the following causes :
(a) Loss of capacity.
(b) Loss of active material.
(c) Sulphation.
(d) Loss of voltage.
(e) Buckling of plates.
These will be briefly treated in their order.
(a) Loss of capacity may be caused by the filling of the pores in the
plate with sulphate, thus preventing the taking place of the proper reaction
in the active material in the interior of the plates. This condition can
be remedied by a prolonged overcharge at low current rates, or at from
one-fourth to one-half the normal eight-hour rate.
(b) Loss of active material occurs to a greater or less extent in
lead storage batteries, but is greatly increased by frequent over-discharge,
and the amount of sulphate deposited in the plates will cause undue ex-
pansion of the active material, resulting in cracking and shedding of
same and depositing at the bottom of the plates.
When the negative active material contracts to such an extent as to
reduce the capacity perceptibly, the positive plates may be removed and
"dummy" plates (lead sheets) substituted. The connections with
terminals should then be reversed. The negative plate then becomes the
positive plate and the "dummy" the negative The charging current is
then reversed and the negative plate changed back to sponge lead. This
process has the effect of opening the pores and bringing the negative
plate back to its normal condition. The current when reversed should be
about double the normal rate.
(c) Sulphation results from over-discharge and can be prevented
by not permitting the discharge to fall below a voltage of 1.8 volts per
cell. Sulphation takes place very rapidly when a battery has been over-
discharged and is permitted to stand idle in this condition before charg-
ing.
The treatment for sulphation consists in charging a battery as rapidly
as possible without overheating. As the resistance of the cell is greatly
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1189
increased by the sulphate deposited on the plates, it will become hot. The
temperature should not exceed no degrees Fahrenheit. When the plates
begin to gas freely reduce the rate of charge to normal and continue
until gassing again takes place. The rate of charge should then be re-
duced to about one-half the normal rate and continued until further
gassing occurs. The cells should then be partly discharged and the
process repeated. Several cycles of this treatment may be required until
the capacity of the cells is restored.
(d) Loss of voltage is due directly to loss in capacity of one or
more cells. The cells having the lower capacity, being in series with the
main battery, will discharge at the same rate as the cells of higher
capacity, causing the voltage of the former to drop more rapidly, bring-
ing them below those of higher capacity. The remedy lies in bringing
up the capacity of the lower cells by treatment for the causes which in-
duced the loss of capacity, by treating the lower cells specifically.
(e) Buckling of plates is due to the over-expansion of the plates on dis-
charge, and is caused by sulphation to such an extent as to cause expan-
sion of the plates beyond their safe limit. This difficulty results from
over-discharge and consequent excess deposit of sulphate on the plates,
and is intended to be provided against in the construction of the plates,
but when this expansion exceeds a safe limit, buckling of plates result?.
Buckling may also result from rapid charging or discharging, causing
unequal distribution of electro-chemical action on two surfaces of the
plate and thereby setting up stresses, which, if not resisted by the plate,
result in distorting them.
The remedy against buckling of plates lies in well constructed plates,
and care in not over-discharging, or too rapidly charging or discharging
batteries.
(f) Loss of electrolyte is a frequent cause of loss of capacity in bat-
teries. If through evaporation or other causes the level of the electrolyte
falls below the top of the plates, the portion exposed performs no func-
tion, and the surface of the active material for the electro-chemical
action is reduced, cutting down the capacity of the cells. The remedy
lies in keeping the level of the electrolyte above the top of the plates.
When adding electrolyte, care must be taken not to increase its specific
gravity. The added portion should be either pure water or a very dilute
solution of about 5 per cent, of acid and 95 per cent, of pure water.
TYPES OF PLATES.
The lead storage battery plates are divided broadly into two classes
in accordance with the process of manufacture, namely, the Plante or
formed plates, and the Faure or pasted plates.
In the Plante type of plate the active material is formed electro-
chemically out of the metal of the grid itself. In order to obtain a sat-
isfactory formation, it is necessary that the grid should be practically of
pure lead. In order to obtain a sufficient extent of surface on which to
produce this formation of active material, the lead grid is sometimes
1190 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
provided with leaves or ribs extending across its face, which may be
produced either by rolling, spinning or cutting the original lead blank ;
or a cast grid may be produced consisting of vertical and horizontal
ribs with openings extending entirely through the plate. The latter type
of grid, having no central web, has the advantage, when used as a posi-
tive, of permitting the active material to be worked uniformly through-
out, even though the amount of work on opposite sides of the plate is
unequal, whereas with a positive plate having a central web, unequal work
on opposite sides (a condition which is almost sure to occur, due to dif-
ference in separation, or in the capacity of adjacent plates) will dis-
charge one side of the plate before the other, producing unequal expan-
sion and contraction of the active material, and a tendency to distortion
called "buckling." This does not apply to the negative plate, as its active
material does not expand and contract appreciably in normal service.
(Figs. 3 and 4.)
Fig. 3. Tudor Positive Plate, Fig. 4. Rolled Negative Plate,
Type "EP." Type "EP."
In addition to these pure lead grids, composite Plante plates have
been extensively used for the positive plate, consisting of a grid or
frame of hard antimony lead alloy, supporting sections or buttons of
soft lead on which the active material is formed. The best known plate
of this type is the Manchester plate in which the buttons are made of
pure lead ribbon corrugated crosswise, and rolled up into rosettes which
are forced into circular openings in the alloy grid. The active material
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1191
is then formed on the surface of the corrugations of the ribbon. This
latter type of composite Plante plate has been used only for the posi-
tive plate, while the pure lead Plante plates are used for both positive
and negative plates. (Fig. 5.)
Fig. 5. Manchester Positive Plate.
Rigid Grid, impervious to the action of the electrolyte, thus insuring
original conductivity and mechanical support for the active material through-
out the life of the plate.
Growth of the active material does not distort the plate, but increases
the contact pressure between the buttons and the grid.
Absence of a central web prevents buckling or other injury due to any
unequal work on opposite sides of the plate.
The Faure or pasted plate consists of an antimony lead alloy grid,
to which is mechanically applied, by a process called "pasting," the
active material consisting principally of oxide of lead with small quan-
1192 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
titics of other ingredients, applied in the form of a paste. After drying,
the active material is either reduced, or formed to the higher oxide, to
produce the negative or positive plate, respectively. Many designs of
grids have been brought out for such pasted plates, the principal object
£. a .a.' 'tb'.'iif
Fig. 6. Box Negative Plate.
Rigid Grid, impervious to the action of the electrolyte, thus insuring
original conductivity and mechanical support for the active material through-
out the life of the plate.
Active material enclosed in compartments by perforated sheet lead.
Thus, the active material need not be mechanically self-supporting, but is of
a permanent porous composition best adapted to the electro-chemical re-
quirements of the negative plate.
usually being to arrange ribs or pockets that will retain the active mate-
rial in position, and at the same time maintain good contact between the
active material and the metal support. (Figs. 6 and 7.)
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1193
CONTAINING VESSELS.
Three kinds of containing vessels are used for storage battery cells,
namely, glass jars, lead-lined wooden tanks and hard rubber jars. Glass
jars are used for stationary batteries of smaller capacity up to capacities
of about 800 ampere hours at the normal rate. It has been found im-
possible to obtain glass jars on a commercial scale for batteries of larger
sizes owing to the excessive breakage, due to the weight of plates
and electrolyte and to expansion and contraction with changes of tem-
perature. For stationary batteries of larger capacity, therefore, lead-
lined wooden tanks are used. It has been found that selected long leaf
yellow pine is a very durable wood for these tanks on account of its acid-
resisting qualities. Special precautions are also taken in the design of
ESBC0209
Fig. 7. Shelf Negative Plate.
these tanks to keep the acid away from the wood. These precautions
consist in carrying the lead lining up over the upper edges of the tank,
and down a short distance on the outside clear from the tank; these
overhanging edges being provided with drip points to concentrate any
dripping due to the creeping of the acid, where it will do no harm. Rub-
ber jars are used for portable cells on account of their lightness.
(Figs. 8, 9 and 10.)
The plates in stationary batteries are supported by plate lugs pro-
jecting from the plates near the top, which rest upon the edges of glass
jars or upon vertical sheets of glass in lead-lined tanks. This leaves
1194 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
a free space beneath the plates for sediment to collect without the pos-
sibility of short-circuiting the plates; this space being free from obstruc-
tions which would interfere with the removal of this sediment, and this
must be done at intervals of several years in most stationary batteries.
In rubber jars the plates are supported on ribs moulded into the bottom
of the jar. These ribs must be made of sufficient height to provide
ample sediment space.
In stationary batteries, where there is ample separation between the
plates in a cell, wood diaphragm separators supported by vertical slotted
dowels are installed between adjacent plates. (Fig. n.) In the larger
Fig. 8. Multiple-Plate Type "Chloride Accumulator" Installed on
Two Tier Racks in an Outbuilding.
cells hard rubber pins through the dowels near the top serve to support
them from the tops of the plates. In smaller cells the dowels extend to
the bottom of the jar. The dowels prevent the plates from coming in
contact with the separator, and the separator prevents the growth of
so-called lead trees between adjacent plates which might produce short-
circuits. In portable cells where the plate separation is reduced to a
minimum no dowels are used, but a perforated sheet of hard rubber is
usually inserted between the positive plate and the wood separator on
either side to avoid the destructive action of the lead peroxide on the
wood separator.
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
1195
1196 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
In stationary batteries, cells in glass jars are, in some cases, sup-
ported on wooden trays filled with sand to produce a uniform distribution
of pressure on the bottom of the jar ; these sand trays being mounted on
glass insulators. In other cases, glass sand trays provided with suit-
Fig. 10. Rubber Jar Container.
Fig. ii. Type "F" Wood Separator.
able feet are used in place of the wooden sand trays with their insulators.
Cells in lead-lined tanks are usually mounted on oil insulators. These
consist of a glass insulator provided with an inverted petticoat, pro-
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1197
ducing a circular trough which is partly filled with oil, this insulator
being covered with a lead cap extending down over the sides. In some
cases, where the voltage is low and the circuit is not grounded at any
point, a double tier of petticoat glass insulators may be used instead of
the oil insulators. (Figs. 12 and 13.)
Fig. 12. Oil Insulator, Unassembled.
Fig. 13. Assembled Oil Insulator Mounted on
Earthenware Pedestal.
The insulation of lead-lined tanks, especially in batteries connected
to high voltage systems (greater than 150 volts) or in systems where one
side of the circuit is grounded, is of very great importance. A slight
leakage of current which may take place over the surface of insulators
coated with dirt or acid-laden moisture is liable to produce electrolytic
corrosion of the tank linings. The oil insulator described above has been
found to practically eliminate these difficulties.
1198 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
METHOD OF CONTROL AND CONTROLLING APPARATUS.
Several methods have been adopted for controlling the charge and
discharge of stationary batteries. One of the most important pieces of
apparatus for this purpose is the booster. This is a dynamo (which
may be driven by belt or a motor) connected in series with the battery,
and used to compensate for the difference in voltage between the electric
circuit and the battery during charge or during discharge, or both. This
booster may be controlled by manual operation of its field rheostat, or by
automatic apparatus. Wherever automatic control is employed the
booster usually controls both the charge and the discharge of the bat-
tery. Where control is effected by hand, the booster is generally used-
only for charging, and the discharge voltage is controlled by end cells,
or counter electro-motive-force cells. End cells are a series of cells at
one end of the battery connected to a multiple point end cell switch by
which the number of cells included in the circuit may be controlled.
Counter electro-motive-force cells are electrolytic cells, in which the
plates are plain lead grids or dummies having no active material, and
no appreciable capacity. They are connected to a multiple point switch,
and are operated in the same way as a rheostat to reduce the voltage
during charge, or at the beginning of discharge when the battery- vol-
tage is above that of the circuit. In some cases an ordinary rheostat is
used for this purpose, but the counter cells have the advantage of cut-
ting down the voltage by a fixed amount per cell (2.3 to 2.5 volts) ; this
amount being but little affected by changes in the amount of current,
whereas the voltage absorbed by a rheostat varies directly with the
amount of current transmitted. (Fig. 14.)
Where a booster is not employed, the high voltage necessary for
charging is sometimes obtained by raising the voltage of the generator,
(Fig. 15.) This may be done when no current is required for lights, or
if lights are burning, the lower voltage necessary may be obtained by
introducing counter cells, or by an end cell switch. In other cases small
stationary batteries are charged by dividing the series of cells into two
equal groups which are connected across the circuit in parallel through
suitable resistance, so that the voltage of the circuit need not be al-
tered. In many small battery installations no voltage control during
discharge is required. (Figs. 16, 17 and 18.)
DEFINITIONS OF COMPONENT PARTS.
Positive Plate. — Brown in color, active material lead peroxide. Figs.
3 and 5.)
Negative Plate. — Gray in color, active material spongy metallic
lead. (Figs. 6 and 7.)
Positive Group. — The set of positive plates of a single cell lead
burned to a connecting strap. (Fig. 19.)
Negative Group. — The set of negative plates for a single cell lead
burned to a connecting strap. (Fig. 20.)
Wood Separator. — A thin wood sheet, specially treated, placed be-
tween adjacent plates in a cell. (Fig. 11.)
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1199
/£/<V/^^ £///?/</
1200 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
t
1
o
O
w
u
k
inc o x v^xvrvvjn. Drt. 1 x r^i\. i xin i\.n.xx_, vv /\ i oxlxs. v xv^il. iwi
1202 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
Fig. 17. Switchboard Front with Round Pattern Cell Switch.
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1203
Fig. 18. Remote Control Cell Switch. Two of the Four End Cell
Switches Installed in the Sixteenth Street Substation of the
New York Edison Company. Maximum Capacity,
20,000 Amperes Each.
1204
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
Q
I I II"
mm
si
ESB CO. 206.
Fig. 19. Manchester Positive
Group
Fig. 20. Box Negative Group.
Fig. 21. Two Plate Type. "ET" Elements in Glass Jars.
Rubber Separator. — A thin sheet of perforated hard rubber used be-
tween adjacent plates, either alone or with a wood separator. (Rubber
separators are not used in stationary batteries.)
Hold-down. — A glass weight used in stationary batteries to prevent
wood separators from floating.
Element. — A positive group and a negative group with separators
and hold-downs assembled for a single cell. (Fig. 21.)
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1205
Electrolyte. — The fluid or solution in the cells consisting of dilute
sulphuric acid.
Cell. — A single jar or container equipped with element and elec-
trolyte. (Fig. 21.)
Two-Plate or Couple-Type Cell. — A cell containing only one posi-
tive and one negative plate. In a series of such cells the positive plate
in one is permanently connected to the negative plate in the next by a
"U"-shaped lead strap which supports the two plates on the edges of
the jars. (Fig. 21.)
Multiple Plate Cell. — A cell having more than two plates. In such a
cell there is always one more negative plate than positive, the outside
plates being always negatives.
Pilot Cell. — One cell of a series selected for taking readings of vol-
tage and specific gravity to indicate the condition of the entire series.
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS REGARDING LEAD STORAGE BATTERIES.
Complete instructions for the care and operation of lead storage bat-
teries are issued by the Manufacturing Companies. A few of the most
important points, however, are given below:
Keep the level of the electrolyte above the plates. For this purpose
add only pure water; never add electrolyte or acid, except to replace loss
by spilling. Weakness of the acid in the cells is an indication of a dis-
charged condition of the plates and the acid density should be restored
by charging, and not by the addition of acid. Such low specific gravity
in a single cell of a series may be the result of a short-circuit between
the plates. After removing this short circuit the cell may be separately
charged or the entire series may have to be overcharged in order to
bring this cell up to equality with the rest.
Do not over-discharge a battery. High rates of discharge in am-
peres are not injurious, but excessive discharge in ampere hours will
shorten the life of the plates.
Do not overcharge. Charging should preferably be done at the
normal or eight-hour rate of the cells, and should not be continued after
the cells are fully charged. Higher rates than the normal are permis-
sible at the beginning of the charge, but the rate should be reduced to
normal toward the end when gassing begins.
Do not allow cells to stand for a considerable length of time in the
discharged condition. After a battery is discharged it should be re-
charged within a few hours. This is particularly important if the full
capacity of the battery has been taken out.
Do not allow any foreign material whatever to get into the cells.
Ventilate the battery compartment. This is especially necessary when
charging, as the gases given off form a mixture when confined, which
may explode in the presence of an exposed flame.
Never allow the sediment which accumulates in the bottom of the
jars to reach the plates.
1206 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
THE EDISON STORAGE BATTERY.
There are many combinations which can be utilized as secondary
storage batteries, wherein when charged with a current of electricity, by
virtue of the electro-chemical action, a portion of the electric current is
returned in the reverse direction of the charge. Of the various com-
binations, however, none excepting the lead sulphuric acid battery has
proven commercially practicable, until within the past few years, when
through the genius of Thomas A. Edison a combination has been suc-
cessfully developed which has for one of its electrodes nickel oxide and
for the other finely divided iron or iron sponge, these being immersed in
a solution of potassium hydrate.
THEORY OF CHEMICAL REACTION.
Starting with oxide of iron in the negative electrode, green nickel
hydrate in the positive electrode and potassium hydrate in the electrolyte,
the first charging of a cell reduces the iron oxide to metallic iron while
converting the nickel hydrate to a very high nickel oxide, black in
color.
On discharge, the metallic iron is converted back to iron oxide and
the high nickel oxide to a lower oxide, but not to its original form of
green hydrate.
In every cycle thereafter the negative active material charges to
metallic iron and discharges to iron oxide, while the positive active ma-
terial charges to a high nickel oxide and discharges to a lower oxide.
Current passing in the direction of charge or discharge decomposes
the potassium hydrate of the electrolyte, and the oxidation and reductions
at the electrodes are brought about by the action of its elements. An
amount of potassium hydrate equal to that decomposed is always re-
formed at one of the electrodes' by a secondary chemical reaction, and
as a result none of it is lost and its density remains constant.
The result of charging, therefore, is the transference of oxygen
from the negative to the positive electrode and a discharging of a trans-
ference back again of oxygen from the positive to the negative elec-
trode.
A comparison of the two types of batteries may be made as follows :
Element.
Lead Battery.
Edison Battery.
(I)
Positive Plate,
Lead Peroxide
Nickel Hydrate
(2)
Negative Plate,
Sponge Lead
Iron Oxide
(3)
Electrolyte,
Dilute Sulphuric Acid
Potassium Hydrate
(4)
Insulation,
Wood, Rubber or
Porcelain
Hard Rubber
(5)
Container,
Glass, Rubber or Lead
Nickeled Steel Cans
Lined Tank
Wood with Steel
(6)
Trays,
Wood
Cradles
(7)
Connectors,
Lead Straps Burned
Copper Wire Steel
on
Lugs
A description of the component parts of the Edison Batteries follows :
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1207
POSITIVE PLATE.
The positive plate consists of one or more perforated steel tubes,
nickel plated, filled with alternate layers of nickel hydroxide, and pure
metallic in thin flakes which form the active material.
The tube is drawn from a perforated steel ribbon, and has a spiral
lapped seam. After being tilled with the active material, the tube is re-
inforced with eight steel bands equally spaced to prevent expansion and
breaking of contact of tube with its contents. (Fig. 22.)
NEGATIVE PLATE.
The negative plate consists of a grid of cold-rolled steel, nickel
plated, holding a number of rectangular pockets of perforated steel, also
nickel plated, which contains powdered iron oxide, the active material.
After the pockets are filled they are inserted in the grid and compressed
Fig. 22. Positive and Negative
Plate.
Fig. 23. Insulation.
between dies, corrugating the surface of the pockets, and forcing them
into integral contact with the grid. (Fig. 22.)
electrolyte.
The electrolyte consists of a 21 per cent, solution of potash in dis-
tilled water, added to which is a small per cent, lithia.
1208 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
INSULATION.
After the plates are assembled narrow strips of hard rubber are in-
serted between the plates, separating and insulating them from each
other. The side insulators have grooves to fit the edge of the plates,
separating the plates from the steel container. At the ends the negative
plates are separated and insulated from the steel container by means of
smooth hard rubber sheets. At the bottom the plates rest upon a hard
rubber rack or bridge, insulating the plates from the bottom. Very
little space is required at the bottom, as no active material is precipi-
tated. (Fig. 23.)
CONTAINER OR JAR.
The container or jar is made of rolled sheet steel, nickel plated,
with welded seams. The sides of the jar are corrugated to increase the
strength. (Figs. 24 and 25.)
Fig. 24. Container or Jar.
Fig. 25. Cell.
trays or boxes.
The assembled cells are enclosed in wooden trays of special con-
struction, using light wood. The cells rest directly upon a steel cradle,
which is supported on the lower side slats of the tray. The cells are
held in place by steel hold-downs, attached to the upper side slats. The
trays have no bottoms, the cells being supported by the cradles. (Fig. 26.)
connectors.
The plates of a cell are assembled on steel connector rods; with
steel spacing washers, all attached to a steel terminal post, the outer
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1209
end of which is tapered to fit a terminal lug. The tip of the terminal
is threaded to receive a nut to hold down the lugs. The terminal post
is insulated from the cover of cell by means of hard rubber washers and
bushings. (Fig. 27.)
The terminal lug is of drop forged steel made to fit the terminal
post. The connecting link between two terminal lugs is copper, swedged
into the lugs.
VOLTAGE.
To charge an Edison Battery to full capacity a D. C. voltage of 1.85
volts per cell should be provided. A 60-cell battery requires, therefore,
a D. C. voltage of 60x1.85, or in volts.
The normal discharge rate of the Edison Battery is 1.2 volts per
Fig. 26. Trays or Boxes.
Fig. 27. Connectors.
cell. The terminal voltage divided by the average voltage per cell will
give the required number of cells.
efficiency.
The efficiency of any battery is the ratio of the discharge to the
charge, of the electric energy derived from the discharge, or use of the
battery, divided by the electric energy expended in charging the battery.
1210 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
The watt hour efficiency of the Edison battery, at the normal dis-
charge rate, is approximately 58 per cent. The watt hour efficiency of the
lead storage battery at the normal discharge rate is approximately 75
per cent.
While this is the efficiency of the two types of batteries, as far as the
relation between input and output of energy is concerned, it does not take
into account other considerations which affect the life and maintenance of
the various types of batteries.
Some of the advantages claimed for the Edison type of battery are
as follows :
Longer life due to the use of nickel steel in the elements and an
alkaline solution as an electrolyte eliminating corrosion of parts.
Lighter weight per unit of energy output due to the use of lighter
material in plates and parts of battery. No injury is done to cells if
battery is overdischarged and if left discharged.
Absence of such difficulties as sulphation, buckling of plates, loss of
active materials, sedimentation, breaking of jars from vibration, corro-
sion of plates and grids.
The first cost, however, of the Edison type of battery is about
twice that of a lead battery of equivalent capacity. The Edison Battery
has not been in general commercial use long enough, in competition with
the lead battery and under equal conditions of service, to demonstrate
whether its life is twice that of the lead battery and whether or not,
therefore, it is more economical as far as first cost is concerned.
APPLICATIONS IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
The applications of the storage battery in railway service may be
enumerated as follows :
Train Lighting.
Signaling.
Draw-bridge Operation.
Lighting of Stations and Terminals.
Storage Battery Traction.
TRAIN LIGHTING.
The principal systems of train lighting are : Straight storage, axle
lighting and the head-end system.
In the straight-storage system the batteries are used to carry the
entire lighting load during the trip, and sometimes during a complete
round trip, the charging being done at the terminals. Where the run
is not so long as to require excessive battery capacity or to endanger
over-discharge, and where the service is sufficiently regular to insure that
the batteries receive proper care and systematic inspection, the straight-
storage system is eminently satisfactory.
The head-end system has been adopted where the run is too long to
permit straight storage, but the train makes the entire run as a unit, and
is not sub-divided for service on branch lines. In this system a battery
may be installed on each car, or several batteries may be distributed
throughout the train and a dynamo is installed either on the engine or
baggage car at the head of the train, driven by steam from the locomo-
tive boiler. The dynamo is run at a voltage sufficiently high to take
the lighting load when the steam supply is available, the batteries float-
ing across the circuit under these conditions without any considerable
amount of charge or discharge. When the engine is disconnected, the
batteries supply current for the lights. Under normal conditions of serv-
ice the amount of discharge taken from the batteries is comparatively
small, and it may be restored by raising the voltage of the dynamo dur-
ing a daylight run when the lamps are disconnected, or the batteries
may be recharged at the terminals.
Whenever the conditions are not suitable for straight storage, or
the head-end system, as, for example, where cars are liable to be operated
on branch lines, without facilities for recharging, or where the service is
intermittent and irregular, the axle lighting system is very generally
1211
1212 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
adopted. In this system a dynamo is mounted on one. of the trucks, and
driven by belt or chain from one of the axles. In order to control the
voltage of the dynamo to compensate for the variable speed at which it is
driven, many automatic regulating devices have been introduced. In
general these devices are designed to maintain a constant current output
from the dynamo, regardless of speed, and are controlled by this current
output in such a manner that variations within certain limits will vary
the field excitation of the dynamo to produce the desired regulation.
The output of the dynamo being maintained practically constant, it is
obvious that when there is no lamp load, the entire output will be utilized
for charging the battery. As the lamps are turned on 1he amount of cur-
rent delivered to the battery is reduced, and if the demand under maxi-
mum load conditions is greater than the output of the dynamo, the
battery will discharge to assist the dynamo in carrying the load. When
the car speed is below a certain limit, the voltage of the dynamo cannot be
maintained, and an automatic switch disconnects the dynamo, leaving
the battery to carry the entire load. This switch again closes auto-
matically when the voltage of the dynamo has reached a proper value.
The varying charging current into the battery, and the varying state
of its charge, produces a considerable variation of voltage at the bat-
tery terminals. In order to prevent this variation from affecting the
brilliancy and life of the lamps, a lamp regulator is ordinarily intro-
duced to control the lamp voltage by varying a resistance in series with
the lamp circuit. In the earlier axle lighting systems the constant out-
put of the generator was adjusted to keep the battery fully charged un-
der maximum load conditions, and whenever the load conditions were
less severe the excess output produced serious overcharging of the bat-
teries, and a marked reduction in their normal life. Recently, auto-
matic devices have been introduced to reduce the output of the gener-
ator, and avoid some of this overcharge when the battery voltage rises
to a certain point. This does not entirely eliminate overcharging, but
reduces it appreciably.
One modification of the head-end system has been tried with some
success, under special conditions, in which a battery is located at each
end of the train instead of on each car. with a dynamo at the locomotive
end. This system provides for keeping the lights burning when the
train is parted in the middle, but does not, of course, provide for cutting
out an individual car.
Train lighting batteries are mounted in compartments supported
under the car-bodies, and generally consist of separate units, each con-
taining two cells mounted in a wooden crate. (Fig. 29.) In most cases
two-compartment lead-lined wooden tanks are adopted, the plates being
supported by porcelain wedges on the bottom of the tank. In some
cases hard rubber jars are used, embedded in insulating compound, which
fills the entire space between the jars and the wooden crate, the jars
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1213
Fig. 29. Two-Cell Unit of Type 13 "EP," in Lead Lined Tank
with Special Connectors.
Fig. 30. Two-Cell Unit of Type ii "EP" in Rubber Jars, Wood Crate.
being floated in while the compound is hot. (Fig. 30.) Hard rubber
covers are used which fit the jars and the terminals, and are sealed in
with compounds, so as to prevent the slopping of acid, a vent being pro-
vided to allow the escape of gases while charging.
Two different voltages are being extensively used in train lighting,
namely, 64 and 32 volts, calling for 32 and 16 cells respectively. Owing
to the introduction of the Tungsten lamp, and its greater ruggedness at
1214 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
lower voltages, the 32-volt systems are becoming more generally stand-
ardized, especially for axle lighting systems. The higher voltage is still
used for head-end systems on account of the drop in train line conduc-
tors, and for straight storage on account of the additional capacity ob-
tained by the increased number of cells, which would involve excessive
size and weight of individual cells at the lower voltage.
SIGNALING.
In signal service the storage battery has, in many situations, sup-
planted the primary battery. It is generally found less expensive to
maintain, and it also offers other advantages over the primary cell, suchu
as low internal resistance, uniform voltage and large output for inter-
mittent service, such as the operation of motor-driven signals. In some
cases portable batteries are employed for this purpose, which are col-
lected at regular intervals for charging at some convenient charging
point, a certain number of spare batteries being provided for service
while the discharged cells are being charged. (Fig. 31.) In other sys-
Fig. 31. Four SS 9 Signal Cells Assembled in Case.
tems the batteries are charged without removal by a charging circuit
which extends along the right-of-way, into which the cells may be con-
nected in series. Duplicate batteries are installed, one of which is con-
nected to the charging circuit, while the other is supplying the current
to the signals. In some cases the storage cells are connected in parallel
with a sufficient number of primary cells of the "gravity" or "bluestone"
type. These primary cells supply a small amount of current continuously,
sufficient to keep the storage cells fully charged, while the storage cells,
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1215
on account of their low internal resistance, furnish the high momentary
current demands for operating the signals. The choice between primary
batteries and storage batteries for signal service, as well as the best
method of charging the cells, will depend upon local conditions, particu-
larly on the space between the signals and the facilities available for
charging.
DRAWBRIDGE OPERATION.
The introduction of storage batteries for supplying current for
operating motor-driven drawbridges has been quite general of recent
years. The battery in this service has two important functions. The
first is to provide an absolutely reliable source of current which is not
subject to interruption. Accidents which have occurred, due to failure
of power while a large vessel, under considerable headway, is approach-
ing a partially opened drawbridge, have shown the necessity for such an
auxiliary supply of current. The second function is to provide, by means
of a small continuous current supply, for the heavy intermittent serv-
ice required. The 24-hour average demand of the drawbridge is usually
very small as compared with the momentary maximum demand. By
the installation of a storage battery, the primary source of current, which
may be a dynamo driven by a gasoline engine, or a motor generator set
operated by alternating current supplied from a distance, may be only
sufficient for the average requirements, and for charging the battery at
its normal rate. On discharge, the battery may be called upon for an
output up to eight times its normal rate, or under certain conditions for
even greater discharge rates, for furnishing the heavy momentary cur-
rents required for operating the bridge. This function of the battery, by
reducing the maximum demand on the primary source of power, not
only reduces the amount of investment for generating machinery, but
where power is purchased it will often make a marked reduction in the
power bills. Another advantage of the battery in this service is to per-
mit a 24-hour supply of current with only a few hours' operation of the
generating machinery; the battery having no moving parts does not re-
quire constant attendance, and the cost of labor may thus be reduced.
(Figs. 32 and 33.)
STATION LIGHTING.
For the lighting of stations and terminals the storage battery is a
valuable adjunct to the power plant, permitting the latter to be shut
down entirely during the hours of lighter load when the battery sup-
plies the entire demand, and also assisting the generating machinery
during the few hours of excessive or peak load. Such a battery is
usually charged from the station bus by means of a booster, which is a
motor-driven dynamo connected in series between the bus and the bat-
tery, and supplies the additional voltage required for charging. The
discharge of such a battery is controlled by end cells connected to a
multiple point end cell switch which may be operated by hand, or by
remote control apparatus to cut cells into or out of circuit, for con-
trolling the battery voltage, and the amount of discharge current when
the battery is operating in parallel with the main generator.
1216 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1217
1218 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
STORAGE BATTERY TRACTION.
In the early history of storage battery development considerable at-
tention was paid to storage battery traction, and a number of storage
battery cars were put into commercial service on different roads. For
one cause or another, however, these were finally abandoned. Within
the last two years this application of the storage battery has been revived,
largely owing to improvements in the storage battery itself, as well as
to a better knowledge of the conditions under which storage battery
traction will prove successful.
The Third Avenue Railroad Company, in New York City, is oper-
ating about eighty storage battery cars, in which lead storage battery
cells carried on the cars furnish the current for the motors ; 58 cells,
each having a capacity of about 400 ampere hours, are installed on
each car under the longitudinal seats, these cells being charged during
the night without removal from the cars. Some experiments are also
being made with storage battery cars on branch lines of steam rail-
roads', where the traffic is light, and only infrequent service is main-
tained. It is probable that in many such situations the storage battery
car will prove to be the most economical method of providing for the
passenger service from a commercial standpoint. The cost of labor and
power will be less than for locomotive operation, and the initial invest-
ment will, in many cases, be considerably less than that required for
equipment with the overhead trolley, particularly where power can be
purchased from a local lighting company, at a low rate, during the
hours when the lighting load is a minimum, and, therefore, no invest-
ment for additional machinery is called for.
STORAGE BATTERY CHARGING APPARATUS.
The means employed to supply a charging current for storage bat-
teries vary with the circumstances surrounding each individual case. The
most desirable condition is that in which current can be secured from
some outside source, available without the installation of a prime mover.
Such conditions are provided in cases where there already exists a gen-
erating plant, either operated by the railway company or by commercial
concerns where current can be secured at reasonable rates.
There may, however, be no outside sources of power available, in
which case it becomes necessary to install a plant for the purpose of
generating the charging current; or the condition may arise where cur-
rent is available, but it is of such a character as to require conversion as
may be necessary, for charging the batteries.
The character of equipment required to provide the necessary charg-
ing current will usually consist of one or more of the following types of
apparatus :
(1) Motor Generator Sets.
(2) Mercury Arc Rectifier.
(3) Rotary Converters.
(4) Steam Turbine Unit.
(5) Steam Engine Unit.
(6) Internal Combustion Engine Unit.
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1219
The first three types named are simply converters of electrical
energy, and presuppose that current of some character is available from
an outside source, which only requires a change in its character to con-
form to the required charging current.
Types (4) and (5) are usually used where steam supplies are avail-
able, but where separate steam supply is necessary for the installation
of this type of generator it may become prohibitive.
Type (6), the internal combustion engine with its various available
types using low grade of oil products for fuel, is the most practical and
economical type of installation, where no external source of power or
energy is available.
The various types are more fully described as follows :
(1) Motor Generator Sets. — Motor Generator sets are in common
use for battery charging installations. They should be preferably direct
connected. They are adaptable to the various voltage and current re-
quirements. While constant voltage is desirable for driving the motor,
even such fluctuating current as trolley current may be used, with proper
automatic voltage regulator.
Motor Generator sets are either of the D.C.-D.C. or A.C.-D.C. type,
the former known as the direct current generator set. The generator
should be shunt wound with considerable range of voltage, through reg-
ulation of field by suitable rheostats. Moderate speeds are recommended
for mechanical reasons. The generator's are shunt wound for 125 volts
with variation of from 70 to 140 volts. Motors are furnished for 115,
230 or 550 volts D.C. Capacities range from 125 watts to 12.5 k.w.
In many localities it is possible to secure at fair rates supplies of
alternating current, usually at 60 cycles, single or three phase at suitable
voltages. The A.C.-D.C. motor generator sets are frequently used in
such cases to convert the current for charging purposes. The genera-
tors are shunt wound for 125 volts normal operation and range from
70 to 140 volts. Motors may be no, 220, 440 or 550 volts for two or
three phase current. Capacities range from 200 watts to 10 k.w.
(2) Mercury Arc Rectifiers. — Mercury Arc Rectifiers, with the im-
provements made in recent years, are proving one of th<» most prac-
ticable and economical devices used in battery charging. They are com-
plete in themselves, requiring no auxiliary apparatus not available in
small floor space. They are furnished in standard sizes from o to 175
volts D.C, and in capacity from 10 to 50 amperes. Where battery charg-
ing is done at a terminal for car lighting service it is possible to use a
number of rectifier panels side by side to obtain the necessary amount
of current required.
Ordinarily Rectifiers are designed for operation where the Alter-
nating Current furnished has a frequency of 60 cycles and at from no to
220 volts, single phase. They are, however, readily adapted to other
voltages and frequencies down to 25 cycles. Rectifiers are simple in de-
sign and very satisfactory in operation within the limits to which they
are adapted.
1220 THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE.
(3) Rotary Converters. — The Rotary Converter in small sizes for
use in battery charging is not in great demand on account of its cost
and characteristics. The impressed alternating current voltage bears a
constant ratio to the direct current voltage current generated by the
rotary converter, so that the direct current voltage can only be changed
by regulating the alternating current voltage. The ratio of A.C.- to D.C.
current is 6/10 in three-phase circuits and 7/10 in single and two-phase
circuits. On account of these limits of voltage regulation the rotary
converter has not been used in small capacities such as apply to battery
charging.
(4) Steam Turbine Units. — Small Steam Turbine driven units for^
direct current generation have not been generally installed for battery
charging purposes. Such units can, however, be secured and may prove
economical where a source of steam supply is available without
special steam supply installation. There are numerous types of steam
turbines available, the smaller units ranging from 7 to 15 k.w., speeds 4,500
to 5,000 R.P.M., with shunt-wound generators 125 volts normal opera-
tion and a range with field regulation to give voltages ranging from 65
to 140 volts.
(5) Steam Engine Units. — Where a steam supply is available, a
direct or belt connected steam-engine-driven generator unit is one of
the most practicable outfits for battery charging. These are adapted to
steam pressures as low as 80 lbs. They occupy little floor space and,
when supplied with fly-wheel and closely regulating governor for speed
regulation, result in practically constant voltage, eliminating automatic
regulators for voltage. The direct-connected steam units range from 25 to
50 k. w.
(6) Internal Combustion Engine Units. — The devlopment of the
internal combustion engine, especially the types using low grades of oil
for fuel, opens up a wide field for the application of such prime movers.
They are built with various numbers of cylinders and either two or four
cycle operation. When reliably built and of good design, they provide
the most economical prime movers adaptable for charging service at iso-
lated locations. They can be secured in sizes varying from 1 to 25 k. w.
This type has the advantage of being capable of mounting on a car
and thereby providing a portable charging plant which can be utilized
wherever desired.
In general, the selection of types of apparatus for proposed charging
plants should be made only after special investigation into the power
supply conditions at each particular point.
In the limited quantities of current required for charging stations,
current can ordinarily be purchased more cheaply, or as cheaply, as it
can be generated independently, and where this can be done much an-
noyance and expense may be saved by utilizing such sources of supply.
THE STORAGE BATTERY IN RAILWAY SERVICE. 1221
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.
Fig. No. Title. Page,
i. Approximate Charge and Discharge Curves 6
2. Capacity Curve. Rate Time Relation 7
3. Tudor Positive Plate, Type "EP" io
4. Rolled Negative Plate, Type "EP" io
5. Manchester Positive Plate 1 1
6. Box Negative Plate • • 12
7. Shelf Negative Plate 13
8. Multiple-Plate Type "Chloride Accumulator" 14
9. "Exide" Battery at Sixteenth Street Substation, New York
Edison Company 15
10. Rubber Jar Container 16
11. Type "F" Wood Separator 16
12. Oil Insulator, Unassembled 17
13. Assembled Oil Insulator Mounted on Earthenware Pedestal 17
14. Booster and End Cell. Diagram of Connection 19
15. Counter E. M. F. Cells. Diagram of Connections 20
16. Parallel Charging. Diagram of Connections 21
17. Switchboard Front, with Round Pattern Cell Switch 22
18. Remote Control Cell Switch 23
19. Manchester Positive Group 24
20. Box Negative Group 24
21. Two Plate Type. "ET" Elements in Glass Jars 2.
22. Positive and Negative Plate 2;
23. Insulation 2]
24. Container or Jar 2«
25. Cell 28
26. Trays or Boxes 29
27. Connectors 29
29. Two-Cell Unit of Type 13 "EP," in Lead-Lined Tank with Special
Connectors 33
30. Two-Cell Unit of Type 11 "EP" in Rubber Jars, Wood Crate... 33
31. Four SS 9 Signal Cells Assembled in Case 34
32. Northern Pacific Railway Bridges at Duluth, Minn., and Superior,
Wis., Equipped with "Chloride Accumulators" 36
33. Chicago & Northwestern Railway Draw Span at Clinton, Iowa,
Operated by "Chloride Accumulators" 27
INDEX.
INDEX.
A
PAGF.
Abutments, design of bridge ,. 1085-1150
Address, President's 40-48
Advantages of Oil as Fuel Compared to Coal 437, 43S
Alfred, F. H., election of as Member of Nominating Committee. 61
Amendments to Committee Reports 1079- 1082
Arrangements, Committee on, resolution of thanks to 60
Association Affairs 40-44
B
Ballast, report on 95-300
Conclusions . . . . 97, 98, 99, 102
Discussion 945~950
Experiment to Determine tbe Necessary Depth of Stone
Ballast 1 13-265
Conclusions 126, 127
Description of Test Track 114-121
Gravel as Ballast 266-289
Gravel Ballast, grading of 99-102
Gravel Washing Plant, R. F. & P. R. R 103- 1 10
Methods of Test 122-127
Physical Tests of Stone for Ballast 97-99
Proper depth of, to insure uniform distribution of loads.... 95-97
Report of Maintenance of Way Committee on Ballast, New
York Central Lines 290-300
Definitions , 29 r
Description 291, 292
Photographs and Description of Ballast 295-300
Recommended Practice 294
Specifications 292, 294
Use of Oil to Secure a Dustless Roadbed 295
Ballasting, rules governing 66
Boiler Corrosion and Treated Water 420-428
Bremner, Geo. H., re-election of as Treasurer 61
Bridges, Specifications for Erection 83-87
Brush Coating and Dipping, value of 867
1226 INDEX.
PAGE.
Buildings, report on 885-899
American Method of Laying Asbestos Shingles 897,898
Details of Flashing and Counter Flashing for Roof and
Walls 891-896
Diagonal Method of Laying Asbestos Shingles 899
Discussion 1054
Flashings 889-890
Roof Coverings 885-889
Business Session 39-62
C
Carbon Steel Rails, specifications for 565-571
Churchill, Chas. S., election of as President 61
Installation of as President 62
Clearance Lines for Equipment 525
Clearances 510, 511
Coal and Fuel Oil Resources 437, 456, 457
Coal Fields of the United States 449"452
Coal Supply, duration of 453, 454
Coating and Dipping, value of 867
Committee Reports 65-916
Committees, appointment of, rules governing 32
Concrete Fence Posts 902
Concrete, methods of depositing under water 487-502
Concrete Ties, report on 343~3"o
Conservation of Natural Resources, report on 429-457
Advantages of Oil as Fuel Compared to Coal 437, 438
Annual Fire Loss 456
Coal Fields of the United States 449-452
Coal and Fuel Oil Resources 437. 456, 457
Crude Petroleum 457
Discussion 989
Duration of Coal Supply 453, 454
Evaporative Tests — Oil as Fuel 439-441
Government Fuel Oil Specifications 443, 444
Inspection and Tests of Fuel Oil 441-443
Methods of Preventing or Lessening Waste in the Petroleum
Industry 444-449
Natural Gas in Canada 457
Peat Deposits in Canada 4 457
Petroleum as a Locomotive Fuel 438, 430
Tree Planting and General Reforestation 430-437,455,456
Bibliography 435-437
Constitution 23-31
Construction Contract Form 909-916
INDEX. 1227
PAGE.
Creosote Oil, specifications for 865, 866
Crossings of Electric Light and Power Lines, specifications for
overhead 512-521
Crude Petroleum in Canada 457
Cypress Lumber, classification and grading rules for 875-884
Gushing, W. C. (see also under "The President") :
. Address of 40-48
Resolution of thanks to 62
D
Darling, W. L., election of as Director 61
Delano, F. A., election of as Director 61
Design of Railway Bridge Abutments 1085-1150
Discussions of Committee Reports 919-1076
Division Engine Terminal, typical situation plans 91,92
Drainage, agricultural, as it affects railways 396, 397
Drainage, rules governing 66
E
Economics of Railway Location, report on 905, 906
Discussion 1058
Electricity, report on 509-558
Clearances 510
Discussion 998-1016
Foundations 518
General Requirements 512-514
Loads 514-516
Material 516-518
Protective Coatings 518
Recommendations 511
Specifications for Overhead Crossings of Electric Light and
Power Lines 512-521
Transmission Lines and Crossings 511
Engineer, defined 87
Ejigine Service, furnishing of 84
Equipment Diagrams of Various Railways 526-534
Evaporative Tests — Oil as Fuel 439-441
F
Felt, C. F. W., election of as Member of Nominating Committee 6r
Fence Posts, concrete 902
Fence Wire 900-902
Fire Loss, annual, in Canada 456
Flashing, for roofs and walls 891-896
1228 INDEX.
PAGE.
Forests of the United States 430
Freight, handling of by mechanical means 90, 91
Fritch, E. H., re-election of as Secretary 61
Fritch, L. C, paper by on "The Storage Battery in Railway
Service" 1 181-1221
Frogs, Crossings and Switches, general specifications for 375-386
Frogs, general specifications for 377~38o
G
a
Gas, Natural, in Canada 457
General Information 32-36
General Plan for a Reinforced Concrete Sub-Structure and a Re-
inforced Concrete Water Tank 407-409
Government Fuel Oil Specifications 443, 444
Grading of Lumber, report on 873-884
Classification and Grading Rules for Cypress Lumber and
Shingles 875-884
Barn or Dimension 880, 881
Cull or Peck 881
Finishing ^81, 882
General Instructions 875
Pickets, Battens, Car Roofing and Siding, Car Lining,
Shingles 883, 884
Selects 880
Siding, Flooring and Ceiling Partition 882
Standard Defects 875, 878
Standard Finished Sizes of Cypress 878, 870
Standard Lengths 878
Tank Stock 879, 880
Discussion 1052, 1053
Recommendations 873, 874
Guard Rails, progress report 79
I
Indiana Railroad Commission, hearing before 841-862
Ingots and Derivative Shapes, tests made at Watertown Arsenal ~$3
Inspection and Tests of Fuel Oil 441-443
Insulation Resistances, table of ' 70
Iron and Steel Structures, report on . 81-88
Conclusions , 82
Discussion 934, 935
Secondary Stresses 88
Specifications for the Erection of Railroad Bridges 83-87
INDEX. 1229
L
PAGE.
Lead Battery Characteristics 1 188. 1 189
Locomotive Boiler Corrosion 420-428
Locomotive Tonnage Rating 1151-1180
M
Manual, general rules for the publication of 36
Masonry, report on 459-504
Conclusions , 476, 477, 488, 504
Discussion 990-995
Methods of Depositing Concrete Under Water 487-502
Methods of Patching and Repairing Plain and Reinforced
Concrete 474-487
Report on Work of Joint Committee on Concrete and Re-
inforced Concrete 502
Unification of Portland Cement Specifications 502-504
Waterproofing of Masonry 459-474
Materials, handling and storing of 84
Monographs :
Design of Railway Bridge Abutments .1085-1150
Equated Tonnage Rating for Locomotives 1151-1180
Storage Battery in Railway Service .1181-1221
N
National Railway Appliances Association, resolution of thanks to 59, 60
Natural Gas in Canada 457
Nominating Committee, election of 61
O
Officers, election of 60, 61
Oil, advantages of as fuel, as compared to coal 437-449
Oil Tanks, general specifications for 417-419
Osgood, Jos. O., election of as Member of Nominating Committee 61
P
Painting 86
Paragraphs in Specifications for Overhead Crossing of Electric
Light and Power Lines as Adopted by Other Associations.. 522,523
Passenger Stations, typical situation plans 90
Peat Deposits in Canada 457
Petroleum as a Locomotive Fuel 438, 439
Petroleum Industry, methods of preventing or lessening waste. . 444-449
1230 INDEX.
PAGE.
Piling, sheet, progress report 78, 79
Portland Cement Specifications, unification of 502-504
President, address of 40-48
R
Rail, report on 559-862
Comparative Wear of Bessemer, Open-Hearth and Nickel
Steel Rail on Pennsylvania Railroad 635-654
Discussion 1017-1038
Hearing before Indiana Railroad Commission 841-862
History, Development and Use of Rails by Railroad Com-
panies of the United States from 1830 to date 843-850
Influence of Rolling Temperature on the Properties of Bes-
semer Rails 797-839
Rail Failure Statistics for One Year Ending October 31,
1910 613-633
Thoughts Resulting from the Study 633
Segregation and Other Rail Properties as Influenced by Size
of Ingot 655-752
Specifications for Carbon Steel Rails 565-571
Chemical Requirements 565, 566
Details of Manufacture 569-571
Inspection 565
Material 565
Physical Requirements 566-569
Steel Rails, Investigation by the American Society of Civil
Engineers 851, 852
Study of Seventeen Good Service Rails 573-6n
Summary of Work of the Committee 559-564
The Question of the Improvement of Rail Design and Specifi-
cations, from 1893 to the Present Time 853-862
Rail, rules governing laying 67
Ray, G. J., election of as Member of Nominating Committee... 6i
Records and Accounts, report on 505-507
Conclusions 506, 507
Discussion 996, 997
Reasons for Maintaining a Storehouse 506,507
Reinforced Concrete, methods of patching and repairing 474-487
Reinforced Concrete, use of for railway water tanks and supports 402-417
Roadway, report on 387-400
Agricultural Drainage as it Affects Railways 396, 397
Discussion 981, 982
Tunnel Construction and Ventilation 396, 398-400
Unit Pressures Allowable on Roadbeds of Different Materials 388-396
Waterway Formulas 387, 388
INDEX. 1231
PACE.
Rules and Organization, report on 65-68
• Discussion 919-931
Instructions .• 66-68
S
Secretary, report of 49-52
Scott, W. B., election of as Director 61
Sheet Piling, progress report 78, 79
Shingles, asbestos, method of laying 897-899
Signals and Interlocking, report on 69-74
Conclusions 69, 70
Discussion 932, 933
Minority report 75, 76
Recommendations 71-74
Signal Fundamentals 71
Supplementary Indications to be used where required 71
Uniform Signaling 70-74
Signs, Fences and Crossings, report on 900-904
Concrete Fence Posts 902
Discussion 1055-1057
Fence Wire 900-902
Signs for Railroad Purposes 903, 904
Track Construction and Flangeways at Street Crossings in
Paved Streets 902, 903
Specifications :
Carbon Steel Rails 565-571
Creosote Oil 865, 866
Cypress Lumber 573-612
Erection of Railroad Bridges 83-87
Frogs, Crossings and Switches 371-374
Galvanizing Iron or Steel 521-529
Government Fuel Oil Specifications 443, 444
Ordinary Steel Water and Oil Tanks 417-419
Overhead Crossings of Electric Light and Power Lines.... 512-521
Reinforced Concrete Standpipe Water Tank for Railways. . 413-417
Standpipe, design for reinforced concrete 410-412
Storey, W. B., Jr., election of as Vice-President 61
Stresses, Secondary, progress report 88
Storage Battery in Railway Service 1181-1221
Storehouse, reasons for maintaining 506, 507
Stuart. Francis Lee, election of as Member of Nominating Com-
mittee 61
Surfacing, rules governing 68
Switches, general specifications for 381-386
1232 INDEX.
T
PAGE.
Tellers, report of 60, 61
Resolution of thanks to (&>
Third Rail Clearances, data regarding 524
Third Rail Structure Diagrams of Various Railways 535-558
Ties, report on 30i-37<>
Conclusions 33*- 342, 370
Discussion 951-964
Metal, Composite and Concrete Ties 343. 370
Stresses to Which Cross-ties are subjected 301-331
Arrangement of Ties Under Joints 330
Bibliography on Size of Cross-ties 307-311
Bearing Strength of Ties Under the Rail Tests 303
Cross-Ties, size of in current use .. 307
Tie Renewals in Continuous Stretches Versus Single Tic-
Renewals 332-342
Ties, rides governing 66,67
Timber, Standing, in the United States 431
Timbers, grouping of for antiseptic treatment 868-872
Tonnage Rating for Locomotives 1151-1180
Track, report on 37^-3^6
Conclusions 374
Discussion 965-080
Frogs, Crossings and Switches 371-3/4
General Specifications for Frogs, Crossings and Switches. . 375-3B6
Frogs 377-tfo
General Instructions 375
Inspection 375, 376
Material 376, 377
Switches 381-386
Workmanship 377
Track Work, Instructions as to 66-68
Ballasting 66
Cross-Sections 66
Drainage • 66
Rail 67
Surfacing 68
Ties 66, 57
...
I transportation, furnishing of 84
Treasurer, report of 53
Tree Planting and General Reforestation 430-437, 455, 456
Trestles, fire protection, progress report 79, 80
Tunnel Construction and Ventilation 396, 398-400
INDEX. 1233
U
PAGE.
Uniform General Contract Forms, report on 907-916
Construction Contract, Agreement Form 909,910
Construction Contract, General Conditions 911-916
Discussion 1059-1076
V
Ventilation of Tunnels 396. 398-400
W
Waterproofing of Masonry 459-474
Water Service, report on 401-42S
Conclusion 4J9
Discussion 983-998
General Specifications for a Reinforced Concrete Standpipe
Water Tank for Railways 4T3-4T7
General Specifications for Ordinary Steel Water and Oil
Tanks 417-419
Locomotive Boiler Corrosion and Treated Water 420-428
Reinforced Concrete, use of for railway water tanks and
supports 402-41 7
Water Tanks, general specifications for 417-419
Conclusions 419
Waterway Formulas 387. 388
Wickhorst, M. H., paper by on "Equated Tonnage Rating" 1151-1180
Wooden Bridges and Trestles, report on 77-So
Discussion 946
Fire Protection 79, 80
Guard Rails 79
Pile Formulas 79
Sheet Piling 78, 79
Wood Preservation, report on 863-872
Conclusions 867
Discussion 1039-1051
Forms for Reporting Inspection 866
Grouping of Timbers for Antiseptic Treatment 863,864,868-872
Merits of Various Preservatives 864
Records from Service Tests 864
Revision of the Adopted Specifications for Creosote Oil.... 865,866
Specifications for Impregnation with Creosote Oil 866
Value of Brush Coating and Dipping 867
Value of Impregnation with Crude Oil 867
Working Unit Stresses 518, 510
1234 INDEX.
Y
PAGli.
Yards and Terminals, report .on. . ,,. .3 8q-q*
Conclusions . Q7
Discussion - 0.^ ^.o
Division Engine Terminal, typical situation plans 91, 9,.
Freight, Handling of by Mechanical Means 90, 01
Hump Yards, design and operation of oi
Passenger Stations, typical situation plans 00